yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] stevezlk:
Thanks, unfortunately it didn't make any difference...

Just to be on the same side: saying "processes in MagiskHide list" you mean the MH settings in the props menu, right? Therefore the MHPC module needs to stay enabled till that step. Or am I misunderstand sth?

I installed USNF v1.2 via Magisk, not via sideload, could that make a difference?

@pndwal that was exactly my setup, correct
[Magisk] pndwal:
No, MagiskHide list in Magisk App; Click shield symbol in floating menu, then MagiskHide at top.

This was really just in case you had fiddled with these.

You can keep this enabled; only fingerprint should be configured.

I just meant you have to Install from storage since it's not it the repo.

Please say resulting basicIntegrity, ctsProfile and evalType. PW
[Magisk] stevezlk:
Ok, so I guess my steps were correct, anyways

Result = identically to before:

basicIntegrity: OK

CTS Profile: NOK

Eval type: Basic
[Magisk] pndwal:
So could be ROM issue.

This user had same issue with Pixel Experience / Poco F3

https://xdaforums.com/t/magisk-module-universal-safetynet-fix-1-1-0.4217823/post-85148269

No idea if he solved it

Working w/ MIUI here

https://xdaforums.com/t/magisk-module-universal-safetynet-fix-1-1-0.4217823/post-85413465 PW
[Magisk] rezpower:
Can someone please tell me how to (remove/disable/cancel) Systemless hosts in Magisk?

In the Magisk app you have an option : Systemless hosts and when clicking on it Magisk gives you this message:

"Added systemless Host module". But there is no way to undo this and remove it!
[Magisk] pndwal:
Clue is in the name!

Remove it from Modules; puzzle-piece icon in floating menu (bottom of home screen). 😉 PW
[Magisk] pndwal:
Further, have you tried official PE ROM, or only unofficial?

https://xdaforums.com/t/rom-11-alioth-aliothin-pixel-experience-official-aosp.4323569/ PW
[Magisk] stevezlk:
ah, I didn´t know about these threads - ROM seems obvious now... but it´s so 1000x much better that MIUI :D can you recommend a working ROM close to stock android 11?

I´ve just tried the one you´ve linked to - are you talking about the one from pixelexperience.org?
[Magisk] rezpower:
Oh! Stupid me! thanks a lot :)
[Magisk] pndwal:
Just linked one 😜 ; see my post above. PW
[Magisk] stevezlk:
jep, that´s the one that´s on my F3 ;) thinking about trying the following: https://download.pixelexperience.org/alioth
[Magisk] xSnowLeopardx:
Sooo after reading a lot in this thread + didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHideHidingRoot, I am asking you guys what is going wrong:

- Outlook with root is fine. It opens, no problem.

- Adding any normal email to it, still opens up everything, no problem.

- Adding my work email to it, a screen pops up with a fallen ice cream telling me my device is rooted and therefore, I can't open that specific email account.

- This also happens with the McDonald's app - but that's not the priority right now (fixed for some reason!)

- Things I tried have been, of course, MagiskHide, randomizing Magisk, installed and added and removed every module that could've helped/injured. Also tried edExposed, removed it, tried LSposed, still nothing. Cleared data of the Outlook app, tried again. Also tried isolatedProcess, nothing. Fingerprints, nothing. Removed Titanium Backup, nothing. MagiskHide Props Config, nothing.

- Basically, I am desperate at this point. I can always ask for a different phone for work, but I want to know how to bypass things and learn from my mistakes.

I also have a logcat file for you guys. Hopefully it got the whole process of my opening up the app fresh (deleted cache and data) until the fallen ice cream page with it telling me my device is rooted and it not letting me in.

Again, it's Outlook. Not the app itself, but rather the attached work email through the app.

Thanks in advance! <3

Update 1:

McDonald's decided to work?? I have no idea how. So that makes me a bit happy haha. But the main issue is still there.

Update 2:

Tried RootCloak, also not working.
[Magisk] pndwal:
Well, this seems to be the same official ROM (there should only be one 😜); 'download' links to https://download.pixelexperience.org/alioth also... So you already have official?! PW
[Magisk] stevezlk:
apparently I do... thinking about living w/o google pay and enjoying stock android, or crapping around with MIUI :D
[Magisk] pndwal:
Well I know maccas app is easily fixed; just need fully passing SafetyNet (Universal SafetyNet Fix module etc), certified Play Protect shown in PlayStore settings (clear data to fix), maccas app in MagiskHide list, reboot and clear app data and Robert's you mother's brother.

