yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] arrrgh:
Folder is just named "MagiskManager" and should be in /sdcard (where you see the other Download, Music, etc. folders).
[Magisk] Fif_:
[MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION], I'd like to make a few Xposed experiments.

However, I cannot find the sources/GitHub repo for Xposed 87.3.
[Magisk] Pixelhouse:
So this is the 2nd time im trying to install a module i downloaded outside Magisk.

And the 2nd time i get

blabla

"Unable to extract zip file!"

"failed!"

This is on a OnePlus 5 with latest TWRP and latest Magisk.

Hope someone can help me out, thanks in advance.
[Magisk] kkube:
On Moto Z Play 7.1.1

When ever I try to download any module via magisk manager, it downloads and installs without any problem. However the module section states no module found.

Happens with every module.

Any solution?
[Magisk] lalitjoshi06:
Using miui rom and root beer app detect rw path.

Is there any cmd or solution for this.

Pls help.
[Magisk] ä½ ä¸«ä¸«:
Have someone flash magisk14 by dual boot succeed?
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
It uses PurifyOS' Xposed sources: https://xdaforums.com/xposed/xposed-android-nougat-sdk-25-arm64-t3639221
[Magisk] Fif_:
Yeah, but he patched it, notably to look into /xposed.prop.

I'd like to build Xposed with his patches.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
They're in the repo:

https://github.com/Magisk-Modules-Repo

But it does work when installing from the Downloads section of the Manager?

A complete uninstall and reinstall of Magisk and the Manager might work...

Logs or it didn't happen. But, having said that... Doesn't the Moto Z have the faulty f2fs implementation (you won't be able to write to the Magisk image, hence no modules)? If that's the case a new kernel that has this fixed might work.
[Magisk] czupakabra:
I have p9 lite VNS-L21 kernel stock and on android 6 SafetyNet worked on MagiskSU v12, v13,3, v14. Now I have Android 7, exactly the same settings and SafetyNet does not work. Please help
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
If you haven't already, take a look here:

https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/guide-magisk-troubleshooting-t3641417

Or you could just go straight for the Universal SafetyNet fix module and give that a shot.

OT: mythical goat-sucking monster, eh? :laugh:
[Magisk] Shriac:
I am on Magisk v14 galaxy S6, with viper with audiolib, busybox and deep buffer remover modules. I keep loosing root randomly. restart fixes it.
[Magisk] mayur.3.92:
[MENTION=4667597]Didgeridoohan[/MENTION] / [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] I have v14 magisk installed and everything went good as well.

However after a reboot i noticed that magisk shows NO ROOT error and none of the root granted apps have root access. any idea what is the issue here ?

Please note that after first install everything was good untill a reboot

Details : Oneplus 5 on Official Lineage OS Rom.

Let me know on which logs you might need to help solve this issue.
[Magisk] prown:
Anyone here passed safetynet with new miui global stable 8.5.3.0?
[Magisk] darkeyes22:
I want to relock my bootloader and (probably) get my warranty back. Can I use Magisk by patching a boot image through Magisk Manager with locked bootloader?
[Magisk] DeathHacker:
No. The point of a locked bootloader is that only the original boot image is allowed to boot.

If you change it yourself (such as with Magisk), it will refuse to boot.
[Magisk] darkeyes22:
Okay, thanks!
[Magisk] Fif_:
That's the repo for the compiled modules.

I'm looking for the source code for the Xposed module.
[Magisk] kallekula33:
Hi, totally new to Magisk so please bear with me and perhaps my dumb questions.

I installed the Magisk application (v14) but the modules section is completely empty.

Is that supposed to be that ? Or how do I get the module part populated?
[Magisk] Ibuprophen:
Are you able to provide a screenshot that reflects this?

Sometimes, in certain circumstances, seeing is believing... :)

I just took a quote from Peter Pan... I have no intentions of stating that nobody believes you LOL!

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

I DO NOT PROVIDE SUPPORT VIA PM UNLESS ASKED/REQUESTED BY MYSELF.

