yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] abhye_x:
I can't download ota update for my phone.. It takes me to boot to to TWRP.

After reboot the update status still there.

How I can download an OTA update for my phone??

Should I uninstal magisk first or what the steps?

Thanks in advance
[Magisk] PYCON:
After reading last 2 pages of posts... I have to ask :

all of you remain on 13.3 due to the problems flashing 13.6 and 14.0 :D

There's someone who uses Magisk 14.0 without problems ? :D:D:D
[Magisk] zelendel:
Many are still on older versions because they work so there really is no need to update. The constant update trend is starting to wear thin for alot of people when it comes to apps and things on our phones.
[Magisk] Windforce0511:
I keep losing root on Galaxy S6 running stock Nougat firmware & stock kernel. After restart it works again and after a while it stopped working again.
[Magisk] WolfKodi:
I'm experiencing the same thing.
[Magisk] Loriot:
I use Magisk 14.0 without any problems. My device is Oneplusone running with AICP rom 7.1.2:)
[Magisk] lox2013:
I have a problem none of the download don't work it keep saying error on downloading the modules. Latest Magisk manager 14.0
[Magisk] westeight:
Uninstall Magisk.

Reinstall.

Problem solved :cowboy:
[Magisk] bzlmdfk:
I install xposed freamwork 25, if you mean this, nothing happen, i uninstall magisk install super su them unroot and fresh install magisk. I install "universal safetynet module" from download section inside magisk, android pay still does not work.

Ciul Dup Jeb z Xperia iX Zet
[Magisk] Thomas_BA:
Problem with Busybox Magisk Module.

I have susessfully installed Magisk 14 and xposed 82.3 on both of my units which are running Lineage 14.1, but..

.. when installing the Magisk busybox module the recognition of xposed in the latest xposed installer gets broken. This happens on my Moto X Pure and Samsung Tab S2.

The xposed modules are still working but xposed is stated as not active.

Anybody the same problem with this Magisk Module?

Enviado desde mi SM-T813 mediante Tapatalk
[Magisk] tag68:
Are you sure you need a method of adblock which can not be configured per app? If you don't need VPN simultaneously to adblock I'd recommend DNS66, then systemless host isn't necessary.
[Magisk] Kallepalli:
Can i flash greenify4rmagisk(externally downloaded) through twrp because on magisk it's showing this error:confused:
[Magisk] SysAdmNj:
Ha I'm really not sure but I'm attaching mines now. Let me know if it doesnt look right.
[Magisk] chinhlevn:
after flashing magisk for my galaxy J7 2016 (nougat rom) : :Unable to restart your device. The integrity verification has failed. You need to reset your device to factory default settings. This will erase all your data."

plz help

---------- Post added at 05:18 PM ---------- Previous post was at 05:18 PM ----------

after flashing magisk for my galaxy J7 2016 (nougat rom) : :Unable to restart your device. The integrity verification has failed. You need to reset your device to factory default settings. This will erase all your data."

plz help
[Magisk] Jfelips:
Magisk hide isn't working after the last update. Only me ???
[Magisk] derAndroidler:
Any idea, what I can do to get the magisk manager app visible again ?

I use this option:
[Magisk] pssgcsim:
Hello [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION],

do you think that by any chance you could add an option for whitelist/blacklist mode in Magisk Hide?

Thank in advance you.
[Magisk] Alucard:
I did that 2 times and still the same issue.
[Magisk] SupDr:
so the patched boot.img if flashed through odin will trip knox
[Magisk] anonxlg:
I have a nexus 5x on stock 7.1.2 with magisk 14 with elementalx kernel

I tried a bunch of things to try and hide root/pass safetynet and nothing worked:

i installed magisk 14 with NO su permission given to any apps

i toggled various combination under magisk (core only mode, magisk hide, systemless host)

turned off adb via usb

installed the universalfix module (beta 5 v14 hotfix)

hide/unhide manager

it was working at some point with 13.3 (i upgraded to 7.1.2 with magisk 2 weeks back), but now when i tried to reinstall back 13.3, i'm getting the same issue of not being able to hide root and pass safetynet

i dont know if this is obvious or not, but uninstalling magisk does make the app work again, if that helps out ruling another rouge app affecting root checking.
[Magisk] PYCON:
Old version 13.3 works perfectly, u've right. Mine is not a trend to update everything on my phone, I've tried to do it just for the notification on Magisk Manager but I prefer to download the ZIP and flash it manually. Just to try. That's all :)

Lucky man, mine is Meizu PRO 5 and there's no way to update a version newer than 13.3 so... I remain on this one :p
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
For an actual OTA updated to work you'll need to restore the stock boot image (there's an option for that in the Magisk v14.0/Manager 5.3.0) and probably also your stock recovery. You'll also have to have made sure that none of your apps have ever made any kind of modification to /system, /vendor or /oem. Just mounting a partition rw is considered a modification.

