yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] :
This is probably been asked a ton of times, but I haven't found any solution to my problem yet.

I am on Magisk 10.2 with SR3-SuperSU 2.79 on RR 7.1.1 with SELinux Enforcing.

Magisk Hide is enabled (without any app checked), BusyBox and Systemless hosts also enabled.

Still, SafetyNet Failed, can't figure out what is the problem.
[Magisk] ipmanwck:
I stayed on the older version and did not update. Maybe try the old version and see what happens.
[Magisk] ipmanwck:
I am on megapixel ROM nexus 6p. Banking apps working fine with root and using hide in menu.
[Magisk] gk1984:
What phone? You might need a kernel that hides bootloader unlock status. There was also something that seemed to break SN again recently but I never followed it close enough to see what it was...

I can still pass SafetyNet on my Nexus 6, stock 7.1.1, Franco kernel, Magisk 10.2, Magisk hide set, and ARISE installed.
[Magisk] :
OnePlus X with Arsenic Kernel-R32.

I've noticed that after every system Reboot Magisk Hide gets disabled. Is it happening just to me?
[Magisk] gk1984:
Reread your earlier post. I think your problem is SuperSU. I had issues with Magisk and Magisk hide with it. Have switched to the built in Magisk phh su
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
What most people seems to be missing is (from the Official thread by topjohnwu):

Included root solution = phh's superuser topjohnwu version

In other words, Magisk Hide does NOT work with SuperSU.
[Magisk] :
Yeah, it should have been more clear, that Magisk Hide only works with phh's SuperUser

PS: Nevermind, it is explained in #5 post.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Well... If you'd actually taken the time and read what the developer has written (the whole Official thread), you'd see he states it quite clearly.

But, having said that, since the issue arises quite a lot, it's not clear enough. Luckily that'll be remedied with the next update of the Manager.
[Magisk] biggdevon:
Is it listed anywhere as to what version of busybox is baked into magisk? Noticed there's a fairly new version from a newer dev that picked up where the previous left off.
[Magisk] culiacanazo:
Someone has exclusive, all-access, insider's info

VIP status, huh?
[Magisk] yochananmarqos:
Version 1.25 is included, but you can update it with Stericson's BusyBox app or something similar.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
I just pop on GitHub once in a while and check out the new commits... :D

Well, actually I think I'm slightly wrong. I'm not sure it'll be in the next update, cause the only commit I see right now is the one with info on why Pokemon Go and Android Pay won't turn up in the Magisk Hide list. Hmm... I'm sure I read it somewhere...

Found it! It was an issue opened about this on GitHub. That a lot of people don't understand about SuperSU not working with Hide and that you don't need to add PoGo and AP to the Hide list. Topjohnwu took it to heart so I'm sure it'll get worked out somehow. Issue #63 for the Manager, if anyone's interested.
[Magisk] biggdevon:
Would updating cause any conflicts with hide or the ability to use android pay (my goal). I'm inquiring about busybox because the latest SELinux mode changer app functions best with the latest busybox.

https://xdaforums.com/showthread.php?t=2524485
[Magisk] culiacanazo:
What I'm reluctant to believe, is that so many ppl want these things this bad and go long ways just to play PoGo... (torn between emphasizing PLAY or PoGo...)

Really bewildering, hard to believe, i mean, i run out of adjectives before i run out of surprise...

That really should have a thread all its own with all the different issues surrounding it and whatnot

---------- Post added at 09:08 PM ---------- Previous post was at 09:01 PM ----------

Please elaborate on that because that'd be a twist for me...

"Functions best" impresses me with the notion that there's 'it functions' and then there's 'it functions best' (unless it merely is a spoken typo, in which case, disregard)

Last time i checked, selinux changer either functioned or it didn't.
[Magisk] biggdevon:
Functions best indicates it does indeed function more often than not with little or no issues.

Just because something functions does not mean it is functioning at it's full capacity (FC's, error generations, causes reboots, etc.)
[Magisk] yochananmarqos:
No, it will not conflict or interfere. It updates the existing Magisk busybox installation.
[Magisk] biggdevon:
Did you ever get it to pass, if so please spread the love.
[Magisk] midgarsormr:
Can't get it to pass on any new roms installed on OnePlus3. Adb off, magiskhide, various kernels. I feel like new installs are being checked differently. I have a rom from early January that still works. Basically cat and mouse these days.
[Magisk] aenmo:
I'm new to magisk, I installed this on my Nexus 5x running on 7.1.1 Pixel rom for enabling dual speaker. Can anyone tell me why "Sefty Net failed CTS profile mismatched" error is showing ? Is everything is fine ?
[Magisk] culiacanazo:
Of course! I just didn't know this app was one of them... :P
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Do you need SafetyNet to pass? Do you even know what it is? If the answers to those questions are "no", don't worry...

