yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] krzygaj:
Hello, i've problem with tasker - it doesnt recognize magisk:

- Magisk 17.1

- Magisk manager 6.0.1

- Tasker 5.6

- Mi A2 Lite - stock rom

I think it happened after last tasker update.

Does anyone have any solution?

I can not use tasks that require root access.

I tried to remove the Tasker from magisk and re-add it, but no window appears where I can grant permissions.

For example, an attempt to turn on GPS using the tasker ends with the following message:
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
Looks like Tasker still has issues recognising root with the Manager repackaged. It's not a Magisk issue... Bring it up with Tasker's developer.
[Magisk] sconly:
I've done all that but still no success. The only difference from your setup is that I'm running Nougat.

Any other ideas?

Thanks
[Magisk] philcoo2:
Hi Sconly.

Is your Android version is to date with security updates, when I was on Nougat I had a problem when I was not up to date with updates.
[Magisk] Cookie__XD:
endless boot on my Doogee s60 lite

On my Doogee s 60 lite all versions approximately after 16.7 aren't working.

With Magisk 17.1 and 17.3 I am stuck on the boot screen.

Where are log files that I may provide to solve the problem?
[Magisk] Wolfcity:
You have to deliver these logs. Use adb or use something like logcat.
[Magisk] jsauder2:
Kind of a weird question... I've got a Pixel 3 and successfully rooted with magisk by patching the boot image through the app and flashing through fastboot. I installed a few modules and apparently one of them is causing issues so I'm stuck in a bootloop. I can flash the stock boot.img and boot normally but lose root (obviously). Since the Pixel 3 doesn't have a custom recovery yet, I can't disable the modules in recovery or use the core only mode zip to disable them.

I'm wondering if there's a way to edit magisk apk settings to auto grant root access. This would allow me to use ADB during boot (before it loops) to add the .disable_magisk file in /data/cache and get back in to fix things or just use remove the modules folder. Right now, it's prompting for root access but since I can't get all the way in, I can't grant it (so ADB root is not allowed). Would there be a way to edit the settings or build the apk with that setting to grant so this would work? I know you can change in the apk but that only shows up after successful boot with magisk.
[Magisk] chickygamon:
strange .... does not open ... maybe something with the ROM. i'm on sagit omni pie with magisk 6.0.1 beta 17.3

thank's
[Magisk] casouzaj:
Do you pass both Safetynet tests?
[Magisk] chickygamon:
Yes...

---------- Post added at 08:16 PM ---------- Previous post was at 08:11 PM ----------

i don't know why in magisk settings was not "on" the Magisk Hide option....now it's ok... sorry for boring you... '-.-
[Magisk] casouzaj:
Is Magisk Manager itself hidden in its settings?
[Magisk] kevdog98:
I am having issues getting pop.up notifications to display on my pixel 3 xl and I'm rooted with magisk 17.4. I also had the same issue with 17.3. anyone else experiencing this? I have check all.my settings and they are set to allow pop up notifications they are not showing while the screen us on it during the always on display. Any help would be appreciated. Thanks. Kevin
[Magisk] hamidezat:
Tnx
[Magisk] The Analog Kid:
On which device?
[Magisk] Akash Raj1:
Deleted.
[Magisk] yujinloh:
Before installing magisk, safetynet passes (two green ticks)

After installing, magisk both of them fails.

What could be done?
[Magisk] guest4711:
You could use the search function and test the solutions mentioned in this thread or read [MENTION=4667597]Didgeridoohan[/MENTION]s's fine manual at https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHide
[Magisk] Ænimal:
Yeah I forgot to mention on my Moto G5s running lineage 14.1 - but I'm using the latest canary build now which is working just as fine :good:
[Magisk] paymentscash:
I need help with my problem :(

fixed
[Magisk] cjrivera04:
Hey guys is there a fix for pixel 2 xl getting stuck on splash screen when rooted on latest Magisk? When the phone is powered off and you charge it, the phone gets stuck on the battery splash screen. Only way to boot up is to force a reboot. It's been happening since Magisk 16.7 I think, at least for me. Not sure if it affects others but I've seen pixel 2 xl people say they have the same issue. Any help would be appreciated. Thanks.
[Magisk] Pkt_Lnt:
Quite a few mentions, NO logs provided.

https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHideHelp
[Magisk] Chekm8Qc:
Hey my Magisk just started asking for an additional setup. Dunno what it is and why but first time I went through with it and rebooted my phone boot looped once then booted. Next Magisk start-up it still asked for the same setup.

