yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] Wolfcity:
After trying to flash the magisk.zip in TWRP go to "Advanced" and there to "Copy log".
[Magisk] martyfender:
And you must do this before rebooting.
[Magisk] XzndrDroid:
Actually, it might very well be the phone that's broken... Yesterday I tried wiping everything and after flashing stock Android without Magisk or anything (actually I tried with 3 stock versions), and the phone was still be very unstable and would crash randomly. So it is probably not a Magisk-related issue.
[Magisk] JaskaranIsGreat:
After "Copy log" where will it go??
[Magisk] ktmom:
Usually to the sdcard. /sdcard/recovery.log

"find somebody that you think is undeserving of your compassion and give it to them" - Christian Picciolini
[Magisk] vMAC:
Any help on this. Another month another update of the OS and another month where for some reason it will not let me pull OTA.

Is there anything I can do to find out why this might be happening?
[Magisk] hfam:
17.1 to 18.0 method/results, and a possible hint for safetynet issue

Thanks to everyone here for your selfless help, I really am amazed at this community. Truly brilliant dedicated people I appreciate deeply.

That said, I wanted to share for anyone like me who just uses Magisk for root, doesn't use TWRP, uses stock images, and was waiting to move to 18.0 based on the plethora of issues being presented. I have a Pixel 2, purchased from Google, and am running Pie, current through December on updates and Magisk 17.1. The Jan update came out and 18.0 was now the stable release, so though 17.1 was flawless for me, I figured it was time to move to 18.0 while applying the Jan update.

I use [MENTION=6842057]nathanchance[/MENTION] amazing tutorial on rooting the Pixel 2. It has always been flawless.

- Download full factory image, extract boot.img to adb directory, edit flash-all.bat and remove "-w".

- Update MM to latest version, do NOT update Magisk

- run flash-all.bat to update to Jan sec update

- adb push boot.img to /sdcard/Download

- run MM on phone, choose yes to update Magisk, choose patch boot image, select pushed boot.img in Download

- adb pull /sdcard/Download/patched_boot.img

- reboot phone to bootloader

- fastboot flash boot patched_boot.img

- fastboot reboot

This worked as usual, flawlessly. I know this was wordy but when I was n00b, [MENTION=6842057]nathanchance[/MENTION] tutorial and a few others here helped me decypher it all and fill in blanks so I could update successfully. Hopefully this helps someone.

On the issue of the randomly disappearing SafetyNet, I don't know if this helps, but I checked SafetyNet over a 28 hour period and never had anything but green/green. Perfect. However, today I had the idea that perhaps the reason Verizon Tones would load a loading screen then go blank was related to root detection. Using MagiskHide I selected Verizon Tones, and went to run it. Nope, it's just a really badly coded app. BUT, upon going back into MM to deselect it again, I was in the habit of checking SafetyNet, so I did, and came up red/red!! Tried again, red/red. So I then deselected Verizon Tones in MagiskHide, went back to SafetyNet check, and green/green! Hasn't been back to red yet.

Point is, wondering if at least, as a method, this couldn't be used to determine if a particular selected item is causing loss of root detection protection.
[Magisk] DrPglixq:
Am I the only one experiencing that there were no su prompt in Magisk v18.0 with Magisk Manager 6.1?

I am using redmi note 5 / MIUI 10,

su prompt is not showing and it denies the su request :(

Edit: Sometimes it works, most of the time it won't
[Magisk] jcmm11:
First thing to check is to make sure that battery optimization is off for Magisk Manager

---------- Post added at 03:24 AM ---------- Previous post was at 03:23 AM ----------

Custom kernel or stock?
[Magisk] vMAC:
Stock kernel, no TWRP.

Only modules systemless root, app systemizer, and YouTube Vanced.

That's all everything else is completely stock.
[Magisk] eliezerjk90:
I guess you mean systemless host and not systemless root
[Magisk] bima1997:
Magisk Manager is not installed

Hi, I'd like to ask something

I'm on Xiaomi Redmi Note 4, latest PE build, Franco kernel.

Steps I've done:

Flash firmware

Flash ROM

Flash Magisk

Flash Franco kernel

Today I try to flash Magisk through OrangeFox Recovery, and there's no error. After doing basic setup, I complete Magisk setup by opening the app and install Magisk Manager. But when it's done, it says that Magisk Manager is not installed. I've checked that Magisk is installed in internal storage, not an external or adoptable storage. Then I restart my phone and it says that Magisk is installed. Is this normal? Thank you!
[Magisk] martyfender:
Did you mean Magisk Manager is not installed, or did you really mean Magisk is not installed?

