yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Atrix 4G Android Development] Harrson:
Preliminary Findings

Flashing the recovery image and ROM went without issue, and upon first boot the phone showed SIM NOT FOUND. Flashing PA Modular Micro GApps removed this message, but while phone calls worked, mobile data did not. Flashing baseband-N_01_100.00R enabled mobile data (which is awesome).

Wifi: Good

Camera: Functional, but flash behavior is imperfect - taking pictures with only the shutter button does not trigger the flash, however tapping somewhere in the image to focus the camera before taking the picture causes the flash to function normally for that picture. If you want to take multiple pictures, you'll have to focus the camera each time if you want the flash to go off.

Bluetooth: Appears to be functional - it paired successfully with my headset - but audio for calls does not work. The headset does go off when I receive a call, and I can answer it by clicking the 'answer' button on the headset, but I get no sound from the BT earpiece and the other person cannot hear me, either. I have not tested it with music.

Memory: With only the ROM and GApps installed, it shows that 443MB are used, and 344MB are free, with a total of 768 shown in About Phone.

Note on Mobile Data: A bug in CM9 limited the network connection to HSPA:10 (or was it 11?), but this ROM does not show what HSPA type the phone is using in Phone Information, which can be reached by entering *#*#4636#*#* in the dialer. It may or may not suffer from the same limitation.

Anyone have better luck with BT audio?
[Atrix 4G Android Development] Voldemort:
My bad, there must have been some sync while I checked the ram, now everything seems normal.
[Atrix 4G Android Development] sandeep1415:
Not able to download the file

Hi If any one has the back up of the file would you please upload into another source and provide the link here, I am not able to down load the file,I am getting network error each time i try,

Thank you
[Atrix 4G Android Development] cailloup:
Awesome! Thanks Z! Impressive how the first version can already be a daily driver!

mobile data also works for me, with baseband-N_01_100.00R.

Downloaded the gapps from a link found in a previous post: http://xdaforums.com/showthread.php?t=2397942

FULL MODULAR PACKAGE works fine

I confirm this behaviour

confirmed too, same behaviour as CM10.2, music ok, but no audio or mic on calls
[Atrix 4G Android Development] ovitz:
I've got a lot of random reboots (4-5 per hour), everything else is fine and stable.
[Atrix 4G Android Development] Zn7mkUKzN1r8aCIV:
THE "CWM-based Recovery v6.0.3.7" is included in Olympus_Kitkat.zip package, just unzip it, you don't need to look around for that recovery.img ( of course it is NOT from Atrix HD :) )
[Atrix 4G Android Development] PolesApart:
Looked at the dock issue more deeply and the way it's currently implemented it depends on whisperd. There are two problems with it:

a) permissions of some /dev files are wrong regarding what whisperd expects.

b) fixing that, it still fails to issue an ioctl to cpcap.

The ioctl is supposed to be present in the kernel and it seems that somehow the compiled whisperd from old-days had different ioctl numbers from current kernel. At least that was what I concluded after killing whisperd and running strace on a new instance of whisperd.

I've found the sources for xoom's whisperd on https://android.googlesource.com/device/moto/stingray/+/master/whisper/, and it seems like it's somewhat compatible with atrix. The problem is that it have to be added to android build system and probably the whole thing would have to be rebuild. Also some fine tuning would be necessary to fix permissions on /dev. That would probably match the expeted ioctl numbers.

The way whisperd is written it assumes /dev/cpcap /dev/hidraw0 and /dev/ttyHS0 are accessible by either user or group 'radio'. It seems it's compiled idea of what GID radio has differs from what's on these files on /dev as it is now.

*****

HAVING SAID THAT, here (in annex) is my two-line-magic-patch that makes the kernel recognize both docks by itself. The idea was to recognize the docking and fix the undocking on a second patch, but the undock is working too :P

If someone wants to play with it, I can make a kernel update package too.

Another thing is that this just supports multimedia and car dock. The regular dock will either work without this patch or still don't work without it.

The lapdock is probably still unsupported as I have none to test.

Edit: for the car dock support to actually do anything, you need to install car home or an equivalent. I downloaded the apk somewhere (google is your friend).

The audio routing probably will work fine in v3 if Z merges that audio stuff, at least I see some interesting intents on logcat regarding the absent receiver for cm.dockaudio messages :)
[Atrix 4G Android Development] Zn7mkUKzN1r8aCIV:
Great work, Poles!!!

the fact is the whisperd in V1/V2 was built from Xoom's source :) though I only disabled log.txt output to /data hoping to fix disk encryption in Kitkat, let me know more fixes you want to do with whisper sourceode. Thx. a million!

