yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
I don't think you ever said: do you fail both cts profile and basic integrity when checking SafetyNet?
[Magisk] kojak1989:
Hi, i have nexus 5X with android 8.1 and if i flash magisk i will be able to install updates from google ota img or something ?
[Magisk] HigherStateD:
Trying to get safetynet to pass without changing my device Id. It passes CTS with the universal fix, but I don't have a xaomi m1... Wiped phone, reflashed, now having issues with magisk installing YouTube modules, and running boot scripts. Iytb seems to install fine, but the icon and apk aren't anywhere. This is on the latest resurrection remix for perry, moto e4 snapdragon
[Magisk] Yasharkhan:
Someone help please.....

I've asked this question many times, my problem is that my magisk modules don't stick after a reboot. I'm using pixel 2 xl on 8.1 with latest magisk version, but no TWRP installed, can any one help me what's wrong?
[Magisk] madbat99:
Everything works and passes safetynet here on moto e4 Perry. Running stock though. Might be an issue in your rom.

I'm also using iytbp module.
[Magisk] Pkt_Lnt:
Here is a ** maybe **.

https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=75523385&postcount=4977
[Magisk] HigherStateD:
I had the injected youtube background player on my original Resurrection remix install, and was able to pass the CTS safetynet check with the xaomi mod, but encryption wasn't working. Magisk would promppt for a reinstall on every boot, and the install wouldn't work. after trying a few others, i did a clean install of RR to try and work on that with some new info for passing safetynet with my original fingerprint. I am stumpted as to why this install isn't working as well as originally. And yes, the stock rom is the difference, as that should pass safetynet with magiskhide alone, as it has the right fingerprint.
[Magisk] spiritflare01:
jcm

after installing magisk 15.3, go to downloads section in the magisk manager (app) and you'll see: Init.d linker

(There's also a sudo.)

Maybe that will help.

/s
[Magisk] Draizix:
On February security update with magisk I pass both.

On December security update with supersu I fail both.

That's how I came to the conclusion of fire emblem doesn't care about passing it or not and that it is something else.
[Magisk] DanteDeSalvator:
I'm using Magisk 15.3 in Android 8.1 (upgraded today), it installed correctly, root access works good, modules installed correctly, rebooted for their activation and they all were properly installed and activated in Magisk Manager, BUT, none are in the apps list. AR stickers and gcam, viper4android fx, dolby, AML, iYTBP, none are installed in actual directory or showing anywhere. I unindtalled Magisk with uninstaller and began again, I rebooted multiple times, once they all showed and it worked but then I opened the AR sticker, system rebooted, and boom, all gone again, shows they're installed in Magisk but they're nowhere to be seen.
[Magisk] NLBeev:
The only 'module' on my N6 that's in the app list, is Unified Hosts Manager. Because it's a shortcut in Magisk.
[Magisk] rnexusv:
Hello I just updated my Galaxy S8 (SM-G950F) to Oreo and when trying to install magisk I get stuck in the boot animation where the samsung logo shines and the blue LED is on

Has anyone heard about this problem before and is there a way to fix it ?
[Magisk] HigherStateD:
Iytbp should come up as a YouTube app icon with a black border
[Magisk] madbat99:
Seems to be an issue on some Oreo roms. Various reasons. F2fs data causes it for some (even without the loopback bug).
[Magisk] DanteDeSalvator:
I even tried on a different 8.1 ROM, still the same issue. What to do :crying:
[Magisk] anonymvs_xda:
Hi,

I am new on this field, and I need help, please. On my SM-J500FN (Samsung Galaxy J5 2015) I flashed the "Odyssey Note8" ROM (Android 7.1.1) with Quasar_Kernel v1.6 (all by [MENTION=6911575]BlackMesa123[/MENTION]) which is prerooted with Magisk. Later I updated the Magisk to v15.3. Everything works fine ... I have Superuser privileges, but my problem is that I can not install any module from Magisk manager. Tried with "Greenify4Magisk" and "ExSDCard Access Enabler". Every time I got a message "! Installation failed". I have install log, but can't attach link now, because of 10 post threshold ...

