yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Xposed General] Kachelistic:
Current Using : Xperia XZ1(G8341), 8.0.0, 47.1.A.12.235 / Magisk v16.6, Magisk Manager v5.8.1

When I install systemless ver. Xposed Framework (tried from 90 beta1~3 all) successfully, there's no problem at all. However when the Installer app installed(3.1.5) phone keeps rebooting. Anyone faced this problem?

-----

Solved by downgrading rom...
[Xposed General] Andro1dism:
Hi guys,

I am currently joking around with my D5503 because I was stuck in a Sony / Android Bootloop.

I am currently on this ROM:

https://xdaforums.com/sony-xperia-z1-compact/development/rom-z5mx-rom7-5-0extended-battery-t3227779

and have a few (actually just 2) questions, I hope you won't stone me for 'em ;)

* I don't quite understand the "Systemless Xposed" - what does it mean? I mean what is the main difference to "Not-systemless" Xposed ?

* The other question just solved itself while writing

Thanks!

James

EDIT:

I think I found my answer folks: https://www.xda-developers.com/magisk-vs-xposed/

Thanks anyway!
[Xposed General] ColdUser:
Finally i got Magisk working with Beta1 installed through TWRP and no bootloops.

Maybe a noob question but is this systemless or not installing via TWRP?

Magisk doesnt recognize the Beta1 (sdk26) i downloaded this one via Xposed installer and installed in twrp.
[Xposed General] MajinkenSword:
Been trying to use systemless xposed and hide itself from some of my apps that stop working via dotmod and have been unsuccessful.

If I install the regular xposed, will it work? Sorry if this is the wrong thread.
[Xposed General] JoroBo:
It will not work with regular xposed which modifies the system. As far as I know, you can't hide systemless Xposed either. What you can (possibly) do is disable systemless Xposed, reboot and use MagiskHide to hide Magisk (not Xposed) from the problematic apps. Check the Magisk general thread on MagiskHide and SafetyNet. I haven't used this feature and don't have any personal experience with it but many people seem to successfully hide Magisk/root from certain apps.
[Xposed General] MajinkenSword:
Thanks for your inputs ?

I am able to hide root from apps with just Magisk. Installing the framework alone and activating it through Magisk is ok. But they all seem to break after I install the Xposed App.

The reason I want xposed is for the extra features of greenify and 3c... ☹️
[Xposed General] sexlord89:
Are you using Magisk 16.0 Or 16.6?

Where did u get the beta1 file? Xposed installer or forums?

Which Xposed App are you using? 3.1.5 or lower and is it the systemless Xposed installer File or the official Installer?
[Xposed General] ColdUser:
Im using Magisk 16.0 and not the latest Magisk Manager.

Downloaded the beta1 file from Xposed installer.

I had to install in TWRP cause Magisk doesn't recognize this file.

I downloaded the installer App from this Thread and since Magisk doesn't recognize the file Beta1 i dont know if this is systemless.

Im still new to Xposed but got it finally working on Oreo.
[Xposed General] JoroBo:
I know, I use it too for Greenify, Afwall+ and a bunch of other great modules. If it works for you without systemless xposed then you should be able to use these apps hidden when you deactivate Xposed (toggle in the upper right corner) but you have to deal with the inconvenience of deactivating, rebooting, using the app then reactivating xposed and rebooting again. No other option right now. I believe the actual installation of systemless xposed should not be problematic for the apps if you disable it although if you have a logcat and provide more details as to your device, rom etc. then somebody here with more knowledge about xposed could help you :)
[Xposed General] sexlord89:
Which manager version are you using then?
[Xposed General] ColdUser:
Magisk 5.8.1. Im gonna try 5.8.3 the latest version and see if it works
[Xposed General] MajinkenSword:
Thanks again. I expected as much.

Guess I'll do just that and try it for now. ?
[Xposed General] sexlord89:
Just tried beta1 on my Mix and got bootloop.

