yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
1. Magisk won't survive a /data partition wipe

2. No (since Magisk v13.1)

3. Which modules did you install?
[Magisk] andreasy:
I don't remember. Which one because I installed 4-5. Now it's ok. A few other caused me problems so they need testing
[Magisk] ananthakrshnan10:
Is there any link between SafetyNet check and the google play apps history?
[Magisk] andreasy:
About safety net check, why should I care if it passes or not? I see that if I disable xposed it will pass but what's that point of passing or not?
[Magisk] teddy0209:
Some apps won't appear on play store if your device is uncertified, and you can't use apps which requires passing SN...
[Magisk] papzi57:
As Android OREO arrived on ONEPLUS 3/T, we would need the MAGISK that supports OREO as a matter of urgency!

Please [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION], help us with ONEPLUS 3 owners!
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
https://android.gadgethacks.com/how...le-actually-cares-about-android-root-0177638/

---------- Post added at 02:34 PM ---------- Previous post was at 02:33 PM ----------

Magisk v13.1+ supports Android Oreo
[Magisk] ananthakrshnan10:
Actually I am using a Redmi Note 4 Indian variant with Official LOS and GApps. When i log into my google account, after a while the SafetyNet check fails, however when i logged in my cousin's google account the both SafetyNet checks are true even after the unlocking the bootloader. I am really confused. (i have replicated the same scenarios with clean flash but with different google account)
[Magisk] papzi57:
It looks like stable 14 and 14.2 beta will not work under Oneplus 3 Android 8.

https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=74153517&postcount=284 :(:confused:
[Magisk] Anas Rahman:
You can download app lock from playstore and do that.

---------- Post added at 02:47 PM ---------- Previous post was at 02:45 PM ----------

How do i make a bootnaimation as a magisk module so that i can use it via magisk manager
[Magisk] Artim_96:
No, that's completely different. It can not randomize your logo screens num pad.

And for that, just get the module template and put a folder "media" in the system folder and there your boot animation. Then just edit the module.prop and zip it. Done
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Correct me if I'm wrong, but that Oreo is beta, right? It might just be that there's something wrong with that build rather than Magisk... Until someone provides logs, there's not gonna be any "fix" or support.
[Magisk] papzi57:
Yes, but...:

I have Open Beta since first...

Last (Open Beta 24) works fine with Magisk 14.0.

Only Open Beta 25 (OP3) and Open Beta 16 (OP3T) incompatible with Magisk.

But I would like to use the MAGISK modules. I like, I got used to it.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
So... If you want it to work, provide logs. Logcat or magisk_debug.log from /data would do.
[Magisk] lcsboy:
My hTC M9 Android 7.0 can pass SafetyNet after installing Magisk v14.0 1st time.

Due to some issues, I uninstall Magisk V14.0 and restore Stock boot image to boot to Android 7.0.

And then, I reinstall Magisk V14.0, but ctsprofile is always false.

Even I update to v14.2 and Magisk Manager 5.0.3.5, it is still false.

Does anyone can help me to pass?
[Magisk] Fif_:
Dirty flash your ROM then reinstall Magisk.
[Magisk] andreasy:
About 1. I was thinking, will it be possible after data wipe or new rom flash, to restore all these (magisk, xposed, their modules and settings) via titanium backup or I'll have to reinstall everything each time?
[Magisk] teddy0209:
It will survive a new rom flash as long as you don't wipe /data..., otherwise, you have to reinstall everything...
[Magisk] andreasy:
Yes I understand but I ask if restoring magisk modules with xposed from TB is possible Instead of reinstall
[Magisk] teddy0209:
I already answered that... As far as I know TBU cannot do such thing...
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
As for Magisk and all of its modules, backup your /data/magisk.img file somewhere, backup your ROM's stock boot image somewhere as well (if you're only doing a factory reset or a /data wipe), flash the boot image that you backed up (if you're only doing a factory reset or a /data wipe), flash the Magisk ZIP in TWRP, put the backed up /data/magisk.img file in its original place and reset the permissions for it ("chmod 0644 /data/magisk.img; chown 0:0 /data/magisk.img")

