yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] humzaahmed155:
Magisk 10.2 on the latest OnePlus 3 stock ROM w/f2fs is causing some performance issues... I couldn't find a definitive statement anywhere but I'm sure with the similar issues with SuperSU has made developers aware.

At random moments for extended periods of time, the CPU usage will top out at 99% and I'll lose around 40% a night because of wakelocks. This is solved if I uninstall Magisk/SuperSU.

Is this an OP3/f2fs issue or a rooting solution issue?
[Magisk] jjhaohao:
Yes, i have. No way to get it boot. The only way was force reboot, enter TWR, flash v9 again, and wipe dalvik/cache. It f**ed up something anyways, i can't install any APK now. I can from ADB or playstore, but not with file managers. The logging say "I/O error" and "Permission denied". I get "parse error" when i try to install any apk. Checked permissions of files, and checked installing from internal/external SD and it's the same. I think i need to do a clean install now . :rolleyes:
[Magisk] Wesley_NL:
[MENTION=3615867]teddy0209[/MENTION]

ok i did a test,

1. installed offical boot.img

2. rebooted phone, red line top left was gone

3. after a few sec phone rebooted automaticly and red line top left appeared and i got warped into recovery

4. installed magisk and it seems no fails with offical boot.img

so my problem now is phone won't boot with offical boot.img got any options i can do ?

here are links to the boot.img

Audax 13

samsung offical
[Magisk] Wesley_NL:
well i cant help you, but i hope you have a backup of your phone, sofar i never encountered any problems with my sm-g928f that where like this, the worst i had was bootloop but that mostly was fixed either with clearing cache or dirty install the rom i use, or the restore function since i have abackup before i f*ckup stuff
[Magisk] teddy0209:
Delete that su.img and magisk.img, restore your roms boot.img, reboot to system to verify if it's booting fine, reboot recovery/twrp then flash magisk10.2, reboot to system. If it boots fine, don't forget to install magisk manager and pph superuser from playstore if you haven't installed... Hope this helps... Need to sleep now... I hope you find a solution to your problem... ?
[Magisk] Wesley_NL:
forgot to mention that , i did that , deleted all those files in/data/ of magisk and su, i resintalled audax boot to get my phone up again, seems i uploaded wrong screenshot to lol
[Magisk] teddy0209:
Lol... I'm running out of ideas... Maybe it's better to head to your device forum and ask if someone have gotten their phone to work with magisk.
[Magisk] kyrunter3:
Safetynet updated again ? can't use android pay since a few minutes now
[Magisk] Wesley_NL:
ok im back on stock rom with mgisk but i can not pass saftynet somehow , i followed everyste i cold find but this is what im stuck with safetynet, i did set file permissions like wroten in the guide but still no luck
[Magisk] rignfool:
I seem to recall that app being unreliable for testing safety-net...
[Magisk] ahac85:
[MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] Hi hope you can take a look at this post and have the fix in the next release of Magisk?

https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=68983223&postcount=5402
[Magisk] Wesley_NL:
what wierd is this, the 1st time after clean install and safetynet test i get "attachmnt1" and then i remove su/magisk i get "attachment2"

and yes i changed permissions and stuff, i dled all apps they list there and so on yet i cant seems to pass safetynet for pokemon go
[Magisk] nimjk:
How can i use sbin_orig binaries with magisk? i have to use it for my kernel tweak app...
[Magisk] mobileman88:
Have you updated your Google Play Services? I just used mine and it still works.
[Magisk] Wesley_NL:
Yes, i updated , but i can pass the test on stock rom with custom recovery , but other than that i cant get it to work on my device, i dont know how to pass safetynet for pokemon go with root
[Magisk] Honeycd:
Hi,

I have Kurama v3, I would like to know if it works on my note 4, thanks
[Magisk] jrk190:
So, I managed to get Android pay to work yesterday morning, and safety net passes, but Pokemon go hangs on load, and Miitomo crashes.
[Magisk] Black's:
Hello guys

Help me please with my LG G3 d855 16gb (Tekafe 5.4) to flash Magisk on it
[Magisk] jrk190:
So, I managed to get Android pay to work yesterday morning, and safety net passes, but Miitomo so crashes.
[Magisk] teddy0209:
Use safetynet playground for checking or better the one included in the magisk manager.