If it is really Magisk Manager, download the Magisk Manager installer and install it as you would any normal app in Android. What version of Magisk is this? The message you received sounds like one you get in MM and if that is the case MM is installed, but not Magisk, itself. A clarification is needed.

I would suggest that you try the latest Canary debug build and provide logs:

https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHelp
[Magisk] bima1997:
Hi, thank you for your reply.

Sorry for the confusion, I flashed Magisk v18.0 through TWRP, and reboot to system without any errors, then I see MM app, and I opened it. It says that Magisk is not installed. So, I reboot my phone, check it again, and it says Magisk is installed. Is this normal? Thanks a lot!
[Magisk] iluvatrix:
hi guys if i want to go back to magisk 17.3 must i also go back to the magisk manager 6.0.1?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Sorry, no idea... Logcat or strace when checking for an OTA, maybe? You're really gonna be the one who needs to figure it out, since that's kinda hard to do for anyone not experiencing the issue...

If I had to guess at somewhere to look if would be that there is some setting that's triggered somewhere or that the OTA system doesn't recognise your device, for some reason. Or something completely different... :silly:

I can't remember: have you done a complete wipe to see if the issue persists? Use the next to last factory image to see if the OTA appears after that.
[Magisk] Rinoceros:
As mentioned earlier in this thread, if you have this troubles, flash the uninstaller via TWRP and after that flash the new 18 version via TWRP.

This worked perfectly for me. Search back in this thread for the reason why ;)
[Magisk] Devilsho:
Clean installation but root didn't work.

Wiped every thing data internal media, then flashed ROM flashed gapps reboot did some setting .

After reboot to recovery flashed magisk v18 wipe cache\delvik reboot to system magisk not installed.installed magisk manager manually but shows not installed .

Zip flashed successfully no error .

Then again wipe every thing flash latest build then flash magisk reboot no success.

Magisk zip is not corrupted I flash same magisk zip on Oreo it worked .

None of the magisk version is working on this build neither magisk 17.3 nor magisk 18 .

Please help .

Uninstalled magisk with uninstaller .zip install again same error .

Klteduos

lineage 16 pie
[Magisk] jenslody:
Check whether MagiskManager is installed in external/adoptable storage.

If yes, move it to internal.

If not, try to get a logcat via adb.
[Magisk] 气人小萌新:
Hello, author!

I need to speak with you.

Please send me your email address.

thanks
[Magisk] eliezerjk90:
Hmmm... I don't think this is an appropriate way to do it... You might want to try to write here or mention him on twitter or other social platform...

I don't know but asking his email here (and the way you ask him) seems to be a little bit rude and impolite, at least in my opinion...
[Magisk] garylawwd:
I wouldn't trust it anyway it's his first post on xda and everything about it seems suspect.

Topjohnwu is obviously no fool anyway so he would know better
[Magisk] mkdante381:
pl.tesco.clubcard detect root/Magisk. Magisk hide not hide root for this app.
[Magisk] guest4711:
Did you try it after repacking MagiskManager?

And did you try "MagiskHide Prop Config" module?
[Magisk] onliner:
Hi, I have a little problem, my "downloads" tab is empty, I can't see/download any module, my device has internet connection, I cleared the cache of the repo under manger settings and also I reinstalled Magisk from the scratch without luck.

Screenshot

Logcat

Magisk.log
[Magisk] mkdante381:
Repacking not help.
[Magisk] guest4711:
Do you run any ipfilter/firewall like AFWall+ (Control network traffic) - https://f-droid.org/app/dev.ukanth.ufirewall - which blocks internet access for all apps which are not explicitly allowed to use it?

If you are using a host based add blocker like AdAway (AdAway is an open source ad blocker for Android using the hosts file.) - https://f-droid.org/app/org.adaway - disable add blocking and reboot to check whether your hosts file may be the culprit...
[Magisk] RealPsygnosis:
Hi, I have magisk 18 on Huawei p10 oreo. SafetyNet is OK, but for some reason I cannot install app that I've installed before root (like netflix), is it for the unlocked bootloader? how Can I hide the unlocked status?

thank you
[Magisk] guest4711:
You could try [MENTION=4667597]Didgeridoohan[/MENTION]'s "Magisk Hide Props Config" module to hide the status. You should also read his fine "Magisk Trouble Shooting Guide" with many good ideas.

https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHelp
[Magisk] jenslody:
Check whether playstore show certified.

If not delete its data annd force close it.

