yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] zgfg:
[MENTION=9683515]daveh077[/MENTION] had the same issue (Huawei P9, Oreo, could not hide MM).

He followed the same procedure from the post #36544:

https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/mod-magisk-v1-universal-systemless-t3432382/post80659957

and successfully obfuscated/repackaged Magisk Manager, and thus solved a problem with his banking app.

Btw, there is one more observation:

With recent Google Play and without MM obfuscated, I was unable to obtain Device Certified by GP.

It didn't show that Device was not Certified, though - just the whole Certification info was missing from GP/Settings.

Although SafetyNet (incl. CTS profile) and Play Protect were green.

I tried a lot:

- Putting phone to Airplane, cleaning caches to GApps, cleaning Dalwik and Cache, then disabling Airplane but no avail.

- Additionally tried by manually adding a line:

<boolean name="device-google-certified"value="true" />

to:

/data/data/com.android.vending/shared_prefs/finsky.xml

but the whole line was always deleted (not changed to"false") by GP.

Now when MM was successfully obfuscated, GP added the line to finsky and it shows now that Device is Certified.

Hence the MM obfuscation problem might have with GP...
[Magisk] Icarus_GTR:
Oppo A5 2020 support?

Is there any support for Oppo A5 2020 (CPH1933), I can't seem to find a single forum about this phone in XDA :(. If it's supported, how can I install Magisk, tho I can't seem to find TWRP support either.
[Magisk] redplate:
It the post you mentioned the poster writes about an own update channel.

Is it possible to edit the json file with my own FTP server and paste the json file on the right path (where ever it is) on my device, to update MM from my own server?

Just an idea
[Magisk] zgfg:
Yes, to use a custom channel pointing to own http server with json whose Magisk and MM urls point to desired versions on GotHub (or likely to the copies of zip and apk on your http server).

Probably, FTP can work as well

Quote/ask the original poster if you need his help
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
That's actually intended behaviour. And it's been asked enough times for me to add it to my Magisk guide:

https://didgeridoohan.com/magisk/Magisk#hn_Cant_edit_system_files
[Magisk] redplate:
True.. I could point to the github page instead of setting up an own http server.

Thanks a bunch
[Magisk] nathanmuccino:
Personally, I would not recommend trying to install Magisk without a detailed tutorial for your exact device model from a trusted community member. However, If you are 'brave' and or an expert already then John provides a generic tutorial to install magisk on most devices. Again though, I will repeat, I would not recommend following any tutorial that is non-device specific unless you are extremly confident in your own skills! That being said I am not allowed to post links yet, but see below for the location of the tutorial:

topjohnwu dot github dot io / Magisk / install dot html
[Magisk] ballerd:
Not sure if am in right thread but we are having trouble keeping root with magisk and twrp could it be my twrp config file excuse the syntax I had to cat them together in terminal and save them in a text file
[Magisk] saiz0313:
My Nokia 7 PLUS can't connect to PC with download mode.

Adb mode is fine.

How can I flash Magisk with stock recovery?
[Magisk] nathanmuccino:
"Some devices seem to have issues with loosing root randomly and the Manager reporting that "Magisk is not installed".

This may be caused by memory management where the Magisk Manager will not be kept in memory and as a result root management is lost. This can sometimes be fixed by clearing the Manager from memory (swipe it away from recent apps list) and opening it again. Make sure the Manager is removed from any battery optimisation.

Other reasons for this issue include a failed update and having the Manager installed to external/adoptable storage"

Also see the following:

https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=80657309&postcount=36536
[Magisk] jagadesh krishna:
there is no installed module visible in my app drawer after flashing through magisk & custom recovery tooo! ..but magisk shows module has been installed... i tried with 3 old versions of magisk also ..but bothing worked?
[Magisk] nathanmuccino:
"Make sure you haven't enabled "Magisk Core Only Mode" in the Manager settings. This option disables all modules and only keeps the core functions of Magisk active (MagiskSU and MagiskHide). If you do not have "Magisk Core Only Mode" enabled, there's likely something wrong with your Magisk installation and you need to figure out what. Post details and *logs* in the support thread"
[Magisk] zgfg:
You install modules through Magisk Manager, not through Magisk, but ok...

Also, in MM / Modules, you see which modules are installed and activated or not.

But modules usually don't have apps to show in app drawer.

YT Vanced does have.

JamesDSP also, but on some phones the apk fails to install with module and you must install it manually.

Some you operate by commands through Terminal Emulator, like AAC.

Some have no 'interface' at all, like BusyBox.
[Magisk] redplate:
Hi. Where did you exactly put the json file on your server and how did you name it?

