yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] 1droidmod:
Hello!!

I have been using magisk for a good while now. tonight I went into the latest magick manager which I have installed and tapped Superuser because I had just downloaded an app that asked me to grant rights. I just wanted to see if it showed up there but every time I tap Superuser magick manager crashes. I can't figure out how to get it not to. I tried flashing my original stock image and then start over and reflashing Magic that did not help either..

Anyone else with this issue?
[Magisk] jenslody:
Clearing the data of MagiskManager usually helps.

You will not lose any modules, but all your settings and granted root-rights.
[Magisk] 1droidmod:
[MENTION=8340552]jenslody[/MENTION]

did the trick, thank you very much.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
I can't say much about the first part. Not my forte...

But, I can say that the current Manager (in internal testing) works perfectly fine on stock Android 5.1.1 on my Nexus 6.
[Magisk] Izzysoft:
I had to disable automatic updates as fdroidserver failed to find the certificates. Which means either the app had not been signed at all, or it uses v2 signing without v1 signing. I don't know where you've installed the app from, [MENTION=4667597]Didgeridoohan[/MENTION] (a different source might mean a different file) – so let me specify that I refer to the one attached at Github.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
When I'm talking about internal testing I'm referring to a Magisk Manager provided directly by [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION], for testing by a small group before it goes out to the general public. The code for it is not yet on GitHub...
[Magisk] Zepar7:
Problem I am facing is its not showing universal safety net fix module in module section anyone else facing similar problem can someone suggest some fix
[Magisk] zachar.89:
Guys how often You get updates? on my Redmi Note 3 Mtk with Resurrection Remix i get updates nearly every day... And its anoying...
[Magisk] iluvatrix:
I've just flashed magisk 14 on on Next it Robin on official Los 14.1.

When I used magisk hide to hide Citibank app the app is still able to detect I'm rooted. While the app still allow me to continue to use I'm just curious why it is detected?
[Magisk] yochananmarqos:
No, it does not. Termux & NeoTerm don't "muck" with anything. The both have their own Linux environment.
[Magisk] azZA_09:
Where can I find a link on how to convert a v3 template to v4? Its not my module, but in the 14.3 update, all the modules under v4 shows "No information provided"
[Magisk] DenyDarko:
AFAIK a locked bootloader will check if the boot image is signed by the manufacturer and will not proceed further if it's patched/modified by 3rd party tools.

You can try though and unlock it again if it won't work for you.
[Magisk] walid77dz:
Hi,

Thank you for this great tool. Please help us to root our " Lenovo K10a40". Here is a link to my stock boot image and thanks in advance.

https://ufile.io/11esi
[Magisk] Sirius_Balzier:
Hey! I've done a backup of everything, and tried to flash Magisk through CWM on my Huawei Y520 (MT6572 of course). The point is, when i see the logs, it says Magisk is only for LP 5.0+ and my phone is 4.4.2 KK. Tried from version 12.0 to 14 (current) and nothing can be done. So, is there a version available for KK nowadays? Hope anyone can provide it (a link would be useful, as rules says, or Topjohnwu will be upset lol jk :laugh:) My goal is to give it a try on this chipset (and for magisk hide of course.) Thanks in advance for anyone :D
[Magisk] dilshahdirar:
Someone Help me with this. I cannot install anything. Not even a single module

:crying:

See attached screenshots

Log :

10-25 07:49:09.372 9028 9028 E Magisk : mount /dev/block/loop2->/dev/magisk_merge failed with 13: Permission denied

I have been trying to solve this error. I cant install any modules because of this.

What i have tried so far

* Magisk 14.0, 14.3

* Flashed Firmware Twice

Device is Lenovo P2 (P2a42)
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Magisk never worked on KitKat and never will...

That's the same issue that Moto devices with the flawed f2fs implementation have. Loop mounting doesn't work...

If it's a similar thing on Lenovo devices (which wouldn't be surprising, if the parent is having the same issues) you'll need to use a custom kernel with a fix for it. Or, I haven't seen anyone reporting about this so I have no idea if it's possible, but maybe change to ext4 instead?
[Magisk] dilshahdirar:
Thanks for reminding me about f2fs. I missed to format data partition from f2fs to ext4
[Magisk] risya896:
does mandiri online still work you? i can't get it to work on my phone after doing all of the above.
[Magisk] Sirius_Balzier:
Oh, ok. Feel so bad, but it's the device, i'll try sudohide instead.