---------- Post added at 12:44 AM ---------- Previous post was at 12:40 AM ----------

You need to rebump your boot.img after flashing magisk... Any method should work extract it and bump it on a pc or the simplest one via flashing a zip in recovery.
[Magisk] Black's:
I tried many times to do it but unsuccessful! Could you please help me with instructions and files?
[Magisk] teddy0209:
Give me more info about what you have in your device, what you did and what help do you need...
[Magisk] Black's:
Device LG G3 D855 16gb,

Rom tekafe 5.4,

supersu 2.79,

Recovery twrp-3.0.2-0

Apps requested root installed only adaway, wifikill...
[Magisk] teddy0209:
Is that rom 6.0?

1.Unroot your device using full unroot in the supersu app or via unsu zip by osmosis.

2.restore your roms unmodified boot.img.

3.flash magisk 10.2

4.rebump your boot.img (search for cbump, a flashable zip via recovery)
[Magisk] Black's:
Yes, this is android 6.0

1. Can I unroot it from supersu just pressing full unroot in this app?

2. Where could I get a unmodified boot.img?

3. When I try to flash magisk 10.2 I get this message in twrp.. (Screenshot attached)

4. Unfortunately I don't know how to do that... :( could you help me?
[Magisk] jrk190:
I'm on a Nexus 5X with Pure Nexus and ElementalX, Pokemon go and AP work, but Miitomo crashes.
[Magisk] teddy0209:
Yes you can unroot via the app, just make sure there is nothing left and check for safetynet via safetynet playground from the store. Your boot.img is inside your rom zip, you can extract it from there. The bootloader of g3 is locked so you have to bump the boot.img for it to work, since flashing magisk modifies the boot.img, you have to rebump. Just search for cbump and do some readings. Unfortunately I don't have my g3 anymore so I can't test it, and give you exact steps using your rom. If you need more help about your device, you have to go to the g3 subforum...
[Magisk] Wesley_NL:
I know but. I can not get it to work with root i tried what I readed sofar but no luck, and there is barly support for my device so yeah, i like to stay audax bcuz i like his rom
[Magisk] GryphonBR:
Magisk Manager 3.1 from Play Store crashes on my phone every time, and 10.2 isn't recognized by 2.1

Im out of ideas on how to fix this, since I've tried reflashing boot.img and reinstalling from recovery but still no change in my situation.
[Magisk] teddy0209:
Did you grant it superuser?... reflashing magisk from recovery should fix it, if you have problem with root then flash also the latest phh module.
[Magisk] GryphonBR:
Yeah, it's inherited from previous version. Tried flashing everything from recovery, to no avail
[Magisk] teddy0209:
Most of the time you have to grant it again... Did you check the superuser app? Wiping data/cache of the app might also help.
[Magisk] GryphonBR:
Yeah, tried all that. No use, it FC as soon as I grant it superuser access.
[Magisk] tag68:
If you have phh su installed without topjohnwu changes, Magisk can not run. But Magisk Manager does not show that it is wrong version of phh superuser. Can it detect this and show it?
[Magisk] teddy0209:
Maybe it can, it can detect supersu, so why not the official phh superuser.
[Magisk] Black's:
Ohh grate! But where is it?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
There's a search bar at the top of the page. Type "lg g3" and... voila!
[Magisk] zzz2002:
Phone gs3 (sgh-i747m) running cm 13 d2att, rooted through the developer options.

tried to install Magisk using Majisk manager and TWRP, in both cases the install seemed to work (no error msgs). But if i try to use Majisk to anything, like installing pph-superuser I get "Majisk has stopped working".

Suggestions on how to fix?
[Magisk] Artim_96:
Remove inbuilt root with Osmosis' UPDATE_unsu.zip. not compatible with Magisk
[Magisk] Black's:
This it's that subforum? :eek:
[Magisk] neox456:
I have a Xiaomi Mi4. Latest Global Stable. Installed Magisk Manager. Saftey Net check passed (other ones are red of course). Flashed TWRP, rebooted and checked again. Test still passed.

Booted into TWRP and flashed that Magisk-10.2.zip, Rebooted and SafteyNet Failed.

What did I do wrong? Will Unmagisk repair my keys? How can I root my device without breaking possible future apps...?
[Magisk] Artim_96:
Magisk installs root a of course you need to enable Magisk hide to pass SN
[Magisk] topjohnwu:
I'm here just to tell you that I'm finally back from the finals and the absurd amount of projects :p

More development is coming!
[Magisk] neox456:
Thank you. Okay, I did that. But it is still red and not passing the test. I could not select the Magisk Manager in the Magisk Hide list though as it does not seem to show up. Is that required?
[Magisk] Artim_96:
Don't check anything, it automatically hides everything needed.
[Magisk] ambasadii:
From where su daemon start su.d shell script before boot on magisk ?

