yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] amar2cool99:
Is there any way to unroot in build root
[Magisk] teddy0209:
Why would you do that?

Edit: Install the other root management app, grant it root rights and update the binary... Then you can disable root in magisk settings...
[Magisk] optimumpro:
[MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION]

Greetings and thanks for excellent work. I'd like to make a suggestion: As you might know, Nougat doesn't have its own busybox, it uses toybox instead. I know Magisk has internal busybox, but it is set to off by default, which results in numerous f/cs for system apps when you select 'hide root'. And users usually are not so smart to figure it out. So, could you please enable builin busybox by default? Again, thanks for the excellent work.
[Magisk] :
I am having a problem with Magisk 12 it doesn't allow any music player to read from the sd card and also the files explorers like solid
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
I'm curious about this one... I have not experienced anything like what you're describing. Do you have any details about if it's on certain devices, ROMs or specific combinations of the same? Logcats, etc?
[Magisk] Hooxp17:
lost root

and the location of boot.img was empty.:crying:

I'm a new comer, and don't know how to upload screenshot.:crying:
[Magisk] rocky78:
yes (but how is this related to magisk?).

go to twrp-->mount system (if you dont, you will not see the su files)--> in system/bin and system/xbin, change su to s_u and reboot.

good luck

---------- Post added at 03:42 PM ---------- Previous post was at 03:39 PM ----------

give more details. what rom/phone/version...?
[Magisk] :
Please provide logs to help the developers finding the problem. You should also tell a bit more.

- Device:

- What build are you on:

- Clean or Dirty flash:

- Custom kernel:

- When did it start:

- Brief description:

- Steps to replicate:

- Log:

An easy way to get logs is via the Syslog app: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.tortel.syslog
[Magisk] Vasanth Vasi:
My safety net pass...... Failed. (cts profile mismatch)

I'm running on marshmallow.........Any solution

Plz plz plz helpppp:(
[Magisk] unbreakabl3:
Attached.

Btw these are the things I've done/tried:

-enabled MagiskHide, busybox, systemless host within Magisk Manager but that didn't work.

-Osmosis' unSu, uninstalled Magisk and reinstalled.

-I dont have Xposed either.

-flashed boeffla kernel. Still fails.

When flashing the ROM i did a clean wipe (including internal storage). I had flashed latest version of Chainfire's supersu before the wipe but when the phone booted up, only Magisk Manager app was there. No SuperSU. Would that be why safetynet fails?
[Magisk] BoozYooNit:
FWIW, I was having the same problem with Magisk 12 on my Nexus 6 running Dark ROM (LOS based) with Substratum installed. Magisk Manager could never locate a boot image and wouldn't let me browse for it or use the Detect button. And I was losing root after trying to flash anything in TWRP. With Substratum & themes uninstalled, everything's back to normal.
[Magisk] culiacanazo:
Lol i like how it's become "the other root app"......
[Magisk] mchapa489:
How do I get the su section to switch to magisksu?
[Magisk] Tesla:
Please read the OP and at least a couple of pages in this thread.

What you will find is that users that do get help provided more information and a rudimentary understanding of what they where doing.

You can't understand the answers without first learning to ask questions.
[Magisk] rocky78:
as said before, you can't use supersu and magisksu.

from what i understand, your rom comes prerooted.

what you need to do is this (i did that in crdroid v3.0 that comes prerooted):

clean flash.

restart sytem.

reboot to twrp-->mount system, in system/bin and system/xbin locate su and change su to s_u (this will unroot built in root).

restart sytem.

reboot to twrp -->flash magisksu v12.0

restart sytem.

update magisk manager from play store.

open magisk manager.

in status 'tab' check that you are rooted with topjohnwu

enable (tick) magisksu hide.

restart.

check in status tab again that you are rooted as above.

tick and untick magisksu hide (at this point, don't enable busybox or system hosts).

try to pass safteynet check.

hope that helped you out.
[Magisk] mchapa489:
I have systemless root with SuperSU
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
Get rid of SuperSU and re-install Magisk
[Magisk] Iceman248:
I have a new Pixel XL and have some questions regarding boot image modifications that Magisk does and using an ElementalX kernel, which is what I'll switch to soon instead of stock Pure Nexus kernel, which is ROM I am running.

I have Magisk working fine on latest 7.1.2. From my understanding, Magisk modifies boot image. What exactly does it modify? Is it modifying the kernel at all? When I flash a kernel after Magisk is already installed, whether from ROM update or new update to ElementalX, do I need to reflash Magisk because the kernel would've overwritten the Magisk modifications to the boot image?

