yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] HippoMan:
There was some small discussion about it within maybe 30 minutes or so before the channel was cleared.

It was a post which showed screenshots of some other messages from one or more other threads/channels somewhere, and which mentioned that huskydg isn't the one who actually wrote the comments, but someone else in a conversation he was in.

... or something like that.

But who knows? ... maybe that post itself was incorrect.

... or like I said, maybe I misunderstood.
[Magisk] sawdoctor:
The screenshots are also shared in the links @huskydg posted above you. Hopefully the real culprit for the language will be held to account whoever it was. Really can't afford to lose Devs and have them fighting
[Magisk] HippoMan:
Oh, I don't have access to the TG channel which contains the Hasuki Inu screenshots posted above my message, so I can't read those comments.

(By the way, "Hasuki Inu" is Japanese for "Husky Dog")

Thank you.
[Magisk] pndwal:
When the LSP post https://t.me/LSPosedArchives/4156?single was first made it clearly showed the comments were made by admin for HuskyDG Club... Now the author is redded out, but here are originals (censored):

Also, only 4 hours ago there were plenty of similar vulgar comments from the same author in that channel, eg if one searched with 'clog' etc as search terms, however these have all been expunged in the last few hours...

FWIW, @huskydg is blaming another "anonymous "admin he assigned for this comment:

but apparently the vulgar ones were simply his joke:

😶 PW
[Magisk] zgfg:
Not pointing to anybody particular but general comment:

Logical-Mathematical(STEM, Engineering, Programmers) Intelligence does not always come with Interpersonal-Social Intelligence

We have already seen that here several times
[Magisk] pndwal:
Not always, but an intelligent assessment says the logical answer is always the factual one... Unless the logic is flawed... We can all do the maths... PW
[Magisk] pndwal:
The culprit for the 'language' was clearly @hudskyDG... But agree it's certainly not representative of the feelings of this community as a whole...

Hope @canyie is still watching here... PW
[Magisk] zgfg:
Maybe, we can all do the math.

But we don't know all 'do'' the people
[Magisk] xcl1pse:
Nice now KernelSU got archived too
[Magisk] DougMG:
So to recap the score so far LSPosed, Zygisk Next and KernelSU are archived over all this B.S. Any wagers on when Shamiko joins the list?
[Magisk] pndwal:
Back a bit:

👀 PW
[Magisk] Nergal di Cuthah:
Well I'm lucky i don't need any of those projects that locked up, but if i understand what is hapening, which i don't, I'm sorry for your loss(es)
[Magisk] xcl1pse:
Shamiko already archived
[Magisk] DougMG:
Yep I saw that. I however was checking the Shamiko Github and it has not been changed to archived yet.
[Magisk] pndwal:
Since it's closed source (for very similar reasons, despite that they said they'd wished to open source it), you can't see repo... It's not public... There's only the LSPosed release link on GitHub... PW
[Magisk] huskydg:
They start archived it because many of clown reactions. (Some rumours said that I told other people to react the clown while i did nothing 🤷‍♂️). I wonder why they would care about it.

Then they broke into chat and took a screenshot of my joke with my member in chat. And it doesn't mean any bad meaning about their projects

The second screenshot of a message of an anonymous admin of my chat, which was sent over a year, one of devs complain about it and I already apologized for that. And then I don't know why they take serious about it again 🤷‍♂️
[Magisk] DougMG:
Don't know if it's related to the LSPosed debacle but MRepo github is archived now.
[Magisk] sawdoctor:
So is PIF and KernelSu
[Magisk] zgfg:
Good excuse now for stopping to provide support
[Magisk] carlosbellino:
It's not their obligation, they also have a right to protest in the way they want it.

What you wrote it's basically the kind of toxicity that leads people to get pissed and stop wanting to keep contributing to the community..
[Magisk] zgfg:
Interested how many and where did you contribute to the community (apps, modules on Github, helping here on XDA, etc) to judge about that

Btw, I'm certainly not the one who posted any pissing-off comments on the TG channels - long ago stopped reading those channels where 4/5 posts are zoo pictures and the rest are ever repeating questions and answers, or rages (with the same types of vulgarity as now being offended about) when one normally asked something or pointed to a problem or an issues - those who ever joined that channels would well know which channel I'm talking about

Also, if you know anything from the background, you will see that PIF developer has nothing with the group around LSPosed and what was happening about Alpha/LSPosed on their Chinese TG channel

Anyway, think whatever you want, I'm not interested in the further discussion
[Magisk] pndwal:
Did PIF go down?... Cos it looks up now... 🤔 PW
[Magisk] borisSweden:
So people have noticed that freaking RCS breaks of you dont pass SN and PI. Can someone log and check what's needed to pass just to make RCS work?
[Magisk] Lord Sithek:
Yea, kind of protest I think :ROFLMAO: What a ****storm...
[Magisk] sawdoctor:
He archived bootloader spoofer and pif in support of lsposed Devs but had no intention of shelving them
[Magisk] JazonX:
Sooooo ... G00gl3 Finally Won?
[Magisk] conspibro:
Seriously? Pulling the petty card just over some words and reactions? Geez...