Anyway, thanks a lot. :D
[Magisk] walid77dz:
Hi,

Thank you for this great tool. Please help us to root our " Lenovo K10a40". Here is a link to my stock boot image and thanks in advance.

https://ufile.io/11esi

Sent from my Lenovo K10a40.
[Magisk] Tron_Legacy1680:
I have a Moto G3 XT1550 running ResurrectionRemix 7.1.1, have this ROM installed since months, comes preloaded with Magisk, worked great all this time. Now suddenly Magisk says it's not rooted and 'functionality greatly limited'. No apps can detect root either. Should I flash the Magisk uninstaller zip and then flash the latest Magisk zip(or the latest SuperSU zip)?

Thanks in advance!
[Magisk] easytotype:
Hi all,

I am developing a Magisk Module and I'm facing some simple issues.

Hopefully a Magisk module developer could shed some light and help me sort this out.

Thread: https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/developing-module-framework-jar-files-t3695060

Thank you.
[Magisk] Pkt_Lnt:
Try a simple reboot first.

What Magisk version? Magisk beta 14.3 is an attempt to stop that root loss, but does updating work for you with a pre-installed Magisk? Most of us update via the Magisk Manager by changing channel from stable to beta.
[Magisk] Tron_Legacy1680:
Tried rebooting multiple times doesn't work. Magisk version is 11.6. The Magisk Manager App says 'cannot check for updates, no internet?' and if I tap on that it takes me to the install screen with the option to download the latest zip with version 'v-1.0'(obviously not right).
[Magisk] DenyDarko:
You realize that you're using a VERY VERY outdated version right? I mean if 11.6 is not a typo.

I would suggest to download the Uninstaller zip and the latest beta 14.3 zip installer, enter recovery, run the Uninstaller and the 14.3 right after.

Then clear cache and reboot
[Magisk] Zepar7:
Is magisk supporting android o
[Magisk] Wolfcity:
On most devices yes.
[Magisk] Bwangster12:
Currently on 5.1.1. Lollipop with my LG K7 using SuperSu... but see there have been mixed results with flashing Magisk on Lollipop. Has anyone had success? I'd hate to reenable all the changes and apps I've disabled, remove SuperSu, only to find that Magisk doesn't work.
[Magisk] Pkt_Lnt:
oops, nevermind, I need coffee
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Depends... I have had very few issues when I test Magisk on Android 5.1.1 with my Nexus 6. The latest beta (v14.3) have worked perfectly. YMMV...
[Magisk] Bwangster12:
If I rooted with Kingroot.... can I just totally uninstall Kingroot through the app, boot into TWRP and flash Magisk? Will I pass Safetynet? I thought I saw something saying that if I disabled any apps (which I did with Kingroot and App Quarantine) or made any changes which I have with L Speed... I'd have to undo everything?
[Magisk] Tron_Legacy1680:
Ok I'll try that.

Thanks!
[Magisk] tomiga:
I created a systemless font ZIP to use a custom font on my phone. When I use it, SafetyNet no longer passes with MagiskHide (it used to up until recently, did a bunch of troubleshooting to realize it was this, figured this would be the LAST thing to cause a SafetyNet failure). If I disable it, I pass SafetyNet just fine. Does anybody know if there was an update to SafetyNet to check for custom fonts (and if so, wtf), and if there's anything that I can do about it in my module?

Module is for Samsung Nougat-based ROMs.
[Magisk] AlexBMoto:
Hi, using the Moto g4 xt1622. I went through the process of unlocking my bootloader and installing the latest twrp for my device and tried to flash the magisk zip. Unfortunately everything I've tried so far has not worked and only results in my device failing to boot each time magisk v14 has been "successfully" flashed. Can anyone suggest a reason why I'm unable to use magisk?
[Magisk] Pkt_Lnt:
See this section -

Here.

https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/official-magisk-v7-universal-systemless-t3473445
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Your module looks fine and I tested it without any issues. It's something about your device/setup.

You can try keeping dm-verity and/or forced encryption when installing. More details here:

https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/guide-magisk-troubleshooting-t3641417
[Magisk] tomiga:
That is so bizarre... The only thing that I could imagine changed was updating iYTBP's Magisk module, and even then, I did a clean install of Magisk, reinstalled all of my modules one by one, all passing SafetyNet until I use my custom font ZIP. Then, it fails...

I'll have to dig deeper into it some time this weekend, maybe try a completely stock ROM with Magisk.
[Magisk] zimler:
I was on unofficial V14 and am getting the same signatures do not match error and I cannot get offical 14 or plus to install. I'm on a Pixel XL. I searched the thread and this was the only post I found. I did try flashing the uninstaller, too. Any ideas?
[Magisk] Mandeep Hundal:
Greetings XDA members,

I'm totally new to systemless root,

Can someone tell me how to root,

Please explain the process.