Tell me if u get it to work with 5.8.3

Tnx
[Xposed General] ColdUser:
Works for me on Mi 5, rebooted phone and no bootloop.

You have tried all Beta's?
[Xposed General] Mikanoshi:
You flashed a regular Xposed.
[Xposed General] ColdUser:
Thank you for your reply.

So that means systemless is only through Magisk?

Or is it the file thats made to flash systemless?
[Xposed General] sexlord89:
Yes, i tried all 3 beta's and tried installing them all via twrp and via xposed installer.

Is your TWRP on the mi5 asking to enter password to decrypt before using it?
[Xposed General] ColdUser:
No password asked in TWRP never had that with Xposed or any Zipfile.

Which Rom are you using? Im on the latest Xiaomi.Eu version 8.7.12 MIUI 10
[Xposed General] sexlord89:
Im using the 9.6.1.0 official 8.0, and the Mix doesnt have a normally working TWRP it seems.

They all ask for a password before entering the main menu, but maybe its not the issue coz im still able to flash stuff via sideload.
[Xposed General] Mikanoshi:
Regular zip flashes to system partition (or data, or any other defined by dev).

Magisk zip flashes files to special Magisk image.

Just enter your PIN/pattern and it should decrypt data partition, then you can interact with Magisk from recovery. Works on Mi Mix 2S :)
[Xposed General] sexlord89:
ENtering my Pin/Password doesnt do any good, the twrp files arnt too good for this device and it just sais wrong everytime.
[Xposed General] rainsmile:
Redmi note 5 pro sdk 27 caused bootloop is there any working for whyred?
[Xposed General] ColdUser:
Got it Thank you for making me understand this.

Thats why i got some apps crashes and log says "Xposed.bridge"

But i tried everything and every way to install systemless.

I just saw Magisk 16.7 Beta maybe gonna try with that one got nothing to lose.

Keep up the good work!
[Xposed General] belej:
Same here. :confused:

I managed to put phone back to fastboot with buttons, boot TWRP with PC, reboot to TWRP again and uninstall/reinstall Magisk.

(whyred, TWRP 3.2.2, MIUI 9.5.19.0)
[Xposed General] ibanex0r:
well, firstly thankyou for yur effort on this however xposed sdk24 refuses to mountand subsequently install with error 1, i am not happy.
[Xposed General] Ja_som:
You will be unhappy longer, because no one will be able to help you with a lack of information you provided.

Also fid you search here? Error 1 is mentioned meny times...
[Xposed General] Artim_96:
Alt is especially for some Note variants. So if you used normal Wanam's XPosed use the non alt one. If it doesn't work use alt

---------- Post added at 08:33 AM ---------- Previous post was at 08:31 AM ----------

Is romracers systemless? Not that I think so.
[Xposed General] topjohnwu:
Mine is not build from source, but have better compatibility such as support Samsung and Pixel C.

I plan to build my systemless version from source soon, I just cannot get any time to do so.
[Xposed General] Ruuu:
[MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] this is my 4 message asking for help. I know you're busy but you can spare little time like you spare for others. I have Note 5 on Stock & I've flashed systemless xposed v85.7. The problem is that after flashing it i have lost access to private mode and also dm-verity verification fails.

What wrong have i done? I've followed all the steps perfectly. Should i Flash the 'alt' version? Please get back to me!:(
[Xposed General] topjohnwu:
I have no Samsung devices, so I don't know what you mean "private mode".

Also, there shouldn't be dm-verity issues if you flash SuperSU correctly. SuperSU will remove it.

If Xposed is what breaks it, then I cannot do anything for it. I only changed the installation method, I didn't change the behavior of it.