Try this for Outlook too... PW
[Magisk] xSnowLeopardx:
Haha, Mac is fixed already! (: But Outlook is still not working...
[Magisk] Ikikass:
Try Hide My Applist and DataFilter modules in LSposed
[Magisk] xSnowLeopardx:
Will try them! I can't find DataFilter though, where can I get it?

Added a screenshot of the applist detector. Does this help?
[Magisk] Rendering:
UBS Access application still finds out that my phone does not run stock ROM.

Is there anything you can do to fix it?

Thank you
[Magisk] Depressed T.Bear:
A good point to start is checking with the Momo app from the well known vvb2060 if your Magisk/Xposed etc hiding works.

It's arguably the strongest app for detection of all common modifications and unfortunately used by a growing nunber of banks. While root can be hidden: Riru and the the "abnormal environment" due to xposed /xprivacy can almost not. At least, I haven't found a reliable way. That's why using my banking app is currently impossible :/
[Magisk] pndwal:
I have no experience with these methods, but, FWIW, some report success with 'sandboxing' apps / modules.

Some mentioned in this thread previously include MagiskCloak module, Shelter and Island.

XPrivacyLua Xposed module (use LSPosed if trying) may also help (can use hook definitions like BlockGuardOs.open), but again you'll need to research. PW
[Magisk] pndwal:
Here's an example of basic settings for passing SafetyNet & hiding root from an app:

https://xdaforums.com/t/magisk-general-support-discussion.3432382/post-85558177

If this doesn't work, app likely uses custom methods to detect a non-trusted execution environment. Check this:

https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHideHidingRoot# PW
[Magisk] pndwal:
I saw your post in Poko F3 Unofficial PE ROM thread...

Just to be clear, you did actually switch to the newer official ROM? ... Perhaps a clean install might help. PW
[Magisk] xSnowLeopardx:
Thanks for the reply!

Could you help me with finding the shelter and island applications? Struggling right now to find them.
[Magisk] jons99:
new alpha is out don't update if you care for safetynet

edit: add back paly services (gms.unstable) to get safetynet working again
[Magisk] 73sydney:
Step 1: go to https://play.google.com

Step 2: type shelter or island in

Shouldnt cause a struggle :)
[Magisk] xSnowLeopardx:
Oh lmao, I tried both names with "module" after, that's why I couldn't find anything, thanks!
[Magisk] 73sydney:
hehe no worries :)

someone prolly should have pointed out theyre just apps
[Magisk] pndwal:
... so it's as users / I reported it seems: "'sandboxing' apps / modules mentioned in this thread" that "include MagiskCloak module, Shelter and Island."...

Maybe I shouda said 'modules / apps', but I'm prolly a bit lisdexic. 😜 PW
[Magisk] zgfg:
Seems you have updated already

Magisk Hide is still present?

You say, SN does not pass - can you share the screenshot (szpposing with 31it was all ok for you)
[Magisk] jons99:
yes it's still there it just got reset once I add back play services safetynet is good again
[Magisk] 73sydney:
Or maybe youve had a glass of fruity (dys)lexia or two

been on the goon ? :P
[Magisk] Rendering:
I have been using Magisk since years with many applications. It's just the UBS Access application that is so good in understanding if the phone runs a custom ROM or not
[Magisk] pndwal:
Latest @vvb2060 Magisk Alpha build (August 31, 2021) changelog (Chinese Translated):

alpha update log​

Magic (f98c68a2-alpha)​

Based on f98c68a2, please refer to the upstream update log for related modifications

- see my following post for John's upstream changes since his May builds.

Properly process any data from magiskd

Support SharedUserId

Delete the backup file after restoring the boot image

Built-in current version update log

Use the local version when the stub cannot be downloaded, now Magisk can be used completely offline

Listen to the PACKAGE_FULLY_REMOVED broadcast to remove completely uninstalled apps from magiskhide

Show waiting pop-up window when hiding/restore Magisk application

App adapted to Android 12

Hide screen overlay when super user pops up (Android 12+)

Fix incorrect signal sending in MagiskHide

Add untrusted_app_30

Prompt that some devices do not load the sepolicy module

Add mount information to the log file

Fix the default shell path of busybox

Use SELinux context to distinguish zygote processes

https://github.com/vvb2060/Magisk/b...ccb6885399f/app/src/main/res/raw/changelog.md

Last build on GitHub

1eb83ad8-alpha-31

My earlier notes:

https://xdaforums.com/t/magisk-general-support-discussion.3432382/post-85098469

Current notes:

Check 'earlier notes' for installation method / details.

Alpha build users don't yet see Update button notice in Magisk App despite VersionCode changing. I'm not sure why, but users will observe the 'Latest' and 'Installed' version difference.

