yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] Pkt_Lnt:
That website is more than shady!

https://otx.alienvault.com/indicator/ip/104.28.16.193

Goes to show how many users can be so careless and help promote malicious web sites. :eek:

[MENTION=3490562]pellajl[/MENTION] I would never go there again and if you downloaded anything, delete it immediately and scan any devices for malware!
[Magisk] theandroidguy:
Same here.....Download the zip from Magisk thread and flash it manually

---------- Post added at 05:00 PM ---------- Previous post was at 04:57 PM ----------

It is not an official thread, Official Magisk can only be downloaded from tophjohnwu's XDA thread
[Magisk] gudenau:
It appears that Google updated SafetyNet, it no longer passes with Magisk v14.3.

Edit:

Core only passed, I'll check normal mode again.

Edit 2:

Just needed a reboot, it seems that "invincible" isn't invincible!
[Magisk] beardymarrow:
Nope, still working for me.
[Magisk] dominj97:
Works for me in normal mode ;)

Sent from my OP5
[Magisk] Massyboy:
Is there anyway of having SafetyNet pass with Xposed installed?
[Magisk] Fif_:
There we go again. Every 3rd post asks the same question. Can you read the OP? Good.

In more interesting news, Magisk 14.3 on OOS 4.5.13, OnePlus 5 works flawlessly so far.
[Magisk] RandomPooka:
A quick search would have shown you that you need to wipe data for the Magisk Manager app.
[Magisk] pellajl:
Point taken about the MagicManager site and will keep that in mind in the future.

However, back to the original issue, why the package downloaded from the correct thread fails to install. I haven't tried this yet, but why do you need create a folder named MagiciManager like other have done to get the package to install? To me it just doesn't make sense.

Can someone confirm the size of the file in MB of the file downloaded from the official thread?

Thanks
[Magisk] shaggyskunk:
It'd be just great if people would post a link to their Logs instead of pasting the entire log file.... Just sayin'

?

Sent from my SM-G955W ??
[Magisk] Sutcliffe9:
Thanks for this wonderful program, it is very much appreciated.
[Magisk] mfr122887:
I am having an issue that is driving me crazy. I have tried searching and it led to many deadends where the answer was never posted. This is my current setup:

Pixel on stock 7.1.2

TWRP RC2

ElementalX 1.15

Magisk 14.3

Here is the log:

10-21 13:39:56.884 446 446 I Magisk : Magisk v14.3(1437) daemon started
10-21 13:39:56.919 446 453 I Magisk : ** post-fs mode running
10-21 13:40:00.157 446 592 I Magisk : ** post-fs-data mode running
10-21 13:40:00.159 446 447 E Magisk : fopen: /cache/magisk.log failed with 1: Operation not permitted
10-21 13:40:00.160 446 592 I Magisk : * Creating /sbin overlay
10-21 13:40:00.161 446 592 I Magisk : * Mounting mirrors
10-21 13:40:00.161 446 592 I Magisk : bind_mount: /system_root/system -> /dev/magisk/mirror/system
10-21 13:40:00.161 446 592 I Magisk : mount: /dev/block/dm-0 -> /dev/magisk/mirror/vendor
10-21 13:40:00.162 446 592 I Magisk : bind_mount: /data/magisk -> /dev/magisk/mirror/bin
10-21 13:40:00.162 446 592 I Magisk : * Setting up internal busybox
10-21 13:40:00.173 446 592 I Magisk : * Mounting /data/magisk.img
10-21 13:40:10.297 603 603 I Magisk : Magisk v14.3(1437) daemon started
10-15 17:55:26.024 1354 1354 I Magisk : Magisk v14.3(1437) daemon started
10-15 17:55:26.027 1354 1411 I Magisk : * Starting MagiskHide
10-15 17:55:26.027 1354 1411 I Magisk : hide_utils: Hiding sensitive props
10-15 17:55:26.029 1354 1411 E Magisk : fopen: /magisk/.core/hidelist failed with 2: No such file or directory
10-15 17:55:26.029 1354 1411 I Magisk : hide_list add: [com.google.android.gms.unstable]
10-15 17:55:26.071 1354 1411 E Magisk : fopen: /magisk/.core/hidelist failed with 2: No such file or directory
10-15 17:55:26.071 1354 1411 I Magisk : proc_monitor: init ns=mnt:[4026531840]
10-15 17:55:28.187 1354 1411 I Magisk : proc_monitor: zygote ns=mnt:[4026534243] zygote64 ns=mnt:[4026534244]

