yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[HTC Droid DNA] mdphoenix:
Failed. Sent one message. Then subsequent failed until cycling Airplane mode.

Stopped messaging app. Cleared defaults. Cleared cache. Cleared data.

Same issue.

I'm going to shoot myself in the face with a bazooka.

EDIT: F5 F5 F5 F5 F5 F5
[HTC Droid DNA] RLGL:
try clearing cache from fastboot, I do not know the command.
[HTC Droid DNA] mdphoenix:
THAT is something I know how to do. Brb.
[HTC Droid DNA] orangechoochoo:
Flash a custom kernel.
[HTC Droid DNA] mdphoenix:
No love.
[HTC Droid DNA] mdphoenix:
I will attempt that. Stand by.

Looks like I can use this one:

http://xdaforums.com/showthread.php?t=2559529

??

I was going to use Beastmode but it shows as 4.3 only.
[HTC Droid DNA] orangechoochoo:
You need crpalmers kernel.

---------- Post added at 04:38 PM ---------- Previous post was at 04:37 PM ----------

The link you have is right.

---------- Post added at 04:40 PM ---------- Previous post was at 04:38 PM ----------

Don't bother with the kernel settings for now.
[HTC Droid DNA] mdphoenix:
Just flashed it and tested. No love. Same exact issue. I don't HAVE to use KitKat. Shall I try a 4.3 ROM? Or should I just call VZ and see if there's something on their end? I just did a bunch of Googling and found that lots of people appear to be having similar problems with custom ROMs on S3s now.
[HTC Droid DNA] orangechoochoo:
Try the 4.3 GPE ROM, or Carbon ROM 4.3. They're both solid. I'm still using Carbon 4.3 because I don't like some of the changes in KK.

---------- Post added at 04:52 PM ---------- Previous post was at 04:47 PM ----------

I looked and the highest non-KK version of GPE is 4.2.
[HTC Droid DNA] mdphoenix:
My man, I'm not seeing a 4.3 DLX CarbonROM anywhere. I did lots of Googling, and looking here. I only see 4.4.
[HTC Droid DNA] orangechoochoo:
You're right, Pio didn't upload it after his site was taken down by the feds. PM pio_masaki and see if he can upload the last version of Carbon 4.3.

Try Newtoroot's GPS 4.2 ROM. With this it feels like aosp and you can use the xposed modules for more tweaks.
[HTC Droid DNA] mdphoenix:
Man, sonofa@#%^!@!*()(^#!!!#@#$

I flashed Newtoroot's 4.2. Can't send multiple SMS and stuck in 3G.

Looks like I'm destined to run a stock friggin' ROM with sense.
[HTC Droid DNA] orangechoochoo:
You need to get logs and post them so the developers can see what's going on.

It's hard to believe that two phones and two sim cards still have the same issue. It could be bad luck with having to get two defective phones and defective sim cards, but it is not impossible. With odds like that I would buy some megaball/lotto tickets just in case your streak of hitting the unlikely odds can produce something positive :)
[HTC Droid DNA] mdphoenix:
I hate computers....

I did find this:

http://forums.androidcentral.com/ve...y-send-text-message-once-every-few-hours.html

Interesting. Exactly what I'm getting.
[HTC Droid DNA] orangechoochoo:
It's a Samsung, so even though it has the same/similar problem it could be caused by two completely unrelated things.

For Newtoroot's ROM, there's a patch you must apply.
[HTC Droid DNA] d08speed3:
Have Verizon over the phone reset your network or something like that.

HTC DNA

LG Optimus G
[HTC Droid DNA] mdphoenix:
This is exactly what I'm thinking. I'm friggin' done. Everything was perfect until this started. Now two phones and two SIMs? I can't believe it's the fault of any ROM. And, not that I'm a genius, but I've been doing this since the old Windows Mobile and my XV6700. I'm calling them if this last flash doesn't work. If that doesn't do any good, I'm switching carriers and going to a feature phone.
[HTC Droid DNA] mdphoenix:
This has been escalated to Verizon Wireless network support. We'll see what they come up with.
[HTC Droid DNA] orangechoochoo:
Did you try a different messaging app?

