yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Xposed General] HippoMan:
1. Work hard to create something really, really useful.

2. Make it (and all the resources for re-creating it) available for free.

3. Millions of people use it.

4. Decide not to work so hard on it.

5. Get hounded day in and day out for months by thousands of people.

This is a classic example of "No good deed goes unpunished".

Rovo is a saint. In his shoes, I would have told all of the "hounders" to f**k off a long time ago.

In other words, people, learn how to be grateful, get off of Rovo's case, and move on.

.​
[Xposed General] Dwyan3Wad3:
This is sad, I would donate to help the dev, especially since all this is free
[Xposed General] Rix70:
i'm a user and for me is normally this long time...the system of cache is completaly changed....and see it immediately in the booting process and the loading apps process.

Be patient!
[Xposed General] Grooov3:
Go On Rovo u can do that =)
[Xposed General] nasempire:
I hope you are wrong

It is already 2015 and there is still no support for lollipop. It was working fine with jelly bean. I just installed a custom lollipop rom and I wanted to user xposed with greenify. It seems I have to wait and your saying will just be a conspiracy. You should really stop creating this kind of threads. Value people's creativity. That fact that, there is a delay doors not mean it will not be made. If for anything at all, give them some morale
[Xposed General] siealex:
Lollipop is a completely new system. The difference between KitKat and Lollipop is almost the same as between Windows 95 and Windows XP, if not larger... Lollipop looks like ordinary Android, acts like it, but it is NOT it...
[Xposed General] nani666:
Awesome news... Had to downgrade back to 4.4.4 cos if lack of Xposed.... Couldn't continue with Lollipop without my Xposed modules.....
[Xposed General] shahrooz.omd:
Weeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee, thanks rovo89
[Xposed General] Puckapunyal:
It's happening
[Xposed General] Spl4tt:
Holy ****. That's probably the best news since... since.. Holy **** an eternety.
[Xposed General] Dan1234567890:
I know that Gravity Box dev said that he would need to write the module almost from the scratch, if/when xposed for art will be available... So I think other module devs are in similar position... [emoji6]
[Xposed General] ayoubij:
And rovo loves and enjoys to develop xposed. So you wana stop him so you can take more credit.

So selfish....
[Xposed General] Rapooo:
Good News Love 5.0 Xposed :)
[Xposed General] Goldie:
No. Not at all, if you actually read the post you would see I said its great.
[Xposed General] ayekhine:
Awesome

Best news so far in months. I can't wait.
[Xposed General] ayoubij:
Ok but then what is the point of your post.. You say its great but then you complain.

I wish we could all support and help each other on xda
[Xposed General] jayjay3333:
God I've missed you.... I am actually giddy :D:p
[Xposed General] wanam:
It's all about the first step :) just try to make your first xposed module, your smali modding skills should help you a lot, i'm sure you won't regret it.
[Xposed General] mattspfld:
This makes me happg
[Xposed General] Midomad:
The best info of the day

Thank you
[Xposed General] mikeymopar:
that's a pretty hollow wish when you pulled out a quote from many pages back just to call a respected RC/RD selfish when he has helped many, many devs and members and thus perpetuating animosity all because you didn't understand his comment

everyone agrees that there is a place for xposed just to different degrees. don't crucify anyone for their opinion on it. either way y'all are gonna have it if/when it's available

(now i've said too much like roughly 50% of all the other posts here too but criticizing/name calling bugs me to no end :p )
[Xposed General] Svartsyn333:
1100+ thank you's? U guess this is the largest amount I've ever seen on a single post. :D:D:D

Of course I'm one of them, I just moved on to Lollipop on my new phone with a big tear in my eye and now it turns into one of joy. :thumbup:
[Xposed General] HeckNoTechnO:
I am super excited about getting xposed on my Nexus 6. I miss being able to tweak things. I am glad for all the smart folks who know how to code and share it with us. I am just a beginner in coding python and only know what I have learned here on xda. Thanks to all who take time to work on this project. I am very thankful and willing to donate to the cause.
[Xposed General] faslane:
agreed.
[Xposed General] HorstiG:
Why not without Xposed

https://plus.google.com/105874565005620383688/posts/5V9ru8sSSVk

---------- Post added at 01:20 ---------- Previous post was at 01:13 ----------

Das sind die besten Neuigkeiten seit dem es Android gibt. Danke.

