yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Xposed General] Slim2none4u:
Working on mine.

I'm telling you it's not a bootloop. it's your process. You're not being patient and letting xposed do it's thing during the start up process. It does seem to hang and it will reboot, but it's not a bootloop.

I did the same thing. Thought it was looping,or stuck, pulled battery, started over several times. Then I finally just let it sit and do it's thing and reboot a few times and it booted up.
[Xposed General] Badger50:
Pulled the battery?! Very lucky man for sure! :good::good:
[Xposed General] Ricardo Flowers:
After the installation I left more than 5 minutes, I took the battery and waited another 5 minutes and I called, I stayed more than 20 minutes waiting and nothing.
[Xposed General] divineBliss:
Try waiting 30 minutes. Yes, it can be frustrating and seem like the phone won't boot, but it needs more time on some devices than others.
[Xposed General] doenx:
NVM seems to fix itself
[Xposed General] PPintoo:
Welp, I also left my phone (Samsung S7 edge, Android 7.0) loading for what must have been over 30 minutes to no use.

Has anyone actually managed to get the systemless version, via magisk manager, working on a Samsung phone?
[Xposed General] jwds1978:
I'm using it without issue on my SM-N900W8 (LineageOS 15.1 — Android 8.1.0).
[Xposed General] Fild5x:
No problem on a500h galaxy
[Xposed General] Tecalote:
Solved, found it in attachments in OP :)
[Xposed General] flyologist30:
After I followed the guide and installed systemless xposed this is what's happening to my magisk...

Help please
[Xposed General] rickysidhu_:
Magisk is installed, safety net isn't passing which is normal
[Xposed General] flyologist30:
So I should be okay??

---------- Post added at 03:20 AM ---------- Previous post was at 03:20 AM ----------

Is that okay then???
[Xposed General] rickysidhu_:
Yes, unless you rely on things like banking apps/payment
[Xposed General] grymkmb:
Yes, you cannot pass SafetyNet with Xposed installed. If the installer shows it is installed and your modules work, then everything is fine.
[Xposed General] vo-1:
For make it works
[Xposed General] petrusrpenha:
Lenovo Vibe k5

my lenovo vibe K5 does not activate the Xposed 85.7 how do I work?
[Xposed General] hgoldner:
Yeah, the problem is that it is hard to tell which file is the right one from the XDA app. I downloaded a different file and it did take. Thanks.
[Xposed General] knpk13:
[MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION]

You can add to the OP that works on the oneplus devices. :victory:

Tested on my OP2.

And someone else posted that it works on the OP1 as well. I expect it to work on the op3/opX as well.

I am using official CM, so systemless isn't really an advantage (in terms of OTA atleast), unless there are any other advantages.(I don't use Android pay either) But still, just wanted to let you know it works.

Boot time seems slightly longer though?

[MENTION=4636930]Yash Doctor[/MENTION]

Did you get it working on your OP2?
[Xposed General] Kusoo:
Can be used on android N ?
[Xposed General] pbeckmann:
Hey.

AFAIK there is no closed version for Android N. So no there is even no systemless closed for n....

Greetings
[Xposed General] Blackscorpion3:
Glad to see it worked for you.
[Xposed General] aleasto:
LG G2 here. I tried latest zip but it breaks Boot certification verify. I tried re-bumping boot image but nothing changes.
[Xposed General] teddy0209:
Did flashing systemless supersu work for you?
[Xposed General] tartanpion:
I try to make a systemless android system for OTA with a samsung galaxy note 4. I can have root, xposed, adaway, busybox with systemless : tested and operational. For trwp i'm trying to use "fastboot boot twrp.img" for not flash twrp / OTA. But i have realized that i can't use fastboot with samsung but just odin or heimdall. Is it a way to have the "fastboot boot" command with this softwares ?
[Xposed General] Artim_96:
No and I doubt there will ever will. To use fastboot the bootloader has to be unlocked, but on Samsung devices you can't do it. With the download mode they're at least kinda open (except us devices) but it's completely different to a truly open bootloader. Try to use FlashFire for everything possible but if you need to use TWRP the only chance could be to flash it but flash the recovery.img found in the system update file you can get from sammobile through twrp before making an OTA update. Or try to use FlashFire to flash the OTA and tick "Preserve recovery". But for me it's not working. I already tried flashing an OTA on my Note 4 through FlashFire since it always says the zip is corrupted.