This Latest build is available in GitHub magisk_files repo as well as from Telegram group. Telegram links:

https://xdaforums.com/t/magisk-general-support-discussion.3432382/post-85229385

I've just tested latest build, and all is good /working.

As expected, SafetyNet now fails initially w/ failed basicIntegrity as well as ctsProfile, and Google Play services is no longer added to MagiskHide list by toggling MagiskHide on due to John's "Remove all non-Magisk hiding code" commit(s).

However S/N fully passes again simply by adding the SafetyNet service in Google Play services (com.google.android.gms.unstable) to MagiskHide list manually! (Check 'Show system apps'.)...

As John indicated, it's 'trivial' to re-implement MagiskHide settings. 😜

👍 PW
[Magisk] 73sydney:
Unsurprisingly theres a list of complaints on the Magisk Alpha Telegram Group, banging on about SafetyNet, because no one in that lazy Telegram world ever reads anything they just expect to be spoonfed everything...
[Magisk] Papote3:
Viper4android only working on Google play music. Can't get it to work on Spotify or Pandora or any other media player.

I've installed the module that's inside the manager. I've tried freezing musicFx but nothing, viper is not working anywhere but GPM

I have Nexus 6P stock nougat NBD90X magisk v7 rooted with Magisk phh's superuser
[Magisk] aroblu94:
Forum me Viper4Android is not working at all... I've installed it from Magisk manager, it says that it will be updated at next reboot but it doesn't work.

V4A FX app also says it's not installed or has to be updated.

Does anyone know a fix?

Thanks
[Magisk] grep_i:
There are people who succeeded with this device.

The best way to start is searching in your device specific thread.
[Magisk] stangri:
And yet, there's no issue for it on github. If you know what's causing it, do consider adding an issue against either Magisk or Magisk Manager.
[Magisk] joshuaw84:
+1 for this, that's what git is for, no way to track bugs in a forum setting needless to say guarantee it's on the radar. Also, if others have the issue they can add info to help in it being squashed.
[Magisk] Rhoban:
Just flash the v4a Magisk zip and then install the 2.4.0.1 apk from the respective threads.

Also make sure you're permissive.
[Magisk] paranoia_gu:
a little question:

while or what show i reflash or do , after i flash the new build rom. i do not wipe data ?
[Magisk] aroblu94:
Oh ok, so I am missing a zip.. I thought I could install as a module from Magisk manager without doing anything else, will try thanks!! :)
[Magisk] SavageDamage:
Does Magisk touch encryption at all by default? I want to root and keep encryption.
[Magisk] Radit26:
So I have to reboot every time I want to hide root? Didn't the previous magisk just had a toggle I can use without reflashing superuser? Sorry about the questions, new to all this hiding root and magisk stuff.
[Magisk] myishika:
Dear all.

Need your help.

I am using Verizon Galaxy S7 (Qualcomm) SM-930V, with most probably locked bootloader. I have used engineered boot image for rooting. Now I want to install magisk and then systemless root followed by systemless xposed.*

But since there is no custom recovery available for S7 , how do I flash magisk, systemless SuperSU and Xposed on the device ?

I've tried flashfire but ended up with error "Custom binary locked by SECURE IMAGE (boot.img)".*

Flashed the engineered boot.img through Odin to restore the phone.*

My goal is to flash - Magisk + Systemless Root + Xposed+suhide.

Had it working on HTC M8 but it was bootloader unlocked. New S7 is giving headache....

Anyone who could help would be greatly appreciated.

Thanks

PS: sorry. couldn't reply to previous msgs so had to post it again.
[Magisk] Captain_Throwback:
That toggle has nothing to do with hiding root. Please read the official Magisk release thread to see what was changed in v7 of Magisk and Magisk Manager.
[Magisk] grep_i:
I will give you the same answer as before less than 10 posts back.

There are people who succeeded with this device.

The best way to start is searching in your device specific thread.
[Magisk] Artim_96:
It won't change encryption as far as I know. It only disables forceencrypt
[Magisk] chrisg4:
Hi guys i was of for like 4 days does this trick with magisk and suhide still working?
[Magisk] Grinninga:
can i uninstall magisk over recovery? like twrp?

i am having issues at booting after installing the zip... stucks in boot screen (htc one m8s)
[Magisk] theredbaron1834:
Just flash the uninstaller, downloaded from the main magisk thread (link in 1st post).
[Magisk] Artim_96:
At least you need to be able to flash your stock boot.img. if you have it, flashing it should work for the moment. It's no complete removal, but it should stop Magisk from doing anything, to the bootloops should be fine afterwards
[Magisk] tech_head:
Working how?

