yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Tip: Asking for an ETA is considered quite rude. It'll be done when it's done.

If Magisk isn't working as expected on your device, the least you can do is to provide some logs (see OP). If flashing fails provide TWRP logs. And so on...
[Magisk] Nagato Yuki:
The original Bump (not Bump'd recovery, not open Bump script) development post, there is the installable package for flashing kernel/boot image which not Bump'd.

But beware you have to have the bump-able bootloader, i.e. KK version bootloader
[Magisk] TheSaiyan:
Unable to detect boot image

I get the "unable to detect boot image" every time I try to flash Magisk v6. I'm using a M4 SS4045 phone, which is a very unknown phone, but it has a MTK 6582 processor, and I'm running Android 6.0.1 through CM 13 (yeah, I've seen many users succesfully using Magisk ok CM 13). I've looked for solution, but all the replies that asked for a solution to this got ignored. Don't have any logs (I don't know where are they stored), I'm using the latest Philz Touch recovery, I can't use TWRP, I get bootloop every time I flash it.
[Magisk] kryptikal:
[MENTION=2961225]KeyzerSuze[/MENTION]

That was over a month ago, using an older version of Pure Nexus and an older version of Magisk/phh. I can tell you that with the latest Pure Nexus (8-21 build) and the latest Magisk (v6)/phh (17) it works perfectly; I even have xposed (v86.5) installed and works perfectly as well.

If you want to run Pure Nexus, go for it; just make sure you install the 8-21 build & 8-3 gapps then proceed to install Magisk, phh, etc. It all works together perfectly now.
[Magisk] Lister Of Smeg:
Hi All,

Is this supposed to work on the Samsung S2 i9100 / and N7000? I've tried on my S2, fresh install of Marshmallow 6.0.1.

I've tried to install SuperSU from playstore, so I can do a fully CLEAN UNROOT process as described in a guide on AndroidPolice. When I go to install the Magisk v6.zip, it goes through the install in TWRP. However after reboot it freezes on splash screen (Samsung i9100) screen.

I then cannot access Recovery (TWRP) and the only access I have is Download Mode, in which I can flash a custom kernel/recovery in Odin, and then re-flash a newer recovery TWRP 3.0.2.1

When I have flashed the various Magisk packages, and can boot the S2 i9100 backup... It shows SuperSU (the phh version) it says complains it can't get root. And Magisk Manager says "Inproper Install" and cannot MOUNT....

I'm running a custom rom if that helps, either ACIP or AOKP.... as our stock rom OS is back in the JellyBean days of 4.1.2.

Does Magisk work with Custom Roms? As I hear summit about STOCK BootImg ??

Cheers, Lister
[Magisk] stanleyopar2000:
Niantic has appeared to have fix Pokemon Go server sided where Pokemon Go will not launch anymore with Magisk
[Magisk] gusso:
Don't think Niantic has done anything. As far as I can tell Magisk is no longer passing the safetynet validation.
[Magisk] deedeeceleb:
It's still working here

Gesendet von meinem ONE A2003 mit Tapatalk
[Magisk] jallenhayslett:
Same here. Update via Direct Install, repack, reboot, still on 17.2. Same result when flashing via TWRP.
[Magisk] SimplyCity:
[MENTION=3262915]habylab[/MENTION], got exact same behavior, no matter if I flash from mmanager or twrp, it stays at 17.2. Note8 950f, phantom kernel 1.7.

Log from mmanager: https://we.tl/t-OMoyXUThkS
[Magisk] habylab:
I downloaded the beta from the release thread, all okay now. Flashes fine on my OnePlus 6. Something's wrong with the provided one in the app.
[Magisk] dark0shark:
Same here on a Nexus 7 tablet, see screenshot from TWRP.
[Magisk] Brendanus:
Same here!
[Magisk] habylab:
Download from the release thread guys.
[Magisk] firozpatel:
Apps can not detect root after updated the magisk manager ( 17.3 fails to install) anyone else can't not get root access?
[Magisk] RandomPooka:
Seems like somebody needs to report a success story.

