yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] acestars:
I have Xiaomi Redmi Note 2. What I did for installing magisk:

1. I flashed xiaomi.eu 7.3.9

2. Reboot to system

3. Set initial configuration, google account, etc.

4. Reboot to recovery

5. Install Magisk

6. Reboot to system

7. Install Magisk Manager, xposed installer dvdandroid

8. Reboot to Recovery

9. Install xposed magisk by solarwarez

10. Reboot to System.

11. Checked magisk manager, magisk already installed and properly rooted by magisksu.

12. Checked xposed installer, xposed installed successfully.

But i have some problems:

1. Safetynet failed with cts mismatched.

2. Titanium Backup stuck when restoring apps, I have to " set enforce 0" via terminal and enable install via usb and need to login using mi account that i hated.

3. If I installed custom kernel, not truly custom kernel just edited ramdisk, I cant install magisk with error something like "cannot found stock boot image". But if I restore the stock kernel magisk can be installed.

So basically what I want is, How I can install custom kernel with ramdisk or what is the specification of custom kernel for installing magisk. I can ignore about SafetyNet failed because not available in my country anyway.

The custom kernel I install is

https://xdaforums.com/redmi-note-2/development/b-skinny-pro-t3347906
[Magisk] gtpy:
Ok. I reflashed. Now with v11.1 and its working.

Try the new 11.5 with my other smatrphone and will report.
[Magisk] corleone48:
V11.1 pb of recognition

Hello,

I've got an issue since new built 11.1 (I'm on oneplus3t)

I've install it after being with supersu 2.79 and the bug start to appear.

Some App don't see the root

I choose to install again with SU 2.79 + clean wipe but the continued

After another clean wipe (data/system/dalvik/cache) I reinstalled Lineage + SU 2.79 and the same, some app don't see i'm rooted...

I'm back to FreedomOS +SU 2.79 but Es fileexplorer still don't work with root...

Anyone can help me to find the way to reset my phone properly ? or fix that root pb ??

I'm newbi with magisk may I have done a mistake...
[Magisk] gtpy:
I use magisk 11.1 and magiskSu. That work really good. Is there a reason why you use supersu and magisk?

Why don't use magiskSu?
[Magisk] myshya:
Root lost on LG G4.

I need help with downloading uninstaller. I click on the link in the Magisk main thread and get this error message:

Edit: I followed instructions from the main thread and reflashed Magisk without any root (just the MagiskSU). Works like a charm!
[Magisk] teddy0209:
Just restore your boot.img and delete magisk.img in /data...
[Magisk] saurabhkashyap:
Google app and play services force close after updating to v11.5, disabling magisk solves this.Pls check this issue. On Aosp 7.1.1 moto g titan.
[Magisk] corleone48:
Hello

I discover magisk recently and i wanted to try it.

It's why when i have issue with it, i try to come back to supersu
[Magisk] maxwarp79:
On S7 edge (G935F) with stock Nougat ROM and custom TGP kernel updating to 11.5, I lost root. Solutions?

Inviato dal mio Galaxy S7 edge
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
To everyone reporting issues by stating "it doesn't work" or "this and this crashes" and nothing else: Logs or it didn't happen! Without logs it's a huge pain to troubleshoot any issues users might be having. Maybe, just maybe, you spending those extra few minutes it takes to grab a logcat could help the entire community...

There was even an guide about this on the xda front page just last week:

https://www.xda-developers.com/guide-sending-a-logcat-to-help-debug-your-favorite-app/

And also:

https://xdaforums.com/showthread.php?t=1726238

---------- Post added at 09:48 ---------- Previous post was at 09:47 ----------

Solution: Use v11.1 for now.

https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=71505449&postcount=18
[Magisk] maxwarp79:
Ok, thank you!

Inviato dal mio Galaxy S7 edge
[Magisk] jusztin:
hello,

had v1.1, vodafone and SEQR pay apps were not hidden, after the automatic update to 1.5 everything works.

LG G3 D855 with Mokee 7.1.1
[Magisk] Naudiz:
Just a minor issue in Magisk Manager:

Received update notification this morning, but Magisk Manager still showed 11.1 as the most recent version to me and wouldn't download 11.5.

I then flashed 11.5 manually in TWRP and now Magisk Manager looks as if my version is newer than the latest (see screenshot) :D
[Magisk] chrcol:
I restored my system from nandroid backup.

Magisk still works with busybox files cleaned out of system/xbin

However if I delete toybox and all files symlinked to it (I assume is busybox renamed) from system/bin then magisk completely breaks. Those files I suspect is why some banking apps and myee remain broken on my device even with magiskhide and xposed disabled, note I am still using 11.1 due 11.5 issues reported.

