yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] avik735:
I am on Xtended ROM for Mi Max 2, Magisk 17.1. I can't enable fingerprint authentication to grant root permission. When I try to enable the toggle, I get an authentication problem toast.
[Magisk] martyfender:
I would suggest trying the newly released 17.2 beta and Magisk Manager 6.0.0.
[Magisk] sonu0070:
Already added mAadhaar app in magisk hide... I reinstalled the app but still root detected in mAadhaar app... Magisk hide working fine in every app but not in mAadhaar app..
[Magisk] Alibaba0101:
Us998 lg v30 Oreo

Magisk 17.1

Manager 6 crashes when selecting magisk hide from the menu.

5.9.1 also crashed before the 6 update. Not sure how to fix it.

Thanks,
[Magisk] guest4711:
Did you hide MagiskManager itself (MM - Settings - Hide Magisk Manager [Repack...])?

---------- Post added at 07:29 AM ---------- Previous post was at 07:25 AM ----------

Probably your hide list is defective. Move /sbin/.core/img/.core/hidelist out of the way (rename it) and try again. (You have to setup the hidelist again).
[Magisk] sonu0070:
Not now... Will try....

Edited

Thanks bro it's working..... :)
[Magisk] ahya93:
Searching problem fixed with magisk manager 6.0, thanks dev...
[Magisk] Killua96:
Same here for FGO, strange thing is that some user (Reddit, Twitter and even here on xda) report it working fine, maybe there is some kind of settings in our devices that break Magisk Hide for those apps? Because FGO, in my case, is the only app that sees root, GPay works perfectly...
[Magisk] Raikem:
Bootloop after installing Magisk

Hello, I'm facing a bootloop with Xiaomi mi6 new MIUI 10 update. All stock.

I don't have a custom recovery, I'm installing it with fastboot, patching boot.img with magiskmanager. It was working fine with MIUI 9, but after the OTA update flashing the patched boot image results in a bootloop.

I've attached the adb logcat with the cannary build.
[Magisk] soder:
It looks like I've lost that I have to type a code during the boot, to unlook the encryption.

The phone still says it's encrypted, but I've lost it during boot and before I enter recovery.

Can I do something to get that back?

Thanks.

Edit: OnePlus 3T, on beta, with Magisk 17.2 installed.

/Söder
[Magisk] Fabio Santos 90:
In version 16.3 it worked normally, and in CR's 6.0 version 17.1 of magisk also worked for root normally, with same kernel used in the current ROM. Only in nougat ROMs did this happen.
[Magisk] Homeboy76:
It is working now, thanks.

---------- Post added at 02:45 PM ---------- Previous post was at 02:45 PM ----------

It is working now, thanks.
[Magisk] curtricias:
*deleted*
[Magisk] pranavateja99:
Deleted
[Magisk] TheUndertaker21:
gear 3 spay is detecting root on note 9, worked on GSI roms

seems like it's a note 9 root issue itself rather than magisk :(
[Magisk] pranavateja99:
On LG v30 stock ROM (android 8.0 based), Every update after magisk 16.0 crashes when I try to open magisk hide. I even flashed latest magisk 17.2 and manager 6.0 today. cleared cache to be sure on it. Still it's same. Any fix??

Or Should I stop updating to latest magisk from 16.0 ??
[Magisk] martyfender:
Have you tried to use the latest Magisk Uninstaller and flash a fresh stock boot.img?

Also, you should provide the magisk.log, magisk install log and a logcat of when crash happens. Apps such as Logcatx have a per app logcat feature where you can choose Magisk Manager so that the results are filtered. Other logcat apps have an option where you can filter the results, for example: com.topjohnwu.magisk.

https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/HomePage
[Magisk] pranavateja99:
Restored stock boot, flashed magisk 17.2 and issue of magisk hide crash is still same.

