yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Xposed General] Devilix:
Done! completely unroot... magisk finally working! But now there is another issue:

the SafetyNet Helper app give me a grey screen... this is because i have installed the framework! Tryed to unistall the framework, and SafetyNet Helper give me a green screen!

In this case, i can say the systemless xposed here, is not fully compatible(systemless-ly) with CM 12.1

I will try with Ressurrection Remix rom...
[Xposed General] HamsterHam:
I tried this earlier and android pay wouldn't work so for me I need to disable it and then reboot. For now I have stopped using xposed. Hoping this can be worked on apart from that it is quality.
[Xposed General] Artim_96:
Yes, it seems to be not working already as it should be, in that case it's enough to just disable it in the installer app and reboot though.

But it can happen that some module has changed stuff in /system which could be a problem
[Xposed General] guigui39:
Hello, i have one problem with your Xposed systemless application : my phone reboot after ~30 minutes i start it.

I have phh SuperUser 17 magisk installed and your xposed v86.5 sdk21 ( i have android 5.0 ).

All is working fine, but :

1/ after i boot my phone, after almost 30 minutes, my phone reboot, SU works but xposed is noted as " installed but not active " in the xposed installer materiel design. And then, all my xposed module are nor working.

2/ But when i restart my phone by myself, the Xposed is noted as correctly installed and working.

3/ 1st step begins again

How can i fix the problem please ?

PS : soory for my english is he's bad

---------- Post added at 04:46 PM ---------- Previous post was at 04:43 PM ----------

One other thing : before i install this version of xposed, i had the common xposed , but above the v72 version , my phone was constantly rebooting, is there a link ?
[Xposed General] Dalamar666:
is there a way to integrate this systemless version with Samsung ART - SDK21?

There are unofficial xposed versions but there aren't systemless...

http://xdaforums.com/xposed/unofficial-xposed-samsung-lollipop-t3113463

Thanks
[Xposed General] kihtrak778:
Miui systemless xposed framework for sdk22

Can someone please share systemless xposed framework for sdk22 for (miui)
[Xposed General] Armandooo:
I would love to have the same. I don't really understand what means systemless as you still need to flash but is seems to be better...
[Xposed General] Dalamar666:
If you've systemless root on your samsung 5.0.x and wants xposed, systemless version is mandatory (common xposed Useless because it's in system...)... but there isn't version right now =(
[Xposed General] Armandooo:
I don't want root. I just want xposed to run along with android pay on my non-rooted device that runs stock S4 Android 5.0.1.

So what you are saying is: if I have systemless root then I need systemless xposed... I have red some post where root was not necessary to run xposed though.

Am I wrong?
[Xposed General] westeight:
That's not going to happen.
[Xposed General] FlemishDroid:
Someone knows there is a systemless Adaway for Magisk Phh Superuser? I know there is one for SuperSu but SuperSu is removed from my phone after the CCTM debacle.

I know there is an systemless adblocker but with Adaway you can whitelist some sites.

Sent from my lightning fast SM-G930F (S7)
[Xposed General] westeight:
Standard Adaway works fine along with Magisk, Phh, Android Pay, SafetyNet and Pokemon Go.

Why the need for systemless?
[Xposed General] Captain_Throwback:
Magisk supports systemless Adaway by default. If you already have Magisk installed, just use Adaway as normal and it will be systemless.
[Xposed General] FlemishDroid:
Thanks for the quick response. I thought it also but with Adaway hosts file and root disabled SafetyNet helper fails with stock hosts file and root disabled SafetyNet helper app passed so I thought Pokémon Go and AP wouldn't work.

Sent from my lightning fast SM-G930F (S7)

---------- Post added at 08:46 PM ---------- Previous post was at 08:44 PM ----------

I try to install Adaway again. Thanks again.

Sent from my lightning fast SM-G930F (S7)

---------- Post added at 08:57 PM ---------- Previous post was at 08:46 PM ----------

I removed Adaway and installed it again and now SafetyNet helper passed. After a clean install of my rom I always restored it with Titanium Backup so maybe that's the problem. Thanks again.

