yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Magisk] FeraVolt:
I don't use twitter, so replying to arter97 on his post (https://twitter.com/arter97/status/1228058860612546560) here.

Lil intro..

First of all, I don't even know him personally, he never contacted me or my friends, advising or pointing on mistakes or whatever. And so I don't understand why he publically offends me & my work.

This is what you should know about his personality first. This type of behavior kinda reminds me YaroST.

Anyway.. I am not going to be rude as him. If I have any mistakes in my work, I will inspect 'em, admit & fix if any. This is how adequate critics works. I am totally for the ADEQUATE critics, but not for the rude hate.

To the facts..

I will reply to every single issue he points in my "stupidity" code.

1. "But FDE.AI also overrides the manufacturer’s values." - I am OK with that. They provide those tunables for tuning. So why not.

2. Thanks for "smb135x" wakelock info - I will fix this asap.

3. https://github.com/feravolt/FDE-sc/blob/master/fde.c#L1124 > this code is valid for only for 2.6.x kernels (very old devices), and it realy does improve UX a lot since I personally tested that on my 2011's device. For rest kernels this is simply not applied. I might just add kernel version check.

4. I will add a kernel version check before applying BBR.

5.1 "dumbest choices for tuning your I/O device" + https://github.com/feravolt/FDE-sc/blob/master/fde.c#L1217 > This code should fix rare deep-sleep issues on older kernels and as per my tests (I do own 2 UFS & 2 MMC devices), does not impact performance. I might add kernel version check before apply here too and/ro simply remove this string.

5.2 Will change that to single hit merge and/or check for storage type, because on slow MMCs this helps a lot in write speed.

5.3 I did researched about this and know what this option do. With my value it showed a better result in benchmarks which may fooled me up. Will research about this more.

5.4 I will research this more & maybe just add OS version check before apply.

6.1 My bad. I really mixed this up & thought that they are milliseconds, not seconds. Will fix.

6.2 That's true - I mixed this up with f2fs fsync_mode=nobarrier. But still from f2fs docs (https://www.kernel.org/doc/Documentation/filesystems/f2fs.txt) "This option can be used if underlying storage guarantees its cached data should be written to the novolatile area. If this option is set, no cache_flush commands are issued BUT f2fs STILL GUARANTEES the write ordering of all the data writes." Anyway, will fix that to be 'fsync_mode'. Also nobarrier (in rare cases) could corrupt FS, not physically destroy block. I believe that none of existing FS mount flags can actually physically destroy a block. (Don't mix up with file system corruption)

That's it. It could be a great conversation and I'd be very thankful for this points if it was not in this type of manner, calling me & my users dumb..etc.. I don't know him personally & never talked anything about him in public before. Maybe he got that "God complex" or something..otherwise I don't see the reasons to act like that. Cheers.
[Magisk] :
Talking to your "community manager" Niko is hard. His behavior and Ferat's ignorance lead to this.

The issue I was trying to resolve was "how to prevent kernel tweakers from messing with my and others kennels", helping K20P community quickly became secondary objective after I learned that FDE got internal restrictions that would prevent further bricks and that issue with those devices could not be resolved by EDL flash.
[Magisk] meduza:
I'm very happy we have been warned here on xda! Thanks for doing so! Not every user want to use extra communication channels. It's offered here on xda, so all important info should be placed here, at least on my opinion.

m.
[Magisk] cnjax:
If you have been following this thread and project for a while then you'd know that there's a pattern of of people who show up here trying to discredit the dev:s work, not sure whether it's jealously or a personal beef. If there was something nefarious about FDE don't you think xda would have removed this and Google play store would have removed the app?
[Magisk] mattgyver:
Thread cleaning...

If you're going to operate on other phone forums, do it there. XDA rules specify not passing people to other phone forums. 4PDA, especially, when it's riddled with warez.
[Magisk] franciscofranco:
Because it was never there in the first place. But since with the GPL licensing he finally "open sourced" it and there's no AI to be seen then this new version has "AI removed". Convenience at its finest.