Attached all

1). Recovery log,

2). magisk log,

3). logcatX "com.topjohnwu.magisk" log.
[Magisk] martyfender:
What apps are you trying to hide? It crashes when you first choose Magisk Hide? Have you tried turning Magisk Hide off in settings, then turn it back on?
[Magisk] pranavateja99:
It never opened for me to hide. I just want to hide banking apps..they show root msg everytime and some even close.
[Magisk] JBolho:
I have 17.1 running on my Honor 9 with phh Treble AOSP Pie.

Everything works but... After every reboot or medium/long time standby, I loose Safetynet and CTS certification, and I have to disable Magisk Hide and re-enable it again.

I also lost root, and Magisk "disappeared" (said it was not installed on Manager) after overnight idling, forcing me to reboot to have it back to normal.

Any chance that beta 17.2 fixes these issues?
[Magisk] A.lemane:
Don't think so

Same think was happening to me but In my case it became permanent
[Magisk] Newmark196:
Hi, I have two identical phones running Magisk 17.2, OnePlus 3Ts with the Pixel Experience 9.0 ROM, and one of them can hide a game, Fate: Grand Order, just fine, while the other one still gets an "Error 60" code from the game detecting root. The only issue I can fine on the one that can't hide is an error from the Magisk logs saying " select failed with 9: Bad file descriptor". Any ideas on how to fix the phone that can't hide the game? Tried relfashing the ROM and reinstalling Magisk.

Here is the full Magisk log in case I missed something: pastebin / LTgGPLmC
[Magisk] jcmm11:
The Magisk log is complaining about a bad file descriptor, but doesn't state which file. Try deleting/renaming the hidelist in /sbin/.core/img/.core/ and rebooting
[Magisk] pranavateja99:
Deleted and rebooted, but still i get same magisk crash when selecting magisk hide. U need any more logs??

---------- Post added at 08:10 PM ---------- Previous post was at 08:08 PM ----------

Yes...as soon as i click on magisk hide, whole manager crashes.I tried OFF/ON in settings still it crashes.
[Magisk] ttabbal:
Kind of a weird problem here, but I can't seem to get Magisk Hide to store the list.

Open Magisk Hide

Select an app checkbox marks

Hit back

Go back to the hide list, app is not checked

There is no hidelist file in the directory mentioned. /sbin/.core/img/.core/

Magisk 17.2 manager 6.0.0.
[Magisk] guest4711:
Please try the canary buillds (set update channel to custom in MM, use

https://raw.githubusercontent.com/topjohnwu/magisk_files/blob/master/canary_builds/canary.json ). Install and reboot. Try again and post the magisk log (MM - log - Magisk). Perhaps we can see the cause of your issue.
[Magisk] mirallasadams12:
hi. I have been using magisk on galaxy j5 prime nougat 7 .0 without any problems.now after upgrading to oreo , I get root alright but my SIM and imei is not showing up .even after resetting network and rebooting after some minutes, it still doesn't work so I have to revert back to stock oreo. can anyone please help me overcome this problem. A day without root is like I'm not really using a phone.:eek:
[Magisk] ttabbal:
I'm not sure what got it going, but while I was waiting I realized that I had logging disabled on my device. So I dirty flashed my ROM to get that working again. I also installed the canary build and combined I have it working and hide works properly. Thanks for the help!
[Magisk] draiyan:
Hi there,

I got 17.2 flashed via twrp. All is fine except that the game Fate Go still won't open.

I already checked it under magisk hide. Any tips?
[Magisk] mxperial:
Hi there,

I don't know if I'm missing something but I have a problem that is bothering me a little bit since I updated my z3c (CarbonROM 8.1) to the latest stable magisk 17.1 running with manager 5.91 and now 6.0.

Everytime that I install a new module (any module) and I press restart button right after installing it, the phone reboots normally but all the modules installed won't load till I re-check them again on Magisk Manager. When I was on magisk 16 everything worked fine.

Anyone?

