yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] robiox:
Hello,

This is my experience:

- I've correctly unlocked and installed magisk on my Mi A2 Lite,

- Correctly installed october's OTA (uninstall magisk, apply ota without reboot, reinstall magisk, reboot).

I made a mistake with november's OTA, I uninstalled magisk, apply OTA and reboot without reinstall magisk before reboot.

Is it a problem?

Could I install magisk now or I've lost the root???

If I open Magisk it say that isn't installed, It ask me to download as zip or update boot image...

Please help me!

Thanks!
[Magisk] tioubxancur:
I use fingerprint authentication for superuser. But the problem is the default superuser action is grant/deny forever.

This way what happens is, once authenticated, the app has superuser access all the time and doesn't ask for authentication the next time. If i want it to work correctly, every time an app requests superuser access, I have to change the action to once or 10/20/30 mins etc. The reason I use fingerprint authentication is, it is quick. But this beats the purpose, when I have to manually change the setting everytime.

I have looked around in the settings, but couldn't find a way to change the default action. Please don't point me to the Automatic Response (Prompt/Grant/Deny), thats not what I am looking for here.

I want a way to set the default grant action to once instead of forever. Is there a way to do this? If not can you add an option to change this default behaviour?
[Magisk] IzaacJ:
Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge (Exynos)

Samsung Stock ROM 8.0 Oreo (September security patch)

Magisk 17.3

Magisk Manager 6.0.1 (151)

MagiskHide Off

Superuser Access Apps and ADB

No matter what I do I can NOT get `adb root` to work. Tried with MagiskHide Props Config to set ro.debuggable=1 and ro.build.selinux=0 without any luck. And as soon as ro.debuggable is set to 1, Developer Options instantly force closes on me. Tried [MENTION=631273]Chainfire[/MENTION]'s ADBD Insecure v2 and as soon as insecure adbd is active USB debugging is disabled until I deactivate insecure adbd.

Is there no way to get `adb root` to work properly on Oreo with Magisk?

Root works perfectly using `adb shell` thou.
[Magisk] martyfender:
What about ro.adb.secure=0 set in MagiskHide Props config in addition to what you have set?
[Magisk] Paget96:
I have a problem with my app L Speed, people saying that it won't grant root with the latest Magisk update. I'm asking now, is there anything what I miss, probably in implementation or something?

At the moment root check happens asynchronous in background, I don't see a problem there.

I'm asking because I don't have problem at all on several devices.

Thanks.
[Magisk] partcyborg:
You need to set ro.secure=0 too for adb root to work I think. I did anyway. Try it
[Magisk] martyfender:
I have 5 Nextbook Ares 8A's, x86, Android 6.0.1 and I have the latest Canary builds on 2 of them, 1 with [MENTION=7187684]ianmacd[/MENTION] unofficial build and 2 devices with [MENTION=3306843]kantjer[/MENTION] unofficial builds.

I have no problems on the most recent builds of each with lspeed granting root.

I did have a strange problem though, on recent builds where the first launch of the updated app, not exclusive to lspeed, where upon update and on launch of the updated app, where root was granted, even though I have in MM settings:

Re-authenticate after upgrade, was checked. I did not get the root prompt. Killing the app in recents and relaunching the app, I did get the root prompt, as expected. In the most recently released builds, I am getting the root prompt, right away, as expected.

what version are they saying this is from, the stable, 17.1, or the beta 17.3?

Some fixes have obviously been made on Canary builds and the most recent commits, the unofficial builds.
[Magisk] Paget96:
Yeah, seems line v17.1 don't have a problem. The most reports are from v17.3
[Magisk] nuxbag:
Last time I tried this on my note 4 sprint, it gave me issues. Is it now ok to use? Stock note 4 rom latest. And I was thinking of getting the sprint s7 used will this work? again would be using it stock. I can't find anything concrete on this and have looked. Thanks for any help.

I am trying to switch because my note 4 is now rebooting it self many times a day now with xposed.
[Magisk] warrencoakley:
I was wondering if someone can help with this app that seems can't be hidden and is detecting root? Appreciate the support. SKY Go. I'm on stock rom 9.0

https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.bskyb.skygo
[Magisk] wes'side:
I'm trying to figure out why when I go to flash no longer on the menu mods through the recovery it tells me magisk isn't found, on a nexus 6p, mm6.01 an 17.1, let's get one thing straight every magisk mid should be available on that list an I can name a few if nessisary but I'm sure there allot of people who still find use of those repost, it's a shame how great my device functioned having said no longer available mods, fo instance force enable skia opengl mod, can't seem to find it nor do I longer have it due to a ransomware attack putting all my files in a position of useless on my laptop so everything file wise was encrypted with nozelesn at the end of each file an I can't seem to fix that other than removing the the issue that caused it so anyone know how to unencrypt a file to normal again let me know.

