yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] DragonFire1024:
And here we go again. I'm on 19. Changed the boot animation to test it. And wouldn't you know, magisk erased it and defaulted it back to the original. Can't delete files from system. I toggle on core mode only, then everything is fine. If I have to always keep core only mode on, then what's the point?
[Magisk] chooks06:
No, I didn't intend to describe your exact procedure. Just sharing my experience in case someone did the same.

My usual way is to use the uninstaller, reboot to TWRP then flash the new zip then be install manager and setup, without reinstalling OS. It worked all this while till now.

When you reinstalled the OS, it means you effectively have to set up the phone again?

Sorry, but I'm not an expert in this area.
[Magisk] kotuamoalt:
No. Just install the OS without wiping anything. When I did it, it restored my phone without losing any data or settings. After I verified the phone was working and without Root, I went into TWRP and installed v.19. And up until this new version, I also had no issues previously installing or updating Magisk.
[Magisk] chooks06:
Noted. Thanks for the input mate!

Have a great weekend ahead!

Cheers..
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Sounds like you haven't quite understood how Magisk works. If you have a module mounting files to /system or /vendor, any alterations you make to that part of the partition will only alter the Magisk mask, not your real system. If you then reboot, that alteration will of course be lost when a new mask is mounted.

If you don't want to do systemless modifications (with Magisk modules) you have to edit the files you find in /sbin/.magisk/mirror.
[Magisk] kotuamoalt:
Good luck!:svetius:
[Magisk] chooks06:
Thank you!
[Magisk] DragonFire1024:
The modifications I'm doing have nothing to do with the modules installed. And unless im missing something, I don't have any modules installed that do that specifically. I have a GPS module, init.d, viper, hosts, just mostly mods to tweak the kernel and what not.
[Magisk] jcmm11:
Change the boot animation via TWRP and you should be fine.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
I don't know about the GPS module, but all the other ones you mention mount files or folders to /system and/or /vendor. So, you do have an active Magisk mask. That's why Core Only Mode works, no modules are mounted then.
[Magisk] Harshdeepagrawal:
Hi,

Issue:

Magiskhide not working after updating to 18.1 and magisk manager to 7.1.1 (203)

Device: oneplus 2

Os: pixel experience pie official rom

Magiskhide was working perfectly fine before this update.

I've tried reinstalling banking apps, clearing cache, disabling magisk hide restart device and re-enable magisk hide. Nothing worked.

Anybody else facing the same issue? Please help to fix
[Magisk] RandomPooka:
Have you used the option to repackage the manager?
[Magisk] g000n:
tried to install magisk v19 beta through magisk manager on my samsung galaxy note 5 and my phone is stuck at the samsung logo splash screen, any help?
[Magisk] bmonteiro:
Hey guys, i've searched on Google and here and couldn't get a definitive and clear answer... there's no Magisk for s10 yet, right? Even the Canary Builds won't work?
[Magisk] jcmm11:
It's being worked. You can try ianmacd's latest unofficial build. That apparently has some s10 stuff in it

https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/unofficial-magisk-v10-beta-built-t3521901/page307

But it's not yet ready for prime time so be ready for it not to work yet
[Magisk] bmonteiro:
Thank you so much! Gonna check that
[Magisk] oseiasrodrigues0:
the 19v magisk is with a bug when i install in LineageOS 14.1 samsung it goes straight to the twrp more if i delete all the modules it initializes normal. also found if, agent installs the modules by the magisk itself it also enters the twrp, but if you clear the cache, initialize the normal
[Magisk] n0j0e:
Also here on my stock OxygenOS 5.1.7 (Oreo 8.1). Tried to flash Magisk 19 in latest Magisk Manager and TWRP. Restored my boot partition in TWRP with Magisk 18.1 all fine!

Sent with much love & Android. OnePlus 5T
[Magisk] DragonFire1024:
So for the changes I made to system, I have to make in the mirror? Do I have to turn core only on when I do this?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Should just be a matter of editing the files and rebooting.
[Magisk] AndrzejDwo:
I have just checked once again to confirm, and in my case changes which I made to the system stick after reboot. I have changed bootanimation and rebooted 4 times and it sticks. Try to uninstall all the modules and install one, check if your modification stick, then install another module and try to figure out which one is causing the problem. I have substratum, NFS and Viper modules - with that configuration changes remain.

I don't know how else I can help you because the problem you're facing is very annoying - I know that.

Cheers
[Magisk] elliwigy:
I need some guidance/suggestions as I am going crazy.

