yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] lulonen:
Magisk 24.1 worked fine with image 2.55.401.3 (pie) on my HTC U12+ until my phone accidentally auto-updated system to htc original image(same build!). Now it works without root and when I only patch boot.img -> whatever slot_a or b - phone hangs after login.

fastboot flash boot_b boot.emmc403.img

Sending 'boot_b' (65536 KB) OKAY [ 3.490s]

Writing 'boot_b' (bootloader) HOSD CL#1088647

(bootloader) start@1

(bootloader) boot_b@100%

(bootloader) Update partition OK

(bootloader) end@Done

OKAY [ 7.221s]

Finished. Total time: 11.141s

Changing active slots doesn't change anything, and when I flash stock boot.img then system works ok again.

Patched boot.img doesn't start after encryption pass/ unpatched boot.img works ok.

Whast's going on? Can You help me? Most stupid is that google pay stopped working saying that my phone is rooted while it isn't. LOL
[Magisk] maybeme2:
Does deleting /data/magisk_backup_xxxxxx

Cause any problems?

I deleted 2 such files on my phone and now I am concerned I may have caused a future problem.

Have I?
[Magisk] VD171:
Those files are restored if you want to uninstall magisk "directly".

You can remove them safely, but now you have to uninstall magisk "manually". I mean, flashing original stock boot.img.
[Magisk] maybeme2:
Thank you.
[Magisk] trentini:
I did some testing this weekend. When I install magisk stand alone, without TWRP , root remains even after being online and updating various apps. I guess problem is related to TWRP.. accepting sugestions.
[Magisk] Lughnasadh:
In addition to what @VD171 said, they are also used to restore the stock boot images when using the "Install to inactive slot" function when upgrading via OTA.
[Magisk] maybeme2:
So essentally, I should not have deleted those files. No way to recreate them now?
[Magisk] Philnicolls89:
Is it possible that when you had TWRP installed you were rebooting the phone wrong?

If your phone restarts normally, say after installing a magisk module, then you will boot without root. (The phone will start and everything will work except root won't be active)

Each time you want to restart your phone you need to either select the 'reboot to recovery' option from within the magisk app. Or turn off your phone and use the button combo to boot using the recovery partition.
[Magisk] trentini:
No, its not possible. I did rebooted it the right way, pressing keys and releasing and immediately entering TWRP menu and applying the multidisabler.

Another issue, when rooted with magisk , phone went to only 32gb storage... weird.

Denis
[Magisk] i8890321:
I experienced a problem when i clicked " Hide magisk manager" in the setting of magisk.

It did partly like the web said, it renamed the package to "manager" . After that , i click on that fake "manager" app, it freeze 5 sec and nothings happen

now my magisk look very strange, the home screen shows Magisk install N/A and sometimea it pops up a message say magisk denied super user.

Can any body point me to a right direction to recover or reinstall the magisk?
[Magisk] Lughnasadh:
You could flash the stock boot image and then re-root.
[Magisk] J.Michael:
In the app drawer, do you have both "manager" and "Magisk"?

Have you tried "un-Hide Magisk Manager"?
[Magisk] J.Michael:
Is this a Samsung phone?

If you used Magisk to patch TWRP, then when you shut down and use buttons to "boot towards recovery", every time you get to TWRP you have not danced right -- you are not supposed to get to recovery, you are supposed to almost get to recovery.

"storage size reduced" is warned about, may result from running Odin without specifying all four files/slots.
[Magisk] trentini:
Yes, I am using a S10+ , using this method to TWRP, exactly what is in the description:

How to Install TWRP Recovery on Samsung Galaxy S10/S10+/S10e (Exynos)

Unofficial and official builds of TWRP for Galaxy S10 devices is now available. In this guide, I will show you how to install TWRP Recovery on Samsung Galaxy S10, Galaxy S10+, Galaxy S10e.

www.thecustomdroid.com
[Magisk] rick_th1:
I need some help guys, today i updated to magisk 24.1, my main payments app & one of my bank's app is working fine but my other bank's app(Axis mobile) isn't working because it detects root somehow. My next step is shamiko, but I don't really use that app so I'm double minded, i have magisk hidden and the modules are in the screenshot attached, thanks for reading...

Edit: forgot to mention I'm on Xiaomi.eu stable rom on K20/mi9t pro with orangefox.
[Magisk] zgfg:
Shamiko will probably not help you for the banking app (frankly, I don't believe you came accross an app that looks for Zygisk that you need Shamiko to hide it)

From your Momo, you are probably on Xiaomi?

Maybe Xiaomi.eu or which ROM if you pass SN without using USNF?

