yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] mobileman88:
I am using it with 7.0 just fine. Go right ahead to upgrade.

---------- Post added at 12:21 AM ---------- Previous post was at 12:19 AM ----------

@topjohnwu

Thanks for Magisk. It has been working well for me all the way. I have just upgraded to 7.0 and it all works fine. It's there's any issues if I upgrade to the ex kernel from [MENTION=4684315]flar2[/MENTION] after I have already installed magisk v6 and phh v17? Should I remove everything before switching to ex kernel? Thanks
[Magisk] Captain_Throwback:
Flashing just the kernel *should* be fine, as [MENTION=4684315]flar2[/MENTION] typically doesn't replace the ramdisk in his kernel flashes.
[Magisk] steveo17:
the kernel should be the last thing you flash because it is then modifying the "final" boot.img. If you flashed EX kernel first and then magisk and mods, you might have to flash the kernel again
[Magisk] Captain_Throwback:
None of these mods will change the kernel, so the order really shouldn't matter, as long as you started with a stock boot.img at the beginning of the process.
[Magisk] mobileman88:
Thanks ! That's what I wanted to confirm.

---------- Post added at 12:55 AM ---------- Previous post was at 12:54 AM ----------

Thanks! I got the idea. Kernel the very last.
[Magisk] KalolParty:
I'm running Resurrection Remix 5.8.2 and got the Magisk installer script within the ROM. It was automatically installed when I installed the ROM.

I'm not able to login into Snapchat. I tried disbaling Magisk from Settings > Disable Magisk but it didn't work

Any solutions?
[Magisk] Karls0:
Switch MagiskHide to "on" position. Reboot if necessery.
[Magisk] Captain_Throwback:
Try the unofficial version.
[Magisk] yochananmarqos:
Collection of Magisk Modules v2
[Magisk] konoplya:
can someone help me out a bit please? i'm on nexus 4, running 4.4.2 kitkat. i'm rooted. how do i install this? i read the official thread and i don't understand how to do it. do i just flash it through twrp? i rooted my phone using supersu, not the magisk method.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Until you upgrade (custom ROM) you can forget it. Take a look at the release thread titel: "[2017.2.22] Magisk v11.1 - Root & Universal Systemless Interface [Android 5.0+]"...

After that it's just a matter of flashing the zip in TWRP and installing the Magisk Manager from the Play store. If you wan't to use systemless SuperSU you flash that beforehand, if you want to use MagiskSU (required for Magisk Hide) you make sure you don't have systemless SuperSU in your system before flashing. Done.
[Magisk] yilun:
Unroot and flash magisk.
[Magisk] Artim_96:
It can't run on Android 4.x...
[Magisk] yilun:
Oh, right...
[Magisk] konoplya:
thanks. which lowest android is it compatible with?
[Magisk] rehan707:
flash stock recovery and safetynet check passed
[Magisk] Artim_96:
besides the fact [MENTION=4667597]Didgeridoohan[/MENTION] already told you that, you are always supposed to read the OP or in this case the threads behind the links in the OP. Do that!
[Magisk] dj_atom16:
Latest update 11.5

I updated to 11.5 from 11.1 through the magisk manager application, and it broke dm-verity for me, although I had checked the option to "Keep dm-verity".

How do I fix this without losing data?
[Magisk] maplestrat:
Thank you! 11.5 fools my banking app now. :good:
[Magisk] :
Oh new update. Hopefully it works on my sony kernel now
[Magisk] Artim_96:
It should. Report back if you know more

---------- Post added at 12:49 AM ---------- Previous post was at 12:45 AM ----------

Ok, in 11.5 root seems still be dropping with busybox installed

https://www.dropbox.com/s/q2vkou8yzrff3kf/magisk.log?dl=0

https://www.dropbox.com/s/1qfaaw6bfkkgjlp/last_magisk.log?dl=0
[Magisk] lahceneamine:
[MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] :

I've updated to the lastest Magisk v11.5, I lost root (MagiskSU)

Is that normal ?

I'm using a Samsung S7 Edge.
[Magisk] bland.life:
I updated to 11.5 and the device's sepolicy became permissive and many apps are crashing.

