yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Xposed General] topjohnwu:
[MENTION=4419114]rovo89[/MENTION], I just found out something interesting (you might have known though)

Regarding you said you might want to offer Xposed Systemless without SuperSU as a dependency, I just found out that SuperSU itself is not required, but the patched sepolicy is mandatory to run scripts located in ramdisk (selinux issues), which systemless is heavily relying on. So you have to either patch it during Xposed install, or just simply make root a requirement for Xposed (SuperSU or not, all root methods requires patched sepolicy).

----------------------------------------------------------------

[MENTION=631273]Chainfire[/MENTION], you once mentioned in this thread that you might make SuperSU start much earlier in the init process, I assume it's most likely post-fs-data.

I've got some issues here. If I want to support unaccessible data in recovery (so we install image in cache), the merge-cache-to-data process won't work if the script is run at post-fs-data. I spent some time and found out that the problem is encryption. On late-init, it will trigger post-fs-data once, and if it found out that the partition is encrypted, vold will decrypt it, and trigger post-fs-data once more. This "might" be a problem to you (or maybe not lol, you're more skilled than I am, you always come with solutions). The problem occurs in the first post-fs-data trigger, when the data is still not available yet. If I try to move image file from cache to data, it will make the device stuck at boot. Everything runs fine when no encryption is in data. If I detect the decryption complete property (vold.decrypt=trigger_post_fs_data) before merging, it will then won't work on unencrypted devices.

In v85.2 I overcome this difficulty by placing a script in su.d to overwrite Xposed image and reboot. Do you got some ideas to fix it elegantly?

----------------------------------------------------------------

I think you can use Chainfire's flashy new app FlashFire to apply OTAs on Nexus devices :)
[Xposed General] bagarwa:
I flashed the June factory images to my N6P. This is what I did -

Flash boot.img, system.img, vendor.img

Boot into recovery (latest twrp)

Flash SuperSU-v2.74, Franco r17, xposed-systemless-v85.2

Clear cache, Reboot system.

When the boot finished, everything works as expected, other than the fact that Material Xposed Installer says "The xposed framework is not installed". All xposed modules are working, but the installer app is not detecting the framework as installed. Weird and funny at the same time. :eek:

Attached my xposed log. [MENTION=5345056]DVDandroid[/MENTION] [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION]
[Xposed General] DVDandroid:
You are using an old version of the Xposed Installer. Please update it from 1st post of my thread.

Thanks for the log
[Xposed General] VanGolfer:
Worked great! Thanks!
[Xposed General] bagarwa:
Just now installed your today's app update and all is well now. :good:
[Xposed General] azZA_09:
I think you already know about this, but on Resurrection Remix ROMs 85.2 nor 85.1 can't be installed, it always shows only version 85 which i flash from official rovo89 thread
[Xposed General] badelie:
I installed the new material installer last week and disabled xposed (84.0 wanam), installed Android Pay, added cards, used them to pay a couple of times, never enabled xposed again and the strange thing is that all my xposed modules are still working. The more I read the weirder it gets, as this doesn't seem to be the intended consequence of systemless xposed. How are the modules still working after disabling?

Samsung Galaxy S6

Xtrestolite 3.1.1 (Android 6.0.1)

Xposed 84.0 wanam
[Xposed General] Mr.Yawnie:
Seems as if the xposed framework is not disabled. The xposed installer app doesn't always tell you the truth. It depends which framework version you have installed and which installer app supports those paths.
[Xposed General] DawoodSahi:
Again flashed a new pre rooted stock rom.

Rebooted

Flashed 2.74 su

Flashed systemless xposed

Rebooted normally, no fw.
[Xposed General] KbaB.BroS:
Try flashing the standard Xposed immediately after you flashed the systemless, it's working for me. I can disable xposed whenever I want through the app.
[Xposed General] topjohnwu:
New version will be up soon. I'm currently out.

