yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] ipdev:
[MENTION=7321560]AndroidFL[/MENTION] seemed better to answer you here in the "General" thread.

Is there a particular version you are looking for?

I may be missing some but, I have most of them backed up. Even found Magisk-v2 on one of my archive drives. :)

Note:

Remember going backwards is only a stopgap. It may get you going again. The real solution is to try to help fix the current and newer versions.
[Magisk] Jaymin.0.1910:
Hi,

Can you give me every Magisk zip that is not available officially, cause I'm analyzing their code.

Sincerely thanks.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
The source code going all the way back to v7 is available on GitHub:

https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/releases
[Magisk] wafebreaker:
Anyone know why i have to reinstall magisk every 3-4 reboots? I mean after some reboots magisk is still installed but often i need to reinstall it. Really disappointing

I have a LG G5 with Lineage 14.1 installed
[Magisk] xdataibai:
I enabled dm-verify by re-install magisk, the phone cannot boot, so I went back. Thanks.
[Magisk] Fivegates:
The newer version 0.95.2 of Pokemon GO can detect Magisk (safetynet is all green); it's not like only me and my phone, but for all. https://ibb.co/kEZZLS

I tried core only mode and change name package (from the option of magisk manager), but it still can see something
[Magisk] Karls0:
It seems that Magisk hide is not working properly anymore. Some apps like PoGO can now "detect" root, or at least crash on safetynet check. For more details look here: https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/discussion-pokemon-magisk-discussion-t3465722/page322
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
There's absolutely no need to double post.

It's already known.

Please keep Pokemon discussion in the Pokemon thread. PoGo users have a habit of really cluttering up the thread otherwise. :D

It's already known.

If you'd looked through the Pokemon thread, you'd have seen it's been discussed extensively.
[Magisk] sgtslaughter64:
Maybe someone can help. I am attempting to replace superSU with magisk. I downloaded the manager app, am able to start the installation process, but I can't get past the screen that checks if i am a robot until I rate the app in the play store. I have attempted multiple times with no joy. Can anyone tell me what I should do next?
[Magisk] chandan kumar_92:
Hi I am on MM and magisk safetynet fails due to that I an unable to install some apps in my device as app says my device is incompatible but till yesterday it was running fine now what could be the reason someone please help me to pass safetynet issue

Thanks
[Magisk] Karls0:
That's true, but even despite of discussion there was no response and concert fix. Not everyone looks to Pokemon thread, so I posted it to inform, and let you know that if it is possible for simple game, soon it may also be for GooglePay and other more serious apps.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
You need to immediately uninstall that fake Magisk Manager and download the correct one from the release thread. The only place to download Magisk is right here @ XDA or on [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION]'s GitHub.

https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHide

Cheers for that, but... There's no fix posted, because there is no fix yet. The only thing to do is to wait...

And I promise you that all threads in the Magisk forum are looked at, there's no need for double posting.
[Magisk] jenslody:
Might even be related to this: https://www.xda-developers.com/google-blocks-gapps-uncertified-devices-custom-rom-whitelist .
[Magisk] RasAlGhoul69:
It's the first time i come across magisk can someone tell me what is the difference between magisk and root cloak?
[Magisk] Pkt_Lnt:
What Magisk is and all it does and its features can be found here.

https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/official-magisk-v7-universal-systemless-t3473445

You can compare with root cloak to see the differences.
[Magisk] ink718:
Magisk is breaking hotspot, tested on a few ROMs on PH1 phone.
[Magisk] jenslody:
What exactly is broken ?

Using your device as WLAN-Hotspot ?

Connecting to hotspots ?

Both works here flawlessly.

Please provide logs if possible.
[Magisk] mobileman88:
Hotspot via Wifi and USB are working well for me here. Using the stock 8.1.0 rom with Magisk 16.0 . Thanks.
[Magisk] RandomPooka:
Working fine here with PH-1 on Oreo 8.1 using Sprint.

Then again, I'm running an open network when I use my hotspot because I literally only use it when I know where I am and who could connect. Try disabling wireless security, if you have it enabled, to see if that's the issue.
[Magisk] vulturext:
Im using Mi6 on global dev rom 8.3.22. After flashing magisk, the device takes too long to boot (more than 30 minutes and still loading). I have to flash the stock boot.img and the phone boots normally. How can i make Magisk v16 work with my current Mi6 8.3.22 global dev rom? Thanks.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
What's your output of:

getprop init.svc.logd
[Magisk] martyfender:
The correct output should state: running
[Magisk] gregcd:
Hi I have a nexus 5x running 7.0.0 (N5D91L, Nov 2016). I extracted the boot.img file from here, https://developers.google.com/android/images#bullhead , but have the below failure when repacking.

