yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] chugger93:
never used magisk before. Flash it on my pixel and the manager seems to be in my new oreo image. Assuming this will work on android 9 too? So does this replace superSU? It basically roots the device and can hide SU?

Sorry so use to the old way of things with superSU
[Magisk] tom1807:
I don't think it is related to Magisk, even I have only a OP3T but I don't face that problem.

Take the card out and put it into the second SIM slot

Cheers

Tom
[Magisk] Omegagoth:
Hi,

I'm encountering a weird behavior. I'm on a Xiaomi Max Pro with the ROM of xiaomi.eu 8.8.23. I'm trying to get magisk to work at the same time as my banking app "UBS Access". At first I wasn't passing the SafetyNet and only get an "invalid response" error (and obviously the app was detecting the root). But then following the advise of julien712 in this post, after the installation of both the unofficial magisk and the MM, I manage to pass the test on both MagiskManager and an undependant app (SafetyNet Device Check by SebastianG). Unfortunately the UBS Access still detect a modified ROM and don't want to launch itself despite having check the box on Magisk Hide and multiple reboot...

I don't know what to do next ? Do you guys have any ideas ?

Thanks in advance
[Magisk] Zepar7:
Hello guys i facing this issue and tez is not working...

Plz helpp....

Logs are before checking the safety net after safty net logs show error.
[Magisk] martyfender:
Have you tried disabling USB debugging and developer options?

https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/HomePage
[Magisk] Zepar7:
Logs for the magisk issue
[Magisk] :
Search before posting, please.

https://xdaforums.com/search/thread/3432382?query=invalid response
[Magisk] @srmahunt:
Hi, I am having a safety net issue. Google's payment app for india Tez/Google pay is not working on my device. I have xposed installed but i disable it and reboot when i have to use the app. It used to work but for some 5ime now it isn't working. Plz help.
[Magisk] Omegagoth:
No I don't have this settings enable now. I used to have them but they are disabled during the test of the app...

I'm reinstalling the app between every change juste to be sure that there is no cache of the previous state in the app.

I just want to precise that I don't have any magisk module install other than the YouTube vanced. No busybox or xposed that could be detected despite magisk.
[Magisk] greenmasser:
I have the same issue, Shamu, intune picks up my root. I tried the unofficial version also. For now I am just not updating my app, I had to go back and find a version from July and install that and turn off auto updates.
[Magisk] JimZiii:
No one really responded and I never found a way to access those logging options so i'm still not sure if that would have helped but after trying multiple firmware versions, the one that actually fixed it was updating to oreo. I've seen it for honor 8 on firmware finder a while but I was waiting for them to officially push it through the system update.

Not really wiki worthy but I thought I'd let you know.

Only problem now is that twrp don't seem to work as intended on oreo and it can't decrypt storage, but I can live with that at the moment
[Magisk] jcmm11:
Android 9 - I think so. At least the unofficial versions (which contain latest commits) definitely do. Pretty sure that 16.7 (current beta release) does. Topjohnwu just moved to USA from Taiwan so things may be a bit hectic for a while

Yes it replaces SuperSu and roots the device. Yes it can hide su.

For your reading pleasure:

https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/HomePage

https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/blob/master/docs/README.MD

https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/official-magisk-v7-universal-systemless-t3473445

https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/beta-magisk-v13-0-0980cb6-t3618589

https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/unofficial-magisk-v10-beta-built-t3521901

(If you want to install an unofficial build I suggest you search this thread on 'custom channel'. There's 2 flavors at the moment.)
[Magisk] Jeik:
Any news on a fix for the broken wifi after flashing Magisk on the latest phhusson GSIs?
[Magisk] :
Version 17 is online!!! :victory:
[Magisk] Chinaboy5216:
V17.0 bootloop on HLTE CHN havoc Oreo
[Magisk] Wesley_NL:
i installed v17.0 but my sony xpedia x performance (f8131) boot loops now

rom and kernel are stock,

i reverted to old version 16.0 for now ,

my galaxy s9+ sm-g965f works fine, safetynet pass

i dont know how to log a boot looping phone , so if need a log , please assist me
[Magisk] jurekn73:
Boot loops on stocks roms:

-lg spirit 4g lte

- tab s 8.4

What can I do now? I can't use those devices...

