yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] xpil:
Miui and magisk 17.1 problem

Dear all I need help for the following issue....

I have a REDMIPRO phone running miui 9.5.3. It is unlocked, rooted and xposed. Everything was functioning perfectly under magisk 16.4

Yesterday I decided to upgrade to magisk 17.1 and magisk manager 6.0. This opened the pandora's box for me. Google play started crashing continuously at a point the phone became completely useless. Luckily I had made a nandroid backup just before the magisk update and that saved my life.....

Could anybody suggest any solutions to the problem, or should I stay with magisk 16.4 for the time being? :(
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Do you happen to have quite a lot of your apps and device processes added to the MagiskHide list? If so, try clearing out the list and only keep those apps/processes that actually detect root.

MagiskHide was improved in Magisk v17.0 to kill off a lot more background processes connected to the target UID, which means you might experience app and system instabilities if you add the wrong things to the Hide list. For example, you do not need to add the Play store to the list to pass SafetyNet, that's already taken care of by default by Magisk.
[Magisk] xpil:
Well, When I rooted the phone and installed magisk 16.4 I did NOT do anything with magisk hide, except turning the switch ON in settings. Other than that nothing. Yesterday I just installed 17.1, which I assumed got the 16.4 settings by default. Do you think I should look into it? I hate to be forced to do a nandroid restore again...:(
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Provide logs:

https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHelp
[Magisk] byReqz:
Is there a way to backup and restore installed magisk modules?
[Magisk] Jherson R. Martinez S.:
Remove magisk in install version 16.0, in that version if I could grant permissions to SD maid. When I install the latest version of magisk manager and update it is when I have the problem. The Screen Shot is how it is currently, apparently installed :(
[Magisk] rs_sharma:
#request #suggestion Can u enable magisk hide option for newly installed app via notification when it installed first.

Because now we need to open magisk manager everytime to enable magisk hide for new apps. It'll help a lot. Thanks [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION]
[Magisk] guest4711:
Use a good filemanager (MixPlorer e.g.) to copy the contents of /sbin/.core/img to your external sdcard to backup.
[Magisk] Ænimal:
In MM 6.0.0 under 'Superuser' remove/delete Sdmaid if there is. Anyway, reboot and wait long enough, then start an activity in Sdmaid (e.g. overview scan) and the su-prompt should show up..
[Magisk] byReqz:
i thought about that, can i really just copy it there again?
[Magisk] guest4711:
Yes, after reboot the module is there again... I use this method to test some settings or modify existing modules without the need to sign them.
[Magisk] kunjumonpillai:
Root hide problem in FedMobile app

Hi. I have rooted my phone using magisk. Other apps are working fine while using magisk hide option. But the fed mobile app is checking if there is any root hiding app installed. Any hope in using the app without this issue ?

screenshots attached

---------- Post added at 12:46 PM ---------- Previous post was at 12:31 PM ----------

Hi. I have rooted my phone using magisk. Other apps are working fine while using magisk hide option. But the fed mobile app is checking if there is any root hiding app installed. Any hope in using the app without this issue ?

screenshots attached
[Magisk] 100497:
The latest version of magisk is very helpful. I have two smartphones,both of them are xiaomi. The xiaomi max 2 runs the official miui 8.9.20 dev. Of course,uses magisk 6.0

(17.2).The other one, xiaomi mix 1,which was flashed with lineage 16(android 9),uses magisk 6.0(17.2).however，max2 can run the game called "kirara fantisia",mix can't.

Anyone can solve the problem?
[Magisk] elwhiteboy01:
I'm sorry if this is the wrong place to ask this question, but could somebody make a magisk module similar to that of the xposed module known as fake gapps? In order to install microG you have to install xposed and then the fake gapps module in order for it to work. There are other methods I know, like running scripts with adb. I'm too lazy for all that to be honest. I just figured I would request the magisk module to install microG! If someone could create that, that would be perfect.
[Magisk] Nebrassy:
Try magicgapps
[Magisk] xunholyx:
That won't happen. You shouldn't hide all of your apps, only the ones that have root detection. Hiding too many apps will cause system instability.

The way you should use Magisk Hide is to hide the apps that you KNOW try to detect root. If you come across an app that looks for root besides the known ones (you'll get a prompt telling you the app won't work on rooted devices), hide it and go to ~ settings > apps ~ and clear storage for it. Reboot and it will be hidden.
[Magisk] ante0:
Any of you are using Huawei Mate 9 or Mate 10/Pro with Magisk 17.1/2?