AI implies there's an "artificial brain" that tries to think like an human being and mimic our behaviors. That's really hard to do and trust me, no one here can build on.
[Magisk] deathblade200:
this one is nothing but a scare tactic this wakelock is a huge problem for people and refuses to let their device sleep even when they aren't charging their device. it gets activated with "fast charging" then refuses to ever go away even if you turn off fast charging, it sure as hell won't make a battery explode which is a ridiculous claim.
[Magisk] :
I would need to extend the logs beyond 20mb to be 100% sure that the message in the log is not cut of due to long uptime. That would be a massive waste of RAM.
[Magisk] deathblade200:
did anybody actually ever think it was an AI? I mean all it does is run all its tweaks at boot then all its "AI" changes is cpu and gpu boosting automatically based on load which is something other apps can already do
[Magisk] :
It was advertised as having one, plus check the tags on the thread:

Tags

artificial, engine, fde, feravolt, tweak
[Magisk] fitsuli:
Still doesn't look that difficult

You can find a way around it like creating a file in the temp folder that indicates optimizer detection. Then your log collection may end up right after asking a user about existence of this file.
[Magisk] :
I can't create any files in userdata folders because of selinux.

Making dmesg go beyond a few mb would totally wreck memory management when dumping of dmesg is requested.
[Magisk] fitsuli:
Then don't you have sysfs where you can 'just' create an entry and put a number that will indicate optimizer detection? AFAIK it should be available to you even with SELinux policies in action

Getting completely off-topic here, uh

Edit: if it's impossible, I'll stop here
[Magisk] :
Let's stop here.
[Magisk] mattgyver:
Reopened thread...

Went through the posts since I cleaned a few hours ago and did A LOT more cleaning.

Stop attacking the character and motives of other users and developers. This forum exists for the developers. Your attitudes are ridiculous. Everyone on this forum knows that anything you do to your device is at your own risk. What works for one doesn't always work for another. Users should always read through the threads to check for issues before flashing or installing anything to their devices. That doesn't give anyone the right to belittle or flame someone else.

Formulate your own opinions. If you think it worthwhile, use it. If you think it's not worth trying to use it, don't. Don't bad mouth it. Instead, if you have issues using it, provide logs.

If this continues to be a problem, where you all decide to go after one another, this thread will remain closed, and the OP can PM me when updates need posted or the OP needs updated for any reason.

Civility goes a long way....
[Magisk] GwapongModder:
Time to uninstall...
[Magisk] unsygnal:
Is there any other optimizer can be used together fde.ai without any conflict?
[Magisk] zioloiso:
I give bad info. The phone slowed down through Energy Save mode. After turning it on and off it was getting slow.

Wysłane z mojego OnePlus 7T przy użyciu Tapatalka
[Magisk] gohaaron:
I bought this app a week ago and felt like its just gives a placebo effect. I also tried using L speed and wanted to compare which is better on terms of battery savings. So I asked the dev or admin on their telegram channel and he said that you can actually use both and it will or MAY with even better. That raised a red flag and from them on my suspicion arose. So I tried it and the result was it made my battery life worse. After testing for more than a week now... I can kind of conclude that most optimizers are kinda bull**** (incl this one and l speed) and does nothing much rly... Just a gimmick that u may possibly gain 1-2% improvement at most... So far there's nothing wrong with my phone but I don't think it's a worthwhile app... therefore I might just decide to uninstall it sooner rather than later.
[Magisk] SacredDeviL666:
Thread Cleaned and it will keep on happening till either or all of you take your internet war somewhere else...

I am sure we've created awareness(of whatever that is) already for everyone and proved your point. Now can we move on?

You want to use it good, don't want to use it even better but stay out of this thread and save some internet energy to be utilized elsewhere / other threads :highfive:

Thanks

SacredDeviL666.
[Magisk] franciscofranco:
Is this a joke? We've proved this "module" is malicious (not that it's evil, but that it says it does one thing but then it's a clusterfeck all over) and all you guys can do is "omg thread cleaned". This isn't the XDA I remember. I wouldn't want to come to this but do I need to talk to the overlords to get this sorted? Because coming in here cleaning the thread isn't going to save users from installing this crapware.
[Magisk] SacredDeviL666:
You are tenure enough to understand that if you have proof of something being malicious you hit report button, surprising that i need to tell you this.

