yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Xposed General] geekmug:
According to your signature line, you use the Viper10 ROM, so I am guessing you fell into the same trap I did. TL;DR: The "Viper10 Magisk Module" breaks the "Xposed Framework" Magisk module.

If you dig into how Magisk works, developers can mark entire directories to be replaced by putting a ".replace" file into their module. It happens to be the case that the "Viper10 Magisk Module" marks /system/framework with .replace, which makes it uncooperative with any other Magisk modules that want to plug into the /system/framework directory, such as the Xposed module.

I don't know of an obvious way to know if any given module does this other than to look through your Magisk logs. In the case of the "Viper10 Magisk Module", you'll find something like:

06-17 04:38:36.864 609 633 I Magisk : bind_mount: /sbin/.core/img/viper10rom/system/framework -> /system/framework

A solution to this problem is to mount /data/adb/magisk.img and add the XposedFramework.jar to the viper10rom, with the obvious peril of breakage due to updates in the future. If it's not obvious to you how to do that, then I'm sorry, this is a pretty advanced hack to perform and I wouldn't recommend it. Rather, I would complain to the Viper10 ROM team about their Magisk module.

After I patched that, I still didn't get any Xposed modules to load, most likely because I upgraded my phone to get to this point, and I needed to un-check and re-check the boxes to disable/enable the Xposed modules (to rewrite the modules.list file).
[Xposed General] Joseahfer:
[MENTION=7694286]essor-13[/MENTION] I installed the Xposed Installer first (remember to install the one from this thread, which has a different firm), but I don't know if it's relevant the order. Also keep in mind to download the SDK 24 (Android 7.0).

Regarding Magisk, I use the official update channel in beta and works well (no bootloops on my device), but probably in the Magisk thread can help you better with that.
[Xposed General] essor-13:
[MENTION=8179198]Joseahfer[/MENTION] : I'll check if my installer was the specific one. Thanks. I'll doownload ad fresh one to be sure.

How long was the first post install Magisk Xposed boot for you ?
[Xposed General] Joseahfer:
[MENTION=7694286]essor-13[/MENTION] longer than default (and after Xposed the boots take a bit more than without it) but no more longer than a ROM instalation.
[Xposed General] essor-13:
[MENTION=8179198]Joseahfer[/MENTION] : I have the same phone. What is Galaxy Project 1.20.00 (TGP Kernel 5.9.10) ? Maybe I should remove AFWall+ and Greenify wich are also Xposed modules before installing Xposed from Magiskmanager ?
[Xposed General] jenslody:
You should either use the one from this thread, or the unofficial material installer by [MENTION=5345056]DVDandroid[/MENTION] .
[Xposed General] Joseahfer:
[MENTION=7694286]essor-13[/MENTION] the ROM and Kernel I use, for a more detailed information.

The modules won't work unless you enable it, so keeping the apps shouldn't cause any problem.
[Xposed General] essor-13:
[MENTION=8179198]Joseahfer[/MENTION] does this rom support Samsung camera app with all features ? Raw DNG files, HDR, slow motion... ? Are there any limitation comparing with the stock rom ?
[Xposed General] Joseahfer:
[MENTION=7694286]essor-13[/MENTION] the ROM is based in stock one, so it has all features you can find in stock and more (floating messages, edge panel in flat devices, app lock... And also you can select things in the aroma installer, as tweaks or mods for sound and camera).

http://xdaforums.com/showthread.php?t=3440314
[Xposed General] essor-13:
[MENTION=8179198]Joseahfer[/MENTION] : yes seems to be great ! I'm gonna try it right away ! Thanks for the information. You can use xposed without safety issues ? Google pay, Samsung Health, samsung pass, etc ?
[Xposed General] Joseahfer:
[MENTION=7694286]essor-13[/MENTION] with Xposed you can't pass SafetyNet. Samsung Pass works well (logins in browser with fingerprints, Samsung Pay doesn't work of course).