Should I upgrade to 8.1 first, then try to patch the boot.img from https://developers.google.com/android/images#bullhead ?
[Magisk] Paresh18shah:
After doing said process can not bootup system..:confused: stuck on bootanimation only..
[Magisk] lvbaal:
I (might) have an issue with (receiving toast notifications of granted) superuser rights in Magisk (v16 / 5.6.3 (110)):

I have a system monitor app installed of which I was used to getting a toast notification ¨Systempanel has been granted superuser¨ on startup of the device (Huawei Mate 10 Pro).

This notification seems useful to me, also knowing that I will be informed of other apps being granted superuser. At this moment however, this toast notification does not pop up any more. Therefore I wonder if the setup is okay.

- Android (stock Oreo 8.0. Settings>Apps>Magisk Manager>Notifications>Allow notifications is set to on

- Magisk Manager>Settings>Superuser notification is set to ¨toast¨

I have un- and re-installed the Systempanel app, but the issue persists.

I see this behaviour with other apps granted superuser in Magisk Manager as well (I've tried a few, not all).

Any ideas where I could look to debug and/or resolve this?
[Magisk] guest4711:
Make sure the notication for this app is enabled (see the screenshot: I will be notified if KernelAdiutor requests root, but not if OsMonitor does it...
[Magisk] Jaymin.0.1910:
1) Copy /data/adb/magisk.img to /cache/magisk.img.

2) Flash Magisk.

3) Boot into system and let Magisk handle the merging:D
[Magisk] lvbaal:
All notifications are on. Always have been. So this is not the reason.
[Magisk] -Duir-:
It doesn't returning anything. There is no logd.

I've already tried faking it with resetprop but it doesn't help.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Could you send the entire output of:

getprop

Feel free to PM me if you want.
[Magisk] 29988122:
tl;dr: add package name randomization for xposed installer, in order to avoid the detection from fate grand order.

I believe this is the support thread of magisk/systemless xposed. A little feature request, thank you!

First, environment

Android 8.0

latest stable magisk

systemless xposed and topjohnwu fork of xposed installer.

I can confirm that once you disabled systemless xposed module in magisk manager, safetynet will pass but fate grand order still failed to start.

THE solution after I tested is to uninstall xposed installer temporarily, then fate grand order can start.

To enable xposed again, 1.restore xposed installer 2.enable the module inside magisk manager 3.reboot.

Is it possible to add an option like magisk manager's hide option to also randomly change the package name of xposed installer - topjohnwu fork?

According to this tweet by topjohnwu, https://twitter.com/topjohnwu/status/921753929372725248

you are willing to support fate grand order under magisk, right?

(Thank you!)
[Magisk] -Duir-:
Output is attached.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
This is the General support thread for Magisk, yes, but not for systemless Xposed. You'll find that here:

https://xdaforums.com/xposed/unofficial-systemless-xposed-t3388268

Doesn't sound like something that would have any kind of priority though... The only reason [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] has released his own version of the Xposed installer is to add the systemless paths so it can detect systemless Xposed. Sounds more like a request that should be aimed towards [MENTION=4419114]rovo89[/MENTION]. Or possibly [MENTION=5345056]DVDandroid[/MENTION] and his Material Design Xposed Installer. I'm just guessing here or course, but like I said I think [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] has other priorities...

If nothing else you could always try building the app from source yourself and just replace the app id with one of your own (nowhere near guaranteed to work :p).

---------- Post added at 17:32 ---------- Previous post was at 17:04 ----------

Thank you for that. Could you also provide the result of ps (as root):

su
ps
[Magisk] senthil01:
Plz anyone tell how to install Magisk on my android phone (oppo f1f 5.1.1).....i have unlocked bootloader and rooted..
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Either flash the Magisk zip in TWRP (or custom recovery of choice), or patch your device's boot image with the Manager and then flash the patched boot image manually.

You'll find instructions in the release thread. And you'll find lots of more info in the Magisk guide.
[Magisk] -Duir-:
I've had to revert to fully stock, so not rooted at the moment. May be a bit before that changes.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Ok, too bad... Thanks for your help anyway.
[Magisk] pawelik001:
I'm using magisk, but I can't pass ctsProfile. I'm using universal Safety net fix for Fix the ctsprofile. But... I can't pay with Google Pay. Any help? I'm using huawei p8 lite with RROS 5.8.5.
[Magisk] gothicVI:
Are you using xposed?