You mean AndroidPay working? No.
[Magisk] pndwal:
TJW Magisk commits since his official May builds (to f98c68a280cac29910e4e1e448dd75ac77a1e960, Aug 30, 2021), ie. Upstream changes now merged in f98c68a2-alpha Magisk build (above).

• Clean up unneeded rules

• Do not use glob in the system's unzip parameter …

https://android.googlesource.com/pl...android-10.0.0_r47/libziparchive/unzip.cpp#57 unzip did not support glob before Android 11

• update and fix some text in strings-sq

• Do not allow remove the module to be updated

• Update Belarusian translation

• Use std::map instead

• Support oplus.fstab

• boot image header v4

• Norwegian Bokmål translation

• Fix and update strings-sq

• Remove unnecessary umount

• Fix line editing on Android 8.0+

• Fix always enter safe mode …

`getprop("persist.sys.safemode", true) == "1"` -> `getprop("persist.sys.safemode", true) == ""`

• Use isolated devpts if kernel support …

kernel version >= 4.7 or CONFIG_DEVPTS_MULTIPLE_INSTANCES=y

• Fix meizu compatibility

• Check util_functions.sh version

• Generic parsing methods

• Support bootconfig …

https://android-review.googlesource.com/c/platform/system/core/+/1615298

• Zopfli is not always smaller

• Cleanup compress.cpp

• Cleanup magiskboot code

• Add zopfli gzip encoder for better compression

• Add support for legacy ARM32 zImage

• Update README

• Cleanup module.cpp

• Modernize db.hpp

• Significantly better AVD support

• Implement cached thread pool

• Minor bug fixes

• Connect to magiskd log daemon

• Make xhook log as Magisk

• Generalize gen_jni_hooks.py

• Hook up denylist IPC routines

• Update recv/send fd function

• Refactor hook.cpp

• Use magiskd to setup files

• Remove all non-Magisk hiding code …

Magisk no longer interferes with any signals/info that were not created or caused by Magisk itself.

• Make Zygisk 1st class citizen

• The name is Zygisk

• Cleanup magiskboot cpio code

• Remove unused code

• Extend stream support

• Fix log file writing

• Don't depend on vtable ABI layout

• Revise logging code

• Cleaner daemon handlers

• Reorganize injection code

• Android 5.0 is actually supported

• Support code injection on Android 12

• Use code generator for jni_hooks

• Store all native JNI methods in data structures

• Update Android Studio

Ref for @curiousrom

https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/commits/master

👍 PW
[Magisk] curiousrom:
Why not include a link to where this comes from? 🤷‍♂️

***
[Magisk] pndwal:
I always do now, just as I promised you! ... BUT as I said, I haven't yet added regular notes incl. links!... I'll get around to it, (unless I drop dead first) ... I've posted all the changes incl TJW upstream and alpha Chinese translated for everyone's early convenience... And getting to other things...

But I'll interrupt proceedings to get it for you pronto! - since you asked so nicely... 😛

One minute...

...

...

And here you go:

https://github.com/vvb2060/Magisk/b...ccb6885399f/app/src/main/res/raw/changelog.md

🥵 PW
[Magisk] pndwal:
Hope that's going well...

As you may have noticed, @vvb2060's alpha is now released incl. John's last upstream commits.

As expected, SafetyNet now fails initially w/ failed basicIntegrity as well as ctsProfile, and Google Play services is no longer added to MagiskHide list by toggling MagiskHide on.

However, surprisingly S/N fully passes again simply by adding the SafetyNet service in Google Play services (com.google.android.gms.unstable) to MagiskHide list manually!

This makes me wonder what sensitive props were changed by MagiskHide previously, what they do, and if I / we really need them. 😬 (A list would still be appreciated!)

I guess time will tell, but happily all seems as it was before for me on RN8T, stock ROM & alpha Magisk (S/N passing, PlayProtect Device is certified)! ... But perhaps John hasn't made all intended regressions yet? PW
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
As far as I know, those props weren't really needed for SafetyNet, but for troublesome apps using their own methods of detection.

I was hoping that the new barebones implementation of MagiskHide would still be able to do the basics of hiding Magisk itself, and me adding the sensitive props that has been removed to MHPC would be enough to keep everything going without interruption. Maybe that's the case, maybe not. I still haven't taken the time to fully dig into what the new state of MagiskHide actually means for the future...
[Magisk] pndwal:
Well that makes sense, and it does seem that simply hiding root from SafetyNet process is all that was really needed within Magisk (accompanied by USNF and sometimes MHPC modules for the spoofing functions).