I still doesn't have the occasion to use Android Pay, but if I'm not wrong it works. Also don't use Samsung Health.
[Xposed General] jes0411:
I tried with new stable magisk v15 and it's the same as with v14.5 and 14.6, after install xposed (any version, also with 87.3) I have bootloop.

I take a logcat with magisk v15 and xposed v89.0 (when in bootloop) and other logcat with magisk v15 and without xposed (phone boots normally).
[Xposed General] ~Blood~:
Xposed v89 - Rovo89

lol.
[Xposed General] Timberlake.C:
This is the problem when I trying to flash Xposed sdk 24..please help
[Xposed General] Slavik1000:
Xposed

Please make Xposed under art 32
[Xposed General] DodoGTA:
What's your device and ROM?
[Xposed General] Timberlake.C:
EMUI 5.0
[Xposed General] DodoGTA:
And device?
[Xposed General] SP2FET:
Waiting for Xposed for Oreo 8.0
[Xposed General] Ja_som:
Very useful post.
[Xposed General] matuszp:
Which version should I flash to work on LG G6 ?
[Xposed General] CecoM:
Samsung Note3 Neo (SM-N7505) Stock 5.1.1

xposed-v87.3-sdk22-topjohnwu.zip works fine with Magisk 14.x

Bootloop with Magisk 15.0.

There are other Magisk modules (busybox,debloater,mm) and these work fine until xposed installed. Is xposed 87.3 compatible with 15.0?
[Xposed General] V4LKyR:
First of all, I have to use Xposed. Xposed has to be in my phone because I love it. I cannot think of my phone without it. However, in the other hand, we are using Magisk to pass SafetyNet with softwares which would normally modify system partition. And this Xposed (systemless) cannot pass SafetyNet, right?

So... Is there any point for me to use Magisk? I won't be able to pass SafetyNet ever because I want Xposed. So why use Magisk?

Please enlighten me if there are other good benefits of Magisk. Especially performance-wide.
[Xposed General] jenslody:
To have root ?

To easily disable xposed, reboot and pass safetynet temporarily ?

Do what needs to pass safetynet, reenable xposed in MagiskManager, rebot and be back on a system with xposed.
[Xposed General] M@xFactor:
Honor 8
[Xposed General] KurogamiZz:
Installing xposed causes my phone to bootloop. I'm using Huawei P8 Lite with C432B618 ROM modded by Persona78. I do exactly what this guide tells to do. Installed magisk xposed installer. Installed magisk. Installed xposed using magisk manager nadI had bootloop. Uninstalled xposed and tried flashing it in TWRP and the same result.
[Xposed General] Jbgamer04:
I think there is something wrong with the Xposed framework v89.0 when I flashed it using magisk It broke the root
[Xposed General] V4LKyR:
What if I don't have anything regarding SafetyNet? I mean... it doesn't bother me not being able to pass SafetyNet, I don't do any payments with my phone or something like that.

However, I am interested in performance benefits, if there is any. So... the only main aim of Magisk is being able to pass SafetyNet?
[Xposed General] mobileman88:
Not really just passing Safety net, but also to hide unlocked bootloader from various apps which checks for it and there are a bunch of mods which you can install on top of your phone without touching the system partition which used to be required in the past
[Xposed General] fubo73:
The main purpose of magisk is to keep partitions as much untouched as possible, so that you can do even firmware updates without reinstalling all mods again. Safetynet passing should be a consequence, although some mods like xposed let it fail although systemless.
[Xposed General] q13017:
Is this thing capable of miui9?
[Xposed General] gajju.m:
How to fix this???
[Xposed General] Poppeye0:
Same here. Which version of Xposed Installer works with Magisk 15?
[Xposed General] d_Schizzo:
Just press on "Install / Update" again and install it without twrp. Worked for me
[Xposed General] gajju.m:
Thanks it's worked..
[Xposed General] V4LKyR:
Well, speaking of my phone; I'm using a Sony Xperia Z2 from 2014. It's an amazing phone and I love it. Planning to use it until 2020. Sony cut the support for it in mid 2016, so I'm not getting any new firmwares. Also, I don't ever need to hide my root. So I guess I don't really need Magisk, right? Unless it has a performance benefit too... Like maybe untouching the partitions would cause a performance leap or something like that? Maybe SuperSU and other flashable zips modify system so it goes in a low performance mode or something like that haha.