Sent from my lightning fast SM-G930F (S7)
[Xposed General] Armandooo:
And why isnt it possible to have xposed on nonrooted device?
[Xposed General] Captain_Throwback:
Because Xposed requires root access.
[Xposed General] igorinolw:
any way to make this work on miui ?

as it have a different zip installer, i could not make the systemless zip work. It says "xposed is installed, but not active", only working when i install the proper miui version. but then i cannot play pkgo.

any help is aprecciated :good:
[Xposed General] buayasawah:
I believe theres no systemless xposed for MIUI atm since the dev told me so. However just be patient and wait for him to make it work for us. Donate some if its done tho.
[Xposed General] sgtgs:
Wich version i need to install on my Nexus 6P? Im on android 6.0.1. The simple sdk23 version or the arm-sdk23 version?
[Xposed General] Toutatis_:
xposed-v86.5-sdk23-topjohnwu
[Xposed General] Armandooo:
In the prerequisite it does not say root required.
[Xposed General] Captain_Throwback:
Well, it is.
[Xposed General] lancespahr:
Sorry if I've posted repetitively but my issue is lock screen does not work once I've installed Xposed (systemless or official) with magisk. I can see the power menu and some notifications. Any ideas what the issue could be? :/ possible that selinux could cause issues?
[Xposed General] Captain_Throwback:
Same answer applies.
[Xposed General] lancespahr:
Official Xposed works fine but not if magisk is installed.
[Xposed General] Captain_Throwback:
With Magisk installed you should only be using this version. If that doesn't work, then you need to post some logs, as indicated in the Magisk thread.
[Xposed General] lancespahr:
Thank you, guess I missed that post. Post here, in magisk thread, both?
[Xposed General] Captain_Throwback:
This thread is fine.
[Xposed General] FlemishDroid:
I think Xposed itself doesn't need root but some modules need it. For me root and Xposed are the first things I do after buying an device so why should you install Xposed without root.

Sent from my lightning fast SM-G930F (S7)
[Xposed General] Captain_Throwback:
Xposed needs root (at boot time).
[Xposed General] FlemishDroid:
Okay

Sent from my lightning fast SM-G930F (S7)
[Xposed General] Fangs87:
So I think I have everything working right, titanium can see root, but when i toggle root in the magisk app it just turns back on, and if i try to use root explorer it never gets permissions.

I installed magisk v6

uninstalled old exposed

installed new xposed

installed new systemless 2.76-magisk root

xposed is all green & magisk manager sees v6 roots mounted but toggle doesnt stick and i cant add more apps to allowed root access

So it seems like it just takes a while after the phone starts to get caught up. The toggle does work.

However when I toggle it off, safety net and android pay and pokeymon go all fail to auth. Am I missing some step ? I thought I read it as just toggle root off.
[Xposed General] Captain_Throwback:
Wrong root.
[Xposed General] Artim_96:
Since when? For all I know XPosed itself only needed root when it relied on SuperSU. XPosed shouldn't need root. Why? It's flashed through TWRP and else, so there is no barrier, the systemless modifications are made by Magisk. The manipulation of apps is mostly through a modified dex2oat file so everything necessary gets compiled into the apps after installation. So the normal XPosed definitely doesn't need any root access, otherwise you would find that requirement in the post for every modified versions. Greenify was even changed so it can rely only on XPosed and did not need a rooted device.

So why should systemless XPosed require root? The only requirement is Magisk.
[Xposed General] Devilix:
installed new systemless 2.76-magisk root <--- Bad move!

I was in your same situation...

supersu 2.76 its not fully compatible with this xposed by my tests.... You have to flash phh zip and download the relative apk from playstore! Forget supersu if you want magisk + xposed fully working/systemless-ly :D

Also there is an app called "SafetyNet Helper" on playstore to test this...

supersu 2.76 magisk version and xposed framework seems to get failed test result for SafetyNet app, and just not working for Pokemon go... (This is what i have had).

