yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] Peter Handless:
LG G3 bootloop with Majisk 19.1, 19.2, 19.3

Hi,

First thank You so much for the development of the amazing Majisk solution and all the years of very pleasant usage of it.

My aged LG G3 D855 is running the very last version of the Fulmics ROM 8.0 (Android 6.0)

No never version after Majisk 18.1 is working for me.

19.1, 19.2, 19.3 are all causing bootloops at the first static LG logo, returnig to boot backup still saves my day after each new try ;)

Will this generation of android devices be still supported or can i allreay stop trying to update?

Thank You so much

have a nice day

PB
[Magisk] ISoreo:
In Magisk 19.3 (actually random reboot but i already fix it), No issue since i restore image to unroot the Magisk then, reboot into recovery to flash 19.2 after reboot go to Magisk Manager and install 19.3 to upgrade. maybe this solution can help other guys who facing random reboot
[Magisk] Artim_96:
Then probably you'll have to wait for the next stable release
[Magisk] mrps2:
Redmi Note 5 - MIUI 10.1 -

Still having bootloop when accepting to do Additional Settings, which happens everytime I open Magisk app...

If I don't accept it it does not allow me to install any module. 19.2 and now 19.3 Magisk keeps asking for install additional settings... Here is the log from Magisk

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1-Bc-7fETebVSa76zE3gitPw0YIyusJaT/view?usp=drivesdk

Tried to upload the log straight to xda app but it is not uploading... Hope someone can help!
[Magisk] goutham200589:
Magisk Hide issue on 19.3

Just updated 19.3, Intune Company portal works fine but having issues on Outlook as it can still detect root. Had to go back to 19.2 to get it working.
[Magisk] bohemist:
Just a few. Pls see image attachment for reference
[Magisk] jason972000:
Same here, 19.3 wasn't passing safety check and PS Vue app wasn't hidden from root. Went from 19.3 back to 19.2.
[Magisk] bschatzow:
I have a strange problem that started in Feb. I have a Samsung T813 with Lineage 16 and the latest Magisk. I get random reboots where the device goes back and then the system restarts. It loads to my home n screen but the touch is inactive. After several minutes it then loads another screen that says Tablet is starting. This takes about 10 minutes. It then boots into TWRP. If I go to custom wipe and clear both caches it will boot normally until the next either random reboot or a normal reboot. I thought it might be failing hardware so I purchase another T813 (bran new) and loaded it the same as my old tablet. I just did a normal reboot after after making a change in the build prop and it exhibited the same issue. Not sure if it is a Magisk issue, Lineage issue or maybe one of the Tasker programs that I granted root access. Any ideas? I have never seen the screen tablet is starting before on any ofy devives. Maybe this gives a clue on where to start?
[Magisk] belloni:
Is there a way I can patch my boot.img if I can't get into the phone? I'm stuck in bootloop and can only access TWRP?

Thanks
[Magisk] guest4711:
Either flash the saved boot-image, usually something like /data/stock-boot.....img

Or extract the original boot image from your stock ROM, boot it per adb boot or copy it to your sdcard and flash it from there.
[Magisk] belloni:
I've found the old magisk_patched.img but when I flash it says "FAILED (remote: partition length get error)
[Magisk] UnnA^:
Just updated from 19.1 to 19.3 on my galaxy tab 2014 running lineage 14.1 and one of my apps (Foxtel go) detects root and doesn't run. I rolled back to 19.1 and it's fine again and the app runs fine. Something has changed in 19.3.
[Magisk] Tombab:
Same here, switching Magisk hide off and back on again with 19.3 made check pass but when I used phone later banking app complained about root and safetynet checks failed again. Uninstalling and reinstalling 19.3 didn't help. 19.2 now installed and life is good. Maybe better luck with next version.
[Magisk] KitsuneFoxy:
That's really strange then. The modules i had/have in magisk, dont show what it used to.

It might be because i'd not updated the repo before i had to re install my phone.

But, since then i dont get as many show up. lol
[Magisk] Klaus N.:
There's bootloops on Sony a/b devices since Magisk v19.0, at least with the XZ2 (I own a H8216), running the latest Sony stock Pie fw (52.0.A.8.50) here. You'll find the corresponding bootlog.log and the magisk.log in the attachement. It has been recorded with the current version 19.3.

Btw, the bootloop is regardless, if Magisk will be directly installed/updated via the Magisk Manager app, or if there are modules installed or not; even a clean install with the pure Sony stock kernel (I also removed the whole content of /data/adb/ to be on the save side) didn't get it to boot into system. It always results in a bootloop.