But now it's clear to me that I'm okay without Magisk and I don't really need it. I've been wondering about what this Magisk exactly is, so now I think I've found an answer.
[Xposed General] Poppeye0:
I don't get it... Xposed Installer is an app not a zip. I'm talking about DVDAndroids installer.
[Xposed General] CecoM:
Same bootloop with Magisk 15.1
[MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION], is xposed 87.3 compatible with Magisk 15.x?
[Xposed General] d_Schizzo:
I dont understand your problem. The Installer that works with magisk v15 is the one from the OP?!?:confused:
[Xposed General] pikachu27:
Now xposed is 89 version

Regards

Envoyé de mon MIX en utilisant Tapatalk
[Xposed General] fubo73:
Before replying, read previous posts. A lot of people is having issues with latest magisk and xposed. Each one is trying to find a proper working combination for his/her phone, waiting until all issues with latest mods will be fixed.
[Xposed General] CecoM:
OP:

"...

For Samsung users with devices still on SDK 22 or 23, please use v87.3 (which is based on [MENTION=3562083]wanam[/MENTION]'s build) instead.

..."

Of course i tried also 89.0 with no hope and... No hope :)
[Xposed General] smoke_dks:
i have installed the v15 of magisk but when i try to install the sdk 23 version (87.3) it says "unable to extract zip file) then i tried to go back to the v14 version but after flash it and restart the phone it freezes on the "working on apps" screen, and when it finally load, the phone freezes and stop working as it gets warmer and warmer
[Xposed General] hazantariq:
Try Upgrading v15.1 on Magisk Manager. It worked. but as for Xposed i am still not able to figure out the problem. I am getting the same Boot Problem.
[Xposed General] essor-13:
I installed Galaxy Project Rom and since then it works perfectly.

[MENTION=8179198]Joseahfer[/MENTION] thanks for the trick ! ;)
[Xposed General] Soumy1234:
I've tried to install the zip for my device (Samsung Galaxy Tab 3 with Lineage OS ROM 7.1.2) and yet the app doesn't say the framework's installed. What should I do?
[Xposed General] Joseahfer:
[MENTION=8489742]Soumy1234[/MENTION] do you use the Xposed Installer from this thread? It's different to the official one, a special version for the Magisk module.

https://xdaforums.com/attachment.php?attachmentid=4337506&d=1511193653
[Xposed General] suleymanov_aydar:
delete
[Xposed General] Cerhio:
Very frustrating. I just installed Magisk 15.1, flashed xposed 89 AND NOTHING!

EDIT: Using Z5C with latest LineageOS
[Xposed General] Soumy1234:
Oh, that makes sense. Thanks!:)
[Xposed General] Cerhio:
Will I have to do a clean install if I try and install xposed and it fails or does a failed installation mean that literally nothing has changed?
[Xposed General] RedSkull23:
Take a backup before flashing any, and try both. Then keep the one you prefer ;) i went from normal framework to systemless, but before i had removed the normal one flashing Xposed Uninstaller
[Xposed General] rascalifah:
Same here..but reboot back my device and its pass..
[Xposed General] pcsuite:
after i do this, I can not boot now, so I can not go into Magisk Manager, how to uninstall Xposed in twrp?

---------- Post added at 01:37 PM ---------- Previous post was at 01:29 PM ----------

Already fixed, I just uninstall Magisk, thx
[Xposed General] naruse99:
xposed for oreo already out?
[Xposed General] mrjuniork:
Follow this thread and you'll be the first to know :)

https://xdaforums.com/showthread.php?t=3034811
[Xposed General] Abdullah_a86:
how can pass SafetyNet any plan ?
[Xposed General] jenslody:
Disable xposed in magisk and reboot.

