yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] milesian:
Congrats to you, but no luck here on my stock Samsung 910T kernel. Whereas the v9 manager log at least it told me "Magisk Hide Error," the v10 log only says "Starting Magisk Hide," and that's the last line. Sigh... so close.
[Magisk] Apexpredator12:
I have magisk V6 installed, have tried installing newer versions in thr past but it bricks my phone. To update to newest magisk could someone give me a guide on what I have to do to get from v6 to v10, just not sure if I'm doing something wrong.

If I try to install from manager I just get "installation error"

In the past I was trying to update to v8, I uninstalled v6 and installed v8 but my phone would just brick,
[Magisk] broomer68:
Somewhere in these 1000 messages, (I believe in the first already) is stated that Samsung does not work out of the box.

Verstuurd vanaf mijn ONEPLUS A3003 met Tapatalk
[Magisk] android_htc:
It will pass for you as well.. not sure what the issue is... I tried installing everything again and ended up with SafetyNet fail. I eventually passed SafetyNet again after uninstalling Magisk Manager and reinstalling it again!
[Magisk] Apexpredator12:
I'm not 100% sure what you mean
[Magisk] darkeyes22:
Sorry for being undetailed, what I mean, is if I flash a custom Rom that has Android Nougat, will multirom feature work for my device, or I will have to wait for a Rom to be developed for my device separately? Thanks in advance! ☺
[Magisk] mobileman88:
I still have out of date binary, seems some apps have root access and some apps don't. Titanium backup is one of those that don't despite several reboots which used to fix it in V9.
[Magisk] Biz92k:
Same here on Moto g 2013, v9 works good, v10 gives installation error from the magisk manager 3 and error 1 from TWRP... What's wrong?
[Magisk] wcoast:
Something to do with patching kernel but not sure, hopefully the log I posted may help

Sent from my SM-N930T
[Magisk] Oki:
Magisk v10 continue FAILING in the ZTE Axon 7. The symptoms are no root and Magisk Manager doesn't detect the ZIP was already installed in the boot partition.

The issue was reported for Magisk V9 and V10 beta, but still present in V10 official.

Regarding my device, it is a ZTE Axon 7 submodel A2017U using the latest Stock ROM B29 with Android M. By the way the Axon 7 rocks!!! amazing screen, sound, processor, battery, looks, and more than 152K points in Antutu.

The ROM used in this test is stock B29, the latest OTA available. Magisk Manager 3 and phh Superuser 1.03.3 apps were previously installed. I followed these steps to create the dump files:

1. I dumped before.boot.img from TWRP and the corresponding before.logcat.txt after rebooting into the system.

2. I went to TWRP and flashed Magisk v9 and phh Superuser for Magisk r266-2 in the same session. Recovery.log is also attached.

3. I rebooted directly to TWRP again and made a dump of the boot image, called after.boot.img. Then I rebooted the system and dumped after.logcat.txt.

4. After testing that Magisk is not working and the system was not rooted, I rebooted into recovery to dump magisk.log, but there was no Magisk log file inside /cache.

The dumped files can be downloaded from this MEGA shared folder. I hope these files could provide some insight on the problem in this device. Same issue when using Magisk v7 and V10-161227. And when using phh Superuser for Magisk r266. I have tested all combinations.

By the way, thanks for all!!! I hope this could work also in this device.

Thanks
[Magisk] Darke5tShad0w:
V10 Working Fine here on Nexus 5X Marshmallow
[Magisk] Artim_96:
Suhide will give you always a bootloop when you have Android 6/7.x with november patch. Furthermore, suhide wasn't updated for a very long time so it probably won't work anyway

---------- Post added at 02:37 AM ---------- Previous post was at 02:30 AM ----------

Oh great...and SPen command can't detect the SPen when it's enforcing... Thankfully I don't really have any app that fails cause of SN
[Magisk] jhedfors:
Wrong thread.
[Magisk] quorn23:
topjohnwu just updated to 10.1 and still get the out of date message fyi.

