yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] martyfender:
I believe they used spflashtool to do it, but I have never done it. On the original Onn 8, I have used spflashtool from Windows to restore the true stock, unrooted firmware, quite a few times though.

When you patched the boot.img in Magisk Manager, did you have preserve AVB 2.0/dm-verity and preserve forced encryption enabled? Did you try the latest Canary Magisk build?

I believe this discussion has now becoming OT for this thread and would better be addressed by those participants in the Onn xda threads.
[Magisk] Telperion:
Respectfully, I didn't take it off topic, I posted in here for support as to why a Magisk Manager-patched stock boot image bootloops my bootloader-unlocked tablet, and how to provide relevant logs.

I agree that discussions of mtk-su and spflashtool are off topic, and not relevant to my current situation.
[Magisk] martyfender:
I am guessing you have seen this to determine the type of system as root device you have with terminal commands to verify, so you can use the proper boot.img patching method, just in case:

https://topjohnwu.github.io/Magisk/install.html

I work at a Walmart and we just got the new pro models, but did not buy one based on the reports of the terrible screen bleed. I however only saw this on the black boot screen, so it may not be that bad. My current Onn 8's are more than adequate for my needs, so I did not buy any of the new models. So this still may not be OT here, but I am just following what I often see posted here, concerning specific devices.
[Magisk] professorbil:
Ok so my phone is red magic 3s rooted with magisk 20.4

Went to upgrade magisk 20.4 to 20415 problem is through magisk I get stuck on boot tryed through twrp. Same problem stuck on boot logo have to force power off my phone to get my phone working what am I doing wrong or is this just magisk? Also phone is running Android 9
[Magisk] cojocar.andrei:
Hi, thanks for answering. I'm struggling with IngHome Bank. With a previous version 6.12 it's ok with magisk hide, but they up-ed the game in the latest and magisk hide + manager hide does not work anymore... I was wondering if they could detect the patched boot image somehow because they throw the warning as soon as I patch the boot with magisk (no magisk manager installed)... I read on a site that they use proprietary root detection and they changed the root detection method in the latest update (security insite or something like that - probably much better detection...)...
[Magisk] Rhoban:
Remove any form of root from your device.

Flash Magisk zip and install the Magisk Manager apk. That's about it.

And don't forget about rooting again. Either SuperSU or phh root will do.
[Magisk] NoWayIn:
I see, please correct my steps if they are incorrect before I go and destroy my phone xD

1. Full uninstall of root via SuperSU Chainfire

2. Flash Magisk V7 and then Magisk Manager V2

3. Flash/Install Phh

Then I am able to use modules without problem? And I am able to use apps that requires root like Titanium Backup? (TB is really important because I froze a lot of apps with it, if I can't use it without root my apps will be gone)
[Magisk] Captain_Throwback:
You can still disable offending modules in recovery (or over adb if you have a root shell). That hasn't changed.
[Magisk] putridfoetus:
Yes, and i've been able to remove the module folders, but the SystemUI fc problem keeps happening after, and the only way to fix it (as far as I've been able to) is to factory reset.
[Magisk] Jay794:
Can someone point me to a tutorial on how to update to the latest security patch withe Magisk installed?
[Magisk] Aakash Kaushal:
[MENTION=1162986]Captain_Throwback[/MENTION]

I am seriously confused....

so whats the real meaning of supersu suhide??

I think it means to use androidpay on rooted phones right??...

Supersu+suhide (without any magisk)=androidpay,pogo works but xposed dont

so whats the real meaning of magisk??

xposed+magisk+supersu/phhsupersu+suhide=pay,pogo,xposed works

Right??

No

Xposed again wont work..either xposed will work or androidpay,pogo

So whats the reason of magisk if we can already be able to run apay and pogo on rooted phone with the help of supersuhide??

I think the reason of using magisk should be for using apay,pogo along with xposed..

right?? If yes then why xposed dont work along with magisk

I am confused????

Sorry i dont mean to insult the developer's work but seriously want to know the reason..

Thank you
[Magisk] CrazyCypher:
Did you try to mount different systemuUI.apk? Because same thing happen to me and I had to do factory reset... :/
[Magisk] soder:
With Magisk you do changes to /system without actually doing the changes. There are other perks then play a child's game like POGO! =)

Without changes to /system, updates are more likely to work. Since Fireflash also works pretty well for flashing .zip's, you can also stay on stock recovery if you don't need functions in custom recovery's. Then OTA's will work.