It seems that /magisk is getting mounted as read only. Magisk Hide apps do not persist after a reboot and all modules look like they install successfully but after the required reboot they are not listed.

I was originally on PureNexus and have been upgrading Magisk as the new versions were released. When I tried 14.3 I could not get the module (Xposed v88 or v88.1) installed. After trying stock kernel, stock boot image, and all variations it would not work. I wiped and installed the factory 7.1.2 image. Went through all of the setup and I still cannot get the module to install. SafetyNet passes, systemless hosts works, root is hidden. Any help would be greatly appreciated.
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
Magisk v14.3 should solve your installation issue: https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/beta-magisk-v13-0-0980cb6-t3618589
[Magisk] andreasy:
I read everywhere that with Magisk's systemless root, we are also able to flash OTA updates but this I assume needs a few clarifications:

1) Is this still possible with Custom ROMS or only on stock?

2) In order to flash OTA, SafetyNet must pass check so first we disable XPosed. (Y/N)

3) Now, where do I find the OTA updates if I have Samsung S7 Edge? I never saw an offline OTA file, just full ROMs on Sammobile.
[Magisk] Artim_96:
1. Custom ROMs normally give a sh** about root/Magisk/whatever and their OTA update path are quite strange

2. Most likely

3. You won't find those files, but you can Google where the phone saves them if it downloads them. Then you just have to wait for one
[Magisk] andreasy:
Clear enough. I use the SuperStock ROM but apparently software update is disabled, obviously for a reason. In conclusion, I cannot flash OTA updates most probably, right?
[Magisk] Artim_96:
I have no idea. That is something you have to ask your ROM dev
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
You cannot install an official OTA update on a custom ROM...

If the ROM has OTA functionality it's a completely different thing and it's probably nowhere near as strict as an official OTA.
[Magisk] faisalsiddiqui:
If I have adaway installed with root permission from Magisk why do i need systemless hosts? Additionally, is there any advantage of using unified adblock hosts module over adaway?

Thanks
[Magisk] :
Hello! Could you make an adaptive icon for your application, please?
[Magisk] asterius:
Did anyone tried Maigsk on MTK6580 with Android 6.0 with out root permissions? I saw signatures with chinese phones like my config below at topic. Need your expertise.
[Magisk] patzzz:
Error mounting /magisk directory

I have installed Magisk 14.0 and 14.3 without errors from TWRP 3.1.1-0 in Nexus 10 with PureNexus 7.1.2, but both are returning this error in log:

mount /dev/block/loop0->/magisk failed with 22: Invalid argument

/magisk directory is mounted as read-only and post-fs-data.d and service.d directories aren't created, although MagiskSU is working correctly.

I attach the Magisk log.

Is possible fix this error?

Thanks.
[Magisk] Part.0:
i dont know if this the right thread to report regarding safety net.

safety net check fails with 14.3. has done all combinations (update within manager, via twrp, reflashed boot img, etc,,still doesnt work) and sometimes phone got stuck on loading stage after rebooting.

device info; OnePlus X, custom aosp-oreo rom, no exposed, no modules, *fresh from the oven

-logs attached
[Magisk] St Sinned:
What is the meaning of the red one? What is the use of this? Is this an error? TIA..
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
The purpose would be to prevent AdAway from modifying /system.

