yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] :
There are several threads on this, though none with my situation it seems. I did try toggling USB debugging. No luck. I'm on the latest Magisk version (13.3)
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
Please attach a screenshot of main Magisk Manager screen
[Magisk] :
here you go

Magisk error log:

--------- beginning of main

I( 215: 215) Magisk v13.3(1330) daemon started

I( 215: 217) ** post-fs mode running

--------- beginning of system

I( 215: 230) ** post-fs-data mode running

I( 215: 230) * Mounting /data/magisk.img

E( 215: 230) mount /dev/block/loop0->/magisk failed with 22: Invalid argument

I( 215: 369) ** late_start service mode running

I( 215: 369) * Running service.d scripts

I( 215: 369) * Running module service scripts
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
Can you also attach Magisk log from Magisk Manager?
[Magisk] :
Added the log to my previous post.
[Magisk] Firdhaus81:
Good evening to you Sir Artim,

So i did a clean boot.img installation via odin. Flashed Twrp via odin. Then went ahead to flash magisk 13.3 and Voila! Installed Magisk Manager 5.1.1 & checked. Results were breath taking. Thanks again Sir. :)
[Magisk] buayasawah:
Hi, what do you mean by short reboot? Whenever i flash a file via TWRP i always clear dalvik/cache and reboot.
[Magisk] napster113:
S6 edge plus all works fine. Exposed - Pokemon go - Pokemon go joystick - Root and Tasker, I'm one happy bunny.
[Magisk] Norbix1999:
Please Help
[Magisk] Kiid:
After days of messing around manually adding files, tweaking permissions and whatnot, I still can't get viper to work.. It's still asks to install the driver. I've searched this thread and come up with nothing.. There's a v4a file in the Magisk directory but I'm stuck here. Don't know what to do.. Anyone kind enough to walk me through getting this to work? Cheers.

S6 SM-G920I 6.0.1 XtreStoLite Rom
[Magisk] Eneco:
Hey guys, I just installed Magisk, but now I'm having some trouble getting AdAway to work. Installed the app from FDroid and from what I've read I should just be able to use the default settings using /system/etc/hosts, right? Unfortunately that doesn't seem to work, neither does using the hosts file in the magisk folder. Am I doing something wrong here?
[Magisk] adrman:
Not sure about the FDroid version, but give MrRobinson's build a try here. Don't flash the systemless zip there though. It works just as it is with Magisk.
[Magisk] WillyRy:
Up and running on Viper for HTC 10! Android pay "working", just gotta actually try it at the store! Thx, Mr. Wu!!!!

Full uninstall SuperSU, TWRP flash Magisk v6 then flash "phh's SuperUser 17 (Magisk Version) (2016.8.20)", reboot install Magisk Manager apk, Playstore phh super user.
[Magisk] djjohnnyblaze:
[MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] [MENTION=1162986]Captain_Throwback[/MENTION] [MENTION=7672672]Ph@nta[/MENTION] [MENTION=2769839]DanielF50[/MENTION]

Attempt: Trying to port ARISE Numbers 3.5 Mod to Magisk V6 Module

Device information:

Samsung Galaxy S6 (SM-G920W8)

Android 6.0.1

Stock TouchWiz G920W8VLU4CPG2

Magisk V6

Magisk Manager 1.2

phh's SuperUser 17 (Magisk Version)

Systemless Xposed (Magisk Version)

Issues after flashing the zip:

Loss of Magisk root (as reported by Magisk Manager and confirmed by trying apps that require root)

Loss of Xposed (says installed but not activated)

Most /magisk/arise/system files not being Magisk Mounted as per logs

Magisk logs provided (attached to this post)

Mod link: https://mega.nz/#!MUpT2SzS!aUrgEdpR0RUD7PpS5h8nP0hAQg-ivANmcAr2wcGcmyI

When removing all files from /magisk/arise/system except for a few:

/magisk/arise/system/priv-app & /magisk/arise/system/bin,

the files in those directories are actually mounted. You can see the difference in the logs labeled "before removing files" and "after removing files".

