yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] IronTechmonkey:
Wait for it to be released.

-------

General note/nag: I merely followed the link from the OPs of this thread to the Magisk GitHub pages and looked at the most recent issues because... when I saw no answer here I reviewed the OPs of the thread. Hint hint.

If that is applicable it might be best shared in the githib ticket. Also, it seemed (some hours ago) that people were still kicking around ideas in the ticket but a full solution was not yet found. I cannot tell because I'm not running Canary on my Moto devices and it might not affect them even if I was.
[Magisk] BakaPhoenix:
I have this weird problem with this game https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=jp.co.cygames.princessconnectredive&hl=en

It has root check and also check if magisk manager is installed, using hide and changing manager name made this run fine but starting today i have trouble running it on my tablet it start fines but after 10 to 30 sec game crash and close itself i have same problems on both of my nvidia shield tablet (one using los 14 and the other los t15) but works fine with no problem with my phone (a poco f1).

It happened the same in the past and i fixed by doing a wipe but this time even changing rom didn't help at all

I used to have this same error in the past on same tablet and i fixed by doing a full wipe, this time even changing rom didn't fix it

Edit: I made a clean install without installing magisk and works fine i have no idea on what might case the crash
[Magisk] HannibalLecter:
HDFC PAYZAPP suddenly stopped working today. It says cant work on this device because of an error.

Safety net is passing and device is certified. still not working.

It worked just a week or so before when i paid a bill.

Tried today and suddenly poof.

Anybody can try using Payzapp and confirm?

---------- Post added at 02:15 PM ---------- Previous post was at 02:14 PM ----------

HDFC PAYZAPP suddenly stopped working today. It says cant work on this device because of an error.

Safety net is passing and device is certified. still not working.

It worked just a week or so before when i paid a bill.

Tried today and suddenly poof.

Anybody can try using Payzapp and confirm?
[Magisk] Tops1:
Hi I can't find the hide option.

Thanks

All good found it thanks so much.

Love you're work ?
[Magisk] samhhmobil:
You have to activate it in "Settings" first.

samhhmobil
[Magisk] Tops1:
Yeah I found it thanks so much for your reply ?
[Magisk] hjjiang:
FYI Latest Canary - 20412 - fixed oneplus 8 fingerprint reader compared to build 20411
[Magisk] vandyman:
Canary is updated to build 20413 now. [emoji106]
[Magisk] chez123123:
Hi,

i installed Magisk v 20.4 by TWRP 3.3.1-0 on Redmi Note 8T, when i try turn on wifi, it doesn't work. it's happening after installation Magisk

Rom: willow_global_images_V11.0.3.0 - official
[Magisk] rupeshmaurya35:
This is not magisk problem. TWRP is causing this issue.

Patch the boot image and flash magisk_patched boot image directly from platform-tools into boot partition without twrp.

Command - fastboot flash boot magisk_patched.img

If it have A/B partition then flash in active partition.
[Magisk] guest4711:
20414 is online...
[Magisk] vandyman:
Wow! A lot of new updates lately. LOL.. [emoji41]
[Magisk] mkdante381:
When you want run any app who is on Magisk hide list, this app freeze. Help only remove this app from magisk hide list. Problem on Google Play Services 20.18.16 and 20.18 17

Tested on Magisk Canary 20308 and 20409. On latest 20414 I have bootlop after restart...
[Magisk] atoti:
Hello

Does anyone know how app "B.a.n.c.o P.A.N" (remove dots ?) is being able to detect root? It only runs when Magisk is removed.

I am using Magisk 20.4 and Manager 7.5.1. This app was selected in Magisk Hide, Magisk name was randomized (hidden), no TWRP folder and no Magisk zip files inside internal memory.

PokemonGo and Ingress doesn't detect Magisk and run perfect, so this app is doing something new...

Try yourself there.

This info may be useful to keep Magisk undetectable for more years ?

Regards

[/COLOR]r
[Magisk] NHNXDA:
Tried edxposed which triggered safety net, removed & passed fine, tried another updated edxposed canary version which apparently allowed usage with safetynet passing, didn't pass, removed again but now magisk isnt passing at all.

Reinstalled magisk from the install option in magisk, made no difference.

Anyone else got issues (OnePlus 7 pro 10.0.5 EU handset)

Running 20.4 & 7.51, so I'm uptodate.

Any ideas how to restore passing.

TIA.