But force opengl skia for Nexus 6p I can't seem to find it which is why I believe it should be back on the list amongst other that's have been taken off. Thanks
[Magisk] GrndSers-Rcng:
Hello, I'm having the issue where I cannot install any modules on my phone... I currently have a Pixel 1, 2 and 3 XL with the same issues... Both are on the latest OS and magisk 17.3... I have done research on the issue and haven't found any good answers... Thanks in advance for the help!
[Magisk] jcmm11:
Have you tried a Canary build?
[Magisk] GrndSers-Rcng:
Not yet... Ill try it and report back...

---------- Post added at 11:17 PM ---------- Previous post was at 10:52 PM ----------

Just tried it on the canary build and same issue...
[Magisk] xunholyx:
Flash the Magisk uninstaller, the reinstall it.
[Magisk] GrndSers-Rcng:
That's how I did it.
[Magisk] xunholyx:
That's strange. I have a Pixel 2XL and haven't had any problems with downloading/installing any modules. 17.3 beta build (17302)
[Magisk] beardymarrow:
https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHide
[Magisk] J4jks:
Losing magisk after reboot, rebooting again brings back magisk.

I'm on magisk 17.3, Moto G 2014

What could be the reason?
[Magisk] martyfender:
Use Disk info to determine if your data partition is formatted as F2FS. If it is, you may have the bugged version of the kernel.

This Magisk Module, or a custom kernel, such as ElementalX, with the bug fix, can solve your problem.

https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/guide-magisk-official-version-including-t3577875

This module works by moving magisk.img to the cache partition (EXT[2-4]-formatted).
[Magisk] unhappybirthday:
This happens regularly on my Pixel 1. I just install them through TWRP instead.
[Magisk] 1nikolas:
Hello. I have a problem with Magisk. On some apps (like Migrate, matlog or terminal emulator when I type su) I don't get a prompt for root, thus apps don't get root. I have latest magisk beta (17.3) on a Redmi Note 4 with AOSP Extended. Thanks in advance!

EDIT: I just reinstalled magisk and this happens with every single app.. :(

Please fix this bug.. I can't live without root :crying: :crying: :crying:

EDIT #2: Here is the magisk log http://fii.cz/jjaww

EDIT #3: It somehow fixed by itself. While I was doing something else apps randomly started requesting root. Weird stuff....
[Magisk] IzaacJ:
Thanks for your suggestions. Don't know what's different now, but after flashing the new system update for my device (oct security patch) it worked OOTB with magisk and adb root :D Can't seem to find those props in build.prop either, so maybe they're not needed at all xD
[Magisk] J4jks:
Thanks.

I'll try the module as my device doesn't have those custom kernels
[Magisk] guest4711:
Did you try the canary build?

https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/dev-magisk-canary-channel-bleeding-edge-t3839337/post77549897
[Magisk] Technical:
Hi, when I'm flashing Magisk I'm losing WiFi. I've tested with Stable Magisk (v17.1) and also the Beta Magisk (v17.3). If I uninstall Magisk (flashing the uninstaller), WiFi is back again. Does anybody know what is happening? I'm at Moto Z2 Force and using PixelDust ROM (https://xdaforums.com/project-treble/trebleenabled-device-development/9-0-pixel-dust-pie-t3862484). Thanks.

I've trying to search xda, however, I did not find an exact correlation on installing Magisk and losing WiFi.
[Magisk] Pkt_Lnt:
That should be easy to track with the proper logs.
[Magisk] Technical:
You're right. I'll try to get them next days.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
I believe that's a relatively common issue with GSI ROMs. Best place to ask for advice would be your ROM thread. But since I don't think anyone yet knows why it happens, I'm pretty sure they'll tell you to go to the Magisk forum. :laugh:
[Magisk] warrencoakley:
Cheer's. Just hid Magisk and it work.
[Magisk] demonoidmaster:
must be that then, maybe a bug in one of the previous magisk releases back then
[Magisk] partcyborg:
On pre treble devices they are in /default.prop
[Magisk] raosahab:
I am facing a problem with three magisk modules -

