yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] HippoMan:
Thank you!

Also, I assume that upgrading to 20.3 won't change anything about the ability of my device to recognize the device-encrypted nandroid backups that were made during the time I was at 20.1, correct? I have not disabled encryption via dm-verity.

.​
[Magisk] ktmom:
Magisk doesn't touch encryption.
[Magisk] HippoMan:
Thank you.

So now, it seems that I have a usable path towards downgrading Magisk, if I need to ...

(1) Take a nandroid backup in TWRP (making sure it backs up system, data, and boot).

(2) Upgrade Magisk

(3) If there are failures and I have do downgrade, go into TWRP and restore the nandroid backup to get my older version of Magisk back.

I will use this procedure from now on, given the problems I encountered in the past when downgrading v20.2 back to v20.1 simply by reflashing v20.1.

One last time ... does anyone see any problems with this? The reason I'm checking and double-checking is that I want to have as much confidence as possible that a TWRP upgrade won't leave my device in a state where I can't restore the old Magisk version.

Thanks to all of you for your patience with these postings.

.​
[Magisk] ktmom:
I've used that method for years. But these types of device specific things really are better asked in the device forum where others have your device. What works on my Google phone may/may not work on a OnePlus.
[Magisk] HippoMan:
I will ask. Thank you.

.​
[Magisk] One-ti-teuf:
Heps

7.5.1 just for Android 10 or up? [emoji848][emoji4]

Envoyé de mon HTC U12+ en utilisant Tapatalk
[Magisk] alroy214:
I was asked by [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] to bring the problem on XDA, when I'm in root mode after upgrading to Android 10 on my Galaxy S10, it doesn't let me sign in to my Samsung Account, the phone frequently bugs with notification and popups to sign in and most features like backups are blocked, I can't sign in even if EdXposed turned off and even when I pass safetynet, every time I turn the phone on in root mode there account deactivates and locks untill a in the unrooted mode, what can cause the Samsung Account to even know I'm on root if MagsikHide is on and the safetynet passes?
[Magisk] Wolfcity:
Nope.You can use it on every android device running 4.2+:

Source:

https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/official-magisk-v7-universal-systemless-t3473445/post68966662

As I read here in the thread there has been some issues with the latest magisk version and LG or also HTC devices so maybe wait a bit if you want to update to 20.2.
[Magisk] ktmom:
After setting everything up, hiding the Samsung account app in Magisk, hiding the manager, go to settings -> apps and clear data for samsung account

Lots of tips here
[Magisk] Cedoresti:
a link it`s really fake, explain just nothing. please stop post all link don't help.
[Magisk] alroy214:
As stated already, the link is less useful as it doesn't work on Samsung Android 10, as it's not possible to clear the data from the setting in system apps on Android 10, so I used a root app called Link2SD and it did clear the data and still continues to fall the sign in like before. Can someone explain how to fix the issue if it's not a safetynet issue? I wish I know how Samsung directs root
[Magisk] J.Michael:
what fake link?

I don't understand the reference to a fake link: I followed the link and got a page of advice on how to use Magisk.
[Magisk] chooks06:
The link is not fake. I was able to reach the site.
[Magisk] alroy214:
The link is not "fake" but it's not relevant to Samsung with Android 10 and not related to the link it doesn't solve the issue on hand

---------- Post added at 07:46 AM ---------- Previous post was at 07:39 AM ----------

I'm able to pass safetynet with the help of MagsikHide, MagiskHide Props Config (that should clear the device fingerprint issue) and I'm hiding all the Samsung Apps after hiding cleared all the data of those apps and the Samsung Account still won't sign in

---------- Post added at 07:47 AM ---------- Previous post was at 07:46 AM ----------