PLEASE KEEP IT IN THE THREADS WHERE EVERYONE CAN SHARE
[Magisk] moordi:
Have you checked the download section? Until you download a module, the modules section will be empty.
[Magisk] RandomPooka:
The modules section WILL be empty until you install some.

The Download section is where you can find them to install.
[Magisk] gudenau:
I'm sorry, the other fourms I use it is customary to update the original post with the latest versions of software. My mistake to assume that happens here as well.
[Magisk] lcsd:
MagiskSU UI apk force closing after upgrade to OP3T OOS_B15. Cat log attached.

--

--

EDIT: SOLVED clearing Magisk Manager cache and data.
[Magisk] mayur.3.92:
Any suggestions anyone?
[Magisk] Pkt_Lnt:
Did you read [MENTION=4667597]Didgeridoohan[/MENTION] 's Troubleshooting guide, and the part about random losing root?

https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/guide-magisk-troubleshooting-t3641417
[Magisk] jenslody:
As far as I know it's done manually (e.g. a hexeditor works fine), I also did this myself for testing.

Both are binary identical (except for the path to xposed.prop) and that's (almost) impossiible, if they are both build from sources on different build-systems.
[Magisk] kkube:
Thanks for that. Did not know that I had to flash a custom kernel with f2fs fix.

EDIT - Just did some tinkering and found that f2fs was patched in march update by motorola and I am on august update.
[Magisk] kaitozaki:
Yes and no... Without custom but the tv does not have fastboot... There is no way to connect the tv via cable... Only adb... Would it still work? To install a zip instead of a apk...
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
If you have no custom recovery and no way of flashing a patched boot image to your device, then Magisk is a no-go.
[Magisk] kaitozaki:
http://www.nairaland.com/2351005/how-set-up-run-fastboot

This website may have an answer... Will try it when im free...
[Magisk] haybill:
Sorry if this has been covered already- I did search but found nothing.

After installing an app to backup my EFS (it was Dr. Ketan Note 4 version) Magisk Manager (v.5.30, and Magisk v.14) cannot access the internet- my device has internet and everything else can access internet- but, since Magisk Manager cannot, that means it cannot check for updates, not can it show any modules available for download.

I've uninstalled both Magisk Root and the Manager app, and wiped Dalvick/ Cache, and reflashed v.14 in TWRP, and although it grants Root Permission to apps that require Root, it cannot access the internet itself.

My only thought is to uninstall and remove Root again, and reflash my ROM( Alexandr Dev Base for N910F, which includes Magisk v.13.3 at installation) in the hope that whatever is broken gets fixed.

Any better ideas?

Incidentally--the Dr. ketan App, did not seem to want to install, could not be opened, and all in all acted strange--so, I fear that this did not play nicely with Magisk, because I am sure that Magisk was able to access the internet before trying to install the Dr.Ketan app [ don't get me wrong--I'm not saying anything bad about the good Doctor, only that my device did not like the app, while I was using Magisk Root]
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
That requires an already rooted device. If you've already rooted it, it might be easier to try something like Flashfire.
[Magisk] qiurigao:
Hello, my phone is Android 6.0, I use TWRP successful installation v14 version, the system can not start, the phone in the boot logo interface, and every 6 seconds to restart once, I was lucky to get a valuable boot log (It is not easy, because adbd process did not start, logcat did not run) log show magisk started (init: starting service 'magisk_pfs' ...init: Starting service 'logd'....�b38&�init: Starting service 'magisk_pfs'...�i�5$�logd.auditd: start�5(�logd.klogd: 5193015153J><,�SELinux: 2048 avtab hash slots, 16104 rules.��><,�SELinux: 2048 avtab hash slots, 16104 rules.��>TB�SELinux: 1 users, 2 roles, 1010 types, 0 bools, 1 sens, 1024 catse&�>4!�SELinux: 87 classes, 16104 rules%��>\K�SELinux: Permission audit_read in class capability2 not defined in policy.u��>TA�SELinux: the above unknown classes and permissions will be denied��]@\L�type=1403 audit(2528364.549:4): policy loaded auid=4294967295 ses=4294967295Ҿ�@\L&Unable to handle kernel NULL pointer dereference at virtual address 00000000O�@ &pgd = ea0700002�@("[00000000] *pgd=00000000��@<,Internal error: Oops: 5 [#1] PREEMPT SMP ARM�-�@$�Modules linked in:#S�@`N�CPU: 1 PID: 363 Comm: magisk Tainted: G W 3.18.24-perf-g53d8be1 #1%k�@@-�task: edb24780 ti: ea05e000 task.ti: ea05e000v��@,�PC is at m_show+0x324/0x6cc0@D1�LR is at klist_iter_init_node.part.0+0x618/0x2dd0ځ@tc�pc : [<c02291ec>] lr : [<c0bd6c08>] psr: 200f0013