How can I fix the problem? Thanks.
[Magisk] DocLem:
So did I, lost root on my S7 flat Exynos. How do I fix this?
[Magisk] Uzuki:
Anyone try new magisk-11.5? I notice different file size. Downloaded, it's 6.1MB, but at magisk app thread, it's​ 6.4MB? And no md5
[Magisk] ahrion:
The new Magisk broke my SystemUI on boot with OP3 running LineageOS 7.1.1
[Magisk] :]Dragonfire[::
Same problem. Adobe Acrobat, Miitomo, 2 Amazon apps... are crashing :(

I've tried changing the selinux profile (with "setenforce 1"), but it does nothing.

When I used the previous version (11.1) and a script (.sh) to configure the .prop, everything worked perfectly. I tried using a magisk module to modify the .prop, but I remember that it gave me these problems.This new version brings these modifications by default, maybe there may come these failures.

Nitrogen OS 7.1.1_r28 / Quanta v21 Kernel / Nexus 4 (All working perfectly with MM 4.2.6, MSU and M v11.1... I will try to uninstall and return to these versions.)
[Magisk] armando_rod:
It changed SEpolicy to Permissive for me too but no crashing, LineageOS 14.1
[Magisk] taldarchi:
After updating from 11.1 to 11.5 i lost root!

What can i do?

Did i do something wrong?
[Magisk] sontjer:
EXACTLY the same with samsung s7e:rolleyes:
[Magisk] Buffydamion:
No more root

Magisk 11.5 problem

After updating from Magisk 11.1 to 11.5 in Magisk Manager, I have no root anymore...

I flashed the uninstaller file in TWRP from https://xdaforums.com/app...mless-t3473445 and rebooted, then flashed the 11.5 file in TWRP an rebooted again. still no root.

What am I missing?

Any suggestions?

On Helios ROM 7.9 Samsung SM-G930F S7 flat
[Magisk] djb77:
Hey [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] :)

Giving you a heads up with some issues with the latest Magisk (11.5)

Device: Samsung Galaxy S7 (G930F)

Firmware: XXU1DQBO (Android 7.0)

Kernel: TGPKernel 4.42 (worked with Magisk 11.1)

Magisk: 11.5

Magisk Manager: 4.2.7

I was previously on 11.1 / 4.2.6 where everything was working perfectly (Safetynet / MagiskHide / MagiskSU)

Now that I've installed 11.5 I still have Safetynet, but I have lost access to MagiskHide and I have no MagiskSU.

This is the steps I did to update my phone:

- Downloaded Magisk 11.5 via Manager app

- Downloaded Magisk Uninstaller from official thread

- Downloaded Magisk Manager 4.2.7 via Play Store

- Rebooted to Reocvery

- Flashed uninstaller

- Reflashed Kernel (to ensure a fresh start)

- Flashed Magisk 11.5

- Reboot my phone, the booting time takes AGES, I thought the phone was stuck at the boot splash screen there for a second lol

Once the phone is started I go to Magisk Manager:

- No MagiskSU (root)

- In settings, there is no option for magiskhide / magisksu

I've read a few other samsung users have had issues too, so what ever has been done in 11.5 has broken it for us. Magisk Manager 4.2.7 still works fine with Magisk 11.1, but I won't be upgrading my phone or installer with this release unfortunately.

Would it possibly be ramdisk / kernel changes that are made to my kernel (TGPKernel) before flashing?

One thing I did notice is that Magisk now takes care of /sys/fs/selinux/enforce, so does my kernel (and so does a few other Samsung S7 Custom Kernels), but I don't think this would have an issue with MagiskSU would it?

Let me know if you want any assistance with testing out anything regarding fixing this, I'll try removing my patch on /sys/fs/selinux/enforce and see if that helps, I'll post another message if it makes a difference, so if you don't see another post in an hour or so, you know that it didn't help.
[Magisk] Boldizzle:
Have also lost root on my S7E G935F Exynos after updating from 11.1 to 11.5.
[Magisk] dynospectrum:
Same for me, except on Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge.

