yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] xsycox:
Anyone can help?

I also tried Root Beer, but the app crashes at "rw paths".

Also the app Mount /system rw/ro tells me, there was no root.

And when I installed busybox pro, it tells me systemless is not configured and lets me not install to su/bin.

But apps like magisk or titanium backup say, they have root.

Can't figure out what is wrong. Did I flash the wrong superuser?
[Magisk] teddy0209:
With 11.1 there is no need for phhsuperuser, it comes with magisksu, it has its own busybox also so no need to install it (just activate in settings).
[Magisk] Joloxx9:
Many apps on OP3T stock rom doesn't see root. For example titanium backup, see root but cannot remove system apks. Solid explorer same, after changing to supersu no problem.
[Magisk] xsycox:
Okay, how do I uninstall phh superuser? Did not find an uninstall script to flash.

And which app is needed then for the superuser control/management?
[Magisk] Alin63992:
Is Magisk compatible with Nougat on S7? If yes, can I install Wanam so I can run apps like SHealth with Knox tripped?
[Magisk] eXtremeDevil:
Hi, love this new system, thanks to the author, but I have a couple of doubts:

1 - My ROM comes with a minimal root, so what I did was flash the ROM, flash SuperSU, and then use the SuperSU function to full unroot the device. After that there was no trace of any root and I could install Magisk easily. I understand that now I can apply future ROM updates without losing Magisk or its modules, like SuperSU, Viper, etc, right?

2 - If I apply a ROM update, this will have a little su/root built-in. How could I deal with that? Will I have to full remove Magisk, full unroot and then reinstall Magisk??

3 - How come that Viper, SuperSU are modded for Magisk with their graphical APKs but LiveBoot is only command line? Can't the APK be modified as well to have a better control?

Thanks!
[Magisk] kraoc:
Hello.

I am on a i9505 LTE using "JDCTeam Optimized CyanogenMod 13.0 builds Stable-2" with latest Gapps and latest bootloader/modem.

I installed Magisk v1 and Xposed Systemless v86.4 and it works fine.

I just performed a full wipe (everithing but sdcard) and install ROM + Gapps + Magisk v6 then reboot.

After device boot logo, my S4 just reboot to recovery... I can't provide any log or boot image because I'm stuck in a bootloop and must restore my previous nandroid backup via TWRP.

As I performed a full + clean install I think that "Is your device supported by Official SuperSU's systemless auto boot image patch? If not, then Magisk is not supported either." is my problem.

Where can I check this compatibility ?

Any help welcome... And I apologize for not being able to provide log/boot.img ...

Thanks for helps and your great work :)
[Magisk] smohanv:
Thanks. Still I can't understand the use of this "Magisk-module-template.zip" and how can this be used. Sorry for not being techie here.
[Magisk] topjohnwu:
Magisk v6 do support Official Nougat, just tested on my Nexus 9 with a fresh new system.

Oh and BTW, a small teaser....
[Magisk] smohanv:
1 - Yes. If you have systemless root (magisk version) installed

2 - Try to remove root from custom ROM zip file. If you can not achieve this, i would suggest you to unintall magisk and also check for any reminder/leftover (i.e magisk img file) via recovery and remove it. It is also good to remove SuperSu (if systemless is installed) which can be seen in magisk folder as well. After flashed your new ROM, flash magisk in the sequence of Magisk, phh's or SuperSu (magisk version). Any expert may please correct me if I am wrong here.

3 - I could not answer this
[Magisk] kartikb:
Magisk Android Nougat No Go

Hey buddy, I just tried it on my Nexus 6P and it didn't boot. I flashed the uninstaller again from TWRP. Back to normal now without root. I guess you can use the standard system root method to have root working for now.

I'm going to wait on having Magisk work on Android Nougat.
[Magisk] devilloki:
a u a chinese
[Magisk] Artim_96:
It's supposed to be still encrypted. Why do you want do decrypt it? As long as everything is working, leave it how it is, Google didn't made encryption mandatory for no reason.
[Magisk] :
They made it mandatory so they could tout device encryption for all those paranoid people who think they're devices are gonna get taken over.
[Magisk] nayanbhana:
Anyone think it is possible to get Magisk going with Systemless Xposed on an android emulator? I managed to get Xposed going on an android emulator but this looks way more difficult.
[Magisk] Artim_96:
No, more for idiots not knowing how to take care of their devices and that it gets harder for police to break into the device.

