yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] zgfg:
It has been reported several times (and it was repeated yesterday or a day ago again):

- Magisk v19.x does not work on Huawei phones with Nougat / EMUI 5.x (it asks for password to decrypt, then complains that storage is corrupted and finally wrongly requests to do Factory reset)

- Magisk v18.1 (or older) does work with EMUI 5.x (Huawei Nougat firmwares)

Hence, download Magisk v18.1 to root with and do not accept updates to v19.x

(Or, if you want to test new Magisk, have a backup of your Boot img patched by v18.1, and when it fails to boot with v19.x, just restore/flash back the Boot img patched by v18.1 and happily continue using the old v18.1 with the modules you installed, etc)

And btw, there is Search button on the top-right, it can be searched eg for Huawei, to get a list of posts mentioning the keyword
[Magisk] muschiu35bv:
Thank You very much! I search with huawei magisk broke but i think i did not look very well.
[Magisk] sanskar98:
how to upgrade

previously i have flashed magisk v17.3....recently i tried to update magisk manager .apk in my mobile..now it doesnt open and says it doesnt support magisk version lower than v18.0 . you can either manually upgrade or download the app to an older version.... how can i upgrade....i have to uninstall magisk or simply flash again????
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Downgrade to a working Manager. Then download the current Magisk zip and flash it from the modules section of the Manager (as if installing a Magisk module manually, through the "+" button).
[Magisk] guest4711:
Uninstall Magisk Manager and flash current magisk.zip from TWRP. You may download it from GitHub: https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/releases
[Magisk] sanskar98:
installing rom

i have alredy flasheed magisk to my device...now can i install custom roms like venom, blackbird without any problem???

---------- Post added at 11:55 AM ---------- Previous post was at 11:54 AM ----------

how can i uninstall??
[Magisk] guest4711:
The same way as for every app. settings -- apps -- (Magisk) Manager -- uninstall
[Magisk] guest4711:
When clean flashing you have to flash magisk again after flashing your ROM.
[Magisk] halfbytecode:
[MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION]

Please fix the repeated superuser prompts for Cerberus Anti-theft, with recent versions of Magisk (19 onwards?).

I have attached a screenshot of the log. System framework = disguised version of Cerberus. Device is Oneplus 5T, magisk version 19.3, ROM is AOSiP 9.0 20190612.

I found this also happened with Franco kernel app, over 2 years ago.
[Magisk] Ch3vr0n:
Shouldn't that be something Cerberus needs to fix?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
As already stated, that's up to Cerberus. And, I believe I've seen reports that their current beta release has fixed that issue.
[Magisk] martyfender:
I've had this happen to a couple of other apps in the past and the issue was a fix on the app authors end.
[Magisk] keonramses:
Magisk Prompts (Pie GSI)

[MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] [MENTION=4667597]Didgeridoohan[/MENTION]

I don't know if you've seen threads with people saying that they are unable to grant root access to root apps on PIE GSI's because no Prompts come up although we gained root using magisk and they (we) resort to editing the magisk db granting access to apps and replacing it via twrp or adb.

Is there a possible workaround for this?

Thank you.
[Magisk] halfbytecode:
Thanks for the replies. It seems strange that it broke with Magisk updates, and other apps were working fine.

It's good to know that Cerberus has made changes for the newer Magisk releases.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/issues/844#issuecomment-502904584
[Magisk] drezz2:
what version of cerberus you use? i ask time ago, and here, was told that with 3.6.3 this does not happen now (although I still use an old version of magisk where there was no problem)

https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=79704849&postcount=34069

if the version I have installed continues to pass safetynet, is it necessary to update?
[Magisk] kotuamoalt:
No. You don't need to update, unless you NEED to update. If everything is working properly, I suggest you leave it that way. "Don't pick up a happy baby."
[Magisk] keonramses:
Thank you.
[Magisk] Jarvis_chintu:
Can you install any version of magisk on top of any version of android?
[Magisk] halfbytecode:
I have been using Cerberus 3.6.3 for a while, and the issue started happening with recent versions of Magisk only, 19.1/19.2 maybe.
[Magisk] jcmm11:
No. But most of the restrictions involve very old Android versions.

From https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/official-magisk-v7-universal-systemless-t3473445/post68966662

Android Version Support

Android 4.2+: MagiskSU and Magisk Modules Only (*1)

Android 4.4+: All features available (*2)

Android 6.0+: MagiskHide guaranteed support (*3)

Android 7.0+: MagiskHide full protection

Resetprop and MagiskHide is not possible to be supported.

