yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] biggoldfish:
I have tried flash EX kernel before Magisk, and the problem still exists.

However, it seems that it is just a UI problem in Magisk Manager, rather than losing root actually, root access grant dialog can still be prompted and other app can get root access if granted

Screenshot: https://goo.gl/photos/GtvTSsSiMpVgwAA16

Thank you for your help anyway
[Magisk] dahawthorne:
Just a suggestion. You could try Magisk v13 and Manager 5. Yesterday I migrated my Nexus 10 from SuperSU to Magisk v12 and it didn't work, but as soon as I installed v13 and Manager 5 it was 100%. It seems hit and miss - it may be a combination of device/ROM/setup where some are OK and some aren't.

https://github.com/stangri/MagiskFiles

V13 flashes over v12 easily. If you have problems installing Manager 5 (as I did), uninstall v4 first.
[Magisk] Jithin0801:
Could u plz say step by step i am new to this
[Magisk] yochananmarqos:
You said you already tried Mount Magisk. Delete /magisk/Udb_Remover and reboot.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Yeah... Don't put the log in your post. Attach as a text file or use pastebin (or similar).

The log is probably not gonna show anything useful unless you cause the app to trigger by detecting root. And even then, the chance of actually finding anything useful is really, really low...
[Magisk] Jithin0801:
after flashing the mount magisk zip what should i do?
[Magisk] yochananmarqos:
I just told you.
[Magisk] Jithin0801:
Sry bro I didnt get that method it would b more helpful if u xplain it step by step
[Magisk] Lubo99:
MATLOG log.

ok txt attached.

seems like there is more now. i searched for string skylink and found some interesting staff which I do not understand LOL.

this line worries me:

05-27 19:09:29.786 I/KnoxTimeoutHandler(3982): Target Activity is not fullscreen. We will not show this activity0
[Magisk] yochananmarqos:
1. Flash Mount Magisk in TWRP

2. Use the TWRP file manager to browse to /magisk and delete the Udb_Remover folder

3. Reboot
[Magisk] Dark❶:
Instead use uninstaller.

Instead of breaking ur head ....

Use uninstaller given by the author of the module here in this topic : https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=71533217&postcount=1

Uninstaller flashable ZIP is here : https://www.androidfilehost.com/?fid=673368273298947369

Best regards.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
I'd say it has something to do with these lines and what happens between them:

05-27 19:09:35.276 I/Drm (3726): virtual status_t android::Drm::openSession(Vector<uint8_t> &) is called from nl.streamgroup.skylinksk(pid:17523)
05-27 19:09:37.216 I/Drm (3726): virtual status_t android::Drm::closeSession(const Vector<uint8_t> &) is called from nl.streamgroup.skylinksk(pid:17523)

I don't think there's much you can do with Magisk and this app... If you really want to figure out more about what's going on I'd say the next step would be to decompile the apk and try to find the code that deals with DRM. My know-how ends here though. Good luck.
[Magisk] Lubo99:
aaaa fu...k it! I think I will use dual boot. one image rooted and one not rooted.
[Magisk] jrmt077:
Hi all, I wanted to share my experience. On a Droid Turbo OG, systemless rooted and exposed. I was originally on SuperSU & exposed, which I uninstalled root using SuperSU, then installed Magisk V12, moved to Magisk systemless exposed. So no matter what I tried following the troubleshooting guide, like many here, I failed Safetnet. Today I decided on a clean start, so I TWRP flashed the latest TWRP flash-able ROM for my device & kernel to hide unlocked bootloader, and using Safetynet attest app, I passed. So next I flashed Magisk V12, confirmed I was rooted, and failed the Safetynet test. This was because the root re-activated my Magisk systemless exposed, which will give a fail. I disabled the systemless exposed via switch, rebooted, and passed Safetynet. Then I went into Magisk hide, and ticked off Netflix and the Safetynet attest app, Android pay is already hidden. The Safetnet attest app verifies Safetynet pass using Magisk hide. Now Android pay is working, Netflix re-appeared in my play store apps. So routinely I will reactivate sysyemless exposed, when I want to use Google pay, I switch exposed off and reboot. All seems well so far.
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
Xposed isn't compatible with Magisk Hide
[Magisk] jrmt077:
Yes that is why I said I switch stystemless exposed OFF to pass Safetnet test. Thanks.
[Magisk] admicos:
Can the magisk su log section show all commands instead of just saying:

command: /system/bin/sh

I miss this from SuperSU since I want to know what the root apps I have do.
[Magisk] biggoldfish:
Thanks for your advice. I'm in a trip now and will try that when I'm back.
[Magisk] Chucknorris1975:
Lost root happened again. Busy box was never enabled to begin with.