Cheers!
[Magisk] TheUndertaker21:
Fortnite isn't working either lol

Maybe we are doing something wrong
[Magisk] Eckho93:
anyone knows why every time the module is installed it doesn't work, but the module has been successfully installed. in the log looks like there is an erorr message

01-02 16:23:32.689 218 218 I Magisk : ** Initializing Magisk

01-02 16:23:32.689 218 218 I Magisk : * Creating /sbin overlay

01-02 16:23:32.699 218 218 I Magisk : * Mounting mirrors

01-02 16:23:32.699 218 218 E Magisk : mount /dev/block/bootdevice/by-name/system->/sbin/.core/mirror/system failed with 16: Device or resource busy

01-02 16:23:32.699 218 218 I Magisk : mount: /sbin/.core/mirror/system

01-02 16:23:32.699 218 218 I Magisk : link: /sbin/.core/mirror/vendor

01-02 16:23:32.699 218 218 I Magisk : bind_mount: /sbin/.core/mirror/bin

01-02 16:23:32.699 218 218 I Magisk : * Setting up internal busybox

01-02 16:23:32.759 225 225 I Magisk : Magisk v17.2(17200) logger started

01-02 16:23:32.769 222 222 I Magisk : Magisk v17.2(17200) daemon started

01-02 16:23:32.779 222 227 I Magisk : ** post-fs-data mode running

01-02 16:23:32.779 222 227 I Magisk : * Mounting /data/adb/magisk.img

01-02 16:23:32.829 222 227 I Magisk : * Running post-fs-data.d scripts

01-02 16:23:32.829 222 227 I Magisk : * Running module post-fs-data scripts

01-02 16:23:32.829 222 227 I Magisk : * Loading modules

01-02 16:23:32.829 222 227 I Magisk : * Enabling systemless hosts file support

01-02 16:23:32.829 222 227 I Magisk : bind_mount: /system/etc/hosts
[Magisk] JJohnson1988:
Edit: Please disregard.

<I swear I looked through the forums for this issue, but couldn't find a solution>

Apparently I can't write to /sbin/.core, despite all directories inside being 755 permissions. No modules will install as a result, and manually copying files to subdirectories returns an access denied (root is the owner). I've already tried a fresh LineageOS install, and Canary Magisk doesn't help either.

Anyone else experiencing something similar? Issue began yesterday, and I don't think it's related to that crash everyone was complaining about and was subsequently fixed.
[Magisk] RandomPooka:
I wasn't actually asking for a fix. I just had never tried searching the module repo, and was surprised.
[Magisk] martyfender:
A fix was released in both the beta channel and the Canary channel. MM 6.0.0.
[Magisk] ashyx:
See your device forum. This has been fixed.
[Magisk] mirallasadams12:
don't understand how this works. I'm new on xda. do I reflash using the same process or how
[Magisk] potatocactuz:
idk but even with 17.2 update FGO is still somehow able to detect my phone even with Fingerprint cts bypass. Should I just flash completely clean and root the phone using Magisk then do the process again or did I do something wrong somewhere? Note I had Magisk Hide on and Magisk manager being hidden as well. I may have as well messed up my ROM cause I deleted some Google apps using titanium backup idk if it affects it. After that FGO prompted me an error code 61 which is nowhere known what causes it really.
[Magisk] Watanabe_You:
What have you done so far to hide from FGO actually
[Magisk] martyfender:
If I am not mistaken, error code 61 means it has detected that your device is rooted with Magisk?

Did you disable usb debugging and developer options? have you tried Magisk Hide Props Config Module? Improved Hiding? If it shows disable, then those critical prop have already been hidden.

Install the Magisk Hide Props Config Module. Open a terminal and type su, enter, type props, enter. it should show that the module was loaded successfully.

https://github.com/Magisk-Modules-Repo/MagiskHide-Props-Config/blob/master/README.md
[Magisk] potatocactuz:
Nothing really other than hiding Magisk Manager and activating Magisk Hide. Other than that what I said I have to bypass ctsProfile cause it was ticked. Disabled developer options as well as some said it makes FGO think your rooted

---------- Post added at 05:56 AM ---------- Previous post was at 05:49 AM ----------

I done those things already which is why I asked why i got the error even though I used the MagiskHide props config to change my fingerprint. As for improved hiding it's disabled and yeah it prompted me that all crucial props were hidden
[Magisk] Watanabe_You:
Make sure your kernel has sultanxda's safetynet patch.

