yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] RandomPooka:
Is there a master list of banned apks? I only know of one. Would be nice to know what posts/questions that should not be responded to, due to being a banned subject
[Magisk] :
I actually had this discussion this week lol. The problem with making a list of banned apps is we are then telling members about warez apps they may not be aware of
[Magisk] Tesla:
Oh that slippery slope :D
[Magisk] teddy0209:
Wow... Nice find there!!! Though I don't have problems using play store, it does make the device certified again... ??????

---------- Post added at 01:37 AM ---------- Previous post was at 01:34 AM ----------

Guys, is there anyone here able to use magisk hide on MIUI based on N?
[Magisk] adewisman:
Im using it atm bro ... tho on older version.. need to tweaks some build.prop build fingerprint to stable release to make it work, attaching my magisk module base on someone on the git that report the issue on mi5, I edited some line for my phone (libra/mi4c) ... so may be you could edit that to according your phone stable release. :good:

edit : and I use modified magisk according the git issue too here is the link : https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B-pSptpnbKwlR2lvQUotUkZWVzA/view?usp=drivesdk

edit2 : this is the so called git issue : https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/pull/149
[Magisk] teddy0209:
Thanks for the reply!!! What variant of MIUI are you using? Global dev?
[Magisk] adewisman:
Im using miui.eu base on china dev ... about phone attached.
[Magisk] RandomPooka:
I hadn't even considered that. Good point.

Also, let's ban 2LiveCrew. That will be a super effective way to keep anyone from listening to them!
[Magisk] teddy0209:
Okay... Thanks!!! I'm still on global stable, but I'm planning to switch to global dev on my mi5...

Edit: The modded 11.6 works as is with MIUI Global Stable... So I'm guessing the changes has not been merged to v12 yet?
[Magisk] AXelzero1:
No matter what I do, magisk manager says that magisk is installed bur there's no root access. This happened after rebooting the phone and root won't come back even if I uninstall and reinstall magisk or reinstall my kernel. Root worked fine before rebooting
[Magisk] Scrapyard Loot:
Turn off busybox.
[Magisk] AXelzero1:
How? I don't have root access
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
You could try clearing data for the Manager.
[Magisk] Shararti1:
Hi,

I Flashed Aicp ROM By [MENTION=5651185]GreekDragon[/MENTION] For Redmi Note 3 (Kenzo) And Getting this Error with Magisk After flashing of ROMs and 2,3 Reboots its fine but after That Its Breaking. I Tried To uninstall it and Re install it but its also not working so any body knows what's the problem is ? I never had any issue with Magisk on other ROMs. Please tell me how do completely Disable or delete Magisk From This ROM so I can root it with SuperSu. It also not working with SuperSU...
[Magisk] AXelzero1:
I used an uninstall zip from XDA and it worked! Thanks!

That didn't fix anything but thanks for the help
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Out of curiosity: what zip was that?
[Magisk] Shararti1:
Can u give the link of that uninstaller? Is that a Magisk Uninstaller Or Un Root file ? And after that u flash Magisk or SuperSU ? Thanks
[Magisk] AXelzero1:
It uninstalls BusyBox, then I flashed magisk. Use the BusyBox-cleaner zip. https://xdaforums.com/android/software-hacking/tool-busybox-flashable-archs-t3348543
[Magisk] Shararti1:
So the problem I with busy box ?
[Magisk] AXelzero1:
Mine was. Just give it a shot, it won't hurt anything.
[Magisk] adewisman:
no idea how [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] implement those git request on his build, but v12 never work on any miui I've tried, magisk hide always fail to un/mount, can only use that modded v.11.6 to pass safety net and have a working magisk hide, hope [MENTION=225651]op[/MENTION] could fix it on the next build, finger crossed
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Ok, cool. I just realised I was a little unclear earlier. Woke up 5 minutes before, I'll blame that... :)

What I meant was: clear data (or uninstall would work also) as well as uninstalling and reinstalling Magisk. Don't know it that's what you tried, but that's what I meant... :p

Great you got it working.
[Magisk] Shararti1:
OK right now no issue after few reboots if again it comes I will try ur method now
[Magisk] :
1. Don't Flash SuperSU On Top Of Magisk

2. Try Enabling Through Settings→Enable Root
[Magisk] Artim_96:
Don't flash superuser.zip, only Magisk!
[Magisk] Darkem:
I only flashed Magisk, because I don't want SuperSU.

Which settings? Magisk? There is no option "Enable Root"....

I only flashed Magisk, but I don't have root privileges.
[Magisk] :
1. What ROM ?

