yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] UMU24013:
That did not help. SafetyNet passes. Added Samsung Music to the hide list, cleared app data, hidden the magisk itself. But it still detect root and quits. Various root checkers show that the device is not rooted when I decline their su reqests.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Does it check the Knox counter? If so you're probably out of luck...
[Magisk] rachit011:
Hello, my device passes safetynet but I cannot use a particular app(Tez).

Tried magisk v14.3, v16.0 and v16.3. Used magisk hide as well. For some people it works on the same rom and kernel as me.

Device : leeco le2 x526

Rom : aospx 8.1.0

Gapps mini

Tried on both stock and custom kernel.

Any help is appreciated. Thanks.
[Magisk] Pkt_Lnt:
Read the posts above about Tez, there are many and I think I remember seeing a solution.
[Magisk] UMU24013:
For some reason several knox bit checking apps and the samsung info app show that warranty is valid and the bit is not set. It is 0x0
[Magisk] Iod77:
I can´t buy apps at Samsung Galaxy Apps

Hello,

I have installed Magisk root in my cellphone Samsung S7 (SM-G930F) with a custom ROM (Superman ROM.). I already tried to hide the Samsung Billing at Magisk Hide to allow I can buy an app at Samsung Galaxy Apps, but it didn´t work. Does anyone know how to trick Samsung Galaxy Apps in my root cellphone to I can buy an app there? My Knox status is 0x0. Thank you.
[Magisk] UMU24013:
Well, I just flashed a completely stock firmware. And the Samsung Music app DOES work with it. So the Knox counter has nothing to do with the problem.

UPD: After I flashed TWRP and installed Magisk on this stock firmware, the Samsung Music app stopped working again.

What else can I try in order to make it work with Magisk?
[Magisk] madbat99:
Might be detecting recovery or any number of things. Or modified boot.img, dmverity, etc
[Magisk] ssojyeti2:
Is there a way to view a download count for magisk modules? I remember this feature existed on Xposed, but is it possible for magisk? I'd love to be able to check how many users I have :)
[Magisk] demonoidmaster:
Yeah ik it's fixed
[Magisk] :
Still not work...
[Magisk] bipinbedi:
Most of the times u l get safety net failed error on OP3T beta 25, please check the logs attached. Although the apps work fine.
[Magisk] Jaymin.0.1910:
+1 over here.
[Magisk] guest4711:
You would get the number of downloads, not the number of users using the module now...
[Magisk] ssojyeti2:
Regardless. I want. Lol
[Magisk] peterlee928:
fyi mm crashes 1-2x every time i open it. from what i can gather, it does work.

see attached log.

p2xl google variant

stock rom april update

no custom kernel

magisk 16.3 beta

systemless xposed

selinux permissive app installed (ibuprophen's app)
[Magisk] mctiew:
I need help. I did some updates of the modules then suddenly i realised in the downloads section, it becomes 'no modules found', as though it unable to go to the right repository. The modules I installed are still there. I can't install other modules, check updates.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
You'll need to provide a logcat from when the app crashes if there's gonna be any chance of knowing why it happens...

Make sure you have an internet connecting and pull down to refresh.
[Magisk] peterlee928:
thats what i thought my log was. i grabbed the log immediately after i was able to open mm after 2 crashes. please let me know if you need any additional detail.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
You posted the Magisk log, that's something different. Open the link I posted and you'll find info on the different kind of logs.
[Magisk] HigherStateD:
Moto E4 Qualcomm with resurrection remix room. Every day or so, magisk will show as not installed, requiring a reboot. Please help
[Magisk] Wolfcity:
Provide at least a magisk log and a logcat as the guys here are no clairvoyants. Also magisk/android/TWRP version would be helpful.

Have you tried to uninstall/reinstall magisk?
[Magisk] Encik Panda:
Cant really wait for Magisk to work on Galaxy S9+. Wont root it before Magisk settled the problem on new Sammy's device.
[Magisk] MojoManagement:
I have got a Ulefone Power 3s with a Helio P23. Magisk v14 is working, but every other version above not.

I am not able to get any log with >v14, is there any chance to find the problem?
[Magisk] Lucifer20:
I think I found A bug in magisk. I had disabled superuser in magisk settings but still solid explorer was able to get a root access. More over it didn't prompt.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
What exactly is it that isn't working? Details please... And there are many kinds of logs you can provide. Take a look here: https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHelp

If Solid Explorer was granted superuser access right before you disabled superuser requests in the Manager, it would still be in memory as having elevated privileges. I'm guessing that as soon as you clear Solid Explorer from the recent apps list, it'll fail at acquiring superuser access.

