yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Android Software Development] Seongnam:
I need some help.

I've ported opengapps aosp to amlogic s905x4 aosp.

This is android 11 version.

Apps run normally, but Can't log in(sign in) to google in youtube tv or setupwizard or etc..

I've used both google webview and android webview for webview, but it's the same problem.

I've also ported Mindthegapps and I get the same problem.

When I log in, I always get the following log.

W Auth : [FrpUnlockTask] FRP not required. Device was not locked.
I Auth : [AddAccountOperation] Initializing sign-in
I Auth : [AddAccountOperation] fetching LST for auth code
E GmsTaskScheduler: sendWakeUpEvent called on SchedulerClientBroadcastStrategy
I Auth : [AddAccountOperation] Handle addAccountResponse.
I Auth : [AddAccountOperation] sign-in complete with needsBrowser response
W Auth : [AddAccountTask] Failed to sign in SERVER_ERROR
I Auth : [AddAccountTask] Delivering result.
I Auth : [AddAccountLoader] Got result: status=1unicorn=false

What could be the cause of not being able to log in(sign in)?

What usually causes login problems?

gapps build option

GAPPS_VARIANT := tvmini

The text may be awkward because I used a translator.

The log file is attached.

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1Y3DEEl7Xa0r5pRqY4UQnrTiJ6riQRgXU/view?usp=sharing
[Android Software Development] G A S T:
Are those formentioned GApps really the only ones that MTG consist of compared to -let's say the bare Minimum - like the Open GApps pico package? Can you tell me more details about the differences between MTG and GApps pico?

Application Name​

gapps-config keyword​

p

i

c

o​

​

​

​

​

​

​

Google Play Services​

​

X​

​

​

​

​

​

​

Google Play Store​

​

X​

​

​

​

​

​

​

Google System Base​

​

X​

​

​

​

​

​

​

Android Auto stub⁵​

GearheadStub​

X​

​

​

​

​

​

​

Google Calendar Sync​

CalSync​

X​

​

​

​

​

​

​

Dialer Framework​

DialerFramework​

X​

​

​

​

​

​

​

Google Text-to-Speech​

GoogleTTS​

X​

​

​

​

​

​

​

Google Package Installer​

PackageInstallerGoogle​

O​

​

​

​

​

​

​

In my OGApps cfg I ditched Google Calendar Sync, Dialer Framework and Google Package Installer.

I also skipped swipelibs and vendorlibs and

forced the New Camera API.

What's up with those componenents in MTG? Are they all in- or excluded?

Google App and Google TTS are by the way mandatory, when Android Auto shall run on the device. So with those two I'm totally fine with the circumstance that they come preinstalled with MTG. But all the other componenets I took out in my cfg-file or things like Acessibility Suite, Markup or the Market Feedback Agent are totally obsolete imho.

It's a sad thing that there's no way to adapt and customize MTG to what's really necessary.
[Android Software Development] runekock:
@G A S T

This is off-topic, but there are other options if you don't like MTG. A popular one is NikGApps.
[Android Software Development] G A S T:
Huh, this is Off-Topic? Really?

So tell me - what is the real topic here? Of course not "GApps Daily" like the thread title promises, since the development came to hold months ago. Do you want to discuss "GApps yearly" with me? Makes no sense...

The topic here atm is "alternatives to OGApps" until there is a further development again. By the way - I'm not sure whether or not I like MTG because it's not that clear what ist consists of.
[Android Software Development] curiousrom:
MindTheGapps vs. Pico

These extra apps included in MindTheGapps but not in Open GApps Pico can be disabled in Settings > Apps & notifications > Show all > 3-dots > Show system:

* Android Accessibility Suite

* Google (search app)

* Markup

These are included in both Pico & MTG can also be disabled in their respective app's info:

* Android Auto

* Google Text-to-speech Engine

* Market Feedback Agent

The rest are core GApps.