2. What Version of Magisk are You Flashing ?

3. If your ROM Is Pre Rooted with SuperSU Try Flashing This -

https://xdaforums.com/attachment.php?attachmentid=3931994&d=1478779893
[Magisk] Darkem:
1. Axon 7 Stock ROM - Bootloader unlocked

2. v12

3. The ROM isn't pre-rooted but I also already flashed this unSU.
[Magisk] rocky78:
check that is not disabled

p.s.

do you see that you are properly rooted in status'?
[Magisk] Darkem:
Magisk Manager says "rooted, but no root privileges. Was the root access denied?" (translated from german)

I don't have the Superuser Settings, because the Magisk Manager don't has root privileges.
[Magisk] :
Flash The Magisk12.zip Again and Try Disabling Built-in Busybox It Solved Most Of Issues Like This for Me afaik
[Magisk] Darkem:
Done but nothing changed.

I can't even enable busybox because I don't have those settings till I have root access.
[Magisk] :
• Have You Unlocked Your Bootloader ?

• Check This Out

https://xdaforums.com/axon-7/how-to/guide-installing-magisk-systemless-phhs-t3524270
[Magisk] jacklul:
On my Redmi 3S running xiaomi.eu ROM installing Magisk causes it to be stuck on boot or boot into OS without a lockscreen and SystemUI not launching. Device heats up a lot during this.

How to fix this?

It's weird because it used to work, one day after reboot it started this and I never figured it out why.

[MENTION=5103250]adewisman[/MENTION] I see you have a fix for SafetyNet for you device, any advice how to make it for mine? (when I get the Magisk working again...)
[Magisk] Darkem:
The bootloader is unlocked.

This guide is with SuperSU, but I don't want to install it with SuperSU. With SuperSU I have root, but it don't pass the SafetyNet check, Magisk is useless with SuperSU.
[Magisk] rocky78:
do a screen capture of your error and upload it.
[Magisk] Darkem:
Attached
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
That's very, VERY far from the thruth.

Magisk Hide doesn't function properly with SuperSU, but there's a whole lot more to Magisk than that...
[Magisk] Darkem:
Ok, but it is useless for me, because I only need Magisk Hide.
[Magisk] adewisman:
try the moded v11.6 that previously I shared (gdrive) .. if you still unable to pass safetynet try to edit the post-fs-data.sh in the module I attached on that post ...

find the line :

/magisk/data/resetprop ro.build.description "to-your-stable-miui-version"

/magisk/data/resetprop ro.build.fingerprint "to-your-stable-miui-version"

note: you can extract only that file using 7zip and edit it using any txt editor and put it back ... (choose the lowest opt to zip it/save)

ask your friend who uses the same phone with stable miui to provide you with the build prop string by executing this command on terminal emulator:

getprop | grep build >/sdcard/giveittome.txt

ask him/her to sent the giveittome.txt file you'll find the string you want on that txt. and then install the module ofc XD

hope you got it solved :svetius:
[Magisk] rocky78:
try:

reboot to recovery, flash latest uninstaller, reboot system.

reboot again to recovery and flash v12 again (download it again, and flash)
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Very different from your last statement...

You're not the first with this problem on an Axon 7. [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] is aware of the problem and there are open GitHub issues about it, like this one: https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/issues/157

I don't think there's much more you can do but wait for a possible fix in a future release. Edit: or try the version mentioned in that GitHub issue...
[Magisk] soder:
Sorry for not reading all the posts. I got a OP3T and a OPO. OP3T runs OxygenOS beta 5 with Franco v20 kernel and Magisk v12 with no problem.

But the OPO runs LineageOS 14.1 (build 10/4) r49 Franco (but the same happens when on stock kernel) and I often find that apps doesn't get root access.

Also, when checking with Magisk manager it sometimes tells I don't have root, but sometimes it tell me I got root, but apps doesn't got it..

What's up with that problem?

/Söder
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
That's a known issue with Lineage. Try disabling Magisk built-in busybox.

From the release thread's troubleshooting section:
[Magisk] teddy0209:
Yup, v12 or v13, i tried implementing the fix, but it didn't work... Lol...

Edit: with the moded 11.6, I need to disable systemless host to pass SN... Never had to disable anything on my m9... Was really a device/setup dependent...
[Magisk] jacklul:
Sadly seems like that modded version causes same bug happen - SystemUI not launching.

V12 seems to work stable but... Now in addition to CTS fail Integrity Check fails as well no matter if busybox/hosts are disabled.