Last module I installed was a safety net fix.. Which is working properly. I don't see why this would be the cause.

I'm running kaosp rom on a Moto g5. Everything is working great. Maybe I should simply reinstall Magisk?
[Magisk] vagsvag:
Same here
[Magisk] cjrivera04:
You have any luck getting a log of the problem?
[Magisk] vagsvag:
Sorry, nope.
[Magisk] martyfender:
Have you tried the latest Canary build? I saw mention in that thread of it fixing a similar charging issue for a ONEPLUS user. I, however, have no idea if the issues are related, or not.
[Magisk] play8oy:
Hi,

Just wanted to report that Magisks app ver.6.0.1 crashes everytime I try to open it. Ver. 6.0.0 works fine though.

See attached for log and device info. Hopefully I've done the logging part correctly.

Thanks.
[Magisk] guest4711:
It looks like Magisk does not find his (hidden) MagiskManager. Perhaps it would be sufficient to unhide MagiskManager, reflash Magisk, reboot and hide MagiskManager again.

If this does not help you could try to uninstall every MagiskManager you see in appdrawer and then reflash Magisk from TWRP.

Good Luck!
[Magisk] tee aiy emm:
Magisk is failing the SafetyNet check for me now.
[Magisk] putridfoetus:
Here's my audio_effects.conf from /magisk/<viperfolder>/system/vendor/etc/

The parts I commented out are at the very bottom in the output_session_processing { section. all the xxx_helper {} functions can go, but I only commented out music, ring, and notification.

Hope this helps!
[Magisk] stanleyopar2000:
Google has changed SafetyNet. Users are reporting Android pay is not working now either
[Magisk] liverpool1208:
Hi it worked for me too... but does yours drain battery now?
[Magisk] westeight:
:cowboy:
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
My device is still passing SafetyNet.

Nexus 6

Stock 6.0.1 September security update

Magisk v6

phh's superuser Magisk version 17

Xposed not installed

Selinux enforcing
[Magisk] 3Shirts:
Mine was failing (Xperia Z5, stock ROM, Magisk v6) but I just disabled Xposed and rebooted and it is passing SafetyNet now! Pokemon is back.
[Magisk] Tha_Reaper:
Not passing here.

CM 13 latest nightly

I use systemless xposed.
[Magisk] JudgeDread11:
Root verifier will tell you.

Sorry, but this way you'll learn more then when I just tell you what to do.
[Magisk] 3Shirts:
Try disabling Xposed. That fixed it for me (I was using systemless too)
[Magisk] mlazzarotto91:
My smartphone isn't passing SafetyNet.

Samsung Galaxy Note 4

ROM Emotion R21

Magisk v6

Phh Superuser module v17

Xposed v86.5 by topjohnwu

EDIT

Disabled xposed , Pokémon Go is working again

Inviato dal mio SM-N910F
[Magisk] putridfoetus:
Same for me.

Nexus 6

Stock 6.0.1 September patch

Magisk v6

phh su 17

Xposed installed

Disabling Xposed and rebooting allows SafetyNet to pass.
[Magisk] liverpool1208:
anyone knows if it drains your battery? i find that mine drains alot now
[Magisk] esquiloazul:
Looks like the issue is xposed.

Any idea how can this be baypassed?

having to disable exposed and reboot every time is a pain in the ass >.>
[Magisk] igoticecream:
SafetyNet detects systemless xposed even with Magisk unmount
[Magisk] exodius48:
Me too, get that message.
[Magisk] mlazzarotto91:
Just disable xposed if haven't done yet

Inviato dal mio SM-N910F
[Magisk] Amahr:
Same here:

CM 13 latest nightly, Magisk, Systemless phh, systemless xposed on Sony Xperia Z (Yuga/C6603/LH36)

At about 12:30 GMT+1 today Safetynet won't pass anymore, same error as quoted. No updates were installed since yesterday, so I guess it must be a change at the serverside of safetynet check.

But once systemless Xposed is on disabled SafetyNet will pass again, so they blocked systemless Xposed...
[Magisk] Tha_Reaper:
You are right. Xposed disabled and it's running again. Too bad that I'm not feeling like ditching xposed just to play a damn game ;)
[Magisk] IamIrene:
well just now around 8pm (GMT + 8) still working even with xposed

after that around 8.30pm (GMT + 8) not working anymore

I thought is my internet issue, hence go restart phone, modem and even use my mobile data to play it, no luck

so uninstall and reinstall the game and wipe cache & dalvik cache as well also no luck

luckily found back this thread, off the xposed > reboot then are good to go
[Magisk] jcmm11:
Can you try the latest Canary build and see if that fixes the issue? https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/dev-magisk-canary-channel-bleeding-edge-t3839337
[Magisk] cjrivera04:
Not yet, but I'll look into it. Thanks.
[Magisk] play8oy:
Thanks for the respond.

