yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[L Speed] Paget96:
Fixed and reuploaded, go to mega or gd and download ;)

Thanks dude :)

Use gaming for ram for sd use 2048 ;)
[L Speed] insigma28:
What bout me [MENTION=5514152]Paget96[/MENTION] I'm using nexus 4 2gb ram which you recommend.
[L Speed] Paget96:
Try gaming if this kills your apps go to more free ram or balanced ;)
[L Speed] asusgarb:
Thanks. I have a problem with seeder. I tried using "default" and "light", but when I verified it with the entropy monitor of L-Speed, nothing changed.
[L Speed] k1ks:
This is intentional . I say what thinks and defends my work.

Only I do not agree entropyness variable.

Now just wait.
[L Speed] churapa:
You have a lot to learn about human interaction.

Of course it's intentional, what else do we expect of immature persons?

Nobody is saying that entropy values that is not your work.

And you just threaten openly, you really are funny.

Let's stop this here because I won't lower myself to answer you anymore.

By the way you have been reported for breaking xda rules.
[L Speed] Casper1982:
Amazing!!!

I'm using it on my Defy with kitkat, and moves very well and smooth... Thanks bro..!!! :good:
[L Speed] Maltonator:
I think you have to update the third post and and "flag tuner removed" to changelog ;)
[L Speed] razvantudurache:
[MENTION=5514152]Paget96[/MENTION] -I can use this tweak whit synapse ??Civato kernel 2.2 note3 n9005.
[L Speed] insigma28:
Sorry for answering for paget yes it works with synapse.
[L Speed] razvantudurache:
Tks.Baterry life is good whit this tweak?
[L Speed] insigma28:
I think it is good on battery life, can only test mate as everyone will have different opinions off this mod.
[L Speed] Paget96:
I will, but don't have time right now :/ but I will dude ;)

No problem ;) everyone who knows can answer ;) hah :D

Yes, as [MENTION=6053015]insigma28[/MENTION] said ;)

Try and feedback ;)
[L Speed] Paget96:
Ok, thanks fR report, I will revert back our old seeder in next update ;)
[L Speed] Paget96:
Impossible to pay over paypal for google developers console :/ damn

I think that app will be on playstore for a month or two, i need a time to collect hah :D
[L Speed] Nandowiko:
When i turn on zram my value of memory is 0 why
[L Speed] Paget96:
Reboot device and check again :)
[L Speed] Nandowiko:
I have kernel auditor when i reboot the value is 0 i max tu 300 and with returns to 0 every thing is fine thanks for this amazing project
[L Speed] Paget96:
I will check zram script later :)

Thanks for reporting :)
[L Speed] kolheRk:
Hi, I have successfully have installed the zip by using CWM recovery in my Xperia u.. When I'm going to configure in android emulator SU getting not found result. Can you help me in this mess?

Sorry for my English
[L Speed] Paget96:
Uninstall that, and use app version :)

Tyrant ;)

Thanks
[L Speed] Paget96:
Btw guys, do you more prefer snackbars than toasts ;)

I prefer, looks better ^~^
[L Speed] s-advance:
Looks wonderful man....

thanks...
[L Speed] LoverBoy2415:
Yeah..It Looks NYC Than Toasts .. [MENTION=5514152]Paget96[/MENTION] .. I think The Next Update Comes With This Too ?? [emoji2] .. it Will Be Cool If It Comes Means ;) ..
[L Speed] Paget96:
I just remade whole app with this :'D
[L Speed] LoverBoy2415:
Its Awesome Man [MENTION=5514152]Paget96[/MENTION] ..It Really Gives A New Classy Look To The App Than Toasts..
[L Speed] Paget96:
It will be cool that app is on playstore, because i can push an update after every little change, and it will be auto downloaded to your devices.