I'll upload it when I get home, hopefully it will fix many issues you experienced.
[Xposed General] DawoodSahi:
Now in the app it says that it is active but also gives an error that framework is loaded and modules aren't working.

Anyways I hope the new version will fix it :)
[Xposed General] SyCoREAPER:
Modules have little (practically nothing) to do with the framework.

Short answer: you can install whatever modules you want, they are 99% of the time not dependent on the framework type (system vs systemless), only the version (and of course install any module is at your own risk)
[Xposed General] Tecalote:
[MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] Hello Sir, I have some questions. First thanks for all your work! :)

The phh superuser seems to make systemless Root. Root Checker say, it is located in /sbin/su - would it root in system, it would be located in /system/xbin/su. I always like to install the BusyBox from YashdSaraf, newest version 1.25.1. But when I install this, it goes not to /su/xbin - it goes to /system/xbin. Usually the Universal installer from YashdSaraf checks first the Root and if it is systemless, busybox will also installed systemless.

I have seen, you have integrated busybox from this developer in Magisk v9 - yds 1.25.0. It can be activated in settings of Magisk, but once it is activated, busybox is also in /system/xbin. I am wondering why it goes not to a systemless directory? - cause Magisk, systemless Xposed, phh superuser is all systemless.

Thanks beforehand!

Edit: I have tested Magisk v9 on Huawei p8 last Marshmallow Stock Rom - First I must install the phh Superuser.apk, after Magisk Manager 2.5, after flash the Magisk v9.zip, after flash the phh.superuser.zip (last one). After reboot I must go to Settings /Apps and Permissions and activate the permission for Storage. If I dont do it with this steps, Magisk Manager would not recognice, that phh superuser module is already installed and he would not have permissions to install any other module - cause the Manager gets just root permissions, if Superuser.apk is installed beforehand.
[Xposed General] xsever:
Uninstall lucky patcher.
[Xposed General] nick491:
The version I tried installing (87.1) with even recovery doesn't work. In the log it shows Android 6.0 and I'm running Android 7.1 with SDK 25. I tried Magisk 9 before but couldn't.

Will there be a version for Android 7.1?

EDIT: Nevermind, I found out that Android 7.1 is in the works. http://androiding.how/xposed-android-nougat-7-0/
[Xposed General] habylab:
Where did you get 87.1 from?
[Xposed General] nick491:
Here's a screenshot from Magisk. Also it's also mentioned by topjownwu in XDA.
[Xposed General] Nomelas:
Magisk installer has xposed reporting 87.0 as 87.1, though they are the same versions.
[Xposed General] EpicLPer:
Is the 87.0/87.1 version the one with the November patch fix included or not? It's confusing, the changelogs don't show anything like that...
[Xposed General] habylab:
Can't see 87.1 in Magisk or Xposed, no update listed.
[Xposed General] habylab:
Not listed as an update for me. Can't see anything in the changelog, so perhaps it was the issue with the zip file that was fixed and that was it?
[Xposed General] teddy0209:
Same... 87.1 is just a fix...
[Xposed General] lentm:
I have Systemless Xposed v87 with Android N-ify, YouTube AdAway, and GravityBox[MM] installed,

and everything seems to work okay except GravityBox.

It just doesn't get activated, not sure why...
[Xposed General] habylab:
Yes, I've seen that. No prompt, Magisk and framework app have no updates prompting.
[Xposed General] Orka82:
Getting "Framework not installed" from Xposed Installer. The thing is, xposed works. If I check the status after a fresh reboot it does say v87 installed but if starting the installer later will show not installed. What gives?

Edit: Ooops, changed to "Material Design Xposed Installer", works better now. ;)
[Xposed General] CrazyCypher:
Hy guys, I see that in changelog it says latest version of Xposed is Magisk independent, so that means I can install it without Magisk and it will work?
[Xposed General] lover:
Same here. Although i think it does mistaken wanam's xposed for Samsung devices with systemless xposed!