Also, I've seen instructions to flash TWRP after Magisk and not to. Does Magisk modify the recovery at all?
[Magisk] adma84:
Sure, I understand the module I was making (purely for myself) was trivial. I am just trying to get my feet wet. I am trying to figure out why build.prop isn't getting modified with my very simple case, even though I think I followed the instructions properly.

I do appreciate the help for sure, I am just trying to work through the mechanics of magisk and was surprised this very simple case didn't work.
[Magisk] culiacanazo:
It doesn't modify recovery, and it patches boot img; now, I'm no expert at this, but I am an English teacher and "patch" and "modify" are two different things.

Lastly, I've flashed both first kernel, then Magisk, and first Magisk then kernel, and both techniques have worked (I'm on an S5 and I've flashed Skater's Boeffla and Smart Pack as well... but if I had to guess, I'd say it'd be "something"-dependent
[Magisk] mchapa489:
How do i get rid of it completely?
[Magisk] :
Flash This -

https://xdaforums.com/attachment.php?attachmentid=3931994&d=1478779893
[Magisk] betus81:
i have a rom resurrection in my oneplus 3. Today I've seen this application and I'm looking for what it is. I've readed that can be used for hide root at some app. i want to hide root at app "samsung smart home"

i have this situation in magisk and i think thath is no good

what i can do?
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
Upgrade to Magisk v12 and install topjohnwu's Magisk Manager or upgrade to RR 5.8.3
[Magisk] betus81:
ok. is this the next step?

is correct (auto)sde 18?

i must to click "scarica e installa"

excuse for my Low knowledge
[Magisk] mchapa489:
Settings in magisk manager then tick magisk hide. Then go to magisk hide in the menu and tick off the app
[Magisk] adma84:
How does this work exactly? I can't see in service.sh or in the init script where your buildprop_edit script gets called. This is pure magic!!!!!!!
[Magisk] mchapa489:
The link isn't sending me anywhere

---------- Post added at 11:31 AM ---------- Previous post was at 11:30 AM ----------

Disregard I got it
[Magisk] betus81:
you are great, i've solved with app samsung smart home, now it function in my device. thanks also to DodoGTA
[Magisk] Tesla:
Link the developers thread and post please. Not just the file.
[Magisk] techinv:
I'm seeing safety net fail on my Nexus 6P today. I have the latest magisk manager and zip. Is there a specific app to hide for Safety Net?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
There's a few lines added to update-binary that copies buildprop_edit to /magisk/.core/post-fs-data.d when installing the module. Nothing magical about it...
[Magisk] adma84:
Clever. That's what I was looking for, thanks.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Guys... Details, please! As much as you possibly can think of and then some... And logs, or it didn't happen.

There's something fishy with your setup. The process is detected properly, but nothing is unmounted. Could be a ROM, kernel or a bit of both issue...

You can see in the log that he's using MagiskSU and that he has neither busybox or systemless hosts enabled...

A couple of times I've experienced that some props doesn't get set when using system.prop but that it works with the resetprop tool and post-fs-data.

SafetyNet is already hidden by default. If you suddenly can't pass SafetyNet when you previously could, the first thing to try is to toggle Hide off and on again. For more tips, check the link in my signature.
[Magisk] iu1nguoi:
The new Magisk Manager 4.3.2 crashes at startup. I revert back to 4.3.1 for now.
[Magisk] Midomad:
I can't unistall system apps with Titanium back up using Magisk !

Could anyone confirm?
[Magisk] adma84:
FWIW, I don't think the magic mount of your modified build.prop is working on my pixel. I can see your modified build.prop in /magic/TASKERROOTBUILDPROP folder, (it looks good there), but it's not making it to the systemless /system

Any ideas?
[Magisk] Crix.Ful92:
For me SafetyNet controll not work

Android 5.1.1 CM 12.1

Moto G² [Titan]

Inviato dal mio Moto G 2014 utilizzando Tapatalk
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Works just fine here... Tried clearing data?

Pixel, huh? I guess it could be because it's not yet an officially supported device and it has it's quirks... What version of Magisk are you using? I don't see anything in the log about it mounting anything. Do you have verbose logging on? And that log is a mess. It's supposed to clear on a reboot...

---------- Post added at 22:04 ---------- Previous post was at 21:59 ----------

Upload a Magisk log and also you could try disabling busybox and rebooting.

Big, big images... Hurts my eyes... :crying:
[Magisk] adma84:
Ok, I uninstalled your module, rebooted. Cleared the log, checked the verbose options (2 of them), installed your module again, and rebooted. Attached is the log. I am using Magisk 12 on the pixel. Its working great for a lot of things so far, but maybe the magic mounts don't work?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Try attaching the log again...
[Magisk] mchapa489:
I tried that but then when I try to flash magisk zip after it doesn't work. Gives an error in TWRP.
[Magisk] unbreakabl3:
So what should I do? try another ROM?