SafetyNet is used in some apps to find out if your device is secure, i.e. not rooted. Android Pay and Pokemon Go are two well known apps that use this API. If you feel the need to use these apps and have Magisk and root access on your device, you'll need to switch to the included Magisk root (SuperSU does not work with Magisk Hide). Read through the entire Official thread by topjohnwu (stickied at the top), it's got lots of good info.
[Magisk] aenmo:
I was also thinking the error is showing because of incompatible superuser but i was not sure. Thanks bro for clearing my doubt.
[Magisk] Fild5x:
This is how I easily install magisk on my galaxy a500h just to help those with my type of phone to manage. I have used this method for cm14 as well as aryamod Note 7 roms that are currently on my phone.

- Please install Magisk apk but do not run it.

- download phh superuser zip and flash it in recovery

- reboot and install phh superuser apk

- Now run magisk and give root permission as requested (select remember choice for ever)

- Then you can start using the modules easily.

- If a module cannot be installed then go to recovery and flash it from the Magisk manager folder of the internal memory (sdcard)

This way even xposed will be less of a problem than otherwise.
[Magisk] Kal-El7:
Hello all,

I have an inquiry.

Not long ago this week I had successfully flashed the Magisk v10.2 zip in TWRP and was able to verify that SafetyNet passed after I had enabled the Magisk Hide option. Tonight, I reformatted my phone and went though the same process. However, when attempting to launch the Magisk Manager app, I do see the top two statuses in green - indicating that Magisk is installed and TopJohnWu's phh SuperSU is successfully installed. But that's just it - I'm not rooted because the two Root Checker apps I use show that I'm not rooted. So when I try to launch other root-dependent apps, they too state that I'm not rooted. But yet, again, Magisk Manager says I'm rooted with TopJohnWu's phh SuperSU. And, also, when I try going into settings to enable Hide Magisk or do any other activity in the Settings, Magisk Manager simply crashes.

Does this sound family to anyone? I've tried flashing the Magisk Uninstall zip countless of times, rebooted to ensure it's uninstalled, go back to TWRP to re-flash the Magisk v10.2 zip but I get the same outcome. I'm a little puzzled.

Thanks so much.
[Magisk] nathanchance:
Have you tried clearing the manager's app data?
[Magisk] kantjer:
did you install the superuser app?
[Magisk] Kal-El7:
I did, rebooted, nothing - I did that prior to moving on to uninstalling it all together via the Magisk Uninstall zip, leaving what I believe is to be no traces of it all all.

---------- Post added at 05:19 AM ---------- Previous post was at 05:18 AM ----------

Oh snap....no! I forgot about that! I did that before, Hold on....be right back.
[Magisk] Kal-El7:
[MENTION=3306843]kantjer[/MENTION] - you see that right there? Thank you!! =)
[Magisk] morfinrider:
SN Error, but managed to get Airwatch working

[MENTION=4667597]Didgeridoohan[/MENTION] So I flashed latest LineageOS again to get Airwatch to work. Got it to work, but not to my satisfaction. Here's what I did:

Wipe Data, System, Dalvik, Cache (Except Internal Storage)

Install LineageOS 01302017 version + GApps Nano 01022017

Ran unSu command

Logged into System and set it up with Wifi access

Installed Magisk Manager from Play Store (but did not open)

Installed phh Superuser from Play Store (but did not open)

Installed SELinuxModeChanger apk (but did not open)

Rebooted to recovery - Flashed Magisk v10.2

Booted into System and gave superuser right to Magisk Manager

Enabled Magisk Hide

Opened SELinuxModeChanger app and set to Enforcing after giving it root rights

Rebooted System

CTS Profile Mismatch error for Safetynet Check :(

Installed Airwatch Agent from Play Store

Hide Airwatch Agent + Settings in Magisk Hide

Opened Airwatch Agent and enrolled into corporate network (It did ask for root rights, as 2 different apps/IDs, after being Denied Root Rights in Superuser app. Is this expected?)

I did not enable Developer Options anytime during the install. Later on when I did, ADB was turned on. I turned it off and tried Safetynet test again, but failed again!

