yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] culiacanazo:
You nailed it! It all boils down (as of currently) to circumstances...

Plenty of times i have not passed SN! But it isn't like I didn't pass, went to sleep, woke up, and suddenly passed! There's been tinkering all in between from kernels and roms (read, SDKs) down to mods and patches, spoofs and "unofficials", systemless and whatnot and everything AND anything within a hair of my device's screen edges.

That's the reason why i didn't reply to [MENTION=4997341]Finchy11[/MENTION] 9 hours ago and why i may not address this further now.

Experiment, experiment, try, try, back up, and mess up, and start all over! Want different results? Do things differently (than previous time, etc).

Just between the two of us, it's a pet peeve i highly dislike when people basically say (in coated wording): "has anybody messed up their device so i don't have to? How did it work, blah, blah, blah...", all because they're too lazy to nand up... (I'm not saying you, Flinch, I'd share my exact setup with you if you want)

Here's to hoping that [MENTION=4384464]fake2die[/MENTION] doesn't become disturbed or unsettled by the contents of my post.
[Magisk] culiacanazo:
Why! What happens? :confused: i was Magisking and AICPing not too long ago.. Nothing funny going on...
[Magisk] Elanza_48:
This is nothing to apologise for. Insted I must regard u for ur work.:o
[Magisk] biggdevon:
Device, rom, kernel? I'd love to be in your electronic vicinity.
[Magisk] carlcarl2014:
Help with asus

Hi guys, I was wondering, on the main magisk post it said that asus devices need you to sign your boot image, I have no idea what that means or how to do it, currently I just have invalid boot image when I try to boot
[Magisk] :
Can't seem to install Magisk on this install. I keep getting Insufficient Boot Partition Space. Error 1. Any ideas?
[Magisk] Artim_96:
That's something you should ask in your device specific forum, they can tell you how to do so

---------- Post added at 10:12 PM ---------- Previous post was at 10:11 PM ----------

Remove Magisk, fish sure stock boot.img and start fresh?
[Magisk] culiacanazo:
If I'm missing some info let me know. The steps, well:

Completely clean flash, no ifs, ands, or buts! (Not saying it wouldn't work, I'm saying that's not how i did it.) Used TWRP 3.1: rom, kernel, Magisk, Xposed, thingies here and there such as swipe for keyboard, pixel launcher, nougat boot animation, you know, the usual, nothing big. NO GAPPS!; I said nothing big. You can get those later as you will see. Lastly, Magisk again, no wipes afterwards. AGAIN, I'm not stating a way, just how i accomplished it. Boot up, finish Magisking it up, then proceed to enabling Xposed and MicroG, since both require a reboot anyway.

Voila

P.S. Freaking screenshots, hold on
[Magisk] culiacanazo:
Thing is, i typed "voila" and the corrector put it with the right letter "a" in French, after which or anything of the sort, gets a big, nice wipe, at least in this client, therefore they didn't appear. I keep forgetting.

P.S. "Nothing's impossible!"

- [MENTION=5201751]str8str[/MENTION]
[Magisk] futhwo:
I have a problem with magisk hide: my credit card app (MySi) still detects root. I am on version 11.6, busibox deinstalled and enabled the internal magisk one, selinux is set to enforce (but still the phone info tell it's permissive, it might be that the problem) and of course I enabled the app in magisk hide configuration

Edit: i also tried to reinstall the app
[Magisk] culiacanazo:
If it's green you're screwed, it's not gonna be able to detect from hundreds of ways to tell that are out there. Sorry, bud!
[Magisk] DiamondJohn:
So how do you test/differentiate "Pseudo-enforce" from a real "Enforce" without testing/checking every single possible permission combination explicitly?