It seems proc_monitor doesn't start at all after a few reboots.

It's fine if you do a fresh install using uninstaller, then install a module. If you reboot after this proc_monitor doesn't log anything.

I did notice that when I install busybox it will eventually say in log that it can't find /system/bin/logcat, and it doesn't seem to set up mirror?

Its fine on Magisk 16.4.

Log attached

Edit: mirror is set up in /sbin/.core/

Edit 2: tested again, flashed magisk 17.2. Rebooted a few times, basic still passes. Flashed Busybox, rebooted, rebooted again. not passing basic. Uninstalled Busybox, passing again.

When busybox is installed it doesn't show it's monitoring gms.unstable. BUT, it's not monitoring zygote32/64 at all, it seems.
[Magisk] Jherson R. Martinez S.:
It does not work ... after installing Magisk-v16.0.zip through the recovery, download rootchecker to check if it had root access, and indeed if it had access so I gave SDmaid permission.

After that I installed MagiskManager-v6.0.0.apk and updated to the latest version of Magisk, I opened the rootchecker and a message appears that root access is not installed correctly :(

The strange thing is that a moment ago I downloaded an application from a bank, and when I tried to log in I blocked access because I had a device with root. Use MagiskHide and I can login.

Attached photo of the main screen of Magisk, modules, and rootchecker
[Magisk] Wisteru:
Hi, I have problem with my Xiaomi Redmi Note 4. After magisk root i can't uninstall system app because there is no permission to r/w /system. Before last rom installation everything worked great. Could you guys help me?
[Magisk] Alibaba0101:
Renamed hidelist to hidelist.old

I can enable magisk hide under settings, but when i choose #magisk hide from the menu in magisk manager, i get

"unfortunately magisk manager has stopped:

I see that magisk has created a new hidelist at 32B
[Magisk] Ænimal:
Again: Delete Sdmaid from superuser, reboot, start activity in Sdmaid which requires root permission, allow su-prompt..
[Magisk] mirallasadams12:
Im using galaxy j5 prime SM-G570F with oreo rom. If i flash magisk, whether 17.1 or 17.2 it roots my device but blocks my Imei and sim network from showing. I've been reading forums back and forth for 2 days nows since someone suggested this issue has been sorted already. If so someone please reply with a solution or the link to the solution. Waiting patiently but hopefully. Any help would be much appreciated. Thanks guys.
[Magisk] Jherson R. Martinez S.:
I already did it for the second time and it did not work ...

As I wrote in the previous post with the rootchecker I have the same problem, the dialog box to give root permission never appears.

Is it probably an error of the latest version of magisk? because root works well in magisk 16.0 and not in the latest version
[Magisk] Ænimal:
I got the same message from Sdmaid. Clean flash latest magisk (stable/beta), allow su for Sdmaid, Sdmaid will complain no matter, delete Sdmaid from superuser, skip reboot, just clear Sdmaid from recent apps, start it again, eventually it will get root..
[Magisk] Jherson R. Martinez S.:
I did not understand "Clean flash latest magisk (stable / beta)" so I completely uninstalled the magisk and installed the latest version of Magisk-v17.2 and I still can not accept root access because the permission dialog box does not appear.
[Magisk] Ænimal:
Just keep trying with the above steps..
[Magisk] A.lemane:
Mate 8 here same thing & more

Now none of them pass no matter what I do

---------- Post added at 09:44 PM ---------- Previous post was at 09:40 PM ----------

Happens a lot I usually await 10 sec if it doesn't appear I just force close the app & try again , that works 4 me
[Magisk] akwala:
Getting notifications for updating the last couple of days but tapping on the notification results in "There was a problem parsing the package."

When I try to update from Magisk Manager it identifies the update as MagiskManager-v6.0.0(147).apk. Upon tapping Install the same error is reported.

How can I install the update?

Device:. Moto XT1687, Android 8.1 (Omni 8.1.0-20180812-potter-WEEKLY)
[Magisk] martyfender:
Do you by chance have one of the unofficial builds installed where the Magisk Manager is signed with a different key? Try to

uninstall your current Magisk Manager only,

then try to install the new one. when you do this you will have to go into MM settings and set it up again.

You can also get a parsing error if the downloaded apk is corrupt.
[Magisk] sabbahy:
After updating magisk to 17.2 all the modules stoped working they are shown on magisk manager as installed but they are not, root working good,

tried fresh magisk install throw recovery, tried separately install modules then restart after each one, tried clear cash... Unfortunately the problem still exists after all this attempts to fix it! Tried downgrade to 17.1 i got the same problem!