Now i need to do a lot of changes then to post, because AFH have defined storage. :)
[L Speed] LoverBoy2415:
Yeah Its A Good Idea Man [MENTION=5514152]Paget96[/MENTION]...So the Next Update Will Be In PLAYSTORE ;) ..Yeah Bro Take Your Time & Give The Next Best .. 1.3.4 :) .. Waiting [emoji2] [emoji2] [emoji7]
[L Speed] Paget96:
I hope, i need to collect money eheh :D
[L Speed] LoverBoy2415:
How Much Will It Cost To Upload an New App To Playstore ? ..
[L Speed] pavlepiramida:
I feel that there should be a separate thread for settings of lspeed where users could share their own....

at least it would make Daniels and other moderators of this thread ,job easier,not to have to scroll through pages of "settings" just to get to relevant stuff like bugs and other stuff that could be relevant for the development of the app

(Sorry If i miss spelled something)
[L Speed] Paget96:
25$ is google fee to open a google console app. I will collect for that ;)

I can't open other thread because can't take 2 threads on xda for one thing. :)

We will use this one, i will add some users presets to the one of the post on first page :)
[L Speed] LoverBoy2415:
;) ..Good Luck Brother For That [MENTION=5514152]Paget96[/MENTION]..Will See L Speed In Playstore Soon :) [emoji106] ..

---------- Post added at 08:44 PM ---------- Previous post was at 08:37 PM ----------

[MENTION=5514152]Paget96[/MENTION] .. And a Small Suggestion Bro ..

After The Playstore Update ;) ..

Try to Change The App Color & Image In every Update (If It Doesn't Take So Much Time For That)..

I Think It Will Be Cool & New(Surprise)..For All Users ..
[L Speed] Paget96:
Not take too much, that is few clicks :)
[L Speed] pavlepiramida:
I can swear on me moms,that I've seen so far,a few (two or three) devs redirecting users to their Q&A for roms they built so that they could have a clean dev thread just for bugs and logs.

But to be honest I've never read XDA rule book to the end,so please forgive me If Im mistaken!!!
[L Speed] Paget96:
This is DevDB not a simple thread :)
[L Speed] LoverBoy2415:
[emoji8] If That So...then Try To Change It [MENTION=5514152]Paget96[/MENTION] Man ..It Will Be So Cool Really ..:) ...& It's Just A Suggestion ;) [emoji39] ..
[L Speed] mrrocketdog:
plus maybe more time consuming jumping back and forth from threads.

unless you had someone else as maintainer of 'other' thread while you stay focused here. (if you decided to have a Q&A thread).

again , just a thought. ;)

"err on the side of kindness"
[L Speed] insigma28:
Yeah I think snack bar is better the toast bar bro could we get this on the next update.

Sent from my Moto G
[L Speed] Paget96:
This is already done :)
[L Speed] OnceHeaven:
A little OT but i just can't keep it inside any longer. I just love to be here where everybody is sharing info. Questions are asked and sincere genuine information is passed around. I guess it really starts with the OP/dev. I've been in threads/forums where dev themselves shows attitude and demands people to respect them or else F off. In those threads, you start seeing keyboard warriors behaving the same and portrays the exact negative attitude.

Here? Its so peaceful and informative...
[L Speed] Paget96:
App will be able for download from playstore after 5th march, i can't promise, will see what google will say.

Thanks for support
[L Speed] insigma28:
Awesome news bro congrats in putting the app onto the playstore.

Sent from my Moto G
[L Speed] omarmonajed:
Wo wow wowwwwwwwww this is incredible!! Now u can post some minor changes all the time!
[L Speed] Paget96:
I know :D

Yes, that is good side ;)

Also bad side is, maybe google will not approve LS, we will see.

If someone want to help, please search about google rights and give a link from where you find that.

I need to see everything, to avoid removing app ;)
[L Speed] orgulloso4202:
Here are some helpful links

http://developer.android.com/distribute/tools/launch-checklist.html

http://www.androidauthority.com/publishing-first-app-play-store-need-know-383572/

Hope this helps

Send using Tapatalk on

Samsung Galaxy S4 SPH-L720

WICKED X 10.8 Rom

Android Lollipop 5.0.1

Aurora Kernel
[L Speed] omarmonajed:
Will it be free? Hope so...
[L Speed] Paget96:
LS app??

for sure, i don't want force someone to pay to use app features. app will have donation button that if you want you can donate :D
[L Speed] jomar_uk:
This speaks volumes of what we knew about you all along :)

I'll even donate again when I am able :)

Shalom my friend, john
[L Speed] jugoslavpetrovic:
Snack

---------- Post added at 06:47 PM ---------- Previous post was at 06:33 PM ----------

Just my own noticing.

