yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] jimger:
Guys has anyone managed to work with supersu and magisk 14 (or 13.3)? I remember around 11-12 editions it used to work. Now I would like to have some magisk modules with supersu (and suhide) instead of magisk hide. Is this possible?
[Magisk] ska8tdude:
I just installed Magisk on a fresh install of AOSPA Extended 7.3.0 [UNIFIED] for the OnePlus 3T and it doesn't appear that downloaded modules are taking effect. I installed the EmojiOne module and it installed without issue, but after a reboot it does not make any changes. I've tried uninstalling the module and just flashing the ZIP in recovery, while that is successful, it still doesn't make any changes. Anyone have any ideas why the modules aren't working correctly?
[Magisk] woozie.2007:
please help me, how can i make OTA update without factory reset? Is posible? Magisk 14, moto g5, nougat 7.0. Thank you
[Magisk] kalokagathia:
Alright. I'll sound noob af, but I think I am with boot.img already on.

And doing this, am I going to lose any thing?
[Magisk] Dchoi229:
You're going to have to read and learn all of this. I can't walk you through it..
[Magisk] Artim_96:
Only if you have never replaced recovery and never touched /system.

You can try to let the system download it, find out where it's stored and try to flash it through FlashFire (just got an update to better work together with Magisk) if you already did, bit no ideas if it can post with a custom recovery, not to speak of tampered /system
[Magisk] ryaniskira:
SafetyNet on 14.1 Pixel?

Is anyone else failing SN or is it just me? On my homemade Magisk 14 and the one John Wu just dropped today, both fail Safetynet. Magiskhide is enabled and always has been, systemless hosts is disabled. The old unofficial 13.x builds passed SN just fine.
[Magisk] woozie.2007:
i have stock recovery, if i flashed stock boot, the phone is stuck to logo, if i flashed magisk the phone boot normaly, its stramge because not boot with stock boot, but boot with magisk and then i can't install the update

---------- Post added at 06:51 AM ---------- Previous post was at 06:12 AM ----------

i can't find magisk manager 5.3.5, can give me someone a link please? thanks
[Magisk] ErnyTech:
[MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] why don't merge last commit of selinux?

Do they have any compatibility issues? for me it does not even look like because in aosp repo they are merged
[Magisk] Paschfire:
Magisk Manager 5.3.5 is available within Magisk v14.1(1410) beta archive.
[Magisk] draiyan:
Hi, I'm new to Magisk. I have a OP3T, I already have Magisk installed.

Can I just grab a flashable font zip and import it as a module for Magisk? Got 2 modules installed. And I want to change fonts..

Thanks.
[Magisk] woozie.2007:
Thank you, i will try it
[Magisk] Artim_96:
Then you flashed the wrong boot.img, maybe from a different version. And the modified boot.img shouldn't prevent OTAs, since they normally only scan for changes in /system and just need their stock recovery since they can't handle custom ones.

I know too little about Motorola firmware, but in worst case, get the full firmware and flash that. And in stone way that should also contain the boot.img you'll have to use afterwards if you want to remove Magisk.

But either way, this is very OEM specific, especially if it won't work with untouched /system and recovery, not even through FlashFire. Discuss that in your devices thread
[Magisk] Lordfall:
I'm new with magisk, I want to try emoji one module but why i can't install it. it's written installation error . how to fix it. thanks
[Magisk] skiely666:
First of all I only have my pixel XL a week so I'm not used to the A/B yet. I've patched my boot.img with 5.3.5/ 14.1. do I have to rename it boot.img & do I just fastboot flash it & reboot I'm rooted or am I missing steps? Any direction would be great

Also I tried booting TWRP in fastboot but it wouldn't boot, the TWRP splash screen just kept flickering on every 3 seconds or so & wouldn't boot.

Thanks

Nevermind, I went for it, renamed boot.img & flashed via fastboot, rebooted & I'm rooted. I love magisk!
[Magisk] kalokagathia:
No problem.

