yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] EotT:
I have an issues with hiding magisk. Without it, everything is fine, rootbeer app is green, an banking app is working. After flashing magisk, and hiding the manager and rootbeer, su binary, root native and magisk binary is still detected by rootbeer. Banking app isn't working either.

What am I doing wrong? Problem existed already with magisk 2.4 and manager 7, and is the same with magisk 21 and manager 8 ( I also tried canary versions).

One issue I encountered: when disabling and reenabling magiskHide, I cannot start any app anymore (not even the manager) and a restart is needed.

Any suggestions?

Edit: safetynet is ok.
[Magisk] meiser:
I disabled all build.prop changes, the DKB app still failed to open. I think, it's the /vendor re-mounts.

SafetyNet passes fine here.
[Magisk] JudgeDread11:
Did you enable Magisk hide (not only hiding the manager) and added your banking apps and rootbeer to the list?

Rootbeer detecting those suggest is not on the list.
[Magisk] EotT:
Yes, I did.
[Magisk] AndDiSa:
Did you check whether Play Store is certified? If not, try to clear data of Play Store.
[Magisk] J.Michael:
Why don't you eliminate encryption before/during first installation of Magisk?

Do you really have the option of removing encryption as part of re-installing Magisk through Magisk Manager?

This is the first time I've noticed you mentioning being able to set KEEPFORCEENCRYPT to false, and being forced to do a factory reset. I think that's as good as it gets -- I don't think you get to remove encryption without wiping the data.
[Magisk] oxidehaxs:
Im not to sure there no s20 on tarp.me site I got it from xda so what recovery is s20 support

---------- Post added at 09:57 AM ---------- Previous post was at 09:54 AM ----------

No im using Android 10 I have got magisk know think issue was trans patch image from phone I uploaded it to mega then re dl it from pc and worked so that's been taken care off know gotta find a recovery that for s20 twrp bootloops me some reason
[Magisk] pndwal:
There is NO TWRP fully supporting ANY devices that shipped with Android 10, as explained...

...so, instetof flashing unsupported TWRP, did you try booting it only, from PC, using command prompt, fastboot boot TWRP, as suggested? PW
[Magisk] AndDiSa:
[MENTION=7550078]pndwal[/MENTION] in former times there was no fastboot mode on Samsung devices, not sure whether this changed in the last time.
[Magisk] meiser:
Yes, it is.
[Magisk] sportytony:
Hi All,

I did all required steps to patch my newly updated to 11 boot.im on my once rooted one plus 8 pro and everything appeared to work normal, including flashing to both slots, no error messages but when i reboot ITS STILLNOT ROOTED. Would appreciate any ideas. Thanx ( never mind) After reading all around and more reading, I've come to realize 11 most likely needs Canary! Yup that's what it was. Re patched boot.img file with Canary and it's rooted. I hope this helps someone.
[Magisk] zgfg:
Canary Magisk Manager 309 released, hiding/repackaging now fully works (ofc, on MIUI, Install via USB must be enabled)
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Not quite... Note that the stub reports that 12 is the latest version available, but you'll get version 11 when updating or repackaging the Manager. Probably just a small thing... I've let [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] know about it already.
[Magisk] zgfg:
Not sure is anything really wrong or is it only cosmetic.

First screenshot shows 309 upon update, second upon (successful!) hiding/repackaging.

All versions Installed/Latest are labeled as efb1eab3 (309).

Not sure what about those secomd brackets (11) vs (12) - btw, that bracket is missing for Installed label upon update
[Magisk] kold11:
Could anybody help me please. :crying:

I messed up with TWRP and magisk flash after ROM update.

The post is here.
[Magisk] H113408:
Maybe I was wrong all the way. Maybe Magisk Manager doesn't remove encryption, but is somehow able to patch the boot.img with the new magisk without system noticing that the image has changed.

Again the goal is not to remove encryption, but just to update magisk from ADB (without using Magisk Manager). :(
[Magisk] JudgeDread11:
Madison manager patches the system when either it's in the Android system or the TWRP system. Both give access to an encrypted system.

But i don't think the boot image where Magisk is installed is even encrypted. Because otherwise you would need to give your PIN before hitting your device.

Afaik only data is encrypted.
[Magisk] pndwal:
Magisk (872c5520) (21004)

- Support boot images with header_version = 3 (devices launched with Android 11)*

- Support new APEX modules for dynamically load libsqlite.so

- Make magisk --remove-modules more reliable

*That means Pixel 5! Device just announced. Not bad.

