yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] khanhdx:
I'm usinng Magisk 16.3. Magisk root works but Modules don't.

Somtime after reboot, Module works then don't work again at next reboot.

My /data is ext4.

The same problem also happens with magisk 16.0

Anyone plz help.
[Magisk] JudgeDread11:
The op states toggling root doesn't work with SuperSU. Some people post it worked for them. They can consider themselves lucky. Don't expect it to work on SuperSU.

Try phh's superuser instead.
[Magisk] lesscro:
If you keep Kitkat on your device, you can sit on this this new way of "systemless feature solution" ?

Request lollipop minimum, and it's not integrated in prerequisite somewhere...
[Magisk] Anyelou:
Misstake, I want say phh superuser, I test with 3 Superusers app different and dont work
[Magisk] MrMagicPotato:
How to install BusyBox?
[Magisk] desztan:
Have you tried the latest release from Chainfire superSU v2.78 SR1?
[Magisk] zelendel:
It's not from chain. It is now CCMT. Just a minor bit of info to prevent confusion.
[Magisk] NetWasp:
this doesnt work at all with the Renovate N7 Port for the SGS7 Edge just causes bootloop.

I did an advanced wipe clearing:

Dalvik/ART

System

Data

Cache

Then i installed the ROM, then Magisk v6 and then bootloop....

Whats going on?

---------- Post added at 07:03 AM ---------- Previous post was at 06:50 AM ----------

It would be great if this could work with YOUR version of SuperSU...

thanks for all the releases over the YEARS [MENTION=631273]Chainfire[/MENTION]
[Magisk] rosekiller:
after do all of that. i was success. But can not toggle root?? i was install spuser and phh but can not do it.
[Magisk] Agloxp:
Same here.

I can toggle out Selinux, but cant toggle out root.
[Magisk] solar666:
Check if su is still installed at /system/bin or /system/xbin

It was the case for me. It need to be deleted
[Magisk] Äptiva:
Download Root Validator from play store after removing root and before installing Magisk. If you're rooted or even if there are traces of root it will tell you where they are located.
[Magisk] guhvanoh:
Actually, this is from Chainfire. Check the SuperSU BETA thread.
[Magisk] JimSmith94:
This Tasker profile works well for me: http://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=68291750&postcount=836
[Magisk] Artim_96:
Then probably either SuperSU wasn't removed properly or you had BusyBox installed

---------- Post added at 08:16 AM ---------- Previous post was at 08:15 AM ----------

That version was not, he stated that himself over at G+.

---------- Post added at 08:16 AM ---------- Previous post was at 08:16 AM ----------

Only 5.0+

---------- Post added at 08:17 AM ---------- Previous post was at 08:16 AM ----------

Probably don't since parts of our are already installed with Magisk
[Magisk] 0.0:
I did. From a stock boot.img, I installed SuperSU first, then ElementalX kernel, then Magisk. I keep getting asked to update the binary when entering the SuperSU app but when I open and use root apps (i.e. AdAway), there is no error and I am able to download the hosts file without confirmation. I tried another root app and it is able to perform rooted functions without asking me to "Allow." So it seems, any root app will work without "Allowing" which may be something I should report. I am on a Nexus 5X.
[Magisk] bon122728:
[MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] unable to detect boot image when i try to flash magiskv6. I'm using zenfone 5 with RR 5.7.2 (6.01) how to fix?
[Magisk] iscaela:
Tried installing Magisk on my LG G Pad 7.0; running CM12.1 and TWRP recovery, after rebooting to system, I get the static LG splash screen (before the kernel starts) with

ERROR : boot certification verify

. It actually only reboots when the power button is held down instead of powering off completely now. The same message is displayed on the charging screen if I plug in the charger cable. I didn't change any of the settings for Magisk installation.
[Magisk] mathy007:
here's the recovery from twrp don't know why magisk can't install on HTC one M7 dual SIM or is my phone not supported am currently running stock lollipop 5.0.2

http://cloud.tapatalk.com/s/57dbaa7175e56/recovery.log.zip
[Magisk] dimitri.thibaut:
Systemless ViPER4Android -SURROUND- (Nexus 5)

Hi,

Nice work!