This version of Magisk Manager 6.0.1 - 9b063856 (155) works. No crashes of any sorts.

Thanks again.
[Magisk] iLuxi:
i just opened my banking app and this reported root detection and locked itself, after that i,ve started magisk manager and this requested to instal magisk 6.0.1 , wich i believe was the same version of that i installed before. just before that point everythink was working fine, now i cant pass safety net check , and i cant hide magisk from any apps? did u start an update recently or something ?
[Magisk] Nozomi9090:
Help mate. After 168h, oem unlock not appear in Developer option. I tried to flash the firmware 2 times and I have always waited for 168h. I've been trying for 2 weeks. My Csc is ITV (Ita)
[Magisk] cjrivera04:
Just flashed it and still have the same issue. Thanks for pointing me to the canary build.
[Magisk] martyfender:
Sorry to hear that. Since you are now on Canary, you can report it here:

https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/issues

I was searching last night there and it has been reported there before, so it may be flagged as a duplicate, but more reports of this issue may get some attention, especially if you can provide logs. However, I'm not sure exactly how to go about doing that since you phone is not running when this issue happens. A start may be magisk logs and logcats. Also, have you checked the Pixel 2 XL xda forums for others who are having the same issues? I don't believe you mentioned the Android version and if you are stock or using a custom rom or kernel.
[Magisk] cjrivera04:
I have checked the pixel 2 xl forums and folks there have noticed the same issue and have not managed to get a log. I'll try and see if I can get a log. I'm wondering if I'll be able to get anything either. If I force a reboot, I should be able to start the device and look at the magisk log, yes?
[Magisk] potan:
hello

i have some question

i do factory reset in twrp but i forget to uninstall magisk, when i install magisk will it make new stock boot image?

or if i uninstall magisk and do a factory reset the stock boot image still the same the one from the first time i install magisk?

are even without uninstall magisk first when i do a factory reset in twrp it will back how it first after i do a fastboot install?

i mean no magisk leftover at all?

thanks
[Magisk] EXV:
Is there a way to flash a module OUTSIDE of using magisk manager? I keep getting force closes everytime I try.
[Magisk] DenyDarko:
Check if the manager has storage permission btw.
[Magisk] potan:
hmm if me most of the time i flash it from twrp but you need the zip file downloaded first

if the app closed after preparing zip file, the zip already in my download folder
[Magisk] Dery94:
Magisk hide is not working with all custom rom samsung galaxy S8/8+

I was try any custom rom, but in stock rom is working fine
[Magisk] garylawwd:
Thats because on your custom roms it more than likely doesnt pass safetynet thats why it doesnt work. There are magisk modules to fix that though like "magiskhide props config" that changes your device fingerprint to one which passes safetynet.

This isnt magisks fault it is because your custom rom is built using a fingerprint which doesnt pass safetynet
[Magisk] Dery94:
The safetynet its was pass sir

But magisk hide still not working
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
That means MagiskHide works... You've got some other issue so you're going to have to start being a bit more specific.
[Magisk] Nebrassy:
Where's the most appropriate place to post suggestions?
[Magisk] EXV:
Yeah I double checked that after you mentioned it and it's enabled already. Thanks for the suggestion though.

If I can flash it via TWRP then that works for me. Thank you!
[Magisk] yochananmarqos:
This would be the place. However, the developer is a busy man (notice I purposely did not tag him), so don't expect a timely response. Don't let that deter you as there are many eyes on this thread and one of us can pass it along.
[Magisk] Grennith:
So, I earlier (couple weeks back) reported Magisk repackage not working on LOS 15.1 on my OP3

10-30 09:39:49.846 7470 7470 E Magisk : write failed with 32: Broken pipe
10-30 09:39:49.846 7470 7470 E Magisk : readlink /proc/7090/cwd failed with 2: No such file or directory
10-30 09:39:49.846 7470 7470 E Magisk : read failed with 9: Bad file descriptor
10-30 09:39:49.846 7470 7470 E Magisk : read failed with 9: Bad file descriptor
10-30 09:39:49.846 7470 7470 E Magisk : stat icu failed with 2: No such file or directory
10-30 09:39:49.846 7470 7470 E Magisk : su: Wrong permission of pts_slave