No, not ALL phones, but I stuck my neck out on the assumption most recent Marshmallow and Nougat ROMS do.
[Magisk] Krishna Eyunni:
I'm getting this message "no root functionality greatly limited" ok let make things clear

I install the magisk manager from. Play store i download the zip and flashed it booted fine everything was fine until a reboot ? after I reboot it started saying no root thing I don't think its my rom issue as I verified it on 3 to 4 Roms

BTW, device : OnePlus 3t

rom : Los , based Roms !

And one more thing on stock OOS 4.1.0 and even 4.0.3 it works fine !
[Magisk] biggdevon:
Your manager app screenshot says 4.2.7. So you're using the play store version apk with the snapshot .zip? Wanted to confirm because I had one of the snapshot apks showing the wrong version before.
[Magisk] culiacanazo:
You're surely forgetting something.... Magisk can't mess things of that sort up since it only plays with data.

---------- Post added at 01:01 AM ---------- Previous post was at 12:58 AM ----------

I used the "official" manager from the direct link over at the thread, and the unofficial Magisk. I like that! Attention to detail's very good.

Presumably, the app's the same, but i like to stay away as much as i can from Google. Google is evil. Google's NOT your friend. Who knows what sort of microphone or camera they might pack in their versions! Lol
[Magisk] acestars:
any specification for custom kernel so magisk can be installed upon it?
[Magisk] tamer7:
From your screenshot, your android security patch level is at August 5th, 2016. That's why you're still passing safetynet with xposed.

If you have a more recent ROM build, with Android security patch level March 7, 2017 , for example, then you certainly won't pass safetynet if you have xposed, even if systemless.

latest suhide 0.55 also stopped working a while back, so March patch level really reveals root everytime.

---------- Post added at 05:46 AM ---------- Previous post was at 05:44 AM ----------

A lot of Lineage OS users have been reporting issues with latest Magisk. So not surprised you're having issues with a LOS based ROM.

Maybe I'll try to help topjohnwu investigate this, in my free time :)

---------- Post added at 05:48 AM ---------- Previous post was at 05:46 AM ----------

Make sure logcat is enabled in kernel. Magisk process monitor needs logcat because it uses it to to detect when a MagiskHide blacklisted process is started.
[Magisk] culiacanazo:
Of course, that's what were talking about; any newer it would have been a Nougat and had it been a nougat, it wouldn't have had Xposed, and all this conversation wouldn't have had taken place to begin with, now, would it?
[Magisk] Artim_96:
Newer doesn't mean Nougat. Besides that all patch levels are backported to 4.4, even November 2016 can kill it off or December 2016. Even in Marshmallow
[Magisk] culiacanazo:
Well, i find that a little difficult to fulfill since that was the last MM (aka Xp-comp), soo...
[Magisk] Artim_96:
For die device, yes. But Samsung is not the end of all wisdom
[Magisk] culiacanazo:
Party A denounces SUCH AND SUCH ISN'T possible. Party B comes into the scene proving it INDEED IS possible.

~ notice in both sentences the verb is TO BE! ~

Now, when in predicament, Party A changes approach and begins to focus on HOW what Party B accomplished can be _________ (blank for possible/not possible) IF ________ (blank for "x" situation/"y" factor) CHANGES or DISAPPEARS.

Derailing much? :confused:
[Magisk] mrspeccy:
I am on a HTC device, Android 7.0, February 2017 patchlevel, with Magisk 11.6 and the most recent MagiskManager app from Google Play. Safetynet passes. I have a banking app, which I hided in MagiskManager; however, the app reports: "Found an app that is used to hide root access". Should MagiskManager also be hidden from the apps that I add to "MagiskHide", or is it only the root access that is hidden? If the later is the problem, would it be possible to hide the MagiskManager app as well?
[Magisk] doomscooter:
Same problem with me.

BUT already fix to my problem with

Magisk Manager v5.0.170323

Magisk v.12.170327
[Magisk] culiacanazo:
Somebody smarter than I needs to come up with some sort of walled garden for these apps!

Really tired of other ppl telling me what i can and cannot do with a device I paid for. It's MINE!

