yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] jenslody:
Asked and answered many times:

most likely a missing MagiskManager-folder in the root of your internal memory.

Create it (name should be "MagiskManager" without the quotse of course) and it should work.

It's a known issue and will surely be fixed.
[Magisk] DankMemester:
Does anyone know if Majisk works with Motorola devices? Specifically moto g 2 in my case.
[Magisk] MultiKoopa:
I know this isn't the FlashFire topic, but... has anybody ever managed to do one of the monthly OTA updates entirely through FlashFire, and keeping Magisk/root/custom recovery?
[Magisk] John877:
[MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] [MENTION=4667597]Didgeridoohan[/MENTION]

I installed Magisk 14/Manager 5.3.0 and it was working fine, had root, could probly download modules (didnt get to that yet), etc but had one hugely annoying problem. I was getting a long series of apps force closing. Mainly Google Play Services Framework, Samsung Notes, and a few others. I referred to the apps force closing section of the troubleshooting thread and installed/uninstalled all the apps mentioned (Chrome stable, Chrome beta, Android Webview) and nothing worked.

I have since completely uninstalled Magisk 14/Manager 5.3.0 and reflashed the stock boot.img back to try to get rid of this but the force closes still persists. I dont have TWRP recovery flashed as I wanted to retain the ability to get OTA updates so I flashed the boot.img in ODIN instead. As a result I cant flash the Magisk Uninstaller since its not flashable in ODIN.

[MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] I have since also installed MatLog to create logcats of the events surrounding the force closes and I have uploaded a logcat in this thread here: https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=73770037&postcount=37

Im not sure how much help it will be but I hope it does help some.

[MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] Is there another way to flash the Magisk Uninstaller possibly from ODIN maybe? In the stock recovery it wont let me mount the SD card, which I take to mean the internal memory even though I do have an external SD card installed as well. The only other option is through adb but I am not really familiar with adb beyond copy/pasting commands.

I REALLY REALLY would like to avoid a factory reset or even reflashing the complete stock ROM which I got from SAMMOBILE. Therefore any help to fix this would be greatly appreciated.
[Magisk] hany0u:
Xposed have, but I dont have xposed.

https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.mrchandler.disableprox
[Magisk] deepak3048:
Can any one help me i have one issue with magusk ... I am using op3 rr rom 5.8.4 with magisk 14 some times magisk manager showing magisk not installed then i just restart my phone then its ok it showing it installed after few hr or few days it showing same problem.. Then i repeat same procedure then ok.... can any one tell me why it happen and what's the solution
[Magisk] Stoucks:
I can download and install the module, but when i reboot my device (Asus Zenfone 2 Laser Z00ED, Lineage 14.1 Unofficial) under the module i can read "Module will be update after next reboot" and if i reboot again, i can read again the same phrase.
[Magisk] Artim_96:
Depends if your phone has the same buggy F2FS implementation like other motorolas. If yes you should be able to find a modified version that installs to a ext4 partition
[Magisk] sushuguru:
Something went wrong with the latest Magisk or maybe the template, i made a test with Magisk 14 and Magisk Manger 5.3

1. Installing Module with old template (13.3 Compatible):

- Via Manager: "Module will be updated after next reboot"

- Via Recovery: Flash successfully and the module works fine when checked at Manager

2. Installing Module with new template (v1400)

- Via Manager: "Module will be updated after next reboot"

- Via Recovery: Flash FAILED.

So basically you can try finding old version of module (the one that worked with 13.3) then flashed via recovery for temporary fix.
[Magisk] Pkt_Lnt:
https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=73768843&postcount=18933
[Magisk] Stoucks:
I have already a directory called MagiskManager, so? i tried a lot of time this method and still don't work
[Magisk] mika91:
+1

Same problem, same solution.