As for Magisk Manager and all of its data, Titanium Backup may work (but there's no guarantee)

As for the Xposed framework, it's already restored along with all of your Magisk modules by following the Magisk part of this mini-tutorial post (if it's a Magisk module)

As for the Xposed Installer, its settings, Xposed modules and their settings, Titanium Backup may work (but there's no guarantee)

Magisk note: If your ROM has addon.d support and if it doesn't flash Magisk, then Magisk should be kept after a dirty ROM flash
[Magisk] andreasy:
Another question for something I read and I'm not sure I got it right. Is it true that by even mounting the system partition as rw or modifying a file in there will stop safetynet from passing test and you'll have to reflash a rom from beginning?
[Magisk] Fif_:
True if dm-verity is on which is the case in most stock ROMs.
[Magisk] teddy0209:
I'm not sure about mounting system as rw, my system has always been ro... For modifying a file yes, but not all I guess...
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
With Magisk installed and fully enabled (and Magisk Hide enabled), it's pretty much impossible to make changes to the actual /system partition when you're booted to Android (But, in recovery, you can mostly make changes to it without tripping SafetyNet (but some changes will trip it, like Xposed)

But without Magisk installed (or with Magisk Hide disabled, Magisk core-only mode enabled or without a kernel that can hide dm-verity state), it's a different story (You can make changes to the /system partition when you're booted to Android, but they will trip SafetyNet, especially on devices with dm-verity)

Note: There are other things that can trip SafetyNet, like unlocked bootloader, non-CTS-approved build fingerprint and more...
[Magisk] rockthenet:
Hey guys, great app. really useful. :)

But i encountered a problem: i tried to hide the app for seqr. Unfortunately it wasn't possible.

So i tried to use the "fake delete mode" (don't know the actual name anymore). But seqr still detects it. Next i tried to get back out of the fake delete mode but this wasn't proper working at all. nothing happend... :(

So i finally did a complete uninstall via TWRP. This works fine.

But unfortunately I can't reinstall it anymore. some how - I guess the app is still in the "fake delete mode". So how do i proceed? As I need it back, now!
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
"pm unhide com.topjohnwu.magisk"
[Magisk] rockthenet:
Thanks for the quick response...

I just tried this command via adb shell. But i guess it was not successful?!

C:\adb>adb shell
OnePlus5:/ $ pm unhide com.topjohnwu.magisk
Error: java.lang.SecurityException: Neither user 2000 nor current process has an
droid.permission.MANAGE_USERS.
1|OnePlus5:/ $

any idea?
[Magisk] Fif_:
You need root to run this command.
[Magisk] Diomorgan:
wih magisk 14.0 Mysi don't find the root, BUT when I try to turn on the switch "MyPay" to pay contactless it says to try again because there's a tecnical problem.

I reported it to Cartasi and they (probably with a lot of fantasy and unknowing what I was talking about) they say that contactless pay with phone is enabled by default...

I would like to ask you why did you remove busybox and the selinux thing...

I'm afraid that one problem could be the NON NFC simcard by Wind operator.

The Intesa san paolo app instead let me see how much money I have and do home banking stuff, but whe I try the "PayGo" for contactless pay t finally find that the item is rooted.

Maybe newer versione will be more "powerful" hiding the root, but I won't exclude the NFC chip simcard, do you have it?

My hone is an LG G5 italian H850 on nougat 20j firmware.
[Magisk] rockthenet:
I guess due to the hassle with Magist unhide i lost root completely. So i just installed the classic SU and got root back.

so next try. but again without success:

|OnePlus5:/ $ su pm unhide com.topjohnwu.magisk
sush: unhide: not found
127|OnePlus5:/ $

Any ideas?
[Magisk] jenslody:
"pm uninstall com.topjohnwu.magisk" should work, and does not need root.
[Magisk] Diomorgan:
Same problem here, did you find a fix?