Check root/default.prop and make sure ro.debuggable=0

Check build.prop that ro.build.type=user

I only used these 3 with magisk to bypass fgo
[Magisk] potatocactuz:
The ro's are fine they are all on "safe" as for the safetynet patch I don't know about that as far as I see sultanxda kernels were designed for a specific device unless your implying to flash a custom rom then I guess I have no choice and see if it bring any results
[Magisk] Watanabe_You:
I'm stumped then. His kernels are for certain devices only but his patch is universal. It requires someone to know how to compile kernels though, that's the downside.
[Magisk] Cookie__XD:
Not booting and more on my Doogee s60 lite.

The versions 17.1 and 17.2 are not booting on my device (Doogee s60 lite) most of the time.

Sometimes it does boot, but than my device doesn't recognize both of my sim cards. Where can I find the log files to share then here? (lastest working release I testet was 16.7)
[Magisk] Killua96:
Full obfuscation won't be 100% enabled until the stable release, if you want to play FGO just stay without root, clean install, custom kernel ecc... Are all useless, FGO is detecting Magisk and nothing else
[Magisk] Watanabe_You:
Did you check what I wrote on your phone? I was able to hide with Magisk

Edit: I'm on latest canary
[Magisk] Killua96:
Good for you, for me is impossible and i'm 100% sure it's magisk fault because if i run the uninstaller all works fine, so:

- It's not the kernel, it would crash with or without magisk

- It's not dev settings/ debug usb, error is different

- It's not searching for root apps, it would crash with or without magisk

- It's not something in props, it would crash with or without magisk

- It's not some kind o modifications in /system, it would crash with or without magisk

How you hid it from FGO, for me, and for other users, it's just black magic, don't know what to say.
[Magisk] potatocactuz:
Okay I suppose the options are to wait for a stable release where the obfuscation is working as what it should be or buy a new phone. But since the later is unlikely anyway I'll find a workaround hopefully with my limited knowledge
[Magisk] Killua96:
If you find something share it pls, it's since the release of first canary build that i'm getti crazy to understand what's the problem, moreover because there are peopel that can't get it working and other yes...
[Magisk] elyaaz:
cannot patch my boot.img with magisk manager. after selecting boot file magisk does nothing not downloading zip no nothing . ihave working internet access full battery. ihave tried uninstall then install apk. download fresh stock file for my phone to get boot.img

pls help me to sucessfully patch my bootimg

iam using LAVA Iris 88s
[Magisk] Cookie__XD:
Is your phone rooted?

Else install the zip file via a custom recovery.

Have you been trying via cellular data or WiFi?

Just try the other one.
[Magisk] whitebait:
Has anyone had any issues with BlackBerry Work lately? As of the beginning of this week it started detecting root. I was using Magisk Hide and that'd previously been fine. Tried uninstalling and reinstalling Work but it still claimed that I was using a rooted phone.

I needed to get work emails working again so have used Magisk uninstaller to unroot for now, but I miss AdAway so would like to get it sorted.

Worth noting that other apps I was hiding Magisk from continued to work (HSBC banking app, EE app etc), so I'm guessing Work is looking for something else to determine whether I'm rooted? I was using the OP5T Google Dialer/Contacts module, if that makes a difference?

Thanks
[Magisk] magmakocka:
What can I do?

Hello guys!

I am tried to flash Magisk v.17.1 and my phone bootloped, and I uninstall magisk and works fine. I installed Magisk v.16 and fully worked.
[Magisk] paarnoutse:
No root detection at my device for BlackBerry Work (nor for BlackBerry Access or BlackBerry Tasks).