My device is rooted, so do I have to unroot it?

Do I still need to flash SuperSu binaries?

If yes, so after flashing magisk or something.

Do I need to flash custom boot. IMG?

I'm using 5.1 version of android

Thanks in advance.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Some answers:

https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/guide-magisk-troubleshooting-t3641417
[Magisk] Титан:
Crashes when I open #superuser tab in 5.4.0, so I use 5.3.0 and don't have this problem
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
I'll try to make it work on KitKat and below (but without Magisk Hide)
[Magisk] Grv0541:
I'm Using S7 edge Running Superman Rom with Natorious Kernel And I'm Losing Root access Again and again (v14) never Had This Before Any way to Solve This ?
[Magisk] Sirius_Balzier:
Good luck man, it will be awesome! :D

Hope you can do it :good:

(Magisk hide can be later, possibly anyone would do this later :) )
[Magisk] robollama:
Moto G5 Plus here, lost root overnight. Rebooted and it seems to work now, but I always fail safetynet regardless if magisk hide is enabled. What's the solution for getting the safetynet back to passing after losing root?
[Magisk] papzi57:
[/COLOR]Please kindly love [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION]: Make us an easy-to-use Magisk version for the Oxygen Oreo!

:crying:
[Magisk] neep8:
Moto e3, g4 and redmi note 4 all loosing root and needing reboots to temp restore
[Magisk] FearMyAnus:
Hi! Do you think there'll ever be a chance we'll be able to pass SaferyNet while having xposed installed?
[Magisk] mobileman88:
It;s already been mentioned many times. It will never happen
[Magisk] FearMyAnus:
Do you know why that is? What's preventing it from happening? Even though it's systems systemless it doesn't pass, do you know why?
[Magisk] Zepar7:
Magisk failed on Android oreo. After installation not able to install any other app thought i got root acess and was able to install modules
[Magisk] mobileman88:
it interferes with the integrity checks done by safety net, system or systemless, its modified
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
Some info:

https://xdaforums.com/apps/supersu/suhide-lite-t3653855/post73337773

And some drama about Xposed + SafetyNet :D:

https://xdaforums.com/apps/supersu/suhide-lite-t3653855/post73974904
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Also, there's this:

https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=73691464&postcount=4200

If that's something you're expecting to get help with you're going to have to post some more specific

details

and

logs

.

---------- Post added at 08:51 ---------- Previous post was at 08:36 ----------

Have you tried clearing data for the Manager after updating to v5.4.0? That might solve it.

There's a possible fix for this quite common issue in the works.

You could try v14.3 beta. There's been some changes there to keep the daemon from dying. It might fix it, but there's also reports that it doesn't always help with root loss.

It doesn't work if you just toggle Hide off and on?

For clarification: Have you ever been able to pass SN on your device? If not, it's because Moto messed up f2fs on your device. A custom kernel that's fixed the issue or changing the data partition to ext4 might help.

Really? Wait. Just wait...

The losing root problem is a tough one. Have you tried the v14.3 beta?
[Magisk] robollama:
Sorry I guess i was a bit vague. Yes, I previously passed safetynet (using custom kernel ElementalX), but since I spontaneously lost root overnight, I no longer pass safety net. A reboot fixed the root problem, but did not fix safety net failure.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
What about toggling Hide off and on again? If that doesn't work, some logs might be helpful (magisk.log, magisk_debug.log, etc).
[Magisk] Izzysoft:
Thanks for the details. And update from my end: Issue seems to be solved, the APK from the release page now integrated fine. So I've turned auto-updates back on for the app in my repo.
[Magisk] neep8:
No I haven't tried the beta I will give that a go just now and see what happens.
[Magisk] robollama:
Toggling Magisk hide doesn't work. I've attached the log from Magisk, not sure how to get a debug log
[Magisk] takur69:
Work Samsung J510FN Nougat 7.1.1 Api 25

thnk you :fingers-crossed:
[Magisk] ScottIsMyName:
Don't think it works with xposed.
[Magisk] robollama:
It worked fine before... Passed safetynet, was able to log into Snapchat, etc
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
You cannot pass SafetyNet fully with Xposed active. It just can't be done unless you do some serious tinkering and downgrade your device to a pre November 2016 security patch. Even then it's a huge if and hardly even worth thinking about (IMHO).

