yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] Wesley_NL:
im so sad T.T if i knew this i never would have bought this device, i mean devs dropped the sm-g928* so fast, i can't do anything with it anymore

---------- Post added at 10:42 AM ---------- Previous post was at 10:15 AM ----------

ok i finaly got it passing safetynet \o/

in a other tread xJovs mentioned that he used arter97 kernel and it seems that one works ,

thx xJovs and arter97 for your kernel, i once returned to arter97 kernel and im happy it works with magisk
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
That's great news. Glad you found a kernel that works.
[Magisk] teddy0209:
Good, finally you got it working... ???
[Magisk] Wesley_NL:
yes i thanks the people that try to help me and specialy thanks to xJovs for mention arter97 kernel, i never thought that kernel would work since it looked outdated, but it seems it works fine
[Magisk] oblitus:
hey guys. I'm using 7.1.1 on LG G2. I've installed the files needed. It seems fine but 2 problems.

1. I still cant pass the safety check. It says CTS profile match error.

And the second one is, in Magisk hide list, I cant find the pokemon go app.
[Magisk] teddy0209:
The problem might be on your rom... Give more info... There is no need to select pokemon go app... It was meant to work by default, just activate magisk hide and reboot.
[Magisk] sk8lucas:
Hi everybody,

I'm running magisk v10.2 with pph's superuser r2 on my s7 edge g935f with Resurrection Remix and magisk hide is not working, it makes the target app to constantly force close and re-open, did someone find out if it's possible to solve this? I'll leave the magisk log and post it in magisk support thread too.

Thanks!! n.n
[Magisk] oblitus:
I'm using this ROM https://xdaforums.com/lg-g2/development/rom-aospextended-v2-0-t3527025
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Do NOT post your entire log! Attach a file, use pastebin or whatever! Gaah!

Log looks ok though. There may be several things causing issues... Your SELinux might be permissive, there may be leftovers of previous/built-in root, kernel might be incompatible with Magisk Hide.

---------- Post added at 14:11 ---------- Previous post was at 14:06 ----------

[MENTION=5640774]sk8lucas[/MENTION] [MENTION=4891207]oblitus[/MENTION]

https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=70426733&postcount=7120
[Magisk] teddy0209:
It says in the description that the rom comes with supersu inbuild... you have to fully unroot, check that you are passing safetynet prior to flashing magisk... If it still doesn't work, provide some logs.
[Magisk] oblitus:
Yes I know it comes with inbuild root. I did unroot fully with the application and the flashable unsu.zip file. I did not check safetynet prior to magisk install. But after installing root checker which have builtin safetynet checker, I hide it in Magisk hide list. Before hiding, it said you have root. After hiding said you havent. That way I understand that I can hide my root from apps. But both cases, I could never passed the safetynet. Alwasy CTS mismatch error.
[Magisk] teddy0209:
Check the link posted above... hiding root and passing safety net are two different things. Use safetynet playground to check, it is more reliable. Magisk manager has it's own checker but it needs root...
[Magisk] sk8lucas:
Sorry, I tried but tapatalk didnt allow me to, i'll edit

I'm using this ROM

I've fully unrooted before installing magisk and maked a clean install (I've done it a lot of times and it worked on 6.0.1 stock).

I thought that it might be the kernel too but in that case, is there something i could do to "magiskify" the kernel?
[Magisk] oblitus:
Still no luck. Here are the log files.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Still no luck? What did you try?

Those log files tell us nothing, except that you've got Magisk up and running. Obviously you've got Magisk Hide working, if you can hide root from apps. Your issue is not with Magisk, but the rest of your setup.

Safety Net also triggers if SELinux is permissive. Have you checked that?
[Magisk] sk8lucas:
Seeing his logs seems like he is having the same problem as me.