Log

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1dQ_GIT4KOTo3TsaGq9LvkfymC7UcfGIl2qmVwLWO2i0/edit?usp=drivesdk
[Magisk] valeriee:
Hey guys I am running OP3 with OOS OP16 with Franco Kernel r23. I am systemless root with SuperSU but magisk is giving me an error for CTS profile mismatch and I don't know what to do... I've deleted SuperSu app as well as Busybox but no luck? Any help would be much appreciated!!!
[Magisk] xAnubiSx1:
Magisk doesn't work with SuperSU, after removing it you should flash the boot image of your rom (or a dirty flash rom)
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Looks like Magisk Hide is going completely haywire one your device. I suspect that's your issue... Try going without Hide for a while and see if the issue appears or not.
[Magisk] dw24:
I'm trying to install Magisk v12 but is not working. Gives me error 1.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Flash a stock boot image (one that isn't patched for SuperSU) and try again.
[Magisk] dw24:
But will that make me install TWRP again? It was very difficult the first time
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
No. You don't have to flash your entire ROM/factory image. Extract the boot.img from the ROM file and flash it in TWRP. Most of the times that's just a matter of opening the file as a zip file and copy the boot.img.
[Magisk] dw24:
Where do I find it? ?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
On XDA you're encouraged to do most of the work yourself by researching your issue... There's tons of information around and a pretty good search function. Google is also very useful.

A good place to start is your device's forum. I'd happily point you in the right direction, but since you haven't given much information I have no idea what device you have. Just type your device's name into the search bar at the top of the page and you'll find it.
[Magisk] Artim_96:
You have many entries from Magisk hide at the end of your log.

Only add apps that really need to be added and see if maybe Magisk hide itself is the cause. Because for most the problem is busybox but there were also claims that Magisk hide was the cause of root loss
[Magisk] aeroxy:
Is it just me or the busybox doesn't work well?

Here is my code:

Apparently busybox doesn't recognize `route add -net 1.0.1.0 netmask 255.255.255.0 gw $gateway`...

Update: I tried to update to magisk 12.0, and now it just shows applet not found instead...

BTW, what's SafetyNet?
[Magisk] dahawthorne:
A senior member doesn't know how to use Google...?
[Magisk] aeroxy:
A senior member doesn't know Google is blocked for 45% of the internet users?
[Magisk] KevinX8:
And uh all other search engines in existence and VPNs and proxies too?
[Magisk] dahawthorne:
Wow. New York has blocked Google? Things over there are worse than I thought... :)
[Magisk] aeroxy:
Like which search engine exacly? Bing.cn? Or Baidu? Apparently SafetyNet is a Chinese program that prevents unsafe materials such as Google to pollute the internet for the good citizens of China and other friendly allies such as Iran.

---------- Post added at 07:00 AM ---------- Previous post was at 06:59 AM ----------

I will patiently wait until I get back to new york to Google SafetyNet if someone else hasn't already told me what it was. :)
[Magisk] dahawthorne:
Now we're getting into the realms of fantasy and conspiracy theory, so to help my XDA colleague I looked it up in Google:

"The SafetyNet API provides access to Google services that help you assess the health and safety of an Android device."
[Magisk] dw24:
Actually, there are countries who's internet access is heavily restricted. Is not fantasy.
[Magisk] dahawthorne:
I was referring to "SafetyNet is a Chinese program". I'm well aware of internet restrictions in China.
[Magisk] trewelu:
How to change boot animation using magisk? is there a module for that?
[Magisk] jrmt077:
This has been interesting, but respectfully, lets get back on topic.
[Magisk] yochananmarqos:
Check out the Magisk All-In-One Wiki under Cache mounts.
[Magisk] Imp_GL:
** Magisk post-fs mode running...