... sorry if I am off topic ...
[Magisk] Yasharkhan:
HEEEELPPPP

its the 4th time i am posting regarding this issue and i have not found any help. My device is Pixel 2 XL ,i am on Android 8.1 latest feb security patch now with 15.3 zip and 5.5.5 apk installed with custom Kernel. Even with stock kernel i was facing this issue that no module is sticking, they get installed but after reboot they disappear. it doesnt matter if i flash them through twrp or from inside the app, they disappear after reboot. what is wrong? and can anyone please help me?
[Magisk] jimbomodder:
I assume you on stock rom, have you tried a custom rom to check if it's just stock that's an issue? Make sure to have a backup of current before trying it out. Also have you tried an older version of magisk? Maybe worth a shot
[Magisk] kkuehl:
I have a Pixel2 which of course is a skip_initramfs style device. TWRP + Magisk working properly.

Is it possible to use a magisk module to modify initr.c and ueventd.rc files?

Due to the skip_initramfs, I cannot just unpack/repack the boot.img and modify the ramdisk to change those files like I could on an older device.
[Magisk] Yasharkhan:
Yeah I'm on stock room ,I have tried older version of magisk notably 15.1 but faced the same issue
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Might be a module causing issues. Try one module at a time to see if any one of them is the culprit.

Use Pastebin and then post the id here.

I looked at your posts and not a single one of them contains any logs. Installing/recovery log, Magisk log and preferably a magisk_debug.log would all be very useful.

Look here:

https://didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHelp
[Magisk] Yasharkhan:
I always install them one by one, I install one module reboot and it's gone
[Magisk] Teracotta:
I purchased a Galaxy S7 (G935F) on Nougat but I can't install Magisk. The /data partition doesn't mount in TWRP. I go to do a factory reset, and that fails too for the same reason. The phone bootloops so I can only go to recovery and download mode. Knox hasn't been tripped yet.

What do I do to solve this? I enabled OEM unlocking and USB debugging before installing TWRP.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
The "one by one" module advice was for another user...

You don't happen to have Core Only mode activated in the Manager settings. Your log kind of makes it look like it is and that would disable all modules... There's also an error in there that makes me think you might have an issue with your Magisk installation, rather than the above.

That sounds like a question better asked in your device's forum...
[Magisk] Teracotta:
I don't have to since I figured out the problem - the data partition is encrypted once you boot the phone up, so you have to wipe & factory reset. Which doesn't make sense considering the OEM unlocking step, but I guess that's a device difference.
[Magisk] JimZiii:
i really need some help. i just updated my honor 8 (frd-l09) to B399 and after doing that i'm getting a bootloop on every magisk version available. i've tried the beta, 15,3 15,2 and 14 and of course i'm forced to flash the magisk uninstall to get my phone to boot again.

when updating i had some serious issues with data and system partitions locking up, making it impossible to mount them, so i formatted them which fixed the problem, but this also removed the encryption if that makes any difference

thnx in advance
[Magisk] anonymvs_xda:
<script src="https://pastebin.com/embed_js/gMyaRwHQ"></script>
[Magisk] Artim_96:
You should play around with the controls for "keep force-encryption" and "keep dm-verity", maybe one of them needs to be changed to work with the update
[Magisk] jenslody:
Did you install another module before ?

If yes, did you try to reboot after installing just one module ?

Can you also provide a recovery.log from a failed install through TWRP ?

Directly after flashing the zip (at least before reboot), go to advanced and copy the recovery.log to your sdcard/internal memory and paste it here (or in pastebin etc.).
[Magisk] plukanin:
Installed via 5.5.5 manager app latest 5.6.0 update, it gives me an fc starting it on oneplus 3 device, omni rom 8.1, latest firmware and modem

Any idea to solve that issue?