---------- Post added at 02:18 PM ---------- Previous post was at 02:18 PM ----------

Tried edxposed which triggered safety net, removed & passed fine, tried another updated edxposed canary version which apparently allowed usage with safetynet passing, didn't pass, removed again but now magisk isnt passing at all.

Reinstalled magisk from the install option in magisk, made no difference.

Anyone else got issues (OnePlus 7 pro 10.0.5 EU handset)

Running 20.4 & 7.51, so I'm uptodate.

Any ideas how to restore passing.

TIA.
[Magisk] meiser:
Hi,

I just found out that none of my magisk modules (e.g. AirAudio or AuroraServices) works if selinux enforcing is enabled on my Xiaomi device. It works on my OnePlus3 with selinux enforcing.

Does anyone know which selinux rules are mandatory to make magisk modules working with selinux enforcing?

Thanks,

meiser
[Magisk] zgfg:
Most modules are independent of Selinux Enforcing or Permissive.

Spme, like certain audio mods require(d) Permissive, but check on the corresponding portals, threads, subforums or Telegram channels.

TG, V4A works fine on Xiaomi (with Enforcing mode)
[Magisk] bdawwgg:
Try changing your channel back to stable.

You can change the build by selecting a different update channel. (This was the advice I read earlier in this post that helped me)

I'm brand new to pixel 3 xl. Just got it in yesterday.

Successfully unlocked bootloader, flashed pixel dust 10, and root w/ passing safety net.

I wasn't passing the checks on the safety net with Canary selected.. went to stable and safely net passed and I was able to add cards to my Google pay.

I'm loving the upgrade OG pixel XL to Pixel 3 xl
[Magisk] meiser:
Reinstalling the modules solved the issue. No idea what went wrong during the magisk updates.
[Magisk] JudgeDread11:
Did you clear the data from play services?
[Magisk] NHNXDA:
Tried few things, ended up using 0.5.0 4548 edxposed module, added the aod module, worked, then didn't, reinstalled again, working again , lol, weird behaviour.

All this to get AOD working when those damn OP software engineers should of added it ages ago.
[Magisk] wilsonhlacerda:
You have to clear Google Play Store + Play Services + Framework data. At least that is what suggested on EdXposed Github Issues by some users that have had problems like yours.

---------- Post added at 12:32 AM ---------- Previous post was at 12:27 AM ----------

Is this bank the Brazilian one? I don't use it, but maybe I'll try it and report later. I have no problem with any Brazilian bank, at least till now.

Install the app Rootbeer Fresh from Play Store, hide it on Magisk and run it. Do you get green on all tests?

This app checks more conventional root traces and probably the app is using something similar (some Brazilian banks apps does do that).
[Magisk] wikiuse:
Hello

My device is A505F Android 10, I flashed sucessfully module without Magisk, but when my phone was rebooted I don't see module which has been installed.

So module was flashed sucessfully?

A lot of modules in problem the same....

Why wasn't it show in Magisk?

My English is not good!
[Magisk] KZekai:
Speaking of audio modules, I have weird issue with

https://github.com/Magisk-Modules-Grave/gjf_bt

This is the only module I have installed. it works fine but when it is active (after a reboot) I'm unable to mount any of the system/root partitions for rw, it just silently fails (as if remount was sucessfull, but I cant do any writing operations, every single one of them timeouts with permission errors).

Any idea what might cause it?
[Magisk] J.Michael:
What do you mean when you say you flashed a module without Magisk?
[Magisk] wikiuse:
I'm sorry.I wrote wrong. I flashed the module with magisk, but when my device was rebooted I didn't see module in Magisk

---------- Post added at 06:01 AM ---------- Previous post was at 05:55 AM ----------

Sorry. I wrote wrong. I flashed module into Magisk but when my device was rebooted I didn't see module in Magisk

---------- Post added at 06:02 AM ---------- Previous post was at 06:01 AM ----------

Sorry. I wrote wrong. I flashed module into Magisk but when my device was rebooted I didn't see module in Magisk

---------- Post added at 06:02 AM ---------- Previous post was at 06:02 AM ----------

Sorry. I wrote wrong. I flashed module into Magisk but when my device was rebooted I didn't see module in Magisk

---------- Post added at 06:03 AM ---------- Previous post was at 06:02 AM ----------

Sorry. I wrote wrong. I flashed module into Magisk but when my device was rebooted I didn't see module in Magisk

---------- Post added at 06:04 AM ---------- Previous post was at 06:03 AM ----------

Sorry. I wrote wrong. I flashed module into Magisk but when my device was rebooted I didn't see module in Magisk
[Magisk] zgfg:
Be patient when posting. Sometimes it takes time but it posts. If you click Post several times you post the same in duplicates.

