yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] guest4711:
Systemless hosts means that it does not write to /system. The hostfile is located at /sbin/.core/img/.core/hosts

So you need free space in in the root- rsp. sbin partition.
[Magisk] wannaskoo:
Okay, got it, but still i don't know why this weird behaviour happens
[Magisk] gerchev:
I have the following problem with magisk 17.1. When I try to browse and download a module, it says that magisk stopped and the application shuts down. I'm clearing his cache and data, but the problem continues.
[Magisk] DanGLES3:
Update to beta 17.2
[Magisk] gerchev:
I updated, but the problem remained.
[Magisk] Trakost:
Same problem even with magisk 17.2

Inviato dal mio ALE-L21 utilizzando Tapatalk
[Magisk] NYCHitman1:
Is it just me or does adb pull not work with newer Magisk versions (17.1+)?
[Magisk] A.lemane:
Be more specific please
[Magisk] Apexpredator12:
I am still having the issue, so what I did last night was uninstall the xposed installer version of the 87.3 systelmess xposed SDk 23, and tried to install the magisk version but it just boots on an endless black screen. So I disabled that module and then tried to install the xposed systelmess version again but I get an error in recovery saying that magisk is not installed even though it is. I have been trying all day looking it up on the internet trying to fix it but I can't seem to get xposed framework installed. It is really stressing me out so any help would be appreciated.

So I can't install xposed version it says using have magisk and the magisk version gives me a black screen.

Edit: If I try to install the version of systemless xposed I already had on it says you must have magisk 14.0+ installed. I don't know what's changed I have magisk installed.

I have even updated to the latest version of twrp, but still either get error 1 magisk is not I stalled or installed properly /data/magisk or whatever the address was, or I get zip is corrupted even though I have downloaded it a lot of times with different version of xposed framework
[Magisk] zoel.fahmi:
I've got this kind of error

Especially when using direct install

Any idea?

Redmi Note 4x, dotOS
[Magisk] A.lemane:
That's caused by one of ur modules

Probably incompatible
[Magisk] spawnlives:
I think your issue is (correct me if I'm wrong) is that the exposed has not been updated to to the new module template which is why it is saying you need magisk 14.0+.

You could try from the repo exposed framework(unity) which was updated recently.

For more info see here

https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/HomePage
[Magisk] Apexpredator12:
I managed to get it working by restoring a really old backup, the xposed I have installed is via magisk v 87.3 SDK 23, I daren't even try and update it again
[Magisk] störte:
Hi

I have a Note 9 (N960F) and use latest Magisk.

Today i flashed via Odin the latest Stockfirmware.

PDA N960FXXU2ARI9

CSC	N960FOXM2ARI7

After that i flashed TWRP and also Magisk 17.1 after rebooting i lost my IMEI.

Flashing untouched Boot Image restored it again. I tried it again with 17.2 with same result. No IMEI.

There where no Errors while flashing.

Then when i flashed the previous Stockfirmware and later Magisk 17.2 all went normal

PDA . N960FXXS2ARH6

CSC	N960FOXM2ARH6

Any idea what that could be. Somebody else faces this problem ?
[Magisk] zoel.fahmi:
Wow

Gonna check this
[Magisk] hallohallo222:
Hello,

could it be that tan2go (DKB banking app fron TANs) doesn't work?
[Magisk] jcmm11:
Assuming you have systemless hosts turned on in Magisk then you played with the Adaway configuration and set something wrong. Take this to the Adaway thread. Also make sure you specify what version of Adaway you're running, and any settings you changed from the defaults.
[Magisk] Test_subj:
Any idea why renaming manager is creating a duplicate? It seems to be because magisk isn't updating itself on the new name, so it installs a stub on the next boot. I'm not sure where to look for the problem though.
[Magisk] jcmm11:
That'll happen if Manager is installed as a system app (definitely not a good idea).
[Magisk] Test_subj:
It's not installed as a system app.

These are the only errors in the log:

09-27 19:58:33.534 13728 13728 E Magisk : select failed with 9: Bad file descriptor

09-27 19:59:53.879 14495 14495 E Magisk : select failed with 2: No such file or directory
[Magisk] martyfender:
I test unofficial versions of Magisk built on the latest code at the time and I used to see this kind of behavior back in Jan or Feb, not sure? But I must point out that I never hid the MM, then and still don't, with the exception of testing FGO, which will not run on my x86 device.
[Magisk] Test_subj:
Weird. I'm currently running 17.2 / 6.0.0(147). I have to uninstall magisk manager to play pokemon, then reinstall after. It works for now, but I'm a little afraid to reboot my phone.
[Magisk] JetlagFunk:
Hello, I have the same issue.