Returned back to 5.5.5...

Thanks in advance
[Magisk] bluenote73:
Same on ZTE Axon 7 nougat 7.1.1

Looking for previous MM now.
[Magisk] megarain555:
Same issue, except on nitrogen OS. Latest firm though.
[Magisk] MyronAz:
Ditto.

Previous here: https://github.com/topjohnwu/MagiskManager/releases
[Magisk] Dreaminday:
The latest magisk manager doesn't work on my AICP & phone . It forces to quit again and again . So I have to flash the previous version .
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
When you experience this issue, could you open a terminal emulator, type "mount" (without quotation marks) and post the output?

Things to try:

Make sure no themes are applied to the Manager when updating

Clear data for the Manager

Uninstall the old Manager and reinstall the new version clean (you'll find it in the release thread)

If nothing works, providing a logcat from the crash/FC is MANDATORY if expecting any kind of resolution
[Magisk] Dreaminday:
Yeah , I just rebooted to REC mode , and flashed the newest version that downloaded from the link which provided by XDA labs , but after I restarted system , and tried to open the magisk manager , it forced to quit . And I also tried to reflash rom and flash manager , of course , nothing in magisk manager , I tried this way for many times , but no succeed .So a few minutes ago , I backed to the previous version . As...Well, it is visible that I had no time to get a logcat . Maybe I can find one who met the same issue , confused about that and remained logcat . If I found , I will provide for you at the first time . Good luck :victory:

---------- Post added at 07:18 AM ---------- Previous post was at 07:15 AM ----------

By the way , how to catch a logcat ? I would like to update it and show you something if you don't mind the screenshot based on Chinese .
[Magisk] piranime:
New version doesnt support ctsprofile and basicintegrity?

Need logs?
[Magisk] gothicVI:
Google or XDA search... Seriously?!

Read op...

Gesendet von meinem Moto G 2014 LTE mit Tapatalk
[Magisk] NLBeev:
Nexus 6, Oreo 8.1 Beltz, EX kernel 5.0.7, Magisk 15.3, Mgr 5,60.

No issues. CTS and Safetynet passed. Test latest Netflix: working.
[Magisk] Voldemort13:
same

Im also on omnirom 8.1 with the same problem. People on the resurectionremix forums have said that the magisk problem could be that its F2FS fault. Maybe i try to change it.

But How did you reinstall 5.5.5? I get fc when i installed it back through TWRP.

The uninstal file is missing on the first post?:confused:

Invalid Attachment specified
[Magisk] Uzumaki:
I can't install any modules. In the log I'm getting this

Copying zip to Temp Directory
Installing Enable_Doze_For_GMS_Magisk.zip
update-binary[46]: .:/data/adb/magisk/util_functions.sh: Required key not available
failed!
Installation aborted

Can anyone help?
[Magisk] caike08:
[MENTION=7164624]Joshmonster995[/MENTION] actually I hadn't installed busybox on my phone. I was following a tutorial written by Android Police, but when I came to read this thread carefully, I realized they had flagged they found problems with Xperia phones. As I haven't found any solution so far, I'm still trying to play the 0.35 version. Just did a full restore in it, and I may not try to install it so soon :( just hope they manage to find something out
[Magisk] GFXi0N:
Magisk + tasker

Root:$(getprop magisk.supath)/su -c "setprop magisk.root 1"

Unroot: $(getprop magisk.supath)/su -c "setprop magisk.root 0"
[Magisk] Ice_machinE:
I never said that I think it's a root hide, hence my question about the roggle.