I got an LG G5 20j rom magisk 14.0 .

MySi app for my VISA card can't see the root, but doesn't let me turn on the contactless payment feature anyhow telling about a tecnical problem.Maybe because I'm on Wind that has no NFC chip on simcard....
[Magisk] rockthenet:
Success! :) Thank u!

So how should i proceed to get back to Magisk now?

deinstall SU?

Install Magisk zip? App?
[Magisk] Fif_:
That's not view su works. You need:

su -c "pm unhide com.topjohnwu.magisk"

With the quotes and all.

I'm unsure of the result since you've removed Magisk...
[Magisk] rockthenet:
Tried this also:

C:\adb>adb shell

OnePlus5:/ $ su -c "pm unhide com.topjohnwu.magisk"

Package com.topjohnwu.magisk new hidden state: true

OnePlus5:/ $

Don't know what "true" means. Success? How should i proceed?
[Magisk] Fif_:
Sounds like it worked.
[Magisk] Aneuryst:
Hi guys I just searched the thread for this but never found a final solution.. when trying to flash modules in either Magisk Manager OR TWRP, both come back with the error "/data/magisk_merge.img mount failed...". Maybe I missed something in the thread but I have looked on both this thread and google for the past 2 hours and haven't found anything helpful.
[Magisk] Artim_96:
Is Magisk otherwise running? That sounds like your /data partition is formatted with a buggy version of F2FS, the only fix I know of is simply get a ROM/kernel that had a working implementation
[Magisk] Aneuryst:
Yup, Magisk itself is fine besides that. I'm using AEX on a Moto G5 at the moment, couldn't really find anything regarding the issue over there either. Not sure if it matters but AEX worked flawlessly with Magisk on my G3 and G4+ previously, but that's probably irrelevant is it?
[Magisk] Lizard:
It seems Magisk Manager won't update from within the app on oreo on a Pixel C. I had to download the update to 5.4.0 manually.
[Magisk] mattspew:
If I click on the notification to update the APK or click update in the app, nothing happens. No error, nothing.

Any ideas?
[Magisk] deathblade:
Same here, running Oreo on OnePlus one
[Magisk] carlylemiii:
14.3 Beta, Pixel XL, Oreo, ElementalX, TWRP.

Magisk Hide works just fine but for only an hour or so. Then a toggle of the switch makes it work again. Any ideas?
[Magisk] St Sinned:
Update came...but when I tap to install, nothing happens...
[Magisk] mrkrazy:
Same here, I ended up downloading and flashing it manually and wiping dalvik/cache and all is well :)
[Magisk] St Sinned:
OK...I will do that also...thank you...
[Magisk] Anas Rahman:
Magisk manager keeps crashing after the new update. Any fix?
[Magisk] VAMGDroidFan:
Got Magisk manager 5.4.0 apk update and now safety net fails. On 5.3.0 there was no issue. Can't revert to 5.3.0 as it says package might be corrupted.

Please help
[Magisk] exodius48:
I've magisk 14.0 installed, but i get notif update magisk manager to 5.4.0 this morning. When i tap instal it does nothing. What should i do?
[Magisk] Anas Rahman:
Magisk manger 5.4.0 wasn't working. Had to revert back to 5.3.0
[Magisk] VAMGDroidFan:
How did you revert to 5.3? I'm getting corrupt package error.
[Magisk] Anas Rahman:
Uninstall the new version and then install v5.3.0 apk
[Magisk] VAMGDroidFan:
Still having CTS error.
[Magisk] Sagar Srivastava:
I have a successfully installed magisk 14.0 from twrp still safety net was showing false so i tried to update through magisk manager but installation keeps on failing for magisk v14.2 now same error with 14.3 it says unable to unpack boot image, any help would be greatly appreciated
[Magisk] St Sinned:
Try to flash it
[Magisk] VAMGDroidFan:
Finally installed universal safety fix module through Magisk and now it's fixed!
[Magisk] 000001a:
updating of the magisk manager never works.

