yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] zzz2002:
Running unofficial Lineageos 16 on a S7 edge, Magisk 19.4 + manager 7.3.1.

Everything seems to work as expected, touch wood.

So maybe its something about your phone & apps which are the problem.
[Magisk] djjohnnyblaze:
EDIT 2... So I thought this was fixed but it isnt. I tried clearing cache/app data but eventually the crash comes back when going to the superuser tab. Not sure whats going on here.. Any help is appreciated.

EDIT 3: Logcat is attached.
[Magisk] kotuamoalt:
You should be sending logs as attachments, not in the post itself.

---------- Post added at 01:21 AM ---------- Previous post was at 01:15 AM ----------

There is an old saying: Don't pick up a happy baby. If you are on a working version of Magisk, just stay there, until it is no longer working. Mmmkay?
[Magisk] djjohnnyblaze:
Ah wasnt aware. I have edited my post and attached the logcat. Thanks!
[Magisk] nacos:
Completely agree with EVERYTHING you stated, hence still using Android 7.0.... it's the frustration of going through all these trials and then wasting hours to recover.

Take my comments as venting off, nothing else...yes, with sincere appreciations for the hard work that was put into this phenomenal venture. Cheers!
[Magisk] gil80:
hi all.

I use 1+1 with TugaPower ROM latest build.

I freshly installed this ROM now.

I use latest magisk manager and magisk versions.

Magisk hide simply doesn't work for me.

It used to work, but seems to be broken now.

Can someone please help me troubleshoot it?
[Magisk] mctiew:
I want to ask something about DRM. Would installation of Magisk affect the Widevine level of a device ? Example, if I have a Widevine security level one, will it be dropped to some other lower level ?
[Magisk] Dominic.B:
Yes, it does. You can check your widevine level with some app after installing magisk. Although it doesn't affect much.
[Magisk] guest4711:
On my devices MagiskHide does not start after booting. I have to toggle it off and on again to get it working (til next reboot). Did you try it?
[Magisk] zgfg:
Random issue with crashing when opening Superuser list was reported in this thread two days ago ( few users):

https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/mod-magisk-v1-universal-systemless-t3432382/post79749002

and also in the Canary build thread - happens both for MM v7.3.1 stable 222 and Canary 223

In fact, bug is already fixed in the code, so waiting for new MM release with the fix

https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/dev-magisk-canary-channel-bleeding-edge-t3839337/post79750191
[Magisk] kotuamoalt:
Your question is waaay to vague...

"Magisk hide simply doesn't work for me" does not really convey the information necessary to help you with your issue.
[Magisk] gil80:
Apps that used to work are now detecting that I'm rooted.

Since the last magisk update, I'm not able to use these apps.

toggeling the magisk hide option on and off after a reboot, seemed to resolve the issue with the exception of 1 app that still detects I'm rooted.

I tried to hide magisk manager app, using the option in the settings. That seemed to solve the issue but it introduced a new issue -> launching Manager, it now shows that magisk doesn't exist and I cannot restore magisk. I had to flash the ZIP again.

So I can't seem to really solve the issue where Magisk hide is working on boot and is able to stay hidden from few apps I'm using.

Hiding magisk causes the manager app to not show an option to revert back.
[Magisk] kotuamoalt:
Much better. When you say "newest versions" , exactly what versions are you talking about? What are your build numbers?
[Magisk] gil80:
Stable Magisk Version: v19.3

Magisk Manager Version: v7.3.1
[Magisk] kotuamoalt:
Have you tried reflashing your OS? Another thing to try would be one of the Canary or debug builds. Also, the last thing to try would be deleting the offending app's cache/data. Especially after root has been detected by the app, and you upgrade magisk.
[Magisk] gil80:
magisk is 19.3 (19300) and 7.3.1 (222)
[Magisk] kotuamoalt:
I am going to assume that you mean 19.3?
[Magisk] gil80:
corrected. 19.3 (19300)

in the log I see:

* starting MagiskHide
hide_policy: hiding sensitive props
hide_list init: [{some vendor name}]
** boot_complete triggered

But it doens't work. I have to toggle magisk hide on and off. but out of 4 apps, 1 still can see I'm rooted. and as mentioned previously, before the last magisk update (I'm always updating as they get released so I assume I was on the build previous to 19300) I had no issues with magisk hide.
[Magisk] Ps24u:
Since updating Magisk Manager to 7.3.1, sometimes when I select the "Superuser" tab, the Manager crashes with error: "Manager has stopped."

I'm using Magisk 18.1 on Android 7.1.1

Previous versions of Magisk Manager never crashed like this.
[Magisk] wilsonhlacerda:
This is a bug of v19.3. Read some previous pages and you gonna see some posts of mine and replies to them.

The one detecting Magisk: uninstall it, reboot, toggle Hide, install it....may help. If not, you have to better debug it (follow suggestions previously written on this thread about apps detecting root).
[Magisk] kotuamoalt:
Have you ever heard the saying; "Don't pick up a happy baby"? If a previous version was working for you, I recommend that you revert back to that version. There is no need for you to upgrade, unless you start having issues with apps seeing root. This is as far as my help can take you.
[Magisk] gil80:
Is there a terminal app that can run commands on boot?

Because if it can run:

su
magiskhide --disable
magiskhide --enable

on boot, then it's an OK workaround.
[Magisk] cryogeno:
Some problem here!
[Magisk] wilsonhlacerda:
Yeah, that can be an easy way to circumvent the bug with v19.3

Can do that with with any automation tool (Tasker,...), some Kernel Management (Kernel Adiutor, SmartPack Kernel Management,...) or even a simple script on init.d (maybe with a Sleep before toggling Hide). Or even a simple Magisk module.

Nice suggestion.
[Magisk] guest4711:
How about putting it into a script in /data/adb/service.d/ ?
[Magisk] djjohnnyblaze:
Ah thanks! Guess I'll wait for the new version of MM to drop.
[Magisk] gil80:
Can't create a folder adb in /data because a file in the same name exists.

That file is 0kb.
[Magisk] blud7:
My solution to the dual Magisks was to simply uninstall the unpackaged Magisk that was fouling up using Link2SD.
[Magisk] Ob.sys:
Understanding and fixing systemless root issue

Hello.

I rooted my phone and a few days later, I was stuck on boot screen.

A. I flashed the stock boot img file and also "fixed context" from TWRP and lost root access.

B. Now, when I try flashing the same magisk 19, it succeeds and I get stuck on boot screen for hours without boot.

Step A restores a (rootless) phone after step B.

Questions:

1. Has the phone been unrooted?

2. How do I root my Infinix-X603 again?
[Magisk] JudgeDread11:
[Somebody posted a while back a link to a thread with exactly that, a simple Magisk module to run these commands.]

Edited, sorry I was wrong. I got confused with this

It's to restart the su deamon, not Magisk hide.
[Magisk] Syoenth:
this can be a noob question but to install the patched ramdisk on huawei devices I must unlock the bootloader?

---------- Post added at 08:58 AM ---------- Previous post was at 08:47 AM ----------

I don't know if this the proper thread to post this but I have a problem with magisk on my Samsung J7 2015, PoGo detects my device is rooted when I use the Android 6.0.1 stock Rom, but when I use a custom rom with Android 7and 7.1 it works flawless, I haven't had this problem before
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
1 - An unlocked bootloader is required.

2 - Procfs leak?
[Magisk] zgfg:
Do you have Oreo or Nougat, stock or custom ROM?

You need unlocked Bootloader, for Nougat you must patch Boot, for Oreo Ramdisk.