I'm able to pass safetynet with the help of MagsikHide, MagiskHide Props Config (that should clear the device fingerprint issue) and I'm hiding all the Samsung Apps after hiding cleared all the data of those apps and the Samsung Account still won't sign in
[Magisk] J.Michael:
I've seen a warning to be sure to remove your Google account before rebooting to download mode. Maybe it's necessary to also remove any Samsung account.
[Magisk] alroy214:
Maybe, but then it yet, the Samsung Account does work on non-rooted mode, so I don't think that's the issue anyway it's not really possible to fix the past as the rooting already has been done.
[Magisk] Cedoresti:
the link just half explain! nothing explain complet, dont explain all settings how...
[Magisk] cnjax:
No reason to be rude when someone tried to assist you. Magisk supports numerous devices therefore it's impossible to document, test, etc specific devices issues. Get some logs and submit them so hopefully your issues can be fixed. Also ask in your device forums where you may get help from others with your device.
[Magisk] Cedoresti:
my friend, the site talking about Edxposed and about blacklist and more, but dont explain concret nothing! what its explain in the site, the xda explain more, for this i writing the site non sense.
[Magisk] zgfg:
The page he gave you the link

https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHide

provides general instructions and tips on hiding root (and fixing eg SafetyNet), it is not limited to EdXposed.

It may not address your particular Samsung problem but you could check its tips, something similar may also apply to your issue (like Clear Data or Detecting apps requiring root sections)
[Magisk] Cedoresti:
trust me, my note 9 work well all! edxposed gpay bancking and pay pal.

Thank Xda.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
If you have suggestions on how to improve the guide I'm always happy to listen. You can either PM me or post in the guide thread here on XDA.
[Magisk] alroy214:
I did as well, then got redirected to the rooting itself, until I got asked to write here, I'm not trying to be rude and I'm grateful for all help, as I try to fallow instructions it could be really helpful to know what logs I should attach and what more information can I give to help, as I do pass safetynet it's something more complex then that.

https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/issues/2180

Also redirecting to the closed but yet to be solved issue where another person having the same problem managed to log more information then I could.

I'll try with more forums on XDA but it could be very helpful to also try and get support here to figure out how to fix the issue that more people won't need to deal with or could have a solid place to see a fix.

---------- Post added at 02:56 PM ---------- Previous post was at 02:54 PM ----------

If you want me to PM to help solve the problem and give more suggestions on how to act and what to do, I'll be happy to do so, I'm still a bit confused and how to help with the process.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
That post wasn't directly aimed at you, but if you (or anyone for that matter) have information that could be useful for me to add to the Troubleshooting guide please do PM me.

About your issue I really think you are better off looking for help in the Samsung forums (since this is a Samsung issue). It doesn't seem like anyone here (so far) has an answer and right now we're just going around in circles...
[Magisk] kgirlx:
LG V30 running stock OREO, US998 version. I updated from 20.1 to 20.2. Only have 3-4 modules installed. I got lucky I guess no bootloop. For info purposes here.
[Magisk] iw2ngg:
Can't hide magisk for app: "Nexi Pay"

Hi all.

This app play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=it.icbpi.mobile can detect magisk even with magiskhide (and with magisk randomized name).

Seems that it ALWAYS can try to request root access...

It's a challenge... :)
[Magisk] fubo73:
I had the same. Hiding is not enough. I'm using a module for proper CTS pass: MagiskHide Props Config. Currently I can use the app with no issues.
[Magisk] iw2ngg:
I already use it: Safetynet tests both are OK.

But... If you can use it, then It is possible...

I'll do further tests ;)
[Magisk] schafi03:
LG G5 H850 no issue to and including Nov 11 build
[Magisk] OhioYJ:
I also had this issue. However, I found you can just remove the 7.5.0 APK, reinstall the 7.4.0 APK (all with 20.2 installed), rename the 7.4.0 APK whatever you want, then choose update in the 7.4.0 APK. It will update to 7.5.0 and keep you current name. No need to downgrade to 20.1 if you dont want to. Just another option.
[Magisk] Zeuszoos:
Hi,

Ignore my question. I got impatient, so I did a NanDroid Backup just in case and then installed the following updates:

Magisk v20.3

Magisk Manager v7.5.1

Device (Phone):

LG V20 (H910A)

Android Nougat 7.0

I installed the Magisk Manager first, then Rebooted, then installed Magisk, then Rebooted again.