Just create a "MagiskManager" folder on storage root.
[Magisk] InfinityFath:
Same here, i tried many things but it won't fix :rolleyes:

I think it's magisk problem, but i'm not sure where is the problem

In my case, all modules works just fine though, so till next update i'll ignore it
[Magisk] Stoucks:
Me too, all modules works. But it's impossible to update they for now. Not a big problem, i just report this to all the community. For sure is a bug of Magisk
[Magisk] GCalzo:
I had problems with v13.3 on my old MotoG2 but with v14 it's fine without any "tricks" :good:
[Magisk] sushuguru:
Nope that's not the case, this fixed the bug when downloading or install module directly via Manager, my case is with a downloaded module zip file.
[Magisk] Pkt_Lnt:
This issue *needs* logs to identify the issue and solve it then. Magisk log and a logcat running while you try install and reboot.
[Magisk] mel2000:
My phone won't boot flashing the latest Magisk v14 zip. I just updated to the latest June OTA for my Moto G4+ xt1644. Also successfully reinstalled TWRP 3.1.1.0 and ElementalX 1.04 kernel.

I uninstalled previous Magisk Manager and also flashed the Magisk uninstaller.zip via TWRP. Then I installed Magisk-v14.0.zip and wiped cache/Dalvik, then rebooted. Phone stayed stuck at the 'bootloader unlocked' screen for more than 20 minutes. I gave up and rolled back to a non-Magisk archive. System is now fine but without root.

I haven't found others with the same issue. Since my phone doesn't have NFC anyway, and since I doubt there will be another G4+ update, would it be better for me to try an alternative root process instead? Or does anyone have troubleshooting tips for my Magisk issue? Thanks.

EDIT: I flashed with Magisk v13.3, which worked for me before. It flashed and booted without a hitch. I hope Magisk v14.0 gets fixed soon because Magisk Manager 5.1.1 keeps prompting me to install Magisk v14.0 after every step I take within the app.
[Magisk] fndpena:
I just flashed September update + magisk 14.0 using flashfire, but now ctsProfile is false. Anybody knows why this is happening?
[Magisk] Pkt_Lnt:
Did you read through this post and try some suggestions?

https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=73145987&postcount=4

From the definitive [GUIDE] Magisk and MagiskHide installation and troubleshooting (Magisk v14.0) by Didgeridoohan
[Magisk] Empty Hand:
Same issue after installing the Sept update. I tried all the troubleshooting tips from the guides.
[Magisk] abced123:
installation question

What is the real difference for the installation between flashing thru TWRP and the magisk manager ? If i do not have stock boot image dump, and install by the manager; will I have problem later if I uninstall magisk ? TIA
[Magisk] jeffreymcclain:
Same issue with me, just flashed the September Oreo update on my Nexus 6P as well.
[Magisk] Vithon:
Just give it a few hours then it should say true
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Maybe Google messed up the certification on the update. Wouldn't be the first time... :p

If you want to install Magisk (from a clean slate) through the Manager without a stock boot image file available you won't have any issues uninstalling later, because you won't be able to install Magisk at all... :D

If you already have Magisk installed it's a different matter through. There shouldn't be any issues updating through the Manager.
[Magisk] robbyoconnor:
I CONSISTENTLY lose magisk -- I don't know _HOW_ but it happens frequently.
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
Magisk FTW!
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Unless you can provide useful details, logs, reproducibility steps, etc you'll likely not see any fix...
[Magisk] theandroidguy:
what files are these??? Whenever I'm turning on the data the dowload starts automatically

Feel free to pm me and hit the THANKS button
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
What does this have to do with Magisk? :confused:
[Magisk] rfgamaral:
I have Magisk v13.3 currently installed, can I install v14 and keep running all my modules or will they stop working until they are updated to the new module template?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
They'll most likely keep working. Some modules using boot scripts or similar might need updating...

There might be some issues requiring clearing data for the Manager or a clean install off v14.0, but I'd say cross that bridge if you get to it...
[Magisk] anandverma458:
Anyone with an answer?
[Magisk] LironImaN:
With Magisk V14's new installation method, can we root Samsung devices without tripping Knox?
[Magisk] Artim_96:
No. And it will never. Just no dev cares to invest any time into finding out how to do so. The chance that it will ever be needed is too low.

