yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Xposed triggers SafetyNet, yes. Magisk works fine with Xposed, but Magisk Hide can't hide Xposed.

Battery drain isn't a subjective thing... Use BetterBatteryStats or something similar to measure if your battery drains faster than expected and to find what app or service is causing the issue (if there is one). I've not experienced any increased battery drain as a result of using Magisk on three devices.

Recovery log where it shows the error would be useful.

Still at it? You're gonna have to do some work yourself dude... This isn't a modules request forum...
[Magisk] :
If any of you guys experience battery drain, check your CPU usage from developer options. V12 made magiskhide clock at maximum all the time, not sure why. The issue is in github now, but do open one up as well with the logs and stuff.
[Magisk] Pekempy:
SystemUI seems to be freezing a lot in Android O. Updated last night and had constant freezes until I uninstalled Magisk. Tried with SuperSU and phhs superuser.

It doesn't crash/FC, just totally freezes my device until I reboot.

Any help would be appreciated.

(Fully clean stock ROM Nexus 6P Android O DP2)
[Magisk] karthik km:
Here saftynet failed

As usual CTS profiles mismatch

BTW I'm not asking any suggestion/solutions for this

But one thing is not clear

Pokémon go is running fine

I'm on Tesla 7.1.1 ROM

Magisk V 12

Yes of course I've turned on magisk hide
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
That means Magisk Hide is doing it's job and you're passing SafetyNet's basic integrity (device side check). PoGo doesn't use the full SafetyNet API. CTS profile mismatch (server side check) means that something about your device isn't recognised by Google as a certified device (most likely your ROM).
[Magisk] Doc Franky B.:
First, thx for your help Didgeridoohan

To point 1: Magisk disabled..

Can't toggle to permessive

To point 2:

Can't toggle to permessive

To point 3:

Can't toggle to permessive

I tested even without Xposed, also didn't work.

I tested an other kernel which was on permissive, but then I can't toggle to enforcing.

Now I'm on pure stock without su, busybox and xposed installed. (dirty flashed)

Is there a way to test the selinux state without any root?

I think I have to live with it.

If it's now the wrong place for my question, let me now [emoji6]

Edit : damn forget point 4

To Point4: yourfile.txt is the two lines from the fix for 11.6 (@jhedfors)

"chmod 640 /sys/fs/selinux/enforce

chmod 440 /sys/fs/selinux/policy"

Send from Note4 - 6.0.1
[Magisk] jonakin:
I've been having issues with Magisk 12.0 and losing root. I actually thought it might have had something to do with using SuperSU in the past, so I wiped and flashed everything from scratch, only for the problem to return.

I think it might be related to Bluetooth functionality, because everything was working just fine until I turned it back on, and then suddenly nothing could request root anymore, including the Magisk app (with the message about rooted but limited functionality). If I disabled Bluetooth and rebooted, root came back... but not if I didn't disable Bluetooth first.

Is this a known issue or bug? The most recent post I saw about this didn't seem to get a reply. I'm on a Verizon Nexus 6 (shamu) with LineageOS 3/31 nightly and flashed Magisk 12.0
[Magisk] biggdevon:
I was wondering if it would be possible to create a module to implement more reboot options(recovery, bootloader, etc). I'm not knowledgeable enough to know how deep of a modification that is and whether it can be done systemless-ly or not. If someone could clarify I might try my hand at module creation. Thanks
[Magisk] teddy0209:
Try reinstalling magisk, then reboot twice after install... just reboot, don't do anything in between, see if it helps...

---------- Post added at 06:32 PM ---------- Previous post was at 06:26 PM ----------

I think yes, by replacing a file systemlessly with a modified one, but it would be device specific...
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
If it doesn't work even with no Magisk installed it's not a Magisk issue... You don't need su to run the getenforce command in terminal.

Have you tried disabling Magisk built-in Busybox in the Manager? LineageOS has been known to have this issue if Busybox is enabled.