Working perfectly on a Nexus 6, Nexus 6P and OnePlus 3T.

Make sure there's a folder named MagiskManager in the root of your internal storage. If there isn't, create it manually and try again.

You might want to elaborate on what this whitelist/blacklist feature is supposed to be about...

---------- Post added at 23:52 ---------- Previous post was at 23:47 ----------

That looks better... :laugh:

By the way, is the issue happening only when installing through the Manager, or recovery as well?
[Magisk] rasseru16:
I'm suffering with the dreaded issue that Barclays Banking App in the UK is getting stuck on the splash screen and no longer works with magisk... tried on a Samsung Galaxy S7 & Sony Xperia XZ both suffer with the same issue with magisk 14.0. Please fix asap! Thanks.
[Magisk] Pkt_Lnt:
The developer can not fix the Barclays app which it the problem, as reported earlier.

https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=73692316&postcount=18588
[Magisk] jenslody:
No issues her, Samsung J5 latest stock MarshMallow.
[Magisk] UserNamist:
I use adaway which in my experience blocks most in-app stuff as well. Will try DNS66, haven't tried VPN blocking before :good:
[Magisk] SysAdmNj:
Its happening whether I try to install module from within magisk manager or from twrp. By the way we are only talking about the modules. Magisk installed ok :)
[Magisk] koko115:
I have problem. I have magisk 14 on samsung s8+.

When i install module Youtube background, or xposed 87.3 i cannout enter to settings tapatalk.. when i disable or delate this modules all works great in tapatalk.

https://youtu.be/-1Ks-HyDIiI

How fix this ?
[Magisk] patster98:
Guys anyone with working, latest op3 "dual" speaker mod? All magisk versions I flashed are outdated and hence not working...can't seem to find it anywhere
[Magisk] blackwind.:
So, any thoughts on my logs?
[Magisk] undefinedsahil:
Hello,

I have unlocked my bootloader, flashed TWRP, from there i flashed Magisk, after flashing, when i restarted the device to system, it boots to TWRP only, everytime, i can boot to fastboot menu also, but not to system

Asus Zenfone 2

i used latest Magisk 14.0

Kindly help
[Magisk] viking_kong16:
Dolby Atmos still does not work? Even on latest v14.. ???
[Magisk] Sam Nakamura:
Oh, it's working fine for me...

Please refer to the official support thread found in magisk manager, download section, when you click the module a support thread is linked, this thread is for Magisk, not for specific modules...

Regards
[Magisk] rasseru16:
Can you send me the working version as an apk?

Many thanks.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
No, I didn't have any thoughts on them actually. Hence why I hadn't posted anything else about it... Now I looked again and have a couple of questions:

When you install Magisk fresh, through recovery, doesn't the Manager get installed (on the first boot you might have to wait a while before it appears)?

Have you given the new recoveryless installation method a go? Some Samsung users have reported issues with it, but it could be worth a shot...

Have you tried on a clean install of your ROM?

Both your logs have in common that there's a segmentation fault right at the beginning, so all I'm qualified to say is that you probably have some memory issue...
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
[MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] can't fix this issue, because AsyncTasks are broken in older Android versions/security patch levels
[Magisk] garris_bibop:
SN problem on Huawei P10 lite

Bought a Huawei P10 lite (WAS-LX1C432B124) a few weeks back. Followed the guide about installing and rooting it with supersu. After finding out about magisk i uninstalled supersu, applied the stock boot.img and installed magisk v14. Magisk su is working fine, i have root access. However, i can't get safetynet to work. Magiskhide doesn't work either, root checkers still recognize root, even when blocked. Unfortunately, i can't attach error.log, maybe because i am new here?