sp : ea05fecc ip : 0000001c fp : ee00d740�@<+�r10: 00000000 r9 : 00000021 r8 : 00000040(�@L:�r7 : 00000021 r6 : c1411c88 r5 : 00000090 r4 : 00000090�@L:�r3 : 00000000 r2 : 000000e2 r1 : c0ea69fb r0 : 00000000#3�@TA�Flags: nzCv IRQs on FIQs on Mode SVC_32 ISA ARM Segment userH�@D1�Control: 10c0383d Table: aa07006a DAC: 00000015�[�@D3Process magisk (pid: 363, stack limit = 0xea05e238)dq�@4!Stack: (0xea05fecc to 0xea060000)?��@`Mfec0: 00000000 ebc0b010 c0bd6c08 00000000 ebc0b010,��@`Mfee0: 00000001 00000021 00000000 ea05e038 ebc0b010 c0bd8828 00000000 c03af704Q˂@`Mff00: ffffffff ee040800 00000000 ebc0b000 ea18ca00 000001ed ea05e000 c0211688m�@`Mff20: 00000020 00000040 00000000 ee00c190 edc02088 00000000 00000041 ffff41ed��@`Mff40: 00000001 c03af704 00000000 00000000 eba2c4c8 00000000 000001ed 00000000>%�@`Mff60: 00000000 00000000 00000021 7f5e95ec ea05e000 00000000 c010f440 c02353fc"B�@`Mff80: 00000000 7f5e95ec 00000000 00000000 00000000 00000003 c0105e60 00000015

Finally, a reboot command appears

cpuidle_enter_state) from [<c015ecb0>] (cpu_startup_entry+0x268/0x360)"y�@P?�[<c015ecb0>] (cpu_startup_entry) from [<80100604>] (0x80100604)���XFfcpr_panic_callback: apc_corner: [corner:6, fuse_corner:3] = 1305000 uV���(Rebooting in 5 seconds..���,�Going down for restart now���(�set_dload_mode_bbk[1]!!!N��`Mfmsm_restart_prepare 721 need_warm_reset = 1 get_dload_mode() = 1 cmd = (null){�%��I,qcom,qpnp-power-on qpnp-power-on-13: PMIC@SID2: configuring PON for resetSUBSYSTEM=spmiDEVICE=+spmi:qpnp-power-on-13

Complete kernel log in the attachment

TXH
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
I added a small part to the text [MENTION=4403217]Pkt_Lnt[/MENTION] is referring to. Basically, this is a really tough one to troubleshoot and detailed logs are needed.

Yes, a reflash of your ROM might work.

Sounds like that app doesn't play nice with MagiskSU. Try a different way to make a backup, maybe... In recovery is one way.

That was one seriously hard to read log... I'm making a completely unqualified guess here, but that looks like some kind of kernel panic. Incompatible boot image, possibly?

What's your device, by the way?
[Magisk] haybill:
N910F (Note 4) Snapdragon.

I just tried a ROM reinstall, and the Magisk v.13.3 that's included in the ROM didn't install correctly on that install, so....I completely removed Magisk, using the included Uninstall option.