Samsung might have some special detection method or so, I don't know the details since I never use Samsung products.
[Xposed General] g2uzer:
Looks like some one else replied.
[Xposed General] hgoldner:
So, I was originally able to write to the \xposed folder and create another folder on which I could attempt a bind mount. Since 85.7 (or perhaps 85.6) I cannot write to the \xposed folder any more. Is there any reason *not* to enable read/write to that folder? Doing so won't suddenly make \system writable, will it? (is it possible that the bind mounting already loaded with xposed is interfering with read/write in the xposed directory?) I suppose if that's so, I could try to play with it in file manager in TWRP, but I thought I'd ask first.
[Xposed General] Captain_Throwback:
/xposed folder is perfectly writable here, using 85.7. Though I use a completely separate folder and script for my bind mounts ;).
[Xposed General] legendt:
Same here in Galaxy S4 GPE roms
[Xposed General] MrBrowseGierza:
Sdk 22 will cause the phone self destruction
[Xposed General] rfgamaral:
I side-loaded (with TWRP) the xposed-v85.7-sdk23-systemless.zip on my HTC 10 and I was asked twice to decrypt my phone with my lock screen PIN. At the first attempt, it just rebooted the device. On the second one, it started to boot... However, it took a while before booting, I looked at logcat and it was doing a bunch of stuff and now it is "optimizing app X of Y".

I'm trying to be completely stock (just systemless root/xposed) to keep receiving OTAs.

Is all this behavior (twice decrypt, slow boot and optimize apps) normal?
[Xposed General] topjohnwu:
Yes, that mean Xposed is activated.

ART cache is required to re-build for Xposed to work fine.

Everything only happens in data and boot, so no worries :D
[Xposed General] rfgamaral:
Nevermind... Please delete.

---------- Post added at 11:05 AM ---------- Previous post was at 10:09 AM ----------

Actually, I have another question...

I just noticed there's a new Xposed version available (it showed on the app).

What's the proper way to update to the new version and keep it systemless?

Also, this new versio states "added support for new systemless method (/vendor), does this change anything regarding the .zip provided on this topic?
[Xposed General] anagramgenius:
Just download and update the app.

/vendor is for xperia roms.
[Xposed General] DawoodSahi:
Been trying since the start of this systemless xposed. Some of you may remember, hah. But it never worked on my xperia z2 marshmallow. Tried switching between different roms but still all in vain. I couldn't even get systemless root, obviously it was the matter with my kernel (boot.img).

Today I finally decided to unlock my bootloader and flash a custom kernel in which systemless root was supported.

In terminal added following commands,

echo systemless=true>>/data/.supersu

echo systembindxbin=false>>/data/.supersu

Flashed systemless supersu 2.74-2 and voila it worked.

Flashed systemless xposed, rebooted and everything is working very well.

Thank you so much for your efforts :)
[Xposed General] tartanpion:
When i'm trying to reverse to stock recovery from twrp (flashing the recovery. img with odin or flashify, extracted from officiel firmware) : the stock recovery has "supported api :3 and dm-verity verification failed..." at the bottom. What is wrong to recovert a stock recovery ?
[Xposed General] maxwarp79:
I've a stupid question: now I have root and Xposed on my G935F but I want to receive OTAs and now I read of "systemless" Xposed but how to obtain "systemless" root first? I checked and there isn't su.img under /data... :confused:
[Xposed General] ianmacd:
Unroot your device and then use CF Auto Root to reroot it. That will give you systemless SuperSU.
[Xposed General] maxwarp79:
Ok, thank you! [emoji6]

Inviato dal mio SM-G935F utilizzando Tapatalk
[Xposed General] CRXed:
Too bad it is not compatible with FrancoKernel on Nexus 6 :(

Flashed FK and it made the Xposed go inactive. Reflashed systemless Xposed and it did not fix it.
[Xposed General] torecdude:
Factory reset my phone. So I want to install closed again from scratch. Unlike OP, I flashed the zip first and then installed materialized xposed app. Tried to uninstall xposed and reinstall, and reinstalling the app but the app won't recognize xposed, it says its not install. What more can I do besides flashing the whole ROM again?

