yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] IzunaHatsuse:
I have gone through those steps in both link you shared, still not working.

I have also went through my storage to delete any magisk named files related.

What I also have done is that, I uninstall magisk, phone is still unlock but FRP is locked, all other apps stay untouched. the Grab Driver app working fine.

But right after I install magisk, my grab driver app detect root again. With all magisk hide function, still detected.

* I install my magisk by patching "RECOVERY_RAMDIS.img" *

I tried termux to use UDSbypass, done it, "no daemon is currently running" try going in the grab app again, still detect root.
[Magisk] WANTES:
Pokemon GO dont hide on Magisk 19.3 and 19.4.

CatLog:
[Magisk] Wolfcity:
https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/discussion-pokemon-magisk-discussion-t3465722
[Magisk] mctiew:
I would like to customize a ROM with Magisk and Magisk Manager preinstalled. But I would like to preconfigure the setting so that it will hide root for a few applications and also do not prompt for granting root permission.

Is this possible ? Where are the configuration stored ?
[Magisk] Gotmilkman:
Any chance we can get magisk working on chromebooks?
[Magisk] dope77:
Open magisk manager, go to settings and enable magisk hide. Go back to the manager and open the drawer, you'll see magisk hide. Press on it and select the apps u want to hide root from.
[Magisk] mctiew:
That is not what I am asking. I want to have all these set up completely without user interaction, ie I want to include all these in the ROM image without any need for booting into the system and configure via user interaction.
[Magisk] Soul Spark:
Magisk Hide not working for StepSetGo 0.6.9

https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.pepkit.ssg

Is it working for any one else then please ping how to make it work.

Thankx.

If someone need logs please let me know.
[Magisk] guest4711:
Most of these settings are stored in /data/adb/magisk.db So setup your choices and include the db into your ROM.

But it is no good idea to include Magisk into a ROM. You'll make it hard(er) for your users to update Magisk...
[Magisk] jcmm11:
Config is stored in magisk.db but you may well run into issues because part of the settings include the uid for the apps which changes from install to install.

The other issue is that you should not install Magisk Manager in the system partition. You should also supply a non-rooted backup of the boot partition so Magisk can be removed if necessary.
[Magisk] TheArkive:
my pixel has been "pied" in the face

How many catlogs are preferred for posting issues? I'm afraid I've only managed to start a catlog once (recently) that manged to capture a crash/reboot. I've attached the one I have managed to capture so far. It's quite random. Still not sure if it's magisk.

Running Android 9, Pixel Dust on Pixel, TWRP v3.3.0-0, April 2019 bootloader.

EDIT: Also using Substratum Swift Black theme. I've tried removing all app themes and still get random crash/reboots.

I have all major magisk features disabled except MagiskSU. I usually seem to get issues when using a navigation app like OsmAnd or Google Maps, but it happens sometimes frequently when there seems to be no major activity or usage.

I have yet to try a config without magisk long term to check for any major stability difference.

Please let me know if I can do something specific and post results to help with troubleshooting.

EDIT2: I was just downloading updates map files for OsmAnd. I happened to notice the GUI crash and reset about 4 or 5 times in a row, and OsmAnd definitely crashed. I saw another user post about noticing several GUI crashes related to Google Maps. Maybe it's just the location provider (maybe interacting / coexisting with magisk??) as opposed to the actual map apps themselves?

EDIT3: My WiFi settings now forget the password used to connect to the last Wifi network. I noticed this behavior about 1 or 2 days ago. It's consistently forgetting after reboot.
[Magisk] andrew2432:
[MENTION=3519832]TheArkive[/MENTION]

I second all issues you just mentioned on my old version of magisk and the 19.3. Tried clearing cache and life is better momentarily. I also wonder if signal issues and hotspot connectivity problems are related, however I'm just as quick to blame good ol sprint. Ugh its been so long where is this log. I can also not get magisk manager to update and stick, it is constantly rolling back but that isn't new.

I am on pixel dust as well, older twrp and boot, man I gotta catch up
[Magisk] lm089:
No probs on my devices (2x old xperias running LineageOS 15.1 / 16.0, 1x Oneplus 6 running latest stock). On all of them I run Magisk 19.3 and make frequent use of TB both backing up and restoring
[Magisk] zgfg:
Try Magisk Canary v19.4 (19302).