Now I cannot access emails on Nine app, which is my preferred app for emails, or connect to corporate WIFI, but I could push Airwatch Inbox from my corporate Airwatch dashboard and can access work emails on it. Also Airwatch Agent does not show the phone as compromised anymore! A little victory nonetheless, thanks to all the help and assistance from folks on this thread!

I have attached logs from Magisk to this thread. If anyone can help me figure out what went wrong, it would be great!
[Magisk] yochananmarqos:
I think you forgot the step where you actually installed Magisk. :silly:

FYI, Magisk contains phh superuser, no need to flash it separately.
[Magisk] Fild5x:
Silly? Well am sure that is the one I said please install Magisk apk ( or app from play store as advised). Now on my phone (a5h), if I install Magisk (from play store) without root, I will be able to open but will not be able to install any module or zip because upon opening Magisk it tries to ask for root permission. It is either I root the phone with superSU or phh superuser first. Hence the reason why am trying to post this here so that all those that have a phone like mine can manage, if they are not. Thanks.
[Magisk] jhedfors:
"Silly" is the XDA emoticon tag. Apparently emoticons do not transfer well to tapatalk. Otherwise, yes, your steps are not quite correct as suggested. Need to flash Magisk - recovery if no root, or from the app if rooted. Do not need to flash PHH superuser zip, as it is included in Magisk.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Well... No. Magisk is a two part system. You need the Magisk Manager (the app) and you also need to flash the installation zip in TWRP, or if you're already rooted it can be done through the Manager. You never mentioned anything about the Magisk zip...
[Magisk] Fild5x:
Ok on my phone I can only install the magisk zip v10.2 only when I open the magisk app because at this point it will detect that I have not installed magisk. Depending on the situation, the zip will install directly or it will give an error and advise to install through recovery as I said in my first post. Please if you have a500h and you are finding difficulties to install magisk then try to follow what I have suggested because I followed what everyone is saying but it did not work and I used to have serious bootloops with xposed but now I can install any suitable xposed module even wjthout hiding magisk or whatever and without a risk trust me.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
You have not mentioned the Magisk zip until now... Are you saying you cannot install the zip through TWRP at all?

If you're not rooted and starting from scratch the steps should be:

-Flash Magisk zip in TWRP (MagiskSU will be installed automatically).

-Boot up phone.

-Install Magisk Manager and phh's superuser app (with the next update Magisk Manager will manage root permissions and phh's superuser app won't be needed).

-Grant root access to Magisk Manager.

-Enjoy Magisk.

The above doesn't work for you?
[Magisk] Kal-El7:
Greetings friends,

I read something in this thread a while back, so I wanted to test it out - requiring me to install Magisk Xposed. After successfully installing the Xposed Magisk module & rebooting, I proceeded to install the Xposed app, something I've done infinite number of times over the years.

When opening the Xposed app to install the Chromepie module for Chrome, the app states that the Xposed Framework isn't installed, although Magisk Manager showed otherwise. Have you seen this conflict before?

Thanks so much.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Did you use the Material Design installer by DVDandroid? According to topjohnwu's instructions in his Xposed thread it's required...

https://xdaforums.com/xposed/material-design-xposed-installer-t3137758
[Magisk] Kal-El7:
Hmm....I'm not sure, let me go check that out, thank you.

Additionally, I'd like to note that I've already had the Magisk Xposed Framework working correctly with a functioning Xposed manager & installed Chromepie before I fully wiped my phone. I simply repeated the same steps this time around, but the outcome isn't the same.

Be right back....thanks again. =)
[Magisk] Kal-El7:
Beast. Thank you....I suppose I must have used this one before & just didn't remember. Ok, I'm gonna upload this to my Google Drive so I won't forget. =) Now to test a module out.....

Thanks all for being super-duper.
[Magisk] H4X0R46:
Every rom I try to pass safety net on, while checking if safety net passes, I just get stuck on an endless loop. It never actually says pass or fail! How do I fully remove built in root on a rom? Where do I look for that? Thanks!
[Magisk] Artim_96:
UPDATE-unsu.zip by osmosis
[Magisk] H4X0R46:
I'll give that a shot! Thanks man! :D
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Sounds like your Google Play services aren't working. Have you flashed the proper gapps with the ROM?
[Magisk] Kal-El7:
This zip works very, very well. I've used it.
[Magisk] Artim_96:
That's why I recommended it...
[Magisk] staygreen420:
can someone give me a strait forward way to root s7e, theres so many tutorials i dont know what way to go!

i have a stock phone want to root and play pogo, i have downloaded magisk v10.2 and phh-superuser-topjohnwu-r2.img.tar now what?
[Magisk] Team DevDigitel:
With 800 pages im not sure where to look for a discussion about this issue. Im a dev working to add phh and the magisk to a rom version on the lgv20.

