yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Yes, that log looks fine. If you open up the build.prop (in /system), the first line should read:

#modversion this line enables Tasker root support

From the log it looks like Hide is working just fine. Since you can pass SafetyNet we know it does...

You need to either make sure that all your prop values are set to "safe" values, set SELinux to enforcing yourself or it's possible you just can't fool that app.
[Magisk] marcolino7:
Hi [MENTION=4667597]Didgeridoohan[/MENTION]

I need some help to achieve this.

Thanks
[Magisk] kozyy:
How can i flash another rom aside my current one with this, it says something about multi rom but i cant really find anything?
[Magisk] sherindroid:
Magisk is breaking the android web view system causing UI lag and jittering...

Any fix?

Is this a known issue?

On AEX 4.2
[Magisk] xsycox:
Well, reboot the phone and then root is back.

Also, you can disable systemless host to be sure.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
I've covered a bunch of that stuff in the guide I linked you earlier. They're under the "Other things to try" section. Take a look there and see if you can figure it out. I'll have to say though, that in my experience, the tv and video streaming apps that detect root are very hard/hopeless to fool...

MultiROM is still only a concept/work in progress.

Not really a known issue... Don't think I've seen many reports on that subject, if even any (but my memory is horrible).

To troubleshoot we'll need device and ROM details, steps to reproduce, Magisk log, logcats and whatever else necessary information is available.
[Magisk] yukkio:
Hi, i have 2 dispositives (redmi 4 prime miui beta and n7 2013@lineageOs 14) with magisk v12 / magisk manager. In both I can't enable the ads block, adaway or magisk module "Unified Hosts Adblocker". I try enabling/disabling magisk busybox, systemless hosts and magisk hide. Hosts file is edited correctly and I can see the modified hosts file but apps still load ads.

What is it happening?

BR.
[Magisk] Pkt_Lnt:
I had the same thing happen. Import this profile and run it once.
[Magisk] kgr:
Hi, I'm new to Magisk. Been a staunch SuperSU user, until I decided to try using Android Pay.

I'm not sure if I should post this in ROM or Magisk thread... So I have managed to successfully pass SafetyNet and Android Pay is working on my current setup which is: OP3, RR 5.8.3, blu_spark r134 kernel, Magisk 12, BusyBox 1.26.2 by osm0sis, Magisk BusyBox off, SELinux enforcing (see screenshots)

Now, my challenge is that TiBu won't uninstall apps; it has superuser access, and it will restore apps and their data fine - but when uninstalling apps it says successful, the app name is greyed out with a line through, but upon reboot the removed app is still there in all its glory. I have tried this with 'Force system BusyBox' both ON and OFF in TiBu settings. I am able to successfully remove apps with System App Remover, so its not exactly a general system problem... is this to do with BusyBox or SELinux?

I found this thread: https://xdaforums.com/google-nexus-5/general/fix-issues-uninstalling-apps-tibu-t2592456, but I'm hesitant to messing with that or install Stericson BusyBox for fear that I'll start failing SafetyNet.

I'm hoping someone here can shed some light on my predicament?

Thanks!! :)
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
Please give me a logcat
[Magisk] kgr:
Thanks for your reply.

This is probably the first time I have actually done a logcat - is this what you are looking for?
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
Did you reproduce the issue while capturing a logcat?
[Magisk] teddy0209:
Well, that's not always the case for MIUI... There are instances where a reboot won't give you back root... I can enable magisk busybox and systemless host fine in my case and still pass SN... I only lose root if I install more modules, and it can only be fixed by reinstalling magisk...
[Magisk] kgr:
I believe I did. I opened the logcat app, made sure it was capturing, then opened TiBu and attempted to uninstall the 'Contacts' app.
[Magisk] PupuDroid:
Hello! I'm new to Magisk... Actually, I'm new to Android and I have an Alcatel IDOL 4 (6055B). I managed to root it by flashing Magisk and got a green check on SafeNet. However, when I install the systemless version of Xposed Framework, SafeNet turns red. Can anyone help me?
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
Disable or uninstall Xposed
[Magisk] xsycox:
Maybe first try something before arguing against it?

There are several users stating that they had the casual root loss (like I did, too)

and when they deactivated the Magisk Busybox and the systemless host thing,

the root losses were gone.

Why not try first and then complain, it does not work (if it still does not work)?