You guys are making Google's job a lot easier. They need not lift a finger when the community is already fighting amongst itself.

If the devs are around, my suggestion would be to take a short mental break, then close the Discord and TG channels, and focus on just Github. DC+TG are just rife for abuse. Just get on with it, the community is very appreciative, I'm sure.
[Magisk] Lu5ck:
In the beginning, the banks and governments apps alike try to kill root.

Then Google try to kill root.

Ultimately, the community kill itself.
[Magisk] mrjuniork:
Hello everyone out there, hope you are having a good one 😃

I have deleted some posts, since they contained disrespect and violated our forum rules.

There is nothing wrong with having some sort of discussion (clearly visible at the thread title), but it is definitely not appreciated to cross the line!

@carlosbellino

Pardon my bluntness, but I wanted to make sure for everyone to know, that the individual is definitely not someone, who "screws the community", quite the opposite, a highly knowledgeable member with quite some history on XDA. This is not TG, this is XDA.

Quite the developments lately, yes, but I hope that we can at least find a way towards "agree to disagree", without the ugly part. Too much of that out there already.

Cheers,

mrjuniork
[Magisk] makeyourself:
Seems the like the likes of Telegram are a big part of the problem to me. Far too much drama, trolls, bullying, idiocy and general unfettered chaos. I've never seen any point whatsoever in moving stuff off of a well moderated public forum like XDA which mainly consists of intelligent discussion. Telegram groups mainly consist of the polar opposite to that.
[Magisk] makeyourself:
I'm sure it will survive. At least until/unless Google ever manage to kill it. These sorts of things always happen in every internet "community" from time to time but ultimately life goes on, new people turn up etc.
[Magisk] borisSweden:
sign.....

Will have to find a good jailbreak iPhone modell as Apple imposter syndrome doesn't recognize it as a hack of its security in official terms but will patch it in secret. google wants dat dat enterprise certification money.
[Magisk] borisSweden:
Well piracy will return as DRM apps still exist that fragment the media. There are payment apps that can replace Google and Apple. But on the issue of regular apps that edit stuff like banks and ID, hard pass. Right now some of my apps work without safety net but Google could force domestic options to use Play Integrity, RCS demands it. If BankID started to use PI it game over, I will have to use G-Apps after many years of sending BS metadata.
[Magisk] Munk.3:
For my android 4.4.2

Magisk v22.1 shows ramdisk as no. But v8.0.7 shows as yes.

Furthermore copy to cache fails in 22.1.

How would or could I keep magisk 8.0.7 without force update?
[Magisk] pndwal:
If 22.1works with 4.4.2 you can use it, just ignore ramdisk info but always keep Recovery Mode unselected... You must patch boot.img (not recovery.img) on your device, and don't boot via recovery to system with Magisk either.... That's only for Legacy SAR A-only devices (all launched with Android 9)... PW
[Magisk] Munk.3:
Copy to cache also fails when recovery mode is unselected as well. It has somethig to do with my the unbranded device I'm using.

However another xda member was able to use magisk on his device and patch magisk for me. (But device isn't rooted still)

Regardless ty for help!!
[Magisk] pndwal:
Just be aware that if it can work w/ 4.4.2 which I'm unsure of, you should NEVER patch image or run using Recovery Mode... Your device uses Boot Mode... You may also be able to patch from recovery with Magisk archive named as .zip too...

Someone may know more if you say device... PW
[Magisk] Munk.3:
Well noted,ty for advice!!! 😃

Haha it's a funny little device I bought off Amazon to learn android better (I had planned to attempt reverse all the restrictions the manufacturing did) in hopes of learning android, in a way it did, but not efficiently.

But anyway:

Device is Timmkoo Q5 (no one has it here because its Bootleg mp3 player $40-50 . fun snrs emulator though!!)