I'm using an Essential PH-1 with ElementalX kernel 3.09 on the October update.

Was using Magisk 17.2. Opened the app, it updated itself fine. Opened it again, and it installed 17.3 using direct install with no errors. Rebooted and checked the version and whether it was functional, and so it was, as well as safetynet passing.
[Magisk] jallenhayslett:
Cheers! Worked like a charm.
[Magisk] jcmm11:
It depends. If you just tell it to download and not install then it's in your regular downloads folder.

If you're telling it to do a direct install (or, I think, a patched boot image) it's in /data/data/com.topjohnwu.magisk/files/

If that location doesn't work for a patched boot image then look in /data/user_de/0/com.topjohnwu.magisk/files/
[Magisk] Brendanus:
Worked fine, downloaded and flashed in TWRP . Thanks.
[Magisk] maybeme2:
And the release thread is where?

Nexus 5 lineageos 14.1

I just received my notification that a

'New Magisk Manager Update is Available.

Press to download and install'

but I'm afraid to do so after what I'm reading here.

What to do?
[Magisk] Wolfcity:
https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/official-magisk-v7-universal-systemless-t3473445
[Magisk] devilth48:
Read here, there is the answer. Some devices have this issue.
[Magisk] Nimueh:
Honor View 10, RR Oreo - updated the manager and then let it update the .zip and everything went fine. :victory:

Rebooted and it shows 17.3 and apps can use root just like before.

Just figured a report of a device where it does work would be nice in between all those "doesn't work" posts :) :good:
[Magisk] firozpatel:
I have a OnePlus 6 and still don't work when I downloaded from release thread
[Magisk] The_Voice_70:
Same on OnePlus OOS 5.0.6 . Modell 3/3T.
[Magisk] Brendanus:
Problem solved (on Xiaomi MiA1) by downloading 17.3 from op and flashing in TWRP.
[Magisk] Paschfire:
How about the next time you all feel like posting "same" without providing any Magisk-logs, recovery-logs, logcat, or detailed device and setup information.

Do everyone else especially the Mods a favour, just don't.

All you are doing is clutter the thread, wasting the Devs time, while offering zero help in trying to solve the issue.
[Magisk] HorstiG:
Same on Note8 Oreo 8.0 Stock Dev Base and Kernel.

Here a Log File please

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1Lv2_UEkQxGI1KudsTNHy5Btwvovjp8eJ/view?usp=drivesdk

---------- Post added at 04:08 PM ---------- Previous post was at 04:06 PM ----------

As it looks, the log file doesn't really help.
[Magisk] sunchau:
delete
[Magisk] Paschfire:
Pls use the forums search before posting.

The answer to why that's happening is easily found within the last several pages of this thread, as it is a current topic of discussion.

Besides that fact, twice now you've provided no information regarding your device, it's current setup, or details regarding what Magisk version you're having issues with, Magisk-logs, Recovery logs... Etc.

For more details,

https://mobile.twitter.com/topjohnwu/status/1053920234237767680?s=09
[Magisk] Brendanus:
Fair enough, but some of us also shared solutions which worked, which is surely useful?
[Magisk] kryshnakishore:
guys the update showing in the magisk app is not the latest one, download zip in the release thread(below link) & flash it via recovery.... working on my op6 pie stable rom.

https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/releases/download/v17.3/Magisk-v17.3.zip
[Magisk] edward566:
Trying again
[Magisk] kpirnie:
I must be blind, but I have not found a resolution to this in here... so please excuse me if it already has been posted.

I am attempting to copy a couple of scripts to /sbin/.core/img/.core/post-fs-data.d/ or even /sbin/.core/img/.core/service.d/ during my flash process. I grab my ramdisk, unpack it, copy everything I need., then repack it.