If you need something else, just let me know!

Many thanks in advance!
[Magisk] guest4711:
Did you try MagiskManager -- Settings -- Clear Repo Cache?
[Magisk] KitsuneFoxy:
Yes. It goes all the way back to the earliest module which is 28th of march
[Magisk] levone1:
Quick question for anyone who might have ideas... Using v18.1 on stock Sony XZ2c, and using MicroG. I had Safteynet passing until yesterday. I tried to upgrade Magisk to new version, but didn't work (bootloop), so I uninstalled and went back to 18.1. Everything is working fine, but now Safteynet fails. Not sure if it's the cause, but one thing that's happening is that I can't add DroidGuard to Magisk Hide. I can check it, but it will automatically uncheck itself. I'm pretty sure I had it hidden before... I have read some posts about a hidelist file, but I don't seem to have it.

Any ideas?

Thanks
[Magisk] slave200701:
Hi,

I have a problem, can't install Magisk after weekly update on Xiaomi MI 8. Till now I haven't any problems. I went back to earlier update but it doesn't help more.

Thx in advance.

Solved : Finally I have installed magisk with TWRP, but I don't understand, why no success with magisk manager.

Gesendet von meinem MI 8 mit Tapatalk
[Magisk] Pandemic:
Bro [MENTION=6283426]levone1[/MENTION]

Go into settings of magisk and enable magisk hide, see screenshots ;)

Hope this helps for you, it did for me ^^
[Magisk] RMarques:
OnePlus 5 6/64, latest Oxygen OS OB. Magisk 19.3 + 7.2.0 manager. Still losing root like once every day/2 days.
[Magisk] jcmm11:
Try this https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/magisk-installed-workaround-t3908748
[Magisk] levone1:
Magisk Hide has been enabled, (I'm pretty sure it won't even show up in the side menu if it's not enabled), and many other apps are checked, and remain checked, (including the other two MicroG apps). For some reason now, after removing and reinstalling Magisk, DroidGuard won't stay checked, but always unchecks itself as soon as I leave the hide menu.
[Magisk] diehard2013:
Is this a byproduct of rooting?

non-rooted devices do not show this.

thx.
[Magisk] Ps24u:
I believe 18.1 has DroidGuard hidden by default, you shouldn't need to add DroidGuard manually on this version.

Just clear Magisk log, reboot, use device for a while (open play store,..), then check Magisk log to see what process is being hidden, at the bottom of the screen

Sometimes the safetynet checker server is down, rare but can happen.

Finally try to disable and reenable Magisk hide (toggle the option), it can help on 18.x.
[Magisk] Marvino.:
I think it's time to design a new splash screen for Magisk Manager..
[Magisk] jbarcus81:
Anyone having issues with the Playstore? I'm noticing even with Magisk hide enabled, and wiping data/cache of the Playstore and Google Play Services, I'm still unable to install Netflix from the Playstore. Says my device isn't compatible .. Is that an issue with root or maybe just a Playstore issue? If it matters, I'm signed up for the Beta of Netflix. Using a Pixel 3 XL on the June update. Stock, but Magisk and Kirisakura-Kernel. No other modifications.
[Magisk] jcmm11:
Device? ROM? Definitely not standard. I suspect you have a custom ROM, in which case check in your ROM thread
[Magisk] JudgeDread11:
I have had that in many custom ROMs. I don't know if it's hidden without root as I have always rooted my devices.
[Magisk] diehard2013:
I observe this on a tab s3 (sm-t820) and tab s4 (sm-t830), both magisk rooted and with stock ROMs.

On the other hand, I have installed many apps and modules such as Nethunter with its terminal feature, so I'll look there.

The 'local terminal' option shown in screenehot reminds me of Cyanogen back in the Nexus 4 days.

Do stock android ROMs have an internal/native/hidden terminal app?

I forgot to mention that the option appears only after a search under Settings. Clicking on it takes me to Developer Options, however, the 'local terminal' option isn't there.

thank you.
[Magisk] nsievers:
Anybody else have an issue with Magisk 19.3 not passing safety check? I have tried installing it 3-4 times. No issues with 19.1 or 19.2. Ended up reflashing 19.1. So currently 19.1 and Manager 7.2 working fine.

Samsung Galaxy S4 L720

Lineage OS 16 Release 8
[Magisk] wilsonhlacerda:
Turn off and on Magisk Hide on settings.