Is it posiible to back to the old magisk 16 even I have a boot loop?
[Magisk] Wesley_NL:
roll back boot partition in twrp ?
[Magisk] Chinaboy5216:
Ok boots now on havoc, device hltechn, su working steps done: 1 flash Magisk Uninstaller 2 reboot to home 3 boot to TWRP 4 flash Magisk 17
[Magisk] andrea0807:
I got a bootloop with the flash of version 17 of magisk.

It's the first time it happens.

I went into recovery and I flash the uninstaller.

I have a leeco le max 2 with aex rom 8.1

Is there a way to install magisk 17 without bootloop?

Do I have to uninstall version 16 first?
[Magisk] _Pink:
v17 Bootloop

OnePlus One, LineageOS 15.1, TWRP v3.2.3-0

Reverted back to v16. Had a few errors along the way, so I'll list the order I did everything.

Reinstalled Manager v5.9.0 > Reboot to recovery > Flashed uninstaller > Flashed Magisk v16 > Reboot to system > Install manager v5.8.3.apk
[Magisk] edimonoarfa:
Bootloop on zuk z2 plus aex 5.8

Revertback to v.16
[Magisk] GilaLuNdro:
Bootloop on whyred using AEX 5.8
[Magisk] rushier.ivan:
I'm using a custom kernel. Is it okay if i follow your steps in reverting to v16?
[Magisk] Killua96:
Installed 17.0 over an unrooted OnePlus 6, working fine, unfortunately FateGO is still detecting Magisk, log attached.

- Edit -

Seem unable to attach the log, here it is: https://mega.nz/#!vAxGxSyC!daomr8slZrKNjBx3E5KJA2Ke6aQ0fU5m0w6vaJZwE0c
[Magisk] -Happy Feet-:
I get an cts profile mismatch after upgrade to v17.
[Magisk] andrea0807:
To install magisk 17 without bootloop must first uninstall version 16 with the uninstaller. I tried now and it works.
[Magisk] danmaman:
OnePlus 3T with omnidragon rom

All good...

Flashed magisk uninstaller...

Booted into system

Then back to twrp and flashed magisk v17
[Magisk] trinaldi:
Also bootloop with Samsung J7 Prime (LineageOS 15.1).

Had to run the Uninstaller then the v17 zip.
[Magisk] :
op3t, nlos-15.1, [MENTION=7187684]ianmacd[/MENTION]'s snapshot:

uninstalled [MENTION=7187684]ianmacd[/MENTION]'s MagiskManager

installed official 5.9.0 MagiskManager

directly installed Magisk 17.0 from within the updated MagiskManager 5.9.0

rebooted

Works like charme. sf api checks passes, playstore shows certified, sparda secure app (banking app) works like charme.

Thank you very much for all your efforts, work and this awesome piece of software, [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION]! Have a great time at your new home.
[Magisk] Jeik:
Good to see that wifi is still broken with v17 on the OP6 running PIE GSIs.

This is an issue other devices experience too...
[Magisk] TheLostOne:
I also can't enable Wifi now on my LG G4 (v29a) :(
[Magisk] Silent2743:
Is v17 support treble?
[Magisk] Peterlymo:
make a BACKUP before updating GUYS:

installed on j500f and never pass on boot so i had to factory reset and worked maybe its true you have to uninstall previously version to make 17v work
[Magisk] Carotix:
with v17 on S8+ everything work fine

thankssss topjohnwu :good:
[Magisk] romantissm:
Everyone who has the bootloop issue with new v17.0, try the following:

1. Flash Magisk Uninstaller via TWRP

2. Flash new Magisk zip

3. Clear Cache

4. Reboot into the system

5. Again reboot into recovery and flash a kernel (if any)

6. Reboot into the system
[Magisk] Darkestnoir:
After update to 17.0 i got a bootloop.

Then i used the uninstaller.