Then...... Flashed SuperSU, which seemed to redo the Boot partition image, or whatever....I did read something about boot. image. during the flashing process.

Anyway, so far so good, but it seems like the Modem is not fully functional now!!

I'm going to flash a Stock ROM and start again.

Sorry, I meant to say Thanks for giving me some advice- and I agree that it does seem like a bit of a problem, but needing the phone, I had to cut and run.
[Magisk] puturaya20:
Help sir not working masgisk 14 wih module v2 beta 5 test 7

Please check my log

My rom miui 8 8.5.8.0 global rom and device redmi note 4x
[Magisk] Fif_:
Ah okay.

Not the cleanest thing in the world, but it works.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
You need to be a little but clearer with what you want help with.

What about Magisk isn't working? You can't get root access, or can't properly install modules?

Or did you mean that MagiskHide isn't working?

Or is MagiskHide working and you just can't pass SafetyNet?

Your use of the Universal SafetyNet fix points to the latter. You'll probably get more help with that module in the module thread...
[Magisk] Shished:
Magisk manager should be able to open Magisk modules zip files. Download zip in browser, press open and manager will be opened.
[Magisk] mayur.3.92:
Yes but no joy...
[Magisk] zagzag99:
The checkboxs on the Magisk Hide activity gets reset.

It causes apps to identify root access and block and uninstall.

:(

Using OnePlus5.

In general, i think it should be changed. If Magisk is set to hide it's presence then by default all apps should be checked in that screen. Only those that one permit root should be unchecked manually by user. (Or better yet switch the meaning of the activity - to whitelist Magisk identification, instead of blacklist).
[Magisk] kallekula33:
Not to sound like a total idiot, but from where do I download the moduls?

In the application I can't find anything to download. The reason for asking is

that I watched the rooting video from XDA and a lot of moduls were present.

I think though it was AB older version of the Manager :eek:.

Or atleast I think so anyway.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Downloads section in the left-side menu of the Manager... You won't see it unless you have a working internet connection though (which of course would be needed to download anything :p).
[Magisk] kallekula33:
OMG ! Do I feel like a total moron :silly::silly: , I guess I was so excited to finally root my phone so I didn't do the basic setup of the phone.
[Magisk] jenslody:
Already fixed, will be in next release.
[Magisk] Arguablefire:
I know this is a book question, I'm fairly new to all of this. I have a Samsung galaxy s7 active SM-G891A. I went back to stock PI2 and adb sideloaded to QB2. I installed the magisk manager latest version, and got the patched_boot.img, but my question is how do I flash it to my device either with Odin or adb. I tried with odin, putting the img.tar in the AP slot and connecting my phone while in bootloader download mode. Yet it failed every time. I used the stock PI2 boot.img for magisk manager to use. I'm just not sure how to go about flashing the patched_boot.img or patched_boot.img.tar to my phone? Any info or if anyone can point me in the right direction, or hell maybe I am totally wrong and it won't work with my phone..
[Magisk] qiurigao:
Yes, I already know that this is a kernel panic, probably need to modify from the kernel, but my device kernel source code is not open, does this mean that you can disassemble to modify?
[Magisk] qiurigao:
I re-upload the log, read it better:cyclops:
[Magisk] Gauravlonkar:
Fc on taping super user v14.0 stable.
[Magisk] jenslody:
Did you try to clear MagiskManager data ?

In general @Didgeridoohan's great troubleshooting guide is always worth reading.

And logs please !
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
That was a bit easier to read, yes. :good:

I'm a bit curious... Do you experience the same thing if installing SuperSU systemlessly or using phh's superuser?
[Magisk] AkshayGunplay:
module installation error

hi. i'm not able to install any module. i have attached logs. can someone tell what's wrong? :confused:

i have also attached a screenshot with the error i'm getting while installing a module
[Magisk] qiurigao:
Yes, I use TWRP to install the latest version of SuperSU, but the system is in the start logo interface, and magisk, it does not automatically restart, has been stuck in the first logo interface has not changed
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Your answer is in the error message.

(Hint: your Magisk version is too old.)