Magisk is on 17.2, working fine, but when I try to hide the Manager, after a while, it simply won't launch, and after a reboot, I have the stub reinstalled. So I have to uninstall the hidden Manager, and update the stub.

It's giving me issues with PoGo, and I don't really want to delete Magisk nor PoGo

Huawei CLT-L29 on Android/EMUI 8.1.0 (152C432)

Plz halp ?
[Magisk] ouzqan:
How fixed?

Lineage os 14.1

Android os 7.1.2

Phone z5 premium
[Magisk] bhadanamayank:
Dolby atmos not running on lenovo vibe k5 a6020 with aosp extended rom v5.7 after showing successful installation on magisk v17.1 . Dolby atmos is not showing in app drawer but installed module of dolby atmos can be seen in the magisk manager. This problem is occuring from v16.4 to v17.2 . Till v16.3 it was working great.
[Magisk] guest4711:
Did you update the module? Older ones are not compatible with current Magisk.
[Magisk] Artim_96:
I have quite a question about really hiding Magisk and all its traces from logging:

I have some WiFi trouble and in the device forum of the manufacturer they want a log of that (with dev options, USB debugging and verbose WiFi logging turned on), but obviously I don't want them to see any traces of Magisk and other typical root apps, that I partially have running as system apps installed via Module, like the F-Droid plugin.

But when I check the collected log file for those apps, they are mentioned there. I also tried collecting them in "safe mode" and even uninstalled the apps and disabled Magisk with a system update which replaced the boot.img before, but still I can find them, and manually clearing up the log is quite some work since I always have to make sure it's not obvious that something was removed.

So how do I hide all of them from those logs, at least for the few minutes it takes to record everything necessary? Or at least clear the log storage (which exists because I have dev options always enabled?) so when I boot to secure mode they are all prevented to be loaded and thus wont be mentioned in logs?
[Magisk] niyonsv:
I'm not sure if it's already posted. I've a suggestion/request that what about hiding the Magisk (Magisk Hide) for newly installed apps by default? I think only a few apps need the SU support (I'm not sure) so what about enable the Magisk-Hide for all other apps?
[Magisk] bhadanamayank:
How to update module i dnt knw

And if u hve updated dolby atmos module plz send the link
[Magisk] xunholyx:
This has already been posted about.

https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=77700018&postcount=27857
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
And also:

https://twitter.com/topjohnwu/status/1039528958289760256
[Magisk] niyonsv:
Thank you for the replies. I too thought of that. A few apps (like PayTM, but not now) requested root access a few months back. Also some apps (like Tez) uses other apps (like telephony, messaging, etc.; I'm not that sure but some workaround says to clear data of these kind of apps) to register or signing-in. That's why I thought of hiding Magisk for all apps except that need SU. No need to reply, thanks again. :o
[Magisk] guest4711:
Open MagiskManager and there the menu, Downloads. Click the desired modul and select " install".
[Magisk] gerchev:
I've solved the problem! I deleted the last three installed magisk modules.
[Magisk] goldmobile:
My bank application not opened after root. İ guess for this application Freeze :(
[Magisk] martyfender:
[MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] wrote on Twitter:

PSA: Stop being paranoid and hide tons of apps with MagiskHide! *ONLY* hide those you are *SURE* it's needed!

With the way MagiskHide works, too many apps could make the system unstable! Also don't hide apps like Chrome, it is used as system WebView provider WTF are you doing

10:59 AM · Sep 11, 2018
[Magisk] archpenguin:
Magisk Manager locked itself out

I changed the setting from allowing root access to apps & ADB to ADB only; unfortunately, now Magisk Manager cannot open at all, so I can't change the setting back. How do I fix it? Is there an ADB/terminal command I can use to manually change the setting and grant Manager access to its own settings again? I already tried running Magisk from ADB as SU, but it didn't work.

Magisk 17.1, Magisk Manager 6.0.0, ZTE Axon 7 with LineageOS 15.1, log says: "Magisk: (ERROR) Root access limited to ADB only!"
[Magisk] yochananmarqos:
It's just you. Besides, adb pull does not use root let alone has anything to do with Magisk.
[Magisk] 1immortal:
guys, i need a little help, if possible, please:

I need to set these values of build.prop:

ro.secure=0

service.adb.tcp.port=5555

persist.adb.tcp.port=5555

i'm running a Galaxy S8+ rom with latest magisk pre-installed in the rom.

my initial idea was to use resetprop from magisk to set these, but i'm having some issues in setting them correct for the init.d folder.

what it the correct structure syntax i need to use for it to be set as it should on the system ?

