yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] panostheodorakis7:
I'm SO frustrated with Magisk these past two updates !! So a notification came in through magisk manager that said a new magisk update is available and i start downloading it when the zip file was finished nothig happened after that the button on the bottom of the manager changed to update from install ...so i pressed it and it showed me "not thanks" , "release notes" and "install" so i hit install and i have two options "download only zip" or "patch boot image file" ...SO how am I going to intall something that doesn't give the option to do so ?!

Additional info:

Mi A1 on 8.1 oreo stock

Previous magisk version 16 and previous manager too

updated to last manager and retried nothing changed

I rebooted and made things worse ...right now I cant even manage my modules with my already magisk installed version .

if you have a solution I will be thankful ..sry for my caps but I'm beeing let down again and again from magisk
[Magisk] Rapid81:
I had bootloop first also, then I uninstalled Magisk, then flashed v17 again and everything is fine now.

Thank you for the developer for this awesome app!
[Magisk] :
Magisk latest update broke. Reverted to older one, didn't fix.

uninstalled and reflashed old magisk zip and didn't fix.
[Magisk] anthonykb:
Magisk Functionality

Would it be possible to extend the kernel command line limit beyond the 511-512 bytes of arguments it allows on most devices so we can tweak these devices with the various available parameters that can be passed in /proc/cmdline at initial startup? I like to optimize the IRQ handling and all that and most of the time my command line goes beyond 511-512 bytes. This would be a useful feature for us android nerds. Thanks [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] ... :):D:):D
[Magisk] alroger:
http://xdaforums.com/search/thread/3432382?query=root toggle
[Magisk] Nexus11:
If I'm right the LG G3 has never actually had its bootloader unlocked do Magisk will trigger secure boot error.
[Magisk] jarecki22:
Is it possible to find like Magisk tool/mod for Android 4.4.4 Kitkat?

I mean as simple and easy to use and reliable like Magisk, I rather find out another [ROM] for my Note 2 [GT-N7100] with SDK 21+...
[Magisk] -Happy Feet-:
I also would use these mod with the Elitekernel. But the same Problem. Any idea?
[Magisk] JuergenZ66:
please search this thread, this was answered multiple times.

e.g. here http://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=68728205&postcount=2591
[Magisk] Äptiva:
If you can run custom kernels and recoveries via bump see here:

http://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=68723635&postcount=2540

You will need different ROM and kernel than the ones I used (G2 so obviously) but the process is the same
[Magisk] Daswolven:
Excited about trying this on my HTC 10. Followed the installation steps without issue, and booting back up after getting xposed in place. Good work!
[Magisk] Norbix1999:
Please help me install Magisk on the Xperia M4 Aqua Andoid 6.0 unlocked bootloader and TWRP recovery

Phone after installing magiskv6.zip hangs constantly on the Sony logo (turn on and after a while) (flash sony logo and turns off)

I noticed that this is problem with boot.img

I have Stock kernel sony

I would have uploaded these files from Magiska and super user to boot.img? This may work if

Please

Here a link to boot.img https://drive.google.com/file/d/0Bwf...GJlamI3enA1VDg

It is boot.img installed SuperSU version 2.76 so I had to delete it and route files magisk and superuser phh

I also tried on its original (including wgranym by flashtool) but there did not move (sony logo and reboot) and here even starts but does not work for me Magisk

Will load and like all ok but I can not switch the switch from the root of the root is always off

Help please
[Magisk] Artim_96:
No

---------- Post added at 08:47 PM ---------- Previous post was at 08:46 PM ----------

Yes... For the thousandths time
[Magisk] requiiiem:
But the v4a magisk dont work on Android N?
[Magisk] Xebazzztian:
It was before of it... U can check it out if u read a few pages back..

Dumb@ss
[Magisk] SpasilliumNexus:
Oh, so you decided to be specific after being vague by posting about your issue again? That means you didn't read OP all the way through, unsurprisingly.