Now i didnt get any notifications, developer options says there are not available for my user, cant get out of the settings menu without reboot etc..

What can i do?

OnePlus 3T@ OOS 5.0.5
[Magisk] Indashio:
The same on my xperia xz premium
[Magisk] AC130PL:
Got bootloop after flashing v17 in TWRP. Okay, now I know, that I should flashed first uninstaller... Now is a question- how to get into TWRP without "volume up" button (mine is broke heh). Before flashing I turned on ADB Debugging (just in case). Right now- I can enter fastboot, there is my device on "fastboot devices" list, but adb isn't working somehow. Any suggestions? New buttons? (they'are flying from China :D). Mi5, LOS 14.1 , TWRP 3.2.3.0
[Magisk] AndrOmega:
about 50% of magisk users installed v17 and get bootloop. [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] please remove this version from server and fix it !
[Magisk] demonoidmaster:
maybe read what the previous poster above you said to do. But tbh sounds like your android install got screwed up, only way to fix it is to clear some specific files in /data/system and such but I'm tired and don't wanna explain
[Magisk] Darkestnoir:
Yeah tried everything that was posted on the last pages.
[Magisk] rinaldi14:
Maybe u use xposed..
[Magisk] demonoidmaster:
vol down will bring up your device options, selext recovery then press power
[Magisk] starbright_:
Installing it via sideload in TWRP directly after LOS gives error.

The log is here below.

I found that kind of error before with some other project. Reason is, that the link /vendor is not available at that stage. Link has to be created first by

ln -s /system/vendor /vendor

Installing zip file '/sideload/package.zip'
I:Update binary zip
I:Zip does not contain SELinux file_contexts file in its root.
I:Legacy property environment not used in updater.
Archive: /sideload/package.zip
inflating: META-INF/com/google/android/update-binary
inflating: META-INF/com/google/android/updater-script
inflating: arm/magiskboot
inflating: arm/magiskinit
inflating: chromeos/futility
inflating: chromeos/kernel.keyblock
inflating: chromeos/kernel_data_key.vbprivk
inflating: common/addon.d.sh
inflating: common/boot_patch.sh
inflating: common/magisk.apk
inflating: common/util_functions.sh
inflating: x86/magiskboot
inflating: x86/magiskinit
inflating: META-INF/MANIFEST.MF
inflating: META-INF/CERT.SF
inflating: META-INF/CERT.RSA
************************
* Magisk v17.0 Installer
************************
- Mounting /system, /vendor
- Target image: /dev/block/mmcblk0p10
- Device platform: arm
- Constructing environment
cp: can't stat '/data/adb/magisk/.': Too many symbolic links encountered
cp: can't stat '/data/adb/magisk/.': Too many symbolic links encountered
cp: can't stat '/data/adb/magisk/chromeos': Too many symbolic links encountered
cp: can't stat '/data/adb/magisk/busybox': Too many symbolic links encountered
chmod: /data/adb/magisk: Too many symbolic links encountered
- Adding addon.d survival script
Error preloading public library libandroid.so: dlopen failed: library "/vendor/lib/libcamera_client_shim.so" not found
libc: Fatal signal 6 (SIGABRT), code -6 in tid 3387 (main), pid 3387 (main)
Aborted
/dev/tmp/install/META-INF/com/google/android/updater-script: cd: line 112: can't cd to /data/adb/magisk: Too many symbolic links encountered
/dev/tmp/install/META-INF/com/google/android/updater-script: .: line 115: can't open './boot_patch.sh': No such file or directory
Updater process ended with ERROR: 2

After link this happens:

************************
* Magisk v17.0 Installer
************************
- Mounting /system, /vendor
- Target image: /dev/block/mmcblk0p10
- Device platform: arm
- Constructing environment
cp: can't stat '/data/adb/magisk/.': Too many symbolic links encountered
cp: can't stat '/data/adb/magisk/.': Too many symbolic links encountered
cp: can't stat '/data/adb/magisk/chromeos': Too many symbolic links encountered
cp: can't stat '/data/adb/magisk/busybox': Too many symbolic links encountered
chmod: /data/adb/magisk: Too many symbolic links encountered
- Adding addon.d survival script
Invalid image: not signed
/dev/tmp/install/META-INF/com/google/android/updater-script: cd: line 112: can't cd to /data/adb/magisk: Too many symbolic links encountered
/dev/tmp/install/META-INF/com/google/android/updater-script: .: line 115: can't open './boot_patch.sh': No such file or directory
Updater process ended with ERROR: 2
[Magisk] adiel91:
Hi

Please help

Updated manger app through magisk itself

After that it states Magisk not installed

I tried downloading the zip, boot twrp recovery - but it requires password to decrypt files, wtf?

I have no password and all files shows as gibberish, and no magisk :(

How to resolve this?

Thanks
[Magisk] meskafonas:
i installed Magisk v17.0.zip over TWRP to Huawei nova and it bricked now. Day before i used Magisk v16.0 and it was fine. I cant even recover from TWRP. because boot loop.
[Magisk] brunokutta:
Modules not working after update to 17.0

I had Dolby atmos module for Orea ( by guitardedhero) working earlier with 16.0 version and now after update to 17.0, there is no dolby app seen in the app drawer .It seems to have vanished all together. Re-installing the module does not work either. If i use 16.0 it works fine again, but magisk forces automatic update to 17.0 :(
[Magisk] edimonoarfa:
Wow, it works. Many thanks.
[Magisk] AC130PL:
Ehhh, it doesn' work
[Magisk] TheLostOne:
Thx!

This gets me out of my boot loop but I still can't enable WiFi and also USB mode stays in "charge only" :(
[Magisk] DanGLES3:
Updated successfully from 16.7 to 17.0,Thank you [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] but you probably should do something about all these bootloops
[Magisk] :
updated latest v17 and app v590, when i try check safetynet app will crash
[Magisk] M1chiel:
For me it does (Huawei P10).
[Magisk] lilbrat:
All good on my Sony XZ, ExsitencZ rom highly debloated.. Straight install from new manager...
[Magisk] abdoh01:
Hi guys magisk 17.0 does not work My LG K10 phone was stuck in the screen lock but when i flashed the stock rom and installed magisk 16.7 it works fine so there are a lot of errors in the stable version and i hope it will fixed soon
[Magisk] Indashio:
Still not working safety net
[Magisk] Badger50:
Updating to the new apk and 17.0 versions went smoothly with direct install from the Magisk Manage app. All modules and SN working without issues on the P2XL. Thank you very much kind sir :good::good:
[Magisk] Hopie:
Same on HTC 10
[Magisk] Torontus:
Same here [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION]. Log in attachment.WiFi off. I did the update through magisk. I will try flash it with twrp. I will report back.

[MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION], through TWRP all weent good, no loops. But still my wifi is off.

I guess i will have to do a dirty flash. :silly:
[Magisk] byReqz:
If bootlooped, just flash magisk uninstaller, then magisk 17
[Magisk] Terrigible:
Is it just me or is the Downloads tab extremely laggy when loading on Magisk Manager 5.9.0
[Magisk] Barquillo:
Just got a bootloop with v17.0 on lg g3 i booted into TWRP used the unistaller and then booted to the system the phone works and after tried to install magisk 17.0 in twrp and now i don't have a bootloop.
[Magisk] Rom:
Feature changed ?

Hello,

Apparently with the new v17 version, the /data/adb/magisk img file is no more mounted on /magisk, i haven't got test v16.7 so i didn't see if that was removed on previous versions after the v16.

It's normal ?
[Magisk] DanGLES3:
Its been on/sbin/.core for a long time now on the betas
[Magisk] hoqpus:
I got into bootloop after updating from 16 -> 17 by flashing the zip via TWRP.

solution:

- flash uninstaller

- flash M v17
[Magisk] rzarectha:
My phone is also in a bootloop

-Axon 7 G2017G (Europe)

-Stock MiFavor ROM 7.1.1 (B12)

-TWRP 3.2.3-0

The phone boots up to the unlocked bootloader warning (that's perfectly normal for this device), then reboots again straight in recovery.

