yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] jenslody:
TWRP write a message, where it stores the recovery.log.

It should be in the chosen storage (for me either in root of sdcard or in /storage/emulated/0 [internal memory]).

Magisk is not (yet again) compatible with SuperSU.

Latest Manager is only compatible with Magisk v13 and vice versa.
[Magisk] MPeti1:
i've wrote it once.

- magisk su is slower in execution if i give a bunch of tasks to it

- if i use magisk su, and copy a bunch of files to a place which needs su permissions, i get a "xy used su permission" notification for every single files, and it's annoying to see that message for half an hour or more, but i don't want to fully turn off notifications for that. i would like to use only one app for everything systemless and for root, but now i don't like how magisk su works, even if the time limit is working here (in supersu it doesn't (for me))

livelog (colored logcat at boot) not working with magisk su (i heard something around it in the magisk news, but i'm not sure if the 2 are the same). it's good to know what is my phone doing when i modify something, and good to know if my phone is generating art cache, or bootlooping, or stuck somewhere.

---------- Post added at 09:25 PM ---------- Previous post was at 09:19 PM ----------

thanks for the replies :D no problem, it seems i missed some version's changelog. anyway, where can i write requests for modules? it could go to the main magisk forum or to the module collection thread?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
I saw that... Still doesn't answer why you're asking for SuperSU support in the Magisk forums.. There's a SuperSU forum for that. :D

If you feel a need to stay with SuperSU you'll have to stay on Magisk v12 and Manager v4.3.3. No way around that at the moment...

Are you talking about LiveBoot? Works perfectly with Magisk. Just symlink /magisk/.core/post-fs-data to /system/etc/init.d and let the LiveBoot app take care of the rest.
[Magisk] fndpena:
Just reporting: ctsProfile not passing with magisk 13.3 in the just released DP4. If you need safetynet, wait for an update.
[Magisk] MPeti1:
Yes, liveboot, i'm not on the top today :D (I'm saying it as if it's not usual..) my phone has no init.d support, so this won't work for me. i've tried once this, but it not worked. Anyway i will try it again in the weekend, if i not forget. One more thing: is the "xy used su permission" message optimized? i mean does it happen in the latest version? i really don't want to be negative, just want to know :)

if i use magisk su, and copy a bunch of files to a place which needs su permissions, i get a "xy used su permission" notification for every single files, and it's annoying to see that message for half an hour or more, but i don't want to fully turn off notifications for that. i would like to use only one app for everything systemless and for root, but now i don't like how magisk su works, even if the time limit is working here (in supersu it doesn't (for me))
[Magisk] xehed:
Somebody could help me please, after updating Magisk to v13.3 some apps is getting force close (Google app, fb, line).. any workaround to fix that??
[Magisk] Artim_96:
Well, since this thread gets flooded again every day since v13 got official it's possible that I missed a fix, but I'd start from scratch. At least flashing stock bit image and Magisk again, if not even uninstall Magisk first
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
I don't have init.d support on my device either. I just run this command:

ln -s /magisk/.core/post-fs-data.d /system/etc/init.d

Then I can run LiveBoot and it'll detect the init.d folder and start, it'll install the script, I can set up the app and that's it.

If you can't create the symlink because of the /system partition being read-only (if you care about keeping your mods systemless that's the way you want it), you can create a magisk module that mounts a dummy file (just an empty file) to /system/etc and then add the above script to the service.sh.

How on earth are you copying those files? Why would whatever method you're using need to do a su request for each individual file?

---------- Post added at 22:51 ---------- Previous post was at 22:48 ----------

Sounds like the WebView issue. Take a look under "Apps are force closing" in the troubleshooting guide.
[Magisk] xehed:
[MENTION=4667597]Didgeridoohan[/MENTION], thanks for your help sir, it solved now by unhiding magisk, no more apps fc.

Thank you so much ?
[Magisk] n.p.:
Has anyone been able to get Titanium Backup working with 13.3? Never used Magisk before. Followed the instructions and downloaded from the links on this page:

https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/official-magisk-v7-universal-systemless-t3473445

When I start Titanium Backup, I get a warning "Your SU binary (version '13.3:MAGISKSU (topjohnwu)') is functional but might not work reliably on some Android 4.3+ ROMs. If you encounter any issues in TB, please try SuperSU instead."