But if you are on Nougat, you must go for Magisk v18.1 - do not use any Magisk v19.x, because it's useless on Huawei with EMUI 5.x, it asks for password to decrypt Data, it fails to and wrongly asks you to do Factory reset (although, one just needs to revert back to Magisk v18 and everything is ok, no need for password to decrypt, no need for Factory resetting).

Same problem in all Magisk v19.x versions (stable, beta, canary), reported by several users (P9, P9 Plus, P9 Lite, P8 Lite, Mate 8)

Open ticket on GitHub:

https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/issues/1409
[Magisk] DalekMechanic:
Problem installing Magisk

Hello guys,

Hope you can help me. I'm trying to install magisk on a Lenovo Tab 2 A10-30 (TB2-X30L) with LineageOS 14.1-20170220-UNOFFICIAL-TB-X30L.

Kernel Version is 3.10.49.

Problem is following: I can patch the boot.img succesfully, but after flashing the patched boot.img magisk manager still says that magisk isn't installed.

I tried flashing the patched img, then installing zip with TWRP right afterwards, then it recognizes that boot-img is already patched by magisk but after reboot magisk manager still says that magisk is not installed.

I uploaded the install.log from magisk manager at https://mega.nz/#!VkYTWKSB!TUS2xhmYRLOGM4AsfPxckffxnQYog89ntgJexFdCCdc , if you need something else please ask and i will try to send!

I hope you can understand the issue with this description, as english is not my native language.

Big thanks for future replies and

Kind Regards

Tobi
[Magisk] Syoenth:
That's weird, SafetyNet pass with magisk, only Pokémon GO detects I'm rooted, before wasn't detect it, even with Magisk v19.2

---------- Post added at 01:02 PM ---------- Previous post was at 01:00 PM ----------

I want to root a Huawei Y6 (2018), it have Oreo, where can I unlock bootloader for that model? Thanks in advance
[Magisk] mrspeccy:
Danish banking app detects Magisk 19.3: easy to fix

I just realized that MitNykredit (https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=dk.bec.android.mb1.b00032.prod&hl=de) and probably further Danish banking apps now use the amateurish and error-prone UDS root detection "heuristic" to detect Magisk 19.3. Easy to circumvent: open a root shell and execute

su -c chmod 000 /proc/net/unix

(see https://github.com/Ingan121/UDSBypass)
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
https://twitter.com/topjohnwu/status/1140717667118018560
[Magisk] zgfg:
Better search and ask on the appropriate XDA Y16 forum (Guides, Q/A, or so)

https://xdaforums.com/huawei-y6

Don't know if DC Unlocker and Ministry of solutions provide Bootloader codes for Y16 (they do for some other Huawei models)

https://www.dc-unlocker.com/

https://ministryofsolutions.com/paid-services
[Magisk] reneftw:
Hello.

I use a oneplus 5 with Oxygen os 5.1.3 (android 8.1.0). Tonight I updated magisk manager and magisk to latest version. The problem is I lose root about 20-30 seconds after I restart the phone. If I check the magisk app right after I start the phone, it shows magisk is installed, but after about 20 seconds, magisk is not installed anymore. I tried using an older version, uninstalling from twrp and install it again, absolutely nothing worked. I never had any problem till I updated. Can you please help? Thank you.
[Magisk] Shadow$777:
regarding sm-j727p

as I own this phone (all i could afford at the time with some regrets and as I couldn't leave well enough alone) I rooted under Nougat w/success (tx XDA, YOU GUYS ROCK). Ugraded to oreo. still rooted until security upgrade. I am what you would consider a noob BUT I am an old school programmer and can't help modding stuff. IF YOU WANT A REAL PHONE the learning curve on the SM-J727P is steep. Most people would buy a better phone. I am disabled and on a fixed income (also incredibly stubborn) and can't afford an upgrade right now. THE EFFORTS OF ALL WHO WOULD SPEND TIME HACKING OLD HARDWARE IS SUPREMELY APPRECIATED. I am forever grateful for your efforts!!!! first time post
[Magisk] RogerNZ:
OnePlus 7 Pro with TWRP.

