yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] toshi127k:
if you have not modified boot.img. it must be installed zip ahead.( #3302)

but now,I provided the boot.img to answer the needs of QWEnter. so you can flash the boot.img ahead(#3543)
[Magisk] alroger:
You have some other root or leftover file, or some other thing that is causing this. phh su magisk module never asked me for an update since it was released.
[Magisk] veaceslav:
Does it work on x86_64? I flashed it, but magisk manager shows Magisk v and no number...
[Magisk] Chaos234:
I have currently still the problem like written a few posts ago.

I have run SafetyNet Helper and it shows me a blue warning screen.

On this screen the SaftyNet Request was successfull but the Response validation failed.

What can I do now to get a valid response validation from the SaftyNet request?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Just guessing here, but I think you have Xposed active.
[Magisk] tech_head:
I have a similar issue and I have gone back and have redone the install multiple times.

I reinstalled the Stock Sept Security update (Nexus 6P).

1. Flashed ElementalX Kernel

2. Flashed MagiskV6

3. Flashed PHH

4. Flashed Xposed 86.5

I get no love. I go and toggle root in Magisk and SafetyNet fails.

Only if I disable Xposed and reboot does SafetyNet Pass.

If I can't get SafetyNet to pass with a single toggle in the Magisk application, then it's no better than toggling root in SuperSu while Xposed is disabled. I've is there a solution? If not I'll go back to doing what I was doing and it didn't involve AndroidPay.

I only tried this because it looked like a single toggle could get AndroidPay working. For me that is not the case.
[Magisk] agentdr8:
It was that way, until Google recently updated SafetyNet. Now it detects Xposed process(es) if it's active, which is why you have to disable Xposed, soft-reboot, and then toggle root for AP to work.
[Magisk] Rhir7:
Lineage
[Magisk] Utini:
I also checked the log within the magisk manager but there is no special entry.

I also tried re-installing magisk manager.. still doesn't work.
[Magisk] ktmom:
I suggest grabbing logs. The more detailed logs may provide insight.
[Magisk] Ridianod:
Guys hi. I have mi9t, miroom stable miui 10. When I upgrade to 20.1, I cant see any root asking window anymore. Why is that?
[Magisk] Utini:
So I installed the cannary build with verbose logging. The log file is attached but it doesn't seem to give any clues/hints.

Also I am not the only one with that problem. See this post: https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=80898927&postcount=37017
[Magisk] ktmom:
That's a Magisk log. I linked to a page to help you get complete logs. Though at the end of the Magisk log is:

E Magisk : su: cannot find manager
[Magisk] Be4st187:
Got an issue hopefully someone can help with. I recently got a OnePlus 6, installed Magisk fine and it works just as it always has done on previous phones minus the repackage and hide option. When I do this, any app that requests superuser causes Magisk to open. When I unhide and repackage Magisk back to its original state, it works fine and grants superuser with no popup. Anyone got a clue as to what's happening here?
[Magisk] ktmom:
There have been several posts to this affect. If memory serves, the commonality is the device. I'm not aware that anyone has provided detailed logs.
[Magisk] vishal.b:
Magisk hide not working

I am using realme 3 pro with magisk. In magisk manager there is no magisk hide menu. So, I'm unable to hide root from apps.
[Magisk] DroidJP:
Hello all

Has anyone notice that in magisk manager, su no longer retains root sessions regardless if you have denied or grant access for apps, no matter if its for 10 or 60 minutes deny/grant, it simply disappears from the su list upon reboot. It started happening when i updated magisk.

I am trying a couple of things first before i can rule out that maybe this version has a bug. Maybe something went wrong during the update. Anyways, that is just weird.
[Magisk] Antidote03:
i actually read it twice but i didn't understand fully

i lost when it says " boot/recovery image "

which one should i patch via magisk manager the boot.img or recovery.img or both !

i tried to patch the boot.img with magisk manager without select the recovery option and flash it via fast boot command no avail

but i didn't try to patch the recovery

please much appreciated if u could help
[Magisk] zgfg:
Sorry, I don't know how it looks like on Xiaomi but on Huawei there are different partitions corresponding to boot.img (or ramdisk.img) and recovery_ramdisk.img

Hence, you must patch that second img corresponding to recovery, not the boot.img

If I recall, you said you tried with TWRP - therefore, extract and patch the stock (!) img for that same partition where you otherwise put TWRP (and flash it by Fastboot the same way you are flashing TWRP).

Needless to say, you will not be able to have TWRP and Magisk together.