There's something about your setup though. The file for the Hide list doesn't seem found. MagiskHide probably won't work at all...
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
I'd try installing the v14.3 beta if I were you. It works quite well and have had a lot of changes from v14.0. You won't pass SN with Xposed active though...
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
I'm currently trying to build busybox without any errors :)

Travis-CI link:

https://travis-ci.org/HoloAndroidPorts/Magisk

Source:

https://github.com/HoloAndroidPorts/Magisk (branch kitkat-test)
[Magisk] Josey Wales:
Hello guys, I recently upgraded from Galaxy s4 to Note5 which is currently running stock Android 7.0. . . I flashed latest Twrp recovery, Xposed Framwork and SU but if Magisk will allow me to do more I'd like to get rid of SU. How can I do this?

Thanks in advance!
[Magisk] Frank_s_ph:
Hi guys,

I'm using a Huawei P10 and was in v14 until last night SafetyNet suddenly stopped passing. Today I reinstalled my stock rom and tried with v14.3. I'm just using Unified Host Adblock, iYTBP and O NotoColorEmoji Replacer, tried a couple of times and got the same. SN works fine for like 30 minutes then stop working.

Here's my log file, in case you wanna take a look: magisk_error_20171028_200110.log

Thanks in advance.
[Magisk] Pkt_Lnt:
There is a section here of how to install if you have another su already. Down in the 2nd post but this is chock *full* of good info, keep it handy! :good:

https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/guide-magisk-troubleshooting-t3641417
[Magisk] Incineroar:
Out of curiousity, is it possible to suggest other apps that automatically have Magisk Hide applied to them like Pokémon GO has? The Animal Crossing Pocket Camp app (com.nintendo.zaca) seems to use a really gnarly version of root checking that relies on SafetyNet, however, if it's ever triggered in-game, it does a client-side ban that requires deleting all the files and restarting the game if the user hasn't linked a Nintendo account yet.

I went and did some research online and it seems a lot of people are now getting these client-side bans randomly, and I just got it today because my device apparently can't remember apps that I've told Magisk Manager to hide root from and had to do a reboot while unaware of this.

Edit: Additionally, I did find another app that does not work whatsoever with Magisk (Even with Magisk Hide), but uses SafetyNet for root checking, but I'll leave that later for inquisitive minds should they ask.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
If you do want anyone to take a look at your log, you should upload it somewhere where a decryption key isn't necessary (unless you provide said key, that is :p).

Attaching it to your post usually works...

Pokemon Go isn't automatically added to the Hide list, it's just disabled from being added to the list since it doesn't need to be (since it only relies on SafetyNet). That's from back when it was a bit crazy around here, with all the Pokemon hunters screaming for a way to play their favourite game and still be rooted.

The only service that is automatically added to the Hide list is SafetyNet.

Starting to add other apps is a bad idea (IMHO), since there are so many different variables and setups out there and the Hide list should really be kept as short as possible. Best to keep that to the individual user.

If you want help with your issue with the Hide list some logs would be useful.
[Magisk] alien2924:
Hello,

I use AirWatch which detects the root despite the fact that I activated MagiskHide and ticked the right applications in the list (see log below);

Does somebody have an idea ?

Thank's
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
1 - Please don't add logs directly in the post. Attach or use a service like Pastebin instead.

2 - Have you searched through the thread? AirWatch has been discussed before:

https://xdaforums.com/search/thread/3432382?query=airwatch

All you really should need (according to earlier posts) is to add AirWatch and Settings.

3 - Does MagiskHide work otherwise on your device? As in you can pass SafetyNet and hide root from root apps?

Edit:

4 - Go with the times, dude. Update to v14.3. :p
[Magisk] alien2924:
[MENTION=4667597]Didgeridoohan[/MENTION]

Thanks for your answer.

Sorry, i don't know this :(

I read a lot of AirWatch post in this thread and tested several solutions always without success

AirWatch, Settings and other applications are hidden.

SafetyNet is OK

Yes, MagiskHide work for other application and i have test RootBeer :

If I hide RootBeer in Magisk, all tests are green and the application indicates a non-rooted device.

On the other hand if I don't hide RootBeer, all the tests do not pass and the device appears well as being rooted

Edit:

I have update to V14.3 but still the same problem
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
No worries. It makes posts unnecessary long, that's all... I didn't think that updating to v14.3 would change anything, just thought you should update. :)

The app is looking for something else then. Have you tried hiding the Manager? It's in the Manager settings. If that doesn't work, the next Magisk update will have a much improved way of hiding the Manager. Maybe that'll work.

Have you tried disabling USB debugging and/or Developer options?
[Magisk] alien2924:
Yes, i have disable USB debugging and/or Developer options and also tried hiding the Manager and always the same problem :(

Is there another log to analyse to know what's happen ?