As mentioned previously, this started 5 minutes ago after flashing the 17.0

Edit: I tried flashing the uninstaller and installing the zip from TWRP after but it does not work.
[Magisk] :
Maybe some mods are effected by the path changes mentioned in the release posting for 17.0 in the Module Templete section. Give the mod devs a chance...

Why not disable "check updates" in settings?
[Magisk] Torontus:
[MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION], so, i did dirty flash, WiFi still not working. Any ideia what could happen?
[Magisk] shadavis08:
My phone went into a boot loop after updating to magisk 17.0 and all I get is errors trying to flash 16 .0 back and magisk uninstaller wont flash as well . I really need my phone back if possible. Thanks for any wat to fix this. Also I can not restore a backup either due to recovery wont accept magical to recovery .

LGV20 h918
[Magisk] xsycox:
Thank you very much. :)
[Magisk] Silent2743:
Thanks, its work for me too
[Magisk] xsycox:
Btw, my wifi is also not working after the update. :\

I used the Magisk uninstaller and then flashed Magisk 17 (stable).
[Magisk] kokos1000:
Is there a easy way to port manually installable modules from v16 to v17? Some of them are not updated anymore and i liked them
[Magisk] scorpionvert:
Hi everybody,

I've got a Xiaomi Redmi 5 plus with unlocked bootloader.

I succeed in installing the v17 on my phone.

First, go to TWRP and flash the uninstall.zip.

Then, without exiting TWRP, flash the v17.zip and at the end, reboot to system.

That's all folks !!!!

And no problem with the safety net.
[Magisk] T.A.R.D.I.S.:
Thank you Mister Green :good:
[Magisk] scorpionvert:
Hi Lolo,

How are you ?

It's very funny to speak to you in English.

I succeed in flashing this new version like you see it.

Have a good day friend.
[Magisk] beastobadness:
Magisk v17 all good here. Axon 7 AEX v5.8 8.1.0 NFound treble.

Updated to latest manager within app then flashed v17 directly on top of v16.7 in twrp and wiped dalvik/cache. No issues
[Magisk] Rom:
I just checked, indeed the path is present, i had not tested the Beta versions in the v16 branch.

But the path didn't go up to TWRP level, is that the case for you too?
[Magisk] pahlawanto:
Bootloop after hide fusedlocation in magisk v 17.0

i have issue with magisk hide.

after I install Magisk. I tried to hide fused location in Magisk Manager. in version 16.0 hide fusedlocation works, but on version 17.0 it doesn't work and it becomes bootloop. does the other experience the same thing?

Regards,
[Magisk] DanGLES3:
Yes,sbin/.core is not mounted if you are on twrp
[Magisk] SignetSphere:
Guess I'll skip this update until the situation is toned down by topjohnwu.
[Magisk] TheLostOne:
Anyone could fix the WiFi problem already?

My MAC address is changed to 20:00:00:00 btw.

Anyone else also having the problem that the USB mode can't be changed from "charging only"?
[Magisk] Naudiz:
Updating to 17.0 broke SafetyNet for me. MagiskHide seems to be non-functional. On 16.7 it still worked (luckily I just checked it yesterday, so I'm super-sure about that).

Anyone else who broke SN with 17.0 update?
[Magisk] MarcusBremen:
after updating to 17.0 and manager 5.8 my whole system is fcuked up...

when i wanna flash the zip i get error 2. after that i landed in a stucked bootscreen.

so back, wipe cache and reflashed the rom (latest lineage os).

after that it boots, BUT...

several apps get stucked, like playstore, chrome...

my latest dialer app get deleted, can't install it anymore from apkmirror (says not compatible, BUT works flawlessly before).

after checking i get a new manager update to 5.9... installed and re-downloaded the recommended 17.0...

flashing it and gets error 1. FCUK...

so wipe data, fresh rom... but after installing manager and tried to flash the 17.0 zip i get error 1...

can't root my rom anymore...

that update is buggy as hell...

after several tries and errors, an update to the manager and zip i finally have root, but still can't install the dialer app from google??
[Magisk] wandang:
I flashed v17 on top of v16.x via twrp resulting in a boot loop on my HTC 10. Just a heads up.

