yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
I haven't looked into the app in question, but if it's using loopback devices in any way, Magisk releases before v16.6 might interfere.

[MENTION=4270006]metropical[/MENTION] Have you tried the current beta release?

Patch a copy of the stock boot image with the Manager (there are instructions in the release thread) and flash it to your device manually. If it doesn't work you just flash back your stock boot image and it should go back to normal.

I know nothing about your device though, so if it's non-standard it might have issues... Make sure to have a backup of any important data.
[Magisk] bakemcbride21:
Anyone else in NJ with a rooted/Magisk Android phone that cannot get Draftkings or PlayMGM apps to pass location check even with them in Magisk Hide (I have a Verizon Pixel 2)? The MGM people told me my phone fails the geolocation check because I have Magisk on my phone....so they're scanning it (perhaps like how Pokemon is now doing it?)
[Magisk] JimZiii:
Ok, not much progress since last time, magiskhide still don't work but I read your magiskhide troubleshooting guide again and it said I can check for apps mounting/unmounting and even though I get logs I can't remember seeing that. So I typed in the logcat command and at start it says

"Note: log switch off, only log_main and log_events will have logs!"

And I'm also on a huawei phone which you wrote often have logcat disabled.

Googled it and found huawei have a project menu where you can enable all logs, you can reach it through a dial code. But for some reason the dial code isn't working, it just brings me back to the call log.

So if you or anyone else know how to activate logs another way or get the project menu working please let me know
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
That could definitely be the cause...

I guess you saw this: https://www.xda-developers.com/huawei-phones-disable-logcat-heres-how-to-restore-access/

There's a comment to that article that mentions that the code doesn't work anymore, but unfortunately no more info.

I was gonna suggest you start looking for help in your device's forum (Honor 8, right?), but I see you've already done that. :good: Let's hope you find something about it, and if you do please share so I can put that in the wiki.
[Magisk] gFknQ:
Sorry if this is off topic [MENTION=4667597]Didgeridoohan[/MENTION], but I received this notification in manager, but could not find any further information about official beta release
[Magisk] martyfender:
That is because you have a custom update channel set in MM settings, for [MENTION=3306843]kantjer[/MENTION] 's unofficial builds. If you want the official, 16.7 beta, you have to set it to the beta channel in MM settings.

However, the unofficial builds have many fixes since the official beta was released, such as the safety net check.
[Magisk] gFknQ:
Ahh, makes since. Didn't think about switching channel. Many thanks!
[Magisk] martyfender:
One of the fixes in the unofficial builds is the safety net check fix.
[Magisk] gFknQ:
Yeah, that was working for me unofficial build 16.7. Actually everything was working very well. And all processes are lightning fast. New to the unofficial builds, but so far, love them a lot.
[Magisk] xshunin:
Only with the time workaround. It does not work for me with 16.7
[Magisk] Floston:
Hello

How can fixed the problem of hiding the Privat 24 application ?

v16.0

redmi note 5 (f/w 9.6.3.0)
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Well... At least this post ended up in the correct thread... :p

Basics of hiding root from apps:

https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHideHidingRoot
[Magisk] Floston:
Hide worked, but after reboot stopped working.

deleting, reinstalling privat 24 does not help.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
There are a whole lot more things to try in that link than just reinstalling the app... Give them a go.
[Magisk] kroening.s:
I got it working now.

Reformatted /data of my OP3T with EXT4, it was F2FS with encryption before.

I don't know if it had something to do with it, but now it works permanent:confused:
[Magisk] Floston:
it seems to me that you can not hear me - the private 24 application can use a fingerprint to enter the system.

Everything worked fine after installing v16.0, but after reboot - the fingerprint entry in Private 24 stopped working.

privat 24 sees that there is a root... and what's the reason I do not know
[Magisk] sk8223:
Um... I'm playing FGO on my Redmi Note 4 (mido) that's treblized. I'm using LOS 15.1. But I'm using a custom Magisk build from here: https://gist.github.com/Jerry981028/b6a7fdfcf1823325c2f94f83677fa554

However 16.7 works with Treble devices. So it should work... I need to try FGO on my Magisk 16.7 device again. The first time I tried it worked.
[Magisk] yochananmarqos:
Did you try anything listed on the page he linked? If you did, you haven't mentioned it.