I guess I'll wipe and try this.
[Magisk] adma84:
One more try
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Where's the recovery log. Without that, what follows is pure guesswork...

Flashing that unSU zip only removes files. The boot image is probably still patched. If that's the issue you'll need to flash a boot image without the patches.

If your ROM comes prepatched it might get tricky. Ask in your ROM thread in that case.

If it doesn't come prepatched, extract the boot image from your ROM zip/factory image and flash that to your device. You could also dirty flash your ROM...

---------- Post added at 22:38 ---------- Previous post was at 22:33 ----------

Are you using Magisk to make apps into system apps? In that case uninstalling other system apps with TiBu won't work, since what it's seeing, and trying to remove, is Magisk's systemless mask rather than the actual system (or something like that). Use a Magisk module to debloat or disable the systemising module and reboot before using TiBu to uninstall.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Nope... Doesn't look like it's Magisk mounting. Have you gotten any other modules that mounts files to /system to work?
[Magisk] boldonc:
After (apr. 25) v4.3.2 Magisk update Safetynet Failed. Before that working good! :( What happened or changed in update! (Nexus 5x, PureNexus ROM, ElementalX kernel)
[Magisk] Midomad:
No,I'm only trying to delete some system apps like swifkey?

It was working with chainfire SuperSu!
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
I'm gonna quote myself here...

---------- Post added at 22:46 ---------- Previous post was at 22:43 ----------

I just tried it on my Nexus 6 and it worked without issues with Magisk v12, MagiskSU. Did you reboot after uninstalling?
[Magisk] Midomad:
Yes there are here again!
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Upload a Magisk log, verbose logging enabled.
[Magisk] Midomad:
Will do,when back at home and i will quote you,

Thanks for you're help!

Appreciated.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
No worries... It's probably something simple, but I'm too tired to think. If no-one else beats me to it I'll check it out after I've had a few hours (days?) of sleep.

Peace out.
[Magisk] techinv:
Toggling magisk hide off/on and then reboot fixed this for me.
[Magisk] westeight:
Same on my HTU U Ultra. Back to 4.3.1.
[Magisk] adma84:
I haven't really tried any other modules that I think need the modified /system (besides systemless hosts).
[Magisk] boldonc:
Ok. Thanks, but banking applications still not working! (Saftynet passed)
[Magisk] Luniz2k1:
4.3.2 working OK here
[Magisk] culiacanazo:
Hate to be late but i made it
[Magisk] Midomad:
Can you check if the app is still there after a reboot?
[Magisk] culiacanazo:
Also, i assume this is the right place for the following, since it's not a bug per se, but in settings (I'm sorry, it's the teacher in me), says "All modules will not be loaded" when it should be "No modules will be loaded"... And i don't offer myself up for translating since I speak the two most WIDESPREAD languages in the world, so, it's not like I'm a rare item
[Magisk] Artim_96:
It's a pretty old problem already, many apps aren't able to properly mount /system rw.

You should get it working by entering

mount -o rw,remount,rw system

In a terminal emulator app before doing such things.
[Magisk] Midomad:
I wonder why it's still not fixed with all those magisk updates?

I never encountered this issue with Chainfire SuperSu!
[Magisk] culiacanazo:
Ooopppsss... Creepy... Came back.

Is this only with titanium? I mean i know i can with ES and i also know i can restore data no problem with TiBu
[Magisk] Midomad:
Dunno,for now it's only Titanium back up!
[Magisk] jhedfors:
I would suggest taking a look at an existing module that just makes just build prop changes - for example "Enable EIS for Nexus 5X". Just download, and unzip it. Good luck.
[Magisk] mchapa489:
Where do I get the recovery log?
[Magisk] jhedfors:
In TWRP, select Advanced --> Copy logs to SD.
[Magisk] SynaTech:
hope I can get this one figured out...

Magisk installs fine, however the app wont open at all costs.

I've deleted, cleared cache, deleted all data, wipe dalvik cache, uninstalled and reinstalled magisk, etc...

help? (OnePlus 3 running OpenBeta 14, was working for a while, now just stopped working.)

edit: fixed it by installing a backup through titanium backup... no clue what caused it... make your backups people!
[Magisk] kutysam:
Hi, Could anyone try and see if magisk hide is working on this UOB MIGHTY APP? Mine isn't.

https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.uob.mighty.app&hl=en

I tried magisk hide on android pay and a few others and they all work. (Mi4i v8.1.7) 5.0.1 version.