Honestly, the image in header looks nice but not related to app itself. Im telling you this from a point of view of a graphic designer. If anything, all you nees is the l speed logo. Logo is made perfectly, applause for designer of the logo and app icon. Color is nice and familiar, tilted L as formula seat and the rest as car body, I can picture wheels in it:)

Header should be simply made of those two cyan-ish-blue colors, maybe some stripes, circles, triangles, material designed shapes, doesnt need mountains.

Sorry for pointing, just meaning the best.
[L Speed] King_root:
But what about selinux and ad blocker? They'll be removed?
[L Speed] Paget96:
Don't force your self ^~^ please :D

Gonna make some pics now :)

Helps bro, thanks a lot :D
[L Speed] Paget96:
yes for now.

I have a plans to implement them as a 3rd party app ;) don't worry, i just need a time. :)
[L Speed] King_root:
Take your time man. You've done enough for all of us. Do what you can do best and sleep well. Good luck to you.
[L Speed] looney_tkp™:
ha :)

i knew he will go for play store

thats a good move bro
[L Speed] Paget96:
Thanks guys, well thanks to one guy who donate for this over WU, i will put his name if he approve that :)

Thanks to him for timing. :)

All this things will not be forgotten. :)
[L Speed] looney_tkp™:
one day, someway, somehow

am gonna donate and my name will be there [emoji6] [emoji6] [emoji6] [emoji6]

i want my name to be there
[L Speed] Paget96:
dude, don't force your self with that. :)
[L Speed] quintas84:
I will pay the fee to you can I made a donation to your PayPal?
[L Speed] Paget96:
thank you bro, doesn't needed. one guy from here paid over WU that i can add on bank account since i can't from playstore. i will go to the bank after 5th march to pay for that :D
[L Speed] quintas84:
Anyway I will made a donation....
[L Speed] Paget96:
thanks a lot bro :)
[L Speed] JhoonB51:
No problem at all [MENTION=5514152]Paget96[/MENTION], we are all thankful for your time and energy for what you do for us.
[L Speed] Paget96:
Thank you bro a lot. :)
[L Speed] omarmonajed:
Thanks [MENTION=5514152]Paget96[/MENTION] for listening to our recommendations. This is the trait of successful people.

---------- Post added at 09:51 PM ---------- Previous post was at 09:46 PM ----------

Will this app be available in play store all countries?
[L Speed] Paget96:
If i can chose, then for all. Don't have any information, since this is my first app uploading :)
[L Speed] alokt27:
When I switch from cleaner to io tweaks / dashboard to cpu tuner ... And so.. There is lag .. Of few milliseconds

It's just my phone and kernel settings or the app??
[L Speed] Ikmalblack95:
then it will be the best, must have app for root users for sure ?
[L Speed] Paget96:
yup ^~^
[L Speed] kchaisu:
Hi Paget96,

Thanks for all your affords to go this far. It is not only a good apps that you have made, but also you have created a wonderful community as well. I am very appreciated what you have created so far.

Thank you very much for your kind contributions.
[L Speed] boswelja:
[MENTION=5514152]Paget96[/MENTION] I think you should work with [MENTION=4443334]Grarak[/MENTION] to combine LSpeed and Kernel Adiutor for the ultimate AIO performance boost
[L Speed] Nandowiko:
Kernel auditor works fine with L speed
[L Speed] boswelja:
I mean to make them one app
[L Speed] Nandowiko:
Ok its a great ideia
[L Speed] Rhoban:
It wouldn't really make sense to combine them.

L Speed is a mod and kernel adiutor is a tweaking app. L speed has predefined settings and kernel adiutor allows the user to set their own custom values. They are different.
[L Speed] Paget96:
Thank you ^~^

Success is in individuality :)
[L Speed] Paget96:
I will buy Google Console later, then need to wait some time (48h) to activate an account, and hopefully app will be on playstore :)
[L Speed] LoverBoy2415:
It Will Be Bro ;) ..
[L Speed] aljedheed:
Then i will b d first one to give 5 stars and and and an awesumm reviews
[L Speed] Aakash Kaushal:
Thanks for the update bro..i wanna ask something related to selinuxmode..i always change it to permissive but after some minutes,it reverted back to enforcive?
[L Speed] Paget96:
Maybe your kernel not allow to change it :)

Apps like kernel adiutor and selinux changer just holds a printout to you that selinux is changed, but it isn't, check it under

/sys/fs/selinux/enforce

Open file 0 means permissive, 1 means enforcing.