Device: Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge (G935F)

Firmware: XXU1DQBO (Android 7.0)

Kernel: TGPKernel 4.42
[Magisk] degsyh:
Same here - no root after 11.5 update. S6 Edge on 7.0. Can't reflash 11.1 either as it keeps rebooting back to recovery? Any ideas?
[Magisk] taldarchi:
Yes tried that also with my galaxy s6 edge plus running nougat and also got back to recovery.. had to reinstall the 11.5 to go back to my system... also the uninstaller returns an error in recovery and wont work.. waiting for a fix... right now stuck with 11.5 and NO root.
[Magisk] zapahacks:
Same here on a Galaxy S6 Edge running AlexisXDA ROM
[Magisk] westeight:
Working perfectly on my HTC U Ultra :svetius:
[Magisk] Doc Franky B.:
FYI [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION]

I'm on Note4 MM 6.0.1 Feb patch

After update 11,5 can not install/flash modules via magisk app.

Only over twrp

But root works

Send from Note4 - 6.0.1
[Magisk] andacro:
Upgraded to 11.5 and lost root on my S5 klte MM too.
[Magisk] :
So I unrooted and uninstalled Xposed before flashing the Magisk zip and updating it from Play Store, everything was done without issue and MagiskSU is functioning but Safetynet keeps getting CTS mismatch.

All my apps are still detecting root, I even used the Osmosis unSU script but nothing works. I'm running the Xperia C3 5.1.1 stock firmware.

[MENTION=5125527]Artim_96[/MENTION]

[MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] I've attached the stock boot.img, please have a look and let me know if anything else is needed.

https://www.dropbox.com/s/l2zm4v5pfodhcz5/boot.img?dl=0
[Magisk] rulide:
I lost my root after updating to 11.5, then i followed this video on youtube and got my root back without losing data.

watch?v=kByjiftra2c (cant post outside link cause im new here) but I still cant pass safety net...

Im running superman rom on my s7 edge, does anyone know how to get it to work?
[Magisk] Anova's Origin:
Magisk v11.5 working well on OnePlus 3T with OOS 4.1.0 and Franco kernel f14.

When I first updated Magisk through Magisk manager, safetynet kept failing for some reason. Dirty flashing OOS 4.1.0, then Magisk seemed to fix the problem (safetynet passing again).

SELinux has been changed into permissive mode though.
[Magisk] sontjer:
Could you pls describe in details how to get root back?:good:
[Magisk] degsyh:
Same position as me. :(
[Magisk] gk1984:
Magisk 11 to 11.1 did that to me. Had to factory reset. It's also happened a few times trying to get a module to work. I think corrupting is too easy with magisk...
[Magisk] rulide:
So i downloaded the file in the description, then inside the file has odin and i flashed this file with it. The phone rebooted a few times then its rooted again, all my files are still there. Sorry I cant post any photos of my device as Im still new here.
[Magisk] Zuma1302:
Same here.
[Magisk] Buffydamion:
Heute used Chainfire SuperSU, but we want systemless MagiskSU....
[Magisk] shantam3108:
To all those having problems with getting root.

Dirty flash the rom first and flash magisk 11.5
[Magisk] rulide:
Oh true... sorry about that... but what is the difference with supersu and magisksu? sorry im pretty new to this rooting thing
[Magisk] deeplyyoung:
As per instructions updated Magisk app and updated to latest 11.5, everything seems working just perfect. ROM aicp (Primary, using multiROM), whereas whenever I tried Magisk over secondaries(using multiROM) Root options are ok but I never able to pass safety net..App keep checking & checking & checking. At the moment using Tipsy as secondary and gonna update to latest sooner.

Device :- OP3
[Magisk] sontjer:
Thank u all the same, gonna wait for magisk 11.5 to be fixed.:good:
[Magisk] DjDiabolik:
I friends... i need an HELP.