Thanks!
[Magisk] kopitalk:
No go for me too. SafetyNet is cleared and Android Pay can make transactions though.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
If you guys can't fix the issue, how about helping out the community instead of just going: "doesn't work, I won't use it". Capture a logcat from the crash and upload it to a relevant issue on GitHub.

How to logcat:

https://www.xda-developers.com/guide-sending-a-logcat-to-help-debug-your-favorite-app/

https://xdaforums.com/showthread.php?t=1726238

Most apps don't use SafetyNet and many apps look for more than just root. Check the link in my signature for a bunch of troubleshooting tips.

Some apps just have really good detection methods and can't be fooled...

Gah! Can't be unseen!

Man, oh man... I did not think about that. Mainly because rw issues was supposed to have been fixed in v11.5.

Hmm. I have it working on my N6... I'll do some more testing when I get the time.

Meanwhile: [MENTION=4065345]Midomad[/MENTION] did it fix your issue?
[Magisk] szunyi77:
How can this be corrected? Thanks
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
First of all, make sure that magiskhide process doesn't use a lot of CPU usage

Second of all, set ro.build.type property to user and ro.build.tags property to release-tags using Magisk or with build.prop edit
[Magisk] Rush94:
Here's the magisk log

** Magisk post-fs mode running...

** Magisk post-fs-data mode running...

* Running post-fs-data.d

* Loading core props

* Preparing modules

* Stage 1: Mount system and vendor mirrors

* Stage 2: Mount dummy skeletons

* Stage 3: Mount module items

* Stage 4: Execute module scripts

* Stage 5: Mount mirrored items back to dummy

** Magisk late_start service mode running...

* Linking binaries to /sbin

* Starting MagiskSU

* Running service.d

* Starting MagiskHide

MagiskHide: Moving and re-linking /sbin binaries

MagiskHide: Removing dangerous read-only system props

MagiskHide: resetprop by nkk71 & topjohnwu

Initializing...

Modify data structure: 'ro.debuggable'='0'

Existing property: 'ro.debuggable'='1'

Recheck property: 'ro.debuggable'='0'

Done!

MagiskHide: Starting MagiskHide daemon

MagiskHide: Unable to watch /magisk/.core/magiskhide/hidelist

I am unable to bypass safety net

Can any1 help me
[Magisk] teddy0209:
Well, there are other root management app to choose from... He didn't mention a specific app...
[Magisk] Xennet:
[MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION]

New magisk manager app 4.3.2 crashing on opening

Installed old version 4.3.1 working fine

Oneplus 3t on STOCK OOS 4.1.3

MAGISK v12

Anyone having this issue???
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
Post a log: https://xdaforums.com/showthread.php?t=1726238
[Magisk] Crix.Ful92:
Deactivating busybox does not work. How can i make it work?
[Magisk] nathanchance:
1. Please use a site like Hastebin for logs in the future.

2. Do you have a theme on Magsik Manager?
[Magisk] Artim_96:
I'd guess because of supported commands. Magisk would probably need to run busybox and maybe a different version to fix that.

I had read something about this topic from Chainfire a while ago, either at release of M or N where he complained a bit about busybox and toolbox.
[Magisk] kutysam:
Anyone can assist with this issue? Any thing needed on my end? Please let me know. Thanks..
[Magisk] szunyi77:
Cpu no problem .. build.prop edit can you help? What needs to be changed?

thanks
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
You can use this app to edit your build.prop file (Changes that you need to do are in your post): https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.jrummy.apps.build.prop.editor
[Magisk] Xennet:
Sorry will post the logcat separately

Got it rectified had substratum themed magisk. Uninstalled now working fine
[Magisk] szunyi77:
Think about that? Do I have to modify this?

Manipulate system props (build.prop)

Since the early days of XDA, people love "build.prop" mods. It can bring cool effects to our devices.

build.prop files are loaded early in the boot process, and once read-in, the values cannot be modified... in theory.

Magisk included a tool called "resetprop", it can modify any system props you want easily.

...............etc...
[Magisk] Dev_Mashru:
Hi guys,

I'm facing this error while trying to flash magisk:

I unrooted and tried again, but I still I get an error.

Device: Lenovo Tab 2 A7 10F

Android v5.0

Thanks!!
[Magisk] Midomad:
No,i ended up using solid explorer to delete the apps manually!

I hope it will be fixed in future updates.

Is [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] aware?

Thanks again for you're interest.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
I would have liked to see a Magisk log. Easier to troubleshoot that way.

There's no unmounting of necessary folders being done. Could be a ROM or kernel issue or a bit of both...