Personally, I like the Unified Hosts module because it's an easy way to get a good hosts file (contains a lot of records), it doesn't require me installing an extra app and I can easily automate updating the hosts file with Tasker.

Take a look here if anything's applicable to your situation:

https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/guide-magisk-troubleshooting-t3641417

It means MagiskHide is working, but your device/ROM isn't properly certified for SafetyNet by Google. More reading here:

https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/guide-magisk-troubleshooting-t3641417
[Magisk] St Sinned:
Thank u
[Magisk] Diomorgan:
Disabling what? They are already hidden on magisk.

Does your intesa san paolo pyago work now? :)

Thank you
[Magisk] bmg002:
Thanks for the tip about downgrading; unfortunately it didn't help. Downgrading to 13.3 (which on the MIUI forum indicated it should work), didn't help. I think it is a problem with the MIUI ROM version 8.5.2.0. I think the only solution I can see is to downgrade my ROM or switch off of the global stable in favor of the developer ROM, but I'm not sure that'll help pass safetynet or help with magisk hide either. I updated to the latest magisk (14.3) and still no luck. I think the problem with magiskhide is with the proc_monitor part. I see it in my log, but only for init ns=mnt:[4026531840]; I don't see it doing anything for any other process like I've seen in this thread for other processes. I believe that the log should have a proc_monitor entry for each process being monitored for magiskhide, no?

running ps | grep magisk shows me I have 2 processes with magisk in the name running (magisk_daemon and the magisk app which I have set to always run on my phone). Running magiskhide --enable says it is already running. I tried putting Rootbeer sample into magiskhide and it still detects root files. So going to do more digging and see what I can figure out.

Unrelated but with Magisk Manager 5.4.0, if you turn on the dark theme and go into the log, the save, delete and refresh icons are nearly invisible. I think those should invert too with the dark theme.
[Magisk] Lamba92:
MagiskHide does not hide Developer Options, It hides root to whatever app you decide. So if the Intesa San Paolo app detects Developer Options enabled and/or adb enabled PayGo and other security-hungry features will be disabled.

Summarizing, yes it works if you disable developer options and enable MagiskHide, or at least it should. I tried it on a OnePlus One with Sultanxda's LineageOS and works like a charm.
[Magisk] ggkameleon:
Hi ! I have an Oneplus 3 with Fos 2.12 (Oos 4.5) with Magisk 14.0 and manager 5.3.

But when I update to manager 5.4 the app crash !?

I had rollback to 5.3 and work fine now.

But I receive always a notif for update it.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
If you don't want to update, turn off notifications in the settings.

If you want to update, try uninstalling 5.3.0 first and then install 5.4.0 clean...
[Magisk] bmg002:
Update - So I think I narrowed down that it ISN'T busybox related. I replaced busybox (using the /cache/magisk_mount folder) with the one from /data/magisk and same thing. I then got curious what would happen if I used that folder to replace busybox with a blank file, essentially removing busybox. First thing I noticed is my device booted a LOT faster. Root checker was weird about it... it still found it but was not sure what to do with it but it thought the blank file should be runnable. I changed the permissions on the files (chmod 600) and gave it another shot and it looks like magisk automatically resets the permissions in the magisk_mount folder to match what is live. If I do an "ls -al busybox" on the magisk_mount/system/bin folder before rebooting but after running chmod 600 busybox it says that the permissions are -rw-------. After reboot they change back to the same as what is in system of -rwxr-xr-x (or 755).

One thing I did notice that I'm not sure if it makes a difference or not, but if I load up adb shell, run su followed by getprop | grep magisk, it says the magisk_daemon is running, magisk_pfs is stopped, magisk_pfsd is stopped and magisk_service is stopped. Is that normal or should those all be running?
[Magisk] GalaxyS3only:
Hey!

My setup:

samsung galaxy S3

newest nightly of LineageOs 14.1

Magisk 14 + MagiskSU

TWRP 3.0.2-2

My problem are maybe systemcrashs or Black Screen of deaths...everything works fine, but sometimes phone won't wake up after locking...screen stays black, no button works except longholding the powerbutton til reboot...