When I install magisk and reboot my phone, it starts up then immediately shutdown.

As a poor substitute, I tried to install SuperSu. Resulted in phone being able to boot, but no root.

Any suggestions gratefully appreciated.

Thank you in advance.

---------- Post added at 04:26 AM ---------- Previous post was at 04:25 AM ----------

OnePlus 7 Pro with TWRP.

When I install magisk and reboot my phone, it starts up then immediately shutdown.

As a poor substitute, I tried to install SuperSu. Resulted in phone being able to boot, but no root.

Any suggestions gratefully appreciated.

Thank you in advance.
[Magisk] reneftw:
The same thing happens to me on Oneplus 5. But only since the update to Magisk 19.3, it worked ok before.
[Magisk] RogerNZ:
In the end, what worked for me was magisk v17.1
[Magisk] RamsPyrope:
Huawei P8 Lite 2017 user here on Android 7.0 (EMUI5) with TWRP

Magisk versions 19.3, 19.2, 19.1 and 19.0 all cause a bootloop, 18.1 works fine though
[Magisk] zgfg:
Unfortunately, this is a known issue, reported a month+ ago, affecting various (all?) Huawei phones with stock Nougat / EMUI 5.x

https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/mod-magisk-v1-universal-systemless-t3432382/post79764676

[MENTION=507649]devs[/MENTION], since Magisk worked just fine on Huawei phones with Nougat with all versions v18.1 and earlier, is there are any chance to fix/revert it back in Magisk v19.x?

Or, problem was introduced by deep architectural changes in v19 (adaptations for Pixel, Q, A/B devices and so), and there is no way to get it working back also for (Huawei) Nougat
[Magisk] HpNoTiQ:
Hi,

I think there is a problem with magisk not hiding bootloader status.

My 2 smartphones (Pixel 3a stock + EXKernel + Magisk canary / N5X Pixel Experience) won't see netflix in store while safetynet is ok and device certified.

My A5 2017 running Pixel Experience can download and run last Netflix.

---------- Post added at 12:13 PM ---------- Previous post was at 12:13 PM ----------

Hi,

I think there is a problem with magisk not hiding bootloader status.

My 2 smartphones (Pixel 3a stock + EXKernel + Magisk canary / N5X Pixel Experience) won't see netflix in store while safetynet is ok and device certified.

My A5 2017 running Pixel Experience can download and run last Netflix.

Moreoever, I can use Pay with no Attest Tasker script or any mod on my A5 but need to edit DB on my P3a.
[Magisk] vip5912:
Is there any way of Magisk Manager update not from Magisk Manager?

Last 2-3 updates brought the phone to a hang and I need reboot. :(
[Magisk] vip5912:
Screenshot of MManager update

I can see "Application is installed" but I can't go to any where from this screen only reboot.
[Magisk] zgfg:
If you only updated MM, no need to reboot

You can eg kill and relaunch MM
[Magisk] djjohnnyblaze:
Just wanted to let everyone know after updating to latest MM today it seems like the app no longer crashes when going to the superuser tab. Cheers!
[Magisk] zgfg:
Which exactly MM version are you talking about?

It was random issue with v7.3.1, 222 official and 223 Canary, if it didn't happen once or twice id does not mean it will not happen next time

Also, it was not crashing for all users/phones

Edit: There was no today update for Canary Debug, butvI see now update 224 for official
[Magisk] djjohnnyblaze:
I got the update today. Now running 7.3.2 224

I've tried it many times now and so far no issues.
[Magisk] zgfg:
Yes, thanks

I was on Canary but when I switched to Stable channel, then received notification for update to official 224

Tested several times, no more crashing for me when opening Superuser
[Magisk] armando_rod:
Has anyone faced huge lag opening apps on Android Q after flashing Magisk 19.3? Also it sometimes hangs at the G boot screen.

