yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] sushuguru:
I keep getting message "Module will be updated at next reboot", tried rebooting many times but didn't work, reinstall Magisk failed too.
[Magisk] blackwind.:
Ever since Magisk 13.0, during installation of Magisk Manager (always the latest version from the latest zip), tons of other apps start force closing, and the "Installing..." progress bar keeps running indefinitely.

If I press my home button and check my app drawer, Manager appears in there, but when I run it, my phone instantly reboots, so I can't even capture a logcat. When Manager is half-installed like this, any app requesting root also causes the phone to instantly reboot, and opening App Info for Manager causes Settings to force close.

I've tried each subsequent Magisk 13 release and just tried Magisk 14.0, and all exhibit the same issue, while Magisk 12 with Manager 4.3.3 work just fine.

This occurs both from an upgrade of Magisk 12 and also a clean install after running Magisk uninstaller.

Device is a Galaxy S3 running the latest official CM13 nightly.

Has anyone come across this issue yet and found a solution? And if not, is there any way I can provide more information to help crack this nut?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Inside the module directory, in the system folder, look for a file named placeholder (or any other file that isn't normally found in the root of your /system directory). Any file like that may cause a bootloop. It's currently under investigation.
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
Upgrade to Android Nougat
[Magisk] blackwind.:
Can't. Xposed.

Yes, I know about the unofficial version, but I also know how unreliable it is.
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
You're not alone (in terms of that issue):

https://xdaforums.com/galaxy-grand-duos/development/rom-cyanogenmod-13-t3294849/post73547624

---------- Post added at 08:29 AM ---------- Previous post was at 08:20 AM ----------

Run an adb logcat, reproduce the bugs and stop the adb logcat :)
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
That's a bug with module template v4. If the module haven't been updated to template 1400, you'll have to install the module through recovery.

You can manually remove the modules by deleting the module folder in /magisk.
[Magisk] Semela:
Hey guys I need a bit of assistance. :)

I got xiaomi mi max 2, global developers rom(miui9) .

So, I decided to install TWRP and magisk.

What I did:

1)flashed TWRP

2) enabled modifications, so that my recovery wouldn't get rewritten

3) got stuck at MI logo coz of activated dm-verify

4) Installed magisk which obviously fixed this problem

Now everything works fine but when I test safetynet I get "Safetynet check was successful, ctsProfile:false, basicintegrity:true"

Pokemon go seems to be working fine.

Do I need to worry? Why haven't I passed ctsProfile check? Does it even matter if pokemons and other stuff are working fine?

- I haven't wiped /Data after installing TWRP. Should I have done it? Should I do it now? Will it delete only my apps but leave my contacts, phone settings and stuff intact?

- I have adaway installed without systemless hosts enabled.

Thank you.
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
Install Universal SafetyNet Fix module from Magisk Manager Downloads section
[Magisk] tau.gi.mo:
I have a problem installing modules...

I installed Magisk 13.3 (same issue with 14/13.2 also) and Magisk root is working.

But when I try to install a module, I tried for example td-binds, I get a Failure while setting permissions and Magisk Manager crashes. No matter if installing from repo or local storafe, in-app or in TWRP.

When I try flashing any other module after this I get a Magisk image mount error.

The first module I tried was installing Xposed, after flashing it on TWRP without errors this time, I got Xposed installed but not active in Xposed installer. I tried to un- and reactivate it but it didn't help. Reinstalling gives mount error.

I suppose sth in my Magisk installation is not working or some file structure is missing (?)

Anything I can do about this?

I am currently on MIUI 9 7.9.7 xiaomi.eu Dev Rom on my Xiaomi Redmi note 2 based on 5.0.2...