These are the best news since there is Android. Thank You.
[Xposed General] FormeriPhoney:
I'll get you a towel. [emoji2]
[Xposed General] SystemErrorOne:
Heck yeah man you're the best! If you need any graphic help please let me know, I am more than happy to help :good:
[Xposed General] jucytec:
well, my virtual wiener got a hard on reading this update.
[Xposed General] Roblewis17:
How can I root?!?? (Sprint HTC one)
[Xposed General] kleitonk:
This made my day!
[Xposed General] mdamaged:
Wrong thread, very wrong thread, you want this.
[Xposed General] davexd97:
Can't wait for it, you are an awesome developer but you already know that! The wait will be worth it i know
[Xposed General] HorstiG:
You did´t understand the question :D ;)
[Xposed General] SpaceCadetWilliam:
I hope soon means in 17 minutes
[Xposed General] ranasrule:
I literally have tears of joy in my eyes right now
[Xposed General] vanisleguy1976:
I thoroughly enjoyed this!!

And props to you for redirecting him lol
[Xposed General] xFryz:
Very nice.

Waiting for this
[Xposed General] veener79:
Edit messed up reply.
[Xposed General] zenaldo:
That's awesome indeed!!!! You make my day.
[Xposed General] aeonix_05:
You're making NEWS! You will make Lollipop even sweeter!
[Xposed General] ampire_dan:
Thanks

Thank you very much!
[Xposed General] leandroqm:
I can't believe thisss!

That is awesome!

I will recheck again tomorrow after I sleep 9h so I am sure I am not dreaming! hahaha :)
[Xposed General] aillez:
No. 1 reason that I still on Kitkat is Xposed still not available on Lolipop.

but since I heard this news.....

My hope is rising :)

you made my day dev

Thumb up !!!
[Xposed General] methuselah:
The last thing I needed for LOllipop

Well at last [MENTION=4419114]rovo89[/MENTION] is back with a biggest news for Flashers. I was missing xposed from so many days. With the time i spend with xposed on kitkat was worth trying. Well its time to move and i will use official ROMS once xposed landed for better battery and better stability. :)
[Xposed General] vishal91:
WOW!! You made my day dev.

great job.

eagerly waiting:good::good:
[Xposed General] psylooooo:
Thank you for your job, and your time dude, Xposed framework is the most useful app ever :good: :victory:
[Xposed General] x27767589:
ya.... support for 5.0 thank you
[Xposed General] drdionysius:
I'm getting way more excited over this than I should be. The Xmessias has returned!
[Xposed General] hell-o-world:
Uhm...

Hey there! I'm really new to XDA (though I have some experience with rooting, etc. back from when I was playing around with my Galaxy Nexus. Anyways... yesterday I got myself an S5 (900F, international GSM version). First thing to do was of course custom recovery, root and flashing CM. Then I remembered Xposed and as I wasn't informed about Lollipop and Xposed not functioning together I just downloaded the installer app and installed Xposed and the Xprivacy. Yes I installed them both and everything worked! (??) I've not used Xprivacy before but I went into settings and started blocking permissions. It all seemed to work (though I don't know whether it really blocked the apps or just showed as if). I then had some issues with CM being stuck in a bootloop (maybe because of Xposed?). Flashed new and tried to install Xposed again. Now it tells me the thing with SDK 21 not supported yet. Funny eh?

Now I have a question (OT)... what do you guys use to control privacy? Any good app? Or is the built-in CM Privacy engine good enough?
[Xposed General] 95A31:
Hi [MENTION=4419114]rovo89[/MENTION]. Great work :good: I am curious about how Xposed work. Can you give me an overview ? What issues have you find from Dalvin to ART? How you bypass it? (Feel free to use technical details :D)
[Xposed General] friendshaiju:
jolly good

ready to test/brick
[Xposed General] vivekkalady:
Awesome !!!!
[Xposed General] Killberty:
つ ◕_◕ つ xposed hype つ ◕_◕ つ
[Xposed General] mokkami:
Rovo89 and M66B should get a Peace Nobel Price! :)

Great News Rovo and thank you very much for your hard work on this exciting piece of Software.
[Xposed General] rrichards:
GREAT
[Xposed General] FdeKlerk:
Hi [MENTION=4419114]rovo89[/MENTION]...