Trying to backup anything gets me "Backup failed: insufficient free storage space." Searching for this error suggests changing a setting is SuperSU regarding namespace separation. In Magisk, I tried all three of the settings in "Mount Namespace Mode" (rebooting after each change), but none of them worked.
[Magisk] atarek:
Hello,

Regarding quoted "manager log is empty"

i flashed new rom:nxteam magma. With magisk 13.3 flashed and without busy box after boot issue still exist then i flashed osm0sis "UPDATE.Busybox.Installer.v1.26.2-ALL-signed" after boot manager start log successfully, magisk.log and magisk_last.log created in /cache. After that

i flashed unfied hosts from magisk and reboot then manager stoped logging again. I tried to flash kernel then magisk but same result busybox system or systemless no results also.

Could this info guide anyone to relate any troubleshooting approach. shall i link anything validate busybox i don't know :(

Ps: current status:

Magisk v13.3

Manager v 5.1

Osm0sis systemless busybox

Modules: unifed hosts , viper4android fx by ahrion and audio modification lib by ahrion.

Safety net passes and root is functional flawlessly.

Any advice.

Regards,

Ahmed.
[Magisk] Legendary Cryptid:
I keep getting the same umount error every boot. What does it mean?
[Magisk] The Wrath of Kahn:
Yea, just noticed this as well... it also seems to have issues acquiring root for things like Titanium. Other things like ElementalX seem to work fine however, so yea, most might want to hold off.
[Magisk] Wolfcity:
A few weeks ago I switched to magisk v12 because of some issues with superSU and as I don´t need to pass safety net v12 is ok for me at the moment, no hurry to update. I like the modules of magisk. But may I ask out of curiosity how an installation of magisk manager 4.3.3 with superSU is done?

Can´t find any guides about that. In this case only the root app changes and all other features (except hide I suppose) and modules will still work?
[Magisk] thelangosta:
I'm using it right now and have never had that issue with tibu and magisk.
[Magisk] divineBliss:
This is what I used a few months ago to install Systemless Xposed with Magisk: https://www.howtogeek.com/263663/ho...k-for-frustration-free-android-customization/

My phone was already rooted with SuperSU.
[Magisk] fndpena:
Hey man, magisk 13.3 is actually working just fine. You just need to flash it after everything and then safetynet passes again ;)
[Magisk] oldwolf613:
First time I installed Magisk after unlocking BL, installing TWRP on my HTC U11 ocnwhl Sprint, Sandisk 128Gb migroSD. & it didn't root my U11. I tried Supersu, per TiBu instructions no joy. I ran the Magisk uninstall & then the install fm TWRP install - after wiping cache & dalvik & rebooting & voila root!

I ran TiBu & even tho it was in batch mode for all system & user files, it tried to b/u that 1st listed file & stopped. No backup achieved. Then I went for one file at a time as proof of concept- & again, the process started, screen said b/u-ing filname, but then when it stopped, no joy.

Love the Hide feature in Magisk, it fools VPN s/w that doesn't want to work on rooted devices- but I really need to be able to b/u & restore files- that's why I got HTC, bc of unlockable BL & clear path to root- so I could back up & protect my 3d party data & settings so ...---... HELP PLEASE!

Also sep. question, don't know where to post, so I'm putting it here: In Magisk Advanced Settings there are two checkboxes - one that says: Keep force encryption & the other says: Keep dm-verity what is that about & isn't encryption a prob - all YouTube vids said to not put in a password bc encryption causes problems- but I don't know enuf abt this- so should I check off one or both of those boxes? TIA, oldwolf

HTC U11 Sprint 1.13.651.6 , SanDisk 128Gb Class 10, Rooted w/Magisk 13.3 Magisk Mgr 5.11 (love that Magisk Hide! )
[Magisk] CyberHawk44:
Hello,

I have a little Problem, when I have Installt CrossBreeder Lite than I have that problem that I become Problems with the RW Accsess from the System. I cn only get it back when Im disable that Modul.

I have write it in his Forum and try to find the Problem but he means it is a Magisk Problem.

https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=73156301&postcount=158

When you need some Logs or somthing tell it me please.

I have Observe a other Problem too. When I do a fresh install from the System and Install Moduls over TWRP bevor the first Boot. It ends in a Black-Screen after first initialization and I must enter the key to unlock the Handy. It was with every Modul that I try.

I have a Galaxy S7

Thx for Help :)
[Magisk] johnhazelwood:
You don't even need to reflash. Safety Net is passing again.
[Magisk] Pkt_Lnt:
https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=73073205&postcount=16583
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
If you wan't to stay with SuperSU, make sure you have it installed systemlessly, flash Magisk v12.0 and install Manager 4.3.3. That's it...