I have try on CM12 and Resurrection Remix, and was not the roms my issue... but SuperSu 2.76 magisk version.

CONCLUSION: Magisk v6 - phh zip - phh superuser apk - xposed v86.5 topjhonwu - xposed installer by dvdandroid - STOP.
[Xposed General] The_tomorrow_person:
I can't install Systemless Xposed on my OnePlus 3. Does anyone else have the same problem?
[Xposed General] -Duir-:
This is based off official Xposed, so there won't be a SDK 24 version of this until there is one of official.

Did you get Magisk installed okay?

Either way, logs or it didn't happen.
[Xposed General] The_tomorrow_person:
I don't have logs. How do I get logs? (Sorry, I'm kind of a noob) Magisk didn't install properly either. (It showed that it was installed but when I tried verifying with SafetyNet Helper I got a blue screen with an error. http://i.imgur.com/oSpuHTe.png

Please help, tell me what to do.
[Xposed General] -Duir-:
If Magisk didn't install properly, then Xposed won't either.

Refer to the Magisk thread (link in OP) for help with that and getting logs. As for safety net not passing, no clue on that.
[Xposed General] The_tomorrow_person:
Okay, thanks. Will do it and report back in a few weeks.
[Xposed General] _M4rc05_:
Xposer v86.5 topjhonwu and Xposer offical: Causes not turn on my device (Samsung galaxy grand prime SM-G530M, Android 5.0.2). (Bug report? xD)

Is there any chance that higher versions not such a thing happen?

=(
[Xposed General] bon122728:
is magisk working on zenfone 5? i tried it using a custom rom (RR 5.7.2) which is 6.0.1 but when i try to flash it it says "unable to detect boot image". how do i fix this? thanks
[Xposed General] Vichrly:
i follow this step , and make it work

1. Use Universal Systemless Installer for Xposed Framework to install Solarwarez' MIUI Version. (Rename "xposed-v86-sdk23-arm64-MIUI-edition-by-SolarWarez-20160710.zip" to "xposed-v86-sdk23-arm64.zip" so it can find it.)

2. Install topjohnwu's "xposed-v86.5-sdk23-topjohnwu.zip" as well.

Yes, I believe installing two framework is kind of danger and unstable.

But this is the only way that I got Pokemon Go 0.37 (Of course root disabled) and Xposed Modules xMIUI working.
[Xposed General] mrceli:
Any effect happen to your phone after doing this? Want to do so, but thinking alot :)

I Installed sdk21 in miui8 but too long to boot after installing. So i uninstalled. Really wish solarwaze will realease the systemless version for miui sdk21 arm64.
[Xposed General] Vichrly:
no any bad effect. its work in my ROM . xposed model work well.:)
[Xposed General] hash87:
Did you install both frameworks at once or did you boot your system after installing the first one and then reboot to recovery once more to install the second framework?
[Xposed General] Vichrly:
flash two framework at the same time, then reboot
[Xposed General] buayasawah:
Well. Im not sure if it doesnt do any harm to your phone. But nice to know that.
[Xposed General] mrceli:
did u do it base on tutorial here? --> http://xdaforums.com/xposed/unofficial-universal-systemless-t3419472

since that tutorial show you to flash both exposed's at the same time. just wondering :confused: :confused:
[Xposed General] Artim_96:
Jesus Christ, learn to use the goddamn search function!

Neither official XPosed nor systemless XPosed is compatible with Samsung 5.0 since that version needs a different special version of XPosed which is not merged to this version and a deodexed ROM. For devices with Samsung's TW ROMs: only Android 5.1+
[Xposed General] Sterist:
Jesus Christ doesn't use android, just a bolt of lightning for ppl with attitudes.