Before I get into it, just note that what I am trying to do is most likely not supported and the device I am using is also not supported.

With that being said, I found a page written by wu himself where he provided a sample idea of an exploit using his magisk tools to root a device using sbin and not patching the boot image systemlessly.

I have a SM-N960U (Locked BL Note 9.) I have a working exploit that is not public yet that allows me to run commands as uid 0 on each reboot. It isa script that is executed by an init script. I am also using factory combo firmware which has dm-verity disabled and permissive selinux.

The three main partitions I could install root to (system, odm, vendor) are not able to be mounted due to other security features. When I mount them the phone crashes and kernel panics. DD doesnt not apear to do anything either to these 3 partitions as well as they appear to be write protected.

What I can do... I have root/rw access to every other partition. I can for example mount / as rw, use sbin, data etc.

I followed the instructions which basically as root user uses the magiskinit binary to create magiskpolicy then install to sbin and patch sepolicy etc etc.. All seems to go smoothly except I am unable to execute su.

When I try to execute su it says there is no daemon running. When I try to manually syart the daemon with the --daemon action it says there is no daemon running.

I am only trying to get a very basic root shell for further testing. I did read in some comments that I should not use /data/local to store the magisk files? If that is my problem then where is best tostash them? If that is not the problem then does anyone have any suggestions?

I only tried with Magisk 19 so not sure if thats my problem either or not.

I will try to get some logs later.

Any help is appreciated.
[Magisk] Unspec:
With magisk v19 installed, "clear storage" and "clear cache" are greyed out for applications. Applications appear to be flat out not caching or something as well. Also causes system UI crashes in google maps.

Pixel 3 XL with ElementalX kernal, march security update. Any insights into what might be causing this? Didn't have this issue with 18.1

Edit: After system ui crashes and reboots on its own, I can once again clear storage and cache. Google maps consistently crashes the system ui though.
[Magisk] rub1k:
Actually, I may have spoken too soon. Everything seems to be working fine on 19.0... as long as I don't try to reboot.

If I reboot, it sits at the "MI" screen for about 20-30 seconds and it reboots again into bootloader/fastboot mode.

If I then power off and back on, it boots correctly.

If I reboot again, it gets stuck again, rinse and repeat.

I tried re-flashing 19.0 via TWRP but it didn't help.

Anyone successful at getting rid of the reboot-into-bootloader issue (if you had it to begin with...)?
[Magisk] jcmm11:
I've passed this on to somebody I think might be able to help. In the meantime as far as where to store Magisk files try /data/adb/

Not sure exactly which files you mean though. magiskinit, magisk etc are normally found in /sbin, but they're generated at boot from within the kernel. Since you said you're not patching the kernel /data/adb is probably your best bet.

But this is all guesswork on my part. Wait for better info. He's in Europe so it may be a few hours.
[Magisk] elliwigy:
Hello and thanks for the reply.

I was following wu's post as seen in the screenshot. Steps were place magiskinit on data somewhere, ln it to create magiskpolicy, patch sepolicy using magiskpolicy, mount tmpfs sbin, extract magisk from magiskinit and place it in sbin, copy magiskpolicy to sbin, install magisk in sbin, and launch magisk daemon
[Magisk] tovarichtch:
UPDATE : I rebooted my phone and went into bootloop again. I went back to 18.1 for now. It seems that with 19.0, I was able to boot every sixth try of booting.

If you get the ERROR 1 after uninstalling Magisk and trying to reinstall it, it's because your boot.img is corrupted from all those changes (it normally do if you have a custom kernel). Extract that file from your rom and flash it in any way you want (twrp, sideload, etc.) THEN flash your custom kernel (if you have one) THEN Magisk. No more ERROR 1.
[Magisk] plusminus_:
Slightly random but I'd like to say that I LOVE having the modules in /data/adb/ now, and the updated modules folder is just *chef kiss* (personally, it simplifies some modifications I make to modules I use)
[Magisk] kosiak07:
After install Magisk v19 I'm stuck at screen with "enter password to unlock mass memory".

On Magisk v18.1 is ok.