I was wondering if someone could create a Systemless ViPER4Android SURROUND version for Nexus 5? (So both speakers are used for audio output)

Like this file: http://xdaforums.com/attachment.php?attachmentid=3431647&d=1438967541

Thanks a lot!
[Magisk] yldlj:
Sorry if this has been answered before but to remove magisk and xposed can you just dirty flash ROM? Or do you need to run the uninstall zips?
[Magisk] edzamber:
Wipe data from Playstore then uninstall it (delete it from system/priv-app/Phonesky)

Then reboot and install Playstore apk from Apkmirror (9.5.10)
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
If you want to keep your system partition untouched that's not an option. But it'd work... :good:
[Magisk] edzamber:
Next solution is to rename Playstore from Apkmirror to Phonesky.apk and push it into system/priv-app/Phonesky with 0644 perms and reboot instead of install as normal apk :)

By the way, i have build a Magisk 16.3+ Modules Remover.

:)

It uninstall all Magisk modules... Maybe it can help...

Working only with Magisk v16.3 and up because of Magisk img path change since 16.3...

Flash by twrp...

https://www.mediafire.com/download/ehh5m9xt2q40841
[Magisk] Jaymin.0.1910:
Nice that you created an uninstaller, but rather than uninstall all, letting choose to which would have been better.

Also note that you can still push Play Store downloaded from APKMirror to /cache/magisk_mount/system/priv-app/Phonesky/Phonesky.apk and let Magisk bind mount it for you.

EDIT: magisk.img path was changed in Magisk versionCode 1455
[Magisk] Digity101:
Hello can someone help me? Im trying to play Chrono Ma:gia, but it keeps crashing. I have tried Magisk hide but that didnt work. Im running LineageOS 14.1 on Nexus 5 and i tried Magisk 16.0 and 16.3. The japanese version of puzzle and dragons from the same developers also keeps crashing.

Logcat pastebin.com/29fpF3gS

Device info pastebin.com/XrZ59b2y
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
If it's because of the app detecting root:

https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHide#hn_Hiding_root_from_apps
[Magisk] GizmoTheGreen:
Hi, I just installed oreo beta on a Huawei P10 Lite, it works good, but because no one has made working twrp for oreo on this device yet I can't install Magisk with recovery

I tried patching stock image with magisk manager (extracted kernel.img from UPDATE.APP)

but it fails to flash with fastboot, says partition error. but patching the stock image works fine! bootloader is unlocked.

any suggestions?
[Magisk] ranchu-panchu:
Hello,

on trying to pull file with adb from /data I get "remote Permission denied".

I checked setting, but I don;t understand if anything is missing.

Thanks for any idea,

ranran
[Magisk] edzamber:
Thanks,

Here is Disabler as well :)

Now we can Only disable Modules instead of Remove theses :)

https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/magisk-v16-3-magisk-modules-remover-t3776718
[Magisk] sk8223:
Refer to my earlier post where I got FGO to work (again, after screwing up my Magisk install): https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=76158784&postcount=24112

To get Magisk to work with these types of games, you need to force stop the game app, clear its data (just to be safe), hide Magisk in Magisk settings, add the game to the Magisk Hide list, and start the game again. This works for most games.

If it doesn't work, the game app could be detecting another problematic root app on your device that causes it detect root and crash. Like SuperSU, Busybox, or something else. Pokemon Go does this: https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/discussion-pokemon-magisk-discussion-t3465722

Also check www.reddit.com/r/pokemongodev for ideas on what you might need to uninstall if this is the case. For some it was random apps like "Busybox Installer Free".

Ideally, you should only be using Magisk (and its built-in Superuser). Not Magisk + SuperSU. If you have Xposed (systemless or normal) installed, uninstall it.
[Magisk] GizmoTheGreen:
hmm, okay tried again with beta... and this time I could install the kernel image! at least fastboot reported success... but

after booting still no magisk installed according to the app :(

ok got it! on oreo huawei you have to patch the ramdisk image/partition not the kernel! :)
[Magisk] Digity101:
ty guys. I decided to wipe phone and update to oreo (dirty unicorns). Then the first thing i did was installing magisk and used magisk hide on chrono ma:gia and this time it worked
[Magisk] Zoran81:
Hi,

I'm facing some issues with Magisk on OP3 with Lineage Os 15.1.