Would you answer me one thing: I'm still using stock rom, in this case, do I need to flash the boot. img?
[Magisk] Dchoi229:
Yes. When you get that error 1 message when you try to download magisk that means you need to flash the stock boot.img. Afterwards you should be able to download it. Also keep in mind that you need to also flash that F2FS fixed kernel so magisk can pass the safety net. Sorry if I came off as a ****. I cant walk you through it because I myself, am not really a pro at this. I have been doing this a while but explaining it through a post is hard for me.

- Best of luck
[Magisk] woozie.2007:
i have the stock firmware of my phone, i flashed the original boot.img and the phone refused to boot, if i flash magisk, the phone starts normaly, so i am confused why with the stock boot.img doesnt starts
[Magisk] Dchoi229:
If I were you I'd just flash flashallthetime's stock roms instead of flashing the firmware. I'm pretty sure everyone is aware of upgrading and downgrading firmwares might cause your phone to get bricked ( FOR GOOD theres no fix).
[Magisk] itzsarath:
Am currently on zcx-twrp recovery with pre-installed supersu in Redmi Note 3 SD officially unlocked. How can i move to Magisk?
[Magisk] culiacanazo:
It was posted by TopJohnWu that it lost compatibility for the time being for some reason I can't recall

Methinks you can install it systemly, tho
[Magisk] woozie.2007:
i have many settings and i don't want to lose them, if i flash only system the settings is keept, but still can't update ota
[Magisk] pharaohdk:
Currently on stock rom for nexus 6p and it is updated to latest oreo firmware, ive flashed magisk v14. 0 through twrp in recovery and installed the magiskmanager 5.3. Everything works for a while but at random times i lose root and manager say I dont have magisk installed if i reboot phone it works again. Any advice on how to fix this permanently
[Magisk] jimger:
I can install supersu but not supersu+MAgisk. In the past we could have both.
[Magisk] ValidSmile:
custom kernel

So, im thinking of flashing a custom kernel (SuperStock 2.8.0), just wondering, is it compatible with magisk and can i flash it after magisk (after using the phone with magisk for a few weeks)?

Sorry if its a stupid question, but im new to this stuff, so im not really experienced with kernels/roms, etc. (Although i know what the terms means).
[Magisk] Pkt_Lnt:
Read the bottom bullet point of this post.

https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=72587983&postcount=22
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
You'd probably be better of asking for support in the module thread. And provide logs and details.

There's a section about that here:

https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/guide-magisk-troubleshooting-t3641417

In the past you could, now you can't (unless your Magisk installation is broken, intentionally or unintentionally).

If the kernel uses AnyKernel2 you should be fine. But you won't really now until you've tried, right?

If it doesn't work you can just flash your stock boot image, the kernel and then the Magisk zip (in that order) and you'll be back in business. As long as the Magisk image isn't removed from /data you can flash the boot image, any custom kernel and the Magisk zip as much as you want and not lose your Magisk setup.
[Magisk] Rikiki87:
Hey, I just bought an LG V20 H990DS and rooted it using dirtysanta and magisk but I have a few problem.

Root works completely fine, and magisk manager says magisk is installed but modules are not working and logs are empty. And even when i tray to change a setting (ex: toggle systemless hosts on), it doesn't stay after a reboot and is reset every boot. I looked in the /magisk folder and it's there but completely empty, is this normal ?

The only thing that is written in the logs is :

------ beginning of system

------ beginning of main

**late_start service mode running

*Running service.d scripts

*Starting MagiskHide

I tried with magisk v14 , 14.2 and 13.3 and none of them work. I also tried flashing modules through twrp but it didn't work either.