Your screen shot is really attracting allot of attentions...

But I have not seen one response from you yet? Or did i miss it?

So how about proving to us that you do read this thread indeed and give us a test .apk so we can see what it does to what devices. Not everybody is running a nexus device with lollipop.

So how about it?:fingers-crossed:
[Xposed General] Primokorn:
Rovo89 will post at the right time. He said that Xposed will be ready

soon

. Period. No need to read & answer every question.
[Xposed General] 1ceb0x:
Lol.... are you serious?
[Xposed General] kyan31:
Or you could just wait.
[Xposed General] caruhe:
Will current modules work with lollipop version, or should they be revised by the developers?
[Xposed General] 1ceb0x:
revised... granted the SDK has changed.
[Xposed General] robertogl:
Xposed API will be the same, if the modules don't touch important part of the system it will work.
[Xposed General] dave7802:
Xposed will not come out in a BETA form (Am Very doubtful), Also Rovo has nothing to prove.

If i recall back, Xposed would be released on a very stable version. Not Pre-Release / ALPHA / Beta

With the number of user base, how popular and how many different devices this will be install on, Can you imagine releasing a Pre-Release.

Can you imagine the 5000000 users spamming in relation to bugs... with no relevant information (Lets be honest most users are unable to provide logcats)

Then people complaining why X Y Z does not work. (We all see it happen enough times on Pre-Releae / BETAs)

The more i think about it, I envy Rovo's stance on this, and understand why information / discussions are kept to a minimum.
[Xposed General] Cyclu:
Awesome News! Big Thanks rovo89 you are the man:)

I'm surprised that XPrivacy is not even once quoted in this thread nobody care about security and privacy? Just for that I stay on Kitkat and no one of the custom rom have an good alternative (including App Ops)

You will be surprised the number of sensitive data leak in Android app's that I have remarked since I use XPrivacy.
[Xposed General] MattBooth:
To be fair, it's not an anti-xposed thread, so the posts were a little off-topic.

For every bugged ROM there's a bugged xposed module.

This is a worrying trend I'm noticing in these threads. Two things.

"No name developer"

"bugged ROM"

Two annoying concepts to be allowed to be let loose. Not all custom ROMs are bugged. Just because YOU don't know the developer, doesn't mean they don't do good work.

JustArchi is in a league of his own. Simply put. He is also the first person to admit his weaknesses. He knows his Unix stuff, but will freely admit to not being up to scratch on smali modding and the likes. He's only human.

EDIT:

At the end of the day in this, it seems to be developers vs users. And, personally, I think I'd put my faith in the idea that developers know ROMs better than users. But it seems here we have users, with no development knowledge, experience or skills, trash talking developers. This IS a sad day for XDA for that reason alone (not the advent of xposed for LP).

I hope I'm not alone in finding it a sad thing that so many people held off Lollipop because of xposed, also.
[Xposed General] kingvortex:
I don't find it sad that people held off on updating to Lollipop because of a lack of Xposed compatibility.

Is there a reason to update to a newer version of Android "just because", even if it means you lose access to features that you find useful (or even vital to some for example XPrivacy) for an unspecified amount of time?

Everyone uses their device in a different way and for different purposes. If that wasn't the case, then everyone would stick to the rom their OEM loaded on the device and this place wouldn't exist in the first place.

There's room for both custom roms and Xposed in my opinion and arguing about this is unnecessary.

Sent from my C6603
[Xposed General] jeeg_eu79:
[MENTION=4419114]rovo89[/MENTION] you are the best!!!!!
[Xposed General] xdamami:
Agree. King Thank you for your Efforts!!!
[Xposed General] MattBooth:
AppOps is suitable enough for privacy. And there is every reason to debate it. The people coming out in opposition are the ones making the ROMs you used to use.

Lollipop has been a nice upgrade for me on my S4, though. It is better than the Kitkat ROMs used to be, by far.
[Xposed General] kingvortex:
App Ops is suitable for you. It has nowhere near the level of options for privacy as XPrivacy does that are required by others. If you don't need that level of protection, then that's OK. Don't think that your needs are the same as everyone else's though.