Edit: logcat attached
[Magisk] djjohnnyblaze:
I have a new issue now though. After rebooting my device, more often than not MM gets stuck at the app loading screen (splash screen), hangs there and finally the system asks me to wait for the app of close it. If I close it and re-open it, its fine.

So it seems like it crashes on the first launch after rebooting the device now.
[Magisk] guest4711:
Nice idea, but did not help. According to logs the script is executed. MagiskHide is stopped and started again. But not working until I toggle it again.

Edit: I had to put the correct shebang into the first line of the script /data/adb/service.d/MagiskHide_enable.sh: #!/system/bin/sh

Now it worked...

#!/system/bin/sh
# toggle MagiskHide
magiskhide --disable
magiskhide --enable

Edit2: On a second device it does not work this way. Hm.
[Magisk] vip5912:
I need reboot because:

"updates brought the phone to a hang.

I can't go to any where from this screen."
[Magisk] dd721411:
Just download latest versions from GitHub and install the apks directly from any file managers. The GitHub link is in the Announcement thread.

Cheers!
[Magisk] vip5912:
Thanks :good: I forgot about GitHub :)
[Magisk] kotuamoalt:
I'm going to assume that because it is a stable build, it no longer has the canary debug channel for updates?
[Magisk] Pandemic:
https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/dev-magisk-canary-channel-bleeding-edge-t3839337

-___-
[Magisk] kotuamoalt:
The link you posted doesn't reallly answer my question. A simple yes or no would answer my question.
[Magisk] Rickydwi:
Hello can anyone confirm magisk 19.3 did not compatible with gltools version 4.02? Cause i keep bootloop when installed it. It used to work fine
[Magisk] wilsonhlacerda:
I think it is related to Magisk itself, booting times, maybe even the bug itself.

I also tried like you and it failed, even with some "sleep" commands.

Then I moved same scrip to /system/etc/init.d and everything works fine always! This is a feasible workaround. (But NOT systemless!)

Certainly this can be also done with Tasker or something similar (thus systemless).
[Magisk] guest4711:
Thanks for the hint. I've put the code into /data/local/userinit.sh now. Works great.

#!/system/bin/sh

echo 'toggling MagiskHide'
/sbin/magiskhide --disable
/sbin/magiskhide --enable
[Magisk] zgfg:
Please always be patient

Now, Canary is also updated to v7.3.2 (225) with the fix for random crash in SuperUser tab

Although, for the matter of fact, once installed it declares itself as MM v7.3.1 (225) instead of v7.3.2 :)
[Magisk] Pandemic:
Let the dev [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] fix the bootloop issue with magisk v19.+ on xperia devices like xz2 and xz3, needed log is posted on github but we still hear none... ><"
[Magisk] ElsaReyes:
Yes hi, I have the Tab S5e and have it rooted through Magisk. At first everything was running fine, and technically everything still is running fine. But the past few days at like random times my tablet will all of a sudden just crash and I'll have to hold down the power button for awhile for it to turn back on to the lockscreen.

Could this be an issue with the latest version of Magisk? I see people are having issues so I'm hoping that's all this is, but I'd really like to know if this is happening to anyone else cause I really hope I didn't break my tablet somehow.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
If you'd have been paying attention, you might have realised that [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] is very busy with his internship at the moment, and will work on Magisk whenever he has time. All you do is come in here and demand something should be done. The Github issue is open, [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] himself has edited it only 10 days ago. That means the issue will get some attention, whenever [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] feels like it. He has no obligation to do anything else than that...