Don't know about the Bluetooth thing... If you can reproduce that while running a logcat it might be useful. If you happen to not be sure how to catch a logcat, look here.
[Magisk] 01000010:
Magisk has stopped hiding itself from my internet banking app.

(I was using beta7, now I updated to version 12)

Perhaps Safetynet has been updated?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
SafetyNet hasn't ben updated (passing right here with v12). Have you made sure Magisk Hide has started properly on boot? You can see if it has in the logs. If it hasn't toggle hide off and on and reboot, possibly twice. Of course, there might be other issues as well...
[Magisk] biggdevon:
Thank you, I'll do some searching then. Anyone with some experience creating modules and/or knows what file I need to track down that's willing to give me some incite would be appreciated.
[Magisk] soder:
I need some help from you guys.

I've been using Magisk on my OP3T some some time now, and got no problem at all. Every new update from my phone I just reflashed Magisk and it has worked well. I got some mods installed from Magisk manager itself and some installed from somewhere else. One mode I use to just add more files to the /system (more than the mod itself).

Right now I was on Magisk v12, and what I did was to change a framework-res.apk I had added to /system with help from Magisk, by adding the new apk when I was booted (in the magisk folder, not direct in /system/framework.

The problem is that the .apk wasn't working, and the phone will not boot. If I reflash my ROM .zip and not Magisk it boots.

Soo, I wonder how I can get to the Magisk stuff, and remove that .apk, but I would love to keep all the other Magisk mods. I would like to get to that stuff that usually in /root/Magisk when the phone is booted.

Thanks.

/Söder
[Magisk] biggdevon:
Download MagiskMount.zip from the OP and flash from recovery, don't reboot. That will give you access to the files through recovery

Sorry mountmagisk.zip is here https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/collection-magisk-modules-v2-t3575758/post71501349
[Magisk] 01000010:
That's very strange, I have just activated high logghing and rebooted and now Magisk hide works again...

:D
[Magisk] XDANexusAnx:
Magisk

Safety Net passes without Magisk but when I flash magisk it didn't work, I tried wiping and re-flashing but it didn't work. However, I disabled systemless hosts and now safety passes? I'm running Magisk v12 on my Nexus 6P with the latest Pure Nexus ROM. Enabling systemless hosts again fails safety net.

Wondering if i could enable systemless hosts without safety net failing

log of magisk pastebin UwcBPZNU
[Magisk] soder:
And after that? Flash ROM and then Magisk?

I'm looking for the file.... Couldn't see it as an attachment though..

/Söder
[Magisk] biggdevon:
If you're just looking to get rid of the file flashing that file should give you access to the magisk directories from within your recovery file manager. Just navigate to the Magisk folder most likely /data/magisk or similar and find/delete your problematic files
[Magisk] Citizen_Snips:
I'd ask Beans in his thread, maybe? I'm on Vanilla ROM and SafetyNet passes with hide, BusyBox and systemless hosts enabled. Besides, you're at least the 3rd person to have this same issue on the same phone & ROM combo in the last 5 pages or so. ROM related.
[Magisk] bushwakko:
Here's the log from magiskhide, dnb is the so that just quits on start-up:
[Magisk] XDANexusAnx:
alright thanks mate
[Magisk] soder:
Worked great.

Now I only need to find a working modded framework-res.apk from beta4. ;)

Thanks.

/Söder
[Magisk] ethanhunt123:
I know how this must sound.....

So everything was working until today. As far as I can tell nothing has changed on the phone (nexus 6) but all of a sudden Magisk Manger is saying... Installed (core mode only), but not rooted. I tried flashing it again... no go....