Even if you do, you can reopen your post and edit

So, what do you mean you don't see your module?

Reboot after flashing the module, open Magisk, Modules and check does it show that module is installed. If it shows, your module was successfully flashed

This is not Xposed and many modules do not install any application - hence don't think that module was not flashed if you don't find any new icon on the home screen
[Magisk] wikiuse:
This is my video. I think you should see it one time

My device: A50(A505F), Android 10, module: Ram clean fix

https://streamable.com/kqbp3i
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
You'd have to check the module install log to be sure, but I'm guessing that the module is using an outdated module template and can't install on current Magisk releases.
[Magisk] wikiuse:
Is there any way to install that module?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
First check the install log, to make sure what's going on. No use in working on something until you know what's wrong...
[Magisk] NHNXDA:
Yeah cleared cache on all but framework, but its working again now, not sure why it failed but alas let's see how long for lol.
[Magisk] shadavis08:
Ok guys I found a bug where Magisk will not flash properly after an Ota update. Don't know why but the "install to inactive slot" will not work. I'm using a Asus Zenfone 6 wd101
[Magisk] vandyman:
I had the same problem back in January and gave up and just flashed the modified boot.img. If I remember correctly, it had something to do with Busy Box.
[Magisk] amk316:
hi

rootbear-fresh dose not detect my rooted phone all green but a banking app "stc pay" latest updated has detected it

see the attachment

any suggestions please
[Magisk] eustilou:
Same issue with BT Pay

It detects the presence of edxposed Magisk module

I know it asks Google Play (Services?) because if I freeze Google Play, the app hangs on the splash screen and no detection message is given

I'm using Canary 0.5.0.0 YAHFA on a OnePlus 5 with 9.0.11 stock OOS. It's the only one that passed SafetyNet.
[Magisk] wilsonhlacerda:
Read carefully:

https://didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHide#hn_Hiding_root_from_apps

Besides that the app may be querying system for installed apps in order to find some well known root demanding apps and in that case some tools like XPrivacyLua, Root Cloak and others (need Xposed / EdXposed, what in some cases can be another problem) or "sandbox" like Shelter, Island may help.

Also app / Magisk module Storage Isolation (Storage Redirect) may help if they reading all your downloads, files, folders.

---------- Post added at 06:47 PM ---------- Previous post was at 06:37 PM ----------

I've tried it. It detects root by asking Android for all installed apps and searching for some known root apps.

I could bypass it by using XprivacyLua. You can use that or other tools like I wrote on my previous post above to the other XDA user.

Another alternative is to freeze all root apps the Banco P.A.N. app is searching for, just before running it, and then unfreeze afterwards. You may use some automation tool to help that.
[Magisk] wikiuse:
Thank you!. I did contact with dev 's module, they sad "This module was old, couldn't use with Magisk lastest"
[Magisk] Johnn78:
If you have Edxposed then disable it, restart device and retry. Else clear data and cache from Google play store, Google Framework and Google Services and reboot your mobile to try again.
[Magisk] Lefteris Fragiadakis (Frago):
Hi.trying to make a sony android tv to work,

i extract the boot img from tv,patch it with magisk but bricked,

i saw a very big diffrence in the size,original is 65mb,the pached is always 25

someone can check it?

here is original boot img

http://www.mediafire.com/file/3qboj8qovrg2p8w/boot.img/file

patched

https://www.mediafire.com/file/moc09tgzlegvdtv/magisk_patched.img/file
[Magisk] eustilou:
The presence of EdXposed module is the defining factor on whether the app detects root.

If I remove EdXposed module, the app works.