If you on the other hand can disable superuser and still get root access with a completely new instance of Solid Explorer, there's something very wrong, yes. In that case: logs!
[Magisk] Lucifer20:
No I did not give any permission to solid explorer
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Like I said: logs!
[Magisk] Lucifer20:
I have just installed it. And before that a clean flash. On restriction remix rom on osprey
[Magisk] crimemastergogo9999:
I tried the method but it didn't work.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
What does that have to do with grabbing logs of a possible issue?

If you've found a bug, the right way to go about reporting it is to give a detailed description of the issue, preferably a description on how to reproduce the issue, and of course logs (logcat, etc).

If you can't provide info on how or why the issue arises, and no way to reproduce and test, there might as well not be an issue...
[Magisk] MojoManagement:
Installation works, but bootloop with all versions above Magisk v14, my TWRP version for Power 3S also not mounting /data correctly after reboot.

I will check the provided link if there is any chance to get a log after bootlooping
[Magisk] Zam1000:
Should I flash the patched Boot.img as BL in odin?

---------- Post added at 02:11 PM ---------- Previous post was at 02:02 PM ----------

When I have flashed the patched boot.img and the device reboots, then comes this "the device could not start verification error reset the device". What went wrong?
[Magisk] HigherStateD:
Tried both magisk 16.0 and 16.3. current Verizon is 16.3. Android version 7.1.2. twerp is 3.12. the latest for Moto E4. Not sure how to do a logcat, sorry. Will attach the log though.
[Magisk] prathamb:
Install magisk

I have Lenovo k3 note with marshmallow, I have mooded twrp 2.8.7 installed, with SuperSU version 2.46 installed. I am thinking to move to magisk , how should I install magisk and use it as app to manage root permission ?

Thanks for help
[Magisk] martyfender:
You must first remove SuperSu.

https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/HomePage
[Magisk] prathamb:
Thanks .. ?
[Magisk] kiko60:
Hello All,

I tried to flash root with magisk to my device. I faced safetynet was shown error. How can ı fix it?

Device: Samsung Galaxy Note 3 -N900 with stock rom.
[Magisk] Pkt_Lnt:
Try these ideas.

https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHideSafetyNet

From this excellent page (I suggest you bookmark it!!) :good:

https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/HomePage
[Magisk] peterlee928:
thanks... murphys law - i dl-ed the app, and now mm running fine. ?
[Magisk] hacker001:
I have some question

I try to install magisk on my ifive mini 4s (rk3288) but it's unsuccessful

It shown "unable to unpack boot image"

I uninstall supersu and restore stock boot already but it doesn't work

please advice me about how to fix it thanks
[Magisk] Pkt_Lnt:
Complete instructions and extensive troubleshooting solutions here, including how to get logs to post so someone can see how to help you:

https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/HomePage
[Magisk] hacker001:
I have some question

I try to install magisk on my ifive mini 4s (rk3288) but it's unsuccessful

It shown "unable to unpack boot image"

I uninstall supersu and restore stock boot already but it doesn't work

please advice me about how to fix it thanks

send you a installation log

thanks you for your advices
[Magisk] ananthakrshnan10:
Can we flash the official Magisk over a Treble ROM after flashing custom Magisk? Will it break the ROM?
[Magisk] Hiempsal:
Hey guys,

Since I've rooted and flashed CM 12.1 on my phone, I have been receiving errors from Magisk "Magisk Manager has stopped working". It happens when I launch it one time after a reboot, and every time I try to download a module.

Maybe you can help figure out what is the problem, and what I can do about it o/

BTW, I have Magisk 16.0 and Magisk Manager 5.6.4 installed.
[Magisk] guest4711:
Perhaps the permissions are not (really) granted. Try to switch "storage" permission off and on again. If this does not help, (make a backup and) deinstall MagiskManager and reinstall it afterwards (you have to setup MagiskHide and RootAccesses probably again).
[Magisk] Antoine164:
Hello everyone!

I've got a problem. Magisk 16.0 crash when refreshing downloads by pulling down.

I'm using RR OS Nougat. No xposed. I tried clearing magisk cache and Magisk repo cache, nothing worked.

I attached a log if anyone can help. Thanks.
[Magisk] DenyDarko:
It's already fixed.