Had that issue on Huawei P9 with EMUI 5.0.1, 'decrypton password/corrupted storage/must factory reset', now with 19302 resolved, booting again just fine:

https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/issues/1409

Encouraging the others with Huawei EMUI 5.x devices to try this new Canary Magisk

Edit: Today again even newer Canary Magisk v19.4 (19303) released (and Canary MM v7.3.3 (227)), all working fine
[Magisk] spbx123:
yeah I tried that but I lose it in hours instead of days when I had it and when I check the logs for the module nothing was written
[Magisk] Raygen:
Hey, just asking, is it normal that an app i've hidden with Magisk hide still prompt me for root permissions when started?

Magisk hide shouldn't hide root entirely from that app?
[Magisk] martyfender:
What app is it? Normally, one would hide an app that detects root and therefore doesn't work properly because of that, instead of hiding an actual root app.
[Magisk] wilsonhlacerda:
Some apps request root (and may expect an instantaneous deny) as part of their strategy to detect root. I myself have two local bank apps that do that for instance.
[Magisk] guest4711:
No, it's not normal. I hide root from my root checker app. If MagiskHide is working as it should the checker app does neither ask for root nor dors it detect root. If MagiskHide did not start, the checker app is asking for root.

tl;dr: If root is properly hidden, the app should not know how to ask for root...
[Magisk] sinchan_nohara:
How can i uninstall magsik 19.3 each time i try it bootloop my device :crying:

Device : moto g5 plus

Omni rom official

Magisk 19.3
[Magisk] garylawwd:
Flash the boot.IMG of your rom.

Extract your rom zip and you will find a file boot.img and just flash it.

Or flash uninstaller and then dirty flash your rom
[Magisk] Raygen:
Yup, it's a banking app.

But i was doing some tests later with a simple root testing app too, and that also does prompt me for root, even if it's should be hidden for that app in MagiskHide.

Well, then i think i've some problems with MagiskHide.

I've tried plenty of steps of the official Troubleshooting guide by Didgeridoohan, including:

- Restarting the phone (obv)

- Force stop and erasing data&cache of the apps detecting root

- Hiding some system and google apps in MagiskHide too

- Completely uninstall and reinstall Magisk and Magisk Manager

- Hiding the Magisk Manager by the built-in setting

- Switchin on and off the MagiskHide service

- Trying to enable the MagiskHide service by terminal with "magiskhide --enable"

- Checking for errors in the Magisk logs

- Running only Magisk Core mode

- Disabling USB debugging and Developer options

- Tried the Improved Hiding setting by MagiskHide Props Config module

- Checking for files or app installed that could recall the presence of root or magisk (i just have Titanium backup and SDmaid installed, and no comprimising files in the internal storage)

But still, every app i try to hide with MagiskHide, still prompt me for root when i test them.

Including that banking app that, even if i deny its root request immediately, it keeps detecting root.

The phone is a OnePlus One running LineageOS, with SafetyNet integrity resulting always true. So is not even a bloated rom of some sort that could interfere with Magisk or Root in general.

Any other tricks i can try?
[Magisk] martyfender:
You could try today's newly released Canary build 19303 and Magisk Manager 227.
[Magisk] jenslody:
Check whether the app is installed in adoptable/external storage, MagiskHide does not work if an app is not installed below /data/user_de/0 on proc_monitor start.
[Magisk] sinchan_nohara:
Okk thanks for the help. I will try that
[Magisk] Raygen:
Yeah, i could probably try the Beta and Canary versions as my last resort.

The Manager is normally present under /data/app/, /data/user/0/, and /data/user_de/0/. Nothing wrong here it seems
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Thanks for the reminder... I've added this to the list of tricks, together with the UDS bypass workaround.

Not the Magisk Manager. The app you're trying to hide from...
[Magisk] Raygen:
Oh, my bad. Yeah, they're both under /data/user_de/0 and other /data directories.