Magisk may be FC the safety net service and it starts again over and over
[Magisk] Trainer_Red:
I've seen speculation that SafetyNet has been updated again. Pokémon GO has given me the "Incompatible Screen" and unrooting and uninstalling Magisk hasn't helped. Again, the SafetyNet updating is still speculation.
[Magisk] Captain_Throwback:
SafetyNet still passes here. So I don't know...
[Magisk] teddy0209:
Still passes here too... ???
[Magisk] Gustave17:
It worked for me 4 hours ago...

And now Safetynet failed...

Magisk v10.2

Nexus 6P Android 7.1.1
[Magisk] teddy0209:
Maybe its something that you did? Still passes, I just checked now.
[Magisk] biggdevon:
Is there a way to get the toggles (Root and SELinux mode) on the latest version v10.2? Or can I at least use the older manager apk with the latest flash?
[Magisk] teddy0209:
No... as for selinux, you can use selinux mode changer.
[Magisk] Gustave17:
I did absolutely nothing with my phone
[Magisk] Hakem:
Same here
[Magisk] Elmarigo:
Thank you for making the SafetNet warning optional! Great support! :)
[Magisk] biggdevon:
Does v10.2 work with android pay by itself? I'm on a stock SM-N920T 6.0.1, rooted via Magisk v10.2 using phh from the flash, and Xposed module from Magisk manager. Everything I've seen points to toggling root through the Magisk manager apk. I know I need a custom kernel since stock Samsung kernels don't work but is there something else I'm missing? The SELinux mode changer is just for convenience.
[Magisk] teddy0209:
If you didn't do anything like update an app for example, then maybe they are detecting something now like none stock rom or system mounted rw... Just maybe... ?

---------- Post added at 04:57 PM ---------- Previous post was at 04:54 PM ----------

I can only confirm 10.2 is passing SN and works for PoGo... I can't test AP because the service is not yet available in my country.
[Magisk] biggdevon:
SElinux didn't pass after flashing for me. Might be due to still having stock kernel.
[Magisk] teddy0209:
Might be... Also magiskhide does not hide xposed, so it needs to be disabled to pass safetynet...
[Magisk] aryan531:
i am on cm 14 does xposed work on me through magisk?? and if it ... then any procedures

plzz guide
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
CM 14 is Android Nougat, right? So... I'm gonna tell you what's been written all over the Xposed forums for some time now: There's NO Xposed for Nougat.

Just wait... As soon as rovo89 manages to figure it out (if he ever does), it'll be all over the web. You won't be able to miss it.
[Magisk] OhayouBaka:
Also can confirm, Safetynet stopped passing here, when it was working perfectly fine yesterday. I asked someone else using Magisk and they also had Safetynet not passing since today. Seems like Safetynet must have gotten updated.
[Magisk] Quinny899:
SafetyNet worked fine here at 3:02pm GMT. It's now 6:41 GMT and it's failing. I think we may be seeing a rollout of a new check. boot state is green, I just reflashed the system to check it's not been modified (it's not), and I don't use any modifications beyond mounting SystemUI, ActionLauncher, v4a, a boot animation and the hosts file.
[Magisk] bmg1001:
If someone here is having SafetyNet fail, do you have ADB enabled? If so, can you try disabling it and checking SafetyNet again? Some people on the Pokemon Go thread said this worked for them.
[Magisk] armando_rod:
I'm passing SafetyNet here Nexus 5 unofficial LineageOS, Franco kernel and Magisk 10.2 with phh superuser.

edit: ADB enabled and just tested Pokemon Go...

edit: for anyone who is failing SN, stock ROM kernel and unlocked BL? Or custom kernel? The CM stock kernel was flagged by SN I had to always flash a custom kernel different from CM
[Magisk] Quinny899:
Stock ROM, just the Magisk kernel modifications. ADB doesn't seem to make a difference, unless you need to reboot to see the change?
[Magisk] nixie2121:
So I have passed safetynet for weeks now. I just checked today and now I fail with a mismatch. I believe the only changes I have done is applying new substratum themes. Could this be a cause? Not sure what else it could be.