Maybe it works for you (OTAs are saved under /data/fota and you have to take the flash firmware option to find the zip in FlashFire), I seem to still oversee something on making the device completely systemless since SafetyNet helper fails. Systemless root let's it still pass it and I don't throw out bloat from /system anymore but freeze it with Titanium backup, but somewhere between rooting and finishing freezing apps (before even flashing XPosed) something lets SafetyNet fail and I have no clue what it is.

PS: is SafetyNet Helper passing for you, even with Busybox? I let it install in /su/xbin so it shouldn't affect systemless but something has to be the reason for me.
[Xposed General] aleasto:
I am using latest systemless supersu, yes. Or do you mean if I tried re-flashing it over?
[Xposed General] Citizen_Snips:
Had some issues with that happening for me in the past as well. Right now I have systemless root (SuperSU 2.74-2) and systemless xposed on my N6P. Disabling and rebooting and I pass SafetyNet check as I should.

I've also passed the check previously by installing busybox to /su/xbin as you mentioned. However there's always been some issues and it's a pain to get to work. The easiest way to get working busybox, hands down, is just to flash the busybox zip by [MENTION=4544860]osm0sis[/MENTION] found here;

http://xdaforums.com/showthread.php?t=2239421

It has also been shown that certain build.prop modifications will cause a SafetyNet fail as well as a non stock DPI. That's all I can remember for now, but I can dig around and see if there's anything else.
[Xposed General] mikeszf:
Quick question, why my xposed got erased when I replaced the system partition while updating the phone with the stock one? I kept the root but lost the xposed :confused:
[Xposed General] fatspirit:
Well, that's the way it should be. xposed.img is placed on /data. I wonder how supersu survives (:
[Xposed General] tartanpion:
Don't even know what is safety net :rolleyes:

I have try to make a OTA with flasfire, no success because twrp.

Is it a way to install supersu without a modded recovery ?

I have try to install the superuser.apk from the common directory of betasupersu.zip but it says no su binary installed. Can i do that with adb and how ? or with the original recovery ?

After i can use flashfire but need root first....
[Xposed General] Artim_96:
No, SafetyNet is the API Android Pay and others use to verify the device is not manipulated. So only if it passes (with XPosed deactivated) you can be sure no change you made is detected and OTAs should work as long as the recovery is untouched.

For rooting without Custom Recovery you have luck, you can use CF Autoroot (download the zip for your file from https://autoroot.chainfire.eu/, unpack it, open the ODIN exe, klick on "AP" and navigate to the directory with the unpacked zip where it should find a .tar.md5 file. Boot your device to download mode, connect it to your computer - Odin should say added - and klick start.) Then just wait till it reboots to your system, then you are rooted. It will reboot a few times, that's normal
[Xposed General] tartanpion:
I doubt that with cf autoroot the su is systemless : it's just the supersu beta at this time. Any other idea to install su without a custom recovery?
[Xposed General] Artim_96:
It is. It uses the 2.74 beta since there is no non-beta for Android 6.0. I'm using it myself.
[Xposed General] ldeveraux:
Since when do Samsung devices not have unlocked bootloader capability? S5 is unlocked.
[Xposed General] flyologist30:
I need my banking apps lol but I don't do android pay... With xposed you can't use your banking apps?
[Xposed General] Drzhivagolikesandroid:
You can use some banking apps.