Edit: dam auto correction
[Xposed General] rfgamaral:
I'm having a couple of issues on my HTC 10 that started to happen when I enabled Xposed on my device (it was installed through Magisk when everything was working, but the module was disabled).

Today I enabled the Xposed Magisk module and Xposed itself and rebooted my device. Enabled a few Xposed modules and rebooted the device again. I noticed my phone was very sluggish after enabling Xposed... Home screen widgets took a lot more than they used too to load, long-pressing the power button (to show the reboot/power off menu) too like 10 seconds to show up (it used to take like 1 second or less) and overall device was a bit slow. I decided to disable all modules but keep Xposed enabled, rebooted and the phone was still very sluggish, like nothing changed. Uinstalled all Xposed modules and the Xposed Magisk module too for now, the phone is not slowing down to a crawl anymore.

However, after all this I'm having some issues that I didn't have before all this:

I can no longer open the "recent apps" menu. The button works (it vibrates when I press it) but nothing happens.

Pulling down the screen from the top to bottom I can expand the notification bar but pulling down again to display the quick settings tiles does nothing.

I don't understand the relevance of Xposed with these issues but they started to happen when I enabled Xposed. At first I though some module was interfering with these things, that's why I disabled/uninstalled Xposed, but the problems remained.

Thoughts?

EDIT: Fixed my issue with this: https://stackoverflow.com/a/39394723
[Xposed General] alego500:
Can anyone find an announcement of the A/B flashing magisk during update feature being removed due to update process being changed. Read a very short comment from [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] on an article.
[Xposed General] teddy0209:
Check on github...
[Xposed General] Didgeridoohan:
It was flawed (although did work for some cases) and was removed until improved. It'll be back soon:

https://github.com/topjohnwu/Magisk/commit/07140d33a76f66cdc9a9f5c4d757b0afa52d6eef
[Xposed General] sexlord89:
Have you succeeded installing xposed?

Have you tried the "Unity Installer" via magisk?
[Xposed General] ColdUser:
No if i install systemless i always get bootloop.

And in TWRP only Beta1 works for me but thats not systemless.

Unity installer...? You mean installing the framework in Magisk? Did you succeeded to install systemless?
[Xposed General] sexlord89:
Yeah i mean via magisk, i havnt tried the newest one yet, will update after a try or 2 :p
[Xposed General] Mikanoshi:
Why is that? :) Magisk version is basically same as regular but with a single path edited in binary.

Maybe it works on MIUI 10 then, but how your Mi5 updated to 10 if it's still in beta? You updated it manually! :D
[Xposed General] ColdUser:
Yeah via Magisk always bootloop unfortunately i tried many magisk versions etc..

---------- Post added at 02:53 AM ---------- Previous post was at 02:49 AM ----------

I don't know you tell me.. only beta one works for me in TWRP or installing via the Xposed installer but this is not systemless and i get sometimes some apps crashing thats why i want magisk.

Can the developer make all Beta's as a Magisk Module ?

And yeah I'm updating weekly the new beta from Xiaomi.eu based on China versions but smoother and cleaner.
[Xposed General] alegend1979:
is this working son sm-g965f installed via magisk and on Stock rooted??
[Xposed General] Jacky Zhou:
Can you hide the Xposed like hide the magisk.

Xposed is very very usefully,but when i install Xposed.zip the jp.gungho.padRadar will exit.Can you make the Xposed.zip and the Xposed Install have random name,so it will not to be detected by the others apps just like Magisk.Thank you very much.
[Xposed General] Didgeridoohan:
Sorry... Xposed can't be hidden like Magisk can. Some pretty smart people have looked at that problem long and hard and deemed it impossible.
[Xposed General] Dantalionblood:
I try to install xposed systemless but my phone get bootloop, i running android 5.1 clean stockrom(not samsung but asus z00sd), i try to use another version of framework but still bootloop, anyone can help me? :)
[Xposed General] Suryo75:
Xposed installer is Still not work with hh redminote 2 prime lollipop

