yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] zgfg:
I think there is a misunderstanding, but we both point to the same:

- In case of having a bootloop with a modulem (and if there is no TWRP to disable/uninstall module(s)), boot Android to safe mode and back to normal mode

- It should boot then correctly because modules are disabled, and you can then manage (keep disabled, re-enable, update, unibstall) all midules through Magisk Manager

Btw, I've tested that, so writing exactly how it worked
[Magisk] zgfg:
Once it installs that patched.apk, it deletes the old folders related to the old, not scrambled package names

Sorrry, I don't.get to which apk 7.4.1 version name are you referring.

What I tested and described yesterday was all (started with) the latest Canary, MM build 305 and Magisk build 21001 - pls see the screenshot (these build numbers are how we usually refer to the particular Canary version)
[Magisk] HippoMan:
v21.x working similarly to v20.4 for Android 10?

Please forgive me if this has been answered recently and if I might have overlooked it.

I am running Android 10 (OnePlus 7Pro, OOS 10.3.5) with Magisk 20.4 and MagiskManager 8.0.1 (304) (11).

If I upgrade to the latest Magisk 21.x version, would I then have to patch boot, or be unable to flash TWRP, or anything like that?

... or do these kinds of things only apply to Android 11?

In other words, on my device and with my OS, will Magisk 21.x work more or less the same as version 20.4 with regard to TWRP, the boot partition, etc.?

Thank you very much.

.​
[Magisk] Incognito777:
Yes, sir, I have the hidden core Xposed module installed, thanks a ton for your reply, what would we have done without Magisk? Didgeridoohan amazing job, kudos! :good:
[Magisk] m0han:
had magisk manager v7.5.1, magisk stable v20.4, colt os v6.4 (smokey) android 10 on device x00td. had to dirty flash rom; chose magisk manager v8.0.1, magisk (beta) v21.0. device booted and running fine with data intact.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
In that case I completely misunderstood your other post. :good:
[Magisk] andrea0807:
hi, when i try to hide magisk manager by reinstalling magisk manager with random package and app name, the application says: magisk manager could not be hidden. I tried both the canary version and the latest beta version. I have a poco F2 Pro with Rom xiaomi.eu weekly (Android 11)

Inviato dal mio lmi utilizzando Tapatalk
[Magisk] sabei:
I think I am similar to [MENTION=1364858]sdeft[/MENTION]

I installed Magisk 20.4 on a Redmi Note 8 running Miui Global 11.0.9.0 via TWRP. I have recently moved to AEX 7.3 (based on 10 I believe) and reinstalled Magisk via TWRP again. It was only when Magisk Manager updated to 8.0 that I see, or noticed, Ramdisk - No

It is now asking me to update to 8.0..1

Can you just clarify for me is there likely to be any issue on me just staying with 20.4 as it works (for me) - unless I decide to move to Android 11? Any likely issue if I disable access to the Internet in AF Wall for Manager?

Thanks
[Magisk] zgfg:
Check, do you have Install over USB option in Developers menu (or elswhere) and enable - it is needed on some phones (MIUI) for pm install command as used by MM when repackaging

Otherwise, see the manual workaround:

https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=83653761&postcount=41904
[Magisk] dope77:
Latest manager (306) isn't working properly, it's saying I'm not connected to internet (i have internet connection).
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
[MENTION=7786725]zgfg[/MENTION] [MENTION=1364858]sdeft[/MENTION] [MENTION=10945125]sabei[/MENTION]

John replied to a similar query regarding ramdisk here:

https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/issues/3239
[Magisk] sabei:
Thanks.

So that suggests that the answer to my question may be that if it ain't broke, no need to fix/upgrade it?
[Magisk] Mr.Jay:
Hey guys today I installed Lineage OS and I'm trying to get rid of the outdated UI sounds that comes with it. In order to do that I always used a module that replaces stock android UI sounds with the Pixel ones, it always worked like a charm in all phones I had, but this time nothing happens... I'm thinking this may be due to the newer Magisk update? In that case how can I update de module to work properly, because looks like who created the module has dropped it and no more updates are coming ever so I decided to take things on my own but I have no clue on where I supposed to start...

I have attached the module in case someone knows what could be happening in this case
[Magisk] J.Michael:
What do you expect? When you used the module in the past, did it instantly change the noises made by the phone? Or do you then have to go through the settings changing sound choices, but you now have more choices?