Thanks
[Magisk] Nebrassy:
Just uninstall magisk manager and reinstall it, that should reset the settings

I don't think the crashes are caused by changing that setting though

---------- Post added at 11:52 PM ---------- Previous post was at 11:50 PM ----------

Try https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/module-magiskhide-props-config-t3789228
[Magisk] archpenguin:
That's what I thought at first. I have in many combinations of testing reinstalled, installed the previous stable version, wiped cache/Dalvik, rebooted, flashed Magisk over itself, and still no dice. The log comes up the same every time. I don't believe the setting is in app data.
[Magisk] Nebrassy:
The setting is in magisk manager's shared prefs, which then controls magisk's settings in /data/adb/magisk.db

try running the uninstaller then flash magisk again, if that doesn't work I think the only other option is to edit that db manually
[Magisk] goldmobile:
Not supported
[Magisk] bixirulo:
Hi all,

When I install magisk, I am not be able to charge after turn the phone off. I turn it off, put the usb cable, and the phone stuck at boot screen. If I uninstall magisk, I am can see charging screen with phone off again. I have tried 17.1 and 17.2 on a xiaomi Mi A2 oreo 8.1

Somebody with this issue?

Regards!

edit: with magisk 16.6 there is not any problem
[Magisk] Danny1976:
I keep loosing root on version 17.2 and have to reboot to get root back. I am using Nokia 6.1 2018 on Oreo 8.1. I search this thread and someone in May or April had the same issues, but no one replied to him. Any idea on a fix?
[Magisk] Aki_9982:
magisk manager crashes whenever i try to open magisk hide tab in the latest stable version(17.1) on havoc 2.0 pie mido

is anyone faceing same issue?

if anyone has any fix then plz tell me i would really appreciate your help;)

i even tried rebooting and reinstalling it again but it's no better
[Magisk] Gallion:
My Nexus 6P keeps failing SafetyNet for unknown reasons and the problem is usually intermittent but this time I can't seem to make it go away. It's on stock 8.1. It fails both CTS profile and Basic Integrity. ro.build.fingerprint looks okay (I haven't needed to change it in the past). Magisk is the only root thing I have. Magisk is obfuscated and hidden. I don't know what I'm supposed to do at this point. I recently attempted an OTA updated which failed, but SafetyNet still passed. Then the phone ran out of battery. Now SafetyNet won't pass. Automatic updates are disabled. I have no idea what caused this to break.
[Magisk] bobby janow:
No it doesn't. Yes there will be.
[Magisk] topjohnwu:
Guys, I know Samsung MM is broken, you don't need to report again and again :)

I'll add this to the OP after I get home.

Unfortunately I do not have one of those devices (only get a Sammy crap that is stuck at 5.1 and will never receive Marshmallow...), I still need testers for Samsung MM, thanks.
[Magisk] l1ttl3z:
Im also not able to make a purchase. I can pass safetynet and AP opens up but then fails
[Magisk] SirVilhelm:
Same thing with me on AP, I pass safety net but cannot make purchases. Nexus 6P, August update.
[Magisk] LLStarks:
Well now...

I got AP working on my OPO running CM13 with Magisk and phh superuser. Had to delete /system/xbin/su (/system/bin/su too?).

Yes, adding cards and payments worked.

This project is already a success as far as I care. I hadn't been able to do mobile payments since the final days of OG Wallet.
[Magisk] usvimal:
I tried fully unrooting my device, then installing Chainfire's SuperSU (Magisk version) but SuperSU says that I have no root. How do I fix this?
[Magisk] rnpasinos:
looks promising... i sure hope you'd be able to make it work on s7 / s7e devices... keep up the good work!
[Magisk] dhepaa:
Is it possible to flash this on locked bootloader using flashfire? Im on LG G4
[Magisk] ninjazx:
I am also very interested in this answer. I'm also on Verizon LG G4
[Magisk] fjdifede:
Did you dirty flash your stock rom or boot image after you do that and be before doing anything let your device start and try Android pay or your bank app if working then reboot in recovery flash magisk then the su recommended here after that Xposed you can do all that in one installation let it boot and you'll be fine don't forget to wipe dalvik an cage