What should I do ?
[Magisk] kotuamoalt:
Yes.
[Magisk] vegetaleb:
Hello

I have Magisk 19 installed and everything is on the green when checking for safetynet, but my banking app is seeing root and doesn't allow to use it, what can I do to hide root state to this banking app?
[Magisk] guest4711:
Did you hide MagiskManager by repacking it to a random name (MM - settings - Hide MM)? And did you put the banking app on magisks hidelist? Probably you need to clear cache and data of the banking app afterwards to get it running.
[Magisk] R77:
I have had the ROM lineage-15 and lineage 16 PIE for the Moto X Pure. The problem is with magisk it didn't matter if I had 15 or 16 they both would boot up fine when I don't flash magisk. I had no problems with the Roms but when I flashed Magisk Version v18.1 it flashed successfully but when I rebooted it just stayed in the Android logo it turned off rebooted and did the same it never leaves the Android logo. I even installed the Magisk Manager Version v7.1.1 first and flashed Magisk in twrp but it still does the same. Is there a solution for this?
[Magisk] vegetaleb:
Thanks just did all that and rebooted but the banking app still sees root
[Magisk] ZeeSmilez:
Does Magisk work with Factory Treble ROMs? I tried installing Viper FX 2.7 but it doesn't detect the driver/module after rebooting and always asks me to install the driver
[Magisk] harrymason37:
Galaxy Note 5 Naugat 9/2018 update works like a charm :)
[Magisk] baldomo:
I have the same fastboot/bootloop problem, but when i try to rollback to 18.1, the manage always sais that Magisk is not installed, even though flashing the zip returns a success

And how did you do it?
[Magisk] n0j0e:
After updating to these builds no stuck-on-boot anymore!

Sent with much love & Android. OnePlus 5T
[Magisk] guest4711:
So have a look at [MENTION=4667597]Didgeridoohan[/MENTION]'s famous guide at https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHide
[Magisk] kotuamoalt:
OK. I got it working a couple of days ago, but I'll try to tell you what I did to the best of my memory.

I first tried to uninstall magisk using the manager. If I remember correctly, it boot looped to download at reboot at this point.

I then forced the phone into TWRP, and flashed the latest uninstall zip. It again was still boot looped.

I again booted into TWRP, and flashed my OS (Lineage) without wiping anything. ("Dirty Flash") The phone then rebooted normally, with everything intact. After verifying that the phone was no longer rooted, I rebooted the phone into TWRP, flashed magisk v.19., and rebooted the phone.

I then installed magisk manager v.7.1, and was good to go. If this does not work for you, I cannot help you any more other than to suggest that you search through the troubleshooting guides. Good luck, and let me know if it works!
[Magisk] siivet:
Updated magisk manager to 7.1.1 and now safetynet status is invalid. What to do?
[Magisk] niyas0:
Magisk Hide not allowing 'YONO' app to Run

Unable to access yono App due to rooted device. Magisk Hide also not working.
[Magisk] guest4711:
Did you toggle MagiskHide off and on again?
[Magisk] martyfender:
Did you try clearing the banking apps data in settings apps?
[Magisk] Heathmcdonald:
Snapdragon s9 support yet or will magisk forever need an unlocked bootloader?
[Magisk] forumi0721:
Hi,

When I use 19.0 - 7.1.1 magisk on MultiRom, magisk module did not load.

magisk su, suhide works great, but only module did not load.

/data/adb has module, but magisk didnot show modules, and did not load.

But 18.0 works great on multirom environment.

There's no user who use multirom?
[Magisk] chenqi:
Error
[Magisk] Bobthahog:
Same here on SM-G900P running Resurrection Remix 7.0.1. I just restored a backup in TWRP and all is fine.
[Magisk] Bobthahog:
Yes it needs unlocked bootloader. It changes the boot.img.
[Magisk] bluenote73:
Did you ever find a solution?
[Magisk] GryphonBR:
I got lucky in that the app was updated and apparently no longer manages to detect Magisk on its own.
[Magisk] heynando:
Google Pay is blocking me even though safety net passed

Should I go to version 19.0?

Edit: I updated to beta version 19.0 and Google Pay started working again, problem solved
[Magisk] n0j0e:
Try Magisk Manager #204 and Magisk #19001.

https://github.com/topjohnwu/magisk_files/tree/master/canary_builds

Sent with much love & Android. OnePlus 5T
[Magisk] xdauser'17:
hi,

im curious how magisk treats common files among different modules. is there any precedence while mounting files? the case is that i want to create a module to override some files provided by another existing module. any way to achieve this please?

thank you.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
If I remember correctly, whatever module was installed first takes precedence.
[Magisk] jcmm11:
What, exactly, do you want to do? Pretty sure I can tell you how to do it but I need details.
[Magisk] vegetaleb:
Yes