Btw, losing root has nothing to do with passing SN or not. I have never passed

SN, but still I never lost root (on my other phone/installation). On this one now

it happened several times until I unticked those two things.
[Magisk] PupuDroid:
I know I can solve the problem by disabling or uninstalling Xposed. I guess I didn't explain myself well. The thing is that I installed the systemless version of Xposed, so it shouldn't create a problem with SafeNet. They are supposed to be compatible. So what I'm asking is for someone to help me get Xposed work without causing issues with SafeNet. Thanks in advance.
[Magisk] h_maharaj:
It has already been mentioned on numerous occasions in this thread that Magisk cannot hide Xposed, systemless Xposed included.
[Magisk] Deic:
setprop persist.magisk.busybox 0 or edit /data/property/persist.magisk.busybox file with 0 inside
[Magisk] PupuDroid:
I'm sorry, but there are 1409 pages of this thread. I'm sure you understand it is quite difficult to find all those "numerous occasions" that fact was mentioned throughout that many pages.

Nevertheless, please, teach me what that means and tell me if I can install any module without affecting the Play Store behavior. Thanks in advance.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
There are a couple of search functions available, both on a forum and thread level that would have shown that. I'm actually curios as to where you got the information that systemless Xposed would pass SafetyNet. We see that from time to time (hence "numerous occasions")...

Are you talking about Xposed modules? Or Magisk modules?

Keeping Xposed active on your device will cause SafetyNet to fail and also make your device appear as uncertified in the Play store, leading to some apps not showing up or unable to install.

Most Magisk modules are going to work fine and won't affect SafetyNet or the Play store, but it all depends on what the module actually does.
[Magisk] PupuDroid:
Then I don't understand what's the point of developing a systemless version of the Xposed Framework if it will cause SafetyNet to fail and render my device as uncertified. I mean, the official thread of the systemless version of Xposed says it is meant to work without affecting certifications (I'm paraphrasing, obviously), or did I get it all wrong? (I might have, since my mother tongue is not English but Spanish).
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
We can't pass SafetyNet anymore with systemless Xposed enabled
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
To keep your system mods systemless. There's a few advantages to that... I'm gonna copy-pasta:

I've said it before and I'm sure I'll say it again. The purpose of Magisk is NOT to hide root and pass SafetyNet (it's just a really nice feature); it's to make your system modifications systemless. You could use this to keep your devices ability to update through OTA, with a couple of extra steps. But, the main advantage for me (and it's the deal-breaker) is that I don't have to redo any of my system modifications after an update. These could be changing screen density, debloating system apps, systemising apps, changing prop values, etc. Before Magisk I could spend 30-45 minutes after an update just setting upp all the system tweaks the way I wanted it, only to realise a couples of days later I'd forgotten something. Now, with Magisk - flash the update, done!
[Magisk] PupuDroid:
Got it! Now it's a lot clearer. Thanks a lot ?
[Magisk] dberthia:
New user here. On my Nexus 6, I'm stock 7.1.1, rooted with Magisk. The latest version of the YouTube and Google Home apps force close every time I launch them. If I revert to previous version of the apps, I don't see the problem. Could this be Magisk related? I don't see any chatter about this happening to other folks.
[Magisk] BoozYooNit:
Maybe a dumb question, but is it possible that Magisk Manager might get messed up by airplane mode? MM seems to lose root a lot on my Nexus 6 running an LOS ROM (Dark ROM). Sometimes overnight. Sometimes in a matter of hours. I just now had to reboot my phone because MM was telling me the phone was not rooted. The phone was also in airplane mode: I use Fi, and that's the only reliable way to make use of WiFi calling. I can't say for sure that the phone was definitely in airplane mode each time it lost root, but the odds are pretty good that it was. At any rate, I took it off airplane mode before I rebooted, and all is now well with MM.

I'm asking because I've read through the troubleshooting guide and nothing mentioned there has worked to keep the phone from losing root, and because a lot of people on the DarkROM thread have claimed that they've never experienced this root loss issue.
[Magisk] JRJ442:
Did you actually try an app that needs root? I've seen it say that sometimes too. But I haven't actually lost root. Swiping it away from recents or just killing MM will make it work as expected again. No reboot required. That happens on both my 6p and N6.
[Magisk] BoozYooNit:
I guess I've done that. If I try to access the root folder via Total Commander (which is a superuser) when MM is having issues, I get told I don't have permission to access the File system root folder.
[Magisk] teddy0209:
???... I wasn't complaining... I'm just stating my experience... And of course I tried those things, everything I can think of...