All went really well and smoothly and I have Rebooted 3 times with no problem.

TTYL
[Magisk] Badger50:
Gotta love those black hole time loops! ??
[Magisk] ktmom:
[MENTION=4784771]Zeuszoos[/MENTION] you could make life easier for those of us on a device by editing your post and removing the multiple replies [emoji846]
[Magisk] Zeuszoos:
I understand. Like you, I post from my phone and so, "Edit" was the first thing I looked for. The problem is that I don't see any way to do that in Tapatalk Pro.

But I just remembered as I was reading your post that I could do it in my browser, even in a Mobile View.

So I loaded it in my Opera web browser on my phone (typing this in it now) and I edited it down.

I sincerely apologize for the inconvenience.

TTYL
[Magisk] Ralf_AM:
TK-App detects rooted device despite magisk hide

Hi,

Specs:

Magisk v20.3

Magisk Manager v7.5.1

Device (Phone): LeEco LeTV Max 2 (x820)

Android 9 with Custom ROM: MoKee MK90.0-x2-201912151834-Nightly

Problem:

The "TK" app (a german health insurance app) from Google Play Store (https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=de.tk.tkapp&hl=de) can detect magisk even with magiskhide (and with magisk randomized name) or is able to detect that my device is rooted regardless of hiding the app by magisk.

I added 2 screenshots (german) - the 1st is the permission the app asks for and the 2nd shows the warning that my device is rooted and the app therefore cannot be used.

Is it maybe possible to analyze this app (and other health insurence apps) to get it running with future versions of magisk?
[Magisk] Brasscat82:
Always loved Magisk, but I just updated to M20.3 with the latest 7.5.1 Mm, and I can't install modules (doesn't seem to matter which one). I had this problem with 20.2 but a reflash of M20.2 TWRP seemed to fix it. Not this time.

Device: SM-G900T (KLTE)

ROM: Official LOS 9 (P)

TWRP: Up to date

If there's no known issue or fix, please consider this a bug report.
[Magisk] ktmom:
There are many ways an app can decide your device is rooted. Not all of them include actually "seeing" root. It can be inferred because of apps you have installed - think TiBu or root explorer. It can be because of some folder associated with rooted devices - think TWRP. It can be because of modules or other mods in the device.

For a comprehensive discussion, look at https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHideHidingRoot

BTW, if you hide Magisk or the manager after the app has already "seen" them, then you have to clear the app's cache and maybe data to make the app forget.
[Magisk] curiousrom:
Tapatalk - How To Edit XDA Posts

Thanks for editing & deleting your multiple merged duplicate posts above. :good:

I was also baffled the first time I wanted to edit an XDA post in Tapatalk Pro v8.6.0.

The trick is as shown in the attached screenshot:

Navigate to the post you want to edit.

Hit the Moderate button in the bottom of the post.

If you are not a Moderator the only choice will be Edit.

Edit your post!

***
[Magisk] Soumy1234:
I have a minor issue with granting su permission with Biometrics. Ever since I update to Magisk 20.1 or 20.2, the pop up that comes with granting su has turned into the original grant/deny pop up. After I hit grant, then the fingerprint Icon shows to give the permission with Biometrics. Before, I could just give my fingerprint to grant. Toggling Biometrics option doesn't work. Currently using Magisk 20.3 with Magisk Manager 7.5.1 hidden. I'm not sure how to log this so I apologise for not providing logs.
[Magisk] JudgeDread11:
First of all, this is not the Android pay thread.

Second there will never ever be a permanent solution fit getting around safety net with root and/or xposed. It will always be poached and new workarounds have to be found. Until push Google to the limit where they make it so secure we can't find any workarounds anymore.
[Magisk] zakijesk:
is there a way to change the path where the binaries are stored ?

maybe then v86.5 will work with Magisk
[Magisk] grep_i:
86.5 already works with Magisk in fact it only works with Magisk
[Magisk] Mibutastic:
Magisk is amazing. Thank you so much for creating this. I initially stumbled upon this so I could play pokemon go again but it has since been able to give me access to Android pay which I had been dying to use. So thank you so much.
[Magisk] killbox.kb:
Need help plz

Hi all,

I am having samsung galaxy s4 I9500 and i want to install magisk + phh superuser.