Talk to overlords or whichever lords you may feel comfortable but keep the drama out of this thread and use the correct channels to highlight your findings.
[Magisk] franciscofranco:
You guys can't act without me hitting the report button? I'll do it, but you scan the threads looking for posts to clean, you can also read the posts containing all the prove you need.
[Magisk] bozokaydin:
Is it possible to add an option to disable all debugging and logging systemwide?
[Magisk] AtoZ0to9:
I had this installed for several months, paid apk version. Sometimes it felt like it was faster or more efficient or both, and there were other times when I forgot to enable it for some days or longer after a clean flash, and couldn't tell a difference. I didn't devote the time or energy needed to determine if it truly was beneficial or not, so I relied on the OP and users' comments, and how my phone felt, or didnt. My phone didn't brick (op5+), etc., but following the thread these past few days, I went ahead and uninstalled it. Where there's smoke there's probably fire, so I'm just gonna play it on the safe side and try out L speed, or no optimizer at all. Just don't got time for the tomfooleries and shenanigans.
[Magisk] meduza:
+1!

m.
[Magisk] cnjax:
Just downloaded the latest app update, thanks Fera. Maybe now the forum will get back on track
[Magisk] DoggyStar:
Version 8.1.1 works fine, thanks FERA ??
[Magisk] Help The Peace:
On my Pixel XL from 2016 running Lineage OS 17.1 it worked wonders! My phone is way faster than it was before and much smoother in terms of UX.
[Magisk] :
What about battery?
[Magisk] DoggyStar:
Battery is much better than without that, i have 1+6t with lineageos 16 and franco kernel. Try Your self, Its not that expensive. But i can say its much better with FDE. I can easily go day and half with that. Without that maybe day.
[Magisk] cnjax:
Even the moderators said to cease, hopefully they're still watching
[Magisk] deathblade200:
they said to cease the drama in general which both of you are starting again by targeting him just because you didn't like what he said.
[Magisk] cnjax:
I'm getting 5 +plus hrs screen on time and all day usage. With a rather small stock battery
[Magisk] deathblade200:
all 3 have positive tweaks in them but also have a load of negative tweaks as well that they just grab from google without knowing what they actually do and that is why their only defense is ever "don't use it". this is why I do all my build.prop tweaks manually otherwise you get loaded with a bunch of useless/bad tweaks
[Magisk] Help The Peace:
Battery is "OK". My battery sucks anyways on my Pixel XL. But FDE.AI doesn't use much more battery than without it.
[Magisk] :
All parameters are very balanced - you may gain performance without increase of power consumption AND reduce power consumption without losing performance. FDE is totally compatible with very wide range of devices and Android versions.

So this is a lie?
[Magisk] cnjax:
Nope, I'm getting 5 +plus hours screen on and all day usage
[Magisk] Mukuhorisu:
FDE.AI is getting better and more power efficient even though I am using a kernel that has just been released (Xenium) for AZMPM1.. Thanks Fera.!!!
[Magisk] rignfool:
Easily explained ... Ready... I learned this on XDA

Code Aurora does some testing... And comes up with a recommended minimum frequency, which is usually considerably higher than shipped minimums(8998 ships at 300/300 and CAF recommends 518/806)

If you load the processors slightly, you will run near these frequencies and not change so often... The cost of changing freq vs higher idle favors higher idle greatly...
[Magisk] cnjax:
Don't know what you state has anything to do with my post, without mod maybe 3 hrs SOT with mod 5 to 6 hrs SOT that's real world testing.
[Magisk] svetius:
Admin note: use this software with caution. Many have reporting device damage as a result of flashing this. Use at your own risk. We are investigating this further and might take further action.
[Magisk] TjNiko:
WoW that was even statted in the first post, Every User rooting his devices should be aware bad stuff can happen. Also "many" u might mean the K20/p users with their nice broken Firmware. pls Consider to make a good research and summary before u write something like this. Thanks.
[Magisk] svetius:
We will.
[Magisk] :
Btw, to people wondering. Device model checks are broken and I/O optimizations are still applied even on K20 Pro. Now I understand why some people still complained about K20 Pro getting data corruptions and other wonky stuff even 2-3 months after FDE was updated.

https://github.com/feravolt/FDE-sc/blob/master/fde.c#L775-L776

Custom roms change ro.product.name, also, there are _eea and _in variants of the device.

That's a full, 100% fiasco, Ferat.