And you will boot Magisk by Vol+ (?) as you boot to Recovery/TWRP
[Magisk] Be4st187:
I had already done a logcat to see if there was anything that stood out, but nothing jumped out at me. But then again, I am no developer lol. I can provide the logs if need be or is there a certain log that would provide the details needed?
[Magisk] ButtonBoy:
OOS 10 and Magisk 20.1

I have not been able to get Magisk to hide itself. It won't even pass the basic SafetyNet test. I'm just beginning to figure this out, but I did find this beauty with logcat:

AndroidRuntime

FATAL EXCEPTION: pool-3-thread-1

Process: com.topjohnwu.magisk, PID: 3579

android.database.sqlite.SQLiteCantOpenDatabaseException: unknown error (code 14 SQLITE_CANTOPEN): Could not open database

at android.database.sqlite.SQLiteConnection.nativeOpen(Native Method)

at android.database.sqlite.SQLiteConnection.open(SQLiteConnection.java:215)

at android.database.sqlite.SQLiteConnection.open(SQLiteConnection.java:197)

at android.database.sqlite.SQLiteConnectionPool.openConnectionLocked(SQLiteConnectionPool.java:505)

at android.database.sqlite.SQLiteConnectionPool.open(SQLiteConnectionPool.java:206)

at android.database.sqlite.SQLiteConnectionPool.open(SQLiteConnectionPool.java:198)

at android.database.sqlite.SQLiteDatabase.openInner(SQLiteDatabase.java:930)

at android.database.sqlite.SQLiteDatabase.open(SQLiteDatabase.java:910)

at android.database.sqlite.SQLiteDatabase.openDatabase(SQLiteDatabase.java:774)

at android.database.sqlite.SQLiteDatabase.openDatabase(SQLiteDatabase.java:763)

at android.database.sqlite.SQLiteOpenHelper.getDatabaseLocked(SQLiteOpenHelper.java:374)

at android.database.sqlite.SQLiteOpenHelper.getWritableDatabase(SQLiteOpenHelper.java:317)

at a.jw.a(Unknown Source:4)

at a.kw.a(Unknown Source:2)

at a.bv.c(Unknown Source:5)

at androidx.work.impl.utils.ForceStopRunnable.run(:3)

at a.r40.run(Unknown Source:2)

at java.util.concurrent.ThreadPoolExecutor.runWorker(ThreadPoolExecutor.java:1167)

at java.util.concurrent.ThreadPoolExecutor$Worker.run(ThreadPoolExecutor.java:641)

at java.lang.Thread.run(Thread.java:919)
[Magisk] Masamune3210:
What logs would be needed? I am having a issue with the Manager opening itself multiple times immediately after the phone is unlocked for the first time
[Magisk] pep01:
Hi.

I had to uninstall Magisk with TWRP with an uninstall file to fix a problem of continuous update. When reinstalling Magisk again with a zip with TWRP 3.3.1.0 I lost the root in the rom. Why could this have happened?

Enviado desde mi SM-G965F mediante Tapatalk
[Magisk] 32bitTech:
Magisk audio issue in OOS 10 (/system/media/audio)

I have a OnePlus 6 that's just been updated to Android 10 (OOS 10). In the previous version (9.0.9), I was able to run a Magisk module that replaced ogg files in /system/media/audio/ui. This no longer works in Android 10. The zip flashes fine and files aren't corrupted. I played them to make sure. At first, I thought the issue was isolated to Gboard, so I installed another keyboard app. Didn't work either.

I also tried disabling all other modules, but that didn't make a difference. I flashed another module that changes the system sounds. The files did get copied to the audio folder, but the system refuses to acknowledge those audio files for some reason.

What's even weirder is that without the module enabled, there's no audio folder in /system/media. I wonder if it's because Android 10 uses a different method?

I'm currently running Magisk stable 20.1 (20100) and stable Magisk Manager 7.4.0 (253).
[Magisk] m0han:
find audio folder in /system/product/media
[Magisk] ktmom:
The post you quoted contained the link to the information you are asking for.
[Magisk] rexendz:
Hello, I'm using magisk 20.1 with magisk hide and repackaged name. It seemd that banking apps are getting smarter. Some banking apps are detecting root by looking at apps requiring root (titanium backup) AND checks for folders like TWRP and others which I don't know. I was unable to access my banking app due to having a folder named TWRP but once I deleted that folder I can access fine. Is there any way to block apps' read access to storage/emulated/0, or hide other apps' package name from a specific app using magisk or a module? It would be nice to have a feature that automatically hides a flagged folder name like TWRP or a flagged app.
[Magisk] user822:
Hi,

I went back to an old TWRP and Magisk 19.4

That also did not fix it :(
[Magisk] ktmom:
Try 19.3.