I have the basics down. And I've built it into the rom successfully. I need to know if i can manipulate magisk hide to not stop root permissions to the systemui. It seems only when on the systemui will fc when calling a command as a root user. The logcat also identifys that there is no user that has the sufficient rights to do things. But even with the request failing it will do the task. Like rotation or locking screen that requires the system to play along.

The wifi.. Services.. Etc all are effected and draw the same error in the log to some sort. Im just not sure if this has been a issue elsewhere and if theres something i can do directly for magisk to be 100%

I have a few logs during boot pre and post turning on magisk hide.. As well as during a system fc that results in the entire uirestarting. Even tho the system fc the ui will function for a period of time before actually freezing. Going black and then rebooting the ui and all services..

I dont mean to be rude but i just cant see catching up on 800 pages of troubleshootting for such a specific issues that may be device specific.

Thanks guys.. As well thanks for the awesome addition to the xda family. Def a great addition exp. With chainfire supersu being rehomed. Much appreciated work good sir!
[Magisk] H4X0R46:
Flash Magisk in TWRP, and then phh zip in TWRP, install the magisk Manager app from play store as well phh superuser app from play store. In magisk Manager, tick "Magisk Hide" and reboot.
[Magisk] staygreen420:
Thanks mate will do now :)

oh also do i need to wipe anything? or i get to keep phone as is with this root method?

BTW love the shirt ;)
[Magisk] nathanchance:
Don't actually have to flash the phh zip, it's built into 10.2 as long as you are unrooted to begin with.
[Magisk] bgenesis12:
From what I understand you only need safety pass if u plan on using Android pay and such. I have an LG v20 h918. I have installed magisk and I am trying to use it so that substratum will allow me to theme everything including prop and setting but it still will not allow me. Any help please?

---------- Post added at 04:43 AM ---------- Previous post was at 04:14 AM ----------

What of ur rootes
[Magisk] staygreen420:
so correct me if im wrong, im half new at this.

first flash twrp to phone with odin then intall magisk10.2 though twrp restart install magisk manager and phh from the playstore reboot then done?

no wiping anything or any other steps i missed?
[Magisk] jhedfors:
Just missing the part where you need to select "Magisk Hide" in Magisk Manager, and reboot.
[Magisk] midgarsormr:
Having the same issue and still can't fix it even with correct gapps. It seems to happen when magiskhide is ticked.
[Magisk] staygreen420:
okay i hit a problem installing twrp, i got a red screen after switching from vol down+home+pwr to vol up+home+power im assuming twrp was ment to show up but it didnt i downloaded twrp-3.0.2-4-herolte.img for sm-g935f what am i doing wrong? do i need twrp to flash magisk? and what about the dm-verity thing with this method? Flash Magisk in TWRP, and then phh zip in TWRP, install the magisk Manager app from play store as well phh superuser app from play store. In magisk Manager, tick "Magisk Hide" and reboot.
[Magisk] yochananmarqos:
1. Never start a sentence with "okay."

2. No one wants to read a jumbled run-on sentence.

3. This is not a TWRP support thread.

4. Last but not least, read.

5. Read again.

6. Comprehend.

7. Still stuck? No worries, post information about your device and ROM.

8. Logs.
[Magisk] FaserF:
I am unable to use SuperSu with Magisk.

Everytime I flash Magisk, my phone gets unrooted and SuperSu says that the binarys are missing.

I went with the instructions to FIRST flash SuperSu, then flash Magisk. Tried the way through the app and the flashable method. My phone gets always unrooted!

What to do?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Sounds like you're using system SuperSU. Magisk requires systemless SuperSU.

I get what you're doing now... You're using the regular, non-Magisk phh's superuser prior to installing Magisk. Unless there are some major incompatibilities with your device this is NOT necessary and may cause issues with Magisk Hide (if you want to use that).

The recommendation is still to just flash Magisk zip in TWRP. MagiskSU will be installed automatically.