I can't find anything for now where to put this file.
[Magisk] Devaster:
Not sure where to report : official app from McDonald's is detecting root, even hide is used...

I am using magisk v20.
[Magisk] elliwigy:
report to mcdonalds.. they should update their app to work on magisk rooted devices
[Magisk] zgfg:
There is Search icon top-right, put MDonald and search previous posts about

Read also about banking apps finding root

And did you check GitHub Installation guide for tips about
[Magisk] redplate:
OK, I've now set up my own http server. It's open to the internet on port 80.

Its http://<ip-adress>/magisk/ (that's also the URL I put in MM custom channel)

following files are in there (see screenshot please)

my .json file contains following: (i had to make my own .json file since i couldn't find the one from github for 19.3)

{ "app": { "version": "7.3.5", "versionCode": "243", "link": "[url]http://<IP-ADRESS>/magisk/MagiskManager-v7.3.5.apk",[/url] "note": "[url]http://<IP-ADRESS>/magisk/changelog.md"[/url] }, "uninstaller": { "link": "[url]http://<IP-ADRESS>/magisk/Magisk-uninstaller-20190604.zip"[/url] }, "magisk": { "version": "19.3", "versionCode": "19300", "link": "[url]http://<IP-ADRESS>/magisk/Magisk-v19.3.zip",[/url] "note": "[url]http://<IP-ADRESS>/magisk/notes.md",[/url] "md5": "088fb6545e7042a4939bda7d21423b8b" }, "stub": { "versionCode": "1", "link": "[url]https://raw.githubusercontent.com/topjohnwu/magisk_files/canary/stub-release.apk"[/url] } }

3 questions, please:

Does this setup is so far okay? Because MM doesn't connect to the server.

What's the stub file for?

Is it allowed to delete the hash value string or is it ok to not match the md5 of the original file?

Thanks a lot in advance
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
I'm curious why you guys are making it so complicated... Github has version history, so the old json files are still available if you really want to stick to an old version.

Last Magisk v19.3 json from Github:

https://raw.githubusercontent.com/t...4f8098a52304d0e60de3f0c16bcc3ef69/stable.json
[Magisk] redplate:
why make it easy if you can make it complicated ... :silly:

Thank you :cyclops:

anyway.. would have been great if i could manage MM connects to my own server. It's weekend. What else should i do then this :eek::eek:

Edit: guess the trick is the custom URL should point directly to the json file. Not only to the path which contains it
[Magisk] guest4711:
You'll notice them only in app drawer if an GUI is installed. Not all modules install an GUI, most have a command line interface (so you use the terminal emulator to invoke them/change your settings). Please refer to the fine documentation of your modules how to deal with them. A short doc is visible in download section of magisk manager too (tap on the description of the module).

---------- Post added at 10:28 AM ---------- Previous post was at 10:26 AM ----------

That's right.
[Magisk] jcmm11:
This app? https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.mcdonalds.app

At what point does it detect root for you? At initial start or after you login? (I don't want to set up an account if I don't have to)
[Magisk] redplate:
Nvm
[Magisk] Minth:
Can confirm Fate/GO is able to detect either Magisk or a related anomaly with v20.

Doesn't seem like the app detects Magisk directly, as the error code (16882567) isn't the usual one.
[Magisk] Soumy1234:
Just out of curiosity (I don't have any system as root devices), does Magisk v20's new SAR implementation apply to all SAR devices or only those running Android 10? And how would one access other directories like /data?
[Magisk] martyfender:
It sounds like you don't have the proper drivers for download mode, or you need to go into the Windows device manager when booted to download mode and choose the proper one.
[Magisk] saiz0313:
More than once flashed it ,so I installed driver in pc.

Device manager shows error 43 or not found,it's the same for changing pc or cable.

I don't know what happened.

I want to reflash magisk after OTA,and download mode can't found in pc.
[Magisk] ktmom:
Maybe this thread will help you. It's specific to your device.
[Magisk] PoochyX:
Magisk has changed everybody vision about supersu [emoji19]

([emoji3590]09-09-18[emoji3590])
[Magisk] Ch3vr0n:
You can only speak for yourself
[Magisk] Pkt_Lnt:
Clockwork Mod Superuser by Koush changed everybody vision of Superuser by ChainsDD.

CF-Root supersu by Chainfire changed everybody vision about Clockwork Mod Superuser.

Something new will come along and replace Magisk, nothing lasts forever.
[Magisk] PoochyX:
Why cause magisk developer going to be picked up by Apple [emoji520]

([emoji3590]09-09-18[emoji3590])
[Magisk] martyfender:
Do you have the option set in Windows 10 to allow unsigned drivers to be installed? Also, try to uninstall them then reinstall them. You may need to reboot after uninstalling them.