Also:

https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHide#hn_SafetyNet_fails_after_an_update
[Magisk] nsievers:
Thanks for the tip, I will try it next time I update. :good:
[Magisk] guest4711:
The local terminal is a build-option in most custom ROMs I use, but it is not implemented always. On some ROMs it is missing, on others there is an entry in the helpfile only.. But I did not see it is visible/usable on rooted devices only.

Even if it is is implemented I miss some features in the standard implementation (e. g. cut and paste, setting font size) so I use Terminal Emulator for Android (Access Android's built-in Linux command line shell. Unleash your inner geek!) - https://f-droid.org/app/jackpal.androidterm
[Magisk] samhhmobil:
It's the same bug with 19.3. Bluetooth doesn't connect to "Ford Audio" Device anymore. So the phone is unuseable in the car. Downgrade to Magisk 19.1, and it's working again without any issue.

samhhmobil
[Magisk] Pandemic:
[MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION]

You see this and can you fix it for our xz2 users ?
[Magisk] brown1178:
Hello,

just updated my OP6 to OOS 9.0.6. Magisk 19.3 flashed to other Slot before restart. Phone shuts down automaticly. This happened before and could be solved with a beta of Magisk. Is there a fixed beta already? MagiskManager shown 19.3 (19300) for both channels, are these the same or can beta contain fixes?
[Magisk] jenslody:
Besides droidguard-helper being added to hidelist auronatically on 18.1 (as stated above), you can not pass safetynet with it currently, due to changes on googles site.

Check github of microG, probably also microG-thread on xda and definitely in Nanodroid-thread.
[Magisk] stefano91av:
Hi at all. I have this problem when try to install any magisk module on Tablet Chuwi Hi8 Pro: "UNABLE TO EXTRACT ZIP FILE".
[Magisk] vermajai93:
After updating to 19.3, one of my bank app is not working anymore. It's the idfc bank app which detects root now. I'm running latest oxygenOS on OnePlus X onyx. I only have magisk installed with no other mods like Xposed etc. Please help fix this or let me know what information I need to provide. I'm going to switch to previous version for now.
[Magisk] Fild5x:
I think we should be able to launch modules from magisk its self don't you think so?
[Magisk] zipsu:
+1, although the app would need to tell apart modules with or without user interfaces and there are still those that run from terminal, probably hasn't been a priority for the dev.
[Magisk] levone1:
Thanks. I actually did see some information like that, but I know safetynet passed before, so I was confused... I guess it's because the changes in question must are pretty recent.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
If you're manually installing a downloaded zip, download it again. Otherwise, installation logs are necessary:

https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHelp

https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHide#hn_Hiding_root_from_apps
[Magisk] stefano91av:
Hi, thank you for support!

These are my log files.

EDIT: I have solved!!! It was a busybox problem after a past failed installation. I have cleaned busybox and reinstalled Magisk 19.3. All it's all right! My tablet is happy now with Magisk + Modules (Busybox, Init.d Injector, FDE.AI). Thank you so much.
[Magisk] SimoneSessa:
Hi,

the systemless hosts module creates a problem with the storage displaying.

I've Magisk 19.3 and Manager 7.2.0 on my Pixel 3 and when I enable the systemless hosts module, I can't clear data or cache of my apps. Every app display "User Data 0 B - Cache 0 B" and in settings/storage, the size of the system is incorrect.

Other users has this problem:

https://xdaforums.com/pixel-3-xl/help/storage-displaying-incorrectly-t3919923

https://xdaforums.com/pixel-3-xl/help/storage-cache-grayed-apps-t3921353

They will fix flashing a custom kernel.

Is it a known bug?
[Magisk] jcmm11:
https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/issues/1109
[Magisk] XBatteria:
My Oneplus A6000 isn't charging normally when it's off.What I can see is only the Bootloader unlocked warning and no charging screen.

I've had this problem for about a month..? I am not sure about the version of magisk when I noticed it. But I have already tried 19.1 and 19.3. And I'm sure this issue appeared after I flashed magisk.

Using H2OS(OP6_H2_BETA22，the same problem appeard at BETA_21 and stable 9.0.5), Android Pie

Here is a post about the same problem:https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/magisk-17-1-17-3-oneplus-6-pie-9-0-2-t3861668/
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/issues/906
[Magisk] habylab:
It's fixed on 9.0.6 I read.
[Magisk] vandyman:
Magisk version 19.4 fixed the boot loop when installing the patched image.

Pixel 3a XL.

THANKS....
[Magisk] rxk:
Hi ALL,

Lately, I saw magisk notification for latest update. I clicked and when to Magisk Manager and showing Magisk & Magisk Manager is up to date.