So how's Magisk for out for you? LOL.
[Magisk] CoolHwip92:
Viper4Android processing on Android 7.0

After following these posts:

http://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=68545451&postcount=1327

http://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=68555708&postcount=1346

I was able to get V4A to say processing when using Play Music, however, YouTube, SoundCloud, and Pandora show no processing. Some other threads referenced making changes to the /system/etc/audio_policy.conf file helped the previous Android version, but that has been moved to audio_policy_configuration.xml for Android 7.0 and changed a bit. I don't know enough about this to make a fix myself, but I would appreciate any input from more knowledgeable users.

I'm on the Nexus 5x.
[Magisk] villo88:
Ok, basically you've done the same as I do but it isn't working... I'm asking what i did wrong!

The difference is that you're running a multiboot (nice idea by the way) while i have the developer rom from xiaomi.eu to have the system in my language. My steps were:

-Uninstalled Xposed.

-Unroot from SuperSU app.

-Flashed Magisk

-Flashed phh magisk

-Installed Phh

-Installed Magisk Manager

The results is that i can't toggle root from Magisk Manager (also if i've granted permission) but rooting is still working, i have lost Xposed, instead Se linux can be temporarily disabled.
[Magisk] Norbix1999:
Please help me install Magisk on the Xperia M4 Aqua Andoid 6.0 unlocked bootloader and TWRP recovery

Phone after installing magiskv6.zip hangs constantly on the Sony logo (turn on and after a while) (flash sony logo and turns off)

I noticed that this is problem with boot.img

I have Stock kernel sony

I would have uploaded these files from Magiska and super user to boot.img? This may work if

Please

Here a link to boot.img https://drive.google.com/file/d/0Bwf...GJlamI3enA1VDg

It is boot.img installed SuperSU version 2.76 so I had to delete it and route files magisk and superuser phh

I also tried on its original (including flash by flashtool) but there did not move (sony logo and reboot) and here even starts but does not work for me Magisk

Will load and like all ok but I can not switch the switch from the root of the root is always off

Help please
[Magisk] Ranomez:
Flash the UnSU zip as well, it's around here on this thread somewhere, miui has some leftover files from the normal dev root along with the SuperSU ones. Also I am using CM12.1 not miui.
[Magisk] westeight:
https://m.reddit.com/r/android/comments/536www/_/?utm_source=mweb_redirect&compact=true)?

:p
[Magisk] dimm0k:
does magisk somehow prevent direct edits to /data/system as well? trying to give external write permissions to an app through packages.xml and it keeps reverting after reboot
[Magisk] Teh_Chuz:
You are rigth. It does work on Moto X 2014 (Victara) on stock?
[Magisk] westeight:
Just tried AutoMagisk... works very well. Instant switching of root on/off per app.

e.g. SafetyNet:

:cowboy:
[Magisk] seaskimmer:
s6e 925f touchwiz

Device bootlooped when I flashed v17.

Fixed by running the latest magisk uninstaller and re-flashing v17. I did not need to re-flash the rom.

Thanks for the updates topjohnwu
[Magisk] :
The length of the kernel command line array is defined in the kernel, not in magisk. You need to edit COMMAND_LINE_SIZE in arch/your-arch/include/uapi/asm/setup.h, and recompile the kernel. This is arch dependend and may be limited.
[Magisk] romantissm:
It might be a bug of the build/ROM. Go to Developer Options and search USB settings over there. Also try to restore the stock kernel (if you have custom one), that might fix the WiFi issue. If that didn't work, you may try to reflash your ROM; wipe only Boot and System sections. Good luck, man
[Magisk] slim_pickins:
I'm running an unofficial version of Resurrection Remix on an HTC One M9 but I was having the exact same problem. I tried flashing V17 from TWRP & got a boot loop. Tried flashing magisk uninstall then V17 from TWRP & it wouldn't flash. So on a whim I extracted the boot.img from my custom ROM zip then selected "patch boot image file" in magisk manager & flashed the boot.img that I extracted. This took a good 5 minutes & it seemed like magisk manager was hung up but it finally said the operation was complete. I then booted into recovery & flashed V17 over V16 & rebooted. I thought I was stuck in a boot loop again bc it kept showing the logo screen but I waited & it finally booted up & V17 is installed & everything is working like it should. I don't know if this will work for your phone bc I'm honestly not sure why it worked for mine. I would definitely Nandroid backup before trying.
[Magisk] vMAC:
Thank you very much. Update to 17.0 worked perfectly in my Pixel 2XL.

