yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Xposed General] Didgeridoohan:
You've got more issues here than finding the "correct" version of Xposed. Magisk Hide cannot hide Chainfire's SuperSU and v9 does not have a root toggle... Go to the Pokemon thread in the Magisk forums, I'm sure you'll find some help there.
[Xposed General] Edebeton:
no custom recovery to install

sorry..., but

there is no custom recovery present

to install as You mentioned in the how to written above.

pls explain in detail how to manage a stock device with sdk23 on it as long as xposed-installer wont even run without root access to fs.

missing the hint to get rid of the stock recovery...!

best regards

ede
[Xposed General] mattie_49:
HTC 10 Verizon running nougat, viper 4.2 do I use sdk 21,22,23? S-off
[Xposed General] Didgeridoohan:
Nougat = 24 or 25 (depending on 7.0 or 7.1).

Meaning: No Xposed for Nougat (yet)!
[Xposed General] even91:
Nice things but I'm using nougat,sad...
[Xposed General] Artim_96:
Then wait till rovo is ready. We have to read **** like that since 7.0 was released...
[Xposed General] Prattham:
I have a game which doesn't work if i have root

If i install this will the game work with root?

I have tried root cloak but when evr i open the game it gives a soft reboot

Anyone?

Cheers
[Xposed General] :
Thread cleaned of a few posts.

Please keep things respectful.

:good:
[Xposed General] Artim_96:
Probably yes of you can pass SN with it. The problem is with banking apps which use detection methods no one really knows how they work
[Xposed General] Prattham:
So what about xoosed?

Can i install my normal xposed with this?
[Xposed General] Artim_96:
Can't be hidden, causes bootloops from November patch on
[Xposed General] i2andog:
that's not true... magsik will Auto detect and patch during install
[Xposed General] cudi90:
Support on cyanogenmod 14.1?
[Xposed General] teddy0209:
What are you talking about? You are just confusing others here...
[Xposed General] Artim_96:
Learn to use the search function. It was already asked very often.

No, no support until the official version is done. So just follow the official thread by rovo and yup be notified if it's ready

---------- Post added at 10:49 PM ---------- Previous post was at 10:22 PM ----------

No. That's only for SuperSU. XPosed v86.2 can only run where systmless supersu runs, which is Android 6+ or Android 5 on Samsung phones only.

And Magisk can't use anything below v86.3 (or whatever version was released after 86.2)
[Xposed General] JRoebux:
I'm on Magisk V9 with phh SuperSU and the latest Statement Xposed. I can only get Andromeda Pay to work if I uninstall Xposed and reboot. Is there a way around that?
[Xposed General] MaxSkynet:
bump
[Xposed General] Artim_96:
Not really. Just a statement, that you can disable it with root switch when in specific apps
[Xposed General] Crazyphil01:
Xposed is installed but not active

I just tried installing Magisk v9 with the current Xposed module on a YotaPhone 2 running Android 5.0, but it seems that the module doesn't correctly initialize.

I downloaded the XposedInstaller_by_dvdandroid_26_11_16.apk from the other thread and downloaded and installed the Xposed SDK 21 module in Magisk Manager v2.5. After reboot, however, the module list in Magis Manager was empty (not even phh's Superuser was visible there). However, the Magisk log shows that the Xposed script is executed:

** Magisk post-fs mode running...
** Magisk post-fs-data mode running...
Preparing modules
Bind mount dummy system
Bind mount module items
post-fs-data: /magisk/xposed/post-fs-data.sh
Enabling systemless hosts file support
Mount: /magisk/.core/hosts
Bind mount system mirror
Mount: /system
Bind mount mirror items
** Magisk late_start service mode running...
service: /magisk/phh/service.sh
phh: Live patching sepolicy
phh: Mounting supath
phh: Starting su daemon

The Xposed Installer now shows on the status screen that Xposed is installed but not active. An Xposed log file in /data/data/de.robv.android.xposed.installer/log doesn't exist. Logcat has no entries for Magisk nor Xposed. What am I doing wrong?
[Xposed General] LuanTeles:
i get android is starting everyboot when i flash Xposed. how to solve this?

Galaxy s6 Edge
[Xposed General] Artim_96:
... What is everyboot?
[Xposed General] Ibuprophen:
I think, in the first portion of his statement, he may have meant that he gets "android is starting" after every boot...

Sent using the d2vzw Communicator from the Bridge of the U.S.S. Enterprise (N.C.C. 1701).
[Xposed General] LuanTeles:
Yeah, That's what a meant!
[Xposed General] Artim_96:
... So where is the problem? Android has to start after every boot.