Am on havoc AOSP oreo 8.1 Rom, latest magisk manager.

Now am on magisk 16 all working "root, modules"

So is this a common bug?

How can i fix it?
[Magisk] TheCoryGuy:
Magisk Hide crashes the app after new update.

Modules stop working also. Going to try reverting to v16 for now.

Oreo 8.1 fresh install, stock LG V30.

-----

EDIT: seems I'm repeating what others are saying without reading. v16 works.
[Magisk] otonieru:
for one who facing magisk hide issue and module issue in 17-17.2

its one of your module that causing it,

module need to be updated. Try one by one by disabling each module and restart the phone until you find the troublesome one.

for me, it used to be the Wireguard module
[Magisk] A.lemane:
Not all cases

It doesn't work even with no modules (fresh install)
[Magisk] Wisteru:
Sorry for same post, but I really need answer. I have problem with my Xiaomi Redmi Note 4(mido). After magisk root i can't uninstall system app because there is no permission to r/w /system. Before last rom installation everything worked great. Could you guys help me?
[Magisk] jago25_98:
Sorry for what could be a silly question but why can't we use a new kernel?

I guess the reason is that the way Magisk works relies on support at hardware and rewriting magisk for less hardware would be too much work?
[Magisk] guest4711:
The precompiled proprietary drivers of our hardware (so called BLOBs - Binary Large Objects) are not compatible with newer kernels. And we cannot adopt and compile the drivers ourselves because the sources are not open. As long as their manufacturers do not open the sources or create compatible BLOBs we must stay on the current kernel which does not support some functionality Magisk needs.
[Magisk] akwala:
Thanks. It is unlikely that I would've knowingly installed an unofficial release.

I downloaded MagisManager-v6.0.0 from the releases at GitHub and was able to install it. Therefore, I believe that the earlier download attempts were partial/corrupted.

While MM now is the latest version, it still shows both the latest and installed Magisk version to be 17.1. Should I expect the latest to switch to 17.2 shortly and be notified about the update and presented with the option to update Magisk in MM?
[Magisk] elwhiteboy01:
Yeah I've commented on the actual magic gapps thread because it doesn't work on my device. So that's not an option. I am subscribed to that thread and waiting for the dev to do an update, in which he said the update should support more devices. So again, anybody, please make a module similar to fake gapps.
[Magisk] jenslody:
17.2 is currently beta, you can switch to beta update-channel in MM's settings if you want to try it.
[Magisk] starbright_:
Do have an issue with Titanium Backup. Just get "parse error" while attempting to restore backups. There are two differences:

- Backup-device was LOS 14.1 S5mini while Restore device is a A3(2017) with LOS 15.1

- backup was created with addsu (LOS) while I try to restore it with TB running under Magisk for root. I also installed the busybox module, as the TB-FAQ blame on a bad busybox ....

Does someone has been suffered from this problem too and found a solution?

Deinstalling Magisk, install SU, restore Backup, deinstall SU and Install Magisk might one expensive idea - others?

Done with latest 17.1 Magisk, Logcat for some reasons doesn't show any valuable info.
[Magisk] leonardus_magnus:
I hoped the issue would find a solution in 17.2... unfortunately not. My device keeps turning on when I start charging... . Any suggestions, please? Thanks.
[Magisk] krishu_s:
play.google .com/store/apps/details?id=com.fss.jnk

This banking app still able to detect Root. Even after Magisk Hide
[Magisk] tcat007:
Curious why module files quit going to /sdcard/..../magiskmanager folder. They end up in downloads and I have to cut and paste them to the magisk folder (just to keep downloads fairly clean).
[Magisk] Pkt_Lnt:
Explained in one of the last few changelogs as one method to avoid detection by apps looking for Magisk folder, they don't block if a Downloads folder is found.
[Magisk] dknight178:
Guys, badly need help. I screwed up using hidelist - and now I can't boot into system. I do have TWRP but I can't find the hidelist directory to delete it. Any way to delete it via TWRP terminal or file manager? I can access sbin but can't find .core. thanks
[Magisk] casouzaj:
Just a thought: Have you mounted the system partition, under TWRP's Mount button?
[Magisk] jcmm11:
In TWRP you need to mount the Magisk image first. I just use UPDATE-SUmount by [MENTION=4544860]osm0sis[/MENTION] since I still have it hanging around from when I was running SuperSu - and it works just fine for Magisk. It works as a toggle, first time you flash the zip it mounts Magisk image to /data_adb_magisk. If you flash it again it'll unmount it. Once it's mounted you can go to /data_adb_magisk/.core and delete the hidelist.
[Magisk] Killua96:
Guys is there any other type of log apart from catlog to see why an app crashes? I'm always here for FGO and i wanted to understand why it does crash with error 61 despite latest version of magisk, manager hidden and app added in hide list, strange thing is that other problematic apps like Pokémon Go work perfectly...
[Magisk] darkknight200:
I finally got the lg v20 to work on oreo. I am using magisk 17.2 on stock lg h910 oreo. It fails both cts and basicintegrity.