I'll have you know that there 1. IS a sdk21 version available next to all the others, and 2. the OP, FAQ, and all the rest of the entire first page contain the word "Samsung" one time, and it is for the Alt versions (sdk23), therefore the doors are left wiiiiiide open for unsuspecting Samsung 5.0 users to, as they should, fully read OP+FAQ, and believe it to be working, only to find out by experience that it is not.

at least you didn't make a fool of yourself by telling him to go check the first page posts lol that would have backfired much harder :silly:
[Xposed General] Artim_96:
That's why I told him to use the search function.

In theory we would need a mod constantly listing all problems that appear. Samsung 5.0 isn't the only problem, it's even not that visible that it works only with 5.0 and up (at least when you have no idea what the SDK versions are) and that's something that should be directly in the title.

But there are also problems with Sony's stock ROM and MIUI. There seems to be a systemless version, but I don't even know if it's compatible with Magisk.

But everyone posting in any forum needs to learn to first search. Only when nothing can be found, then post. This problem was already mentioned a dozen times and it gets extremely annoying
[Xposed General] DerNetzreporter:
I am using an Asus Zenfone 2 (Z00AD) with Android 5.0 ((WW_2.20.40.196)

when I try to run the german "Sky Go" App (v1.3.10 - not the newest version, but the last that is starting, because officially my phone isn't supported. With newer versions the App closes itself immediately)

And Sky Go detects the activated xposed app and tells me "you are using software, that prevents the usage of Sky Go. Uninstall it".

Is there a way to "hide" or deactivate xposed-app, without rebooting the phone? Such a simple switch like Magisk to root or unroot?
[Xposed General] htb2050:
Since this doesn't modiy the system partition in any way does that mean the negative performance effects or xposed when installed are not present in it?
[Xposed General] Captain_Throwback:
A different install method shouldn't change the effect of the mod or modules on your device. But the best way to know is try it yourself and find out.
[Xposed General] mafury:
don't work T_T only got me on fastboot mode :<
[Xposed General] Giacomo_ITA:
Xiaomi RN 3 PRO Xposed systemless doesn't work and Xposed MIUI version is seen by PoGO
[Xposed General] madeye88:
Thanks. Got this and Magisk running on Note 3 with CM13 a few days back. Works flawlessly.
[Xposed General] 1337haXXor:
Stuck

Boost Mobile Galaxy S5. Resurrection Remix Nightly. Uninstalled old Xposed, installed Magisk, set up root right, installed Systemless Xposed, and granted root access to it. Everything seemed fine. I went in and enabled all my old modules (and updated 2 or 3) and now I get "Unfortunately, SystemUI has stopped" loop, and can't do anything on my phone. What did I do? And how do I revert it? Will downloading the uninstaller and flashing that fix it? I'm at work now, so can't download things... :/
[Xposed General] McKebapp:
Unfortunately not working with the SDK21 versions on Redmi Note 2 (Latest sMIUI).
[Xposed General] Artim_96:
No, not at the moment. Deactivating and rebooting is the fastest way existing... The further way was to fully uninstall it and need to let the device recompile every single app. So this is sheet way faster
[Xposed General] Armandooo:
I guess when you are following the post from the beginning it all makes sense. But when you are like me, just wanting to try xposed for the first time, then seriously, even the installation guide seems to be a little bit light.

Is there anyone who can just help someone like me getting started?

Thank you,
[Xposed General] CRXed:
I'm not supposed to, but here, let me spoonfeed you: http://xdaforums.com/xposed/xposed-installer-versions-changelog-t2714053
[Xposed General] lancespahr:
Okay, here's the logs from before Xposed (last_magisk.log) and after flashing (magisk.log) where the lock screen does not work. I'm on a HTC 10 Verizon variant, 6.0.1 stock, SuperSU root. If I need to find a stock boot img let me know? Hopefully I can figure this out... in the mean time I'll try uninstalling Xposed and await a reply :) Thanks so much

Edit: Order of flashing things:

Uninstall Magisk

Magisk v6

SuperSU Magisk (latest)

Reboot System to confirm everything working

Flash Systemless Xposed from Material Installer

Reboot System
[Xposed General] Captain_Throwback:
I was also hoping for a logcat....