I installed Privat24, immediately added it to the hide list then opened it. I don't have an account, so I didn't enter a phone number or agree to the terms. It did not complain about root, but it's possible it doesn't check until later on in the setup.
[Magisk] squaresmile:
Are you playing FGO NA with the latest update? The JP version still works but the latest FGO NA update detects Magisk.

Edit: looks like the JP version updated with the same root detection like NA.
[Magisk] xunholyx:
have you tried hiding Magisk?

Magisk Manager > settings > hide Magisisk Manager?

The go to settings > the app you want to hide root from > Storage > Clear storage

After you do that (if you haven't already tried that) reboot your phone and it should work
[Magisk] bakemcbride21:
That does not work. And as a side note if you have developer options enabled then the play MGM app won't even start and tells you it cannot run with that enabled.

I think it's similar to the Pokemon Go issue as it scans your storage for the magisk folder. I've read for PG that if you do the Magisk hide, and hide magisk manager and repackage as a random name, then delete/rename the Magisk storage folder and rename the downloaded magisk zip that works. I think it could for me but what happens to my edge sense module if I were to do all of the aforementioned?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Nothing. The MagiskManager directory is only for storing downloaded module and Magisk zips, and logs. It is perfectly harmless to delete it... Next release of Magisk doesn't even use it anymore.
[Magisk] bakemcbride21:
Thank you. I went and did the Hide Magisk Manager and then renamed my Magisk zips and folders. Though it was a little hinky at first. I was getting a system app force close message and my keyboard wouldn;t come up in any app. My phone would then turn the screen off and come back on (like ahot restart maybe....it wasn't a full reboot) and it would ask me for my PIN to get back in like it did a reboot.

A full reboot cured this behavior and now both apps (Draft Kings/PlayMGM) work and the phone is behaving as usual. I now don' have to feel TOO degenerate by not having to carry a second phone that I put back to stock in order to bet lol
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Just out of curiosity: Did you touch any of the files or directories in /data/adb or /sbin/.core? If so, don't... Those are core files of Magisk and cannot be detected by any apps that don't have root access anyway. Only touch any files or folders directly in your internal storage, nothing else.
[Magisk] bakemcbride21:
Hello. Appreciate the inquiry. I only went to settings and selected the Hide Magis Manager option. Then renamed the Magisk install zips that I had on my internal storage to ksigam, renamed the MagiskManager folder to ksigam and deleted all of the contents of that folder (which were downloaded modules, etc).

I did not touch/rename anything in those directories..

I have a Verizon Pixel 2.....was lucky to hop on it and get it for the month (December) that you could unlock/root it. It's always been a little peculiar. Almost whenever I restart a lot of times it just sits at the Google G screen and thinks for minutes then I force another reboot and it boots properly. It keeps me on my toes!
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Ok, thanks. I was just asking because none of the issues you mentioned should have anything to do with renaming those files or folders.

Randomly getting stuck at boot might be a Magisk issue that have been fixed for the next release.
[Magisk] mobileman88:
Seems that safety net is failing today
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
It's probably just having a bad day. After a good nights sleep I'm sure it'll be back in action.

Nothing wrong here. It's something on your side...
[Magisk] zelendel:
With google being able to target not just regions but directly to devices this may not be a valid optional view point soon. Just because you are not seeing it will not mean Google is not doing something.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
That's a possibility. But I've not yet seen any signs of this. Most of the times it's simply a case of the user having to toggle MagiskHide off and on, or that something else has been changed on that users device. Who knows... Today might be the day it happens. :D
[Magisk] zelendel:
Cant say I have ever seen it with this set up but we have all seen it on other things like server side roll outs and tests. Heck recently Google completely changed an app on devices, so I wouldnt put it passed them. But again without a log we really cant tell and I cant be sure when my stopped. I have not made a single change to my device in a couple of months. (no real need to) Nor do I pay attention to if it passes or not.
[Magisk] martyfender:
It is working fine for me, here in the United States, on 4 devices, with the latest unofficial builds with the Safety Net fix for MM.
[Magisk] metropical:
TextAide issue

[MENTION=4667597]Didgeridoohan & yochananmarqos[/MENTION] - as it turns out ............ fixed it. toggled expansion in TextAide and Accessibility . rebooted.
[Magisk] Dragonknigh:
How does rooting with magisk for multi users work? I have magisk root working on my main user and I have selected "User Independent" in Multi user mode but it's not working for all other users (I checked with root checker). What am I missing here?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Have you installed the Magisk Manager on the other users?
[Magisk] KleberRomeu:
I installed the custom rom Ressurrection Remix 8.1 in Galaxy On 7, but Pokemon Go does not enter. I saw that the magisk hide can solve, but when I install the magisk it appears that already has another app in the system, but it has not. What do I do?

