yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] Moniclock:
I have installed m5 with n910f fix&kernel and on device details it say I'm on m4. It's normal?
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] bollycao18:
Flashed n910F working great as allways tanks Dr

---------- Post added at 11:29 AM ---------- Previous post was at 11:26 AM ----------

you have to flash latest m5 fix ;)

---------- Post added at 11:29 AM ---------- Previous post was at 11:29 AM ----------
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] dr.ketan:
Which fix you installed? M4 or newly posted M5 fix? Flash newer and report back
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] -HacKasS-:
This app copy apk + data or only apk?
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] bollycao18:
i think is only apk but saves me lot of time ;)
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] sibinn:
After cheksum md5 downloaded M5 rom (pass)

flashed M5 over M4 ( with Factory reset,cleared cahe and data) and then immediately flashed M5 fix for N910F

rebooted I get screen Android samsung Galaxy note 4

an then black screen 15 min.

Any ideas?
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] dr.ketan:
Shouldn't be more than 11 min after first splash screen appear. You should check md5 on device itself (can use root explorer)
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] caohuong22:
Hi guy, what the name font you use?
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] sibinn:
cheked too now I cant enter in cwm or downlod mode

uffff
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] caohuong22:
what is name font you use? tks
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] -HacKasS-:
Hello Doctor .. I ask here because the thread F is not updated.

1. flash last TWRP (3.0.0.0 or 3.0.2.0)

2. flash bt and modem Lollipop

3. flash rom m4 and m5 fix.

Exact?
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] dr.ketan:
Are you sure you haven't flash wrong bl modem?

Remove battery and try charging. Make sure battery isn't too low
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] louz:
Thanks. ..it's working now
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] dr.ketan:
Step 3 - ROM M5 not M4
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] sibinn:
Flashed again booting samsung logo blinking :) good

but on firs start i have yelow sighn warranty bit; kernel

thinking cable of charger mesed up instalation
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] -HacKasS-:
Ah sorry.. Ok
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] bollycao18:
bauhausltmedium ;)
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] lorilucille9:
Most people must be still sleeping today... lol! I was going to wait for others to ask but... [MENTION=3931450]dr.ketan[/MENTION] am in Love with your Rom :victory: Using it on my Verizon retail Note 4 that I converted to a Developer. Have one question I haven't seen a clear answer on it yet. Do I dirty flash over M4 or do a clean install and do I still use H Vitamin kernal? I'm using the 910G port currently on M4... thanks!

Well apparently XDA app did not update fast enough... got 3 pages of posts after I posted the above... ugh!
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] bollycao18:
Dr rom is incredible almost bugs are fixed the only 2 things that i can live with
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] jordiz86:
[MENTION=3931450]dr.ketan[/MENTION] just a curiosity, if I keep n4settings it's possible to use fingerprint to unlock the device? I lost only edge settings? I mean, if I set all as my wishes for edge, can I keep n4settings and use fingerprint? Thanks a lot!

Ps: installed this night m4 on my n910f (I made some mess with systemUI with m3 so I decided to upgrade :D), seems really good, I miss only fingerprint unlock because at work the phone unlock often when in pocket! Maybe I solved using glance plus that keep the screen dark, but if possible I prefer fingerprint :)

Thanks again! Keep up the good work ;)
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] sanjaydev:
[MENTION=3931450]dr.ketan[/MENTION] Downloading MM5.

One quick question: I have N10G and I am currently on stock TW rom N910GDTU1DPE1/N910GODD1SPE1/N910GDDU1DPB4 MM 6.0.1. Do I have to flash the BL and modem you have mentioned in the MM5 installation instructions?
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] dr.ketan:
No. N4 setting also won't allow to use lockscreen unlock with fingerprint.

Why don't you try C Locker

I will post my Clocker data backup, should be similar look.

Yes you have to flash BL otherwise device won't boot.
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] bollycao18:
Last one sorry too excited
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] Watchyv2:
are there any kernels that are supported for the G variant, that you know of for the MM5? loving it so far, just want some tweaking of the kernel :)
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] jordiz86:
OK thanks a lot! I was thinking that is only settings related! So it's base related I suppose? Now I'll try glance plus, this night I will try c locker, thanks! :)
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] stefaanovic:
Thank you very much Dr. ketan for this awesome rom.

I have noticed two bugs on the M5 that was not on the M4.

I cant update the people edge and the sound recorder.

I get a -113 in the galaxy apps.
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] sanjaydev:
[QUOTE

Yes you have to flash BL otherwise device won't boot.[/QUOTE]

Thank you Doc. I will definitely support you by going PRO. Playstore way appears to be the easiest for me. I was on your M4 before and it was impressive... M5 must be awesome!!:good:
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] barabangel:
delete...
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] KLPFL:
Sorry did i miss the AOD.apk app download link? Look and read but didn't see but instructions said to install as apk. TIA
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] dr.ketan:
Here is C locker widget (Free version) to set lockscreen with fingerprint

- You should have Titanium backup installed. and register your fingerprint with ROM tool

- Download and extract attached locker zip

- Copy extracted file to device and click on it with file explorer

- open with titanium

- select to restore app+data (OR you can download from play store and select data only)

- open application once and close it.