So after your patch, is V2 able to detect and run in media dock & car dock (ya know I have neither to test it myself, my apology) Is dock audio output normal???

/packages/apps/DockAudio was already built also in V1/V2, but of course it is marked as Gingerbread
[Atrix 4G Android Development] PolesApart:
With the kernel patch, android sees both docks and react ok on plug/unplug, except for the audio routing (the audio in car dock is supposed to work ok as it shouldn't attempt to reroute it). The audio on the multimedia dock is muted, so there's something missing here. IIRC it wasn't working 100% on epinter's with kernel 3.1 as well, but I maybe wrong. There was someting on logcat which could help debugging audio routing, I'll look at it again when I find a spare time.

Thanks!
[Atrix 4G Android Development] Zn7mkUKzN1r8aCIV:
So you have a LapDock???

Can you test it for us, post the state values of (they are all in "/sys/class/switch/FILL_IN_NAME/state";

"whisper";

"smartdock";

"emuconn";

"dock";

"extdock"

& maybe "hdmi"

after PLUG and UNPLUG of LapDock, Thx.
[Atrix 4G Android Development] Mustkeg:
With lapdock attached, smartdock is "1". Everything else docked/undocked is "0", including hdmi.

Edit: Wrote a batch file, that's more comfortable :)

Feel free to use/change:

@echo off
echo whisper
adb shell cat /sys/class/switch/whisper/state
echo smartdock
adb shell cat /sys/class/switch/smartdock/state
echo emuconn
adb shell cat /sys/class/switch/emuconn/state
echo dock
adb shell cat /sys/class/switch/dock/state
echo extdock
adb shell cat /sys/class/switch/extdock/state
echo hdmi
adb shell cat /sys/class/switch/hdmi/state

Undocked Atrix:

whisper
0
smartdock
0
emuconn
0
dock
0
extdock
0
hdmi
0

Atrix in Lapdock, Lapdock closed:

whisper
1
smartdock
0
emuconn
0
dock
0
extdock
0
hdmi
0

Atrix in Lapdock, Lapdock opened (and showing "no signal" after few seconds):

whisper
0
smartdock
1
emuconn
0
dock
0
extdock
0
hdmi
0

Atrix in "simple" dock (USB, Audio out). Oh, just like closed lapdock :)

whisper
1
smartdock
0
emuconn
0
dock
0
extdock
0
hdmi
0
[Atrix 4G Android Development] jcrahul:
Ready to help just give me little time

Hi Zn7mkUKzN1r8aCIV

I currently have two atrix 4G also i have the car dock, the lapdock and the HDMI dock, i'd be glad to help test stuff just PM me whatever you need till the 2nd of nov i'll be helping at a slow pace as am giving exams after that would be continue helping on a wider scale just PM me what help you need regarding behavior with dock :) i was unable to PM you so messaged on the thread. ( one of the atrix is running this rom the other one is still on nottach)
[Atrix 4G Android Development] torecdude:
after a couple of weeks i can report that youtube app is still crashing to me after i updated ( mabey its because im using youtube adaway?)

Only CM browser is crashing when i try to download anything. stock browser working fine.

Internet connection is still droping quite often and gets back only with reboot, it still takes a long time until iget service connection after boot.

lots and lots of random freezes and reboots (about 10 a day).

if i plug usb cable and mount stroge, i noticed that when i turn off usb storge and unplug my cable, phone is trying to prepare SD card for use and then phone automatically soft boots every time.

im proving you aduit.log + logcat.txt for your inspection. please take a look. Thanks :)
[Atrix 4G Android Development] Zn7mkUKzN1r8aCIV:
after a second thought, there might be more testing needed on the docking

for example in CAR_DOCK, whisper state is toogled even if a charger is attached, we have to differentiate it

i.e. accy == CPCAP_ACCY_CHARGER || accy == CPCAP_ACCY_WHISPER_PPD

so more test, sorry
[Atrix 4G Android Development] PolesApart:
Yes, you have to differentiate between charger & dock, nice catch, Z!

I have patched my sources and will try it on the wall charger just in case (haven't tried it since first patch).

I just didn't put the debug lines in the kernel as it prints the accy stuff at some points so we probably can catch the same info.