Imagine Chevrolet dictating where you can go, what brand of parts to buy, or who you can give a ride to!

Ok, it's a banking app, i understand the implications; it should all boil down to " Got root? Cool! Just don't expect any guarantees from us".

But noooo! Because it comes from a higher place, one that doesn't care for the meager amount of money you could ever amass in your life... Chump change for them who have "a mountain's view", brother.

And to finally address you, Sir, no, can't help you there, sorry. :P

---------- Post added at 09:16 AM ---------- Previous post was at 09:14 AM ----------

Don't do that, you'll have [MENTION=4384464]fake2die[/MENTION] convulsion into a comma state
[Magisk] githyanki:
Some apps detect root using system apps. Try hiding root to everything, then test. May be just the phone app needs root hidden....
[Magisk] JohnCorleone:
I have been using topjohn's stuff going back to the systemless Xposed and root and then he just designed MAGISK and now lots of people are thrilled with systemless everything while the system was left untouched. I haven't had any of the root problems on my HTC 10 running Nougat which is the device he has I believe. There is a ad free background playing YouTube that works on rooted phones, I am glad this is getting more modules.
[Magisk] juanysara:
Don't install binaries in samsung I9505 custom rom lollipop
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
There are many things an app may detect and thus percieve your device as not safe. Magisk Hide takes care of a few of the usual suspects when it comes to prop values, but there are others it might search for as well. As already stated there might be dependencies on other apps as well, but Magisk Manager is not one of them. The phone process and settings are two usual suspects.

Check here for a few more tips and tricks:

https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/magisk-magisk-hide-troubleshooting-tips-t3561828/

No.... Hiding too many apps may break Magisk Hide's functionality alltogether.
[Magisk] jasio2k:
Hi

Quick question any idea why after installing magisk 11.6 and any other snapshot fauxsound not working anymore ? any idea ? or you need logs ?

Edit:

On 11.1 works fine :)
[Magisk] juanysara:
Where I can download version 11.1?, the first post does not work
[Magisk] Finchy11:
For me even on "unofficials" with xposed I cannot pass safetynet. Without xposed everything is passing perfectly :(

Wysłane z mojego SM-N930F przy użyciu Tapatalka
[Magisk] teddy0209:
Simple, because magisk cannot hide xposed...

Edit: You can use suhide in combination with magisk, but suhide is outdated, you can only use it prior to novemver2016 sec patch...
[Magisk] Captain_Throwback:
I don't understand why people that are posting an issue keep asking this question, as if the answer is somehow unclear. The answer to this question is ALWAYS yes. Always. Posting an issue without device details, steps to reproduce and logs is completely unhelpful. All it does is waste space in the thread and frustrate the people that are genuinely trying to help.

Additionally, posts that say "the new version is broken, going back to the old one works" is equally unhelpful. Depending on how many changes were made between the versions, it can be near impossible to determine what change caused an issue on your device, unless details and logs are included in your post. So the bottom line here is, if you think you need to ask if a log would be helpful, JUST POST A LOG. Because undoubtedly, it's better than not providing one.
[Magisk] jasio2k:
Ok sorry just one more question what you need exactly logacat , kmsg dmseg all of it?
[Magisk] Helmut.Hartmann:
Hello tamer7,

can you explain me what you are changed in enable script of magisk-hide(log_prin "BINPATH/resetprop -v-n ... <- is this the right string to modify)? Download 1.0.9 of s-PUSHTan don't work for me (even with clear al app-data and reboot). S-Pushtan is still ticked in the magisk-hide list.

Thx
[Magisk] SyCoREAPER:
Am I missing something?

I am new to Magisk. Nexus 6P worked no problem.

Went to do my Samsung tablet (T560nu 6.0.1) and nothing but problems.

Magisk 10.2 works if phh r266-2 is installed but all else fails?
[Magisk] Captain_Throwback:
Your post falls into the category of "the new version is broken, going back to the old one works" and you have no logs attached to your post.
[Magisk] lalitjoshi06:
On my leeco s2 everything working fine with magisk.

