yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] kepetmania:
Hi,

This is maybe the most stupid question, but how do I attach a file to a post?

I've read this :

"How do I attach a file to a post?

To attach a file to your post, you need to be using the main 'New Post' or 'New Thread' page and not 'Quick Reply'. To use the main 'New Post' page, click the 'Post Reply' button in the relevant thread.

On this page, below the message box, you will find a button labelled 'Manage Attachments'. Clicking this button will open a new window for uploading attachments. You can upload an attachment either from your computer or from another URL by using the appropriate box on this page. Alternatively you can click the Attachment Icon to open this page.

To upload a file from your computer, click the 'Browse' button and locate the file. To upload a file from another URL, enter the full URL for the file in the second box on this page. Once you have completed one of the boxes, click 'Upload'.

Once the upload is completed the file name will appear below the input boxes in this window. You can then close the window to return to the new post screen."

But I can't find the attachment button.

Sorry for bothering you.
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
/sbin/su
[Magisk] manthes:
How can i use file manager or file manager hd with magisk? Every time i tried to enable root i says that root explorer cannot be enabled https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.rhmsoft.fm.hd
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
That thing hasn't been updated for almost two years. I'd go with something that's a little bit more maintained.

FX File Explorer is a great file manager and the developer is right here on xda as well.
[Magisk] Prattham:
I am using stable version, why i can't see all the modules in download section?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
If you can't see modules that should be there, try clearing the repo cache (in the Manager settings) and reload (pull down in the Downloads section).

What modules are you missing? Modules that haven't been updated to at least module template v4 will not be available through the repo.
[Magisk] manthes:
hd version hasn't been updated for 1 year but this one updated before 3 days. https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.rhmsoft.fm .

I know fx explorer but i don't like it's interface so my question is if it exists any solution or i have to try other file managers

........................

Also i tried fx and i have the same problem. It granted superuser access but it gave me the message that "The operation could not be completed".
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Ah... I posted based on the info in the Play Store link you posted first.

If the file explorer doesn't recognise MagiskSU you'll need to contact the developer to update the app.

FX works perfectly with MagiskSU...
[Magisk] manthes:
Both of them granted super user access but root did't work for them. I can't understand it. Do you have any suggestion what to try? With root browser i am ok
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
I tested that file explorer and it does not recognise root with MagiskSU, even tough it is granted root access. Like I said before, contact the developer.... Edit: or if you're lucky, someone here will know a trick.

Don't know why you can't get FX to work... You did install the root add-on, right?
[Magisk] Sureshkhatri:
Hi guys am using Oneplus one as Well Oneplus two both running on Resurrection Remix 5.8.5 Nougat 7.1.2 my phone rooted checked in Root checker I have installed Magisk manager but it's showing not installed if I flash its showing Failed

How to fix am sending Screen shot
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
There are instructions included with the error message in your first screenshot. Check here for more details:

https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/guide-magisk-troubleshooting-t3641417
[Magisk] manthes:
I saw that i am not the only one with that problem. Maybe it has something to do with the custom miui rom. Anyway i will leave with root browser until i find something better
[Magisk] Rosa Elefant:
I just came around SafetyNet and Magisk for the first time. (The Android scene changed a lot over two years of inactivity, obviously.)

One quick question: Am I mistaken when I assume that "enabling MagiskHide" basically means "installing a software that works like a trojan on your smartphone so you can play Pokémon Go"?

If no: Why do I seem to be the only one who thinks that this is a horrible idea?
[Magisk] HypoTurtle:
Magiskhide last i checked isn't a software or anything its simply a mask for calls/checks on whether the device is rooted or not
[Magisk] Rosa Elefant:
How does it - technically - work then? I mean, it seems to be able to intercept low-level system security checks? (Sorry if that has been explained somewhere.)
[Magisk] Pkt_Lnt:
Have you read the documentation linked in the OP / post #1?

https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/blob/master/docs/README.MD

There are more links in post #1, including source code so you can put your mind at ease. :good:
[Magisk] Rosa Elefant:
Yes, I did, and I could not find reliable information about how exactly it hides from SafetyNet (or how SafetyNet tries to detect it).