I am not getting any errors during the process, however, when I then reboot the device... my scripts are not there.

Am I even copying them to the right place to begin with? Have an Honor View 10 US version.
[Magisk] Sam Nakamura:
Thanks for sharing, flashed via TWRP and now having Magisk 17.3 up & running on my 5t... definitely no issues for me!
[Magisk] RisjadB:
17.3(before pulled down) mi a1 pe pie work fine flash with twrp
[Magisk] TheUndertaker21:
lost root on xl3 with canary

can't seem to get 17.3 to work

since it only shows 17.2 only

---------- Post added at 09:08 PM ---------- Previous post was at 09:08 PM ----------

lost root on xl3 with canary

can't seem to get 17.3 to work

since it only shows 17.2 only
[Magisk] Pkt_Lnt:
Read the post above that has the tweet from topjohnwu stating he pulled 17.3 due to problems.
[Magisk] paiktaras:
the 17.3 version retired ... I think so something means this.....
[Magisk] smileguy91:
I'm on 17.1 with Google Pixel 2 and flashing the patched boot image isn't working. I rooted my phone successfully just a few weeks ago with the same firmware...

Anyone having the same problems? Am I doing anything wrong?
[Magisk] xunholyx:
Not reading back the last few pages is the only thing you are doing wrong ;)
[Magisk] k@iserex:
Hai guys and gals,

I have a question if I may, it's gonna be long one :

Rooted latest stock Miui 10 dev version running Andy 8.1 on unlocked Pocophone F1 smartphone and the way I did was just booting, not flashing, compatible TWRP image through fastboot without allowing system modifications at TWRP initial boot, important for second part of this very long sentence, and then proceeded with flashing Magisk v 17.1 and installing appropriate manager app.

So the whole purpose of above described process is to stay with stock OTA delivery on choosen pipeline cos I do love MIUI but having root access is essential for me. Now, Magisk supports OTA delivery trough process described here:

https://topjohnwu.github.io/Magisk/tutorials.html#ota-installation

My first OTA is to be delivered next Friday and the problem I have is with this step right here:

Wait for the installation to be fully done (both step 1 and step 2 of the OTA),
[Magisk] smileguy91:
I'm kind of new & confused (as you can undoubtedly tell). Last time I installed Magisk without TWRP. Is there currently any way for me to root without having to flash Magisk via TWRP?
[Magisk] xunholyx:
I usually use TWRP after a clean install of an update. But I don't install TWRP to my phone, I put it into my adb folder on my PC and fastboot boot it.

If it's just that you don't want to flash TWRP to your phone, this is an option to be able to still use TWRP to flash the Magisk.zip
[Magisk] 15xda:
Is there any way to get MagiskManager to install a particular version of Magisk? I have a Pixel 3, and have Magisk-v17.3.zip, but MagiskManager always seems intent on downloading v17.2. I'm wondering if there's a way just to supply the .zip file instead of downloading it from a channel.
[Magisk] Pkt_Lnt:
Change the channel to canary
[Magisk] 15xda:
Thanks, but that doesn't exactly answer my question. That does answer the question of how to use Magisk on a Pixel 3 today, but is there in general a way to ask MagiskManager to patch a particular boot image using a particular Magisk release zip?
[Magisk] TheUndertaker21:
anyone losing root every reboot with xl3 ?

flashed 17.4 and 17.3

same issue.

new phone so sure not many have it yet
[Magisk] 15xda:
Also, canary will install 17.4, and I want to install 17.3.
[Magisk] Pkt_Lnt:
Is the 17.3 in the beta channel of Magisk Manager? Otherwise the only way is TWRP which I'm sure it not out for the P3 yet.
[Magisk] martyfender:
Yes, from the modules section of Magisk Manager choose the + button and select any Magisk.zip that you have downloaded to your device. This works for flashing Magisk as well as modules.
[Magisk] smileguy91:
What is the most recent version of Magisk that still boots correctly and where can I download it?