I have attached magisklogs. My logcat is working and I can toggle magiskhide thru terminal emulator fine. It just won't pass safetynet. I do find that when i boot up phone safetynet does pass both test for a bit and then afterwards settling down, it fails.

When I was on stock nougat of the v20, magisk 17.2 passed both safetynet tests.

So I don't why all the sudden on 1 newer android version it fails. These are all on stock lg v20 firmwares.
[Magisk] jmcf89:
I don't know if I should report this here, but the latest magisk manager 6.0.0 crashes the root management tab in options on aosip oneplus 2.
[Magisk] whitebait:
Whilst the phone was unrooted today I installed Magisk Manager and BB Work immediately said I was rooted. So guessing it wasn't actually detecting root but it's now detecting the presence of Magisk Manager itself. So tonight I've reinstalled Magisk via TWRP and installed the Magisk Manager apk. I then hid Magisk Manager (where it renames the package) and hid Magisk from BB Work and it seems to be working ok. This is definitely new behaviour for BB Work, as I'd never had to hide MM previously so hopefully this is of some use to someone else!
[Magisk] Rukbat:
JOHN, HELP! Either way I install 17.2 on a Pixel 2 running the September update, TWP-installing it or having the 6.0 manager patch the boot.img file, then booting it in the bootloader, it hangs during the boot, reboots, then ends op on the stock recovery. No usable boot, until I flash boot.img (not patched-boot.img), and no TWRP - it just replaces it with the Try again/Factory reset menu.

Flashing the update should totally get rid of the Magisk binary, right? (Even just flashing boot.,img seems to.) But the only way I can get it to work (sometimes - I've been trying things for 2 days, and don't always keep perfect notes) is by wiping user data. Should I be looking for something? Or should I just make a list of every app on the phone, set it up with no user data, then hammer on Play for a day or so until I either get everything back or find an app that kills Magisk? (I'm at the point now where I'm ready to do that, as much as I hate to, because the phone has the "blank fingerprint file" bug - but I will if that's the only way. I can live without using my fingerprint to unlock my pay apps, but I can't live without root, and I certainly can't live without being able to boot the phone.)

Edit: I guess Magisk-uninstaller didn't work the first time. I went through the whole uninstall, reinstall, install from Magisk, reboot thing again, and it seems to be rooted. (Thanks to whoever posted the link to the [was it OnePlus?] patched boot images for making me try one more time.)
[Magisk] A.lemane:
4 Xposed users

CYBER APPX - http://repo.xposed.info/module/net.gdi.module.appx
[Magisk] dknight178:
Yes, mounted already

I fixed this by flashing uninstaller.zip but will do look for the file you mentioned. thanks!
[Magisk] Jaka1945:
Hi..iam from indonesian..i am using magisk for hide detection my application called tcash wallet..but still fail the application still detect my device its rooted..i was check my safetynet its passed with green checked..please explain why..?my device its xiaomi mi max 2 with rom revolution os and iam using magisk v17.2..
[Magisk] Rukbat:
That depends on how tcash wallet is detecting a rooted phone. If you installed it normally, you have no folder named Magisk, but it might be seeing the app itself.
[Magisk] martyfender:
If I am not mistaken, doesn't error 61 mean it has detected Magisk? Also have you disabled USB debugging, developer options and made sure that you have ro.debuggable=0 in default properties. You can set that, along with other safe properties with the Magisk Hide Props Config Module. I have an x86 device with less than 1gb of ram, so it will not run on my devices, but before I found this out, I learned the above. Those that actually have the game running may have some better answers.

---------- Post added at 10:43 PM ---------- Previous post was at 10:39 PM ----------

Did you hide the app in Magisk Hide, hide the Magisk Manager app itself, in MM settings and clear the banking apps cache and data?