If someone have a "dumb" dock, i.e. not the multimedia one and is willing to help, I can send a kernel update zip and you can report if the docking/undocking works. Alias, it would be nice to know if that works even without the patch, as I was expecting it might.
[Atrix 4G Android Development] plinkykev:
Sorry, just saw this. I've got all dock types (dumb/media/car/lapdock) so let me know what you want me to test (and how!)

Sent from my KitKat Atrix
[Atrix 4G Android Development] Sloosh:
sorry but is it stable enough for a daily use ? (did not find enough information about what works and what doesn't)

Does wifi and mobile data works too ?

Thanks
[Atrix 4G Android Development] guruzen:
Wifi and mobile data works. There are a few modem drops when wifi and mobile data are turned ON. Apart from that it is a daily driver except for battery drain. Turn off data if you want a better battery life.

Do try it and enjoy the taste of kitkat.. I have been with this Rom for over a month and i am enjoying the phone. Waiting for v3 from Z.
[Atrix 4G Android Development] DooMaster:
¿You mean this?:

BTW I have to change the digitalizer of my second atrix...but haven found proper courage to do it with time, dont wanna break anything in the process :rolleyes:

Hey Z, cannot send PM to you, ¿Do you want the HD Dock for further testings?, as I stated before, I have several and I prefer to donate one rather to sell it.

Best Regards
[Atrix 4G Android Development] iTaisHi:
for my opinion CM11 is better than CM9,

i use it for daily.

Z&K and the all the other doing Holy Job that let our Old good Atrix function with KK444 :good:

some things that need to be improve (important for me):

1. camera light - the picture get low light and locks sometimes too dark.

2. there are Reboots and Freezes (in Freeze situation, if you wait enough time - finally it will reboot)

3. operating system load time can be better - for me its 1 min and 45 sec till the system finish to start, and more 45 sec till it connect to the carrier.

4. Data network drops - happend to much time, and reboots solve it - my WIFI is always disabled

Z&A and all other,

i dont use LapDock,

but if you need i can make tests - just tell me what should i do for that. (i know how to collect and attach Logs here).

do you need more Logs of Reboots and crashes?

do someone use Shazam app ? its crash also....

thanks again for all.

I.
[Atrix 4G Android Development] plinkykev:
Dockmodes

OK, finally got around to testing this too, using the script posted by Mustkeg - thanks - saved me some typing!

Basically mains charger, dumb dock and car dock all report "whisper = 1" and smartdock and lapdock report "smartdock = 1" (all other values 0), which I think is the same as others have reported. Screenshot attached.

Interestingly while the lapdock screen didn't work (usual HDMI issue), the lapdock keyboard and trackpad did work (presumably as a USB keyboard and USB mouse), meaning once HDMI is working, the trackpad and mouse will hopefully just carry on working too, giving us full functionality!

I guess the question is what other flag(s) need checking, as mains/dumb/car all report as same type, and smart and lapdock report as the same type as each other. What tells all of these to be different from each other?
[Atrix 4G Android Development] ranjithkumar1201:
I really appreciate the support and hard work you guys are putting for keeping this beast alive

Have immense respect

But plz let us know what all is working and what not is otherwise starters like us don't understand your hard work

I request you to update
[Atrix 4G Android Development] guruzen:
Hope you are using 100.R baseband. With this baseband and wifi disabled, network drops are hardly seen on my phone.

http://a.hiyouli.com/860/bp.html
[Atrix 4G Android Development] plinkykev:
I use this as a daily build, and a few pages ago (post #342) shared my views. Other have posted their views in this thread too. I suggest you start 10-15 pages back and read forwards....
[Atrix 4G Android Development] kyva1929:
Anyone got wifi 5GHz working on this rom?
[Atrix 4G Android Development] guruzen:
May be you should try the "Workarounds" section in the below link

http://www.androidpolice.com/2014/0...uble-connecting-to-5-ghz-wi-fi-access-points/

Let us know if it helps for Atrix.

---------- Post added at 03:20 AM ---------- Previous post was at 03:18 AM ----------

May be you should try the "Workarounds" section in the below link

http://www.androidpolice.com/2014/0...uble-connecting-to-5-ghz-wi-fi-access-points/

And, there is a Motorola forum question around this..

https://forums.motorola.com/posts/9ef2aa7633

Let us know if it helps for Atrix.
[Atrix 4G Android Development] iTaisHi:
thanks guruzen,

i had tried before, but there was no connection with 100.R,

i tried it again now, and again, after flashing 100.R, again - no connection, and first boot took along time.

finally i found out that there is no APN configured, i enter it manually, and still nothing,

made another reboot , and on the 2nd boot, APN was added (than i erased the manual configured one),

connection good now, with 100.R,

i will look after that, and inform here .