Magisk Manager (339ca6d6) (310)

- Minor updates to DoH implementation

PW
[Magisk] J.Michael:
Are you able to update Magisk using TWRP? Does your /data get wiped?

You mentioned Odin. Is your phone a Samsung? System-as-root? A/B?

However you first install Magisk: If you just do it again -- running the Magisk patched system -- but use a different version of Magisk Manager, and do *not* wipe data between running Odin and booting Android, does it boot? Can you get it to boot with Magisk active?
[Magisk] H113408:
Thanks for all the support, specially [MENTION=8875326]J.Michael[/MENTION]. I was able to achieve the desired result.

The entire process was to be able to have a one click command from my computer to update Magisk whenever I wanted to instead of doing 3+ clicks on a user interface.
[Magisk] starbright_:
I probably didn't understood the concept.

I changed the GmsCore.apk and GsfProxy.apk in /system/priv-app (in TWRP, or with a root-Filemanager), but it seems not have an effect. Is there a shadow of this files? Where do I have to change the apps so that it will work as wanted.
[Magisk] zgfg:
Things are not that simple - do you mind is your system SAR read-only, A/B, etc

Because of all that Magisk provides you a framework for the systemless overlay instead of manually changing the system files (that may not be possible on read-only SAR). Please read the Magisk Documentation, link to GitHub is on the Magisk Manager front page

To make it simpler, enable Systemless hosts in Magisk Manager and reboot.

Then inspect the difference between /system/etc/hosts file when you open in TWRP and by root explorer, like from MiXPlorer

Actually, go to /data/adb/modules/hosts (folder belonging to Magisk Module Systemless hosts), go to its subfolder system/etc and make a change to its local hosts file, e.g. add a commented line:

# Dummy comment

When you reboot, changes you made there will be visible (mounted by Magisk to) in the /system/etc/hosts

However, if you reboot to TWRP, you will see there the intact /system/etc/hosts file (systemless changes are applied/mounted by Magisk only at the boot time)

The same way you can make your own module (just as a subfolder in /data/adb/modules, it does not need to be flashed via zip)

Again, read the documentation but also inspect the structure of the other Magisk modules you install

E.g. attached is my module I use for debloating my phone. It similarly replaces stock applications like BasicDreams.apk and tons of others with empty files.

Unzip, copy Debloater folder (rename as you wish) into the /data/adb/modules and adapt my system tree there with how you want to change your system applications (files, folders)
[Magisk] The Analog Kid:
Magisk manager 8.0.1 suddenly got partially freezed for downloading any updates and it won't even apply themes. Is there someone experiencing same issue? Also, when looking for 8.0.2 in Magisk site for manual update, it throws previous 8.0.1 instead of 8.0.2 version for download. Do somebody knows what's going on?
[Magisk] pndwal:
Think you'll need to download Canary Manager to set channel to Canary for later than 8.0.1. PW

Edit: 8.0.2 should show / work.
[Magisk] dcarvil:
8.0.2 shows in both Stable and Beta channels for me.
[Magisk] The Analog Kid:
Ok... so there is actually no 8.0.2 stable version? So why is Magisk manager promoting to download it?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
When you say the "Magisk site" I sincerely hope you mean Github:

https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/releases/tag/manager-v8.0.2

Any other site is in best case just offering official files for download and trying to profit from ads, and in worst case offering an altered version of Magisk that'll mess up your device...
[Magisk] The Analog Kid:
It shows but you can't update... ¿right?
[Magisk] dcarvil:
It updates fine for me. Have you downloading the apk and reinstalling the Manager?
[Magisk] pndwal:
Sorry, hadn't checked as I'm on Canary now.

Just checked on another device:

Stable does show 8.0.2 (307) w/ 20.4 (20400), and just updated fine for me from 8.0.1.

Changing to Beta channel shows Magisk 21.0 (21000).

Canary builds are up to 310 / 21004 now.

https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/mod-magisk-v1-universal-systemless-t3432382/post83692687 PW
[Magisk] The Analog Kid:
Just downloaded 8.0.2 from the github and installed, but still no update or theme capability...