/Söder
[Magisk] Aakash Kaushal:
But still magisk was made for using androidpay on rooted phones...now this is possible without magisk and with the help of supersuhide....the only drawback in suhide method is we cant use xposed along with safetynet...i and maybe some other people thought that with magisk we can run xposed with safetynet...
[Magisk] teorouge:
Actually I'm using suhide + super su sr1 + xposed systemless 86.2 and I can play pogo just fine, so I guess safetynet works.

Inviato dal mio LeTv 1 Pro utilizzando Tapatalk
[Magisk] soder:
I don't think the main reason with Magisk was to use androidpay. It came with the that you could hide root and so on.

I tried early versions of hidesu, that didn't work for me, and I found Magisk (had to change root method though).

Now I'm back to SuperSu and suhide, newest version of Magisk AND got the systemless version of Xposed installed.

I pass the safetynet test and I can start Androidpay.

/Söder
[Magisk] Captain_Throwback:
No, it wasn't made for using Android Pay on rooted phones. Go read the Magisk release thread. It tells you what the purpose of Magisk is. Being able to use Android Pay on rooted phones was a "happy side effect" that doesn't change the original purpose of Magisk. You can apply system mods without modifying system, which means you can take OTAs and have mods persist through updates. Just because you were only using it for Android Pay doesn't mean that's its purpose.

Also, Magisk is still needed to use Xposed with suhide, as 86.6 requires Magisk and supports suhide. So yes, you can use Magisk with Xposed and pass SafetyNet.
[Magisk] rgawenda:
Looks like you don't pay attention but lots of screenshots are being post like mine, safetynet OK with ... How is that sun next to the clock in status bar. Can it be a xposed module? What sorcery is that.

Well, seems that I've read OP and understood instructions.
[Magisk] Aakash Kaushal:
I managed to get xposed work along with safetynet but after rebooting the phone once...the xposed shows that framework is installed but not active...

I tried all the procedure atleast 5 times,xposed works initially in the very first boot bit after rebooting the phone,it stoped working always..
[Magisk] KaMyKaSii:
You just tried to delete /data/data/com.android.systemui/ folder on TWRP?
[Magisk] habylab:
I had exactly the same. It worked for a bit, then not again.

It's too many hoops to jump through for me!
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Did you do a soft reboot? IIRC, you need to do proper reboots or systemless Xposed will get disabled.
[Magisk] Aakash Kaushal:
Woow!!!

After doing soft reboot,xposed started working along with safetynet but i tried to do simple restart again!! and xposed again stopped working....so i tried to soft reboot once again and it started working....

After doing this i came to conclusion that....only soft reboot can run xposed while simple reboot dont...atleast in my case!!
[Magisk] putridfoetus:
No, I'm not even touching SystemUI. I'm trying to get Viper|Atmos to work. Had it working on v6, but v7 is just different enough to have given me a headache lol.

---------- Post added at 03:28 PM ---------- Previous post was at 03:27 PM ----------

I have not tried that. Would that do it? I'll give it a try next time.
[Magisk] ness151:
Does Magisk just not work for the G900R4 (US Cellular) Samsung Galaxy S5? I'm running stock 6.0 and had installed phh's superuser and it just bootloops.
[Magisk] wodgey:
I searched Google for "ing home bank magisk" and the first hit is the GitHub issues page. In June 2019 there was a series of posts saying that ING uses IBM trusteer to handle the safety checks.

Someone reported success by blocking the trusteer site using adaway (the device contacts trusteer during the boot process so you'll need to reboot), hiding root from the app and changing the name of the manager package.

I don't know if this information is still current.

Obviously it will leave your device compromised so don't blame me if you have all your money stolen! Lol.

I'd use the DNS logging feature of adaway to see what lookups are called, and then add them to the blacklist

Good luck
[Magisk] Spaceminer:
Does anyone know how to change the behavior of Magisk so that rebooting normally will give you root?

I maintain twrp for 2 devices and Magisk creates a conflict with both. Twrp needs you to reboot into recovery to work. Magisk also needs you to reboot into recovery to boot the OS with root. It's not possible to have both installed because of this.

I need magisk to boot with a rooted OS when you boot normally, so when you "reboot recovery" twrp will actually work. I can't figure out how to change this behavior. The only other solution that'd make them both work together, is if Magisk starts using system root instead, and I don't see that happening any time soon, or ever for that matter. And Phh root doesn't work on stock, so that's out of the question.
[Magisk] zgfg:
You should always mention what is your device and Android version (this is not a Pixel thread but general Magisk thread with users running Magisk on all kinds of Android phones and with varios Android versions).