From Wanam:

http://xdaforums.com/xposed/unofficial-xposed-samsung-lollipop-t3180960

v87.1(28/11/2016):

- This update fixes a compatibility issue with the new Note5 UX Roms (Technical details).
[Xposed General] Captain_Throwback:
That's not what it says.
[Xposed General] CrazyCypher:
So what does it mean "now it's Magisk independent"?

Thanks..
[Xposed General] Captain_Throwback:
Again, that's not what it says. Go re-read it.
[Xposed General] CrazyCypher:
Ohh..sdk22 is Magisk version independent I guess..
[Xposed General] Iceyogurt:
OnePlus 3, OxygenOS 3.2.8, stuck at boot animation using v87.0 or v87.1

Edit: I saw someone succeeded. Now I guess it's a compatible problem with xposed modules.
[Xposed General] ldeveraux:
It only works on certain devices with certain kernels. And the developer makes no bones about unwilling to help anyone else.
[Xposed General] EpicLPer:
Is your Bio right about using CM13? If so, it should work... Weird.

You sure it doesn't work? Is the module activated? Do, as example, the custom media volume step options work? Because some things really don't work correct.
[Xposed General] lentm:
I'm on last build of CM13 w/ Nov Security Patch for Nexus 6,

and GravityBox was working okay.

Just using it for quick pin # unlock feature.
[Xposed General] ldeveraux:
So it was working, updated the ROM, then it stopped? Or did it stop after updating Xposed to 87?
[Xposed General] lentm:
I was with the Oct Security Update, and updated the build with Nov Security Update.

Therefore, I also had to update Xposed to 87 because of bootloop.

When I run GravityBox, it says that it's waitng for the response,

then I get 'GravityBox system framework not responding. Exiting.' message. :(

Before I update the rom and xposed, GravityBox worked well.
[Xposed General] ldeveraux:
Man, sorry, wish I could help. That's wacky...
[Xposed General] Fild5x:
I am thinking you have to do a proper root
[Xposed General] alvin853:
I've been using the v86.2 systemless for a long time now since it was the last version that didn't require magisk, but now with november security patches for Marshmallow I want to move on to v87 systemless. Problem is I can't seem to find the uninstaller for v86.2, the uninstaller in the opening post just fails because it can't find magisk (duh, I'm using a version that doesn't require magisk, so no magisk installed). I've been searching through the thread as well as on google, but I can't find the uninstaller for the previous versions, or only dead links.

If someone could give me a hint how to remove the old version that'd be great.

edit: praised be lentm, my lord and savior!
[Xposed General] lentm:
This might help:

http://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=67805517&postcount=1233
[Xposed General] rami_m98:
I installed xposed 87.0 systemless

Magisk 9.0

Phh superuser

But

Unable to authorize on Pokemon go

How to solve it
[Xposed General] dlinkb:
I get a bootloop after installing this on the ZE551ML Zenfone 2 (i.e. the x86 variety). (6.01 MM)

I had been using a modified version of the v86.6 version of this that someone posted on the Zenfone 2 specific forum, but they haven't updated it to 87.0 and aren't sure if anyone will. The modified version fixed something that would cause bootloops, but it'd be great if the "official" systemless xposed worked for this phone too. (http://xdaforums.com/zenfone2/general/superuser-r272-magisk-v7-xposed-86-6-t3475045 - the particular modificaiton to get it working on the Zenfone 2 was documented as "- Forced oat 067".)

I've uploaded the logcat if that helps anyone : http://pastebin.com/NCBUcCeZ

(most of it is duplicate).