Edit: I posted the screenshots to remind you I'm not the one asking for help, I just gave a suggestion to a fellow Mi user... ?
[Magisk] teddy0209:
Good, thanks for that info!!!
[Magisk] AmazingToast:
Has Magisk Manager disappeared from the Play Store for anyone else, or is it just me?
[Magisk] jsaxon2:
Hmm, I just checked and I don't see it either...
[Magisk] synxx:
Was just about to post the same thing. I know it was there because I didn't do the last app update due to wanting to do a nandroid first and not having enough space. So it was there on the update apps list and now it's gone.
[Magisk] tsjanda:
Yep gone for me as well
[Magisk] bluenote73:
So I flashed to stock, then flashed magisk, and I get 'rooted but no root permission'. I do not see any MagiskSU in the list of apps.

I'm running an Axon 7 on Nougat.

Can anyone suggest what to do? I have not run magisk before but I'm excited to do so.

thanks
[Magisk] :
So I read the last few posts that Magisk Manager is MIA from the Playstore, and I just checked and it's gone for me too, even from My Installed apps...

What's Google up to now?...
[Magisk] brian 11:
I noticed a few days ago on GitHub a few days ago that there was a magisik manager 13 was on there even though my magisk manger didn't notify​ me when I installed it it said my magicSu should be updated so I did and I still have mine. But the manger has an error every time I try to install a mod. But most will install fine through TWRP I'm still rooted and still pass the safety net check
[Magisk] partridge79:
Can't find magisk manager on playstore had it been removed? After clicking link on first open after flashing
[Magisk] nomesrjp:
Yes, it would appear that's the case! Since it's unavailable, simply use the direct link provided in the OP (in the downloads section).

https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/official-magisk-v7-universal-systemless-t3473445
[Magisk] bakkiss:
What happend Magisk Manager on Play Store?
[Magisk] Albert Poon:
Since HSBC moved to HSBC HK, Magisk Hide no longer can hide it
[Magisk] Pkt_Lnt:
look up ^^^^^^^^^^^^^

:p
[Magisk] lalitjoshi06:
Solution for all banking apps which detects root or other protection.

I am sharing this here for the information to developer.

I am using this on unofficial magisk snapshoot version 170531. (So Try it with stable version can solve issue for most peoples)

1. Safety net must be passed.

I am using leeco X526 with us X522 Rom and magisk version 170531 build.

just install app and tick in magisk hide and reboot device.

now open your banking app it detect root, no worry.

just uninstall magisk manager app and open your bank app it will work.

@ Developers now the point is these banking apps is detecting this app (magisk manager) and not working.

so when need to use banking app just uninstall the app and after again install this and all is ok, root works.

I checked this on Spushtan and UOB apps and its working.

if this app can be able to hide itself then all banking apps will work without any issue.

developer must to see in this matter. (Banking apps just detecting this app and force closing nothing else)

Thanks.
[Magisk] Bartoshevsky:
Can you tell where it is? I cant find any working link...
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
That link you were given contains the link to the Manager. Scroll down to "Downloads".
[Magisk] DiamondJohn:
I dont need SafetyNet pass for anything. I was just thinking you may also wish to try freezing & unfreezing the app instead of installing and uninstalling. Just a thought.
[Magisk] Albert Poon:
Just tried, freezing the Manager doesn't work, it must be uninstalled
[Magisk] Chucknorris1975:
Keep failing net safety check
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
Try Magisk v12.0
[Magisk] Nimueh:
Maybe [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] could give us an update as to why the app vanished from the Playstore?

I just switched from SuperSU after the weird update-goings-on and would really prefer a stable root app without issues or strange happenings now ... :crying:
[Magisk] abhayruparel:
I'm facing a strange issue after flashing aosgp los latest build.

I flashed addon su zip to get root access but unfortunately it didn't rooted my device. So i flashed magisk but it was also not able to give me root access error while flashing second screenshot. So then I have finally flashed full stock rom then again repeated the process but still no root access. So I have flashed magisk uninstaller and then flashed magisk installer after a boot, again no root access.

Please help me.

Also flashing only boot img will cause data loss?

