yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] eliezerjk90:
Well, I don't have any experience with huawei devices. Maybe you should wait for other input. Sorry I can't help you further.
[Magisk] robbayani:
before i'm flashing Xposed my Magisk can bypass SafetyNet.. after flashing Xposed i fail to bypass again..

it happen again when i'm clean flash rom..

is imposible bypass Safety when using Xposed??

btw i dont care if i cant bypass safety, because there is no apps banking on my phone.. i just want to know why i cant bypass..
[Magisk] eliezerjk90:
Xposed will always make safetynet fails
[Magisk] fiverings:
Thanks, that tread was helpful. I installed Magisk 15.4 and that installed Magisk manager 5.6.0. still had same issue with safety net. So I tried to hide Magisk manager, came back with red warnings, went back and and returned it to unhide and that came back ok. Then I checked Safety net and a box opened and said something like this " if you want to pass safety net, try installing this (don't remember what this was) I hit ok and passed safety net." And everything is working fine now.
[Magisk] DB126:
Xposed module OP clearly states SafetyNet will fail. Also well documented in numerous Magisk threads. Please do your homework before asking.
[Magisk] robbayani:
thats bad.. very bad..

i'm always using some cool module in Xposed..
[Magisk] eliezerjk90:
Earlier you wrote that you don't care if you can't pass safetynet... Gosh. At least be consistent...
[Magisk] DB126:
Huh? So you're inhibited from using a few banking/media apps while checking out some "cool module" in Xposed. Whew...that's bad, very bad. :rolleyes:
[Magisk] robbayani:
bad for someone want using Xposed + Magisk + Safety succes, likes my friend :p .. not bad for me :D

i'll tell my friend using Xposed + Magisk +Safety succes = impossible, + buy new phone with locked bootloader specially for banking apps..
[Magisk] ManikandanGuru:
Magisk hide is not working with banking apps anymore.

Most of the banking apps gives an error message not supported in rooted phones and then it closes. I'm in LineageOS 15.1 OP3T

Apps like BHIM and HDFC Bank New app are not working. Can someone help me fix this please.
[Magisk] robbayani:
not me not me..

my phone just using root Lineage + Xposed, all my apps & games not detecting root or need safety succes.. its enough for me..

---------- Post added at 02:59 ---------- Previous post was at 02:58 ----------

buy cheap phone specially for banking apps :D
[Magisk] DB126:
Exactly! $40 USD for a stock Moto E4 at WalMart that works great w/o a SIM card. In the absence of secure WiFi I simply spin up a hotspot on my primary phone for mobile access. Same gizmo can be carrier unlocked for about $3 for use with GSM networks and even some CDMA MVNOs (but not Verizon).

Sure, one device that 'does it all' is nice but there are practical solutions since hiding root will ALWAYS be a cat-and-mouse game that favors content providers. I prefer a stable solution that doesn't break every few days/weeks/months.
[Magisk] :
What's up guys.

Does anyone know why I can't use adb root with Magisk? I'm running the latest build of LineageOS-microG 14.1 for Moto G falcon.

The root functionality is working perfectly for apps, but when I try to adb root, I get the following message on my terminal:

adbd cannot run as root in production builds

I've found some workarounds for that on Google (none of them Magisk specific), but I didn't try any of them because I figured this is supposed to work out of the box, right? I've also tried the addon-su provided by LineageOS (while Magisk was uninstalled, of course) and adb root does work, so I guess this has something do to with Magisk itself.

Just for the record, I obviously have Android debugging enabled in Settings, and Superuser access also enabled for both Apps and ADB on Magisk.

Am I missing something? Any help is appreciated.

Thank you!
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Take a look in the the Magisk Guide - Hiding root from apps and see if there's anything in there you haven't tired yet. Also try the latest beta (v15.4) since it has improved hiding features.