thanks
[Magisk] OhayouBaka:
Custom ROM and kernel (AOSIP)
[Magisk] bmg1001:
Still passing here so either it's a staged rollout or I'm lucky. I'm running a Nexus 6P with PureNexus 1/27 and Flash Kernel (with Magisk, F2FS, and Viper).
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
What's your Google Play services version? Mine's at 10.0.84 and passing Safety Net with no issue.
[Magisk] armando_rod:
Try another kernel, one that is known to be patched against unlocked bootloader verification for your device. Sometimes even without root I got blocked because of the kernels on some roms
[Magisk] jrk190:
Nexus 5X with Pure Nexus and ElementalX, safetynet still passing.
[Magisk] Quinny899:
10.0.84 440-137749526 so it's not that
[Magisk] jrk190:
I'm curious, will safetynet pass without root at all and just a good kernel that passes
[Magisk] nixie2121:
10.2.91

using latest weekly of dirty Unicorns with their kernel. Phh su and magisk... thanks
[Magisk] OhayouBaka:
Ok, I managed to get Safetynet passing once again on my device. Just disable ADB Debugging from Settings > Developer Options.
[Magisk] nixie2121:
that worked, thanks!
[Magisk] olivercervera:
Are you on 10.2? That's interesting: how could ADB debugging break SafetyNet compliance? Google, are you serious?

I'm on 10.0.84, N5X with Pure Nexus 7.1.1, Franco Kernel and Magisk 10.2, all good and green so far.
[Magisk] OhayouBaka:
Yep, I'm on 10.2.
[Magisk] bmg1001:
I wouldn't be surprised since unlocked bootloaders trip it too. Google being Google.
[Magisk] Artim_96:
It won't if you install Magisk. It hides it
[Magisk] SpasilliumNexus:
Device: OnePlus 3T

ROM: Stock OxygenOS 4.0.2 (Android 7.0)

Kernel: ElementalX

Root: Magisk 10.2 with Phh's Superuser

Play services: 10.2.91 (448-144333517)

USB Debugging: Enabled

Bootloader: Unlocked

Encryption: Disabled

For modules, I have 14 of them in use, from bonding WiFi connections, enabling Daydream VR, Assistant, Google Dialer, to having ViPER4Android FX and Busybox by osm0sis.

Still passing SafetyNet. Even Google Play Store shows my device as Certified under Settings > Device certification.

EDIT: Speaking of encryption, disable it on this phone if you want to use Magisk with no issues (I've explained about removing it in a 3T Q&A thread here). Or else you will be playing Russian Roulette upon reboots, and end up with a black screen until you factory reset. Not even removing Magisk or re-flashing a ROM without a factory reset fixes it.
[Magisk] skyLucifer:
Hi. I'm not sure whether installing Magisk or Xposed causes my phone cannot be connected to my PC through USB connection. Right now I'm using Redmi 4 Prime with Magisk 10.2
[Magisk] Artim_96:
Quite impossible. The chance is more that it won't install because of MIUI

---------- Post added at 11:31 PM ---------- Previous post was at 11:27 PM ----------

Ok...I'm trying to get a script to run in init.d, quite as an excitement. It needs to have owner root, group shell and permissions 0755, but the line

set_perm_recursive $MODPATH/system/etc/init.d/91fixoverlays 0 2000 0755

in config.sh isn't doing it's job (not with or without _recursive. It stays at root, root and 0644.

How do I properly change the permissions?
[Magisk] olivercervera:
Seriously? This is a core feature of Android (stock). It can't be the cause of the problem. We'll see more in the coming days.
[Magisk] 23Six:
3T owner who's still encrypted. Been using Magisk since v9 on OOS 3.5.4 and no issues like you described even until this date.
[Magisk] SpasilliumNexus:
Thinking about it more, do you have your device set to enter a pin/pass/pattern upon boot, or when the lock screen shows? I've had mine set to ask for those on the lock screen.
[Magisk] J_E_F_F:
I'm new to magisk, but it does not seem to be working for me at the moment.

I just installed the official Lineage OS build on a OnePlus One.

I flashed magisk 10.2 zip, and when rebooted, opened magisk manager from the app drawer, it requested to upgrade itself from the play store and did.

