yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] heslo.rb26:
You don't. V7 has removed this functionality but it seems our dev has re-added root hiding as of a little while ago. Not sure if he's released this version yet as I'm still on V6 :)

See here... http://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=68974895&postcount=3939
[Magisk] zgfg:
For the beginning, you can prepare and easily but manually install your myXYZ to /data/adb/modules/myXYZ to let it show in Magisk Manager as an installed module.

With that you can disable/enanble and uninstall your myXYZ module through the Magisk Manager

Once you have it working with all the systemless changes you needed to the /system, /vendor, etc partitions, you can pack it to the zip file and add install.sh, README.md and so to 'upgrade' to the flashable zip file for your module installation (and submit to Magidk repo)

Eg, suppose that you need to replace some stock XYZ.apk application from /system/priv-app/XYZ with your custom XYZ.apk.

You also want to rename the original XYZ.apk to XYZ.bak

Unzip the attached myXYZ.zip template and manually copy the unzipped myXPZ folder to /data/adb/modules - see the screenshot.

Edit the textual BuildProp file - put your 'module' version, description, etc, there

Make changes to the system subolder. Instead of priv-app/XYZ, make your path structure and include your files you wanted to add/overwrite to the /system partition.

If you need to remove some file from /system, include an empty file with the same name to your system subfolder structure

If you need additional changes also to /vendor partition, include the similar vendor subfolder to your /data/adb/modules/myXYZ

For the complete structure of /data/adb/modules/myXYZ see instructions:

https://topjohnwu.github.io/Magisk/guides.html

Reboot and open Magisk Manager - under the Modules tab you will find your myXYZ module as installed - see the second screenshot
[Magisk] physwizz:
Thank you very much for the detailed answer but I am able to make changes to /system using TWRP file manager.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
No. You'll have to mount /system rw yourself (if possible).
[Magisk] zgfg:
Fllashable zip module example for systemless changes to System partition

Following to the previous post.

Here comes a minimal myXPZ-1.0.zip file that can be flashed as a module in Magisk Manager and that makes changes to /system/priv-app/XYZ as described in the previous post

Unzip, adapt system subfolder, add vendor subfolder (if needed), all as described above

Edit textual files BuildProp and README.md and archive back to the zip file

Ready for flashing in Magisk Manager, Modules tab, Install from Storage, as your simple Magisk module that makes systemless changes to the /system (/vendor, etc) partition(s)
[Magisk] JudgeDread11:
That screenshot is from the dual boot twrp, which has magisk included.

So the new release is not a new twrp it's a new dual boot script with a newer magisk version included.

Twrp it's still the same version.

---------- Post added at 08:09 PM ---------- Previous post was at 08:05 PM ----------

There is no newer version of twrp made for magisk 20.4.

See above.

I would suggest take your stock boot image and start from scratch.
[Magisk] physwizz:
Thanks

---------- Post added at 09:31 PM ---------- Previous post was at 08:55 PM ----------

Thanks
[Magisk] DiamondJohn:
Just to clarify, rooting allows you to mount system as RW, where non-root, system would only be mounted as RO for you.
[Magisk] physwizz:
My a20 is rooted and system is ro from the Rom but is rw from TWRP.
[Magisk] DiamondJohn:
I was speaking directly about the ROM. TWRP is a different world, and whether the ROM is rooted or not is irrelevant.
[Magisk] Mahz4130:
I ghk
[Magisk] neroes:
Hello, how can I deactivate a module via twrp? I'm in a boot loop. Magisk v.20.4

Can somebody help me please
[Magisk] JudgeDread11:
You have to create a empty file with the name 'disable' in the module folder (data/adb/modules/)

---------- Post added at 10:04 AM ---------- Previous post was at 10:01 AM ----------

Even rooted in Android 10 on many devices it is not possible to mount the system partition as rw.

Therefore it's only possible to make systemless modifications.
[Magisk] neroes:
data/adb/modules/ right here or in this one : data/adb/modules/EsModMi9 ?

thx
[Magisk] zgfg:
Inside the module folder create an empty file "disable"

Or delete the whole folder for that module

Better first option, then from Magisk Manager uninstall the module
[Magisk] neroes:
Perfect, it worked that way THX
[Magisk] Swierk:
I am in a need of Magisk or Xposed module to remap bluetooth keyboard keys. Anyone recommend something?