---------- Post added at 11:29 PM ---------- Previous post was at 11:22 PM ----------

No problem, so far I been updating through the manager only until 8.0.2... downloaded from the github and installed manually, but it has the same issues.
[Magisk] dcarvil:
What are you trying to update? I know nothing about themes, so can't help with that.
[Magisk] The Analog Kid:
No problem, so far I been updating through the manager only until 8.0.2... downloaded from the github and installed manually, but it has the same issues.

---------- Post added at 11:32 PM ---------- Previous post was at 11:30 PM ----------

Magisk manager from 8.0.1 to 8.0.2...
[Magisk] dcarvil:
Sorry, I don't understand. If you downloaded 8.0.2 and installed it, there is nothing to update. 8.0.2 is the latest.
[Magisk] The Analog Kid:
Magisk manager from 8.0.1 to 8.0.2...

---------- Post added at 11:40 PM ---------- Previous post was at 11:38

There isn't anymore because I just did it minutes ago; however 8.0.2 has the same issues as 8.0.1: no updating and no theme change; it is always white theme.
[Magisk] pndwal:
Just checked themes in 8.0.2. They change / work fine for me!

Also, as explained, 8.0.2 is latest update for this channel. You'll need to change manager to Canary for later build(s).

And please post once, close and check if posting from Labs app and you get 'post failed' message. This is a Labs app bug, so PLEASE edit all your duplicate posts above, so mod doesn't have to do it for you. :good: PW
[Magisk] slsamg7112:
how to disable force encryption and AVB 2.0 in Magisk manager 8.0.2?

there is advanced settings in v7.5.1 to disable force encryption and AVB

but it's gone in v8.0.2

i went back to v7.5.1,unchecked those two checkboxes then try to install magisk again

but it cannot just install module but ask me to update manager first

how to solve this problem?

my device is Xperia XZ3 and no TWRP
[Magisk] The Analog Kid:
8.0.2 is "latest" or "last" update for this chanel (stable)...? in any case, that doesn't explain the issues I'm experiencing with it... and I'm not using Labs for posting, so I can't explain the multiplicated postings. I will edit anyway.
[Magisk] pndwal:
Is yours a supported / legacy device? PW
[Magisk] J.Michael:
It can also happen using a browser: Sometimes it takes a long time for the web site to respond to clicking "SUBMIT REPLY". If you click it again, you post again. Also, some alignment of post with the multiple of ten displayed on a page seems to provoke an error page. It has usually posted the reply. If you back out of the error page and hit SUBMIT again, it will post again. And, since they cleverly merge the new post with your previous post, it doesn't change the alignment, so you get the error page again.

TL;DR No matter how you are viewing this site, after clicking SUBMIT, wait.
[Magisk] zgfg:
You can lock yourself to Magisk 20.4 and Manager 7.5.1 by changing the Update channel to Custom:

https://raw.githubusercontent.com/t...5ffa9b079f3a411dd2c00a80a3d985ccc/stable.json

(stable.json took from GitHub, at the time of commiting 7.5.1 release)

With that channel you will never see an update, it will not bother about, it would hide Manager sticking to 7.5.1, etc

If you ever wish to 'unlock', switch the Update channel back to Beta or Stable

Btw, if you have an issue with theming, please report to the Github (but not for that old Manager 7.5.1)
[Magisk] slsamg7112:
thanks for the information

i use the tools to patch my kernel but FE and AVB still there

maybe something went wrong when i did that

it works, thanks a lot!
[Magisk] EotT:
I did a clean flash, but the issue persists. I cannot hide su/magisk. The issue with reenabling magiskHide is also still present. Any ideas?
[Magisk] The Analog Kid:
I think I found responsible for Magisk manager theme culprit in my device. One app called "Dark Mode" I used to have and just recently uninstalled, apparently got linked to Magisk manager theme feature and prevented it to shift from white to dark theme and vice versa once uninstalled/reinstalled. Manager is still unable to shift themes, but at least I'm now stuck (I hope temporarily) in dark interface, which is the one I like. BTW, I still can't update from manager 8.0.2...
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
What is it you want to update to? There is currently no release after 8.0.2 (unless you count the Canary builds, but I didn't get the impression that you wanted to install that)...
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Providing the Magisk log is a good start...

https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHideHelp
[Magisk] zgfg:
I had a similar 'problem' (now on Canary 310). When I choose Always light, it changes background from black to dark grey, not to white