Gesendet von meinem Moto G 2014 LTE mit Tapatalk
[Magisk] pawelik001:
No. But I'm using adaway.

Sent from my P8 Lite with RROS 5.8.5 [emoji41]
[Magisk] guest4711:
Did you enable "systemless hosts" in MagiskManager before installing AdAway?
[Magisk] senthil01:
I already tried...it stuck into bootloop...what can i do??

I'm using stock os of oppo(colorOs-v2.1.0i)
[Magisk] pawelik001:
No

Sent from my P8 Lite with RROS 5.8.5 [emoji41]
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHelp
[Magisk] edzamber:
Hi all,

After a while i loose root. It happening after let screen off a long time or suddenly without any reason. Magisk returns not installed. I have to reboot, sometimes twice for root comes back.

Any idea how to fix ?

Using Magisk v16.2, S6 Edge G925F Nougat custom Samsung based.

Many Thanks.
[Magisk] -Duir-:
As mentioned I'm not rooted currently, but if it can help at all here's the output without root.
[Magisk] guest4711:
Safety net will not pass if you modify /system. So you should revert to the original hostfile ("disable ad blocking" in AdAway), enable "systemless hosts" in Magisk Manager, reboot and enable AdAway ("download files and apply...") again.
[Magisk] senthil01:
Thanks
[Magisk] pawelik001:
Still doesnt work. Maybe it caused by BusyBox? I have installed BusyBox systemless, but I still havent passe ctsprofile :(

Sent from my P8 Lite with RROS 5.8.5 [emoji41]
[Magisk] -Duir-:
I didn't see any mention so I'm assuming yes, but with the new Magisk 16.3 and Magisk Manager 5.6.4 is logd still a requirement for Magisk Hide to work?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
No change in this beta release. It's under investigation though...
[Magisk] @ Ayush Garg:
There wad no magisk log.. Magisk log alway show remains empty with new versions.. I uninstalled completely and then install v16.3 but still there is no log..

..

When i install v15.3 or previous versions.. Magisk and safetynet works fine and also magisk has logs...here is magisk log of v15.3

..

My device is Samsung galaxy note 4 (SM-N910G)

..

(sorry for bad English if i did any mistake)
[Magisk] @ Ayush Garg:
There was no magisk log.. Magisk log alway show remains empty with new versions.. I uninstalled completely and then install v16.3 but still there is no log..

..

When i install v15.3 or previous versions.. Magisk and safetynet works fine and also magisk has logs...here is magisk log of v15.3

..

My device is Samsung galaxy note 4 (SM-N910G)

..

(sorry for bad English if i did any mistake)
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
It's known. Search for "logd" in the later parts of the thread and the beta thread and you'll find why (spoiler: Magisk v15.4+ looks if logd is enabled to start MagiskHide and your device doesn't use it). It's under investigation.
[Magisk] @ Ayush Garg:
Hmmmm.. And safetynet is also not working... I was working fine on v15.3 but with new versions its not working and for UPI payment apps its must..

..

Please do something about this.. ?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
That's how it works... If MagiskHide can't work (because of the logd thing), SafetyNet will fail. And like I said:

Use v15.3 meanwhile, or live without MagiskHide, until there's a fix (if there is one).
[Magisk] Rom:
@Didgeridoohan

Hello, sorry to bother u, would u know which Busibox source topjhonwu have included in Magisk?

I ask this question because the official website dosn't indicate the "e2label" applet that would serve me in the action i wish to make.

The package in question is included in another Busibox source with additional applets ready to be compiled.

Thank u in advance.
[Magisk] AZImmortal:
When using the patched boot.img method of installing Magisk, is it necessary to do the patching on the same device with the same software version as what's being patched? In other words:

If I have a Pixel 2 running 8.1 March update, can I use that to patch April's boot.img before I actually flash April's update?

Can I use the Pixel 2 to patch the boot.img for another phone?
[Magisk] ipdev:
Outside of the architecture it does not seem to make a difference.

- arm64 boot image has to be patched using an arm64 device.

- arm boot image has to be patched using an arm device.

- I assume x86 is the same.

- Not sure if Pixel is different. :confused:

---------- Post added at 03:40 AM ---------- Previous post was at 03:22 AM ----------

Unless there is a reason you want to stay back on 7.0. UPDATE :D

Beside the obvious reasons, there are some nice new options in "o"

Looks like something is not correct, interfering or corrupt on your device. You might want to think about a clean install.