I'm on TugaPower N27 and i obtain the newest version of Magisk Manager............ from this app i have downloaded and installed the new magisk 11.5. Apparently all it's append whitout any problems... i obtain the request to reboot my OPO and i do it. At restart of Tugapower the phone goes unusable because on screen appears a message says "App ArkamysAudio it's interrupted" and i click on "Close App" and never append.... how i do to remove/fix this ??
[Magisk] sontjer:
Does it work with Samsung devices? Because it seems to have root loss issues with Samsung devices as reported.
[Magisk] shantam3108:
Working great
[Magisk] shantam3108:
No idea on that. Don't own samsung one. But use a 6p, nexus 7 and everything working great here
[Magisk] AtlasRedux:
BAM! Now it works with LineageOS 14.1 on Sony Z3+, payment apps/deeper SafetyNet works again! WOOOOHOOOO!
[Magisk] sino8r:
Tmobile Samsung Note 4 not working since 11.5

Just updated to 11.5 and it no longer works for the tmo note 4 (latest stock MM). Still works fine on 11.1 though. Thought that might help some who might run into issues. I lost my log cat since I had to reflash otherwise I would have posted it. Hope that helps.
[Magisk] degsyh:
I just dirty flashed the rom and reflashed 11.1. I didn't think 11.5 would work!

EDIT: not sure it would work anyway?
[Magisk] Emenaria:
Someone please help? I got Magisk updated to 11.5 and now MagiskSU(root) is gone! I also updated the app to 6.4.3 but It didn't help.

I use Samsung Galaxy S7 edge, SuperMan ROM v2.2(Nougat), and SuperStock-Kernel v2.2.1.

What can I do?

Sent from my SM-G935F
[Magisk] shantam3108:
It's working check above. But I would still say stay on 11.1 to avoid issues with modules after updating
[Magisk] degsyh:
See previous posts. 11.5 is currently not working for (mainly) Samsung devices. I've reverted to 11.1 but had to reflash my rom.
[Magisk] Emenaria:
Oh I got it. That's sad. Thank you for telling me.

Sent from my SM-G935F
[Magisk] khangcobra:
V11.5 break my games : Dual link and Dynamix...better revert to 11.1
[Magisk] MarcTremonti:
After update to 11.5 my wifi isnt working anymore on oneplus 3 oxygenOS 4.1.

03-20 03:25:28.209 E/WifiStateMachine(2164): Failed to load driver

03-20 03:25:28.210 E/WifiController(2164): WifiControllerWifi turn on failed

Should i manually flash the update? Cause i let the manager do the magic.
[Magisk] andacro:
I restored a stock boot, and reflashed Boeffla and Magisk 11.1 + the patch for enabling adopted.
[Magisk] Captain_Throwback:
MultiROM itself causes SafetyNet to fail on secondary ROMs - that's not a Magisk problem. v11.5 should actually get you to a failed result. If it doesn't, please post your Magisk log here.
[Magisk] CryonicCore:
I updated to magisk 11.5 but when it finished I somehow lost my root access. I don't know why but I need help with this.
[Magisk] ToHellWithGA:
This is my first time trying to install and use Magisk on my Nextbit Robin (ether) with OmniROM. I get a "CTS mismatch" error when testing if it's working properly. Log and screenshot attached. What have I done wrong?
[Magisk] Captain_Throwback:
I see no log or screenshot, but did you enable Magisk Hide?
[Magisk] Captain_Throwback:
Try running the uninstaller, and then flash the v11.5 zip in recovery.
[Magisk] ToHellWithGA:
Here are the log and screenshot that refused to post above.
[Magisk] shantam3108:
Uncheck USB debugging and see
[Magisk] fralacos:
It's the same for me. Just updated to 11.5 on a galaxy core prime running stock odexed android 5.0.2 and root is lost.

I've uninstalled magisk, reinstalled 11.1 to get root back.
[Magisk] Captain_Throwback:
I think there's a slight bug in the resetprop update - it's actually disabling SELinux rather than making sure it shows as enabled. I think there's a typo in the post [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] got the ro.build.selinux prop from (@Didgeridoohan you may want to check your post) :eek:.
[Magisk] ToHellWithGA:
Disabling USB debugging didn't fix it.
[Magisk] CryonicCore:
Yea but that's weird. Just means there might be a bug somewhere. I didn't try installing the zip through recovery but I just don't want to run the risk of messing my phone up. Takes time to get everything back to normal lol.
[Magisk] A_Random_Guy:
Same here on a 6.0.1 Samsung J5
[Magisk] fralacos:
Just tried installing as Cap'n suggested above and the result is the same. I'm now going back to 11.1 one more time.