But encryption is something that should be mandatory everywhere possible since it makes it way harder for script kiddies to steel information and just makes everything more reliable, especially in terms of networks.
[Magisk] bouchigo:
It does work, I just installed it 10 minutes ago :good:
[Magisk] KaMyKaSii:
For who is noobie like me and do not know edit the template and would rather leave it to the developers, here is a simple tutorial on how to mount files: Go to your file manager with root access and navigate to /magisk. Create a folder with the name of your mod. Inside create a system folder and place all of your mod files in their respective directories. Create an empty file in the root folder of you mod and rename it "auto_mount". Now just reboot and ready. In the example of screen became the GLTools app in systemless-ly
[Magisk] Captain_Throwback:
You should also create the file module.prop with permissions 666 and the following contents (spaces are okay in all the fields):

name=your_mod_name
version=version string, can_be_anything you like e.g: v1
description=My awesome mod

This is for compatibility with the soon-to-be-released updated version of the app.
[Magisk] sylvisj:
Magisk v6 does not work on my Moto X 2014 (XT1095).

It's showing the same issues as with v1-v3 - upon reboot to system, I get thrown to the bootloader with the warning "Fastboot reason: fall-through from normal boot mode".

I've attached the Magisk v6-patched boot.img and the stock boot.img.

Edit: For what it's worth, the boot.img is definitely patchable - Chainfire's SuperSU patches it just fine for systemless root. I'm not sure what's so different between your boot.img patches and Chainfire's, especially since yours seem to have been largely based off his back in v1, but something's off.
[Magisk] eXtremeDevil:
How can I apply a ROM update with Magisk already installed? The ROM is based on CM and WILL have root, can I unroot the ROM before? Any specific steps?

Thanks.
[Magisk] Artim_96:
You might want to look into the zip, but I don't know if it will still flash afterwards. But as long as you don't uninstall Magisk, just flash CM, disable it's root system and flash the Magisk zip, the rest should still be there... At least that worked for me this morning with the flashing of a full Samsung ROM
[Magisk] eXtremeDevil:
What I did to unroot the first time was installing SuperSu and then full unroot the ROM. Disabling system's root make Magisk usable? No need to fully remove it?

Looking at the rom's zip I only see /bin/su and /xbin/su but I don't know if those are the only ones to be removed...
[Magisk] benwalburn:
The mod template script has a bug preventing the module.prop from being set (it shows in the mod folder as a blank file). You can correct it by modifying the update-binary. Change the line that says "cp $INSTALLER/common/module.prop $MODPATH/module.prop" to "cp -f $INSTALLER/common/module.prop $MODPATH/module.prop"

This is important to set for that fancy looking module manager we're getting (in case somebody missed out on the news)
[Magisk] sharp3r:
This is the 1st time using magisk. I'm using renovatr edge rom (latest build). Root access works fine with all my apps except for PAIRS.

Whenever i try to launch the app i get the message This app needs root permission. I checked magisk manager and it's not listed under Superuser section.

I used this app with supersu without a problem.
[Magisk] 24imelqui:
Dirty flash ROM or flash the ROM boot image to remove phh superuser, magisk app can manage root.
[Magisk] matif525:
Could anyone help me to solve SafetyNet CTS Profile Mismatch?

I uninstalled su use unsu.zip, flashed my rom's boot.img and Magisk 11.1, both Magisk and MagiskSU installed success, but I can't pass SafetyNet check even I enabled Magisk Hide. I saw someone says it need to remove Xposed, is that true? I need Xposed (I installed Systemless Xposed which by topjohnwu).
[Magisk] KevinX8:
Magisk hide must be enabled and you must reboot after enabling it, your system has to be able to pass SN without magisk installed first so make it does before installing.
[Magisk] teddy0209:
Not necessarily...

No need to uninstall xposed, just disable it in xposed app and reboot...
[Magisk] KevinX8:
Yes necessarily, as if it doesn't pass without any modifications it certainly won't pass with magisk no matter what you do. Magisk is used to make the modifications systemless and hide them on the fly but if you have none and it still fails SN then magisk will not help you.
[Magisk] teddy0209:
That was before SN was modified to detect an unlocked bootloader...
[Magisk] KevinX8:
What that is not relevant to what I am saying? Also you can hide the fact you have an unlocked bootloader by taking advantage of the legacy support for phones that don't support the detection system via disabling the flag in the kernel. What you are saying is it is unnecessary to have a system that passes SN before installing magisk to pass SN which is complete nonsense since magisk isn't magic.
[Magisk] teddy0209:
That's why I am saying not necessarily, because there are users who are not using a patched kernel, thus needs magisk resetprop to do its thing for them...
[Magisk] KevinX8:
You should use a patched kernel anyway to test SN on stock before getting magisk since magisk isn't 100% guaranteed to make your SN problems go away
[Magisk] teddy0209:
I don't use one, I'm pure stock sense... So if I remove magisk, it will trigger SN... [emoji6]
[Magisk] matif525:
Thanks, I passed SN in old Magisk, I just tried disable Xposed and enable Magisk Hide then reboot, it still the same.