19.4 was the start of the A10 changes where Magisk started following the Google SAR
[Magisk] wilsonhlacerda:
You may like the app + Magisk/Riru module Storage Redirect.

Besides that the Xposed module XprivacyLua and maybe the Privacy feature of Lineage OS can also help.

To hide packages, beside XprivacyLua also Xposed module Sudohide do that.

Another alternative is trying isolate apps under the work profile, using apps like Shelter (on F-Droid) or Island (by same dev of Greenify).
[Magisk] foxboyjt:
Hey so, let's say I wanted to install an old version of Magisk with boot install , is there a way for me to do that? 20.1 dosnt work for what I'm doint, but I know 17.3 does.
[Magisk] kingracer:
Hey everyone, does somebody know how to make magisk manager not to reset magisk hide list after each reboot on Android 10? Thank you!
[Magisk] hfam:
Well, if you have a version of MM installed on the target device, you could use this link in Settings/Update Channel/Custom:

https://raw.githubusercontent.com/topjohnwu/magisk_files/3e34f20142f29a29df1989e8cf189f282eda0bf2/stable.json

...and then be sure to actually select the "custom" option. Also select "check for updates". Then close MM, restart it, and it should present the option to install 17.3 and MM 6.0.1.

Install MM 6.0.1. Get your boot.img on the target device, patch it with 17.3, and do your thing with magisk_patched.img (although it might be named "magisk.img" or whatever it was prior to changing it to "magisk_patched.img", can't recall what version that naming convention changed)

(Thanks again to [MENTION=4667597]Didgeridoohan[/MENTION] for the education on json versions on github!!)
[Magisk] foxboyjt:
That worked perfectly, thank you! (Actually yeah, 17.1 was the version I was looking for.)
[Magisk] hfam:
No worries, glad I could help, mostly I'm on the other end of the equation! :laugh:

Here's the link for 17.1, same instructions. Good luck!

https://raw.githubusercontent.com/topjohnwu/magisk_files/c834ae6f3f11d001993a49c461039cdf1f121fba/stable.json
[Magisk] Atharkhan101:
Yes Satetynet is not working properly. The CTS and Basic integrity values are false now. Need to fix
[Magisk] toxinburn:
Magisk Hide not working for one credit card app in particular that I know of.

Hi, I have recently found after last update of First Premier Credit Card app on google play that even if I unhide then rehide the root that it still detects it anyone have or know of a workaround would greatly appreciate thanks!:good:

---------- Post added at 12:53 AM ---------- Previous post was at 12:49 AM ----------

I have some apps that require it and others that dont, however first premier credit card app is catches the root no matter what after their last update so they are somehow bypassing magisk hide I will have to run it with some logs and see what info we can get.
[Magisk] ktmom:
There is a ton of good information on Didgeridoohan's Hiding root and passing Safety Net help pages.

Use the link posted above and make sure to look at the links in the right hand sidebar.
[Magisk] spykolofficial:
I use a rom and phone that support magisk. On the same phone a rom I wiped system to flash something but I changed my mind and flashed magisk again to regain root. After that after trying everything, formatting using other ROMs and kernels I can't get root access. I just flash magisk, it succeeds but then magisk manager says I don't have root. Rom pixel experience official build on Android 10 nov 5 patch Xiaomi mi a1
[Magisk] aiamuzz:
sadly i am facing this issue ...

Updater process ended with error 1 | Magisk ERROR 1

any idea why its happening ... it worked fine the first time ... but now after setting up my device with stock ROM after a failed restore ... i have been encountering this error !
[Magisk] ktmom:
The error 1 description should be telling you that Magisk finds the boot.img is already modified (or recovery.img if that's where root is being installed). You need to re-flash the stock image to completely remove root, then install Magisk again.

If you continue to have trouble, you should include much more information, including device, ROM and android version, Magisk version, method of installing Magisk (recovery flash, image patch) and logs.

There is an approaching infinite combinations of devices, android versions, patched ROMs, install methods.