Probably because of MagiskHide's prop changing. Try disabling MagiskHide and rebooting, that might make it work.
[Magisk] :
That did the trick, thank you very much! WiIl I miss some useful functionality with MagiskHide disabled though? Thanks again.
[Magisk] Artim_96:
Well, you won't be able to fool apps into thinking your not rooted and that you pass safetynet which can render some apps useless
[Magisk] :
Hmm, I see. Well, so far I haven't needed any app that uses SafetyNet, so I guess I will leave MagiskHide disabled until then. Thank you.

EDIT: I tried to re-enable MagiskHide, rebooted my phone, but Magisk still says it's disabled, no matter how many times I try to reboot
[Magisk] rahulrajmishra36:
Flashing Magisk in Oreo roms make the phone laggy. I tried it on AEX and pixel experience. Why is it so? Using it on Moto G xt1033 falcon.
[Magisk] ManikandanGuru:
I've followed everything in that Guide and I am using Latest Beta v15.4 only.

But still the apps are detecting Root. :(
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Hm... Try toggling the MagiskHide setting on - off - on and then reboot, and please report back if it works.

In that case it's likely the app has found something that Magisk can't hide. If you can figure out what, it's possible that there could be a fix, otherwise you'll have to live with it...
[Magisk] napes22:
Hiding Magisk Manager and clearling Chase Pay's data allowed it to work. If you're having issues with banking apps, set that option in settings. Worked for me on OP5, Codename Phoenix ROM with Magisk 15.3 installed. Only snag is that with the App hidden, you cannot apply Substratum skins to it anymore.
[Magisk] Weetbix:
I can confirm that this also works with the St George banking app in Australia. Fingerprint login was unavailable, I hid magisk manager, cleared the apps cache - then the fingerprint login was an option :good:
[Magisk] beastobadness:
Thought I would drop my logcat. Magisk manager 5.6.0 with magisk 15.3 is force closing for me on my stock 7.1.1 Axon 7.

Magisk Manager 5.5.5 works fine for me though so rolled back
[Magisk] HeliosV:
For whatever reason, Magisk isnt granting access for anything. i click grant, says it has but nothing is in superusertab, also when i tried updating to magisk manager 5.6, it always crashed. i tried reinstalling magisk manager, uninstalling magisk and reinstalling, even tried the 15.4 beta and still the same, nothing in superuser. AFter installing Magisk 5.6 it says magisk has stopped and magisk keeps stopping.
[Magisk] L0g4n:
Got the same problem, with magisk manager 5.6.0 it just force closes, on OnePlus 3T with omni 8.1 and magisk 14.5 (beta).

A logcat is attached.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
That's a known issue caused by an issue with SQLite and f2fs, mainly on custom 8.1 ROMs. The solution for now is to reformat /data as ext4, if possible (or revert to an older Magisk and Manager release, but that might bring other issues). There is troubleshooting and testing going on to see if the issue can be worked around...
[Magisk] HeliosV:
How do i get the logcat?
[Magisk] gothicVI:
Google and search on XDA or specifically in this thread. It has been mentioned countless times...

Gesendet von meinem Moto G 2014 LTE mit Tapatalk
[Magisk] ATP4:
https://xdaforums.com/showthread.php?t=1726238
[Magisk] HeliosV:
Figured it out. heres my logcat, magisk just crashed again.

Says the txt file was too big so i had to compress it. pleasde help?

View attachment logcat.zip
[Magisk] theman480:
So I installed my preferred modules, then everything is running perfectly, my problem is after a reboot, a module named "DownloadProvidet" is installed and actived. That module could be a virus?

Here is the screenshot:
[Magisk] madbat99:
Virus? No. Read up on Android and virus, not really possible (not the way we define virus normally). Looks like an issue though. Try to re do your steps on clean install and get logs.
[Magisk] famewolf:
What is the easiest method to get magisk installed on phone B with all the config and modules from Phone A? I don't want to have to keep manually installing all of them. I can copy over the whole Magisk directory on storage which includes the modules but there does not appear to be a simple method to import or export the configuration. It would seem pretty useful to allow "importing" even if it just tries to download all the modules from the repo so it gets the latest versions.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Pull /data/adb/magisk.img from device A, install Magisk to device B, push magisk.img to /data/adb on device B, reboot.