You said it works fine with stock Sense, so the problem is most likely not on their end.
[HTC Droid DNA] mdphoenix:
I did. Handscent did the same thing.
[HTC Droid DNA] mdphoenix:
I do not understand this. I don't program so I don't know what's going on in the background. But VZ says they can see my phone try to send texts, only to be rejected and bounce back. They aren't clear on why it's happening. Only that it's happening. Of course I haven't told them I'm not stock. But it makes no sense. It is incomprehensible to me that no one else has experienced this.

They're going to activate my line on a test phone tomorrow at their support center with me on the phone to see if it works. Of course, it will. Then they're going to send me another phone. This appears to be hopeless.
[HTC Droid DNA] orangechoochoo:
That's weird, I've been on non-stock ROMs for a year and a half without a problem. At least you found out that the problem is on their end. You did everything right as far as flashing and wiping.

Maybe they can swap your phone for a One M8 :)

---------- Post added at 05:45 PM ---------- Previous post was at 05:43 PM ----------

And how is activating a phone at another location going to help? Maybe something is funky with the tower nearby.

Have you tried going a few miles away and texting?

---------- Post added at 05:49 PM ---------- Previous post was at 05:45 PM ----------

Maybe something is funky with your APN or network settings. They confirmed that your phone sent it but their network rejected it.
[HTC Droid DNA] mdphoenix:
I have identical results both at home and work. Work is 20 miles away in a dense little town just outside of Baltimore. Plenty of towers and signals. I think they just want to try it to see what happens. I dunno what's going to come of this. But it's insane. I hope someone else has this issue and comes forward so I don't feel like I'm cursed.
[HTC Droid DNA] iamjonmiller:
I have the exact same problem.
[HTC Droid DNA] mdphoenix:
SCORE!

If you've already gone through troubleshooting to verify it's not the phone or SIM, please harass them (politely. I've not been belligerent or stern with them once), so they realize this is not an isolated incident.
[HTC Droid DNA] santod040:
H

Well, I'm curious.

Did you ever do rooted stock Rom and stock recovery and perform a factory reset while on stock recovery like I suggested and you were linked to?

This is a known solution for repairing the phones NV radio partitions.

A custom recovery does not do this and once those partitions are screwed up, they will remain that way until the above process is done.

I wouldn't suggest it if it wasn't necessary or didn't work.
[HTC Droid DNA] mdphoenix:
I didn't. And I don't know why. I"ll try it tonight.
[HTC Droid DNA] mdphoenix:
Just so I'm clear, am I just flashing the stock rooted RUU then resetting factory defaults from Stock Recovery? I realize that's pretty much what you said. Just want to make sure I've got everything right before I do it.
[HTC Droid DNA] santod040:
Ruu isn't necessary.

But you have the rest correct.

I would just flash my stock odexed rooted Rom and stock recovery.

Then do a reset from settings.

Back everything up first to a pc that you want saved.
[HTC Droid DNA] mdphoenix:
I want nothing. I've been running around with a phone with nothing except my Exchange e-mail account on it for two weeks now. I just want it to work.

I'll report back shortly.
[HTC Droid DNA] mdphoenix:
Okay. I'm back on stock. I skipped the wizard and reset everything. Now I'm back on the phone. I've got 4G and just as with previous returns to stock root, I can text all day long.

What do you suggest as the next step. Because if this is indeed "fixed" then whatever I'm doing next is what's breaking it. Pick a ROM, a recovery, and a method and I'll do it as you direct.
[HTC Droid DNA] iamjonmiller:
So I tried this whole deal. I flashed the stock rooted ROM, and of course everything worked. Then I flashed the stock recovery and did a factory reset. Then I flashed a custom recovery (tried TWRP first) and the latest CM11 + Gapps. SMS was broken again. So I went back to the stock rooted ROM and flashed the stock recovery and factory reset and then flash Clockworkmod and CM11 + Gapps. SMS still didn't work.