(and indeed, I do see some errors about boot.oat)

11-29 22:47:35.089 3252 3252 W dex2oat : Failed to open .dex from file '/system/framework/x86/boot.oat': Failed to open oat file from '/system/framework/x86/boot.oat': Invalid oat header for '/system/framework/x86/boot.oat': Invalid oat version, expected 0x3036340, got 0x3036370.

though the first error message I see is (which I'm not sure matters)

11-29 22:47:35.051 201 226 I KERNEL : [ 120.415034] type=1400 audit(1480477655.029:38): avc: denied { read } for pid=3194 comm="zygote" name="input" dev="tmpfs" ino=1756 scontext=u:r:zygote:s0 tcontext=u:object_r:input_device:s0 tclass=dir permissive=1
[Xposed General] Artim_96:
Learn to search. XPosed can't be hidden.

And stuff about pogo absolutely does not belong here, it will only clutter the thread with useless stuff and the same questions over and over again:

http://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/discussion-pokemon-magisk-discussion-t3465722
[Xposed General] steve51184:
Is its possible to get Pokemon go working with magisk+xposed and no suhide?
[Xposed General] Citizen_Snips:
Read the post that is literally right above yours to find an answer. Please start reading before posting.
[Xposed General] Demicro:
Magisk Works fine without modules, but when I install the exposed, the Ui of the system stops working

Thus having to delete the data partition

The exposed works fine at first

Samsung J510FN
[Xposed General] kuyakom:
Thankyou for your hardwork!

I'm using latest build of CM13 from my asus zenfone 2 if i install this then its ok to install ota without uninstalling the xposed?
[Xposed General] Artim_96:
Impossible.

1. XPosed can be detected by SafetyNet

2. If you don't want to use suhide you have to use phh's SuperUser and the r root hide methods for it. Or how do you want to hide root?
[Xposed General] steve51184:
My current set up is: supersu, suhide, xposed + root switch and works perfectly
[Xposed General] Artim_96:
Ok, you can use rootswitch to turn off XPosed while using pogo, and probably you can hide root with it by disabling it (au least that's what I read in the suhide thread because suhide is outdated), but my comment was on having both installed and running while using pogo, since that was the reason Magisk was built
[Xposed General] SDMU:
What does toggling the Xposed status switch do ?
[Xposed General] Artim_96:
It can disable XPosed... After a reboot

---------- Post added at 11:26 PM ---------- Previous post was at 11:25 PM ----------

Just got an update to v87.1 over Magisk manager. Have I overseen the changelog?
[Xposed General] SDMU:
87.1 in Magisk is the same as 87.0 in Xposed
[Xposed General] Captain_Throwback:
The changelog is right in Magisk Manager...so yes, you have overlooked it ;).
[Xposed General] laggardkernel:
Hi, bro. Do you use OxygenOS? My phone with OOS 3.2.8 and xposed v87(Magisk) ended stuck at boot animation. I don't know it's whether v87 doesn't work with oos 3.2.8, or some modules aren't compatible. Thx in advance.
[Xposed General] SDMU:
I am still on FreedomOS 1.6 , sorry I don't know why you might be facing a bootloop . Why don't you just try flashing only magisk first ; before that , do flash the magisk uninstaller . After that your superuser zip . Reboot after every flash . Lastly flash the xposed zip .
[Xposed General] Artim_96:
Thanks. Have totally overseen the changelog button
[Xposed General] laggardkernel:
deleted.

Update 1: Not solved. Still with other problems. I'm sure it's about the Magisk modules now.

Update 2: Except substratum themes, the overlay themes, the ARISE sound module, Leviticus, have to be removed at first reboot.
[Xposed General] kushal biswas:
Currently I'm using Jgcaap(cm13) on my Oneplus One. The rom is pre rooted. Should I need to unroot first in order to install Magisk?
[Xposed General] jlster:
MMv9 Error Message

Phone: Note 3, Lollipop, running 'phh' Superuser.