So if I understand you right you can't install any systemless root solutions without experiencing reboots or bootloops, correct?

Sounds like your boot image simply isn't compatible... And considering that the kernel isn't open source I'm guessing there are no custom kernels available for you to try.
[Magisk] qiurigao:
Yes, I think this probably only by modifying the kernel source to solve, I decided to transplant a kernel source, from the CAF official MSM8937 source
[Magisk] 1XXDXX1:
My magisk keep unstalling any ideas why :D
[Magisk] SaadatM:
Got a weird issue with Magisk since v14

Prior to 14, I could install modules without problems or any issues.

Since 14, I can install modules, however, they don't show up as installed and I can reinstall them. The log put out an error "sendfile failed [..]"

Device is running Slim7, fresh install.

(formatted all and then installed the ROM, then Magisk)

Magisk Log attached, hope anyone can help!
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
It's probably the capuchin monkeys doing it... :silly:

No, but seriously. Without any kind of logs or details no one has any idea why.

Sounds like your Magisk image is mounted read-only. Try typing the following in a terminal emulator and see if it reports rw or ro:

mount | grep "on /magisk"

If it's ro, the question is why...
[Magisk] SaadatM:
I fixed it. It was very weird because I tried it before aswell:

Uninstalled Magisk 14, installed 13.3 in the same instance I was in recovery. Booted, installed some modules and updated to 14 and now it works seamless and installs new modules properly.

In termimal it also shows as rw now.

But thank you very much for helping!
[Magisk] longxa762:
Do I still need phh's SuperUser? It's really confusing when people who make root tutorial said that install it after Magisk and Magisk Manager but Magisk have MagiskSU
[Magisk] Captain_Throwback:
No, you don't. Magisk includes MagiskSU by default.
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
Here's a breakdown of support for root methods in Magisk:

phh Superuser​

- It was supported in Magisk since ???

- Support for it was partially dropped in Magisk v10.x and it was partially replaced by MagiskSU (and because support for it was partially dropped, you'll still have to install phh Superuser app for root management)

- Support for it was fully dropped since Magisk v11.0 and it was replaced by MagiskSU

SuperSU​

- It was supported since Magisk v1 (with some drawbacks, like Magisk Hide not being able to hide it)

- Support for it was fully dropped since Magisk v13.0 beta builds (but users are reporting some success with it (by installing it after Magisk)

MagiskSU​

- It was included since Magisk v10.0 (but with Magisk v10.x, you'll still have to install phh Superuser app for root management)

- By default, it's installed if no root is detected, older Magisk-compatible phh Superuser is detected or non-systemless root solution is detected
[Magisk] Darthnilus:
I am facing an issues with Firefox And Amazon Prime, they keep crashing after installing Magisk. I have changed web view from google to chrome stable and chrome beta to no avail. I am attaching Logs do let me know what the issues is .
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
Can you try to disable Magisk Hide?
[Magisk] siren_shadows:
Hmm, having an issue here. Nexus 6P. Flashed android oreo cleanly, I installed elementalx, and then magisk, but every so often (hours at most) magisk hide will disable itself. I got a random reboot, and at another point magisk was completely disabled and i had to reflash it. ANy clue on what's going on? Did i do the wrong order of the kernel first? Thanks
[Magisk] longxa762:
nvm fixed it
[Magisk] FearMyAnus:
Hi! I'm having some trouble getting SafetyNet to pass. I'm running Resurrection Remix 7.1.2 on OnePlus 3t. I've attached the log from Magisk. So far, I've cleared app data, dirty flashed a rom update, uninstalled then installed Magisk 14.0.

Do you think there's anything I can do before I try a factory reset and fresh install?

I've asked on reddit if people with my same phone are passing SafetyNet, they said yes.

Thank you!
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Flashing the kernel first is fine.

It's really hard to say anything about your issues without logs. And catching any with your issues might be quite hard...