I tried running the uninstaller... and reinstalling v12, and that worked, but it still says that the device is not rooted (also passes safteynet?)... what am I missing here?
[Magisk] manalicream:
Anyone else having force crashes with Titanium Backup?
[Magisk] edoardotavecchio:
Nope I use it like every 1-2 days and I've never experienced any bug
[Magisk] manalicream:
Weird I simply cannot get it to run. I'm on pure Nexus BTW. Any other alternatives to titanium worth trying?
[Magisk] teddy0209:
If I remember it correctly, that's one of the file that needs modification, the framework-res.apk the guy above is trying to replace... It's been a long time since I did modification myself(nexus 7 days). I think you could start by searching advance reboot option or guide...
[Magisk] Artim_96:
Known issue because of Googles app verification. Go into the for settings app, security, app verification and turn off both. Then go to developer options and disable verify apps over USB
[Magisk] culiacanazo:
Logs

---------- Post added at 11:41 PM ---------- Previous post was at 11:40 PM ----------

Neither am I
[Magisk] manalicream:
Still not working
[Magisk] HamsterHam:
Anyone passing safetynet on 7.1.2 on Angler?
[Magisk] Artim_96:
Strange. For me it's not Titanium but chrome dev and snapchat. But that can have any kind of reason
[Magisk] stephendt0:
Attached are the Logs from my Lenovo K3 Note. I attempted to flash the uninstaller zip here. Any suggestions to get my phone to boot again would be appreciated :)
[Magisk] culiacanazo:
Is your recovery up to date?
[Magisk] stephendt0:
TWRP 3.0.2.3. Should I try to find a TWRP 3.1.0.0 build?
[Magisk] culiacanazo:
I'll zip it, you're more updated than i knew it could be possible, I'm on 3.0.2 even

Edit: i meant 3.1.0

Edit 2: What I'm all confused, yes, you should
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
The issue is that your boot image's ramdisk is in an unknown format for the uninstaller.

You could try extracting the boot image from your ROM and flash it in TWRP. That should get you up and running again.
[Magisk] SaibalManna:
I am using Tesla 3.6 (Ported Custom Rom) in my Lenevo A6000 (8GB) rooted through Magisk v12, phone rooted successfully but failed to pass Safetynet.
[Magisk] Shen Ron:
Magisk v 12.0 no root and failed xposed

I am still unable to use magisk version 12.0, every time I install it I lose root permission when my phone(Samsung Galaxy On5) reboots and even if I don't reboot Exposed Framework suddenly goes missing even though I still see the files and the modules are still active. But my phone is no longer allowing r/w permissions for anything unless I go to recovery and enable it which is only temporary as well.
[Magisk] gtpy:
I use v12 on my Xperia z3 compact with root, UB, stock based.

All works great.

Thanks a lot for your development
[Magisk] markm94:
Cannot check safteynet, No internet?

Has anyone run into an issue with safety net it says "Cannot check safteynet, No internet?" any help will be much appreciated.
[Magisk] purpse:
Does anyone know if Magisk works on Nexus 5X running new 7.1.2 stock rom?
[Magisk] stephendt0:
Thank you. I have an old TWRP backup so I might just restore just the boot partition and hopefully that should do it.
[Magisk] edoardotavecchio:
I don't know I'm sorry, I'm using Titanium Backup since my Ice Cream Sandwich days
[Magisk] tech_head:
SafetyNet passing on Nexus 6P running 7.1.2 stock with ElementalX.
[Magisk] HamsterHam:
Interesting. I can't pass but on 7.1.2. I'll try a different kernel.
[Magisk] Citizen_Snips:
On the 6P the kernel runs checks to see if the bootloader is unlocked and if it shows that's the case, you won't pass SafetyNet. EX and several other kernels have this check removed, so that's why they're able to pass and you're not. EX kernel and Flash kernel are 2 that I know have the checks removed, but I'm sure most if not all do as well.
[Magisk] HamsterHam:
I'm running ABC ROM (7.1.2) and it has the bootloader check removed as well. I just got it to work by toggling magisk hide off and FC magisk manager, turning it back on.