** Magisk post-fs-data mode running...

* Running post-fs-data.d

* Loading core props

* Preparing modules

* Stage 1: Mount system and vendor mirrors

* Stage 2: Mount dummy skeletons

* Stage 3: Mount module items

* Stage 4: Execute module scripts

* Stage 5: Mount mirrored items back to dummy

** Magisk late_start service mode running...

* Enabling systemless hosts file support

* Linking binaries to /sbin

* Starting MagiskSU

* Running service.d

service.d: /magisk/.core/service.d/radio_magisksu.sh

* Starting MagiskHide

MagiskHide: Moving and re-linking /sbin binaries

MagiskHide: Removing dangerous read-only system props

MagiskHide: Killing com.google.android.gms.unstable

MagiskHide: Killing ru.mos.helper

MagiskHide: Starting MagiskHide daemon

MagiskHide: Update process/package list:

MagiskHide: [com.google.android.gms.unstable]

MagiskHide: [ru.mos.helper]

Zygote(0) ns=�

MagiskHide: com.google.android.gms.unstable(PID=5022 ns=[0 5022 10009 com.google.android.gms.unstable service com.google.android.gms/.droidguard.DroidGuardService]

)

It makes sense to create an issue and send out boot.img?
[Magisk] DNikola:
magisk says is rooted and ccleaner says is not..i can't give root acces to ccleaner
[Magisk] tag68:
Open some terminal. Type su. If you get asked for root permission, ask ccleaner support why it does not recognize root if su is available via path.

My opinion: No app should rely on fixed paths. No app should search in any hardcoded path! Not additionally, not "just to make sure". Just shouldn't.
[Magisk] bggold:
Anyone been able to get flashfire v.57 working with ElementalX-P-1.11 and Magisk V12-pixel on a pixel xl? I have Magisk working and it is wonderful. I miss using the backup/restore feature with fashfire since it backs up all your data unlike TWRP.

By the way the issue I am having is that when I try to do a backup on reboot it just gives me the black screen

Thanks
[Magisk] DNikola:
i try..nothing happens
[Magisk] tag68:
For me it usually works fine and asks for permission if not already granted. Then I wonder why Magisk tells that root would be ok. Does this stay the same if you take the task list, close Magisk Manager and then start it again? Does it then still tell root would be fine?
[Magisk] DNikola:
I uninstalld magiak and flashed supersu 2.79 old version..and i try terminal and su give me access root but only ccleaner not..
[Magisk] trewelu:
I have read that but i got this issue.
[Magisk] zeft64:
I'm using the stock room on the Moto g5 plus. Is it safe to mount busy box? Will I lose root if I do this?
[Magisk] wheels01:
I have Magisk installed on a Nexus 6P with PN Rom and Flash Kernel. Been using it for a long time. It hides root for several apps that I need for work. However it does not hide root from the United Airlines App. I fly often and everytime I try and use the personal device entertainment I get an error message that the devices is not compatible due to root. Any ideas why only this app gives me this issue.

Thanks!
[Magisk] puneet724:
Hi, I have baught pixel xl recently. I have just unlocked bootloader, flashed custom recovery and super su. I just wanted to check can magisk be flashed directly through twrp on stock rom and will i be able to install modules thereafter or i need to have custom rom for that purpose.
[Magisk] teddy0209:
I don't know about the progress of support for pixel devices, but you can try the v13 snapshots...
[Magisk] Chucknorris1975:
Switched Magisk hide off and busybox has never been turned on, and I still problems.
[Magisk] Artim_96:
Then try without cache mount. Just create the media folder inside the already existing system folder and put your bootanimation there
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Wasn't your problem loss of root? Looks like you have root now...
[Magisk] Chucknorris1975:
I feel silly for not describing the problem properly but what I meant was that Magisk wasn't hiding root. Not passing Safety net check. Would work fine then out of the blue apps would stop working because of safety net check.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
That makes more sense.

Your log shows that the Hide list is getting updated a huge number of times, seemingly out of control. That's probably why it isn't working.

Try the latest unofficial beta snapshot (both Magisk and the Manager) and see if that works better.
[Magisk] Chucknorris1975:
Looks complicated. :eek:
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
It's not...

Flash the Magisk snapshot zip in recovery. If you want to be completely sure nothing's interfering you can flash the official Magisk uninstaller first.. Uninstall the official Manager and install the snapshot version. Done. Activate Hide and see if it works.
[Magisk] habylab:
Feel free to shout at me, but how do I install/enable MagiskSU?

I used Magisk a while ago, and want to use it again to hide root for Android Pay usage. I currently have Super SU, which I believe, correct me if I'm wrong, doesn't work when trying to hide root from Android Pay.
[Magisk] Chucknorris1975:
Done. So far so good. Will repost if any troubles. :good:
[Magisk] dahawthorne:
Flash Osmosis' unsu.zip, flash your ROM's clean unrooted boot image, flash Magisk, install Magisk Manager apk. Done.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Full unroot in SuperSU app and let it restore your stock boot image. Alternatively you can use the unSU zip and flash a clean boot image yourself.

