yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Xposed General] chaopac:
Then I guess if you are able to disable Xposed and get back SafetyNet pass, OTA should work again. Though I'm no expert so take my words with a bag of salt.

I'm having issues here on my device that after disabling and even uninstalling the Xposed module in Magisk, I still can't pass SafetyNet, even though I was passing it fine before installing Xposed, and Xposed is the only module I install/make changes to the device.

Still not sure what is causing it, trying to figure out why.
[Xposed General] jenslody:
In general every process with root access can modify the system-partitition, even with systemless root.

And that can also trip safetynet or break OTA.
[Xposed General] Nightmare[ITA]:
I had to uninstall the Xposed installer too, in order to pass SafetyNet again. You could try that.

[MENTION=8340552]jenslody[/MENTION]

That's why I was wondering if anyone knows more about OTA with systemless Xposed
[Xposed General] kolibre:
magisk with systemless xposed caused my camera lag when starting, any solution?

os: lineage 15.1
[Xposed General] itandy:
I just got a OTA notification today. I'm using Magisk and Xposed. But when I tried to upgraded via OTA, it didn't go through even if I had uninstalled Magisk. Had to flash the new FTF using Flashtool.
[Xposed General] Nightmare[ITA]:
An FTF file is only the Firmware on Sony afaik, and not the whole OTA, right?

Could it be possible that you had a custom recovery when you did the OTA?

Because on HTC for example the OTA works on TWRP but you still have to flash the firmware

manually, so i'm not sure if this was an issue because of a modified system partition by an xposed module.

Usually broken OTA functionality doesn't really start and gets stuck in the verification process

in the beginning.
[Xposed General] itandy:
FTF is the entire Sony firmware and OTA is just an incremental change package. And you're probably right that my failed OTA upgrade was due to the custom recovery and modded kernel or both.
[Xposed General] Didgeridoohan:
It's from the official release:

https://xdaforums.com/showthread.php?p=75248580#post75248580
[Xposed General] Dante63:
Are you using dvdandroid xposed installer?

If so, go to path "/data/data/de.robv.android.xposed.installer/shared_prefs/" and check for file "disabled",if it's there delete it...

That's the only help i can provide...
[Xposed General] spartanz51:
Hi , any news about Systemless XPOSED on Samsung devices ?

On s7 exynos it doesn't boot (stay on Samsung logo) with the magisk's xposed systemless

(SDK 24)

I tried to install systemless xposed with magisk , and with twrp but no differences

BTW I have xposed non-systemless and it's working

If u want any logs or any detail tell me!

Thanks
[Xposed General] Rom:
Hello,

Just after having install the system-lessy xposed package for your cpu arch, have u perform a wipe of cache and dalvik ?

If yes, so maybe u don't have uninstalled your first install of xposed by using the last uninstaller ?
[Xposed General] spartanz51:
Thanks for your reply

I think I uninstalled xposed with the right uninstaller, and I don't remember if I wiped cache & dalvik

So I'm going to try right now to uninstall with the lastest uninstaller, and to wipe cache & dalvik after installing xposed systemless
[Xposed General] Rom:
Ok, and immediatly after having installed xposed systemless, reboot into TWRP to WIPE the cache and the dalvik.
[Xposed General] Donphillipe:
If installing the versionless new xposed systemless zip via TWRP, the auto selection doesn't seem to carry out. I had to install the specific version (SDK23 for me). Still I'm having no luck configuring Xposed and XprivacyLua on my BLU STUDIO XL 2 even if the "green screen" in Xposed says it's up.
[Xposed General] Michael.Shuldman:
Same problem here

I have the same problem. Magisk v16.0. After installing systemless Xposed 89.2 (SDK 24), phone no longer boots, but hangs at the SAMSUNG logo.

Magisk_Manager_for_Recovery_Mode-2017.11.25-1-M15.zip saved my bacon and let me disable the Xposed module from recovery, and the phone subsequently booted.
[Xposed General] braschlosan:
To double check I removed the xposed installer and used the one attached to this thread https://xdaforums.com/showthread.php?t=3034811

Xposed still is not detected and there was no file named disabled in the path that you suggested
[Xposed General] Avalon:
Works flawlessly on my OPO running Candy ROMs Oreo 8.1 :) so far everything module I tried is not causing any issues.
[Xposed General] Dante63:
Why not the xposed installer in this thread...?