My second problem is related to the first one. After safetynet didn't pass (both ctsprofile and basicintegrity fail), i tried several methods from the magisk troubleshoot, including toggling magiskhide off and on again after reboot and starting it with a terminal. It did not work but at some point, i wasn't able to access my phone. I got stuck after entering my pin. The phone would tell me something about storage being full. After a fresh install of magisk the problem was solved. I encountered this problem a second time, this time it occured after installing the magiskv14 safetynet fix via TWRP. In the troubleshoot guide, i found something about magisk_debug.log taking up all the storage space because of the magisk daemon crashing. I cannot find the magisk_debug.log on my phone...
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Huawei devices are a little bit tricky. They often have logging disabled and this'll cause MagiskHide to fail. Try enabling logging or simply enable USB debugging in Developer options. I'll update that part of the troubleshooting guide a bit...

Don't know about your second issue... Try monitoring your storage space to see if there's anything eating the bytes.
[Magisk] blackwind.:
I just installed Magisk 14 again and waited 20 minutes to eliminate the possibility that I've just never waited long enough, and everything started crashing again, so apparently the new version of Manager does come through on its own eventually. Same problem, though, when it does.

Since Magisk itself seems to be installed correctly -- it's Manager that isn't taking for some reason -- the thought hadn't occurred to me. Given that, do you still think there'd be any reason to try? If so, I'll need a link to the ADB installation instructions. They've apparently been removed from the main Magisk thread in favor of installation via Manager instructions, which obviously isn't an option here. Google wasn't helpful.

No, but based on what DodoGTA is saying, it sounds like that would be a no-go as well.

Interesting. Could you explain to me what, exactly, the issue is (or provide a link) so I can file a bug quoting that information? Manager worked just fine before, so surely he could come up with some sort of workaround for users on broken ROMs. Goodness knows it wouldn't be the first time.
[Magisk] garris_bibop:
Thank you very much, will try that ;)
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Face, meet palm. I'm gonna see myself out now... :silly: The adb installation method has been replaced by the Manager installation method, yes. I did not quite think there, did I? I'll blame my wife's coughing all night for my muddled mind today (question is what I can blame it on all other days). :laugh:

Considering the info [MENTION=6429309]DodoGTA[/MENTION] gave I don't know if there's much more you can do. I'm assuming there are no newer ROM versions for your device? Or are you one of the Nougat hold-outs waiting for Xposed? :p

I'll see if I can pass your info on and if there's anything to do about it.
[Magisk] blackwind.:
Haha, no worries at all. For once, someone is at least *attempting* to help me. That's all I can (and ever do) ask for.

Alas, waiting for Xposed. :( What I'm currently running, unfortunately, is the most recent Marshmallow build that exists for my device. Even the unofficial maintainers have moved on to greener pastures.

So I should defer writing a bug report for now, as you'll pass it along to [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] directly? Even better. Thanks for your effort, and please do keep me updated. :)
[Magisk] tag68:
Idea: Could the Magisk manager display a warning if logging is turned off when being started?
[Magisk] garris_bibop:
You were right, Hide is working when i turn on logging via the hidden menu ( Safetynet is not, but i'm closer ;) ). However, its turned off again after reboot, no idea why.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
I did take a look around and I believe you're gonna have to make a choice.... :(

Stay on Magisk v12 and Manager v4.3.3

Update/change your ROM so you can install a never version of Magisk

Use a different root method that suits your needs

The Magisk Manager is quite heavily dependent on newer features of the Android SDK and you won't get those on incompatible/broken platforms...
[Magisk] xdauser'17:
Hi, guys

My phone is Samsung Galaxy s8 (snapdragon chinese variant, sm-g9500), and I saw the change log of the latest magisk v14 mentioned 'Samsung Stock Kernel Workarounds'. I'm not sure what does it really mean, then I tried to flash it on my phone through twrp with the stock kernel. But after that, my phone stuck in an endless bootloop. So it didn't solve the samsung's kernel root check issue. What does that mean? and any solution to this? thanks in advance. :)
[Magisk] Joangarc:
I am on Samsung S8+ not rooted.

I've installed Magisk v14.0.

Sorry. I don't understand what I must do about "However, you MUST have a stock boot image dump beforehand, " How can I do it if I'm not root?

I get error "unable to unpack boot image".

Thanks in advance!!!
[Magisk] callumbr1:
Can I ask why you are installing magisk without root?

EDIT: ignore this post. Didn't read the updated OP my bad
[Magisk] Joangarc:
I follow instructions to install Magisk from here.

Extracting them.:

"Via*Magisk*Manager*(Only support v14.0+):This method does not need*root, and also does not require a custom recovery.