Device: OnePlus 5

Android: OxygenOS 5.1.5

Magisk: 17.1

At my device I've not only to use (for my employer) the BlackBerry apps, but also (for my client) the Microsoft Office 365 apps (like Outlook, SharePoint, OneDrive, etc.), where access to the O365 environment and device enrollment etc. is controlled by the Microsoft Intune Company Portal app. Related to the Intune and O365 app hiding, I've also installed the great and indispensable Magisk module "Intune Hider" (see https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/module-microsoft-intune-company-portal-t3780451).

Because this Intune Hider module *also* includes hiding of other processes (directly or indirectly related to Microsoft Intune cq. O365, and some generic root detection process hidings), it *may* also help to prevent root detection by BlackBerry Work and/or its Office 365 email access.

Therefore I think it's worth to just give it a try... Possibly it's the reason why there is no root detection by BlackBerry Work at my device.
[Magisk] ChronoReverse:
Huh, FGO is working now, awesome!
[Magisk] Rehvix:
Can someone help a fellow out? I was using Magisk 16.3 perfectly fine, safety net was passing and I could open apps that checked for it. I updated to 17.1 which was supposed to be better and all the sudden Pokemon Go, Fortnite, Google Pay, and Snapchat wont open. I go into SafetyNet check and it says failed. Help? Thanks in advance.
[Magisk] Jherson R. Martinez S.:
Hello, sorry for my bad English. I installed magisk in my lenovo vibe B, and I wanted to give Sdmaid root permission but the dialog box to confirm the permission never appears.
[Magisk] Strephon Alkhalikoi:
I've had this happen once before. Go into Magisk Manager, tap on the 3 bars menu at upper left, then tap Superuser. Grant SD Maid permission there.
[Magisk] Jherson R. Martinez S.:
I'm already here, but I do not see an option to grant permissions to apps :(
[Magisk] otonieru:
which magisk version did u install ?

try to re install magisk altogether. installation might botched
[Magisk] Lord. Tech:
Did u find out what it is?
[Magisk] Strephon Alkhalikoi:
You should have seen an option to grant SD Maid root permissions. You're not, and thus I don't believe you're rooted. Show us a screenshot of the main Magisk Manager page. But try installing Magisk again, as others have suggested.
[Magisk] Luedgiary_89:
I have a Motorola C Plus, the next week I will install the root, the question is, if I install the SuperSU, these modules are sharable with this superuser? is that I am going to flash them via TWRP, because with the other previous phone -Moto C-, it restarted having the Magisk installed; I need you to take me out of doubt
[Magisk] Nayibmc:
¿Can I rename some files in system/etc/framework and change the bootanimation and keep playing Pokemon?
[Magisk] StrykZ:
Yes the toggle root works and root checker detects my device is not rooted, i also disabled the root access in developer options
[Magisk] drew2d1:
Only mentioned a couple of times but anyone else having issues with deep sleep on the S6? As soon as i install Magisk my phone doesn't enter deep sleep. On stock and arter kernel.
[Magisk] Artim_96:
Well, it looks like it want's to open something but can't.

And I see you use TWRP 3.0.0. Is 3.0.2 available? That could be the problem

---------- Post added at 20:16 ---------- Previous post was at 20:15 ----------

Do you have XPosed installed and still activated?
[Magisk] StrykZ:
Yes, xposed seems to be working still
[Magisk] Artim_96:
Then of course SafetyNet will fail unless you deactivate XPosed and reboot
[Magisk] d0pecr4wler:
But it's the systemless root, that's supposed to work w/ SafetyNet.
[Magisk] JudgeDread11:
Most likely you have some leftover root files or BusyBox files in your system somewhere.

---------- Post added at 07:55 PM ---------- Previous post was at 07:54 PM ----------

You need to remove the built in root first.
[Magisk] Rls4ever12:
Flash unsu zip just google unsu zip XDA and you will find it!
[Magisk] JudgeDread11:
Where is your boot animation located if not in the system partition?