There's been a few reports as to Titanium Backup not working with MagiskSU. From TiBu not recognising root to not being able to backup/restore. No idea why... Edit: Well... I have some ideas. It can have something to do with Mount Namespace and issues can sometimes be fixed by changing the Mount Namespace Mode in the Manager settings.

Have you tried setting a different location for the backup folder?

Grab a logcat from when you're running the backup. It might show something.

Looking at the module thread, you have issues with adding stuff to the init.d folder, correct? A Magisk log from having the module installed and the problem active might show something. Also, check the permissions for the init.d folder and also /system/etc. You can do this with a file explorer or in terminal:

su
ls -ld [I]<path-to-folder>[/I]
[Magisk] colinlinton:
When using magisk with a custom kernel and twrp, what is the best way to apply the monthly security patch ota's?
[Magisk] Artim_96:
Flash back stock recovery and kernel. Otherwise you need to find a way to flash the updates through TWRP
[Magisk] colinlinton:
Too bad there wasn't something built into magisk or FlashFire to automate this
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
In theory (I haven't tested it myself or seen it verified anywhere) you can just add the stock boot image and recovery to the top of the flash queue in Flashfire and any custom kernel and the Magisk zip to the end of the queue. Also make sure to enable the option to preserve custom recovery. That should be it...
[Magisk] CyberHawk44:
Yes, thats right it was with init.d. I have now check all permissions and they are all OK.

With Busybox I have something similar problem and permissions are OK too.

I have check Magisk log and it looks different with and without that Modul but i cant it interpret.

When you tell me where I can Export it you can take a look.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Just attach both Magisk log files (with and without the module) to a post here. You save them by pressing the "save"-button in the top left of the Log window in the Manager (you can also find it in /cache).
[Magisk] CyberHawk44:
I use the Dark Theme in the Manger because I cant see the Buttons. A little fault in the Manager ;)

Here now the logs....
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
The logs look fine and /system/etc is Magic Mounted when you have the module installed. Are you saying that it is not mounted rw?

When you have a module Magic Mounting a part of the system, there's going to be weird stuff happening if you want to manually add/edit things. You could of course do it all in recovery, since there hasn't been any Magic Mounting, or make a Magisk module that does it for you (probably not applicable in this case though).

Anyway... Is there any reason as to why you're not using Magisk's built-in boot script execution (/magisk/.core/post-fs-data.d)? Personally I don't have init.d support on my device, but I symlink /magisk/.core/post-fs-data.d to /system/etc/init.d to allow apps that rely on init.d to function (won't work in all cases).
[Magisk] n.p.:
Are you backing up to a TF card? I can't set any place on the TF card as the backup directory (Titanium Backup is telling me that the entire SD card is not writable). The issue apparently involves namespace separation.
[Magisk] robgee789:
Hey guys if I flash magisk can I still use flashfire to flash any OTA updates we get in the future?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
:laugh:

6 posts and not even 3 hours earlier:

https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=73158658&postcount=17374
[Magisk] kevin8082:
So I recently tried to update to magisk 13+ and for some random reason after I install it magisk manager simply doesnt detect magisk at all, with version 12 everything worked fine but since I need to update since the safetynet check is not working I came here wth the log as well, I do want a reply because since the first released v13 the install simply did not work, and I'm on a xperia Z3 with android 6.0.1
[Magisk] CyberHawk44:
When I dont know that gives built-in boot script execution than I cant use it :D

Why not auto symlink from Magisk by install?

I tell it the Modul developer and I hope he have a solution^^
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
It hasn't got anything to do with the module, except for the fact that it's Magic Mounting /system/etc. That's a function of Magisk.

---------- Post added at 12:07 ---------- Previous post was at 11:50 ----------

I've seen a couple of reports like yours, where the only thing in the recovery log that might be anything is a "cat: xwrite: Broken pipe" right at the end.

If you could upload a copy of your stock boot image, the recovery log and a detailed description to a GitHub issue, then [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] might be able to take a look at it and see what's up.
[Magisk] Jimbus369:
Magisk hide has stopped working after some hours. I have tried to turn off magisk hide and turn on it again, but nothing. Reboot solves the problem, but it's frustrating when I have to pay with phone.
[Magisk] nzube14:
On resurrection remix with latest magisk 13.3 and 5.1.1 manager. Unable to add any modules. Everything else works though. Log from after attempting to install module.