This is one of the may reasons I prefer LInux.
[Magisk] xunholyx:
He wasn't "picked up by Apple"

He applied for internship while his university classes were on summer break with Google and Apple.

Apple offered him the internship, Google did not.

So he took the offer.

TJW will be with Android for a long time to come.
[Magisk] redplate:
Hello. I've searched but didn't find any satisfyfing answers.

I can't patch latest twrp tar file (img works) with MM. it always says there is no recovery.img found after extracting. But it's there.

And I need to patch it for properly flashing via Odin.

I've also converted the img with 7zip or a script to tar, but that doesn't work either. Failure while flashing with Odin or recovery error while booting. But I guess that's not related to magisk

how am I able to patch this file?
[Magisk] saiz0313:
.

I already uninstall driver again,

and reboot to allow unsigned drivers mode.

install driver again(use OST LA 6.0.4)

It is still not work.

tested in VMware(xubuntu-18.04.3-desktop-amd64.iso)

tested in notebook (win7x64)

the same.

I think if stock recovery can flash magisk,everything is ok.

But I flash magisk.zip in stock recovery,

show "signature verification failed"
[Magisk] amg314:
Try patch your boot using Magisk Manager first.

Magisk --> Install --> Install --> Select and patch a file --> Point to your boot.img

Then copy patched_boot.img to adb directory on your PC and run command:

fastboot flash boot patched_boot.img
[Magisk] zgfg:
If you can extract boot/ramdisk, then you patch in MM and flash by fastboot - read Installation guide on GitHub
[Magisk] saiz0313:
download mode = fastboot mode

1.My N7P can reboot to fastboot mode (download mode)

2.My N7P can't recognised in fastboot,but adb is ok.

Error 43 or not found in device manager
[Magisk] amg314:
Try NTool to flash patched_boot.img

https://www.ntool.info/

Why you can't reboot to recovery using

Power Off --> Connect to PowerSupply --> Vol+ + Power --> Robot+No command --> Hold Power + press Vol+ for 0.2s --> Stock recovery
[Magisk] Devaster:
This one https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.mcdonalds.mobileapp

I am from europe. It is showing root detection in start and closing after pressing OK.
[Magisk] redplate:
Don't waste your time with it. It's bad programmed and scam. Ask yourself what this kind of unnecessary app needs root for. Deinstall it.
[Magisk] jcmm11:
Tried it with latest Canary. Picked Poland and Polish. Started up with no problem, I didn't even put it on the hide list.
[Magisk] DroidJP:
I am not convinced. This time around, Android has changed drastically that it leaves room only for those that are willing to deal with the hurdles that Google has placed. SAR (system as root) is a big change that has ever happened to Android.

I mean no ramdisk in boot.img will only make rooting pain in the ass, that is assuming your boot loader is even unlocked. So there is that.
[Magisk] palmbeach05:
I think its hit or miss. I've been watching this issue for the last few days and decided to try it out. It gave me the rooted device error too. Latest magisk and magisk manager via canary branch.
[Magisk] saiz0313:
I said in #36587

I will try Ntool,thanks!
[Magisk] martyfender:
I was just about to suggest that there may be a flashing tool for his device and you just confirmed my suspicion.
[Magisk] nathanmuccino:
Does anyone know where I can find a list of Android TV devices (streaming boxes, streaming sticks, actual television sets, etc.) that are able to successfully install and use Magisk?
[Magisk] PoochyX:
Magisk on a TV box would void its warranty

([emoji3590]09-09-18[emoji3590])
[Magisk] nathanmuccino:
I don't care about voiding warranties.
[Magisk] Wolfcity:
[MENTION=6274645]Makifylmzz[/MENTION]: My advice too. I used the SAI installer to install a Netflix version grabbed from a Nexus 5 since then Netflix is available in playstore. And if it should disappear again, there is a thread with active development where you can get the latest split APK's for the SAI installer.

Sorry for getting a bit off topic.
[Magisk] dbreed53:
Problem updating Magisk 19.x to any update on Samsung Galaxy J7 Perx (Boost)

I've used Magisk and updated it from version 17.? to 19.0 without problems. But have been unable to successfully update to any further updates.

When I allow Magisk Manager to install the offered updates, it successfully installs and gives me the RED BOOT button.

When the phone reboots, it only goes as far as the 1st boot logo that displays the brand and model name and number, before the Samsung scroll, and Boost animation logo.

That is as far as it goes. Stuck.

Each update has done the same.

So, I pull the battery and reboot TWRP, then flash the 19.0 .zip, reboot and the phone is fine.

