yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] demonoidmaster:
If it's anywhere in /data then you're fine, but if it's in /system it might get deleted if you're flashing a delta update and sure as heck will be deleted if you're flashing a full rom zip update though

But yeah if you're putting the script in the magisk folder in /data/adb/ then you're fine, just keep a backup though in case you ever need to uninstall magisk + reflash magisk because the uninstaller wipes the /data/adb folder clean
[Magisk] wangdaning:
My main point was that this would be impractical. Not many devices run on pure AOSP, and even then I do not think AOSP can flash a boot/recovery image cleanly unless it has the right keys. So, if it were to work you would need a lot more effort than it would take to patch and flash.
[Magisk] nerdfail:
yes sir. i completely understand. appreciate your response.
[Magisk] pariantes:
Until magisk 20.3 on OP6 with android 9.9 all works fine.

With new updated of magisk 20.4 you'll get a bootloop.
[Magisk] Pandemic:
Updated yet to magisk 20.4 on my xperia 1 with latest android 10 and by settle it up it rebooted 3 times but no worries.. All works good ?
[Magisk] sherindroid:
I unticked the recovery option while updating now my recovery is lost. Could someone tell what that option actually do ?

Using A10 MSM Xtended v7.0

System-as-root device.
[Magisk] zgfg:
Please check Magisk Installation guide.

Generally, if your device is SAR and not A/B, you have to patch Recovery image and of course with Recovery option checked in (alas, on Xiaomi MIUI 11/Q, it is still boot image and therefore without Recovery option checked in)
[Magisk] eosdigic:
Does anyone meet this issue? Since yesterday, Safetynet check randomly fails. When I click Safetynet check of MagiskManager, both CTS and Basic check randomly PASS or FAIL. Everything was fine before yesterday. Magisk is upgraded to 20.4 but the problem is still there.
[Magisk] T.A.R.D.I.S.:
Hello

Since last Canary, impossible to flash any module or previous version of Magisk

It runs to infinite. No log because flash don't start in fact

I'm on 1+ 7pro
[Magisk] zgfg:
Canary Magisk 20401 and Manager 279 also released.

So far everything ok (MIUI 11/Q)
[Magisk] Shahrokh.KING:
Magisk 20.3 and previous versions: working fine

Magisk 20.4: phone got restarted all of a sudden while in sleep and got stuck on samsung logo

Galaxy note 4 android 6.0.1 stock
[Magisk] plepew:
Just sharing this on my OP6T McLaren

After the update, Safetynet & Basicintegrity showed up as false at first refresh. As I did it again, it said true for both.
[Magisk] kgursu:
Same here, but a bit different.

I can't update Magisk through the new Manager and flashed with TWRP. Garbled screen is mostly on Magisk Manager app, when I scroll up and down on every page and Installation progress cannot be seen.

Any solutions?
[Magisk] Tuxedo.Bond:
I am having the same issue except mine hasn't passed at all since it started failing a couple days ago. After the latest Magisk update, same situation. I have not tried reinstalling Magisk yet.
[Magisk] martyfender:
Is anyone else having problems hiding Magisk Manager in today's Canary release? This is on my Onn 8, Android 9 tablet. I did see the release note:
[Magisk] zgfg:
Same here (but not a deal breaker for me, and not going to install Debug and taking logs)
[Magisk] pndwal:
Yes. On updating MagiskSU it failed once then passed. If I keep clicking 'check' I get fails (always both) once in about five times (my guess is it's both because it's actually 'basicintegrity' that fails, which fails CTS in turn), then 'safetynet API error' after about ten clicks. This goes away after waiting about one minute. Mi Pad4 w/ LOS 17.0. PW
[Magisk] Paresh18shah:
Hide magisk manager failed.. Magisk canary build(20401)
[Magisk] omek07:
Magisk failed to hide in the latest Canary Build
[Magisk] Ps24u:
Just installed update 20.4 over 20.3. (Sony Xperia, Android 7.1.1).

Magisk log shows a crash right after startup, and the email app just continously crashes when trying to launch it.

Restarted the phone multiple times, same issues at every boot.

Reflashing 20.3 solved everything instantly.
[Magisk] T.A.R.D.I.S.:
The bug is probably causes by Magisk Manger 279. With the 7.51 (268), there is no bug
[Magisk] zgfg:
We are talking about today's Canary Manager 279, not the previous 278
[Magisk] T.A.R.D.I.S.:
Sorry, the bug is on 279, not 278.