Wait for the update.

Till then you can go into settings and clear repo cache and refresh it. It won't crash that way.
[Magisk] guest4711:
It's a known problem on some devices and already fixed in [MENTION=3306843]kantjer[/MENTION]'s unofficial builds. You msy either wait for an update or give the unofficial builds a try (you must uninstall the official MagiskMsnager before).

Current snapshots by kantjer can be found here:

https://github.com/kantjer/MagiskFiles
[Magisk] Antoine164:
Thank you for your help and the time you took to explain me this! I'll wait for an official update, it's not a big issue for me, I can still update my modules even if it crashes. Thank you again.
[Magisk] Kobushi:
I am having issue installing 16.3 on my redmi note 4x(lineageOS 15.1), it keeps sending my device in a bootloop. 16.0 works but doesn't seem to be able to update/install the manager 5.6.4 apk. Mostly trying to get Pokemon Go working again. Anyone got any suggestions?
[Magisk] Artim_96:
The manager apk is inside the Magisk zip. If it's not getting installed properly just extract the apk and install manually
[Magisk] Kobushi:
I'm not sure where to insert the manager 5.6.4 apk in the 16.0 zip, tried a few places but when I try to flash with twrp if always throws error and abort instalation
[Magisk] gothicVI:
You don't have to flash the apk. Just sideload it or use a file manager.

Gesendet von meinem Moto G 2014 LTE mit Tapatalk
[Magisk] Kobushi:
In both instance it says "apps not installed", is it possible the redmi note 4x is not supported yet?
[Magisk] martyfender:
Did you, by chance install the unofficial build by [MENTION=3306843]kantjer[/MENTION] , by chance? If you did, it is created with a different signing key. If that is true, you must first uninstall the existing Magisk Manager, to get the beta Manager apk to install properly.
[Magisk] Artim_96:
Sounds like a corrupted installation. Or really incompatibility for some reason.

Use a file manager (maybe best would be the one in TWRP) and delete the folders /data/app/com.topjohnwu.magisk and /data/data/com.topjohnwu.magisk if they already have been created, then try again with both apk files from the arm and arm64 folder. I don't know if you have the Qualcomm or the MediaTek version, but on the latter I wouldn't even be surprised about problems
[Magisk] md1982:
Hi just wondering if not passing the safetynet check is a major problem what do i loose out on if anyone knows?
[Magisk] Kobushi:
Magisk was 16.0-cust found on the lineage 15.1 install page (https://xdaforums.com/redmi-note-4/...other-development/rom-lineageos-15-0-t3690465) and the manager was from the xda thread about 16.3.

Just tried the "vanilla" 16.0 and it gets me on the same bootloop as the 16.3...could the unofficial treble lineage be the cause of the issue?

It is the qualcomm version so arm 64 I should go for technically

Edit:

So turned out I needed to erase all magisk components and install the 5.6.4 manager then go in twrp to flash the treble enabled custom 16.0 version...my netflix and online banking apps are working as well... thanks for everyone that helped.
[Magisk] md1982:
My magisk is failing safety net cant get xposed to work in fact cant get any sort of mod to work on it magisk even force closed when i tried selinux on it this is the first time iv used systemless root must say im not impressed iv got the xz1 compact build no 49 iv not got all the detals to hand as im at work the xz1 at home im stuck with this problem any help would b great thanks
[Magisk] andynx1:
Here's an odd one.

I have a working v16 running on LOS15.1, no issues. Then I get an update announcement, for... v16. Magisk manager is showing that Magisk is no longer installed, so I try to update, the update fails.

But, magisk hide still works and I still pass safetynet! So despite saying 'not installed', it's still working.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
No-one is trying to impress you... :laugh:

But, I do have some reading for you:

https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk

---------- Post added at 11:00 ---------- Previous post was at 10:54 ----------

The issues like this might have something to do with MagiskHide not being able to relink files after hiding. But, I unfortunately don't have much data to verify this theory (pure guesswork).

A magisk_debug.log might show a little, and what does "the update fails" mean (logs, please)?
[Magisk] luinloke:
I can confirm this bootloop is happening on my Mi A1 as well on the March and April 2018 OTA updates. The strange resolution in my case was to force the phone into fastboot mode; then boot into an original boot.img (not flash) (even if it's the March boot.img instead of April for example) and the update will complete upon restart. Once done, another reboot is needed to "refresh" the latest update is installed as shown in the kernel build number. Magisk still shows as installed after that. Not sure why but it appears the device is checking whether the boot.img is modified upon the first restart after the update is installed.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Wrong thread. That is not an issue with the current beta release. It's an issue with the module you're trying to install... Ask the creator to update to the current module template.

