yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] matwlodek:
So, I run uninstaller script, dirty flash rom (cm12.1 - togari - nightly), reboot, install supersu app from playstore, full unroot, installed newest magisk manager (working without issues), twrp - flashed magisk v13.3 - installed clearlly with no errors, no root detected when installing, reboot and still no magisk and no root...

I really want Magisk, specially for Sony Framework module. Can anybody tell me which log to send here? How can i help with debugging problem?
[Magisk] whalesplaho:
Didnt work???

Wooooopppsssss.... Working here!!!
[Magisk] stewie2806:
Howdy! Love the work and a BIG fan.

A couple of bugs, I'm aware about the safety net issue and will await the new version which will 'hopefully' fix it!

But I use YouTube ad free with background play magisk module

Whenever magisk hide is active, not only does background play not work, after reboot I loose root (according to the apk and root dependant apps like Titanium) so I have to re flash Magisk13.2 zip EVERY TIME. :crying:

any ideas on how to patch/fix this? :fingers-crossed:

Thanks in advanced :svetius:
[Magisk] kitcostantino:
i don't have a solution as i am only another user, but it would help you and others in the same situation to specify your device and attach logs of what happens when it goes wrong. just my .02. no offense intended, just trying to expedite progress. ;)
[Magisk] jDally987:
For anyone who got a Moto G5 Plus recently and has been struggling to get Magisk Hide working like I have the past several hours, check out my post here:

https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=73080688&postcount=73

FWIW to the devs, Safetynet fails in the stock rooted G5+ ROM no matter what, it seems. I flashed the debloated latest security update ROM, then flashed the latest Magisk, THEN finally flashed the ElementalX kernel, and only then did safetynet pass - and for basic integrity only, cts profile is still a fail.

However snapchat finally works now. What's weird is before, Magisk hide seemed to work for everything else; root checker was none the wiser when I turned on Hide. But snapchat was stalwart and still wouldn't let me log in. Does it check safetynet or the bootloader instead of just root?
[Magisk] :
Well, my "friend", if Magisk ever fixes its non-existent and promised multiuser feature, I will be partly to thank for that. I don't need to mess with my already setup and functional system (with SuperSU, which is competent at multiuser root) just to test every new Magisk "fix", yet I do, and that is to help.

I don't appreciate being ignored (after all, original bugs persist, and a new one just came up, and I can't retrieve any logs on the new one, it's impossible, when the app auto-shuts down), nor do I appreciate arrogant devs with dellusions of grandeur, who think they're better than everyone else, even though they themselves don't even act on reports other than the ones on SafetyNet.

I will not apologize for reporting a new error (which can't be "logged", it just is, it just happens) nor for defending myself when a contributor mocks or attacks me. Keep it to yourself, "friend".

[MENTION=6842057]The Flash[/MENTION]

Try GitHub issue #247. Logs are from Betas, but stable version logs's present the same error. The updated ones from stables are in this thread, but there was no real reason to update it, since it's all the same.
[Magisk] mike.bss:
Just updated Magisk to 13.3, passes safetynet when I checked with another app. But the Magisk manager app is not opening now!!! Anyone else having same problem? Anyway to fix it???

--LG G5 H830

Android V7.0

Fulmics ROM V3.3

Magisk manager V5.0.6 (Latest)
[Magisk] Ta3hi:
When ever I have my phone on airplane mode and I open the app it doesn't work and crashes and it doesnt hide root.

Nexus 5x

Lineage OS 14.1

7.1.2

Magisk 13.2 and app 5.06
[Magisk] ryaniskira:
Same issue here, I got the app to open once but since then it still doesn't open. Rolling back to Magisk Manager 5.0.6 works.
[Magisk] saccentekennedy:
Hey everyone...

I've just been prompted to update MagiskManager and I have, except now it hangs and won't open! I've uninstalled it and reinstalled it. The app just freezes. Weirdly all my modules are loaded and running... Any ideas?

EDIT: I see I'm not the only one. I'm on a OnePlus 5, Oxygen 4.5.5
[Magisk] mike.bss:
Well, there should be a problem with Magisk manager app, I guess...
[Magisk] energyadj:
Hello.