Should work, I've never tried... Device specific modules might cause issues...

---------- Post added at 07:37 ---------- Previous post was at 07:12 ----------

The "module" looks like it has no version or module info. I suspect it's simply a directory that for some reason have been placed in /sbin/.core/img. Take a look...
[Magisk] Beatzekatze:
Hello to all,

i use a Samsung S8 with Renovat CustomRom. And i have the MagiskManager. And now i want to make some Apps to delete the root. I hear that is it possible with Magisk. Then i go to Magisk Hide and click example the Google Play Store. But the tick does not stay there. What did i wrong?

Thank you for your help.... and sorry for bad English... i am german ;)
[Magisk] gothicVI:
Log?

Gesendet von meinem Moto G 2014 LTE mit Tapatalk
[Magisk] Beatzekatze:
Hello,

here is the log.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
You need to update your Magisk installation...
[Magisk] chaopac:
removed
[Magisk] fiverings:
I installed Magisk for the Feb 8.1 update on my Pixel XL, having some issues, can't pass safety net. And For the past 3 days, when I update apps, the apps would stay where they say Open. I tried pressing on open and nothing happens. I have 22 apps that say Open and not a one would change. I'm still rooted and still Certified. Anyone seen this before?
[Magisk] gothicVI:
There's no point in going back although older versions are available e.g. on github if I remember correctly.

However, it'd be better to help development and bugfixing by using the current version and by providing logs and information on potential fails.

Gesendet von meinem Moto G 2014 LTE mit Tapatalk
[Magisk] zfk110:
Hi, My magisk was passing SNet, last night this morning I check and now its failing, I didn't do anything in between. Im on Lollipop 910T
[Magisk] dragonF6:
Amazing work. By using it, able to root Z500M. No major problems.
[Magisk] Varun.Shanbhag:
Im using Xiaomi Redmi Note 3 (kenzo) Running MIUI 9.2.4.0 Android 6.0.1. Magisk version installed:15.3 Magisk Manager version installed:5.6.0 I'm trying to update Magisk from 15.3 to 15.4 through magisk manager using direct install method but it fails . Logs attached . Please reply.
[Magisk] ohtoulouz:
Some settings do not stick in mm

Hi

Magisk is great. The only issue I have in mm is that some settings do not stick. Each time I open the app, I have the info about the update and some settings, not all, revert back to default. Any ideas?

Cheers
[Magisk] zfk110:
dont use direct method it might put you in soft boot loop, use whatever recovery you use to install it in the first place
[Magisk] Varun.Shanbhag:
Even Recovery update doesn't work.I need to unistall magisk and reinstall.
[Magisk] NightHeron:
Hello guys, magisk is my heart of my Redmi Note 4, and since 15 versions, Magisk cannot hold superuser's rights. In the app, there is an empty page in superuser, and every time (even greenify) wants to ask root privileges, it shows me the prompt pop up.

I have 4 other phones without this Problem. How can i delete all the settings to flash it from the beginning?

Clear Data didn't work, even clear flashing other ROMs.

I am sure that if i format the whole data partition, it will work, but i am seeking a solution to avoid this.

Any ideas?
[Magisk] SgtWendigo:
after flashing magisk, system prompts a notification saying "android is updating...", when it finishes, camera launches really slowly.

logs attached.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Have you tried turning it off and on again?

That log is not very useful for this case... Details about how it fails and three installation log works be nice.

Is that a device specific thing? Never experienced that...

Logs...

https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/Magisk#hn_Asking_for_help

Sounds like the f2fs issue experienced by a bunch of users. Solution so far has been to format /data to ext4...