I have edited my last post
[Magisk] zgfg:
NP

Btw, I uninstalled Manager 279 app and wanted to install 278 but it's also failing. hence installed 279 back.

Didn't want to uninstall Magisk or to delete its db or something - installed modules and root apps work fine
[Magisk] T.A.R.D.I.S.:
If you uninstall the v279 manager and install instead manager v278, it works without reroot

View attachment 4980817
[Magisk] zgfg:
I said that:

- I uninstalled Manager 279

- I tried to instal 278l but it failed (tried twice, before and after reboot)

So I installed 279 back (installation of 279 didn't fail)

---

However, generally, uninstalling only Manager does not remove root, modules, db of apps granted root - all stays and you just install Manager (same or another version if it allows going back and forth) and you are fully back in business
[Magisk] drezz2:
thanks

perhaps with a new magisk update it is no longer necessary to create the service? or is it not predictable? (I understand that it does not happen to everyone)?
[Magisk] LouMinartey:
Updated to Magisk 20.4 on OG Nvidia Shield Tablet, now bootlooping to recovery. Tried magisk uninstaller + downgrading to earlier version, still bootlooping. Really hoping this isn't going to need a reset... Not a good time.

EDIT: Managed to fix by restoring vanilla boot from a previous backup without losing any data. Went back and tried flashing 20.4 zip through TWRP this time (first time was mm direct install) and bootloop happened again. Going to restore again and stick to 20.3
[Magisk] b0unty:
hi guyz,

i'm on stable channel on my samsung N910F, magisk 20.3 and magisk manager 7.5.1(267)

i recieved notification to update to 20.4 when i launch the update in magisk manager it fail

it's the first time fail here is the log

thx for the help
[Magisk] jotha.dx:
I update last Canary and modules are displayed normally.....no erros

Op7tpro oos 10.0.7
[Magisk] osm0sis:
Please add your device and ROM info to the GitHub issue for this here: https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/issues/2609
[Magisk] zgfg:
Did you try to install an additional module (some people were complaining about).

And on your second screenshot if you press Ok to start repacking Magisk Manager - does that work with Canary 20401 (for me and few others it was failing)
[Magisk] simonk206:
Repacking/hiding Magisk Manager works fine for me with 20401 (279). But install Modules dont work for me too.
[Magisk] raxp:
I have the same problem on Xperia X Performance (Stock Android 8.0 41.3.A.2.107). Installed 20.4 through direct flashing - got a bootloop on Sony logo (doesn't go to animated). I've found unpatched boot.img, and flashed it through fastboot - device boots successfully again. Tried to patch boot.img again with 20.4 - device won't boot.

magisk.log doesn't seem to be generated. I have one in /cache, but it is from earlier boot before update. I'm not sure how to obtain kmsg since I'm unable to run TWRP without full device shutdown.

Even battery screen doesn't show.

The patching itself doesn't have any errors shown.

UPD: Installed 20.3 through TWRP. Phone boots fine
[Magisk] newtonc:
Could anyone please point me to the latest unninstall zip?
[Magisk] Wolfcity:
You'll find the uninstaller like the latest zip on the GitHub release page (tap assets). Here it's for 20.4.

https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/releases/tag/v20.4
[Magisk] Einheit-101:
Is there a custom channel for magisk 20.3? 20.4 is broken, edXposed is no longer working and magisk magically still lacks a rollback Option.

TWRP not available. Thanks in advance.
[Magisk] xunholyx:
All of the versions are available on topjohnwu's github.

Here's a link for 20.3: https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/releases/tag/v20.3
[Magisk] CustomROM4ever:
Hello! I'm using Magisk Canary on my OnePlus 5T with OxygenOs. Both Magisk 20308 / Manager 278 and the new 20401 / 279 can hide the "Die TK-App" play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=de.tk.tkapp from root. Now I'm trying to configure my new Xiaomi Mi 9T Pro running Evolution X but both Magisk 20308 and 20401 (and also stable 20.4 / 20.3) in connection with Manager 7.5.1 (because 278 and 279 fail to hide Magisk Manager) can't hide root for this App. I really don't understand what's going wrong. If the app has a new root-finding mechanism, why does it work on my OnePlus (and not on my Xiaomi) although I've tried the same Magisk versions?
[Magisk] Einheit-101:
But i cant install it, do i have to get a PC in order to patch the boot image just for a small rollback?
[Magisk] mewbow1:
No...