A little feedback from me, maybe can help some of you.

I am using Magisk on my HTC 10. As many of you, I got stuck after latest update.

As a workaround, I flashed Magisk-Uninstaller, and then Magisk 13.3 from recovery, rebooted and all good, until I flashed one of my favorites modules "Dolby Atmos 6.5 rc?!", and after that Magisk stuck again.

Repeated the flash from recovery (Uninstaller + 13.3), reboot and again all good, but without any other modules for now.

Good luck.

Many thanks to the developer for his hard work. Much appreciated. Respect!
[Magisk] UnbracedTundra:
App not opening for me either. Tried clearing app data flashing magisk again via recovery and force stopping.

Running on OP3T OB9
[Magisk] Joloxx9:
All modules are broken under 13.3 is it normal? Im coming back to 13.2
[Magisk] stewie2806:
Just updated, mine fails both. System UI hidden using hide

Samsung S7 G930F

Android v7.0

Ambasadii rom v18.0

Latest magisk manager
[Magisk] Aria.A97:
Turn off internet connection to open the app, or use AFWall or similar firewall apps to block Magisk for now
[Magisk] stewie2806:
Convientnly, just updated to Magisk 13.3 and newest manager. After reboot both seem to be working fine.

If the eroor occurs again I'll reply with logs
[Magisk] e.artillery:
Apparently the bugs that commented happen in android 7, I have a huawei with 6.0.1 and emui 4.1.3 and did not experience any error.
[Magisk] nathanchance:
Thanks, I'll pass it along :good:
[Magisk] stej16:
-took update 5.1.0 straight from the app - got stuck at magisk flash screen.

-read to uninstall & re-install using uninstaller from the magisk thread - flashed unistaller - rebooted (1 said you don't have to reboot so do u) - reflashed magisk 13.3 (downloaded from the thread) and worked perfectly.

- tried to download a module from the app (ios 10 emoji) and got stuck at the processing window - rebooted to TWRP to flash the downloaded module and failed (sorry forgot exact description ) -- also when trying to add the module in the magisk app, came up as " not a magisk module"

apparently something is wrong with the magisk app with downloading things, possible server problems, idk... but i am sure things will be fixed -- also: Safetynet passed - moto x pure stock MM.

thank you for Magisk.
[Magisk] stewie2806:
Scratch that, happened again :crying:

Running 7.0

G930f

Ambasadii rom v18.0
[Magisk] njascgil:
Can't update Magisk to v13.3 through Magisk Manager v5.1

The new (and excelent) flash log shows "! Magisk is only for Lollipop 5.0+ (SDK 21+)" even though I'm on Marshmallow and build.prop has ro.build.version.sdk correctly set to 23 (this is a Moto G 2014 on stock ROM).

Is anyone else also experiencing this? Could I be doing something wrong?
[Magisk] olivercervera:
Just to provide feedback, no issues in upgrading Magisk Manager 5.1 & Magisk v13.3 on several devices I have under my control

Nexus 5X stock + Magisk (7.1.2)

Xiaomi Mi5 (Custom AOSP ROM 7.1.2)

Galaxy Note 3 Int. (N9005) (Custom TW ROM 6.0.1)

OnePlus 3T stock + Magisk (7.1.1)

However please note no modules have been loaded on any of these devices.
[Magisk] LucaXperia:
Hello guys,

My Galaxy S6 is rooted by Magisk (latest) and I pass safetynet nicely.

I want to install Xposed Framework by Magisk Manager, it will trigger safety net?

And if it not trigger safetynet, which APK I have to download?

Thx!
[Magisk] saccentekennedy:
I've rolled back to MagiskManager 5.0.6 with Magisk 13.3, and it's working again. Not sure what's up, but I'm sure someone much cleverer than I is working on a fix!
[Magisk] tinystranger:
everytime i flash the magisk uninstaller wifi stops working (stays disabled even if i try toggling it on the settings)

flashing a backup of almost every partition (boot, system, system image, data) prior to this fixes the issue

so i have just been dirty flashing every magisk update until now, in which the manager just hangs on the splash screen

flashing the uninstaller once again broke my wifi so im kinda stuck with 13.2 for now

anyways thanks to the magisk team and all that for the app, its appreciated

(im running a moto g 2015 xt1542 osprey on marshmallow resurrection remix)
[Magisk] kramer04:
Just try v13.3 to see if can pass safetynet.