1. AM3D Zirene Sound

2. Viper34Android FX

3. Audio Modification Library

All are wotking with my Samsung Galaxy Note 3 SM N900 HA3G Exynos Version Running with RR 5.8.5. The problem is whent i install these modules the icon and name does not apperas in my app drawer and don't show real name. The name becomes com.viper.xyz.xys..htdc somethng like this for both apps please suggest me how to modify this. Whats is happening with them.Please help me
[Magisk] mrjoy:
Hi dev. I'm on s8+ Repulsa rom but magisk hide not working for me. It won't hide from root detection. I'm unable to run my banking apps. Even i have tried on ambasadii rom too, still same problem. Please help me.
[Magisk] 12Fully:
I got magisk working on pixel 3 XL November patch, but on apps like Pokemon Go they won't work and I pass safety net. Before, using magisk hide, hiding any magisk related files via explorer and the Hide Magisk Manager option usually worked. When I hide the magisk Manager and reboot it makes me install a second magisk Manager and the initial one doesn't have root anymore. Any advice?
[Magisk] martyfender:
Have you tried the latest Canary build?
[Magisk] gnam:
Any news about the OP6/6T bug with power off charging screen?
[Magisk] Killua96:
Is magisk still being detected from fate go?
[Magisk] mrjoy:
i have checked, most apps worked in magisk hide but one particular app not working.
[Magisk] jenslody:
Real helpful post.

Which version of Magisk ?

Which device ?

Which Rom ?

Which app ?

Logs ?
[Magisk] Gr8man001:
+1
[Magisk] geminium:
Sorry for nub but how to downgrade from beta to stable?

Can I just overwrite 17.1 or I need to uninstall 17.3 first and then install 17.1?
[Magisk] mrjoy:
1. Magisk 17.2

2. Samsung galaxy s8+

3. Repulsa rom

4. https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.idea.ideamoney

5. Logs attached
[Magisk] Paschfire:
To avoid any issues it's best to use the Magisk-uninstaller.zip when changing to different Magisk builds.
[Magisk] martyfender:
https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHide

There is an option to filter the logcat in Catlog, I suggest filtering it next time for com.idea.ideamoney. LogcatX allows a per app logcat feature, also.

On launch, does the app state that it is detecting root? I could not find any evidence of that in the logcat, but then again, there is so much to filter through, so I could have missed it.

Does your device pass Safety Net?

Do you have the Magisk Manager hidden in it's settings?
[Magisk] fleischbanane:
Hey [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION]

My banking app stops working with it's new version. I already tried Magisk 17.1 and 17.3 on different phones and roms:

OnePlus6 OxygenOS OpenBeta6

Redmi Note 5 Pro Lineage 15.1

Moto G3 Lineage 14.1

Of course I use Magisk Hide and I use the option to hide the app. Without hiding both versions detect root.

I use an old version which works right now: de.fiducia.smartphone.android.securego.vr_18.17.0.apk

The new version detects root: de.fiducia.smartphone.android.securego.vr_18.17.7.apk

I really hope you can help me, because without this app I can't use my bank account any more. If you need any more infos please contact me!
[Magisk] 12Fully:
No I havent. The only version I've managed to find is 17.3. I randomly decided to root and I haven't been following Magisk since I got my P3.

I'll try and find it via Google.
[Magisk] mrjoy:
Yes safety Net passed & magisk manager hidden in settings.
[Magisk] martyfender:
No I havent. The only version I've managed to find is 17.3. I randomly decided to root and I haven't been following Magisk since I got my P3.

I'll try and find it via Google.[/QUOTE]

https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/dev-magisk-canary-channel-bleeding-edge-t3839337

I always add xda to the end of my search terms to find most things on xda:

Magisk Canary builds xda, for example.
[Magisk] guest4711:
No need to send data to google (or any other search engine). Using search+ in xda with parameters "magisk canary" will show the relevant threads, beginning with the Magisk Canary thread:

https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/dev-magisk-canary-channel-bleeding-edge-t3839337/post77549897
[Magisk] xunholyx:
[MENTION=8126387]martyfender[/MENTION] [MENTION=4545537]12Fully[/MENTION] The XDA search function is actually powered by Google as well.
[Magisk] guest4711:
Oh, thanks. Not mentioned nor to see when using the xdalabs app :(
[Magisk] starach:
Hi,

In reference to my post https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=78141702&postcount=295

I've been able to patch boot.img of my Android 8.1 using Magisk 17.3 ( output log below )

I'm quite new to all of that and would like to ask you ... what should I do with patched_boot.img ?

Should I just flash it using:

adb reboot bootloader
fastboot flash boot patched_boot.img

I'm freaking out a bit because I really don't want to destroy my phone. :crying: but on the other hand it could be so much better with root ...