However, you MUST have a stock boot image dump beforehand, and also be able to*flash*the patched boot image, either through fastboot/download mode or ODINInstall*the*latest Magisk ManagerIf you're planning to*flash*the patched boot image through ODIN, go to Settings > Update Settings > Patched Boot Output Format, and select*.img.tar. For normal users leave it as the default*.imgPress*Install*>*Install*>*Patch*Boot Image*File, and select your stock boot image*fileMagisk*Manager*will now*patch*your boot image, and store it in*[InternalStorage]/MagiskManager/patched_boot.img[.tar]Flash*the patched boot image to your*device*and reboot. Voilà!"
[Magisk] Rom:
Hello,

I try to understand how my partitions on my phone using RR 7.1.2 are mounted.

I tried to mount again my system partition in a specified folder but i get an error related to /proc/mounts.

So i try to create a symbol link but i get the error "No such file or directory".

An question about that: its possible to create multiple mount points for an partition ?

Thanks in advance.
[Magisk] pssgcsim:
Thank you for quick reply. I had in mind two modes one in which you allow applications the whitelist or the blacklist in which you deny the applications. The current one is just the blacklist so inversion of it would be a whitelist. I like to hide root from all applications except ones I want to use root so I would find whitelist mode very handy. I hope this makes at least a little bit sense to you.

Thank you in advance.
[Magisk] Si73:
What I did was download my S8's current firmware on my PC (used Sammobile) and unzipped it. Extract the AP file you and will find the boot.img file. Then copy it over to your phone, patch it, copy it back to your PC and flash it through Odin.

I am not sure whether I did this right as when my phone booted up, it failed on verification. Not sure what I did wrong or need to do. Any one have any suggestions?

The new non root/stock recovery installation method works fine on my Nexus 6P without any issues but not my S8.
[Magisk] Joangarc:
Have you tried to change extensión .img with .TAR? I think that Odin needs extensión TAR in new versions.
[Magisk] Si73:
You don't need to change it as Magisk saves the patched boot image as a .tar file.
[Magisk] Elie.Be:
*Solved
[Magisk] Joangarc:
Yes of course, sorry.

I'll download my firmware, then I'll try to do the same and will report how it has gone with my S8+ without root.

Thanks
[Magisk] k0m3n9:
Dont install superSu.. IMHO it will break safetyNet check. Just install Magisk without Systemless Xposed & you will get safetyNet pass. With Systemless Xposed safetyNet will fail.
[Magisk] jenslody:
Don't do that! Changing the extension does not change the file-format!
[Magisk] eried1:
How do I edit the build.prop? I'd like to change the date format on my phone and was told that I should change ro.com.android.dateformat=aa-bb-cccc to whatever I think is approporiate, in my case ro.com.android.dateformat=yyyy-MM-dd. That sounds pretty simple, but I know nothing about doing this in a systemless way.
[Magisk] hany0u:
Anyone knows any module to disable proximity sensor?
[Magisk] Deus.:
Yeah, it is the Settings. Look around there, for example in the Ambient Display submenu, if you have such.

[MENTION=7499385]eried1[/MENTION] use a file explorer (for example Solid Explorer), get into the /system directory (that is in the / (root) directory), there you can find that file.
[Magisk] Ashley david:
Does anyone know which version of magisk will work on lollipop?
[Magisk] AmyClaraRose:
All versions should
[Magisk] Ashley david:
But when I try to flash v12( I know it an old version) it bootlooped.i haven't flashed v14 because when I was on marshmallow flashing v13 or v14 on marshmallow didn't flash so I used to flash v12 and update to v14 through manager
[Magisk] Joangarc:
Please, in which folder did you put the boot.img original file, in your S8?
[Magisk] AmyClaraRose:
What Device
[Magisk] Ashley david:
It's an Indian device called lyf water 8
[Magisk] AmyClaraRose:
It could be the device boot.img setup or software that causes bootloop as magisk supports every android version 5.0 upwards
[Magisk] Si73:
I don't think it matters as long as you remember where to find it but I put mine in the Downloads folder.
[Magisk] culiacanazo:
You hadn't met Didge, had you! Helper is his middle name. ;)
[Magisk] hany0u:
Nexus 6p does not have this option to turn off. That's why I'm looking for a module.
[Magisk] Joangarc:
I don't understand your answer. I'm talking about the Android app Magisk Manager.

When you click "Install", it goes to /data/user/0/com.topjohnwu.magisk/install/boot.img

I can't select any folder. Can you?? Or we are talking about a diferent thing?

Thanks.
[Magisk] bzlmdfk:
Thanks for help but kernel included in update in my rom dont support safety net :/ I need change kernel to pass android pay.