- From setting-lockscreen - set screen lock type to none

Now you will have lockscreen with fingerprint lock. password is 0000 (you can change from c locker app)

Link to Original app on play store
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] itsme_4ucz:
Hi [MENTION=3931450]dr.ketan[/MENTION]

I am unable to any event in splanner can check on this issue I have clean installed the rom. Its happening since M4 onwards.

Regards

Thank-you
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] dr.ketan:
Can you elaborate more how can i re produce it?

Issue was there on M4. It was causing FC on setting time of event but fixed on M5
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] bollycao18:
N910f i think everything is working
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] :
Hi

Great job on new Rom??

Any luck on the issue with Oncircle People Edge Mgs crash when sending Mgs?
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] Krrish. John:
910G M5

Everything working fine till now..AOD screen flickers on its own..and is too dark..can its brightness be set to auto? Also it is showing an update for AOD..shud i update?

New keyboard is cool.

Splanner fixed.

Thank you so much dr.ketan once again for this amazing experience.
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] PeppeGT:
Now i dont know which is the best DOCTOR!? You or Vale46 !! :silly:

Thank you very much Doctor :highfive:
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] alirey:
Everything is working on n910f.

Great work! Best ROM.

Thanks alot
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] konstantyno110:
910F I have M4

I would like install M5, do I have to do wipe data ?
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] masterchif92:
i was on m4 then i made a factory reset, flashed m5 and m5fix then rebooted. stuck at samsung logo....i have the same BL and modem from m4....i missed something? which modem and BL i must have for run it?
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] sPEADy:
Flash Supersu 2.71
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] konstantyno110:
910F I have

BL_N910FXXU1POK1.tar.md5

CP_N910FXXU1POK1.tar
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] Honeycd:
Not is a

Bootloader: N910FXXS1CPD1

Baseband: N910FXXS1COK1

for N910F?

Enviado desde mi SM-N910F mediante Tapatalk
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] sPEADy:
CPD1

COK1

this is what you need you can download both from Alexnder thread as well.
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] anikn96:
[IMG="My sim network name not showing instead this number"]http://i1230.photobucket.com/albums/ee497/AnikGupta/Mobile%20Uploads/Screenshot_2016-05-27-21-22-16.jpg[/IMG]

My carrier name is GP. After flashing with dr.ketan marshmallow roms m1 to m5 .my carrier actual name is not showing instead this number.Dr. can you tell me how to fix this.
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] -HacKasS-:
link download for recovery cwm marshmallow? (n910f) Please?
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] konstantyno110:
Answer someone or full wipe is necessary ???

---------- Post added at 05:53 PM ---------- Previous post was at 05:52 PM ----------

https://dl.twrp.me/trltexx/

Please :)
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] -HacKasS-:
Not twrp.. Cwm recovery.. Philz
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] konstantyno110:
http://xdaforums.com/devdb/project/?id=6498#downloads
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] -HacKasS-:
Is compatible with M5?
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] 04kiran:
Dr.. u got material black theme for m5?
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] garysully1986:
Hey Guys, my phone has been working prefectly the last few days. But I just got an error, the phone crashed and is in download mode now and saying "could not do normal boot, ddi: MMC_read failed". Unfortunately I am on holidays so I have limited resources to fix it here. Is there anything I can do to resolve this issue?
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] itsme_4ucz:
it says event created. but it dosent display it on widget or in the app.:mad:
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] konstantyno110:
Yes, This is the last version.
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] bollycao18:
it looks you need to do this it happens to me and it worked

http://xdaforums.com/note-4/orig-development/note-4-pit-files-repartiton-f-g-c-t-w8-t3282641
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] dominicstg2:
Is that because of lollipop also my phone lags so much any fix to that also play store apps don't download have been tried all day un rooting stock everything so laggy
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] ForceField:
Yes I did have a lag when I flashed without wiping my system and my internal phone memory

So I reflashed again by wiping everything (System and Phone Memory , Data , Cash , Dalvik...) and even cleaned my SD Card

Since then I am having no lag at all.

So I think make a backup on what you need from your internal phone memory and wipe it from Recovery before flashing

You will feel the difference right away from the first boot up of the phone

When the phone is working recopy the folders you backuped previously to your internal memory

(in my case DCIM and and titaniumbackup folders)
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] dominicstg2:
I tried this and nope so Lagg on stock just the indan rom it's not Laggy at the beginning it was no force closed on this rom I get so many problem if what to do
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] ForceField:
Strange , I am not having any lag. The ROM is snappy .