But now I can say the even with the toggle, AP, didn't work and I couldn't use my phone on the bus.
[Magisk] gk1984:
Did you verify everything is working correctly? Unmount su, then open Pay and try to add a card. If it fails, then you might have something tripping safety net. Not entirely sure what it could be without knowing your system. If it lets you add a card, then no issue. You may have to periodically try to add a card to let it see you're not rooted. It may check root in the background and remember it, causing the failed transaction. I haven't seen this reported much but some have had to do this trick.
[Magisk] benengyj:
Working perfectly on my Xperia Z5P as stated on the last page. :)
[Magisk] Uz986:
magisk is working fine when i toggle root it umount root ...all roots apps doesnt work

but pokemon go still doesnt work...

i am on cm14 on oneplus 2

anyidea?
[Magisk] Äptiva:
So after some serious testing I was unable to get AP and PoGo running again with Magisk and Dorimanx. I believe it's due to this kernel installing busybox, but I can't be sure until I attempt to recompile a stock kernel with gzip.
[Magisk] jcrompton:
I have successfully installed Magisk on the latest Nexus 6 DU ROM

Had to do full unroot with SuperSU, then install

After that still had to delete system/xbin/su to get the root toggle button to work

For done reason my Selinux button will still not toggle

How to fix?
[Magisk] xkwizt:
SGS5 - Samsung Galaxy S5

Not working for me. Heres what i did:

I flashed back to stock via Samsung Kies

Rebooted.

Flashed TWRP via odin.

Rebooted

Wipe data/factory reset

Flashed Magisk v6 via TWRP.

Flashed phh superuser via TWRP.

Flashed Systemless Xposed

Rebooted.

Phone not loading. im getting stuck on SAMSUNG boot screen. Am i doing something wrong?

I have now flashed back to stock.. ready to try again.
[Magisk] Marcoevo9:
Chris9000

I had the same problem after I installed xposed
[Magisk] bpear96:
It's only compatible with Android 7.0 nougat. Sorry
[Magisk] JudgeDread11:
Did you install the phh's superuser apk from Google play?
[Magisk] Marcoevo9:
I Uninstalled xposed, magisk, etc. Did a master reset and re-installed magisk. My root checker says I'm rooted when I have the toggle on and not rooted when it's off. Pokémon go won't load it stays on the loading screen with the white poke ball spinning. I didn't install xposed this time. Don't know what to try. I don't know if my account is banned. If I have to choose between being rooted or pogo. I'm staying rooted.
[Magisk] aliabkad:
For those of you who have the problem with pokeman , to solve it just don't take the update , it works well with root,
[Magisk] Marcoevo9:
Try rebooting after flashing phh superuser via twrp. See if it boots. If does then continue installing xposed.
[Magisk] xkwizt:
I cant get into the system after installing magisk, phh and xposed. Do i need to install the APK before installing these via TWRP? That means i dont do a factory reset before i flash the zip files.

Heres my new order that im going to try, let me know if this is right:

Flash back to stock via Samsung Kies

Reboot

Flash TWRP via odin.

Reboot to TWRP

Wipe data/factory reset

Boot/setup up phone, install APK's phh superuser, magisk manager and xposed installer

Reboot to TWRP

Flash phh superuser via TWRP.

Reboot to System. Check phh superuser installed correctly.

Reboot to TWRP.

Flash Magisk v6 via TWRP.

Reboot to system. Check Magisk installed correctly.

Reboot to TWRP.

Flash Systemless Xposed

Reboot to system.
[Magisk] topjohnwu:
I know Chainfire released a new version. He replied me with some info (finally!!), I'll see what can be done from my side.

v7 is around the corner :)
[Magisk] patkor:
Theres over 50 pages with questions why toggle goes automaticly on, instead of searching there are coming new posts.

So this is my method which worked for me:

CM 13

LeTV X800

1. via TWRP installed CM 13

2. flashed unSU

3. deleted folder supersu, next delete from system/bin/su or/and system/xbin/su

4. flashed Gapps

5. Magisk v6

6. phh SuperUser

7. Reboot and installed from market phh Superuser and Magisk Manager

8. run both and in Magisk manager turned off root

9. Run successfully PoGo 0.37 and picked my buddy

:)
[Magisk] Ice_machinE:
I can add my card but when I try to purchase something, I get the error message attached.