Did you do regular staff like adding the bad banking app to your DenyList (and rebooting)?

And did you try hiding Magisk app?

If that does not help, you would need to try with Hide My Applist (it was mentioned many times here but in the new Magisk-Zygisk thread you can find guides for HMA)

But search about your app - the trick is maybe already known and described (sometimes it's as easy as renaming/removing TWRP folfer - albeit that primitive checking for root is nowadays getting rare)

PS: I see now you are indeed on Xiaomi.eu.

Momo is hard on Xiaomi, and unfortunately some banking apps, too - it might not be easy (or even solvable)
[Magisk] zgfg:
Is the below Welcome screen ok?

I have a similar environment like you:

- Xiaomi Mi 9T (not Pro), Xiaomi.eu Stable, Canary 24102

I put the Axis to DenyList, and used Hide My Applist to hide Magisk app and my LSPosed modules apps) from Axis

Rebooted and then opened Axis (you would need to wipe Data for Axis in Settings, Apps)

My Magisk app is not hidden. I do have Shamiko but it's probably not crucial
[Magisk] rick_th1:
Thanks for reply & sorry for not mentioning earlier, when you click login in the app then it shows rooted phone not supported (you don't need to enter any credentials, just login)
[Magisk] zgfg:
Then a problem.

Maybe hiding the Magisk app could help - but maybe really a problem to pass for that app on Xiaomi
[Magisk] rick_th1:
I'm able to pass SN without USNF. i added the app to denylist & rebooted after making changes in denylist & before opening the app & cleaning its data everytime. Magisk App is hidden. I'm out of luck i guess, thanks for your help.
[Magisk] Philnicolls89:
Yes but after flashing multi disabler did you select reboot system or reboot recovery? You need to reboot to recovery everytime you restart your phone. This reboot to recovery option should not be confused with rebooting to TWRP, it doesn't mean booting to twrp, just booting the phone using the recovery partition not the boot partition.

Regarding the 32g file size shrinkage.

To attempt to repair the damage, you need to boot to TWRP, select Advanced Wipe, tick Data, select Repair or Change File System followed by Resize File System. Your /data will return to its former size, but you will probably find you have lost some data. Restore a /data back-up afterwards to be sure of having all your data.
[Magisk] zgfg:
I searched in this thread and in the new Magisk-Zygisk thread for Axis - not found

But there were also the other banking app(s) not usable on rooted Xiaomi phones - bad luck if this one is too.

Maybe a Second space or similar
[Magisk] lulonen:
Can anyone give me any ideas how to restore root?
[Magisk] Spartacus500:
The Axis bank does not work on my Samsung either.
[Magisk] trentini:
After flashing I selected reboot recovery ( "Finally, go to the ‘Reboot’ menu in TWRP and select ‘Recovery’ to boot your Samsung Galaxy S10 device into rooted OS with TWRP.") ,then connected to the internet and download magisk update, and let it reboot.
[Magisk] Philnicolls89:
There might be your problem, with the s10 device you shouldn't use the direct update option in magisk (you can direct update the app but not magisk itself). On a fresh install when u first open the app it will do a finishing set up routine but not update. If u want to update magisk versions then you need to delete the old app, download the new app and repatch and flash firmware etc.

Also don't let device reboot by itself, you need to shut it down and reboot using button combo. Or if it does restart by itself be quick and use the button combo before it can restart properly.

Installing a custom kernel with magisk built into the kernel is the best way to avoid having to do this stupid button combo stuff! Then u don't need to patch and flash firmware as the kernel is already rooted.
[Magisk] J.Michael:
Have you checked the S10 thread?

As for the shrunken data: The article you linked shows installing TWRP by running Odin with only the AP slot filled. @topjohnwu's instructions specifically warn against doing that.

Further, Magisk has changed. There used to be a checkbox "Recovery mode" when patching a file. From what I've read in these threads, that option may have disappeared. It may be that now the only way is to present Magisk Manager with a .tar file containing a "recovery.img" file -- and be running on a device that requires that the recovery image be patched.

*Did* you have a "Recovery mode" checkbox? Was it checked?
[Magisk] Philnicolls89:
The shrunken data partition is an easy fix, it's happened to me before even when filling all slots in Odin. These instructions were taken from the old ianmcd twrp thread.

To attempt to repair the damage, you need to boot to TWRP, select Advanced Wipe, tick Data, select Repair or Change File System followed by Resize File System. Your /data will return to its former size, but you will probably find you have lost some data. Restore a /data back-up afterwards to be sure of having all your data.