Enviado desde mi Redmi Note 2 mediante Tapatalk
[Magisk] Semela:
I get "process error" message" when i try to download\install it..
[Magisk] LastSilmaril:
Thanks! I encourage everyone else who's having the 'process error' issue to try this.
[Magisk] Deus.:
Try this: https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/mod-magisk-v1-universal-systemless-t3432382/post73724060
[Magisk] Semela:
It worked like a charm :)

Btw should I uninstall adaway and restore my default host file and reinstall it having systemless hosts enabled?

If I enable systemless now all checks fail.

Cheers
[Magisk] ReznaMusicOfficial:
I got this issue and I don't know how to get out of this:

With Magisk v13, after come back to a stock ROM (Huawei P8Lite ALE-L21, before I was on LineageOs 13), when I was trying to install the systemless Xposed I stuck in a bootloop, uninstalling Magisk or Xposed was resolving this issue.

Then I restart from the beginning, flashing a stock ROM in fastboot and upgrading manually and then via OTA to the last build (B605). Then I flashed TWRP 3.1.1 and Magisk v14, but when i install the Xposed framework my WiFi and Bluetooth doesn't work anymore, but uninstalling the framework let they work normally. Anyone has a solution?
[Magisk] Deus.:
Well, didn't check so far, give it a try and let us know the results.
[Magisk] xbgpx:
i cant found that file can you give me screenshoot ty advance:o
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
Try this workaround: https://xdaforums.com/xposed/xposed-android-nougat-sdk-25-arm64-t3639221/post73723828
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
If it's not there you probably have some other issue. You don't happen to have an Xposed module installed? If so, it's probably that.
[Magisk] jenslody:
For the xposed related bootloops, please try my modified versions from this post and please give feedback if it works.
[Magisk] ReznaMusicOfficial:
WiFi and bluetooth still doesn't work with Xposed module active
[Magisk] Kyan_Belger:
This fixed my issue with Magisk saying "process error" on the Oneplus 3T, Thank you very much [MENTION=252677]deus[/MENTION]
[Magisk] SB13X:
Samsung G935F Samsung S7 Edge on Three UK FW

I've tried using the new method to create patched_boot.img.tar to flash with ODIN.

ODIN flashes successfully but device just hangs at boot animation.

Reboot and flashed stock boot.img and boots fine.

Opened up New Issue on [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] GitHub here: https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/issues/356

I've seen these quotes from

[MENTION=4667597]Didgeridoohan[/MENTION]

[MENTION=5125527]Artim_96[/MENTION]

With v14.0 and this method being so new I can't find anything on a special installation process as I want to install using new method only. Any advice or anything further I can supply to help Troubleshoot.
[Magisk] Artim_96:
Best will be to just wait for topjohnwu to take a look at the images and see if he sees what went wrong.

But you can try something: get the whole .tar.md5 flashable of the firmware version you are running, remove the .md5 from the end of the name and give that tar file Magisk manger, maybe it's able to extract the boot image from there. Make sure that you load the .tar.md5 into Odin before renaming, then it will check if the file is intact.

If it fails again, extract the patched_boot.img, flash it through TWRP and see if ODIN just had a problem flashing it properly
[Magisk] SB13X:
Thanks for the fast response and I'll have a look at doing that after couple of good suggestions.

I'm not that desperate for MAGISK that I'd installed TWRP. I've only become reinterested since the new method became available to keep everything else intact.
[Magisk] joeherlev:
I have downloade latest 8.5 Rom for xiaomi redmi 3s prime international version..

I also have installed the flashing tool..

Can I flash without a full reset and then keep apps?
[Magisk] rason77:
Im running a Galaxy s7 originally on AOSP and then when i tried to flash my Modules all of the Modules disappeared in the manager even if tried to flash them all in recovery or all in the manager. Inside the manager i get a warning that says "sendfile failed with 2: No such file or directory." And from there nothing on Magisk worked, then i went to a stock rom thinking it was AOSP messing it up and it still doesn't work Please Help. I've tried uninstalling magisk and reinstalling , i've tried different settings in the Manager and nothing fixed it and it doesn't happen when i flash one module it happens to everything i try to flash , and i also get a failed to process error on the repo

Samsung S7 (AOSP and Stock)

Magisk 14

Magisk Manager 5.3.0
[Magisk] Artim_96:
That has nothing to do with Magisk, take that to your devices thread
[Magisk] xbgpx:
i have problem when instal update 1.4 can booting but when instal xposed via app update n flash via recovery get bootloop redmi note 4 sd here
[Magisk] Paschfire:
[MENTION=5318895]Simone98RC[/MENTION]

Logs.. logs.. LOGS..