Also some apps that use busybox such as titanium backup and terminal emulator are still functioning even with busybox supposedly off in magisk. I am pretty sure the files in system/bin are to blame.

Also if I check /sbin in TWRP it shows loads of busybox files, but if I check /sbin inside android the contents is completely different.
[Magisk] turbo1781:
Same here
[Magisk] chrcol:
H bud, since you helped me alot already I wonder if you have thoughts on my post here, regarding busybox files in /system/bin, hopefully you can check your phone and see if you have toybox binary and files symlinked to it. Thanks

https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=71507267&postcount=10526
[Magisk] teddy0209:
The update was pulled... Check the official release thread...
[Magisk] rocky78:
hi guys, need a hand over here.

searched the thread for my problem.

I flashed magisk 11.5 and suhide 0.55 and after that I have an app-kik it's called and now it force closing all the time.

maybe someone knows or encountered with something similar to this? really need a hand over here.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Magisk v11.5 got pulled from the Manager notification because of issues with Samsung devices. That's why the "newest" version for the Manager is v11.1.

https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=71505449&postcount=18

Edit: Waaaaay to slow... :D
[Magisk] Naudiz:
Ooooh, nevermind :3
[Magisk] gtpy:
That's right. I used super before. Tried magisk out and decided to change.
[Magisk] corleone48:
Fixed, pb with es file explorer

https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=66140836&postcount=5493
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Just a quick thing about some of the things you write here: IIRC many apps use their own built-in Busybox, including Titanium Backup. And that's also true for TWRP (as well as it's own root solution). That's why you'll only see those files when in TWRP and not booted into android.

And be careful deleting Busybox and Toybox files (they're not the same, Toybox is an alternative to Busybox). As you've noticed you might end up with things breaking. Toybox shouldn't casue any issues with Banking apps, since it's included in Android since Marshmallow (6.0).
[Magisk] gtpy:
Thanks for the info. I'll try it on my other phone ?
[Magisk] casouzaj:
Really? I did the same in my Z3C and everything is working fine, just like before!

Edit: v11.5 was pulled from the server.
[Magisk] GHFear:
Nexus 6 problem

I have used Magisk on my Nexus 6 without problem since the beginning of magisk and for some reason 11.5 won't work for me. When I install it and reboot, My phone bricks and will not get past the Google logo. Is it just me?
[Magisk] laggardkernel:
Using multirom with Magisk? How about using secondary ROM with v4a. Whenever I install a Magisk module with libraries, I got a boot stuck.

Op3, OOS 3.2.7. BitO-TWRP-3.0.3-MROM-oneplus3-006-20161220

Magisk v9 works well with multirom. So what I'm doing now is try to adapt the magisk_mount.sh script back to the v9 style.
[Magisk] gtpy:
You installed over magisk manager?

I try it again when I'm at home.
[Magisk] Soheil_70:
Im on a latest version of nexus 6p.

Am i okay flashing 11.5 using TWRP. Would i go in a boot loop, or should I wait for a bit.
[Magisk] bland.life:
I went to TWRP, flashed the uninstaller, wiped system+both caches.

Then reinstalled the ROM and GApps.

The ROM came with Magisk 11.1.

Magisk downgrade went well but SEpolicy is still permissive instead of enforcing.

What did I forget to wipe?

EDIT: Fiddled around and went back to check, it turned into enforcing. So its fine now.
[Magisk] bluedragon38:
Someone arrive to play pokemon Go with the last magisk ? Because i can't... it doesn't want to connect and my safety check = CTS profil mismatch ... :/ :(
[Magisk] MarcTremonti:
simple reflashing of the kernel also worked. ty!:)
[Magisk] chrcol:
ok so those toybox files are also on your system?

I got another update regarding synapse and busybox

It seems the busybox in /system/xbin remained from the module even after that module was disabled, if I enable magisk busybox after deleting that remnant busybox and then try to use synapse it does indeed fail still with the UCI error, scol works.

Since you ruled out toybox all I can say is this.

Barclay apps are completely unaffected by magisk hide, barclays works regardless if hide is on or not as long as xposed is disabled, barclaycard does not work at all. Tesco bank works when xposed is disabled, doesnt work when its enabled, it doesnt care if magiskhide is enabled. MyEE doesnt work at all.

However if I disabled magisk (either by me breaking it or uninstalling it), barclaycard and myee suddenly start working. The only thing magiskhide fixes on my phone is safetynet. But none of my apps seem to care about safetynet.

