yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] Tesla:
Maybe. First you need to read more about magisk.

Then you need to provide more information.

Where you rooted when you installed Magisk and so on?
[Magisk] Tech 4 9:
Hello all. I read most of the unofficial magisk v13 and manager 5.0 snapshot thread before figuring out I should probably started here.

Ultimately I would like this on my moto g4 plus but it's my daily driver so I'd like to test on HTC m8 running resurrection remix N. Both phones have twrp but they might be 'unofficial' if that matters. Ideally I'd like to gain use of xposed on nougat and possibly get back to microG. I have a moto 360 1stgen smartwatch which requires (at least) the google app, moto connect app, and the Android wear app. I dont have much optimism regarding the watch/microG thing because I think it's pretty dependent on Google play services but just have xposed on nougat would be awesome. 12000 posts....pretty daunting. Are there 'instructions' anywhere? Is still build.prop this and that because I've never messed with editing build.prop. Also daunting. Should I start at beginning of this thread?

Thanks in advance. This seems very exciting!
[Magisk] PGHammer:
I'm Officially Curious - so much that I have downloaded the current Magisk and I'm now testing it as a straight-up alternative to SuperSU 2.79-RC3 - which has been my go-to- root program from my first Android device (a Lenovo tablet running KK at the time). I stuck with Super-SU when it added systemless mode (a requirement for N - which I now run on my phone) - and it was - until Magisk came along - THE systemless-root program. I started hearing more and more folks swearing by - not at - Magisk's systemless root - however, I had a different, unrelated-to-Magisk problem - finding a combo of ROM and GApps that didn't bork installed clean. With that solved, I'm now putting the current Magisk under the gun.

In practice, it's no harder to install Magisk than SuperSU - both installers are designed with popular third-party recoveries in mind; the shootout uses TWRP 3.1.0.0 (Official for the Samsung Galaxy Nexus) - my recovery since it was released. A standard install of SuperSU puts it at the near-tail of a multi-zip install (only an install/reinstall of the Official TWRP app follows it); the same is true of Magisk 12 (latest version). Therefore, this is a true apples-to-apples shootout. The installs of both, therefore, are as-recommended (clean).
[Magisk] Tech 4 9:
I saw something about moving files around in twrp if custom rom has supersu (cm supersu) built in, flashing, then moving files back. Is this still necessary? It will definitely be clean install with most recent gapps. Do I just flash rom/gapps per usual then install magisk like su? Tick some boxes and hope for three big green boxes declaring victory?! (thumbs up) If I could get Nugat , magisk and xposed on both phones tonight that would be frigging amazing!
[Magisk] yochananmarqos:
Xposed is not available for Nougat.

You'll need to flash osm0sis' unSU ZIP to remove built-in root before installing Magisk.
[Magisk] PGHammer:
I don't see why it would matter as to whether the version of TWRP is official or not, as all versions of TWRP - even the unofficial ones - have requirements in their building; for example, I run unofficial TWRP for the Lenovo A7-30F - but do so using the Official TWRP app on the same tablet (which does not HAVE an official version of TWRP). Due to that minimum standard (which applies to all versions of TWRP) whether the TWRP recovery is official or not is quite moot - if it weren't, wouldn't you think it would be an issue for Magisk's developer?

In the official Magisk thread (here on XDA), it is (rather explicitly) stated that Magisk root is, in fact, mostly usable with any ROM that can be rooted with SuperSU (so far, the only exception is LineageOS). I won't run LineageOS for any device that has an AOSP alternative in the same API (basically no Lineage OS 13 if AOSP MM is an option, for example) - however, that has nothing to do with Magisk; instead, it has to do with quirks in LineageOS operation itself; said quirks are NOT unique to LineageOS (Omni 6.0 - same API - has those same quirks; which is why it is no longer in contention, either, at least for me).
[Magisk] Tech 4 9:
I knew there was no xposed for nougat but I thought that one of the amazing things magisk can do. Ive seen in threads where people are using some form of xposed. A port or a module maybe? Idk but I know I saw it.

Edit: Actually, now that I think about it, I may have assumed the folks talking about xposed were on N. I'm so excited at the prospect of finally moving up to N with xposed that I assumed that everyone was interested in magisk for mostly JUST this purpose and all the other stuff was just awesome bonus. Like Magisk was born JUST for N and xposed. Ha! Tunnel vision. I'll look back at what I saw.
[Magisk] Tesla:
Maybe one day have it you will my young Padawan. ;)
[Magisk] bocondo:
Ok, I have spent several hours trying to make it work and now time to ask for help. I got Leeco LePro 3 with custom Ron based on EUI, and trying to get Magisk working. First I tried installing system less SuperSU and Magisk, but it failed safety check multiple times, so I tried uninstalling SuperSU and use Magisksu, but not I am not able to move forward. I installed Magisk manager and when it try to install Magisk manager it downloads but doesn't show way to install it, I even try flashing Magisk 12 zip using TWRP, but it fails to update. Can someone please help me with getting Magisk working with safety check?
[Magisk] Vasanth Vasi:
As I said earlier safety net pass failed........I'm on Lenovo k4 note marshmallow s232 built..........