There is a difference between both...

If I recall correctly, the installer you're using won't detect systemless xposed... The installer in this thread is dvdandroid xposed installer, which is able to detect it...
[Xposed General] mezhh:
Uninstall

Hi. I have installed it to lineage 15.1 but the phone doesn't boot. How can I remove it?
[Xposed General] spartanz51:
Use the uninstaller , flash it with recovery
[Xposed General] Eversmile23:
Just interested to know which Oppo device you are using.
[Xposed General] teddy0209:
I think he didn't mean Oppo but OnePlusOne... Not sure though... ???
[Xposed General] Didgeridoohan:
There's no auto selection of SDK version for this module... You might be thinking of the Xposed Unity installer module, in which case you're in the wrong thread.
[Xposed General] raptorerz:
Hi im installing sdk23 zip

im using miui 9 mm, rom multirom

but its stuck on boot loading, been waiting for 15min but still loading
[Xposed General] Avalon:
I didn't expect this question :P But yeah, [MENTION=3615867]teddy0209[/MENTION] is right, I'm using a Oneplus One.
[Xposed General] Rom:
Hello, after having installed the xposed framework, have u reboot into twrp to perform a wipe of your cache and your dalvik ?
[Xposed General] Ostry10:
@up Yes
[Xposed General] Aman Dewett:
Hello dev, I've Moto G5s Plus with 7.1.1(sdk 25) stock. I tried to i stall xposed by you but I'm getting this error. Please do check attacked log.

Log:

- Copying zip to temp directory

- Installing Xposed_Framework_(SDK_25)-89.2_(Systemless).zip

- Mounting /system, /vendor

Archive: /data/user/0/com.topjohnwu.magisk/cache/install.zip

inflating: common/XposedBridge.jar

inflating: common/post-fs-data.sh

inflating: config.sh

inflating: module.prop

*******************************

Xposed framework installer zip

*******************************

******************************

Powered by Magisk (@topjohnwu)

******************************

- Extracting module files

Archive: /data/user/0/com.topjohnwu.magisk/cache/install.zip

inflating: META-INF/com/google/android/update-binary

inflating: META-INF/com/google/android/updater-script

inflating: README.md

inflating: arm/system/bin/app_process32

inflating: arm/system/bin/dex2oat

inflating: arm/system/bin/oatdump

inflating: arm/system/bin/patchoat

inflating: arm/system/lib/libart-compiler.so

inflating: arm/system/lib/libart-disassembler.so

inflating: arm/system/lib/libart.so

inflating: arm/system/lib/libsigchain.so

inflating: arm/system/lib/libxposed_art.so

inflating: arm/system/xposed.prop

inflating: arm64/system/bin/app_process32

inflating: arm64/system/bin/app_process64

inflating: arm64/system/bin/dex2oat

inflating: arm64/system/bin/oatdump

inflating: arm64/system/bin/patchoat

inflating: arm64/system/lib/libart-compiler.so

inflating: arm64/system/lib/libart.so

inflating: arm64/system/lib/libsigchain.so

inflating: arm64/system/lib/libxposed_art.so

inflating: arm64/system/lib64/libart-compiler.so

inflating: arm64/system/lib64/libart-disassembler.so

inflating: arm64/system/lib64/libart.so

inflating: arm64/system/lib64/libsigchain.so

inflating: arm64/system/lib64/libxposed_art.so

inflating: arm64/system/xposed.prop

inflating: common/XposedBridge.jar

inflating: common/post-fs-data.sh

inflating: config.sh

inflating: module.prop

inflating: x86/system/bin/app_process32

inflating: x86/system/bin/dex2oat

inflating: x86/system/bin/oatdump

inflating: x86/system/bin/patchoat

inflating: x86/system/lib/libart-compiler.so

inflating: x86/system/lib/libart-disassembler.so

inflating: x86/system/lib/libart.so

inflating: x86/system/lib/libsigchain.so

inflating: x86/system/lib/libxposed_art.so

inflating: x86/system/xposed.prop

inflating: META-INF/MANIFEST.MF

inflating: META-INF/CERT.SF

inflating: META-INF/CERT.RSA

- Creating /data/adb/magisk_merge.img with size 64M

Creating filesystem with parameters:

Size: 67108864

Block size: 4096

Blocks per group: 32768

Inodes per group: 4096

Inode size: 256

Journal blocks: 1024

Label:

Blocks: 16384

Block groups: 1

Reserved block group size: 7

Created filesystem with 11/4096 inodes and 1294/16384 blocks

- Mounting /data/adb/magisk_merge.img to /dev/tmp/magisk_img

! /data/adb/magisk_merge.img mount failed...