(i am with this Radio now : N_01.100.00R_gb_retail_22sep2011.zip)
[Atrix 4G Android Development] guruzen:
Glad that it works.. Be on data only if you want lesser modem drops. We have seen modem drops quite often if Wifi is ON.

So, keep it OFF if you can manage all your sync with mobile data.
[Atrix 4G Android Development] joshua764:
Hello from Mexico to Argentina Z are grateful for your work. We look forward to v3

Enviado desde mi atrix latino:D
[Atrix 4G Android Development] sarasasasa:
Installed and testing!

I was waiting for V3 to come out and install it but today i had the time, so I installed it ^^

Looks amazing! Thank you very much Z!!!!!!!!!!!!!

As soon as you post V3 i'll update ^^
[Atrix 4G Android Development] torecdude:
Some apps are force closing after i used them for a couple of weeks. They worked excellent at the begining but now they are force closing after i press their action button. For example, battery fix for the atrix is fc after pressing run the fix. Hiromacro which is for touch auto reply is fc after im pressing "tap to start recording". Both apps uses root permissions and worked fine when i flashed v2. I tried clearing apps data, reinstalling, force closing manually, no luck. How is this possible for this to happen and how can i fix this? It didn't happened to me with V1.
[Atrix 4G Android Development] dattafilthyd:
google play services force close

google play services force close issue after updating itself from version 5.0.89 to 6.1.09.

Anyone else facing this issue?
[Atrix 4G Android Development] guruzen:
No.. May be you can try the following.

1. Clear cache and restart the device for Google Play Services.

2. Delete Play services apk from system/app, restart and re-install the new one.

3. Revert it to 5.0.89 if nothing works.
[Atrix 4G Android Development] Zn7mkUKzN1r8aCIV:
V3

Rather occupied right now, will post V3 by end of Oct at most, be patient
[Atrix 4G Android Development] iTaisHi:
guruzen,

thanks again.

the 100.R Baseband is really a big improvement in the Atrix daily use.

no reboots and no network drop for 2 days already. :good:

i can tell for sure that this is a good version for daily use.

still bothering me the camera Performance:

1. the amount of light getting into the lens it too dark.

2. focus is not stable (or not accurate).

3. for those who are using "lens blur" - in this mode the app crash.

waiting patiently for V3 :D
[Atrix 4G Android Development] dennis789:
hello,

This rom power display normal?

http://xdaforums.com/showthread.php?t=2060064&page=403
[Atrix 4G Android Development] thecjan:
thanks Z, see u month later and then L will out?
[Atrix 4G Android Development] guruzen:
Not really. It charges till 70-80% and if you use Atrix Battery Fix, it shows 150% or so.. However, least significant as we are just happy that atrix got 4.4.4
[Atrix 4G Android Development] PolesApart:
Testing Kernel for Z's Kitkat

** post edited ** I have a new atrix and was able to setup it to a working state apparently without the need to a custom kernel. As such, I'm dropping this version to avoid any unnecessary support. Please disregard it ;)
[Atrix 4G Android Development] attrixnor:
whoo , it's a great function, i will stand for it :D.

could you tell us if gps google or other work better as old android version ?

Thanks
[Atrix 4G Android Development] iTaisHi:
PolesApart,

in the begining of your messege is sounds really good,

but when i keep reading, it seems that you had alot of reboots caused by all the music, battery and etc' you mentioned

all those reboots - did they happened every couple of hours?

i have now the original V2 kernel , and hardly have network drops,

so the new kernel (patches) wont improve something i can feel or see ....... :confused:

guruzen,

i had today 2 reboots, after 2 days without reboots after configured 100.R,

i will keep inform about it.

(the 2nd reboot causde the Atrix uploading taking alot of time - strange)
[Atrix 4G Android Development] PolesApart:
Clarifying:

My scenario was:

a) random reboots when not wall powered. Sometimes they're seldom, sometimes (i.e. listening to music w/ bluetooth headphone) very frequent.

b) Modem drops (eventually in 2g mode, almost immediately in 3g).

If you happen to have a more stable scenario, please don't experiment the kernel, just be happy with what you have.

If you happen to have frequent modem drops - a common complaint - , please try the kernel.