Plz try to solve this problem.........:crying:
[Magisk] PGHammer:
xposed is not a driver for me; I have other reasons

In my case, xposed is not a driver - as I don't use xposed even on my tablet (which runs L, and therefore supports xposed).

I have the following reasons for interest in Magisk (as opposed to SuperSU - which I had been using).

1. Root hide - that means I can use apps that don't normally support rooted hardware (Android/Samsung Pay, Visa Checkout, etc.)

2. Module-based control in general (again, something that SuperSU lacks).

3. Does NOT interfere with Substratum (all my preferred AOSP ROMs either support, or use, Substratum - I can also run Substratum on L).
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Recovery log from flashing in TWRP, please.

Start by reading here:

https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/magisk-magisk-hide-troubleshooting-tips-t3561828
[Magisk] zukers:
I have installed Gsam battery monitor 3.32 and it can't get root (magisk 12) privileges, is any remedy for that?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Try again... Works fine for me with Magisk v12 and MagiskSU so it's not an issue with it not recognising MagiskSU.
[Magisk] zukers:
Unfortunately even after phone reboot I have this error on Gsam:

"A Error Occcurred, Unable to obtain superuser authority. Do you have root? Did you give Gsam authority?"

but nevermind, I grant perrmission by adb command:

adb shell pm grant com.gsamlabs.bbm.pro android.permission.BATTERY_STATS
[Magisk] lrsong96:
May I ask what the use of Magisk Module Template? Does it required to flash it ? I'm new to this MOD.
[Magisk] putridfoetus:
Deleted the viper folder from /magisk & rebooted to make sure it was all gone, flashed topjonwu's viper zip, flashed your zip to "systemize" the apk, still not processing. Even setting selinux to permissive does not help.

I miss my viper :crying:

I'll try a cache/dalvik wipe when I get home. Couldn't hurt...
[Magisk] topjohnwu:
Hello! Here are the new exciting features work in progress:

Install Modules in Magisk Manager without flashing in recovery

A repo open to developers to upload their work, handle updates and installation in the Manager
[Magisk] shuckeru:
Somebody in those organisation is doing their job too well...
[Magisk] soder:
Great! And cool. =)

Would someone please be so kind and try to explain for me, in an easy way, what the differences are between Magisk and Xposed for me? I use both, but I'm kind of not understand all this in a complete way like I'm sure you guys do.

Both do stuff for me, without having to change the android system, but, what are the differences?

Thanks.

/Söder
[Magisk] putridfoetus:
Interesting result after cache/dalvik wipe. It hurt. On reboot, after optimizing apps, I got bombarded by "Viper4androidFX has stopped" messages and had to hard shutdown and restart. I was able to disable the app immediately after getting into android and deleted the module. I think my issues with viper are deeper than magisk. Going to try a full wipe/flash factory image and start over.
[Magisk] gohamstergo:
Maybe use search next time.

http://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=68436436&postcount=1137
[Magisk] JudgeDread11:
Magisk runs system mod systemless. It can change anything in the system without actually touching the system partition.

Xposed where systemless or not is a framework to run apps that make modifications at runtime. So it can change the system as well as other apps on the fly.

While xposed run the system first and then modifies it, magisk modified the system on boot. The original of whatever is changed in magisk will never be loaded
[Magisk] donsandra:
Gud day. This rom is fit to lg g2 d802?
[Magisk] teddy0209:
It's not a rom, but rather a mod. It will work on your device as long as modification of boot.img is allowed...
[Magisk] Artim_96:
What teddy said... So I don't exactly know how good it will work on the G2 since your stuff needs to be bumped. And I don't know how well that will work together with Magisk. So maybe you search the G2 forum here while someone that has a G2 could give some more information
[Magisk] Iceyogurt:
What device are you using? Maybe you should disable or delete deep _buffer, topjohnwu didn't do this trick in his viper-magisk.zip package. If you are using OnePlus 3 oxygen OS like me, you also have to fix the audio_effect.conf problem.
[Magisk] ridobe:
This is my first post in this thread. I want to say hello and thanks to the op.