And please don't post the entire log like that. At least use HIDE tags if you can't attach a file.

Since you're not actually working with the current beta release, I'm answering you here instead.

Many apps do not use SafetyNet to detect a device that's been tampered with. They have all kinds of different root detection methods. More reading about that here:

https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHide#hn_Hiding_root_from_apps

One thing that is not yet documented there is manually hiding sub-processes to the Hide list, like has been shown to work for Pokemon Go and Microsoft Intune. This will very likely be implemented natively in Magisk in the near future (which is why I've not added it to the guide).
[Magisk] Jaymin.0.1910:
Yes, you're right.

And fortunately, I found this PR
[Magisk] Rom:
Magisk Manager crash when when update Download list

Hello,

My Magisk Manager crash when i want to update the downloads list, i have got install 9 modules, all of them works fine, but when i naviguate into "Downloads" tab and swype from top to bottom to update the modules downloads list, Magisk Manager app crash.

I must clear the Magisk Manager repo download cache in Magisk Manager, and the update list work again, but if i repeat this task by make again the swype in "Download" tab of Magisk Manager, it crash again.

Apparently there is no error(s) in the Magisk log, so i have started an loggcat reader, reproduce this bug and send the txt loggcat in attachment.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Should already be fixed:

https://github.com/topjohnwu/MagiskManager/commit/684c5d225a28de616cdffa327af2ac222d708523
[Magisk] halfbytecode:
[MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION]

Magisk v16.0 does not seem to detect decrypted or wiped data partition. I have to flash the no-verity zip file.

The Magisk output from TWRP log always has that encryption was detected and force enrypt is being enabled.

In Magisk manager, disabling force encryption has no effect too. After disabling it, if I reopen magisk manager, force encryption is again enabled.

My device is One plus 5T running codeworkx's latest TWRP build.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
The forced encryption checkbox in the Manager only has any use when you're installing Magisk. If you want to disable forced encryption, uncheck the checkbox before doing a direct install. If you're installing through TWRP, run this command in the TWRP terminal before flashing the zip:

echo KEEPFORCEENCRYPT=true>>/data/.magisk

Is your data really decrypted, or are your just removing the forced encryption flag?
[Magisk] Rom:
Yeah i had already check if i have the last version (5.6.4), i got it, but the problem persist..

So i expect that my loggcat file will help for debugging.
[Magisk] halfbytecode:
Thanks for clearing that up. I have always had SuperSU in the recent past.

Yes, my device is really decrypted now. I flashed the no-verity zip. As a confirmation, when I boot TWRP, it's log no longer has any entries about decrypting data partition. The settings within Android also say my device is decrypted.

I had read that recent versions of magisk had a way to detect if the data partition is decrypted, and it is not required to write to the .magisk file.

Anyhow, the TWRP log displays that magisk detected the data partition as encrypted, even when it is not.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Manager v5.6.4 was released March 28 and that commit is from April 6. It's not available in any official release yet...

Yes, Magisk is supposed to detect if /data is encrypted or not. Might be a bug in the detection somewhere...
[Magisk] LivArt:
Does Magisk survive LineageOS 15.1 OTA updates? Thanks :)
[Magisk] jenslody:
It normally does, if the ota-zip supports addon.d.

This should normally be true.
[Magisk] BigMatza:
I think I just realized what's contributing to all this madness: The overzealous ZTE power management on the Axon 7. I'm gonna try tweaking these settings a bit. If I can't find something that works, I'm leaving the stock ROM behind.
[Magisk] martyfender:
Download the Magisk Manager on, from here:

https://github.com/kantjer/MagiskFiles

uninstall your current Magisk Manager, then install the latest one at that link.

You have to uninstall first because this one is signed with a different key.

I had been using the unofficial builds for some time, but yesterday I reverted to the official 16.3 beta with the latest Unofficial Magisk Manager because in the latest 3 unofficial builds I eventually get the messsage that Magisk is not installed and I loose root. That has not happened yet with v16.3 beta after almost 24 hours.
[Magisk] hungvip2001:
Hello. Sorry for my English. I have a question. If I install magisk then my phone 's performance would slow down or effect ,...?
[Magisk] gothicVI:
Personally never experienced that and am also not aware of it.