edit: Scratch that, after another reboot no message anymore
[Magisk] dimm0k:
so apparently when you flash Magisk for the first time it makes a backup of your boot.img, however I mistakenly flashed Magisk twice (late, wasn't paying attention)... does that mean the backup of the boot.img is no longer pure?
[Magisk] Crayvolt:
unable to detect boot image Error how to fix pls
[Magisk] Portgas D. Ace:
Let me just check my crystal ball... Ah, I see. That's the issue. But I am not entirely sure, because you do not provide enough information like device, Android version, other system mods, steps you performed to install Magisk and so on.
[Magisk] Max88888:
I only wish somebody nice has do step by step tutorial :)

Will try to do it soon! Thank you!
[Magisk] steveo17:
upgraded to DP 5 on my 6P (encrypted) and Magisk V3 won't boot.

anyone able to offer some help?
[Magisk] :
N & Encrypted 6P's don't play nice.
[Magisk] esrvR:
how can i test that im systemless?? I can't tell if I'm being dumb or not :/
[Magisk] Artim_96:
Well, the easiest way would be to get SafetyNet helper from PlayStore, unmount root in Magisk and run SafetyNet test. When it passes you have systemless root. But for ask I know shouldn't be even possible to install root as non systemless anymore. I don't know if you can see it in a file manger, besides the fact that you have /data/magisk.img and /magisk. So as long as you have them and have root I don't think there is even a chance that you aren't systemless
[Magisk] KAsp3rd:
So the easiest way I found to get it systemless is to use the Magic Mount built into Magisk..

Put the apk (not the root companion but the original gsam apk) or the folder (whichever you can find in /data) in /magisk/mounts/system/priv-app

Then in /magisk/mounts/lists/ create an empty file named update

Reboot and score
[Magisk] KAsp3rd:
See my above post
[Magisk] topjohnwu:
Magisk v4 will be a groundbreaking achievement, and I think it can change the way people deal with Android Modding. I hope the influence can be as significant as Xposed brought to the Android community :p

I'm thrilled and can't wait to release it, currently constructing the documentations for developers.

Also, new demo projects is coming live soon!
[Magisk] NetWasp:
Can't wait, works flawlessly in sgs7e, sac23 n7 port, phh root....

Amazing
[Magisk] KAsp3rd:
I believe that it is already as groundbreaking as Xposed (at least for me) it just hasn't reached the masses yet.

The only modification I cannot get to work properly is boot animation and boot sound. I haven't put any time into troubleshooting as to why. Was more just an acknowledgment putting it here.
[Magisk] Captain_Throwback:
Are you putting them in the "cachemount" section? That's the only way they'll work. I have custom boot animation working fine here :).
[Magisk] seand88:
Really excited to hear this news and see what you've come up with! Hopefully there will be some good news for us Nexus 6P owners in the announcement!
[Magisk] KAsp3rd:
I think I tried it there but it only showed the default "android" boot animation, the one when you don't have a boot animation. As stated I didn't look into it too much.
[Magisk] Captain_Throwback:
You also have to set the proper secontext on the files added in /cache/magisk/mounts/system - by default they end up with the cache_file context, whereas they need to have the system_file context. The next version of the Mod template will make this much clearer :).
[Magisk] rgawenda:
I've been thinking this since first release!
[Magisk] KAsp3rd:
Ah ha that's probably it then. I'll check that. I appreciate it.
[Magisk] TheSt33v:
Crossing my fingers that v4 is the one that will work on my Droid Turbo!
[Magisk] HaloTechnology:
FInally its working on Oneplus 3 with android 7 thanks Magisk :D
[Magisk] DrunphO:
yap, i have also 2 or 3 huawei stock apps that dont work when enforcing... anyway i also dont really need SN passing too :p

btw, updating magisk 10 to 10.1 and phh's SuperUser topjohnwu r1 to r2 with magisk manager made me lost root for almost apps but reflashing both from TWRP make it work again :good:

--- edit---

ah topjohnwu is buzy tonight, heres come another update 10.2... lets test it :), thanks mate for your hard work :)

--- edit2 ---

updated 10.1 to 10.2 from manager... working good so far :good:
[Magisk] lover:
I have android M April 2016 security patch ;) and i never update it
[Magisk] babygau:
does anyone know why flashfire doesn't work with magisk. i have latest magisk 10.2 installed but still not able to do anything with flashfire. all i have is a deathly black screen and a reboot.
[Magisk] AnonVendetta:
I see that v10.2 is out, just installed, is the much-awaited multi-ROM ready and functional yet? I dont see any options for it in the new Magisk Manager. Is there some guide I need to follow so that I can boot CM13 alongside LG stock? For now I'm just going to assume it's on hold.
[Magisk] A_Random_Guy:
New magisk doesn't work on Xiaomi Redmi Note 3 RR N
[Magisk] nimjk:
Can I ask you to add one thing? Dorimanx stweak needs its own busybox to use, so if i flash magisk to use with it, magiak works fine but stweak doesn't work... so i want to ask you that adding process to choose whether installing magisk's busybox or not. Or is there anything i can do to solve this problem?
[Magisk] yochananmarqos:
You can install it in /magisk/.core/busybox.

---------- Post added at 10:09 AM ---------- Previous post was at 10:07 AM ----------

Try reading the changelog in the release notes thread.
[Magisk] akk29:
Does the STweaks you use request Superuser permissions with Magisk? The version in my ROM does not. If so do you have the link?
[Magisk] Morteza-Sk:
I got this error . What should I do ?
[Magisk] Artim_96:
But still, I don't think that Chainfire updated it since I left the thread so either is not working anymore or it could be broken with the next update of SN
[Magisk] lover:
so what is most recent solution for SN? is it combination of Magisk Hide and RootSwitch?
[Magisk] chudy_85:
I use magisk v10.2 and superuser 2.0.11 beta and my sn pass. If I want use xposed I use root switch
[Magisk] FlintStoned-:
Thank you for your reply. Even with Xposed framework not installed I can't pass the safetyNet. I normally have systemless Xposed installed.

I do have unlocked bootloader and running Elite Kernel v3. (Sony Xperia Z3 Compact)

What other triggers are there? Will it eventually work with Xposed installed?
[Magisk] Link_of_Hyrule:
Using the latest magisk everything seems to work great so far however, when I try to update or install stuff from the app it doesn't seem to work and the Systemizer specifically even when I tried to flash the file manually in my TWRP it wouldn't flash so I think there's a bug with the new version in the repo.
[Magisk] nimjk:
no, i don't neither... So i want to ask to fix that...
[Magisk] Artim_96:
If it won't pass without then it definitely can't pass with XPosed.

Other possibilities are SELinux at to permissive, Build number containing "test-keys" instead of stable (at least that's what's detected sometimes by other detection methods), leftovers of system based root or XPosed...
[Magisk] nimjk:
How? Could you give me a method to do it? is it just copy and paste the busybox in my kernel zip file? but in my file, it is a busybox_tiny...
[Magisk] Artim_96:
Is there any way to manually patch the SELinux file to let those apps run as permissive while the rest of the system is enforcing? I mean, that's the way SuperSU and Magisk work to be systmless...
[Magisk] rignfool:
Had this problem with the unofficial betas as well...

I cannot resize the magisk partition... It only wants to be 64mb...

In recovery resize2fs says it works... But root explorer only tells me it doesn't change...

Any ideas

[MENTION=1162986]Captain_Throwback[/MENTION]
[Magisk] MMFreax:
Good morning, after update of Magisk is no more. Before everything was okay, could use my Norisbank TAN app. The Magisk Manager also wanted to update himself. Now SatetyNet Failed appears. Root I now again ... but SyfetyNet just no more ... Can one help me?