Try kernel adiutor to change selinux, you will get permissive in the app all the time, but look inside the file there is still 1 ;)
[L Speed] Aakash Kaushal:
There is 1 in the file...bro also there is no option to change selinuxmode in kernel auditor..?
[L Speed] LoverBoy2415:
You should Click Plugins & Need To Download The Selinux Plugin Brother ..
[L Speed] Aakash Kaushal:
Thanks for this... Also is it possible to change 1 to 0 in enforce file by editing to change selinux mode?:)
[L Speed] LoverBoy2415:
Yeah Set Permissive in Kernel Auditor ..And Check The File as [MENTION=5514152]Paget96[/MENTION] Said .. May Be U Need A Reboot ..After Setting It In Kernal Auditor App ..
[L Speed] Paget96:
Uploading app to play, stay tuned :)
[L Speed] LoverBoy2415:
Woww..Wowww..Wwoww..Bro [MENTION=5514152]Paget96[/MENTION] Here We Goo ..[emoji8] [emoji8] ..Countdowns Starts ..[emoji106] [emoji106] [emoji111] [emoji111] ...
[L Speed] Aakash Kaushal:
Bro changed to permissive but after reboot it reverted back to enforcive..im using s4 stock kernel..?(even there is 1 in the file..)

---------- Post added at 01:44 PM ---------- Previous post was at 01:42 PM ----------

Thankyousomuch...i will tell my all friends to use this app:D
[L Speed] omarmonajed:
WE ARE SO TUNEDDD!!!
[L Speed] LoverBoy2415:
Then It Won't Work Bro ..in Samsung Devices As Samsung Knox Will Be enabled In It..So it Doesn't work Bro From Enforce To Permissive ..
[L Speed] Aakash Kaushal:
No im using custom rom with deknoxed,deodexed etc...selinuxmode is always in permissive mode till yesterday but from today this is happening with me..(both in kernel auditor and in lspeed,it always reverted back to permissive after opening the app again..maybe [MENTION=5514152]Paget96[/MENTION] can help..?
[L Speed] LoverBoy2415:
I think [MENTION=5514152]Paget96[/MENTION] Will Help You In this Brother :).. May Be Its A Small App Issue Or Something Brother.. He Will Help You..
[L Speed] Paget96:
"We're processing your update. It can take several hours until it is available throughout Google Play."

Sooo, we need to wait ;)
[L Speed] gavilan2010:
Awesome man.
[L Speed] LoverBoy2415:
So On Your Side Everything Is Finished [MENTION=5514152]Paget96[/MENTION] Bro..

Now Its On Google to Finish Their Side Work .. ;) ..

Let's Hope The Heat(L Speed Is On Playstore) Will Be Turned On Within Hours itself...[emoji39] [emoji7] [emoji12] ;) ..#Countdown_Starts ;) [emoji106] [emoji111] [emoji111] ..
[L Speed] omarmonajed:
You're the best!!!! #Countdown_Starts
[L Speed] vekye:
awesome app I like it!

morning 7am - battery 100% charged

evening 9pm- battery left 35%
[L Speed] orgulloso4202:
Use Aurora Kernel for the s4, it come with Permissive and way better than stock

Send using Tapatalk on

Samsung Galaxy S4 SPH-L720

WICKED X 10.8 Rom

Android Lollipop 5.0.1

Aurora Kernel
[L Speed] Paget96:
L Speed v1.3.4 TYRANT is up!!!

We are now on playstore :D

Thanks guys

UNINSTALL FIRST

Changelog:

Fragments code fixed and optimized

Changed toasts with snackbars

Dashboard code optimized

Selinux changer removed, because of google rights

App cleaned up

Permissions updated

Downloads :)

GooglePlay

Also here is mine donation URL:

http://xdaforums.com/donatetome.php?u=5514152

Thanks guys for everything :D

I'm so proud on users which I have :)

Good luck ^~^
[L Speed] bullfinch110:
Congratulations!!!!
[L Speed] Aakash Kaushal:
Ohhhh...you done it:D

Downloading now...thankx alot for the new update...now playstore will automatically update the app:sly:
[L Speed] Dor71:
Great news, my friend.
[L Speed] insigma28:
Congratulations [MENTION=5514152]Paget96[/MENTION] finally on the playstore you are a legend thank you for all the hard work you put into the app.