I'm not sure if the problem is @ Magisk or @ lineageos, but it appears even at fresh system and without any installed Magisk modules.

i need magisk for ViperFx+Dolby Athmos ;)

thx for your help and greetz
[Magisk] mfr122887:
Seems like these problems are all related to /magisk being read-only. Does anyone know what's going on with this?
[Magisk] Meowdib:
I have the same issue on the Moto G5 Plus and Stock ROM
[Magisk] seshanth:
Magisk version 5.4.0 , unable to unpack boot image.

While the last stable version of magisk patches the same boot image .

Edit:

It seems the problem is not with magisk manager app but with the zip. Magisk v14.0 patched the same boot image,but unsuccessful with magisk v14.3 and previous beta version.
[Magisk] santo_007:
Magisk installation error

Showing boot image already patched by other program. I just installed SuperSU and custom kernel.how to solve this
[Magisk] seshanth:
Flash UNSU zip then give it a try...
[Magisk] SDMU:
Hello !

In the Magisk Manager is it possible to add an option to sort modules by creation/addition date . That would make it much easier to find out the newly added modules .
[Magisk] ggkameleon:
Thanks for your support. :laugh:

But the safetynet work too with the 5.4 .0 ? I see a lot of mistake.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
No issues on my devices.
[Magisk] drewski_1:
Works for me :svetius:
[Magisk] ggkameleon:
Ok ! Great..

I make the update for see. Uninstall 5.3.0 and then install clean 5.4.0.. thank you ;)
[Magisk] Phenomzye:
Hello everyone. I am running Magisk Manager 5.3.0 and it's been prompting me to install 5.4.0, I would love to, but it simply does nothing when I tap "update", and I can't even install it manually because the "Next" button is greyed out. Here's a video of my issue:

https://youtu.be/GRoAqHX_6ZY

Why does this happen?​
[Magisk] Vivek Kantesaria:
[MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] I m using latest beta and 5.4.0 manager when i check safety net status it just keeps loading not showing anything..

---------- Post added at 08:18 AM ---------- Previous post was at 08:16 AM ----------

You can flash the zip
[Magisk] Phenomzye:
The zip flashes Magisk, not Magisk Manager, which is what it's telling me to update
[Magisk] Vivek Kantesaria:
Check common folder of the zip i have 14.3 beta with 5.4.0 manager
[Magisk] Phenomzye:
Oh, you were talking about the beta, I don't have the beta version, I flashed the latest 14.0 zip (you can see it between my flashable files if you watch closely at the video) but why I can't have 14.0 and 5.4.0 manager? can't update, yet it's telling me to do so
[Magisk] Vivek Kantesaria:
What if you uninstall current version and install latest 5.4.0? After backing up your current version..
[Magisk] manmoy123:
Privacy concerns with certain apps on a rooted phone

Ive googled the concern I have, but I havent found the answer.

With the introduction of certain applications using an app blacklist function (yes pogo just introduced such a function into the apk), I have a privacy concern that some app developers will blacklist the "Official TWRP app", the "Magisk Manager" app, even the "unhide Magisk Manager", and apps like "Service Disabler" and even the "SafetyNet test" app. All these apps are only present on a rooted phone, so its likely to tell the app developer that they are dealing with a rooted phone and can ban the gaming account.

Is there a way to "hide" certain applications from showing up using eg. the "App extractor" list ? Remember the "app extractor" doesnt require storage permission to list all installed apps - which in itself is a giant security issue on android.