It comes down to what I said about people having different needs/use cases for their devices. There's nothing wrong with choice. The desire to provide choice is what drove the explosion in rom development and Android in general after all.

There's absolutely no reason that custom roms and Xposed can't coexist. The people in here speaking up for both options are proof that neither is going away any time soon. :)

Sent from my C6603
[Xposed General] DoctorRzepa:
Will this work on KitKat with ART also or only on Lollipop? Great job!
[Xposed General] Mike Cross:
Today is a good day for everyone of us! Thanks very much [MENTION=4419114]rovo89[/MENTION]! :D
[Xposed General] Ejvyas:
Replace custom rom by stock OEM and xPosed by custom ROM. Even Google / stock OEM can make this claim.

That is the power of open source

Sent from my Moto X
[Xposed General] nyr35blue:
Awesome news indeed!
[Xposed General] krachlatte:
finaly, with xposed going to upgrade to lolipop finaly
[Xposed General] Blackbird256:
This so much. Exactly how I feel. For me there is literally not a single thing that L offers to me so I don't need it now. And I'm not one of those people that upgrade to it just because it's higher version or has different theme/animations. That's like upgrading to Windows 8, because it has flat theme. Seriously? How pointless.
[Xposed General] magnamentis:
this guy is so "anti xposed" that one could easily assume that he never tried it out and therefore does not know what he's talking about. the latest posts and especially the latest about xprivacy would easily support this assumption. this is an xposed thread and to post consistently against xposed here is offending and OT. this is not a thread about if xposed is good or bad but a thread for Xposed users, not xoposed downers. how did you get your batch anyways. this would be a reason for reporting as you know or could be considered trolling which is not appropriate behaviour for an RC. just my 2 cents, willing to take any bashing hahah.....
[Xposed General] Eshi:
Thanks Rovo89! Like many others I'm waiting with upgrading to Lollipop until Xposed is compatible with ART. Keep up the good job!
[Xposed General] Aria.A97:
I think it's better to stop "Xposed or not" discussion. Nobody can stop a project that has more than 10K downloads per day except the developers.

You hate Xposed Framework? You thinks it's a development killer? Build a rom that doesn't need Xposed at all, nobody here wants an extra application.

And it's not always about rom customization, for example I used "Instagram Downloader" module to save Instagram top videos and pictures instead of taking screenshots. So for me that module made things easier. There are lot of other Xposed Modules which are more useful. For example Greenify!

I myself prefer to install a new module to change things, instead of backing up apps, rebooting to recovery and wiping data,system and caches to flash a new rom.

Again,if you wanna stop 3,000,000 person who are using Xposed, build a better app/rom. That's better way than complaining "God damn it, why Xposed became Lollipop compatible? :mad: "

Also best regards to [MENTION=4419114]rovo89[/MENTION] and [MENTION=4322181]Tungstwenty[/MENTION] for bringing Xposed to Android 5.0, giving Lollipop a better taste :fingers-crossed:
[Xposed General] Xiph1980:
/me does the happy dance! :victory:
[Xposed General] sherlock5545:
The one thing I miss the most is Greenify. Without Xposed it becomes very limited. Hope it works again when Xposed is released for Lollipop :)
[Xposed General] aouerfelli:
I'm assuming that all the other modules won't be there because of incompatibility issues, and that devs are going to have to make modules from scratch?
[Xposed General] bdizzle1686:
Wow... Dude, sorry to be so blunt, but u just uttered the most awful, arrogant, comment I've ever seen on here. This is easily the worst post I've ever seen on Xda. Rovo89 doesn't OWE us anything, AND , CERTAINLY NOTHING TO PROVE to the Android community. HE CREATED XPOSED FRAMEWORK. He will Never need to PROVE anything to us. Now the rule on here is Never ask for ETA'S right!?? Well rovo said SOON, and it should be left at that. For u to say he should put out a beta apk to "PROVE" it to us , is 1 of the most RIDICULOUS things I've ever heard.