If I enable that busybox module with busybox disabled in magisk, the systemui goes into a restart loop after a reboot (had to do full nandroid restore to recover). I am trying to get synapse to work without using that module but it seems I may have to install it again as synapse is not liking the magisk built in busybox binary, did the dev remove some functions from the included busybox?

Having navigated all my root file structure I dont see any remnants of old su or busybox installations now, the only standout thing was those toybox files.
[Magisk] GHFear:
Trier installing 11.5 on 2 different Nexus 6 with Franco kernel and Android 7.1.1 and both bootloop :p So I would advice People with Nexus 6 to stay away from 11.5.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
I'm a N6 user as well and have not yet had time to try v11.5. What version of FK are you using? There's been reports of bootloop issues with both r64 and r65. Some users have reported success if they let the device boot once with Franco Kernel before installing any root solution. You could also give r63 a go...

---------- Post added at 13:12 ---------- Previous post was at 12:55 ----------

Yes, of course. Like I said, Toybox is a part of Android.

Many apps look for more than "just" root or passing SafetyNet. With Magisk v11.5 some of the more common prop values are taken care of, but there might still be other prop values and/or dependencies that apps look for.

Barclay needs the Phone (com.android.phone) to be added to the Hide list and what you wrote got me interested and I tried a couple of things. Seems like the Barclay app stores the rooting information from the first time you start the app. If you let the app detect root once, you won't be able to start it without clearing/reinstalling the app. If you add it to Magisk Hide (together with Phone services) before firing it up and start it once, you can then remove it from the Hide list and still start it. It may be that it will do another root check after a certain time... Interestingly, as soon as I removed Phone services from the Hide list it detected root again. I couldn't fully try it, of course, since I'm not a Barclay customer.

Just goes to show that hiding root from apps can be tricky...

I've experienced a couple of apps not liking Magisk built-in Busybox. It might be they're programmed to use a specific Busybox version (usually Stericson's). Magisk Busybox is, from what I understand, a very complete Busybox though.
[Magisk] Magister54:
This update installed on my Zenfone2 and now it bootloops in TWRP, how can I recover my phone?

EDIT: default updater/installer do not sign boot so it fails on Asus.
[Magisk] deeplyyoung:
Till now have flashed 11.5 over primary (aicp), bit busy whole day but seems ARISE is not working, DTS also not working whereas my secondary is also with magisk (Tipsy) but using 11.1.
[Magisk] GHFear:
I am using r64. I just tried installing 11.5 with stock kernel and FK r63 and it Still doesn't boot after install :/ I am not sure why it's happening.... I can install all other Magisk versions tho. :P weird stuff.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Hm... I might give it a go in a few hours when I'm home from work. I might just wait for the next update though, since there are some issues with v11.5.
[Magisk] tamer7:
Hi,

I'm using CM13 (Unofficial by trader418) on Note 3 N9005

Magisk v11.5 installs properly with MagiskSU, and I can pass SafetyNet checks.

However, my banking app (S-PushTan) still detects I'm rooted.

Using iSu + cm-su on LineageOS 14.1 (unofficial by trader418) , however, the app doesn't detect root and runs ok.

According to rootcloak2 docs about S-PushTan: https://github.com/devadvance/rootcloak/wiki/Working-and-Nonworking-Apps

If it can work with iSu, I imagine Magisk can also bypass its checks, no?
[Magisk] MTKW:
What's the directory that Magisk in flashed to?
[Magisk] teddy0209:
/data
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
At what point does it detect root? I tested it right now and without adding it to Magisk Hide it won't even start, just keeps crashing. If I add it to the Hide list it starts fine, to a screen with a bunch of check boxes and German text.
[Magisk] casouzaj:
Yes, I did! Anyway, keep the version 11.1 until it is updated again.
[Magisk] chrcol:
Yep phone is added, but now you gave me new ideas, I will wipe cache and data from the barclays app and even maybe reinstall it, same with myee. Snapchat does something similar where by if you can login once without root it doesnt check again.

Also synapse is now solved and I mean properly, I did some investigating as it stayed broken with the module.

So the module is now off, it was a red herring.

I checked the UCI file and it is like this.

UCI in /sbin pointing to UCI in /sbin_orig which points to UCI in /res/synapse, the permissions were 644 so no execute rights, I figured that out when I tried to run in terminal emulator and got a permission denied.

I then discovered all the synapse binaries in /res/synapse/actions were also lacking +x flags so fixed those also.