***

Check https://gitlab.com/MindTheGapps/vendor_gapps

***
[Android Software Development] :
Still no news? At this point, I am afraid this project is over. It seems like the server problems are unfixable without outside help or something.
[Android Software Development] AnonVendetta:
If you would like to donate a million $ to their cause, or pay them a salary, then I'm sure you might catch their attention. But unless and until then, there's no point in whining.

It is, and will remain so until they have enough time to resume. Or you could give them an incentive by giving them the outside help they need. You would have to at least donate or pay more than whatever they're making from their jobs.
[Android Software Development] simplepinoi177:
MOD ANNOUNCEMENT​

THREAD CLEANED (posts edited or removed)

Everyone is expected to conduct themselves in a decent and respectful manner. Please keep your replies in accordance to XDA Forum Rule 2. Member Conduct.

XDA Developers Forum Rules said​

2. Member conduct.​

2.3 Flaming / Lack of respect: ...When dealing with any member, provide them with guidance, advice and instructions when you can, showing them respect and courtesy. Never post in a demanding, argumentative, disrespectful or self-righteous manner.​

​

2.4 Personal attacks, racial, political, and / or religious discussions: XDA is a discussion forum about certain mobile phones. Mobile phones are not racial, political, religious or personally offensive and therefore, none of these types of discussions are permitted on XDA.​

I would like to remind you “that mobile phones are not racial, political, religious, or 'personally offensive' and therefore, none of these types of discussions are permitted on XDA.” (as stated in Forum Rule 2.4 -- which also includes “personal attacks”). Criticism (which any/all criticisms are to only be in regards and restricted to mobile phone related matters) is to be constructive, objective, reasonable, and to keep personal opinion (mobile phone related matters notwithstanding) & attacks out of it. Although you might have your own personal reasons to be against certain things, criticisms about it should still have a modicum of respect and courtesy, and that nothing positive comes from posting in a hateful, argumentative, disrespectful, and/or self-righteous manner (as stated in Forum Rule 2.3).

I refer you to Forum Etiquette -- which is why your statement was reacted to so negatively.

Although, @AnonVendetta, you shouldn't make assumptions on the state of finances of another member & what they may or may not be able to afford. Also, using the term "whining" gives a sense of condescension (as if you are talking down to a child) and superiority (from you) -- which is also unnecessary. If anything, it comes off as "self-righteous" and not really "showing...respect and courtesy" which we are all supposed to follow as per Forum Rule 2.3 as shown above.

If anything, it is better to refrain from responding to or making any antagonistic or mocking remarks whose only purpose is to incite defensiveness, confrontation, and/or further bickering. Refraining from addressing them will keep from leading to more arguments and insults. It is better to ignore and refrain from even responding than to reply and fuel the fire more.

If you feel & truly object to such remarks (as it does break Forum Rule 2), it would be best for you to simply report the post & member than respond and escalate the situation. The Moderation Team will be sure to handle it.

Everyone's cooperation is appreciated. Let's all try to be better. Thank you.

simplepinoi177 FSM
[Android Software Development] Lostek:
Hello,

I am not skilled with Gapps installation, so I hope that somebody will help me here. I would like to install Gapps on LineageOS 20 (Galaxy S10). Well, I have couple of question about:

[1] I am a bit confused if there is a "OpenGApps" solution for Android 13, because I can see in the repository only v11.0. May I use the latest ZIPs with Android 13? On Source Forge website there is stated "last update 20220503". So may I use it with Android 13? Or is the project "OpenGApps" already terminated? Is there any descendent?

OpenGApps - Browse /arm64/20220503 at SourceForge.net

OpenGApps daily releases

sourceforge.net

I also found in SF repository all Packages, but on SF website there is stated that only "Pico" and "Nano" are stable. So the "Micro" and above Packages they are still not safe to use?

[2] Do I have to instal "OpenGApps" package right after flashed ROM (LineageOS)? Or can I install this anytime later?

[3] Is TWRP absolutely necessary to install the "OpenGApps"? May I try it with other recovery (on Galaxy S10, there is no need to use external recovery for example).

[4] Is it possible to uninstall any app (like Google Markup, Google App (Search) etc.) added in concrete package? And might be uninstalled apps simply installed again?