Luckily, there might be hope on the horizon (related issue):

https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=75604245&postcount=5210
[Magisk] denreylim:
Hello, i'm using Magisk v15.3, I managed the MagiskHide to hide my apps for root. I had checked flags to Mandiri Online, BCA Mobile, and TCash Wallet. My mobile apps (Mandiri Online & BCA Mobile) working properly. But, my TCash Wallet not working for Magisk Hide. How to solve it? Thankyou.

I'm using Xiaomi Redmi 3 (ido)
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHideHidingRoot
[Magisk] denreylim:
Thanks for answer my question, but not working for me. Any solution for this TCash Wallet? :(
[Magisk] NightHeron:
Sounds like the f2fs issue experienced by a bunch of users. Solution so far has been to format /data to ext4...

Luckily, there might be hope on the horizon (related issue):

https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=75604245&postcount=5210[/QUOTE]

Yeah of course, sorry I forgot to mention the f2fs partition. I'll wait! Thanks a lot for the answer.
[Magisk] funm@sterz:
Hello,

Using Redmi note 3 special edition.

From magisk 14.0 (since I started using magisk)

I've never been able to pass safety net test basic or cts.

Also magisk hide or magus on manager hide not working from the beginning.

Tried magisk safetynet bypass beta v5 also. No effect.

Kindly help.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
You sure you tested everything from that link? I just did a quick test where I could get the app to open just fine. Didn't examine closer what it actually was that triggered it, but just added the app to the Hide list, his the Manager and also disabled USB debugging and developer options. After that it started without any "root detected" prompt.

Some apps are just to hard to trick though... If you can figure out what it detects, there's a

slight

possibility that MagiskHide can be updated to circumvent it.

You need to provide the logs and details...

https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHide#hn_Asking_for_help
[Magisk] denreylim:
i had tested all of solution from that link, but not working for me.. I had added the apps to the hide list, hide Magisk Manager, disabled USB Debugging dan Developer Options. No changes for this Apps. :( . I'm using Lineage OS 14.1 (Android 7.1).
[Magisk] Deerar DS:
Hi all,

I've searched a lot but couldn't find the right answer,.

I'm on RR Android 7.1 final oneplus 3, the first time I opened Magisk Manger it asked me to update to 5.6.... After the update It is always force closes... Any suggestions???
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=75604245&postcount=5210
[Magisk] Deerar DS:
Thank you very much..... But I wonder If I simply re-flash the room again.... is that will help?....
[Magisk] Draizix:
Alright I'm back again here after about a week of trying different things. I *JUST* now caught something interesting. Right when I got my error in Fire emblem heroes I went to magisk manager and saw SafetyNet failed its check literally right after the error happened and locked the game.

SafetyNet is still failing here, store says certified still. Can still see store apps like Netflix etc. Any ideas? Should I post another magisk beta log again to see if it has anything of use?

*edit a few minutes later*

Restarted phone and am now getting all green on SafetyNet again. So I guess something is tripping it? I know the playstore had an update recently that happened in the past couple weeks. Not sure if that has a potential to be the issue or not.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Give this a go and see if it works:

https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=75610628&postcount=5225
[Magisk] melendi:
Flash Magisk on Shield TV

Hello gentlemen, I would like to ask you how to flash Magisk on Nvidia Shield TV 2017 16GB (Rom: Full Nougat v1.5) when there is an error CANNOT MOUNT /VENDOR?

In TWRP under the tab "Mount" there is no option to mount /vendor.

Is there any workaround?

View attachment recovery.log

View attachment dmesg.log
[Magisk] jenslody:
Tcash wallet reads the original "/default.prop", at least it did a month ago see my post: https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=75080892&postcount=21878
[Magisk] amphi66:
Phone is Axon 7 2017U -- Data is encrypted, formatted ext4 not F2FS.

MM5.6 (w/ Magisk 15.3) immediately FCs. MM5.5.5 is just fine.