Also attached is my magisk settings.

Edit: I forgot to mention - I have OnePlus 3 running OxygenOS 3.2.4

Thank you.
[Magisk] IamIrene:
But it won't work for me, totally no idea what wrong

Using normal version xposed on my note 4

The game detected I'm rooted, and I forget to test to run the pokemon go before I flash xposed, will do later ...
[Magisk] BergischNRW:
Here is my logcat of Magisk Manager 5.6.0. It just force closes.

I uninstalled the old version before installing the new one.

Running an ZTE Axon 7 on 8.1.0
[Magisk] mrror:
I gave up. Manager all of a sudden started to crash upon launch, without letting me even grab a log (Matlog just hangs forever, and yes I did the adb command to read logs). Tried the beta but nothing changed, now I reverted back to 5.5.5, which works.

I already had problems with 5.6 (root always lost and random fc's) and I posted the logs here in the previous weeks. I'm on a Moto G 3 with latest stock (6.0.1)
[Magisk] Yasharkhan:
I don't have core only mode enabled, should I enable it? And what kinda error during installation are you seeing and how can I resolve it?
[Magisk] Shriac:
I am on magisk v14.0 and today after updating to magisk manager 5.6.0 all my installed modules like viper and busybox have disappeared. reinstalled them again and after reboot they disappear again. I am using galaxy s6 stock nougat.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
No, don't enable it. It's designed to disable all modules. Your log kind of looks like it does when this mode is enabled, that's why I asked. Might be worth toggling it on and off...

The error I saw was related to core parts of Magisk that couldn't be found. If that's the case, your installation is broken. A complete uninstall and a reinstall might fix that, but I seem to remember you've already tried this. A clean install of the new beta might be worth a shot.
[Magisk] supermaus100:
Which version can I take for the Sony xzp 8141?
[Magisk] n82freak:
sometimes lost root - logs

Hi.

I collected now some logs...
[Magisk] Wolfcity:
MM 5.6.0 working flawlessly on Moto G titan with AEX 4.6 (7.1.2) and magisk 15.3 stable.
[Magisk] AndrOmega:
I am on magisk v14.0 and today after updating to magisk manager 5.6.0 all my installed modules like viper and busybox have disappeared. reinstalled them again and after reboot they disappear again. I am using galaxy s7 edge stock nougat.

reverted to 5.5.5. and everything back to normal.
[Magisk] Artim_96:
Then update Magisk. Don't expect Magisk manager to support older versions of Magisk
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Copy-pasta? :silly:

Anyway... The advice by [MENTION=5125527]Artim_96[/MENTION] above is a good one.

---------- Post added at 16:52 ---------- Previous post was at 16:47 ----------

The latest (currently v15.3 stable or v15.4 beta) is usually a good start.

Those logs don't really show anything except that you should try to update Magisk to a current version or support is going to be non-existent...

If you can't update you'll need to help troubleshooting by providing all proper details, logs, boot image, etc.
[Magisk] AndrOmega:
dont want to update

cant u see that everybody is complaining with 15.3

dont want to reinstall rom and sh.t

went back to 555 and stayed here :highfive:
[Magisk] Artim_96:
I see no real complaints. Just try it. If it doesn't work make propper bug report

Btw: 15.4 is already out
[Magisk] gothicVI:
1. Nandroid -> no need to reinstall sh*t

2. If people don't test there won't be feedback. However, development needs feedback.

3. Not at you specifically: people need to get out of their comfort zones. You're getting great software and support for free in this forums. So give back by at least proper feedback and bug reports...

Gesendet von meinem Moto G 2014 LTE mit Tapatalk
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
It's already been covered above, but if you don't want to update, don't expect support...
[Magisk] Haldi4803:
I'm not really well versed with the android (magisk) boot order but would it be possible to load a seperate vendor partition from an .img file on /data before /system starts?