I don't think it's a known problem since i didn't find anything about it but i hope there's a way to fix it.
[Magisk] woozie.2007:
how can i installmagisk14.zip with stock recovery? i tried on magisk manager, everything is fine, the boot.img was patched, but i have not root and magisk not installed. Thanks
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
You'll have to flash the patched_boot.img file from your computer, with fastboot, ODIN or whatever is used for your device.
[Magisk] woozie.2007:
pffff that simple was that? i'm biggest noob here then :))) thank you, works very well, no error. I think twrp brokes my boot, because when i boot into twrp(not flashed, just boot) after exit from twrp without any modifications....the phone was stuck in boot logo, so i decided to flash the system and install magisk with stock recovery and everything works very well. But how can i make a full nandroid backup without custom recovery?
[Magisk] Pkt_Lnt:
adb backup is one, there are other backup solutions available with searching :good:

type "adb --help" (no quotes) to get syntax like below

adb backup [-f <file>] [-apk|-noapk] [-obb|-noobb] [-shared|-noshared] [-all] [-system|-nosystem] [<packages...>]
- write an archive of the device's data to <file>.
If no -f option is supplied then the data is written
to "backup.ab" in the current directory.
(-apk|-noapk enable/disable backup of the .apks themselves
in the archive; the default is noapk.)
(-obb|-noobb enable/disable backup of any installed apk expansion
(aka .obb) files associated with each application; the default
is noobb.)
(-shared|-noshared enable/disable backup of the device's
shared storage / SD card contents; the default is noshared.)
(-all means to back up all installed applications)
(-system|-nosystem toggles whether -all automatically includes
system applications; the default is to include system apps)
(<packages...> is the list of applications to be backed up. If
the -all or -shared flags are passed, then the package
list is optional. Applications explicitly given on the
command line will be included even if -nosystem would
ordinarily cause them to be omitted.)
[Magisk] olivercervera:
Thanks for your report. I was not aware of strace (not a linux geek).

Anyway, I tried to run it on Barclays Mobile Banking, which is detecting Magisk as well. I have reported few days back that Barclays is able to find Magisk, but not much was found from ADB logs, other than it was accessing the app list to look for Magisk Manager.

I have noticed a very interesting thing: Barclays changes its PID every time I start it. Magisk Manager is smart enough to pick it up, that's how I discovered it, by looking at Manger's logs. Unfortunately every time I close the app the session terminates, so a new PID is created when I reopen this.

May this weird behaviour break Magisk Hide?

That's what I needed to do:

- With the device plugged into a PC, run Barclays. The app luckily asks for Phone permission, which pauses everything.

- Run ps | grep barclays, which returns the current PID

- Run strace -f -p CURENTPID -o /sdcard/strace.txt

- Accept Phone permission and let the app run, it will eventually close.

In this way I was finally able to run strace. I made two tests: one with only Magisk Hide enabled on Barclays and Phone Services, the other with Magisk Manager hidden as well.

Unfortunately there is no result using keywords like: root, magisk, hide, compromised.

There are a lot of <unfinished ...> events like this

Line 782: 13705 rt_sigprocmask(SIG_SETMASK, NULL, <unfinished ...>
Line 782: 13705 rt_sigprocmask(SIG_SETMASK, NULL, <unfinished ...>
Line 784: 13705 <... rt_sigprocmask resumed> [QUIT USR1 PIPE], 8) = 0
Line 786: 13705 rt_sigprocmask(SIG_SETMASK, NULL, <unfinished ...>
Line 786: 13705 rt_sigprocmask(SIG_SETMASK, NULL, <unfinished ...>
Line 788: 13705 <... rt_sigprocmask resumed> [QUIT USR1 PIPE], 8) = 0
Line 790: 13705 rt_sigprocmask(SIG_SETMASK, NULL, <unfinished ...>
Line 790: 13705 rt_sigprocmask(SIG_SETMASK, NULL, <unfinished ...>
Line 792: 13705 <... rt_sigprocmask resumed> [QUIT USR1 PIPE], 8) = 0
Line 794: 13705 rt_sigprocmask(SIG_SETMASK, NULL, <unfinished ...>
Line 794: 13705 rt_sigprocmask(SIG_SETMASK, NULL, <unfinished ...>
Line 796: 13705 <... rt_sigprocmask resumed> [QUIT USR1 PIPE], 8) = 0
Line 875: 13705 rt_sigprocmask(SIG_SETMASK, NULL, <unfinished ...>
Line 875: 13705 rt_sigprocmask(SIG_SETMASK, NULL, <unfinished ...>