I will try the uninstall.sh method after my backup got restored.
[Magisk] scorpionvert:
Hi, take a look at my post above.
[Magisk] Naudiz:
UPDATE: MagiskHide is indeed non-functional. For testing I put TitaniumBackup on Hide-List and it is still granted root.

???

I don't see any post from you regarding SafetyNet or MagiskHide.
[Magisk] sabbahy:
after updating to magisk 17 modules not working, am on xiaomi redmi 5 plus "havoc oreo rom".. does anyone encounter this issue??
[Magisk] -Happy Feet-:
No. Removed Magisk. But the same. I think it's kernel related
[Magisk] shekinahsmoke:
so i panicked. when I installed 17.0 I lost my baseband and everything. I flashed back to 16.7 via recovery and it was all back working. So you guys are saying to turn off MagiskHide in settings AND THEN flash?

angler/nexus 6p

8.1

aicp rom

latest vendors bootloader etc

using SuperUber kernel
[Magisk] sherpya:
Just installed v17, I had to manually remove the /data/adb/magisk symlink that was pointing to itself, since the manager was unable to make the initial configuration, after that, the manager succeded
[Magisk] fubo73:
Same issues here. Updated to 17.0 on Moto Thea, LOS 14.1 -> bootloop. Still struggling to recover.
[Magisk] ZyronX:
No bootloop but neither sim card nor wifi work, I tried downgrade to 16.7 and they work just fine. I'm in MIUI 10 beta 8.8.30 whyred.
[Magisk] trtr365:
I also encountered the problem of not being able to enter the system after flashing v17. Later, I tried to uninstall Magisk and then installed v17, and finally it can run normally. Only root and all modules are lost.(Just Google translate,I'm so sorry about you can't understand.)
[Magisk] abdiessa:
Same issue Multi Errors & Bugs and not boot and nothing
[Magisk] AC130PL:
Thx dev, now I have to delete all my data from phone, because bootloop...
[Magisk] shadavis08:
I had to restore a backup with recovery unchecked in order to fix my phone
[Magisk] kennethstarr:
Redmi 4x, EU rom miui 10:

Bootloop after v.17 installed.
[Magisk] TAJ_Rocks:
I did installed magisk 17 on top of 16 and faced bootloop

To solve this i just clear cache and dalvik and installed magisk 17 zip

Phone everything is back to normal no bootloop but my WIFI stopped working.

So i flashed latest uninstaller 17. And booted phone but still my wifi isn't working.

What should i do to get my wifi working.

Im on ViperOS 7.1.2

Mi 5s plus natrium
[Magisk] brunokutta:
Disabled the updates now and back to v16.0. Will wait for the issues to resolved.
[Magisk] simo6:
OP5 with Latest nightly lineage os 15.1, after flashing magisk 17 safetynet seems broken

Inviato dal mio ONEPLUS A5000 utilizzando Tapatalk
[Magisk] raynherrera:
Got bootloop after updating viq magisk manager from v16 to v17. What i did to solve the issue is download the v17 zip from github and flash via twrp then everything works fine again. But im afraid to update again via magisk manager

Samsung galaxy S8+ Exynos

Latest Stock Firmware
[Magisk] aron11195:
no problems on my mido so far, updated thru magisk manager and on magisk core only mode when i was updating.
[Magisk] khal_nayak:
for all those who suffer bootloop after flashing v17 from twrp, i did too on my oneplus 3t oos 5.0.5, the only way to fix this was, boot into recovery, install the magisk uninstaller zip, dirty flash the last version of the rom and then flash v17 of magisk and then it works fine
[Magisk] Wolfblade1215:
I downloaded the new apk and magisk and the uninstaller. I flashed uninstaller on my 16.7 then magisk 17 and booted just fine. Safety net fails for some reason even with magisk hide. Running aosp 9.0 treble on axon 7. Any ideas?