Trying to install Xposed Framework: found and downloaded Magisk v9 and installed. It seemed to work but after a while I got "Magisk Manager isn't responding..." Per instruction I tried manually to install MMv9 via TWRP but did not see that package listed via TWRP Install button. Any advice?
[Xposed General] Captain_Throwback:
Not with Xposed installed....
[Xposed General] Artim_96:
That's not up to us. Subtribe to the XPosed thread by rovo and wait till he releases
[Xposed General] sniper9911:
it kinda worked at first but then it got stuck again to yellow

i just finished clean install developer rom 6.12.1 miui8 based on 6.0.1 marshamllow on my phone xiaomi redmi note 3 kenzo 2gb ram i have twrp 3.0.2 installed and bootloader unlocked

This is what i did

Wipe system data cache internal

Flash miui 6.12.1 recovery zip (moded to keep BL unlocked and twrp safe)

Flash magisk v9 and phh262_2 and sdk23 miui xposed from this thread

Reboot and wait about 15 minutes to reach miui 8

Installed superuser app and magisk manager and xposed material i open it and all was green

Then i installed some xposed modules (xmiui and youtube adaway)

Reboot

Then open xmiui says xposed not installed so i open xposed material and i see yellow warning not active but installed

What did go wrong ? Please help me fix it

Thanks in advance
[Xposed General] Didgeridoohan:
When I still used Xposed (Magisk v6), I remember getting this if I did a soft reboot. A hard reboot fixed it. Give it a try...
[Xposed General] rummsbumms:
try this one for ze551ml. it's just a small modification of the libart.so with a hex patch by shakalaca.
[Xposed General] sniper9911:
Fixed my problem just had to uninstall and reflash xposed systemless miui v87 again

Another problems appears after about a day without restarting ... No root access availabe and no xposed is back red again in the xposed app ... While magisk app is working fine and those modules are always on ... If i reboot root and xposed are back working again for a day or so :/

Maybe something is wrong or missing .. anyway i am going to change root app from phh to supersu because 6.0.1 is supperted for systemless

Wish me luck
[Xposed General] MiAndrew:
Not working magisk v9 on xiaomi.eu_multi_HMNote2_6.12.1_v8-5.0

Installing causes bootloop on RedMi Note 2 on weekly 6.12.1. Try on clean install.

On 6.11.17 everything was fine. Can't even get to TWRP through Vol+
[Xposed General] Artim_96:
no crossposting!
[Xposed General] astrit1:
-deleted
[Xposed General] snake_mgs:
Im trying to uninstall Xposed flashing the uninstaller zip but after tje reboot the Xposed app still show active Xposed, i tried to uninstall magisk with a zip and got bootloop, a twrp backup saved me

Im missing something to uninstall Xposed?
[Xposed General] MaxSkynet:
So I installed the latest xposed through recovery and it worked. I installed some modules, green lights etc everything seemed tippy top. Restarted phone after activating modules.

However none of the modules take effect, it's just for show

So any help would be appreciated greatly!

I'm on the Honor 8 dl09
[Xposed General] prithvee:
Can anyone please provide me a link to download v86.2 systemless xposed, I couldn't find it anywhere. Thank you.
[Xposed General] Portgas D. Ace:
http://xdaforums.com/apps/supersu/suhide-t3450396/post68424603

Check download section of the OP.
[Xposed General] prithvee:
Can't thank you enough :D
[Xposed General] buiducphuc™:
Nougat s7 edge please
[Xposed General] Portgas D. Ace:
Xposed isn't available for Android Nougat yet.
[Xposed General] ht9937:
Help

it works on Xiaomi Redmi Pro (Android 6.0 ROM MIUI by Xiaomi.eu) ?
[Xposed General] Artim_96:
Not this version but if you search this thread you'll find a version compatible with MIUI
[Xposed General] MaxSkynet:
which one works on honor 8

the default one doesn't seem to work although it shows green light and everything
[Xposed General] :
The system less version works fine
[Xposed General] Mr.Yawnie:
Any possibility to get a non-Magisk version of Systemless Xposed v87? Or make Magisk Hide hide the Xposed framework? Since November security patches it is not possible to pass safetynet with xposed framework active. Disabling Xposed framework gives a green light with Magisk v9 + phh's superuser.