Or do you mean the compiling message of Android 5/6? That is a known problem, just ignore it.
[Xposed General] Manok98:
I had the same problem when I've installed the Magisk boot IMAGE. Are you sure that the problem is the Xposed framework? By installing another version of Magisk (v.9) for me System is started and now all work perfectly.
[Xposed General] LuanTeles:
Yeap. even system xposed gives me it, only unistalling xposed solves
[Xposed General] Veronezzi:
I recently bought a Moto G4 .... Coming from a Nexus 4 with CM i never bothered to use Magisk instead of the old default root+xposed instaled into system... But because Motorola locks a lot more the device than a Nexus, i tried to used Magisk + Xposed systemless.... And i bumped into a problem....

After unlocking the bootloader (while using 100% stock rom), if i enter at the bootloader mode in the device a message indicates that my G4 is unlocked, but running official software... If i try to install SuperSu systemless everything goes OK, and the smartphone keeps showing that the software is official (even after SuperSu modified the boot image, which is a necessary step to achieve the systemless root)...

So i thought that Magisk + Xposed Systemless would work the same way... After Magisk instalation, the message keeps being "Software Official" ... But as soon as i install Xposed Systemless, and reboot the device once, then immediately the message changes to "Software Modified" and i am unable to do any OTA update...

So i'm confused: SuperSu and Magisk both modify the boot image from the G4.... But why SuperSu is capable of modify it and the system doesn't see any change, but Magisk + Xposed modify it but aren't able to prevent the change detection as SuperSu does?

To add one more info: as i said, because Magisk + Xposed Systemless make changes at the boot image that are detected by the ROM, the phone status is changed from "Software Official" to "Software Modified", breaking any OTA updates... But if i re-flash the stock boot image, the OTA updates are able to be instaled again. (but then i lose SuperSu, Magisk and Xposed Systemless)

My main question: if SuperSu can patch the boot image to work, and that change is invisible to the smartphone, allowing me to do OTA updates, why Magisk + Xposed Systemless don't use the same technique ? I'm guessing that the technique is different because , like i said, the patched boot image from Magisk + Xposed is detected as altered, while installing SuperSu only doesn't generate any problem to the OTA updates...

In the actual scenario, at least for a Moto smartphone, the Magisk + Xposed Systemless aren't actually "systemless" .... Ok, they don't change the system image, but change the boot image, which leads to blocked OTA installation (because of the SOFTWARE MODIFIED status that checks the boot image, sees the alterations and stops the update), and at the end it acts as a system modification when anyone tries to update a Moto phone wiht Magisk + Xposed Systemless installed...
[Xposed General] Captain_Throwback:
The simplest answer to your question is that Magisk can't use the same method as SuperSU. SuperSU is proprietary and closed source software. Magisk is open source and uses open source tools. So I don't know exactly what's different, but you'll either have to deal with it, or just use SuperSU. The point of Magisk is to avoid making system modifications, not retain the integrity of your boot.img. If your device requires a stock boot.img in order to install an OTA, then flash it, take your OTA, and then re-flash Magisk. Your mods will still be there. THAT is the point of Magisk (among other things).
[Xposed General] Anagastes:
I have a problem with the new Magsik 10.2 and xposed 87.1 .... always "not active" complete removed and new flashed, same... :S

Now I have Xposed new installed... and its show me 87.0? I have xposed framework removed :D weird. I try the uninstaller-zip and make it new with magisk.
[Xposed General] Manok98:
What Rom and devices do you have?
[Xposed General] Anagastes:
It's Elephone P9000 with AEROM (based on last stock Android 6). The framework 87.1 is now completely new flashed with magisk. And Xposed App show me 87.0 (but its active)? Magisk say 87.1 :D weird. And no xposed modul works...

Sorry, I have no logcat for this problem :S

So, now I start a new flash and with new magisk 10.2... wish me luck. :D

sorry, my failure... selinux in this rom is very bad... -.-
[Xposed General] Manok98:
Is strage that xposed modules don't Work...If you are using phh superuser, you can try to use systemless root. I will send you in a private message the files that you are searching (Xposed 87 and Magisk v.9);). You can also use RootSwitch to byapass SafetyNET, following this guide: https://xdaforums.com/xposed/module...okemons-iv-t3469462/post70364293#post70364293. :good:

Good Luck
[Xposed General] Anagastes:
Thx, but it was my failure... selinux in this rom is very very bad... i'm now on CM13. There works fine...
[Xposed General] ModUser01:
Thanks I had the same problem, this solves all mine!:D
[Xposed General] naveenfre:
how to set root access to normal i installed phh's superuser,cts profile mismatch - false,
[Xposed General] Artim_96:
Well, with XPosed you can't pass SN, go over to the main thread and search it
[Xposed General] Wesley_NL:
it fails at installing the magisk 10.2 zip

"updater process ended with error: 1, error installing zip file -/usb-otg/android/magisk-v10.2.zip"

and i followed your guide

install clean rom of audax

removed super su

rebooted into recovery

installed magisk v10.2zip

get the error

as followes

rebooted

installed magisk app

downloaaded installed pph superuser

reboot recovery

reinstall magisk v10.2 again

and error still the same
[Xposed General] Artim_96:
Wrong thread. Nothing to do with XPosed
[Xposed General] Wesley_NL:
oh ok
[Xposed General] abel408:
I'm having a problem installing this with systemless supersu. Magisk manager tells me I have root and I can download and install xposed from the app. When I reboot after installation, xposed installer app tells me that "xposed is installed, but not activated".

My log says this:

Cannot read log/data/data/de.robv.android.xposed.installer/log/error.log: open failed: ENOENT (no such file or directory)

Looking in that directory, I do not see an error.log. It is completely empty.

Another strange thing is that after I install systemless xposed, it doesn't seem to get along with facebook and facebook messenger. Those apps keep crashing... Even though xposed isn't even working.

I've tried uninstalling everything and starting clean probably about 5 times. I can install xposed without systemless, but that is not what I want.
[Xposed General] Artim_96:
Does it even recompile the system after installation? If not it's obviously not running, but if, does only the app day that XPosed isn't running or do modules not have any effect?
[Xposed General] abel408:
How can I tell if it recompiles the system? It seems to install successfully and tells me to reboot. Xposed will not let me activate the modules. It says "The latest version of Xposed is currently not active. Did you install the framework and reboot?" And the answer is obviously yes...
[Xposed General] Artim_96:
Well, 1. The restart takes much longer and 2. It tells you

"optimizing apps

X of xx"

Of that isn't happening, the core part of installation stunt kick in, it needs to recompile every app on order to include the hooks. Then just wipe cache and dalvik cache in TWRP
[Xposed General] cusun12:
Does not Xposed SDK 21 version support the exynos? i have been used "xposed-v87.1-samsung-5.0.x-By-dkcldark" but "xposed-v87.0-sdk21-topjohnwu.zip " can't boot.
[Xposed General] sunbinyuan:
I can confirm they there is some issue with the systemless xposed with Facebook or Messenger. I tried to clear the dalvik and the cache but the application still crashes after multiple attempts of reinstalling it.
[Xposed General] EViollet:
Actually, I think the problem comes from Facebook and messenger themselves.

Many people are complaining that the latest versions are crashing.

My daughter is one of them. And she doesn't have a rooted phone.

Regards

Envoyï¿½ de mon ONEPLUS A3003 en utilisant Tapatalk
[Xposed General] Artim_96:
Can't be a problem. The only differences are between arm, arm64 and x86. But they are all in one zip, so if you can't boot your device isn't compatible. We already had some cases of Samsung devices not working. Ask in your devices forum, maybe you need a special kernel.

---------- Post added at 03:12 PM ---------- Previous post was at 03:11 PM ----------

Flash the UPDATE_unsu.zip by osmosis and afterwards flash your ROMs stock boot.img or just reflash your whole ROM and afterwards reflash Magisk.

---------- Post added at 03:14 PM ---------- Previous post was at 03:12 PM ----------

Yes, right. But thankfully I found the lite versions of these apps on apkmirror.com. I only have the messenger but at least it's not crashing. Maybe you're daughter wants to try them even though she might lose some functions.
[Xposed General] sunbinyuan:
Maybe, but it's kinda weird as it starts working again when I remove xposed?
[Xposed General] JJXB:
Is there any possibility of this supporting API21 on Samsung phones? when samsung won't fking release 5.1 for your phone not being able to use Xposed is a nightmare. and i do not want to have to go to a custom rom because i am not going to be backing all of my stuff up to flash a new custom rom (A300FU). Missing it for YT Adaway and a gyro emulation module.
[Xposed General] Tkkg1994:
Just open the OP and look a little closer:

Sent from my SuperMan powered SM-G930F
[Xposed General] JJXB:
you assume i haven't gone into magisk manager and installed 87.1 for API21 on my phone already (and got a bootloop that i fixed by uninstalling xposed with the flash file). I specified 5.0.2 because the last time i checked that was the version they had updated to on the A3. i just rechecked and now it's on 6.0.2 but for that i'm still gonna have to wait an hour for it to download the ODIN update file (because screw sammobile and their 15kb download speeds)
[Xposed General] Artim_96:
It's quite impossible. You need a deodex ROM on Android 5.0 Samsung devices for XPosed
[Xposed General] AxelCM1:
Edit
[Xposed General] ryankabir:
any update for cm14 *7.1* ?
[Xposed General] :
There is no official xposed for 7.x
[Xposed General] Artim_96:
Search first, then post. And don't quote anything you aren't replying to.
[Xposed General] Shailesh1711:
I tried installing systemless xposed on my LeEco Le 1s alongwith Magisk latest version. It is showing Xposed Framework not installed. Please help.
[Xposed General] Artim_96:
1. Never quote anything you aren't directly relying to

2. Obviously flashing went wrong. Upload TWRP logs.
[Xposed General] Shailesh1711:
Sorry.

So i need to flash the zip again & upload TWRP... Right?
[Xposed General] Artim_96:
Yes. But if the log you see during flashing shows something written in red, posting that might already be enough, that could already tell what went wrong.

And in the worst case, your phone might be incompatible and you need to search your device specific forums. But lets see at first
[Xposed General] Shailesh1711:
No. It has not shown any error or any message in red. Pl find enclosed recovery log.
[Xposed General] ilfastidio:
I tried the sdk21 systemless on a Galaxy Note with Magisk and phh root.

It goes bootloop.

I tried from Magisk manager and flashing the zip from recovery. Same. Bootloop.

Any idea?
[Xposed General] Shailesh1711:
Can anybody help me please???
[Xposed General] Didgeridoohan:
The recovery log looks fine. How about posting the Magisk log instead (from Magisk Manager) to see if it actually loads?
[Xposed General] Artim_96:
Not compatible. For Samsung devices you need at least Android 5.1.1. Thank the stupid idiots at Samsung messing around with stuff they don't understand
[Xposed General] Shailesh1711:
Magisk logs show below msg:

** Magisk post-fs mode running...

** Magisk post-fs-data mode running...

magisk.img mount failed, nothing to do :(

** Magisk late_start service mode running...
[Xposed General] Didgeridoohan:
Is that your entire Magisk log? Your Magisk installation isn't working and that's your problem rather than Xposed not working. Maybe you should head over to the Magisk forums instead...

Try installing it again and if it doesn't work, provide a recovery log from the flash and the Magisk log.
[Xposed General] kawasaks:
for people who has successfully installed this, anyone actually able to open(launch) Airwatch Agent app and able to use corporate emails?
[Xposed General] Shailesh1711:
But bro my Magisk status is showing properly installed & rooted. Pl check the screenshot.
[Xposed General] Didgeridoohan:
I'm gonna ask again: Was that your entire Magisk log? If not, please post the whole thing and make sure to enable verbose logging.
[Xposed General] Shailesh1711:
Thanks bro. I removed Xposed, Magisk & reinstalled them. Now working fine.

Thanks again for help.

Any nice xposed modules?
[Xposed General] Demicro:
The latest version of magisk works perfectly much better than the previous ones but the viper4 sistemless application does not load the library. Ask to install it in system. Magisk manager 3.0 no longer closes when I install a ZIP.

♪☆＼(^０^＼) ♪(／^-^)／☆
[Xposed General] hogze94:
Thanks, this worked. I could not find this anywhere in any guide relating to xposed or magisk.
[Xposed General] -Happy Feet-:
Is it possible to hide Xposed from other apps?
[Xposed General] Artim_96:
At least not with Magisk, no. But don't have latest information, which method work
[Xposed General] Fild5x:
I don't know why OTA updates won't install anymore on my phone
[Xposed General] Artim_96:
Which device?
[Xposed General] Fild5x:
Samsung galaxy a500h running resurrection remix
[Xposed General] Artim_96:
Blame Samsung's stupid mechanisms. When I still was on the TW ROM (and it was possible to hide root and XPosed) it would only download corrupted files and with the hiding disabled at detects then and refuses do download updates
[Xposed General] Fild5x:
Thanks for that information.
[Xposed General] Shailesh1711:
I have installed Magisk + Xposed on my LeEco Le 1s. It installed successfully but battery seems to be draining fast after Xposed installation.

I have both Amplify & Greenify instlled but still battery is draining fast. Max by Cell standby.