This message appears: boot image patched by other programs
[Magisk] Shagrinar:
Hello,

I flashed my OnePlus 5T with Resurrection Remix 6.1.0 and OpenGAPPS Stock for ARM64 and Android 8.1. I'm using Codeworkx TWRP 3.2.3.0.

After flashing both RR 6.1.0 and OGAPPS and formatting the data partition the phone boots up. But when flashing Magisk 16.0 the phone goes directly into bootloader and refuses to boot to system...

Do you have any clue how I can fix this problem?

Thank you in advance!

Best Regards!
[Magisk] Floston:
the problem with Privat 24 was solved when the application was patched hide root, thx https://4pda.ru/forum/index.php?showtopic=226055&st=3320#entry76070403 ( file is changed \smali\ua\privatbank\ap24\utils\DeviceUtil.smali )

perhaps it will help you to modify in future versions of Magisk

p.s. Privat 24 is a very popular application, so do not ignore requests that are similar to my ...

anyway thanks.
[Magisk] DroidJP:
Hey xda members

Can anyone explain what Safety Net really checks for or how it really works? I ask because i integrated app updates into the system partition and that really freed up space on the data partition.

The system partition has about 704MB free space, and i know there will be no more firmware updates for my phone either. That is unused space that can be put to good use lol.

Anyways, so far attest app is passing safety net after app updates has been integrated as system.

The goal here is to make use of every bit of space available.

Thanks
[Magisk] peterlee928:
https://developer.android.com/training/safetynet/

https://www.nowsecure.com/blog/2017/08/03/android-apps-google-safetynet-attestation-api/
[Magisk] mobileman88:
Thanks! It was indeed... everything's back to normal.

I have a banking app which failed. Not sure what's preventing it from working :

Tried the following :

- Hiding Magisk

- Core Only mode

- Rename MagiskManager folder

https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.uob.mighty.app
[Magisk] stab244:
Not passing SafetyNet here but I also just updated my Op3t from 5.0.4 to 5.0.5. Tried uninstalling and reinstalling to no effect.
[Magisk] mobileman88:
How can I trace what is causing that app to detect root and close? Once I give it Android permissions it tells me I am rooted. I am on P
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Give the beta release a try.

Nobody was ignoring your request for help. I was simply giving you the tools to help yourself (a long list of things that have worked for hiding root from other apps).

First thing to try is to toggle MagiskHide off and on. If it doesn't work after that:

https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHide

Phone permission? Also add the phone (com.android.dialer) to the Hide list and try again.

Other than that:

https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHideHidingRoot
[Magisk] mobileman88:
Thanks man. I am using Magisk 16.4 and have tried everything other than the props values. For now, I shall just use that particular banking app on my old Samsung phone. Was hoping I don't have to.
[Magisk] HatRiGt:
i have installed a magisk module which causes me bootloop. so could someone tell me is there any way to manually remove the module ? i tried to uninstall magisk and reboot the phone . phone got booted into the system and works fine. but when i flash magisk again and then i boot into system, i get stuck in bootloop due to that magisk module gets triggered on install of magisk. so someone tell me is there any way to manually remove that magisk module.
[Magisk] Oswald Boelcke:
Maybe you like to tell us more about your system and the module you're talking about? Logs can always be pretty useful.
[Magisk] Aki_9982:
Guys use magisk 15.4 stable and everything is working execpt saftey net check and which can be checked through saftetynet helper from playstore hope i was helpfull
[Magisk] HatRiGt:
i have oneplus 6 . installed hydrogen os based on pie. i tried to install auto brightness magisk module

https://xdaforums.com/oneplus-6/themes/mod-brighter-adaptive-brightness-t3796846
[Magisk] NLBeev:
as said already; not enough info.

In general you have the options to restore the system from a previous backup. Or a factory reset and clean flash of your rom.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Wrong thread. That's the Beta development thread. This is the one for general troubleshooting.

https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magis...agisk_functionality_bootloop_loss_of_root_etc
[Magisk] guest4711:
If you have installed MagiskManager for Recovery you may use it to deactivate the module in shell of TWRP.

Otherwise you may force "core only mode" of magisk, boot to system, open MagiskManager, re-disable "core only mode" (then you will see more menu entries like "modules"), and deinstall the module in question.