To fix it on my Xiaomi Mi 9T, MIUI 12, I had to go to my phone Settings, Display, and exclude Magisk Manager to follow the theme (dark theme) as dictated through the Settings/Display - upon that, swiching in Manager to Always light, provides black (whatever) text on the white background

Hence the theming actually works properly for me (just I must take into account also the global settings)
[Magisk] MajicDroidPirate:
Hi, having an issue with the latest canary (I know it's Canary I don't know if it qualifies for support) but i just updated to 21004 and 310 manager. First i kept getting the notification that an update for manager was available even though i was on latest. So i tried uninstalling magisk manager and reinstalling from github. Now, i cant hide manager at all it just says hiding forever. I cant access my modules it just force closes, and i fail safety net both on cts and integrity. Any suggestions? All is appreciated, thank you!

Edit: if I use the beta manager instead of canary I'm now able to both hide magisk and access my modules, it appears without Canary safety net passes but within manager I can't check it I get an API error and it won't download the files necessary period that itself is not a big deal
[Magisk] robbayani:
Clean install Xiaomi.eu + Magisk 21.0..

in Magisk Manager 8.0.2, MagiskHide can't find miui.securitycenter..

so i can't Hide it, causing Miui Security always detect root.. i'm also using random name & package..

but Miui Security still detect root..

after reflash with Magisk 20.4(including Magisk manager 7.5.1) problem is gone.. MagiskHide can find & Hide miui.securitycenter..

#UI Magisk Manager 8.0.x confusing me.. i still comfort with Magisk Manager 7.5.1..
[Magisk] zgfg:
Maybe it could help, idk, click to the search icom bottom-right in the Magisk Hide tab, and then enable Show system apps (Canary, new Beta and Stable Managers)
[Magisk] robbayani:
i'm doing this(Show System Apps) since long time bruh..

check my screnshot.. there is no "com.miui.securitycenter"..

MagiskHide in Manager 8.0.2 cant find this package name..

*in Magisk Log 8.0.2 there are "com.miui.securitycenter".. because before update to Manager 8.0.2, in Manager 7.5.1 i'm Hide it first..
[Magisk] zgfg:
Ok, I see now, I have also MIUI (eea, not eu werkly) and if I run that Security Scan it indeed finds the root (screenshot) - and I also cannot find Security in the Magisk Hide tab (Canary 310), filtering for security finds nothing

Workaround (if that could make you happier?): open Settings in the Security scan and disable searching for root (screenshot) - then it won't report root as a security issue
[Magisk] JudgeDread11:
It might be caused because often system apps share the same UID. Most apps will only show 1 name of the group. If you can figure out what make that is and hide that it'll probably be hidden from the whole group.

Afwall+ works the same. In the screenshot you can see what is all under the UID 1000 on my OnePlus 7.
[Magisk] zgfg:
Sorry [MENTION=5993745]JudgeDread11[/MENTION], rewriting my answer after looking to the screensot from:

From his screenshot, Security app is running under UID=1000, unlike the other apps, maybe it's the rwason

Nevertheless, as he pointed, he was able to see that same Security app in Magisk Hide with Manager 7.5.1, but no more with 8.0.2 - hence it was changed now with the new Magisk
[Magisk] JudgeDread11:
Yeah, I was not taking about dual apps, just about the regular UID every app has assigned.

I did add screenshots, but unfortunately they didn't make it. It's a screenshot from afwall which shows a lot of different packages with the same UID

Anyway I don't have a problem with this. I was just trying to think among and suggest a possibility which could cause it.
[Magisk] The Analog Kid:
Interesting. However, it seems your device runs on something OS 9 or higher, mine's still on 8.0 so no global settings for dark to play around. I will be stuck on "amoled" theme until find some time to dig deep into it. Apparently it is not going to be fixed just by updating Magisk manager...

---------- Post added at 05:55 AM ---------- Previous post was at 05:31 AM ----------

There isn't, I know, but that's been happening since 8.0.1... I commented that in my first related post, that's why I updated to 8.0.2 from the github... and yes, I've actually tried the beta channel and no update was possible too, not even changelogs I can see. You tap on those buttons and nothing happens...
[Magisk] pndwal:
Thing is Magisk is pretty much John Wu's baby, with a lot of help from [MENTION=9815783]diareuse[/MENTION] on Manager UI. https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/mod-magisk-v1-universal-systemless-t3432382/post83637567 It's basically his hobby, and he has a demanding real job for Apple also.