Spush tan not working.

rootbeer aap exposing busybox binary even after hiding in magisk.

I m using 11.6 magisk.
[Magisk] tamer7:
comment out these 2 lines:

# Sammy device like these permissions
chmod 640 /sys/fs/selinux/enforce
chmod 440 /sys/fs/selinux/policy

Change these 2 lines:

[ ! -z "$BUILDSELINUX" -a "$BUILDSELINUX" != "1" ] && \
log_print "`$BINPATH/resetprop -v -n ro.build.selinux 1`"

to

[ ! -z "$BUILDSELINUX" -a "$BUILDSELINUX" != "0" ] && \
log_print "`$BINPATH/resetprop -v -n ro.build.selinux 0`"

Reboot and profit.

---------- Post added at 07:02 PM ---------- Previous post was at 06:59 PM ----------

Then your ROM came bundled with busybox, and you need to

1. uninstall magisk

2. use Busybox cleaner (flashable zip)

3. reinstall magisk.

That will help you pass rootbeer test about busybox, but won't solve for S-PushTAN

for workaround for S-PushTAN, see my last post about S-PushTAN
[Magisk] SyCoREAPER:
Very productive answer, thanks for your help.
[Magisk] Captain_Throwback:
Can't help without logs. I've said that too many times to count (and now a second time to you, and you still didn't post logs).

EDIT: [MENTION=4667597]Didgeridoohan[/MENTION], et al I think you guys have this thread under control, so I'll be unsubscribing before I say something I regret about people not posting logs, etc. Maybe you can get people to post logs, I dunno. I give up.
[Magisk] SyCoREAPER:
It was just a general inquiry if Magisk acts differently between the two versions (besides what's listed in the changelog).
[Magisk] Genericxx:
I would like to inform my fellow sufferers that i was able to make the very latest S-PushTAN available via PlayStore work by using the Unofficial Snapshots of Magisk V12 and Magisk Manager . I edited the "enable" file to make SELINUX appear as enforced, according to what [MENTION=5946138]tamer7[/MENTION] wrote above. All i had to hide via Magisk Hide was S-PushTAN and the Dialer.
[Magisk] lalitjoshi06:
I did exactly said above. But still rootbeer aap detecting busybox binary.

I checked it with root check and the location is sbin, i think its by magisk.

Log

** Magisk post-fs mode running...

** Magisk post-fs-data mode running...

* Linking binaries to /sbin

* Starting MagiskSU

* Preparing modules

* Stage 1: Mount system and vendor mirrors

* Stage 2: Mount dummy skeletons

* Stage 3: Mount module items

* Stage 4: Execute scripts

* Stage 5: Mount mirrored items back to dummy

* Enabling BusyBox

** Magisk late_start service mode running...

MagiskHide: Moving and re-linking /sbin binaries

MagiskHide: Removing dangerous read-only system props

MagiskHide: resetprop by nkk71 & topjohnwu

Initializing...

Modify data structure: 'ro.boot.verifiedbootstate'='green'

Existing property: 'ro.boot.verifiedbootstate'='orange'

Recheck property: 'ro.boot.verifiedbootstate'='green'

Done!

MagiskHide: Killing com.google.android.gms.unstable

MagiskHide: Starting MagiskHide daemon

MagiskHide: Update process/package list:

MagiskHide: [com.google.android.gms.unstable]

Zygote(0) ns=mnt:[4026535692] Zygote(1) ns=mnt:[4026535693]

MagiskHide: com.google.android.gms.unstable(PID=9275 ns=mnt:[4026535802])

MagiskHide: Permissive detected, switching to pseudo enforced

MagiskHide: Unmounted (/sbin)

MagiskHide: Unmounted (/system/xbin)

MagiskHide: Unmounted (/magisk)

MagiskHide: com.google.android.gms.unstable(PID=10219 ns=mnt:[4026535803])