Pre 6.0 kernels are very likely to have no mount ns procfs support, which is required for MagiskHide to work properly. This Linux kernel feature is only required to be added in Android 6.0.

If your kernel lacks this feature, you can build (or ask your custom kernel dev) with some additional patches. The relevant patches are: set CONFIG_NAMESPACES=y in defconfig, and apply this patch. More info: Namespace file descriptors (2010 original article)

Pre 7.0 does not support hidepid=2, thus cannot provide full protection

Some older versions of Magisk need Android newer than 4.2
[Magisk] Nimueh:
I have been using Magisk on my TV box (Android 6.0 Beelink Mini MXIII S905X) since I got it last year, never had a problem with it until now. The box is mostly used for running Kodi to stream content from my PC and is set up to start Kodi when I turn it on. Latest Magisk + Manager.

A couple of months ago I started getting "Magisk Manager isn't responding. Do you want to close it?" errors randomly shortly after booting up. If I click on Wait the UI remains mostly unresponsive until the dialogue box pops up again and when I click Yes it jumps out of Kodi and back to the Homescreen. This doesn't happen every time I start the box, but often enough to be very annoying lol :angel:

Attached log is all I could find, not sure if it actually helps but I hope so :fingers-crossed:

Thanks in advance to anybody that can help me shed some light on the issue and hopefully fix it :)
[Magisk] drezz2:
ok, I recently use magisk and I really do not know how it works, I'm using 18.1 and 7.1.2 for the manager, and at the moment it shows that safetynet passes

yes, I noticed, although I tried it with a previous one of magisk (I returned later to 18.1) and with the 3.6.2 of cerberus, but for the comment that I mentioned I thought it was solved
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Do things start working if you disable MagiskHide (the error in your Magisk log is related to MagiskHide)?

Best thing would be if you could capture a logcat that shows what's happening when you try to open the app and the issue manifests.

https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHelp
[Magisk] ammar18:
share the magisk.log and recovery.log (if possible) by using TWRP file manager if you cant get root permissions.

---------- Post added at 02:32 PM ---------- Previous post was at 02:30 PM ----------

probably not, since it needs unlocked bootloader
[Magisk] 4RK4N:
confirmed working on nougat. magisk v6 + phh's root v17. safetynet helper reports success.
[Magisk] KyeWalker:
Magisk working on cm13

Attached are genuine, I've got magisk to work on CM13 and AndroidPay to work!!! The only thing I'm not able to do is have Xposed active, whether it's Systemless or System but heck ;)

Check this link, I take no credit for finding this method but possibly for finding this link :cool: https://m.reddit.com/r/pokemongodev/comments/5393pf/simple_and_easy_magisk_on_cm13_tutorial/

Using S4 mini running CM13
[Magisk] knipp21:
Same for me. Is there a nougat xposed working with this yet?
[Magisk] fabi_92:
Sorry guys. i saw many post on this thread first of ask but nothing.

I'm on custom rom 7.0 (nexus 5).

full unroot supersu (no boot. img stock)

flash magisk +pph superuser zip

reboot

install magisk manager apk

install pph superuser playstore

open magisk manager but... root not switch on first toggle.

how i can solve? :/

thank you guys!

Inviato dal mio Nexus 5 utilizzando Tapatalk
[Magisk] 4RK4N:
there is no nougat xposed yet. go annoy for an ETA in the xposed thread and u die :D

besides even systemless xposed is detected by safetynet which fails the check. if u want that check to pass (on pre-nougat) turn xposed off in xposed installer > framework and reboot.
[Magisk] KaMyKaSii:
After doing unroot on SuperSU must still flash unSU.zip on twrp

http://xdaforums.com/showthread.php?t=2239421&p=40409356
[Magisk] fabi_92:
wow, thank you man.

works fine.

now.... automagisk ?

Inviato dal mio Nexus 5 utilizzando Tapatalk
[Magisk] jaffa1980:
Hi i have followed the instructions... I think lol. Its a custom rom (genisys 4.5 lgg4) i booted and unrooted in the app, then went into recovery and deleted the files left over manually. The flashed unsu.zip. then the 3 files in order. Then booted. Then magisk manager and phh superuser from the pay store... And im getting this and cant add a card.

I thought i did really well lol... Any ideas?
[Magisk] d0pecr4wler:
Tried that, too. Didn't solve the problem for me.