the build in updater loads a broken file.

parsing error.

but it loads afile with icon...

but i cannot install it manuality... still parsing error...
[Magisk] Massyboy:
Where is the universal safety fix module VAMGDroidFan? It's not available in the download section of MM
[Magisk] Sagar Srivastava:
I have installed the universal safety fix still safety net bypass not working , I am using Lenovo k3 note with androium v1.1 custom rom.
[Magisk] VAMGDroidFan:
It's available in Magisk downloads.
[Magisk] Fif_:
Do you have the original Magisk Manager from [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION], or a variant from someone else?

You can always uninstall the Magisk Manager package and install the new one, or flash the full Magisk from recovery.

And if you want your error to be looked at, post log files.
[Magisk] 000001a:
the orginal.

i found out the "update" is the same version as the current.

even the md5 is the same.

i compared the version from orginal xda download and the updatefile from the manager.

why i get a wrong update notification?

why do not work updating working apk files?

after a uninstall & reboot, i was able to install the "broken" apk. the problem is not the apk, it must be somewere the update process...
[Magisk] Massyboy:
Thanks. Got it but still no joy. What device do you have? I'm running a S8 with Renovate ICE ROM
[Magisk] manos78:
Yes. You're right. I use the word "disable" instead of "core mode" because the file is named ".disable_magisk". However, it's true: it forces the Core only Mode.

I know about the modules.

But you pointed in the right direction: the current switch for the Core Mode is the key for remove the ".disable_magisk" file.

Thank you! :highfive:
[Magisk] manshyworld:
Now in the new v 5.4.0(57) Safenet check is failed... Any idea :confused:
[Magisk] lebaud07:
hi,

Updating magisk manager breaks the "SuperUser tab" each time... So have to clean data/cache of the application and add them again each time (nexus 6, official ROM)

Could you please do something to avoid this problem ? (Or maybe add a save/restore mechanism for the list) ?

However, thanks so much for your hard work !
[Magisk] kramer04:
topjohnwu talk about FOSS.

What is FOSS?

If someone can explain that .

Thanks.
[Magisk] woozie.2007:
Full open sources
[Magisk] Lamba92:
It was developer options! Try disabling them and you should be good to go!
[Magisk] Simonex16:
It sais me "impossible to check update.No internet?" So, i have to flash the 14.0 from twrp or simply tap on the apk and install like an update?
[Magisk] Deus.:
Connect to the internet, that's the easiest way.

If you can't, flash the zip file from TWRP, because the apk is just the UI.

Common sense.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
I have not seen anything like that on my Nexus 6... :confused:

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_and_open-source_software
[Magisk] Akshay_1993:
Hi,

I have recently rooted my phone with magisk manager.

After rooting device i found that it is not promiting grant/deny root permission dialog and also it is not showing application in superuser of magisk manager.

Other details :

Phone : Coolpad Note 3

Device : CP8676_I02

OS : Android 5.1

Magisk Manager : 5.3.5

Magisk Root : V14.0

Log :

E/Magisk (22620): select failed with 2: No such file or directory

W/Magisk (22620): su: request rejected (10355->0)

E/Magisk (22644): select failed with 2: No such file or directory

W/Magisk (22644): su: request rejected (10355->0)
[Magisk] theandroidguy:
no
[Magisk] pellajl:
Downloaded MagiskManager-v5.4.0.apk from https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/official-magisk-v7-universal-systemless-t3473445 and it seems to be broken.