Basically, it tries to repackage, gets through with the APK itself, but the new APK apparently is not registered as the MagiskManager managing SU. Thus the repackaged version does not get SU privileges and gets stuck on splash. If I restore the "original" MM, the repackaged one asks for root.
[Magisk] jcmm11:
If you really want to know if it's fixed check the Canary build
[Magisk] sibikallikkat:
Although I had given root permission to some apps, magisk seems not able to provide them with the permission. It is waiting for ever to obtain permission. I checked with superuser tab and permission is granted correctly. I use latest miui 10 beta. Please help
[Magisk] giojj89:
Root a7 2018

Hello, i need to root samsung a7 2018, a750fn/ds, but i dont find twrp. I can root with magisk without twrp? I have see i can root with magisk manager but its compatible with this device? For flash patched boot image i can using odin or need using adb? Thanks..ps sorry for my english.
[Magisk] Nebrassy:
Ok, suggestion:

So installing to inactive slot was a godsent for a/b devices, it's just great to restore stock boot and ota with no problems

but unfortunately that fells short when using a custom recovery or kernel, because either of which will remove magisk and you have to flash magisk again, and when you do that, it will detect your modified boot image to be stock (because it doesn't have root) and back it up, removing the actual stock backup

so, why not allow manually picking the stock boot image to restore instead of "stock backup doesn't exist", like when you pick an image to patch, restore that and ota?
[Magisk] mariosaraylian:
martyfender:

Thanks for the reply, that did the trick and the Current Version shows as v71.3 now. I'm a bit confused as to if v17.3 is considered a Beta or a Stable release or not, but regardless everything is working perfectly, Beta or Not......
[Magisk] yochananmarqos:
Stable = 17.1

Beta = 17.3

Canary = 17.4
[Magisk] H4X0R46:
I see unsu mentioned in the OP under the "Thanks" section. Does Magisk remove system root like unsu does by itself? [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION]

EDIT: Also, is this mostly expected to work on the OnePlus 6t or is that a "wait and see" thing still?
[Magisk] byReqz:
I updated my Oneplus 6 to OB6 yesterday and installed magisk to inactive slot + twrp retention script. Now i cant find the Magisk Folder via a filemanager, it just doesnt show up although everything is working and its installed
[Magisk] DenyDarko:
There isn't Magisk folder for a while now
[Magisk] jcmm11:
If you're talking about /Magisk it's been out of the picture for a while now. Long enough so I don't remember exactly when it was removed 16.3? maybe.

In any case it was only a symlink. Try looking in /sbin/.core/img/
[Magisk] Ingan121:
Some apps like Native Root Checker and Appdome-fusioned apps (I just tested it out) are detecting selinux as not enforcing, even though I enabled magisk hide and hid magisk manager. However, the 'getenforce' command and Root Validator say selinux is enforcing, and I didn't use any special method to enable permissive mode.

I'm using Magisk 17.3 with Galaxy S7 Oreo.
[Magisk] guest4711:
Magisk itself does not change selinux state... But if you need to show other apps it is "enforced" you could try using magisk modules like "magiskhide props config".
[Magisk] avatardiablo:
hi.

the app nexi (for backing credit card) it cant go with hide mode. it is find in play store.

i want to precise that a month ago he was going with hide mode.

when start it closed and give me a notification where alert that the dispositive is not able to start.

i try also beta version of magisk. but nothing new

you can try to find a solution ?

thanks a lot.
[Magisk] casouzaj:
Hide Magisk Manager in its settings.
[Magisk] avatardiablo:
nothing. sorry. app nexi crush with no warning advise
[Magisk] Ingan121:
It doesn't work...

I installed magisk after flashing stock firmware, and I didn't do anything related to selinux. They pass properly on stock firmware without magisk.

---------- Post added at 02:03 PM ---------- Previous post was at 01:55 PM ----------

Clear data then launch. Make sure magisk hide is enabled.

(I've just tested it)
[Magisk] fubo73:
I can confirm that one of latest Nexi App update is not hidden by Magisk Manager (also if it is reinstalled with random name). But I am on LOS and have also Xposed systemless installed, so I do not know if it is detecting xposed presence.