Looks like I got back Slot upgrades also.
[Magisk] klausxda:
Magisk v17.0 ==> bootloop

The same happened on my Samsung Galaxy S4. Solution: I flashed Magisk-uninstaller-20180719.zip, then re-installed

MagiskManager-v5.9.0.apk and flashed Magisk-v17.0.zip.
[Magisk] me_droid:
Running stock P on Pixel 2, on Magisk beta update channel. Got prompt to do v17 update and no issues at all so far.
[Magisk] VerticalCobra:
Update from v 16 beta to v 17 works great! I have safetynet check passing and Google Pay is now working fine.

Pixel 2 XL
[Magisk] Pietplezier:
Ouch, that went not so smooth. Installed magisk 17.. My Xiaomi mi note 3 came in a boot loop. Dirty flashed my Rom to get it working again, then flashed the magisk Uninstaller, then magisk 17 again.. Now it's working.
[Magisk] and_devv:
Updated went perfectly on sGSI on my RN4. Only thing is magisk still shows latest version as 16.0.... was the update rolled back ?
[Magisk] peterlee928:
17.0 :good:

pixel 2xl

stock rom

no custom kernels

:)
[Magisk] anthonykb:
Thank you my friend

I just wanted to know if there was any hackery we could do to extend it because the bind mount thing is only cosmetic for the most part as the variables are already initialized from the cmdline in the boot image during init so trying to mask them with a bind mount won't change a thing. :):D:):D
[Magisk] mayur.3.92:
Magisk hide doesn't work for me:(
[Magisk] DanGLES3:
For anyone with bootloops
[Magisk] cridus:
Neither for me.
[Magisk] martyfender:
I've had this happen twice recently on recent unofficial builds and the only way I found to solve it was, the first time, a couple of weeks ago, to reinstall the rom and the second time, on the same device, was to do a factory reset. In both cases apparently the data partition was corrupted in some way. This just happened to me two days ago on [MENTION=3306843]kantjer[/MENTION] 's 2018083011 build. I had flashed through TWRP and I believe in both cases had deleted both the dalvik cache and cache. Since this happened, I have not been deleting the caches in TWRP when flashing and all has worked fine. It may have been a coincidence, but it was the only device out of 3 others where I had deleted the caches in TWRP. All 4 are Nextbook:

Nextbook Ares 8A

Processor: Intel x86 Cherry Trail Atom x5-Z8350 @1.92 GHz, 1gb RAM, 16gb internal storage

Model number: NX16A8116K

Android version: 6.0.1 Marshmallow

Kernel version: 3.14.64-x86_64

Build number: V3.0.4.MMB29M.201710620..075926

IFWI version: M882_JJ.023_JJ

Recovery: TWRP 3.1.0-0 built by vampirefo

Root: Magisk (2018090110) Unofficial Version Kantjer With [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] 's lastest commits on github.
[Magisk] TheLostOne:
I could fix my WiFi problem.

I've checked the system log (logcat) and saw this line:

WifiHW : Cannot set RW to "/data/misc/wifi/p2p_supplicant.conf": Operation not permitted

So I have backed up p2p_supplicant.conf and deleted it. After a reboot WiFi was working again :)

The WiFi passwords are gone though.

And I'm still having the problem that USB MTP isn't working.