View attachment magisk_error_20170725_035616.log
[Magisk] thelangosta:
Yes to "tf card". Open tibu/menu/preferences/Backup folder location/ignore warnings about unwritable card/click on storage provider above the "Detect" button/select Document provider/select your storage/click Detect allow it search your card/select the location of the Backup/click use the current folder/use the back button to get out of tibu and it should automatically restart with the correct location listed.
[Magisk] kemz_a:
Recently resinstalled stock rom on my nexus4, installed magisk but now I'm having issues trying to install the App Systemizer module. Magisk keeps crashing when I try to download and install thru the app. When I try searching on the phone to install it thru the app again it crashed. Tried thru twrp and no luck there either. I have the same module running on a different phone with the same version of magisk so I'm not sure what's the issue. Any ideas?
[Magisk] oldwolf613:
[MENTION=4667597]Didgeridoohan[/MENTION] tnx for input will try ur suggestion, never knew about logcat or how/when to use it for t-shoot, unlocking BL was my 1st expsure to adb & watched a lot of videos b4 trying. Came fm Sammy world & Odin… will advise once I can try diff sd card directory- I KNOW I have a lot of space left on card >99Gb enuf? ?
[Magisk] :
Clearing data didn't work, still giving me fc after 10 seconds of launching the app. And I'm new into the logcat thing, not sure about it but I hope this helps:

07-25 07:22:34.024 E/SQLiteDatabase(5753): Error inserting pkgname=com.topjohnwu.magisk selected=true

07-25 07:22:53.559 E/SPPClientService(6766): [PackageInfoChangeReceiver] [handlePkgRemovedEvent] PackageName : com.topjohnwu.magisk, true, false
[Magisk] Droidge:
Once again, thanks a lot for the help. Clearing Play Store's data and restarting the device fixed the issue. Interestingly, even though I couldn't find Super Mario Run on the Play Store, I could still find Netflix, before the fix.
[Magisk] ale5000:
Hi,

I would like to change a normal flashable zip (already done) to one that work as both magisk module and normal flashable zip.

Could you please give me some direction on how to start and where to look?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
If you haven't already, take a look at the module template and how it's set up.

Also, check out [MENTION=4544860]osm0sis[/MENTION] Flashable Installer Zips in his Odds and Ends thread. Several of those are made to do both. Maybe you can get some inspiration...
[Magisk] Albert Poon:
[MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION]

May I request a filter function in Magisk Hide? So that we can see the list of hide/unhide apps, just like Battery Optimization in Android system setting?
[Magisk] deepu458:
+1, it would be a gr8 feature for this awesome app.
[Magisk] oldwolf613:
[MENTION=1909613]thelon[/MENTION]gosta, I tried to go into Menu->Prefs & get to backup folder location; & when I tried to change to Directory Provider as suggested, it wouldn't budge fm External. What abt trying FileSystem & pointing to Ext SDcard\ Titanium Backup? I created a new dir (literally called) TiBu & it complained that it is empty & wouldn't let me go any further.

I got MatLog fm PlayStore & I don't know what to expect, how to set the settings, or when it is supposed to stop. It goes on for many minutes & I had to X it off by pressing on the Recents box to close it. I changed settings to errors & ran MatLog right aft trying to backup CalculatorPlus app by com.digitalalchemy which did show in my TitaniumBackup folder - not that I can do anything with it…

I'm attempting to send you a log file, wciohI attached to this msg, (I hope, - never did this b4, & I've been inactive for yrs while I was all set w/my old VZW Sammy Galaxy S4, HTC & adb is a whole new ballgame) BTW, for attempted backups I got notifications that there wasn't enuf storage space, but attemoted restores left notification that said Data Restore complete for (?) ?!

Don't like doing w/out backup, that's why I wanted to root, so last nite I made a nand backup last in twrp 3.1.1 - but I'm not clear on how to restore it- seems same OS based issues w/ext cards is messing twrp up as well… used to be I jpst opened recovery, chose restore, & picked the nand I wanted & twrp did the rest…

I'm sure eventually I will get the hang of this…

All help much appreciated, oldwolf
[Magisk] thelangosta:
It might just be a problem with your card format. I'm not hired any reading logs. I doubt it's a problem with magisk.
[Magisk] dlshad0:
Hi

How can i pass the safetynet ?

