yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] soder:
OK, true. Just an old habit for me since I normally did that when I was going back to stock to apply OTA's

Flashing my ROM, doesn't that also flash boot.img? Do I then really need to run the uninstaller first? When I now look in the /magisk folder, there is only .core phh and xposed. Nothing SuperSu anylonger.

Well I only find magisk.log in /cache and there is nothing about SuperSu in that. Guess I'm all at phh's SuperUser then..

The reason I thought I didn't have to, was that in the older version, it told me to reboot. This never version didn't do that, and I thought that it might have something to do with the systemless version.

After disabling Xposed, rebooted, disabled root, still doesn't work for my apps. Now both crashes or just stop loading. Not just showing that loading screen for the app C More.

/Söder
[Magisk] dimka86:
Chainfire released 2.78 stable SuperSU version. Will there be a 2.78 magisk version soon so play market stops advising to update (when have many updates at a time must always abort update of su or update others manually, not so convenient). Thanks.
[Magisk] Artim_96:
You can just disable auto update for SuperSU, then it will ask you weather you want to update it when hitting "update all"
[Magisk] Tesla:
Sorry but no.

You have to provide more information for us to help you.

I suggest you read this thread and this: Magisk and Magisk Hide installation and troubleshooting tips and tricks

1. Phone model

2. Root?

3. ROM? Stock?

What have you done so far?
[Magisk] Wawax:
I have Nexus 5x root with magisk on pure Nexus rom but i dont have safetynet
[Magisk] Curious Boy:
Did Magisk have any kind of failsafe so you can disable it when bootloop then remove module that cause problem?

No need uninstall it all the time.
[Magisk] Tesla:
If you write to someone then press reply please.

Okey.

But did you have root before you installed magisk?

If so you have to unroot.

You have to tell us exactly what you have done with your phone.

1. Unroot.

2. Flash a Boot.img

3. Flash magisk

---------- Post added at 22:28 ---------- Previous post was at 22:25 ----------

This happen to you often?

How would that work if you bootloop?

Just uninstall magisk and use safe modules.

5 min tops.
[Magisk] Wawax:
Thanks you for all your help I success

Magisk work again I use your link to the other forum and it help me thank you for your beautiful help
[Magisk] Sc4ryB3ar:
On a 7.1.1 LOS based Rom, if we want to update the kernel, should we unmagisk, flash kernel, then re magisk? Or just flash the new kernel?
[Magisk] Tesla:
1. Flash kernel

2. Flash magisk.

Unless the kernel auto root.

Then do this.

1. Flash kernel

2. Flash https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=63615067

3. Flash magisk
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Like stated above, reflashinging Magisk is quite quick. You can also use the Mount Magisk script in recovery to remove the offending module: https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/collection-magisk-modules-v2-t3575758
[Magisk] lukeds:
Installed Magisk Manager v4.3.1 and installed Magisk v12.0 as I wanted to hide my root so I can use my banking apps which I've only selected my banking app so in theory it shouldn't hide my root for other apps right?

Wrong!

It was all working until I did the hide root thing, I'm highly confident that there's something wrong with the app and it shouldn't unroot my device so I'm not sure whether my phone is not rooted anymore or it's just hidden as SafetyNet passed in the manager so i really don't know. I now can't use root apps which is ridiculous. It says "Not Rooted Functionality greatly limited" and I try to undo the hide root thing in Magisk Manager and I can't find it in the app anymore ):

Really disappointed. Was so happy to be able to use my banking app but now it's just worse. Any suggestions as to why it's not working properly for me?

I'd happily use it again and support it but I need to be able to get use root for other apps and not just hide it from every app.

Running: My Galaxy S5 running Resurrection Remix Android 7
[Magisk] Artim_96:
Let me guess, you have Busybox enabled? It's written in FAQ that LOS based runs have problems with that.
[Magisk] Perseus:
No I do not pass. Magisk gives an error. However, I am on stock firmware for Nexus 6. No Custom Rom or Custom kernel. SEL is of course enforcing.