Hence, specific questions e.g. about TWRP on a particular device should be better asked on the XDA subforoum for that device

Anyway, if your device doesn't have separate Boot image (Ramdisk on older Huawei phones), then Magisk must be installed to Recovery and you can no more have TWRP and Magisk together

Please check Installation guide, particularly about devices where Magisk must be patched to Recovery:

https://topjohnwu.github.io/Magisk/install.html
[Magisk] Spaceminer:
Boot and recovery are one partition. That's exactly why I'm asking how to change Magisk's behavior, so both twrp and Magisk can exist together. The devices aren't all that important for this case. I need to know how rewrite magisks init to make reboot system = root, so that twrp can use reboot recovery like it always has. I am well aware of how to install magisk. That is not the issue.
[Magisk] zgfg:
IDK, but if possible it would be of general interest.

You can check something about magiskinit (not much there):

https://topjohnwu.github.io/Magisk/details.html

but better post on Github as a feature request to get attention from topjohnwu:

https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/issues
[Magisk] kafisc:
Does anyone got root with the latest Magisk (Canary build 20415) working on the Pixel 3 XL on Android 11 Beta 1 (crosshatch-rpb1.200504.018-factory-fbe094a6)?

I did try to patch the boot.img and flashed it afterwards, but I'm stuck on boot animation.

I've reverted back on the original unpached boot.img for now.
[Magisk] palmbeach05:
While i do not have that device, the best thing to do is create a bug report, or at least create one yourself, and report it on github, that way topjohnwu can fix things if an issue exists.
[Magisk] Einsteindks:
ANYONE figure out how to get Magisk working on a Droid Turbo xt1254 running LineageOS 17.1? It successfully flashes in TWRP, but doesn't show up after powering on.
[Magisk] palmbeach05:
Have you tried installing the manager apk separately?
[Magisk] Einsteindks:
The manager app isn't the issue, best I can figure. I've been around, but not an expert. After flashing in TWRP, Magisk still wants to be installed while the ROM is up and running.
[Magisk] bengeöxxx:
Hey I have a Samsung Galaxy s20 Plus, I have already installed your software on my old one, it was recognized that it was rooted, I know that can also be used with devices like Samsung Knox, I still haven't understood it completely maybe with Android software I patched properly with twrp because I've also been using (warez mention removed) for almost 8 years, it would be really cool if you could help me with that. As you can get into my magnisk app I just saw my number (phone number removed) or WhatsApp telegram or Facebook

Thank you very much for that Greeting A..F

Hey ich hab ein Samsung Galaxy s20 Plus ich habe auch schon vorher deine Software auf meinem alten installiert, es wurde erkannt das es gerootet ist ich weiß das kann auch bei so welchen Geräten wie Samsung Knox, ich habe es komplett noch nicht verstanden gehabt kannst du mir vielleicht mit einer Android Software vernünftig gepatch mit twrp weil ich auch (warez mention removed) seit knapp 8 Jahren benutze es wäre echt cool wenn du mir damit weiterhelfen könntest. Wie du in meiner magnisk app rein kommst habe ich ja gerade gesehen, meine Nummer (phone number removed) oder WhatsApp Telegramm oder Facebook

Danke dir vielmals dafür Gruß A..F
[Magisk] BillGoss:
See XDA rule 4: https://xdaforums.com/announcement.php?f=263
[Magisk] marcogimbe2@gmail.com:
I want to root my infinix hot 7
[Magisk] guest4711:
Do you really think it's a good idea to post a personal phone number in a public Forum? And who knows? It could be the number of a person most hated by you...

[german]Meinst Du wirklich, es sei eine gute Idee, in einem öffentlichen Forum eine private Tel.Nr. zu posten? Und wer sagt uns eigentlich, dass das nicht die Nummer einer Person ist, die Du ärgern willst?[/german]
[Magisk] JudgeDread11:
Sorry about ot, but what's the issue with a phone number? In the good old days there were phone books who had everybody's number.

Who knows somebody might call and you could be social.

Edit, to avoid more ot messages:

I doubt telemarketers and spanner are roaming random forums for somebody to pay a phone number.

And I assume the poster is not a person who doesn't want to be bothered.