Now that I have lost everything I am just going to use stock. You win Verizon.
[HTC Droid DNA] mdphoenix:
I'm not quite at the "you win, Verizon" point. But I'll be damned if I'm not going to keep trying. I'm running stock right now until the wizards here can suggest the next step. I'm in no hurry. So long as the phone works. And right now - it does.
[HTC Droid DNA] iamjonmiller:
Oh, if this ever gets fixed I am going right back to my ROMs. On the bright side, the KK OTA should be out any day now.
[HTC Droid DNA] Majik Mushroomz:
[MENTION=381071]mdphoenix[/MENTION]: It may be a shot in the dark, and i didn't see anyone mention this as I scanned though the replies, but maybe try flashing the PREVIOUS radio? I've seen on some other forums that individual phones have had better service with the old radio. I know it doesn't make logical sense, but after all this jazz you've gone through, it's an easy check to make.,..
[HTC Droid DNA] mdphoenix:
I'll try anything once. Twice if I like it. I'll do it tonight and report back.

The strange thing is, it WORKS on a stock ROM. Just plain works. Latest radio, latest HBOOT, latest OTA.

As soon as I put something custom, I get a giant middle finger from my phone.
[HTC Droid DNA] Majik Mushroomz:
Been saying that line for years... :highfive:
[HTC Droid DNA] mdphoenix:
I sorta gave up on this. I've been running RUU stock and it's been working just fine. They called me this weekend and told me to reboot as the issue was "fixed". We'll never know until I put a custom on here again.

Since it's been working so well, is there a way to take an image of my phone as it currently is? That way I can revert it if the updated ROM doesn't fix the problem?
[HTC Droid DNA] iamjonmiller:
You don't need RUU...

I have been running the rooted version of the stock 3.06 ROM with no problems for about a week now. I just back it up every couple days in TWRP that way I can switch between it and my AOSP backup at my leisure.

This needs to be fixed and it really appears more and more to be something wrong with our devices specifically. While, sure, a bunch of people have had this exact problem across a range of Samsung and HTC devices, it definitely isn't happening to every rooted user on Verizon. Thus I don't think it is Verizon screwing rooted users (unless they chose some guinea pigs) and I don't think it is a problem with the AOSP base code.

Interestingly, it only works for me if I am running 3.06 (4.2.2) if I try ANY other ROM, even Sense based, ANY other version of Android it doesn't work.

I am confused and this sucks. I miss AOSP.
[HTC Droid DNA] iamjonmiller:
Maybe not..

Scratch that, I can run Viper 2.5 (4.2.2) with now problems. So is this OS based?
[HTC Droid DNA] mdphoenix:
I'll give it a shot tomorrow and report back.

Is there a way to back up the way I asked in case it doesn't work?
[HTC Droid DNA] Egrier:
Just install TWRP again and do a nandroid backup. That way if it doesn't work, you can just restore it.
[HTC Droid DNA] danjull:
Did you ever try reverting back to a previous radio? I'm trying out the nusense 6 Rom and before flashing it I updated my radio and hboot. I drop service a lot since doing so. Seems like I've got to cycle airplane mode every time I check my phone. I'm gonna try the old radio I was on and see if it improves.
[HTC Droid DNA] mdphoenix:
I shouldn't have done both at the same time, but I just flashed the next to last radio and installed the 3.06 Rooted Stock ROM. Texting is working fine.

Sorry about the two changes at once. I'm growing impatient and want to start using my phone the way I use a phone.

Is there a list somewhere of what I can remove with Titanium to get rid of the Sense stuff without wrecking the phone?
[HTC Droid DNA] KohanTech:
Tried a ton

Finally to the point search doesn't get me far. Having this same issue. It showed it's face only after I RUU'd 3.06. Got sick of that so I had myself some rumrunner (Not that I think rumrunner caused the problem). Now all 4.4 and 4.3 roms send one, and only one sms. The second fails. This did not happen before. I have flashed previous radios I have gone as far as downgrading to 1.15 via ruu and OTA upgrade to 2.04. Then moonshine to s-off and I STILL have the same issue!!