If neither of you submit any logs within your post when reporting bugs, your posts are of no use.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Uninstall Xposed and wait for a fix.
[Magisk] Deus.:
Try with the newest one:

https://xdaforums.com/xposed/unofficial-systemless-xposed-t3388268/post73728140
[Magisk] Semela:
I needed to reboot my phone and for some reason now when I launch magisk manager it only shows 3 things at the main page:

Installed Magisk Version v14.0

14.0MAGISKSU(topjohnwu)

Uninstal

SafeteyNet test is gone :))) What gives?

Thanx.

PS ROFL>.. I forgot I didn't have internet connection. active..
[Magisk] jenslody:
No internet, no safetynet.

SafetyNet-test needs an internet connection.
[Magisk] audiomarko:
so .... works .... old Xposedmodul deactivated new material design Xposed Installer installed ... in recovery started ... Kernel flashed (unroot) 14.0 Magist flashed and then immediately the same new xposed-v87.3-sdk23-topjohnwu .zip flashed ... Restart ... and ..... runs perfectly .. (Samsung Galaxy Note Edge 6.0.1. RAM Kernel) Thanks for the great work
[Magisk] sxHeavy:
Deleted post because I forgot picture
[Magisk] sxHeavy:
Magisk Manager up to latest version.

Magisk v.13.3 installed perfectly working.

On my phone, MEIZU PRO 5, running Android 5.1 FlyMe OS 6. Magisk Manager never autodetected boot img. Even after couple research I found my boot img is sda26. Manually put sda26 inside list of Magisk Manager to install newer version never worked that way for my device. So I was used to flash newer versions of Magic directly via TWRP. Which was perfectly detecting sda26 and flashing Magisk.

Today I installe newest Magisk Manager but i can't install Magisk v14.0 :

- Flashing through TWRP don't work anymore, at zip flashing step it says couldn't find boot img (tried again to flash v13.3 then TWRP find boot.img path).

- Manually set sda26 inside Magisk manager then chose "Direct installation (recommended)" flashes correctly without error v14.0 to my phone then ask me to reboot. I reboot but it turns out Magisk manager tells me I'm still with 13.3 :'(

Long explanation but I wanna give as much information I can !
[Magisk] bzlmdfk:
Hi i update my Xperia XZ Existance 7.0.0 to 8.0.0 and magisk to v14.0 and have this. Android pay now not working. Someone have solution?

Ciul Dup Jeb z Xperia iX Zet
[Magisk] Litronius:
Nobody else with the same problem?
[Magisk] Artim_96:
It's stated to not post about SN. Bugs concerning usnf module belongs into its thread... Including logs of course
[Magisk] Semela:
Guys, what about TWRP+Magisk+Encryption combo? Does it work?

Atm I'm running TWRP+Magisk and the global developers miui9 rom.

The phone is not encrypted, but I'd like to encrypt it

What would be a proper way to do this? A mini step-by-step guide(or a link) would be much appreciated.

I was told that TWRP and encryption don't work well together and TWRP won't be able to make proper nandroids.

So. do you think ti would be better to run a stock recovery+magisk+encryption? if so what would I need to do to make it all work?

How would I install magisk on a phone with unlocked bootloader? Only via magisk manager?