EDIT: But you probably won't get a reply anytime soon, so I'd just proceed as you have been.
[Xposed General] lancespahr:
Logcat of..? Just as soon as adb recognizes it while booting?
[Xposed General] Captain_Throwback:
Of the broken lockscreen. From boot time to after it breaks.
[Xposed General] lancespahr:
So starting somewhere in "Optimizing x/y"? Once it says "starting apps" is the last I see of the screen
[Xposed General] Captain_Throwback:
As early as you can. You should have adb that entire time.
[Xposed General] lancespahr:
Alright, so reflash systemless Xposed and reboot system, adb logcat, until it finishes booting (blank screen)?
[Xposed General] slavin23:
Seem like the systemless xposed is not working with MIUI rom too. :(
[Xposed General] Sterist:
1. uninstall xposed via recovery

2. boot to system

3. disable *all* modules. if you can't, then uninstall them too.

4. reinstall xposed via recovery

5. renew your full backup (delete old, make new)

6. enable/reinstall one module

7. reboot and verify that it isn't causing the problem

8. rinse repeat 6 and 7 until you find the module causing the problem.

9. when you find the problem module, restore your backup (only data restore should be needed in this case)

10. enable/reinstall all modules that were *not* causing the problem.
[Xposed General] kick.andery:
same problem with me, i used miui too, i've tried many times, and the result is systemless installed but not active ..
[MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION], we, miui users, need your help :)
[Xposed General] buayasawah:
Apparently, flashing two xposed at the same time does work. You need to flash systemless xposed for miui by solarwarez first then flash topjohnwu systemless xposed. I dont know if it would harm your device tho, but im currently doing fine.
[Xposed General] kick.andery:
ok i'll try it later. does solarwarez release the systemless too like topjohnwu? can you share with me the link?
[Xposed General] buayasawah:
You can search his thread. The link wasnt shared by him tho. Its on 20ish page.
[Xposed General] kick.andery:
that systemless [MENTION=260994]SolarWarez[/MENTION] is for sdk23-arm64, mine sdk22-arm.. not match. do you have the link sdk22-arm. i'm using miui 7 lollipop..

thanks
[Xposed General] buayasawah:
That my friend, i cant help you with.
[Xposed General] diegosps:
I am not able to pass Safetynet test with sy-xposed active.

Magisk, root and my xposed modules are working fine. But if I run the test, I get an error "Response payload validation failed"

Disabling sy-xposed on app and rebooting the phone makes the test pass successfully;

I am on a Galaxy S5 with a custom ROM.

xposed version: 86.5 (systemless by op)

Is this ROM related or am I doing something wrong?
[Xposed General] DaDiDo:
I am using AOKP CM13 (6.0.1) , i installed systemless exposed + framework (86.5) but it always says NOT ACTIVE , magisk is working fine , the root is ok, i can't activate any module since Xposed is not active , please help (screenshot attached).
[Xposed General] Portgas D. Ace:
Did you check the log fiel as recommended by the app?
[Xposed General] hjternan:
Xposed systemless issue

I installed the systemless version of the Xposed Installer v86.5 on my OnePlus One and every couple hours, an error appears in it saying "The latest version of closed framework is installed but not active."

Helppp
[Xposed General] leon_qiu:
xposed systemless framework installed but it can't active on Nubia Z9, can you update a compatible version?