After some time the status should be certified again and Netflix should be downloadable.

If that's not the cause ...
[Magisk] nikal:
Dear [MENTION=4667597]Didgeridoohan[/MENTION]

I am attaching a logcat (sorry no filters applied since I never used before logcat and furthermore, I didn't know what debug level you wanted and what info to be included). There is another one app which doesn't detect root and this is AdAway.

Please find attached the logcat and let me know if I can provide you any additional info or help to troubleshoot this issue.

Forgot to mention that I used the special debug version of magisk (both manager and systemless root) to take this log.

Thanks in advance
[Magisk] 气人小萌新:
I am a Chinese user and it is inconvenient to use Twitter. I'm sorry

---------- Post added at 05:05 AM ---------- Previous post was at 04:54 AM ----------

I am a Chinese user and it is inconvenient to use Twitter. I'm sorry

---------- Post added at 05:10 AM ---------- Previous post was at 05:05 AM ----------

This is my first time to use this, although I registered early.
[Magisk] bendrum30:
Thanks for all of your hard work and contributions to the Android community!
[Magisk] silverik1:
Help!!!

Trying to root without twrp using magisk

Im getting the error : unable to repack boot.img

anybody??????

Samsung S8 stock rom stock recovery

see attachements
[Magisk] Ksilometazalin:
Hello!

On OnePlus 5 last stable 9.0.2 firmware Magisk 18.0 didn't work :(
[Magisk] Roshan justin:
It's not supported for HTC desire 10 pro
[Magisk] Blooddrunked:
Every Morning my magisk root is dissapear and i need to reboot or reinstall. Any idea how i can change that? Thank you.

---------- Post added at 10:50 AM ---------- Previous post was at 10:49 AM ----------

Every Morning my magisk root is dissapear and i. Need to reboot or reinstall. Any idea how i can change that? Thank you!
[Magisk] ashyx:
Device? Android version? Magisk version? Magisk log?

I think you may have mistaken this thread for the Magicians thread not the Magisk thread. . :rolleyes:
[Magisk] Blooddrunked:
Sorry.

Device : pixel 2xl

Rom: Pixel Dust Pie Rom (9. 0)

Magisk: newest (18.0)

Installed magisk modules: Viper4android FX materialized, Global optimized gps file replazer, substratum and youtube vanced

I think it was earlier this morning. I dont know if magisk log delete if i reboot my device.. When i need to reinstall, i cant look at the logs. I must reinstall or reboot to look at the logs and than their are deleted i thing.. I dont know..

Edit:

I cant upload the log on xda... And the log is only from after i reboot. How i can get the log from before reboot?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Could you also post the Magisk log, to see if there are any denials in there? And if you haven't already, check the Superuser section in the Manager to make sure that TiBu and AdAway just isn't on there and denied.
[Magisk] nikal:
Please find attached screen captures from the magisk log. There is no root request from the aforementioned apps that was denied.

Thanks in advance for your time.
[Magisk] chooks06:
You can ask your questions here, following the rules of the the forum, and the people here are more than willing to help, provided they have the necessary info to know where to focus to help.
[Magisk] TriptonFx:
My Magisk has several issues even after reflashing to latest version .

1) It always displays the error Cannot check for updates, no Internet ? Tried googling this and after reading nearly every reference I could find there was not a single valid solution I could come up with . Reflashed from Magisk 13.2 to 18 and issue persists .

2) Same error message for Safetynet. Cannot check SafetyNet, no Internet ?

3) Unable to install modules . WHen I try installing a module I get a msg saying : The zip is stored in /InternalStorage/Magisk/module.zip but nothing really happens and the module never gets listed in the installed modules list .

Any help would be most welcome as I am really stuck with this and I am unable to even use netflix app as the netflix enabler module won't install at all .
[Magisk] Ant$24:
Jus wanna say to all rec. dev. (Especially 4 topjhonwu&didgerjohan), Thanks a lot, because Both of you have helped me - one and maybe many others, as small workers, namely online motorbike drivers in Indonesia, so May God always keep blessing both of you, also all the other rec-dev who have been helping through magisk, so, KEEP THE SPIRIT ALIVE !!!!"

ps: sory 4 my bad english.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
I was hoping you were still on the Canary build... And posting the log file is usually a better idea than screenshots (the little disc button in the top right corner).

At the moment I cannot remember if I've seen anyone posting why TiBu sometimes doesn't get root access. I doubt it's a Magisk issue though. Sorry that I can't be of more help.

1 & 2 - You don't have any apps or services restricting internet access for the Magisk Manager?