Sorry for my Eanglish.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
You can use a boot script and the resetprop tool. Put this in a file and place it in either /magisk/.core/service.d or post-fs-data.d (whichever works, try):

#!/system/bin/sh
resetprop ro.com.android.dateformat yyyy-MM-dd

Or, make a Magisk module and add the prop to the system.prop file and change PROPFILE to true in config.sh. See the linked documentation for info on what else to edit. The system.prop line should look like this:

ro.com.android.dateformat=yyyy-MM-dd

I believe he's asking how to do it systemlessly... :)

:o

Edit: If I could add a custom title tag it'd be: Answerer of endless questions. :D

You're probably gonna have to edit some system files or apk's depending on what your end goal is and then make a module that Magic Mounts those files to system. There's no universal module like that for Magisk... That'd be a job for Xposed.

When clicking "Install" and then "Patch Boot Image File" in the Manager you should be presented with a file explorer. That doesn't work for you?
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
But you already have that tag on your profile in the private Magisk Slack group :)
[Magisk] abhye_x:
Dear,

Already successful installed magisk 14 with latest magisk manager. Safety net successful.

Then I want to ota update my device. Download the zip update and manually update my device from xiaomi updater.

Update success, magisk root gone and twrp gone.

Install twrp again, lazy flasher and magisk in magisk manager. All success with the modules that already download success. But my safetynet failed false status.

Uninstal the modul, reboot system.

TWRP and instal the modules again but still safetynet false.

Anyone know what's the problem?

Or should I uninstal the magisk within the uninstal in magisk manager or with Uninstaller zip file through TWRP?

And reinstall the magisk again?

Thanks in advance
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Might be that the update for your device hasn't been certified by Google. That's happened before... You could give the Universal SafetyNet Fix a try.
[Magisk] Si73:
When you click install on Magisk Manager, select patch boot image image file and search for where you saved the original boot.img on your phone. Then click on the recent button in the top left and it gives you more folders to search on your phone. Are you definitely using Magisk Manager 5.3.0?
[Magisk] Joangarc:
Sorry!!! i was looking for Magisk zip file, not for boot.img.
[Magisk] Rom:
@Didgeridoohan

Hello :)

Do u know if topjohnwu have planned to add an reboot button on the main Magisk Manager activity ?
[Magisk] Machine318:
Same steps, works perfectly
[Magisk] abhye_x:
Already do that.. Previously I'm using safety net universal v2 beta 5 hotfix version for magisk 14. Succeed but after update my device. Uninstal instal still the same false. My Google play store uncertified now.

Any solution?

Thanks in advance
[Magisk] LielBachar:
All my Magisk modules dissapear after I installed IYTBP zip in magisk and I can't install modules when I try to install it success but the module not showing in the modules.

Someone can help
[Magisk] anandverma458:
Bootloop after magisk install!

So I have a vivo y55 (6.0.1), with a locked bootloader,but with twrp 3.1.1 installed. When I try to dorectly flash the magisk.zip, it fails at unpacking boot image (twrp logs say error 13 while getting boot image:permission denied). So I used magisk manager to patch the boot image and flashed it, but it resulted in a bootloop.

After that, I decompiled boot image and manually placed files one-by-one and booted it, and I found that the bootloop occurs when I place magisk file in /sbin, EVEN IF I DON'T PLACE INIT.MAGISK.RC AND SEPOLICY IN IT. Do you think you can help me? I think placing magisk in /system might work (I don't care about safetynet and ota). If so, would anyone provide the steps for it?

Thanks in advance btw.
[Magisk] Professor Woland:
I booted from fastboot kernel modified by magisk (it should be flashed but I booted it to see what happens). It prompted me this error and few seconds after phone just went off. Does anyone know what it means and how to solve. Phone is LG k350nds (mt6735 chipset) running stock 6.0

Oh and I tried to extract kernel with Android image kitchen (on phone) and it throws me an error.
[Magisk] DiePirate:
Magisk Manager can't install any module.

Magisk v14

Magisk Manager 5.3.0

CyanogenMod 13

Error proccesing zip file.

Log attached.
[Magisk] dimm0k:
[MENTION=4667597]Didgeridoohan[/MENTION] not sure if this has been reported, but I had this same issue after I recently wiped my device and installed Magisk v14 fresh. didn't have this problem before so I uninstalled v14, installed 13.3, enabled systemless hosts option there and rebooted. verified that it stuck and then proceeded to TWRP install v14 over 13.3 and voila, systemless hosts still enabled.