Flashing the stock kernel or another one didn't help btw.
[Magisk] cridus:
Update: I went into the settings, disabled Magisk Hide and tried going select the apps in it (they wouldn't stay selected). After selecting them, my System UI app kept crashing, so I had to turn off the phone by removing the battery. After turning it on again, Magisk Hide was working fine.

So maybe keep reeboting until it works, lol
[Magisk] jdgesmlls:
Uh oh... Was 17 pulled?
[Magisk] Darkestnoir:
I flashed a backup from last month and skip 17.0 atm, but thanks for the answer ;)
[Magisk] TAJ_Rocks:
17.1 hotfix available
[Magisk] meskafonas:
Please tell me if v17.1 is safe to install? cuz i got bootloop also on v17
[Magisk] lilbrat:
SONY XZ, ExsitencZ Rom..new update 17.1 also working fine along with new manager.. Did the direct install...
[Magisk] TAJ_Rocks:
Its safe but my WIFI isn't working stil
[Magisk] TheFixItMan:
As per instructions - use Uninstaller to remove v17 if you are in a bootloop

Flash v17.1

Obviously make a backup (of your working device) before you flash anything on your device

If you get a bootloop just restore your backup!

I had no problems with either v17 or v17.1 on my device
[Magisk] Augustoandro:
Sir,

I am creating a custom ROM for my device. I want to install Magisk Manager as a system app within it.

I ask for your permission for doing so.
[Magisk] scj20:
I installed v 17.0, safetynet works (according to magisk app) however root access doesn't, even though the apps shows it's rooted. Tried accessing root with root checking app and Greenify (module) it didn't work.
[Magisk] jc1266:
Loose twrp after uninstall magisk from magisk manager .. anyone facing this also.

Pls help anyone know this issue.
[Magisk] gothicVI:
Don't do that. It creates more problems that benefits.

Gesendet von meinem Moto G (5) Plus mit Tapatalk
[Magisk] aelfinn:
[MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION]

It would be really nice if you could provide checksums for your Magisk downloads. TIA!
[Magisk] LinuxPanda:
He already have given permissions to built it in ROM.

But don't do it. Better to keep the ROM unrooted.
[Magisk] MathewThomasC2305:
Hello,

I'm a happy user of Magisk. Recently after an update of my banking app, there has occurred an issue. When opening the banking app, it gives the message "Root hider application detected. Please uninstall root hider app.". Anyone know how to fix this or should Magisk release a new update?
[Magisk] martyfender:
The way I understand it, Magisk Manager does not work properly when installed as a system app.
[Magisk] leon90xs:
With versioni 17.1 magisk, safetynet check failed :( and Universal fix don't work pls help me
[Magisk] TAJ_Rocks:
Found fix for dead wifi

Delete this p2p supplicant.conf supplicant made wifi a c#nt:laugh:

Reboot after deleting

Hit thanks button (thumbs up) if this saved you from flashing rom again:laugh:
[Magisk] Badger50:
What device do you have my friend?
[Magisk] smowin:
hello, today installed clean LineageOS16 (Android 9.0) on xiaomi mi 5, also installed Magisk (17.1), all checks are passing, but the request for superuser does not pass, what could be the problem?
[Magisk] TAJ_Rocks:
Mi 5s plus 6gb 128G natrium
[Magisk] NotSoSavvy:
After updating to 17.1 today Magisk is now saying "Magisk is not installed" First attempt I used the recommended Direct install. Once I seen that it said it wasn't installed I tried downloading the zip and flashing through TWRP. Same results and I have now lost root. Any ideas?

(Note: I've updated Magisk in the past a couple times easily/successfully with the above methods)
[Magisk] :
This is an far fetched and nearly absurd idea, but there may be some usefull information in the Magisk log and logcat...

BTW: providing logs seems to have a bad reputation lately (not only - but especially - on this thread).
[Magisk] BouncingState:
Hello :) Thanks for the new version :)

Is there any possibility to add the Feature: PIN-Password (like SuperSU). That feature is very secure and nice. Please Implement in Magisk :)

I cannot use Fingerprint because I have Moto G4 Play :(
[Magisk] TheLostOne:
I have successfully installed 17.1 over 17.0 now with the direct installation method from within Magisk Manager.

