yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
So far, similar reports like yours have been caused by parts of the Manager being blocked from having internet access by things like custom hosts files. Make sure you don't have anything like that active and try again.
[Magisk] hackermssharma:
Oh i am using custom hosts by lucky patcher for ads blocking thanx for this suggestion.??
[Magisk] guest4711:
I tried it using a phone with default host file and without afwall. MM does neither download a module nor updates of MM. After restoring an old MM canary version (e.g. 7.4.1 | 262] all is fine until I upgrade to latest canary MM.

See nothing in Magisk Log.

But this problem exists only on my klte-devices. On all other devices I tried downloads and hiding MM works.
[Magisk] hackermssharma:
On removing custom hosts MM is again working for me in both stable and canary builds. So in my case problem is with hosts.
[Magisk] Spartacus500:
It works for me, I will be guessing, do you have TWRP recovery ? If so, delete or change the "TWRP" folder internal memory to ".TWRP" and the application will run ;)
[Magisk] marcog1956:
Magisk unable to repack boot image

Hi, i tried many times to use MAGISK app on a tablet ASUS FONEPAD 7 (model K00E) with Lollipop in order to patch the BOOT.IMG.

Always failed during the patching, with the messages:

DEVICE PLATFORM: x86

COPYING IMAGE TO CACHE

UNPACKING BOOT IMAGE

CHECKING RAMDISK STATUS

STOCK BOOT IMAGE DETECTED

PATCHING RAMDISK

REPACKING BOOT IMAGE

UNABLE TO REPACK BOOT IMAGE!

INSTALLATION FAILED

I have searched for all the possible articles etc, without success.

I have tried many different versione of MAGISK, the last 20.4 and MANAGER 8.0.2 (i have used MAGISK install >> go >> method select and file update >> boot.img)

Obviously i have the original BOOT.IMG file, loaded on internal memory.

Please, may you help me?

Thanks in advance

Marco G
[Magisk] BlueMan_86:
Phone MI 10T PRO Latest EEA STOCK ROM

Magisk manager: 8.0.2 (307)

Magisk: 20.4

Problem: When I thick Google Services Framework in MagiskHide, when I exit and open again it is unchecked...

What can it be?
[Magisk] Lord Sithek:
Reportedly it's just display issue:

https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/issues/3306#issuecomment-706473118
[Magisk] BlueMan_86:
Ok, thank you... Why I cant bypass safetynet cts profile.. even when I disable edxposed?

Also new PS APP does not work even is set to hide...
[Magisk] gorilla p:
OP7Pro - OOS 10.3.5

Play Services 20.42.15

I got a notification that I had a pending Google Play update a couples days ago. I completed it and it required a reboot. After doing so, Magisk manager was no longer installed. I reinstalled it and it shows Magisk not installed.

I rebooted to recovery and flashed latest Magisk. I rebooted to system and opened Magisk manager. It is acting like its not rooted and only Magisk manager is installed.

Update: I tried flashing latest Magisk 21 Beta and am on latest magisk manager (8.0.2). Still getting the same thing.
[Magisk] asrar73:
It works thanks:good:
[Magisk] Tigernoisy:
my phone, a samsung galaxy s20 does not stop restarting after i pressed uninstall in

my phone, a samsung galaxy s20 does not stop restarting after i pressed uninstall in magisk manager, i cannot restart it in recovery, i tried to connect it to the charger but nothing what can i do? I use it to work ...
[Magisk] Philnicolls89:
Did you try using the button combo method? If ur phone is boot looping, then you can press and hold the volume down+power button to force reset.

Then quickly change buttons, press and hold volume up+power button until you see recovery screen.

If its turned off you can either boot to recovery using the same combo of volume up+power. Or for download mode, if phone is powered off, press and hold volume up+volume down, connect to pc and only release buttons when you see the download screen.

You should be able to at least access the download screen no matter what is wrong.
[Magisk] pndwal:
Is basicIntegrity also still failing? Did you clear Google Play Services cache?

https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/mod-magisk-v1-universal-systemless-t3432382/post83588003 PW
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Did you figure this out?

The issue generally seems to be that the latest Manager (v8+) uses a CDN for the downloads and for whatever reason it seems like some hosts files block it. But of course, that doesn't seem to apply to you...

Can you access https://cdn.jsdelivr.net?
[Magisk] guest4711:
Yes, I can...

But thanks for your suggestion.

Did MM change the way it is trying to download (e.g. using wget or curl instead of download manager)?

