yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Xposed General] rosboy:
Hi, I'm on LG G5 D850. When I got the device I unlocked the bootloader and installed TWRP. Flashed Magisk 13 Beta and installed xposed SDK23 V87.0. Everything was working fine. I upgraded to Magisk 13.3 and upgraded through Magisk Manager to xposed V87.1, Everything was still working fine.

Problem started when I flashed a magisk module (busybox) that disabled xposed. Now I can't get it to reinstall. I tried everything possible. With removing magisk completely inbetween. I haven't received a firmware update or any system modifications.
[Xposed General] divineBliss:
If you are referring to the Android security patch level, then that's incorrect as I have a March 2017 security patch level and subject Xposed Framework working with Magisk/Manager v12/v4.4.3 on my Huawei phone with Android 6.0.1.
[Xposed General] Artim_96:
I'm not incorrect, that means your ROM developer didn't include the patches from December that forced the device into a bootloop
[Xposed General] divineBliss:
So you claim a factory ROM with Android security patch level of March 2017 doesn't include post November 2016 security updates, really? :confused: You said everything after November 2016, didn't you?
[Xposed General] Artim_96:
At least that specific patch, yes. The guys that made XPosed for Nougat obviously found a (partial) workaround, but for all I know Google introduced in November and December update each a patch to cause those bootloops. Rovo fixed the one from November but there was never one for December. And it would make no sense for Google to suddenly remove them later
[Xposed General] divineBliss:
Well "everything later than November 2016 will have bootloops" is still inaccurate based on the ROM I'm using being newer than November 2016 and Xposed working - I'll just leave it at that and maybe others with newer ROMs can provide additional data on Xposed working with their ROMs.
[Xposed General] EzioTheDeadPoet:
From where should I take my Xposed installation zip from magisk manager or the Matrial Xposed Installer app ?
[Xposed General] EViollet:
This is totally off topic.

But, just to clarify things, there was a bootloop caused by Xposed after the November patches. But this was fixed and is no longer an issue.

However, suhide was also affected by the November patches and there is no fix at this time. So installing suhide on a post November 2016 ROM will result in a bootloop. It isn't linked to Xposed.

Regards
[Xposed General] EzioTheDeadPoet:
Does this also apply to Magisk Hide ?
[Xposed General] EViollet:
Nope.

Magisk is something completely different.
[Xposed General] divineBliss:
I used the file downloaded through Magisk Manager app and installed it using TWRP.
[Xposed General] rosboy:
Finally got it working. Started with a stock boot image. Flashed magisk 12 in twrp, before rebooting flashed xposed sdk23 v87.1 downloaded from magisk manager. Rebooted afterwards upgraded magisk to v13.3.

Finally everything works again
[Xposed General] ch3mn3y:
Just tried to flash this on my Moto X PLay with Resurrection Remix 5.7.4 (6.0.1), but after installing latest available version through MAGISK Manager, got bootloop. Tried 3 times. Any idea? MAGISK is 13.3, chosen Xposed was SDK23.
[Xposed General] digiscales:
Deleted
[Xposed General] ch3mn3y:
Used 87.0 downloaded using Material Installer and it works fine :)
[Xposed General] divineBliss:
If you look in the Magisk Manager - Modules tab, does it show/confirm you have the topjohnwu Systemless Xposed v87.0 or v87.1 installation? I see v87.1 in that screen - the latest version.
[Xposed General] ch3mn3y:
Its 87.0.
[Xposed General] spartan02sparte:
When can we expect an arrival on 7.1.2?
[Xposed General] ch3mn3y:
When there be Fully working one. Right now there are 3 unofficial test versions. PurifyOS works best, even MAGISK one works fine (tested on Xperia Z2 with RR 5.8.3, only AppSettings for MM tested).
[Xposed General] acaii:
This mod not support sdk25? On nougat 7.1.1?
[Xposed General] jackblk:
Just upgraded my Magisk to 13.3 and then xposed to 87.1 andddddd i got a boot loop.

Maybe i should try using 87.0
[Xposed General] ch3mn3y:
[MENTION=305493]acal[/MENTION]i

This is "official" systemless Xposed. And as there is no official nonMAGISK Xposed, than there is no "official" systemless one.

But still You have 3 unofficial builds and PurifyOS's works - both systtem and MAGISK build (usimg MAGISK one right now).

However almost none of modules work - from all modules I used on MM, only AppSettings works [emoji14]

[MENTION=7634090]jackblk[/MENTION]

Had same problem - 87.0 works fine.