Gesendet von meinem Moto G 2014 LTE mit Tapatalk
[Magisk] martyfender:
I do not see any performance hit with Magisk vs SuperSu, but it is possible I see a slight hit on battery life.

The slight hit on battery life might be due to other things I have running on the system such as Lspeed, Greenify or Apps2sd, their services running or others. I'm not sure.
[Magisk] Rom:
Ok so i can replace the official one on my phone by yours or i must wait for an update from topjhonwu, right ?
[Magisk] martyfender:
I'm talking about replacing the Magisk Manager, only, since it has the crash fix in it when refreshing the download section. And it is not mine but [MENTION=3306843]kantjer[/MENTION] 's, built from the latest commits by [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION]. There are full Magisk installs and the manager only. You need the manager only.
[Magisk] andynx1:
Log attached.

Anybody got any ideas?
[Magisk] tormie:
Thank you, you saved my life :) My GF couldn't play Pokemon GO
[Magisk] Nkaskaj:
Can someone help me please?
[Magisk] mlavende:
Hi, as far as I know I have Magisk root enabled properly and all seems to work fine. I can use Safetynet to confirm this and if I toggle using Magisk Manager it says I should be able to run AP. (Currently I'm on build 3.24 of OxygenOS on my OP3 and that has AP broken so I can't check :()

I just ran Root Validator (nice app) and with root disabled via Magisk Manager it says no root found which is great. It does however say I have BusyBox installed at /system/xbin/busybox. Is that a problem? I thought there wasn't supposed to be anything added at /system

Thanks

-Mat
[Magisk] HcNguyen111:
I was looking for the same thing. Couldn't find one... so repacked the one from http://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=57514832&postcount=75 into a Magisk Mod myself.

Note: this does NOT include Viper4Android like the zip you linked to. All it does is enable stereo mode by enabling the earpiece speaker (which is what you requested).

IMPORTANT: Nexus 5 ONLY.
[Magisk] mlavende:
Hi,

I have the same phone and OS version. I'm sure I read somewhere that OnePlus broke AP in the 3.2.4 release. I've only just got the phone so I'm waiting for the next release to see if they've fixed it.

Thanks

-Mat
[Magisk] Ice_machinE:
I have done that now and will try it later, thanks :)
[Magisk] duartix:
I think this should be stressed in the FAQ, as "may soft brick your device" is much more serious than "doesn't work on Sony devices".

I too ended up with a soft brick on my Z3 Tablet Compact. It wouldn't even boot to recovery. :crying:

Had to connect to PC to fully flash a stock ROM to recover the device. Will have a few more hours of rooting + installing recovery + flashing rooted ROM before I get is as it was before this ordeal. :p
[Magisk] grep_i:
Updating the binary does not mean your not rooted.

Also you never mentioned you was not rooted before.

You promptly stated that you from a stock boot.img (kernel and boot thingies) I assume that you mean by this that you flashed the boot.img

After that installed three things in a particular order root, custom kernel and Magisk.

I'm pretty sure this combination is senseless if you wanna use Magisk.

Try to read the installation instructions better and try again please.

As for your other problem if you were rooted before you did try this and had already given root rights to apps than after doing this the allowed list stays the same.

If you were never rooted before than you definitely have an issue but as far as I know you do not have to be rooted before installing Magisk stronger yet it is preferred you are not.

The rooting you will do from within Magisk so from this point on you should probably unroot completely.
[Magisk] -Happy Feet-:
Hello, some apps like Better Battery Stats or Wakelock detector can't read the Alarms, or Kernel Wakelocks. Is that normal?
[Magisk] desztan:
Has anyone try magisk with supersu? Does it work?
[Magisk] Nkaskaj:
Getting Error: 1 in Magisk

Can someone help me please? I am getting Error: 1. Recovery log: http://pastebin.com/UimEcwM4 Installed stock rom, twrp 3.0.2-0, factory reset done, un-rooted, sm-g361f
[Magisk] Surfinette:
First I want to thank the OP for his great tools. Keep the good work!

Then I want to flag that I was able to install the ElementalX kernel after the whole installation process (including systemless root and xposed). This could prove useful in case you have to upgrade ElementalX (no need to go through the whole Magisk installation process).

Everything seems to work OK for me so far, except that some root apps are popping-up complaints after I toggle to unroot ;)