If you care about Knox, just get rid of your phone and get something better
[Magisk] SB13X:
My issue on GitHub appears to have been closed with the enclosed boot.img from my Samsung S7 Edge has anything been done again or statement made regards the installation of Magisk via the new ODIN Manager patched_boot.img.tar method? [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION]

---------- Post added at 07:09 PM ---------- Previous post was at 07:09 PM ----------

My issue on GitHub appears to have been closed with the enclosed boot.img from my Samsung S7 Edge has anything been done again or statement made regards the installation of Magisk via the new ODIN Manager patched_boot.img.tar method? [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION]
[Magisk] DeathHacker:
It seems to me that he completely removed the issue tracker on GitHub.
[Magisk] danilo_scala:
my question in GitHub closed ,, i can not install magisk 13x and 14 in xperia z5 premium, only 12 and dont pass in safetynet
[Magisk] Sly123:
I have a big problem now.

I tried the new function "Hide Magisk".

But now "Unhide Magisk" is not working. Magisk doesn't show up and I can't grant root access for apps.

Please tell me what to do except(!) using Unhide because it doesn't work.

I tried Reinstalling Magisk - no change

I tried using the newest Uninstaller and installed again - also no change

This is a very big issue for me. Please help.

I never thought this function would break my magisk. So I also did no backup.
[Magisk] Artim_96:
Maybe record a catlog of opening unhide. It should launch something. If it can't, there should be errors
[Magisk] Sly123:
[/COLOR]

I don't have the Unhide.apk no more.

Can someone provide me or is it completely unique?

But at first Magisk Uninstaller should still work, no matter what.

Now my phone is messed up instead.:crying:
[Magisk] Artim_96:
Flashed stock boot.img inbetween? And removed the magisk.img?
[Magisk] robbyoconnor:
I wish I knew what was happening...I just lose root...and then go into Magisk Manager and it shows as not installed...Magisk 14 also caused Xposed to become messed up...so there's also THAT issue,
[Magisk] jenslody:
You should be able to uninstall MagiskManager via adb ( "adb uninstall com.topjohnwu.magisk" ) and reinstall it from the Magisk-zip (the apk is in the common-folder inside it).

At least I could do this with a hidden Manager. Installing the apk over the hidden Manager, without uninstalling it before, does not work. Neither does uninstalling it from a terminal with "pm uninstall ..."
[Magisk] phoberus:
Can someone take a look at my module?

The only thing it should do, is to run a command:

echo 1 > sys/devices/virtual/graphics/fb0/DCI_P3

At the moment it is made in the service.sh file, but Magisk crashes:

--------- beginning of main
I( 460: 460) Magisk v14.0(1400) daemon started
I( 460: 463) ** post-fs mode running
--------- beginning of system
I( 460: 754) ** post-fs-data mode running
I( 460: 754) * Mounting mirrors
I( 460: 754) mount: /dev/block/bootdevice/by-name/system -> /dev/magisk/mirror/system
I( 460: 754) link: /dev/magisk/mirror/system/vendor -> /dev/magisk/mirror/vendor
I( 460: 754) bind_mount: /dev/magisk/mirror/bin
I( 460: 754) * Mounting /data/magisk.img
I( 460: 754) * Running post-fs-data.d scripts
I( 460: 754) post-fs-data.d: exec [dci-p3]
...
I( 460: 754) DCI-P3_Enabler_OP3T: constructing magic mount structure
...
I( 460: 966) DCI-P3_Enabler_OP3T: exec [service.sh]
I( 460: 793) proc_monitor: zygote ns=mnt:[4026534209] zygote64 ns=mnt:[4026534210]
--------- beginning of crash
I( 460: 793) proc_monitor: com.google.android.gms.unstable (PID=4084 ns=mnt:[4026534340])
I( 4096: 4096) hide_utils: Re-linking /sbin

Can someone help me?