I changed the ROM on one test device from HavOC (Android 9) to CrDroid (Android 11) and there it works...
[Magisk] pndwal:
Latest ChangeLog:

Magisk (21006):

- Fix lz4_lg boot image unpacking/repacking

- Support unpacking/repacking vendor boot images

- Support kernel initialized dm-verity on legacy SAR

- Significantly broaden sepolicy.rule compatibility, now tries the following partitions for storing the rule files: unencrypted data -> FBE data -> cache -> metadata -> persist *

- Properly handle factory reset cases on Android 11

- Add magisk binaries to PATH in boot scripts

Magisk Manager (313)

- Fix crashes when network error occurs

- Tapjacking protection

* Seems a good solution for his conundrum!

https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/mod-magisk-v1-universal-systemless-t3432382/post83842897 PW
[Magisk] html6405:
Hi,

Magisk hide suddenly stopped working an all my android 7.1.2 roms,

are there some new changes from google?

Both checks do not pass...

On android 9 it's still working perfectly.
[Magisk] pndwal:
Try toggling SafetyNet off / on again in Magisk Manager.

However, basicIntegrity fail is usually a sign of incompatible mods etc:

https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/mod-magisk-v1-universal-systemless-t3432382/post82166469

Nb. Fix basicIntegrity first! This always trips ctsProfile in turn. PW
[Magisk] wallace108:
Are there any news about magisk rooting Android 10 phones? Shall we give up on this? Thanks
[Magisk] zgfg:
Magisk v21 (Canary and Beta) supports not only A10 but also A11 (I'm myself on A10 and there are lot of e.g. Pixel users on A11 - just please follow up posts here from the previous month)

However, if you don't have TWRP, you must patch and flash the image - but this is also a valid method for installing Magisk, around for at least three years, and well documented in the Magisk Github documentation

Advise:

Please carefully read Magisk docs and specially Installation and Wiki parts.

Search for your phone in this thread (also, for many phones there are subforums on XDA with Q/A and Guides).

If you really cannot find anybody else with your phone and firmware who did successfully install Magisk - then describe all about your phone and ask. If for some reason procedures do not work for your phone, please properly report an issue to Magisk Github
[Magisk] html6405:
Thx, tried this already and 100 other steps and everything, what Magisk Manager offers me.

As soon I'm unrooted, its going to pass.

I didn't change anything in my rom's and they are now working over 2 years rooted and always passed.

This only affect my android 7.1.2 roms, but all of them.

As it looks like, Magisk hide suddenly stopped working (it began 2 weeks ago and affect all my users...)

Could it be, that google changed something the last 2 weeks for the safety check?
[Magisk] wallace108:
Thanks for your reply zgfg. It's been more than a month that I've been struggling with my Oukitel WP5 PRO running Android 10 trying to get root. I've tried all versions of Magisk (stable, beta and canary) but didn't get any result. There is no official TWRP recovery for my phone version so I've gone the route of patching the boot image and uploading with fastboot (I also uploaded and empty vbmeta). The result is always the same: N/A in magisk manager. I know I'm not alone because other WP5 PRO owners complained about the same. The phone has a MT6762D cpu, has ramdisk, is not A/B, and is SAR.

Lately a russian guy (mehanik6) came up with an unofficial TWRP version which is faulty because it works only the first time I make a clean factory reset (all other times it gets stuck at the TWRP logo). Obviously I also flashed Magisk 21.0.zip when that TWRP gave access but the outcome was always the same.

I started a thread over at github which was closed, and I also joined another thread of other people in the same boat, and that was closed also a few days later. So now I'm stuck and out of ideas because I think I tried everything possible.

Michele
[Magisk] zgfg:
I think I remember when you opened the issue on GitHub, and (unfortunately, I saw that also happened with some other issues there ☹️) it was just closed, with no explanation why your issue was not valid?!

If you don't have root, neither TWRP - you cannot supply logs. But there should be probably some other ways to ask you/ a user, to try this or that, to debug and to try making it working for one more make/model

Nevertheless, it's still not true that Magisk generally does not support A10 ?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
It's this your Github issue:

https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/issues/3209

And is this the other one you're talking about:

https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/issues/3228

If so, the first one was closed because it did not have any information that could be used to do any kind of troubleshooting.