Flash Magisk Uninstaller zip first

Then flash Magisk 20.3 zip
[Magisk] Einheit-101:
That requires TWRP if i am not mistaken, which is not available. Otherwise it would be simple.
[Magisk] xunholyx:
Since there is no TWRP for the new RAZR, yes you'll need a PC. If you still have another device, there are ways to use it instead of a PC with terminal emulator. I've seen posts about it but can't tell you how to myself. Google is your friend. :)
[Magisk] H0wdy:
Hello,

On Pixel XL, I cannot upgrade from 20.2 to 20.3 or 20.4. It gets stuck on "compressing ramdisk," no matter what I do. What is the solution? This is from direct patch, adb sideload, etc.
[Magisk] osm0sis:
You can use the manual Module flash button in Manager to flash Magisk Installer zips, guys.
[Magisk] parag60288:
I am using Magisk Canary (Manager 279 & Magisk 20401).

Not able to hide magisk manager. It is giving an error.

Edit: Fixed after updating to 280.
[Magisk] osm0sis:
You're a little late to the party, that's fixed in 280, which is now up on the Canary channel.

Also, see here: https://twitter.com/topjohnwu/status/1244486539284901889
[Magisk] zgfg:
Just updated Magisk Manager Canary to 280, Changelog says that Hiding MM is fixed - indeed 280, now hiding MM works again for me (it was failing with 279)

MIUI 11/Q
[Magisk] Einheit-101:
Thanks a lot, it works fine.
[Magisk] 81!:
Bug...

When I try to go to modules the app closes. I'm using the latest canary
[Magisk] kevin01523:
Yep same with me android 10
[Magisk] osm0sis:
Try again with 281 when it's up. Might be fixed.
[Magisk] T.A.R.D.I.S.:
Same thing with 280.

For moment, back to the 278 for flashing modules normally
[Magisk] kgursu:
Furthermore, now even on Canary build 280, module installation gets stuck, while showing the title "Installing" only, no further log is showing during that process. It freezes...
[Magisk] Dreamer(3MF):
the attached script is running/working without any issue with any magisk version below 20.4 but not with 20.4. i tried osm0sis busybox but it doesnot help so if you could advise me which command(s) should be written with full-path to redirect it to osm0sis busybox, it will be highly appreciated.
[Magisk] shaifullah.ahad:
My Asus ROG Phone 2 is a "Tencent Game" version. I already unlocked the Bootloader and changed the ROM from CN to WW so my device warranty gone already. So should I keep root my ROG Phone 2 or should I keep unrooted. I mean after rooting which extra facilities or which helpful modification I will get? After rooting I deleted some bloatware app like "Armoury Crae", "Netflix", "Facebook", etc but then my phone couldn't reboot after deleting those apps, so I reflash the rom and did not root again. So what I should do with my Unlocked Bootloader phone? Should I keep it rooted or just keep unrooted? If rooted phone can give me some extra advanced feature then please explain me what are those! Please!
[Magisk] osm0sis:
No offense but.. What a ****ing mess. Who knows.
[Magisk] sourceisking:
Bootloop after flashing Magisk on unofficial LineageOS 17.1 (GSI/Treble) (Huawei)

Hi,

I successfully installed LineageOS 17.1-20200309 on my P20 Lite (ANE-LX1).

It seems to work fine but after flashing the Magisk zip using TWRP, I'm stuck in a bootloop everytime.

Uninstalling via uninstall zip does not work either, the bootloop persists.

I am able to undo the installation by restoring LineageOS from a backup. If necessary, I can provide logs (?) etc.

Does anyone know about this issue? Thanks
[Magisk] doctor-who:
How to fix this with device not certified?
[Magisk] Badger50:
Try clearing play store app cache & data and reboot :good:
[Magisk] scrin378:
Clear data of play store and reboot

Sorry, didnt see that [MENTION=3730810]Badger50[/MENTION] has already answered ;)
[Magisk] dirtyreturn:
----------[/SIZE]

[/COLOR]Just wondering, is anyone experiencing the inability to install modules from storage?

On 20.4 canary build - latest.
[Magisk] osm0sis:
Everybody. diareuse has a fix for it pending and 281 will fix it.
[Magisk] doctor-who:
Works, fixed thanks!
[Magisk] chieco:
Bkank/White Manager

Hi everyone,

Im using Magisk for a while now, and everything was fine, until recently for some reason Magisk Manager shows just a blank white space now...

The last big change I made was to hide Magisk and use Magisk Hide for some banking apps which also work.