I have done this way, even i have changed its rom, but still bootloop / stuck onlogo. After instaled magisk and continuing instal xposed from magisk download section.
[Xposed General] Suryo75:
No way out :eek:
[Xposed General] steadyMcat:
I'm using MIUI10(Android 8.0) on Mi5 , after I enabled the systemless xposed v90.2 beta2 in Magisk v16.7 and reboot ,my device got very sluggish. I checked the CPU usage, just one little core always gets 100%,others are almost no load. I've waited for 2 hours, but no significant improvement. It is so slow that can't for daily use. Then I disabled xposed, it begin smooth again.

If someone has a solution please?
[Xposed General] wallacescott:
Hi guys, im facing bootloop problems here as well, i think it would be useful to the thread if someone stick here how to do a logcat.
[Xposed General] spawnlives:
Here is a good starting point

https://xdaforums.com/showthread.php?t=2274119
[Xposed General] ColdUser:
I have tried to install on my Mi5 systemless but always bootloop, i see you're using Magisk 16.7 you have tried also the previous versions of magisk?

And how did you get Beta2 systemless? In Magisk there's only Beta3. Hope you can tell me how you installed this on your Mi5 cuz i tried everything and every beta and always bootloop. but not magisk 16.7
[Xposed General] ColdUser:
I have tried to install on my Mi5 systemless but always bootloop, i see you're using Magisk 16.7 you have tried also the previous versions of magisk?

And how did you get Beta2 systemless? In Magisk there's only Beta3. Hope you can tell me how you installed this on your Mi5 cuz i tried everything and every beta and always bootloop. but not magisk 16.7

Can you please share how you installed this systemless, i just tried Magisk 16.7 but still bootloop and im on Xiaomi.eu Rom
[Xposed General] gqqnbig:
I installed Xposed Installer in Magisk. How do I check if it's Systemless Xposed? Are there two versions of Xposed? Sorry it confuses me a lot.
[Xposed General] zputnyq:
Yes, there are 2 version.

If u installed xposed using magisk, it's for sure a systemless xposed & you will see it on module section of magisk manager.
[Xposed General] Mast3r.71:
Same here. Bootloop after installing xposed.

Android 8

Huawei p10 lite emui 8

Magisk 160.0

Manager 5.8.3
[Xposed General] Dz_diga:
For me xposed is working just fine now ( took long time to boot and everything) but none of the modules are working properly for example Gravitybox is installed on my p20 lite but it does nothing even after rebooting :rolleyes:
[Xposed General] Eleo:
It is normal for boot to take long. For xposed to work, it needs to reload all applications. It should take some time.

Maybe because your firmware is not prone to changes with gravitybox? Please confirm whether gravitybox changes can be applied to other users of p20 with system xposed, if you think it has anything to do with magisk or systemless xposed. Gravitybox is for mainly stock android. Not for modified firmware as huawei.

And try more simple huawei related (or usable on huawei) xposed modules to confirm whether any success is present.

Do not forget to attach xposed logs.
[Xposed General] S-trace:
Hello.

BUGREPORT:

I have installed Xposed_Framework_(SDK_23)-89.3_(Systemless).zip and XposedInstaller_3.1.5.apk (on ARM64 device) - Xposed Installer said me that framework is not installed.

I fixed this problem by simple patch for XposedInstaller_3.1.5.apk:

--- a/smali/de/robv/android/xposed/installer/XposedApp.smali
+++ b/smali/de/robv/android/xposed/installer/XposedApp.smali
@@ -77,7 +77,7 @@

const/4 v1, 0x0

- const-string v2, "/su/xposed/xposed.prop"
+ const-string v2, "/xposed.prop"

aput-object v2, v0, v1

But this is a workaround for xposed.prop misplacement.

topjohnwu, what should be fixed, Xposed_Framework_(SDK_23)-89.3_(Systemless).zip or XposedInstaller_3.1.5.apk ?