So synapse is for sure definitely now working on magisk built in busybox, I will get back to you on the barclay stuff you discovered, thanks.
[Magisk] Poke01:
Any reason I have 11.5 installed but it says latest version is 11.1? Was this update revoked. I have it on one device but not the other. And app says in up to date on 11.1. ??????. Xt1575 on Tesla latest, no exposed.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=71505449&postcount=18
[Magisk] Mecca EL:
[MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] thanks for all the work you put into this. I sent you a small donation, although not nearly enough to cover the hours you put into this, it's enough to cover lunch.

Finally got everything running and haven't bother to do safety net check yet, making sure root is maintained and it's been about 2hrs now.

For those having trouble,I unistalled the previous MagiskSU version, and rebooted back to recovery. Next, I updated my OS, custom 3.10 kernel and rebooted back to recovery. Then I ran unSU, in case my OS had baked in SU, which it doesn't, rebooted to recovery. Last, I installed Magisk v11.5 and rebooted to system. All is well.
[Magisk] Poke01:
.

So since I'm m not on Samsung, and have the update stored, would it be advised to go ahead and install it.? I'm on Motorola x pure. Works fine on second device.. (same phone)
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Go ahead. If it works fine on one device there's a good chance it'll work on the other as well.
[Magisk] Telperion:
Yeah I got it back by uninstalling, but something about the patch messes up the boot image. 11.1 still works and FPS is intact. I opened up an issue on Github to have it looked at.
[Magisk] swapgut:
topjohnwu; Great root app, heard about it months ago, just installed on two 6Ps right before the update to 1.15 and it is doing what I needed. The prompts are quicker than what I'd been using for years.

Thank You.
[Magisk] slekkas:
I'm using an app to watch TV on my Nexus 6 and until this morning I was using Magisk 6.5 to hide root and everything worked just fine.

I wanted to install Sony framework in order to be able to use Sony Remote Play app so I updated to Magisk 11.5. My Sony remote app works fine and the safetynet test passes successfully but every time I try to use my TV GO app I get a message that the app won't run on rooted devices.

I tried most things from the tips #4 section but it won't work. I find it strange as it was working flawlessly with version 6.5 and all I had to do is toggle to hide root.

I even disabled busybox and anything else I could think of.

The only thing I'm not sure is if the app has any other dependencies but I doubt it since it was working fine with 6.5. I would go back but then my PS remote play won't work.

Has anyone had similar issues with some other app?

Thank you.
[Magisk] EpicLPer:
Did I miss something or why did Magisk show an update today in the morning and now it's not anymore? Still on 11.1
[Magisk] ABotelho23:
Would it be possible to implement a way to put a PIN on su requests from apps? I believe SuperSU had implemented such a feature. Sorta like a sudo password/pin?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Ok. We're getting somewhere. Still a couple of details missing though... What app are we talking about (there's a few apps called TV GO or something similar in the Play store). And where's that Magisk log I asked for?

---------- Post added at 16:56 ---------- Previous post was at 16:55 ----------

Yeah, you missed something. Check the latest post in the release thread.
[Magisk] slekkas:
The app is called Cosmote TV GO.

Attached is the LOG.

Here is a line that is referring to the app:

MagiskHide: Killing gr.ote.otetvgo.androidphone
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Log looks fine. I also gave the app a try, but since I don't have an account I couldn't give it a proper rundown and I'm guessing that the app doesn't complain about root until you try playing something.

Sorry... I don't know...
[Magisk] slekkas:
Yes exactly. I can login but when I click play it comes up with the notice that I cannot use the app with root.

What could be the possible reasons it worked with 6.5 but not with 11.5?
[Magisk] Captain_Throwback:
6.5 and 11.5 are doing completely different things. Magisk no longer disables root - it hides itself and its root from the apps in the Magisk Hide list so that they don't know root is present. So rather than manually having to disable root system-wide, the latest version is more selective and an app shouldn't even know you have root. However if the app is looking for something other than an su binary, or isn't calling su to determine if the system is rooted, it's possible that the detection method is something that isn't currently hidden by Magisk.

You'd have to decompile the app APK and figure out what kind of root check it's doing to know for sure.
[Magisk] MTKW:
Is it possible to install magisk without custom recovery?

I haven't been able to install custom recovery on my phone in any way nor have I been able to root it.

The bootloader in unlocked.

I was thinking I could push the files in to the system through adb.
[Magisk] rodomb:
I have Oneplus 3t with Oxygen 4.1.0, magisk 11.5 and magisk manager 4.2.6. My phone pass safety net check, android pay don't report any problems but I didn't test any payment or game.

In Play Store I have info about new version 4.2.7 magisk manager but I have doubts about updating.
[Magisk] ManikandanGuru:
Sony framework really helped me to install some good sony apps.