I'm on Rom Aspire C9 v3.0

kernel Phantom 1.2m

Samsung galaxy note 3 N9005

root : ok

ctsprofile : false

basicintegrity : true

but no log entry in magisk manager, it's empty and no log in /data

so how can i have log ?

I pass safetynet with file beta2v4 edited.

I attach the file, may be it can help
[Magisk] Huskied:
Everything seems good.

Had to install the 13.3 update from the last Magisk Manager update,

Reboot and install the latest Magisk Manager update

And it should work. Somewhat ended the same way.
[Magisk] e.artillery:
So, install magisk 13.3 and when trying to install a module the app manager did not work, so I followed his advice, install version 5.0.6 and it works excellent.
[Magisk] Huskied:
Use Universal SN fix.
[Magisk] storm68:
Now that magisk 13.3 came out, I still have the script in. Should I take it out or leave as is?
[Magisk] ForSquirel:
Thanks Dev et al.

Update is working on MotoG4 Play w/unlocked BL & safetynet pass!

Been struggling since v13 and this works great.
[Magisk] danmit:
For those of you having trouble using v13.3, try flashing uninstaller BEFORE Magisk itself. [MENTION=5031705]pyry666[/MENTION]

Download Magisk uninstaller, Boot into TWRP, Flash Uninstaller, Flash Magisk v13.3, Wipe cache and you're good to go.

For me it's 100% working now.
[Magisk] claytoncamilleri100:
Hi I have been trying to install Magisk on my moto g5 plus on stock rom. I flashed Magisk V13.3 and can't pass Safety Net or install any Modules. Whenever I try to install one I get Magisk is not activated and Failed. I tried flashing in recovery but after it flashes successfully it still doesn't appear in Installed Modules. I tried getting a log from the app but says Log is empty.
[Magisk] John NHT:
Wow, what's with the ungrateful and entitlement attitude of some today?

Patience.

There are a couple workarounds suggested. Check them out in the meantime until he puts out another update to fix the issue.

Again, just be patient.
[Magisk] albysprx:
Magisk manager 5.1.0 doesn't work for me, it stucks in the magisk image, I installed 13.3 and rolled back to 5.0.6 for now

Nexus 5X Android 7.1.2 PureNexus
[Magisk] moore.bryan:
I recently took my Nexus 10 (manta) back to stock, reflashed TWRP, and flashed a new rom; when I flashed the latest Magisk *to root* the manta, Magisk complained "! System installed root detected, mount rw : (". The ROM I flashed--PureNexus--IS NOT pre-rooted, so I'm confused AF.

ANY suggestions would be much appreciated!
[Magisk] shadavis08:
You guys need to download and install the newest magisk manager app 5.1
[Magisk] Arxadius:
Could someone help with this issue? I'm constantly getting this error even though I'm on 6.0.1 Marshmallow. Reset the twice as well but to no dice.
[Magisk] shadavis08:
They can also wipe app data.
[Magisk] atarek:
Magisk log is empty

Hello,

Mobile:samsung note 3 n9005

Rom:nxteam darklord reborn s7 edge

Kernel: phantom 1.2m-dev

Recovery: twrp 2.8.7.0

Magisk manager:5.1.0

Magisk:13.3

My manager log menu show log is empty as shown in screenshots i don't know any reason for than although it worked on v.12 even if i uninstalled v13.3 and tried v12 and manager 4.4.0 it will work without any issues.

Attached all screenshots for manager and /cache folder also i captured matlog during this operation it could help. Also i never changed buffer size in settings/developer mode as attached.

Is there any advise or thinking out of the box for cause of this issue with v13 and later.