I think I have one of the slot with encrypted data (op 6t) could this trigger root flag on the other slot?
[Magisk] xdauser'17:
For example, I'm trying to replace some applets from busybox with those ones from GNU coreutils by creating another module, without changing the module Busybox for Android NDK's contents. (because it may upgrade in the future)

Actually I used to think about replacing some other stuff, can't remember right now though. :p
[Magisk] babyshark1983:
No root

Hi have magisk

But i check root it not rooted

Grand prime 530h

Custom rom 15.1 oreo

Plz what i must do

Thx
[Magisk] James_Oakley:
How are you seeing that it's not rooted? Try opening an app that needs root (I open the root of the directory tree used FX Root Access) and Magisk should pop up a dialog to ask for root permission for that app.
[Magisk] niyas0:
I did , but not working
[Magisk] James_Oakley:
Did what - exactly?
[Magisk] jcmm11:
This one's pretty easy. This assumes osm0sis' busybox. This also assumes you're going to create a personal use only installable module using the template. If you're going to publish it would need some modifications.

1) Make sure that you set POSTFSDATA=true within install.sh

2) modify post-fs-data.sh (common subdirectory in the template) and have it remove the applets you want to replace from the busybox directory i.e.

bbapplets="$MODDIR/../busybox-ndk/system/bin" (or xbin, depending on your device)
rm -f $bbapplets/cp
rm -f $bbapplets/mv

if busybox gets updated this will remove any updated applets. If you want to restore any busybox applets eliminate the rm statements for those applets and reinstall busybox.
[Magisk] kotuamoalt:
I was initially going to help, but I don't think I have the patience necessary to drag the needed information out of this guy.
[Magisk] xdauser'17:
haha, man, this is really a crazy idea. :laugh::good: although this way may not be "dry and clean", i'm pretty sure that it'll work in particular to this instance. thanks for the advice. :good:

so, back to the original question... the truth is, having multiple magisk modules that contain files with the same name is "undefined", right?
[Magisk] jcmm11:
I haven't really looked at it. Maybe I'll run some experiments to see what happens. For the moment we can just fall back on an old IBM phrase from their tech manuals. "Unexpected results may occur".

Multiple mods modifying the same file is why most of the audio mods use the unity template and have to also install AML, which resolves the conflicts.
[Magisk] niyas0:
Yono app is not working ,even with magisk hide

---------- Post added at 06:53 PM ---------- Previous post was at 06:50 PM ----------

am having the same issue and i tried all these above steps...It will close automatically without any error message.
[Magisk] James_Oakley:
You were saying you weren't successfully getting root with Magisk. Is Yono the app that is failing to request root permissions?
[Magisk] ahac85:
On Android Pie for huawei P20, how can i stop it from booting into the patched recovery on every boot? I want to be able to boot into erecovery or bootloader without flash the stock recovery ramdisk.
[Magisk] niyas0:
App is detecting that my phone is rooted. so not opening.
[Magisk] guest4711:
Ah, so you should add the app in question to the hide list... So root should be hidden from this app. If this does not help have a look at [MENTION=4667597]Didgeridoohan[/MENTION]'s famous guide at https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHide
[Magisk] guest4711:
Just tested.

Made two modules named "mod1" and "mod2". Both mount a file to /system/etc/test.txt whereby it contains "1" in first module and "2" in second. After installing the modules and rebooting file /system/etc/test.txt contains "2".

Renamed module "mod1" to "mod3" and rebooted to see if anything changed (expected it is evaluated in alphanumeric order so expected "1"). Result was "2".

So I could not verify there is a strict formula which module is evaluated first...
[Magisk] dd805bb:
Hide app and power off and power on. Rebooting via just hitting restart doesn't do what powering off and on does. I have read through a few hundred pages on this thread. Restarting vs power off and power on can help with a lot of problems. I found restarting holds some things in the background. It is like just a system ui reboot. Doesn't go off all the way and do the full boot. Just my experience. Doesn't seem like it would do much but try if having restart problems. I solved a few bootloops by powering down all the way and booting up. Depending on device but there is always a hold power and volume or something along those lines to do a hard reboot.
[Magisk] rollerce:
It seems like CM13 is still forcing encryption, even though magisk is supposed to disable it. any way around that? I'm on Shamu.
[Magisk] iamelton:
please dont quote the whole OP..
[Magisk] rollerce:
Apologies. Didn't realize that would happen. with quick reply. Lesson learned.
[Magisk] shoey63:
Doesn't work with suhide either. That's one tough banking app to crack[emoji15]
[Magisk] locolyric:
Not sure what's happened.