As it seems this isn't a magisk issue as you had it running without TWRP, I've linked the official TWRP thread to continue this discussion as it's getting a bit OT.

https://xdaforums.com/t/recovery-of...s10-e-5g-exynos.4180287/page-20#post-86429167
[Magisk] Sebastiaanlabr:
Hi guys, first thanks to the developers! I need some support however, i dont recieve notifications on my phone (gmail, news app) the only notifications that i recieve are from Whatsapp, i tried different roms but same situation and i think it has something to do with zygisk or magisk. (saftynet?) any ideas?
[Magisk] zgfg:
Definitely nothing about SsfetyNet - you have SN Framework in Google Play Services regardless of do you use it or not

Disable all your modules, reboot and retest.

Furthermore, disable Zygisk in Magisk app settings, reboot and retest

You can even disable the whole Magisk by flashing your original boot.img (recovery.img, Odin - depending on your phone) and retest

You will either find that particular module or Magisk setting halts the notifications (?), or that you have a problem with your ROM

Usually some optimizations (debloating and so) would be the reason, but that's not the Magisk fault
[Magisk] i8890321:
Thanks for your reply. So nice to have a community here.

In my app drawer, there are Both "manager" and "Magisk"

I have no option to "un-Hide Magisk Manager" in the app "Magisk"

The items in the setting of "Magisk" changed. Some options are missing and the bottom bar is grey out. I try to post a picture to show my situation. Thanks.
[Magisk] J.Michael:
You are not supposed to have two manager apps at once. When you rename Magisk Manager app, the renamed app is supposed to be the only manager app. When you want to upgrade or otherwise change Magisk Manager app version, you are strongly advised to "rename back" (unhide) the Magisk Manager app before letting it update itself, or before installing another version.

I suggest uninstalling both managers (as in, use Android app info "Uninstall" button), then install apk of Magisk Manager app. Convince yourself that Magisk is working (recognized by manager app; able to use "su" in a terminal window) before renaming manager or installing modules.

Of course, if you are adventurous, or just curious, you could try running the renamed manager -- it might still be connected to Magisk. I would expect it to have an "unhide" option -- DO NOT use it until you have uninstalled the other Manager. (Again, unless you want to see if it blows up in your face. Be sure to report the results -- lots of curious people here.) Then try uninstalling newer manager, the one named Magisk Manager, and see if older manager, the one named "manager", now works. (Maybe reboot.)
[Magisk] trentini:
Sorry for the mistake, when I meant update I was referring to the process which magisk auto reboots to finish the root process.
[Magisk] trentini:
Agreed with that. I think the problem is related to TWRP , which I just discovered doing some tests. About the partition, Im lost. I would be okay without TWRP , just using magisk with root. But to fix the partition I need TWRP and doing that I lose root. Doing a search over the threads I found somone that had the some problem and the solution was I think was downgrade using android 10, not 11.
[Magisk] lcsboy:
My phone is ASUS Zenfone6 (Android 9)

I have a question for boot time.

24.1 always takes a long time during ASUS logo. It is more than 60 seconds.

But 23.0 is less then 5 seconds during ASUS logo.

Is it possible to reduce the boot time in ASUS logo?
[Magisk] i8890321:
Thanks for your advice.

I uninstalled "manager" and "Magisk", then reinstalled the magisk apk from another post. Everything is fine now. Thanks
[Magisk] andrea0807:
Is the only way to take screenshots in protected apps with smali patcher?
[Magisk] kevosky:
Pls how do i pass safetynet with edxposed installed
[Magisk] zgfg:
Switch to Zygisk-LSPosed for Magisk v24 (or Riru-LSPosed for Magisk v23 and earlier)
[Magisk] shoey63:
Smali patcher has an option to patch exactly that. Not guaranteed to work on every combination of device and or rom though.
[Magisk] andrea0807:
Precisely I ask if there is an alternative method
[Magisk] zgfg:
LSPosed manager, Repository - see the screenshot

No guarantee they work (I use Smali)
[Magisk] nostupidthing:
I googled a lot but cannot find a definite answer....

long time ago los, when install magisk, there is a direct install option, which will preserve magisk when i install new los builds

nowadays, on 18.1, no direct install option. i can only patch vbmeta and flash boot.img in twrp, but updating los will lose magisk...

any idea? thx!!!
[Magisk] zgfg:
LOS 18.1 or an ancient Magisk v18.1?