Output log:
[Magisk] xunholyx:
Yes.

Pull it from your phone and put into your fastboot folder, then: fastboot flash boot patched_boot.img
[Magisk] martyfender:
Copy it to your computers adb folder, assuming you have Windows and just flash it with the fastboot command you posted, assuming fastboot works on your device, booted into fastboot/bootloader mode.
[Magisk] martyfender:
It is more convenient to type the search term in my browser address bar. I don't have Google set as my default search engine on my Linux Mint desktop, or my Android tablets, I use duckduckgo in Firefox or sometimes Chrome.
[Magisk] unhappybirthday:
You've unlocked your bootloader, right?
[Magisk] Tokoretail:
Dev Pls add support to hide mobile banking apps Mandiri Online, can't hide r now. Thxx
[Magisk] guest4711:
Did you try [MENTION=4667597]Didgeridoohan[/MENTION]'s fine tips on how to hide root from apps:

https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHideHidingRoot?
[Magisk] siddharthpathak221@gmail.:
Sir can you please tell us

How to install magisk on KitKat
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
You can't... Currently Android 5+ only.
[Magisk] Technical:
Tested with Magisk 16.7 and lost WiFi too. Uninstall.

Then I've installed the canary version and took the logs if they could help.
[Magisk] starach:
In theory I did :

D:\MyPhone-Hammer-Energy-18x9> fastboot flashing get_unlock_ability

...
(bootloader) unlock_ability = 16777216
OKAY [ 0.017s]
finished. total time: 0.019s

D:\MyPhone-Hammer-Energy-18x9> fastboot getvar unlocked

unlocked: yes
Finished. Total time: 0.010s

But device-info command does not work:

D:\MyPhone-Hammer-Energy-18x9> adb reboot bootloader

D:\MyPhone-Hammer-Energy-18x9> fastboot oem device-info

...
FAILED (remote: unknown command)
finished. total time: 0.013s
[Magisk] Ezten:
Hiding root in nxb

I'm trying to hide root from naruto x boruto ninja voltage, but in won't work. Everything great with SafetyNet. Version of Magisk - v17.1, device Xiaomi Redmi 4 Standart, firmware "MiRoom" based on miui 10. Also i try "MagiskHide Props Config" and "ShellHide", they won't help.
[Magisk] martyfender:
On my devices and the fastboot binary I use in Linux Mint, the command is:

fastboot devices

To unlock the bootloader it is:

fastboot flashing unlock

fastboot oem device-info
...
FAILED (remote: unknown command)
finished. total time: 0.023s

Your above command fails for me also and is not listed in the command options when I just type fastboot.

With:

fastboot getvar unlocked

I get the same result as you so your bootloader is definitely unlocked.
[Magisk] martyfender:
Thanks for this, I learned something new today about fastboot commands.
[Magisk] Pkt_Lnt:
There are many fastboot commands, many of them hidden, depends on device. Here is a good tutorial to find what will work on your device. It is a couple years old, but still a solid reference for command line jockeys.

https://www.xda-developers.com/how-to-discover-hidden-fastboot-commands/
[Magisk] saccentekennedy:
I have a question about OTA updates on my A/B device. I have found the tutorial on topjohnwu's GitHub, and it makes sense to me. The question I have is this... Do I need to deactivate my Magisk modules first and reboot (because they modify system), or can I just proceed as the OTA is being installed to the inactive partition, which isn't being patched by Magisk?
[Magisk] psychomaniac189:
i keep losing root, i woke up this morning with magisk telling me there was an update to 17.1, but that is just what i flashed last night, before this would happen when i was on 17.3 on the previous update for the rom i am on (pixel dust for the pixel 2xl) I just flashed 17.3 hoping this fixed it. any ideas why this happens?
[Magisk] yochananmarqos:
No, you don't need to disable or uninstall your modules. They do not modify system, that's kind of the whole idea of Magisk, remember? ;)
[Magisk] martyfender:
If you are now on 17.3, do you have the update channel in Magisk Manager set to beta? If you lost root you would be getting the message that Magisk is not installed. Are you seeing that?
[Magisk] saccentekennedy:
Yeah... But it mounts modifications to system on the fly at boot, right? Of course the other point I missed was that it is the B partition where the update is happening, too.
[Magisk] nuxbag:
Hello can someone let me know if this can be installed on Sprint Note 4 or Sprint S7 both stock
[Magisk] mysara saad:
hi

i want to report that the latest nov update for the pixel 2 xl has broke the ability to install magisk many users have the same issue and both ver 17.1 and 17.3 gave the same bootloop
[Magisk] loadie:
Hmm?
[Magisk] mysara saad:
hi

are you using any custom ROM/ Kernel

am completely stock only unlocked bootloader

thanks
[Magisk] loadie:
Stock ROM

Custom kernel.. elementalx
[Magisk] mysara saad:
actually tried to flash magisk after flashing EX kernel with the same version but still got a bootloop :confused:
[Magisk] jsauder2:
Do you already have modules installed? If so, try disabling them and see if it boots. If you need directions on that see this page...