From your log:

It doesn't matter that it's systemless... Xposed will trigger SafetyNet.
[Magisk] FearMyAnus:
I'm sorry, but I don't understand.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
I thought I was quick in clarifying my first post, but you where way quicker...:D

Xposed triggers SafetyNet.
[Magisk] FearMyAnus:
Oh, so I'll have to uninstall xposed? Does having xposed installed completely disable SafetyNet? Because it does not hide it from any other apps like Android Pay.
[Magisk] reversegear:
Disable xposed module you will pass SN
[Magisk] FearMyAnus:
Thanks!
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
Quoting myself here:
[Magisk] FearMyAnus:
I see, thank you very much!
[Magisk] k0m3n9:
I'm not sure about S7 but I think you need to activate Developer options under phone Settings & check the OEM Unlock & USB Debuging options before flash the patched boot img via Odin.
[Magisk] ananthakrshnan10:
I am facing some issue regarding the CTS profiling. I am using the official Redmi Note 4 LOS14.1 build 20170921 with Sept month security patch with GApps (pico) and Magisk 14.0 without no exposed or mods. I checked the SafteyNet status right after the first boot and it was fine. However, after installing my essential apps, the safteynet failed as well as CTS. Is this any app specific problem as i have disable root access in the Magisk Manager. I opted out of Play Service beta in the previous build of LOS. Is Instant apps service the cause of this?
[Magisk] ShadySquirrel:
Do you by chance have any terminal emulators installed? I was busting my mind few weeks ago trying to debug same behaviour (only Magisk + my V4A addon), started out of blue, so I started removing recently installed apps and testing, and voila, after terminal was removed, SN went back to normal.
[Magisk] krembuk:
this app

https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=ovo.id

keeps detecting rooted android after i upgraded from v12 to v14. it used to be resolved by restarting magisk hide in v12. now restarting, and also uncheck-recheck in magisk manager does not help.

cpuld you advise? thank you.
[Magisk] Dchoi229:
Hello,

Anyone having issues downloading modules?? Theres a constant erro message ( merge.img mount failed). I tries everything to resolve this issue. Can someone give me a solid answer as to why this is happening?
[Magisk] culiacanazo:
I recall it happening to me but I was in the process of updating everything, and at one point it just didn't happen anymore. Plus (not sure if it helped, but) in the process, I included a good ole dalvik and cache wipes.

I mean everything: nightly, kernel, recovery, apps, modules for both magisk and xposed (where applicable) and even (framework) patches, overlays, and hosts!

Give it a try. Sorry, that's not a "solid" answer per se, but it went away.

Edit: BTW you probably mean problems flashing, don't you?
[Magisk] FloyderE:
Since the last update I can’t update modules as the app give me the “Can’t extract error” , how can I fix this?

I surf the web but I cannot find a solution
[Magisk] culiacanazo:
Are your app and magisk zip the same date?

If it began with the update, roll back. Or try in the recovery meanwhile.

As a last resort. Reflash, including and beginning with your stock boot.

Welcome.
[Magisk] Dchoi229:
I always do the wipes after everything too. I appreciate your answer if its not solid. I'm going insane trying to figure out why the module wont install in TWRP. Well flashing/installing because the dam merge.img wont mount.
[Magisk] prown:
I've tried to uninstall magisk with zip. Flashed package via TWRP and phone didn't boot (was stuck in my case at MI logo), rebooted once more to TWRP, flashed magisk and the phone was up.

So is there any alternative to uninstall magisk and be able to boot to system after?
[Magisk] FloyderE:
Yeah, same date and already tried to re install Magisk..but I did it from the app, it is worth to try a reinstall from TWRP?

Thank you anyway for your help!
[Magisk] kalokagathia:
Hello guys, I can't manage to install xposed.

Magisksu is working well but it doesn't install modules.

I tried uninstalling and reinstalling it to make it work, but I couldn't.

I also tried installing xposed via xposed manager, magisk manager and through the recovery mode.

Anyway tip?

[IMG="screenshot"]https://i.imgur.com/16T8QMf.png[/IMG]
[Magisk] Dchoi229:
Install your stock boot.img with your rom first than try it.