The Installer produces the following error: "There was a problem while parsing the package."
[Magisk] Immortal0907:
I cant even download the file. I go to Magisk Manager it notifies me about update , I click install and nothing happens

EDIT

I created folder 'MagiskManager' on my internal storage , it works now.
[Magisk] Aman Dewett:
Hi, I'm on dirty unicorns 7.1.2 and recently I've installed official xposed framework and xposed installed by [MENTION=7212517]rovio[/MENTION]. I'm facing safety net issues. Please check screenshot and tell me how and what to do.

THANK YOU
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
Disable or uninstall Xposed.
[Magisk] Aman Dewett:
Isn't it possible to fi t with xposed?
[Magisk] Simonex16:
i've internet connection,it's magisk that can't detect it.I will try from TWRP.
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
It's not possible to pass SafetyNet with Xposed enabled
[Magisk] Aman Dewett:
Ok, thank you
[Magisk] JimZiii:
The manager says 14.0 is the newest but under changelog in the magisk thread it goes up to 14.3

Are those beta releases or am I just doing something wrong?

And if they're stable, where can I get them, are they worth getting?

Thnx
[Magisk] cookie1953:
Does that include the module in Magisk Downloads -- Xposed Framework (SDK24) 88.1 for Nougat 7.0 for the S8 ??
[Magisk] k0m3n9:
You can try Xposed module "No device check".. just to get ctsProfile = true... at least
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
What happens if you first uninstall the old Manager?

Magisk v14.3 is beta, yes.
[Magisk] asterius:
MTK6580

I want to install systemless root via Magisk to my Homtom Zoji Z6 (Zoji is Rugged Subsidiary of Homtom) .Need to remove bloatware and modify governors. Z6 is a MTK6580 architecture device very similar or even maybe same as Homtom 16 or Homtom 17 except 4.7" display. Phone not rooted, stock boot.img , everything stock except unlocked bootloader. I dont want to brick it , it is a indigenius device that no one can repair in this side of world (Georgia) . Any idea? will it be safe to try it? Any instructions and help will greatly appreciate. Regards.
[Magisk] igoticecream:
Fulmics 6.1 kernel (based on MM) and also Im using a KK bootloader since bumping doesn't bypass the security check on lastest bootloaders (LP and MM). Let me test with OpenBump
[Magisk] Norbix1999:
Not working Xperia M4 Aqua E203 Android 6.0 CE1

if you know any addition quirks about Sony

Please help to fix

boot.img backup TWRP

mediafire.com/download/3urns8d6kq9sjoa/boot.zip
[Magisk] Äptiva:
From what I know unpacking the boot image is what is killing the bump. I'm unaware of whether the bumping process for roms like CM is being done at install or at build time. What I can do is bump a stock LP boot image after doing the magisk touch and upload it with [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] permission of course.
[Magisk] Konsumhaus:
Thx
[Magisk] Äptiva:
If you need assistance with pulling the img and pushing it back to the device, inbox me to avoid clutter as bump is off topic.
[Magisk] Aakash Kaushal:
Can anyone please answer my question?? Thanks
[Magisk] Captain_Throwback:
You likely have a root binary in /system, in which case Magisk can't disable root.

Or if your problem is that you can't enable root, did you install the correct version of phh's Superuser and the app from the Play Store? And then grant Magisk Manager root when prompted?
[Magisk] Eddie_Brock:
The part that's not really explained in the instructions is that after flashing Magisk and PHH in recovery, you have to boot in to system and download the PHH SuperUser app from the Play Store.
[Magisk] Captain_Throwback:
You mean the part in RED below? And the giant link to the app on the Play Store?
[Magisk] Toutatis_:
Hahaha :laugh:
[Magisk] Aakash Kaushal:
Yes i have done everything as said in op....but i am using modified supersu for magisk (chainfire)...also when i open supersu app,it says binary needs to be updated and when i tap on istall,it shows fail error...idk why?
[Magisk] azsde:
I am trying this out on cyanogenmod 13, but I can't disable root, as soon as I turn it off it turns itself back on.