I was told that installing Roms that are not rooted such as Slim, were supposed to be the panacea for that issue. Is that not the case?
[Magisk] kyzn:
Happened to me too. Using 6P. A reboot usually solves it and the occasional CTS fail after rebooting. See my problem? I need to reboot to fix the high cpu use but that means CTS will fail until I reboot again, several times. :silly:

Although,an earlier post mentioned, stericson busy box could be the culprit of the CATS mismatch.
[Magisk] Curious Boy:
exam. Xposed could be disabled when bootloop using volume key.
[Magisk] kaotik123:
Hello I have got a rooted Z3 with custom rom and SupeSU installed. I wanted to install MagiskSU so I booted into recovery and flashed the MagiskSU zip (without unrooting) and now the phone won't turn on at all. I can't boot into recovery (by holding the power and volume down button) and I can't get anything to come up on the screen at all. No recharge symbol when plugged into charger either. Although do get the red LED blinking when charging. When I try to power on the phone I get the normal quick vibrate but that's it. Anyone have any suggestions? Thanks. I realized I should have unrooted before installing magisk but unfortunately too late now :(
[Magisk] Artim_96:
Go to your devices forum. Looks like a problem with hardware or firmware
[Magisk] Jaggle:
Can you get into download mode?
[Magisk] Tesla:
There have been a few reports of high cpu usage.

I think that happen to me. My cpu was more or less stuck at 1958MHz and i could not figure out way.

But then my favorite kernel-Dev released a few new kernels for us with SM-N910F to try out.

And of course i had to try them. You know how it is.

That ment that i not only changed kernel a couple of times, I did the whole shebang with unSU Script zip and Kernel Emergency Reset script and reinstalled Magisk 12 the same amount of times.

Then suddenly my high cpu usage was gone. I talked to my kernel-Dev and as far as we know it was not related to kernel.

Maybe this will help someone, maybe not. Just wanted to have it out here.
[Magisk] DvLAx3l:
I can't pass the safetynet even after full unroot, flash boot.img, boot without root!

What I've should do? Ask for a benediction from a priest? ?
[Magisk] djsubterrain:
[MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] Is there any way you can add the functionality to hide the fact that the phone has been unlocked? I'm using Magisk on Resurrection Remix rom and can hide the root so I can use Android Pay but my banking app (Bank of Scotland in the UK) still sees that the phone has an unlocked bootloader and won't let me use it.
[Magisk] broomer68:
Get another make/type of phone. Or try the original rom.

Verstuurd vanaf mijn ONEPLUS A3003 met Tapatalk
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
If your device has an unlocked bootloader it'll trigger SafetyNet.

Magisk Hide does this already. If it didn't you wouldn't pass SafetyNet...

How do you know it's the booloader that triggers the bank app? Does it explicitly state it?
[Magisk] moozer:
What worked for me was not reflashing boot.img, but flashing the entire ROM. Nothing unexpected happened other than Magisk accepting safetynet
[Magisk] djsubterrain:
My mistake, it specifically mentions the fact that the phone is "jailbroken/rooted", I'd show you a screenshot of the app but it also blocks taking a screenshot while it's displayed, I've tried adding the app to the list of "Magisk Hide" apps but it still detects the root.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
The app probably checks for certain prop values. The most usual suspect is ro.build.tags=test-keys (like most custom ROMs have). You can try this by changing it to ro.build.tags=release-keys instead with a boot script or a Magisk module (more info in the All-In-One wiki). Check the link in my signature for a few more "dangerous" prop values that you can try changing.
[Magisk] lukeds:
I can't disable it as I need root to do that apparantly. So what do I do now?

Edit: Figured it out now. Thank you, didn't see that part. Cheers
[Magisk] AndrOmega:
S7 Edge G935F here.

Rooted with CF AutoRoot.

All i have to do is install Magisk Manager from PlayStore and everything is done?
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
What features of Magisk are you going to use?
[Magisk] AndrOmega:
pokemon, mario, viper, etc all goodies.:p
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
In that case you'll need Magisk Hide and for that you need MagiskSU. If it's a systemless install of SuperSU you have you'll need to COMPLETELY remove it before flashing Magisk (in recovery).
[Magisk] AndrOmega:
thx for replying but i think is too complicated and is not sure 100 percent it will work so i'll stay with my super good configuration.

:highfive:
[Magisk] DvLAx3l:
Thanks to everyone who answered my questions, I'm trying another rom, if have any issue I'll let u know.

Thanks again!
[Magisk] biomech91:
I just installed Magisk V12 on my Note5 running the official Nougat ROM (clean install, no modifications done beforehand), and now I keep getting a notification that my Samsung account session has expired.

I've never experienced this before, an I had Magisk installed on a custom Nougat ROM just hours ago and had never gotten this notification. If I log in to my Samsung account, the notification just keeps coming back and I log out again.