Thanks, but of course I tried disable it before ask...

Thanks, I can pass SN in old Magisk, but I forgot which version of magisk. And I can't understand what you said very well, sorry.

My phone info: HTC M7, android 5.0.2, Rom is ARHD 93.0, Sense 6.0.
[Magisk] MurdererFight:
Magisk doesn't work on MIUI

Before installing it I can pass BasicIntergrity then when I flash it no, it won't pass it. Magisk Hide is already enabled and activated on Safety pass Net

Which other option I may need to activate?

(MIUI 6.0, Redmi Note 3 Snapdragon, Magisk 11.1)
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
I don't think you're alone:

https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/issues/84

You could try some of this stuff, but nothing's guaranteed:

https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/magisk-magisk-hide-troubleshooting-tips-t3561828
[Magisk] matif525:
I flashed zip to uninstalled Xposed and Magisk, found I still can't pass SN even I don't have root access.

So that means I can't never pass SafetyNet?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
If you've uninstalled Magisk (v11.1 i guess) with MagiskSU, of course you're gonna be without root...

Not necessarily. There might be something with your setup triggering SN. I posted a link in the post above yours. See if some of the tips there can help you.
[Magisk] MurdererFight:
Founded the reason: Magisk Hide doesn't work

Even if I delete BusyBox applets it will still use it and call "BusyBox free". How I do a clean install of BusyBox?
[Magisk] lalitjoshi06:
I tried this on linage 13 official and the result is attach what to do.

Any idea.
[Magisk] matif525:
Sorry for my English, I mean, even if I don't have root access, I still can't pass SN.

Thanks, I will check that. Is this the link you are talking? >> https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/magisk-magisk-hide-troubleshooting-tips-t3561828
[Magisk] Captain_Throwback:
Well, according to that, you have some problems unrelated to Magisk (though I think resetprop could be set up to fix the "dangerous props").

According to the source for that app, the props it looks for are:

ro.debuggable=1
ro.secure=0

And to fail the SELinux check, I assume your SELinux would have to report as disabled, since if it was permissive, Magisk Hide would patch it to show pseudo enforced.
[Magisk] lalitjoshi06:
Thanks
[Magisk] jhedfors:
This module changes that property.

https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/module-nano-miitomo-1-0-20161115-t3500781
[Magisk] lalitjoshi06:
Here the thing is like

ro.debuggable=1

ro.build.selinux=1

And selinux is changing by magisk its OK but props OK in source. Then any help
[Magisk] igorinolw:
Redmi 2 pro, using latest miui 8, clean flashed

Device boots but when It finishes starting, the screen goes Black and all i can do is reboot and remove magisk so i can use the phone.

How can i help providing logs or anything?
[Magisk] chas123:
Anybody know what causes the errors in the attached log?
[Magisk] royal_eagle:
Had the same Man even if doing this :(
[Magisk] kiki059:
Hi guys . Need help please

I run with lineage OS , my phone is rooted with magiskSU but sometimes the root is gone .. . I must go back recovery for reflash magisk
[Magisk] Filip013:
See here.

It's possible to get Magisk to work. I've had this issue twice before. The only way I managed to fix it is by wiping data, so if you really want Magisk that is the only tested way.

I've had an idea how this might be fixed, but I don't know if it could work. Did you by any chance have suhide installed before? If you did you might try flashing SuperSU and suhide, then reboot. Then flash suhide rm and reboot. Now unroot from SuperSU app and flash Magisk.

I don't know if that will work, but I thought to try it if it happened to me again.

Edit: Sorry just saw you said clean flash. Then I really can't help you.
[Magisk] zee24:
Hey guys. I'm failing safety net on latest purenexus ROM for nexus 6p and I have Franco kernel installed with substratum theme. What am i doing wrong? The last build of purenexus it was passing the safety net so could someone tell me how I can fix this please? I've tried to uninstall and reinstall magisk no avail.
[Magisk] zee24:
Screenshot
[Magisk] MurdererFight:
Managed to fix it, do this in a terminal:

su (grant SuperSU permission)

sh magisk/.core/magiskhide/disable

sh magisk/.core/magiskhide/enable

(You need to do this at every reboot)

Now it's working again!