Uninstalled MM5.5.5 and installed latest "fix", but hangs on Graphic Splash screen. CatLog opened but would not read logs. Rebooted, uninstalled MM5.6 (app-fix), reflashed MM5.5.5 and all is fine.

Can you suggest another test/logging method?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Hook up to a computer and use ADB.

https://xdaforums.com/showthread.php?t=1726238
[Magisk] ScratMan38:
I have an issue using Magisk 15.3 on a Pixel C tab, with LineageOS 15.1 unofficial. When I activate the Magisk Hide feature for an app, the check does not stick, and when I go back and open Magisk Hide menu again, the app is unchecked. So I can't hide the root to apps like Play Store or Netflix. :(

It was working fine previously on stock Android 8.1, but I wanted to switch to LineageOS...
[Magisk] Deerar DS:
Dear all,

Simply, I am on RR Nougat 7.1.2 with EXT4 data file system but Magisk 5.6 still crashing......and I don't have root access..... I tried to install Magisk 5.5.5 but it the installation failed?

I'm fed up trying many things that didn't help.... :crying::confused:
[Magisk] Deerar DS:
Sorry, but I didn't get what you meant.....

Can I ignore Magisk and flash superuser to got root access?

---------- Post added at 07:34 PM ---------- Previous post was at 07:25 PM ----------

Or maybe re-flash the room again? Is that possible or I may face troubles?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
He's asking you to provide logs (just like I have done a couple of times). Take a look here:

https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHelp
[Magisk] Deerar DS:
Thank you for the clarification, but there are no logs since the Magisk came with RR room (So I didn't flash it via TWRP) and I couldn't open the Magisk manager app at all
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Did you read through the link I posted at all? Specifically the part about a "logcat"? We need one of those...
[Magisk] Deerar DS:
Sorry, I tried my best but couldn't get "Logcat" . . . . Actually, I am not an advanced user . . .

I would like to ask again If I re-flash the room RR-N-5.8.5 via TWRP 3.2.1.0 is this will solve the problem since it comes with Magisk 5.4 or 5.5 ??
[Magisk] Deerar DS:
Again, Thank you for your patience
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
No worries my friend. Reflashing your ROM should fix things. Just don't update the Manager until things are settling down...
[Magisk] Deerar DS:
Thank you very much for your help :good:
[Magisk] darkdaemon32:
I cant get modules to install on my device, I have tried from magisk manager (package install failed error) as well as twrp (error 1) and flashfire (which just gets stuck at black screen)

Does anyone have a clue as to why the packages fail to install even from recovery? I've tried using a bootable twrp as well as flashing twrp to my boot image and using super su. I need the systemless xposed/rootswitch and magisk in order to pass safety net on my device, i know that xposed makes safetynet fail but im using rootswitch to turn it off when needed

magisk manager latest, magisk version 15.3, moto x 4 android oreo 8.0.0 rooted using magisk boot img
[Magisk] Deerar DS:
I re-flash the room but it didn't boot . . . attached the logs
[Magisk] xabier-bo:
Hi,

Not a developer, but this is what has worked for me in 2015 16GB model:

while device is running:

sudo adb reboot-bootloader

sudo fastboot boot twrp-3.2.0-0-foster.img

of course you can already be in twrp recovery, and have it installed

while in twrp, from computer console

sudo adb shell mkdir vendor/

sudo adb shell mount /dev/block/mmcblk0p21 /vendor

sudo adb shell mount system

after that you can install the magisk.zip

I was searching how to mod twrp so that the vendor partition would be shown at the mount option, but this is anorher league for me ;)

Hope this is useful...
[Magisk] Deerar DS:
I've made a clean installation . . . I recover my phone :D

This Magisk is sooooo complex . . . . it drives me crazy :cyclops:. . . .