I guess Google apps they replace AOSP ones can not be deleted, is it correct?

[5] If I want to keep my AOSP Calendar, but I want to use also "Google Calendar", which package is enough to use, is it Nano Package?

[6] I need maps working correctly. What package do I need for proper function of (any) maps? Do I need to have installed some Google module (package) for proper maps functioning, even I will not use "Google Maps" app?

[7] If I want to use these Google apps: Calendar, Drive, Gmail, Play Store & Translator - what minimum package do I need? Is it Nano Package enough?

[8] When I use "Google Play" store (which replaces the Stock/AOSP version), is it necessary to tie it with my Gmail email? Or may I download/update apps anonymously as with "Aurora Store"?

[9] To use "OpenGApps" inside of my LineageOS means that any Google app will be isolated, will not collect any data from my phone and will not call remotely home as in usual Google Android system?

[10] May I "Shelter" (freeze/isolate) all Google apps, including the "Google Play" app? Will phone work properly?

[11] Also, I found there are some other solutions for addings Gapps in free ROMs like "MindTheGapps" or "MicroG". Can anyone give me comments about what are the differences between those two solutions and the "OpenGApps"? Are all safe and up to date, ready for LineageOS 20 (Android 13)?

I am sorry for this bunch of questions, but I would like to know the answers.

Thank you very much!
[Android Software Development] runekock:
@Lostek

Let me try to answer as best I can:

1) I haven't seen any OpenGapps for Android 13. There has been no public activity since @ipdev published test builds for Android 12. Alternatives are e.g. NikGapps or MindTheGapps.

2) You have to install rom and gapps at the same time - or at least wipe data.

3) You can probably use any custom recovery, but probably not any provided by the manufacturer.

4) You can't uninstall a gapps app from within the rom, but you can do it by dirty-flashing an OpenGapps without the app. If you want the AOSP app back, you can probably dirty flash the rom too.

6) For apps that use Googles mapping service, you need some kind of gapps, but even the smallest package will do.

7) The best choice is usually a tiny package (pico/nano) and then install the apps you need from the play store.

8) Yes, you need a Google account to use the play store.

9) No, I don't believe LOS isolates Gapps in any way. ArrowOS ProtonAOSP had an option to do that, but I don't know how well it works. In general, installing gapps means surrendering to Google.

11) Any gapps installs the same basic Play Services + Play Store as published by Google. But they vary in how many extra apps they add. MicroG is not really a gapps, it's an open source replacement. MicroG is a better choice for privacy, but any app that requires true Google functionality won't work.

Note: it may be better to start with just a few questions, and then follow up.
[Android Software Development] osm0sis:
Not to get severely off topic/inappropriate in a "competing" thread, but NikGapps has become arguably the most robust configurable GApps solution around, and is my preferred one now that Open GApps is on hiatus. A lot of your questions might be answered by the NikGapps thread OP and/or Wiki.
[Android Software Development] Lostek:
Thank you for your tip with the NikGapps. I will try his support.

Anyway, if there be anybody to answer on some of my question, I will appreciate this.
[Android Software Development] tushargopale:
Opengapps for android 12 is not available on official site. When will opengapps officially release for 12L arm64?
[Android Software Development] Nezorflame:
Hey everyone, long time no see.

Recently I bought Nothing Phone 2 which has support for custom recovery, so that means I'm somewhat back in the game :)

@tushargopale I plan to "resurrect" the project, at least on paper.

For now, no ETAs, but it'll be up soon-ish.

Basically, it'll be in form of unofficial builds, like I did some years ago, with an exception - those will be hosted on our official SourceForge page.

As for the question "which GApps solution is the best for me?", my answer, as always, is - use the GApps package that your ROM developer suggested.

With that said, I also suggest to keep using NikGapps from @Nikhil as the most "alike" solution to OpenGApps, at least until I resume the builds on somewhat acceptable basis.
[Android Software Development] luojx:
hi, Have you solved the problem yet. I had the same problem!
[Android Software Development] luojx:
ROM add GAPPS build, google play login failed.