---------- Post added at 12:58 ---------- Previous post was at 12:42 ----------

Have you tried clearing data and cache for the Magisk manager? Did you clear cache (and dalvik if your device has it) in recovery after flashing Magisk? Are you using the Magisk manager that matches the Magisk release you are using? If you still have trouble, look at/post the Magisk log, along with specifics of which versions manager and Magisk you are using.
[Magisk] DroidJP:
Does anyone knows why magisk manager is not saving root session on reboot? The magisk.db is not saving. I saw a post couple back saying that rename the db file in the adb. If this does not work. Then it is a bug that needs to be reported.
[Magisk] martyfender:
Could it be this new bug:

https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=80918015&postcount=2553
[Magisk] Naresh Rawat:
Greetings Dev

Flashed the latest stable magisk (v20.1, I guess). Before flashing the status of my device always used to show "Device is Not Certified". But too my surprise, after flashing Magisk, my device got certified. Dunno how. But it feel damn sooooo good to hv custom rom with root + "Device is Certified" ????

Also 1 question, (which is indeed soo good for me) i can download google camera now from the play store(which i hd never checked before on play store) HOW???? GCam doesn't show up on my ROG Phone 2's play store(both device hv same google account). I donno that custom rom support google camera or due to Magisk, i m been profited.????Check out attached snap.(last snap is of ROG 2's play store)

Ty so much DEV????

*Deviced used is Redmi 4a.
[Magisk] kiran G.:
Am not able to disable core only mode...it enables again automatically....on colour os.

Any solutions pls
[Magisk] spykolofficial:
Thanks a lot I will come shortly with new status about this. Have a nice day :D
[Magisk] _mysiak_:
I tried to search for this question, but haven't found anything. So, I was using Magisk A/B OTA update guide for more than 2 years without any issues. Recently I switched to a new phone (Mi A3) and I'm having issue with Magisk 20.1 (not sure if it's related to this version). I follow the usual procedure - restore images, install OTA, install Magisk to inactive slot. All goes through without issues, however after I reboot the phone, instead of booting the second updated partition, it boots the same old (and now unrooted) partition. I must switch active partition via fastboot, then my phone boots into updated rooted system.

Magisk log in Magisk manager is empty (and after I try to open it, superuser stops working until next phone reboot), so not sure if it's possible to investigate this issue retrospectively. Anyone else experiencing this? Any known fix?

Thanks in advance.
[Magisk] spykolofficial:
My device still can't be rooted, I'm flashing the latest version (on the latest manager version) and wiping cache and dalvik right after. Here is a screenshot after I've flashed 20.1 like 10 times this is sooo weird
[Magisk] Naresh Rawat:
Greetings buddy

Do 1 thing, what i did is just clean flashed the rom, gapps and magisk 20.1. Thenafter wiped cache and dalvik cache.

Check out my post above. Everythings great.

Ty??
[Magisk] ktmom:
Did you dirty flash your ROM before trying to install Magisk again (to reinstall the boot.img as I suggested from the start)? I'm assuming based on other posts you made that you're running pixel experience on a Mi A1. I have to guess because you're stingy on information.

Where is the recovery log from flashing Magisk?

Flashing and reflashing won't automagically fix problems. You have to follow advice and then share information.
[Magisk] ITasteTerrible:
Hello can anyone help me with this issue? I have a lg v20 with a clean install of alpha omega rom. The issue is that when ever I try to launch the latest version of magisk manager the app immediately crash with the error that it has stopped. It has seem to have been introduced on this update since I can install the 7.3.5.
[Magisk] ktmom:
Any themes applied? You could get a logcat while reproducing the problem.
[Magisk] lividhen99:
Yup, just reset the data of the Google play store, and if it doesn't show up then, just install the magisk module xmlpak.
[Magisk] ITasteTerrible:
Sorry for the late reply. I am also sorry for wasting your time as it seems that it was somehow fixed? All I did was install the past version and update from within the app and now it works. Once again sorry for not checking this a bit further before asking for help.
[Magisk] Naresh Rawat:
Will give it a try and Ty so much for ur reply???
[Magisk] Phatboyaa:
Hide Magisk Manager failed

Hello! First of all thanks to all the developer for doing awesome work.

Recently I have a problem when I try using Hide Magisk Manager feature on my phone (never use it before). I need this because my banking apps needs this to work and a simple magisk hide wouldn't work with this app. My issue is I can't seem to hide magisk manager and the error "Hide Magisk Manager Failed" is always shown everytime I tried it.

I'm using Redmi 5A running android 8.1.0 Oreo, Magisk version 20.1 and Magisk Manager 7.4.0. I can't seem to attach log to my reply, how do I do this?

Edit: here is the log file on my drive, hope I'm doing this right. https://drive.google.com/file/d/1h03LEBPKwZN5AElmR-salU9_STuWxngk/view?usp=sharing
[Magisk] jenslody:
Did you check if MagiskManager is installed in external/adoptable storage ?