Gesendet von meinem HTC 10 mit Tapatalk
[Magisk] Captain_Throwback:
Nope. Works fine here.
[Magisk] 5m4r7ph0n36uru:
[MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] running Viper 4.4.0 FULLROM including Magisk, on FW 2.28.401.x and got same problem on my end.

All i've done was to updated Magisk App via PlayStore and after this I updated Magisk from 9.1 to 10.2, as well as phhsupersu to r2. Both of the last two, were done through Magisk App. And since I've done this I get the SafetyNet fail as well.

Nothing else has been changed.
[Magisk] danny_bhoy67:
Everything installed fine for me on v10.2 as a new user.

However when I enable Magisk Hide in the settings and reboot, the setting disables again and sn checks fail. It seems the enable Magisk Hide setting will not persist for me after a reboot.

I have xposed installed, is this likely to be interfering and causing the setting to reset?
[Magisk] radar-a:
I got the same thing.

Wysłane z mojego HTC 10 przy użyciu Tapatalka
[Magisk] Drivepnut:
I don't know if this has been mentioned but when I update Magisk and the new Magisk manager and phh's superuser my xposed framework says it is not working. It says it is not active. Is there a fix for this.
[Magisk] dracinn:
How would I go about mounting Viper4Android to system/priv-app?
[Magisk] yochananmarqos:
A Magisk module may need to be created.
[Magisk] soder:
Hi. I just got me my OnePlus 3T, and I'm about to get it rooted. As I understand it, only phh's superuser with Magisk is available to pass SafetyNet and to get OTA's? SuperSU doesn't work with passing SafetyNet, but does it work with Magisk and go get OTA's to the phone?

I tried Magisk on my OnePlus One a couple of month ago, and used both phh's and chainfire's root from day o to day, dealing with the updates for SafetyNet every day,

So, my question is:

Does OP3T work with phh's root?

Does OP3T work with Magisk together with SuperSU? If so, is it only possible to get OTA's to work or also SafetyNet?

/Söder
[Magisk] yung40oz84:
Ok, I am confused as I was under the assumption that phh superuser worked with f2fs on latest version, I treid flashing magisk in recovery and doing it through manger and every time it says no root.....
[Magisk] Biz92k:
Same issue and same behavior with 10.2. At least Magisk is still working without issues.
[Magisk] Captain_Throwback:
Works fine on f2fs on my device. Don't think f2fs is your problem.
[Magisk] Morteza-Sk:
Okay, I reflash SuperSU but now I get this error http://cloud.tapatalk.com/s/586bd3688c522/Screenshot_2017-01-03-10-21-18.png?
[Magisk] jl2222:
Im having the exact same issue with my Oneplus 3 using f2fs. It says both superuser and magisk were successfully installed in the recovery but my device is not rooted. Im thinking about switching back to exfat since I know phh superuser and magisk used to work before I made the switch.
[Magisk] yung40oz84:
It is f2fs, do you have data and cache as f2fs? I went back t ext4, followed identical same steps as I did a few minutes ago on f2fs and root works, magisk works, safety net pass no problem, with f2fs, root would not even install...
[Magisk] frikakwa:
Flashed last version of Magisk 10.2 and last phh superuser 266r2 into TWRP and all is running fine with my OP3 Nougat. ?

Able to use Snapchat and Pokemon go. ?
[Magisk] Captain_Throwback:
/data, yes, /cache, no. Guess I can try with /cache as f2fs and see what happens.