Seems like it doesn't pass on boot for some reason anymore.
[Magisk] mobileman88:
Passes for me with both EX 4.07 and also Flash R50. Either way, it's working fine and AP payments succeeds.
[Magisk] czecx:
Sorry for the stupid question , liveboot works with magisk or not? I have tried v1.30 (zip module) but nothing works. I run 7.1.1 on my Nexus 5x.
[Magisk] Artim_96:
Search for Magisk modules, you'll find a thread where you can get a module for that. Otherwise try to build your own.

But all in all, Liveboot was only meant to work with SuperSU
[Magisk] dreamland2000:
Just out of interest has anyone got this to work with the Dev preview of android O?
[Magisk] czecx:
Not supported yet.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Symlink /magisk/.core/post-fs-data.d to /system/etc/init.d and it'll work (the actual Liveboot app, not a Magisk module). You'll only have to do this when you want to set it up, make changes to settings or uninstall, so it's enough to do it with a temporary symlink through a file manager with root capabilities or through terminal.

Edit: This works with MagiskSU.
[Magisk] teddy0209:
Use supersu to use liveboot, it's closed source and a cause of drama in the past, so I doubt the module will be updated...???
[Magisk] dreamland2000:
Didn't think it would but but just wondered as i saw chainfire has done a SuperSU beta for android O that has some success.
[Magisk] atarek:
Functionality greatly limited

Hello,

I've note 3 n9005 running darklord reborn v 4 with phantom kernel 1.2f-dev version.

When i was using default magisk v 11.1 installed with rom i faced no issues when update to version 11.6 & v 12.0 also with systmless xposed framework installed or not when check hide magisk then run safety check after failure i press unhide magisk then open magisk manager again after a while i found attached screen shot.

any advise will be appreciated .

PS: i update magisk through this steps:

*Using twrp 2.8.7.0 i flash magisk uninstaller

*reflash kernel

*flash magisk update (11.6 or 12.0)

*restart device.

*when i open app require permissions after issue reported it's says app granted su permissions successfully so it seems root working probably but magisk manager couldn't detect it .
[Magisk] HamsterHam:
Do you have any ideas I can try? It was fine on 7.1.1. :confused::(
[Magisk] teddy0209:
Johnwu just bought a new nexus so maybe soon... ?
[Magisk] Sandiramogan:
Need help with Magisk v12 installation

Hi Guys,

I have been trying to flash Magisk v12 on my S7 edge (sm-g935fd) without super su, in hopes of using Magisk Su but I keep receiving ERROR: 1 in TWRP when it is trying to mount SU.

I am using a stock Rom and have performed a clean wipe in TWRP, but still cannot get Magisk v12 zip to install without the error 1 message. Appreciate it very much if someone can enlighten me on how to over come this issue.

Thank you very much
[Magisk] HamsterHam:
So further investigation, magiskhide works after numerous toggles only and I can see that from the logs. It won't do the unmounted part which is odd.

Any ideas why this has only just happened since flashing 7.1.2?

I am having to use this workaround for now "Current workaround is to turn Hide off, reboot, and then turn it back on after boot." and even that sometimes isn't working.
[Magisk] mobileman88:
It could be due to an unclean removal of Magisk and other SU in your phone. Run the latest MAgisk removal 0320 and also the latest unsu.zip then start over again. Also flash over the stock boot.img just to be safe. I used to have such intermittent problems till I did the steps above.
[Magisk] markm94:
safteynet issue on OP3

Good Morning,

I'm running into an issue getting Magisk running on my OP3. Everything passes except for safteynet which says "Cannot check safteynet, No internet?" Any help or recommendations are much appreciated
[Magisk] HamsterHam:
Tried this. Same issue. Magiskhide stops before doing the unmount.
[Magisk] kyzn:
Yeah. Magisk has been weird for me as well since v12. It worked. It doesn't work. It works and then it doesn't again. Varies from one clean install to the next of the same ROM/kernel/apps combo in the span of several hours.
[Magisk] HamsterHam:
Yeah, I have the same exact combo apart from updating my ROM as it is now 7.1.2. :confused: someone else on that ROM has no issues. So frustrating.
[Magisk] kyzn:
And look here. It's now working for me. :laugh:

I failed SafetyNet all day.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Don't cross post... It just leads to confusion...