I still have root because apps who need root function Magisk modules and Xposed all work. But I can't give root permission to new apps because of the manager.

Any way to fix this?
[Magisk] The Analog Kid:
Didn't work for me. Still not certified.
[Magisk] peschie1967:
Problem with installation/update (from 20.3 with MM 7.5.1) of Magisk 20.4 (20040) on Samsung TAB A SM-T550. Installation with MM fails with unable to repack boot image. Installation through TWRP makes Bootlops.

Installation on my SM-G930f without problems. Any help? Thanks in advance.
[Magisk] lorvix:
v20.4 not include "magisk hide" on menu ? why is that? i need hide magisk from some apps ?
[Magisk] T.A.R.D.I.S.:
V281 doen't work too on op 7 pro. Flashing module is impossible as v279 and v280.

Edit : works with v282. Great [emoji106][emoji106][emoji106][emoji106]
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
You'll also have to maker sure that you pass SafetyNet fully first (CTS and basic integrity). Otherwise it won't work.

Sounds very much like this issue:

https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/issues/2609

Save the install log when trying to install from the Manager and see if it matches those posted there.

Have you enabled Hide in the Manager settings? It's disabled by default from Magisk v20.4.
[Magisk] Elektron60:
Can i setup hide on by default for new installed apps?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
No. It's not a good idea to add too many apps to the Hide list since it can have a detrimental effect on the system in general. Only add those apps that specifically look for root.
[Magisk] pyry666:
Same here even with 282..Op7ro 10.0.4
[Magisk] Elektron60:
Is it possible to hide Norton security?

> No, it's not possible.
[Magisk] das-angst:
Hi All, I know that there are ongoing things with magisk. I updated to the latest version today and now ctsprofile and basic integrity are failing.

Update was done via direct install method.

Does anyone else have this issue? Thanks.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
I guess... If it's detecting Magisk I see no reason why you shouldn't at least try.

For more details and tips on how to hide MagiskHide, take a look here:

https://didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHide

It's not yet fully updated for Magisk v20.4 (I'll hopefully get to that the coming weekend), but there shouldn't be any major discrepancies (apart from MagiskHide now being disabled by default and needs to be enabled manually).

Have you made sure that MagiskHide is enabled? And if it is, try toggling it off and on again.
[Magisk] das-angst:
I've tried this but no luck. I will try one other thing.
[Magisk] JT_Preston:
Error downloading Magisk zip file

Whenever i download the magisk zip file from the app or the website, it will show "error downloading file" halfway. I've tried downloading the zip file from my pc too,but the download keeps failing.

PLS help me!
[Magisk] dcarvil:
Download from https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/releases is working for me. Try rebooting your devices, including router.
[Magisk] chenxuwen:
Report: 20.4 Breaks Huawei Honor View 10. Back flashed to 20.3, then everything working.

I know magisk is installed into recovery (more precisely recovery_ramdisk) and reset to recovery is what one should do to boot with magisk / root, but 20.4 is not working for this device at the moment.

What I have tried:

1. Direct install -> failed to boot after reset

2. Direct install -> failed to boot after reset to recovery

3. Direct install with the option "install to recovery" -> failed to boot after reset

4. Direct install with the option "install to recovery" -> failed to boot after reset to recovery

5. Flashed TWRP and installed 20.4 under TWRP -> failed to boot after reset to recovery

What can I do to further help?
[Magisk] thecoolkid:
I'm having that issue as well, but I'm using Canary builds of magisk and magisk manager. I updated the manager to 282 today. Yesterday all was passing. I'm afraid Google might be rolling out their updated SafetyNet server checks that will block MagiskHide.
[Magisk] amg314:
You can install Magisk-v20.4.zip via TWRP
[Magisk] pyry666:
My safety net passes just fine on latest canary. Just cant access to modules page. Manager just crashes
[Magisk] thecoolkid:
Can you tell me what apps and which of their components you have enabled in MagiskHide?
[Magisk] Lycox:
Still not being able to load the module section. Still crashing when trying to open it. Since canary build 279 it was working (as a workaround) when I've cleared the repo cache. (Android 10)
[Magisk] pyry666:
Just two Finnish banking apps

Edit: and they work ok. Rice and xxx does not
[Magisk] robrazil:
For Cubot smartphone.

I have a mobile with android 9, using system-as-root, and I installed Magisk with "Boot Image Patching" method.