Wifi is not broken this time :)
[Magisk] :
Would someone with the broken wifi issue present can check ownership, permissions and selinux contexts of /data/misc/wifi/p2p_supplicant.conf, please?

From adb or twrp terminal:

ls -laZ /data/misc/wifi/p2p_supplicant.conf
[Magisk] scj20:
Can anyone post a link for magisk v16.0 and/or 16.6? I'd be really grateful
[Magisk] leon90xs:
1. Boot to TWRP

2. Flash latest uninstaller

3. Without rebooting flash Magisk v.17.1

4. Reboot

If needed install manager manually

It work for me
[Magisk] :
After you deleted and resetup /data/misc/wifi/p2p_supplicant.conf, it's created with the correct ownership, permission and/or selinux context.

I'm pretty sure this would also be fixable with setting correct ownership, permissions and selinux context - perhaps a simple "restorecon /data/misc/wifi/p2p_supplicant.conf" could do the job.
[Magisk] demonoidmaster:
Your device is encrypted
[Magisk] scj20:
Can someone post a link to magisk 16.0 and/or 16.6?
[Magisk] demonoidmaster:
that's dumb don't do it, link the apk and zip to your rom post if you make it a public, nobody bundles magisk into their roms anymore because the addon.d script now does the job of reflashing magisk after rom updates that get flashed and having it run after your rom gets flashed + magisk causes a bootloop (rom zip runs a script that would flash your rom and bundled magisk, upon ending it will then autokick in the magisk addon.d script, but it will fail because it won't be able to complete and will **** up your boot)
[Magisk] :
Really?

It's there where all releses live in: https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/releases
[Magisk] scj20:
That's the source code, I don't know how to make it into a flashable zip, I have a lot to learn yet. Can you compile it into a flashable zip?

Edit: Found it, thanks. Sorry, I'm new at this stuff I kept downloading the source code
[Magisk] Carotix:
here

download
[Magisk] Peterlymo:
I am on 17v and no problem,, is it necessary to go 17.1v I am afraid the phone will unable to boot again after happened when I tried to move from 16v to 17v
[Magisk] Simone98RC:
[MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] you suggest to "clean install" Magisk v17.1 even for users who are not affected by bootloop (like me)?

Maybe something is messed up on my device?
[Magisk] scj20:
Can someone please tell me why root access doesn't work since I've updated to 17.0? I've even tried downgrading to no effect
[Magisk] xunholyx:
settings > security > screen lock > turn it off

Then boot to TWRP and try again
[Magisk] guest4711:
Use the Magisk Troubleshooting Guide in the SafetyNet section.

https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHideSafetyNet

That site is the authority on issues with Magisk... (and SN is off topics here, see OP).
[Magisk] gkornaks:
With Magisk v17.0 or v17.1 Viper4Android and Dolby Atmos for Oreo showing under modules but no apps. Also with repackaged manager and magisk hide banking apps detecting root now. I had to revert back to v16.0 to get it V4A/Dolby Atmos to show up again and banking apps not detecting root anymore.
[Magisk] sile87:
I'm on a Redmi 4x with latest Xiaomi.eu stable (7.1.2) and can't get magisk to work. Tested v16; v17 and 17.1. Always Bootloop. Once it works but i had no superuser in the Manager. So can someone help please?

Regards
[Magisk] janehull:
Just installed manager update. Root is broken and won't install. Pixel 2 xl, stock 8.x. Thanks.