Not all.
[Xposed General] flyologist30:
Okay thank you. Are you using magisk or xposed... I kind of like magisk better
[Xposed General] Drzhivagolikesandroid:
Magisk and xposed.

---------- Post added at 04:02 AM ---------- Previous post was at 04:00 AM ----------

Try this to use android pay with Magisk and xposed.

https://xdaforums.com/galaxy-s8/sam...device-development/google-pay-xposed-t3762081
[Xposed General] DVError:
Every time i try to install xposed on oreo my phone become so lagy and making crushes "to know i used only one module (obb on sd)"
[Xposed General] dozzye:
install on xiaomi note3, miui9, android 7.1.1, sdk25, both topjohnwu and rovo89 ver, from v88.1 until v89.2, all bootloop......
[Xposed General] FenerKR:
same here. mi note 3, miuipro 8.3.15 with xposed sdk25 stuck in logo bootscreen
[Xposed General] MajinkenSword:
Chuwi Dual OS

Heya buddy! I have a Chuwi Hi10 Plus which is more or less the same as yours. Were you able to have this work? If so, mind sharing what you did? I'd really like to have Magisk and Xposed working on our Chuwis. :)
[Xposed General] arsaam khan:
How to uninstall magisk systemless xposed ????

any link !!! pls
[Xposed General] jenslody:
Just remove it in the MagiskManager (modules-section) and reboot.
[Xposed General] arsaam khan:
what if i am stuck on a bootloop and want to uninstall magisk xposed installer ???? :confused:
[Xposed General] jenslody:
Then you should write it.

If you can use TWRP, flash MountMagisk ("install" the zip in TWRP), it mounts the magisk.img to /magisk, then you can just remove the "xposed_xx"-folder from the folder or create an empty file named "disable" in it.

Alternatively you can create an empty (and hidden) file named ".disable_magisk" (note the dot) in "/cache" to force core-only mode and boot into the system, remove the module from Magisk, disable core-only mode and reboot.
[Xposed General] itandy:
Sony Xperia bootloop with latest March ROM

[MENTION=4470081]topjohnwu[/MENTION], I just upgraded my Xperia X Compact (Oreo) from previous version (34.4.A.2.19, Feb patch) to (34.4.A.2.32, March patch). Everything including Magisk (16.00 or 16.1 beta) works. But once I enabled Xposed my phone is unable to finish a reboot. I captured the logcat and it seems the boot process is almost finished. Other X Compact users are having similar problem so it seems to be an incompatibility issue between Xposed and our latest ROM.
[Xposed General] venomxob:
I am having exactly the same problem on Xperia X. Flashing of Magisk goes smoothly, even xposed framework flashes without any problems, but what I install the xposed installer 3.1.5 and reboot, I am getting a bootloop. I tried installing the installer, then flashing the framework and another way around with the same result, a bootloop.
[Xposed General] :
Does system version of xposed work? If not grab log and post on rovos git
[Xposed General] itandy:
In fact, I found that it's the same with system Xposed. So probabaly it's Xposed issue. Thanks for your advise!
[Xposed General] kjety:
Hi,

I would like to tell how I finally got Magisk, Xposed systemless and XprivacyLua running on my Samsung S7edge, SupermanROM v2.90, Nougat 7.0.

From the Magisk Downloads I searched Xposed Framework SDK24 (Nougat 7.0), clicked on the description and then tried to download the "xposedinstaller(3.1.5)" through the provided link. The link didn't work ("could not parse forum URL"), so I searched for the XposedInstaller_3.1.5-Magisk.apk on my own, downloaded and installed it manually.

Next step: the Xposed Framework. From the Magisk downloads the Framework didn't download (nothing happened) so I again searched and downloaded the Xposed_Framework_(SDK_24)-89.2_(Systemless).zip manually and install it via twrp. Juhu, Xposed installed. If I open it I get the green bar saying everything's ok.