Sent from OnePlus 7 Pro, OxygenOS 10.0.3, TWRP 3.3.1-75, Magisk 20.4, TaiChi Xposed 6.1.8, Modded Play Store 16.5.15, android core.java patched and SafetyNet pass OK
[Magisk] luvcustom:
Has anyone experienced installing ainur sauron and instead magisk installs narsil instead. I think this is a bug of some sort.
[Magisk] mobile.legand.acx:
Magisk hide not pass native root checker

Magisk hide dont pass native root checker ,only pass root checker ,rootbeer can sameone give me guide to pass i
[Magisk] chris1892006:
If i donated can you allow the app to support 2.3.5? I have no access to a computer and badly need to update my 2.3.5 rooted yp-g70 Samsung Galaxy Player 5.0. Thanks
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
That sounds like a module issue the needs to be raised with the module creator, not here.

That looks like a false positive to me. It's an old app, and RootBeer passes all checks... I would ignore that app.

That's not how things work.
[Magisk] mobile.legand.acx:
Than mean is false alarm ,oke sir thankyou for answer i realy appreciate
[Magisk] Atrate:
Is it possible to replace files in /firmware and /persist, /persist-lg?
[Magisk] anuajayan:
Hai i tried to install edxposed and uninstalled it.. Now in magisk safetynet is showing false. How to rectify this?

I'm using oneplus 6 stable os 10.3.2
[Magisk] dbroer91884:
This is probably a ridiculous question but I'm struggling mightily with this. I am attempting to find the flashable zip for the latest version of Magisk for my pixel 2 XL and I can't find it. I have no idea where I need to go. I stumbled upon this website magisk.me but can't find if it's an official website and on top of that it has version 20.4 but the announcement thread doesn't seem to go that high.

Is that website legit and if not where do I download the correct files?

---------- Post added at 09:49 AM ---------- Previous post was at 09:49 AM ----------

This is probably a ridiculous question but I'm struggling mightily with this. I am attempting to find the flashable zip for the latest version of Magisk for my pixel 2 XL and I can't find it. I have no idea where I need to go. I stumbled upon this website magisk.me but can't find if it's an official website and on top of that it has version 20.4 but the announcement thread doesn't seem to go that high.

Is that website legit and if not where do I download the correct files?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Magisk can replace files in /system, /vendor and /product.

https://didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHide#hn_SafetyNet

If you look at the top of the Magisk forum you'll find this thread, that tells you that you'll find everything you need on GitHub.

Downloading from anywhere else is fraught with peril since you can't really be sure what you are actually downloading...
[Magisk] dbroer91884:
thank you so much for your help. I do appreciate it. And I also know that you shouldn't download from any other website because of the dangers that poses which is why I even though that one website looked super legit I kept digging and digging to see if I could find the correct place.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
You've got great instincts. Most people don't seem to think along those lines... :good:
[Magisk] chris1892006:
Can someone mod the apk to work on 2.3.5 so i can flash twrp on my rooted Samsung Galaxy Player 5.0 yp-g70? I dont have a computer.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
It is very unclear what you're actually asking.

Are you asking for someone to make Magisk work on Android 2.3.5? If so that is extremely unlikely to happen (as in: it's impossible). [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] worked miracles to make Magisk work (albeit only the basics) on Android 4.2. That's as far back as it'll go...

But, you say you already have root, and that you want to flash TWRP. Why do you believe Magisk can help you with that?
[Magisk] chris1892006:
I watched people flash twrp using magisk manager on YouTube.

I have twrp 2.8.0.0 .zip how do i flash it?
[Magisk] RandomPooka:
You could use a kernel manager app, but I recommend not doing anything until you've gone over the procedure many times, fully understand it, understand what could go wrong during the process, and have all the tools already available to fix your brick if you mess up.

Since you don't have a PC, I would just say to NOT do this at all. Every method that comes to mind for recovering a botched flash requires a PC.

---------- Post added at 03:11 AM ---------- Previous post was at 03:09 AM ----------

You're asking for trouble if you do something that you have no way to fix, if it goes wrong.

Judging by the obvious uncertainty in your questions, it's very likely that something will go wrong. And you will have no way to fix it.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
The Magisk Manager is not for flashing general zips. I don't know what videos you've been watching, but they don't seem entirely trustworthy.

As already stated, you would be better off using something like Franco Kernel Manager (not sure if that has support for Gingerbread either though). You might be creating more hassle for yourself than it's worth though, especially if you want to try doing this without a computer.

This is getting off topic though, so try to keep the discussion in your device's forum or in General Q&A. You could even tag me in one of your posts if you want to and I might be able to give a few more tips.
[Magisk] Philnicolls89:
Are other people failing safety net today? Any info out there on why? Is it something else Google has changed server side, or more apps now triggering safety net fail??