I wonder if we can get a blackberry framework magisk module, it would be so much helpful to install some unique blackberry apps.
[Magisk] raptorskate:
Pokemon Go stopped working on 11.5 on Moto G4 Plus Aokp ROM, it was working on the past version, know why?
[Magisk] android_smater:
lossing root on latest magisk 11.5

---------- Post added at 07:39 PM ---------- Previous post was at 07:28 PM ----------

every time i loss root but some app working but some not with root and masgisk manager show not rooted but masik insalled
[Magisk] cciechad:
FYI Magisk 11.5 seems to break WiFi(it is disabled and wont turn on) on the OnePlus 3 OOS 4.1.0/bluspark kern. Resinstalled OS/bluspark/magisk 11.1 and everything is happy again(I know this is an unsupported combo but in case anyone else runs into it).

Edit: Fixed. Just make sure you flash the kernel again after the Magisk upgrade(on 11.6 now). CTS passes and everything :)
[Magisk] CryonicCore:
Did anybody find a fix for the SafetyNet CTS profile mismatch? I seem to be having that issue with that in magisk.

My phone works fine even when I says this but I wouldn't mind fixing this issue.
[Magisk] Karls0:
So overall, v11.1 seems to be more stable?

@Up - do you have MagiskHide on?
[Magisk] CryonicCore:
Yup I do
[Magisk] Karls0:
So check if your SElinux is showed as enforcing or not. It should be called enforcing but act like permissive.
[Magisk] Artim_96:
It should but it doesn't. Not on 11.5, not in the 12 beta
[Magisk] slekkas:
Is it possible to install 6.5? Is all I have to do uninstall 11.5 and slash 6.5 and supersu again? Such pity I can't use both apps I want.

Would it be difficult to add the same function as in 6.5 to completely disable root for all apps? I'm sure many would have similar problems then me and would find this useful.
[Magisk] Captain_Throwback:
v11.5 has an option to disable root - it's in Settings - just set Superuser access to "Disabled."
[Magisk] kosmasgr:
So we can temporary disable root access , run the app and then enable it again
[Magisk] Karls0:
The longer I read this thread, the more I think it is good idea to stay with v11.1.
[Magisk] kosmasgr:
11.5 works flawlessly on my Moto G4 , stock ROM 7.0 nougat .
[Magisk] MrHomebrew:
Try disabling USB debugging in the developer section in settings app.
[Magisk] slekkas:
So I disabled Superuser and it still didn't work. Then I disabled Magisk. Still doesn't work. The thing is that even though everything is disabled in the status screen in Magisk manager it has the check-mark and it says properly installed.

Am I doing something wrong?
[Magisk] topjohnwu:
Samsung hotfixes are now live!

Samsung users please check it out, the release has been tested by several Samsung developers
[Magisk] DeathmonkeyGTX:
11.6 Working fine on angler
[Magisk] gtpy:
Right. Magisk hide = on

I had the same issue. For me was the solution not to use PlayStore in beta, and do a clean flash. Before I pass SafetyNet I didn't do a clean setup. Tried many things out like new PlayStore, then doesn't come from a clean flash.

I do a reset, build and flashed all again. It worked.
[Magisk] Doc Franky B.:
No problems at all on Note4 after install 11.6 ?

Send from Note4 - 6.0.1
[Magisk] JonathanRAZ:
11.6 working perfect note 5 tmo
[Magisk] venelar:
11.6 installed fine on angler here too.

Still can'get get v4a to work though. The module installs/boots fine. When i install the apk it says the driver installed successfully but every time i reboot it asks again to install the driver. Lineage based rom on 6p.

Maybe after a few days some people will get a method figured out.
[Magisk] Soheil_70:
is 11.6 working ok on nexus 6p
[Magisk] carlosggb:
AWESOME! Thanks buddy!!!

One question, if my system is already rooted with supersu, will magisk manager totally remove supersu to get magisk as the sole root method?
[Magisk] gtpy:
Anyone tried v11.6 iwith an D5803 (Sony Z3C)?

If not I'll test it tomorrow.
[Magisk] Captain_Throwback:
No. You MUST fully unroot with SuperSU prior to flashing Magisk if you want to switch to MagiskSU. This includes restoring stock boot.img.
[Magisk] carlosggb:
Copied that! Thanks Captain!!!:good:
[Magisk] Pkt_Lnt:
Is you kernel still set to Enforcing? Mine changed to Permissive with 11.6 again, NOT what I want.
[Magisk] Soheil_70:
its works fine on angler(nexus 6p)