The idea is to get older phones treble compatible even if they don't have a free partition that can be missused.... according to: https://www.xda-developers.com/xiaomi-redmi-note-4-project-treble/
[Magisk] fiverings:
I have a Pixel XL running Feb. 8.1 update. I had Magisk 15.3 with 5.5.5 manager and everything was working correctly. Yesterday I up grated to Magisk manager5.6.0 and now I can't pass safety net. Pass first one then I get

Cts profile:false and basic integrity: false. So I went back and installed Magisk manager 5.5.5

And now I get the same failures as the 5.6.0

Could use a little help, Thank you
[Magisk] DiamondJohn:
Well, lucky you did a Nandroid backup BEFORE you made any system changes, like, for example, updating your root provider ;)

I did the upgrade, and all is good for me.:good: I have not had to use my nandroid. I did have a small issue in that it didn't install from the interface, I had to go explicitly into the Magisk folder on SD and run the APK manually. But that may be because I downloaded it and did not install it, then went to TWRP to make my backup, rebooted and tried from the interface, which failed.

However, I don't use any modules, or require Safetynet; which passes anyway.:cool: Samsung, Galaxy S4 GT-i9506 running self build Nougat RR
[Magisk] anonymvs_xda:
[MENTION=4667597]Didgeridoohan[/MENTION], [MENTION=8340552]jenslody[/MENTION]

yesterday I updated Magisk Manager to v5.6.0, and since then I can install both modules I was interested in. :good:
[Magisk] Android361abc:
Hi, and I am using Magisk 15.3 with Magisk Manager 5.6.0 on Android Oreo 8.1.0

It cause me can not install any applications with Package Installer. I tried to use 'pm' command to install one, but it report 'readlink failed : EACCES (Permission Dentied)' by kernel.:confused:

After I flash the stock bootimg, it works.

Is there anything I could do to fix it now?
[Magisk] n82freak:
Now i updated to newest Version Magisk 15.3 and Manager 5.6.0 . Next days i watching if Magisk sometimes lost root again.

My Device (samsung s7 nougat) run on Tgp-Kernel.

Thx for reading...
[Magisk] Homeboy76:
Suggestion: Post this question in this thread ' [BETA][2018.2.13] Magisk v15.4 (1540) by topjohnwu' with the Magisk 15.4 and 15.3 logs. They are very good at solving Magisk problems
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Actually, it's preferable if people keep SafetyNet stuff out of the Beta thread. Here's an excerpt from the OP:

[MENTION=6062138]fiverings[/MENTION] Take a look in the Magisk guide of there's anything you've missed.
[Magisk] piranime:
Issue with safety

Cant install netflix and other apps that need safety.

Xiaomi mi5s

Unlocked bootloader

Lineageos

Latest magisk manager

Latest magisk beta

Magisk_debug.log https://pastebin.com/4HtmbTGC

Install.log

https://pastebin.com/3wNd0Wsr

Magisk_log_date.log

https://pastebin.com/KZDVnXmx

Thanks for reading
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
That's because you have Xposed installed...

You might want to take a look in the Magisk guide. All your questions are already answered there...
[Magisk] Homeboy76:
Gotcha! Thanks for directing [MENTION=6062138]fiverings[/MENTION] to the appropriate thread. :)
[Magisk] kluczus:
Hello,

I have a problem with magisk 15.4 (I also tried 15.3) on Mate 9 Pro (LON-L29) with android Oreo and twrp 3.2.1

Unfortunately during installation I received an error - unable to find boot image. Any idea how to fix that ?

Log from recovery in attachment.
[Magisk] eliezerjk90:
Flash the ROM zip first (or at least boot.img which you can extract from the zip). You need to have a stock boot image to properly install magisk.
[Magisk] kluczus:
Ok, I have opened a update.app (from Oreo update file) with Huawei Update Extractor but there is no boot.img.

In Nougat update file boot.img is present.