May I install a xposed normal framework(not systemless) with Magisk?
[Xposed General] DaDiDo:
Yes i just checked the log file, i think the problem is from the "modules.list" could you help me fix it ?

log:

09-15 07:30:51.320 I/Xposed ( 2593): -----------------

09-15 07:30:51.320 I/Xposed ( 2593): Starting Xposed version 86.5 (Systemless by topjohnwu), compiled for SDK 23

09-15 07:30:51.320 I/Xposed ( 2593): Device: GT-I9192 (samsung), Android version 6.0.1 (SDK 23)
09-15 07:30:51.320 I/Xposed ( 2593): ROM: aokp_serranodsdd-userdebug 6.0.1 MOB31E f10db217ea test-keys
09-15 07:30:51.320 I/Xposed ( 2593): Build fingerprint: samsung/serranodsxx/serranods:4.4.2/KOT49H/I9192XXUCNG2:user/release-keys
09-15 07:30:51.320 I/Xposed ( 2593): Platform: armeabi-v7a, 32-bit binary, system server: yes
09-15 07:30:51.320 I/Xposed ( 2593): SELinux enabled: yes, enforcing: yes
09-15 07:30:54.062 I/Xposed ( 2593): -----------------
09-15 07:30:54.062 I/Xposed ( 2593): Added Xposed (/magisk/xposed/system/framework/XposedBridge.jar) to CLASSPATH
09-15 07:30:54.155 I/Xposed ( 2593): Detected ART runtime
09-15 07:30:54.165 I/Xposed ( 2593): Found Xposed class 'de/robv/android/xposed/XposedBridge', now initializing
09-15 07:30:54.305 E/Xposed ( 2593): Cannot load any modules because /data/data/de.robv.android.xposed.installer/conf/modules.list was not found
09-15 07:30:54.329 I/Xposed ( 2806): Lazy unmount app_process
[Xposed General] Niksior:
I have Xiomi Mi4 with MIUI V8, android 6.0 and systemless xposed is installin, phone is booting but is not working.

My log file for v86.5 sdk23 https://drive.google.com/open?id=0B7VLpSQEN_6edWEtcEc5dS1xZjg

Log file for v86.5 sdk23 alt https://drive.google.com/open?id=0B7VLpSQEN_6eWklJelEtM3AydnM

Could you help me?
[Xposed General] 1337haXXor:
Huh, so I did that and the problem never happened again.. I did each one one at a time (I have about 10), and the problem never surfaced. Maybe it was with activating too many at once? Or certain ones at once that were conflicting?
[Xposed General] supernova29:
Hi, I'm on a Oneplus One with CyanogenOS 13.1.2 (Android version 6.0.1). Everything seems to be fine, I flash the zip via recovery and when I turn on the device Xposed is there and all modules working. Yet, this is only until next reboot; then, it says the framework is installed but not active. I guess I should reproduce the issue and post a log to be helped. If anyone could explain to me how to grab a logcat at boot, I'd be very grateful - I couldn't find a neat guide to that. Sorry I didn't read the whole thread, I just scanned through and couldn't find a solution. Thank you in advance
[Xposed General] cthulhu1987:
All's working fine, but about yesterday the installer started bugging me with an info about an updated version, should or shouldn't I update?
[Xposed General] Captain_Throwback:
You can update - it's just an app update.
[Xposed General] Lazurea:
I have an SM-P900 (Samsung Galaxy Note Pro 12.2), it runs the stock 5.0.2 firmware. I got magisk/phh's superuser installed and working fine. However, when attempting to install the systemless xposed (sdk21) image from the xposed installer, it says it downloaded successfully but then it gives me errors saying it could not copy to /cache. So when it reboots into TWRP, it does nothing.

I have tried to manually flash that zip using TWRP, but then the tablet stays on the samsung logo forever and doesn't boot. I can fix it by flashing the uninstaller... but this means no Xposed for me. I tried to install the 'alt' version, but I noticed you only have that available for sdk23, not sdk21... so I have to have marshmallow (which I do not on samsung stock for this device). Is there anything I can do? I tried to use CM13 on this device before, but no matter what.. it cannot seem to pass SafetyNet... so I went back to stock ... where it actually does pass SafetyNet.
[Xposed General] lux_nova:
Exactly the same symptoms as my N9005 on 5.0.