Just not updated.

Suggestions are invited and appreciated.
[Magisk] Devaster:
I am curious only that relatively safe app has better root detection as nearly all banking apps :laugh:
[Magisk] ct760ster:
The latest usable Magisk for the SM-J727P is the 19.2 version. Once you update by mistake past that version even the uninstaller ZIP file will be unable to fix your phone which caused me to have to restore to Stock and debloat all over. The latest version 20.0 still broken so just stay with 19.2 for now. Also as a word of advice, don't make your IMEI number public for your own security, remove it from your phone information screenshot.
[Magisk] Bi0haZarD:
Pay attention to what ct760ster said:

Can't stress this enough bro :good:
[Magisk] Milan kanti Ghosh:
sbi yono is not working in latest magisk.

I am im havoc os,max pro m1.

---------- Post added at 12:33 PM ---------- Previous post was at 12:33 PM ----------

sbi yono is not working in latest magisk.

I am im havoc os,max pro m1.

---------- Post added at 12:34 PM ---------- Previous post was at 12:33 PM ----------

sbi yono is not working in latest magisk.

I am im havoc os,max pro m1.
[Magisk] chrcol:
I use 19.4, 19.3 threw up errors when trying to install renovate ice or xxx nolimits, but both work fine on 19.4, and I am staying away from 20.x well because its new and likely broken :) 19.4 is working pretty much perfect. Probably the best ever working magisk I have ever had.

Passing safety net even with edxposed installed as well, its sweet.

---------- Post added at 16:11 ---------- Previous post was at 16:11 ----------

I use 19.4, 19.3 threw up errors when trying to install renovate ice or xxx nolimits, but both work fine on 19.4, and I am staying away from 20.x well because its new and likely broken :) 19.4 is working pretty much perfect. Probably the best ever working magisk I have ever had.

Passing safety net even with edxposed installed as well, its sweet.

---------- Post added at 16:17 ---------- Previous post was at 16:11 ----------

I use 19.4, 19.3 threw up errors when trying to install renovate ice or xxx nolimits, but both work fine on 19.4, and I am staying away from 20.x well because its new and likely broken :) 19.4 is working pretty much perfect. Probably the best ever working magisk I have ever had.

Passing safety net even with edxposed installed as well, its sweet.
[Magisk] mewbow1:
Edit:

This app again started working by Turning off and again turning on Magisk Hide in Magisk Manager->Settings->Magisk Hide
[Magisk] FriedOvaries:
Hey sorry for the late reply but I that did not work for me either. I also went through the safetyNet troubleshooting guide. I ended up rolling back to v19.4 (still SafetyNet fail on both), then v19.3 and safetyNet was true on both again. After clearing storage for the Play Store was Play protect certified again.

So hopefully there is a future fix for SafetyNet failing on v20 on some devices. It seems random because I've seen people with Pixel 2/3's in this thread who pass SafetyNet and some like me who do not.
[Magisk] tag68:
You mean de.mcdonalds.mcdonaldsinfoapp?

Running fine here using Magisk 19.3. without using hide (Moto G7+)

If you mean another one: I guess McDonalds has far more than one official app. Never refer to an app only textual, without link to the one you mean ;)
[Magisk] yahoé:
LG Smart Thinq won’t run

Hi,

LG’s latest Smart Thinq won’t run on a rooted device, even with Magisk Hide. Do you have any idea how to trick to run (Android 9)?
[Magisk] ktmom:
Start with didgeridoohan's Hiding root and passing Safety Net
[Magisk] Ail2024:
Google Framework module

Can I get the Google Framework module as the same seems to be missing from Magisk. Thanks
[Magisk] martyfender:
I’ve never heard of a module for The Google Framework. Do you mean the Google Services Framework? If so, you can download it from apkmirror.com, but it is not a Magisk module.
[Magisk] zgfg:
In which way is it missing - go to Download tab, take Search and put goo - it will find you.

Is it compatible for your phone/firmware, you should know or find on the forum for your phone (btw,, you didn't specify)
[Magisk] adi90:
Hiding Workprofile Apps

Hello,

Is there any way to hide root for application only install in Work Profile ? At the moment, I have to install the same app in normal profile to be able to hide root for both ?
[Magisk] 8bitcode:
Magisk getting uninstalled

Hello, i have a problem with Magisk, im on Redmi Note 7 Lavender, and using Bootleggers Android 9 Custom Rom based in AOSP, sometimes magisk is getting unistalled saying that is not installed, and when i do a reboot is normal again.

The modules i have installed are:

PetNoires Safety Spoofer

Smali Patcher
[Magisk] hristcroixqwerty:
Hello!