Trying to download Xprivacy. Unfortunately also here there is no possibility to download the module:

The only thing I get is an endless progress bar and in the end "error 1004".

Again I bypassed the Repository, visited the xprivacy/Lua homepage and downloaded the eu.faircode.xlua_v109_71a415.apk from there. Install, activate and reboot was fine. My Xprivacy is running now.

What can't understand is, I cannot download any modules - neither from the Magisk nor from the Xposed Repository. Has anyone a hint? I've got AFWall+ installed and Magisk and Xposed configured accordingly. Some screens attached.

Best, kjety
[Xposed General] badabing2003:
You probably have AFwall blocking internet access.

Disable AFwall and see if it works, if it does then you know it's your settings.

Alternately you can enable logging in AFwall and see which apps are blocked internet access.
[Xposed General] venomxob:
The same situation with rovo's system xposed. The phone goes into bootloop.
[Xposed General] :
Yes then logs should be shared to rovo rather then topjohmnwu since he won't be able to help
[Xposed General] kjety:
Oh my god - this was easy. Enabled AFWall Log and found out that I had the system app "downloadmanager, downloads, mtp host" disabled.

Thanks a lot!

kjety
[Xposed General] problemathic:
i got the same issue here :)
[Xposed General] dragon3384:
Same problem here but with my Xperia XZ ... upgraded from 41.3.A.2.75 (February Security Patch) to 41.3.A.2.99 (March Security Patch) and as soon as i enable Xposed/Xposed Systemless i get an bootloop ... with 41.3.A.2.75 Xposed worked fine...
[Xposed General] N!ghtmare:
And i the same too
[Xposed General] nicolasmart:
Using latest Magisk 16.0 here, getting "Please install Magisk 15.0+" error when trying to install
[Xposed General] kodein:
Too same problem... Sony xperia performance
[Xposed General] andres_pr88:
I tried to install this version in a Redmi 4x global with Miui 9 Android 7.1 and didn't work. I had to use this https://xdaforums.com/xposed/unofficial-xposed-miui-9-t3688486
[Xposed General] itandy:
For the issue with latest Sony firmware (March security patch), I've opened an issue in github. You may follow the status there.

https://github.com/rovo89/Xposed/issues/339
[Xposed General] farscape1a:
+1
[Xposed General] DirkStorck:
Hi,

I have installed your module on my Android 7.0 based S8 Port Batman ROM. The Xposed-Installer says, that Xposed isn't installed but an app that checks if XPosed is installed (Sparkasse) says that it is installed. :confused:

Thank you!
[Xposed General] jenslody:
Are you aware, that only the installer from the OP of this thread and [MENTION=5345056]DVDandroid[/MENTION]'s material installer work with the systemless xposed ?

The original installer by rovo does not work !
[Xposed General] DirkStorck:
Hi, no I didn't but I had flashed this installer xposed-v89.2-sdk24-topjohnwu.zip from this thread. The module got installed and shows in Magisk app but the XPosed App says I don't have xposed installed.
[Xposed General] jenslody:
Maybe I was not clear.

I do not mean the installer of xposed, but the xposed companion app, that installs the xposed modules, see the first post of this thread.
[Xposed General] venomxob:
I have installed the installer from this thread and it works like a charm.
[Xposed General] DirkStorck:
Ah OK now I get you... Thanks will try that one [emoji3] [emoji106]
[Xposed General] FSLenviant:
Hi guys, always got this error when using Xposed installer 3.1.5

"Cannot read log/data/user_de/0/de.robv.android.xposed.installer/log/error.log (No such file or directory)"

Anyone have some solutions or workaround that error ?

Edit : restarted the phone and suddenly works .. thanks guys.. case close for now.
[Xposed General] shaiya87:
Hello! In the future, will it be planned to pass the safetynet check?
[Xposed General] Adam3Sixty:
It's impossible!!

Read the thread and search the forums, it is spoken about everywhere!!