However, even though the files are mounted, root/xposed still dont work. Maybe is is one of the setprop commands causing issues?

Please take a look and provide any insight / feedback.

Thanks!
[Magisk] Jeggu:
I've used magisk for a while now on MM and it worked great. However now when I try to use it on CM14 nougat installing magisk v6 kills mobile data (unable to connect)
[Magisk] Artim_96:
Well, maybe something in flashing went win and a reflashing/factory reset would help or CM just messed too much up... Probably the last one, they are known for that.

Either way, maybe someone can tell you which logs would be helpful here since I don't know if there would be anything in the recommended ones, but just to be sure just provide them as explained somewhere in the OP

---------- Post added at 11:57 PM ---------- Previous post was at 11:56 PM ----------

No, Android 4.x isn't supported

[MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] maybe that's something you could write into the threads headline so everyone sees it even without opening this thread. I just looked at the OP and if I wouldn't know anything about systemless it would be quite hard to find out which Android versions are actually supported

---------- Post added 13th September 2016 at 12:06 AM ---------- Previous post was 12th September 2016 at 11:57 PM ----------

In theory it should work, but I'm reading some comments lately that there are still problems with Sony stock firmware.

And no, phh's SuperUser and Chainfire's SuperSU are two completely different things. Basically they do the same main thing (allow other apps to access root rights), but that's it with similarities
[Magisk] buayasawah:
Hey there. How did you get it activated? Im using mi5 and cant get the systemless xposed activated on my device. Magisk and phh SU work though.
[Magisk] JudgeDread11:
Probably yes, your doing something wrong, but without telling what 'doesn't work' and any other details we can't magically know what you're doing wrong.
[Magisk] CKWTHN:
HTC M8 Help.

I got my HTC M8 rooted a while back, It was particularly difficult. Android 6.0, followed tutorial right here on XDA.

I got Magisk flashed, Magisk Manager installed, SuperSU flashed (No updated binaries) cant find the supersume, and now I got to the Main Magisk screen.

I can toggle Selinux, but, When I toggle ROOT, I get a transparency message from SuperSU informing me of Magisk granted permission, but IT DOES NOT TOGGLE IT OFF, after a maybe 2-3 seconds it switches back and it root status says Mounted

Can someone give me some hints, Ideas .. Thanks

CKWTHN
[Magisk] Norbix1999:
Please Help me
[Magisk] Captain_Throwback:
Wrong root. You need phh's SuperUser, not SuperSU if you want that toggle to work.
[Magisk] alatnet:
Phone: Nexus 6

Android Version: 6.0.1 - MOB31E

Installed: Magisk v6, phh SuperUser v17 - systemless, Xposed 86.5 systemless., Viper4Android systemless, Hydra v4 Kernel.

Having problems getting Android Pay working. I was able to add my card but everytime i try to use it it errors out saying that it cant verify my system and that i may need to unroot. I did use the magisk manager to disable root but it still gives me that... I do have the safetynet test app and what not but, before i used the safetynet bypass xposed module, it would say that CTS Profile Matched is false. Tried to even "hide" root from android pay via RootCloak, but i doubt it does anything. I was beforehand system installed with supersu, viper4android, xposed, and busybox, but i would assume that erasing (via adb) both Boot and System that i would be "clean" of any system type installs.

I have tried not applying the Hydra kernel but i still get the same thing with android pay.

Any Ideas?
[Magisk] alatnet:
Ah, yea, sorry, found out about the android pay thread and copied my post there.

But i think my post might be helpful though so... yea...

Again sorry...
[Magisk] RandomPooka:
I'm using SuperSU 2.76, not phh's Superuser app. Nexus 6. No Xposed. Both Selinux and Root toggles are functional for me.