Otherwise I'll wait for the next Magisk release impatiently...
[Magisk] Frank_s_ph:
I'm sorry, I was sure it was with no encryption key. No I've attached it :)
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
That works better... :) But, any useful debugging information will be found in the magisk_debug.log. You'll find it in /data.
[Magisk] Josey Wales:
So from my understanding thus far since I'm already STOCK rooted w/twrp the only things I need to are:

1. Uninstall Xposed Framework and any modules.

2. Enable that "OEM" setting in Developer Options.

3. Uninstall SU from within the SU app.

4. Flash MagiskManager v14.0.zip

5. Reboot and install the MagiskManager .app

I hope I'm NOT forgetting anything? ? ?
[Magisk] Pkt_Lnt:
1. Uninstall Xposed Framework and any modules.

2. Enable that "OEM" setting in Developer Options.

3. Uninstall SU from within the SU app.

4. Flash unSU zip *before* Magisk flash (may not be necessary, but good insurance to save headaches)

5. Flash *stock boot image* *before* Magisk flash

6. Flash MagiskManager v14.0.zip

7. ? Reboot and install the MagiskManager .app *only* if not installed when you flash Magisk zip. (It is in the Magisk zip and *should* install, very rarely it does not and you need to flash after.)
[Magisk] nicorg3221:
Not sure if it's the right place to ask.

I tried to run some init.d script in service.d. I believe I manage to run the script successfully because I print a debug log showing some error in the script. However, after the phone completed the boot, I checked the CPU freq setting etc and nothing has changed. What is the problem?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
The late-start service (service.d) might be too late. Try post-fs-data.d instead.
[Magisk] nicorg3221:
The same issue with post fs data as well.

A line of the init.d script I run: echo 0 > /sys/module/cluster_plug/parameters/active

Is it possible that after the script is finished in Magisk it's replaced to default value by other process?
[Magisk] Helbelinc:
Hey,

I've googled my behind off but couldn't find any working solution.

I've got a Sony Xperia Z2 on the latest Stock Rom (6.0.1; Firmware .291) and running Abricot Kernel. The installation itself works flawlessly, but after the boot Magisk Manager tells me that Magisk is not installed.

I've tried both the stable 14.0 and the 14.3 beta.

Before I was running on Lineage 14 and everything worked like a charm.

I've also tried BootBridge for Sony's ELF, but this is apparenty not for my device.

Any idea on how to get that running?

PS: I'm not rooted, but have a custom recovery installed (TWRP 3.0.2.0)

Thanks in advance.
[Magisk] Josey Wales:
Ok I uninstalled the Xposed modules from Xposed, turned my SM-N920T off, rebooted and was stuck in a bootloop(black screen). I reflashed stock firmware, wiped cache/data to start fresh. . . back on stock 7.0 but if I boot to stock recovery I get the blue "No Command" screen.

Should I be worry about this, do I address this and how before proceeding?

Since I'm back to stock firmware should I continue from step 4. . . ?
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
You should flash TWRP recovery and proceed to step 6

Note: Welcome to 2016, the Magisk year! :D
[Magisk] terrancez:
Hi guys, I'm running the latest version of magisk on my OnePlus5 with the latest OTA, but I noticed a kinda annoying issue, my safety net check will randomly fail after reboot, both ctsProfile and basicIntegrity returns false, I found the only way to fix this is to reboot, is there any way to permanently fix this?
[Magisk] Josey Wales:
Thank you sir[emoji16] will flash TWRP via Odin. . .
[Magisk] Josey Wales:
I flashed TWRP in Odin and immediately got Samsung screen bootlooped. Check in Developer Options and "OEM" was infact enabled[emoji30][emoji30][emoji30]
[Magisk] BearOfXDA:
When I clean flashed the latest system, boot, and vendor for the Nexus 5X with the latest Magisk zip, Google Play services keep crashing so I can't restore from cloud backup on startup
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
How did you flash TWRP with Odin?
[Magisk] Josey Wales:
Yes, with Odin. . .
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
But, how?

Note: Welcome to 2017, the year of suhide-lite! :D
[Magisk] Josey Wales:
In Odin v3 11.1:

AP checked

Options Auto Reboot and F. Reset Time checked

Everthing Passed, perfect log. . .

Now since I'm back to stock firmware when I power off then boot to stock recovery the first thing I see is this blue screen saying "Installing System Upate" then goes to a blue "No Comand" screen before entering stock recovery. It reboots system perfect. . .