Any ideas?
[Magisk] 12gage:
Hello, I just flashed a ROM that allowed me to utilize Magisk but it's very new to me. Is there a way to hide root with Magisk from certain apps that block rooted phones? I have Xposed installed but RootCloak doesn't seem to work, I tried checking Hide Magisk in the settings but no luck. I'm trying to use Vudu's disc to digital option, which seems to kick an error when root's detected. I got around this with RootCloak on my last ROM, I'm hoping there's an alternative. Thanks in advance.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
A quick Google search seems to point to this being a random Samsung issue. I wouldn't know though... I don't do Samsung.

Are you using MagiskSU? It's required for Magisk Hide to function properly. If you do, all you hopefully need to do is activate Magisk Hide and add your troublesome app to the Hide list. It might also be that your app uses other ways to detect a "compromised" device.

Check the link in my signature for more info.
[Magisk] biomech91:
I've owned multiple Samsung devices over the years, rooted them countless times, and this is the first time I've ever seen that notification. And it happened when I rebooted after installing Magisk.

I don't know, maybe it's just a bad coincidence.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Like I said, I wouldn't really know... But I just searched for "samsung account session expired" and got quite a few results. That usually points to it being a (relatively) common issue.
[Magisk] Jfelips:
I just installed magisk and everything was working fine, root and safetynet working too.

Then I installed xposed via magisk and activated one single module. Reboot. After that safetynet is not working anymore! What should I do? Remove the Xposed ?

Moto X Play(6.0.1)

Magisk v12.0
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
If you want to pass SafetyNet with Magisk, yes. Disable works as well.
[Magisk] 12gage:
I'm pretty sure I do, under status I have "properly rooted - 8:MAGISKSU (topjohnwu)", I went under "Magisk Hide" and activated Vudu, and under Settings I checked "Magisk Hide". Is there a step I'm missing? Thanks for your help
[Magisk] Jfelips:
So the only issue I have is the Xposed?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
You've got the prerequisites... You can check if your setup works by adding a root checker app to the Hide list and see if it detects root. If it doesn't, you're good. After that it's just a matter of finding out what else the app is looking for. Like I said, take a look in the link in my signature. I've collected a few tips on how to possibly get it running.

---------- Post added at 20:41 ---------- Previous post was at 20:38 ----------

If SafetyNet passed previously and the only thing you've changed since is installing Xposed, I'd say that's a pretty safe bet. Magisk can't hide Xposed and it doesn't matter if it's systemless.

Quoting the release thread troubleshooting section:
[Magisk] Jfelips:
It worked by just disabling and reboot. Thx for the advice.
[Magisk] 12gage:
I tried applying hide to my kernel app, it still gets SU permissions. I went through some of the troubleshooting tips. I toggled Hide, switched Hide off, rebooted, then turned Hide on, then tried the Terminal line "sh /magisk/.core/magiskhide/enable" but got this stating I don't have permission. Did I forget something?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Run the command as su?
[Magisk] 12gage:
Thank you, I'm dumb :) I got the daemon to start, but it's still allowing SU permissions on root apps that I test, and Vudu is still giving off an error.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Sounds like an incompatibility issue. Upload a Magisk log (verbose logging enabled).
[Magisk] 12gage:
I enabled verbose, I hope I did this correctly

https://drive.google.com/open?id=0B0TWavRo1LuUa3JZUW5HWkJhRXc
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Magisk Hide isn't unmounting anything. This comes up from time to time and I'm not sure how to fix... Another few things you could try:

Enable Core Only Mode.

Use a different kernel.

Wait for the next release and hope it gets fixed. :p

That last one you could help out with by uploading a copy of your boot image and your logs to a relevant issue on GitHub.

The unofficial beta snapshots doesn't seem to be working at the moment, but it could pay to keep an eye on those as well, if you don't want to wait.
[Magisk] tamer7:
Make sure logcat is enabled in kernel..