Time goes on, people change. And these changes are mostly the result of fear mongering.
[Magisk] m0han:
telemarketing, text messaging (read spam) were not present then. that's not the case now. although all callers are not antisocial, people prefer that they not be bothered; times have changed. (sundry YT link removed)
[Magisk] Rappala:
I feel a bit silly asking this, but... where is the "downloads" section on the XDA's official Magisk thread? I can't find it... I remember downloading Magisj directly from XDA but now I can only find the zip archive on topjohnwu's github
[Magisk] Wolfcity:
topjohnwu decided to handle everything regarding Magisk on GitHub, so that is the official source now. Also bug reports/logs are supposed to get posted there in the required form.
[Magisk] Zaxx32:
Yo bro...check ur pms bud...
[Magisk] m0han:
this post is in response to the edit of the post i quoted (of which i wasn't aware) and the subsequent mod edit.

telemarketers and spanner spammers don't have to

roam

random forums. there are other ways to get phone numbers.
[Magisk] khanhtranngoccva:
I would like to know if you can bring Magisk to Chrome OS, since SuperSU will deactivate every time the Chrome OS system rebuilds or updates.
[Magisk] zgfg:
You must ask to GitHub as Feature Request (TJW does not follow XDA communications anymore)
[Magisk] shadowofdeth:
Does anyone know of a module that could force full screen apps in landscape without the thick black? I found one but it pushes items in the left-hand side of the status bar so far left the camera is in the way. I'm on the standard OnePlus 8.
[Magisk] J.Michael:
I don't think Magisk would make it better. You still have to back out Magisk before a system update. If the problem is that you have to fuss with it every two days, you need to find a way to block updates.
[Magisk] MeowDotEXE:
I just updated to the Android 11 Beta "1.5" (RPB1.200504.020 on my Pixel 3a XL) and can't get the hide Magisk Manager thing to work for the life of me. I've tried completely uninstalling Magisk, clearing the data for Magisk Manager, but nothing works. Anyone else having these problems?

Edit: Figured it out. Play Protect was the issue.
[Magisk] dd805bb:
Why would you use either? You can grant yourself root privileges. Be root user. SuperSU and magisk are meant for Android which has no way to grant yourself root privileges. Yes I can have root user on chrome os and not even unlock the bootloader.
[Magisk] dreamsayer:
Can't find the uninstaller

Hi, I have recently updated my phone ROM and I have experience my phone goes to bootloop if I flash magisk without uninstalling first, my phone goes to bootloop... Can anyone please help me providing the latest uninstaller link please? On GitHub I can only find the zip file and the magisk manager but no uninstaller.. I don't know if I'm missing it somehow.. I'm looking for it for 2 days..

Thank you.
[Magisk] guhvanoh:
For releases: https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/releases

For canary: https://github.com/topjohnwu/magisk_files/tree/canary

To moderators/admins: please delete these links if they aren't permitted.

Cheers!
[Magisk] dreamsayer:
Thank you for the reply.. it gives me 404 page cannot be found...
[Magisk] PoochyX:
Magisk that lives in the recovery partition doesn't exist in twrp during custom recovery modifications...

([emoji88]Havoc GSI[emoji88])
[Magisk] andy356:
That's because of the spelling mistake in the link. It's Magisk, not Magik.
[Magisk] dreamsayer:
Ok I've fixed the link and went through... But I couldn't find the uninstaller that.. the link only contains the magisk flashable zip and the manager app..

Is there any link for the uninstaller please?
[Magisk] pndwal:
ALL OFFICIAL MAGISK INSTALLATION FILES:

Edited 28/07/2020

Click announcement thread link in OP here, go to OP there, click 'Magisk's GitHub Page' to see John's Magisk repository.

Alternatively, from root of John's GitHub, https://github.com/topjohnwu, Click 'repositories', 'Magisk'.

Scroll down to 'useful links' for links to official and endorsed documentation.

Scroll down to 'downloads' for latest stable Magisk (SU. zip), and stable and canary Magisk Manager releases. Scroll down to '+102 releases', for latest as well as archived releases by version. Click 'assets' under 'Magisk' SU headings for archived Magisk-uninstaller (zip) and Magisk (SU zip), and under 'Magisk Manager' headings for archived Magisk Manager (apk) downloads.

For Canary releases (from Magisk repository), click 'topjohnwu' at top to see root of John's GitHub, https://github.com/topjohnwu, then click 'repositories', 'magisk_files'.

Next, change branch from 'master' to 'canary', click 'Go to file' and you'll see app-debug.apk (canary manager), magisk-debug.zip (canary Magisk SU), magisk-uninstaller.zip etc. Click any of these, then 'download'.