After that you'll just need to reinstall Magisk and you're done.

Edit: Ninja'd :laugh:
[Magisk] dahawthorne:
Snap... :)
[Magisk] boldonc:
When I'm using Magisk 12 with Magisk Hide the banking apps isn't working. If downgrade to v11.6 all (3) apps is working. :( What is changed?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Go here: https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/magisk-magisk-hide-troubleshooting-tips-t3561828

Look under: "Magisk v12 can't hide root (but v11.6 could)"
[Magisk] habylab:
Thanks both!
[Magisk] dimm0k:
anyone here using an LGV20? I finally switched from SuperSU to MagiskSU with Magisk 11.6 and while I'm able to use AndroidPay now, my device seems to be less stable. When opening up Settings for my device, it's taking a lot longer to load up and the theme I once applied which gave Settings a black background is no longer being applied. any ideas?
[Magisk] dnlilas:
Another confirmation that Magisk v13 and Manager v5 work for my Axon 7 A2017G on Nougat., while Magisk v12 and Manager v4.3.3 did not work for me.
[Magisk] Judson1975:
Maybe a newbie issue idk. I just installed aicp on my smp600 tablet. It comes with magisk 12 and manager 4.3 installed. I tried to dl and install magisk 13 but then I can't install manager 5 and can't uninstall the manager. Also with 4.3 it doesn't recognize 13, just wants me to install 12
[Magisk] spicervolt:
unable to set enforce

So, i'm trying to hide root from T Wallet apps but i'm failed. Magisk's log says that:

Permissive detected
Unable to set to enforce, hide the state

Fyi, i'm using Suemax PureBasic 3.1 for kernel. Anyone has any idea?
[Magisk] marcolino7:
Hi I running Magistik 12 and Magistik Manager 4.3.3, installed embedded into RaceRom 10 for note 4.

I Enabled Magistic Hide and all 3 check are green, but when I try to install any modules, I got and Error, without any detail.

I have a Note 4, Android is 6.0.1.

Do you have any suggestion? Thanks
[Magisk] dahawthorne:
Does Magisk 12 not work for you? You do know that v13 is under development? If v12 works, leave it alone.
[Magisk] PokemonTotalWar:
I had the same issue, you can uninstall it because v13 root should still work. If you can't do that, delete /system/app/MagiskManager from recovery. Perhaps locate and delete MagiskManager from /data/app/, too. Then you can install it
[Magisk] Judson1975:
It works kind of. If I do a hot reboot, just a soft boot it says I don't have root. Also I'm having trouble with fontfix and root toolbox which I used with lineage today change my font and boot loader
[Magisk] blcklgn:
Hello, I updated Magisk from 10.2 to 12. Now I get the notification that the binary of superuser is old and has to updated. How do I update the binary?
[Magisk] teddy0209:
Remove the phh superuser app...
[Magisk] dahawthorne:
I have no idea what fontfix and root toolbox are. And where does Lineage come into it? You said you installed aicp?

Magisk v13 and Manager 5 are a pair. Manager 4 doesn't know aboout v13. If you want to have Magisk and for whatever reason aren't happy with v12, you need to flash v13 and then install Manager 5. If v12 is installed v13 should install over the top ok.

Edit: you mention that you can't uninstall Manager 4. I had a similar refusal - Manager 5 complaining that there was already a Manager installed, and I could see no obvious way of uninstalling Manager 4. I'm on Pure Nexus with Nova Launcher - I don't know your ROM - Pure Nexus/Nova allows a long press on the Manager icon and then I got an "uninstall" option. Then I was able to install Manager 5.
[Magisk] blcklgn:
Thanks. I removed the phh superuser app and reinstalled Magisk Manager. I cant pass safety net "CTS profile mismatch".

In Magisk Manager settings I have activated:

- Magisk Hide

- Busybox

- Systemless hosts

Any idea, why I can't pass safety net?
[Magisk] Judson1975:
I was on lineage, just switched to aicp. Fontfix is an app to change your font. Root toolbox is actually a collection of programs in one app to allow you to have more control on your rooted device
[Magisk] dahawthorne:
I'm not sure if this comment is a reply to my comment above...? It looks as if you're answering my comment by replying to someone else's. Please see my comment above again, where I've added another couple of lines.
[Magisk] teddy0209:
Post the magisk log...