Failed!

! Installation failed
[Xposed General] Rom:
Hi,

Have u tried to install xposed system-lessy version through TWRP or Magisk Manager ?

And have you installed the last Magisk version ?
[Xposed General] Aman Dewett:
I've installed xposed through magisk manager and yes I have latest version of magisk manager.
[Xposed General] Rom:
Try to fix them by making a fresh install of Magisk (by TWRP) and flash again the module through Magisk Manager..
[Xposed General] Didgeridoohan:
Try this:

https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/guide-magisk-official-version-including-t3577875
[Xposed General] Master_44:
Hey buddy, stock rom is the issue

I installed this S8 Oreo rom https://xdaforums.com/galaxy-s8/samsung-galaxy-s8--s8-cross-device-development/g95xf-fd-n-oreo-beta-2-soldier9312-zqk4-t3703183

and Xposed work now
[Xposed General] gazdajezda:
Hi, is there anyone with working Magisk 16.0 / Xposed on Pixel 2 XL 8.1? Thanks.
[Xposed General] peterlee928:
yep works for me
[Xposed General] SnakeByte:
Stock rom is not the issue here. I'm running stock 7.1.1 on ZC551KL and xposed systemless sdk25 works miracles, along with magisk 15.4, so there must be something else.
[Xposed General] Zincoshine:
I am wondering, if I install a bunch of xposed framework modules via this systemless xposed framework, and then uninstall the xposed framework magisk module from magisk itself (modules/trash can icon) what will happen to all those xposed framework modules? I am particularily curious as to what happens to the changes that Amplify made especially since I installed that module via the google play store.
[Xposed General] Ja_som:
All modules will stay installed, but they will not work.
[Xposed General] Bludwurst:
sorry for the silly question, but then how one could uninstall them (after getting rid of xposed)?
[Xposed General] Ja_som:
They are normal apps, so you can uninstall it via Settings/Apps on your device, or via Play Store if they are installed from there, or via Xposed Installer (it will not be removed when you disable/uninstall Xposed module from Magisk)
[Xposed General] g202824262:
EMUI8无限重装启动：哭：
[Xposed General] grymkmb:
English only.
[Xposed General] :
To my understanding

(from translation) unlimited reload start which means bootloop.

---------- Post added at 03:10 AM ---------- Previous post was at 03:09 AM ----------

Emui8 is not working with xposed read more about it https://github.com/rovo89/Xposed/issues/310
[Xposed General] Master_44:
Did you read the whole post?

i talk about the

SAMSUNG GALAXY S8
[Xposed General] Aman Dewett:
:)

Thanks, It worked.
[Xposed General] ayush.gl:
Which xposed installer app should i use for oreo systemless framework?? I'm getting xposed installed but not active error.
[Xposed General] Ja_som:
From the first post or Materialised version from dvdandroid.
[Xposed General] Ricardo Flowers:
When I install xposed sdk 22 by magisk after reboot it goes into bootloop, does anyone know how to solve?
[Xposed General] Aman Dewett:
Unable to pass Google safety net check

Hello, so far I've managed to flash xposed framework systemless through magisk but still I'm unable to pass google safety net check. I want to use google's tez application which is required to pass safety net first. I can not pass safety net if I install xposed framework by ruit (the original xposed dev), I can not pass safety net even if I install xposed framework through magisk module either which actually says it is for passing safety net of google (systemless).