---------- Post added at 11:41 PM ---------- Previous post was at 11:35 PM ----------

17.3 and 17.1 both don't boot for me after flashing via TWRP
[Magisk] bohemist:
My current setup is Magisk 17.2 with latest Magisk Manager on OnePlus 6 with Pie with Blu Spark TWRP.

Works well.
[Magisk] smileguy91:
17.2 doesn't work either for me. I am at a loss for words...
[Magisk] 15xda:
Unfortunately there is no modules section until you've already installed magisk. I don't think Magisk itself is a module. So effectively it seems Magisk 17.3 works on pixel 3 but there's not a convenient way to install it. I guess I could create my own update channel by hosting a JSON file somewhere, but that's not very elegant.
[Magisk] ahmdnz7797sy:
Hello, A few days ago, there were a magisk modules to pass safty net check and now I didn't find them in downloads.

Where can find old modules?
[Magisk] martyfender:
Sometimes authors post them in the dedicated module thread. It was probably one that was removed from the Magisk Repo for not complying with the current requirements.

https://github.com/Magisk-Modules-Repo/submission

It could also be in the grave yard and be deleted after November 1st, if it is not updated to conform to the new rules:

https://github.com/Magisk-Modules-Grave
[Magisk] cogelindo:
Ok, I spent all day trying to install magisk 17.2 in October stock N950f.

I could do it, and also root and pass safetynet, but when I download a module and reboot everything is ruined.

The message that only official binaries are accepted appears, along with the bootloop.

It's a rmm problem, or a magisk problem?
[Magisk] Stonecaper:
Unable to install even after patching the kernel :(

(https://xdaforums.com/zenfone-5/development/magisk-magisk-v12-0-installer-t3608257) maybe its time to give up
[Magisk] iambidhan:
Many app detecting root instead of enabling magisk hide on that app. Safetynet passed also. What can be the solution. I can't access many important app for that reason. Please help.
[Magisk] casouzaj:
Have you hidden Magisk Manager itself in its settings?
[Magisk] InsaneNutter:
I think SafteyNet has been updated? I now get "SafteyNet API Error" when checking on a OnePlus 5T and a Mi A1.

I was on Magisk 7.1, however updated to the 7.2 beta and get the same error. Apps such as Pokemon Go which check SafteyNet seem to no long work. They did however work fine about 12 hours ago and had been for months.
[Magisk] bohemist:
I just checked SafetyNet when I read your post and it is working.

OnePlus 6 / Android Pie
[Magisk] paarnoutse:
Thanks, didn't know this was possible!

Any idea whether this method will also be OK for downgrading Magisk (eg. from 17.x to 16.0)?

(assuming the Magisk module versions being installed were manually checked before on their downward compatibility)
[Magisk] spawnlives:
It's your RMM state causing the issue not magisk.
[Magisk] InsaneNutter:
It does seem to be working now, I was certainly getting a "SafteyNet API Error" for around 45 mins earlier however.

Maybe just a glitch then!
[Magisk] rr4444:
Hi there, I am having an issue hiding Magisk Manager.

MM sticks on the hiding dialogue forever and I have to close it. A new version does load, but it requires root permissions to be granted as if it is not MM. That also shows up in the new randomly named MM (see attached image)

It also means that I can accidentally remove root from MM, ironically. I can always reinstall MM, which sorts it.

BTW The original MM is not automatically uninstalled. I waited for ages and had to uninstall it manually.

I'm running a Huawei P8 GRA L09
[Magisk] prashant2198:
Cts profile is false for me, so I cannot use Google Pay. Magisk version is 17.1 stable, magisk manager version 6.0.1(151).

Any help on this ?

Thanks.
[Magisk] bohemist:
It may be a glitch. Someone has similar issue a few hours ago...you can backread a few posts.
[Magisk] cogelindo:
ok, so is there any way to download the module zip to flash with twrp? I believe that in stock you should flash the rmm fix along with what you want to install...? I have looked for guides for these situations and I did not find anything. Do you know any method?
[Magisk] blackfake:
How can I reset the installed modules?