After power on the mobile in recovery mode enabling the Magisk, the Android 9 ran fine except on the activation of dual SIM card. Only when I restart the mobile in normal boot method, without Magisk, the dual SIM cards are activated and works to make and receive calls. In recovery boot mode, with Magisk activated, the dual SIM cards are disable and the options to enable them are locked.

I used Magisk-v20.3.zip / MagiskManager-v7.5.1.apk .

Thank you for any help.
[Magisk] prot-:
The same just started happening for me today.

How do I fix this?
[Magisk] zgfg:
Have you checked in Magisk settings if Magisk Hide is enabled
[Magisk] warrencoakley:
Just got a notification from GPay that I'm not set up for contactless and then checked Magisk and safetynet seems to be down. Working fine today. Magisk hide is enabled. Any fix yet? Looks like Google is up to their sneaky ways again.
[Magisk] Wolfcity:
Same here. On latest canary and on stable 20.4 both safetynet checks fail. Never had any problems on that particular device.
[Magisk] pyry666:
Safetynet forks fine form me but mudule button crashes the app. I am on latest canary and oneplus7pro 1.0..0.4. This is weird

Edit: ok I removed xxx and rice and now i can acces modules page in magisk manager:fingers-crossed:

Edit2: apparently both of those modules causes modules crash now or I am missing something..I tried them separetly with dame result
[Magisk] The Analog Kid:
Magisk 20.4 stable release note says "every single command will be forced to use the one that is in Magisk's BusyBox (if available)"... is osm0sis BusyBox actually "Magisk's BusyBox" or there is something I am missing? I'm delaying update from 20.3 because I'm not sure if I'm running or have "Magisk's BusyBox" available or not. Could someone be kind enough to clarify a bit on this, please?
[Magisk] pndwal:
I think only CTS will fail if G switches on key attestation, and Basic Integrity should still be ok. If I'm not wrong, both failing indicates a different system setup problem. PW
[Magisk] tech_head:
Interesting.

I'm on 20.3 and it's working flawless on my OnePlus 7 Pro with OxygenOS 10.3.1
[Magisk] Tuxedo.Bond:
Both of mine also failed beginning a few days ago and before I updated to the latest Magisk. However, Google Pay still worked at a Wells Fargo ATM today. I did not try a transaction at a point of sale device.
[Magisk] JudgeDread11:
My modules page is crashing and I don't have those modules installed, so either there are more modules causing the crash and/or there there is more going on.

Will do some testing later if I get the chance.
[Magisk] osm0sis:
diareuse is working on it: https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/issues/2631
[Magisk] JT_Preston:
I've tried downloading from the link that you gave but it still says couldn't download file. I've even tried to do the boot image patching in magisk. When I go to twrp and flash the magisk_patch image and reboot my phone,the magisk app and the root checker app shows "root access is not properly on this device"

---------- Post added at 06:46 AM ---------- Previous post was at 06:41 AM ----------

@dcarvil

I've tried downloading from the link that you gave but it still says couldn't download file. I've even tried to do the boot image patching in magisk. When I go to twrp and flash the magisk_patch image and reboot my phone,the magisk app and the root checker app shows "root access is not properly on this device"
[Magisk] das-angst:
I didn't sadly. I turned Magisk Hide on and off, reinstalled Magisk via recovery but no luck.

I own a Mi 8 (Dipper) and am currently running Revenge OS. I've not faced any issue with Magisk, apart from when Goolge turned on ctsProfile check. It could be something to do with the device but I am not 100% sure.

If you need me to run any checks, please let me know. I am happy to help.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
If you can't download the files from GitHub it's likely that there's something blocking the download on your end. Firewall, ISP, etc...

But if you can patch a boot image that means that the download in the Manager worked (or it wouldn't have patched the file). If no other method of download works, you'll at least find the Magisk zip in the Manager's cache (/data/data/com.topjohnwu.magisk/cache, or in the directory matching the random package name displayed in the main Manager window if you've hidden the Manager).

You could also try using that zip in TWRP...

But, the main thing is that we need logs. Lots of logs... Take a look here (and also in other parts of that guide for other troubleshooting tips):

https://didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHelp
[Magisk] prot-:
I fixed the safetynet fail and gpay not working by disabling the modules that I've had for a long time which once fixed those issues!
[Magisk] Talladale:
I disabled all my modules. Basic integrity now shows true but cts profile is false and Gpay still saying it won't work but I can still use various other financial and root sensitive apps.
[Magisk] Mangosan24:
Same. was commuting to work when the google pay turn crazy.