The status screen shows I have the latest version, and displays ROOTED BUT NO ROOT PERMISSION, NOT ALLOWED

The 3 magisk options in settings are all grayed out, and unable to be selected. Any ideas how to fix this?
[Magisk] jhedfors:
By chance did you install PHH Superuser from the Play Store? There is nothing specific to the OPO, and I and others have been using it just fine.
[Magisk] J_E_F_F:
that was it, I needed to install phh's superuser, guess this is a 2 step/app process, thanks!
[Magisk] midgarsormr:
I'm running the latest validus on the OP3 with the same set up I have on Tesla with elementalx kernel...the cm version. One works and one doesn't. The safetynet test just loops on validus. Not exactly sure what could be on the ROM end that would cause it to be different on two very similar ROMs.
[Magisk] teddy0209:
Exactly my thought, mine was always on, doesn't affect my passing on safetynet. I'm really curious about this, lol...

---------- Post added at 02:38 AM ---------- Previous post was at 02:06 AM ----------

I think it's the play services crashing...
[Magisk] midgarsormr:
I did notice play services is indeed crashing.
[Magisk] vampire_8_7:
Hey mate, tested mine today and it failed, disabled debugging mode all over since ADB was already disabled and safetynet passed fine. I dont play PockemonGo though, but I have tested Android Pay and processed a transaction fine.
[Magisk] Elanza_48:
Now it's really becoming very wired. Google is pushing hard to fixed all the holes and implementing new policies on safety net. :(
[Magisk] skyLucifer:
I'm particularly sure the Manager shows it is perfectly installed. So does this means permission is needed for the app to let the phone connected through USB? I'm lost at the permission part
[Magisk] Rhoban:
Any actual source or is it just speculation?
[Magisk] MrBrady:
Dang, that's crazy... Mine worked for quite a while and noticed today it stopped. Disabling ADB got it working again. Easy enough fix.
[Magisk] teddy0209:
Are you using custom rom?

I use stock rom with ADB enabled in dev options, no problem passing safetynet...
[Magisk] Elanza_48:
For now this is just an speculation, but in future may not be.
[Magisk] Artim_96:
That's not what I wrote. I want to run a script mounted to init.d which needs to be root, shell, 0755. Now I need to know how to set these permissions since they are automatically set to root, root, 0644.

Nothing to do with anything USB
[Magisk] 23Six:
I've used both options. Upon boot will make TWRP lead pass the splash screen quickly and ask for the decryption pin. Upon lock screen will bypass the decryption PIN in TWRP, skipping straight to auto decryption, hence the long waiting time.
[Magisk] SpasilliumNexus:
I spent a few more hours on this and for me, the pin/pass/pattern upon boot works fine with Magisk instead of straight up removing encryption. It also seems to be much more secure in protecting data, even in TWRP.

----------------

Edit: SafetyNet is still passing, even after a full wipe of the phone with the exact same setup in my other post, except being encrypted this time.
[Magisk] Nomelas:
Has anyone tested magisk on LineageOS yet?
[Magisk] Artim_96:
More or less, yes. I'm running it on a LineageOS based ROM. Of course you won't be able to pass SN, like in almost every custom ROM
[Magisk] AASonyKK:
There is a planning release of Magisk Manager also on f-droid?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Probably not: https://github.com/topjohnwu/MagiskManager/issues/43
[Magisk] jhedfors:
I am running OnePlus One with official Lineage OS, Magisk w/Magisk Hide enabled. I pass Safetynet just fine.
[Magisk] yochananmarqos:
:confused:
[Magisk] armando_rod:
Of course you can pass SN on custom ROMs, I'm using unofficial LineageOS for the Nexus with Franco kernel and Magisk and it passes SN.

