[Magisk] Frost90:
ING Homebank

Hello,

The latest version of RO ING Homebank version 4.1.9 from 24 Sep 2020 detects root even with Magisk Hide. It didn't detect for version 6.16 from 08 May 2020

Phone: Xiaomi Mi9

Custom ROM: Revolution OS 9.6.23 (MIUI 10.5)

Android: 9

Kernel(stock) version: 4.14.83-perf-g384ad38

Root: Magisk

Magisk: 20.4

Canary: 21001

I have followed all steps from here before posting. Here are my comments on the steps posted there:

TEST MAGISKHIDE - Tested, RootBeer passes

THE HIDE LIST - DONE

HIDE THE MANAGER - DONE

THE BASICS

Requirements

•	Enabled MagiskHide (from Magisk v20.4 it is disabled by default). - DONE

•	A Linux kernel version of at least version 3.8 - KERNEL 4.14

Magisk can not hide

•	Other known root apps (see "Detecting apps requiring root"). Apps used with root: AdAway(tried with hide on), MatLog(installed after root issue encounter), MiXplorer, Servicely(installed after root issue encounter), Substratum(module disabled), Termux(installed after root issue encounter).

•	Remnants of previous root method, including any root management apps (a good way to remove most remnants of root is osm0sis unSU script). Only used Magisk

•	Files and folders on your device (TWRP, Titanium Backup, etc, see Files on the internal storage). No Titanium, TWRP folders exist but tested with Storage Isolation and didn't work

•	Unlocked bootloader on devices using hardware based key attestation (see Unlocked bootloader). – Safety net check passed with Props config module

•	A tripped Samsung Knox counter. – Phone is Xiaomi Mi9

•	Xposed (deactivate it or uninstall). –Never had it

•	EdXposed. Detection of EdXposed can sometimes be worked around with newer release of EdXposed and/or features like the EdXposed Manager blacklist. –Never had it

•	USB/ADB Debugging (disable under Developer options in Android settings). - DISABLED

•	Developer options. - DISABLED

•	Some Magisk modules - Depending on what the module does, it may not be able to be hidden by MagiskHide. – Disabled all but Props config which is needed to pass Safety check - CHECK

•	Some modifications to /system. Make sure to use Magisk modules so that any modifcations you do are systemless... – Can’t think of any modifications

•	Also make sure that your device conforms with the basics for MagiskHide to work and take a look at what Magisk can and cannot hide (also see "Basics"). – It hides RootBeer

PASSING SAFETYNET – YES WITH PROPS CONFIG MODULE

UNLOCKED BOOTLOADER – SAFETY NET CHECK PASSED WITH PROPS CONFIG MODULE

UPDATE – USING LATEST MAGISK VERSION to date of posting

CANARY BUILD – Tested (Magisk Canary build 21001, Manager build 303)

CLEAR DATA - Always cleared data when retrying

ISOLATED PROCESS – DISABLED ALL

OTHER ROOT APPS – NO TITANIUM, XPOSED – APPS WHICH USE ROOT ARE MENTIONED ABOVE AND WERE ELIMINATED FROM THE SUSPECT LIST

FILE ON THE INTERNAL STORAGE

•	Another popular variant of root detection is that the app looks through your internal storage and triggers if it finds any files or folders that may hint at you having a rooted device (Titanium backup, TWRP, Magisk zips, etc). You can either delete or rename these files and folders, or use a Work Profile app or isolation app to get around this issue (see "Isolation apps" below). - No success with Storage Isolation

ADOPTABLE/EXTERNAL STORAGE – INTERNAL STORAGE ONLY ON XIAOMI MI9

MAGISK MODULES – ALL MODULES DISABLED EXCEPT PROPS CONFIG

DEPENDENCIES – HID PHONE APP

OLD ROOT – ROOTED WITH MAGISK ONLY

EXTERNAL CONNECTION – ROOT DETECTED WITHOUT INTERNET CONNECTIOM

UPDATE ANDROID – USING ANDROID 9

UDS DETECTION – LATEST VERSION OF MAGISK

PROCFS LEAKS – USING ANDROID 9

PROP VALUES – WHERE CAND I FIND A LIST OF PROPS TO SEARCH FOR?

BLACKLIST – NOT THE CASE, OLDER VERSION OF THE APP WORKS

OTHER STUFF – TRIED, SAME OUTCOME

Hiding the Magisk Manager - Same outcome

Unhiding the Magisk Manager – Same outcome

Can't hide the Magisk Manager – Not the case

Isolation apps – Tried with Storage Isolation, Same outcome

USB/ADB debugging - DISABLED

OEM Unlocking - DISABLED

Developer options - DISABLED

Samsung Knox – N/A, using Xiaomi Mi9

Xposed/EdXposed and root hiding modules – Last resort, didn't try yet since I understand Xposed can't be hidden from root with MagiskHide

I can upload the ING Homebank apk somwehere if needed.

I have attached the Magisk log and catlog. Please let me know if I should provide any other info.

Thanks!