3 - That's strange. Are you sure that the message doesn't say that the zip is stored in Downloads? Because /Magisk has, as far as I can remember, never been a directory where modules have been stored. And you have this issue with both the Downloads section of the Manager (installing directly from the Magisk repo) and if you use a module zip and flash it from the Modules section (the '+' button)?

As always, if possible, it's good to also provide logs for that extra quality troubleshooting: https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHelp
[Magisk] HC4Life:
Hi,

I want to play this game:

https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.vg.bsm

but it detects Root (Magisk) on my device, i tried Magisk Hide but with no luck.

Anyone tried to play this game on a rooted device?
[Magisk] ew:
Regarding the issue with Safetynet failing after a bit of uptime, I had previously suggested a new flash with TWRP, but that seems to not really work.

However I did see a post elsewhere suggesting running the script below (as su) to dIsable/enable migisk hide. . That seems to work. I have Automagic (similar but better than tasker and have it scheduled to run every 15 minutes. So far so good.

/sbin/magiskhide --disable ; sleep 2 && /sbin/magiskhide --enable

Hopefully this will help others as well - until there is a better fix.
[Magisk] jenslody:
With adb from a pc.

Besides this, the logs should be in cache-partition and will not be deleted on boot (normally), there is an actual log and a copy of the last log.

This should at least work with canary debug build (and it gives much more detailed log).
[Magisk] martyfender:
I find it strange that matlog is the only app showing under the superuser section, unless it is the only root app installed besides TiB and adaway. Have you tried installing another root app, such as a root file explorer such as mixplorer? Open the root tab to see if you get a root prompt?
[Magisk] TriptonFx:
I installed Magisk Manager latest version and everything works now !

Was still using 5.x, that seemed to be the issue :)
[Magisk] vMAC:
.

Any chance you you can check and see if you have a file '/data/system/system-update-info.xml'?

If anyone has that file on the Pixel 3xl Dec 5th please send my way, I would like to see if that helps.
[Magisk] martyfender:
Previously, I was using SuperSu. When v15 was released, I started using Magisk, because it was the first version that I did not eventually loose root on my Nextbook Ares 8A's.

Back when I had my first tablet, the Nextbook Ares 8 with Android 5.0 and then [MENTION=2472806]vampirefo[/MENTION] 's port of 5.1.1 from a slightly never version of the device, I read many posts of problems with TiB having various problems concerning root access. This was, of course with SuperSu. I don't use it even though I briefly had it install as the free version and I could never quite get it to do what I thought it would do in the free version, so I never tried it again on my newer tablets.

All of the above may be irrelevant considering many updates since then.

I find what you posted above very strange, also. Some time back Magisk did use the Magisk Manager folder to download Magisk files and modules, but that was some time back and as you said, the downloads should now be in the Android default downloads folder on the internal SD storage.

Something does not seem correct in his Magisk install. When I view his magisk.log, it appears to be incomplete, at least compared to the logs on my devices. I have long lines of copy link /system/xbin and bind mount /system/xbin, /system/priv-app/, etc and many others.

Am I way off base here, as I know it is a different device, different architecture and Android version, but it seems that there should be more similarities in the logs?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHide#hn_Hiding_root_from_apps

I do not have that file, but I also do not have a Pixel device...

Again: a complete wipe of your entire device might be necessary.

That's simply how a vanilla stable release log looks like without any modules installed.
[Magisk] davcbr:
install via manager fails

Hi all, i'm not sure i'm posting in the right place but i'd like to understand why installation on my S8+ fails.

I tried via Magisk Manager pointing to BL_G955FXXU4CRKG_CL14727133_QB20863876_REV00_user_low_ship.tar.md5 right after downloading from sammobile.

Having a look to log file it seems to me i've to put the BL img to a specific path in \data is that so?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
I don't do Samsung so I might be off here, but are you sure you are supposed to use the BL file? That sounds like "bootloader" to me, and that's not the same as boot image... IIRC I think I've seen mention of using AP for other Sammys, but like I said I might be completely off here.
[Magisk] ClothedKing:
Having issues reinstalling Magisk