If I try to toggle root in Magisk Manager, the toggle goes back right after I tapped on it.
[Magisk] JuergenZ66:
i did not use the uninstaller of magisk, just the steps I mentioned

I found new thread, which says he has used both, unroot from SuperSU and also unSU.zip in recovery. here: http://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=68854296&postcount=3433

It is woth a try to do it like this:

- use unroot from Chainfires SuperSU

- boot into recovery

- use unSU.zip

- install magisk v6.zip

- install phh.zip

- reboot system

- install phh SU app from playstore
[Magisk] neo_mat:
Unable to detect boot image

I get also the message "Unable to detect boot image" when I run magisk 6 into recoverry.

The script fail because he cannot find boot partition; BOOTIMAGE leave at null

no "by-name" folder exist in my system that's why I get the message. and propably other people get this message.

And I cannot find manualy the boot partition into recovery. part5 is system, 6 is cache, 7 data. I mount part1 and part2 to see them and there are empty !

sorry for my bad english
[Magisk] AndroidAlien555:
Thank you guys! I have already magisk systemless interface successful installed

Just follow the suggested instructions,

also I have xposed framework running systemless-ly
[Magisk] Carmenlove:
I am no expert here by any means, but one of the very first things it says in the magisk documentation is that you MUST HAVE an unlocked bootloader to use this software (Magisk). What makes you think it will work on your device with your bootloader locked? I'm not being snarky here, I'm just wondering if you know something about this that I don't. As I understand it, the whole idea behind Magisk is that it gets in an hijacks the OS at the very beginning to work its magisk (magic). The very beginning being the bootloader itself. If it can work on locked bootloaders, I would be very pleased indeed, since I have one myself. Thanks and good luck.

---------- Post added at 02:42 PM ---------- Previous post was at 02:37 PM ----------

Sorry about that, that reply was to the message that YOU replied to, not you. Like I said, I'm no expert around here. Peace.

This person:

Quote:

Originally Posted by smellz

Have now done the following .
[Magisk] jaffa1980:
Update, i got it to work after many different combinations.... Turns out its xposed lol i re read a few posts back and people have said that the new update for android pay detects xposed. I uninstalled that and as you can see from the attachment. Its all good. I suppose i just have to wait for an update to xposed.
[Magisk] gk1984:
I wish people would read and search BEFORE reporting a known issue...
[Magisk] Suppenhuhn:
Hi folks,

after my latest update of CM12.1 (nightly) on my Galaxy Note 3 the "Root Toggle" dosent stay in off position.

Everytime I use it it slides back to root.

What went wrong and what can I do?

thanks and regards
[Magisk] WeirdSoup:
Hello, I have a question about unrooting the CM13 ROMs which have the built-in su binary. Is it OK to just remove the /system/xbin/su & system/bin/su(my cm13 doesn't have this though) only and install Magisk, or should I take some further actions?(e.g. removing some system apps) Of course, I don't installed SuperSU or any other superuser apps.
[Magisk] Olympus593:
Just flash unSU.

http://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=63615067
[Magisk] streetsurfer:
Been trying to get busybox to install in su/bin for the last few hours and can't seem to find any solutions online.

Keep getting message systemless root has not been configured.

Any suggestions?
[Magisk] Nimueh:
Wow, I didn't even notice that Hide WAS enabled, nor do I know why it was :angel:

I've disabled it now and will keep an eye on it. Logcat would be slightly difficult since I only turn on the box and then an app starts Kodi right after boot. I'd have to find a way to start Matlog logging at the same time. :eek:

For now I'll see if disabling Hide had any effect - thank you :) :good:
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
You can create a logcat boot script, as described in the link I posted. That will always save a log at boot.
[Magisk] elicoth:
That might be a specific problem of your setup. I've been using Cerberus (latest version) with Magisk 19.1, 19,2 and 19.3 without any problem.
[Magisk] IzunaHatsuse:
com.grabtaxi.driver2 still detect root in my phone.

Huawei P10+ EMUI 9

Magisk v19.3

Manager 7.3.2

Magisk rename enabled

Magisk Hide enabled.

MagiskHide Props Config installed. Not working with/without.

Safetynet all passed.

Google play is certified.
[Magisk] stefano91av:
Hi, I have a H96 MAX PLUS with RK3328 chip. I have not twrp support.

Unfortunately I have bootloop after flashing the boot.img (modified by Magisk) through fastboot.

How can I solve this problem? :)

---------- Post added at 17:00 ---------- Previous post was at 17:00 ----------

Hi, I have a H96 MAX PLUS with RK3328 chip. I have not twrp support.

Unfortunately I have bootloop after flashing the boot.img (modified by Magisk) through fastboot.