Most apps don't use SafetyNet and some apps check for more than just root. Check the link in my signature for a few troubleshooting tips. Some apps are just to good at finding root though...

I don't think your device is compatible. There are a couple of GitHub issues about Lenovo devices already:

https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/issues/57

https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/issues/128

---------- Post added at 12:06 ---------- Previous post was at 11:55 ----------

No worries. Like I said, since I have it working on my Nexus 6 I might get around to do some more testing later.

Is it purely for debloating reasons you wan't to get rid of the apps? Or do you really need the space? I have a module that debloats (among other things) my OnePlus 3T and that way I don't have to delete apps again after an update... That's the main reason I use Magisk actually, to keep all those kinds of system modifications across updates. There's a nice module in the repo for it as well by [MENTION=7296895]veez21[/MENTION] called Terminal Emulator Debloater.
[Magisk] Midomad:
No,it's only by curiosity since it's working on SuperSu [emoji6]
[Magisk] Honeycd:
I have a doubt, I use xposed but only one important module. Is there any way to convert it to magisk module? Forgive my ignorance
[Magisk] yochananmarqos:
Depends what the module is, but most likely not. Xposed and Magisk are two completely different things.
[Magisk] CROCOLR:
I have a problem with my app bank , ING Direct in Spain...

It works flawlessly with the latest magisk manager app and the magisk v11.6 zip, and i can unlock the bank app with my fingerprint, and pay with my movil nfc...But with the same magisk manager app and the magisk v12 zip,the ING bank app stops to allow me unlock with fingerprint,and can't pay with nfc...

What are the changes that cause it?

I am using a Xiaomi mi5 with Resurrection Remix Un5.8.2 2017/03/13 ROM...A linageos based ROM

Thanks!!!
[Magisk] Feenfleisch:
Xiaomi Mi Max / Lineage 7.1.2 / last Version Magisk 13 & Magisk Manager: Magisk Manager say i have no Magisk install, but the safetynet Status is Ok

Gesendet von meinem Mi Max mit Tapatalk
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
[MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] already knows that problem
[Magisk] westeight:
Same problem with 4.3.3 - tried it on two phones. One an upgrade from 4.3.1 and the other a fresh install:
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
With Magisk v11.6 Hide would change a few ro.build props by default. That caused some issues so it was reverted for v12. Your app probably checks for one or more of those values. Check the link in my signature for more details on those kind of prop values.

Earlier today it was reported that Substratum caused issues with the Manager. Do you have Substratum installed?
[Magisk] drezz2:
hi

the file "Latest Uninstaller" do the same that uninstall from masgisk manager uninstall option?.. so its only if you not use the manager?

thanks
[Magisk] dantexaiver:
Rocking pix Sailfish with Pure nexus and System less Supersized.

Try to install I recovery get told /system can not be mounted installation aborted
[Magisk] Bhujji:
Hello,

I have Honor 7 phone with stock rom. I have only flashed twrp via fastboot and then magisk v 12 from twrp. Magisk manager works properly for the most part, It can hide root and grant root permissions but I am not able to flash any module. It just shows (Installation error!). Tried restarting and enabling and disabling busybox and systemless hosts and magisk hide. I have not flashed supersu or any other module. Please help, I am attaching magisk logs after trying to flash the modules from the magisk manager below.

* Magisk post-fs mode running...

** Magisk post-fs-data mode running...

/data/magisk_merge.img found

/data/magisk.img found, attempt to merge

Expanding /data/magisk.img to 32M...

/dev/block/loop0 /data/magisk.img

/dev/block/loop1 /data/magisk_merge.img

Merge complete

* Running post-fs-data.d

* Loading core props

* Preparing modules

* Stage 1: Mount system and vendor mirrors

* Stage 2: Mount dummy skeletons

* Stage 3: Mount module items

* Stage 4: Execute module scripts

* Stage 5: Mount mirrored items back to dummy

** Magisk late_start service mode running...

* Enabling BusyBox

* Linking binaries to /sbin

* Starting MagiskSU

* Running service.d
[Magisk] westeight:
Sorted, thank you. Unthemed Magisk, upgraded, rebooted and then rethemed via Substratum.

4.3.3 now running fine x2 :cowboy::svetius:
[Magisk] doomscooter:
Where link magisk 433? Last beta 424
[Magisk] westeight:
Themed:
[Magisk] westeight:
Playstore
[Magisk] HEaRiX:
Could anyone help me with Magisk, Miui and Redmi 4 Prime? Thanks :/

I cant pass safety net

Gesendet von meinem Redmi 4 mit Tapatalk
[Magisk] LazerL0rd:
You have different daemons that might be the cause.