Try flashing the modem and bootloader provided by dr.ketan.

Maybe this will help
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] tiwag:
I think BOC3 is the version which is spread to all N910F devices atm.

sent using recycled bits
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] saints5354:
Apex Launcher

Hi Dr. K,

Your rom works great, really appreciate the effort, had been using for 1.5 day, never encounter any problem yet.

I have a question on Apex Launcher which i installed on this rom, after i enable "swipe down" action to show "Notification Bar" in Apex setting, it doesn't response. "Swipe Up" action works great, anyone can help.
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] joe.sebin:
Anybody having floating message working? For me its not.. pls confirm.
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] dr.ketan:
It's working. Long press floating msg from quick panel toggle. Turn off and on again.

It should work unless you flash any mod which may have broken it.
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] mamoo:
Working awesome bro. Once again great cook from Dr. A clean flash will solve many problems I took only apps +data via TB that's it.
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] pratik_193:
hey doc, can you make a flashable zip for reducing end call delay for LP too ? you have made one for kitkat, which worked like charm...!
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] vicelord_l:
Can anyone please suggest me how to get more themes for touchwiz theme.
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] rlorange:
Could someone please help me. I'm having no luck downloading the boot loader and modem rar from dev host. Could provide a mirror?
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] dominicstg2:
i flashed the lollipop n910g from india he said if i did that there was no need? also on stock everything works find but on this so many problems ive tried everything i followed the instructions, i wiped everything including memory card and internal. on stock su app showed the apps and i dont have to put on grant all it prompts it find second my internet works find on the rom it doesnt, there is lag everywhere on stock there is no lag. am i suppose to flash a custom kernal aswell or something?
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] Mussels84:
did you factory reset after installing the custom rom?
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] dominicstg2:
yes i did i said i did a full wipe everything internal and memory aswell
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] Mussels84:
then you shouldnt be having those issues, unless the modems or bootloader failed to update.
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] dominicstg2:
on stock indian n910g everything is find but when i install this rom there are so many problems
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] joe.sebin:
Yes now it's OK doctor.
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] InteliDroid:
Hey, click on the Blue "Download NOW" button and it should download.
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] rlorange:
Nope i get a 14k file instead tried every possible combination
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] masterchif92:
I have these ones but it didn't boot ....flashed all kernel and it works....for 910f users which kernel do you use? With the kernel provided in the fix it won't boot

Inviato dal mio SM-G935F utilizzando Tapatalk
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] bollycao18:
i use this one better battery for me and coj3 bl

http://xdaforums.com/note-4/snapdragon-dev/kernel-xceed-t3344742
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] masterchif92:
The kernel you use is 15 Apr build ?

Inviato dal mio SM-G935F utilizzando Tapatalk
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] garysully1986:
Cheers for that, a few questions, Do I need to get the stock rom or can i ise Dr Ketans? Will i have to update all the bootloader and modem again to get Dr Ketans rom back on to my device, I also used 910G for the ROM, am I still to use the PIT for 910F and will it work for the m4 update for the DR Ketans ROM?
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] bollycao18:
i think you have to do it with odin stock rom first ;(

---------- Post added at 05:51 PM ---------- Previous post was at 05:50 PM ----------

this one N910F-MM-test-bld2a ;)

https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B_3BNlXOVtO5LUNfc3RPZzNkX3M/view
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] dr.ketan:
Can you link me exact version of BL and Modem required for N910F for M5 so i can post it to ChangeLog post. Still many users couldn't find it correct one.
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] bollycao18:
BL_N910FXXU1COJ3.tar

https://mega.nz/#!UtVhTDBI!BtXvtNqBUhjE4jRhaUoPA62QFu_y0T2v_TtnhB74jIY

CP_N910FXXU1COJ3.tar

https://mega.nz/#!51cSBJYD!CnII7icBZ-C5XifRdOFKYCgGHHseobUopfDwsSXEnoQ

no more doubts
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] anikn96:
Flash with latest twrp .as cwm may unroot your phone after flashing the rom which occurred in my case.
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] louforgiveno:
I recommend twrp 3.0.1 over the most recent version of twrp
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] Karl Brunton:
Can anyone tell me how to extend the screen time out on the s view window? Want it to be active more than a second and not close when trying to use the cover camera. Thanks
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] konstantyno110:
repeat the question, do I have to do a full wipe installing version of the M5, When the current I M4 ( 910F )
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] bollycao18:
yes to avoid issues ;)
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] konstantyno110:
Ok, I take for making copies TB :)
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] _Negan_:
I can't understand this sentence, I'm on m3 and i unlock my phone with fingerprint as always, my N910F...
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] bidibull14:
Hi,

I've got n910f and M5.