It has taken me a while to get this figured out so I'd like to post what worked for me.

- stock ROM

- elite kernel

- AdAway

- better battery stats

- no exposed and no multirom

I did all of this in the same recovery session:

1. Flashed back to stock to reset all su mods.

2. Flashed magisk-v6

3. Flashed phh-superuser-17-magisk

4. Flashed AdAway systemless << not necessary. Thanks to JudgeDread11

5. Flashed BBS systemless.

Reboot then load the magical and phh apps. Everything worked.
[Magisk] JudgeDread11:
You don't need to flash AdAway systemless. The hosts file is systemless by default with magisk so AdAway or anything else (firewall) using the hosts file will work systemless without any change.

Or do you mean the AdAway script from the modules thread.
[Magisk] ridobe:
I do not. Thanks for the clarification.
[Magisk] Nomelas:
So updating to a new version of Android with all this systemless installed... All I need is to reflash the magisk zip? Nothing else?
[Magisk] KaMyKaSii:
Yes
[Magisk] soder:
And first stock recovery I guess.

/Söder
[Magisk] adrman:
I've been running Magisk on my N6P since the early versions. Today, I installed it on my ancient Grouper with a MM rom and it's working perfectly. I thought it could be useful on that device since the system partition is so small. Prior to this, I was unable to install Action Launcher to priv-app to gain Google now functionality. With Magisk, no problem.
[Magisk] soder:
That's great. I would then like to do the same with the nexus launcher. There is a .zip going around that install 2 apk's somewhere in /system.

How do I do if I want to install them as systemless apps with Magisk. I guess the .zip I got is useless, and I have to put the files manually somewhere?

Also, about installing OTA's. I will have to go back to stock recovery when there will be a OTA for me. After the install I guess my system will boot up again before I can go back to TWRP.

Can I wait until then to flash the Magisk .zip, and everything will then still be installed systemless as before I did my OTA?

/Söder
[Magisk] Vasanth Vasi:
I have read everthing..........i tried it as it was mentioned.......but safety net fails.......what to doo.

Just tell me any way to solve dis...plz
[Magisk] dahawthorne:
Did you have another root installed before Magisk?

Have you enabled MagiskHide?
[Magisk] zukers:
I think I have more seriuos problem with Magisk, Manager show me that latest magisk v12.0 in installed, root MAGISKSU is accesible,

but every apps on phone can't get root access.

I have tried Magisk unistaller in TWRP then installing again, but it's the same manager show that everythig is OK, but apps not getting root privileges. Root Checker also show that phone does not have root.

Busybox is disabled, could anyone help me?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Provide details about your device and ROM, previous root solutions, current root solution, what you've tried so far, your shoe size etc... And provide logs. Magisk log, logcat, you name it...
[Magisk] yakie996:
often my phone gets unrooted while using it a reboot fixes this but after a while I am unrooted again... is there a fix? android 7.1.1 Motorola x style
[Magisk] zukers:
My device is HTC One M7,

ROM: [7.1.2_r2][23-04-2017] Resurrection Remix N

Previous root, no matter because ROM was installed on full wiped phone.

Log attached.
[Magisk] Sam Nakamura:
Disable busybox in magisk settings... It's a known issue
[Magisk] yakie996:
busybox is already disabled (never been enabled)
[Magisk] Morganator:
I'm on Android 7.1.2 on Samsung Galaxy Note 4.

I have Magisk v12 installed and the manager shows root is successful too. The SafetyNet check just keeps spinning though. And with Magisk installed and Magisk Hide enabled or disabled Snapchat just force closes/crashes. The moment I uninstall it it works again.

Is there something I'm missing?
[Magisk] SavageRobot:
Sorry if this is a dumb question but what am I missing? I have just moved back to stock MM on LG G3 from CR Droid N as I missed Xposed so much. However I just can't get this working at all. Had to completely uninstall Magical cause Snapchat wouldn't sign in and now I have downloaded and tried to install in magisk, wouldn't work, then in recovery and worked but doesn't register its installed.

Also from the start I have had a hard time getting modules to flash saying not magisk modules, even though from repo. Eg iOS 10 emoji and pixel experience. Any thoughts?

Oh yes, I am now on imperium ROM for g4 and had magisk installed in aroma. Then just uninstalled in magisk and reflashed.
[Magisk] Vasanth Vasi:
I'm running on Lenovo k4 note stock ROM s232....

Root works fine.......safety net failed......

I removed all gapps.....and tried but safety net fails........

---------- Post added at 04:55 PM ---------- Previous post was at 04:54 PM ----------

I'm running on Lenovo k4 note stock ROM s232....