When I log in, I always get the following log.

W Auth : [FrpUnlockTask] FRP not required. Device was not locked.

I Auth : [BaseGetTokenFromAuthCodeOperation] Initializing sign-in

I Auth : [BaseGetTokenFromAuthCodeOperation] Fetching token from auth code

I Auth : [AddAccountOperation] Handling AddAccountResponse.

I Auth : [AddAccountOperation] sign-in complete with needsBrowser response

W Auth : [AddAccountTask] Failed to sign in SERVER_ERROR

I Auth : [AddAccountTask] Delivering result.

I Auth : [AddAccountLoader] Got result: status=1unicorn=false
[Android Software Development] G A S T:
Is there anything new to say?

OpenGApps is still pretty dead atm, which is very sad...
[Android Software Development] AnonVendetta:
I think it's safe to assume that OpenGApps is dead, it's well beyond the point of simply being temporarily on hold. The devs havent posted in many months, not even to say that it's just on hiatus and will return in the future. And besides that, the last OpenGApps releases are for Android 11, we are now on Android 14, and 15 is coming soon. Even if it comes back, they will have way too much catching up to do for the project to be manageable. There are a few other GApps providers out there that you can try, I'd move on. OpenGApps always was my fave, but I've managed without them.
[Android Software Development] MJPollard:
What he said. There are other GApps providers like MindTheGapps and NikGapps (which is the one I use) that have taken up the mantle from OpenGApps. NikGapps, in fact, still has releases going all the way back to Android 9 (Pie), and like OpenGApps, provides packages from "core" to "full" depending on how much GApps you need. MindTheGapps, unfortunately, stops at Android 13, so if you're using 14, you're SOL there.
[Android Software Development] AnonVendetta:
MindTheGApps has Android 14 builds. I'm using it on an A14 LineageOS gsi ROM right now. The only problem with MTG, is that it isnt customizable. The zips are take it or leave it, you're installing all the components in the zip, or not at all. There is only 1 version (all the zips are the same, excluding hardware/Android version-specific details) which is essentially 1 size fits all. But most other GApps providers have customization in that you can choose which parts you do/don't want. But MTG is also very minimal, it just includes the core GApps components and little to no bloat. So it's not a big deal to me. I don't need all the extra stuff, just Play Services/Play Store/calendar and contacts syncing, not much else.

MTG for Android 14:

Releases · MindTheGapps/14.0.0-arm64

Contribute to MindTheGapps/14.0.0-arm64 development by creating an account on GitHub.

github.com
[Android Software Development] MJPollard:
My mistake. I was looking at the collection of zips on Android File Host, but it apparently hasn't been updated for a long time (or has been abandoned?). The last zips there are for Android 13.

Yes, same with NikGapps. Their "core" package would be the equivalent to MTG, and their "basic" package more akin to what you want (it includes the core components, plus it replaces AOSP Clock, Dialer, Messages, and Contacts with Google's versions). Me, I just use the core package and add the apps that I want, for maximum flexibility.
[Android Software Development] sieghartRM:
I do not think opengapps is completely dead. There is some activity on their github https://github.com/opengapps.

If that is not their github repository, then opengapps is probably dead.
[Android Software Development] AnonVendetta:
It looks like their official repo. But even if they come back, they're so far behind that they'll essentially be playing catch-up.
[Android Software Development] sieghartRM:
Yeah they will have to do lot work to catch up but if they still want to continue the project they will do it.

I believe they can do it if they want to because Poweramp was not updated for a long time and then it was updated by dev who is committed to developing the app.

Edited
[Android Software Development] landry314:
NikGapps is amazing. i highly recommend. it is flawless and there are packages for anything you want.

Downloads - NikGapps

NikGapps Website

nikgapps.com

NikGapps - Browse /Releases at SourceForge.net

A Custom Google Apps Package that Suits Everyone Needs!

sourceforge.net
[Android Software Development] osm0sis:
Yeah.. I'm unsubscribing finally after all these years. @ me if you need me! 😉
[Android Software Development] Revan335:
So, your Project incl. App, ... are finally Dead and we are must used other GApps? Whats GApps are you recommended?