I wonder if creating a logcat of all the procedure (turn off and on magiskhide from settings, hide the app, and starting the app) would help finding something useful?
[Magisk] jenslody:
At least it's worth a try.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
And installing the Canary debug build and saving the Magisk log after trying to hide from an app might also show something.
[Magisk] GeorgieBoii:
Do not install latest canary on op7 pro

Magical Canary builds prevent the OnePlus 7 Pro from Warp Charging. I fixed this issue by returning to the stable builds and was instantly pulling 3200mA as opposed to the 1070mA prior.
[Magisk] KaMyKaSii:
Create a issue on Github and post a logcat + kernel log during boot (while using lastest Canary debug), you can do this through the Liveboot app
[Magisk] gazza35:
Hi Guys. So the last couple years ive been away from Android on IOS, i recently came back, with an S8+ and of course, things have altered a lot, there was no Magisk in my day, but i was a fan of Xposed. There was a mod on Xposed i used a lot, it allowed you to alter the homescreen size, realistically, it just added extra rows and colums to the home screen, rather than samsungs max of 5x6, i always used 6x6. I can never remember the name of it, but back then it was LP and MM it was for. CAN anyone tell me, if there is a similar mod avail for Magisk??, as doing research on the S8+ forum, there is not a lot of development of that nature, so im struggling to find a mod to suit, i know 3rd party launchers are avail like Nova, but im a fan of Samsungs TW and would rather stay with that. Any help please, greatly appreciated.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Magisk modules and Xposed modules do not work in the same way. The simple explanation is that Magisk injects files and Xposed injects code. For modifications like that Xposed is the way to go.

You could likely do such a modification with Magisk, but you would have to modify the launcher files manually and create a module from those files. So, not really practical...
[Magisk] tuvok1981de:
Hey Ho ..

i com from this Forum https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=79808630&postcount=1907

and i will write here for my Problems with my S4 GT-9506

Thank you first [MENTION=4667597]Didgeridoohan[/MENTION] for your patience with me

so is this possible to get a Kernal newer as 3.8 with https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHide#hn_Requirements

i can not found a Kernel on Forums with this Option and run with my LineageOS and this Device
[Magisk] JudgeDread11:
Many custom ROMs have a setting to change the screen size.

You can also do this by changing the LCD.Density in system/build.prop

And I do believe there are Magisk modules that can change build.prop values.

Or in worst case you make a copy of your build.prop, change the value and then create a Magisk module to load your edited file

Or you can just use an app like

https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.chornerman.easydpichanger

Or if you just want extra rows in your launcher you can use a alternate launcher, like Nova launcher.

https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.teslacoilsw.launcher
[Magisk] ashyx:
Don't.

[MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] specifically requests it not to be done.

Plus as said you will create issues

A rom should never come prerooted and devs need to stop doing this as it's unnecessary.
[Magisk] ventu87:
guys the latest version of magisk the 19303 causes problems with the warp charge of oneplus 7 pro !!! solve please !! with 1902 it goes perfect!

---------- Post added at 09:33 AM ---------- Previous post was at 09:32 AM ----------

guys the latest version of magisk the 19303 causes problems with the warp charge of oneplus 7 pro !!! solve please !! with 1902 it goes perfect!

---------- Post added at 09:33 AM ---------- Previous post was at 09:33 AM ----------

guys the latest version of magisk the 19303 causes problems with the warp charge of oneplus 7 pro !!! solve please !! with 1902 it goes perfect!

---------- Post added at 09:34 AM ---------- Previous post was at 09:33 AM ----------

guys the latest version of magisk the 19303 causes problems with the warp charge of oneplus 7 pro !!! solve please !! with 1902 it goes perfect!
[Magisk] dd721411:
What the hell you just did? Stop that repeating request! Just provide developers with error logs and go back to the last working version.
[Magisk] bafforosso:
I've had similar problems on my Pixel 3 on Android 9 when using navigation apps when UI would become really slow and unresponsive, then launcher and other apps would FC, MagiskHide would fail (having me reinstall all my work profile because it detected my phone was compromised) and all the way to soft reboots of the phone.

I have narrowed it down to the phone overheating : I have had this happen only in my car while using navigation (Google Maps, Waze,...), usually with Spotify in the background and often when phone was charging at the same time causing even more heating of the battery, and the issues would completely stop once I got an air vent car holder and turn the A/C on.

It may be a completely different issue though, but thought it might help some.
[Magisk] tuvok1981de:
Can anybody help me with my Problem for a newer Kernel for the Galaxy S4 GT-I9506
[Magisk] garylawwd:
Better ask in your device forums.

This is a magisk thread it has nothing got to do with what kernel you have.

Plus the guys that own your device would probably be the best to ask as they would more than likely know what you need to do
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
From the screenshot of the log you posted earlier I don't think that's your issue... You might have something else causing this.