The second thread was closed referencing another issue (actually, [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] accidentally referenced the wrong issue, but that was corrected by another user in the following post):

https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/issues/3042

As you can see, that issue is still open and is about incompatibilities with MTK devices. So, you are (in all likelihood) experiencing a known problem (the Github issue is still open) that currently do not have a solution (apart from possibly using an older release of Magisk).
[Magisk] wallace108:
[/COLOR]

Thank you Didgeridoohan for pointing that out. I must have missed that thread. Glad to see the issue is still open and under investigation. I'll start following that thread and keep my fingers crossed.

Thank you

---------- Post added at 09:13 PM ---------- Previous post was at 08:52 PM ----------

Thanks zgfg for the acknowledgment.. I was frustrated and confused to see the thread being closed without a word. I guess an explanation would have been nice and would have clarified things.

Michele
[Magisk] pndwal:
Possible, but unlikely unless we see many reports...

Do you have EdXposed, Xposed, or any Magisk modules at all installed? If so, which? PW
[Magisk] kevinwu128:
I updated to the latest Magisk (Canary) version 21006 and Magisk Manager 313 - It seems Riru Core doesn't work for me anymore. Downloaded Riru APK and it says "No libriru.so found in /system/etc/public,libraries.txt. Check if there is other Magisk modules that modify /system/etc/public.libraries.txt

Samsung S10, Safety net passing (when edxposed is unticked)

I only noticed this because my EdXposed shows it as active but all my modules are not active even when ticked.

edit: downgraded to 21005 and 311. working now.
[Magisk] Xanth0k1d:
Hi, I got this app called Singpass, its basically a 2FA app by the singapore government. It seems to detect magisk installation, and detects root even after magisk hide had been enabled and the magisk manager itself being reconfigured to a random package name.

At times magisk hide works on the app, but will stop working soon after. clearing the app cache and ticking unticking the app in magisk hide works sometimes.

I'm running lineage 17.1 with magiskhideprops config enabled - my device is sony kirin, and I'm able to pass safetynet check, any idea how I can debug this?
[Magisk] html6405:
I've made a clean installation to test it, without any modules.

As soon it's rooted, the test failes...

Two weeks ago it was still working for all my users.

The device fingerprint and device name are original.

Selinux is enforcing

developer options are disabled

I'm really wondering what could have changed.

(There are no erros logged from magisk, looks like if magisk hide should be working, but it doesnt)
[Magisk] Sval:
i got same problem, with "mandiri online" banking, after they update their apk on 8 Nov 2020. i cant pass with magisk hide anymore

My Phone:

Realme X2 Pro

Country: Indonesia

Android: 10 (latest available on OTA)

realme UI 1.0 (latest available on OTA)

I'm able to pass safetynet check

Problem APK = Mandiri Online

https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.bankmandiri.mandirionline
[Magisk] rund3:
Magisk on Samsung Galaxy XCover Pro (SM-G715FN) not working

Hi,

I want to get root on my phone and to achive that, I tried using magisk, but failed on all tries.

My Phone:

Samsung Galaxy XCover Pro (SM-G715FN)

Country: Germany (DBT)

Android: 10 (latest available on sammobile/OTA)

One UI 2.0 (latest available on sammobile/OTA)

FRP_LOCK: OFF

OEM_LOCK: OFF

There is no TWRP image for this phone.

Also Auto-TWRP script is not working (failing to fastboot)

I tried default Magisk update channel (20.4 as far as I remember).

I tried beta Magisk update channel (21.0 as far as I remember).

I tried canary Magisk apk/update channel (don't remember exact version, but it was only ine hour ago).

I tried last firmwares down to G715FNXXU6ATH1.

I always tried to patch complete AP file and to only patch boot.img.

When patching complete AP file I have to also patch empty vbmeta file to not run into an vbmeta error.

Then, in both cases I run into a boot loop. I get the unlock warning, for a few seconds the cutom OS warning screen, and after that the reboot.

Of course I tried to set factory default, by using recovery mode and by using non-HOME CSC file.

If I access ADB shell on stock firmware, root partition is read only and not remountable, so I can't change files directly.

How can I get it to work?

Is someone here able to tell me how to fix this, or can fix this in Magisk code, or can build me a working boot.img with Magisk or at least "ro.security=0" or can someone build a TWRP-recovery image for this phone or tell me, which other recovery image I should try to install Magisk that way?

Thanks a lot!
[Magisk] pndwal:
To clarify, please confirm both basicIntegrity and ctsProfile are failing w/ SafetyNet toggled on in Manager settings.

Also, please say what device, and Magisk Manager status for SafetyNet evalType, SAR, A/B and Ramdisk. PW
[Magisk] LuminousMazim:
Hello sorry if this wrong thread to report this kind of issue.