I also suggest to install BusyBox on rails and do cleanup & install, then if it isn't working install BusyBox by Sterisicon and install it.
[Magisk] Artim_96:
Is it passing before flashing Magisk? If not then probably the kernel is the problem

---------- Post added at 11:11 PM ---------- Previous post was at 11:10 PM ----------

That's now a veeeery old problem. You are supposed to search before ask.

PS: try BusyBox and Magisk hide
[Magisk] kiki059:
I try that ... Don't working
[Magisk] Artim_96:
Then you'll have to wait till topjohnwu had the time to fix it. It's that easy
[Magisk] jcrompton:
It's been a while since I used my Nexus 6 but I have to agree that I was unable to use Franco kernel for this reason
[Magisk] rignfool:
You have a bad case of user error or a ROM that won't pass... Franco passes safety-net on the N6 on Pure Nexus...
[Magisk] jcrompton:
Lol
[Magisk] phen0m2016:
Hi,

I have the following questions:

1.- Is it possible to install Magisk v11.1 on Stock Android 7.0 Nougat without having TWRP v3.x.x installed, and rather executing it using the fastboot boot function from the Bootloader?

2.- Has anyone tried it?

3.- Does Magisk require a Custom Recovery to be installed in order to work?
[Magisk] afuller42:
You'll need a custom recovery for initial install. Afaik
[Magisk] migaspepino:
Could you recommend a good kernel for LOS14?
[Magisk] Xennet:
It is said dat titanium backup has a known issue with magisk and magisk root dat it cannot mount system. The solution given in t OP was to mount system r/w and use titanium backup. I tried mounting system r/w with es file explorer. Still cant restore my backup. It just tells processing and hangs...

Do help please. Cannot restore...:crying::crying::crying:
[Magisk] teddy0209:
It should work...
[Magisk] jhedfors:
Not really. Official stock LineageOS 14.1 kernel/ROM seems to work fine for OPO.
[Magisk] leolawliet:
The latest Magisk is actually working perfectly on my Nexus 5X running Pure Nexus. Successfully bypassing safety net without a problem. I just used my phone to take money out at the bank. Thanks [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION]
[Magisk] Jsilver73:
In my experimenting I discovered that TB seems to just not like some apk back ups, it's a bit of a fiddly pain in the arse and far from ideal but the way I got around this was to restore 10 apps at a time (starting with the most important apps to me with data that I really didn't want to lose) and every time it hangs I liked TB then started again excluding the app that it hanged on, this behaviour send totally random.

The plus side for me was that I got to seriously clean up my system and got rid of a lot of those 'just in case' apps that rarely saw the light of day and were really just kleptomaniac resource hogging hoarding stuff that I thought was useful once upon a moon :eek:
[Magisk] HamsterHam:
Titanium Backup works flawlessly for me [MENTION=7874870]Xennet[/MENTION] and [MENTION=5528810]Jimsilver73[/MENTION]
[Magisk] Jsilver73:
Interesting - and you have actually restored all your data with it, I mean backing up works, just sticks on restoring?
[Magisk] HamsterHam:
Yes, I did that on Friday. I do have phh superuser installed from play store and frozen so that might be it.
[Magisk] Jsilver73:
Ah right, yes I forgot about that, thanks for reminding me
[Magisk] Xennet:
May be phh su did t trick. Magic su alone Titanium backup gives errors.

Ders an option to create UPDATE ZIP in titanium. Finally t only way it worked was to create an update zip from t backup file and flash it via twrp. It flashed in just 20secs and restored everything. But tit backup has problems with magisk su alone. Earlier with super su chainfire it worked flawlessly...
[Magisk] pkdon123:
Sir, SafetyNet failed on latest magisk, it happened just now, in morning it was working perfectly.. Any solution??? :rolleyes:
[Magisk] darkeyes22:
Have you installed Xposed? Because it breaks SN. Deactivate or uninstall it. Also disable USB debugging if it's enabled, since it also breaks SN
[Magisk] pkdon123:
I am on Android Nougat, XPOSED FRAMEWORK is not available for Android N Yet, I Think The Error was due to Android Debugging.. :D

Now SafetyNet passed again.. :laugh:

Thanks For Reply I'll Keep In Mind These Things.. ??
[Magisk] darkeyes22:
You're welcome 8)
[Magisk] lostreal:
Some applications such as Link2sd, /system/app mover do not recognize the MagiskSU and those don't get root authority! What can i do for those apps?
[Magisk] Artim_96:
Install phh's SuperUser app but freeze it with titanium
[Magisk] lostreal:
Any other way?
[Magisk] Artim_96:
That seems the most reliable way known. Other ways are not known
[Magisk] laggardkernel:
Or link su to /system/xbin/su systemless-ly. See here https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=71157728&postcount=8. But you will break safetynet obviously.