Thank you.
[Xposed General] jenslody:
That should not be needed, if you use the xposed-installer from the OP of this thread. And it's intentionally for systemless-xposed.
[Xposed General] S-trace:
Sorry, missed README.md inside .zip because it wasn't shown during installation from Magisk modules repository

Maybe Magisk should tell user that README or README.txt or README.md or something like this was detected in install .zip when user installs module from repository?

And about Xposed Installer - mine fixed version works fine for me, and all the fix is just one String in String array of xposed.prop paths - maybe this should be merged to Xposed Installer upstream repository (and so user will be able to use any future version of the official Installer .apk)?
[Xposed General] williamcll:
Edit: nevermind

clicking	XposedInstaller_3.1.5-Magisk.apk on the OP does not download the apk, I don't know why.
[Xposed General] philippe734:
Fail with Moto G5s

The xposed framework (v89.3-sdk25-topjohnwu.zip) fail to be installed with Moto G5s

Android 7.1.1, Magisk 16.0, TWRP 3.2.1, XposedInstaller_3.1.5-Magisk.apk

Here in attachment the logs of Magisk and TWRP.

I tried to install the xposed framework within Magisk 16.0 > fail, here the log

I tried to flash it in TWRP 3.2.1 > success, here the log, but framework not detected by xposed installer, neither Magisk manager.

Edit: with classic Xposed framework flashed = bootloop

For the moment, I can't install xposed framework on Moto G5s.
[Xposed General] Suryo75:
magisk xposed

xposed - magisk are not compatible, i have done and all i see was just bootloop. every member suggest to do everything but nothing.
[Xposed General] Eleo:
Systemless xposed inside magisk works with no problem here. Since you fail to provide any logs, any info about your device and android version, we will not be able to help you.

Good luck
[Xposed General] Suryo75:
Thank you for reply, my device redmi note 2 lollipop 5.0.

How could i give my device's log, meanwhile my device ia always bootloop after i installed xposed from magisk ?

Thank you
[Xposed General] Eleo:
Logs from adb. Search xda. There are many logging procedures present
[Xposed General] Mast3r.71:
Any fix for xposed bootloop?
[Xposed General] Eleo:
Many. Provide info and logs
[Xposed General] dh33r4j:
Any progress on Xposed for MIUI 10 Oreo?
[Xposed General] Mikanoshi:
Stop it, no one cares about betas. Make it work on 9 Oreo first :)
[Xposed General] remcoland59:
Xposed installed but not active

So I installed the zip in magisk, rebooted and installed the Xposed installer apk but now it says that it's installed but not active

[IMG="Screenshot Xposed"]https://preview.ibb.co/khE6Qe/Screenshot_Xposed_Installer_20180806_105152.png[/IMG]

PS my phone is in Dutch let me know if I need to translate anything
[Xposed General] jenslody:
Which installer apk did you install?

The normal version does not work, you need the version from the first post of this thread.
[Xposed General] Groot:
Can't seem to install systemless xposed using magisk. I have an Asus Zenfone 3 Max 5.5 on Android 8.1.0 and rooted with Magisk through boot image patching (without custom recovery).

- Copying zip to temp directory
- Installing Xposed_Framework_(SDK_27)-90.2-beta3_(Systemless).zip
*******************************
Please install Magisk v15.0+!
*******************************
Failed!
! Installation failed
[Xposed General] remcoland59:
[/COLOR]

[MENTION=8340552]jenslody[/MENTION] nevermind I found the problem: I had the Xposed installer app installed on my SD card ?*♂️

I put it on my internal storage and it was fixed
[Xposed General] evs-ru:
Can somebody port/convert the xposed-v90-sdk26-arm64-beta4-test1.zip version of Xposed from https://github.com/rovo89/Xposed/issues/310 (https://www.dropbox.com/s/bkb7iluiqob8qwa/xposed-v90-sdk26-arm64-beta4-test1.zip?dl=1) into Systemless, for Magisk?