I have Samsung S8 with magisk 0.14 and latest magisk 5.4 manager.
[Magisk] jelive:
See if app info has storage permission allowed.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
It's a bug in Manager v5.3.0. Give it storage permission manually and it should work... Or uninstall v5.3.0 and download v5.4.0 from the release thread and install it manually.
[Magisk] danilo_scala:
i have same problem in xperia z5 premium, only magisk 12 install but safety net no pass, .... magisk version 13 and 14 no install and no root.
[Magisk] adeich:
magisk 14.2 install safety net pass, magisk 14.3 install but safety net no pass :(

logs
[Magisk] Jesus Follower Daniel S:
Magisk app stuck at magisk logo

I have a Meizu Pro 5 running CM 12.1: I've used v14.0 and v14.3, as well as managers 5.3.5 and 5.4.0. Magisk installs fine, but then when I open the app it gets stuck on the magisk logo. Clearing the app data makes no difference.

I've searched, but I can't find a working solution. What can I do?
[Magisk] hoost_pt:
Any way to put SEQR app (contactless payment) working?

App selected in Magisk hide.

https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.seamless.seqr

Oneplus one with 7.1.2 Tugapower Rom
[Magisk] tangcla:
I'm having difficulty installing Magisk 14.0 from the app with the patched boot.img.

The app generates the patched file successfully, I flash it successfully, but when the boot logo comes up, the phone vibrates twice and proceeds no further. Is anyone able to provide insight on this?

Samsung Galaxy S7, stock Nougat firmware.
[Magisk] BlackTangerine:
Trouble uninstalling magisk

I've searched this thread and I don't think I've found a comment regarding getting into this particular problem, anyhow.

I have Magisk v14.0 with Magisk manager v5.3.0 on a Samsung S6 edge SM-G925F UAE XSG 7.0 on stock rom. I installed the most current version of TWRP and flashed Magisk (I believe it's a dirty flash, I didn't fact. restore anything), after that I made a recovery.

Although Magisk worked apart from some instances of root being lost (which I known is a problem), I went about uninstalling magisk using the uninstaller and the uninstall button within the manager

The uninstaller I flashed using TWRP and it leads me into a bootloop. The only way to remove the bootloop is to reflash Magisk.

I retrieved the original boot.img from /data/magisk although the logs from magisk_uninstaller shows it does restore the backed up boot.img, so I don't think flashing a boot.img via odin will do anything.

Does anyone have any suggestion on what I can do? As far as I understand because I flashed Magisk and then made the backup - this backup is useless

Cheers

Log

https://pastebin.com/g1ntsURq TWRP

https://pastebin.com/eam4HdHX Kernal
[Magisk] uodii:
Did you happen to figure this one out? I'm running into the same issue and it's bugging the crap out of me.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Question: Does MagiskHide work at all? Check by adding a root app to the Hide list and see if it still can make su requests.

Provide a logcat from when you open the Manager.
[Magisk] ali.ahmad:
I installed latest version of magisk beta but having problem with safety net, log attached

Need help.
[Magisk] SaadatM:
Well, we meet again [MENTION=4667597]Didgeridoohan[/MENTION] haha!

Same odd issue like last time, Magisk V14 and Manager 5.4, installed modules and rebooted and in the manager under the modules section, there is none listed.

Logcat attached, tried mount/grep on magisk like last time but Terminal isn't responding (command mount | grep "on /magisk" returns nothing, just a new empty line)
[Magisk] Alan-B:
Hi,

With version 13.5 I have no problems installing my rom.zip. But with version 1.4 some commands to install zip in the updater-script, the zip does not install!

Model:

ui_print("-> Installer Magisk-Script");

package_extract_dir("Pyrana/magisk-perm-script", "/tmp/magisk-perm-script");

run_program("/sbin/busybox", "unzip", "/tmp/magisk-perm-script/magisk-perm-script.zip", "META-INF/com/google/android/*", "-d", "/tmp/magisk-perm-script");

run_program("/sbin/busybox", "sh", "/tmp/magisk-perm-script/META-INF/com/google/android/update-binary", "dummy", "1", "/tmp/magisk-perm-script/magisk-perm-script.zip");

delete_recursive("/magisk-perm-script");

Work to 13.5 and not work to 14.0

A solution idea ?
[Magisk] Part.0:
magiskSU working just fine here, but fails on safety net. im sure they're working on it to make stable release
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Could you test on beta v14.3? There's been a lot of changes since v14.0... And for most users it seems quite stable.
[Magisk] Part.0:
create manual folder named "MagiskManager" in sdcard (internal storage) and retry
[Magisk] mfr122887:
Same for me.