*edit* I'm also failing basic integrity check
[Magisk] J.Michael:
I think if you're running a version of Android that was built for system-as-root, the Android itself is liable to complain if you forcibly mount /system rw. Similarly, you can use another system, like TWRP, to modify the /system partition, but you might run afoul of integrity checks. The so-called "systemless" approach offers the possibility of making changes that are in effect while Magisk is active, but that can be removed completely by booting without Magisk active.

So you probably *can* do what you say you want to do, but it's likely to cause you more problems than it solves.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Have you made sure that Hide is on (and toggled it off and on again if it is)? If it is on it's likely that you have some module that's causing issues (known ones are Safetypatcher, FDE.AI and EdXposed versons before 4.6.3, there may be others).

https://didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHide#hn_Check_your_modules_and_mods
[Magisk] Shished:
Yesterday safety net checks passed on my phone. today I tried to install edxposed canary to test if it will pass and lboth checks failed. After that I uninstalled riru and edxposed and it still fails both checks. I see other people also having problems with it today so it might be a coincidence. I'm using Poco f1 with official LOS 17.1 and props module.
[Magisk] Soumy1234:
Maybe it's some other module/mod? Try enabling core only mode in Magisk and see if SN passes after that. If it does, enable a couple of modules at a time to see which one(s) cause the issue.
[Magisk] Shished:
I have BusyBox by osmosis, magisk hide props module and systemless hosts module installed. They should not trigger fail of both checks.

I also tried to clean cache and dalvik, didn't helped.
[Magisk] Philnicolls89:
I have toggled magisk hide on and off, enabled core only mode and still I do not pass basic integrity check. Which is weird because I have not changed 1 single thing in my rom since a few days ago when it passed safety net, no new apps, modules etc. That's why I thought it must have been something to do with Google:confused:

*edit* I also do not have riru core, edexposed, lucky patcher or any such modules that are known to cause issues lately.
[Magisk] supermax:
I have same problem today.

i try to uninstall magisk but the problem is still there.

I suppose google changend theyr check but is too restrictive and it fails even if nothing strange is installed

i have a xiaomi cc9 and xiaomi.eu rom
[Magisk] gahu777:
same issue, today magisk suddenly fail safetynet :( note 9
[Magisk] johnnyman25:
I have same problem with mine oneplus 7 pro with latest 10.0.5 rom and magisk 20.4.

Safety net doesn't pass...
[Magisk] zgfg:
Xiaomi Mi 9T stock QFJEUXM 11.0.4 (Android Q)

and Huawei P9 stock Oreo,

SafetyNet passing with no issues with the following modules:

Systemless hosts,

BusyBox NDK,

YouTube Vanced,

Viper4Android on Xiaomi, i.e JanesDSP on Huawri

Since stock ROMs, I don't use Magisk Hide Props Config

Edit: Test with the attached SafetyNet checker to see exactly which component is failing (do not let the checker auto-update from Playstore to the paid version)
[Magisk] johnnyman25:
I have same problem on my oneplus 7 pro!

U still have same issue?
[Magisk] Shished:
Yeah, both checks are failing.
[Magisk] johnnyman25:
PFff same here...have tried every possible solution...U think its edxposed fault?
[Magisk] Shished:
I don't think it's edxposed fault because I installed version from magisk repo 2 days ago to install vanced and then uninstalled it and safety net checks passed after that. I will try to wipe data and see if it will help.
[Magisk] johnnyman25:
ok my friend waiting for your response here!
[Magisk] supermax:
Done

fails in

...

APK package name match

....

Signing sertificate match

CTS profile match

Basic Integrity
[Magisk] pndwal:
Just wondering, do all you people with basicIntegrity fail all have Xposed in some form?

(Just checked my MiPad4 -originally Chinese ROM, never was certified, but never used Xposed- and SafetyNet is still fully passing.) PW
[Magisk] TheHolyCity:
Yesterday safetynet passed, today it fails even with no modules installed
[Magisk] johnnyman25:
Same for me...You had edexposed installed too?
[Magisk] TheHolyCity:
I fail the exact same ones with no modules installed just base magisk
[Magisk] pndwal:
Do you have any XPosed framework? Ever had previously? PW
[Magisk] supermax:
yes,

I tried it a week ago. but i deleted everything..