View attachment log.txt
[Magisk] e.artillery:
Version 5.0.6 with magisk 13.3 works wonderfully. I had to install the previous version since when trying to install some module, the app manager was frozen.
[Magisk] pyry666:
Tried that also..I just reverted back to manager 5.0.6 and its working fine for now. But thanks for your input!
[Magisk] shadavis08:
I thought someone said Magisk would give a false error like that sometimes
[Magisk] Legitsu:
something is broken with magisk manager upgrading to 5.1 just results in the app hanging on the mask screen

clearing the apps cache didn't fix it either
[Magisk] danmit:
I had the same problem, try to uninstall Magisk and then flash it again (read my last posts)
[Magisk] 29988122:
Since 13.3 have been released, I'd like to know if currently you can install both magisk and xposed and still passed Safetynet?(or play pokemon go)

On my bootloader unlocked htc 10, it cannot be done..
[Magisk] demonoidmaster:
Umm 5.1.0 is the newest, which won't open, that's the issue people are having
[Magisk] shadavis08:
Yeah it force closed on me and I had to wipe data and wipe the cache repo rebooted and it works fine
[Magisk] stanleyopar2000:
No. Sorry. But you can't use your Xposed modules to cheat in Pokemon go. Xposed will trip safteynet. Looks like you'll have to play it normally. ?
[Magisk] PokemonTotalWar:
I posted a log, here it is again
[Magisk] :
It will always shut itself down when in a user profile other than the owner's one (making it impossible to re-test multiuser root, which Magisk has promised and is yet to really deliver). But apparently, it can happen to the owner one too, by what you two just said.
[Magisk] shoey63:
Easiest way is to uninstall Magisk manager and dirty flash latest Magisk in TWRP. No need to flash Magisk uninstaller.

It will automatically install Magisk 13.3 and manager 5.1 without FC'S and you can install modules (I have 3).
[Magisk] spida_singh:
Flashed Uninstaller then latest zip wiped data on latest app lost root and stuck on splash screen for me..... Oneplus3t using lineage OS
[Magisk] 29988122:
You're being mean assuming people cheating.

I am a bilingual person and I prefer Pokemon Go running in Japanese, since that's the language I'm most familiar with.

However my phone's system language is in Chinese.

Therefore I need appsettings (xposed module) to alter language settings per app.

Also one of my friends with Zenphone(Asus) can pass 7/17 update with xposed - I have no idea why.
[Magisk] killerojrc:
Hey, I can no longer edit system apps via FX as it says the system is mounted, anyone else having this issue?. Any input would be appreciated, thanks! :)
[Magisk] dimm0k:
Works for me too... until I install a module and then it's back to crashing!
[Magisk] Albert Poon:
It stucks at start up screen forever and won't run. Workaround is to install 13.3 and then install Manager 5.0.5 from 13.2
[Magisk] viktor92:
Great, now is working again !!! :good::good::good:
[Magisk] psychoela:
magisk manager 5.1 not open,so back to 5.0.6 and it work just fine with magisk 13.3, also safetynet passed without madule safetynet fix:D
[Magisk] rom116:
So regarding Safetynet, when i run the test and it says, "SafetyNet Check SUccess"

cts Profile: false

Basicintegrity: true

Is this a pass or a fail? I have Magisk hide checked but don't know if ctsprofile is important or what i need to do to get it to pass if it is.

I'm running 13.3 and Magisk Mgr 5.06
[Magisk] shadavis08:
Yeah that's what I keep hearing. I dont use modules so I wouldn't know lol
[Magisk] dimm0k:
I ended up installing the previous version of MagiskManager and everything is fine... seems like the changes in 5.1.0 needs some work
[Magisk] ZerosMadness:
Flashed v13.3 and booted up then installed 5.1 manager and it's working every time I open the app. I do have an issue though. I'm unable to got to the superuser menu of magisk manager. I've already uninstalled, reflashed and downloaded the manager. I'm on Nexus 6. My logs are blank after it says crash but I'll try a few more times and post logs if I'm able to.
[Magisk] LuthorKid:
Same here. I can't delete, rename or set permissions in system apps including folders. Only works when I don't use magisk :(
[Magisk] serajr:
I had... thank you bro!

ta-poc was the culprit, do you believe that? I don't know why but magisk does not work with kernel patched with ta-poc (drm-fix does work)!