Install order that I used:

ROM

Gapps

ElementalX

Magisk_v6

SuperSU modded for Magisk

Team BlackOut Theme Ready Gapps and TBO stock Play Music (That is per their instructions to eventually flash the transparent/clear themed Play Music)

Installed SuperSU app and Magisk Manager after first boot and setup completed.

-------------

Two questions, if anyone is able to answer them.

Does PHH's Superuser app require to be in permissive 100% of the time, or am I misunderstanding this? ( [MENTION=6842057]nathanchance[/MENTION] I'm kind of directing this mostly at you on this one)

Are Substratum and Masquerade both being granted root access with PHH's Superuser solution for everyone? I've seen reports that it wasn't working, but I'm curious to give it a shot, so I can use Xposed and still be able to PokeAP as desired.
[Magisk] HamsterHam:
[MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] - Magisk is awsome first of all! My issue is when installing magisk on bacon Nougat experimental build it won't boot up. I used a diff kernel and the ROM booted up however the root toggle wouldn't work. It would just switch back. I think I took everything needed to report it so here it is. Hoping you can see what is going wrong. Cheers.
[Magisk] will5:
Any tips to install it on a note 4 running beastmode kernel? Tried everything with no luck. Flash just gives error.

Tried unsu, flash only kernel inside beastmode kernel zip, none worked.
[Magisk] x8bitrain:
Just one question: I need to have the bootloader unlocked in order to flash magisk su right?

Or is am I able to keep the bootloader locked if I flash via ADB?

I'm on a nexus 6p, just upgraded to Android 8, stock rom, stock recovery, bootloader locked, kinda don't want to unlock it so I can use Android Pay.
[Magisk] Ashley david:
Try flashing the v12 and try updating the magisk to 13.3 through the manager.see if it works
[Magisk] Artim_96:
Without logs telling us what's the problem we can't do much.

But maybe ask your Kernel developer, be should know what he did that might interfer
[Magisk] bnsmb:
Hi

did you get autostart working?

I use AsopExtended 4.5 with Magisk 13.3 . In general it works - but the autostart apps to disable the autostart of some applications does not work because it thinks the device is not rooted. I tried various apps to disable the autostart and all print the same error message.

regards

Bernd
[Magisk] will5:
I just got error 1 on both v12 and v13. Probably kernel has root related mods that magisk cant handle.

Thanks. Sadly, kernel is no more on development.

I just got error 1 when flashing. Probably kernel has root related mods that magisk cant handle.
[Magisk] Artim_96:
Error 1 is saying pretty much nothing. We need the real TWRP logs from flashing, they contain a lot more than it's showing you
[Magisk] will5:
Thanks. Tried with stock kernel and works fine. So, it´s related to beastmode kernel. Will try to contact developer or check real logs, didnt know they were more explicit.
[Magisk] DenyDarko:
What a surprise (not).

Many of the patching issues we see everyday are caused by customised boot.img
[Magisk] am2006:
Thanx [MENTION=2641771]DenyDarko[/MENTION] ,

I have a new issue , when I install a new module it show me the red message , but after reboot , nothing changes, and the module is not installed, also I can't delete it

*****************************************

I solve it, the problem from Xposed module , it must deactivate before install a new module
[Magisk] zacharias.maladroit:
got the same issue on Note 3 with RR v5.8.3, RR v5.8.4 on Xperia Z5, Stock Nougat on Xperia Z5, LineageOS on Xperia Z5 and CarbonROM on Z5

what is this about ?

still happening with v13.3 :confused:

The device is REALLY getting quite hot and the battery is draining pretty fast :eek:

When peeking at the google results the Xiaomi Redmi Note 4 users also seem to be affected by it consistently (?)
[Magisk] Shores:
Hello!

I've got an S3 Neo, running a Cyanogen 12.1 rom made by Rox. I've tried installing Magisk, by first using SuperSU to completely unroot my phone, and then installing Magisk by means of the TWRP recovery.