Root works fine.......safety net failed......

I removed all gapps.....and tried but safety net fails........

Magisk logs ???

** Magisk post-fs mode running...

** Magisk post-fs-data mode running...

* Running post-fs-data.d

* Loading core props

* Preparing modules

* Stage 1: Mount system and vendor mirrors

* Stage 2: Mount dummy skeletons

* Stage 3: Mount module items

* Stage 4: Execute module scripts

* Stage 5: Mount mirrored items back to dummy

** Magisk late_start service mode running...

* Enabling systemless hosts file support

* Linking binaries to /sbin

* Starting MagiskSU

* Running service.d

* Starting MagiskHide

MagiskHide: Moving and re-linking /sbin binaries

MagiskHide: Removing dangerous read-only system props

MagiskHide: Killing com.google.android.gms.unstable

MagiskHide: Starting MagiskHide daemon

MagiskHide: Update process/package list:

MagiskHide: [com.google.android.gms.unstable]

Zygote(0) ns=mnt:[4026534591] Zygote(1) ns=mnt:[4026534593]

MagiskHide: com.google.android.gms.unstable(PID=5121 ns=mnt:[4026534675])

MagiskHide: Unmounted (/sbin)

MagiskHide: Unmounted (/magisk)

MagiskHide: Unmounted (/system/etc/hosts)

MagiskHide: com.google.android.gms.unstable(PID=8060 ns=mnt:[4026534723])

MagiskHide: Unmounted (/sbin)

MagiskHide: Unmounted (/magisk)

MagiskHide: Unmounted (/system/etc/hosts)

MagiskHide: com.google.android.gms.unstable(PID=13960 ns=mnt:[4026534633])

MagiskHide: Unmounted (/sbin)

MagiskHide: Unmounted (/magisk)

MagiskHide: Unmounted (/system/etc/hosts)

Plz helppppppp
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Logs look ok...

Have you checked if you pass basic integrity (like I mention in the thread I linked). Check with an app like SafetyNet Helper. If basic integrity is true there's probably not much you can on that device with that ROM. If there is you have a better chance of getting help by asking in your device's forum.

What it basically means is that if CTS fails, but basic integrity is true, Magisk Hide is working as it should but Google doesn't trust your device/ROM.
[Magisk] karthik km:
Reflashing boot.img and magisk via recovery

May fix this issue
[Magisk] yakie996:
I have lineageOS and i am rooted on with magisk flash zip
[Magisk] karthik km:
I have the same issue with Tesla AOSP

But after flashing just boot.IMG and again magisk on it,

Fix the problem

Try
[Magisk] chudy002:
Manager show me that latest magisk v12.0 in installed, root MAGISKSU is accesible,

but every apps on phone can't get root access.

I have tried Magisk unistaller in TWRP then installing again, but it's the same manager show that everythig is OK, but apps not getting root privileges. Root Checker also show that phone does not have root.

MI5 miui.eu 27.4.17 android 7.0 - same problem
[Magisk] batuken:
I got SafetyNet failed. I don't have Xposed installed. I also fully unrooted my device and flash Magisk afterwards. My device is Redmi Note 3 Pro running on RR Marshmallow. Here's the log:
[Magisk] guessingagain:
Might be stupid to ask but superuser is enabled in settings right?
[Magisk] davejimson:
Any solutikn for CTS profile mismatch:crying:
[Magisk] Ibuprophen:
One or more of these links should, at least, point you in the right direction.

https://plus.google.com/113289507447038338532/posts/cvRKddGaC8g

https://xdaforums.com/nexus-6p/help/cts-profile-mismatch-t3562465

https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/issue-magisk-hide-t3533171

Good Luck!

"Live Long and Prosper..."

~Ambassador S'chn T'gai Spock

Sent via Communicator [D2VZW] from the Bridge of the U.S.S. Enterprise [NCC-1701].
[Magisk] PGHammer:
Magisk v.12 and MM 4.33 (both current) on ex-VZW Samsung Galaxy Nexus on Tracfone. Root works fine; however, SafetyNet flops (same issue that ibuprophen sees - CTS profile mismatch). However, I'm also seriously considering doing more testing over the weekend to see if it is, in fact, a Magisk-related issue. ROM is PureNexus 7.1.2 unofficial (based on Unlegacy AOSP 7.1.2); due to that base, the same issues likely affect Unlegacy 7.1.2 and Dirty Unicorns 7.1.2 for the Galaxy Nexus as well. As a straight root program, it works fine - if anything, it is LESS of a drag on performance than SuperSU. Okay - the G+ Community that ibuprophen linked to above suggests using Magisk Hide - while it is hidden from Android Pay by default, it was NOT hidden from the two CTS applets (oooopies). Apparently, that is NOT enough - still getting the profile mismatch flag. (So much for a quick fix.)
[Magisk] Vasanth Vasi:
I tried all d safety net helper apps.......they didn't​ help me.......