Yeah, might be a bug. I'll stay on 11.1 cause I think I'm not missing anything with 11.5 (besides root ... lol)
[Magisk] :
I'm on a Sprint Galaxy Note Edge (N915P), and I lost root with 11.5, going to downgrade to 11.1 for now.
[Magisk] fralacos:
It may be something broken with samsungs. It's failing on me with a Galaxy Core Prime, on stock 5.0.2 odexed. It used to work with Magisk 11.1
[Magisk] CryonicCore:
Yea I think they might need to look into this if im not the only one having this issue. :confused:
[Magisk] deeplyyoung:
Thanks Capt. I was expecting your reply... Well now it's Crystal clear for MR. will boot into secondary and revert with status sooner.
[Magisk] test00za:
Same thing here, went back to 1.1

---------- Post added at 05:07 AM ---------- Previous post was at 05:07 AM ----------

Same here, go back to 1.1, works flawlessly :)
[Magisk] Pkt_Lnt:
Yes, confirmed here on a Nexus 6 with Pure Nexus 7.1.1 (AOSP). V11.1 showed SELinux Enforcing, then the update to V11.5 set it to Permissive. I used

setenforce 1

in a terminal and confirmed it is now Enforcing with no issues either way. I just want to stay Enforcing. I still have root, MagiskSU and Magisk Hide work plus Safety Net still passes.
[Magisk] Anova's Origin:
Does the SELinux policy reset to permissive if you reboot?
[Magisk] Pkt_Lnt:
Yes it will since Magisk will set it that way each boot. You can set up an init script if you want. I usually go weeks without a reboot. I suspect this will be fixed soon, so I am not going to cobble up something for now. Although I could run a Tasker shell script really easily, hmmmm.
[Magisk] Xephyrex:
Latest (v.11.5) Screwed up my phone.

I just installed the latest update (v.11.5) using the manager and it installed, told me to reboot, and so I did. Upon starting up the device, when I enter magisk manager, it says "Not rooted, Functionality greatly limited". So I go back into TWRP and try to restore the previous v11.1 with root fully working. Now when I try this, it keeps saying "failed, install SuperSU immediately" and so I use Odin to install cf-autoroot for my N910C but now the cf-autoroot gets to the installer with the red text and right at the end it says "failure". I am stuck without root. Can someone please help me? I REALLY shouldn't have updated my magisk as my device is now rootless. Please help!!:crying::crying:
[Magisk] snippem:
Had the same problems here what i did.

Uninstall magisk

Reboot to system

Then reboot to recovery

Reflash the kernel i had installed from Eng.tk

Reboot to system and WiFi works again.

Reboot to recovery.

Then flashed the latest magisk again.

Reboot to system .

WiFi still works.

Edited
[Magisk] Anova's Origin:
Since when does TWRP need root to restore backups? :confused:

Regardless, flash the Magisk uninstaller and flash Magisk v11.1 again through TWRP.
[Magisk] Xephyrex:
Btw, on version 11.1, I had root and safetynet passed. Now after installing version 11.5, I have lost root and now safetynet isn't even passing. Beware to anyone else planning to update Magisk. Version 11.5 is broken.
[Magisk] aeroxy:
Hey, I upgraded Magisk and lost root... What did I do wrong? Also, besides re-flashing the zip, is there another way to get the root back? Thanks.
[Magisk] Xephyrex:
Thanks for the swift response, i used the uninstaller zip and tried to reinstall v11.1, but it keeps saying failed "flash SuperSU immediately".
[Magisk] Anova's Origin:
I'm assuming you're using a Samsung phone, which many have already reported to be incompatible with Magisk v11.5

Flash the Magisk uninstaller then flash Magisk v11.1 again. Stay on v11.1 until the issue is sorted out.
[Magisk] tag68:
Is Magisk 11.5 supposed to work on a device with f2fs formatted /data with broken local loopback device, like Moto Z Play?