What happened is that my phone started acting strangely, Trebuchet was constantly crashing, and root seemed to be absent. I resolved by installing Nova Launcher for a moment, then uninstalling Magisk and reinstalling supersu from TWRP, now I'm back to normal, but Magisk was out... :)

Something I've missed? Should have done something differently?

Thanks in advance to every body!

(Ah, by the way: MAgisk is wonderful and works perfectly on my Galaxy Tab A '16 !)
[Magisk] razmth:
I'm using Magisk 13.3 but I can't find where I could give root privileges to any applications such as Tasker.

I've read it's supposed to eliminate the need of side apps such as phh's superuser. Is that right? The root checker is ok, and requested permissions normally.
[Magisk] Firdhaus81:
Same issue here but i havent tried any other apps cept for root checker which prompt for permission itself.
[Magisk] Larrycleve:
How do you use modules?

I installed several modules from Magisk manager. They seemed to install properly with the black box running script and it says success. After reboot they show as installed in Magisk Manager but there are no icons. How do I use these modules? This is with a Samsung Tab E. I installed AM3D Zirene Sound, Audio Modification Library, Dolby Atmos, VIPER4Android, and Xposed Framework (SDK 23) . I thought these could be configured.
[Magisk] Artim_96:
Well, at least in the description of V4A you can see that they have a seperate link for their app. And modules like audio modification library most likely have no app for configuration. You should read their descriptions
[Magisk] DeathHacker:
I don't suppose this could be the issue:
[Magisk] crayg713:
I had magisk 13.3 installed, but when I installed xposed it caused safetynet to trip... In following another thread, I tried to uninstall magisk, so I could reinstall it but now I am unable to reinstall any magisk version with twrp & get error 1.

I have reflashed the stock rom 5 times, factory reset 7 times & reflashed twrp numerous times but still get error1:

/sdcard/Download/Magisk-v13.5(1350).zip

inflating: META-INF/MANIFEST.MF

inflating: META-INF/CERT.SF

inflating: META-INF/CERT.RSA

inflating: META-INF/com/google/android/update-binary

inflating: META-INF/com/google/android/updater-script

inflating: addon.d/99-magisk.sh

inflating: arm/magisk

inflating: arm/magiskboot

inflating: arm64/magisk

inflating: arm64/magiskboot

inflating: chromeos/futility

inflating: chromeos/kernel.keyblock

inflating: chromeos/kernel_data_key.vbprivk

inflating: common/boot_patch.sh

inflating: common/init.magisk.rc

inflating: common/magisk.apk

inflating: common/util_functions.sh

inflating: x64/magisk

inflating: x64/magiskboot

inflating: x86/magisk

inflating: x86/magiskboot

************************

* Magisk v13.5 Installer

************************

- Mounting /system, /vendor, /cache, /data

- Device platform: arm

- Constructing environment

- Creating /data/magisk.img

WARNING: linker: /data/magisk/magisk: unused DT entry: type 0x6ffffffe arg 0x1aec

WARNING: linker: /data/magisk/magisk: unused DT entry: type 0x6fffffff arg 0x2

- Mounting /data/magisk.img to /magisk

WARNING: linker: /data/magisk/magisk: unused DT entry: type 0x6ffffffe arg 0x1aec

WARNING: linker: /data/magisk/magisk: unused DT entry: type 0x6fffffff arg 0x2

Cannot mount image!

! Magisk image mount failed...

- Unmounting partitions

Updater process ended with ERROR: 1

I:Legacy property environment disabled.

Error installing zip file '/sdcard/Download/Magisk-v13.5(1350).zip'

Updating partition details...