I'm not a developer, so if anybody can understand this, please tell if there is anything that could help.

You can find attached the two strace I ran.

Maybe there is a better way to run strace?

Any help is greatly appreciated.
[Magisk] woozie.2007:
i don't understand all commands, for the full backup with aplication and settings, can you tell me what is the correct command? Thanks
[Magisk] Pkt_Lnt:
adb backup -all

This will work for you, good luck. Since we are OT for Magisk, this ends my off topic posting, there are guides and tutorial on XDA

https://xdaforums.com/search?query=adb backup
[Magisk] woozie.2007:
thank you
[Magisk] Pkt_Lnt:
You are welcome, sorry to sound cranky in that last post. Here is another good resource.

https://android.stackexchange.com/q...es-adb-backup-and-how-do-i-restore-part-of-it
[Magisk] woozie.2007:
no problem, i understand, when i've need for help, everytime was somebody here ti help, so i am not angry for few words :))
[Magisk] DragonQ:
I am running LineageOS nightly 20/09 on my Galaxy S5 (klte). I have Magisk 14.0 installed. Sometimes, for no apparent reason, Magisk tells me there's an update to v14.0 (which I already have), and when I check Magisk Manager it claims Magisk isn't installed....except it was. Root access seems to just disappear randomly, and a reboot (usually) fixes it.

Is this a known issue or am I alone with this problem?
[Magisk] hippoguynil:
I am on the beta thread and am getting notifications of a new release of Magisk Manager (5.3.5). When I click to download I get nothing and can't see anything newer than what I have already in the Downloads at the start of this thread (5.3.0).

This version has been mentioned in some on here, can anyone tell me where to get it from?

Edit: also, is it worth it?
[Magisk] bmg002:
I just installed Magisk manager 5.3.5 and Magisk 14.2 using the manager. It installed fine, but I am unable to install any modules using the download section of the manager. Whenever I try, it says:

Copying zip to temp directory

Installing <module name> (Dolby_Atmos-r6.5-d.zip for example)

Archive: /data/user/0/com.topjohnmu.magisk/cache/install.zip

Inflating: config.sh

failed!

Installation error!

I had 1 module installed prior to the upgrade - Busybox for Android NDK.

Attached is my logcat and magisk error log. I don't see anything too crazy in there nor any indication as to why it failed.

I am having an issue getting safetynet to pass too, but I'm thinking I need to install the safetynet bypass module for that to work.

EDIT - As I was just testing things, I also wanted to try the "hide Magisk Manager" option. I click it, it says "hiding Magisk manager..." waits for a few seconds then says it failed. When I look at the magisk log, there is nothing new added.
[Magisk] talliver:
Facebook instantly crashes

[Solved]

Substratum overlay issue. Face palm. It stopped working with supersu as well. Unistalled overlay for Facebook and solved. Original post:

Recently switched to Magisk from SuperSU and have been successful except for facebook instantly crashing on open. I striped everything back to just magisk and still crashes, unistalled magisk and it worked, re installed magisk and facebook crashes again. Switched back to supersu and facebook works.

I don't know what it is. Messenger works, instagram works, chrome works.