My banking app has been updated last night and start detecting root even with magiskhide. I assume there's some new method use by banking app to detect root. So i grab a logcat, and there one line in particular that probably trigger the checker. It's called "CheckForMagiskFiles"

11-09 15:09:52.181 6355 6355 I System.out: positiveRootCheck

11-09 15:09:52.181 6355 6355 I System.out: data:{"DetectTestKeys":0,"DetectRootManagmentApps":0,"DetectPotentiallyDangerousApps":0,"DetectRootCloakingApps":0,"CheckForSuBinary":0,"CheckForDangerousProps":0,"CheckForRWPaths":0,"CheckForMagiskFiles":1,"CheckForMagiskManagerApp":0,"CheckSuExists":0}

It's probably because it detected magiskfile inside my device. My storage doesn't have any magisk leftover, so i have no idea what magiskfile that trigger this checker. Anyhelp?
[Magisk] Xanth0k1d:
Hold on, I think i got a solution....
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
It sounds like there's simply something about your 7.1.2 ROMs that triggers SN. And that it used to work is no guarantee that it will continue to work... Google updates the SafetyNet checks on their end all the time. MagiskHide very likely still works exactly as advertised, but now there's probably something about the ROMs that Magisk cannot hide.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
You sure about that part? There could be any number of files on your internal storage with the string "magisk" in them. A simple find command would find those immediately... You could try using an isolation app or run said find command to see what files to delete. Take a look here for some tips: https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHide#hn_File_on_the_internal_storage
[Magisk] LuminousMazim:
[/COLOR]

Thanks, but sadly it's still same error. find command didn't found any magisk file. I already install my banking app in shelter (isolation app) it's still detecting root. For me to get it working is uninstalled magisk with restore original image. I wonder if an app/module trigger the detection. Will update soon.

UPDATE: nope, still detected. I found thread about on 4da which have the same logcat line. Will do that method and try to update.
[Magisk] Spartacus500:
What is this banking app ? Can you provide a link to google play store? I'll try at home.
[Magisk] LuminousMazim:
UPDATE: using 4da method still doesn't work. Well probably need to wait for a fix, or just restore original image to access my banking app for now.

Thanks! The same with the above before "mandiri online" but I don't think you gonna find it outside my country.

https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.bankmandiri.mandirionline&hl=en&gl=US
[Magisk] html6405:
Yes this could be, my android 9 builds for the same devices doesnt have these problems.

Is it any way possible to debug why all 2 checks fail?

---------- Post added at 07:44 PM ---------- Previous post was at 07:36 PM ----------

I'm building for the Samsung Galaxy Note 10.1 devices (GT-N8000, GT-N8010, GT-N8013, ...) and yes,

basicIntegrity and ctsProfile, Magisk hide is enabled.

evalType BASIC

A/B No

SAR No

Crypto No

Ramdisk Yes
[Magisk] Devilix:
Hello guys,

Someone can say me where is the option "Core Mode Only" in the manager app v8.0.2?

Thanks
[Magisk] guest4711:
Simply boot your device into safe mode. This way magisk does not load any modules.
[Magisk] html6405:
I'm building for the Samsung Galaxy Note 10.1 devices (GT-N8000, GT-N8010, GT-N8013, ...) and yes,

basicIntegrity and ctsProfile, Magisk hide is enabled.

evalType BASIC

A/B No

SAR No

Crypto No

Ramdisk Yes
[Magisk] Xanth0k1d:
I cant find it as well, I think this option had been removed in the recent versions.

---------- Post added at 11:21 PM ---------- Previous post was at 11:14 PM ----------

Okay, someone told me to download this app called servicely, and disable the services containing the string "vkey" for my app, I did a bit of google search and found out that vkey services are provided by this company : https://www.v-key.com , and are used by banks and governments.

I tried disabling vkey services using app manager by muntashirakon instead, but my app kept crashing afterwards. maybe you can try your luck. (I did not try using Servicely, so maybe its a app manager bug.)

also, any ways for me to submit this as a feedback?
[Magisk] Sval:
https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.bankmandiri.mandirionline

or

https://gofile.io/d/ZlvsF7
[Magisk] martyfender:
To clarify, the option to select core only mode button was removed from Magisk Manager. But it can still be run by booting into Android safe mode.
[Magisk] J.Michael:
What I have read elsewhere in this thread is: Boot Android into Safe Mode, then reboot -- possibly holding magic keys to get it to boot with Magisk active -- and during this *second* boot Magisk will be active, but with all modules disabled.
[Magisk] wilsonhlacerda:
Yeah, I've tried it with my good old Samsung S4 Active.