How can I solve this problem? :)
[Magisk] Advanced07:
I dirty flashed my rom and now magisk hide isn't working for some reason. I tried literally EVERYTHING and even reinstalled the game im hiding but it just doesn't work? My poco f1 passes both safetynet tests.
[Magisk] zgfg:
For the beginning, resolve bootloop by flashing the stock boot img

Search by your device in this thread if the same/similar issue was already reported

Install Canary Debug Magisk Manager and Magisk and collect logs by following OP instructions

https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/dev-magisk-canary-channel-bleeding-edge-t3839337/post77549897
[Magisk] kotuamoalt:
Try re-flashing your OS.
[Magisk] xunholyx:
Flash your stock boot.img

---------- Post added at 06:03 PM ---------- Previous post was at 05:59 PM ----------

I know you replied with the same answer, but I thought I would clarify that it is the boot.img and not the system image that he neeeds to flash. Both will work, but one is quicker ;)
[Magisk] jhford:
Magisk Hide

What a busy forum. [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION]. I posted this on Twitter but who knows if you'll ever see it.

I have 2 Nexus 7 debs. About 2 versions ago, Magisk Hide stopped working properly so as to hide root from the Charter TV App which won't work on a rooted device even though Charter advertises that it works on everything. To make it work I had to turn off Hide, reboot, & turn on Hide again. I reverted to 19.1 and 7.02 & turned update notices off which work. I hope you fix the bug so i can continue to update Magisk and Manager..

EDIT: I was advised by a member to upload my logs. So, I upgraded Magisk and Magisk Manager so I could replicate the bug. My logs are attached. This is the first time I've uploaded logs, and I hope I did it right. BTW, the Spectrum TV App error message is: "We're sorry. The app is unavailable on this device. Please choose another device. DFE-1009."

EDIT #2. I have 3 Android devices, 2 Nexus 7 (2013) (deb) LTE tablets and a Samsung Galaxy Note 4 (trlte) phone. When this problem occurred, the tablets we running a Pie Pixel Experience (PE) Rom and the trlte was running Resurrection Remix (RR) but was not having the Hide problem. So, after my first post, I thought it was Rom related, and backed up the tablets, and flashed RR and 19.3 and 7.3.2, but no luck - the Hide problem was affecting RR on the tablets, also. So, it doesn't appear to be Rom related. I just restored one tablet, and it's running PE again with Magisk 19.2 and Manager 7.2.0 without the Hide issue -- root is hidden from the Spectrum TV App and it runs perfectly and Safetynet passes. SO, I'M AT A LOSS AS TO HOW TO CONTINUE UPDATING MAGICAL AND HIDE THIS APP.

EDIT #3. I installed Canary but it made no difference. I just uploaded my Liveboot logs. Excuse the length.

EDIT #4. The spectrum error message has chafed from DFE-1009 to DFE-1012.	Thanks.
[Magisk] joluke:
Logs my friend. Give him logs so he knows what to fix. No logs = no fix

Grab catlog and magisk logs
[Magisk] zzjyan:
Asking for help

my current device is honor view 10

if i keep magisk installed, all message apps won't work at all

could you plz upload EMUI 9.1.0.312 boot.img for me?

thanks
[Magisk] Danny94:
I need some help please, just flashed a custom rom on the Samsung S3 Neo (GT-I9301l), but i dont pass Safety Net.

The Rom i flashed: https://xdaforums.com/galaxy-s3-neo/orig-development/rom-dirty-unicorns-v11-7-2-s3-neo-t3814732

Twrp: https://xdaforums.com/galaxy-s3-neo/development/twrp-recovery-3-2-3-0-theme-edit-t3842870

Followed the steps by flashing rom, fixes, gapps.

Then i booted into rom, reboot flashed magisk inclusive clearing the dalvic cache.

Updated Magisk manager, so both are on latest.

Enabled magisk hide and checked playstore-services, pogo.

Now if i run pogo i get device uncompatible message and i dont pass on SafetyNet Tester(magisk manager).
[Magisk] dd721411:
Should your question be asked on the ROM's thread? Many custom ROMs don't pass SafetyNet.

BTW, did you really "Hide Magisk Manager" in "Settings" and tick "Pokemon Go" and "Google Play Store" in "Magisk Hide"?
[Magisk] Danny94:
Yes i did, so you guess the problem might be rom related ?
[Magisk] Danny94:
Unluckily the module does not work, i do also installed another rom now and rebootet after each step.

I fail at both ctsProfile and basicIntegrity.

EDIT: Ok with the 4th rom (cm lollipop) its passing now. I do used the unsu script after rom and gapps install may that fixed it.