I tried blacklisting Google play/services/framework along with the app in EdXposed manager, but no success.
[Magisk] amk316:
i did not install Edxposed

the only app i us is adaway and i removed it and still dedicated the root

the app used to UDS before to deduct root but after magisk v20 it did not have any problem and the developer said we will not going to have any problem with UDS any more!!
[Magisk] Bxperiaz3:
Hi guys . Having a little bother with my phone. Oneplus 7pro,running android 10 and latest magisk and twrp. I went to install a substratum lite systemui overlay and my phone went into a bootloop. I can still boot into twrp and my phone comes up on my pc with all my folders etc. I ran mm manager and disabled all magisk modules except mm but the phone still fails to boot. Could someone maybe point me in the right direction? First bootloop and its a little stressful. Thanks

Edit: turned on core only mode and still getting a bootloop. I'm really confused,seems like no matter what I do it wont start but the only changes I recently made were all modules I was able to disable with Magisk manager. Do i need to fully uninstall them instead?
[Magisk] J.Michael:
What is "substratum lite systemui overlay"? How did you install it?

How do you run Magisk Manager to disable modules if you can't boot?

I thought you would have to use TWRP to disable Magisk modules. I think you need to put a file with a name like ".disable" in a particular directory.
[Magisk] Bxperiaz3:
Substratum is a ui overlay manager. It comes up as a magisk module when i use TWRP. I can boot into recovery,just not system and from there I can disable all magisk modules. I'm thinking maybe substratum has caused the system crash
[Magisk] Lughnasadh:
Try deleting all Magisk mods (just in case it may be another mod besides or in addition to Substratum) in data>adb>modules from TWRP.
[Magisk] wilsonhlacerda:
Is EdXposed breaking SafetyNet in your device? If so, that's the cause. By removing EdXposed you pass SafetyNet and thus the bank app works.

If even with EdXposed SafetyNet is ok then that is not the problem for the bank app . So you can use for instance XprivacyLua and block the bank app access to installed apps and other things (take care with IDs, cause typically bank apps uses that to validate your identity/device/tokens) and that may help bypass its detection mechanism.
[Magisk] Bxperiaz3:
Just tried that and it doesnt seem to have worked. Still the same result. Guessing its not a Magisk module in that case? Is there anything else I could check? ive uninstalled/deleted everything i can think of. Still have full access through twrp or on my laptop, just cannot get it to boot. :(

Edit: just used a rescue zip that said it uninstalled all overlays and I'm still in a bootloop.
[Magisk] Lughnasadh:
I'm not familiar with your phone so the only other thing I can suggest is flash the Magisk uninstaller zip and see if that works. Maybe it's Magisk or the version you are using that's causing it.
[Magisk] Bxperiaz3:
Will I lose root if I do this? I'm a little out of my depth here as you can tell. I'm really hoping I don't have to do a full wipe and lose all my data. I have a backup but its from a month ago. The last thing I did today was install this system ui overlay and I haven't been able to restart it since.
[Magisk] Lughnasadh:
Yes, if you flash the Magisk uninstaller zip you will lose root. But if it does turn out to be the Magisk version you are using you can always go back to a known working version for your device and have root again.

It does sound like the Substratum system ui overlay you enabled did cause your problem, but disabling or deleting the Substratum module should have taken care of it, at least in my experience. But I would still flash the Magisk uninstaller zip or go to your device forum for more help since I don't know anything about your device.

EDIT: You can also try flashing the Substratum rescue zip as well.
[Magisk] sintoo:
Hi all. I tried all possible ways: A) patch boot.img then flash with TWRP. B) Flash magisk20.4 directly with TWRP C) Flash magisk18 directly with TWRP. Neither method worked, always resulting in bootloop right at the beginning of bootstrap (the logo "GalaxyTab10.1" stucks forever. "Android" Bootanimation never starts.

My question: Does anybody know which Magisk version works with Samsung Galaxy Tab 10.1, GT-P7500, on Lollipop5.1.1, AOSP (closest-to-Stock-4.0.4 but I need-and-want Android 5.x only, not 6+).

Anybody has a hunch of what version should I try ? Thank you all.
[Magisk] Bxperiaz3:
Thank you for your help. I did try the Substratum rescue zip but unfortunately it didnt work. I'll head over to the oneplus forum and ask. Thank you again
[Magisk] Lughnasadh:
Sorry I couldn't help. Good luck :good:
[Magisk] Eedo:
Hi buddy,

I was facing the same problem with banking apps (STC Pay, Alrajhi Mobile)

I found the Solution for that just change your Magisk to Magisk Canary & everything works like a charm ??

Here's the link for Magisk Canary:

https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/dev-magisk-canary-channel-bleeding-edge-t3839337/amp/

Please let me know when you done & hit the like if its work
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Check in /data/adb/post-fs-data.d and service.d if there are any boot scripts related to the module placed there. If so they aren't automatically affected by disabling the module or enabling Core Only Mode and need to be removed/disabled manually.