Sent from my Moto G
[L Speed] orgulloso4202:
I can't rate the app, it doesn't give that option [emoji22]

Send using Tapatalk on

Samsung Galaxy S4 SPH-L720

WICKED X 10.8 Rom

Android Lollipop 5.0.1

Aurora Kernel
[L Speed] Paget96:
Uninstall it then download from play, it will show you only open app because the package is same like on your device.. :D

thanks guys, thanks a lot :D
[L Speed] Aakash Kaushal:
Uninstall it from playstore then install it agaun from playstore..then u can give ratings also dont forget to rate 5stars(i already done this):D
[L Speed] RMarques:
Awesome man!

Congrats!

...play store didn't recognize that I'm rolling with version 1.33 and instead of giving me the option to "update", it just allow me to "open".

Sent from my LG-D855 using Xparent Skyblue Tapatalk 2
[L Speed] derkleinebroicher:
To all of you: don't forget to rate this excellent app on play store - I already did!! [MENTION=5514152]Paget96[/MENTION]: if you need someone to translate into german I will be pleased to do this.
[L Speed] mauam:
You're the man:cool:
[L Speed] orgulloso4202:
I figured that. Already rate it five star. But I'm upset that some one rated it a four star already. Grrr[emoji35] [emoji36]

Send using Tapatalk on

Samsung Galaxy S4 SPH-L720

WICKED X 10.8 Rom

Android Lollipop 5.0.1

Aurora Kernel

---------- Post added at 04:14 PM ---------- Previous post was at 04:13 PM ----------

Congratulations

Send using Tapatalk on

Samsung Galaxy S4 SPH-L720

WICKED X 10.8 Rom

Android Lollipop 5.0.1

Aurora Kernel
[L Speed] LoverBoy2415:
Finally Its Done :) ..

NOW IT'S OFFICIAL "L SPEED" ON GOOGLE PLAYSTORE

2016 An Awesome Year For You Man [MENTION=5514152]Paget96[/MENTION] .. A Big Step For You In The Carrier Of Your Android Development .. & A Small Achievement(Many More & Big Ones To Come) :) In Your Life .. May the God Bless You Man [MENTION=5514152]Paget96[/MENTION] ..Iam Really Happy for You #Danijel Brother.. #Everything_Starts_Right_Now .. #Beginning_For_A_New_Thing ..Its Just A Beginning We Will See You Reach Heights ..

Bless You Brother #Danijel_Markov ..

We Are All There To Support You In Ur Steps [emoji106] [emoji111] ..

Thank You [MENTION=5514152]Paget96[/MENTION] Brother .. [emoji122] [emoji106]
[L Speed] looney_tkp™:
Rated 5 star..am Looney tunez on google btw lol

am seeing 0+ downloads, wtf...is it google fault or what ?
[L Speed] LoverBoy2415:
Yeah Me Too Seeing 0+ ..It Will Take Sometime Bro ..To View The Approximate Download Times..As Its Just Now Entered Into GPlay ..
[L Speed] 99problemz:
I have been using this app since I've updated my g4 "officially" to mm. And I must say, I am certainly impressed with the time and work you have put into developing this app. This is a must app for me here on out. Good job and great work you are very much appreciated. And congrats.
[L Speed] RoyanArt:
can I use script version, only for selinux changer (other mod off, only selinux changer to permissive. Other mod ON --> using playstore version) ?

Thanks :)
[L Speed] JhoonB51:
[MENTION=5514152]Paget96[/MENTION], I am truly happy to see this happening to a wonderful person like you. May it be the beginning of greater things to come!

Your friend, JhoonB
[L Speed] orgulloso4202:
I used both app and script version concurrently with same setting just to mess around and I didn't feel it caused any problems. I was thinking of using the scrip for Permissive until [MENTION=5514152]Paget96[/MENTION] rolls out the plug-in for the app. I I say go for it [emoji41] [emoji28]

Send using Tapatalk on

Samsung Galaxy S4 SPH-L720

WICKED X 10.8 Rom

Android Lollipop 5.0.1

Aurora Kernel
[L Speed] RoyanArt:
I just tried the permissive script by copying LS00Selinux_Permissive to su.d folder. After restarting, it worked (no need to install L-Speed script 4.3.3 tyrant, only copying that file). So now, I'm using L-Speed playstore + script lspeedpermissive.