I have installed some modules trough magisk manager and one of them treats my bluetooth functionality.

I tried to deactivate/uninstall it but this doesn't work. Every time update the list or reboot my phone it's reactivated.

So I'd like to go back to sth like 'factory reset' of magisk. Is this possible or have I to uninstall it completely and reinstall?
[Magisk] Simone98RC:
[MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] you have to fix the Magisk Uninstaller link in the official thread: as of v17.3, the right one is https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/releases/download/v17.3/Magisk-uninstaller-20181022.zip

Thanks for the attention :)
[Magisk] martyfender:
Have you tried this? I believe you need a custom recovery to use it though, if I am not mistaken. TWRP has a terminal to run the commands from.

https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/module-tool-magisk-manager-recovery-mode-t3693165
[Magisk] rr4444:
Does it? I thought you had to install busybox separately, at least in the version for my phone...
[Magisk] blackfake:
My problem is not that I cannot install sth.

My problem is: I'd like to uninstall a module which is always in the 'Modules' list but not showing exactly what it is (even if I know what it is this doesn't help me :/ )
[Magisk] martyfender:
I'm not sure if it requires busybox, or not. I have never used the module. It makes no mention of busybox in the op and busybox is not in the module zip, that I can see.
[Magisk] NewbieGamingYT:
Magisk Encrypting Phone??

So, I have an issue if I flash Magisk 16 or 17 (or any version for that matter) where if I reboot twice it will encrypt my data with a password I don't know. I am trying to use it on this ROM (AOKP): https://xdaforums.com/axon-7-mini/development/rom-oreo-test-builds-t3850834 but it encrypts, the dev of this ROM tdm says he doesn't help/give support for ROMS running Magisk! I don't know what is going on, it works just fine on this one: https://xdaforums.com/axon-7-mini/development/rom-aokp-nougat-unofficial-t3692405 but I want to run Oreo, any help is appreciative. I have tried patching boot image file no luck, clearing the cache before flashing Magisk no luck. Please Help!
[Magisk] Sibi anandh:
Hello Dev....I'm on magisk 17.2 beta and also used 17.1 stable the problem is before these two updates I was on Oreo 8.1 I used Dolby Oreo and YouTube vanced mods...they were working fine for the past about three months from 17.1 stable and 17.2 beta the modules is getting installed and reboots asusual...but the module is shown as installed in magisk app...but it is not installed in the system....please fix it..I'm on ham(zuk z1)
[Magisk] prashant2198:
Can't answer you buddy but can you share the link for daydream bypass. I need my cts profile true for google pay to work. I don't have daydream enabled in my device but if flashing its bypass works then it's fine. Thanks.
[Magisk] JimZiii:
Hey, quick question about the manager. Yesterday I noticed i had an update available for magisk (17.3) and I tried installing it several times and even tho it succeeded but after rebooting a was back on 17.3.

And now today the newest version in the manager I 17.2, and yes the manager is set to beta
[Magisk] Paschfire:
As a senior member you should know better, use the forums search to find answers before posting.

Had you read the last several pages of this thread you'd know what happened,17.3 was pulled because of issues.

Check out topjohnwu’s Tweet: https://twitter.com/topjohnwu/status/1054406636809412613?s=09
[Magisk] jcmm11:
I assume you have a root file explorer. Go to /sbin/.core/img/

Delete the folder that contains the module you want to remove. Reboot.
[Magisk] HorstiG:
Last update works perfectly, Note 8, S8+ and S7 Edge, Stock Dev Base Oreo 8.0, thank you.
[Magisk] j-a-d-z:
17.3 is back again. Version code 17302.
[Magisk] spawnlives:
Read this thread it will help you out.

https://xdaforums.com/samsung-a-series-2017/how-to/guide-root-install-twrp-samsung-t3747535
[Magisk] prophet4:
Hi. With the new update 6.0.1, my Magisk crashes after running. Reinstalling and deleting data did not help.