There are, however, certain phrases that make me suspicious:

Sounds like BackOrifice, actually. But that might be a bit harsh. According to what I understand from the documentation (not the code, I should check that probably...), Magisk basically behaves like a boot sector rootkit. Which part have I missed?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
In a way you could say that Magisk behaves like a rootkit. It has escalated privileges and can hide itself and some of it's parts from processes that it's been instructed to do so from (the Hide list). A difference would be that Magisk isn't malicious... :) But, as with any root solution, there are of course risks.

The procedure diagram shows pretty well the basics of how Magisk and MagiskHide behaves, but if you want to get technical on how MagiskHide works the best thing would be to check the code.

I'm curious as to why that specific phrase made you suspicious...
[Magisk] BandzTFM:
Hello XDA, I don't know if this issue has been stated already or solved already but I need help with magisk 14.3/5.4 I installed everything ok, passed all checks everything...but when I install a module, it downloads to the internal MagisManager folder, but after it installs, I[ doesn't show up as installed in the downloads section nor do the modules show up in the modules section, but the mod was installed. (Volume Steps Increase) Any insight as to why this is happening? (Moto E4 Perry QC MetroPCS Stock, Magisk 14.3 Manager 5.4)
[Magisk] Rosa Elefant:
[MENTION=4667597]Didgeridoohan[/MENTION] Sorry if I sound overly cautious, but while I'd consider myself to be someone who loves to play with sophisticated software, I also noticed that this sounds a lot like software which nobody wants to have on his/her device. :)

I understand it somewhat better now. Maybe I'll take the weekend for a deeper look. Thank you for the graph, I missed it.
[Magisk] Pkt_Lnt:
Well, ummm. "nobody" ???????????????????

From post #1
[Magisk] Rosa Elefant:
I meant the rootkit part. :) Sorry, I'm tired, that might make my grammar less expressive. I'll check back later.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Being cautious is a very healthy approach...

I look forward to hearing your take on Magisk once you've had a chance to dig deeper.

---------- Post added at 07:52 ---------- Previous post was at 07:50 ----------

To be fair, a large part of those downloads are by users that have little to no clue what they're actually doing... :p

---------- Post added at 08:39 ---------- Previous post was at 07:52 ----------

Sounds like you're a victim of Moto's f2fs implementation. The file you see in the MagiskManager folder isn't the installed module, but the downloaded module installation zip. Modules are installed to /magisk.

If you see something like this when installing modules and you see something like this (also see the rest of that post) somewhere in the Magisk log the above is probably true.

Note to self: Have to update the troubleshooting guide with this info...
[Magisk] DiamondJohn:
anI will guess many to be assuming safety in numbers, and thereby not taking the extra time and effort to truly understand what its doing, just being thankful that it works.:good:

In my case, Magisk is also the default root method in the ROM; ResurrectionRemix.
[Magisk] soder:
I got Magisk 14.3 installed on my OP3T with beta 18 Oreo. Magisk works, and root to, but when I go in to the Superuser menu in Magisk Manager the app crash.

What can I do?

Thanks.

/Söder

Skickat från min ONEPLUS A3003 via Tapatalk
[Magisk] jenslody:
Every root-method can be potential malicious, but unlike some other root-programs (e.g. SuperSU), MagiskSU is open source, so everybody can check the code and if she/he is really doubtful, Magisk can be easily self-compiled.

And it does not use real exploits (or design flaws) to root the systems as some one-click root solutions do, as far as I know.

Magiskhide uses mount namespaces to unmount/hide suspicious stuff from programs in the magiskhide-list and in the coming release MagiskManager can hide itself by reinstalling the Manager with a random package name.

Besides this, the user should always think twice, before she/he grants root-access to any app and for how long they get it.

I have four apps with permanent root-access, but in general I feel better with granting the root-access again for a short period (e.g. if I use termux or adb shell).