All credits to doubleaykay, he tried it some time ago too but for much people it wasn't working
[Magisk] jenslody:
The first thing I would do is use an absolute path in the service.sh.

And then get rid of all unneeded stuff: at least set automount to false in config.sh (because it's not needed), and (that's more or less a matter of taste) remove the example system.prop, post-fs-data.sh and the empty system-folder to make the module cleaner.
[Magisk] phoberus:
OK, I cleaned it like you wrote:good:

I don't understand the thing with the absolute path:

Now it looks like this:

MODDIR=${0%/*}
echo 1 > sys/devices/virtual/graphics/fb0/DCI_P3

How should I change it?
[Magisk] jenslody:
MODDIR=${0%/*}
echo 1 > [B][COLOR=Red]/[/COLOR][/B]sys/devices/virtual/graphics/fb0/DCI_P3

It should not matter if it's guaranteed, that the script is run from the root folder, otherwise the path you use is not valid.

And you should be sure that "DCI_P3" exists. I tried it on my phone, where it not exists, from adb shell and it leads to a "No such file or directory" error.

I assume that the command works as expected from a shell (if not run from inside magisk).
[Magisk] theredbaron1834:
So, I was unable to install any modules. Checked my logs, and it was because of a missing folder. Aka, no MagiskManager folder was found in my main storage. Created, and it worked.

Is this a known issue, the not creating a folder?
[Magisk] InfinityFath:
Here you go
[Magisk] mobileman88:
Been hours. Still false for me too.
[Magisk] truckmann:
Did you ever get it working again? I installed the Sept update earlier today and I'm seeing the same issue.
[Magisk] Asuly:
!boot image patched by other programs! what i can do?
[Magisk] MoistPicklez:
So I'm assuming that other people are aware or my device is just bugging out but I'm not passing safety net fully at all. I just did a fresh install of magisk on Blu spark kernel and no passy..
[Magisk] mobileman88:
I think we will need to wait for a new update from [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] to fix this
[Magisk] cthulhu1987:
Is there a module request thread or something like that somewhere? I'd be nice if there'd be a Magisk version of the "App Locale" or "App Settings" Xposed modules to change the locale of individual apps, if that is at all possible systemlessly, I know very, very, very little about the inner workings of Magisk.
[Magisk] jenslody:
It's known and asked/answered many times before in this thread.

It's fixed on github and should work in next version.
[Magisk] RASTAVIPER:
I own a OP3T with OOS 4.1.7 + Franco kernel and Magisk 13.3 and Xposed.

Everything was working fine but I noticed recently that whenever I click on the Superuser tab of the Magisk side menu, the app closes without any message.

This is creating a headache as I cannot enter superuser and grant rights to some apps. Is there any other way to do it?
[Magisk] Armaldio:
Hello,

When I turn off magiskhide then exit the magisk manager, when I reopen the manager, magisk hide option is re-enabled automatically

How can I turn off magisk hide then ?
[Magisk] phoberus:
Before the latest Oxygen OS beta for Oneplus 3/3T, the file was only there for the oneplus 3T with the right display panel (must be the same as in the Oneplus 5). Since the last beta, it is also possible for Oneplus 3 if the kernel is compatible (-> has the file) with the DCI-P3 mode.

Tested it now as the only activated module:

The echo command works, but magisk still crashes at the end.

Log:

--------- beginning of main

I( 462: 462) Magisk v14.0(1400) daemon started

I( 462: 464) ** post-fs mode running

--------- beginning of system

I( 462: 754) ** post-fs-data mode running

I( 462: 754) * Mounting mirrors

I( 462: 754) mount: /dev/block/bootdevice/by-name/system -> /dev/magisk/mirror/system