In Magisk v24 app (it was also in earlier Magisk app and previously mngr versions), you go: main screen, Install (at the top), Next and then choose Direct install (screenshots)
[Magisk] ashish1989:
Enabled zygisk, rebooted. Configured denylist, added playstore and play services (gms and unstable), device not certified

Disabled internet, cleared play store and services data, still device is not certified

Kindly tell me, what am I doing wrong

Is it necessary to add playstore in denylist too or only play services can do the job
[Magisk] zgfg:
Do not add Playstore app to DenyList

But try with USNF 2.1.

For custom (uncertified) ROMs you might still need to spoof props with MHCP

Also, there is a new XDA thread for Magisk + Zygisk (Magisk v24) with very useful OP posts - covering topics exactly like that (although, they were also covered through the numerous questions and answers here but when same things became asked and answered tons of times, thread becomes unreadable because of the noise pollution - unfortunately, it's already happening to that new thread, too)
[Magisk] Lord Sithek:
The second one is working, I use it
[Magisk] lcsboy:
It seems only I have this issue.

Could some one give me some suggestion to check or do something to improve my boot time?
[Magisk] m0han:
Could take screenshots in Chrome and GPay.
[Magisk] Hayatzada:
Hi Every One

Looking For Magisk Hide Proper Way To Configure to successfully solve banking Apps Detection Issue watch this video, Language is not English but can be translate if u cant understand
[Magisk] HippoMan:
I can't get past the Captcha in order to view the video. Can you summarize the procedure?
[Magisk] J.Michael:
Disable all Magisk modules. See how long it takes when you reboot.

Separate test: Disable all internet -- wifi, cell phone data, whatever you have -- and reboot.
[Magisk] pndwal:
PSA for MicroG users:

MicroG SafetyNet Pass is back!

MicroG was passing SafetyNet with DroidGuard Helper in MagiskHide list and this fix:

https://github.com/microg/RemoteDroidGuard/pull/19#issuecomment-449368819

until June 2019.

At that time, Google apparently made more changes to DroidGuard, and the attestation failed again for the last 2+ years.

Efforts to fix tracked here:

https://github.com/microg/RemoteDroidGuard/issues/24

So this has now been fixed again (for last month):

https://github.com/microg/RemoteDroidGuard/issues/24#issuecomment-1022106867

Seems now need new microG GmsCore 0.2.23.214816, no need for RemoteDroidGuard apk...

https://github.com/microg/GmsCore/releases/tag/v0.2.23.214816

From changelog:

SafetyNet / DroidGuard:

• Implement DroidGuard without additional helper.

• Allow using external DroidGuard via network

• Easy check for SafetyNet functionality in settings

Nb. Later microG GmsCore v0.2.24.214816 is now available also.

🤠 PW
[Magisk] lcsboy:
I disabled all module and wifi/cell phone data, it takes almost 52 seconds in ASUS logo.

So what happened on 24.1? Any idea?
[Magisk] lcsboy:
How do I pass these 2 items as attachment?
[Magisk] c3k:
I tried Momo (4.0.1). It detect su, Magisk (app hidden), module files and Zygisk.

When I put it deny list, it crashes at launch. Normal?

I only use USFN, so I think the detection is an expected result and I've not to worry about it until all my app works, correct?
[Magisk] zgfg:
Momo does not look for Magisk app, hence for Momo is irrelevant did you do Hide Magisk app or not

Scroll through your Momo to the bottom and read, or see the attachment

What does it mean that your Momo detects module files?

Pls better provide your Momo screenshot

E.g., it detects su because of not in the DenyList.

But it's not normal that it crashes - did you reboot after adding Momo to DenyList?

Try also by wiping Cache and Data for Momo app before retesting

Also, what is your phone and ROM, Android version - Momo detections vary between the platforms

Yes, Momo is a powerful play tool that can detect various issues (for some platforms it will detect that Bootloader is unlocked, that ROM is custom, Data not encrypted, etc).

As long as you have no issues with banking apps and so, don't waste too much time on Momo
[Magisk] c3k:
thanks

attached

I've tried to restart & wipe data. It stop to crash as soon as I remove from the deny list.

Samsung latest stock rom, android 12.

yes, sure, it's just to learn something new
[Magisk] zgfg:
Zygisk - install Shamiko module to hide

USB debugging - disable in Developer options if you mind about this detection

BL unlocked - you would probably not be able to hide from Momo

su and modified files- Momo should be in DenyList but sorry, I don't recall anybody else reporting a crash with Momo then

Magisk - maybe DenyList would help but eg on Xiaomi it stays stubborn like BL unlocked
[Magisk] c3k:
Looked at logcat (attached), seems something font related.

Disabled "Font manager" module and now Momo starts in deny list and only Zygisk detected as expected.