To make sure, run this from shell and paste output:

logcat -b events -v raw -s am_proc_start -t 10
[Magisk] 12gage:
I get "Unable to open log device 'events'" when I try to run that. Would AutoMagisk 1.1 help with this? Or is that obsolete now?
[Magisk] tamer7:
No. Magisk Process monitor won't work without logcat support.
[Magisk] 12gage:
Okay, I meant would AutoMagisk help with hiding root, or would ANRC (Xposed Mod) work? I sounds like Hide Magisk probably conflicts with my kernel which I can't change at the moment
[Magisk] Lownita:
So I'm new to magisk and was using SuperSU before. I've got some questions here. I think that the main goal of it is to modify the system partition without actually touching it. So would it still be possible to flash mods like modded YouTube apk or even v4a? Or does everything that would add or change something on the system partition require a magisk module? What exactly do these modules do?
[Magisk] 12gage:
I was able to get it to block a root requiring app after creating .phantom.log (read your post in the Phantom thread) ;) But I still can't get Vudu to work, I think it looks for Xposed as well, is there a way to Hide it like RootCloak did? I thought the fact that it was systemless would prevent it from being detected.
[Magisk] teddy0209:


---------- Post added at 12:29 AM ---------- Previous post was at 12:27 AM ----------

You sure can, but it needs to be a module if you want it systemless... V4A has an existing module.
[Magisk] SalmiakDragon:
Thanks for sharing. I tried using Magisk v11.6 instead, but I couldn't even get root permissions within Magisk Manager. I am now stuck with "Rooted but no permission".

Details:

Just to be safe, I

uninstalled Magisk

made sure I passed SafetyNet

flashed a clean boot image

performed a factory reset (wipe cache and data)

flashed a clean ROM

made sure I still pass SafetyNet

before installing Magisk v11.6.

After that, well ... a whole bunch of nothing.

Relevant apps:

Magisk Manager

Root Checker

SafetyNet Helper

Phone INFO Samsung

Titanium Backup

Result after reboot number:

I noticed "Set Warranty Bit: kernel" during boot-up

MM: still just a stub

RC: Root Not Correctly Installed

SNH: false,false

PI: Root Existence - Yes

TB: Could't get Root privileges

Opened MM and updated it (v4.3.1) from Play Store when prompted.

MM: Keeps checking for Magisk updates, No Root

MM: Keeps checking for Magisk updates, No Root, SafetyNet Failed

Other apps: No Change

No Change

No Change

Disabled USB-debugging and disconnected USB-cable.

No Change

Uninstalled MM.

Other apps: No Change

Other apps: No Change

Installed MM v4.2.6

MM: Magisk v12 available, Rooted but no permission, SafetyNet Failed

Other apps: No Change

No Change

(Disabled Autoupdate for MM in Play Store)

No Change

Cleared MM's data

No change

Cleared MM's data

No Change

Installed MM 4.2.7.

No change

No Change

No Change

If I can bring myself to give it another go, I'll probably try Magisk v11.1 unless someone has a better idea.
[Magisk] Tesla:
Sorry, i haven't followed all your post, but what happens if you try with just TWRP and stock ROM?

Start with full stock.
[Magisk] Pkt_Lnt:
Just wanted to say again, thank you. I just updated my Nexus 7-2013 from Pure Nexus 6.01 to Pure Nexus 7.1.1 tonight and used this module to get root access for Tasker. It works perfectly. I have not seen a reply from [MENTION=3290808]rignfool[/MENTION] if he has tried yet, but I wanted you to know. :highfive:
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
No. It doesn't matter that it's systemless. Magisk cannot hide Xposed.
[Magisk] kaotik123:
Yeah I was able to reflash stock firmware and reboot. However everytime I try and flash magisk through twrp it bricks my device and I have to reinstall the firmware and start again. Any suggestions? Its a z3 dual with locked bootloader.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Pure guesswork on my part, but this little tidbit from the release thread's troubleshooting section might have something to do with it:
[Magisk] JudgeDread11:
Hi all, this might have been asked already but I can't find the answer. The search terms are used in too many unrelated posts.

It might even be that is not a magisk problem but an Android problem.

I'm trying to install a zipped module from SD. But when I try to select the module the file manager opens it as a folder instead of selecting the zip file.

Did anybody have a solution for this?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
A Magisk Module zip? Install it through the Magisk Manager (under "Modules", the + at the bottom) or flash it in TWRP.
[Magisk] JudgeDread11:
I tried to install it through magisk manager, but then it opens the Android​ file manager in which I can't select the zip file because it opens it like a folder. Resurrection ROM. Android 7.1.

I found a work around. In Android filemanager I can choose fx file chooser (from FX filemanager) and there I can select the zip.
[Magisk] Timmmmaaahh!:
Hi all! Bringing this up through search. This S-PushTAN app is one tough cookie and I don't understand why it's failing to work with Magisk. What else is it detecting?? Logcat attached (is that helpful in this case?).
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Ok. Yes that sounds like an Android issue. I always use FX File chooser as well.