Start by testing MagiskHide by adding a root app to the Hide list. If that app still detects root we know that it's MagiskHide that isn't working. Try toggling Hide off and on again in the Manager settings.

If root is successfully hidden for the app, there's something about your device that triggers SafetyNet. That could be modifications like Xposed, it could be the way your ROM is made, etc.

These tips, and more, can be found in the guide I've linked you previously.

---------- Post added at 13:13 ---------- Previous post was at 13:11 ----------

[MENTION=553601]ventu87[/MENTION] Don't do that.. It's extremely annoying and will more likely make people ignore you or try to trash you.

Here are some tips on how to do it properly:

https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHelp
[Magisk] ventu87:
sorry if I rewrite it but I don't know how to communicate with the developers ...guys the latest version of magisk the 19303 causes problems with the warp charge of oneplus 7 pro !!! solve please !! with 19302 it goes perfect!
[Magisk] garylawwd:
You do know the developer has a life other than making stuff just for you. He got a new internship with Apple.

He doesn't get paid for this its just a hobby for him so stop demanding a fix from him.

He will update when he is ready and has free time and not whenever you want him to.

Its not his job to do this.

Why don't you fix it?

Your asking for a fix also without providing any logs?

Where is this sense of entitlement that people have here coming from its disgusting
[Magisk] cnjax:
Then stay on 19302 problem solved
[Magisk] ventu87:
I don't know where to find the log if maybe you tell me you can be constructive don't always do the pundits we are all human beings
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Since you obviously missed it, I'll post this for you again:

https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHelp
[Magisk] garylawwd:
Exactly listen to your own advise, we are all human beings stop acting so entitled and demanding a fix.

Search XDA how to take logcats there are alot of tutorials.

If you can root your phone with magisk you have the knowledge to search the threads and take logcats.

Its a necessity to take logcats of your issues before reporting bugs.

Simply saying its broke and fix it is the reason devs leave the community.

Just research on how to take logcats and then report your issue.

Or like other people said, go back to the previous version
[Magisk] babakmaleki:
How I can root j260f with magisk, no twrp yet
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
https://topjohnwu.github.io/Magisk/
[Magisk] andrew2432:
Hey I can tell you don't speak English as a first language so let's attack your way of understanding...

[MENTION=553601]ventu87[/MENTION] use the help link that was provided by digeridoohan. Look for the log section: good instructions there.

Also, thank you for reporting! We now know the newest release doesn't work correctly with your device.

Your kernel is device specific. I believe the s4 has had mountnamespace back ported in many custom operating systems. To find out more about your kernel, search for your device and look around in there!

When reporting simple information, it is OK to just say it once! You let us know which version works with your device, and now its added to our collective knowledge.

If you need further assistance, try to grab a log with the methods provided. Also be as specific as possible with your issue. That way we can help the best we know how!
[Magisk] vandyman:
What language do you speak? Maybe someone can help you in a PM.
[Magisk] andrew2432:
Hey DM me anytime ;)

I was just trying to help the understanding gap

What ROM?

[MENTION=6162614]tuvok1981de[/MENTION] this was for you and not ventu sorry lol
[Magisk] xunholyx:
I think you should have quoted or mentioned [MENTION=553601]ventu87[/MENTION] here. He's the one with the issue and possible language barrier.

So I'll ask.
[MENTION=553601]ventu87[/MENTION] what language do you speak? Maybe someone can help you via PMs
[Magisk] vandyman:
The post I replied to has been edited.

I have replied to the whole post at the time it was submitted. As you can see in my post the quote was rhe only thing posted.

Thanks..
[Magisk] yuri76:
On s10 plus the latest build doesn't install even from twrp

Inviato dal mio SM-G975F utilizzando Tapatalk
[Magisk] Raygen:
Ok, i got updates:

I've uninstalled, and installed Magisk Canary (debug) 19.4-dd6e55ac (19303), with the Manager 7.3.3 (227). Plus hidden the Manager app, and runned every test only in Magisk Core mode just to be sure. Safety Net is still a go, and i've hidden some google system apps too in Magisk Hide. Rebooted and everything obv.

Still no luck. Both the banking app and the root testing app prompt me for root, even if checked in Magisk Hide. And in normal mode too (not Core).

I managed to get some logs tho:

I've tried to look them up by myself, but i don't really know how to read them.