Thanks
[Magisk] abhayruparel:
Build number and rom version attached
[Magisk] LoV432:
Magisk removed from playstore and cant use magisk until i install it from playstore O.o?
[Magisk] xsycox:
lol ... okay :)
[Magisk] DiamondJohn:
I havent checked, but is it in F-Droid or Aptoide?

It obviously, in some sway impedes on Google making money. Or now we really know its good if Google is scared...
[Magisk] ForgottenDude:
I hope this removal (if that) is not because Magisk helps to pass SafetyNet.
[Magisk] xsycox:
Btw, I lost root again, unfortunately, although

having BB and systemless host turned off.

Any other hints/ideas? Rebooting the phone

is a not so nice solution. :)
[Magisk] teddy0209:
What modules do you have? You might have to remove magisk and reinstall it... Reboot twice after reinstalling and see if it helps...
[Magisk] DiamondJohn:
Did you turn root on in the developer settings?

Did you check if root was enabled in the settings menu. I think it does by default, but it may be worth a check. I normally go in there and turn root and busybox on.

And I think you forgot the screenshots, which probably give the real issue.
[Magisk] abhayruparel:
In developer options root is on but can't use it. For build number and other details i have replied to my own comments and attached them here too
[Magisk] xsycox:
This device is a Redmi Note 3 Pro International Edition with Android 6 (NX ROM).

Those modules I am using in Magisk:

Enable Doze for GMS

Safetynet Props Mi5

Tasker Root Support - build.prop

Xposed Framework (SDK 23)
[Magisk] dahawthorne:
That sounds like an interesting paradox until you think that you can get Magisk and Magisk Manager from the link in this very forum. And you can't be talking about requiring root to install, since by definition Magisk is installed to get root.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Frankly, I'm surprised it's taken Google this long to remove the Manager from the Play store (if that's what's happened).
[Magisk] veez21:
Yeah, me too. Since it has a feature that is tightly integrated in the app (magisk hide) that messes with selinux and let's you bypass safety net ?
[Magisk] LoV432:
Aight clam down bro i know that...i was just reporting the removal of magisk from playstore ._.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Looks like the hidelist haven't been created. Your kernel might be mounting the Magisk image read-only. Type "mount" in a terminal emulator and look for the line that start something like:

/dev/block/loop0 on /magisk

If the text in parentheses starts "ro", you've got issues and might have to try with a different kernel. You could also try remounting it rw, but that hasn't worked for other users with this issue. I believe the command would be (from memory, you'll probably have to double-check the syntax):

mount -o remount,rw /magisk

If you have flashing errors, provide the recovery log from that failed flash. Also, a Magisk log might be useful (in /cache, you'll have to get to it through recovery). You do not lose data by flashing boot image only (unless you screw up, but then you have your backup to rely on).

Turn off Magisk Hide if you have it on and see if that's the issue.
[Magisk] dahawthorne:
No worries. I wasn't having a go at you, I was only commenting because I didn't understand your point. I certainly wasn't annoyed. People might have been misled into thinking that Magisk itself had become unavailable, which isn't the case.
[Magisk] stevenazari:
I flashed magisk onto the phone, but the app says I need to update from the play store... despite flashing onto the phone....

had a look around and couldn't see any info on how to resolve it... any advice?
[Magisk] ForgottenDude:
After flashing the Magisk.zip, you also have to install the Magisk Manager from the Play Store. The problem is, Magisk Manager has disappeared from the Play Store. But, don't worry. You can still download the Magisk Manager apk from here The link is from the Magisk thread

EDIT: Misread your question. Sorry. Which is the current Magisk version according to the app? And what is the Magisk Manager app version?

It should be v12 and app version should be 4.3.3
[Magisk] dahawthorne:
I don't understand your message. You flashed Magisk in recovery (TWRP)? And you also downloaded and installed Magisk Manager?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
When you flash the Magisk zip in recovery it installs an app stub that redirects to the Play store page for the Magisk Manager. Since the Manager has been pulled from the Play store that won't work... The link [MENTION=7227184]ForgottenDude[/MENTION] gave is currently the only official way to get the latest Magisk Manager.
[Magisk] stevenazari:
You are 100% correct, my nubness made me think Magisk, and Magisk Manager were one and the same, despite seeing 2 download links, trying to follow 2 different root instructions don't help matters :p (twrp use magisk in their instructions which was my primary process).