This means whatever time he has to implement changes is generally used to improve Canary builds, and these are often not pushed to Stable for many months - after a test period, and often to coincide with major advances in Android / device implementation.

For example, the last Stable Magisk build, 20.4, was not updated from March till October! And while the new Manager GUI has been available in Canary for some months, it too has only just made it to Stable / 'public release'!

Of course, the impetus for updating Stable recently was Android 11 release, as well as new Hardware configurations, especially new 2SI device checking (needed due to changes in ramdisk structure in Android 11), dynamic/logical partition use etc.

So, if you want fixes, or to check if there are any, the choice is either to wait (possibly for months) for these to come to Stable, or get on the 'bleeding egde' (= fixes, w/ instability, possible bootloops, etc etc) with Canary builds... Hobson's Choice! :D PW
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Beta and stable Manager is the same at the moment. You'll only be offered an update if you change to the Canary channel (the built-in Canary channel is only available in the Canary Manager).

So your issue isn't actually that updating doesn't work, but that clicking on the "Install" button does nothing. Is that correct? Sounds like you simply are having a bunch of issues with the Manager (that possibly are caused by external things like themeing).
[Magisk] The Analog Kid:
Yes I actually have an issue with themeing caused by another app... though I've been offered 21.0 update in the beta channel:
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Yes, but that's for Magisk, not the Manager (which we are talking about, right?).

Was I correct in my assumption when I said that the "Install" button for the Manager doesn't work?
[Magisk] H4X0R46:
Sorry for the dumb question, but where can I find Magisk Canary? I see that stable is v20.4 and beta is v21, but where can canary builds be downloaded?
[Magisk] Adzkii:
it's on the official github page

https://github.com/topjohnwu/magisk_files/tree/canary
[Magisk] H4X0R46:
Ah! I see it. Thanks! Does beta work on Android 11 or is that canary only for now?
[Magisk] The Analog Kid:
Actually I was talking about both things all the way, but I guess it's me not making myself clear. Sorry about that. So I'll resume: Neither of both Magisk nor manager can be updated from the manager; it all started suddenly while on 8.0.1 then updated manually through the github to 8.0.2 yet update issue remains the same. As you say, external themeing might be the culprit since I discovered a theme app (not supposed to theme Magisk manager) doing strange things to manager themes even after uninstalled. It caused manager to follow it's themeing command, leaving it stuck on white or amoled theme. I had to reinstall this app (called "Dark Mode") in order to select amoled. Now, I can't choose themes from manager settings unless I have this messing app reinstalled back again. However, as far as I can tell, update inability was already there prior to theme issue. Nevertheless, I'm getting confident to blame said app for both manager failures...
[Magisk] Adzkii:
yep, i'm on android 11 and using 21.0. works wonders.
[Magisk] zgfg:
Both are for A11 and the same now - by def. Canary is always newer than Beta and IMO its Magisk has one more latest fix for A11 (not sure, I don't follow Beta)

I would not bother with Beta - who wants the stable and does not need A11, stay on Stable (and possibly the old Manager 7.5.1) - until Stable would be fully updated (Magisk, not only Manager as for now)

Otherwise and specially for A11, use Canary.

Patch (don't update directly) and keep your previously patched image, and in case of troubles with the new Canary version, simply flash the previously patched image.

Then you can participate in testing the new Canary, enjoy the latest fixes and be safe in case of a buggy release

---------- Post added at 12:36 PM ---------- Previous post was at 12:21 PM ----------

Can you please elaborate:

- With Manager 7.5.1, you see Security app in the Magisk Hide list (and you can enable Magisk Hide for that app, and Security then does not find the root)?

- With Manager 8.0.2 you don't see Security app in Magisk Hide list but thanks to your old Magisk Hide settings from 7.5.1, it still hides the root for Security app?
[Magisk] pndwal:
All v21 builds support Android 11.

Last Public Beta build is 21.000, and will become new Stable after sufficient time testing.

Last Debug Canary build is 21.004

https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/mod-magisk-v1-universal-systemless-t3432382/post83692687

Last Public Stable release is 20.4. Expect a 21.x Stable build soon.

Nb. I've added decimal points above where they are otherwise assumed.

For Canary, click Downloads, Magisk Manager Canary on main Magisk page:

https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk

This manager allows all channels for Magisk(SU) installation. PW