I recently updated my pixel 2 xl to android 9 and now I no longer have magisk installed, upon trying to reinstall it, my error log is just saying Unable to unpack boot image, installation failed
[Magisk] Hurrdurrdurrdurr:
until the developer finds a way to make Xposed and the new SafetyNet work . I don't think there is any other way :(
[Magisk] pitsch1:
I'm getting ready to install this , but I have a question. It says flash back to stock. So, I'm on an S5 and I'm going to unlock the bootloader (Bod5) and I have the stock bog5 build with bod5 bootloader. If I'm back at stock, no root, that means no twrp, so do I flash magisk via the stock recovery? Hw do I flash in twrp if I'm not rooted?
[Magisk] Hurrdurrdurrdurr:
you can flash TWRP using Odin if your not rooted, once you have TWRP you can then proceed flashing Magisk + Phh's superuser (recommended if you want to use systemless Xposed) + Systemless Xposed via TWRP
[Magisk] xCRUTCIOx:
Hello. I have a Galaxy s3 mini with android 5.1.1 CM12.1 tried to install magisk for PoGo but it gives me this error unable to load boot image or something here is the log file what i saved.

****************************

Magisk v6 Boot Image Patcher

****************************

- Mounting /system(ro), /cache, /data

- Device platform: arm

! Unable to detect boot image

I:Legacy property environment disabled.

E:Error executing updater binary in zip '/sdcard/Download/Magisk-v6.zip'

Error flashing zip '/sdcard/Download/Magisk-v6.zip'

Updating partition details...

I:Data backup size is 0MB, free: 3778MB.

I:Unable to mount '/external_sd'

I:Actual block device: '', current file system: 'vfat'

I:Set page: 'flash_done'

I:Set page: 'clear_vars'

I:Set page: 'main2'

I:Set page: 'advanced'

I:Set page: 'confirm_action'

I:Set page: 'action_page'

I:Copying file /tmp/recovery.log to /data/media/0/recovery.log

Can someone help me please?
[Magisk] Artim_96:
Try a different GPS spoof app? It shouldn't need XPosed, you already have a setting in developer options to allow fake locations
[Magisk] fOmey:
Pokemon users are desperate for Xposed because they need to spoof the mock location status.. There are no GPS spoofers that can operate without mock locations. :)
[Magisk] Raka936:
Hi,

Pokemon GO still not launching after installing Magisk.

Here's what I've done :

Full unroot from SuperSU app

Flashed Xposed Uninstaller

From this point I had stock system/boot.

Flashed Magisk v6

Installed Magisk manager

Flashed SuperSU v2.76 (Magisk Version)

Flashed Magisk Systemless Xposed

Uninstalled XposedInstaller

Installed Material Design XposedInstaller

Toggled off root in Magisk manager

And Pokemon GO still not working.

Everything else works properly...
[Magisk] Hurrdurrdurrdurr:
To play PoGo you need to disable Xposed because a recent update done to SafetyNet detects Xposed which prevents logging in on PoGo
[Magisk] Scherzengel:
Maybe go a step back and try it out without Xposed first?
[Magisk] hammerhead2:
Did you use phh's root?...

CF's is known to trigger safety net.
[Magisk] Raka936:
That means I need to completely uninstall xposed or is there a way to toggle it on/off ?
[Magisk] iamelton:
heard theres a toggle in material xposed installer (though i dont use it so cant confirm)..

and reboot afterwards..
[Magisk] Artim_96:
In the material installer in the framework section...

Don't forget to reboot
[Magisk] hoeni:
Where did you find that info?

That would explain why it's not working for me anymore
[Magisk] teddy0209:
Yes there is a toggle in the material installer... You should be using phh root as far as I know...
[Magisk] Artim_96:
About the last 10-20 pages of this thread?
[Magisk] Hurrdurrdurrdurr:
There should be a switch to disable Xposed (in Material Design Xposed Installer), toggling it then restarting should disable Xposed and all the modules
[Magisk] Raka936:
Thanks everyone, I didn't see the toggle button at first, sorry, not very familiar with this new interface :)

It's now working, thanks a lot.
[Magisk] hoeni:
Ooh sorry. Just got here after a while :)

Niandick needs to sort out it's priorities.

There's a fully functioning PoGo bot for android, tons of bots for Windows and a vast market for ready made accounts.

Yet the worst seems to be to spoof myself over to Australia to catch a Kangaskhan. And God forbid having youtube adaway on the same device.
[Magisk] xCRUTCIOx:
So can anyone help?
[Magisk] garylawwd:
Extract the boot.img from your new firmware download and patch it with magisk.

Then flash the new boot.img and it should work
[Magisk] ClothedKing:
I don't know what any of that stuff means, I am new to Android straight from Apple lol. But could you try to explain it a little more detailed? Sounds like I'll need to use a pc?
[Magisk] 气人小萌新:
thanks

Now the problem I encounter is that I can't hide Magisk Manager. Is there a solution?