This morning I saw notification again, same thing all up is up to date. I open the settings menu and accidentally clicked "Hide Magisk Manager" Repackage Magisk Manager with random package name. After that, Magisk Manager icon text change to "Manager". When I clicked Manager icon it opens Magisk Manager app and shows "Magisk is not installed" and some setting menus was gone like the SuperSU, Magisk Hide, etc... but root seems working. I have attached some screen shoot below.

I would like to ask if this normal?

Is the root still working even if I restart my Phone?

How can I restore "Hide Magisk Manager"?

Am still receiving automatic update for Magisk and Magisk Manager?

Please help... need to understand more on this.

Thank you.
[Magisk] Tejas_Ashok:
Why was Dolby Atmos, Greenify and Viper4Android removed from the download list?
[Magisk] Ryano89:
19.4?
[Magisk] vandyman:
Yes, 19.4 is the canary build..
[Magisk] doomscooter:
i think from this

https://github.com/topjohnwu/magisk_files/tree/master/canary_builds

in my htc u11 working normally
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
You're using the buggy 215 Canary Manager, that's why. Uninstall that and install the 216 build instead:

https://github.com/topjohnwu/magisk_files/tree/master/canary_builds

Atmos probably wasn't updated for the great purge last month.

Greenify4Magisk stopped being developed a long time ago, so it also got purged (you don't need it really, since you can do the same with the systemiser module).

V4A has not been removed... (Try clearing the repo cache in Manager settings and then refresh the list). Edit: unless you're talking about some other V4A module than the ones by Zack, in which case it probably also got purged.
[Magisk] Tejas_Ashok:
Thank you! I cleared the repo cache and it showed v4a!!!
[Magisk] rxk:
Hi Didgeridoohan,

Can you please direct me how to uninstall and reinstall 215 build. I am not good in this field,

Is their any step by step procedure to follow, just to make sure i won't break anything... its to much hustle to setup my phone again. Noobie here, hope you understand.

Thanks.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Uninstall the Manager as you would any other app. Then download the apk from the link I gave you and install that. That's all...
[Magisk] martyfender:
His post stated that you need to install the newer, 216 build, not the buggy, 215 build as you stated.
[Magisk] rxk:
[MENTION=270303]didgeridoo[/MENTION] [MENTION=8126387]martyfender[/MENTION]

I managed to uninstall my old Magisk Manager and install build 216 as mentioned above.

Appreciate your patience and understanding for us not knowledgeable in this field.

Thank you.
[Magisk] jenslody:
The "update-available-bug" persists in 216.

At least on my devices, one with repackaged Manager, one with the default Manager.
[Magisk] Pro4TLZZ:
I installed magisk manager 213, moved to stable but I still get update available losing root
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Yes, that one does persists.
[Magisk] Tommasoleone:
Hi Foolken, i have find this thread: root-j4-plus-pie-u2-2019 . In this thread [MENTION=9101376]kapmino269[/MENTION] maybe have found the reason of Lockscreen issue after root with android pie but dont have solution.
[Magisk] Danny1976:
Same issue here. I am on the canary update channel, 216 manager and I keep getting notifications for update. When I check... No update is available.
[Magisk] sdz2:
Long story, short:

I solved my Magisk Manager won't install, run, or remove modules problem: Magisk Core Only Mode "Enable only core features ... but no modules will be loaded."

While frustratingly trying to pass SafetyNet, I enabled and forgot about that setting. Days later I realized this. *facepalm*

I disabled the setting and everything is better now.

...

Long story, long:

To update Netflix, I had to disable Xposed and pass SafetyNet.

I disabled Xposed, but SafetyNet still failed. I adjusted some Magisk settings and Magisk Hide, and SafetyNet passed. I updated Netflix and enabled Xposed.

Then, I noticed emojis from Emoji One (Magisk module) didn't apply. Other Magisk modules had issues too. I couldn't run, install, or remove any module from Magisk Manager. Reinstalling Magisk didn't fix it.