I restored a previous release (current is 3.0.1, I have 2.13.1 from TB) and it works as exptected (with debug usb off).
[Magisk] psychoela:
Can't anyone helps me to pass. i do not know why,but i can download netflix without passed safetynet.thanks
[Magisk] garylawwd:
Xposed always triggers safetynet thats why magisk hide wont work because it relies on passing safetynet

---------- Post added at 02:42 PM ---------- Previous post was at 02:38 PM ----------

Do you have xposed? If so safetynet will never pass. If not try magiskhide props config module to change your device fingerprint to one that passes the safetynet
[Magisk] fubo73:
I cannot yet say if latest Nexi App is safetynet based. Up to version 2.13.1, magisk hide was enough with xposed installed, so the app was not using safetynet.
[Magisk] psychoela:
No xposed, I'm with pie,,n yes i have try module magiskhide props n changed fingerprint,but still not work:(.
[Magisk] Lownita:
After flashing magisk 17.3, magisk manager wasn't installed. After a reboot it appeared in the app launcher, but it had to install the actual magisk manager app. Why does this happen? Just curious :)
[Magisk] garylawwd:
What? If you dont pass safetynet than magiskhide is useless
[Magisk] avatardiablo:
ok. I solved this way:

in the nexi app, go to storage space, and select: delete data and clear cache. uninstall the nexi app. restart the phone.

go to the google store and reinstall the app. enabled on magisk, hide mode.

so it's working me again.
[Magisk] Spacewide:
Don't shoot me. But this should be a paid app to ensure it's existence.
[Magisk] fubo73:
False. Some apps are still dumb and not based on safetynet for root detection. I have at least 6 apps that, using magiskhide, work also if xposed is installed.
[Magisk] Didgeridoohan:
That's not correct. MagiskHide does not rely on SafetyNet in any way. The only correlation is that MagiskHide can make your device pass SafetyNet with Magisk installed.
[Magisk] garylawwd:
Ohh sorry :svetius: everyday is a school day
[Magisk] NYCHitman1:
What APK version is everyone using to successfully patch boot.img's on the P3/P3XL?
[Magisk] byReqz:
Oof, i was so sure that i had it a few days ago. Maybe im just a bit rusty ?

Thanks guys
[Magisk] martyfender:
I'm pretty sure, the latest Canary build.
[Magisk] guest4711:
I don't install any g-apps so safety net can not be called. And all of my banking apps are working as expected if I hide magisk from then properly...

MagiskHide is a must for these to work.
[Magisk] garylawwd:
My banking app just gives me a message saying its not safe to use with a rooted/modified phone but allows me to use it anyway without magisk hide. My bank and its app are still stuck in the 2000's :silly:

And this was with xposed installed aswel
[Magisk] RandomPooka:
Seems totally legit and safe
[Magisk] debojyotydatta:
Device : MOTO E4 PLUS XT 1770 MEDITEK

Android version : 7.1.1 Stock

unable to install module in MAGISK 17.1

1. Android pie fonts v5

2. Youtube vanced

log file attached

please help me
[Magisk] xunholyx:
You didn't/don't have to do all of that:

-add it to Magisk hide

-settings > nexi app > clear data

-reboot

That would have been enough
[Magisk] akifakif:
When this come for kitkat ı have leagoo alfa 6 and this device not root anyway kingroot,framamroot etc.I flash supersu with twrp it says succesful but not work root
[Magisk] martyfender:
This is a very poor translation and is not understandable. However, kingoroot will install malware on your system, at least the last time I tried it a long time ago.
[Magisk] akifakif:
Ok but what can i do for root
[Magisk] martyfender:
Isn't the minimal Android version for Magisk 5. something? I tried to find the exact version number but could not find it in the Magisk troubleshooting guide, at least with a search.

I would think that SuperSu in system mode would work on your system if you have TWRP to flash it with. Your device may need an older version though. I believe SuperSu flashes in system mode by default on Android versions older than 6, If my memory serves me correctly. You may be able to find older versions on apkmirror.com.
[Magisk] akifakif:
I try all supersu versions

---------- Post added at 07:03 AM ---------- Previous post was at 07:01 AM ----------

I try all supersu version
[Magisk] horlamedyy:
pls is there away to install magisk through stock recovery to gain root,my htc one m9 is nt been recognize by pc.thanks
[Magisk] akifakif:
Please help me for this
[Magisk] ashyx:
Of course not.

---------- Post added at 02:31 PM ---------- Previous post was at 02:28 PM ----------

Post the recovery.log from the Supersu install.
[Magisk] droidholic:
Has anyone experienced issues with Magisk loosing root regularly and prompting you to reflash the Magisk zip? Just trying to pinpoint if it's Magisk or Rom related. I'm on the original Pixel XL running the Pie Pixel Dust Rom. Thanks!
[Magisk] ashyx:
Post the recovery.log from the Supersu install.