With new Magisk if you boot (or reboot) to Safe Mode then when booted you reboot to normal mode, Magisk will load with all modules disabled (but superuser, Magisk Hide and everything else working).

How to boot or reboot to Safe Mode with your device you have to search.

For instance S4 to boot: device turned off, press Power, when (after) Samsung logo shows up press and hold volume down.
[Magisk] Xanth0k1d:
hey guys, got an update, I used "pm disable app/vkey.services" to disable those 2 services, now my app works fine!
[Magisk] Jpwner:
Hello there,

My Magisk manager isn’t showing the bottom menu.

and a toast pops up saying magisk is denied su rights.

Any ideas?

My device is definitely rooted because Su prompts show up in other apps that request it.
[Magisk] Spartacus500:
What application are you writing about? Because probably not about the latest version of Mandiri Online 3.0.2 :confused:
[Magisk] rodken:
[MENTION=4667597]Didgeridoohan[/MENTION] In order to avoid the dreaded Qualcomm CrashDump error again after updating Magisk Canary via Magisk Manager on the OnePlus 8, would it be advisable to just flash the updated Magsik Canary zip via TWRP and if so, is there a preferable Slot that I should be flashing Magisk in versus just flashing Magisk in any slot?
[Magisk] Xanth0k1d:
If you look closely at the first screen, magisk is not installed.

Magisk manager n magisk are 2 different things.
[Magisk] Jpwner:
So I’ve reflashed Magisk multiple times and it doesn’t stick.

Correct me if I’m wrong, but if Magisk isn’t installed, then should I not have root access?
[Magisk] Xanth0k1d:
Did you root your phone in any other ways before?

Installing magisk give you a systemless root, not a real root

---------- Post added at 03:11 PM ---------- Previous post was at 03:08 PM ----------

I'm talking about singpass application

For mandiri there could be a similar service as the vkey service which detects magisk n must be disabled.

I'd suggest you to uninstall magisk and see if you can use the app again, if you can't then there is sth else that's triggering the root detection, i.e. magisk files, magisk manager, or maybe some props.
[Magisk] Jpwner:
No, I’ve only ever used Magisk.

What are your thoughts then on the denied Su rights?

Somehow that happened and I wanna say that it’s related.
[Magisk] zgfg:
Are you sure that you don't have two Managers installled, this one and another one, probably hidden/repackaged with another name?

Please double-check, and if so uninstall both of them and then install Manager again

AFAIK, there was a similar 'issue' reported a day or two ago - and the real problem & solution were as above
[Magisk] Jpwner:
You were 100% correct. it wasn’t hidden just called manager with no app icon. Oddly enough once I opened it, the other manager app vanished almost like they merged together.
[Magisk] Xanth0k1d:
Were your other apps able to get su?

Like have you ever tried su in termux or sth?
[Magisk] bbgarnett:
Hello I have a couple apps that won't work and detect root right away. First the Micheal's app just pops up some error for like half a second and closes the app and I can't even see what the error is. Also my Fetch Rewards app which has been working was updated today and now detects root and won't start. I have both apps hidden in Magisk Manager but they still get detected. I have cleared Cache and storage for both apps and restarted my device but there still being detected. I am on a OnePlus 7 android 10 with Magisk 20.4 and manager 8.02. I can pass safety net and Magisk hide does work as I tested it using a root checker app that detects root and then doesn't when I hide that app. So any suggestions. Sorry if this is the wrong place to post this.

Thanks
[Magisk] zgfg:
Manager, link to Github, Wiki, Magisk hide issues - several more things to check and try than just enabling Magisk hide
[Magisk] bbgarnett:
I was able to hide Magisk Manager and it allows Fetch rewards to work. Micheals still doesn't but that's the least of my worries. I'll keep looking into other things and see if I can figure anything else out.
[Magisk] zgfg:
Btw, RootBeerFresh app (from Playstore), could somewhat help - it would report Root Mgmt app, which meams that Magisk Manager must be repackaged (hidden)

If it reports Root cloaking apps it means it finds something like Titanium or so, but AFAIK it would not tell you which root app it found

However, it does not yell on finding TWRP folder, although e.g. it also means for some apps that they 'detected' root
[Magisk] PoochyX:
Android without magisk is really boring

([emoji88]Cr Droid[emoji88])