---------- Post added at 05:35 AM ---------- Previous post was at 05:29 AM ----------

This is amazing work the beginning of a new development, thanks for your hard work this will definitely make a starting point to endless possibilities. One more time thank you!!!
[Magisk] carlosggb:
Count me in bro, Sprint Note 4 MM 6.0.1 - Ready for instructions, i will clean flash and wait for you :good:
[Magisk] teddy0209:
No... Unless your device allows modification of boot.img w/ locked bl... ?
[Magisk] taufikthexfader:
Flashed successfully on my nVidia Shield Tablet K1 Stock ROM 1,3 (Unlocked BL, Marshmallow 6,01), i havent tested AndroidPay since this tablet doesnt support it, i will test non compatible root Heroes of Incredible Tales tomorrow to test if the root toggle is working.

Thank you for your hard work to make this systemless manager possible, this will make root mode and non root mode as easy as 123 :D
[Magisk] KaMyKaSii:
deleted
[Magisk] devilloki:
huawei honor7 TL01H cann't install

my devices is huawei honor7 TL01H ,soft ver is EMUI4.0.1 - 6.8.1,

reboot, display

"pls update system"

"boot.img load failed"

upload log,pls help me.

ths.
[Magisk] jbaumert:
[MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] - A couple of us with Moto X 2014 are having this error:

"Fastboot Reason: Fall-through from normal boot mode".

Magisk appear to flash fine, but when rebooting the phone, it is stuck at the bootloader. (Re-flashing stock boot.img fixes it) Any thoughts?
[Magisk] wmarcin:
Another PureNexus user [N6] here - for me the toggle to turn off root in Magisk app won't stick. Just bounces back to root enabled.

Great work, nevertheless! Hope to see it working on Pure Nexus Roms too in near future.
[Magisk] :
Stock + Gravity Box [N6] works great. I had the toggle back n forth issue with DU.
[Magisk] FPSUsername:
OP2 user here, root doesn't get enabled. I can let it stick when I drag and drop the switch, but it doesn't activate it :/

Only "fix" is to not give root access to the app. Idc about android pay, as long as xposed + root works (systemless)
[Magisk] LLStarks:
phh is kinda garbage. If you revoke access for an app, you can't get it back.
[Magisk] djrion:
I'm stuck in the spot above too.

Phone/OS

Oneplus 3

CM13 Official (tried unofficial too)

Clean flash of CM13, flashed gapps, flashed Magisk, magisk su, and magisk xposed

I've also flashed the unSU

Magisk Mng only shows Root Toggle on and SeLinux on. when I turn them off, they flip back on within a few seconds...
[Magisk] teddy0209:
Clean install or not, you're still using CM, so that's not clean at all... Check for leftovers in your system (su)... I believe you can delete it in twrp file manager.

---------- Post added at 11:41 PM ---------- Previous post was at 11:36 PM ----------

As I said above, CM is not clean at all... You have to remove all traces of the included superuser...
[Magisk] juangcardoso:
Really? Screenshots, please!

Going to try later.
[Magisk] DerpleNerple2000:
Sadly, it didn't work. Spotify running and playing music, but Viper only reports being enabled, but not processing.
[Magisk] esrvR:
Did you uninstall the old v4p before flashing the newer version??
[Magisk] kelvinpichinini:
m.imgur.$$$com$$$/a/GkdhN

Delete the $$$
[Magisk] Starvirus:
is there a possibility to debug it more, since i flashed Magisk v6 via TWRP on a Axon 7 (A2017G - unlocked bootloader, Stock Rom B03), Magisk manager detects magisk v6, but nothing is toggable nor exist a log in /cache/magisk*.log

Logcat didn't show any sign of magisk either, it starts only with system booting.

Any idea how to debug it more?
[Magisk] AmbientLights:
On CM13 nightly you have to go to dev settings and enable root access for apps and adb after flashing ROM and Gapps. Then install supersu from play store and open it. When it prompts "supersu binary needs to be updated" click cancel. Navigate to settings and click full unroot. Then go to recovery flash magisk stuff
[Magisk] Äptiva:
Personally I feel it's better to do the removal prior to first boot. TWRP supports adb so why not do it all as part of the flashing process?
[Magisk] djrion:
how? unSU did not work for me.
[Magisk] Äptiva:
adb rm -f /system/bin/su

and

adb rm -f /system/xbin/su
[Magisk] Captain_Throwback:
TWRP also has a file manager, so adb isn't even necessary.
[Magisk] Äptiva:
True as well. I just like adb to avoid those oops moments
[Magisk] ViXoZuDo:
phh magisk config

Someone knows how to config the phh magisk ed with eng mode? In the regular version only needed to change 1 file... in this edition looks likes you have to change the script...
[Magisk] arsenal3010:
Is there any solution for this ?