Both image-bullhead-n5d91l/boot.img and image-bullhead-opm3.171019.016/boot.img patch properly for me using Magisk v16.0 and v16.3
[Magisk] Zonezeon:
Magiskhide not working

When I use the terminal emulator to run the command

"magiskhide --enable"

It returns

Logd is not running, cannot run logcat

Magisk version is 16.0

My kernel version is 3.10

Device: Lenovo Vibe X3

Even the basic integrity test has failed, even after reinstalling stock rom and flashing magisk directly.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
As far as I know, the official source.

OT: I once made the mistake of thinking about what this phrase actually implies... Once seen, can't be unseen. :laugh:
[Magisk] jenslody:
For the moment you have to stick on 15.3.

There is already an ongoing discussion about that. [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] knows about it and might come up with a fix.

As long as MagiskHide is not working (because Magisk can not detect log-process), you will not be able to pass safteynet on a rooted phone.
[Magisk] KageyamaOuda:
Sorry for the long wait. The hidelist file wasn't there, I created one and made it writable but the problem of Magisk Hide not working nor saving what I check still persists. How would I provide a Magisk log?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
No worries...

Instead of the Magisk log, try running the following command in a terminal emulator (as su):

magiskhide --enable

If that returns "Logd is not running, cannot run logcat", it's a known issue and is being looked into (take a look at the post before yours).

---------- Post added at 08:33 ---------- Previous post was at 07:41 ----------

Wrong thread (which is why I answer you here instead). Tested and with the game added to the Hide list and with the Manager hidden it doesn't detect anything.
[Magisk] iPusak Gaoq™:
i don't hide the Magisk Manager but i do add that game to list of Magisk Hide and when i launch it i got this popup "this app will be terminated because a security policy violation has been detected [code : 00000034]"....this error doesn't appears prior to today updates so hiding the Magisk Manager can help?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Of course it can. Like I said, I just tested, and without having the Manager hidden (repackaged) the game wouldn't start.
[Magisk] iPusak Gaoq™:
Thanks...hiding the Magisk Manager seems to "fool" the game perfectly now :p
[Magisk] firozpatel:
Could someone explain how magisk can make a uncertified device, certified please
[Magisk] Ja_som:
https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/o...systemless-t3473445/post76042873#post76042873
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Basically, if your device passes SafetyNet it should be perceived as certified, and Magisk can make your device pass SafetyNet.

https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHide
[Magisk] Zonezeon:
To install 15.3 should I first uninstall v16 using unSU?

Or can I just flash it using twrp?
[Magisk] firozpatel:
Okay I get it now, my device passes safety net through magisk so I should be good

Thanks for making it easy to understand
[Magisk] pawelik001:
The universal safetynet fix repaired my safetynet on magisk v16.0. Can universal safetynet fix prevent phone payments?

Wysłane z mojego ALE-L21 przy użyciu Tapatalka
[Magisk] demonoidmaster:
Where did you get it from?
[Magisk] pawelik001:
From this link: https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/xiaomi-safetynet-fix-t3600431

My device: Huawei P8 Lite

ROM: RROS 5.8.5

Anyway, my device before flashing can't pass ctsprofile, but when I flashed module, ctsprofile is passed.

Wysłane z mojego ALE-L21 przy użyciu Tapatalka
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
If you pass SafetyNet you should be good to go.

But, that module messes with Magisk internals and I do not recommend it being used anymore. Nothing's happened development wise in 7 months so it looks like it's abandoned. MagiskHide has also had some serious improvements in that time, so the only part of that module that is needed now is the change of ro.build.fingerprint to make your device look like a certified one.

There are other modules around that can do that, of which my MagiskHide Props Config is one.
[Magisk] vulturext:
I'm wishing for a luck now. im using Mi 6 Miui 8.3.22 dev global rom. With magisk v16, i cant boot my phone. it stuck on loading screen and i have to flash stock boot image. Any way to get magisk working with Miui 8.3.22 global developer rom?
[Magisk] sleeptab:
Hey,

I hope I'm right here and I'm pretty new to Magisk. Haven't found anything yet.

My Problem is when I flash Magisk.zip with TWRP and reboot the device, manager says there is no backup found. However I need Magisk to find OTA on my system but stock boot.img to flash it.

So I need your help. I've got stock boot.img. Can I put it to .gz and into which name and folder on my device can I store it so Magisk-Manager recognzies it as a backup to restore? Thank you:)
[Magisk] MarwanKhalid55:
Does flashing Magisk through TWRP disable OTA? Thanks
[Magisk] sleeptab:
No It's moto x4 with ProjectFi. Very complicated. I need active magisk to get on retus-channel (just changing build.prop is not enough). But a clean boot.img to start flashing.