I constantly loosing root. After I flash magisk through TWRP I have root for some time and than its loosen.

I flashed Magisk several times today.

Can someone help me soove this?
[Magisk] ManikandanGuru:
Even though I hid the Tez app in Magisk Hide

The app still detects the root and it is not working.
[Magisk] Sir Backe:
Hi together

I refer to a problem I already discussed here in the forum with some nice people. It concerns the ebanking app "ubs access" from playstore.

I meanwhile can specify the problem in more details, so may be someone of the team can have a look at it, since I guess it will need some programming.

Problem description: After a factory reset I've built up my phone very carefully. First I installed only Magisk Manager fir rooting the phone. After this, I installed *ubs access" and it worked! Since I need xposed framework (version by topjohnwu) I installed this as last option, and, "ubs access" didn't work anymore. This means, once the xposed framework is installed, the "ubs access" app recognises that this is a rooted phone and stops working. Now my question, is there any workaround for that? Since I have lots of apps that need xposed framework I'd like very much to have it installed.

Tks a lot for your attention!

---------- Post added at 07:02 AM ---------- Previous post was at 07:02 AM ----------

Hi together

I refer to a problem I already discussed here in the forum with some nice people. It concerns the ebanking app "ubs access" from playstore.

I meanwhile can specify the problem in more details, so may be someone of the team can have a look at it, since I guess it will need some programming.

Problem description: After a factory reset I've built up my phone very carefully. First I installed only Magisk Manager fir rooting the phone. After this, I installed *ubs access" and it worked! Since I need xposed framework (version by topjohnwu) I installed this as last option, and, "ubs access" didn't work anymore. This means, once the xposed framework is installed, the "ubs access" app recognises that this is a rooted phone and stops working. Now my question, is there any workaround for that? Since I have lots of apps that need xposed framework I'd like very much to have it installed.

Tks a lot for your attention!
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
If it detects the Xposed framework you'll need to disable Xposed and reboot whenever you want to use the app.

If it detects the Xposed installer you'll have to uninstall it freeze the installer whenever you want to use the app. It would probably also be possible for you to build the Xposed installer yourself, from source, and give it a new package name. If you need to ask how to do that, it's not going to be an option...

Bottom line is that Xposed can't be hidden.
[Magisk] OldMid:
Right, so was doing some testing on my device for a module, was doing another reboot, as i had done countless times before, when my magisk install tripped out on me. No clue what happened but no modules are loading. I've tried reinstalling magisk but nothing. Here's the magisk log, it shows that it couldn't mount something, which must have had a knock on effect. any tips [MENTION=4667597]Didgeridoohan[/MENTION]?

edit: Root also still works
[Magisk] OldMid:
whoops forgot log attachement
[Magisk] OldMid:
Sorry for spam, here's are more detailed log:silly:
[Magisk] Jaymin.0.1910:
Your magisk_debug.log says magisk.img is corrupted, go to recovery, delete /data/adb/magisk.img and reboot.

All guys asking support, please remember to take care of some common things before asking support, i.e. a clean installation.

[MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION], See this whenever you have time, I suggest using e2fsck with the -p flag rather than -y which seems better for such cases.

EDIT: Your magisk.img is phisically resized or not been completely created.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Looks like your Magisk image is corrupt:

I Magisk : * Mounting /data/adb/magisk.img
D Magisk : magisk_img: e2fsck 1.43.3 (04-Sep-2016)
D Magisk : magisk_img: The filesystem size (according to the superblock) is 32768 blocks
D Magisk : magisk_img: The physical size of the device is 24576 blocks
D Magisk : magisk_img: Either the superblock or the partition table is likely to be corrupt!
D Magisk : magisk_img: Abort? yes
D Magisk : magisk_img:

The question is why. To answer that question you'd have to reproduce and grab logs during...