Anyone please help !
[Magisk] stangri:
Do you mind elaborating in which way(s) is suhide better in hiding root?

Also, you do realize that magisk is a systemless framework, the option to temporarily unroot is a beneficial side-effect, not the main purpose, don't you?
[Magisk] JudgeDread11:
There is no need to flash the template. It's an 'empty' template to start creating your own modules.
[Magisk] ReaperXIII:
I have no idea but I guess it has something to do with the boot.img. For Xperia device, we have the option to install TWRP in the FOTA kernel. I think Advanced kernel is installing it in the FOTA kernel while EliteKernel have it inside the kernel. That's why when we flash this mod, it alter the content of the boot.img which in turn made the custom boot.img corrupted.
[Magisk] Lord Meshadieme:
So far what i have done is

- Full unroot supersu

- reboot

- flash uninstall for xposed

- wipe dalvik and restart.

- flash original firmware

- wipe dalvik and restart

what else should i do to get safety to pass ?

thanks
[Magisk] RichardEb:
I have a Feature request: Magisk should show a notification if there is an update for a module from the magisk repository. I'm using YouTube Vanced and doesn't realized for weeks that there was an update.
[Magisk] yochananmarqos:
In the meantime, you can join the Magisk Modules Update channel on Telegram.
[Magisk] davidteri91:
Patching the boot.img from magiskmanager app makes magisk work but SafetyNET is not able to work without install magisk.zip from recovery ...

Inviato dal mio Xperia XZ1 (AOSP) utilizzando Tapatalk
[Magisk] jenslody:
Do you have by any chance androidwebview and/or chrome hidden ?
[Magisk] archpenguin:
It wasn't a Magisk Manager issue, nor a permissions issue! Figured out it was the module I installed titled "Universal SafetyNet Fix". I didn't figure out it was the problem at first because I only noticed the problem when I went back to the Manager to hide a bank app. Re-flashed Magisk and used MagiskHide Props Config instead (to fix my ctsProfile:false issues). To be clear, everything worked except for the Magisk Manager app (thus changing any settings) with the Universal SafetyNet Fix problems.
[Magisk] BillGoss:
You could put a shell script in the Magisk service.d folder. I've attached one that I use. See the comments in the file for details.

Note: rename the file to file_name.sh (I had to change the extension to txt to attach it to this post)
[Magisk] Aki_9982:
nope bro
[Magisk] Aki_9982:
i thought i should provide some logs

hope anyone finds it helpfull in finding the problem I'm having
[Magisk] RichardEb:
I don't have telegram ) :
[Magisk] jkccl9:
I'm having same problem but now my other apps are crashing and freezing now 17.1/.2 on DU
[Magisk] Aki_9982:
i fixed my issue by removing two module i.e universal doze gms and playstore visa and magisk is working fine now

what modules are you using?

try disableing some module before removing any
[Magisk] jkccl9:
I don't have those modules but tried uninstall and reinstall earlier version of magisk. BlackPlayer EX and reddit sync is still freezing/crashing fml probs gonna do a wipe soon upgrade to android p Thx anyways

Edit updating to 6.0.0 manager causing crash in magisk hide tab even when I'm on 16.7 with no modules
[Magisk] Aki_9982:
instead of 16.7 use 15.3 or 15.4 version it's the most stable version if u consider nougat and Oreo but uninstall magisk using the latest uninstaller

i feel like you should try installing the 15.4 just oncekeep the wipe as last resort

try not updateing the app for once
[Magisk] jkccl9:
Something broke on my phone after the magisk update or something else rip. even after uninstal some apps don't work, defo gonna have to wipe. At least it forces me to update to android p now ?
[Magisk] jenslody:
As first try you should always run Magisk in core-only mode (see settings of Manager), to be sure no modules crash Magisk.

If you have universal safetynet-fix (or PetNoire's SafetyNet Spoofer! ) installed, you should uninstall it and (dirty) reflash Magisk, because these modules unconditional overwrite Magisks internal busybox with a version that is partly broken on some (all?) devices.
[Magisk] Aki_9982:
bro do one thing extract the boot img file from the rom zip and flash it to boot in recovery that should almost fix all the issues