Edit:

Ok got it worked :)
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Did you reboot after enabling Magisk Hide?
[Magisk] neox456:
Okay, but the saftey net test in magisk manager still did not work... :confused:

Yes.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Yes, I realised that you probably had shortly after posting. Otherwise you shouldn't have seen the Magisk Hide list...

A Magisk log would help with the troubleshooting.
[Magisk] neox456:
Thank you. I attachted it? I hope this is the correct one...

Btw. I did not check anything and nothing is checked and this com.google.android.gms.unstable not even in the hide list... not sure why it shows up in my logs. Maybe this is from the test, but I hit the test more than once...
[Magisk] LyuboA:
cant install magisk v10.2 from the program and from recovery S7 Edge Echoe Nougat v1 it ends with error 1 (error installing zip file) i dont have that problem with Magisk v9 or even with Magisk v10-170101
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
The log looks ok. Could you enable verbose logging and possibly even reboot and post another?

That entry about gms.unstable is Magisk hiding itself from Safety Net.

It is possible that your device's kernel is incompatible with Magisk Hide. Stock Samsung kernels have this problem.

---------- Post added at 18:51 ---------- Previous post was at 18:49 ----------

A recovery log would help with troubleshooting.
[Magisk] LyuboA:
no need it looks like it dosnt like the kernel i was using with another kernel install thanks for the fast reply :)
[Magisk] phen0m2016:
Please Help!!

I flashed Magisk v10.2 to my HTC One M9 Stock 6.0 and rebooted it, but now is feezed on the HTC Boot logo. How can i force it to shut down, in order to enter Recovery??

Please help!!
[Magisk] DanHakimi:
For some reason, my Magisk Manager didn't update until I did it manually just now. And I did that, and then updated Magisk from v6 to v10.2.

But my magisk phh superuser is still at 1.0.3.3, and apparently that's out of date. This thread: https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/magisk-phh-s-superuser-android-pay-t3435921 tells me that I should be able to update it from magisk manager, but I can't. I'm getting the impression, from that thread, and from things my phone is telling me, that I'm not currently rooted. But I am! I know I am!

Also, I'm using this old "Magisk Quick Toggle" v 0.3. Is that the problem? Did I unmount root with that, and then lose the root? Should I uninstall this toggler, flash root from the above thread again, and install another toggler? Do I need to uninstall/reinstall the play store SuperUser thingy? And the regular version of that works with magisk, right, it's just the actual flashable zip I need to get the special version for?
[Magisk] Artim_96:
Power and volume lower press and hold both at the save time for at least 3 seconds
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
You're talking about different things...

Phh's superuser app is at version 1.0.3.3. That's the latest... From the Manager you can update the superuser binaries. The current version for Magisk phh's is topjohnwu r2. When you open the Manager it should tell you if you're properly rooted or not. Under "Modules" you can see if you're using Magisk superuser and under "Downloads" you can install/update the modules. If you're not rooted you need to download the zip from the thread you linked and flash it in recovery.

Magisk quick toggle doesn't work since v7. Now you use Magisk Hide to hide root from Safety Net and other apps. If you're only interested in SN you don't have to do anything else but activate Hide and reboot.

Read through the Official announcement thread, lots of good info there...
[Magisk] GryphonBR:
OK, so I really went the extra mile here - took a backup of my phone, did a clean install of my system from scratch and then added Magisk Manager... Which still FC after superuser access has been granted. I gotta say, this is really frustrating me.
[Magisk] DanHakimi:
Thanks!

Okay, Magisk says I'm not rooted, and although I know I was, I guess maybe the update or the quick toggle broke something. I don't see a downloads or modules section. The quick toggle told me my SU binary was out of date... But whatever, I guess the best thing to do now is just flash a new root. Should I uninstall phh's superuser app too, or just leave it?

Is root still active when it's hidden? Because if so, then that's beautiful.

And if not, then it's a bit of a hassle, but I can deal.

Link? I'm not seeing anything with the word "announcement" on it except the forum rules.
[Magisk] phen0m2016:
Tried that, but actually Vol UP + Power did the trick. Thanks anyway. Problem solved.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Since you're not rooted Magisk Manager won't work properly. Flash phh's superuser topjohnwu r2 in TWRP and you're good to go. Keep the app.

Root is still active. It'll only be hidden from Safety Net and whatever other app you choose to hide it from. Keep the number of apps on the list (you'll understand when you've activated Hide) as low as possible.