To force " core only mode", yo must restart into TWRP. Open the shell and create a file named ".disable_magisk" (mind the dot, it's necessary) in /cache.

touch /cache/.disable_magisk

. Reboot. Magisk should start in core-only mode (without loading any module).
[Magisk] Watanabe_You:
An app I use had an update today and now detects root or something. I was on latest magisk beta, do I make an issue ticket in github? I was told to do that but iirc johnwu purged and requested it not be posted there anymore.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Check through this and see if you can get it working again:

https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHideHidingRoot

What app? And why do you use the words "root or something"? What are the symptoms?
[Magisk] Galaxy Y User:
Seem like with the latest update of FGO for both the NA and JP version is able to detect Magisk. Have already tried MagiskHide and Repackaging but still detected, luckily my Oneplus 5T have an update, so I flashed the new update without reflasing Magisk. Both version now work eventhough the Magisk App still present in the system -> FGO has not start to detect package and app name but a new detection method. Will try to get a log on both the JP and NA version.
[Magisk] Watanabe_You:
This app https://www.google.com/amp/s/m.apkpure.com/fate-grand-order/com.aniplex.fategrandorder/amp

What it detects:

Build.prop values which was long patched

Magisk Manager (OP fixed in the introduction of randomising package name

I said "root or something" because it might be detecting newer stuff. I've tried renaming the magisk folder but it still fails. Same goes with core only mode
[Magisk] pijas82:
Hi, on OnePlus 3 niteogenOs 9.0(pie)

I lost calls and notification with 16.7

Without magisk it's ok

---------- Post added at 12:44 PM ---------- Previous post was at 12:43 PM ----------

I will sabre log soon
[Magisk] AquariumVitae:
(((Update: from what I read here (https://github.com/Suicide-Squirrel/issues_oreo/issues/13) this must be a error related to LOS 15.1 on the LG G4 with enabled encryption.)))

(so nevermind if it is not Magisk' fault!!!)

I am feeling lost because in this thread I almost only find problems about running Magisk installations and none about ptoblems in the install process.

First I downloaded Magisk (v16.0) from the official announcement thread, installed the zip with TWRP, rebooted, installed Magisk Manager (v5.8.3 from same thread).

Magisk Manager says that the newest available version is the same as the installed version. It offers me to check that SafetyNet (failing, I know, just cosmetic problem), select "Preserve ...". Also "Install"

The side menu offers "Magisk", "Settings" and "about".

Where is the functionality of Magisk, how do I use?

I also used the manager to patch the current boot image from corresponding ROM installation zip, flashed this one, rebooted. Nothing different. Used the uninstall zip in recovery, finished with no errors. Flashed again the magisk zip, in TWRP flashed the mount magisk zip, that one now tells me that no magisk installed. now iterated through installing magisk via boot.img and zip, flashed the uninstaller and the mount magisk zip, started again and again to look for changes in Magisk manager.

I feel as if I am out of options.

LineageOS 15.1 on the LG G4 H815
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
[MENTION=7986756]AquariumVitae[/MENTION] Are you saying that you don't see MagiskHide, Modules or Downloads in the hamburger menu? Do you have Core Only Mode enabled in the Manager settings?
[Magisk] krule031:
Hello [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION]

I have a little bug that I hope you could solve.

There is a problem on Huawei devices on treble with magisk installed, fingerprint sensor to be exact. Treble dev told to send you this and said you will know what to do.

Here: https://github.com/phhusson/device_phh_treble/blob/android-8.1/rw-system.sh#L53
[Magisk] rexmako:
My x626 can't pass safety net check. I need help. I have done everything humanly possible but to no avail. I have installed latest magisk manager and magisk. I've installed device spoofing tool 4 in d module but still cannot pass safety net. Pls I need some assistance...
[Magisk] Terrigible:
What modules do you have installed?
[Magisk] rexmako:
Just two as shown in the pic
[Magisk] Terrigible:
Do you fail CTSprofile, basicIntegrity, or both?

EDIT: Also, do you have Xposed?
[Magisk] rexmako:
Both
[Magisk] AquariumVitae:
These screenshots show all I get in the Manager. There are no such options in settings. (it seems that the forum software refuses to display the 3rd screenshots showing the settings page.)