I( 462: 754) link: /dev/magisk/mirror/system/vendor -> /dev/magisk/mirror/vendor

I( 462: 754) bind_mount: /dev/magisk/mirror/bin

I( 462: 754) * Mounting /data/magisk.img

I( 462: 754) * Running post-fs-data.d scripts

I( 462: 754) * Running module post-fs-data scripts

I( 462: 754) * Loading modules

I( 462: 754) * Enabling systemless hosts file support

I( 462: 754) bind_mount: /system/etc/hosts

I( 462: 765) * Starting MagiskHide

I( 462: 765) hide_utils: Hiding sensitive props

I( 462: 765) hide_list: [com.google.android.gms.unstable]

I( 462: 765) hide_list: [com.joeykrim.rootcheck]

I( 462: 765) proc_monitor: init ns=mnt:[4026531840]

I( 462: 922) ** late_start service mode running

I( 462: 922) * Running service.d scripts

I( 462: 922) * Running module service scripts

I( 462: 922) DCI-P3_Enabler_OP3T: exec [service.sh]

I( 462: 765) proc_monitor: zygote ns=mnt:[4026534210] zygote64 ns=mnt:[4026534209]

--------- beginning of crash

I( 462: 765) proc_monitor: com.google.android.gms.unstable (PID=4027 ns=mnt:[4026534339])

I( 4040: 4040) hide_utils: Re-linking /sbin

edit:

Same result if I check the file first

MODDIR=${0%/*}
dci="/sys/devices/virtual/graphics/fb0/DCI_P3"
if [ -f "$dci" ]
then
echo "DCI-P3 is supported"
echo 1 > /sys/devices/virtual/graphics/fb0/DCI_P3
echo "DCI-P3 is activated"
else
echo "DCI-P3 is not supported. Delete this module."
fi
[Magisk] garris_bibop:
Safetynet still not working. MagiskHide does, however. Also, I have problems booting (no reaction after entering PIN) when i install more than 2 modules.

Could someone give me feedback about my log file? What is the crash about and what is com.google.android.gms.unstable?

Thx in advance...
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
Can you install RootBeer Sample, add it to the Magisk Hide list and post a screenshot of its result?
[Magisk] garris_bibop:
Little confused now ^^

Other Root checkers don't detect it. And busybox is actually installed!
[Magisk] TNSMANI:
I had the same issue. It is recommended to either clear data for Magisk Manager or to uninstall and reinstall it. I uninstalled and reinstalled Magisk Manager and SuperSU started working.
[Magisk] k0m3n9:
On stock (not rooted) Galaxy J1 Ace (SM-J111F) i've successfully installed Magisk 14 via Magisk Manager 5.3.0 with patched boot.img (no twrp). SafetyNet check successful. Superuser works. Hide Magisk Manager works.

Only on boot image location it shows (Cannot auto detect) & when flashing any magisk modules downloaded via downloads section it shows "- Copying zip to temp directory. This zip is not a Magisk Module!”

Any solution.. without installing twrp?
[Magisk] nacho159:
Bricked my phone - no recovery but can access fastboot

Hi I have an Oppo R7g.

I updated to the official spectrum ROM (marshmallow) from ColorOS 2.1.0i (lollipop) (http(removethis)://community.oppo.com/en/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=45652&extra=)

I then wished to root my phone with Magisk root and made the mistake of flashing the v14.0 zip instead of the modified boot.img.

This failed and i was stuck at a black screen. I force rebooted and now I can't get past first splash screen (usually I get a flash screen then boot animation) the splash screen shows and then the phone shuts down.

I can access fastboot but not recovery.

I have tried: http(removethis)://community.oppo.com/en/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=43383 which did not solve anything

I have also tried: http(removethis)://community.oppo.com/en/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=48654 However the Msm8x39DownloadTool exe just says cannot find device even tho it is plugged in and in fastboot mode.

I have tried flashing recovery.img, boot.img clearing userdata etc...

Nothing has helped me so far idk what to do now.

Any help is greatly greatly appreciated.
[Magisk] anhnambroz:
Hi. I'm using Magisk 14.0 on my S3, DND Unf 7.1.2 I can't create any folder in /system. I have tried to mount as rw but still can't write in /system. Any solution? :(
[Magisk] garris_bibop:
Installed new busybox (osmisis) via twrp. Sateynet still failing.