Version 6.0.0 works fine.

Oneplus One, LineageOs 15.1
[Magisk] Brendanus:
Fingerprint enable not working?

Magisk 17.3 on MiA1, LR rom

Edit: it works if you add the fingerprints after reinstalling Magisk.
[Magisk] yochananmarqos:
[MENTION=5544724]godkingofcanada[/MENTION]

[MENTION=4769181]vandyman[/MENTION]

A wise man knows when to stop and let it go.

A fool has to have the last word.

Let's let it go and get back on topic, shall we?
[Magisk] danishajaz:
Hey guys, before modules would download in magisk manager folder and now it downloads in download folder, any way to change back the download folder to magisk manager folder?
[Magisk] TotallyAnxious:
Some apps detect the magisk manager folder and won't work. That's why. I'd just find a root app that can redirect the storage of an app. Or just build the magisk manager app yourself with the download location changed.
[Magisk] showlyshah:
Guys.. why cant i write into vendor folder? I can write into system folder. But writing into vendor folder gives error. I didn't follow this thread for long.. so cant figure out..

Can someone help?

Phone is pixel 2 xl, with latest magisk. Using xplore filemanager.
[Magisk] angelillom:
mate install version 6.0 1 but my Magisk is still in the Zip version 17.2 without passing wing 17.3 Why?

My phone is the Huawei P20 Lite and I have the Original rum ANE-LX1 8.0.0.144 (C432) and I do not install the 8.0.0156 (C432) for fear of losing the root, I have the TWRP

THANK YOU and I would like advice
[Magisk] martyfender:
For some time now, the Magisk default download location has been in the downloads folder. Some apps detect the Magisk Manager folder, that is why the location was changed. And maybe because I use Canary builds and Unofficial builds is why I say, for some time. For me, it was so long ago, that it has now become the norm for me. I have gotten used to the new location and don't see the need for the old folder anymore. If you have backup files in that location you can't live without, I would suggest that you copy them to downloads and delete the Magisk Manager folder. However, that is a personal choice, if you don't use any apps that look for that location and therefore, don't work.

---------- Post added at 11:59 PM ---------- Previous post was at 11:51 PM ----------

I believe it may be a permissions issue you are experiencing.

You are right, I can make a new folder in vendor, but when I try to copy a file to that new folder it fails in Mixplorer, at least. I'm sure there is a good reason for this? Hopefully someone more experienced will explain why. The permissions for my vendor folder are 755.

EDIT: If I change the permissions of the new folder to 777, I can copy a file to the newly created folder. I did this, this time in Total Commander, as it is easier for me than the way you do it in Mixplorer.

Someone who is a Linux or Android guru may have a better explanation than me.
[Magisk] SacredDeviL666:
Member Conduct

Thread cleaned off few off topic discussion and member conduct.

a) This is a general thread and ideally we expect all of you to be in their best :highfive:

b) If you find any offensive or offtopic post instead of engaging yourself please do hit report else both will be looked at the same manner.

Last but not least go through our Forum Rules specially the one below :o

Can we go back to drinking our mojitos/tequillas/rum or just about anything and have fun :p

Thanks

SacredDeviL666

Forum Moderator.
[Magisk] aatattra:
Installed battery life extended and pix3lify this morning, ever since then my phone has been in a boot loop, i'm not sure which one is causing it, i've uninstalled both, tried to flash substratum legacy and i've even uninstalled every other module I have, none of this has worked, I have uninstalled magisk via the official uninstaller (I was previously on 17.3) and the only other thing I have done is deleted an overlays.xml file, I am still unable to boot, i'm running out of ideas, i'd like to keep all my data but wouldn't mind doing anything else to get this fixed (i've already deleted all my magisk stuff)

edit: nvm factory reset