Did read many things were rewritten, but not if it was possible to circumvent this problem. For Moto Z Play only phh superuser on marshmallow is capable of rooting. No topjohnwu version, no SuperSU did it. On nougat or for other su than phh rooting requires installing a kernel with fix for f2fs (did not use myself by now, still on marshmallow with phh). My hope would be that the new MagiskSU could work without modification.
[Magisk] Anova's Origin:
Strange, I've never seen that error before. A while back, I noticed that flashing Magisk immediately after dirty flashing a ROM sometimes resulted in an error 1 in TWRP. It was fixed by returning to the front page of TWRP, going into "Mount" and toggling "system" off and on again.

If that doesn't work, you could try dirty flashing your current ROM, then flashing Magisk afterwards.
[Magisk] Telperion:
Messed up my Honor 8, I lost all fingerprint sensor functionality. I don't know what else it broke since I uninstalled right away.
[Magisk] chrcol:
What is the fix when setenforce 1 doesnt make selinux enforced? My phone is locked at permissive and I think its why I still cannot use barclaycard, myee and lloydstsb apps. Those apps seem to have no relation to if safetynet passes or not.

Also is it normal for busybox binaries to still be present in system/bin and xbix when busybox is unticked? they symlinks to a toybox file. Busybox even still (partially) works, which is bizarre considering the earlier problems I had of getting it to work.
[Magisk] musicman5844:
Just a thought since bootloader is more than likely unlocked go to TWRP recovery advanced check davlk cache,,,,cache,,, data,,,,, system flash rom gapps latest SuperSU reboot should be cleared up
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
:eek: (and I think it warrants and actual eeeeeek as well)

When I've been testing the different props I never had problems like that. I tried right now (with a Magisk module) and my system is still enforcing. [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] You might want to revert that part of the new ro prop patches...

Haven't had time to test v11.5 yet...

---------- Post added at 06:40 ---------- Previous post was at 06:36 ----------

And, reading through this night's posts (I just woke up) I just want to say, with a deeply tired and slightly annoyed voice:

Samsung. Sigh...
[Magisk] acultr:
I have updated the magisk manager via play store and I don't have a update yet.

can somebody tell me why?
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
Magisk v11.5 is broken
[Magisk] acultr:
I read, but I thought only on samsung devices.

thnx for the info
[Magisk] DeadlyByNite:
I got the automatic update from the play store, but I don't think I'm going to be flashing 11.5. I can wait until the bugs get worked out. I'm glad that I checked here before I jumped into something I'd regret. Actually excited about the Multi-rom feature! I see that some people are already using the Multi-rom on their device. I'll have to search around the thread a little, and learn a little more about it. Right now I'm using the HTC One A9, Android version 7.0. Running official firmware and not much to choose from for any kind of custom roms, but maybe a build of LineageOS...?? Anyway I'm going to wait for a fix before flashing latest version, and hope to be able to dual boot soon!
[Magisk] FreeTheWeb:
I can't get the phone rooted with this update i need to go back on 1.11 i'm on s7 935F 6.0.1
[Magisk] gtpy:
I installed the automatic update via magisk-manager on my (aries) Sony Z3 Compact.

Now its hanging at the Sony screen. No chance to boot or get into recovery :(

Any Ideas how to solve?:confused:
[Magisk] chrcol:
This 11.5 update means my issue is getting swamped with update issues :(

An update

I manually removed all busybox related files, once rm had been removed I had to finish it off in TWRP.

Interestingly this process lost me root access and magisk showed as not installed.

I then reinstall magisk from TWRP but this doesnt fix anything, so it is weird but looks like busybox needs to be partially in place for magisk install to work? Or Something really whacky has happened on my phone.

All the apps that didnt work except lloyds now work with my phone in this state, so the core rom itself isnt blocking them. Still really trying to avoid a rom reinstall but obviously if I cannot even install magisk now its either that or revert back to my nandroid backup.

So I suppose the process now is reinstall superSU, see if that at least brings back root, then install magisk again from there, run unsu again after, reinstall clean kernel, then reinstall magisk after.