Safetynet should pass now, do whatever needs it.

Then reenablebthe modulebin magisk and reboot again. Xposed will be back and safetynet will not pass.

With running xposed and actual rom updates, you can not pass safetynet.
[Xposed General] Abdullah_a86:
Thank you very much .. Now works excellently

Do you think there will not be a plan to take them permanently?
[Xposed General] jenslody:
It's not possible with xposed.
[Xposed General] Timberlake.C:
thanks for trying for help ,but I give up. Thanks you
[Xposed General] Cerhio:
Has anyone gotten this working for the latest version of Magisk?
[Xposed General] Adam3Sixty:
Working fine here, no problems at all.
[Xposed General] Rom:
Since from the first time i installed XPosed on Magisk to now, i haven't got any problem:good:
[Xposed General] nightraving:
Hi, whenever I try to install xposed on my One Plus 5t, root check fails and says my device is not rooted correctly. When I uninstall xposed, it returns as rooted. Any ideas? Using the latest xposed and latest magisk.
[Xposed General] takur69:
magisk xposed uninstaller please sent link
[Xposed General] Adam3Sixty:
All fine here.
[Xposed General] nightraving:
Hmm, strange. Also, whenever I try and install via magisk manager I get this

Magisk is not activated

Installation failed
[Xposed General] Sytis:
Just install within the manager or use Magisk-Mount to uninstall it via TWRP
[Xposed General] ncandroid84:
Log error:

Cannot read log/data/user_de/0/de.robv.android.xposed.installer/log/error.log (No such file or directory)

Version magisk v15.2

Xposed framework v89 magisk

Samsung j730g android 7.0

root magisk parcheo boot odin, sin twrp
[Xposed General] rascalifah:
Just reboot back your device..
[Xposed General] trijethero:
Which Magisk/Xposed installer version are you using, I get a UNZIP error installing on M 15.2 and X installer 3.1.4
[Xposed General] Adam3Sixty:
See screenshots.

Hope this helps.
[Xposed General] ncandroid84:
no matter how many reboots you make, it still does not work. Will it have something to do with the way I became root? Do not install twrp, remove the boot.img from my firmware, install magisk, use the image patch option, and then install the patched boot using odin. The xposed framework works for me when I install it and after restarting the cell phone it does not work anymore
[Xposed General] p@to:
[MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION]

Could you help with this

Magisk root

Your system less xposed

Unicorn apk.

Module activated

But...
[Xposed General] Arastha1995:
Maybe it's app that not support on your android os..

Same like xposed for greenfy on Nougat.. But work on MM
[Xposed General] Rom:
The module you are using vaguely says something to me, maybe I have already used it in the past.

Are you sure that this one has been updated for XPosed latest version?

XPosed works great with Greenify on Nougat since rovo has updated his Framework for Nougat (7.0 and 7.1 bases).
[Xposed General] p@to:
[MENTION=5332893]Rom[/MENTION]

Thanks for the reply.

A have not idea!!

[emoji51]
[Xposed General] Rom:
Ok, link me the module thread please so.
[Xposed General] p@to:
https://xdaforums.com/showthread.php?t=2706775
[Xposed General] Rom:
I took a quick look, and unless i'm mistaken, the module has not been updated for about three year and a half, or even the official serverside of XPosed.

Sorry for you.
[Xposed General] joswiackk:
I have a J710MN android 7.0 mobile, I have magisk installed and updated and I have xposed 89, I wanted to put the permissive SElinux and I'm not getting ... does anyone know how I can do it?
[Xposed General] Zotho:
I got crDroid just installed with the tuned Boeffla kernel and got the same error. Any ideas?