And because of the systemless approach of Magisk, it's great to remove system-apps or alter other stuff, without really changing the /system-partition (easier to change back and to survive OTA's of the rom).
[Magisk] Jaitsu:
So I've searched around, and I'm surprised I can't really find this one mentioned: Every time I do anything with Magisk, Systemless Hosts turns itself off. Installing a module, updating a module, updating my ROM (and thus 'reinstalling' Magisk, but everything else is intact)... Every time I do any of that, and sometimes seemingly at random, Systemless Hosts somehow gets unchecked, and loses my modified hosts. Using Magisk 14.0 on a Samsung Note 3 (hltecan/hltetmo builds, Resurrection Remix N ROM).
[Magisk] Ed St John:
Has anyone tried the systemless xposed from magisk? Was wondering if you can still use android pay etc. after installing it
[Magisk] Pkt_Lnt:
Many xposed comments above if you search. I don't remember seeing any mentions of Android Pay, but I don't pay attention to that.
[Magisk] Black-FR:
Delete cache and data of the magisk manager app.

Afterwards the superuser tab will work too.
[Magisk] casouzaj:
OK, I'm quoting myself just to let whoever faces this hidden buttons in his/her Android smartwatch's tiny screen issue, just edit field ro.sf.lcd_density inside the build.prop file, change value 120 to 100, save the file and reboot. Problem solved!
[Magisk] winpooh:
I had the same issue on a Moto G5S Plus and I fixed it by flashing a custom kernel. I realize Moto has had this issue because of their implementation of f2fs but possibly your boot.img got messed up somehow? Just my experience
[Magisk] DiamondJohn:
Will that also remove all history/settings of which apps have been granted SU Permissions?
[Magisk] synesthete:
Clearing the cache won't, but wiping the data will. The su permission pop up automatically, so it isn't too much of a nuisance. You will probably have to re-add your Magisk modules, too. (It will not clear your modules. Thanks Didgeridoohan)
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Clearing data for the Manager does not remove any modules.
[Magisk] lover:
I have a wield problem.

I recently updated oneplus3t from ob15 (nougat) to ob18 (oreo) and successfully rooted with magisk v14.3 everything seems to be working fine like magiskhide or SN

But magiak manager crashes when i tap to start checking SafetyNet. I tried 5.4.1 same and it asked me to update magisk to 14.4 which works well but same problem with crashes.

I tried already dirty flashing and wiping dalvik cache or clear data of magisk manager.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Start by staying on Manager v5.4.0 (and Magisk v14.3). The v5.4.1 version (and Magisk v14.4) was released for the Pixel 2 XL, so that they could have root...
[Magisk] beavis5706:
I don't know how to do a logcat from boot, only once booted.

Here are logcats from installing Greenify4Magisk module via Magisk Manager (logcatinstallmodule) and fixing the problem by deleting the offending module from /dev/source (logcatfix)

The Magisk log always looks like that or its empty. Its currently empty after installing/fixing Greenify4Magisk module.
[Magisk] lover:
well i have same problem with v14.3 and v5.4.0, when i tap to check SN the magisk manager closes itself

i have attached the logcats
[Magisk] Pkt_Lnt:
XDA has your back! :D

A great tutorial here.

https://xdaforums.com/showthread.php?t=1726238

A second one with help to learn to use a logcat yourself to help diagnose problems.

https://xdaforums.com/showthread.php?t=2274119
[Magisk] nvo2411:
Trying to install, following error, Please guide
[Magisk] Pkt_Lnt:
Read the lines in the recovery log:

Remove other root methods and restore your stock boot image.
[Magisk] nvo2411:
Thanks I removed su, but still same error

I also tried dirty flashing my Rom but same error
[Magisk] Pkt_Lnt:
You still have systemless su detritus in /data.

Flash this in recovery, restore stock boot image (dirty flash ROM will then work).

https://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=63615067
[Magisk] nvo2411:
The problem is I am using multi Rom, and this is my secondary Rom, I don't get option to flash.img in secondary Roms, it is only available in primary

Will dirty flashing my Rom zip file solve the problem.. Let me check

Appreciate ur feedback

If you u can suggest any further solution please
[Magisk] Pkt_Lnt:
I know nothing about the current state of multi ROM with Magisk. I have not used it in over a year. I suggest you ask that developer about it and / or in the multi Rom thread for you device.
[Magisk] vasileios26:
Hi guys, and thank you in advance for anyone answer.