Several days later I discovered I had enabled:

Magisk Core Only Mode "Enable only core features ... but no modules will be loaded." I disabled the setting, and everything returned to normal
[Magisk] Artim_96:
[emoji23] classic
[Magisk] cityneversleepz:
A friend asked me to root his old Nexus 7 2012 Wi-Fi. I did and installed magisk 19.3 then a strange thing happened. I got a 19.4 update. So I updated it to 19.4 and all was well. It only happened on dirty unicorn 6.0.1 which I didn't stay on because it was slow. I switched to a 7.1.2 build and never saw that update again. I have several other rooted devices and not one of them has the update to 19.4. I thought I was seeing things but they're it was. Funny thing too, the magisk manager was up to date but didn't have a choice for stable and beta. Anyone know what this was? I'm only posting this because I'm really curious myself.
[Magisk] jcmm11:
Magisk 19.3 (19300) and Manager 7.2.0 (213) are the latest stable and beta available. Magisk 19.4-c1602d25 (19301) and Manager 7.2.0-16b232d2 (216) are the latest Canary versions.
[Magisk] martyfender:
It sounds like it was set to the Canary update channel in settings. I am on the unofficial build and when I uninstall and reinstall only the Magisk Manager, it gets set to the Canary debug channel by default. I'm not certain about the stable build, though.
[Magisk] aoryx:
Having trouble after update to version 19.300 with my banking app S-pushTAN, root detected error msg (log attached)

My device is P20 pro, official (9.0.0.251) had been using version 19003 with no problems with the same app. Updated using direct install method.

App is in hide list, and manager is hidden.

After downgrading banking app is running smoothly (same settings).

Any suggestions?

Thanks!
[Magisk] broomer68:
I have a similar thing on my oneplus6 running beta19, magisk 19.3, no twrp, no custom kernel.

I have woken up with a message that there is an update to magisk, but when I open the manager, it reports it is not installed.

A reboot solves the problem.

Maybe TitaniumBackup does give some trouble, closing the manager?

Verstuurd vanaf mijn ONEPLUS A6003 met Tapatalk
[Magisk] guest4711:
MagiskHide 19.3 does not start (properly) when rebooting. After booting I disable MagiskHide and re-enable it and all is fine. If I forget it, root is detected by some apps.

To check it, I use Root Validator (checks the root state of your device) - https://f-droid.org/app/eu.thedarken.rootvalidator - and hide root from it.
[Magisk] aoryx:
Thanks for your response.

I tried to enable magiskhide again, still banking app didn't work and detected root

Even though other apps don't
[Magisk] ct760ster:
Latest Magisk 19.3 not working in Samsung Galaxy J7 Perx SM-j727P

Hello, I just want to thanks the developer for his amazing effort to bring a way to root devices past beyond Android Nougat. Also I want to drop a little precaution for those who own a SM-J727P like me who unconspicuously want to update to the latest Magisk once is suggested by the manager. The latest version 19.3 just made my phone stuck at boot and I had to re-flash to stock and revert back to 19.2 which is working fine. I tried the uninstaller and it didn't work because TWRP doesn't have access to Data partition in the phone. Hope this will catch the eye of another SM-J727P and prevent them the hassle to restore and redo the root process. Keep the good work going ;)
[Magisk] TomLabert:
I have a LeEco Le 2 x526 with Lineage 15.1 and I want to watch netflix on my rooted phone.

Can I just install magisk on top of my current installation or do I have to use the TWRP-Recovery mode and wipe/re-install my whole device?
[Magisk] xunholyx:
I'm assuming you are rooted with SuperSU right now?

Download the latest magisk.zip and also download the unSU.zip which you can find here to your phone.

Boot to TWRP and flash the unSU.zip

Without rebooting (tap the home button), flash the magisk.zip next

Reboot and you should be good to go.
[Magisk] TomLabert:
apparently it was not rooted and I got it to work thanks mate
[Magisk] cityneversleepz:
Thank you. Makes sense now. I didn't know about the other version. Probably did do something to cause this. The Rom was rooted at install with super SU. I used su uninstaller and then magisk, so this explains it. Silver lining; I found this thread and subscribed.
[Magisk] Ramme:
Hello, can anyone Help me, how can i fix them?

e:

Sorry, so my problem is that I have set up the fingerprint for Magisk, now I've done a Rom update today, but I've removed the fingerprint at Magisk and from my system too. Now I wanted to use the fingerprint again with Magisk and I get the message "Authentication failed"

besides, I thought my screenshot would be meaningful enough :)
[Magisk] sdamark:
Zero information = impossible to help.
[Magisk] xunholyx:
For me, it also zero translation as well. :D
[Magisk] kryshnakishore:
Hey this issue got resolved for me. Just flash this zip in recovery.

https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/magisk-installed-workaround-t3908748
[Magisk] kotuamoalt:
Your screenshot is not meaningful at all, even if one happens to be fluent in what I assume is German? But I'll give it a shot, anyway. Try uninstalling magisk, create your fingerprint, and then reinstall magisk. If that doesn't work, I would start from scratch. But that's just me.