Specifically the CM kernel was being flagged by SN so even if you unrooted it wont pass SN but with any custom kernel it passes
[Magisk] Drivepnut:
I hope someone can help me. When I update to Magisk 10.2 in xposed it says that xposed 87.0 is installed but not active and I can't use none of the xposed modules. This never happened when I updated Magisk earlier versions,
[Magisk] lulli1:
Make sure that you have installed the last phh su and if that doesn't help, flash latest Xposed again in recovery.
[Magisk] Drivepnut:
Yeah I did install the latest phh superuser and the update manager but when I update 10.2 it causes the trouble I even flash xposed again after all that but still the same thing.
[Magisk] MrBrady:
PureNexus on Nexus 6
[Magisk] lulli1:
Did you just update the magisk installer or magisk itself as well. If not, flash newest magisk in recovery.
[Magisk] Nomelas:
Awesome thanks! I also have a oneplus this is good news! I wait patiently now for xposed update....
[Magisk] Punchlinegott:
Hello, I was playing Pokemon Go till yesterday with custom rom/kernel. It worked fine with magisk v10.2, in magisk hide pokemon was ticked. Now without changing anything pokemon go doesn't work anymore (device is not compatible) and pokemon go is gone in magisk hide. What can I do?

EDIT: just had to disable usb debugging
[Magisk] Nomelas:
I don't believe you need to even hide PoGo in magisk hide. Did you run the SafetyNet test and does it still pass?
[Magisk] mrxtc89117:
Try and disable usb debugging. I read this on one of the reddit forums
[Magisk] Wesley_NL:
Works fine here with usb debug enabled, and even if google.say incompactable just install the app manualy , thats what i do, i run apps that are uncompactable in play store but not if i download apk and install it , if safenet still passes then pokemon go work fine
[Magisk] Punchlinegott:
The problem was not Google related. When I tried to start Pokemon it said device not compatible, not in the playstore it was inside the game. But now with usb debugging disabled it works fine
[Magisk] kami2k:
I have twrp installed and magisk 10.2.zip via twrp now how i can install magisk ver. of viper rom?
[Magisk] Crayvolt:
unable to detect boot image :(

Device : S3 mini

Android OS: Omni Rom

Version 5.1.1

No mods :)
[Magisk] benwalburn:
I'm definitely on the new versions. I even redownloaded them and v5. I can't find any indication that anything happened, recovery output and logs don't throw any errors.

Oh, and I'm using a OnePlus 3.
[Magisk] jhedfors:
If I simply want to move an app to the magisk-created system (specifically the Nexus Launcher I currently have installed as user app). Is there an easy way to do this?

The mod-template seems like it may be more complicated for what I am trying to do (?)
[Magisk] -Duir-:
[MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION]

I managed to update to Magisk v5 and the relevant PHH superuser version along with Xposed 86.5 without any apparent issues, however I am unable to install Magisk Manager 1.2.

It only says it failed to install but logcat shows this error:

W/PackageManager( 1798): Package com.topjohnwu.magisk signatures do not match the previously installed version; ignoring!

I checked and while not displayed in the app drawer or in Settings > Apps I did have a version of Magisk Installer in /data/apps so I deleted it and tried again but I am still getting this error.

This will be in my sig, but my device is HTC One M8 running 6.0 (GPe).
[Magisk] KaMyKaSii:
Have you tried to uninstall the old version before installing the new one?
[Magisk] Shockz:
I see that in OP you state to flash custom kernels before magisk, does this apply to kernels that use anykernel2?
[Magisk] -Duir-:
/10
[Magisk] JudgeDread11:
Hi all,

I have Magisk v4, phh's superuser, xposed 86.5 and liveboot all working nicely on my Asus Zenfone 2 Laser (Z00ED) running on Android 6.0.1

I tried to create a module for magisk to run Better Battery Stats as a (systemless) system app.

I am a complete noob and thought this is a good way of learning as it doesn't seem as a too complicated task. I created the module using the module template, but when i flashed the module my phone got into a boot loop. Unfortunately liveboot goes way to fast and the text is way to small to get any useful information out of it.