---------- Post added at 04:40 PM ---------- Previous post was at 04:38 PM ----------

Oh, that's an interesting trick. Could you explain some detail that how the magic happens?
[Magisk] Artim_96:
It seems that some apps just don't trust root rights when they don't see a known app that manages it. Phh's SuperUser app is one of these known apps, so they will request root rights of they see that it's installed. But to prevent messing up the permission system you need to freeze the app immediately. That way other apps can detect it as installed, but it can't run and this won't interfere with Magisk's root managing
[Magisk] Captain_Throwback:
Link2SD works fine for me with just MagiskSU.
[Magisk] lostreal:
Not for me ?
[Magisk] RWOLUPO:
i didnt get magisk on my new huawei mate 9 (MHA-L29C432B156) work.

can anyone help?

boot.img:

https://www.androidfilehost.com/?fid=817550096634747353
[Magisk] godzulu:
Did you ever find solution? It's weird, I have 2 Nexus 6P, running the same ROM and same apps. One works and one first get roots access when trying to open pairs.apk. I even did another clean install... Still no go. Hopefully someone has a to to fix this. Thanks all
[Magisk] finiterex:
Hi all - just wondering if anyone's had any issues with Magisk v11 on a OnePlus 3T causing it to lock up, black screen, white LED on and then require a hard reset using the power button?
[Magisk] leolawliet:
I'm not sure if anyone is having trouble with init.d or su.d scripts, but the directory for that would be here:

/magisk/.core/service.d
[Magisk] xsycox:
I have Android 6 with systemless root (Magisk 11.1) and

would like to know, if there is a way to have the DKB

Card Secure app running/working on a rooted device?

Hiding withing Magisk 11.1 did not work, as far as I can

tell.
[Magisk] Artim_96:
Probably only with XPosed and one of ours module, if it still gets updated.

It's a banking app, most of them use root detection methods even devs like Chainfire aren't able to figure out how they actually work because they work under circumstances they shouldn't be able to detect anything.

That module is the only thing I know that at least was able to break the detection since it seems to either disable it or modify it in a way that it always says the device is clean

---------- Post added at 11:01 PM ---------- Previous post was at 10:59 PM ----------

...or you just make it a post-fs-data script
[Magisk] leolawliet:
That too
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Could be that the apps in question check for props like ro.build.tags=test-keys and similarly "dangerous" props. I've got a couple of more listed in my tips and tricks thread under "Things to try":

https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/magisk-magisk-hide-troubleshooting-tips-t3561828
[Magisk] mzj4213:
can i flash on x86?:confused:
[Magisk] Valiante:
My Titanium Backup is giving lots of issues.

I am using Magisk's built-in SU and I downloaded Phh's Superuser from the Play Store (I have not frozen it yet because I can't! That's one of the issues I'm experiencing)

Titanium Backup is the only app I'm having these issues with ):
[Magisk] jnx_r:
Thanks a lot mate, will give it a read today, and try everything one by one.
[Magisk] Joloxx9:
Magisk doesn't work properly on OP3T. Apps have access to root, but when they use it nothing happen. For example, titanium backup see root, but when I delete system app and restart phone its still there
[Magisk] godzulu:
Figured it out....Install phh superuser. Pairs works again... Profit

Nexus 6P PN 7.1.1
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
1 - It's a currently known issue (v11.1) where TiBu can't mount /system rw. It's fixed in source but meanwhile you can mount /system rw before using TiBu.

2 - As topjohnwu puts it: "BTW, you are using a systemless interface, why don't just freeze bloatware instead of remounting /system rw and remove it :D"

3 - Or, you could make a debloater module... https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/magisk-details-dummies-to-developers-t3473486
[Magisk] Xennet:
As i mentioned in my earlier post even after mounting system R/W titanium backup fails in restoring t apps that were backed up. Restoring is an important feature. [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] needs to do something bout the issue were some apps fails to recognize root or fails to get access to r/w system...
[Magisk] GayCasper:
How do u install expose I did it through the manager but it's not working
[Magisk] GayCasper:
See