I am on Sultan 13 cm (Oneplus 3T)

I activated the magisk hide and core only and didn't pass it
[Magisk] CyberHawk44:
Why not a exception for init.d in Magisk?

I think Apps and other must the possibility have to write in init.d.
[Magisk] Gr0m03eka:
Xiaomi Redmi Note 3 pro. Android 6.0.1 (unofficial Lineage OS port). I'm using Magisk v 13.3, but have to use Magisk Manager v 5.0.1 because update to any higher version (including latest 5.1.1) leads to Magisk Manager crash on start. Clearing app data before and/or after the Magisk update changes nothing. Any ideas? Thank You.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
No, that part is faulty... You should be able to, but it's not likely that it has anything to do with that module.

The question is why your etc folder gets Magisk Mounted read-only. Although, I don't think you've confirmed that yet...
[Magisk] oldwolf613:
Only insofar as it is a known issue that TiBu can & has had problems reported here w/Magisk… the TiBu dev even has a warning popup on opening TiBu…
[Magisk] CyberHawk44:
When I know why it was read-only, was that not a problem for me :D

It comes somehow with that modul^^

Edit: Only when that Modul is enabled....
[Magisk] thelangosta:
I've always ignored the warnings and never had a problem. There are many variables involved including the phone, rom, sdcard brand, format. I've even seen some mention that on 7.x ROMs they have a 32gb card that won't work on any rom but 8, 16, 64gb cards that work fine.
[Magisk] dreamland2000:
Is anyone running this on the DP4 beta? I think I saw a post a few pages back that someone was and it wasn't paying safety net so just wondering if anyone else has had any luck?

I'll be flashing it myself when I get home but wanted anyone's feedback first.
[Magisk] dlshad0:
Can i ask

If i installed xposed

Is that mean i can't pass the safetynet ?
[Magisk] oeusr:
I'm on a Nexus 5x as well. Flashed DP4, booted & set up, flashed ElementalX, then Magisk 13.3. Passes safetynet here. Only possible issue I'm having is the enable doze for google play services module MIGHT be causing occasional force closes on google play services for me.
[Magisk] Wolfcity:
Yes. There should be some very beta workarounds but in a normal manner yes.
[Magisk] dlshad0:
so

what can i do it to run Snapchat and Pokemon go ?

:(
[Magisk] inffy:
Dont install xposed
[Magisk] Wolfcity:
Don't use xposed.

Or search XDA for using systemless xposed and nevertheless pass safety net. I read somthing in this thread, I think posted by [MENTION=4667597]Didgeridoohan[/MENTION] but it sounds kind of highly experimental.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Yes, there are ways... You'll have to use systemless SuperSU, suhide, Magisk v12 with the Universal SafetyNet fix module and systemless Xposed 86.2 or a modified version 87. Instead of Magisk you could probably use plain SuperSU and root switch to disable root. And if course you'll have to be on an Android security patch no later than October 2016. None of the above is guaranteed to work and I've never tried any of it... I might have forgotten parts...

This isn't the place though... It's been discussed in both the systemless Xposed thread and in the suhide thread. If you need assistance with any of the above, go there.
[Magisk] nzube14:
Can anyone help please? :)
[Magisk] benyou54:
mod edit: Discussion of lucky pater is not allowed on XDA
[Magisk] Rom:
Which phone (builder & model) u have ?
[Magisk] Mohamed Elhadad:
can i have both magisk and xposed
[Magisk] Rom:
You can't ask about a problem related an issue with an "warez app" on XDA (cracks packers) and personaly i think that it would be the problem.

Questions about "warez app" are not allow on XDA..

---------- Post added at 23:38 ---------- Previous post was at 23:37 ----------

Its depend which android version and customer phone u have and if you want to install the official xposed.
[Magisk] zelendel:
Look that app is banned here as are all mentions of it. You will find no help here and may even get in trouble for asking. So if it works it works, if it doesnt it doesnt. Either deal with it or find your answers somewhere else.

Just a bit of advise. I would ditch the app. It is the cause for many an android virus.
[Magisk] nzube14:
OnePlus One with RR 5.8.3-20170417. Magisk worked fine before, then one day I noticed I didn't have any modules show up in the list and can't get that error when I try to install one.
[Magisk] FaustTN:
Oops wrong message, nothing to see here carry on.
[Magisk] Ramzh:
Is it possible to run xposed with the root toggle off?

Plus why every time I try to turn on SE Linux it goes off again?

EDIT: I have an HTC M8 S-ROM if it helps