Please do check attachments.
[Xposed General] unhappybirthday:
From the OP (which I suggest reading):

Systemless Xposed does not pass Safety net!!!
[Xposed General] Aman Dewett:
Apology, then what's the use of installing this xposed framework rather than by the original dev?
[Xposed General] Ja_som:
As mentioned so many times here, you can easy disable systemless Xposed to pass SafetyNet when you need. And also, your system stays untouched.
[Xposed General] super-drone:
I swear next time someone ask that I'll kill myself
[Xposed General] Adam3Sixty:
I think the other reason is that rooting ur device using Magisk is Systemless root, and can not use normal Xposed with that way of rooting, this is version of Xposed that works with Magisk, hence, Systemless Xposed Framework.

Feel free to root with the old SuperSU method and use normal Xposed.

Thanx, bye.
[Xposed General] Aman Dewett:
Wrong, you can use normal xposed with magisk as well.

---------- Post added at 09:37 PM ---------- Previous post was at 09:37 PM ----------

Agree
[Xposed General] tremarley:
Wheres the download link for the systemless installer apk. Its missing from this thread
[Xposed General] Didgeridoohan:
Normal Xposed works perfectly fine with Magisk root.

Apart from the already stated reasons, keeping your mods systemless will also make it easier to update your device through an official OTA (possibly). Another reason is that you can very easily reapply any mods after a system update. As long as you don't wipe /data, all the systemless mods will still be there. Keep in mind, though, that this can cause issues if you update to an Android version that doesn't work with your current mods.

It's attached to the OP. There's no link...
[Xposed General] Adam3Sixty:
Shows how much I know then doesn't it ;)

I believed what I said was correct, so I will take back my statement and apologize for being wrong.
[Xposed General] Jhoel04:
Can i install this xposedframework on lg g3 fullmics 8.0 rom installed?
[Xposed General] Rom:
Just try, it should works fine in any case.

Just don't forget to wipe your cache and dalvik after having installed the framework.
[Xposed General] Jhoel04:
I already installed now but this is what happen when i open exposed framework. It says...

Xposed frameworked version 89.2 (systemless) is installed, but not active. Please check the logs for details.

Here is the log .

content://de.robv.android.xposed.installer.fileprovider/log_legacy/error.log: open failed: ENOENT (No such file or directory)

Pls. any one can help me.. Thanks in advance
[Xposed General] rhishisc:
Xposed installer showing Xposed framework is not installed. SDK 25, Android 7.1.2 , Magisk manager v16
[Xposed General] Ja_som:
Do you use the right Xposed Installer?
[Xposed General] Ricardo Flowers:
When I install xposed sdk 22 on my Android 5.1 by magisk after reboot it goes into bootloop. Does anyone know how to solve it?
[Xposed General] imPRAGMA:
I updated Magisk to v16.0, and installed Xposed SDK 24 from Magisk Repo on my S8 Exynos. I clicked reboot, and now its just frozen on the carrier logo screen. Its been a good 10-15 minutes already. What did I do wrong?
[Xposed General] Didgeridoohan:
https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magis...agisk_functionality_bootloop_loss_of_root_etc

You're not the first to report similar Samsung issues... The only thing you did wrong would possibly be to get a Samsung with the intent of modding it... :p

On a more serious note, someone earlier in the thread reported success with a custom ROM. That's about as far as I could help with the installation issue (I don't do Samsung).

To get out of the bootloop, check the link above.
[Xposed General] rhishisc:
SDK 25 is for android 7.1.x right? Then yeah.

What else could have gone wrong?
[Xposed General] Ja_som:
I mean Xposed Installer, the app, not the Xposed Framework.
[Xposed General] rhishisc:
My bad, i thought i had the right version from OP all this time. Should have re checked that before posting here. Thank you
[Xposed General] imPRAGMA:
Im not boot looping though. Anyhow, I went into ODIN mode, and tried loading a PDA/AP firmware. And it failed saying theres NO PIP partition (Which means installation has corrupted my phone massively). I also tried writing a CSC and it couldnt even start a write operation.

Luckily I have a backup from a few months ago, gonna restore it, and then im gonna fully stock firm my phone and backup.
[Xposed General] Ricardo Flowers:
That's not what I wanted to solve, I want to make xposed sdk 22 run by magisk, do you know how I can do this?
[Xposed General] iRashiD:
Any idea how to fix this
[Xposed General] Didgeridoohan:
Apologies. Your question made it sound like you wanted help on how to get out of the bootloop.