I found that Santod's Sense 6 Rom gives me error code 65535 class 3 from an on screen popup. That led me to this thread. There they discuss a epst hard radio reset. That's where I am at now. Working on how to do that as I type. If anyone knows that would be helpful!!

Right now I am using Viper 2.5 running 4.2.2 and of course everything works. [MENTION=381071]mdphoenix[/MENTION] -if you are looking to remove sense this is the Rom for you since there are options upon install to remove sense.

Hopefully this helps get new ideas from someone because this is very frustrating!!
[HTC Droid DNA] mdphoenix:
Thanks for your input Kohan. I'm glad I'm not the only one. But I'm sorry you're having problems, too. Whatever this is, it appears to have affected our accounts in some way. I'm guessing we did something that threw some sort of flag on our account so any subsequent installations or higher results in this bug. That's my theory since no one else is having this issue, anyway.

I was going to try Viper, but it looks like it has wayy too much bling for me. I really just wanted a GPE setup. For now, I'm okay with just using another launcher and leaving Sense in the background out of my way.

Hopefully a solution arises for this. I'm not dealing with Verizon any more.
[HTC Droid DNA] mdphoenix:
I've discovered that this ROM is a hog. My battery doesn't even last half a day. Time to start freezing apps.
[HTC Droid DNA] bryant23109:
I've had the same sms problem for about two weeks and have tried everything to fix it but no luck. Well my One M8 will be here tomorrow so hope you'll find a fix I gave up on it.
[HTC Droid DNA] KohanTech:
It is working!!

Got it working!!! I installed Carbon 4.4.2 then reseated my sim card. I then tried *228 opt 1. This time it took, and said my phone was programmed successfully. Now still on kk 4.4.2 sending and receiving sms's with no problem1 :good:
[HTC Droid DNA] d08speed3:
*228 Fry's your SIM card of 4G. You will only get 3G.

HTC DNA

LG Optimus G
[HTC Droid DNA] KohanTech:
hmmm...

Def. Appears to be so! Welp I guess off to the Verizon store tomorrow. Until then 3g and working SMS...
[HTC Droid DNA] d08speed3:
Yea never use *228 on 4G phones :(

HTC DNA

LG Optimus G
[HTC Droid DNA] KohanTech:
Strange enough... It fixed my SMS issue lol

My luck I'll get a new sim and SMS will break again. :eek:
[HTC Droid DNA] mdphoenix:
I had this happen as well. Definitely borks the SIM card in some way, but also fixes SMS. When your 4G comes back, I'm betting you lose SMS again.

IF this is of any help to the developers, the tech working with me stated that the problem was SMS was trying to go out over LTE instead of 4G. (Is that the Data network vs the Voice network?). So if the SIM card is getting nuked and the phone loses all LTE and 3G service, then one can assume his statement is correct.

Something to consider, I suppose. I'm still on the rooted stock for now, but something to note - I returned the second phone last night. When I returned it to stock and S-ON, I realized I had a 4.2.2 ROM on it. So that sorta throws the "the OS determines the problem" thought. :/
[HTC Droid DNA] mdphoenix:
On a slightly related note, my bluetooth phone conversations now suck horribly. Is there some DSP or something I can load to fix this?
[HTC Droid DNA] orangechoochoo:
Did you try RUUing 1.15 only and not accepting any of the updates?
[HTC Droid DNA] mdphoenix:
Is this to fix Bluetooth or just in general?

I RUU'd

RUU_DLX_WL_JB_50_S_VERIZON_WWE_3.06.605.4_Radio_1.01.01.1112_NV_VZW_4.46_002_release_340974_signed_2

, then flashed the Rooted Stock 3.06.
[HTC Droid DNA] orangechoochoo:
Just in general, someone else mentioned RUUing the latest firmware and got your same problems. Maybe there's some problem with the firmware or the RUU file you guys are using.