Have you tried with just /data as f2fs and seen if you still have an issue?
[Magisk] darkeyes22:
I'm sorry, where I should ask these type of questions?
[Magisk] yung40oz84:
No I haven't yet, maybe I will then, right now I'm just satisfied I got it working, lol!!
[Magisk] polymetric:
Keep in mind guys that if you use SuperSU, Magisk Hide will not work. I had to move to PHH Superuser to get it working.
[Magisk] jhedfors:
There is no multirom functionality in Magisk yet, so I assumed you were asking about the existing Multirom application/recovery. You would need to search/inquire in the forum for your device, if that is the case.
[Magisk] Biz92k:
Lol, I was optimistic. My build is completely broken now, only supersu is working, no magisk or xposed. All the root-related apps are working, obviously the xposed-related don't. Two hours ago everything was fine (on v9 and mag-man 3), I tried a cleaning of dalvik/cache to see if it could fix something but actually I destroyed everything... Nice :)
[Magisk] culiacanazo:
Wrong thread
[Magisk] Artim_96:
Obviously since it can only give Magisk modules. SuperSU is no module
[Magisk] soder:
It's not very clear if you are asking questions or telling that it works that way....

/Söder
[Magisk] Rami04:
I can't flash V10.2

I don't know what I must do

Error in TWRP: "Unable to restore ramdisk"
[Magisk] webtroter:
How do you uninstall magisk? There is no documentation about that.

Thank you.
[Magisk] yochananmarqos:
Use the uninstaller. Check the release thread for more info.
[Magisk] webtroter:
I did. There is just one link, no infos.

Am I supposed to flash it in recovery? Or in Magisk?
[Magisk] danny_bhoy67:
Recovery.
[Magisk] Battery03:
FlashFire needs a permissive kernel in order to work.
[Magisk] frikakwa:
There was no "interrogation mark" in my message.

My message was more kind of a feedback to dev to tell him everything's running fine on OP3 with Nougat.

I cannot imagine how difficult it is for him to track what re the devices which do not support last version of Magisk: e.g. a few comments before mine there was another guy telling this doesn't work (bootloop!) on OP3 with Nougat while this is running perfectly fine on my mine.
[Magisk] soder:
OK, great to know. I just got my OP3T and thought that I wanted to use Magisk again (did it on my OPO before I installed CM14.1 on that phone), and read that only phh's root together with Magisk could hide root and pass SafetyNet and also, I guess, be able to install OTA's.

Then I read a lot of guides to root it and all said SuperSU, and I then got unsure if phh's would work.

Anyway, my problem right now is that TWRP doesn't get installed very well on OxygenOS 4.0 on the OP3T. Only they who got it before they installed 4.0 got it working...

/SÃ¶der
[Magisk] Endormin:
Unfortunately Magisk Manager has stopped.

[MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION]

Xiaomi Redmi Note 3 Pro(Kenzo) and Resurrection Remix MM 5.7.4 + Agni Kernel MM 4.3 + Magisk v10.2 + Magisk Manager v3 + phh-superuser-topjohnwu-r2

Unfortunately Magisk Manager has stopped.
[Magisk] lonequid:
Should Magisk 10.2 and "Magisked" Xposed pass SafetyNet? I was able to pass before installing Xposed 87.1 with Magisk.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Magisk cannot hide Xposed.
[Magisk] dimm0k:
is it possible to have SuperSU and Magisk pass SafetyNet or is phh supersu needed?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
If you only want to use Magisk you'll need phh's superuser. With SuperSU you'll need root switch (or whatever it's called) and possibly suhide. But if your on November security patch or newer you'll have to add a couple of patches to make suhide work. Check the SuperSU forums for more on that...
[Magisk] Magz Heaven:
You mean official exposed installer is supported in magisk?
[Magisk] chudy_85:
Magisk don't support hide xposed only root switch dissable xposed when you don't use. Use official xposed v87
[Magisk] Magz Heaven:
SafetyNet Failed

I use Magisk v10.2 + Official Systemless SU by ChainFire + Material Exposed How to fix this problem? Any help will do. Thanks.