Many Thanks for your Great/hard Work in the Past and so!
[Android Software Development] osm0sis:
Not my project and never was, though I did support it and try to keep it alive. I mostly just helped out on the scripts side of things from time to time.

Scroll up and you'll find my GApps recommendation.
[Android Software Development] D@rekills4:
I will try how my phone goes with wake up and keep awake enabled and report back.
[Android Software Development] ASHURiCAN:
Open-Gapps can be installed only over itself, not other Gapps. Clean system, flash system and flash Open-gapps.
[Android Software Development] mrshark:
eventually, you didn't read completely my 2 posts... that was exactly what i did...
[Android Software Development] ASHURiCAN:
That's not what it's wrote in your logs:

Maybe because your current gapps are 5.0?
[Android Software Development] mrshark:
there nothing apart stock cm12.1s OPO stock rom and root, now...

i wiped cache+dalvik+system before flashing the FULL rom, that includes some gapps, for sure...

there were similar problems months ago, when GAPPS FOR STOCK package arrived, and soon solved...

cm12.1s is only 1 day old, so it can be problems have returned... hope that with this log file, they can be solved again :)
[Android Software Development] ASHURiCAN:
I see... I hope someone will find a solution to your problem! [emoji4]

From my side I have another problem with stock 5.1 GApps, Play Store is not updating since some releases. It's standing on 5.8.8. Is it normal?
[Android Software Development] xonelith:
I haven't read all your posts but if you are coming from another GAPPS package, you need to wipe 'Data'; not just system/cache/dalvik. Sorry if you already mentioned this but didn't see it in this summary:)
[Android Software Development] mrshark:
but this implies to loose all my configurations...

there are the standard gapps embedded with opo stock rom...

as i said, with rom 5.0 i succeeded to installa open gapps... i was coming from a previous package named GAPPS FOR STOCK, which was embedded in open gapps months ago, and from then i used open gapps...
[Android Software Development] ASHURiCAN:
Oh, I didn't know about cleaning data. Use Titanium Backup to restore your configs. Or you can try Nandroid backup/restore data partition... Although it is not recommended, I could restore data between different CM installations.
[Android Software Development] xonelith:
Ya, a clean wipe means wiping data. As mentioned Titanium Backup works great for restoring all your play store apps. I set up all my GAPPS each time I flash since TiBu sometimes doesn't like system apps.

Good Luck!
[Android Software Development] mrshark:
ok, i'll try as soon as my phone is not needed for work... thanks :)
[Android Software Development] ASHURiCAN:
Any help? Thx.
[Android Software Development] dkm911:
Hey man! I was annoyed by the wakelock of play service before. As I mentioned, even we disable the Keep Awake and Wake Up in Privacy Guard, Play Service will crash. But eventually I figure it out. Check this out: http://xdaforums.com/nexus-6/general/script-reduce-google-play-services-t3171224

Now I don't have the wakelock problem of play service (at least not severe). But the android 5.x "Mobile Radio Active" issue is still there which is less annoying though.
[Android Software Development] D@rekills4:
Thank you.

I will give it a shot.

Even right now when I enabled wake up and keep awake to Google Play Services my screen on battery life reduced to half.
[Android Software Development] DGX_Goggles:
I previously had no issues installing the old open g-apps on my One Plus One, but this time when I tried to install the 5-27-15 release of the Android 5.1 Full Modular G-apps for ARM processors package, it told me that my system space was insufficient. I had the same issue installing it on my Nexus 7. Is there an issue with your install package? This never happened before.
[Android Software Development] TheNewNEXUS:
There should be a new gapps package for legacy devices that has only all the aosp removal apps. That way, everyone can have only google apps on their phones, without a second version of the aosp apps.

It gets quite annoying, having hangouts and aosp mms and......

Thanks, this was just something I had in mind. I doubt this will ever happen.