Currently gonna try extract global stable rom to get the prop values.
[Magisk] adewisman:
yeah miui is wierd ... Im only can guest, its really hard to find the cause on magisk as it doesn't give any error message ... my guess is its how miui handle on its permissions, cant be sure until there's an evidence tho.

[MENTION=268073]top[/MENTION]jhonwu if you need some logs and provide how to take it, kindly let us know, will be happy to do it for you. keep up the good works :good:

I have never got system ui crashed with magisk, did you on any way have xposed installed or any other kind of mods or module installed before installing magisk ?

[MENTION=3615867]teddy0209[/MENTION] bro try to install yds flashable busybox installer ... miui busybox has lack of applets .. and toggle off magisk busybox.
[Magisk] jacklul:
Now it works and doesn't block SystemUI, weird. But still CTS and integrity fails... I guess only the prop trick is all that's left to try..

I literally have no idea, it just randomly started working while ~30 minutes ago it didn't.

And yeah, I'm using xposed Magisk module and few xposed modules. But I already tested it some time ago without having xposed and it's modules installed and it was still crashing.
[Magisk] teddy0209:
Yup, i have that busybox installer... I'm just waiting for my data to replenish, i need it to download the fastboot rom so i can switch to dev rom before moding my device further...
[Magisk] Darkem:
Thank you very much!! The version mentioned in the GitHub issue works like a charm!
[Magisk] Richard20000321:
Custom kernel and magisk, which should be installed first?
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
Custom kernel
[Magisk] Tesla:
1. Kernel.

2. Unroot if needed.

3. Magisk

4. Boot, install magisk app.

5. Should be done.
[Magisk] tag68:
Tesla, you forgot one.

0. Do Backup of boot-Partition

;)
[Magisk] sunny1119:
Hello, I had to uninstall magisk and my phone became laggy and started to hang, so i used magisk uninstaller and the phone is now stuck in bootloop between twrp and samsung logo as soon as it restarts it goes to twrp mode. Can anyone help me fix this? Thanks

I am on note 5, nougat.
[Magisk] Tesla:
See if it helps flashing stock Boot.img

AND... give us all the info about kernel, ROM and what you have modified.
[Magisk] sunny1119:
Not able to locate Boot.img from /data/stock_boot_<sha1>.img.gz . I dint back it up manually as magisk does it :/ . I checked it earlier to be sure and it was there. But I cant find it anymore from TWRP, is that cause root is lost? I am on stock kernel/ official Rom.
[Magisk] andrew2432:
You can search for your devices stock boot image, usually available somewhere out there
[Magisk] tdunham:
The note 5 will not boot with the stock kernel. It must be patched and that is part of the root process that you see displayed while Magisk is installing.

---------- Post added at 02:11 PM ---------- Previous post was at 02:09 PM ----------

As for the loss of TWRP, this is normal on a stock rom.

It has detected custom recovery and has restored stock recovery. If you want custom recovery back, it must be flashed again through Odin.
[Magisk] sunny1119:
what should I do to get it patched? I cant even find the stock img. Still stuck in twrp, tried clearing dalvik cache but no luck.

---------- Post added at 07:44 PM ---------- Previous post was at 07:43 PM ----------

I dont need root or custom recovery anymore, I am fine with stock recovery if i can get back.
[Magisk] tdunham:
You have to flash magisk zip again to patch the restored stock kernel. If you need to go back completely to stock, you should find the full stock tar for your device and become familiar with flashing it in Odin. The stock tarball also contains the stock boot.img file as well.
[Magisk] sunny1119:
Tried flashing Magisk again and now stuck in bootloop, cant enter twrp too :/

Edit: can Enter twrp but stuck at samsung logo now
[Magisk] yochananmarqos:
Magisk backs up the boot.img when installing and restores it when uninstalling. 'Course, backing up is always a good idea.
[Magisk] Som3guy:
Hey, I got the newest Dirty Unicorns 11.3 on my Nexus 6 running and flashed it together with Magisk 12. Everything worked fine at first but now I happen to lose root randomly. For example yesterday I did not have root in Magisk/TB/Kernel Auditor etc. and after a reboot it worked again. However, now I lost it again and a reboot won't help.

The Magisk Manager indicates that I have Magisk 12 installed but "Not rooted - Functionality greatly limited" and of course "SafetyNet Failed: CTS profile mismatch". The only things I did these days is play around with Substratum Themes but not really anything aside from that which touches the system.
[Magisk] Tesla:
This happens to some.

You can try an earlier version of Magisk or uninstall magisk, then reinstall it.