MagiskHide: Unmounted (/sbin)

MagiskHide: Unmounted (/system/xbin)

MagiskHide: Unmounted (/magisk)

MagiskHide: Update process/package list:

MagiskHide: [com.google.android.gms.unstable]

MagiskHide: [com.scottyab.rootbeer.sample]

MagiskHide: Update process/package list:

MagiskHide: [com.google.android.gms.unstable]

MagiskHide: [com.scottyab.rootbeer.sample]

MagiskHide: [com.sbi.upi]

MagiskHide: com.scottyab.rootbeer.sample(PID=12111 ns=mnt:[4026535809])

MagiskHide: Unmounted (/sbin)

MagiskHide: Unmounted (/system/xbin)

MagiskHide: Unmounted (/magisk)

MagiskHide: Unmounted (/system/etc/hosts)

MagiskHide: com.google.android.gms.unstable(PID=12469 ns=mnt:[4026535803])

MagiskHide: Unmounted (/sbin)

MagiskHide: Unmounted (/system/xbin)

MagiskHide: Unmounted (/magisk)

MagiskHide: Unmounted (/system/etc/hosts)
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
No support is going to be given for old versions of Magisk. Of course Magisk is going to act differently between different versions, it's been upgraded in a whole bunch of ways... There's been 70-ish commits between the current code and v10.2 with x lines of code. Doing a random compare isn't feasible. With logs it's possible to narrow down the search field to find what it is that's causing issues.

If you want help with the current version, post logs (yay, there it is again). Useful logs are: recovery log from installation, Magisk log (found in the Manager or if your root ain't working in /cache through recovery) and possibly a logcat if you're experiencing strange issues while with your device booted up.

Having said all that, have you tried the latest unofficial beta snapshots on your tablet? There's been another couple of commits for Samsung since v11.6.

Edit: Ah, yes... A copy of your boot image is also useful for developing and finding issues. It's also best to upload all logs and boot image to a relevant issue on GitHub (it get's lost in this thread) or if there isn't one for your particular issue, open a new one.

---------- Post added at 20:23 ---------- Previous post was at 20:20 ----------

Magisk mounts it's built-in Busybox to xbin. You probably have another Busybox installed and Magisk Hide can't hide another Busybox.
[Magisk] carlcarl2014:
Thanks, I have tried but am not getting a reply
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
You did get a reply. I doubt you'll get more than that here. Unless you're really lucky and someone that has the same device as you and have done it comes across your posts. Your device doesn't seem to have much support on xda...
[Magisk] Jaime albino:
did anyone install magisk in Xperia Z Ultra? i asked on z ultra's forum but i didn't get an answer, thanks in advance
[Magisk] lalitjoshi06:
Thanx i uninstall busybox binary with an app stericson.but it was same yds. Ok Now the rootbeer app passed it.
[Magisk] carlcarl2014:
I meant on my post over there, and yeah, it's a shame
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
That's what I meant as well... https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=71616517&postcount=246
[Magisk] Helmut.Hartmann:
Hello tamer7,

you made my day! Now it seems to work proper. SPush-Tan app 1.0.11 opened successful after following your instructions about to apply the modifications.

thx
[Magisk] culiacanazo:
Don't do that! We need bright minds around here! They'll suck the life and brains out of Didge if he's the only other one IQey left around here; instead, enforce some sort of time out (say first offense kicked from the servers for 1 day, second five, third within say 45 days BAN).

Although, i feel you, i was starting to face slap me cause of a guy who didn't read i don't remember what (but i brought it up to Didge.

Didge for Mod, 2020!) :)

---------- Post added at 10:14 PM ---------- Previous post was at 10:07 PM ----------

You guys keep saying "that or this for Sammys", but don't mention whether it matters TW/EX - CM/SP...