If yes, move it to internal.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
From your log:

11-19 07:00:41.991 I/Finsky (15013): [62] zcq.a(10): Verify: Installation silently blocked. package=com.g.V.eTBqnneMA53N

What happens if you temporarily disable Play Project in the Play Store and then try to hide the Manager again?
[Magisk] Phatboyaa:
Trying to disable Play Protect, now hide manager works perfectly. Play Protect is definitely the culprit. Thanks a lot for your help! :victory:
[Magisk] Utini:
Thanks, that finally fixed it for me as well.

I am sure the other users who posted the same probleme here also siply need to disable google play protect.

There should be a notification in Magisk to inform users about that :)
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Magisk actually tries to disable Play Protect temporarily during installation of the repackaged Manager:

https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk...eaeb3c5478/app/src/main/res/raw/utils.sh#L113

Question is why that fails on some devices.
[Magisk] Be4st187:
In addition to the issue myself and others are experiencing with a repackaged Magisk popping up multiple times after a reboot, it only seems to happen with GApps and not MicroG (nanodroid with Play Store as Greenify pro needs it). Thought it was tied to OxygenOS so I switched to Havoc, but its happening there too, but only when I install GApps and not MicroG. Also, the popups happen once per request, so when my Tasker startup script runs, my screen turns into a rave.

I have also double and triple checked logs and logcats and Magisk logs hold no info that I can see
[Magisk] jameeldroid:
hi everyone,

i am trying to root my infinix hot 8 phone through patched boot image method.

phone is encrypted and always asks for PIN when i start it. it also shows encrypted in Settings/Security.

do i have to patch the boot image using some special settings because my phone is encrypted or it is simple?

i don't want to lose the data for rooting my phone. please help.
[Magisk] spykolofficial:
Its internal

---------- Post added at 06:34 PM ---------- Previous post was at 06:30 PM ----------

I had multiple attempts with a clean rom after a data format even but still no luck. I didn't clean cache though but I just want to flash the thing and root. I've done it so many time so what's the problem now? I have wasted a lot of battery cycles to try different things just to make magisk work but no luck

---------- Post added at 06:35 PM ---------- Previous post was at 06:34 PM ----------

I had multiple attempts with a clean rom after a data format even but still no luck. I didn't clean cache though but I just want to flash the thing and root. I've done it so many time so what's the problem now? I have wasted a lot of battery cycles to try different things just to make magisk work but no luck

---------- Post added at 06:40 PM ---------- Previous post was at 06:35 PM ----------

Okay sorry for the inconvenience. I will sorry flash this rom yeah my phone is Tissot and the rom the first stable Android 10 build of pixel experience. The thing that messed me up was flashing a new kernel on top of root but after multiple clean installs I still got no luck. I will try a dirty flash of the same build then flash magisk right away and clean cache afterwards.

P.s. my log is always clean and successful that's the weird part of this story. Always does the same, always "succeeds". Thanks for your help I will be back with more info. (Root is kinda crucial for me on this phone and rom for gestures and stereo speaker mod)
[Magisk] Soumy1234:
Is there a list of root file explorers that work with Magisk 20s SAR implementation?
[Magisk] zputnyq:
It's a bit off topic actually, but probably you can try mixplorer. So far this is the only explorer that I know get updated frequently. You can grab it on its xda thread or play store
[Magisk] Sir Backe:
Realme X2 pro

Hi together

I'm getting these days my realme X2 pro, and I'm planning to try to root with Magisk. Does anyone can help me which installation method I should try?

Has already anyone been succesful in rooting relame x2 pro?

Thanks a lot!
[Magisk] ktmom:
Reading through your device forum, it's pretty clear it can not be rooted. The bootloader can not be unlocked either.
[Magisk] ChingghisKhan:
Radio broken after flashing Magisk

I flashed the newest Q-Beta: OnePlus7Oxygen_13.W.11_OTA_011_all_1910081730_50fc71487fcf4334.zip.

I installed TWRP: twrp-3.3.1-72-guacamole-unified-installer-mauronofrio.zip

Up to this pont, everything was working fine

Then I used the Payload Extractor to get the "boot.img"

I patched boot.img with Magisk, then I flashed the patched_boot.img: Fastboot --slot all flash boot magisk_patched.img

Now, at this point, my radio is not working, SIM-Cards are not being recongnized and I can't make any phone calls. The Phone-App crashes.

I cleared Data & Cache from the Phone-App to no avail. I am using the default Phone-App 4.4.41

Any help is highly appreciated.

Thanks
[Magisk] adrian moran:
my country's bank app (Banco popular Dominicana) detects the root even with the option to hide active