Without this module, capture the names of files under /system/media/audio. Compare to names in module. And compare to names in an OS in which the module worked.
[Magisk] Mr.Jay:
Previous times after install the module and rebooting changed the sounds without touching anything but now it doesn't even appears at installed on the magisk app it's very weird [emoji848]

I'll take a look into it, thanks for the tip!! [emoji1362]

Enviado desde mi Mi 9T mediante Tapatalk
[Magisk] Superwitschi:
Does somone get it to work on Miui device (Mi 10)?

Superwitschi Designs
[Magisk] HippoMan:
Thank you! After reading this, I went to the Magisk beta channel and installed 21.0. There are no problems with my Android 10 setup.

.​
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Pretty much. There are going to be cases where the info on the Manager is "wrong", simply because the Android echo system is so diverse.

What does the install log say? If I'd guess, it's because the installer used is too old (it's for Magisk v17). You likely need to update it, which should just be a matter of replacing the update-binary with the current installer script. You can also remove the common directory (and the files within) and the config.sh file. They're redundant.
[Magisk] zgfg:
Why not, MIUI 10, 11, 12.

You can always search in the thread for e.g. MIUI
[Magisk] Xanatos2:
Installed modules?

Hi everybody, how can I see in the new version my installed modules? Are on the top? Are green? Thnx ;)
[Magisk] zgfg:
Here you go

Seems like you have none - do yo have any in /data/adb/modules?
[Magisk] kiwigi:
Magisk 20.4-MM8.0-TWRP

Hi All

I hope you don't mind me asking if I can flash TWRP onto my Samsung s7 sm g930 F(d) stock, rooted with the above Magisk setup, as I would like to create a full nandroid backup? Just thinking ahead to the new Magisk release.

It would be really nice!!!
[Magisk] Xanatos2:
OK, I didn't remember if I had one or not. Thank you!
[Magisk] HippoMan:
I'm running Android 10 (OOS 10.3.5) on my OnePlus 7Pro (GM-1917) with Magisk 21.0 and MagiskManager 8.0.1. I have renamed/repackaged MagiskManager, and SafetyNet is shown as passing in MagiskManager and also via another 3rd-party SafetyNet checker. And the RootBeer app says that the device is not rooted.

However, my banking app -- for Chase Bank -- still thinks that I am rooted, even though it is listed in the MagiskHide list.

Has anyone gotten this specific banking app to stop detecting root in this kind of Magisk environment? If so, could you describe your setup (Magisk modules, etc.) and anything you might have had to do in order to get this particular app to stop seeing root?

PS: I had the same problem with Magisk 20.4 and the latest 7.x.x version of MagiskManager. Also, I am running TaiChi, but I had the same problem when running EdXposed, instead.

Thank you very much in advance.

.​
[Magisk] ultimatepichu:
I had the same problem, where my bank app detects root even it is hidden in Magisk. The bank app is DKB (Germany).

Solution is to use Magisk Canary. I'm not sure what the difference are between Canary vs Stable/beta, but it works with Canary.

Give it a try. Hope it helps.
[Magisk] sergemerge:
https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/chase-app-detects-root-t4099627
[Magisk] HippoMan:
Thank you. Unfortunately, no one in that thread has solved this problem. But now I am subscribed there and will know if any solutions appear.

.​
[Magisk] PoochyX:
That's how it usually happens.....

([emoji88]Omni Rom[emoji88])
[Magisk] HippoMan:
Thank you very much. I upgraded to Canary, but sadly, it didn't solve the problem with Chase. But I will keep checking the thread about this subject that I was referred to a little while ago. Maybe somone there will eventually come up with a solution.

.​
[Magisk] meiser:
Hi,

I installed this Magisk module to enable 48MP for Gcam.

As soon as this module is active, the DKB PushTAN app doesn't work anymore as the system is "modified".

Does anyone of you have an idea how to modify the module to get 48MP and let the DKB app working?
[MENTION=6792776]eszdman[/MENTION], are you maybe aware of this issue?

Thanks,

meiser
[Magisk] AndDiSa:
[MENTION=3150073]meiser[/MENTION] I am on a Pixel 3a and I never got DKB Tan2Go running on my device. Play Store is certified, SafetyNet is passing, App is added to Magisk-Hide ... nevertheless DKB detects root permissions. What did you do to get it running?
[Magisk] meiser:
It works since I switched to the canary build. But I think, it should also work with v21 beta. Did you disable all screenreaders to check if the app doesn't like one of these? Did you repackage the Manager app? I use the name "Assistant".
[Magisk] PoochyX:
Canary is unstable tho

([emoji88]Omni Rom[emoji88])
[Magisk] Philnicolls89:
Not necessarily 'unstable', just not quite worthy of a public release. There are a lot of creases to iron out before a build can be pushed to 'stable'. Even if the canary will work for 99% of users.