I:Data backup size is 167MB, free: 4587MB....done

I:Set page: 'flash_done'

I:operation_end - status=1

I:Set page: 'main'

I:Set page: 'clear_vars'

I:Set page: 'main2'

I:Set page: 'advanced'

I:Set page: 'confirm_action'

I:Set page: 'action_page'

I:operation_start: 'Copy Log'

I:Copying file /tmp/recovery.log to /data/media/0/recovery.log
[Magisk] R0llin:
"If you suddenly start experiencing high CPU usage and see that a process named magisk_daemon -post-fs is using a lot of your CPU, it's probably caused by having disabled Android logging" how can I enable Android logging back? I don't see the option in Kernel Adiutor. Is it a build.prop key?
[Magisk] Firdhaus81:
Is there a magisk manager version 5.2.0?
[Magisk] navcar:
Try Kernel Adiutor-Mod, should be under Misc Controls. (Or, if your ROM comes Stweaks, use that.)

I think this helps only if you are getting “Logcat read failure” when running "adb logcat"
[Magisk] R0llin:
I do get that error, but there is nothing under "Misc settings" even with that mod
[Magisk] xavihernandez:
I haven't tried again
[Magisk] jamiex:
problem installing magisk Xperia Z1C

Hi. I am pretty new to android in general, but figured I wanted to try to root my old Sony Xperia Z1 compact, build D5503. I am running a rooted version of lollipop with a locked bootloader and am currently trying to install magisk. The only problem is, when I try to flash the zip I get an error message saying: error executing updater binary in zip. . Do anyone have any ideas how to fix this? I haved search everywhere on this issue, but can't find a solution anywhere!

edit: I have also tried the newest version magisk V13.6 and doing it with adb, but it crashes on the third command saying something about busybox and that /common/ isnt a directive.
[Magisk] zacharias.maladroit:
it IS :D

you get 1.000.000 interwebz points :o

well, I turned off the logger to "fix" a different issue: high battery consumption during audio playback on Stock ROM (Z5 with modified kernel and audio changes but I believe the logspam is still there with "stock" kernel)

thus disabling a fix to fix an issue (which is there due to expecting that a situation is given / missing case handling ?) is not really something that makes me happy :(

trading extreme battery drain for higher battery drain :confused:

[MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] could you (or others working on Magisk) please add "error" handling that magisk_daemon still works properly when android logger is disabled ?

Thanks :)
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Did you let the device sit on the splash screen for a while before looking for the debug log? Didn't you write you were on Oreo? That recovery log looks like it's from a device on Marshmallow...

You need an unlocked bootloader, yes. MagiskHide hides the unlocked state so that SafetyNet can pass.

Have you updated to Tasker v5+? If not, it won't recognize MagiskSU. If you don't wan't to update you can use this Magisk module.

Yes, in the current beta.
[Magisk] JudgeDread11:
Hi all.

I'm playing around with dual boot patcher and am trying to install Magisk to the second ROM.

But I can't get it to work. It works without problems on my primary ROM.

Can anybody confirm wether or not it is possible to use Magisk on a secondary ROM?
[Magisk] razmth:
Thanks. I'm on 5.0u5 but it's not working. Do I need to try some uninstall/install? Or is there any hidden config inside Tasker? :confused:

Thanks again.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
You shouldn't have to do anything. Just run a task that requires root and the su request should pop up. A lot of tasks do not require root...
[Magisk] razmth:
Thanks, Did! What I was trying was: adding the GPS feature from the Tasker's main menu, while I should use the Secure Settings' menu.
[Magisk] :
Looking for help on this one:

device: LG G2 (D802)

ROM: Lineage 14.1

Flashed Magisk => Safetynet check fails. (CTS profile mismatch + basic integrity=false)

already tried starting from scratch

any help would be greatly appreciated (or if you guys can refer me to anoher thread)

Magisk error log:

--------- beginning of main

I( 215: 215) Magisk v13.3(1330) daemon started

I( 215: 217) ** post-fs mode running

--------- beginning of system

I( 215: 230) ** post-fs-data mode running

I( 215: 230) * Mounting /data/magisk.img

E( 215: 230) mount /dev/block/loop0->/magisk failed with 22: Invalid argument

I( 215: 369) ** late_start service mode running

I( 215: 369) * Running service.d scripts

I( 215: 369) * Running module service scripts
[Magisk] husky69:
Hi,

Little problem: when I try to install a module downloaded separately I can select the file - but instead of using and installing it the file chooser opens the zip and shows its contents.