It's impossible for me to read 2000 pages, and for this reason i ask here.

I have problem with SafetyNet, I can't pass this.

I have installed Magisk at version 14.0 ,at my device, Samsung galaxy tab 4 (SM T331).

It's installed stock rom, and stock kernel, and i haven't install other superuser methods (like supersu etc), and also i have installed TWRP 3.0.0 .

I have tried to pass SafetyNet with different methods:

At first, i have disabled usb debugging.

After, i tried to install: universal-safetynet-fix-v2-beta-5-magisk-v14 , but also don't pass SafetyNet.

At finally, i tried to apply this guide because it's a guide for Samsung devices, but also nothing happened.

I want to note, that after flash magisk v.14 , when boot/restart the device, up and left of logo, appears on Samsung logo the note: "set warranty bit: kernel", with yellow letters.

What to do for pass SafetyNet??

Edit: Also, doesn't works Magisk hide (I have tried to works this, with terminal emulator with next commands):

" su

Magiskhide --enable " (but with no effect).

Thank you again.
[Magisk] jenslody:
If magiskhide does not work, you can not pass safetynet.

But without logs we can just guess what happens.

I suggest not to use universal safteynet fix if possible, because it overwrites the internal busybox of Magisk on every boot and this is not recoverable without removing usnf and reflashing magisk.

You can try the 14.3 beta or wait till the next beta is out (should come soon) and see if it works.

The "set warranty bit: kernel"-message is normal and nor problem (if magiskhide works).

Another question:

which version of Android do you have on your device, and which kernel ?

If it is too old, you will not be able to use magiskhide with recent Magisk (at least kernel 3.10 is needed, or a kernel with backported mount-namespace support).
[Magisk] vasileios26:
At first, thank you very much for your answer.

I didn't know this information about Magisk hide.

I tried directly, to flash v.14.3 .

Device android version is lollipop 5.1.1 (stock version).

And kernel version is: 3.4.0 (and TWRP version is 3.0.0 if this information is important for you).

Then, need to flash other kernel? Which is your advice?
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
It is very unlikely that you'll find a kernel for your device that has the necessary features for MagiskHide to work. If there is one, you're better off looking for it in your device's forum.
[Magisk] mctiew:
I am running a root check app installed from play store. I have configured magisk hide for this application. When i run this app, it says my phone is rooted, on the basis the there is a symbolic link /sbin/su to /root/magisk.

Is there anything else I could do to hide it from concluding the phone has been rooted ?
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
Logs or it didn't happen.
[Magisk] mctiew:
What log are you referring to ?
[Magisk] vasileios26:
Ok, thank you very much.
[Magisk] LeMoise:
I tried updating from the October Patch to the November one by following the instructions to keep root, but the update fails.

I went into magisk and clicked restore stock, then without restarting I went into settings and try to update but it always fails during step 1.
[Magisk] Artim_96:
Then your ROM detects changes to the boot image. Most likely you'll have to live with that
[Magisk] thiago.net:
I am experiencing errors in Magisk. Help-me.

When you check SafetyNet it closes.

Any solution for this?

Log: pastebin.com/8x5KFN1j
[Magisk] LeMoise:
I am using the Stock ROM/Recovery which was supposed to help bypass this issue, the creator of magisk has a guide on updating OTA while keeping your root which is what I was trying to do. But yeah I am just going to wipe my phone, install the latest update and then decide from there if its worth rerooting again or not. I mostly use it for the adblock and lucky patcher.
[Magisk] quadcrap1:
Has anyone successfully gotten Magisk to play nice with a Google "Work Profile" on their phone?

My situation:

Droid Turbo running stock Marshmallow

Installed Work Profile successfully

Installed Magisk v14.0 via TWRP (booted with TWRP transient load via fastboot; TWRP not installed on phone)

Logged into phone. went to Magisk Manager, and hid Device Policy

Hid Magisk

No go. When the phone tests itself for security I get a message that the device has been compromised and I can't sync with my Work Profile.

If I remove Magisk, I can successfully sync again.

Any help?
[Magisk] Pkt_Lnt:
No logs = no help.