*edit*

I am in this case, talking specifically about magisk v.21 not canary builds in general:)
[Magisk] zgfg:
If you better like Stable label, just released today:

Magisk Manager v8.0.2 (307)

Magisk 20400

Edit: Actually, just new Stable Magisk Manager for now
[Magisk] asv711:
I'm on Redmi K20/ Mi 9T (davinci) running Pixel Experience and when I have kept magisk hide for Digilocker app yet it is able to find out that my phone is rooted....how do I fix the issue?
[Magisk] AndDiSa:
Thank you very much, renaming the Magisk Manager was the secret ... ;)
[Magisk] mielletseed:
On my old Samsung Galaxy Note 10.1 (2014 edition) running Android 5.1.1 TouchWiz the Magisk 21 dosn't work. I can't see installed modules, protocols, apps with root grant - even with the newest Magisk Manger 8.0.2.

Magisk 20.4 and the Magisk Manager 8.0.x is runnig smooth.

Any ideas how to fix that?
[Magisk] Spartacus500:
For me, Samsung S7 E Custom Pie 9.0 works. Try it, if you have the Digilocker application installed then remove it, download it from the play store, attention! Don't run it yet! Enter magisk manager and Hide Digilocker for root. Now it should work without root information :highfive:
[Magisk] asv711:
Tried your method.....but it worked for sometime.....when I tried logging in it quit the app and gave the rooted device error message
[Magisk] yuri76:
How can I use goo

Inviato dal mio SM-G975F utilizzando Tapatalk
[Magisk] chooks06:
You may want to check TWRP site and see if there's a "official" recovery for your device (I believe there should be). Make sure you get the correct version. They're device/variant specific.

Alternatively, there could be "unofficial" versions.

Just need to make sure you are very sure with the instructions regarding installation of TWRP.

Have a stock ROM on hand in case you run into problems so that you can recovery back to stock and start again.

Hope this helps.
[Magisk] Spartacus500:
This method works for me. Try stopping the Digilocker application and clearing the cache.
[Magisk] asv711:
It won't let me open the app now....same error message is popping up?
[Magisk] sidamos77:
I updated an older canary version to the newest on my Redmi Note 5 Pro with Pixel Experience Android 9.0 ROM.

The update of the manager did not work, so I uninstalled it and downloaded and installed the newest canary manager 307.

But I cannot hide the manager with this version. It creates the stub app without error. When I start the stub, there is an opening app animation but the app does not start.

Tried this several times (uninstall/reinstall/hide). Even disabling Play Protect did not help. USB debugging is on and verify apps over USB is on.

So, I installed the latest stable manager 7.5.1, hide it successfully, upgraded to Canary manager and it is still hidden.

So, hiding the manager still has problems with the newest canary manager.
[Magisk] zgfg:
Posted yesterday:
[Magisk] sidamos77:
I checked that, but since I do not run MIUI, I do not have this option. I just have the option "Verify apps over USB" and this is enabled.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Newest Canary Manager is 308, so I think that's what you're talking about (I've seen the same thing).

It's a bug. There's already a PR. Now just to wait for John to get it sorted.
[Magisk] sidamos77:
Thanks for the info about the bug.
[Magisk] sidamos77:
Deleted.
[Magisk] zgfg:
On Xiaomi phones it is very simple, Install over USB must be enabled in Developer options
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
But doesn't that just cause the repackaging to fail outright (and is only for MIUI)? With this issue (that I'm talking about) the stub gets installed (as described by [MENTION=4942571]sidamos77[/MENTION]), but it can't download the Manager files on first opening the app since there's a typo in the url.
[Magisk] dope77:
Hello?! Can somebody help me. Tried clearing data, resintalling but still same issue. After the latest manager update it's not getting any internet connection even when i have internet
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
You don't have a firewall or something that could be blocking it?
[Magisk] zgfg:
Ok, I see - he said he has created the stub, that's then a different issue

Nevertheless, it would be good to add about Install over USB to the Guide
[Magisk] J.Michael:
I would think that you would want "Verify apps over USB" DISabled.