New log and rootbeer results.
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
Do you only fail ctsProfile or both ctsProfile and basicIntegrity?
[Magisk] garris_bibop:
Both :(
[Magisk] mnsor1234:
What is the response is invalid help someone? Samsung s7 edge aosp ROM 7.1.2
[Magisk] mobileman88:
For my case I only fail the CTs profile for the September update of the O rom on 6p
[Magisk] goRt:
Can confirm 14.0 also still breaks VoLTE on S8, removing Magisk enables the function, can't get it working hiding anything
[Magisk] Paschfire:
Are you using any Magisk modules? I had this issue on my Nexus 5 when using the Adreno_gpu_systemless Installer module. Trying disabling/deleting all modules and reboot to see if this solves the issue.

Either way pls include a Magisk Log with your error reporting.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
If basic integrity is passing we know that MagiskHide is working, but if the CTS profile check fails that makes me suspect that Google messed up the certification for the update.
[Magisk] goodboyshek:
When installed Magisk, few apps has crash problem like Mozilla firefox. And without magisk everything works fine but I need magisk to work.

I can't see WebView issue in logcats but I have no knowledge about this. Can you please help me solving this issue? I'm attaching snapshots.

logcat 1

logcat 2

logcat 3

Screenshot

Abhishek

Phone Lenovo A6010

ROM RR 5.8.3 Android 7.1.2 x32

Clean Flash
[Magisk] ito.tm:
I have a Oneplus X with latest ResurrectionRemix (7.1.2) and I experienced a strange behaviour with Magisk 13.3 and 14, the magisk_daemon takes 15-20% cpu, draining battery. Is this a known problem? I unistalled it after a few minutes, did I have to wait?

Thanks
[Magisk] kaw900r:
Sprint U11 latest BadBoyz safety net passes but o get not rooted and magisk not installed...

---------- Post added at 11:18 PM ---------- Previous post was at 10:58 PM ----------

Still running v13.3 since it seems like v14 was having issues.
[Magisk] X-Nemesis:
I'm using a OPO and I noticed that some of my modules have the alert that they will update after the next reboot. I reboot, but they remain with that alert. How do I get these modules to update?

Greenify

iYTBP

Enable Doze

Emoji One

CrossBreeder Lite

Greenify
[Magisk] SGE_DEW:
I have the same issue. Were you able to find a fix? Android pay not working.
[Magisk] 3lMghraby:
hey how to add and echo command on boot with magisk
[Magisk] jaum20:
Safetynet no passing :crying:
[Magisk] mobileman88:
bummer, shall have to wait a while then
[Magisk] lukino563:
Hi guys,

Im very satisfied with your work, but can you add option to settings to switch system mirroring in /dev/magisk?
[Magisk] mobileman88:
Not at all unfortunately. Hopefully there's one soon.
[Magisk] kz hard:
Hi guys! i can't download a module on the magisk manager.. i tried several times but it says, "processing error".. what could be the cause of it?.. my internet connection is fine. i download modules on browser instead from the app, but it kind of a hassle for me.
[Magisk] jenslody:
Do you have by any chance logging disabled (e.g. with kernel adiutor) ?

---------- Post added at 09:35 AM ---------- Previous post was at 09:33 AM ----------

Did you search this thread for the error ? It does not look so.

Make sure you have a MagiskManager-folder in the root of your internal memory. If it is not there,create it and try again.
[Magisk] k0m3n9:
Hurmm.. is there anyone here managed to install Magisk 14 on stock device (not rooted) + without custom recovery?
[Magisk] kz hard:
[MENTION=8340552]jenslody[/MENTION] .. it works! thank you
[Magisk] buayasawah:
Yes. I even reflash my rom to make sure, but it didnt work for me.
[Magisk] kotlin:
Did anyone succesfully installed it on Z3?? I tried several roms and can't make it work - SafetyNet still fails