Sent using XT1562 - Resurrection Remix/Optimus Kernel
[Xposed General] divineBliss:
So you downloaded and installed topjohnwu Systemless Xposed Framework v87.0 using the Material Design Xposed Installer app by DVDandroid? If I understood correctly, then I didn't know that was possible to do.

---------- Post added at 10:19 AM ---------- Previous post was at 10:14 AM ----------

Or go to the Magisk support thread and read about all the people who got problems/bootlooping after updating to Magisk v13.3 - which is probably the case for you too.

Systemless Xposed v87.1 works for me and I don't recall it being a problem for anyone else, but you can confirm that by seeing if v87.0 fixes your bootlooping issue.
[Xposed General] muhaki:
I used the systemless xposed sdk24, got into bootloop.

I've got x64, with magisk 13.3 installed.

Now i cant uninstall xposed, when i try to uninstall, it says:

Update process ended with ERROR: 2

Error installing zip file PurifyOS-XposedMagisk-Uninstaller.zip

Any fix?=
[Xposed General] teddy0209:
You're in the wrong thread... To remove the module, look for mount magisk, flash it in twrp then navigate to the magisk directory, delete xposed there...
[Xposed General] muhaki:
How should that be done? :)
[Xposed General] jackblk:
Tried 87.0 systemless, still no luck, stuck in bootloop. I will try normal xposed then :(.

Edit: got passed logo, optimizing apps, so i think im ok with normal xposed. Still, i prefer systemless :(
[Xposed General] muhaki:
How did u fix bootloop?
[Xposed General] Sam Nakamura:
Download the mount_magisk zip from here, flash it with twrp, now go to twrp file manager and search /magisk, open it and delete "xposed" (or any magisk module you previously installed from recovery)...

That's actually your life insurance when dealing with magisk, especially when you don't want to lose all settings by magisk_uninstaller...

https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/collection-magisk-modules-t3445257
[Xposed General] ch3mn3y:
[MENTION=8238008]muhaki[/MENTION]

Had same problem on my Z2 with RR 5.8.3. Only way is to restore /data partition, as it restores MAGISK.img without Xposed. Uninstaller won't work. If You don't have backup, You have to remove MAGISK using it's uninstaller and start over with fresh MAGISK (no modules).
[Xposed General] BarrySamuels:
I have discovered a little more although it's not particularly useful.

I downgraded to Magisk v12 and Magisk Manager v4 then installed the Xposed module using Magisk. The device then booted without problems but there was no evidence of the Xposed Installer anywhere so I couldn't install any Xposed modules. I've now gone back to Magisk v!3 and I'll wait hopefully for developments.

I hope it doesn't take too much longer as I'm 81 now and who knows how long I've got! :o
[Xposed General] ch3mn3y:
Maybe try to use Xposed systemless version 87.0? In MAGISK Manager available is 87.1 and I too have bootloop after flashing it. However with 87.0 (available through Material Xpsoed Installer) everything works fine.

I have MAGISK 13.3.
[Xposed General] divineBliss:
I had topjohnwu Systemless Xposed v87.0 installed and unsuccessfully tried to update to v87.1 using Magisk Manager.

What worked for me to get v87.1 successfully installed was to download-only the Xposed v87.1 zip through Magisk Manager, then from TWRP flash the Xposed Uninstaller zip then flash the Xposed v87.1 zip to install Xposed v87.1.

Maybe following that method will help someone else vs trying to update to v87.1 on top of v87.0 from Magisk Manager vs using TWRP.

In other words, don't try to update to v87.1 while v87.0 is still installed. :)

Doing the above method should not require reinstalling you Xposed modules either, as you won't be wiping your data partition.
[Xposed General] jackblk:
Okay so i have to use 87.0 normal version.

Systemless wont work with my lastest Magisk anymore. Dunno why, bootloop every time :(
[Xposed General] rosboy:
I had similar issues. Please see my solution above. You need to first upgrade xposed while on earlier magisk and then upgrade magisk
[Xposed General] divineBliss:
That sounds crazy vs uninstalling Xposed framework from TWRP, then installing the newer version from TWRP if someone has already updated to the latest Magisk & Manager.
[Xposed General] BarrySamuels:
Another step forward. I tried the advice given by ch3mn3y above and now my device will boot with Magisk v13 and the Xposed Framework installed. I then installed XPrivacy, which is the main reason for wanting Xposed, but although it is enabled in the Xposed modules list it tells me it can't find the privacy service and suggests that I reboot which I've done twice already. :(

If anyone has any suggestions I'm all ears.
[Xposed General] rosboy:
I tried every possible combination including flashing in twrp. This was the only thing that worked for me.
[Xposed General] Didgeridoohan:
[MENTION=7125933]Sam Nakamura[/MENTION]