I'll link MY threads where I give the firmware files to users:

[TMMKOO Q5 & Q3E] Official Custom Firmware Modding Updates & Downloads (First Release!!) 1/5/24

! Downloads are at the VERY BOTTOM (Do not download will be updating this with better system.img soon!) ! 3/26/24 Update: I got a replacement screen! here is what ive been able to do. So far google services dont work and would need noah to...

xdaforums.com

I'm actually commute to this device because a lot of people actually msg me about it so yeah...but next time IMA just buy an old Samsung or a low end Samsung. (But I their isn't a struggle then I'm not learning...lol I'm ranting now)

Ty to anyone who decides to peep the firmware files, and tell me issues you see or could help me with magisk.
[Magisk] pndwal:
Interesting... MTK device too... Not sure why you want that much of a challenge! 😜

Root may be complicated by MTK issues too... Many have been fixed by @vvb2060 (she had a long-lived MTK test branch a while back), but several fixes came post 22.1... Don't show up in changelogs as MTK fixes either, but you can search commit history... Even now QCom soc devices are still less fraught for rooting...

However you said someone achieved root... Didn't see link... Can you provide? Got me curious... 👍 PW

🍋 gib me lemmonn 🍋
[Magisk] J.Michael:
Do you have a reason for wanting Magisk other than to get root?

Have you looked for a CyanogenMod ROM that can work on your device? Or instructions on how to build one?

I think CyanogenMod always provided root privilege. You just wouldn't have the Magisk module capabilities.
[Magisk] V0latyle:
Won what?

Custom print still working for me on @osm0sis PIFork
[Magisk] zgfg:
Device integrity will also work with PIF (with the right JSON and prints) - btw, PIF was un-archived back on GitHub as of today

However, something else is strange.

Xiaomi.eu had to update their injector app as often as on Dec 2,, 5, 11, 14, 18 and 20

They update every time when G bans the prints hard-coded to the previous version of injector. Now, three weeks have passed and those last prints are still valid

(Ok, it was XMas and NY but Americans don't go for three week holidays)
[Magisk] Nergal di Cuthah:
I'm starting to believe my year-end report theory of why p.i.g seems to have stopped. Maybe our (short?) nightmare is over
[Magisk] V0latyle:
You mean original PIF? Or fork? I can still see both
[Magisk] HippoMan:
Yes. It seems like the Googlefrinchian Telephone Sanitizers might have actually altered their priorities lately.

Let's see.
[Magisk] zgfg:
Play Integrity Fix on GitHub is un-archived and the Play Integrity Fix chat on TG is open and divided into the topics 👍
[Magisk] HippoMan:
Yes, and the number of cat pix in the General and Support sub-channels has greatly diminished from what used to be posted in the single PIF channel.

They have an Off-Topic sub-channel now which is getting around the same number of posts as General and Support, and I wouldn't be surprised if this is where most of the cat pix are now living.

Kudos to @chiteroman for restructuring the PIF TG channel in this manner.
[Magisk] zgfg:
Yes, +1
[Magisk] zgfg:
Just hoping they have not altered the strategy and working now on the final solution for the cheated PI
[Magisk] HippoMan:
Agreed. What we're currently experiencing might just be the calm before the storm.

... and I hope *not*!
[Magisk] Nergal di Cuthah:
The angry is at that prospect not you
[Magisk] HippoMan:
Thank you for explaining, but your explanation is not necessary. I understood from the beginning.
[Magisk] mkcs:
I do not understand why developers take the reactions or comments seriously. Conspiratorially, what if all the blame comes from the minority who whats to stop the mouse and cat catch race on purpose? What solutions or counters are better than to make developers abandon their projects:rolleyes:
[Magisk] xcl1pse:
Good news: All projects which are archived before will come back soon. Don't ask eta. Give them rest

Bad news: If you have a problem with their project right now, go figure it out for yourself
[Magisk] pndwal:
More good news:

I'm very happy to see XDA app available for all now... Thanks to @dr.ketan for reversing enough to fix domains, and XDA staff for finally approving distribution!... (Within XDA forums only.)

I was basically only without it a week (if that) thanks to him... Don't know how others kept up without it!

See:

https://xdaforums.com/t/11-01-24-fi...ink-app-rolling-out-now.4199599/post-89268791

Decision:

https://xdaforums.com/t/petition-for-xda-fixed-modded-app.4649219/post-89268628

👍 PW
[Magisk] HippoMan:
Me too!