Thank you
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
You need to provide an installation/recovery log from the failed installations.
[Magisk] NLBeev:
Although Xposed is turned off, the framework mods are still present.
[Magisk] SgtWendigo:
confirmed 3rd party issue.
[Magisk] krazzyvishal:
I finally settled with an Oreo ROM that I liked and went ahead with installing the Magisk modules that I use. I am using Magisk 15.3. I installed them successfully, but you know you have to reboot to activate them. Mine are just not getting activated, I rebooted several times. This is what I see (screenshot attached).

And the log is:

01-21 14:20:51.664 274 274 I Magisk : * Creating /sbin overlay
01-21 14:20:51.665 274 274 I Magisk : * Mounting mirrors
01-21 14:20:51.665 274 274 I Magisk : mount: /dev/block/platform/msm_sdcc.1/by-name/system -> /sbin/.core/mirror/system
01-21 14:20:51.665 274 274 I Magisk : link: /sbin/.core/mirror/system/vendor -> /sbin/.core/mirror/vendor
01-21 14:20:51.666 274 274 I Magisk : bind_mount: /sbin/.core/mirror/bin <- /data/adb/magisk
01-21 14:20:51.666 274 274 I Magisk : * Setting up internal busybox
01-21 14:20:51.682 274 274 I Magisk : Magisk v15.3(1531) daemon started
01-21 14:20:51.685 274 284 I Magisk : ** post-fs mode running
01-21 19:50:53.544 274 295 I Magisk : ** post-fs-data mode running
01-21 19:50:53.544 274 295 I Magisk : * Mounting /data/adb/magisk.img
01-21 19:50:53.625 274 295 I Magisk : * Running post-fs-data.d scripts
01-21 19:50:53.625 274 295 I Magisk : * Running module post-fs-data scripts
01-21 19:50:53.625 274 295 I Magisk : * Loading modules
01-21 19:50:54.777 274 461 I Magisk : ** late_start service mode running
01-21 19:50:54.777 274 461 I Magisk : * Running service.d scripts
01-21 19:50:54.777 274 461 I Magisk : * Running module service scripts
02-19 11:43:16.816 274 4440 I Magisk : * Starting MagiskHide
02-19 11:43:16.817 274 4440 I Magisk : hide_utils: Hiding sensitive props
02-19 11:43:16.820 274 4440 I Magisk : hide_list: [com.google.android.gms.unstable]
02-19 11:43:16.916 274 4440 I Magisk : proc_monitor: init ns=mnt:[4026531840]
02-19 11:43:17.082 274 4440 I Magisk : proc_monitor: zygote ns=mnt:[4026544766]
02-19 11:43:22.288 274 4440 I Magisk : proc_monitor: com.google.android.gms.unstable (PID=4614 ns=mnt:[4026545267])
02-19 11:43:55.409 274 4440 I Magisk : proc_monitor: com.google.android.gms.unstable (PID=5516 ns=mnt:[4026545266])

Edit: I fixed it by reinstalling the modules and rebooting.
[Magisk] GryphonBR:
Magisk 15.3 on EMUI 8

I've been searching around but can't seem to find anything regarding this; I'm trying to install Magisk to my Huawei P10 Plus running EMUI 8 (Oreo-based). Boot is split between ramdisk and kernel in this release, and at least for SuperSU patching ramdisk seems to be enough. I tried using a modified installer I found for the Mate 10 Pro (which comes with EMUI 8 by default) but it didn't work, so I installed Magisk Manager on my phone and patched the ramdisk.img file I had dd' to my external SD. I then installed the generated img but the device simply bootloops; upon restoring the original ramdisk, I'm back in busicess. Any ideas? Which logs could I provide to help sort out what's going on?

Edit: figured out what was going on, EMUI 8 has a funny implementation of the boot partition, so topjohnwu figured out how to install it manually for now. Magisk up and running, thanks!
[Magisk] rovingthief:
is there a way to download version 14.2., 14.3, and 14.6 ?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Nope. Those are all old, and beta releases at that... You got to move forward, man! :p

If you absolutely need it, you can find the source on GitHub and build yourself:

https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/releases