Just a heads-up... That's the outdated module collection. You want this link: https://xdaforums.com/apps/magisk/collection-magisk-modules-v2-t3575758

(The Mount Magisk script from that thread should still work though, but it's gonna be the only zip from there that does.)
[Xposed General] Sam Nakamura:
Thanks, very welcome.. :highfive:
[Xposed General] Tomixxon:
When are we going to get it for Android 7.1.1? I really can't wait :D
[Xposed General] :
Just for you, in 10 minutes !
[Xposed General] ch3mn3y:
Haha. Love it [emoji14]

Sent using D6503 - Resurrection Remix/RR N
[Xposed General] UpdateYourBrowser:
Does SDK23 work on 7.0 April sec. patch on S6 Edge rooted with magisk.,
[Xposed General] Artim_96:
Sure. Just go flash it right away... Just flash SDK23 on a SDK24 ROM...
[Xposed General] divineBliss:
Just like it says in post #1 ;)
[Xposed General] bkayy:
Got boot loop on nougat 6p using sdk25 one
[Xposed General] Artim_96:
What a surprise genius...
[Xposed General] BarrySamuels:
I have since discovered that although I have installed a number of Xposed modules, including XPrivacy, none of them work. For example if I start Gravity Box it says "waiting for GravityBox System" and then "GravityBox System not found, exiting".

So everything for the Xposed Framework is in place and I can install and uninstall modules, enable and disable modules but nothing actually works. :(
[Xposed General] divineBliss:
Does Xposed Installer app Framework tab confirm that Xposed is running? What do you see in the Log tab? Any errors?
[Xposed General] BarrySamuels:
I don't have tabs, per se, but there is a log option in the menu and if I click that I get a popup which says 'loading' which goes on for a long time then a meassage which says log/data/data/de.robv.android.xposed.installer/log/error.log : open failed (No such file or directory).

When I Start the Xposed Installer there is an 'Xposed Status ' switch which is on and and big green tick below. The message underneath says that it is active.
[Xposed General] divineBliss:
Did you enable the modules and reboot? Check the Modules option list.
[Xposed General] BarrySamuels:
Yes I did and rebooted two or three times but no luck. I've just re-checked the modules list to make sure and there are 6 modules installed all of them enabled.
[Xposed General] divineBliss:
The Xposed Installer log should have had something in it. I would flash the Xposed Uninstaller zip from TWRP, then reinstall Xposed framework with the installer zip - both are in post #1.
[Xposed General] BarrySamuels:
I have now uninstalled and then re-installed the xposed framework (87.0) using TWRP and it makes no difference. There is still nothing in the log and the modules are there but don't work.
[Xposed General] C.3.S.4.R:
There's any future updates for systemless android 7.0? I wanna flash the official 7.0 Ota update to my Samsung Galaxy a5 2016 but the only xposed framework now is unofficial and only for the non TouchWiz based systems.
[Xposed General] ch3mn3y:
[MENTION=5293264]C.3.S.4.R[/MENTION]

Why ask here? It's only systemless mod of official Xposed. If there is no Xposed for 7.x, than there is no systemless version of it, isn't it?
[Xposed General] C.3.S.4.R:
Well the xposed version for 6.0 and lower for TouchWiz it's based on Wanam's unofficial xposed. There's no need to be so sassy.
[Xposed General] ch3mn3y:
There are unofficial Xposed's (3 I know about) for 7.x (both system and systemless), but none I know works with Touchwiz (at least that's what I know).
[Xposed General] divineBliss:
The fact that there's nothing in the Xposed Installer log is concerning.

If you look in Magisk Manager app Modules list, do you have 87.1 or 87.0 and is the SDK version correct for your device architecture? If you don't have 87.1, download it only using Magisk Manager, then using TWRP uninstall 87.0 and install 87.1 using zips. Check the TWRP log for errors during all this.
[Xposed General] BarrySamuels:
I have 87.0 and sdk23 and I'm running Marshmallow. When I installed 87.1 before it prevented the phone from booting. I'll try it once again and report back.
[Xposed General] BarrySamuels:
I installed 87.1 and when I rebooted the phone did boot this time! I can't explain that. Magisk modules tells me I have Xposed Framework (SDK 23) 87.1 but when I run the Xposed Installer I see that the status is enabled but it displays "Xposed Framework version 87.0 is active"

I installed the Material Design Installer when I installed Xposed Installer 87.0 so should I be changing the Xposed Installer too?
[Xposed General] divineBliss:
Great :) . No, you'll still see v87.0 in the Xposed Installer app. Anything in the Xposed Installer log after you enabled your modules and rebooted? Modules working now?