---------- Post added at 12:03 ---------- Previous post was at 11:57 ----------

Is this after stopping the app and clearing its cache?
[Magisk] dope77:
I have afwall installed but the manager is allowed to access internet, also it's been working properly for over a year. It just stopped working after updating the manager yesterday (also tried disabling afwall but still same issue)
[Magisk] zgfg:
Indeed, with Canary Magisk Manager 308, I can no more hide/repackage Magisk Manager no matter how I enable/disable Install over USB and/or Verify apps over USB.

Also, enabling Install from unknown source for the Manager and later stub, does not help.

Disabling Play Protect also does not help

It only installs the stub, showing its icon on the Home screen.

Stub (under the renamed Magisk Manager's name) can be only opened with black window in the background - cannot be brought to foreground, as on the screenshot

Problem is in typo (log rom [MENTION=6345368]Displax[/MENTION]*in the GitHub ticket), Canary looks for inexistent canary/release.json:

https://raw.githubusercontent.com/topjohnwu/magisk_files/canary/release.json

Instead, it should look for canary/debug.json
[Magisk] kiwigi:
@ chooks06

Many thanks, very much appreciated. :)

I will head over to TWRP
[Magisk] yuri76:
Does someone work google pay?

Inviato dal mio SM-G975F utilizzando Tapatalk
[Magisk] zgfg:
Canary Magisk Manager 308, with Canary Magisk 21002, but with Update channel set to Stable, can be hidden/repackaged (I had: Play Protect On, Install via USB On).

As a result, hidden Manager dropped to 307 Beta, but it was repackaged!

Ofc, upon repackaging, Magisk remains 21002 and I can change Update channel to Beta

2) Similarly, Magisk Manager 307 Beta, with Update channel set to Stable (but not to Beta), can be repackaged/hidden
[Magisk] chooks06:
You're welcome mate!
[Magisk] eszdman:
Modify dkb app.

Or remove build prop modifiers from module

Or check safetyNet.
[Magisk] Thamilan:
Im using miui android 10 the magisk hide magisk manager(repackage magisk model not working) how can i fix it?.
[Magisk] zgfg:
1)What is your phone (maybe Xiaomi with MIUI)?

2)At which step does it fail, with the message "Hiding MM failed" and with not even creating the new stub app, or it creates the stub (default Android icon, name you gave it) but you cannot open the stub?

3)On which Update channel are you, what are your Magisk Manager and Magisk versions/build numbers?

If on Xiaomi - question (1) , see this (although, it has been posted in this thread as well) - you need to enable "Install via USB" in Developrs menu.

https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/issues/3304

Same ticket will also help you for (3), if you are on Beta channel - you need to switch the channel to Stable (but keep MM and Magisk as they are on Beta)

See also:

https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=83666887&postcount=41987
[Magisk] njtony:
Magiskhide can’t check Google Services Framework, check it, return or restart, it will become unchecked. Is this my problem or magisk’s problem?

magisk manager v8.0.2, magisk v21
[Magisk] garylawwd:
Clear data for Google services framework and try again
[Magisk] njtony:
Magisk has been reinstalled, and gsf has been cleared. After checking it, it returns to the unchecked state. Android 10 is normal. I just found this problem after upgrading to 11.
[Magisk] Superwitschi:
Can somone explain that?

Superwitschi Designs
[Magisk] garylawwd:
What do you need to hide it for anyway?
[Magisk] njtony:
Google services framework，In China Google feed can only be used when Google services framework is hidden.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
I see the same thing, but it looks purely cosmetical. The Framework still seems to be on the Hide list, even though it's unchecked (note the coloured bar above the list entry, and if you expand it both components are active). You should also be able to see that it's added to the list and that MagiskHide is reacting to it.

It simply means that you cannot mount the system partitions read-write. They are permanently read-only. Magisk and systemless modifications to the rescue.
[Magisk] njtony:
It seems that Framework is not hidden. Whether it is checked or not, after re-entering magiskhide, it is unchecked. When opening google feed, it is blank or the account error is displayed (not available in China), but the Framework is checked in magiskhide, Then press the home button to return to the desktop, then the google feed is normal, so it feels that magisk does not really hide the Framework.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
I checked again, and it seems like it does not add the main process (com.google.android.gsf). No idea if that's a bug or intended... I'll bring it up with [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION].
[Magisk] njtony:
This seems to be a problem with magisk, thank you brother。
[Magisk] Superwitschi:
So i can't do anything against it?
[Magisk] H113408:
Hi All,

I'm trying to update Magisk using the command line instead of Magisk Manager. I use the util_functions.sh script with the Magisk.zip archive.

Basically the steps are:

1.Unzip the magisk archive somewhere on the phone

2.flatten all the files : mv arm/* common/* META-INF/com/google/android/update-binary .