Oneplus 3t open beta 15

Any help would be appreciated, thanks!
[Magisk] Pkt_Lnt:
A log of the crash is the only thing that can help solve it.
[Magisk] SlimPickens89:
Can I just un-install MAGISK 14.0, flash 14.2 in TWRP, REBOOT AND I'M GOOD.... Tried reading tutorial from OP but with my lack of knowledge he lost me after step 2. Normally just CLEAN flash new setup but finally found the perfect setup and it took to long, don't want to lose anything. Thanks

Also, using 5.3 manager should I update to latest beta?
[Magisk] whitak3r:
I accidentally run "Temporarily Hide Magisk Manager" and now there is a "Unhide Magisk Manager" app. I keep trying to run that and nothing happens. Touch the icon and it slows for 3/4 second and then nothing. Tried resetting, re-flashing Magisk 14.1, nothing works. Root currently isn't working.

On Pixel XL, 7.1.2 Pure Nexus. Any idea how to fix this?
[Magisk] bluuquthug:
Sorry for noob question..

I can't download and/or install module from magisk manager, have a fix for that?

I'm on 3T with magisk 14

I was tried uninstall and reflash magisk then still same

solved
[Magisk] Fif_:
http://lmgtfy.com/?q=magisk+process+error+workaround
[Magisk] bluuquthug:
Nice! Thanks for your tips, I know I'm just noob here..

Thanks so much and solved!
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
There are reports like this once in a while. But without logs or precise and detailed ways to reproduce it's hard to troubleshoot.

Does the Manager have storage permission? And yes, it's worth it to update. There's been a few bugs squashed.

But, it's beta so there might still be some crawling around in there...

I'd try a complete uninstall of Magisk and the Manager and do a clean install.

Just flash 14.2 directly over 14.0. If you experience issues, do a clean install...

Easiest would be to set the Manager to the beta channel in the settings and just update directly from the Manager. And you should update the Manager as well if you want Magisk v14.2.

First, for later troubleshooting, capture a logcat from when you try to use the Unhide Magisk app.

After that you should be able to use adb to uninstall the Manager:

adb uninstall com.topjohnwu.magisk
[Magisk] whitak3r:
I flashed "uninstall magisk" and re-installed Magisk 14.2. Now there is no Magisk Manager or Unhide Magisk Manager apps installed. I try to install the Magisk Manager APK and it says "it appears to be corrupted". Tried multiple downloads.

I ended up fixing it, No idea what caused this though

Here was my original problem:

Clicked on "Hide Magisk Manager" in Magisk Manager

Successfully hid, created the "Unhide Magisk Manager" app

Tried to run Unhide Magisk Manager, nothing happens... Rebooted, nothing

Tried a few things... nothing..

ended up fixing it by:

adb uninstall com.topjohnwu.magisk

adb fastboot recovery

adb fastboot boot twrp 3.1-1

flashed Magisk 14.2.

rebooted. Magisk manager was there again.

Turned on my "Systemless hosts" again. Magisk manager closed out

Noticed there was no Magisk Manager again (sigh)

Saw there was now "Unhide Magisk Manager"

Ran Unhide Magisk Manager - everything returned to as normal.
[Magisk] Aijen:
hiii...!!! please help im Nexus 5X running oreo, i want install Magisk Manager/MagiskSu in systemless mode but always install it system, so cant install the OTAS using Flashfire please somebody can help me?
[Magisk] hippoguynil:
Perfect, thank you. All working. Any reasons why Magisk didn't ask for storage permissions?
[Magisk] woozie.2007:
After installed magisk anf patched the boot, everythings works good except camera app, when i try to open it the message is camera busy, reboot the phone but the message is the same. Any suggestion please? Thanks
[Magisk] DragonQ:
Yeah I can appreciate that. I only noticed after fixing it that there is a Magisk log built into the manager app so I've screenshotted that whilst it's working. Hopefully when/if it breaks again it'll show something.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Magisk can't install to system. That's kind of the point...