EDIT: This was the reason, went to recovery, reinstalled magisk, then directly xposed, and then the kernel again. Works :)
[Xposed General] UL7RA:
Is there still the bootloop issue with Magisk 15.2? Cause xposed was bootlooping my LG V20 on 15 and 15.1
[Xposed General] chaostrodamis:
Running Xposed on 15.2 now with no issues
[Xposed General] Fild5x:
Usually it is not easy to change kernel to permissive on stock. That is for Android 6 and above as far as I know.
[Xposed General] Tribes11:
Magisk 15 and 15.2 doesn't work on my Redmi 4 Prime MIUI 8 ROM, however Magisk 14 works just fine. Someone else with same problem?

Everytime I flash v15.x it simply remove root and says that magisk is not installed.
[Xposed General] teddy0209:
Try removing magisk, restore ur boot.img and reflash...
[Xposed General] ctl999999:
Is there anyone using LG G5 ( H850 ) ? Could you please advise which combination of Magisk & Xposed version works for you ?

I tried many between 15.x and 88.x/89 but still not quite stable at all........sometime it will auto reboot or show xposed is installed but not active....need to boot few times to make it work.......
[Xposed General] knnthgngb:
Does anyone experiencing Xposed not working properly? Like it's keeps saying its not active. Anyone solve this problem? I'm running on Stock Nougat 7.1.1 Samsung AOSP-based ROM with Latest Magisk v15.2 and Xposed v89 installed..
[Xposed General] Rom:
Personally, on my phone (info in my signature), i haven't any problem with last XPosed zip from this thread with Magisk v15.2, what was your flash process ?
[Xposed General] ncandroid84:
I install xposed the active and it works, but when I restart the phone I get that it is installed but not active and the xposed does not work again. Installed on a samsung j730g with android stock 7.0, root magisk, stock kernel, it is linux permissive, busybox, without twrp. Install magisk v15.2, the xposed I install it from magisk version v89 that is in this thread.
[Xposed General] ncandroid84:
I leave the log of the xposed installer related to the previous message.
[Xposed General] knnthgngb:
I followed the proper process by using TWRP. Also when I rebooted my phone, still it keeps saying it's not active..
[Xposed General] Rom:
On wich Magisk version are u?

And have u tried to make an proper Magisk install ?
[Xposed General] ncandroid84:
I see that nobody could help me or respond, but no matter I could solve the problem !!!! After getting to put the selinux system in Permissivo mode, the xposed module started working !!!!
[Xposed General] Rom:
Maybe it's due to special Samsung special's SELinux policies but i can't be sure because it's a long time ago that i haven't make several tests on recent rooted Samsung devices.

Samsung is the manufacturer that edit the most things of AOSP sources for their stocks ROMs so maybe that some of their new SELinux policies can make getting issues..
[Xposed General] Ibuprophen:
Keep cool my friend... :)

Most of the time, when there's no response, usually indicates that nobody (who's read your post) has an answer for you.

Typically, if a certain module is not performing as designed, it's the fault of the module and not the fault of the Framework and any issues regarding the module should be geared to the modules developer via the modules thread and, if needed, a PM to the developer.

Just a suggestion/recommendation... :)

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

I DO NOT PROVIDE SUPPORT VIA PM UNLESS ASKED/REQUESTED BY MYSELF.

PLEASE KEEP IT IN THE THREADS WHERE EVERYONE CAN SHARE
[Xposed General] Adam3Sixty:
It's happened!!

https://www.xda-developers.com/xposed-framework-for-android-oreo-beta/
[Xposed General] shawek:
Already downloaded :) let's flash it :)

Sent from my One+3T
[Xposed General] Ericarthurc:
Getting a "Error 1" cant mount system; on Pixel 2 XL 8.1 January update with Magisk 15.2

-Mounting /system and /vendor read-write

! Failed: /system could not be mounted!
[Xposed General] jascolli:
Which module are you attempting to install. I don't believe there is one yet for Oreo.
[Xposed General] tremarley:
Systemless Xposed Oreo on the way?
[Xposed General] MrMarques01:
Yeah, as soon as you're finished developing it and when you're providing it to us.
[Xposed General] teddy0209:
You know it will (as the beta for 8 is already out)... But you can actually create it if you can't wait...
[Xposed General] topjohnwu:
Systemless Xposed Update!!