If you don't use 3g data connection (i.e. you only use wifi), there's not to gain here too, so keep the original kernel.

Also, this is a development thread, so for everyone else that have no problems, just disregard the subject, let's not flood the stream with "I don't have these issues, I have others or I don't have them, should I try the kernel?". The answer would be "please don't". Thanks!
[Atrix 4G Android Development] Totopoxtle:
I want to contribute again with my experience:

I was having a lot of reboots too, but now I'm enjoying a very stable rom, as I understood, in my case (and some others) this was caused of having Wifi an 3Gdata activated at the same time, so, I decided to install Apndroid, so, the most of the time when I'm connected to Wifi I have the 3Gdata off, and when I'm moving to somewhere and theres not a Wifi connection I activate data, and I haven't seen a reboot I think about a week.

I'm using Radio N38P...the most recent (I think.)

The issue that's now more remarcable (at least for me) is that after connect and activate USB transfer, when disconnect is chosed the phone reboots.

Best Regards
[Atrix 4G Android Development] Voldemort:
Does apndroid switch off 3G automatically when you connect to WiFi? I tried to look into the app description but it seems to be a simple switcher - I can switch the connection from the tiles manually without installing another app.
[Atrix 4G Android Development] Totopoxtle:
[MENTION=462587]Voldemort[/MENTION]

It's simply a switch as you say, and you've to activate manually, but with this aplication I haven't had reboot problems anymore, anyway, I have to say that I haven't noticed that touching the signal simbol in the tiles deactivates 3Gdata, if you're having a lot of reboots maybe you'd try apndroid, maybe can be helpful.

Best Regards
[Atrix 4G Android Development] attrixnor:
Totopoxtle, how many time you can use your atrix without reboot if you let in 3G only (with apndroid) ?

did it reboot when the phone is not use (let on a desk) ?
[Atrix 4G Android Development] Sloosh:
good, will try it...
[Atrix 4G Android Development] Totopoxtle:
[MENTION=4913799]attrixnor[/MENTION]

Didn't understand very well, but in my case, when I arrive to my office, or my house I put apndroid in off (no 3Gdata) and keep only the wifi, and in I haven't noticed any reboots, before I installed it I was having 3 or 4 reboots each hour, boot, the 3Gdata was activated too, so, maybe you can get stopping reboots just deactivating 3Gdata in tiles, but as I said, I hadn't noticed that touching the signal symbol you can do it...

When I'm moving (in my car or in the bus) and there's not a wifi connection (usually in the car, here some buses has Internet for the passengers) I put apndroid to on, an I haven´t observed reboots.

As I can see maybe the annoying thing is that it's not automatic and you have to be switching as is needed, but I repeat, in my case I've had good results, the rom is really attractive, but when I was getting all the reboots I did'nt like it, with this I'm really enjoying the phone, again, thanks to Z and all other for all the efforts.

Best greetings
[Atrix 4G Android Development] PolesApart:
Folks, are you disabling wifi when on data mode, just disabling data mode on wifi, or both? :)
[Atrix 4G Android Development] Harrson:
When I tested with V1, I had both wifi and mobile data active at all times and had no reboots for the ~2 days I tried it (using v100 radio).

Frankly, while the idea of having an updated ROM is very appealing, not having bluetooth audio for calls is kind of a deal breaker for me.

On that note, actually, if someone can point me in the general direction of what's causing that issue I'd be happy to look. I've got zero experience with ROM cooking or kernel hacking, but I do develop software for a living, so reading code is nothing strange to me. (warning: I may ask a bunch of questions as I go, as my experience is limited to .NET and suchlike).
[Atrix 4G Android Development] plinkykev:
Hi Poles. I installed this just before noticing you pulled it (!) and saw that at some docking stuff is now working, so looks like that is on track - hopefully included in v3 later this month.

- smartdock - asks for an app (I have Car Home Ultra and the standard Daydream installed) and once set, seem OK

- Lapdock - didn't ask for an app (open or closed), so it knows the difference at least, and keyboard and mouse still worked OK when open

- dumb dock - same as smartdock, asks for app.

- Car Dock - says "car mode active" in status bar and auto launches Car Dock Home (which I already had installed) - it never asked which app to load - is this hard coded, or does it know which possible apps to load?

One random reboot after installing and idle - looked like a BT issue from the log. I'll keep this kernel for now, but won't post logs as it's "unofficial", but happy to test and report anything else, if needed.