Just one thing i cant enable magisk Hide, if i enable it the menu does not appear and after restart its disabled again. Any idea someone ?

Core only is already enabled, the menu dont appear so i cant tick apps to hide.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Your issues might be caused by a number of reasons...

There's a lot of reading you can do here:

https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHide

And this part is particularly useful:

https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHideHelp
[Magisk] jhford:
First, do I have to update Magisk again before copying the logs? Second, I have catlog installed but have never used it. Can you help? Third, do I copy the Magisk log from the Magisk menu? Thanks
[Magisk] wilsonhlacerda:
Concerning logs and Magisk issues in general, this tutorial have nice tips:

https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHelp
[Magisk] jcmm11:
Concerning catlog specifically, that app hasn't been updated in ages. I recommend you replace it with Matlog. It's based on catlog source. https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.pluscubed.matlog
[Magisk] dope77:
Updated my phone to pie,been trying to installl edxposed for the past 3 days, edxposed always fail to load modules. Today i saw someone on github saying this is caused by viper4android magisk module,i disabled the module and since then edxposed is running smoothely.

My question is, what is causing the conflict ?is it magisk or viper or edxposed? (I'd like to find a fix bcz i use those modules.)
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Edxposed. As far as I can tell from the numerous reports that's been posted here and in GitHub, it breaks Magisk's boot order resulting in both it and some other modules not loading (unless it's the only one of those module active). Only seems to happen on some devices though.

It's being discussed on EdXposed's GitHub:

https://github.com/ElderDrivers/EdXposed/issues/265
[Magisk] stefano91av:
I know it. Now all works good.

But, why have I bootloop with latest magisk on that device (rk3328)?
[Magisk] spbx123:
Can a module/app remove root? cause I always lose root after 3-4 days.. daemon crash or something
[Magisk] jesterpaul:
Cannot remove modules I no longer want

Hi Dev.

I have two modules I wish to remove, but Magisk 19.3 Beta do not succeed in removing these.

Attached are kernel and recovery logs, and well as verbose log of navigating to manager and setting the modules to delete upon reboot (which doesn't work: they are still there after reboot).

Also included is a screenshot showing the modules in Manager.

Any suggestions?
[Magisk] AJ:
I get error type 3 :

Activity class does not exist .
[Magisk] jcmm11:
https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/magisk-installed-workaround-t3908748

---------- Post added at 03:39 AM ---------- Previous post was at 03:25 AM ----------

Just navigate to /data/adb/modules/, either in TWRP or using a root explorer, and delete the relevant directores. Reboot. Done.

As far as what's happening I'd need either the magisk.log or a boot log. When you flag a module for deletion the only thing that happens is Magisk creates a zero byte file named "remove" in the relevant directory. This than should cause the directory to be removed at next boot.

You should be able to check if that file was created easily enough.
[Magisk] IzunaHatsuse:
Any reply on my issue? :( Sorry.
[Magisk] wilsonhlacerda:
Can be lots of things, even not Magisk itself related.

Check these tips:

https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHideHidingRoot

and

https://topjohnwu.github.io/Magisk/tutorials.html#best-practices-for-magiskhide

Also search here on Magisk forum for UDS detection method (maybe your case, but may be not).

I'd suggest to do a nandroid backup. Then factory reset. Then install only the Taxi app. And test it. Then, step by step, go evolving installation and testing again (only enable Developer option, then enable adb, then install Magisk core only, then install app X,....) till the app detect root and fail. Till you find what is (are) the root cause(s) of root detection.

Then restore your nandroid backup and do whatever is necessary to hide root considering what you've just discovered with the clean system.
[Magisk] hanspampel:
[MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION]

Please fix a typo in german translation of your magisk app. In Git /res/values-de/ --> "String 32":

<string name="update">aktuallisieren</string>

It should be

<string name="update">aktualisieren</string>

thx
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Just create a PR...
[Magisk] vegetaleb:
Could magisk has any impact on titanium backup? It got superuser rights from magisk but when launching the app it will say "parsing error" as well as with any app I try to restore. I can backup though
[Magisk] Ingan121:
It seems that STC PAY changes activity name on every update. I also found out that this script is not necessarily required to bypass, you can just run 'su -c chmod 000 /proc/net/unix' on terminal.
[Magisk] WANTES:
from today, the game pokemon go, sees the root, gives an error about incompatibility, the manager is reassembled, Magisk hide is enabled, the security profile is working, the problem is only on 8 and 9 Android. Magisk 19.3 and 19.4 canary dont hide this game.