I tried the method stated in the first post. Now i am having error while flashing Phh superuser Magisk version. It shows error while flashing as Magisk not installed.

These are the steps I followed.

*Fully unrooted Superuser using app

*Flashed Magisk V6 using TWRP

*Flashed Phh superuser Magisk Versionusing TWRP

** Error : Magisk Not installed

What is that i am missing?

Even i installed Magisk manager and its showing Not rooted and Se linux Enforcing.

Plz Help Guys

Thank You
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Most likely you're looking at the wrong error. My guess is that your boot image isn't currently supported and that you get an error while flashing Magisk.

A recovery log is a good thing to provide if you want help debugging problems with flashing.
[Magisk] DDHBanger:
Followed the install process but I'm not getting the option to toggle on the Magisk Manager app. Any ideas?

Edit. Think I'll wait for the update and see if that fixes it.
[Magisk] DrakeLyon:
Anyone know if Magisk can be used on the Verizon Galaxy S7 (G930V) with the latest update (PH1)?
[Magisk] Tkkg1994:
We started a seperate samsung discussion here with compatibility list

http://xdaforums.com/showthread.php?t=3467229

Test and report so we can add it

Sent from my SuperMan powered SM-G930F
[Magisk] zakijesk:
i mean passing safety net check for xposed
[Magisk] Tkbf:
I have tried to make a back in TWRP, no problem here.
[Magisk] grep_i:
Are you on stock or custom rom ?

What version of TWRP are you on ?

What is your device and model ?

A couple of simple questions you could have provided answers for by posting your question.

I guess if you can not provide this simple information or logfiles or a better more specific case with version numbers of all used software and hardware it will stay like this that people are passing your post just by.
[Magisk] crackers8199:
I answered all of those questions except for twrp version in my original post, but here goes...

nexus 6, stock 6.0.1 latest security update (MOB31E), twrp 3.0.2.0

also, would be happy to provide log files if someone would tell me what ones to provide...
[Magisk] topjohnwu:
It seems that the application is now finally functioning well with no issues :D:D

Magisk Manager is a pain to develop since nearly all data and UI are asynchronous....

I'll have to make sure the upgrade process works seamlessly, and also make sure the new SuperSU auto adaptation is functioning as expected.

Once these trivial things are done, I'll get the threads loaded and release the goodies!
[Magisk] grep_i:
I don't know for sure but I would guess recovery.log or logcat can provide more information.

Surely this is a strange issue as the problem seems not to be related to the software being installed in this case Magisk.

I would advice you to clean flash the rom and see if twrp backup does work than.

If so flash your Magisk setup and try again.
[Magisk] KyeWalker:
I'm waiting patiently bro, maybe you could add a guide on how people can get your gear working on custom ROMs too. Or someone could do that for you. For me I have no PC at the moment otherwise I would have done it.

Just to clarify, magisk, Systemless Xposed and phh's superuser is working on my S4mini LTE running latest CM13 Snapshot and I pass Safety Net. Android Pay and Pokémon Go are working :D

Thanks ks for everything you've done and doing my friend
[Magisk] rignfool:
What partitions are you backing up...

My assumption would be since the Magisk.img is an unknown to TWRP... My guess is that it would skip over it thinking it was data for something else... Try this... Using twrp file manager... Copy the Magisk.img to your sdcard and then copy it back...

Or are we talking about how the boot.img isn't backing up properly? That would make no sense since dd is just a 1 for 1 copy...

The only other thought could be, that the Magisk.img has some kind of unique identifier that will make it only work on a specific install... Like how substratum uses your imei when making the overlays to combat priacy
[Magisk] putridfoetus:
Except the magisk image isn't mounted in recovery. It's just a file in user data. I did a backup of my data partition to usb-otg and it worked without issue on my N6. Haven't tried a full nandroid or anything...
[Magisk] rignfool:
Yes... But the Magisk.img resides in data and therefore should be backed up no?