I'm new to this thing. Lels

Any suggestion or recommendation will do.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Magisk cannot hide either SuperSU or Xposed (feels like I'm repeating myself). Go to the SuperSU forums for info on how to do that (there's been plenty written about it).
[Magisk] Captain_Throwback:
Welcome to my world.
[Magisk] andrew2432:
Any chance you or someone else can point us towards that? I'm in beta and stable over on the cf side and missed the patching post November discussion. If not here I understand!
[Magisk] Link_of_Hyrule:
The problems i described a few posts back seem to be fixed now.

The next step if it's possible is for Magisk to be updated to be able to survive updates on custom roms like CM/Lineage OS. I know this is probably not possible for stock roms though.

I also have another question. Would it be possible to make a Magisk module that fakes release keys on userdebug builds? With this we might be allow to get Android Pay to fully work on Lineage OS nightlies until they release a snapshot build that it hopefully just works on.
[Magisk] yochananmarqos:
You should be able to create a Magisk module to change the appropriate build.prop entries if I'm not mistaken.
[Magisk] Artim_96:
Search!
[Magisk] Link_of_Hyrule:
Yeah I don't know how the user keys week I know just changing the build type from userdebug to user doesn't work since that's what my Android Wear module does but Android Pay still doesn't work to make transactions. The current issue is even though you can pass SafetyNet and add cards when you touch a payment terminal it doesn't popup at all. If there's a way to change other stuff in the kernel that's needed it could be useful to fix it.
[Magisk] andrew2432:
Not even a link to the main thread?!?! I'm kidding. I'm actually obviously xda illiterate because there's actually a supersu forum. A page itself for supersu...weird...
[Magisk] Artim_96:
For everything big enough (including XPosed, Magisk and SuperSU) there are complete forums for
[Magisk] culiacanazo:
Uninstaller in recovery (might be necessary to manually delete any ".img" left over in/data...

May i ask why you would wanna do that?
[Magisk] DAGr8:
Ok I'll rephrase what has been said by others so I can get proper answer.

I cannot install Magisk 10+ if superSU is not present. I get the error in twrp.

That leads to Magisk hide being unchecked same for phh. I have tried u mnemonic installing the whole thing but then it boot loops. So no clue how to make this work without superSU

Any help ?
[Magisk] Captain_Throwback:
Logs?
[Magisk] DAGr8:
After removing everything and trying to flash

Magisk : the installer in twrp says it sees a patch for superSU in the kernel that I have to install it before the installer can resume.

So I booted anyways and here :

Sure I can give you logs. Of what scenario / when tho? I'm Starting to believe the problem is the source kernel were using is set up for superSU. If I just knew what to remove manually ...
[Magisk] Captain_Throwback:
I'd start with a recovery log from the failed flash and subsequent SuperSU flash and follow-up flash. And a logcat of the failed boot-up.
[Magisk] DAGr8:
here you go twrp log line 517 for fail

recovery2.log after flashing supersu

recovery3 = flashing magisk after 're' - flashing supersu

cant seem to make it boot loop anymore but now i have magisk installed and no root. phh SU is armless. logcat is useless can still post it here f you think it might help
[Magisk] CrsMthw:
While updating Magisk from 10.1 to 10.2, I get the following error in TWRP

Using sukernel to restore ramdisk

!unable to restore ram disk

I am using Magisk with systemless superSU

And I have tried installing it from Magisk manager

[IMG="Magisk 10.2 update error"]https://imgur.com/gallery/3ToLH[/IMG]
[Magisk] yochananmarqos:
Flash your kernel, SuperSU then try Magisk again. If you didn't already know, Magisk Hide will only work with phh superuser.
[Magisk] Aninja:
I was having a similar problem installing magisk 10.2, but by uninstalling everything and then starting over by installing 10.2 and then phh superuser I was able to get it to work.

However, now I'm having another problem that I can't figure out. I can't get magisk hide to work at all. I click it on and it tells me to reboot, but when I do it just becomes unchecked again and nothing changes.

Also at the main status screen it says, "SafteyNet Failed: CTS profile mismatch". Does anyone have any idea what this means?