Everything working now \m/

Time to start creating some modules for us ;)
[Magisk] jenslody:
Magisk 13.3 with MagiskManager 5.1 works fine so far.

Just two bugs (on my system):

flashing through Manager with modules, that use the new template v4 is still broken, see https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=73073713&postcount=16589 ,

and MagiskManager crashes when it tries to flash a module after a download (issue with a possible fix on github: https://github.com/topjohnwu/MagiskManager/issues/230 ).
[Magisk] Teathief:
Is MagiskSU limited to providing only root access functions that will pass SafetyNet?

I need to use some file management utilities that just don't work under MagiskSU (<3 termux midnight commander) among other things, and in many regards I have issues with it, so I was wondering is it only providing rooting functions for things you can do and still pass SafetyNet, is that what is going on?

Also if that is the case being a Amazon store user do they package any SafetyNet apps or do I not have to worry about that at all, or can I probable happily use LineageSU?

I need the full root access way more then I need to pass safetynet, and will happily scrap a application that has it.
[Magisk] demonoidmaster:
Umm i know how to flash Magisk tyvm , no matter what [MENTION=4924615]shadavis08[/MENTION] said the new Magisk apk is faulty, it will not go past the opening image (when apps are loading once you open them, yknow)
[Magisk] demonoidmaster:
Sorry but the app is faulty, did exactly that, upon reboot apps asking for root I'd grant, everything is ok, but opening Magisk Manager just hangs, never goes to the GUI. 5.0.6 apk works though, therefore 5.1.0 is broken, plain and simple

I also noticed that with v13.3 if you try to flash the uninstaller it doesn't find the stock boot img it made as a backup in /data (which the file is there, although it's named differently from the prior way of doing it, previously it would name it stock_boot with a bunch of numbers, now it only names it stock_boot_.img.gz

Could be because it names it .gz too which would make sense, since if it reflashes the stock boot it would have to be named .img instead of a .gz archive name
[Magisk] shadavis08:
So if I tried to install a module it would probably crash on me too
[Magisk] Legitsu:
try anouther non audio module

I think either the audiomod or deep buffer removal is broken
[Magisk] juda iskariotsky:
Xposed doesn't work with magisk since v12 on Samsung s7.
[Magisk] viking_kong16:
Encountered stuck at start screen and flashing uninstaller zip then re-flash magisk 13.3 fixes the issue.. however, all installed modules disappeared..re-installed them and the issue re-occured..now what?..any help would be appreciated..thanks!
[Magisk] Pkt_Lnt:
Except for those of us who upgraded with no issues, and Magisk works flawlessly and passes SafetyNet. :good:
[Magisk] shoey63:
I never said you don't know how to flash. I just suggested uninstalling the app first.

Problems must be device specific then. Works perfectly on Sony Z5.
[Magisk] Anonaru:
Got this to work for two reboots, then I installed the shiny new 13.3 and didn't need it anymore hahaha :laugh:

I dunno what it is about this build, but it just felt smoother and more polished--the whole update process. No problems whatsoever... I'm worried now, I never get away with no problems :eek:
[Magisk] gorillaCF:
anyone have any idea why is that a manually converted app to system app, now keeps force close on me after updating to v13.3 from v12?

and some of the apps that requires root to run, keeps FC as well. hmm.
[Magisk] viking_kong16:
How? Uninstall magisk from app manager and re-flash 13.3 zip through twrp? Correct?
[Magisk] Anonaru:
https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/official-magisk-v7-universal-systemless-t3473445

I'd grab the uninstaller .zip from here. Flash the uninstaller then flash the new Magisk .zip in recovery without a restart inbetween :good:
[Magisk] whalesplaho:
And [MENTION=4120742]munjeni[/MENTION] is away... I used rootkernel also so didnt know if it works or not... Good its working!!!