Solution for this instance: try to repair the image or delete it.

Edit: Ninja'd. :p
[Magisk] OldMid:
Appreciate it MC:good:
[Magisk] Jaymin.0.1910:
You're always welcome. BTW, my real name initials are not MC, they're SJ. I just took MC cause they sound like 'Emcee'
[Magisk] OldMid:
Yeah i assumed that:laugh:
[Magisk] ahhl:
I noticed with magisk, my tv apps loading slower and some channel cannot be loaded at all. the tv app however cannot detect root eventhough i did not hide magisk from it.

i have reflash my rom and run with app and it can load all channels and load faster.
[Magisk] Jaymin.0.1910:
Ask your app developer to update their Superuser library to the latest libsu.
[Magisk] bipinbedi:
For everyone who is facing tez application not working, you can make it work after unistalling the updates in Google play services, until a permanent solution arrives.
[Magisk] ahhl:
no point asking them [emoji28] i dont want them to know i am rooting my phone. they are blocking any rooted phone from watching thru their app.
[Magisk] euleralves:
Google Pay: Out of date build.prop

Yesterday I activated my CC to Google Pay. Today I did my first purchase using Google Pay NFC with success. I went to a second shop to score again. When I approached the phone to the POS, I got the message "Google Pay can no longer be used on this phone". After I closed the app, the message disappeared. I tried another shop twice.

The Magisk SafetyNet and other ones are all greens. I don't get any other warnings.

I headed to the Google Help by chat. The lovely representative investigated my account and concluded that my Moto X4 Android One (from Fi Project) was restored to factory and should contact the manufacturer to update the firmware. I promptly agreed that I did a factory reset and postponed a Motorola update.

I guess the Magisk code that hides the unblocked bootloader is using something out of date, as build or security patch versions. Pure assumption. Maybe Magisk is revealing something out of date to the Google Pay spies servers.

Two days ago I got a Google Pay update. I kept all my Magisk modules activated and I headed to a POS. It simply worked. After all, it was a Google Pay bug, probably because an old app been blocked, nothing to do with Magisk.

The modules currently enabled are:

App Systemizer

Busybox

Debloater

Emoji One

Enable Doze for GMS

Google Lens Enabler

Greenify4Magisk

Magisk manager

Single User Mod

Unified Hosts Adblock
[Magisk] SkippyDream:
Is there some way to add Magisk to my build?

I want my build.zip to be magisk prerooted
[Magisk] cubandanger05:
Got the same message today at a vending machine. Force stopped Google Pay, opened magisk, checked safety net and all was green, put my phone to the vending machine again and it went through.
[Magisk] euleralves:
Good to know I am not alone. I will disable all Magisk modules and try again.

By any change was you using "Google Lens Enabler"?

The modules currently enabled are:

App Systemizer

Busybox

Debloater

Emoji One

Enable Doze for GMS

Google Lens Enabler

Greenify4Magisk

Magisk manager

Single User Mod

Unified Hosts Adblock
[Magisk] cubandanger05:
No, out of your list, only these:

Enable Doze for GMS

Greenify4Magisk

Magisk manager
[Magisk] famewolf:
This happened to me today on an LeEco Le Pro 3. I had recently upgraded the version to the most recent nightly(of Lineage 15.1) so I think you are on to something. Around the same time however google pay/android pay had recently upgraded itself from google play so it's possible they tweaked their code as well.

*update* Ok seeing the more recent posts looks like half my magisk modules may have to be disabled as I have the greenify..the magisk manager...one of the google play throttlers but mine starts with "System" I think.....
[Magisk] sandaljrpit:
when I refresh the download menu, the magisk manager application is force close.

Xiaomi MI4 LTE .

Rom MIUI 9 ( android 6 )

Magisk V 16.0

Magisk manager V 5.6.4

Thanks

:)
[Magisk] daddylonglegs:
I have a USB-C microsd reader for my Google Pixel. Unfortunately most apps do not see the reader. I need to be able to "mount" it to a folder so it shows up along with storage/emulated because otherwise my apps won't find it. For root, the app to use is called StickMount. Unfortunately this does not work with Magisk (has to be SuperSU). Is there a module out there for Magisk that will do what I need?
[Magisk] CrimsonBloodfang:
Magisk Manager always crashed on my other device whenever I refresh "Downloads" section.