If there aren't any scripts related to the module there it sounds like the module did do something that messed with your device... A reflash of your system partition might help, but a wipe may be necessary. I would check with the module developer first though. They might have more insight, or have special instructions for how to remove the module.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHide#hn_SafetyNet
[Magisk] amk316:
thanks ... it work now

جزاك الله خير
[Magisk] Bxperiaz3:
Hi, so I managed to uninstall Magisk and it boots up just fine, however I tried to reinstall and then we go back to a bootloop. Is there any fix for this? I'd love to just be able to reflash magisk and keep all my data but i'm a bit out of my depth here.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
That probably mean that there is something active still. If you have disabled or uninstalled the module the most likely culprit is a boot script in post-fs-data.d or service.d (like I wrote earlier). Have you checked that?

Or did you do a complete uninstall of Magisk? If so you've got something else going on.

Providing a boot logcat might show something.
[Magisk] Bxperiaz3:
I did a complete uninstall of magisk. Boots up perfectly without root, back to bootloader to reinstall latest magisk and then it bootloops again. I'll try and get a boot logcat now

Edit: Do i need the log of it booting into a loop or booting to system?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Seeing a boot to a working system may of course be interesting for any kind of comparison that could be made, but the bootloop is what we are interested in here.
[Magisk] Bxperiaz3:
I understand. I wasnt sure if a working boot would still retain the information you needed about the bootloop. As you can see i'm a noob when it comes to rooting. I think I have the bootlog in this text file. I ran the adb bootlog and then hit reboot with the magisk 20.4 flashed. Please let me know if I did it correctly.
[Magisk] qkx:
Thanks working fine now :)
[Magisk] victorcabral:
I'm having a problem flashing magisk in project treble ROMs, the installation is always successful from TWRP but it stucks in the first boot.
[Magisk] Bxperiaz3:
Tried to dirty flash the same Rom as suggested in another thread and obviously I did something wrong and its stuck on the oneplus logo ,cant connect it to the laptop and I don't seem to have TWRP anymore. So now I have no idea what to do.
[Magisk] LeandritoG:
Accidentally I unticked the Google Play Services on hide list.

The Google Play Services wasn't all ticked.

Some items was selected by default because I never had made changes in it.

I clean the data of the Magisk Manager but the items ticked didn't come back.

Could you help me of what itens to select?

PS: 1 Item called supervisor, them 64 itens called supervisor.isolatted, 1 to 64, and then the last one called supervisor.probe...
[Magisk] anantharam:
Do you have any other better option for a name?

I guess the intention was to make it easily Googlable by using a lesser known word.
[Magisk] Nezorflame:
Yeah, it won't enable it on custom ROMs AFAIK. The intention is to not disable it by rooting and Xposed'ing on stock.
[Magisk] FPSUsername:
Is there a Uninstaller here as well? Seems like it isn't just a apk file to install
[Magisk] StephenSpig:
So just to clarify...

I have successfully re-flashed the boot image for my ROM (Stock, pre-systemless-rooted for LG V10), which removed SuperSu, I flashed the V1 and then the phh's SuperUser mod, and have confirmed that both root is present, and that I passed a SafetyNet check...

In order to regain xposed, do I simply re-flash the latest systemless Xposed?

Thanks!
[Magisk] garthybarthy:
Flashed fine here and working well except the magisk manager app keeps force closing, clearing data doesn't work.
[Magisk] stangri:
Kudos to [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION].

Q1: Can the new "Nexus Launcher" be magisk-ized so I can try it with the proper GNow support without modifying my /system?

Q2: I've looked inside the zips, there are only arm and x86 files, does it mean amr64 isn't supported or is it covered by the arm files?

Again, thanks for brilliant thinking/coding.
[Magisk] yousirname1:
For those of you experiencing crashing in magisk manager, you need to install https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=me.phh.superuser&hl=en
[Magisk] StephenSpig:
So... Everything is working fine... Except that I can't figure out how to get xposed back...
[Magisk] ShapeShifter499:
If I want to update or change BusyBox how do I do this? Seems it's installed to /data/busybox/busybox
[Magisk] hinxnz:
[MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] nice thread, looks interesting, you've been very busy by the looks :)

I thought I remembered the name... from sensation days