Does normal Xposed work on your device?

https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magisk/MagiskHide#hn_SafetyNet_API_error

But, remember that you can't pass SafetyNet fully with Xposed active.
[Xposed General] etofi:
I think you ask the false thread.

Try Magisk thread...
[Xposed General] Ricardo Flowers:
I apologize, yes the xposed works, however if I install by magisk it enters bootloop.
[Xposed General] Computoncio:
Go to Magisk Manager - > Settings - > channel Update - > Choose Stable

Phone: Redmi Note 4 - mido

Kernel: ElectraBlue Kernel 10.0

ROM : Resurrection Remix v6.0.0 [8.1.0][mido] 20180219

MODS: Dolby Atmos for Oreo Black 'n Cheese Edition - Unity 20180220-2 + ViPER4Android 2.5.0.5 Black 'n Cheese Edition - Unity 20180220-2 ,

Audio Modification Library AML,

Xposed v90.1 sdk27 beta3 topjohnwu,

Magisk v16.0 + Manager v5.6.0
[Xposed General] imPRAGMA:
I can confirm thats caused by Proxy/VPN settings or bad connection.
[Xposed General] Computoncio:
In OP it's says if Magisk xposed for sdk 22 and sdk 23 doesn't work use https://xdaforums.com/xposed/unofficial-xposed-samsung-lollipop-t3180960

Phone: Redmi Note 4 - mido

Kernel: ElectraBlue Kernel 10.0

ROM : Resurrection Remix v6.0.0 [8.1.0][mido] 20180219

MODS: Dolby Atmos for Oreo Black 'n Cheese Edition - Unity 20180220-2 + ViPER4Android 2.5.0.5 Black 'n Cheese Edition - Unity 20180220-2 ,

Audio Modification Library AML,

Xposed v90.1 sdk27 beta3 topjohnwu,

Magisk v16.0 + Manager v5.6.0
[Xposed General] imPRAGMA:
So I managed to recover my S8 and im now on fully stock, factory reset, im just about to go through all of the settings to get to the Home Menu. What should I do from here to get Xposed (If I have magisk)
[Xposed General] Ricardo Flowers:
My cell phone is not from Samsung but from Asus, can I install this version of xposed by magisk without problems?
[Xposed General] iRashiD:
I choose stable but still same error
[Xposed General] Bludwurst:
They were asking about the "Xposed Installer" app. Did you grab the one from the OP? Any other (sans dvdandroid's materialized Xposed Installer) won't work properly ("Xposed is installed but not active" & stuff).

edit: this thread moved way too fast (and I got ninja'd)
[Xposed General] imPRAGMA:
this thing is not working well, I went to stock once again, and its just now stuck on a black screen... Any ideas (S8)
[Xposed General] cambr1an:
I̶ ̶c̶a̶n̶'̶t̶ ̶f̶l̶a̶s̶h̶ ̶x̶p̶o̶s̶e̶d̶-̶v̶8̶7̶.̶3̶-̶s̶d̶k̶2̶3̶-̶t̶o̶p̶j̶o̶h̶n̶w̶u̶.̶z̶i̶p̶ ̶o̶n̶ ̶S̶a̶m̶s̶u̶n̶g̶ ̶g̶6̶1̶0̶y̶.̶ ̶I̶t̶ ̶s̶a̶y̶s̶ ̶u̶s̶e̶ ̶m̶a̶g̶i̶s̶k̶ ̶1̶4̶.̶0̶+̶.̶ ̶I̶ ̶h̶a̶v̶e̶ ̶M̶a̶g̶i̶s̶k̶ ̶1̶6̶.̶0̶.̶ ̶I̶ ̶t̶r̶i̶e̶d̶ ̶M̶a̶g̶i̶s̶k̶ ̶1̶4̶.̶0̶,̶ ̶s̶a̶m̶e̶ ̶e̶r̶r̶o̶r̶ ̶m̶e̶s̶s̶a̶g̶e̶.̶

EDIT: Never mind my previous comment. I was trying to flash the module via custom recovery. It needs to be flash within Magisk Manager.
[Xposed General] imPRAGMA:
So on my Samsung Galaxy S8 (SM-G950F) Exynos Variant, The systemless ZIP when flashed or using magisk installer, seems to actually cause it to STAY frozen on carrier screen (NOT bootloop!).