---------- Post added at 11:02 ---------- Previous post was at 10:19 ----------

Ha... That one, again. Yeah, it's been discussed a few times in this thread. I've had some success on getting it to run with Magisk by changing a few ro.build props to "safe" values (see the troubleshooting link in my signature) and if I remember correctly also adding Phone (com.android.phone) to the Hide list. I don't use it though so I was merely experimenting...

I believe [MENTION=5946138]tamer7[/MENTION] have been battling with that app for some time and had success by using an older version. Take a look at his post history...

Edit: I just tested again on my OnePlus 3T, OxygenOS 4.1.3, Franco Kernel, Magisk v12. Added only PushTan to the Hide list and it started right up. If it wasn't added to the Hide list it crashed straight away and opened the web page about a rooted device.
[Magisk] 093236:
You can long press the file and press the Open button at the top right corner in Android's file manager.
[Magisk] Curious Boy:
Magisk cause high temperature, high CPU usage. My phone is super hot and even cant full charge (>80%). I plug the phone and go to sleep about 4hr , its 4hr super hot and painful not only the phone but the charger too. The only magisk module installed is xposed so I try disable, uninstall it but still the same. I uninstall Magisk as final solution and it work. The problem does not occur right after installation but suddenly without any specific reasons.

p/s: Hope you can understand what I try to tell because of my bad English.
[Magisk] Darkem:
I just tried to install Magisk on my Axon 7. The problem is, if I only install Magisk, he says that there is root, but there are no root privilegs. If I install the superuser.zip, I have root, but Magisk denies every app that tries to get root access. Even when I set "always allow" he denies every. How can I use root without SuperSU with Magisk?

Thank you!
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
Go back to Magisk v11.6
[Magisk] ejay_gl:
I'm so stupid...

I have installed magisk on my Xperia Z1 Compact and i bricked my phone. I was in a hurry and i didn't read properly how to installed it. The requiments wasto have an unlocked bootloader and i have lockedbootloader....

Now my phone didn't start. After i flashed magisk from TWRP and i received a message that i have to install SuperUsr and i choose "no". After that my phone doesn't boot up anymore since yestarday.

I tried to power up with simultaneously pressing volume up and power button and is not vibrating. All i have is a red light when i press power button. First time when i pressed power button it has vibrated one time.

I have put the phone to a charger and the light is red and pulsing and the charger isn't warming.

In flashtool i get that the phone is disconnected and in fastboot mode i can't get in, when i pressed volume up and then i put the usb cable all i get is a red light not blue...

Should i unlock the bootloader? But how, because i can get neither in fastmode or bootloader mode...

If you guys know a solution to boot up my phone i will be so happy.

Thanks!
[Magisk] Jaggle:
Maybe one of you have the answer for me. I got Magisk v12 installed and it works. I can play Mario. But when I want to buy the whole game...it opens play store end then gives an error. Is there a workaround for that?
[Magisk] jhedfors:
Sorry, are you advising this because this a known issue that has been reported, and the dev already has all the information needed to fix the problem?

I may have missed something, but I am not sure how advising someone to roll-back helps the development of this application.
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
https://developer.sonymobile.com/open-devices/how-to-access-uart-ports-on-xperia-devices/
[Magisk] Tesla:
Maybe uninstall Magisk, pay for game, install Magisk.

I don't know this game "Mario"
[Magisk] Jaggle:
I mean Mario run. It doesn't run on a rooted phone, but Magisk does the magic except for play store when you try to buy the game

Edit: I got it working now
[Magisk] Tesla:
Good :)

Can you share how?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
I'm gonna guess it had something to do with "Device certification" in Play store settings. Am I right?

If "Device certification" reports uncertified some apps in the Play store won't install or even show up. The solution, I've found, is to make sure your device passes SafetyNet and then clear data for the Play store. That way it'll show that your device is certified again.
[Magisk] Jaggle:
Well I don't know what I did, but somewhere in the settings I checked Mario and Play store. And when I looked in the playstore at installed apps I saw Mario. Didn't changed that much.

Later this evening I'm going to check if I get it working with Fr33d0m ?
[Magisk] andrew2432:
Nice this fixed other compatibility issues unrelated to pgo ad Mario run on my lg, id been using apks :'( that's crazy haha
[Magisk] JimSmith94:
Wow, thanks! This worked for me too on my TMO Pixel XL on 7.1.2.
[Magisk] :
Bit of spring cleaning guys, Can we not discuss banned apks/warez on the boards please guys

Thanks for understanding

Sawdoctor