Safetynet passes for me. I just cant install modules and the hide list resets after a reboot.
[Magisk] SaadatM:
Alright! Will switch to V14.3, thanks again!
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Does MagiskHide work at all for you? Test by adding a root app to the Hide list and then see if it still can get su access.
[Magisk] ali.ahmad:
Safetynet pass when i do a reboot but after 5 to 10 mins it fails.

Magiskhide works well
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Could you upload your magisk_debug.log (it's in /data) from after when you no longer pass SafetyNet.
[Magisk] Jesus Follower Daniel S:
Logcat

Attached is a Logcat (from Matlog).

I just tried RR 6.0.1, and Magisk works flawlessly, so I'm settled.
[Magisk] adeich:
MagiskHide included. shutdown inclusion restart does not help, does not pass the test safety

Root working
[Magisk] k0m3n9:
I'm a bit confused now after I read your post here... Should the Hide Magisk list of app filled with root app or filled with app that detects root? :confused:

There's a latest new issue with my device which run Magisk14.3 with latest Magisk manager... After adding an apk to the Magisk Hide list, it seems that the app still can detect root status of my device
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
You add apps that you don't want to detect root to the Hide list. If an app is added to the MagiskHide list but it can still detect root, there's generally two possible causes:

MagiskHide isn't working.

The app is just too good at detecting root.
[Magisk] suirzes:
How would you suggest to track a bootloop caused by systemless xposed installation on note8?
[Magisk] Pkt_Lnt:
logcat

https://xdaforums.com/showthread.php?t=1726238
[Magisk] Joe_6pak:
Can someone help me? I've got a rooted MDK Galaxy S4 (rooted with Supersu) running stang5litre V3. Like this ROM OK, but I want to try Lineage OS and Magisk for "something new". I can flash the ROM OK, but when I attempt to flash Magisk 14.0 I get the "Error 1" message. I tried flashing the boot.img file in the Lineage ROM and flashed Magisk, but got the dreaded Verizon "yellow triangle - unauthorized software found on your device. Return to authorized Verizon dealer" message. I was able to reboot my device by restoring my nandroid. Do I need to do a Supersu Full Unroot before flashing the ROM? Do I have a bad install file? Is there a different boot image I should be flashing? Totally lost and want to use this - all help appreciated.
[Magisk] Pkt_Lnt:
Can you post logs? Recovery log, Magisk log, Magisk debug log, and logcat?
[Magisk] bmg002:
Turns out it was just my ROM. Put on the Global Developer ROM, installed Magisk 14.3, installed universal safetynet fix and boom! safetynet is passing!. without the usnf it would fail the ctsprofile check, but pass basic integrity.

looks like the global stable MIUI ROM (version 8.5.2.0) just doesn't support Magisk properly.
[Magisk] Joe_6pak:
I wish I could, but I think they got wiped out when I restored my backup. I found the recovery log, but that's about it. Where should I look for the others (besides the logcat, that is)?
[Magisk] randyok@:
Why I can't press install? I tried download the apk again and the same result.
[Magisk] Pkt_Lnt:
Magisk Manager has a menu item for Logs, and the debug log will be in data (only in beta builds) as topjohnwu states in the release thread.
[Magisk] thatOneWeeaboo:
it's probably a pretty much basic Android security: you might have a screen overlay or similar enabled. Package manager will disable the Install button if you have any overlays on screen (screen filter, floating assist buttons, chat heads etc) to prevent tapjacking

Try temporarily disable those before trying again
[Magisk] k0m3n9:
This is what I've found from dex of that app..

any idea on how to avoid from such detection?