But the official non systemless Xposed works perfectly fine for me.

What?!
[Xposed General] Computoncio:
Try uninstall magisk in twrp with the Uninstaller and install again.

Have no more advices :(

Phone: Redmi Note 4 - mido

Kernel: ElectraBlue Kernel 10.0

ROM : Resurrection Remix v6.0.0 [8.1.0][mido] 20180219

MODS: Dolby Atmos for Oreo Black 'n Cheese Edition - Unity 20180220-2 + ViPER4Android 2.5.0.5 Black 'n Cheese Edition - Unity 20180220-2 ,

Audio Modification Library AML,

Xposed v90.1 sdk27 beta3 topjohnwu,

Magisk v16.0 + Manager v5.6.0
[Xposed General] spawnlives:
I don't know if it helps but I am using the s8 exynos version on stock Rom ( noghat 7.0 sdk 24 )

Am using latest magical version

Using latest exposed installer (version 3.1.5)

Using exposed framework version 89 all from rovo89 and everything is working ok
[Xposed General] imPRAGMA:
The one from Rovo 89 is the original non systemless one thoguh

---------- Post added at 01:33 AM ---------- Previous post was at 01:27 AM ----------

Did you flash xposed via the "Xposed Installer" app from this thread?

---------- Post added at 01:38 AM ---------- Previous post was at 01:33 AM ----------

OK that is SO trash. So, the Installation Instructions in OP says install via magisk's download modules section. DONT DO THIS. It just bootloops the **** out your system.

Download the Magisk version of Xposed Installer from OP, and just install inside of that after your rooted using Magisk... Sorted... Wow... Nice instructions.
[Xposed General] Didgeridoohan:
Ok... Now you're just being a bit of a douche...

If you install Xposed from the Xposed installer (doesn't matter if you use the one from this thread, it's just modified to recognise systemless Xposed, nothing else) it'll install the original system version of Xposed. And we've already established that that version won't cause the same issues.

For some reason the Magisk Xposed module doesn't work on some devices (Samsung, I'm looking at you). Since [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION] is kind of busy with military duty for the next few months I very much doubt this'll be a high priority. Sorry...
[Xposed General] imPRAGMA:
Ahh I see, I thought it was the systemless version :/ Guess not.
[Xposed General] teknomedic:
LG V30 (us998) Rooted

TWRP

Android 7.1.2

Magisk v16

Installed Xposed systemless (sdk25) via Magisk.

Safety net check now fails.... Is there a way to pass that check with Xposed installed?
[Xposed General] Ja_som:
No, only with disabled Xposed module.
[Xposed General] zevozki:
So if i want to use banking app, i will disable xposed then run banking app doing transactions then closing it then re enable xposed, will that works whenever i need to pass safetynet temporary?
[Xposed General] Ja_som:
Yes, but you also need to reboot after disable/enable Xposed. Your banking app needs passed safetynet, using Magisk Hide is not enough?
[Xposed General] zevozki:
Thanks for swift replay. Rebooting after disable and enable is manageable since I will need it only once I need to do tranx.

Currently I am using original system exposed and even if uninstalled xposed and disable root the banking app detect root/debugging. So I assume if i used hidden magisk will still be detected by safetynet as the main thread said. However if disable xposed temporarily can fix that then I will install magisk now
[Xposed General] NikonD750:
For my banking app the only think I have to do in order to work is to check it in Magisk hide.

No need of SafetyNet pass thus disabling/enabling xposed.

I don't know if this depends on specific Banking app.
[Xposed General] zevozki:
Thank you for the info, its worth trying.
[Xposed General] Thunderflame2:
I installed this and I can no longer pass NetSaftey

I installed xposed form magisk and I can no longer pass Net Safety. Is there anything I need to do. (PS I have the Pixel 1 XL on RR rom)
[Xposed General] Ja_som:
Yes, read the first post, there is a clear statement about SafetyNet.
[Xposed General] Slim2none4u:
I thought it was a bootloop also but it only rebooted twice then booted normally...
[Xposed General] Ricardo Flowers:
Not working