maybe something was non deleted properly?
[Magisk] TheHolyCity:
I have had it installed before yes, but it fails even with it not installed. I passed safetynet fine literally hours ago and now I don't.
[Magisk] johnnyman25:
Did you removed modules,edxposed manager then flashed edxposed unistaller via twrp?
[Magisk] supermax:
no....

i didn't know it

i removed edxposed modules with magisk ( android 10) and then removed magisk with twrp

and then reinstalled xiaomi.eu rom
[Magisk] tech_head:
Nope. My phone now also fails with no modules and core only. They this started yesterday and it looks like Google had continued to flip switches on server side authentication.
[Magisk] h2aroon:
Working trick for me

1. Hide magisk manager

2. Hide metrash2 in magisk hide

3. Delete twrp folder, if you have backup inside move to PC or maybe renaming folder will also work

4. Give every permission to metrash2 app from settings.

Even though you done this steps you will get error.

For me opening metrash2 3rd time works without any error.

Try this and report if its working for you.
[Magisk] namAehT:
Oneplus 7 Pro here.

Basic integrity started failing last week, worked after I removed EdXposed until today. Uninstalled Magisk and still failing, right now I only have TWRP and an unlocked bootloader. Funny thing is, my banking app (which has always been sensitive to safetynet and rooting) still works, but Google Pay doesn't.

I wish Google would stop removing features from rooted phones in the name of security.
[Magisk] johnnyman25:
7 pro user here too same problem.

So it's not edxposed problem but Google side?

Oneplus 7 Pro Is Rocket Fast
[Magisk] Mahz4130:
[QUOTE=hear
[Magisk] supermax:
that is my opinion after a lot of tests
[Magisk] johnnyman25:
So we wait now maybe for new magisk?

I'm thinking to clean install and start from scratch but I have to move 150gb files to pc and6im bored af.....

Oneplus 7 Pro Is Rocket Fast
[Magisk] tech_head:
Would anyone here own a laptop or desktop where they can't be the administrator? I wouldn't.

Why would I do that on a handheld computer?
[Magisk] namAehT:
Hell, all I really use root for anymore is random UI tweaks and TWRP.
[Magisk] tech_head:
I like the performance of a custom kernel.

I also like Titanium Backup.

There is no real way to backup devices without root.
[Magisk] zgfg:
You don't need Magisk/root to install TWRP (on most devices it is flashed directly from Fastboot) - hence unlocking Bootloader (as needed both for TWRP or Magisk) does not equal to rooting
[Magisk] Soumy1234:
Then maybe it's your ROM? Try dirty flashing it. If that doesn't work, I think you'll have to resort to a factory reset.
[Magisk] namAehT:
I forgot that Titanium needs root, I've just always had it on my phones lol

I'm aware, but just having the bootloader unlocked seems to be tripping Safety Net which I hope isn't the case. Uninstalling Magisk and Xposed doesn't pass Safety Net even though it used to pass with them installed just a few days ago.
[Magisk] johnnyman25:
Guys u read this??

https://twitter.com/topjohnwu/status/1237656703929180160?s=19

The weird is the tweet was from 12 March and safety started to failed today...

Oneplus 7 Pro Is Rocket Fast
[Magisk] zgfg:
It was a month ago and at that time it was massively commented here - at that time, during one weekend, Google enforced checking if Bootloader was unlocked and SafetyNet was failing for everybody, but after the weekend Google returned to 'normal'

Now, it's not that case. Running e.g. on my side two different phones with ofc unlocked Bootloader and Magisk, on both SafetyNet is still passing perfectly

However, I never played with Riru and XPosed. Also both phones have stock firmwares hence I don't need Magisk Hide Props Config and fake fingerprint device - IMO for those to whom it fails now is probably about the fake device fingerprint or about some modules
[Magisk] johnnyman25:
The only way to fix it is to flash again the rom from scratch?

You recommend me to do that?

Oneplus 7 Pro Is Rocket Fast
[Magisk] zgfg:
Sorry, not recommending anything

Hopefully, if people to whom it fails would give more info (not just failing, help, fullstop) and if more people would become affected, it would be possible to conclude the cause.

E.g., ten days ago SafetyPatch was discovered as a culprit..
[Magisk] Shished:
Hey, I'm back!

So, I wiped data and restored apps from the cloud and now phone does not fails basicintegrity. I installed MagiskHide Props config and busybox, now SafetyNet fully passes.
[Magisk] chris1892006:
Thank you
[Magisk] johnnyman25:
Wipe data you mean factory reset eh?

Good to hear it worked!!!

Oneplus 7 Pro Is Rocket Fast
[Magisk] Shished:
Yes, I did it from TWRP.
[Magisk] johnnyman25:
wipe data or format?