Alternatively, after changing branch to 'canary', clicking 'history' symbol shows archived versions by 'upstream' ID. Click one of these, then 'Browse files' at top, click 'Go to file', then click a file for download. PW
[Magisk] jalle007:
I have LineageOS 17.1 running on Oneplus 6t, and its working like a charm.

Now I only miss root access. I have installed Magisk before, but now its different, and I have few

concerns

:

1. Magisk-v20.4.zip is already in my root folder

2. somehow when i boot into recovery mode, TWRP is not there but its LineageOS recovery

[IMG="a"]http://jalle.users.telemach.ba/share/2020-06-18_132448.png[/IMG]

[IMG="b"]http://jalle.users.telemach.ba/share/2020-06-18_132746.png[/IMG]

So, should I try with adb sideload Magisk-v20.4.zip or go with Apply update ?

3. First result I got on Google play for Magisk manager is this

https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.checker.man

It scares **** out of me ? What is this ? And why original link to MAgisk manager doesnt work ?

I don't want to blow up my phone but I need root access. Any suggestions ?
[Magisk] pndwal:
If you have any concerns re. file source, I'd Download and use Magisk zip and Magisk Manager apk from official GitHub. See my post above for proper links. PW
[Magisk] Manetto:
Hi

I am running DerpFest rom on my le max x2. Experiencing an issue with a bank app that's detecting device is rooted even though I have magisk hide applied to it as you can see on screenshot. I'm on the latest magisk.

Can anyone assist on suggestions on how to better hide it or if this might be a bug. I've cleared app cache, storage, uninstalled, reinstalled, the issue remains.

The app is the Metro one shown on screenshot.

Please advise. Thanks
[Magisk] JudgeDread11:
Search the forum and you'll find a link by didgeridoohan with lots of information about how to hide for for problematic apps.
[Magisk] dreamsayer:
I always have the same problem but if I flash twrp and go to recovery straight away without rebooting my phone and then flash magisk and then reboot, it seems to work for me.. I don't know how you're doing it.. if you're doing it some other way then you can try this way.. might help
[Magisk] zgfg:
On many phones one must boot to TWRP immediately after flashing it, otherwise firmware will restore stock recovery.

Also, flashing stock boot and booting to system may restore stock recovery (Xiaomi, MIUI 11) - to prevent, one must first boot to the TWRP instead

In your case LOS might be trying to force its custom recovery instead of TWRP if you don't reflash TWRP and force booting to TWRP

However, this is not topic for the Magisk thread - instructions and user experience should be better found on subforoum for the particular phone, and/or threads about the particular custom ROM

Anybody can steal Magisk Manager icon and Magisk name and put something to Playstore. However, the name is not Magisk Manager, description says that app does not help to install nor it requires Magisk (quite opposite to the real Magisk Manager) and user reviews are very bad - I would never experiment by installing something like that from Playstore

GitHub (links can be found in this thread) is now the only source for installing Magisk and Magisk Manager.

Instructions about installing Magisk are also provided on GitHub.

Last but not the least, issues (really about Magisk or Magisk Manager) must be also raised tonGitHub since TJW does no more care about discussions like here ;(
[Magisk] darkstar73:
I'm not all that knowledgeable about how to submit bug reports so this is more of a FYI. I have a pixel 3xl and I decided to install the Android 11 Beta and root it with canary magisk. It was very unstable. After completely removing canary magisk, all of the issues went away. Wish I could provide help on this issue, but I've never really had an issue with my phone that would require submitting logs or bug reports. If this post isn't allowed here, mods please delete.
[Magisk] gogo9211:
Im having problem where some modules are not showing in "downloads". For example module named youtube vanced is not showing. I have it installed and it shows in modulea but not downloads so i cant update it. And this is not the only one that is not showing. Magisk version: 20.4
[Magisk] Lughnasadh:
YouTube Vanced was removed from the Repo a while ago. The others that aren't showing have likely been removed as well. Also, some apps install a module upon installation but are not part of the Repo.
[Magisk] Philnicolls89:
You should go to the vanced thread, you can still install the old magisk module if you want, but it has been updated to a new version that isn't installed using magisk.
[Magisk] clavelm80:
When installing magisk 20.4 on RMX1931/Realme x2 pro with LineageOS 17. 1 rom (https://xdaforums.com/realme-x2-pro/development/rom-lineageos-17-1-realme-x2-pro-t4069599 ) the system bootloops.

Magisk 20.3 is working fine.

Is there a known reason, and will it be fixed in subsequent updates?
[Magisk] zgfg:
Canary update: 285/20416