I answered your other post, but feel free to post your logs here instead (this thread is a better place for it).
[Magisk] HamsterHam:
Strange! Screenshot your log please.

Reboot, does it still work?
[Magisk] adewisman:
try this be sure you have a working init.d.

edit : its for arm7 only!!!
[Magisk] Plabon7:
Rooted but no root privileges.. Why??:eek:
[Magisk] Artim_96:
Do you have any firewalls or ad blocking apps? Already tried with apps like SafetyNet helper?
[Magisk] biggdevon:
Can someone using Magisk that has Android Pay working check these values and report back? I'm doing some digging in hopes of regaining my ability to use it after root. Thanks in advance.

ro.config.knox=

ro.config.tima=

ro.config.timaversion=
[Magisk] SimplyCity:
I do have AP working, Magisk 12, S7E, Echoerom v11, AEL kernel v5.2

1. [v30]

2. [0]

3. [3.0]

:)

Echoe™ team number / S7E
[Magisk] android_htc:
Galaxy Note 4, stock ROM

ro.config.knox=v30

ro.config.tima=1

ro.config.timaversion=3.0
[Magisk] gk1984:
Had this happen to me with Magisk V12 after flashing the ARISE sound mod. Turns out, enabling BusyBox in the Magisk settings caused this. Had to restore my rom to before flashing ARISE, disable BusyBox, then I could flash it. I hope this clues you in to a solution. Not sure what your setup is.

---------- Post added at 07:58 PM ---------- Previous post was at 07:54 PM ----------

I'm curious as to whether Magisk has addressed large mods being compatible. I use the ARISE sound mod which can take over 100MB (I think they recommend 300MB) of space. Some months ago, they tried building a Magisk module out if it and ran into problems, sounded like it was too large for Magisk. With the updating to Magisk that has occurred recently, can large mods like this finally be converted into a working module? If so, I don't think anyone in the ARISE thread is aware.
[Magisk] HamsterHam:
Fixed magiskhide by not enabling busy box in magisk settings!
[Magisk] Artim_96:
Wow. Because that wasn't recommended anyway in the last release note...
[Magisk] HamsterHam:
Where does it say that?
[Magisk] Artim_96:
In the release note

EDIT: in the updated FAQ to be precise
[Magisk] cloudx720:
Uninstalling magisk on oos beta 13 gave me a bad time lol phone restarted and died, would not boot up. After getting into twrp i flashed magisk again and it worked fine.
[Magisk] HamsterHam:
Quote me which bit says it affects magiskhide. I can't see it.

---------- Post added at 11:22 PM ---------- Previous post was at 11:00 PM ----------

Not trying to be difficult but I can see it says about losing root not magiskhide not working.

Could you link me what you're reading so I know for future. Thanks.
[Magisk] culiacanazo:
I think he means "why didn't they suggest so in the blah blah blah"... I'm an esl teacher
[Magisk] HamsterHam:
Oh, lol. Thought he was being sarcastic haha.
[Magisk] Maxxxel:
I have 2 problems. My Magisk Manager often says I'm unroofed but i have root privileges on apps. After reflashing Magisk i see root status again but it disappears after some time.

The other problem is that i have an app that won't work with root so i tried Magisk hide bur app still says I'm rooted. I tried Magisk hide with root checker and it says I'm not rooted.
[Magisk] tejaskadaskar:
1. If you have toggled on enable busybox in settings then plz toggle it off. You wont lose root.Plz let us know if this works.
[Magisk] kyzn:
Yes and yes.
[Magisk] sonysingh1983:
Anyone tried installing viper4android through the module?