Cheers
[Magisk] kammzaman:
Mount nameless mod

There are no option to disable "mount nameless separation" in magisksu in magisk manager. I've using magisk 14.0. It need to integrate app to system. The option is presented in supersu but no in magisk. So how can I disable the mount nameless separation mod? Thank you.
[Magisk] Oery:
Update Error

After update to Magisk v14.0 and Manager v5.3.0: Safetynet check fail, PlayStore become uncertified, and GPlay Services doze module failed to load.

have to revert back:

1. Uninstall MagiskManager v5.3.0

2. Install MagiskManager v5.1.1

3. Install module Magisk-v13.3.zip (revert back from v14.0)

REBOOT

4. Install universal-safetynet-fix-v2-beta-5-test-8.zip

REBOOT

5. Check safetynet (pass) again

6. Clear data PlayStore

7. Check PlayStore certificate (certified) again.

Q. How disable Update notification? After this accident, I won't update before anyone confirm about (updated) SU.
[Magisk] FurySh0ck:
Hey guys, I am having trouble installing Magisk on an non-rooted device. It is Samsung galaxy s4 gt-i9515, TWRP installed (as I told before, no root. I installed TWRP with ODIN). I pass safetynet in this state.

I tried both methods described in the main thread:

1. Tried flashing the magisk-v14.zip through TWRP. The result was that I was not rooted, no magisk installed and can't pass SN.

2. Tried patching my boot.img and flash patched_boot.img.tar through ODIN (Odin 3.12.3, AP option). The result is that nothing changed, no root, no magisk, pass SN.

I explained it in greater details here: https://xdaforums.com/galaxy-s4/help/installing-magisk-v14-galaxy-s4-gt-i9515-t3670479

Please help me! You can answer me here or on the thread I openned above ^.

Something is not right and I can't figure out what, I am going crazy xD

Edit: I am trying Magisk ver 14 and MagiskManager ver 5.3.0
[Magisk] k0m3n9:
Mine too works now.... Samsung Galaxy S5 (KLTE) LOS 14.1 with Magisk 14 + Xposed-v87.3-sdk25-topjohnwu .zip with latest Xposed Installer by dvdandroid. No more bootloop. Only safetynet still fails once Xposed is installed (same as previous Magisk 13.3). Universal Safetynet Fix module doesn't work. How about yours?

The only fix (same as Magisk 13.3) that works related to Safetynet is by installing/activate Xposed module called "No Device Check" but it just work partially.. Device certification is certified in Playstore while Safetynet Check in Magisk return ctsProfile as true but basicIntegrity as false.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Edit: Sorry... Edited my answer since I'm not quite sure what you're asking.

Edit2: I believe you wan't to pick the global setting...

The best information would probably come from a recovery log from when flashing the Magisk zip in TWRP. After flashing the zip, go to Advanced - Copy log to save the log to your internal storage and then upload the file here.

Of course it does... And that's not likely to change anytime soon.
[Magisk] derAndroidler:
I hide the magisk manager with the new hide option.

But if I start the Unhide magisk app nothing happens. What can I do to get Magisk Manager back?

OnePlus 3T with SultanXDA LineAge OS 14.1 from 3rd September
[Magisk] image45:
Has this started since v14.0 was released?
[Magisk] krazie1:
As long as its systemless, Yes
[Magisk] B6000man:
I cannot install magisk manager it says in twrp for l720t s4 "meta-inf/com/google/android/update-binary" in the zip file is not found
[Magisk] Mussels84:
hey guys, new to this and looking for help.

N910G (note 4, aus version), using an AOSP ROM (its linked in my sig)

I've uninstalled superSU via the playstore, installed the v6 zip in recovery, phh's superSU via zip (and playstore for app), then installed the magisk apk.

Root status shows as "mounted", i do not have Xposed installed.

Everything 'looks' good, but when i hit the button in magisk for the root toggle it just toggles back on - i do see a notification about it being granted root access, but nothing seems to happen.

Any ideas what i need to do?

