[8525, TyTN, MDA Vario II, JasJam General] flashgordonv:
Well, I am onto my fourth Windows PPC device - Casio, HP5450, K-Jam and Dopod838Pro, with various excursions into the lands of Palm, SE P900, Motorola A900. My WM experience is still that the best way to get a fast and stable device is to add the absoloute minimum of today add-ins. Across all these WM devices, whenever I add in something even mildly complex to the Today screen, the device is in some way compromised - either it slows down, needs more soft resets, or it acts unpredictably. When the device was just a PDA, I could live with it. Now that it is my phone, I need it to be 100% reliable. I need the phone functions, I need contacts and calendar. These have to work reliably all the time. After that anything else is a bonus.

So I am in a bit of a dilemma. I added Phone Alarm and everything was fine. Then I added iLauncher3 to the Dopod and BOOM - suddenly there are issues, suddenly everything slows down, suddenly some inbound calls are not answering, suddenly the phone is locking up or executing applications very slowly. SO I take off the Launcher and still there are issues, so I take off PhoneAlarm and everything calms down - except that my WMA ring tones start to play at half speed. And still the occasional freeze. I'm thinking I probably need to do a hard reset and rebuild the phone, but you know, that takes a lot of time and I'm peeved that this is probably the best course of action and I just don't want to have to go through the hassle of doing it AGAIN.

I also own a Nokia E61. I switched back to the Nokia yesterday after using the Dodod solidly for 3 weeks. The biggest reason for wanting to try WM5 again was the jog wheel and the added functionality of it, the cool look of the Dopod and the availability of so much software. But in the final analysis, the way I want to use the device I cannot find a way to use today plug-ins and have a 100% reliable phone - so the available software that I want to use isn't really available at all.

And the E61 is a WAY better phone, has a brilliant profile function, syncs automatically with bluetooth whenever I am in range of the PC (with no intervention unlike the PPC which needs me to manually select bluetooth sync).

I am sure other people will jump in and tell me they have a perfect, stable, fast and reliable experience with their WM5 device, even when using multiple Today plug-ins. I wish that was true for me, but it is not and I so am over doing hard resets and rebuilding the phone with just the short listed software - it should not be necessary.

I am really quite peeved about the whole process. There is much to like about the Hermes, good fast processor, smart looks, there is much to like about the available software, (there is also much to dislike about the relatively disjointed user interface but in reality it is just a way of thinking about how you use the phone). As far as the E61 is concerned it is not perfect either, but at the moment for me it is the better tool because I can turn it on and it will work, perfectly, as a phone, a contacts database and a portable calendar, it gives me fast internet access and availability to the core apps I require (even if it does take an eternity - 30 seconds - to open a spreadsheet that opens in a couple of seconds on the Dopod)

The search for the perfect device continues and yes I am sure sometime in the next month or two I will get brassed off with the E61 and go back to the Dopod - no doubt I will pingpong between these two devices until the next killer device is launched.