I'll try to fetch the TWRP log from flashing Magisk etc. - if you need it.
[Magisk] sk8223:
Looks like FGO JP now detects Magisk with the latest update with error code 61. I'm on a custom version of 16.0. Tried a custom Treble version of 16.6 for the Redmi Note 4 and same problem. Tried 16.7 and and it doesn't work it all. You guys are right :/

But hey, Nox still works: https://www.bignox.com/blog/fix-fgo-crashing-issue-nox-update/

Maybe you can partially pass SafetyNet, like my LeEco Pro3 Elite. If you can find Netflix in the Play Store you pass SafetyNet. I just instaled Magisk 16.7 as normal and hid it in Magisk Settings. It still passes SafetyNet (kind of) because I'm able to see SafetyNet apps. Magisk seems to be broken right now though
[Magisk] Terrigible:
Try using another SafetyNet Check app like this one: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.scottyab.safetynet.sample
[Magisk] rexmako:
This is the result
[Magisk] Terrigible:
Can I have the exact model and ROM of your phone? Also, do you have Xposed? Have rooted with SuperSU prior to this?
[Magisk] rexmako:
Ok, sir. No, I do o not have Xposed or ever rooter with su. My phone nodel and ROM
[Magisk] demonoidmaster:
And your rom? What gapps do you have? Custom kernel? Maybe your obscure barely known phone must not be in googles database

If it's a stock rom that came with your phone it could be that it just fails safetynet because of whatever rom they have on the phone they sell
[Magisk] Terrigible:
Even if it is obscure, it should pass basicIntegrity. ctsProfileMatch is easy to fix.

---------- Post added at 04:24 AM ---------- Previous post was at 04:23 AM ----------

Can you disable your modules and try again? Or even uninstall Magisk if you want.
[Magisk] FMXP:
If you updated your 5T without re-flashing Magisk, you are unrooted. However you have discovered something interesting. FGO works when you are unrooted because it doesn't detect the repackaged Magisk Manager app. This means that FGO is detecting Magisk itself, not the Magisk Manager app. This is useful information for topjohnwu.
[Magisk] byReqz:
After i tried to upgrade to Magisk Manager to 16.7, i was stuck on the bootloader again. So i tried flashing 16.0 but it said "Couldnt repack Boot Image" , i flashed my stock boot.img and im still getting this error

yeah on oos 5.1.11 on an oneplus 6
[Magisk] kiki059:
Hello need help

Safey error ..

My setup :

OnePlus 6

Stock 8.1

Magisk 16.7

Someone have a link for version stable?
[Magisk] julien712:
Hi,

You have to download and flash the unofficial version :

https://github.com/kantjer/MagiskFiles/blob/master/Magisk-v16.8-2018083011.zip

And download the last magisk apk :

https://github.com/kantjer/MagiskFiles/blob/master/MagiskManager-v5.8.4-2018083011.apk

(This is the latest version)

And enjoy !
[Magisk] robbayani:
Goood.. its fixes some problem..

temporary using this UnOfficial, wait Official..
[Magisk] chris1486:
Hi, I'm facing an issue with installing the debloat module on magisk v16.7. Currently running Cardinal AOSP v8.1. I've attached a log file with the error which indicates insatllation of Magisk 15+ but I'm already on 16.7.

Anyone else faced this issue?
[Magisk] aydinbahadir88:
Yes fixes the safety net, but magisk hide it does not work :(
[Magisk] :
If I install Magisk, can I still get OTA on my Samsung phone?

If so, can anyone teach me how to do it?
[Magisk] tom1807:
Thank you, worked perfectly.

Noted today that I couldn't use Google Pay and banking app detected root.

After updating to 16.8 and installed MM 5.8.4 all is fine.

Only tiny problem was, that MM refused to install, so I had to uninstall 5.8.3 and after that it was fine.

Cheers

Tom
[Magisk] kiki059:
I have this error msg its Normal ?

(Sorry about that, but we can’t show files that are this big right now.)
[Magisk] Quinny899:
Request the desktop site and then click "view raw"
[Magisk] kiki059:
After install .. answer is invalid :(
[Magisk] kiki059:
So too my sim card is not enabled :'(
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
[MENTION=4643897]cbd dvd[/MENTION]

https://xdaforums.com/search/forum/5903?query=Cannot mount /vendor
[Magisk] Terrigible:
Try this: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.scottyab.safetynet.sample
[Magisk] kiki059:
I uninstall magisk .. now I want reactivate my card sim :(

I don't want reset factory all