This guide talks about other ways apps can detect root it is my favorite go to for this info, thanks to [MENTION=4667597]Didgeridoohan[/MENTION]:

https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/HomePage

---------- Post added at 10:59 PM ---------- Previous post was at 10:43 PM ----------

I have 5 Nextbook Ares 8A's with Android 6.0.1 x86. On some of them I am using the latest Canary build and on others, unofficial builds. On all of them, for some time now, in settings, backup, the backup account is greyed out. I removed all modules, removed the Google account and readded it and that did not solve it. What did solve it was to enable core only mode and reboot. I am attaching a magisk.bak log before core only mode and a magisk. Log with core only mode enabled.

I did the uninstall of all modules on one of my other devices, not the one here I posted logs for. More device info is in my signature, as always.

Does anyone have any idea why this is happening?

This was also reported by another user in the Sysconfig Patcher Module forum.

I posted logs here:

https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=77702430&postcount=105

I would suggest others having issues with Magisk, try core only mode, as it appears to be different from the default Magisk install without any modules installed. And this

may

have started with v17 or greater, I'm not sure.

I am sorry for posting this in multiple forums, but in over 24 hours, I have not had any anwers, so I posted here, hopefully for a greater audience.

Thanks
[Magisk] Jaka1945:
Hy thanks for your answer but sure i has hide my application to magisk hide..and with no module installed but still the application detects my root..i think the roms not support the magisk because in other roms before its work fine..maybe i should change my roms again..
[Magisk] martyfender:
If I am not mistaken, Oreo and Pie roms have this problem quite frequently.
[Magisk] Killua96:
Yes error 61 is magisk being detected, usb debug is another error (43), all values are safe as I said in the [MENTION=270303]didgeridoo[/MENTION]ha's module thread.

Unfortunately not all FGO users are being able to play it with magisk, and the few of them that can have just done the usual, hiding MM and added the app to Magisk hide, this is way I'm trying to understand why magisk is detected in some cases.
[Magisk] jenslody:
Is the MagiskManager folder in internal storage already removed (or renamed), so it can no longer be detected ?

Probably remaining zip's from modules (or other files) with magisk in the name might be enough (Magisk-logs in /cache etc.).
[Magisk] GryphonBR:
Need some help with a problem previously reported by others but still unsolved. I have an LG V30+ running BoomBox v1.3 (debloated stock LG-based ROM) and the MagiskHide menu option crashes MagiskManager every single time I try to reach it. Grabbing a hidelist from my OnePlus 3T and putting it in /sbin/.core/img/.core/hidelist doesn't help.

Any logs I can provide to help narrow the issue?
[Magisk] Vobi1024:
Hello all!

One of my apps checks for root using rootbeer. I can hide magisk from it, but not busybox. The interesting thing is, I don't have busybox installed!

I had xbin folder, with some files, like antradio_app, box, dtest.sh,... in it, but I already moved them away. So there is no /system/xbin folder on my device for sure!

My path environment contains /system/xbin, but I cannot find a way to remove it from there. Looks like oneplus doesn't set the path variable using init.rc.

Busybox checker also tells me I have xbin folder (which is not true) , I guess it's because the path environment variable. Please see screenshot.

Does Your 5t have xbin folder with these files too?

Does magisk has anything to do with that?

Can someone give me some hint what is going on? Thank You!

I'm on 5.1.5, SimpleGX kernel, latest magisk.

(sorry for cross-post, the other thread is passive)
[Magisk] Killua96:
In 17.2 there is no MM folder, for Magisk files I don't know, is there a list of them and it's safe to remove them? Anyway as I said before Pokémon Go scans the memory for root files but it works perfectly.
[Magisk] martyfender:
Magisk has its own internal Busybox, which should be theoretically hidden.

If I am not mistaken, on my devices it is in /sbin/.core/mirror/bin/

When I open that in a terminal I get:BusyBox v1.29.2-topjohnwu (2018-08-12 18:39:31 DST) Multi-call binary.

I have the rootbeer app hidden in Magisk Hide and it does not detect busybox.
[Magisk] Vobi1024:
True, that one is hidden. I'm guessing not that one is the issue.

So You don't have /system/xbin, right?

Also, there is no /system/xbin in Your PATH?
[Magisk] Killua96:
I have xbin folder with files in it on my OP6 and Busybox checker says that I've no root and nor busybox, and it's correct