Here comes the long awaited Oreo Xposed thanks to rovo89. I'm glad to see Xposed running on my Pixel XL on the latest version of Android :)

All previous versions are also updated to use the newer templates for better support on Magisk v15+.

BTW, the fact that the source code for v90 are not out yet I can still release systemless versions again proven that I do not recompile the binaries, all binaries are repackaged from the original sources.

So if you face any issues, do not complain here :)
[Xposed General] Ja_som:
Yes, thanks rovo and topjohnwu.

Now, what modules works on Oreo
[Xposed General] tomaasz:
I've installed SDK26 on Oreo 8.0 beta 5 on my S8 and have some problems with boot.

What folder should I delete by TWRP if I want to uninstall systemless magisk module of Xposed 90 ?
[Xposed General] hertzschi:
Why not try it out?

Or ask the developer of your specific module.
[Xposed General] MrMarques01:
You, Sir, are a savior and a scholar. Running great on my Pixel XL
[Xposed General] Ja_som:
That was not a question, I did not expect answer to that, it was as "I have working framework, now figure out what modules works", maybe I wrote it wrong, sorry.
[Xposed General] anujyadava:
SDK 26 not working on OP5 with Oreo 8.0.

Flashed it via magisk as well as twrp but still no luck.xposed app says xposed framework not installed.

Also unable to install via xposed app,it says error 404 while downloading
[Xposed General] tomaasz:
how to uninstall systemless Xposed in TWRP ?
[Xposed General] teddy0209:
Flash Mount-magisk then navigate to the magisk folder using twrp file manager and delete the corresponding module...
[Xposed General] anujyadava:
Here are the logs
[Xposed General] tomaasz:
thanks!

What is "Mount-magisk" ? Where I can download this ?
[Xposed General] Xiaojie9162:
8.1安裝成功了，但進入xposed會閃退，無法安裝模塊
[Xposed General] teddy0209:
Here... https://xdaforums.com/showthread.php?t=3575758

I hope I copied it right...
[Xposed General] Ja_som:
Please read forum rules, XDA is English only.
[Xposed General] anujyadava:
There is no module like "mount magisk"
[Xposed General] teddy0209:
Lol, there is... But it's not exactly a magisk module...
[Xposed General] :
How are u getting installed on pixel xl I keep getting error while flashing thru twrp then I installed thru magisk but still saying xposed I sent installed
[Xposed General] anujyadava:
Then what it is ;)
[Xposed General] dragos281993:
85.7 is working like a charm on my granny Nexus 4 running Pure Nexus.
[Xposed General] danielcr12:
Try using flasfire for me it boots but the framework is unusable since it's not activated
[Xposed General] topjohnwu:
So is systemless SuperSU supported on Android 5.1?

I do not have a proper device with lollipop, so I really can't test it. If all reports for SDK 22 are failure, I might drop whole SDK 22 support lol
[Xposed General] KaMyKaSii:
Systemless in lollipop only on Samsung devices. He managed to install on your Motorola making a hack in updater-script
[Xposed General] Captain_Throwback:
Systemless SuperSU is only supported on Samsung devices on sdk22, so systemless Xposed won't work on any other devices on 5.1, right?
[Xposed General] danielcr12:
Well it's working for me flawlessly on CM12.1
[Xposed General] Ruuu:
I am using note 5 on stock marshmallow. Pls can someone tell me the proper steps to flash systemless xposed without losing the private mode?
[Xposed General] danielcr12:
Super su script mods this filea, you could check em out. These are the original files , dunno how to get the modded ones for comparison
[Xposed General] danielcr12:
Edit: installed systemless adaway just to see if my systemless su and setup was working and systemless adaway is working just fine and it's blocking ads, so I dunno I think there are some issues with the updater script of xposed or something. Here the the adaway log.