My actual modem : N910FXXS1COK1

My actual bootloader : N910FXXS1CPD1

( Source: http://xdaforums.com/showthread.php?t=3363871 )

Do I need to change for coj3?

Thx
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] lilicaull:
m5 fix down link anyone pls ? :)
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] bollycao18:
yes ;) this one work for sure
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] arujali:
Thank you for the Rom Doctor!

I need some assistance with the following:

1. How to disable the Heads up notifications and get the old ticker back?

2. Is there any way to map double tap home button to Camera ?

3. Which DPI will the keyboard allow themeing ?
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] shantanil:
Flashed and booted fine on N910GDTU1DPD4_Bootloader_Modem for N910G. Thanks for a smooth ROM Dr. Ketan. Would you mind sending me over your details via PM so that I could pay for the pro tweaks?
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] Maks2005:
Good afternoon. installed m5 from scratch. not installed Russian language. tried everything - no how. prompt where to look
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] Krrish. John:
Anyone having issues with AOD?

AOD flickers on its own..is it a known issue?
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] bollycao18:
yes known issue for everyone ;) have to wait for magic

---------- Post added at 07:54 PM ---------- Previous post was at 07:53 PM ----------

---------- Post added at 07:55 PM ---------- Previous post was at 07:54 PM ----------

let me try ;)

---------- Post added at 08:00 PM ---------- Previous post was at 07:55 PM ----------

I can download this list but i dont think russian appears

---------- Post added at 08:14 PM ---------- Previous post was at 08:00 PM ----------

if you want try this i didnt tested if your phone explode not my fault hehehe flash in recovery

https://mega.nz/#!JplTgTAb!dShToyv_1Q5dBbsjKrnbqrDL5L3vGoH-fFJNh-dXMQw
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] Kryzyss:
Guys dirty flash is not supported method, but someone try that? M5 for N910F works fine?
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] Maks2005:
Russian language is in the list but when trying to load - hangs at 0 percent
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] bollycao18:
M5 is great my friend now dirty flash i didnt try clean install i bellieve its a must ;)
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] Kryzyss:
I know that and understand risk of full "app closed" everywere :) If someone try please quote me :)
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] bollycao18:
my last option flash this file reboot wipe cache just of keyboard then use root browser go to system/app and then delete samsungime folder then reboot again it will work i hope hehehehe

https://mega.nz/#!t4FjXDTZ!KTeyEjIwJbJ4LtuqjNczPVXF4pX3JQqD1yxpqVlfKYk
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] Quuki:
Maybe read changelog again...
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] bollycao18:
This app (settings editor xposed module) is great for editing the settings imagine that you want to debloat smartmanager and dont want to to have it on settings giving error when pressed with this app just remove that setting hope all understand

---------- Post added at 08:31 PM ---------- Previous post was at 08:30 PM ----------
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] yassine78:
can someone advice me how to install this rom correctly on sprint 910p?
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] ozankardes:
Compulsory set a password using the exchange.

I hate exchange but, I'm obliged to it.
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] sibinn:
Report

ROM (M5) is beast blazing fast like lightning also

just to report that I discovered two things

1.When you turn on Night clock on Display settings

you will get blackish screen just like on AOD (Always on display)

So do not activate this option.

2.I also cant download lang. (Serbian) but it was incorporated already in keyboard
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] vivrosh:
Getting force close in massage app when you try to select from. Pin
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] bollycao18:
Yep me too [emoji27]
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] Maks2005:
Quuki - thank you
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] 0-0-0:
Thank you for the new version.

********* Security Risk *********

I've set up my fingerprints, installed C Locker Widget and set the phone's lockscreen to None, as the instructions.

But I've noticed when switching on the phone from off, the phone's UI can be accessed before I'm prompted for the SIM number and again for about 5 to 10 seconds before C Locker's fingerprint unlock starts.

Has anyone else experienced this and can it fixed, so there no waiting for C Locker to start?

Thanks
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] sibinn:
Me not working good
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] PeppeGT:
But for csc ITV? Can i flash the same package of M4?
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] douger1957:
Repeat. Read the installation directions.

"If you have to ask whether you can dirty flash, you should be doing a clean flash." Dr Ketan.
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] jaklm:
i have just one question i want the rom to be so similar to the stock one. so is there any problems in uninstalling the extra app like 3minit battery or others.
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] douger1957:
This is where Titanium Backup shines.

Backup all apps, then freeze the ones you don't want. If your ROM works okay after a couple of days, then you can delete them. I would also have a complete nandroid backup so that if you get too aggressive and have problems, you can quickly recover.
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] OzBoy1:
Thanks for the update will install shortly but this cracked me up...glad to see you have a sense of humour!!

- My bla bla bla is not exact like S7 - Because you don't have S7 :p
[Galaxy Note 4 Android Development (Snapdragon)] jaklm:
thanks for the reply