Starting the root checking app and getting the root prompt while under Magisk Hide, deny the prompt (timer run out), root

not

detected from the app:

Magisk log (form /cache): https://drive.google.com/open?id=1eZQQik8CcdlSh0Yl1lrr8ihNcbVAl4GS

Logcat (taken with Catlog): https://drive.google.com/open?id=1FFnZKhshTqXETODFSUBHQCMcNLlGv7Ha

Starting the banking app and getting the root prompt while under Magisk Hide, deny the prompt (timer run out), root

detected

from the app:

Magisk log (form /cache): https://drive.google.com/open?id=1RUg8TdRHQSMKMWCaimIrlp6dOhDDKH6J

Logcat (taken with Catlog): https://drive.google.com/open?id=1Q20vMR0HDZoG9vI6VnTHod5lvdsw8G-e

The package name of the hidden Manager app is "com.c.tX09.w.mrl1s.o"

The package name of the root testing app is "com.joeykrim.rootcheck"

The package name of the banking app is "it.nexi.yap"

You tell me guys
[Magisk] wilsonhlacerda:
So you have an S4 with LOS. Which one? LOS14.1? LOS15? CM13? Did you get it from XDA section for your device? By chance is it one by user Side?

I myself have S4 Active (i9295) running LOS14.1 and Magisk v19.3 without any problems. My LOS is somewhat derived from regular S4 i9505 LOS code (that have some work, specially on Kernel, by user Side as far as I know), thus I don't believe you should have any problems with it.
[Magisk] typischandy:
Hello, I have a problem. I have rooted my Samsung Galaxy S2 T719 and have no internet access since then. Programs like Discord, PlayStore work without problems. With the browser or e.g. Youtube I do not have internet. There is no message "no internet", but nothing happens.

After calling a link from Discord, I also get no internet, although I see everything in Discord.

I did the following:

On the brand new tablet, I flashed this firmware: "T719XXU2BRF4_T719OXA2BRF1_DBT"

Then I installed TWRP Recovery for SM-T713 / 719/813/819, Qualcomm MSM8976.

In TWRP I deleted data (including mount and check data) as written in the instructions, then installed Magisk and "Boot Image Patch (No verity no encrypt)".

Did I do something wrong? I bought the tablet new because my old one has the same problem. Since the tablet is a bit older, I thought it was a problem of the tablet. Now I have the problem but also with the brand new tablet. I did the same with the old tablet.
[Magisk] andriy_:
Hide doesn't work with Oral-B app (it detects root somehow) even with latest beta under Android 8 (Samsung S8).
[Magisk] zgfg:
I don't understand why (for your tablet/ROM?) you had to 'delete data'

And if you really deleted Data, maybe you deleted some WiFi configuration settings that were stored on Data partition...

Anyway, since you had TWRP, you had to make a full Nandroid backup (all partitons), and then when you found that things did not work, you just needed to restore - you would not have root but would have afain your working tablet

Btw, you can still get rid of Magisk (and this is perpetual question/answer repeating over and over in this thread, apparently new users do not bother to read/search old posts to get informed in advance), just by flashing the original, no-patched Boot image

You had to make its backup - if you didn't, you have to search on the subforum for your tablet how or where to obtain the original, not-patched image of the Boot partition

Btw, your tablet boots - did you scroll down in the Magisk Manager and take Uninstall Magisk?

If everything ok, that should clean-up the Magisk patch (root) from your Boot partition

However, if you really deleted the original Data (and if that caused your problems), then you can only restore it if you made its backup in TWRP

Or, you will need to flash your complete firmware ( again, seek for details on the subforum for your tablet)

Once you restore/reinstall the original (and fully working) firmware, you can retry patching Magisk by testing some older versions, without 'deleting data' , with Verity but without Encryption, or with both, etc - if not working well, you simply restore the fully working, not-rooted formware from TWRP and try another combination :)
[Magisk] jhford:
I followed all your suggestions, but no one has responded. Thanks for your help.
[Magisk] Hemuli:
A toothbrush app which needs magisk hide? Color me in disbelief.

Did you also try renaming magisk manager from the option in its settings?
[Magisk] wilsonhlacerda:
And also asks for location among lots of other permissions..... And app is barely 100MB. ?
[Magisk] RandomPooka:
Maybe it needs to know precisely which tooth you're brushing to adjust to the optimal speed and intensity?
[Magisk] joluke:
Most likely someone saw the logs and they are fixing the bug in a new upcoming version :)

Stay positive