---------- Post added at 07:39 PM ---------- Previous post was at 07:38 PM ----------

I still have not gone past 1.15.
[HTC Droid DNA] KohanTech:
I RUU'd 1.15 but couldn't find the files for Facepalm. SuperCID apk is missing. Just went to 2.04 via ota and moonshined
[HTC Droid DNA] orangechoochoo:
Do you still have the SMS issue?
[HTC Droid DNA] KohanTech:
Yeah.... I am back on viper 2.5... Great Rom... It just bugs me that I am "limited" on roms... Most recently I tried playing with sms over ims... only to have no results...

*edit. I have to go to work now... but I have another 4g phone laying around I'm going to activate that and see if that one has the same issue...
[HTC Droid DNA] KohanTech:
Looks like we this is not the only thread having this same issue. Somewhat of a solution posted:

http://xdaforums.com/showthread.php?t=2674619
[HTC Droid DNA] mdphoenix:
Aside from Bluetooth, everything has been great. Do we really think RUU 1.15 will fix the BT issue? Can I just flash a different radio?
[HTC Droid DNA] KohanTech:
Wait... You have your SMS working on something non oem? I was going to try activating my thunderbolt to see if my problem was with big red... And then my wife's water decided to break... lol
[HTC Droid DNA] mdphoenix:
Yep. Stock Rooted 3.06. I just removed or disabled the bloaty crap. Tethering works, SMS works. Everything works. But my BT phone connection in my truck sounds like a monkey's anus.
[HTC Droid DNA] KohanTech:
Ok. Still in the same boat for me then. I haven't tried bt though. Same Rom here... Sms works great. Guess I'll be stuck on stock roms till HTC decides to release the kernel source... I'll update with anything I find...
[HTC Droid DNA] mdphoenix:
So how about it, boys? Anyone with the SMS problem gonna jump on Kit Kat?
[HTC Droid DNA] KohanTech:
I am on the stock kitkat rom... sms works. New firmware didn't fix the issue on other roms though.
[HTC Droid DNA] mdphoenix:
So, just like my current setup - Stock debloated JB. I can run Kit Kat stock, debloated, and rooted, but not another ROM....

jfc.

I'm getting a flip phone.
[HTC Droid DNA] KohanTech:
Yep. I'm running http://xdaforums.com/showthread.php?t=2560010
[HTC Droid DNA] mdphoenix:
Sigh. My phone's doing just fine on JB for now. No reason to update I guess. :/
[HTC Droid DNA] KohanTech:
See what I found: http://xdaforums.com/showthread.php?t=2657822&page=17

Seems touchwiz has the same issue. They were able to work around it...

---------- Post added at 04:28 PM ---------- Previous post was at 03:55 PM ----------

In your trials did u flash 1.15 firmware radio and recovery and perform a factory restore within the stock 1.15 based rom?

I'm going to try that then flash cm11 via nand backup.
[HTC Droid DNA] orangechoochoo:
Did it work?
[HTC Droid DNA] mdphoenix:
Judging from conversations in other threads, it looks like we aren't crazy and Verizon is effing with us.
[HTC Droid DNA] Jaggar345:
I expect this to eventually happen in the entire United States with Verizon. I guess they don't want people running aosp roms.
[HTC Droid DNA] orangechoochoo:
How could they tell the difference? Is there something in the SMS transmission that contains some type of identifier? If so, and this becomes a big problem, I'm sure the CM guys can add/delete/change whatever it is.
[HTC Droid DNA] KohanTech:
I feel the same way. I see them actively seeking ways to block devs... but I have faith in the collected talent in the Android community. If this isn't just some fluke thing and Verizon is attempting to block development... we will overcome.
[HTC Droid DNA] barkandlink:
Having same problem with SMS not sending on kit kat in Virginia. Did firmware upgrade and flashed Viper 4.0 and could only send one sms and then had to reboot inbetween. Restored nandroid of venom 3.5 and had same problem. Flashed stock Rom and no problem.