Flashfire etc. doesn't work. That's why I ask how to save my boot.img as a magisk-backup.

If you ask for yourself: A changed boot.img always makes OTA unable to install. However, just flash your original boot.img and recovery.img and you can install them again.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
What do you mean with "manager says there is no backup found"? Where does it say that, and when? Logs are also nice...
[Magisk] sleeptab:
Logs are in attachment, thank you.

Original message is: "Stock backup does not exist!"

I don't know why :/

That's why I asked where it is stored and which names they have so I could at least pack my boot.img for Magisk Manager to recognize as backup.
[Magisk] derAndroidler:
I update Magisk Manager, but forgot to unhide it before.

Is this a problem?
[Magisk] jenslody:
No, the originally named one should remove the packaged version automatically.

By the way, that's exactly how unhiding the Manager works.
[Magisk] jcmm11:
Easiest way to get the backup - go into recovery. Flash the stock boot image. Flash Magisk.
[Magisk] flyingjack:
All, I am running a Huawei Mate 9 with latest Oreo FW (MHKL29-C432B367) and latest TWRP.....when trying to flash latest Magisk zip in TWRP I always get an ERROR.....any idea what is going wrong.

Thx in advance for your reply!
[Magisk] sbcrumb:
PNC Mobile Banking

I am having issues using the PNC Mobile banking app, I can get it to load if I hide Magisk from it. However when I try to use the mobile deposit and take photos of checks the app crashes. However it does work before I load up Magisk. no modules loaded. Just bare root access for it.

OP5T Any ROM. Currently Omni.

PNC Mobile Banking app version 4.3.1

Magisk Version 16

Logs attached.
[Magisk] TonikJDK:
Hide Magisk from it, then clear cache data on PNC. That fixed it for me.
[Magisk] sleeptab:
That's what I did several times and why I posted logs. It says it does backup but after start then I start Magisk Manager it says ""Stock backup does not exist!""
[Magisk] sbcrumb:
After hiding and clearing the cache and data. I can login. But the same problem is there. If I try to do a mobile deposit it will FC(Force Close) when It goes to open the camera to take the photo of the check.
[Magisk] sleeptab:
What did you want to say? Don't understand anything..

EDIT: You edited your post haha. I still don't understand why you quote me when I just ask for a solution to a completely different problem.. But now at least I understand I can't understand as there's no reason to refer to my posts with your problem.
[Magisk] jhedfors:
Did you quote the correct post? Does not seem related to what you quoted. however, I am interested, as I have the same problem with my BECU banking account on my OPO.
[Magisk] sbcrumb:
---------- Post added at 01:35 PM ---------- Previous post was at 01:34 PM ----------

[/COLOR]

After hiding and clearing the cache and data. I can login. But the same problem is there. If I try to do a mobile deposit it will FC(Force Close) when It goes to open the camera to take the photo of the check.
[Magisk] jhedfors:
Same here. I did the same, but did not help. On Oreo now, but it was the same for Nougat, been happening for several months.
[Magisk] jcmm11:
According to the recovery log it successfully created a backup of the stock image. It should be found at

/data/stock_boot_295bbdbdcc94fe5e2cd8df080e299e2cadc1f3dd.img.gz

The Magisk log shows me nothing of value in this case.

AFAIK Magisk Manager doesn't care if that backup exists or not. Be right back - going to test that. Ok - renamed my backup. Force stopped Magisk Manager. Cleared cache. Tried to start Magisk Manager. No problem and no message about missing backup.

So something else is triggering that message. Try getting a logcat. I suggest using the app matlog. Start recording. Force the error. Stop recording. Post the log.
[Magisk] demonoidmaster:
tried it just to see if it would while xposed is enabled, it doesn't do nada for me

Another thing i noticed is the "Android is finishing updating" text , same thing happened when i tried the other module you said for props
[Magisk] sleeptab:
Thank you:) Now the Ultimate confusion: There wasn't any file. Anytime I tried. But I was able to pack a boot.img with my PC and save it exactly there - now Magisk could restore it with success.

EDIT: Some information for developers: Reflashing Magisk deletes the Backup I placed there manually. But doesn't create new one.
[Magisk] jenslody:
It os answered so often, but nobody cares, even if the rules ask the user to search before asking.

Xposed != safetynet.

Enabled xposed always breaks safetynet !