My banking application ("BDO Personal") just got updated and doesn't like rooted devices. I selected the app to hide the root but the app still detected i'm rooted.

Edit:

I'm using a Oneplus 3T with Official OxygenOS ver. 9
[Magisk] ktmom:
A few posts above yours

---------- Post added at 00:05 ---------- Previous post was at 00:03 ----------

Try searching the thread. I seem to recall this is related to battery optimizations or background service optimizations. I think a typical solution is to pin the Magisk manager app in recent apps.
[Magisk] Ail2024:
I wanted to get Digital Wellbeing on my Moto G6 Plus. In android.gadgethacks.com/how-to/get-googles-digital-wellbeing-feature-any-android-device-0191116/ they talk about a 'Google Framework' module (not dialer framework) which would enable the phone to get updates for the app directly from Play Store. That specific module is not available. [IMG="screenshot"]https://img.gadgethacks.com/img/original/30/49/63679783147650/0/636797831476503049.jpg[/IMG]
[Magisk] Fardenco:
Hi guys, I had magisk 20 running perfectly on my Oneplus 7 pro (Android 10), but after installing 2 modules, I ran into problems. The modules are CloudflareDNS4Magisk and ViPER4Android FX XHiFI. I don't know which one is the culprit since I installed both at the same time.

My problem is that after rebooting, I was stuck in a bootloop. So I tried to disable and uninstall the modules with Magisk Module Uninstaller through TWRP console, but that did not solve the problem. I'm not 100% sure the uninstaller worked as expected, since I had a lot of error messages during use (I can post them if needed), maybe it's not fully compatible with Android 10. But if I run it a second time, the modules I tried to uninstall are not in the list anymore. Anyway, that did not help.

The only way I found to be able to boot again was to flash Magisk Uninstaller. It worked, but now I don't have root anymore. So I tried to reinstall Magisk, but I'm back into a bootloop again.

So I guess one of those modules is still at least partially installed. Is there a way to fully delete the modules through the file explorer or the console ? Or maybe some kind of log to know what Magisk is doing and what caused the bootloop ?
[Magisk] Giowi:
Anyone knows where can I get "Fira Sans" Font?
[Magisk] amg314:
In your TWRP file manager delete bad module folder in data/adb/your_bad_module_to_remove
[Magisk] justmiike:
Hm, not sure what I'm doing wrong. Can someone assist me?

1. I was rooted with SuperSU, Xposed on Resurrection Remix ROM with a custom kernel (Samsung Galaxy Note 3).

My process:

2. I full wiped in Recovery.

3. I installed Resurrection Remix, flash Gapps and rebooted. Flashed custom kernel.

4. Flashed Magisk v6 and phh-superuser-17. Rebooted. I installed phh superuser from Play Store.

5. I installed Magisk Manager and AutoMagisk.

At first, Magisk Manager wouldn't toggle off root, but then found a zip file called UPDATE-unSU, which I flashed. Then I was able to toggle root.

Now when I go to PoGo, my account won't verify.

Have I missed something? Not sure what else to try? Could it be when I full wiped, traces of my previous SuperSU and Xposed was left in the system?

Any help would be appreciated. I did this with the Nexus 5X, but it's on stock ROM, worked perfectly. Is Custom ROM and Kernel an issue?
[Magisk] teddy0209:
You can't... You have to use the magisk version...

---------- Post added at 05:52 AM ---------- Previous post was at 05:48 AM ----------

You have to unsu/remove root first prior to installing magisk....
[Magisk] vital21:
del
[Magisk] source15me:
Does anyone know the answer?
[Magisk] mathy007:
I followed the instructions in the first post

Flash stock lollipop

No root

Flash magisk with twrp then comes the error message "unable to detect boot image" don't know if has anything to do with the m7 dual sim variants or is it that because am not using custom kernel?, BTW what steps did you follow
[Magisk] RandomPooka:
I must have misread the first time, and I apologize. I thought you meant you had your problem after RETORING your backup. I have no idea why you can't actually make the backup without losing functionality!

Off the top of my head, I'd see much free space you have before and after making your backup. Perhaps you're cutting it too close after the backup? other than that, I got nothing.
[Magisk] misteurz:
Hi, can i install easily magisk, on a lg g5, h850 with twrp and systemless supersu?

My Rom is official v10e patched by [MENTION=2684188]autoprime[/MENTION].

Envoyé de mon LG-H850 en utilisant Tapatalk
[Magisk] andrewia:
Just try it yourself and see what happens. Make a backup first of course!
[Magisk] RandomPooka:
Does the G5 require bumped images?