Xposed = failed safetynet

Simple as that.
[Xposed General] DragonFire1024:
Not true at all. There's a module for that. Just search 'safety' in Xposed. Works on all my devices and all say safetynet pass.
[Xposed General] badabing2003:
Not true either.

The module name is Device Check, and it only passes ctsProfile, but fails basicIntegrity
[Xposed General] Adam3Sixty:
U can "hide" everything u want, but as soon as Xposed is installed, in whatever way u want to do it, it breaks SafetyNet.

No matter what u do, if u have Xposed installed, Android/Google Pay will never work.

This may change in the future, who knows, but right now, no matter what hiding or cloaking is done, this is still the easiest answer:

Xposed = failed SafetyNet.
[Xposed General] xdataibai:
It looks like xposed sdk25 cannot be installed with magisk 14, when I tried it in magisk manager, it says please use magisk 15+, when I tried to flash it in twrp, it failed. But I don't see it is mentioned for sdk 25. Is it the case? Magisk 14.3+ has issue with SD card (some phone says SD card is corrupted, but it is not, for example axon 7).thanks
[Xposed General] Eversmile23:
Inexplicable .

I had been using Xposed for SDK23 with Magisk support for tha last 2 months. Yesterday, I removed some system apps like Gmail, Maps etc to use them as user apps after downloading from Playstore. I succeeded, but I found X-posed is not active( I had to made 2 or 3 reboots for my said purpose). Then I tried to disable and reboot (in the Magisk Manager), then again enable and reboot the X-posed Framework. Still it was elusive. Then I uninstalled X-posed framework and X-posed installer apk, reinstalled both one by one and again went into the xposed installer app, still I found that "The framework is installed(Version 89.2), but not active message'. I went inside the log section in the settings, and found a message like this -- ' Cannot read log/data/data/de.robv.android..xposed.installer/log/error.log:open failed: ENOENT(No such file or directory). But I must say, that the 1st time I observed the problem, I had seen that there was a long list or descriptions in the log and I cleared them hoping that it will get generated again. But, it was not generated. How can I make the Xposed Framework active?
[Xposed General] kodein:
I just upgraded my Xperia X Performance (Oreo) from previous version (41.3.A.2.75, Feb patch) to (41.3.A.2.99, March patch). Everything including Magisk (16.00 or 16.1 beta) works. But once I enabled Xposed my phone is unable to finish a reboot. Has anyone solved this problem anymore?
[Xposed General] miuhen:
very useful. Thankyou for sharing freely. I'll test it as soon
[Xposed General] CoolDude4171:
Try to uninstall using the uninstaller from Xposed Installer App and then reboot. It always works for me after I disable and re-enable Xposed from magisk.
[Xposed General] Gelo31:
Hello, you could not fix the module for miui 9 to android 6 (non-system), almost everything works only when you install the module the curtain does not change (the battery sign, the switch icons in the shutter, etc.) The shutter is always from the built-in theme and although you use a third-party theme though no do not change. Do it if possible!

Здравствуйте, Вы не могли бы поправить модуль для miui 9 на андроид 6(несистемный), почти всё работает только когда ставишь модуль перестаёт меняться шторка (знак батареи,значки переключателей в шторке и тд) шторка всегда от встроенной теме и хот применяй стороннию тему хоть нет не меняеться .Сделайте пожалуйста если возможно!
[Xposed General] d_fens:
same problem for me
[Xposed General] AJ:
Does it work with Android P ??
[Xposed General] super-drone:
Read the title and the beginning of the OP
[Xposed General] 873578156:
谢谢，我发现了一些问题，在miui9.5上，我打开xposed installer之后会发生很大几率的闪退，但是偶尔还是可以打开的，具体需要再详细测试。如果需要日志，请联系我。

---------- Post added at 04:22 PM ---------- Previous post was at 04:18 PM ----------