Oneplus 7 Pro Is Rocket Fast
[Magisk] Shished:
Wipe /data (without /data/media)

Not full /data partition formatting.
[Magisk] johnnyman25:
This wipe all my friend?

Photos, all apps etc?

Oneplus 7 Pro Is Rocket Fast
[Magisk] tech_head:
Just having BL unlocked has tripped SafetyNet for quite a while.

A few custom kernels hide the BL unlocked flag. ElementalX is one that hides the status.

Pay stopped working for me this morning after SafetyNet checks started failing.

I have a Samsung Active2 watch so I activated Samsung Pay on the watch since it doesn't care about the device status it's paired to.

Unlike WearOS that wants the connected device to pass SafetyNet.

So I'll just use Samsung Pay on my watch and move on.

I'm keeping Magisk on the phone.

---------- Post added at 12:05 PM ---------- Previous post was at 12:04 PM ----------

No, do not wipe media, etc.
[Magisk] king.com:
This morning Pay stopped working for me too. SafetyNet for me is green. Having Riru and EdXopsed last canary with HiddenCore Module and all the suggestions hiding modules and blacklisting apps to detect EdXposed and Magisk.

The only thing that appears to fail is GPay
[Magisk] johnnyman25:
Guys just wiped google play services data and play store data and now safetynet passes!!!!!!
[Magisk] namAehT:
I'll gladly give more info, what info should I give?

I've had it unlocked since I got the phone and it has never failed SafetyNet. I'll try ElementalX and see if that fixes basic integrity for me.

I also tried HiddenCore and as far as I can tell it does nothing except keep my screen on and make SafetyNet give false positives. Apps that rely on SafetyNet (like Pay and my banking app) still won't work.
[Magisk] king.com:
Making some tests last week when I noticed this error for first time, I did those cleans and seemed to be fine, but when trying to pay I got the same error, so now that you are "clean", try to pay. I think you will get the first error, and then you will see the permanent button to "check software" inside Gpay.

Please, try to use GPay if you can.
[Magisk] johnnyman25:
Gpay its not supported on my country.

I live in greece!
[Magisk] sinho_robo:
Do I need the Magisk uninstaller and haven't found it on github?
[Magisk] pndwal:
https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/releases Look under 'assets'. PW
[Magisk] brandon5491:
This did it for me... Thank you!
[Magisk] johnnyman25:
Glad this worked for you!!!

Enjoy my friend!!

Oneplus 7 Pro Is Rocket Fast
[Magisk] Jinzuken:
WELP it worked for me thanks bro wtf haha
[Magisk] Cancambo:
Worked for me also. I had been looking for a solution for the past few days that didn't require me to factory reset and relock the bootloader.

Ever since EdXposed got detected I was unable to pass SafetyNet with any configuration of Magisk Modules, using Magisk core only mode, toggling Magisk Hide, etc.

My only problem now is that if I reinstall any version of EdXposed (including the canary build that passes SN) the modules won't load even though the framework reports being loaded. But that isn't a Magisk/SN problem.
[Magisk] dr4go:
Thanks for that, minor thing, which did the trick on my side: I just needed to clear the cache of the play services - nothing else was needed.
[Magisk] JudgeDread11:
Everytime Google makes a change to safety net this thread gets flooded with magisk unrelated messages.

(Topjohnwu has given up on safety net so, yes it's unrelated to magisk)

While it has a connection, this is not a safety net thread.

Would it be possible to create a safety net thread where safety net issues and how to solve then can be discussed?
[Magisk] RandomPooka:
I'm pretty sure that exists already
[Magisk] UselessShane:
Help me i installed nfs module but its not working

They stated that something unsual is there in magisk log
[Magisk] xDark_:
nope. never had it installed on my OPO running TugaPower Nougat, but it started failing a couple weeks ago for seemingly no reason. tried MagiskHide Props Config and reinstalling Magisk/Manager, but that doesn’t help.
[Magisk] johnnyman25:
Try my solution above.

Wipe data from play services and play store then reboot

Oneplus 7 Pro Is Rocket Fast
[Magisk] xDark_:
didn’t work unfortunately. MagiskHide is working fine (RootBeer doesn’t detect my device is rooted when i enabled it for RB). also tried Core mode in Magisk Manager, but i still fail basicIntegrity and ctsProfile.
[Magisk] johnnyman25:
U must have edxposed unistalled for this to work!

Also magisk hide enabled on magisk 20.4

Oneplus 7 Pro Is Rocket Fast