Prior to November security patches I had the following setup working: SuperSU + systemless xposed v86.2 + suhide + root switch.
[Xposed General] Captain_Throwback:
Not from here.
[Xposed General] MaxSkynet:
Thanks,

So how do I go about installing this if I already installed the normal one v.87?
[Xposed General] Mr.Yawnie:
Well, maybe make Magisk Hide hide the Xposed framework as well, then? Just like it hides itself and root. Would that be possible, [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION]?
[Xposed General] :
Simply uninstall the previous version?
[Xposed General] Captain_Throwback:
It's already been discussed. If it was possible, it would've been done already. It isn't.
[Xposed General] Artim_96:
Well, it can't be hidden, but for all I know it can be disabled for certain apps over Rootswitch... But I don't know if that would still work after the December patch. Maybe Magisk could build in something like that.
[Xposed General] MaxSkynet:
Perfect thanks, won't try "overwrite" then. A bit offt perhaps, but if I install updates on the phone after unrooting and installing xposed etc, will the system updates unroot the device again and best not to install updates or what say you?
[Xposed General] knpk13:
Does enabling magisk hide have any negative effects or performance overhead? What I'm asking is that is it okay to leave it on all the time, or should I only enable it when I need it, like to android pay and other apps?

Also where can I find the thread for xsetprop or resetprop (I forget what it's called) ?

I keep hearing about this Rootswitch, where is the thread (info and download) for it?
[Xposed General] Captain_Throwback:
I leave it on all the time. No idea about consequences (besides the random loss of root, which a reboot fixes for me).

And there's no thread for resetprop. It's built into Magisk.
[Xposed General] MaxSkynet:
So now I uninstalled official xposed since it didn't work on my phone.

Using Honor 8, so should I install the MIUI 64 version or the systemless 23 (only 1 version to choose from) on my phone?
[Xposed General] Artim_96:
I don't know if there is even a seperate thread, but it gets linked quite often in the suhide thread since Chainfire have updated for a long time
[Xposed General] Manok98:
Hello topjohnwu,

I need of xposed framework v. 86.2 for SDK 22 (arm). Can you give me a link please? I need it!:)

---------- Post added at 09:36 PM ---------- Previous post was at 09:24 PM ----------

Hello topjohnwu,

I need of framework v. 86.2 for sdk 22 (arm).

Can you give me a link please?

Thanks in advance
[Xposed General] Artim_96:
That is version is not supported anymore and was deleted for a reason. So you won't get it here. Is the latest versions
[Xposed General] Manok98:
OK thanks, but I read that I need of v. 86.2 or Magisk don't work no longer

---------- Post added at 06:43 AM ---------- Previous post was at 06:15 AM ----------

There is a solution?
[Xposed General] ChokingHazard91:
Xposed 86.2 doesn't need Magisk to work. If you need Magisk and Xposed, use Magisk 9 and Xposed 87.
[Xposed General] teddy0209:
86.2 is supersu dependent, hence does not support sdk22... use magisk version instead if you want systemless xposed on sdk22...
[Xposed General] Manok98:
Thanks everyone for replies,

first of all sorry for my bad english (Google transaltor). Now I will explain exactly what's my problem...

I'm running CM 12.1 with magisk (v.9), Xposed by topjohnwu (v.87.0) and SuperSu by Chainfire. Magisk's root toogle work, but when i run for example Pokemon GO, it says me that i can't play this game because my phone isn't compatible.

So I've done some researches on the net, and I found out that the only working way to do this, is install Xposed by topjohnwu (v. 86.2). How can I do?

thanks in advance
[Xposed General] alroger:
Again, no v86.2 here!

Please use the corresponding thread (Pokemon?).
[Xposed General] Manok98:
OK sorry,

Pokemon was only an exemple to say that it don't work.