I tried it on v11.1 and 11.6 but kept getting bootlooped on nexus 6p. Was wondering if anyone tried on the new version.
[Magisk] kopitalk:
Get the one by ahrion. Works like magisk.

https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/module-viper4android-fx-2-5-0-5-t3577058/post71533072
[Magisk] SaibalManna:
Magisk not passed safetynet in Tesla 3.7 (Ported custom ROM for Lenevo A6000).
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Many apps look for more things than just root. Try some of the tips here:

https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/magisk-magisk-hide-troubleshooting-tips-t3561828
[Magisk] sss2sssss:
How do you manage to play Fate/GO with Magisk installed?

Now I'm using custom ROM with Magisk installed. just thinking how to play Fate/GO in this setup
[Magisk] gil80:
Hi all.

I was using till now SuperSU.

I just installed Magisk.

If root is not enabled, I pass SafetyNet.

When I enable root, but use the hide option for some apps, they still see me as rooted.

For this test, I hide root from Titanium Backup. But this app still gets root access.

When I select an app to hide from root, should I reboot the phone after this?
[Magisk] Clandaries:
Magisk Hide 12.0 not working with my bankingsoftware HVB Banking... G935F.

Greetings
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Unless you completely removed SuperSU before installing Magisk you're out of luck. You need MagiskSU for Hide to fully function.

Good to know.
[Magisk] Futurehope:
Error code 1 happens when I use Magisk v12 but it doesn't happen when I use Magisk v11.1.

Btw after FGO updated none of these matters anyway as it detects root and prompt error code 60 even with Magisk hide enabled.
[Magisk] gil80:
Does this screenshot confirms I have MagiskSU properly installed?

How can I be sure I have totally removed SuperSU?
[Magisk] Maxxxel:
Busy box is always off

---------- Post added at 08:55 AM ---------- Previous post was at 08:06 AM ----------

Weird stuff going on.... Magisk says rooted even after multiple reflashing but now app gets root anymore, and i haven't changed a thing.
[Magisk] chjun90:
Is that now magisksu of magisk v12 has permissions to modify the system partition？If so, how to prevent it？
[Magisk] tag68:
chjun90, your question is good. I'd like to have a mount rw,system to ask me if it should be allowed (I'd usually deny), similar and extending requesting root rights. Is that possible and in the scope of MagiskSU?
[Magisk] teddy0209:
As far as I know you can increase the size of /magisk...
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Yes, you have MagiskSU properly installed. And you pass SafetyNet.

I'm not sure I fully understand the problem, the way you've worded it... You have problems using Magisk Hide, I think.

Could you clarify and also post a Magisk log (with verbose logging enabled), please?
[Magisk] xd4d3v:
hi all, i'm attempting a simple module to change build prop product name.

any ideas why it's not working?

thanks
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Looks ok except that you're using an old module template. Depending on what's not working (no details given) that could be the problem.

Latest template can always be found here:

https://github.com/topjohnwu/magisk-module-template
[Magisk] manalicream:
Managed to get titanium backup to boot using Magisk hide but now get stuck on this loop after renabling and granting su. Any thoughts?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Why are you using Magisk Hide on TiBu?
[Magisk] manalicream:
Because previously the app wouldn't boot at all. So I found by hiding it it would boot. It is now stuck in this other loop now that I've made it visible and given su rights
[Magisk] Joloxx9:
Has anyone been able to use new tsb bank app while. Using Magisk?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Well... It obviously didn't fix anything. The underlying issue probably still remains and that's why you keep having problems.

Have you tried starting from scratch? If not, so it in increments. First trying to uninstall and reinstalling the app, then Magisk and if that doesn't work, try doing a clean install of your ROM.

I've used TiBu without issues on Pure Nexus on my Nexus 6...
[Magisk] manalicream:
I have only had this problem since using Magisk