So your upcoming MHPC sensitive props function will be a useful tool for app detection circumvention along with Riru - Enhanced mode for Magisk Hide and Riru-MomoHider etc. ... We'll have quite an arsenal! 👍 PW
[Magisk] finall1008:
Can someone help!

DIYed a module to replace some system app by simply creating folder and putting files in. Then device stucked at boot. Device is Mi Pad 5 Pro so no TWRP(XiaoMi virtual AB device,). Android 11.

Tried:

magisk --remove-modules. It just stucked there with no response. Like this:

elish:/ $ magisk --remove-modules

* after minutes of waiting *

^C

130|elish:/ $

su. The same. Seems like something went wrong while magisk is in init?

Entering Safe Mode. Holding Vol- didn't work. Then I fastboot boot with the original boot image without magisk and held Vol-. Device entered safe mode. But when I rebooted device didn't start with all modules disabled like expected and just stucked there again.
[Magisk] rodken:
Try the '"fastboot flash boot boot.img"' command instead of

'fastboot boot boot.img'.
[Magisk] J.Michael:
I think when trying to boot to Safe Mode to get Magisk modules disabled, you need to have Magisk in Safe Mode. So you need to do something like:

fastboot boot original image -- to get Android booted

long press shutdown -- to get option to boot to safe mode

if Magisk is installed (i.e., you have not yet overwritten boot partition with original image), Magisk should come up in Safe Mode

reboot and you should get Magisk, not Safe Mode, but all modules disabled
[Magisk] Homeboy76:
He did , it's at the bottom of the change log (...changelog.md). :)
[Magisk] curiousrom:
Yeah, the Edit button is a beautiful thing. ;)

As well as the Like button which I used on his post after the edit. 👍

***
[Magisk] pndwal:
If Magisk-patched image was booting ok previously, I'd persist with trying to boot to safe mode with that installed.

From device powered down, did you do this?:

- Turn your phone back on with the power button, and hold the power button until you see an animated logo appear.

- Hold the Volume Down button once you see the animated logo appear.

- Continue holding Volume Down until your device boots.

Yup, Magisk itself detects button combo to add disable module & MagiskHide flags, so you need a way to boot to safe mode with Magisk active / installed. PW
[Magisk] finall1008:
I tried, but after helding vol- for minutes I gave up
[Magisk] finall1008:
It seems xiaomi removed safe mode trigger from the power menu... will try to find solution
[Magisk] dnsmo:
is Magisk going to work on Pixel 6?
[Magisk] gfrank227:
So you're saying that going forward.....even with future magisk releases that have "removed" magiskhide, we will be able to simply add google play services to his "list" from within magisk itself and then magiskhide is back?

Trying to make sure I understand properly.
[Magisk] pndwal:
Can't be sure, but that's what is occurring with all John's new commits (incl reverted S/N related ones) + @vvb2060's experimental commits in his latest Alpha build. 😛

Who knows what new commits John will introduce, but as he's commented "It's trivial to create a whatever hiding module if you want, and I'm 10000% sure something like this will pop up as soon as possible. I'm just not in the position to lead nor assist such effort in the future", it does seem he doesn't intend to create obstacles on purpose, and is simply extracting himself from the process.

So my *guess* is that new official builds will behave much like current Alpha.

I really think all the fuss about loosing SafetyNet pass has been a storm in a teacup as John has intimated also.

As he put it:

Others have been doing the heavy lifting for a while now anyway.

FWIW, I don't think Google are really interested in pursuing short term fixes for SafetyNet bypassing either; they already have a big hammer, it doesn't rely on sanctions involving John or others, it seems to be a fait accompli and it's called Hardware based TEE attestation.

John has seen this coming, and knows MagiskHide's days are numbered (outside of userspace) in any case.

Our fun with S/N bypasses will suffer the ultimate blow when that hammer is swung, and this will be done to protect Google's bottom line; this will catch the big fish; small fry ('white hat' Magisk community etc) are not the worry other than passing normal scrutiny if employees.

more:

https://xdaforums.com/t/magisk-general-support-discussion.3432382/post-85548583

https://xdaforums.com/t/magisk-general-support-discussion.3432382/post-85142583 PW
[Magisk] BajaBlast4Life:
If you flash Magisk onto a new device, there is no more "Magisk Hide" feature in Magisk 23 app?
[Magisk] 73sydney:
State of Magisk: 2021

Ever since my employment at Google, crazy speculations has been spreading like wild fire all over the Internet. The out-of-context private…

topjohnwu.medium.com

Maybe someone can make this a sticky, i can see all of us getting tired having to report this when people stream here and dont read the last 6 pages of the thread like a sane person would