In addition to that I uninstalled all the gapps......so they might pass the safety net........but even that didn't help me out...........

Is it because of xposed I'm facing all such problems...????
[Magisk] lenin1928:
Installed Dolby Atmos 6.5c which was an upgrade. Got a black screen on reboot. Deleted mod but black screen persists. Decided to delete all mods, and reinstalled magisk 12.0 using twrp. Still black screen. No doubt this made things worse, but can I eliminate the black screen and keep my current config without doing a complete wipe? I assume that's the next step...

Xposed never and not installed. No conflicting su super programs. Using supplied root program with magisk.

Running viper rom latest HTC 10 Sprint. S-Off. TWRP 3.03 unofficial. Elemental kernel 1.06

Any help would be EXTREMELY appreciated.
[Magisk] jcarlos7121:
MagiskSu not installed

I installed supersu, then i flashed magisk, with the goal of getting magisk su installed, then i realized the magisk su didnt got installed. I thought it was cause i already had supersu before, so i undo the root, and tried to flash magisk su again, a message appeared saying i need supersu to be installed first, so i flashed again supersu and then flashed magisksu again. Still no luck, i cant get installed the magisksu eventhought the flash installed with TWRP says it was successful. am i missing an extra step?

Nexus 5X bullhead.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
For SafetyNet to pass, nothing extra needs to be hidden. All those apps, Android Pay, SafetyNet helpers, and whatever app uses or checks SafetyNet use an API in Play services. Play services are hidden by default, done...

About your problem: do you have busybox enabled in Magisk Manager settings? That's been confirmed to break Magisk Hide on Pure Nexus (it already has busybox - conflict) and probably other ROMs with built-in busybox.

You didn't read the link I posted to you at all, did you...?

YES!

---------- Post added at 06:31 ---------- Previous post was at 06:27 ----------

Your boot image is patched for SuperSU. Magisk will interpret that as you wanting to use SuperSU.

Restore your stock boot image and try again. How, you might ask. It's been discussed to death. Search.
[Magisk] Sirguda:
All of a sudden, Titanium Refused to work, saying I was not root. But it always worked fine with my ROM and Magisk.

In Magisk, it says I have no Permission :

(it says "Rooted but no root permission, not granted ?")

I tried to install again magisk in TWRP, reinstall my ROM (Revolution Remix which includes Magisk), but it changes nothing. I don't know what to do. Someone has a solution ?

I never installed SuperSu before. I tried today to make Titanium work, but my phone refused to boot, I had to install again my ROM.
[Magisk] Matts_:
Hi all!

Magisk is denying su requests from adaway although I set the default action to allow.

Also there'll be no request for new apps requesting su, so I don't get to choose wether to grant or to deny su. I'm just getting the popup telling me it had been denied (or allowed depending on the default action).

posted mobile with oneplus3 freedomos 2.8
[Magisk] Karls0:
I use adaway and it has normally requested permission. Maybe try to clear app data of Magisk Manager?
[Magisk] Matts_:
I'll try but it behaves this way since the first time I used it, say since I installed freedom OS.

Edit: I took your advice, but still there's no request window when apps demand su. Tested with SD Maid, which gets denied after the set amount of time unless I set the default action to allow.

I'm literally not able to allow any app su.

posted mobile with oneplus3 freedomos 2.8
[Magisk] teddy0209:
Check that root access in apps is enabled in magisk manager setting. If you have other or build in root management app disable it.
[Magisk] Karls0:
Ok, I have one more idea. I had similar issue but with one app, not all. What I did was rebooting phone while in Magisk it was set to ask for permission, not allow all. Just after boot (unlock screen as fast as possible) it asked for permission but only once. If you will be not fast enough you have to try again.
[Magisk] Matts_:
That didn't do anything.

But I found a solution. When I enable core more (modules disabled) I'm getting a request window and can allow su for all apps automatically and manually.

posted mobile with oneplus3 freedomos 2.8
[Magisk] Skulltec:
I recently installed Pure Nexus on my Nexus 5X. I have flashed magisk to my device and passed by safety net. However after flashing a costum rom the safety net fails. I tried with franco and elemental x kernels:(

edit: after reflashing the boot.img that came with the rom, magisk didn't pass by the safety net again..