- Copying image to cache

- Device platform: arm64-v8a

- Existing zip found

- Extracting files

boot_patch.sh[73]: can't create /proc/self/fd/: Is a directory

MagiskBoot v17.1(17100) (by topjohnwu) - Boot Image Modification Tool

Parsing boot image: [/data/user_de/0/com.topjohnwu.magisk/install/boot.img]

No boot image magic found!

boot_patch.sh[91]: can't create /proc/self/fd/: Is a directory

boot_patch.sh[91]: can't create /proc/self/fd/: Is a directory

! Installation failed
[Magisk] Indashio:
I try all this options but still not working safety net. CTSprofile false on my Xperia XZ Premium Dual firmware 47.1.A.12.270

Help
[Magisk] RichardEb:
Same Problem on OnePlus 3. Version 17.1 doesn't fixed the problem
[Magisk] ILoveLamp2234:
Using a LG VS996 flashed to US998 20D, I currently have 17.1 installed and tested safety, everything passes and I still have root. Problem is: when I go to use Hide the app crashes.

I've tried:

- toggling it on and off.

- clearing data.

- clean install.

Anyone having similar issues? I'm a noob to all of this ?*♂️.

*edit*

I've checked the Magisk log and this is what it says everytime the app force crashes.

09-01 12:04:43.642 681 702 I Magisk : proc_monitor: com.google.android.gms.unstable
[Magisk] Torontus:
I think this is not related with the ROM, before i flash the 17th Version, i had WiFi working good, OPO RR nougat latest build and original kernel, and yet, lost WiFi. See attachment.
[Magisk] JeepFreak:
I just installed the Magisk Manager update and now Magisk Manager won't open. It crashes before anything shows up. Root applications seem to work still. I tried rebooting... No dice. This is on a Pixel 2XL on stock Android PIE.

Any advice would be awesome!
[Magisk] RichardEb:
Is the update zip flashable with twrp?
[Magisk] Rush82:
I own a lg g2(d802).

Today I've flashed by twrp magisk 17.0.

Now I have bootloop .

I have tried to enter in recovery mode(twrp) without success: every key combination doesn't work.

I have only succeeded to enter in download mode.

How could I do?
[Magisk] BrotherZero:
Could someone please help me since my phone doesn't work anymore and goes into bootloop after the last update (17).

I have a Nexus 6P running MicroG's fork of Lineage OS 15.1. Today my Magisk Manager asked me to update to Magisk 17, I downloaded the zip file, went into TWRP 3.2.1-0, installed the zip. Installation went fine, then I rebooted, but I only get boot loop. I went back into recovery and tried to flash Magisk 16, but installation failed (error 1).

Anyone knows whats going on and how to fix it?

Grateful for any help!
[Magisk] thedisturbedone:
Hey thanks for this, but it didn't fix my wifi issue. I rechecked after a reboot and the file is missing. But can't switch it on. Any idea why?
[Magisk] adz63:
ok I had v16 installed and today it told me to install 17. in magisk manager it now says 16 is not installed. how can I flash this as twrp does not load only stock recovery?

v17.1 is on my sd ready to be installed
[Magisk] :
You need to wipe everything and flash the latest version 17.1, if you had a backup that would be useful..

---------- Post added at 06:58 PM ---------- Previous post was at 06:55 PM ----------

Same here, none of the modules are working!
[Magisk] TAJ_Rocks:
Install 17.1 zip from twrp and then boot up after that delete the file i mentioned. And reboot

---------- Post added at 08:03 PM ---------- Previous post was at 07:59 PM ----------

The same error i was having and i have posted a fix for wifi on page 2687 go and check
[Magisk] FlavioV:
No need to wipe anything, just flash the uninstaller and then install Magisk v17.1. You may find the latest bits in the official thread.

https://twitter.com/topjohnwu/status/1035912594446594049
[Magisk] elsamuraiguapo:
Same problem. I had a previous version working fine and got a notification from the app about an update. I downloaded the update and pressed install and it just prompts me to download the zip (again) or "Patch boot image file." At the top of the app's main screen I got a green checkmark where it says Latest version v17.1 and a red X next to "Magisk is not installed"

This is weird because IIRC before I would download the zip and it would prompt me to install the latest version and then do so automatically. Now all its doing is sending the zip to my downloads folder after is done downloading.