... except I can't figure out how to access my private messages with that app. Is there a way to do so?
[Magisk] HippoMan:
Aha! Thank you.
[Magisk] zgfg:
I'm actually very happy by using the other, brand new XDA app (developed from scratch) since the October

[CLOSED] [Development] [UNOFFICIAL] XDA Forums App

INTRO : Instead of that XDA app on Google play that the Devs does not update it regularly, takes a lot of time to open and has some bugs, so I decided to introduce for you a new unofficial replacement --- a new XDA Forums app ! In-app...

xdaforums.com

And personaly, I like it much more than the old XDA app since @ZG089 followed the feedback from his users over the last months to make the app friendly

Eg, as @HippoMan asked, there is a direct access from Status Bar to the subscribed threads, alerts and private messages (three most used tabs) - screenshot

Alao there are also no disconnections and needs for re-logging and similar issues that I remember from using the old/original XDA app over the previous years (talking about the time when the original, old XDA app worked and was practically the only app for the Forum at those times)
[Magisk] ZG_DEV:
Thanks, mate :)

This screenshot is from version 13 of my app, right ??
[Magisk] zgfg:
No, I'm on v14, Happy New Year edition - splash-screen attached
[Magisk] makeyourself:
Because... it's TG lol. I do not want to take sides (and certainly not the side of people making abusive comments) but one thing is for sure, drama is part of the culture on that platform. I'm not much of a conspiracy theorist either... so doing a quick Occam's razor on this... if there was a conspiracy to achieve that then I'd expect them to be doing it more directly at the people making mods that bypass PI and/or the most prolific creators of root solutions, one of which is a Google employee!
[Magisk] dr.ketan:
Agreed. I have multiple time raise concern for allowing TG link for support on XDA.

But may be firstly we needs fully woking an open source app for XDA forum.
[Magisk] ZG_DEV:
I guess it is better to create a PM conversation group between devs who are to make a fully open source XDA Fourms App :) , am I right ?
[Magisk] sawdoctor:
Problem is the person who created the original app isn't willing or able to share the original source code. Once /if that's available no PM are needed anyone can fork from GitHub and tweak/make their own app as they please
[Magisk] sawdoctor:
Anyone else had this message on latest magisk canary?
[Magisk] Clasimodo:
Happened to me. Just flashed Lsposed again and no problems.
[Magisk] sawdoctor:
Aah which lsposed version? I downgraded shamiko from v1 back to v0.75 and that fixed it.

Looks like a shamiko/lsposed compatibility issue
[Magisk] HippoMan:
Did you re-download LSPosed before flashing, or did you just re-flash the same LSPosed module?

Oh, never mind. Our messages crossed here.
[Magisk] Clasimodo:
Same, v1.9.2 and latest Shamiko 1.0.1
[Magisk] sawdoctor:
So if I update to shamiko 1.01 i just need to reflash lsposed again afterwards? Good to know 👍👍. Could have saved me a world of pain, spent a day figuring out magical overlays was making me lose root when updating to latest magisk canary. Finally figured it out and then broke lsposed with shamiko.

I only updated magisk so i could update shamiko and then everything went tits up 😂
[Magisk] ZG_DEV:
Oh, well guys, how to update magisk official 26.1 to 26.4 ? I have updated it through app + direct flash and didn't update (booted well but did not update), I have tried patching stock boot img using magisk 26.4 and flashing it myself but unfortunately it made my phone bootloop :(
[Magisk] Nergal di Cuthah:
Stsrt with device/rom/android version/flashing method
[Magisk] ZG_DEV:
Device : oppo A5s

ROM : Stock

Android 8.1

Wait what do you mean with flashing method? I usually flash things using sp flash tool, there's no fastboot for oppo devices
[Magisk] Lu5ck:
Maybe they already burn out to begin with and that is the last straw. I mean, they are not paid to do this, it is like a passion project. If people don't cheer them on but instead put them down, no reason to keep doing it.
[Magisk] Nergal di Cuthah:
That's what i meant (fastboot or what, you answered but) i have no experience with sp flash,, maybe ask at their forum if they have one or in the device board for your device on xda
[Magisk] J.Michael:
Do you any modules?

Maybe a module is incompatible with 26.4. Maybe what you saw as a bootloop was really a successful update to 26.4, unfortunately the patient died.
[Magisk] ZG_DEV:
I have even installed magisk bootloop protector, it didn't protect me from the bootloop, when I flashed the old patched boot.img I found that all modules were disabled because of bootloop protector !
[Magisk] SysAdmNj:
On a oneplus 3, just installed oxygen os 3.2.4 update and kind of an issue.

I stopped passing the safetynet test. I tried installing magisk v3 and nothing shows up in apps, magisk v1 flashes fine and I can see. I flashed phh-superuser-magiskv2 and same, I keep failing safetynet test. Any ideas?