P.S. props to [MENTION=3816568]Myself5[/MENTION] for suggesting to check it.
[Magisk] SacredDeviL666:
Thread cleaned.

An Admin has already posted a warning followed by agreeing to the request of this being investigated further as required.

a) All other discussions for and against that will remain/considered as not relevant to this thread as of now and will get removed.

b) Any further clarifications on the admin post can be received from the DC/Developer Committee if you want to know. (I am sure even the well known RDs are aware of how efficient the DC is)

Any further off topic or discussion which is pertaining to same debate/concern highlighted (Reason; this is already noted and being investigated) will be removed with or without any announcement in thread.

Thanks

SacredDeviL666.
[Magisk] :
New link to a Magisk module btw:

https://github.com/Magisk-Modules-Grave/FDE
[Magisk] Whiskey103:
Oké folks, little update.

We (Developer Comittee) are talking to all parties involved, or will be, taking into consideration time zones and such ;)

In the mean time, I would like everyone to stop pointing fingers while we are looking into things.

We all know that stuff published on xda comes with a "use at own risk" flag attached so there's always some risk.

After all, we are tweaking and hacking, pushing our devices to the limit.

Some times, over the edge even ;)

In any case, we will try to come up with a solution that all parties can live with.

I trust you all can talk friendly with each other, on topic without the flaming ping pong games aye?!

Have a nice day ppl :)
[Magisk] nfsmw_gr:
Maybe the most complete answer so far.

Good job!
[Magisk] marcinj60:
does this mod work on mi 9t pro on xiaomi.eu dev weekly 20.1.21?

Wysłane z mojego Mi 9T Pro przy użyciu Tapatalka
[Magisk] Thanos:
Just a reminder,

Read the post above by [MENTION=2632943]Whiskey103[/MENTION]

Then, read it again just so we're clear.

There will be no more disruption here. The thread is under review. Nuff said.

Posts that continue to try to herd drama llamas will be deleted and actions taken against those posting them may occur.

Just about every moderator on xda is watching this thread.

Go post memes on Facebook like a normal person.

:good:
[Magisk] FeraVolt:
Hello. Can I ask any of moderators, as an OP author to close this thread until we all figure things out. People are bullying & pouring toxisity here as it's a waste(they even admit this), not a months of work project. "Friendly" XDA.
[Magisk] Whiskey103:
Thread closed per OP request.
[Magisk] FeraVolt:
FDE magisk module support terminated.

Due to all optimizer modules were removed from magisk repo, the magisk module project is discontinued from now. APK variant is still supported & updated. Also, please be aware that my telegram support groups were bashed. I've updated the links.

I'd like to ask forum moderator to close this thread again for a reason written above and want to leave a lil comment on all happened drama.

Despite of all toxicity poured on me, my users & my project - I admited some of my mistakes & already fixed them already. In the end, this made my project even better. Also XDA Devs comittee reviewed this situation & code and made this conclusion:

I followed. No more even mentioning 'nobarrier' anywhere from my side.

At last, not going to judge, point or offence anyone. I'll just leave this here in attachments and you decide the rest. Some of "behind the scenes" of the drama happened here in Screenshot.zip. [MOD EDIT: Attachment removed. Thread closed as requested by OP]
[Magisk] b886b:
The newest beta works good, but if my device is connected to 3g network and with the sleeper daemon on the connection will be lost even if I unlock the device the connection didn't come back which means everyte when I unlock and the device. I would have to click the 3g tile again to have internet connection, is it intended to have it thia way? And one suggestion, can we activate the sleeper daemon within certain time? Like when i am asleep i don't need any 3g connection, i would love to be able to set from 0000 hrs to 0700 hrs the sleeper would be on to save some juice instead of merely setting it to be active when battery goes down to certain percent.

---------- Post added at 06:45 AM ---------- Previous post was at 06:35 AM ----------

Just when I sent the above comment then my phone reboots.......and my phone became very hot and i disabled the daemon. Hope that thw deamon will be more stable when time progresses.
[Magisk] SmashTime1904:
I was trying to find if it says it will interact with scripts in init.d, and would also like to know if this will interact with Lspeed?
[Magisk] Punraz_:
Did it will have problems if i use Fera and L speed?
[Magisk] b886b:
I have in one time forgot to uninstall L speed before installing Fera, so that both run during bootup and my phone hanged. However, I think it was beta 2 or 3, haven't tried to have both ever since. However, I wouldn't suggest having both, as conflict is likely to occur. Just try one at a time and get a taste of which suits you best.
[Magisk] Johny Cipeli:
Does this mod make a real difference in the usability?
[Magisk] alial04:
Haha yes it does!! But it also depends on what phone you have and what ROM you are using.