If you really want to get the issue fixed fast, fix it yourself and submit a PR.
[Magisk] kotuamoalt:
What are you even talking about? Where was I demonstrating a lack of patience? I asked a simple question.
[Magisk] zgfg:
And you got the simple answer: Canary is still coming, and will be coming

But devs have also other things to do, they don't live from developing Magisk and Magisk Manager

Stable 224 was released with the Superuser fix yesterday and today was released corresponding Canary 225
[Magisk] kotuamoalt:
Thank you, but you obviously didn't understand the question. I'll try one more time. Does the latest stable MM have the Canary debug update channel? show me how that in any way was a question of impatience, and I will apologize.
[Magisk] Wolfcity:
I'm also not sure if I understand your question but all stable Magisk Managers that I ever installed to my device had three update channels: Stable, Beta and Custom. Never seen anything else.

For using canary builds you need the Canary Magisk Manager which is downloadable here:

https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/dev-magisk-canary-channel-bleeding-edge-t3839337/post77549897

If you're talking about the custom channel, yes it's still there.
[Magisk] kotuamoalt:
I am running a Canary version of MM that is an older build # than the new stable version. It has a Camary and a Canary debug channel in addition to the usual three. So unwittingly, you just answered my question.
[Magisk] vandyman:
I am on MM 225. Is this what you are asking for. (screen shot below).
[Magisk] kotuamoalt:
Yeah, that was what I was inquiring about.
[Magisk] Wolfcity:
As the latest stable MM is 224 I presume this is the Canary Magisk Manager? That's why I wrote all stable versions I used had three update channels.

If so the answer is no, the canary update channel is not in the latest stable MM, it's as usual in the canary version.

So this should be clear now.;)
[Magisk] vandyman:
Yes, the stable channel will only give you three choices.
[Magisk] ElsaReyes:
No one can offer me any advice? Is it possible my issue is caused by Magisk or not? Someone has to know if they've experienced the same thing but on a different tablet.
[Magisk] sdamark:
No idea.

Your minimal post will likely be ignored.

See forum rules and instructions to file a proper report and maybe you'll get the help you need.
[Magisk] Logix:
Friendly mod minder please keep on topic all OT And nonsense out of here.

Thank you kindly,

Logix
[Magisk] zgfg:
Sorry, missunderstanding, but this was always the case:

- With official/Stable MM, you have only three channels: Stable, Beta, Custom

- With Canary MM, you have additional two channels: Canary and Canary Debug

That's because Canary MM app is only for those who want to experiment with Canary (pre-release) Magisk and Magisk Manager. Thus Canary 'alpha' prereleases are hidden from ordinary users using Stable MM

If you want even more channels and to experiment with (daily) builds including changes/fixes from the GitHub code that didn't even make yet to the Canary build, you can install MM app by [MENTION=7187684]ianmacd[/MENTION] (on your own risk; his MM is built with different key hence stable/Canary MM must be deleted before installing; for any questions about this build and channel ask in his thread):

https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/unofficial-magisk-v10-beta-built-t3521901
[Magisk] muschiu35bv:
Magisk Not working with Huawei Mediapad M3 8.4

Hello! I tried to root huawei mediapad m3 8.4 with Android 7 using Magisk manager but has brock my device.i gotinsert pasword to decrypt storage. I tried to uninstall using uninstaller for magisk but has not working. The method i use was this .i have patched the boot.img from original firmware and after pached i boot to twrp and chose img to flash and choose boot partiton. Now i have restore my device with stock and no root. How do i root huawei mediapad m3 8.4 with Emui 5.0.4 latest update. Thank You!

---------- Post added at 18:09 ---------- Previous post was at 17:58 ----------

Hello! I tried to root huawei mediapad m3 8.4 with Android 7 using Magisk manager but has brock my device.i gotinsert pasword to decrypt storage. I tried to uninstall using uninstaller for magisk but has not working. The method i use was this .i have patched the boot.img from original firmware and after pached i boot to twrp and chose img to flash and choose boot partiton. Now i have restore my device with stock and no root. How do i root huawei mediapad m3 8.4 with Emui 5.0.4 latest update. Thank You!