Or remove magisk, restore your boot.img and reinstall magisk v12....
[Magisk] blcklgn:
Only problems. After reboot of my device, Magisk says that the device is not rooted. I am near collapsing.

Why is the device not rooted after reboot?
[Magisk] Judson1975:
I am using galaxy note 10.1, smp-600, and aicp rom. It comes with magisk 4/12 preinstalled. I tried going thru app manager but it just disabled it, I tried a root uninstaller but it said I didn't have root access. I tried thru twrp and couldn't find files. Finally I booted, went to xplore file manager, found magisk folders in root and began deleting. I rebooted once again, full reboot, not partial, and was finally able to install manager 5 and all is working good now. For some reason I was having issues keeping root with 4/12. I'm really liking this aicp so I'm trying to get all working. And if I can maybe hide root from playstore so I can update Netflix direct on my tab instead of sending from my phone...
[Magisk] blcklgn:
Would it help, that I reflash superman rom for marshmallow and choose no magisk and no root during installation with aroma. I don't know if it is possible to choose nothing (Magisk and root).
[Magisk] teddy0209:
Did remove and reinstall?

In twrp remove magisk.img in /data, restore your roms boot.img, reflash magisk... A lot of changes from v10.1 to v12, so it's better if you start fresh...
[Magisk] MultiKoopa:
Just started using Magisk and MagiskSU today, since the latest SuperSU update apparently just removed superuser access from a bunch of devices. Magisk Hide is pretty fantastic!

I'm curious, what happens if you take a regular OTA update? (I'm on a Nexus 6P)

or, if, say, I use FlashFire to flash an OTA image file from Google's website? I'm assuming EverRoot can't re-inject MagiskSU, right?

but if I use FlashFire and keep my custom recovery, can I then just flash magisk again and restore magisksu that way?
[Magisk] blcklgn:
I made a clean install of superman rom just right now. Selected nothing (no Magisk, no superuser). If I download Magisk Manager from playstore and install, the device will be rooted?

How do I have to root the device?

Edit: After clean install it passes now safety net. Thanks for the support.
[Magisk] foosion:
I'm currently rooted with SuperSU 2.82 (Nexus 5 and 6P, both latest stock). When I try to install Magisk using the app, I give it permissions, click the install steps, it churns and I get "installation error!" at the end.

Should I use the SuperSU app to do a "Full unroot", then flash the Magisk zip v12.0 (downloaded by the app) using TWRP? Is there a better way or other steps I should take?

Once I have it installed, would I then install the Hide module, give permissions to the apps needing root permission, and proceed along as before?

Apologies for not finding the answer, as I can't be the only one in this situation.
[Magisk] Pkt_Lnt:
Full instructions from a few hours earlier.

https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=72470820&postcount=13986

https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=72470820&postcount=13987
[Magisk] Ashtrix:
With Systemless Xposed I can't get the SafetyNet passed is that supposed to be like that ? Because prior installing Xposed It passed safetynet.

Yeah, My bad, learnt a new thing ;)
[Magisk] schluger:
So I've noticed there is a lot of talk about updating Chainfire's SuperSu. What steps would I have to take to update from the Google Play Store.
[Magisk] CSX321:
No, I flashed ElementalX after Magisk, and it's all working fine.
[Magisk] SirVilhelm:
Same, flashed a kernel no problem.
[Magisk] djide01:
Can't wait for the update so I can use on DP5; Can't go back to eating Marshmallow after tasting Nougat..
[Magisk] :
Am I the only one who has actually tried making a purchase with AP? I am wondering if updating my build.prop or hosts file is causing the purchase to fail or if this just does not work at all for real world purchases out in the wild
[Magisk] mykenyc:
For some people in here i used PHH Supersu with Adaway and systemless adaway works as usual.
[Magisk] adrman:
Back when I was running phh, I couldn't get the systemless adaway zip to work and just created the bind mount manually instead. Good to hear it's working now.
[Magisk] bobby janow:
Agree, but let's wait for the N release for full support, including TWRP. For now we're testing.
[Magisk] mykenyc:
If a module isn't working that you flashed, what's the proper way to uninstall if your phone can't boot up? I did the waited 100 seconds bit and adb logcat isn't finding my device. my device Nexus 5x with stock image and Elementalx kernel.
[Magisk] mmoogle:
Doesn't work for me either. And I haven't messed with my hosts file or or build.prop.
[Magisk] waylo:
If everyone can post their phones/ROMs that would be super helpful for people trying to troubleshoot.

But that's sad to hear that Android Pay isn't working despite the safetynet fixes.