I successful to hide my root status using magisk and play pokemon go without any issue.

I flash another zip which is Onemoji , and now the magisk doesn't work with pokemon anymore. I can't play pokemon go with unknown reason.

Before this issue happened, when i set my root status to mounted, pokemon go will show the game unable to run with my phone.

But what happening now, with mounted or unmount status, it seems like the phone unable to connect to game server, no incompatible error screen. And i am pretty sure my account were not banned or deleted.

Anyone face the same issue as me?
[Magisk] got2best:
Tested and app started loaded login screen on 6p- magisk v6 - root status = unmounted
[Magisk] HtHNightwolf:
I had the same. Is had to disable XPosed Framework. Do you have XPosed Framework active? Disable it.

If your account were blocked the game would tell you "your account has been blocked"

If Root was detected the game shows "This app is incompatible..."

If you seem unable to log in, it is that you have no root but an activated XPosed ... so far from me
[Magisk] got2best:
Have not experienced this issue.. have you tried flashing magisk over top again? I don't see how it could hurt anything.
[Magisk] xu3sno:
Magisk and phh Superuser work just fine on Redmi Note2 (MT6975) with Bliss-Pop version 4.0.3, Android version 5.1.1.

I can toggle root status with Magisk Manager.

However, can't play Pokemon GO both version 0.37.0 and 0.37.1 :confused:

It said:

This device, OS or software is not compatible with Pokemon GO.

No Xposed installed. Don't know what's wrong!
[Magisk] got2best:
Did you un-root prior to installing magisk?
[Magisk] xu3sno:
Yes bro. I did follow exactly as OP's instructions. I uninstalled completely Chainfire's SuperSU.

Thanks for asking.

Have a great day!
[Magisk] Gamu79:
This is not a pogo thread:confused:

Pls stop posting pogo
[Magisk] Girish_J:
Can I use Emoji Switcher app normally?

I am confused, because I used adaway which modifies host files but I can still pass safetynet, but emoji switcher will replace font, so will it affect my ability to use android pay?
[Magisk] db77:
Hello,

Thank for this hard work !

Don't work for me, on Nexus 5 with Android 7.0 : PokemonGo don't launch (no Xposed, SuperSU 2.76 Magisk)

When I toogle Root, it return to untoogled 9/10 times :(

When it stay, I try PokemonGo, but don't launch
[Magisk] ammar18:
There is a separate thread for pokemon go, don't post those here.
[Magisk] Captain_Throwback:
Works fine here after toggling off root in Magisk Manager. Note that I don't have Xposed installed, which might also trigger the root warning.
[Magisk] got2best:
I tried using emoji switcher and did not work for me. Granted never did work for me on 6P rooted-stock 7.0 .. was able to replace emoji using the font file believe it's a .tft .. if interested I can find link I used. This method has worked with root mounted or unmounted.

I believe his issue is root switches back on magisk after switching it off... Not really a Pogo topic they could help him with. Sorry if out of place just my observation.

---------- Post added at 03:26 PM ---------- Previous post was at 03:21 PM ----------

Using phh super user?
[Magisk] hammerhead2:
I don't have xposed neither, but I am unable to run it.

However, I do have TWRP, and for some reason my phone says that it was modified when launching OTA check.

Might be TWRP, might be remains of CF autoroot...
[Magisk] Captain_Throwback:
I have MultiROM TWRP installed. The app shouldn't care about what recovery you have installed - that has nothing to do with root. It shouldn't be a verity issue either, as Magisk disables the verity check.
[Magisk] hammerhead2:
It might not, but for some reason it detects something as unauthorised modification.

Other than former cf autoroot (removed with cf supersu), twrp, magisk with phh's systemless root and systemless exposed which was removed with material design installer, my n910c is pure stock.
[Magisk] japr99:
Module install error on redmi note 5 pro Android 9

I installed andorid 9 in a redmi note 5 pro and when I install any module I always get an error.

https://photos.app.goo.gl/mmnxTzL6wE5LLGzb6

https://photos.app.goo.gl/Mr5NYe37FXqb2Yoz5
[Magisk] Soumy1234:
Recently, after I install some modules, I keep getting bootloops l. I had to uninstall and reinstall Magisk 18.1 a bunch of times and flash the ROM a lot as well. I can't install more than 3 modules at a time without it bootlooping, and when it does, I have to remove all the modules and start again. I don't think it's a specific module, I think it's multiple modules screwing up.