Sounds harsh, but that is the reality. We cannot see what happens inside your phone without logs.

Magisk log from inside Magisk Manager. Logcat while running work profile.
[Magisk] Veid71:
well it would seem after i installed the greenify module i rebooted my phone and its doing the same issue again :/ the difference is though i nstalled the greenify app then i installed the module then instead of hitting reboot i hit close to see fi it was there and it wasnt then ir ebooted and nothing was there unfortunately
[Magisk] DodoGTA:
The one from Magisk Manager
[Magisk] pafaf:
Hi,is there a place to leave suggestions? i think is missing something very useful on magiskhide. A button to select all or an option to inverse the applied selection. That is , for example, select only the app that you DO WANT root to see. To do this I have to select every each one by one , and what something get wrong ,have to do it again . Alternative is a backup settings.

Thanks for the great work magisk.
[Magisk] mctiew:
Magisk manager log

(Manually edited to delete some lines which show full my hide list )
[Magisk] beardymarrow:
Hi, you shouldn't hide all (or even most) apps with magiskhide, only the ones that detect root and have a problem with it. Having loads of apps in the list causes issues.
[Magisk] ROUGE13:
Hi,

I have installed magisk 14.3 on my galaxy S7 (G930F) on resurrection remix rom (nougat 7.1.2) with the official Xposed.

It works but at each reboot magisk hide don't start alone:

-> I check an app in the list, go out of the list and when I come back, the app isn't checked

-> The app see that root exist on the phone

As in support thread I unchecked an recheck the magisk hide system to restart it:

-> The app previoulsy checked (but staying unchecked) reappear checked

-> The app don't see that the root exist on the phone

So is there a way to make magisk hide starting properly,

or to force magisk hide to stop and to restart at each boot?

(Sorry for my english...)

[I don't found my last post back so I put it again here (sorry if it was somewhere else)]
[Magisk] siliano:
Hi all

I tried to flash magisk on my s8 (G950F), Im on ambasadii oreo rom and i got this error while flashing in TWRP :

(See file attached) What can i do ? [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION]
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
The next version of Magisk has a much improved MagiskHide and a better way of hiding the Manager as well.

Apart from posting those logs that was asked for, waiting for the next release might be your best option.

There's this in your log:

E( 432: 573) open: /dev/target/Greenify4Magisk/system/priv-app/Greenify/Greenify.apk failed with 2: No such file or directory

Not sure what that's about, but v14.2 beta is pretty ancient now in terms what's been developed for the next release. There's hardly any point trying to troubleshoot it until you've tested the next release...

The magisk_debug.log that you'll find in /data is actually more useful...

The solution to your problem is in the error message:

! Boot image patched by other programs!
! Please restore stock boot image

Read more about it here:

https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/guide-magisk-troubleshooting-t3641417
[Magisk] Veid71:
I've tried installing 14.3 but I don't think it mounts or something because it when I install the modules it says it's successful but it won't show up in my modules section, also I uninstalled magisk and reinstalled it and all the modules I previously had showed up for some reason, I think it might be because I don't hit reboot after flashing the modules, if I hit close and wait a little bit that's when I have the issue
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
If you uninstalled Magisk and your modules turn up again after reinstalling, that means that the uninstall didn't work...

But, like I said, it may be that the next release (that hopefully is imminent) will work better... There's been a lot of changes since v14.3 beta.
[Magisk] jenslody:
Are you sure you have only one root checker installed ?

Your image looks eactly like the "technarcs.rootchecker", but your log shows that you added "com.anu.developers3k.rootchecker" to the hidelist.
[Magisk] Veid71:
Is there a newer version I can switch to other than 14.3?
[Magisk] mctiew:
Oh, that fixed the problem. I was testing one checker after another, and then confused which is which after a while. Thanks.
[Magisk] jenslody:
You can try an unofficial snapshot from this thread, but keep in mind, that you have to uninstall the official MagiskManager if you do so. And you have to uninstall the unoffical Manager, if you switch back to official Magisk later.

Or you wait until the next official beta comes. It has many, many improvements according to the 14.3 beta, but it is still in internal testing.

https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/unofficial-magisk-v10-beta-built-t3521901