If that's not working then flash stock Boot.img then magisk again.
[Magisk] tdunham:
Alright, a really bizarre problem when fresh flashing a rom with Magisk integrated that I thought I would share that prevents the Magisk Manager app from validating and providing advanced features...

I like adding shortcuts to my stock Samsung Touchwiz Launcher for convenience sake so that shortcuts to certain apps appear on the desktop after fresh flashing my rom.

When Magisk is added to the default workspace xml in system/csc as a favorite (for the purpose of having a shortcut created automatically on the desktop), the manager app no longer recognizes root and just spins and spins on checking for updates. The phone is rooted and does provide root access to applications, however the management app just refuses to work.

I can add a shortcut to the launcher desktop AFTER rom install, just cant have one created during rom setup.

Another one of those things I suppose. ;)
[Magisk] Rush94:
Have a weird issue since day 1 at magisk v11 the systemless host automatically gets re toggle to off even i click several times on due to which the safetynet fails is anybody has any solution ?
[Magisk] Chillstice:
Hello, I don't know if this is the right place, but I have to ask at some point. I got stuck in a boot loop on my SM-G930V which was already rooted and had superSU installed. When I learned that Magisk Manager makes a backup of the boot-partition I thought to myself "Why not try it, there's always a way to get back". So now I'm stuck in a boot loop and I never restored a boot partition backup before. I don't really know where to start. Is it something I have to do in recovery mode connected to my computer using adb? What would the commands even be? Do I use the Magisk Uninstaller? Can I flash that from recovery? I really wish there was just a step-by-step I could follow in the OP for Magisk.

Edit: What's happening specifically is that after I let Magisk Manager run and reboot, I'm in a boot loop of a "Start Up Failed" blue screen with some small text in the top left that reads: "Custom binary blocked by Secure Boot (boot.img)" I've never seen this screen before.

Edit2: Now that I'm doing more research regarding this issue, I kind-of feel like an idiot for not having TWRP installed at this point. Can I install TWRP while the phone is currently in a boot loop? Should I try?

If you need any more information, don't hesitate to ask.
[Magisk] culiacanazo:
The uninstaller is how you restore your backup

Edit: ooppss just read your edit... Probably has to so with not unlocking something inside android but I'm just speculating at this point as my phone doesn't go thru this

And if you can go into download mode (Odin) you probably can install a tar of twrp but you won't have anything to restore, just something to flash, perhaps
[Magisk] Chillstice:
Thanks for the quick response. So just so I make sure I know what I'm doing: I go into recovery mode and flash the uninstaller using odin/adb something like that? My idea was to install TWRP to do something with the backup boot.img, but if it's specifically built for the uninstaller I'm going to aim for that instead. TWRP can wait until I'm up and running again.

Can you quickly help me understand how to properly run the uninstaller? In the meantime I will look for a guide if it already exists.
[Magisk] Tesla:
Magisk uninstaller here: https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/official-magisk-v7-universal-systemless-t3473445

Install a TWRP with odin.

Run uninstall magisk

Boot and come back here with result.

A good advice would be for you to find a Boot.img that you can flash in TWRP.

Check you phones forum for that.

There are som useful links in my sign.
[Magisk] culiacanazo:
I ran out of thanks, but thanks

---------- Post added at 10:05 PM ---------- Previous post was at 10:03 PM ----------

He (above me) already got to it quicker than me.

---------- Post added at 10:07 PM ---------- Previous post was at 10:05 PM ----------

So that secure boot thingie won't affect him/will let him reboot?
[Magisk] Chillstice:
We'll See when I get home and try it.
[Magisk] Chillstice:
I'm searching for the correct version of TWRP that I can flash using ODIN. I'm using the SM-G930V variant heroqltevzw with the Qualcomm processor. I can't seem to find the right file. I found this thread, but I'm not 100% convinced it will work on my model: https://xdaforums.com/galaxy-s7/samsung-galaxy-s7-roms-kernels-recoveries--other-development-snapdragon/recovery-official-twrp-galaxy-s7-t3458579

Is the SM-G930V the same as the Chinese SM-G9300?

Edit: Could I just flash the Uninstall Magisk zip through odin and install twrp via the app once I'm up and running?
[Magisk] teddy0209:
You need to ask in that in the s7 thread...

As for flashing uninstall zip with odin, not sure if that will work, twrp is recommended...
[Magisk] Chillstice:
Thanks for the reply. I asked on the thread and I'm going to try and wait for a confirmation on twrp. I would like to get this resolved tonight so if I don't get a confirmation I might try just flashing the uninstall zip using odin.
[Magisk] Tesla:
I don't think that will work. It's better to wait for TWRP.