I am running xposed-v86.4-sdk23-topjojnwu.zip and thats working fine.
[Magisk] stu5797:
I pass the safetynet test on the oneplus 3 but I cant add a new credit card or use android pay after I pass the test.
[Magisk] SysAdmNj:
What did you flash and what were your flashing steps ?
[Magisk] stu5797:
Flash new room build, magisk v1, Phh superuser (1st one), xposed v86. 3.

I tried with all the newest versions and I couldn't open the magisk app
[Magisk] joeyddr:
They updated the Android pay app I get the same when trying to use it safety net passes but no go at terminal
[Magisk] Axaion:
I flashed the new build, and i cant even SEE the magisk app

Note that xposed says it is active though
[Magisk] stu5797:
Me too. That's why i

Flash new rom build, magisk v1, Phh superuser (1st one), xposed v86. 3.
[Magisk] jrdnsingh89:
I couldn't find the Magisk manager after flashing v3 and v2 phh superuser, any help...
[Magisk] stu5797:
Flash magisk v1 and you will see the app
[Magisk] gohamstergo:
maybe if you people want your issues fixed, post some friggin logs. all your posts are useless. your phone, rom, version, blah blah mean NOTHING without logs. not that this post is gonna fix anything...what a useless post XD
[Magisk] jrdnsingh89:
thanks, but i wanted to upgrade to the latest version, I think i will hold off
[Magisk] mobileman88:
It should work if you reflash stock boot image before flashing magisk
[Magisk] waylo:
To add to the positive reports here, I successfully installed Magisk v3 with phh-superuser on the LG G5. (I think I'm the only one so far on this growing monster thread).

I made it really hard on myself by trying to dirty flash. In manually uninstalling systemless SuperSU, which restores the stock boot.img, my data encrypted itself (supersu's uninstall warns you of this). I then spent a stupid amount of time working through that but eventually ended up with Magisk working and my data intact. I don't know if just dirty flashing a stock boot.img would have also resulted in a re-encrypt result, as the G5 defaults to encryption. Maybe if I were able to flash Magisk immediately right after the stock boot image. SuperSU's uninstall gives you no time to flash something else in before booting.

Which raises the question, can Magisk be installed with an encrypted data partition? I thought no, which is why I spent the time undoing it.

All my security settings were awry at that first reboot (my pattern lock changed itself!) and Android Pay had reset. I added back 2 cards and will be testing it out next time I can.
[Magisk] teddy0209:
Remove the old app prior to flashing, or you can just manually delete, ectract the apk in the new zip then install...
[Magisk] spartan018:
You're absolutely right, it should work. But it doesn't.
[Magisk] garthybarthy:
[MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION]

It's now working successfully on my Samsung S6, booted first time.

I'm going to test in a couple of hours if I can successfully purchase in store using Android Pay.

Anyway ever since V1 I've had a deep sleep issue since installing Magisk, I've no idea what's causing it. BBS shows nothing.

Is there anything I can provide to look into this further? We're limited with kernels for our S6 so that's not really an option, especially systemless ones.

Thanks.
[Magisk] topjohnwu:
Motorola users: moto's boot image seems not standard, I'll take a look for it.

Asus users: your boot image is also not standard, and I think even SuperSU don't support it either.

Insufficient boot partition space devices: it seems bootimg-repack will pack the boot image slightly larger than necessary. I will look into this issue.

Android Pay reports: please put the Android Pay discussion in the correct thread. Also for those searching for Magisk Manager, it's now included with phh's root, not in Magisk itself.

For safety net to pass, you have to disable root in Magisk Manager. In the next update I'll roll back to the v1 method. My tester has also updated to the latest Android Pay update from Play Store, and it is working fine. I'll stop here, as I don't wish people keep discussing about AP in this thread.
[Magisk] topjohnwu:
Yes, it is patched to encryptable, which means it support both encrypted and not encrypted
[Magisk] JudgeDread11:
I am looking in to trying all this. I have an Asus Zenfone 2 laser. I had systemless SuperSU working before.

I'll report back if and when I give magisk a try.

---------- Post added at 10:15 AM ---------- Previous post was at 09:59 AM ----------

Do I understand correct that I can simply add files to the system by adding then to cache/magisk/mounts/system/?

So if I create a folder there called priv-app and as the "better battery stats" app there, it will run as a system app?

Or does this only work for build.prop?
[Magisk] Agg2ressor:
so where do i magic mount now that the manager is gone. I can't seem to find where to magic mount in the phh superuser app.
[Magisk] Alxoom33:
What is going on with all of the redundant posts...killing the thread!