Any solution please.
[Xposed General] SnoopyOne:
[MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] I installed on my Galaxy S5 with CM based MIUI 8 rom,but it stuck at the boot animation and won't boot into system.:(

I'm going to flash the uninstaller zip to make it boot. Should I install this on this rom?
[Xposed General] Artim_96:
Not compatible with MIUI. Search this thread, somewhere is a link to a modified version
[Xposed General] X46X:
Hi, is there a way how to get working SafetyNet together with Xposed?
[Xposed General] Captain_Throwback:
Not using Magisk.
[Xposed General] gordonk654:
Dear Captain_Throwback,

Do you know other alternative in order to pass Safetynet and use Xposed?

Thank you!
[Xposed General] lulli1:
I would recommend to read this

https://xdaforums.com/showthread.php?p=68966762
[Xposed General] X46X:
But why xposed breaks SN? 2 months before, it works together very well..
[Xposed General] joelh:
SafetyNet got updated. It's a cat-and-mouse game. Chainfire has a good writeup somewhere re: suhide and this topic in general.
[Xposed General] dlads:
Htc 10

Android 7

Have Magisk installed and appears functional.

Just one question.

Is xposed functional? As when I try to install it via the donwnloadable modules it fails to install promoting for an install from recovery, which also fails.
[Xposed General] dlads:
Have tried with all three versions. 21-22-23
[Xposed General] Filip013:
Xposed doesn't yet support Nougat. You need to wait for rovo89 to release the updated version, topjohnwu will then release his version for Magisk.
[Xposed General] dlads:
That was what I originally knew, I just thought that magisk had made a difference.. Good job it failed on the install.. Cheers.
[Xposed General] Artim_96:
No, it just mounts the stuff it normally would change in /system there without changing the partition. Therefore it still needs to be made for that absurd version. Such a magical modification would be great because it's quite possible that M was the last version to run XPosed. The new security measurements introduced in N are just too high at the moment. It was just a coincidence that a workaround was found in M to make it work just before rovo wanted to give up. No one knows if there is one for N and since Google plans to update 4 times a year no one knows how long it will work.

Letting XPosed run seems to become a loosing game like working against SN.
[Xposed General] gordonk654:
need some help..

after installing magisk on my huawei p8 lite with android 6 i tried to download the xposed sdk 23 from magisk manager but failed to install - "flash it manually" -> i did it through TWRP but after flashing the .zip it causes bootloop.

Anyway has an idea how to proper install it?
[Xposed General] Fild5x:
The following is the best procedure that I have used to install magisk on my android 7.0 and Marshmallow 6.0.1 ROMs on my phone. After installing ROM, get back to recovery and flash phh superuser zip. Reboot and then install magisk apk. Also install phh superuser apk. And then you can go on to use magisk.
[Xposed General] Artim_96:
Well....1. that's the wrong thread and 2. That's missing about everything. You need to install Magisk first after the ROM, then the rest, otherwise it wouldn't work. And the superuser zip isn't needed anymore, it's installed when flashing Magisk
[Xposed General] Fild5x:
Thanks for the corrections and my apologies for posting here.
[Xposed General] Localhorst86:
So I have an UMI Super which I had rooted and xposed "regularly" before. I decided to try and become systemless using magisk and xposed systemless. I was able to install everything without a problem, magisk manager says it is running and root is enabled, xposed installer says the same about the xposed framework. However, xposed modules that I have installed are not working at all, gravitybox (MM) says the framework is not responding. I tried uninstalling magisk and xposed and reinstalling them, it did not work, though :(

What else can I try? or should I return to non-systemless versions?
[Xposed General] Tecalote:
GravityBox is the problem, not the Framework. Most parts of GravityBox don't work on MM at all and hasn't been updated since Lollipop
[Xposed General] Fild5x:
Well I still maintain my stance. First flash phh superuser (unless you are already rooted say with superSU because upon running magisk it requires root). Then install phh superuser apk. Now install magisk and run it. Through magisk then download the modules which includes xposed framework. I have done this procedure on my phone and I have no more issues with xposed and it's modules on android 6.0.1 roms. Previously I would have serious bootloops. Thanks.
[Xposed General] Localhorst86:
That's not true, Gravitybox [MM] from the xposed repository worked fine before I switched to systemless. I am now going to revert back to the traditional method as a few xposed modules are very important for me and none work in systemless mode. :(

EDIT: well, I think I know why it's not working in systemless mode. My devices requires something called "grorkmod" to be installed for xposed to work. I assume in systemless mode this wont work. so i'll have to use the traditional method.