3. replace magiskinit with 64 version

4.source the utils script

5.call get_flags to populate $RECOVERYMODE, $KEEPFORCEENCRYPT and $KEEPVERITY

6.override MAGISKBIN with the location where I'm working

7.popupate $BOOTIMAGE with the location of the boot image

8.call install_magisk

It all works well, the new-boot.img is pathced and flashed. I reboot the phone but then I get stuck on the Samsung Logo. While on the samsung logo I'm able to access the phone through ADB. I can see that the issue is the phone is not able to decrypt the /data folder (all the directories are still encrypted) this explains why the phone is stuck on the logo.

If I factory reset, the phone boots just fine and the update works well. But I would prefer if I can remove the encryption all together, or find a way to make it work with the encryption in place.

I know what I'm asking is possible because Magisk Manager is able to update Magisk without me having to factory reset.

Does anyone know either how to disable encryption before starting the update process OR how to make it work like on Magisk Manager ?

Thanks in advance
[Magisk] Lughnasadh:
The same thing is happening to me but with a different app (Spectrum TV). Checkbox keeps getting unticked but expanding it shows it's enabled and there is a colored bar showing above the app, so it looks purely cosmetical for this as well.

However, another app I have hidden is showing correctly (check mark still in place), so it may be affecting some apps but not others.

EDIT: Using Stable Manager 8.0.2 (307) and Beta Magisk 21.0 (21000) on Pixel 4 XL.
[Magisk] HippoMan:
In case anyone is interested, I posted a workaround here (as well as an opinionated rant):

https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=83667431&postcount=59

.​
[Magisk] J.Michael:
What is the value of KEEPFORCEENCRYPT?
[Magisk] H113408:
KEEPFORCEENCRYPT is true. Anyway to remove that ?
[Magisk] J.Michael:
Edit get_flags. (I assume it's defined in the .sh file you mentioned.)

Or, after calling get_flags,

KEEPFORCEENCRYPT=0

.
[Magisk] H113408:
I should have mentionned that. But I already tried with the combination KEEPVERITY and KEEPFORCEENCRYPT =false without success. Maybe it's worth mentioning that the magisk version installed on the phone has KEEPVERITY and KEEPFORCEENCRYPT =true (that's from where get_flags bring its values)

I think the key is to remove encryption from the current boot.img before trying to patch it with the new version of magisk.zip

I saw a chapter on the guide of didgeridoohan about disabling FORCEENCRYPT, but not sure how to use that ?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
After you've disabled forced encryption (KEEPFORCEENCRYPT=false) you have to format /data as well, otherwise it'll still be encrypted.

If you wonder how the Manager does it, you can find all of that in the code on GitHub.
[Magisk] H113408:
I went through the code, that's what got me where I am now (the steps mentioned on the first post). It would be great if you can point me to this last step :D
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
I have no idea... I've never had a reason to dig into that code.
[Magisk] monicaONxda:
I don't understand: why should I use Busybox NDK instead of the normal Busybox and why should I hide it ?

Do you know how I can use Busybox to do a full phone backup (incl. Magisk, apps, system apps and all app settings) or another app?

I have a Samsung Galaxy Note10+...
[Magisk] DiamondJohn:
I am with you 100%, and my custom ringtone is siting in a path on my external SD card. However, a reason to place / force / change your "default" system ringtone, is for when your MediaDB gets damaged and/or cleared. When that happens, it defaults back to the default ringtone, sitting on your system partition.

As I said, I have my ringtone on my external sd card, and my fix s to have a boot script that checks and corrects the selected ringtone on every boot.
[Magisk] zgfg:
Consider a banking app or similar, looking for the root. If it finds BusyBox, it cocludes that phone is rooted.

If you use BusyBox as a module, Magisk Hide will help to hide it

BusyBox for backup, maybe if you make scripts , idk
[Magisk] Nightf0x_007:
Help needed here, dont know if it is related or not

My huawei mate 10 lite android oreo rooted magisk 20.4 and 21.0 was running fine until today suddenly opening some apps like chrome truecaller telegram viber crashes the phone while kiwi whatsapp facebook & messenger is working, in the non working apps the ui work and suddenly freezes the device screen and reboots the phone, on magisk logcat there is a line crash beginning for gms.unstable (something like that)

So i tried disabling & uninstalling all modules, disable magiskhide, updating gms & web systemview and still

I know it might not be related to magisk but dont know where to post for help as the mate 10 lite forum is dead

TIA