Is it a magisk module?
[Magisk] magnum73:
I think in the system where the original was located...it was flashed before the process of magisk.
[Magisk] d0pecr4wler:
Nope, I did a clean install with full wipe and even data format.
[Magisk] Nagato Yuki:
I would like to include Magisk (also phh superuser kernel part) directly to LG G3 F460 (not F400) kernel image then bump it to make it work with locked bootloader.

Then How to deal with this case?

I read the script of image process, but still lack of idea to process them correctly in PC/windows environment, would anyone could give opinions for me?

my side story: directly flash it and the bump package in bump'd recovery wouldn't work, it shows error when normal booting, but since recovery is bump'd and start normally, I would easily recover by flashing original kernel image .

also flash the phh superuser package leads error as above my post. but for many cases in F460 custom ROM, manually modify the kernel image (disable SElinux enforcement and verification) and bump'd with open bump, flash to it , it works
[Magisk] Echo_2000:
I can't get my bootanimation working with magisk.

It is in /cache but there is still the old bootanimation.
[Magisk] parthm6:
phh su improperly installed

i flashed a custom aosp rom

caf custom kernel with the rom

flashed magisk and phh

getting error 2

ive attached recovery log file

device is yu yureka running mm

can anyone help please?

(didnt find anything under system during recovery and cant use root)
[Magisk] Lord Meshadieme:
Hi guys, I have HTC 10, which was previously rooted with supersu and xposed installed, I have now unroot and flash original boot image to clean system, to get safetynet to pass. I still can't get it to pass with no xposed or root in the system. should i be doing something else? I rather not spend 1 whole day reinstalling everything i have just to get magisk to work later.
[Magisk] LeeDroid:
You will likely need to remove all traces of supersu, my rom does this as standard when selecting un-rooted in aroma & safeteynet passes with flying colours, once booted you can then flash Magisk
[Magisk] MUSTANG651:
Can I update magisk version of supersu in google play?
[Magisk] DerpleNerple2000:
Unfortunately, Spotify is not recognizing Viper4Android Magisk Version. Anyone know a solution to make it work?
[Magisk] esrvR:
Try this, it worked for me :) hope it works for you
[Magisk] cubandanger05:
These modules are magisk exclusive. What's SuperSU? *sarcasm* :cool:
[Magisk] A.lemane:
I believe it's required for phone that come with encryption when bootloader is locked so that the system sees it as locked again after installing Magisk
[Magisk] RandomPooka:
While I appreciate everyone's suggestions and links to the fix, I really wasn't asking for one. This isn't even a function that I use. My original comment was just idly remarking on the glitch existing and that I'd never noticed it before.
[Magisk] Lord. Tech:
Mine was tick on oreo but I flash pie manually so it's not tick now. Should I tick it?
[Magisk] A.lemane:
Don't have , so no
[Magisk] Gveric:
After installing MM 6.0.0, the app will not open. I've tried uninstalling the app, then installing 6.0.0. I then tried uninstalling magisk, reinstalling, then updating, still no dice. Thanks :D
[Magisk] martyfender:
On my devices, I have never had that happen, so I am not sure. What device, Android version and ROM are you on?
[Magisk] Gveric:
Nexus 6

Android 9

Nitrogen OS
[Magisk] Rezazahmad:
Magisk (17.1 & 17.2) crashes (Settings keeps stopping) when I click on it in system Settings.

When I open it normally, it works properly.

I use a custom Rom of Resurrection Remix (5.8.5 / Android 7.1.2). Before Magisk update (Magisk 16), it was working without the problem.
[Magisk] elyaaz:
i cannot find custom recovery for ma device so iam trying to patch boot.img

ill try with cellular data and check.

thanks bro
[Magisk] Marvino.:
Does anyone else has that weird glitch of the Manager's icon not showing in the app drawer but instead the default grey droid guy that's showing? :(

Before the latest update the icon used to show correctly, though no additional bugs.