Don't forget the thanks button for all posts/posters that help you :) .
[Xposed General] BarrySamuels:
Sorry I forgot the bad news - modules still not working. Xposed Installer log still empty. Still it's another small step forward inasmuch as the phone will now boot with 87.1 which it wouldn't before.

I do appreciate your help anyway especially when you are the only person to have responded to my posts. I'll press the button now anyway. :)
[Xposed General] divineBliss:
Argh! My last idea is uninstall Magisk v13.x and try v12.0 - but that's a lot of work and I'm not even sure it's the problem :( - I hope you have TWRP backups.

Does anyone with your model phone and ROM have this Xposed working?
[Xposed General] BarrySamuels:
I doubt that anyone on XDA has my phone let alone Xposed with it. I have a Cubot Max. I have always installed Xposed and XPrivacy on my past phones (last one was a Lenovo P2) and have never had any problems.

P.S. I have just seen that selinux may need to be set to permissive on boot. I don't know what the setting is on my phone or how to change it but it's interesting.
[Xposed General] thrasher194com:
Thanks, got it to work on my device.

Sent from my rooted Motorola XT1609
[Xposed General] divineBliss:
I don't know where you found that or if that advice is specific to your device, but mine are all set to enforcing and I personally don't think it's a good idea to change that in the interest of security.
[Xposed General] Fild5x:
So you are using RR? There are several modules that are working on my phone. May depend on which ones you use.
[Xposed General] BarrySamuels:
I saw it on a German forum (Google Translate) where a number of people were complaining of the symptoms that I am getting and all with Cubot phones although assorted models. I don't know what that might mean.

I tried setting selinux to permissive but it didn't change anything and I have reset it now to enforcing. I've decided to put that phone aside temporarily until such time as updates might appear and I've gone back to my Lenovo P2 where everthing Xposed works as it should.

You were the only person who tried to help which is very kind and I appreciate it. :good:
[Xposed General] Artim_96:
Well, it probably only looked like it's still enforcing because Magisk uses a method to hide permissive SELinux. Because for all I know permissive is causing SN to fail.
[Xposed General] Ibuprophen:
Please correct me if I'm wrong [MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION]...

I believe that Magisk does a type of rerouting for the device to work with the SELinux State.

Whereas the SELinux has a traditional way for a device to handle it and Magisk uses an alternative way where the SN doesn't know this and thinks that it's still in Enforcing Mode.

Without going technical, I think I explained it okay... LMAO :) .

______________

PLEASE NOTE: I welcome any member to help with further valuable information/clarification for any of my posts.
[Xposed General] Artim_96:
Exactly. At least that's what he said when releasing the version introducing that feature
[Xposed General] biebie29:
as soon as i install framework syfetynet is gone no modules installed yet
[Xposed General] ch3mn3y:
[MENTION=7140709]biebie29[/MENTION]

Turn it off and SN will be back. Unfotunately You cannot have Xposed and pass SafetyNet same time.
[Xposed General] divineBliss:
Please do not quote long posts like that unnecessarily again. Added absolutely no value. Thanks :) .
[Xposed General] biebie29:
but there is a systemless version of exposed
[Xposed General] ch3mn3y:
Yeah, I know. But it still breaks SafetyNet. However at least it can be disabled for passing the test (You cannot do it with system mode Xposed).
[Xposed General] Mister Tetris:
I have Magisk installed, and it is working perfectly. I've installed the Xposed Framework Installer (Material Design) and I went to the Magisk Manager and installed Xposed Framework SDK23 from there. When booting my phone, it was stuck for one hour. Fixed it by flashing Mount Magisk in TWRP and removing the Xposed folder. But how do I get Xposed Framework to work on my phone?

Phone: OnePlus X
[Xposed General] Ibuprophen:
Just a friendly FYI (in case you weren't aware of it)...

If your looking to post a question for a member, in any thread, (in this case, the OP Developer) you don't need to reply to the whole OP to call-out/get the attention of the Developer.

All you need to do is place this "@" symbol together at the beginning of the developers (or any members) member name.

For example... for a call-out to me, it would look like [MENTION=4828250]Ibuprophen[/MENTION] and, for the developer, just replace my member name with topjohnwu.

I wasn't sure if you were aware of this because some posts with the OP's used as a reply, can be extremely long and take up a huge amount of space.