How can I fix this?
[Magisk] Captain_Throwback:
Sounds like when trying to update SuperSU, the location/setup got messed up and that would explain your problem. I'd start over, and use phh's Superuser if possible.
[Magisk] Äptiva:
You have to use adb whle the phone is in recovery to nuke CM's built in su binary. The way I did this was to boot recovery, wipe system cache and dalvik, install CM and gapps, then used "adb shell rm -f /system/xbin/su" (without quotes). I then installed magisk and phh superuser. Worked fine after that.

You don't have to wipe data or anything. Just want a clean system
[Magisk] olivercervera:
Hi,

I installed Magisk and now Android Pay seems to work. Apps that use Safety Net do trust the device when Root is disabled.

However, apps from Barclays (UK bank) are not working, they detect the device as rooted. Maybe they are not using Safety Net? Root is still not disabled for them?

I don't know if there is anything that can be done.
[Magisk] IceAndroid_g2:
This doesn't work on my lg g2 running aospa 6.0.1

I flashed magisk then superuser then xposed and used bump script to fix the boot error.

But it then displays constant boot animation and never fully boots up
[Magisk] Äptiva:
You did wipe cache and dalvik correct?
[Magisk] Captain_Throwback:
"This doesn't work" posts aren't useful.

http://xdaforums.com/android/software/mod-magisk-v1-universal-systemless-t3432382/post68656308
[Magisk] Tipika:
How to install Ota updates on nexus 5x? It was supposed to work, right? When i press update i boot on twrp. I have to reflash the original recovery?

Inviato dal mio Nexus 5X utilizzando Tapatalk
[Magisk] Captain_Throwback:
Yes, OTA updates will only (typically) install with stock recovery. That knowledge is outside the realm of this thread, which is why it isn't mentioned here. It has nothing to do with Magisk.
[Magisk] Aman Dewett:
No
[Magisk] cookie1953:
OK Safety Net still fails for me when I try that Magisk Xposed Module !!
[Magisk] pellajl:
Haven't tried and I don't think it makes any difference.

If you go to the Magisk website and download the app from there, it say the file size is 3.5MB. when you download it, you only receive 2.3MB. Also, if you view the package in something like ES Explorer, you should see the Magisk icon like previous versions. This package you don't indicating the package is corrupt.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Magisk webbsite? :confused: You mean the release thread, right?

I have downloaded the Manager directly from the release thread and installed without any issue...
[Magisk] VAMGDroidFan:
I'm using Redmi note 4 SD with LOS 14.1

---------- Post added at 02:24 PM ---------- Previous post was at 02:21 PM ----------

To solve that error. You need to uninstall current APK and then install older version. It worked for me.
[Magisk] pellajl:
No, when I couldn't install the package I downloaded from the thread, I tried the website mod edit - link removed and result was the same.
[Magisk] operator207:
I did the same thing, tried via the notification, it would just close the notification and do nothing. Tried magiskmanager.com, and it would not download.

I went to this thread, https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/official-magisk-v7-universal-systemless-t3473445

Go down to the download section (the one higher up in the installation section is 5.3) and click on the "Latest Magisk Manager" link which is: https://github.com/topjohnwu/MagiskManager/releases/download/v5.4.0/MagiskManager-v5.4.0.apk

That one is 2.24mb, and installed fine over my 5.3 install. And passes Saftey Check. (N6, PureNexus 7.1.2)

Hope this helps.
[Magisk] Incomtus:
Hello i installed the latest version of manager and now it crashes when i click on the superuser list...why

Asus zenpad 10 with xposed
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
That website that you listed in the quoted post is quite shady
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Here's a thought: do you see that site mentioned anywhere in the release thread? Or have [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] ever mentioned it anywhere? Do you see [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] as being the one responsible anywhere on that website? The answer: no...

Pro tip: Only download from sources provided by [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION].

From what I see, md5 sums match between that website and the release thread/GitHub so there shouldn't be any worries. But who knows...