https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskModuleIssues

Specifically the "modules causing issues" section. A lot of people have reported specific modules causing bootloops after the Nov update.
[Magisk] starach:
Ok I have flashed the patched boot image and rebooted the phone and it looks like it works.

Magisk Manager hid himself, but ... ekhem ... what now :| I don't know how can I turn the Magisk Manager on to do ... things ... TBH I'm not even sure what things I can do. I just wanted to root my phone :|
[Magisk] xunholyx:
Flash the Magisk_uninstall.zip in TWRP, then flash 17.3 in TWRP.
[Magisk] Happy_Go_Lucky:
I just installed Lineage on my Samsung 7S Edge. When I open the Magisk app a pop-up comes up

"Requires Additional Setup

Your device needs additional setup

for Magisk to work properly. It will

download the Magisk setup zip, do

you want to proceed now?"

When I was on the Samsung Oreo rom this never occurred.

a) Why is this happening everytime I now open the app

b) Is this "normal" and if not is there a fix?

Thanks for any help.
[Magisk] kiiiiiid:
Magisk hide doesn't work on some of my apps like mobile bank here:

https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=dk.bec.android.mb1.b00369.prod

And this one:

https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=dk.e_nettet.mobilekey.everyone

Is there any way for these to work?

Thanks
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Have you tried everything described here:

https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHide#hn_Hiding_root_from_apps
[Magisk] psychomaniac189:
i switched to the beta channel in the app. and now i am still getting the message magisk is not installed. even though i flashed it yesterday left my phone alone and went to bed. wake up in the morning and boom i dont have root and have to flash magisk.zip again. why?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
There's been a couple of commits lately that might have an impact on this. Could you install the Canary build and test?
[Magisk] Fiisk:
So i rooted my S7 Edge with magisk using second method listed on the original magisk forum i.e Via Magisk Manager. I extracted my stock boot.img from original firmware and the magisk manager patched and then i flashed that patched boot.img through odin. Did the setup of the phone after it required factory reset. So basically i wanted to edit build prop file so that i can again use shealth and edit csc file to add few features and then wanted to uninstall magisk so that my phone feels like stock again but with s health working. Problem is when i try to uninstall magisk, it causes bootloop. I tried the following things with no luck:

1. uninstall magisk using restore stock boot.img button

2. uninstall magisk using Complete Uninstall button in which it downloads a zip file and runs a script and reboots the phone

3. flash stock boot.img using odin

Everything leads to boot loop but when i reflash patched boot.img again through odin my phone boots normally.

My phone: S7 edge exynos variant

Android version: 8.0 oreo

Security patch level: 1st october
[Magisk] Soumy1234:
I can't seem to edit files anymore with a root explorer. I can't copy root files as well.

An example of this problem is when I try to open the wpa supplicant.conf, it says "no file found"

Edit: it seems that Magisk "gets disabled". My Emojis don't work and v4a keeps asking to install drivers.
[Magisk] ashyx:
Magisk patches dmverity if it exists in the boot image.

If you flash a stock boot image this leads to a boot loop if you have made modifications to the system or vendor partition.

I'm afraid you can't modify either without that patch.
[Magisk] Fiisk:
So there is no viable solution to this boot loop scenario?
[Magisk] ashyx:
Unfortunately not without modifying the boot image or finding a compatible eng-boot image.
[Magisk] martyfender:
You can unpack your boot.img with Android Image Kitchen and remove dm_verity and encryption, but why not use Magisk to do it? There also may be some extra hoops to jump through to do that with, at least some Samsung devices.

Do you somehow think you will pass Safety Net after doing this or receive OTA updates? more than likely, you will not. Especially since your system has been modified by your build property edits, or do you have some other reason?
[Magisk] mierlo420:
I use the option 'Hide Magisk Manager' to be able to play Pokémon Go. But after a reboot, Magisk Manager gets duplicated and stops working.

I have a Mi Max 3 with xiaomi.eu 8.11.8 beta rom, but also had this on stable version, also tried mi-globe.com beta and stable, same problem.