Edit: solved it 30 seconds after posting... for anyone else with same problem, had to delete /system/xbin/su
[Magisk] Äptiva:
Magisk Manager is not meant to be flashed in your recovery. It's a stand alone apk meant to be installed as usual after the phone boots.

The Magisk v6 zip is what needs to be flashed as well as the superuser of choice (if chosen)
[Magisk] B6000man:
Thank you but the manager is just a zip from the 1st page I was under the impression I must install from twrp. The zip file does not have the apk for the manager?
[Magisk] Äptiva:
This was an added step I had to take on CM13, but could only get it done via recovery and adb.

---------- Post added at 03:35 AM ---------- Previous post was at 03:33 AM ----------

Nope. They are separate downloads. In the OP under downloads you should see 2 links. One for v6 and one for Manager. Flash the zip (and superuser if desired), wipe cache and dalvik, then reboot. Once booted install the manager and it should be running.
[Magisk] B6000man:
I have magisk v6 installed in twrp. I am saying that the manager 1.2 download is just a zip and I tried to install in twrp and got an error there is no apk so I do not know what to do with this zip to install the manager?
[Magisk] Äptiva:
Shouldn't be a zip. Redownload using the link provided in the OP
[Magisk] B6000man:
Everytime I click the link for manager 1.2 this is the file name "Magisk_Manager_v1.2.zip" . Since you say I only need an apk all those files in the zip imply there isn't one.

EDIT: Ok change the zip to apk and I installed it man this cost me so much time. You pointed me in the right direction thanks a lot!
[Magisk] Äptiva:
I just used the link and it downloaded as an apk.
[Magisk] B6000man:
Ok now issue is root toggle stays on when I try to turn it off?
[Magisk] vccy118:
Anyone got the problem of getting root access to work using phh superuser 17 (magisk version)? According to safetynet checker my phone is rooted but I can't set permissions to app and/or data in superuser app. In superuser settings it just stay disabled.

Using Samsung Note 2 on android 6.0.1 CM13. I did everything correctly (also made sure root is completely removed by using safetynet checker before flashing magisk v6 and phh superuser 17), so I suspect the problem lies with phh superuser 17.zip
[Magisk] Äptiva:
What superuser did you choose phh or SuperSU?

---------- Post added at 04:14 AM ---------- Previous post was at 04:11 AM ----------

Did you only flash the zip or did you also install phh superuser app?

If only the zip install the superuser management app for phh here:

https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=me.phh.superuser&hl=en
[Magisk] cire27rn:
Yes it worked for me. But some xposed modules that changes data such pogo ivy and mitm were already detected and data cannot be changed
[Magisk] vccy118:
Yeah I did use the app from playstore, as mentioned in my post "superuser app" means phh superuser app actually.

And I chose phh superuser 17 coz wanted to use magisk with xposed.
[Magisk] Äptiva:
Can't say for sure then.
[Magisk] B6000man:
I had supersu before I installed magisk since phh was recommended I am using phh now.

EDIT: I did not go to stock rom because I do not want to loose all that I have set up. I think this may be causing the root to stay on because some files of uninstalled supersu is still there? Is there anyway to manually sweep that up? I don't feel ike flashing stock rom because it failed to do so in twrp and I think is because I must wipe first which means I would have to start over and I do not want to do that.
[Magisk] FellpeSoares:
my Moto G2 5.0.2 Stock has two problems, no audio after install magisk-v6, xposed is detectable (i have installed xposed-v86.5-sdk21-topjohnwu.zip)
[Magisk] Kiid:
Anyone? Please..
[Magisk] k0m3n9:
Are you saying that Safetynet will always fail once we installed/activated Systemless Xposed on Magisk?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Yes.

Edit: There's a Xposed module to pass the CTS profile check, but you can't pass basic integrity.
[Magisk] derAndroidler:
Yes, hiding magisk manager is a feature of version 14.0
[Magisk] k0m3n9:
Did you installed/activated Systemless Xposed?