Thank you. I found some problems. When I open xposed installer on miui9.5, there will be a great chance of flash back, but occasionally it can still be opened, and it needs to be tested in detail. If you need a log, please contact me.
[Xposed General] RedSkull23:
[delete please]
[Xposed General] 873578156:
Thank you. I found some problems. When I open xposed installer on miui9.5, there will be a great chance of flash back, but occasionally it can still be opened, and it needs to be tested in detail. If you need a log, please contact me.
[Xposed General] The_tomorrow_person:
Hi, my phone recently went into a bootloop after I activated a module and I fixed it by using TWRP's file manger and deleting Xposed Installer's data from

/data/data/de.robv.android.xposed.installer..

Can this harm my phone?

I know, it's a stupid question, but I'm curious..
[Xposed General] sumitarora2:
No, it don't but all modules will be disabled and you have to enable them again. So instead of deleting this file delete that module's apk from data/app/ which is causing this.
[Xposed General] Erulak:
Hi there, I'm running OOS Android 8.1 and installed Xposed through Magisk. The framework is installed ok but I can't install a module, I have an infinite loading bar and it says that the download is waiting ( I tried WiFi and LTE ).

Thanks.

Edit : nevermind, it worked after many retries
[Xposed General] The_tomorrow_person:
But I wasn't sure which one was causing it..

Thanks for the response!
[Xposed General] IanHodgson:
Sorry for the simple question, but I cannot find the Xposed installer in the attachments in OP. I can only see the actual xposed framework zip files. I don't think I need them because I flashed the framework through magisk. Our can I just get the Xposed installer APK from the Xposed thread? Appreciate any pointers.
[Xposed General] Ja_som:
Is there
[Xposed General] teddy0209:
It is there, along with the zips... Or you can use the material xposed installer by dvdandroid... But not the official one...
[Xposed General] q13017:
Tried once on my xiaomi mi mix 2 with miui9 oreo, it won't boot. Stick on the second screen.
[Xposed General] leblvin:
I have the same problem with SDK 26 on mny OnePlus 3 using Magisk 16.0 and 16.3

No logs to give because it stays empty.
[Xposed General] Eversmile23:
Fortunately it is working again.

Fortunately, all things are working alright now. I do not remember, though How it worked. MAy be you can still try disabling and again enabling ( or uninstalling, clearing memory cache, dalvik cache and re-installing type of things). Just suggesting, can not confirm that it would certainly work.
[Xposed General] l4mp4:
how to uninstall it when my Xiaomi MI6 is bootlooping. Tried to download uninstaller for arm and arm64 but doesn't working. Every time bootloop
[Xposed General] irfankamal:
I installed Xposed through magisk and installed modified apk as per instructions but the only problem is that my magisk is not bypassing safety net...... please tell me any solution.
[Xposed General] Darke5tShad0w:
Please read the first post.

You cannot pass safety net with xposed enabled in magisk.
[Xposed General] irfankamal:
Tried everything...but the modified apk provided by developer was not working for me...as it was showing that cannot load zip files and yes I installed it directly from magisk
[Xposed General] Darke5tShad0w:
Please post exactly what you are trying to and list the apks.

There is no way to pass safetynet with xposed enabled in magisk, again it says so in big red letters in the first post.
[Xposed General] jwds1978:
That's an intermittent repo connectivity issue.
[Xposed General] Didgeridoohan:
The Xposed uninstaller won't work on a systemless install. You need to remove the Magisk module:

https://www.didgeridoohan.com/magis...agisk_functionality_bootloop_loss_of_root_etc
[Xposed General] Guivre:
I can't get SDK27 to install on 8.1 (Pixel XL). I've installed the modified XposedInstaller in the OP, then tried to run the systemless install via Magisk Manager, and it keeps coming back with the same error: "Please use Magisk v15+!" I'm already using v16 though.

I tried to flash it manually through TWRP and get "ERROR: 1" and it fails.

Any ideas?