Thanks for the quick help
[Magisk] teddy0209:
Try it with just the props module... As I mentioned before, having more modules leads to root issues on MIUI... I was wondering why you use the Mi5 props? Did you edit it or it works as is?
[Magisk] _TB_TB_:
Problem with OnePlus 3T OxygenOS Open Beta 8

Hey,

I've been using Magisk for couple of months with no problems. OnePlus released a new beta of their OxygenOS, I dirty-flashed it over the stable one, flashed Magisk over it again. After boot, no app using WebRTC works (Chrome, Signal, WhatsApp, Facebook Messenger, Skype...) Logcat throws "No implementation found for boolean org.webrtc.PeerConnectionFactory.initializeAndroidGlobals" (and similar, WebRTC-related errors) . If I reflash the beta again, everything (except for Magiskm that is) works.
[Magisk] xsycox:
To be honest, I just installed it for testing and I realized,

I am passing the safetynet thing. Happy, happy.

Without it I NEVER passed.

I am not using MIUI on my Redmi Note 3 Pro International,

but a normal clean Android 6 (http://nxrom.us/redminote3pro.html).
[Magisk] kgr:
Did you have any further comments on this?

Thanks
[Magisk] topjohnwu:
Yes, I received a notice that my app is banned from Play Store :p

For more info, check out my new post in the main thread.

https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=72508849&postcount=21
[Magisk] teddy0209:
Oh... Okay... That's nice, it just proves we can use props from other device that passes safetynet...

If toggling busybox did not help, then I don't know what else to suggest... Might be related to the rom... It really depends on the setup, Didge usually collects everything in his troubleshooting thread...
[Magisk] Gerard15799:
So if I like clean flash a rom and flash magisk...will the magisk manager app be installed still?.. but I can't update it right?
[Magisk] teddy0209:
Update will still be released here like the good old days... ?... Just save the files you need...
[Magisk] :
1)It would be a great decision to keep online repo for most active development purposes rather than removing them and make a whole new start with new name of the app and many policies

2)We appreciate your decision to keep further development within xda forum which will help rc/rd furthermore as well as updating both magisk root with magisk manager here on Xda community

3)We all obey Google's security policies as well as rules regarding security ethics but every revolution needs breaking of rules at some good-bringing possibilities

Thanks And Regards [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION]

DarkeraXposed,

Xda-Developers

---------- Post added at 02:45 PM ---------- Previous post was at 02:43 PM ----------

Yeah Fortunately I have whole collection of Magisk.zips with Magisk Manager.apk on my PC lol ;)

And The upcoming versions will be first announced and released within the community is a great news though

---------- Post added at 02:49 PM ---------- Previous post was at 02:45 PM ----------

1)If Magisk Manager.apk is pre-added to be installed in Aroma with magisk.zip then yes you will have magisk manager after flashing Custom Rom and Root with Magisk

2)The message will popup to download Magisk Manager from Play Store if App is not pre-installed after flashing Rom and Opening of Magisk Manager through app drawer But Don't worry you will find latest magisk manager.apk in Magisk Root Main Thread Still
[Magisk] Setialpha:
Have you thought about putting it on F-Droid?
[Magisk] ForgottenDude:
Really unfortunate that it happened. I think I speak of every Magisk user when I say this: We are on your side, man. And we will be there wherever you decide to publish the app, whether it be apk mirror or f-droid or, well, XDA itself!
[Magisk] zelendel:
Not a surprise really. I have a feeling soon all apps like this will be removed from the play, store and Google will start not allowing rooted devices to use the Play store at all. We will have to see how tight Google reins in control.
[Magisk] shoey63:
I think a new thread is in order

MAGISK MANAGER [Stable+Beta]
[Magisk] Pkt_Lnt:
Why? All the app development is on XDA and you can use the XDA app to install from XDA. Why go somewhere else besides XDA?
[Magisk] teddy0209:
Oh yeah, I also have them all on my sdcard from first release... ???
[Magisk] Gerard15799:
Oh man I got a feeling too....Haish...
[Magisk] Setialpha:
F-Droid is an App Store for FOSS apps, just like Magisk Manager is. So why don't do it? Xposed Installer and many more are aswell. Why should you be limited to just one?
[Magisk] ForgottenDude:
That would be a big blow to root. Some root users may go ahead without Google services, but still. And by extension it could affect Custom ROM use as well. I know Custom ROMs these days come without root and people do use them without root, but switching ROMs regularly means Titanium Backup is a life saver. So no root, then no Titanium Backup, then no Custom ROMs for some users.