But join our telegram group so we can discuss.

If the instructions helped you or anyone then please be kind and hit the Thanks button :good::good:
[Magisk] Paget96:
101% of conflict :D
[Magisk] asad510:
cant see fde.txt in android folder, using s7 edge
[Magisk] alial04:
Hi! Are you using a custom ROM/kernel or are you using stock? If you are using a custom ROM and kernel first be sure if it supports init.d if it does then type this in a terminal

$su

$sh system/engine/feradroid.sh

And then it will generate a log. But if it doesn't support init.d then you have to emulate it via kernel adiutor and then reboot and you will have a log.

If you dont mind and have time then join our telegram group we have 24/7 support and can answer to almost all questions.

If the information helped you or anyone the please be kind and hit the Thanks button :good::good:
[Magisk] Punraz_:
Fera work for me I think
[Magisk] alial04:
Yes it works! If you want to activate sleeper click on the config file and change the status from 0 -> 1

And reboot.

If the information helped you or anyone then please be kind and hit the Thanks button :good::good:
[Magisk] Abyssialz:
Using beta4 on Existen MM Rom Z2. Often Suffer some lag and freeze few seconds. Not smooth and battery friendly at all but still using it. Thanks for this tweaks, i hope u will improve it.
[Magisk] franta8512:
Hi, I have a samsung ace 2 Rom CM11 cm11-20160616-unofficial-FULL-Codina. I try FDE on my mobile phone?
[Magisk] alial04:
Yes just try it nothing to lose :)

Report with log or join our telegram group.

IF the information helped you or anyone then please be kind and hit the Thanks button :good::good:
[Magisk] bromserge:
Hi everyone! I need help! I installed fde just a moment. And i have a biiig trouble. A cant unlock my phone from lock-button. Just black screen after pressing it. How can i fix it? Help plz
[Magisk] b886b:
Try to uninstall fde by using the uninstaller in the op.
[Magisk] bromserge:
whats all? I just restored my backup. What about fixing my problem?
[Magisk] FeraVolt:
Wait for stable version..coming soon
[Magisk] mrjoy:
This mod is note working on my samsung note 3 device. There is no FDE.txt file in android folder even i tried your manuall method 3 times.
[Magisk] alial04:
Hi! You may need to type in this command in your terminal

$su

$sh system/engine/feradroid.sh

It will work and I'm 85% it will :)

Join our telegram group to get extra details if it didn't work and you will get 24/7 support!

If the information helped you or anyone then please be kind and hit the Thanks button :good::good:
[Magisk] franta8512:
FDE

I attach a file
[Magisk] turnert:
Just out of curiosity will this work on phones with locked bootloader? I have a galaxy s3 mini(g730a) with a safestrap recovery installed.
[Magisk] franta8512:
It probably will not work
[Magisk] mrjoy:
I have already tried but didn't work
[Magisk] alial04:
Hi! Are you sure you have init.d support if not emulate it via kernel auditor and execute it there

---------- Post added at 09:59 AM ---------- Previous post was at 09:56 AM ----------

Yes it will you only need init.d support and a recovery to flash the zip file. Flash it and wait for 3 vibrates and post your log here or in telegram.

If the information helped you or anyone then please be kind and hit the Thanks button :good::good:
[Magisk] turnert:
Thx i got it installed and it seems to be working :)
[Magisk] mrjoy:
Off course i have init.d support.
[Magisk] alial04:
Thats strange ,join the telegram group then
[Magisk] franta8512:
It seems to me that this way of us just someone pulls info on mobile phones. It does not make any adjustments, just burdens the system. It's just my opinion
[Magisk] Paget96:
Well, it seems to you.

Someone spends hours and hours making devices performing better.
[Magisk] anipiot:
You really dont deserve to have access to a place like XDA and to what the developpers are building...

Hopefully no one care of your opinion!