How can I get the desired behavior (e.g. install the zip)?

Android 7.1.2, CarbonROM on Xperia Z5 (sumire), Magisk 13.3 installed and working.
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
Press and hold on the file and tap "Open"
[Magisk] Medyredy:
Hey I just downloaded magisk 13.3 from magisk manager and then from recovery the flash failed. It said corrupt file? Am I missing something here?
[Magisk] wiQbold:
also with the file you can download on the magisk official thread?
[Magisk] Medyredy:
Yeah I downloaded from official thread, there was no issue. Thanks!
[Magisk] mon0theist:
I'm having a strange issue with apps seeing my external SD card after flashing Magisk.

I have two Sprint devices: Galaxy Note 4 and Galaxy Tab 3 7.0

Both running LineageOS 14.1, although the Note 4 is running unofficial build.

No problems on the Galaxy Tab 3 7.0, but I did notice that after flashing Magisk, magisk manager doesn't actually get installed unless I manually install the apk.

However magisk seems to be causing an issue on the Galaxy Note 4.

This is my flash order (not sure if it matters):

1. LineageOS

2. GApps 7. 1 micro

3. Magisk

I've noticed that if I only flash LineageOS and GApps, or if I use SuperSU for root instead of magisk, everything works totally fine, all apps can see my external SD card as normal.

I don't bother with LineageOS's su addon package as it doesn't seem to actually do anything as far as I can tell (someone correct me if I'm wrong).

However if I try to use Magisk as my root, certain apps like PowerAmp, VLC, and others no longer see my SD card, as if it's not even inserted into the phone. I also have issues with read/write with the phone plugged into a Windows machine, I will add/remove files in Windows but it doesn't actually show up on the SD card or vice versa. The only app that seems to work with the SD card is LineageOS's built in music player.

I was also having GPS lock issues before switching to SuperSU but I haven't tested if that was specifically because of magisk or not.

Am I doing something wrong? Has anyone else encountered this? I'd really prefer to use magisk due it's extra functionality over SuperSU. Thanks in advance!
[Magisk] EasyDeath:
Hello guys;

I have LineageOS with Root (provided by lineage) and now i have problems with new apps versions like netflix and some banking apps;

The apps says my system is modified and will not work;

So here is my questions:

1) Unlocking bootloader what means in terms of Safynet? My device got detected even if i run stock non root android?

2) Unlocking bootloader and rooting stock android with magisk will pass safetynet?

3) Unlocking bootloader and rooting lineageOS or similar roms will pass safetynet?

I need to change my nexus 6 soon, and i was wondering which new device(Samsung S8+, LGV30, Pixel2 XL) to buy and then root, still avoiding problems with Safetynet and apps non-root compatible
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
1) Unlocking the bootloader will trip SafetyNet even if you haven't rooted your device (unless you got a custom kernel that can hide the unlocked bootloader)

2) Yes (if Magisk Hide is enabled and you haven't installed Xposed)

3) It depends on what root solution you're going to use
[Magisk] dgray85:
Help request

I am having an odd issue I cannot troubleshoot on my own, so turning here for help please.

Sprint Galaxy S5, Android 6.0.1, Magisk 13.3, Manager 5.1.1

Safetynet fails at boot (checking in Magisk Manager). If I go into settings, Magisk Hide is on. If I turn it off then back on, and check Safetynet status, I pass. Similarly, any app with root detection will fail, even if I have the checkbox checked in Magisk Hide. However, unchecking and rechecking the box under Magisk Hide will allow the app to pass root detection. This works great for everything except for Android Pay, since I cannot uncheck and recheck that box.

I thought this was a resetprop issue, so I opened a terminal window (not adb) and entered

su

resetprop -v ro.test 1

resetprop -v ro.test 2

resetprop -v --delete ro.test

rebooted and same issue. I can post any logs as needed - thanks in advance for the help!