That is all.
[Xposed General] Publiuss:
Just a question: since the only reason I'm still with Dalvik on KK is, of course, Xposed, will the "new" Xposed be compatible also with Kitkat + ART? :rolleyes:
[Xposed General] Primokorn:
I don't think so (that's why rovo89 had to create a 'new' framework).
[Xposed General] magnamentis:
why would it have to be? you have xposed working on kitkat and what thist talk about new and old. xposed is about functionalitiy not about new or old, the new would do the same like the old, depending whether module devs will update or not and the moment you have the function it does not matter which is the version number. this is like saying that a a pitch black background on new software looks pitch blacker than the pitch blach on an older version uuhhh...
[Xposed General] ldeveraux:
Let it go man! This thread is for devs to tell us why we shouldn't use Xposed. How dare you ask an honest question here?? :D
[Xposed General] patvdzwan:
So if I understand right, IF there would never be xposed for lollipop, the most of the people will not update to lollipop ever?
[Xposed General] vikraminside:
Correct. I won't.
[Xposed General] robertogl:
Nope, it will not be compatible.

Exactly.
[Xposed General] sherlock5545:
Some people may not. In my case, I never really used Xposed that much, only a few modules here and there. Which is why I never had problems upgrading to Lollipop when it came out. And now that more and more AOSP ROMs are available, the need for modules, in my case, is pretty much low. However, some Modules like the one provided by Greenify are really great, so I will install Xposed again when it is available.
[Xposed General] DarkBlack22:
Xposed is love, Xposed is life. I'm Sry

Sent from my GT-I9505 using WIGGLE WIGGLE WIGGLE
[Xposed General] patvdzwan:
That's exactly how I feel.

Gravitybox was of course one of them.
[Xposed General] MattBooth:
I feel differently, obviously. Why bother to toil away on hard coding mods and features that users will moan about because they conflict with a module they only want one or two features from? xposed only has one place, imho, and that's in stock OEM ROMs.

The upgrade to Windows 8 also brought about performance improvements, just like Lollipop has for devices that have some official support.

GermainZ said earlier that discussion and opinions are welcome, so long as they're not rude.

What's pathetic are posts like this. This is rude and abrasive.

EDIT:

Anyone who wants to disagree with me has every right, but no-one has the right to be rude and offensive just because you don't like what I have to say. I'm not breaking any rules, so neither should you.
[Xposed General] McFlypants:
Really good point. Calling an app that stands for development a development killer is being a development killer.

If someone does not like xposed for whatever reason just don't use it and don't post in here!

I don't go to a forum of the Miami heat and tell everybody how much I dislike them.
[Xposed General] Svartsyn333:
[MENTION=4419114]rovo89[/MENTION] should've closed the thread until he is ready. Really I've never ever read so much bull**** and arrogant stuff in one single thread!
[Xposed General] MattBooth:
It's not his thread.
[Xposed General] Sim-X:
With M9 release near, this would be holding me back. I know you don't take donations but I would have no problem donating what so ever. I like to support hard work.
[Xposed General] Svartsyn333:
Wasn't aware of this.
[Xposed General] justmpm:
Hi Everyone,

A couple of quick things. This has never been a development thread...it is a discussion thread that started with a joke. That's right a joke. I think a healthy discussion on developing with xposed vs. traditional ROM development is very interesting and I have learned a lot about the different way things work just from reading the posts from the developers. Please, continue with the discussions and don't worry so much about it being "off topic"...as long as it is about xposed it probably fits here. Please remember to keep your posts as respectful as you can. Discussion implies a disagreement or at least differing views and that can quickly turn into full on flaming unless you keep your...umm...errr...vocabulary under control.

Consider this a warning about personal attacks. There is no reason for personal attacks on xda, so please stop insulting people who have a different view point from yours. Make your own case if you feel like it or just try to absorb some knowledge.

Thanks!
[Xposed General] davtse:
[MENTION=3443334]Kryten2k35[/MENTION] Don't worry so much about these people. Some of them I have noticed from my i9300 days to be whiners and whingers(No names mentioned here but the person(s) should know who they are). They complain about every and anything, and contribute zilch.
[Xposed General] theCroh:
Me too. Just too lazy to write about it :P

Lähetetty Nexus seiska 2013:sta Tapatalkilla
[Xposed General] davtse:
What's funny here is someone who doesn't understand jack about coding or developing dares to call someone who actually does contribute pathetic. Don't agree with his point of view? Do it in a civil way. We're all civilized people. Unless you would like to prove me wrong on this.

Edit: See how you just proved me wrong? I guess just about anyone can use the internet, even Neanderthals.