But if you are hell bent on trying, i found this. http://itechify.com/2016/06/23/how-to-convert-kernel-zip-to-tar-md5-tool/

I'm in a hurry here so i just skimmed it over. Maybe it's relevant to you, maybe not. Read it carefully.

Good Luck m8.
[Magisk] Chillstice:
Alright, so I found the twrp file for the MS-G930V, but because the bootloader is locked: "It would flash but the phone would refuse to boot the recovery." Is the option of using twrp out?

---------- Post added at 07:26 PM ---------- Previous post was at 07:13 PM ----------

It looks like that method is meant for individual image files. It appears the uninstaller does not have any single image file within it. I cannot run the tool in this instance.

Should I consider flashing a stock boot.img? I don't think I modified mine unless a root tool automatically did.

---------- Post added at 07:53 PM ---------- Previous post was at 07:26 PM ----------

Alright so this has been a stressful 6 hours or so. I finally decided to give up on the uninstallation process for Magisk and just reflash the rooted boot.img file. It was successful and after rebooting I'm now in android again. Thanks for all the help even though I eventually got to my own solution. I'm going to figure out a way to make backups then try installing Magisk again, if it fails I will report what I can to make it better.
[Magisk] Wawax:
please i have a problem with magisk i'm bored the safetynet is apply when he want i must apply this every day before is apply automatically do you have a solution for the safetynet work automatically please.

i'am on Nexus 5X with latest pure nexus rom and ex kernel.

sorry for my bad english
[Magisk] :
Anyone having troubles installing on the lg v20 vs995 restock kernel
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
https://xdaforums.com/search/thread/3432382?query=lg v20
[Magisk] babis306:
Good morning, because I haven't time to read the 1000+ pages of the thread please can anybody help me?

I have the Xiaomi Redmi Pro and the latest dev rom have root with magisk, I want sometimes to hide the root but I can't do it with the switch of the magisk or the auto magisk. Previous I use the rootswitch but now that tell me it is not full compatible with magisk and has no effect.

Thanks in advance for your help and answers.
[Magisk] teddy0209:
Try the one posted a few pages back, page 1250 I think... Backup before doing so...
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
I think Xiaomi devices have had issues with Hide. You might have to start it manually (through terminal). Check here for instructions (post #4) and further troubleshooting tips:

https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/magisk-magisk-hide-troubleshooting-tips-t3561828
[Magisk] Wawax:
answer my question please i really need help
[Magisk] Tesla:
Revert to stock ROM. Problem solved.
[Magisk] Karls0:
Please rewrite it in understandable way. SafetyNet works automatically and you can't do anything to prevent it.
[Magisk] Wawax:
Cool...

---------- Post added at 12:10 PM ---------- Previous post was at 12:10 PM ----------

I don't understand
[Magisk] Mysterion1:
Hey guys,

I faced a weird issue...in Magisk I tried to install modules for the first time. When I select a manually downloaded zip module it says error during installation...The process actually stops when magisk manager tries to copy the zip to the magisk temp folder. When I select a module from the downloads tab, magisk manager crashes every time...

I have already reflashed the rom and wiped the cache. I'm using an HTC One M9 with Android 7.0.

Any ideas?

Edit: System is not checked as mounted in TWRP. Is this normal or might this be the problem? If I check system, it is automatically unchecked after a reboot.
[Magisk] medes22:
Sometimes you can try these method

Flash kernel

Flash unsu zip

Flash latest Magisk version

Always works for me this way
[Magisk] teddy0209:
Magisk is systemless so it's not related to system mounting... I don't face the same issue on my m9 running stock 6.0, haven't received the 7.0 update yet...
[Magisk] kyzn:
The feeling is mutual. We also can't understand you. If we can't understand you then we can't help.
[Magisk] teddy0209:
You have to rephrase your question, rewrite, change the wordings, make it understandable for us to be able to give you an answer...
[Magisk] sunny1119:
So I tried everything to get out of bootloop but nothing worked, eventually I just downloaded latest stock firmware for my phone and flashed it via odin, Back to normal now. Thanks to everyone that helped :)
[Magisk] Curious Boy:
Is there a way to toggle(disable/enable) root without go to magisk manager setting ? Like shell command or shortcut?
[Magisk] Tesla:
Great. With stock you are primed for Magisk :)
[Magisk] teddy0209:
[MENTION=5103250]adewisman[/MENTION], I'm now using v13 snapshot 0415 as the moded v11.6 causes system ui and theme manager to crash after few reboots or changing themes... I have to re-enable magiskhide every reboot using terminal though...