If you were aware of this then... What a lovely day it is... LMAO :)

______________

PLEASE NOTE: I welcome any member to help with further valuable information/clarification for any of my posts.
[Xposed General] TheGoD:
Same problem for me with Note 4 (910F Qualcom) using the latest Magisk and stock rom.
[Xposed General] topstarnec:
exactly the same happened to my galaxy s6 edge plus. However it can be installed from the Marterial Design Xposed Installer. (choose systemless)
[Xposed General] teddy0209:
Flashing in recovery didn't work?
[Xposed General] kavinferrara:
It happened for me too when i installed the SDK23 downloaded from Magisk module downloads. I installed systemless xposed from material app. It works fine.
[Xposed General] xanthrax:
Guys , please throw the needles in the sharp-box before posting/answering on the threads ...

thread cleaned , a bit ...

Dan - forum moderator
[Xposed General] BarrySamuels:
Further to the problems I've been having in trying, and failing, to get Xposed to work in Magisk even though everything appears to be in order I have discovered, after doing some searching online, that many other people with a variety of 'phones are having the same problem.

It appears to be a fault in the firmware which, as I understand it, causes selinux to malfunction. This can be fixed with a little utility called Grorkmod and, having been through the recommended process, I now have a working Xposed. :D :laugh:

Grorkmod: https://xdaforums.com/elephone-p9000/development/mod-grorkmod-eragon-aerom-v0-5-beta-t3395667

It is important to start with a clean factory ROM. I tried it without and it wouldn't work. Reflashing the factory ROM as part of the procedure got it working.

Guess who is a happy bunny?
[Xposed General] Sehab084:
help with two question

official xposed vs systemless on (i have miui rom) i know the advantage but what i dont know is that

1 any performance difference ( are they the same or the official one will be better)

2 which one is more compatible or works without any bugs in every app (will use gravitybox xposed addition lucky patcher etc)

3 how do i install systemless on miu 8 any link (i have redmi note 4)?
[Xposed General] Artim_96:
1 and 2 there aren't much differences. It's based on Wanam's XPosed so it's compatible with Samsung devices by default. Additionally there are only a few added devices but it's too long ago that I could remember. MIUI devices aren't on that list, however somewhere in this forum somebody made a version for them. It's long ago but since then, official XPosed wasn't continued any further. So if your device is still running Android 6 you can use that. If it's 7 there is little to no chance. XPosed for Nougat is still highly experimental, you'd need to find a ROM which is explicitly compatible. And still there most likely is no systmless version of it
[Xposed General] link22534:
I'll get the logcat but Xposed fails to work on my alcatel idol 4 rooted 6.0.1 it won't uninstall too lol
[Xposed General] link22534:
Don't know if I did it right but here it is
[Xposed General] link22534:
I just want to unistall because it annoys me that it is there lol I tried uninstalling from magisk and the exposed installer app
[Xposed General] Artim_96:
Just use a file manager and delete its folder in /magisk

Or use uninstaller from OP
[Xposed General] Sam Nakamura:
To less information, which android version, magisk, in specific Dolby Atmos?

See

https://xdaforums.com/xposed/unofficial-systemless-xposed-t3388268/post72440385

Try searching, that's how I solved it back in the days :)
[Xposed General] Adzkii:
6.0.1 MM cm13 magisk v13.6

i installed magisk version of xposed framework

also have the latest material xposed installer installed, not sure what the issue can be

i dont have dolby

i have been searching for 2 days i tried all solution i have found but luck. i also looked into data/data/xposed for permissions

shows nothing in the logs section....
[Xposed General] Sam Nakamura:
So, have you tried the usual suggestion like described in this post... Of course you should reboot after deleting the "disabled" file :) also I'd go back to stable magisk 13.3, it's a think of common sense to use the latest stable and not the beta branch in case of issues...

https://xdaforums.com/xposed/official-xposed-lollipop-t3030118/post59651947
[Xposed General] Adzkii:
nothing in that folder, i seen this post
[Xposed General] Sam Nakamura:
Sorry, I can't advise you more than going back to stable magisk to see if it makes a difference...

You can also try both methods, systemless (via magisk manager) and system... Rovo89's xposed for nougat should soon be available, maybe update the rom to lineageOS as cm13 is now dead for quite some time now... Other than that I run out of ideas
[Xposed General] totalcmdext:
It isn't possible to make to work Magisk 13.3 with Lollilop 5.0.2 Vanilla.

It is installed the SDK21 but not activate it after reboot.

With the MAgisk v12 everything is working properly.
[Xposed General] Artim_96:
Wasn't it already mentioned that there are Printen

Problems on 5.0? I think a few days ago someone posted a link to a GitHub bug report
[Xposed General] totalcmdext:
Please could you provide the link?