Note : I need selinux permissive because i'm using Pointer Replacer

[MENTION=5514152]Paget96[/MENTION], i suggest that u should release standalone selinuxchanger script :D

Thanks for your hardwork [MENTION=5514152]Paget96[/MENTION]
[L Speed] mauriicio21:
Is possible to include in app changelog, maybe chrome custom tabs
[L Speed] jugoslavpetrovic:
You dont need to combine with other apps, if you need for more make your own fully featured app. You already know howto?
[L Speed] looney_tkp™:
lol...everyone is fighting for selinux permissive hehehe..its funny

btw, i think the pm.sleep_mode=0 in battery improvement sleeps all apps and i don't receive notifications in apps when my device is sleeping..i receive notifs. only when i open the app..

can i delete the pm.sleep_mode=0 line alone in the script ?

and something causes "phone idle" or i think "phone stanby" drain, i don't remember the exact name and i dont know how and what causes that but am still checking on it, if anyone has a solution pls let me know

sorry for the off topic..paget96, what's the meaning of your name ?
[L Speed] alokt27:
Can anyone share me apk link for 1.3.4 . I don't use play store

I hope paget also upload lspeed to apkmirror .. very useful if you don't have access to play store
[L Speed] jomar_uk:
[MENTION=5514152]Paget96[/MENTION]

Uninstalled 1.3.3 installed 1.3.4 from Google play store!

Delighted your work has such recognition, 5* comments left.

Shalom my friend, john
[L Speed] gnotzilla:
[MENTION=5514152]Paget96[/MENTION]

Hi m8 congratulations to you for being in the playstore gave you 5 star rating

P.S any news from the doctor?
[L Speed] -CALIBAN666-:
great to see it in Playstore,installed and 5 Stars rated,keep it up bro.

--SIGNATURE--
[L Speed] phantom146:
IInstalled from playstore [MENTION=5514152]Paget96[/MENTION] but im worroes about one thing.

Right after i reconfigured my settings i reboot my device. On 1.3.3 it would take some time since partition remount is on before a confirmation/notification flashes that lspeed has been granted supersu (which means the start on boot function was applied correctly) atm, there is none of that and though the logs say it did what it did, i still dont believe it.

Before zram not activated on lseed i will have a 500mb swap. When 1.3.3 has zram activated, the swap is changed to 460 which means it is working as expected. However on 1.3.4 after rebooting, my zram is still in 500 which for me means it isnt working like the older versions that arent uploaded in playstore.

Will be waiting for your feedback

EDIT: everything is fine now i derped it with autostart functions lol
[L Speed] Marvin_1003:
Can i preinstall your old 1.3.3 apk on a new rom i am creating?

We would give you permissions in the rom thread.

Greets
[L Speed] ZDeuce2:
I uninstalled it so I could download and leave a review and 5 stars... Congrats [MENTION=5514152]Paget96[/MENTION]... Now let's see if we can get you all the props and credit there too...

Common sense isn't all that common

---------- Post added at 08:09 PM ---------- Previous post was at 08:05 PM ----------

Any chance in the future you could add the selinux and init.d status to the dashboard? Not the switch, just a status...

Common sense isn't all that common
[L Speed] Paget96:
Thanks a lot for support, you are awesome :D

I will do fixes for the reported bugs :D and will fox them. Thanks for reporting this ^~^

First I will take a rest. :)
[L Speed] kakkooran:
[MENTION=5514152]Paget96[/MENTION] Thank you bro for your amazing work.Already download from playsyore and gave 5 stars.
[L Speed] Vuska:
5 stars on PS.. voted [emoji106] [emoji4]
[L Speed] Aakash Kaushal:
Somebody voted 1star which led to decrease the average ratings to 4.9...i hope the ratings will hike again to 5..:)
[L Speed] JhoonB51:
Posted a good review on Play Store and of course 5*****! Keep up the good work!
[L Speed] Arkonite:
[MENTION=5514152]Paget96[/MENTION] L Speed works fine but it crashes after every boot once.
[L Speed] lenixroman:
I recommend that you put L Speed [root] because some user are lazy to read and may put bad rating