A bug...
[Magisk] Aijen:
So....why when tried install the OTA using FlashFire tell that system, Vendor or OEM was modified? :/
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Some app you've given root access have modified /system or it's something you've done (it's enough to mount /system rw). It's not the act of installing Magisk...
[Magisk] Aijen:
So...ignore that advice or what should i do? Because i don't mount nothing, im in Nexus 5x Oreo Right Now.

---------- Post added at 12:58 PM ---------- Previous post was at 12:42 PM ----------

Sorry for be annoying, but im Noob i this Thing in Nexus Phone....
[Magisk] longxa762:
I have a Samsung Galaxy Note 5 on Nougat 7.0, how do I install Xposed? If I read it right do I just install the latest Xposed installer from here then install the SDK 24 module in Magisk Manager?

Do I still need Samsung AntiRoot Kit when flashing magisk?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
No worries...

Using Magisk it is possible to let your device update through OTA. @topjohnwu recently wrote a nice guide on that in the Magisk docs.

The tricky part is making sure nothing on your device has tampered with /system and possibly /vendor. When apps have root access that's quite easy to do...
[Magisk] St Sinned:
Good Day... Could you please tell me what magisk needed for my Zenfone Max Z010d? I have flashed an AIM ROM....TIA....
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Stable release is in the release thread.

If you want bleeding edge you can go for the beta release.

If you experience issues, some common solutions can be found in the troubleshooting guide.
[Magisk] Twml:
Magisk "uninstalling" it's self Nexus 6P 8.0

I have a Nexus 6P running Android Oreo (8.0) the OPR6.170623.019 build. And have Magisk installed along with the MagiskSU, And busybox 1.27.2 osm0sis. Since updating to Oreo or version 14.0 not sure what one it is since both at same time.

I can be using my phone then all of a sudden i get a notification to download and install magisk 14.0... checking the Magisk manager app there is a red X saying it's not installed. Sometimes just rebooting phone brings it back to green check. Other times i need to reflash stock boot image then reflash Magisk in TWRP. And can not do this until back at a pc since flashing the boot.img i use fastboot on PC. Leaving me without root or safety net for rest of time til i get home.

I have tried reflashing phone back to stock fully and flashing Magisk again. Also tried beta 14.2 Magisk. Same thing happens randomly, lose Magisk fully until either reflashing it. Or if lucky just a reboot.

Not passing safety net leaves me without Android pay. One of the main things i use my phone for. And one of main reasons i use Magisk over other root methods out there. So that's frustrating.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
There have been several reports about this. But unfortunately, so far no-one has been able to provide any useful logs or details for troubleshooting. Without that it's hard to figure out...
[Magisk] meddylad:
Hi guys

Am I able to delete the downloaded packages in the MagiskManager folder once they are installed or are they needed?

Thx
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
I managed to reproduce it, and found out that it probably is Magisk Hide-related
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Oooooo! Nice! Do you have any logcat showing what's going on?
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
Unfortunately, no (But I'll try to reproduce it again and get a logcat somehow)
[Magisk] St Sinned:
Thanks a lot....
[Magisk] zurik:
Magisk 14.2 will work with Nexus 5X? In Magisk Manager I didn't received any notification to upgrade Magisk
[Magisk] atarek:
In manager settings change update channel from stable to beta.

Regards,

Ahmed
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Well... You wouldn't if you're on the stable channel (there's a setting for that in the Manager settings). Magisk v14.2 is still in beta.
[Magisk] zurik:
Oh, the 14.2 is beta...

Thanks for your answer
[Magisk] chudy_85:
Yes it's another beta. You can check in magisk manager setting
[Magisk] dtective:
I think the best workaround right now is to rebuild Magisk Manager with a new package name.

You can find the source on Github, https://github.com/topjohnwu/MagiskManager

I may try this this weekend if I can find some free time.
[Magisk] Mohitjolly:
Hi

Can you pls how I can install MAGISK 14.0/12.0 (ANY) ZIP FILE IN MICROMAX A311