I'm asking cause I'm about to dual flash a Stock M to keep around for Xp while it gets to N... Switching (effortlessly, i should add,) in the meantime up until then

---------- Post added at 10:16 PM ---------- Previous post was at 10:14 PM ----------

Do you ever sleep? I know I'm talking to a reflection on the mirror
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Sleep? :confused:
[Magisk] Artim_96:
Shouldn't be a problem anymore, Sony devices are mostly supported by the latest build
[Magisk] culiacanazo:
Yes, sleep, you're impressing me with the idea of having your bunk in one of the halls, probably hallways between the head and chow lol

And please don't overlook my question
[Magisk] aj8600:
Did a couple quick searches but I apologize in advance if my issue has already been addressed. I have flashed the new magisk zip to root my phone each time it notifies me to do so. I notice that the root suddenly goes away for some reason. I think it has to do with battery saver being turned on at 15%. I have to reflash magisk to get root again. Is there a fix for this? Is this a common bug? Is it not a bug?

Edit: confirmed it was as my battery hit 15% root went away
[Magisk] Windforce0511:
What are the correct steps to install Magisk on Galaxy S6 running fully stock Nougat unrooted rom. I have TWRP recovery. Thanks!
[Magisk] gettingerr:
I installed a Magisk Module that is causing boot loops. is there a way to remove it in TWRP?
[Magisk] jhedfors:
Flash Mount Magisk, then you can delete the modules folder.

https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/collection-magisk-modules-v2-t3575758
[Magisk] gettingerr:
Realized that mount Magisk that someone referred to in another thread was a module, not a shell command. Whoops. Worked a charm! Thanks for the quick help.
[Magisk] culiacanazo:
For what i hope is the broader common good, i share that I've noticed (hardly seldom recently) that when i "lose root", it's either because of a change in app or zip. The first one i remedy it by simply leaving the app, waiting a couple seconds and reopening it, and that's that, root is back (never was really gone).

For the latter fix, i simply begin my flashing queue with Magisk and finish it with Magisk.

Works for me every time.

Of course unless what i want is uninstall Magisk
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
I honestly have no idea about that part of the plethora that is Samsung software/hardware.

I'm allergic to Sammy devices...

---------- Post added at 06:21 ---------- Previous post was at 06:20 ----------

Have you tried simply force closing the Manager when it happens?
[Magisk] nicesoni_ash:
Where is the hotfix zip? Can only find v11.6.

Sent from my "1+2" powered by Official RR 7.x.x

Compiled by myself
[Magisk] Helmut.Hartmann:
I thought I answered you yesterday - but it seems I don't send my reply...

For now: many thanks for your help - after following your instructions SPush-Tan (1.0.11) works flawless.

Thx
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
What hotfix? :confused:
[Magisk] nicesoni_ash:
There is a new v11.6 hotfix release to fix selinux issue and other Samsung phones related stuff. It's mentioned in release thread.

Sent from my "1+2" powered by Official RR 7.x.x

Compiled by myself
[Magisk] sToRm1nG:
11.6 got replaced by the hotfix release, meaning if you download 11.6 this zip already contains the hotfix.
[Magisk] mrspeccy:
Thank you for your fast advice. I hided some other suspicious applications, including phone and settings, and later went even as far as hiding all other applications. Still, the banking app always claims that there is either root or an application that hides root access on the phone. Is it totally excluded that it simply discovers Magisk Manager in some way and refuses to work for this reason? Following the tips and tricks section, I also checked many of the variables that getprop reveals but they all look normal to me (e.g. selinux claims to be "enforce") .
[Magisk] tamer7:
Aha, so latest S-PushTan (1.0.12) is now using the dialer to find root.. sneaky :D thx for the info
[Magisk] yakie996:
maybe after a reboot checking if root is ok and safety net is ok? because not always after every reboot everything is ok
[Magisk] Genericxx:
Maybe you could check if it works with Magisk 11.6 for you. Since i'm using Magisk 12, i am not able to. But i remember that all my affords to bring S-PushTAN to work with 11.6 failed in the past.