It's the one stickied at the top with the word "Official" in the title... :D
[Magisk] Devhost97:
How can i add support to kernel for Magisk ?
[Magisk] alanead07:
What is the problem????
[Magisk] jsaxon2:
Is it permissive?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Details are needed... Lots more then you've given.

Have you activated Magisk Hide?
[Magisk] alanead07:
Yas

What are the details?

Iam on KING OF NOUGAT ROM

My phone is s7 edge
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Details can include, but aren't limited to, what you've done up until now trying to get it working, device and ROM, logs, etc...

Samsung kernels might not work with Magisk Hide. Try a different kernel... And no, I don't know which (I don't use Samsung)...

Edit: it might also be, as suggested, SELinux being set to permissive that's your problem. Type getenforce in a terminal emulator. If it's permissive, Google how to change it to enforcing.
[Magisk] alanead07:
It is enforcing
[Magisk] Filip013:
You have MIUI. The latest version of Magisk does not support MIUI. You need to flash Magisk uninstaller and then flash Magisk v9 and the latest phh SuperUser.

[MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] Can you please look into this issue? I've already left a bug report on GitHub.
[Magisk] Artim_96:
Well, power down is for "killing", power up for recovery
[Magisk] jhedfors:
I believe this is dependent on the device. On OnePlus One Power+VolUp = fastboot, while Power+VolDown = recovery. Not sure what you mean by " killing".
[Magisk] Artim_96:
When you are in boot animation or even system, power and volume down forces a reboot. Device independent (at least I know no company doing different) and probably mandatory in Android compatibility test suite. That what he asked for.
[Magisk] humzaahmed155:
Any ideas?
[Magisk] gyurman:
Hello, what does it meaning SafetyNet Failed: CTS profile mismatch? What can I do? Thanks
[Magisk] Captain_Throwback:
Not for every device.

For the M9, it's power+volume up to "battery-pull reset" the device. Power+Volume Down doesn't do anything.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
It means you've probably not activated Magisk Hide. Or, you have and something in your setup triggers SN.

Read:

https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=70426733
[Magisk] Wesley_NL:
so can anyone give me a guide how to get it to work ?
[Magisk] neox456:
Wow, this was so helpful. Thank you very much. :D
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Since you've left a bug report on GitHub he will look at it... Patience. He's only one guy and have a lot going on in everyday life as well.
[Magisk] bjorn96:
Hello

Been searching around for how to get systemless root, but I just cannot find it. Someone tipped me to go here and ask for help.

So can someone teach me how to get systemless root on the Nexus 6p running AICP, or maybe point me in the right direction for it. Really want to be able to have root and at the same time hide it from root-hating apps.

Looking forward for any helpful answers.

Best, Bjørn
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Don't know if AICP is rooted. If it is, remove built-in root.

Flash Magisk v10.2, it'll install Magisk superuser by default. Install phh's superuser app, install Magisk Manager, enable Magisk Hide in the manager and reboot. That should be it...

On custom ROM's there might be unforeseen issues, but the above works flawlessly on both my N6 and N6P with stock 7.1.1 (January patch) and Franco Kernel.

Read the Official announcement thread for lots of good info (stickied at the top). You'll also find lots of info by searching this thread.
[Magisk] jhedfors:
First and foremost, I assume you followed the installation instructions on the official post linked to in the OP? Please post the details of what you did and the problems you encounter. Many, of not all, of the answers you need have likely been answered already in this thread, so you could have your answer there already.
[Magisk] Snappiestjack:
I've seem to have ran into a issue, I think.

I'm trying to get android pay to work, all is fine with the SafetyNet checks, but when I go to Magisk hide I'm not seeing the Android Pay application, anyone else encountered this behavior?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
If you pass Safety Net, Android Pay should work. No need to hide anything else.
[Magisk] Snappiestjack:
I'm more curious as to why the app doesn't show?
[Magisk] bjorn96:
Thanks a lot. If I only where a good reader... :laugh:

Worked all fine, apps don't see root now. We'll those that shouldn't see it.

Brings my next question, don't kill me if it's been answered before, can I use super su with this? Kinda want to use the pro I paid for in that app.

Also, I think AICP is overwriting the root when I flash it, do I then have to flash the Magisk file for each daily? It does, sadly.