If I swith to CDMA only through phone settings available in misc in Viper rom or through 4g toggle widget from play store I can send texts. If I renable LTE can send one text and then I get error. If I go back to cdma texts go through again.

Certainly not perfect but at least I can send multiple texts and then switch back.

Maybe can automate the process with tasker or a script.
[HTC Droid DNA] jinx01:
I've been lurking in the shadows commiserating with those experiencing these issues with sms and mms after recent flashing. I'm in AZ, have been dealing with these problems for the past month or so.

Like others posting before, flashing to the stock rooted 4.4 Ota rom restored everything to normal, but trying to go back to gummy rom or Viper jacked everything up. I would be able to receive one or two sms, one of two mms, and then nothing else until I wiped cache and rebooted. This actually only worked intermittently, sometimes bringing on the recurring multiple previous delivered message issue. I had accepted my fate, my DNA forever doomed to a stock rom, but was experiencing the horrible sensitivity issue with the capacitive buttons (gag).

Anyway, I gave it one last ditch effort to try to fix the text problem (and ditch the stock rom and the button sensitivity crap) and seem to have stumbled upon something that actually has worked for me. I'm freaked that one small mistake could throw me back into the text problems, but for now, I'm running a fully functional Viper 4.1 without any of the aforementioned issues. If there are those out there still looking for a fix (and not a new phone, like I was considering for a while) let me know with a post in this thread and i'll do my best to explain what I did and why. I am a long time user and have no technical explanation for why it worked, but it did.
[HTC Droid DNA] KohanTech:
What worked for you? I'm willing to try it. I would even perform an exorcism on the phone at this point...
[HTC Droid DNA] orangechoochoo:
Please share. Did you get a cm-based ROM to work too?
[HTC Droid DNA] jinx01:
Posted my method HERE
[HTC Droid DNA] mdphoenix:
Let's revive a dead thread, but not a dead subject. I've been running the stock rooted ROM for two months now with no hiccups until yesterday. SMS wouldn't go through Cycled Airplane mode and it fixed it. But then WiFi wouldn't turn on. Cycled Airplane mode again and all is well. It made me remember this original issue. I see lots of posts, but I didn't see a definitive fix.

Any update on this? Or have we just succumbed to the fact that Verizon is bending us over and there's no fix?
[HTC Droid DNA] jinx01:
Quick update on my end - I finally succumbed to the need to wipe cache on viper, and sure enough my old issues with sms and texting in general returned. I restored back to a nandroid made before the wipe and everything was OK again. I was emboldened to take a few risks since the ball was already rolling - I flashed Carbon Rom with all manner of wipes and with no particular consideration paid to the issue we've been discussing. Surprisingly, everything has been working perfectly with SMS and MMS. Really made me wonder what was going on back then - was it TWRP? was it the wipe? was it something solely on VZW's end that has now been cleared? Don't think I'll ever figure it out completely. Just glad that I seem to be past the issues. Has anyone else seen improvement?
[HTC Droid DNA] mdphoenix:
So when you installed Carbon, what did you use if not TWRP? And what version?

My phone is now being an asshat and I need to either reset it, or flash something new. I've been stock rooted for months now without a problem, and now SMS is being a douche again.

I cannot believe that this forum isn't flooded with issues about SMS on custom DNA ROMs.
[HTC Droid DNA] Steve One:
I too am not able to use aosp or aokp roms due to mms issues. Hope someone figures this out
[HTC Droid DNA] mdphoenix:
So you're just using a stock root?
[HTC Droid DNA] Steve One:
Yes sir
[HTC Droid DNA] KohanTech:
mms issues should be a different problem all together. sms is failing here.

Have you tried setting the apn settings in the sms app itself?
[HTC Droid DNA] Steve One:
Yes I've tried everything if you check out the liquid thread you can find my multiple posts. Thank you for your suggestion though