Downloads section is buggy.

Sometimes on my main device, when I refresh it, the loading is infinite. It will be fixed if I clear Repo Cache then exit the app.
[Magisk] Strephon Alkhalikoi:
[MENTION=2106600]daddylonglegs[/MENTION]: When was the last time Stickmount was updated? I think to fix this the developer needs to add support for Magisk; a module won't do it.

Contact the developer.
[Magisk] teddy0209:
Try softwares from paragon
[Magisk] NYLimited:
Is the message displayed / triggered only when making a purchase?

Or can it be triggered by adding/removing a card or some other activity?
[Magisk] famewolf:
For me only at time of actual purchase.
[Magisk] NYLimited:
Okay, that would explain why I have not been able to duplicate it yet.
[Magisk] AKHIL.cochin:
Hi

On one plus 3t with latest open beta and latest twrp installed , Magisk was working fine but when I updated to latest open beta and installed Magisk 16 it gives me bootloops , any idea how to fix it pls ..
[Magisk] daddylonglegs:
I am for some reason unable to install Magisk (I've had it installed in the past, but I wanted to update my phone).

I am on a Google Pixel (original model) and whenever I try to install it, right afterwards my phone refuses to boot and just stays at the Google loading screen all day and never boots up. I am using the April release of 8.1 (OEM). My bootloader is unlocked, of course.

I tried installing Magisk in two ways: by flashing in TWRP or by flashing the patched_boot.img and both give me the same issue. This is using the latest release of Magisk. As soon as a flash the stock boot.img I am able to boot back into my phone just fine. I have tried no less than 15 times already and I cannot get this phone to boot with Magisk installed.

I am not using a custom recovery and I am not using custom kernels. Does anybody know what I could try?
[Magisk] cubandanger05:
When you update, let the phone boot once first before installing magisk.

You can also try the same but with magisk v14, then once booted you can update to the latest magisk from within the magisk app
[Magisk] AKHIL.cochin:
With 14.3 managed to install and no bootloops but after removing a module again bootloops , didn't update to latest as 15 and 16 also wasn't working
[Magisk] Jaymin.0.1910:
Hi all,

I just wanted to ask you all something. Please read and answer me.

I am willing to develop an advanced Magisk module that'd work on Terminal and be a File Manager. Which will let users manage their /system and /vendor partition system-lessly. Rather than developing their own module for any systemless mod they want, they can simply access my mod's CLI and make modifications systemlessly.

Such as, suppose the user wanted to replace /system/bin/sh with their own compile of a shell, they can access my systemless system modifier or if they wanted to replace some XML files with their own modded files or just any systemless modification that Magisk is capable of.

I just wanted to know before developing whether such module might be useful for general users. I want to let users utilize Magisk's system-lessness in a better way.

Please respond to this post and tell me if you'd like such module and also what features / customizations you'd expect.

[MENTION=8570610]MCMotherEffin'[/MENTION]
[Magisk] guest4711:
I just put the file/folder in the corresponding folder in a skeleton magisk module. So I can systemless debloat (.ignore) or modify apps and files...

The skeleton module is derived from any copy of a module already installed. So no much efforts...
[Magisk] Jaymin.0.1910:
Hi,

Thanks for your feedback.

That's the exact thing I want let users get rid of. Also building a module from a skeleton zip might not be easier for every user.

MCMotherEffin'
[Magisk] famewolf:
Sounds interesting. I personally had to create my own module to add lines to build.prop, change the boot animation and delete the "recovery-from-boot.p" file on another device. Sounds like your module would let me roll all those into 1. Would it have a way for me to LIST the changes it has in case I needed to add/modify one? Are you planning any revision levels or an "undo" option? In some cases a disable option could be useful. For example the build.prop changes are causing a boot loop so I want to disable them till I figure out the exact issue or to remove a line I added etc.