Could someone with more knowledge about this then me have a look at the module i created and let me know where i went wrong?

https://drive.google.com/open?id=0B5_RG3z_DIVRZW9xbDlNSDFLWmM
[Magisk] Mach3te:
Magisk v5 Confirmed working on Nexus 6 with Android Pay, the latest phh SU, and Xposed 86.5! Amazing work!
[Magisk] benwalburn:
Someone else reported this mod not working with f2fs. I can't get it to work and have f2fs on /data and /cache. Is this the problem or is it just a coincidence?
[Magisk] chazall1:
Great Job v5 is working great.

Outstanding work.

Thank You
[Magisk] Alxoom33:
I deleted previous versions of Magisk and leftover files installed Magisk v. 5 and phh Superuser-17-magisk.zip and app. However, can't seem to install the new Magisk _Managerv1.2.apk
[Magisk] dimm0k:
can anyone confirm how to place an app (apk) into /system/priv-app? when I put it into /magisk/$MODNAME/system/priv-app with a /magisk/$MODNAME/auto_mount my device refuses to boot resulting in a re-install of Magisk
[Magisk] fjdifede:
V5 is working perfect oneplus 3 running oxygen OS 3.2.4 thanks for the hard work.!
[Magisk] :
I can't get the magisk manager app to show up at all which is strange since my previous installs of v1 and v2 installed it just fine but now they don't.
[Magisk] topjohnwu:
Please take a look at the FAQ in the OP :)
[Magisk] :
Nvm... Just saw that it was desperate all now
[Magisk] DawoodSahi:
If coming from v3, do I have to unroot first too?
[Magisk] Alxoom33:
Tried the uninstall in Terminal. Got error message "no such emulator or device" did I do something incorrectly or can I remove com.topjohnwu.magisk manually?
[Magisk] bumpaneer:
I am currently having an issue with v4 and v5 of Magisk booting. v3 did work correctly.

Device: HTC One M9

OS: MM 6.0.1

Logs: no logs generated, device boot-loops

Boot IMG: https://drive.google.com/open?id=0B4Nxg3bQ8H5aZzlmRU9Qck4zUGc

Please let me know if you need any additional information.
[Magisk] Pauls57:
Follow the instructions posted here

http://venomroms.com/worlds-first-100-percent-magisk-rom/
[Magisk] Link_of_Hyrule:
Is this or can this patch be replicated using Magisk on the OnePlus One bacon? https://review.lineageos.org/#/c/155394/1/fs/proc/cmdline.c

I'm still trying to fix freaking Android Pay.
[Magisk] kami2k:
not mentioned in which step to flash viper rom
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Magisk Hide already hides the bootloader state. You can see it happening in the log under "* Removing tampered read-only system props".
[Magisk] Link_of_Hyrule:
That's what I thought but I wasn't 100% sure. Well yet another thing ruled out as to why freaking Android Pay doesn't work on Lineage 14.1 on my OnePlus One. Wish I could get this crap fixed.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Of course it's Google related. Pokemon Go uses Safety Net to check for root and other modifications. The Safety Net API is provided by Google...

---------- Post added at 09:47 ---------- Previous post was at 09:44 ----------

Have you tried a different kernel?
[Magisk] Link_of_Hyrule:
Someone suggested that I might try it to see if that works. Has that been known to work on other devices?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Yes it has. There are some kernels that are incompatible with Magisk Hide. Stock Samsung kernels are and I've seen reports of CM's kernel being incompatible with Safety Net.
[Magisk] Link_of_Hyrule:
I'm using Lineage OS 14.1 add it says it passes SafetyNet so it's life wtf.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
That puts things in a different light... I assumed you didn't pass SN since you couldn't use Android Pay. Have you reset AP and started over, adding your card again?
[Magisk] Link_of_Hyrule:
Yeah it's a problem with Lineage 14.1 on the bacon others have been able to use it fine on like the OnePlus 3. I can add cards fine as play Pokemon go fine but when I tap a terminal to pay Android Pay never even pops up at all.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Then you've got other issues than Safety Net I believe. You have activated NFC, right? :p
[Magisk] Link_of_Hyrule:
NFC works fine with Android Beam and such.