---------- Post added at 11:46 ---------- Previous post was at 11:35 ----------

Logs are useful when troubleshooting. You can save them from the Manager.
[Magisk] X46X:
Hi, is there a way to get working xposed and safetynet together? I have installed magisk and xposed from magisk manager but safetynet working only when I disable xposed..
[Magisk] culiacanazo:
Currently, not concurrently
[Magisk] Fild5x:
Well I will try to flash magisk zip next time like that but a few days ago flashing magisk directly like that on my phone wash giving an error though I cannot remember what that was.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Give it a try again and if it gives an error save the recovery log and upload it here.
[Magisk] Fild5x:
So the magissk compatible phh's superUser by topjohnwu is non-magisk
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Your posts have been a little confusing and from what I've gathered you are installing phh's superuser prior to installing the Magisk framework. For that to work you have to use the non-Magisk phh's superuser (the original). Flashing phh's superuser topjohnwu version before Magisk does absolutely nothing.
[Magisk] Drivepnut:
I know this is a silly question but how do you get your ui to look like that for xposed mines look totally different and I also have a Samsung phone and I am running 87
[Magisk] Kal-El7:
Is this question intended for me? because you quoted me. I don't recall ever speaking about my UI nor have I uploaded any images showing my UI, which is plain.
[Magisk] midgarsormr:
It had to do with multirom...go figure. I didn't even try that at all. Looks like it only works with primary for now. I read somewhere it may be compatible in the future.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Ok. Good you figured it out. I've seen reports that Magisk doesn't quite work with a secondary ROM. I haven't dabbled with MultiROM myself, so I've no idea.

Topjohnwu have had some ideas and shown a proof of concept of a Magisk universal MultiROM feature. No idea if he's been able to work on it though.
[Magisk] Fild5x:
Ok I am using multiROM. I installed magisk following the procedure and it installed easily for cm14.0. I will check once there is an update for the android 6.0.1 rom as I wouldn't like to disturb it for now.
[Magisk] Drivepnut:
If you are the one that posted this screenshot this yes this question is for you. Maybe I should of said how do you get your xposed installer to look like that.
[Magisk] culiacanazo:
You mean the tabs across the top? There's the installer by rovo and the one by dvdandroid
[Magisk] patri3x:
I downloaded magisk reading online that it can hide root from certain apps but it is way over my head. Problem is I flashed v10.2 but my TWRP says root lost after flashing magisk. I am on MIUI 8 using Mi4i. Now I tried flash that PHP Superuser through recovery but still no root. Now I don't know how use it and thread is so big that my laziness kicks in to study anything on it. I want to UNINSTALL it now so please tell where is UNINSTALL.zip or any easy measure to get magisk out my phone.:rolleyes:
[Magisk] Drivepnut:
Yeah that is what I meant I need to check that out. Do you have a link to it
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Uninstall zip can be found in the Official thread by topjohnwu (stickied at the top in the Magisk forum and linked from the OP in this thread).

[RANT]FFS... Just search dvdandroid and xposed. It'll be the first result...[/RANT]
[Magisk] Drivepnut:
Thanks
[Magisk] dimm0k:
I have several modules I created and they all display fine in the Magisk Manager app, however a recent one I created that puts Greenify into /system/priv-app isn't displaying properly. the module works and the template used was nothing different than the previous modules I created, but in Magisk Manager it only shows the module name I chose and nothing else. the version number, description, and author are all missing. any ideas why this might be?
[Magisk] crusader727:
maybe you should upload your module so we can check it ? :eek:
[Magisk] gk1984:
The app systemizer module has a file under extras in the Magisk folder you can edit to make any app a system app. I've done it a few times. It's easy.
[Magisk] dimm0k:
lol sorry, here it is...
[Magisk] dimm0k:
thanks, I'm aware of the app systemizer module, but for something that's rather trivial like this I rather make my own...

EDIT: the weird thing is it displays fine after installing the module, but after rebooting to have the module take effect is when the display only shows the module name and nothing else where it should display name, description, version, etc
[Magisk] de.er:
Does the unsu.zip remove the su from /bin and /xbin?
[Magisk] jcrompton:
Was anyone ever able to use Magisk on the Mate 9? Mine arrives tomorrow and I have read about the available TWRP .... so I didn't want to do something that I couldn't fix if the road had already been travelled
[Magisk] Topper59:
So Magisk works great on my 6P with 7.1.1 on the latest Pure Nexus ROM. Android Pay works, but the one thing that doesn't (and the reason for me installation) is Playstation Vue. It somehow still says "Not supported on rooted devices". I heard rootcloak might solve this, but we don't have xposed on Nougat yet, is there any other way?