I'm not sure how twrp handles a data backup...
[Magisk] ammar18:
I have the same phone with the same problem.

Its because the boot image is not compatible with magisk, try another rom or kernel (haven't test kernel), probably CM based roms.
[Magisk] curiousrom:
How To Add Logs To Your Bug Report or Magisk Problem Post

Check the excellent Magisk and MagiskHide Installation and Troubleshooting guide by [MENTION=4667597]Didgeridoohan[/MENTION] >>> Asking for help/reporting bugs

***
[Magisk] alfistoun:
Magisk is not installed after kernel update

My Magisk manager showing me, that Magisk itself is not installed, but before kernel update it was.

What should I do, any suggestions?

Can I just flash Magisk again?:confused:
[Magisk] LATINORAMON:
20.3 with 7.5.1 after 20.1 and 7.5.0 works again with S8 Android 9. Big THX.
[Magisk] grushnickij:
As the kernel is in boot.img, which is also used by magisk, a kernel update will remove magisk.

Just reflash magisk and you're good.
[Magisk] guest4711:
Yes, you should do so.
[Magisk] Jack_Sparrow_:
Anyone else had this after 20.3 update? Any fix?

Thank you!!!
[Magisk] eddietiong:
Hi.. my mi mix2s is 6gb version and I fail to root it using magisk manager app and also by twrp.

Currently installed miui 11 global stable version

Need help and advice!

Thanks
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
That's actually how the new biometrics API works, so it's not a bug. You'll just have to live with it.

Usually fixed by toggling MagiskHide off and on.

If by failing to root you mean that the device doesn't boot after trying to install Magisk, that seems to be a known issue with MIUI 11 (and some other setups):

https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/issues/2133

There currently doesn't seem to be any fix... But, it is possible that you might have some luck with older releases until it has been fixed.

If that's not what you mean you'll have to be a lot more detailed in your post:

https://didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHelp
[Magisk] virag2009:
Direct update magisk 20.1 to 20.3 works well and without problems on Galaxy S7 g930f with galaxy project rom.
[Magisk] cnjax:
Direct install to 20.3 on my LG-H910 V20 no issues, working well.
[Magisk] Ch3vr0n:
20.3 works fine here. No safety net issues
[Magisk] schafi03:
For me, the app works 20.1, 20.2 and 20.3

LG G7 G710EM

---------- Post added at 05:59 PM ---------- Previous post was at 05:55 PM ----------

No issue since 20.1 to 20.3, for me.

LG G7 G710EM
[Magisk] tremalnaik:
V20.3 installs correctly on LG G5 (H850), where v20.2 bricked the phone to fastboot mode. Thanks for the great work!
[Magisk] Halim61:
After update to the new magisk canary, the module list is empty why? Any help? On my s10
[Magisk] Wolfcity:
This question may be better asked here:

https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/dev-magisk-canary-channel-bleeding-edge-t3839337/page266

Also logs and steps of installation should be provided.
[Magisk] tom1807:
Not necessarily Magisk detection, my Citibank app recognizes that the USB debugging is enabled and refuse then to start. As soon as I disable it, no problems. Magisk/Root is not detected by the app

Cheers

Tom
[Magisk] feretio:
I figured out why my phone would only boot to TWRP recovery. I suppose it would help if I used the correct fastboot command. I apparently was running "fastboot flash boot twrp-xxx.img" rather than "fastboot flash recover twrp-xxx.img". That would be a duh (or DOH!).

Once I got the latest TWRP 3.3.1 recovery image installed on my LG V20 US996, I flashed Magisk-20.3.zip from it and it seems to work swimmingly.

I also was able to successfully install it on my Samsung Note 3 running Lineage and my Huawei Mediapad M3.
[Magisk] warrencoakley:
Latest Canary Build 20.4 is showing a black screen in modules. Unable to see them. [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION]
[Magisk] martyfender:
I have a similar issue. What is your device and Android version?

It may be related to this:

https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/issues/2182

Unfortunately the issue was closed because my logcat doesn't start early enough in the boot process for proper diagnose.