:)
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Yes, the answer to your question is in topjohnwu's instructions. You can use systemless SuperSU with Magisk, but not Magisk Hide.
[Magisk] bjorn96:
Oh, bugger. Well I'll just use "as is" then. Thanks for the help. :highfive:
[Magisk] Captain_Throwback:
Because it doesn't need to, and adding unnecessary unmounts to Magisk Hide makes it less efficient.
[Magisk] Snappiestjack:
but every single other app shows up and android pay has in the past, v10.2 also.
[Magisk] Captain_Throwback:
It was a recent change.
[Magisk] Snappiestjack:
with the app? I haven't updated it.
[Magisk] Captain_Throwback:
You sure it didn't get updated through the Play Store?
[Magisk] Snappiestjack:
positive. auto updates are turned off/. I'm not concerned as safteynet passes so it will still work as you mentioned, but I've always gone ahead and ticked the app to hide too.
[Magisk] Captain_Throwback:
And if you read the Official release thread, adding unnecessary apps to Magisk Hide is bad practice.

No idea about why it's not showing up for you, then.
[Magisk] Snappiestjack:
anyway thanks for letting me know about the update, better do that.
[Magisk] Wesley_NL:
guys? anyone wan't to support me to get magisk working on sm-g928f wth audax 13 ?

i cant even get it to work properly pass safetynet on offical rom as i sowed before,
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
I haven't quite followed your adventures, but it seems to me you've already gotten a lot of help.

I'm just gonna add my two cents:

Stock Samsung kernels do not work with Magisk Hide. If audax kernel is based on stock Samsung it won't work either. Try a different kernel... And no, I don't know which since I don't use Samsung.

As I said, I don't know what advice you've gotten so far, but take a look here if there's something that can help:

https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=70426733
[Magisk] Wesley_NL:
Uhm stock rom work with magisk just audax 13 not, but problem is i am not able to hide root, i can not pass safetynet thats my problem on stock rom, , thats whatt i wrote here in tread to i beleve,

And i tried removing root from audax 13 with update_unsu.zip it remove app but root still there and rooted as root checker say

And i also have tried systemless and hidesu but no luck i am doing something wrong but dont know what
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
And like I said, stock ROM (or rather boot image) won't work with Magisk Hide. In other words: won't pass SN or hide root from any apps. With a stock Samsung system you'll need a custom kernel to pass Safety Net.

If you can't even get Magisk to work with your custom ROM, have you posted any logs? Recovery log and Magisk log are very useful. Recovery log from TWRP right after flashing and Magisk log can be pulled from /cache after booting up once.

If you can't remove root from your custom ROM, that's an issue to raise in that ROM's thread, not here.

Edit: Don't confuse Magisk with Magisk Hide. The latter is a part of the former and Magisk can work perfectly without enabling Hide.
[Magisk] Wesley_NL:
I posted twrp logs , and magiks logs , well if i am unable to install it i can not get logs

What i have done is

1. Install update_unsu.zip

2.install magisk 10.2.zip

Somehow it dont work and i checked with root checker to when i use that update_unsu.zip it seems the app is gone but root is still active and fully working, i tried to full unroot in supersu but that option fails
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Well, if I don't know what's wrong I'm gonna ask for as much info as possible. I didn't know if Magisk wouldn't install, just not boot or whatever. You haven't been very detailed in your last few messages...

Now I know what's wrong and I'm full circle with my advice.

The boot image for your ROM comes pre-patched for SuperSU. Since there's no backup of a clean boot image to find, the installer fails. Use another (clean) boot image.
[Magisk] Wesley_NL:
Thx for advice but i already tried a different boot.img in audax13 rom,

i tried using a clean boot.img from offical rom bpl7, in a clean installed audax13 rom flashing trough twrp

if i use that magisk would install but the phone end up in bootloop, i don't know if I do it wrong but i most likely am

1. I did a full wipe except sd storage

2. Installed audax13

3. Booted phone and updated all stock apps

4. Boot into recovery

5. Installed clean boot.img offical rom into audax trough twrp

6. Installed magisk

7. Boot phone and it end up in boot loop

And my device have no active devs besides audax

If i did something wrong or missed a step tell me i try it again

Hope you can support me further, if you need more info i try to explain it in more details
[Magisk] LucentBirch:
I only found a file in xbin...Deleted it, but still not passing safetynet
[Magisk] gamingking8:
Can I install system-less xposed from magisk on a Galaxy Note 4 (exynos)?
[Magisk] Artim_96:
Depends on the Android version. If it's 5.0 and Samsung's crappy TW ROM, then no
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
If you really need Magisk Hide I think your only option is to go stock and find a compatible kernel. Good luck.