Modules all the way....:victory::highfive::good:
[Magisk] viking_kong16:
Yeah.. I've tried that already..it fixes the start up issue but when I install magisk modules, the issue reoccurs..
[Magisk] locolyric:
same issue with me!
[Magisk] CryonicCore:
Thanks OP. Safetynet works again and shows certified in play store and official on phone with the help of Universal Safetynet Fix. :)
[Magisk] viking_kong16:
Let's wait for [MENTION=4675598]shoey63[/MENTION] how he fixed start up issue with magisk modules installed..
[Magisk] locolyric:
I use 5.0.6 again
[Magisk] xarunx:
It's working again. S7e magisk 13.3 and manager 5.1

Both basic integrity and ctsprofile true again.
[Magisk] Anonaru:
Alright, what issue are you having now? Are you having them even with the new magisk app and .zip? For me, I didn't have to uninstall the actual app, only uninstall and reinstall the base side of things. Clearing caches might help
[Magisk] shoey63:
This is what works for me (mileage may vary depending on manufacturer/device)

- Uninstall manager through settings/Apps

- Flash Magisk 13.3 in TWRP

- Reboot and open newly installed 5.1 manager.

- Assuming it doesn't hang, turn off Magisk hide and install any modules 1 at a time, rebooting in between.

- Turn on Magisk hide and check safetynet.

-???

- Profit!! (For me anyway)
[Magisk] Xennet:
Ok... FINALLY GOT MY MAGISK MANAGER UP AFTER IT FROZE ON ME FOR LAST 7 HOURS...

For all those guys out there with the issue of getting magusk manager getting frozen...

Found out the issue...

The solution is not just uninstall and reinstall....

The problem with the manager crashing and freezing is due to FAULTY MODULES....NOT ALL MODULES...

IT OPENS FINE WITH GOOD MODULES...

THE THREE COMMONLY USED FAULTY MODULES ARE:

1) MAGNUM OPUS LATEST 18/7/2017 MAGISK MODULE FOR VIPER 4 ARISE

2) ALMOST ALL VIPER4ANDROID MODULE

3) ADAWAY YOUTUBE MODULE

JUST UNINSTALL THESE MODULES AFTER INSTALLING OLD MAGISK MANAGER 5.0.6 WHICH WILL NOT FREEZE. THEN AFTER UNINSTALLING THE FAULTY MODULE UODATE TO MAGISK MANGER 5.1.0. IT WILL OPEN. NO FREEZING. ASK THE DEVELOPERS TO UPDATE THEM...

Some of the modules that work fine are osmosis busy box module, firmware update module by eng.stk, android image kitchen module, app systemizer module which I have tested myself...

SO I THINK ITS NOT THE PROBLEM OF MAGISK MANAGER BUT OF THE MODULES...
[Magisk] viking_kong16:
After fixing the start up issue and re-install magisk modules, start up issue reoccurs.. cache you mean in app manager?.. yes I've tried that as well..or wiping cache and dalvik cache in twrp?
[Magisk] Anonaru:
via TWRP, though I doubt that's going to be your true solution. Definitely give [MENTION=4675598]shoey63[/MENTION] 's advice a try, that may be your savior haha
[Magisk] gohamstergo:
nevermind
[Magisk] moore.bryan:
Are we sure it's a false error? When I then try to use Magisk Hide with an app, I'm told the app doesn't work on rooted devices.

:-/
[Magisk] Albert Poon:
Try installing Dolby Atmos Classic module and see if it works for you.
[Magisk] Xennet:
To manually remove the modules install magisk manager 5.0.6 which opens fine..

After deleting the faulty module then reinstall magisk manager 5.1.0
[Magisk] viking_kong16:
I'll try this.. module I usually use is dolby atmos..thanks!

You got a good point.. I also suspect that the issue is within the modules as it's not happening without any modules installed..

I might try to wipe from twrp once game of thrones s7e1 download is finished.. ?
[Magisk] CryonicCore:
That sucks. Took you 7 hours to figure that out lol. After 10 minutes I found out that adaway YouTube was causing magisk to hang. However, I'm sure within time the modules will be updated to magisk.