🤷‍♂️
[Magisk] lyor:
What's the difference between installing Magisk with the official guide, and simply side-load it via TWRP by "just" changing the .apk to .zip?
[Magisk] zgfg:
No differences (assuming you patch the right img and with proper options) - but some new devices might not have proper custom recoveries, hence the old school method may not be applicable for them anymore
[Magisk] lyor:
So assuming I'm using custom recovery, no further changes are needed besides to flash the magisk.zip?

I didn't patch any boot.img in the process.
[Magisk] zgfg:
If on your same phone, ROM, TWRP it worked with Magisk v23, the same proc must still work (flashing in TWRP, without patching and fashing the patched img)

Howeverr, if you still have root, you can do Direct Install from Magisk app, the easiest way (easier than TWRP) - but you must first update the Magisk app

Make sure that you Restore Magisk app (your old one), before upaditng (if you ever did Hide Magisk app/mngr)!!!

And make sure that you install the latest Magisk v24 app (Stable or Canary, the same you want to flash)

Btw, find the new thread Magisk+Zygisk, read the OP posts there about installing and configuring Magisk v24
[Magisk] lyor:
I'm asking it for a new phone (just finished to setup LinageOS+TWRP) and didn't have a Magisk installed on it before.

So I could still just use set it up from TWRP via the zip file? (and I mean for the 24.1 directly).
[Magisk] zgfg:
If you trust to your TWRP for the new phone - how can I tell you?!

Check if the TWRP can use /data partition - it must install Magisk files to /data/adb - if it does not properly handle encryption on /data, it will not work

Besides, why would reading OP posts in the new thread and using patch & flash be a rocket science?
[Magisk] lyor:
Because it's much easier, and so much faster?
[Magisk] lyor:
btw, I did it already for my own experiment, I just wanted to know it's doesn't matter to the Magisk services itself.
[Magisk] J.Michael:
Have you read the Magisk Zygisk thread? Have you tried the procedure described in the first few posts?

I haven't done any of this. I have read many reports of success with what sounded like very few steps:

install Magisk

install USNF module

install Shamiko module
[Magisk] Skrjorge9:
Someone has done rooted and used successfuly magisk in a Samsung S21+ 5G??? the model is SM-G996B i already jailbreaked it but it doesnt appear the show up for magisk what i do?? im new in rooting i did the guide from how to install magisk with odin
[Magisk] AndrzejDwo:
Hi! Follow instructions from this thread and you'll be fine.

Cheers
[Magisk] pndwal:
Are you using 24.1? Do you mean unlocked bootloader by 'jailbreak'? What doesn't show up? (Get 'Installed: N/A'?). Was Magisk ever installed on this device before?... PW
[Magisk] pndwal:
Link broken? PW
[Magisk] zgfg:
Sorry but your link is not clickable:

[URL='http://Thread %27[RECOVERY][UNOFFICIAL] TWRP for Galaxy S21+ (Exynos)%27 https://xdaforums.com/t/recovery-unofficial-twrp-for-galaxy-s21-exynos.4241935/']this[/URL]

Seems you meant:

https://xdaforums.com/t/recovery-unofficial-twrp-for-galaxy-s21-exynos.4241935/

Or this if you prefer that way (I prefer seeing the link to be clicked on, to be sure it's not a bomb or something😜)

Ref also to @Skrjorge9 and @pndwal
[Magisk] Hayatzada:
Please copy video link and open in phone youtube app
[Magisk] AndrzejDwo:
The link should be fixed now, thanks for your vigilance xD

Cheers

PS it's not a bomb
[Magisk] sabei:
No captcha for me......

It's 14minutes long.......and it is in a non English language.......
[Magisk] zgfg:
And there is nothing new or special that was not covered by the guides in the new Magisk-Zygisk thread

Moreover, and that's the main problem, all such guides and their authors (silently) claim that the procedure will work generally, for ALL banking apps and for ALL phones/ROMs - but we well know IT'S NOT TRUE

There were already exmples of banking apps that can be easily made to work (DenyList, HMA) on the various phones but not e.g. on Xiaomi phones

Just like Momo. E.g., we all have Bootloader unlocked but Momo reports that only for certain phones (and systematically), altough all make the same hiding procedures

Fine to have the guides, and they can help to many people but the authors and forwarders should be honest to note that the given procedure may not work for all banking apps and all platforms

(Some probably mean that if it worked for them on two or three examples, that they can generalize and if it doesn't work for somebody else, it's not because of a different banking apps or something different with the new A11 or generally with MIUI, or so - but that those for whome it doesn't work did not properly follow their all-mighty procedure)

(Maybe the particular video does say that somewhere, but IDK without translation)