---------- Post added at 04:38 AM ---------- Previous post was at 04:34 AM ----------

Yeah.. I've already edit & add that information to my post previously. Thanks for conforming that ;)
[Magisk] bzlmdfk:
Now no, everything work fine before i update rom and magisk. Where activated systemless xposed?

Ciul Dup Jeb z Xperia iX Zet
[Magisk] blackwind.:
Attached is a logcat of the installation. Anyone?
[Magisk] UserNamist:
Hey guys, every time I try to enable "systemless hosts" in magisk's settings on my Xiaomi Mi4, it triggers safetynet (both basic integrity and CTS profile fail). Anyone have any idea why? It doesn't happen to my other phone, so I have no idea what to do. I can't live without adblock :S
[Magisk] Artim_96:
Tried unified hosts module?

Also, without sooner logs it's probably heard to find the cause
[Magisk] xbgpx:
magisk 13.3 + newest xposed >> booting normal

magisk 14.0 + newest xposed >> stuck n mi logo

ty for sugestion
[Magisk] SysAdmNj:
Ok I'm attaching both types of logs. So I'll say again I cant install any modules. Besides that magisk gives me green checks for being installed correctly and passing safetynet. This started happening after I updated to v.14
[Magisk] John877:
https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/flashing-patched-boot-img-odin-t3670503
[Magisk] WolfKodi:
Samsung Galaxy S6 7.0 Nougat with Magisk v14 being unstable

A few days ago, I tried rooting my Samsung Galaxy S6 running on 7.0 Nougat with a 1st August 2017 security patch for the first time. I flash TWRP recovery using ODIN, boot into TWRP recovery and flashed the zip of Magisk v14 released just 4 days ago. The only Magisk module that I've played around with so far is AppSystemizer-12.0.5.zip. However, as indicated within Magisk Manager, both Magisk and SafetyNet check would fickle between appearing as uninstalled/installed and pass/fail, respectively. It usually takes several reboots to get both Magisk to show up as installed and for SafetyNet to pass. I can't download or install modules from Magisk Manger's built-in repo as they fail with "Process error".

I'm not sure if rooting with TWRP 3.1.1-0 + Magisk v14 should trip the KNOX security fuse on an S6 but it did for mine.

I'm testing Magisk v13.3 (the earlier release) right now and it appears to be more stable. Download and installs from the built-in module repo works too.

Any insight would be appreciated, thanks.
[Magisk] jenslody:
Please check if you have the MagiskManager-folder in the root of your local internal storage, if not create it manually. Then try again.
[Magisk] jabarel:
I can't download nothing ... Process error. Last magisk stable magisk 14. Any chance how can I download a module? Tnx
[Magisk] WolfKodi:
I'm assuming this is for not being able to download from the built-in repo.

You can use the Modules tab in Magisk Manager where you'll find an add button to browser for and "open" your manually downloaded ZIP modules.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
It'd be much more interesting to see the logcat from when you're trying to open the Manager and it crashes.

And by newest Xposed you mean version 87.3 from the Magisk repo, right? How about some logs? If you go to recovery after trying to boot there's hopefully a magisk_debug.log in /data that might show something.

Why is it that your logcat is an exact copy of the logcat posted by [MENTION=2408808]blackwind[/MENTION] above?

As far as I understand it (I don't do Samsung) that's what'll happen.

Make sure there's a MagiskManager folder in the root of your internal storage. If there isn't, create it manually and try again.
[Magisk] blackwind.:
Attached.
[Magisk] jabarel:
Tnx, the folder wasn't there, I created and its ok
[Magisk] cutesniper22:
Hi [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION],

I'm facing the same issue as above. It will auto uncheck magisk hide selection after reboot.

Thanks..
[Magisk] k0m3n9:
It can be found in download section inside latest Magisk. The thing is I just wonder why without Xposed you get SafetyNet check fail.