yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Nexus 5 Android Development] soupysoup:
What? The ROM isnt stable enough for u? I've been running it as my DD for well, since the day i got the device and built it lol, I actually think this is one of the more stable roms on the market at themoment, there are the minor little hiccups in the last build but i'm currently uploading the new build with all the fixes for those issues that were causeed by me lol, anyway give it a shot if u havent already, if u have ans still think its not stable enough, maybe stock w/xposed is more ur thing?

Never mentioned it in the thread as i always thought xsposed was more of a stock thing, but it does cause issues with the custon additions in the rom, because xsopsed essentially modifies the frameworks of the device, and altering my already modifyed frameworks can have adverse effects, sothank u for bringing the point upas now i will mention it in the OP lol, alsothanks for the support!!!!

PS: Can i just say

I love u guys lol!

This thread has been one of themost fun for me, and the way u guys support it is amazing, i work hard to make sure that everything i give u is 100% ok sometimes 90% lol, but i strive for 100, and i think i hitthe bar most of the time, and all the thanks for that goes to you guys, the users, the ones who make me want to be better, and make me strive to be the first with new releases and new features, because for the support u give me, u deserve the best i have to give, so i just wanted to say thank u, and to those of u out there who honor it, merry x-mas, and happy holidays to everyone, I'm currently releasing v209, it shouls take care of the battery draining issue, along with a few others, hope u guys like it and again thank u for all the feedback and thanks, it really does mean alot...
[Nexus 5 Android Development] FlolB:
Thanks for the update, but have you upload the right built? I have the UI bugs in the new version too.

Gesendet von meinem Nexus 5 mit Tapatalk
[Nexus 5 Android Development] Batfink33:
I noticed the version is the 16th also,however the kernel says the 22nd.
[Nexus 5 Android Development] FlolB:
OK sry, the rom is nice. Works fine, but the loading animation is bugi.

Gesendet von meinem Nexus 5 mit Tapatalk
[Nexus 5 Android Development] xtothec:
Hey guys, what is the most simple way to remove holo and nova launcher ? If I do it over the play store they just keep asking for some update..
[Nexus 5 Android Development] FlolB:
Titanium or go system/app and erase the apks and reboot.

Gesendet von meinem Nexus 5 mit Tapatalk
[Nexus 5 Android Development] frewys:
Thanks for the great reply and your dedication.

I doubt I will be able to let go of Xposed as the flexibility for every ROM.

The simpleness of doing a titanium restore to get all the configuration back is just amazing. Xposed might be the biggest thing to hit Android in my opinion.

My hope is that cooks build their ROMs with more compatibility for Xposed or have more on/off buttons for there settings. I don't expect it to be over night but maybe in the future. Until then I will live with the two small issues I have (the one we are talking about right now with Active display and the inability to have the option of battery none as it currently overides the gravity box option for no battery. Maybe the new 209 0build will take it as it works with the new official beanstalk)

After all said it is a fantastic release stability/speed and option wise, and I will continue to run it!!
[Nexus 5 Android Development] FlolB:
The rom runs good, but when you charge it, its funny bugi. Short video coms.

Here the vid.

https://www.dropbox.com/s/cxvtzzucma3q90d/VID_20131223_193904.mp4

Gesendet von meinem Nexus 5 mit Tapatalk
[Nexus 5 Android Development] frewys:
Just an update. I guess I am alone in my exposed issues. But if there are more like me out there...

I disabled xposed. Got access to active display disabled it. Turned it on rebooted. Cool surprise. Xposed is on but still have access to animation settings.

Dirty flashed 9 and everything is great. Love it!

Edit: anyone has any experience with active display? It just keeps popping up like a battery drainer from hell.

The "Redisplay notification" is set to an hour. What else do I do to keep from being on all the time?

Edit2: SystemUI seems to be a little screwed as it is FC when I put the phone to charge over and over and over. 209 build.
[Nexus 5 Android Development] gavin-phelan:
That's because it is a battery drainer
[Nexus 5 Android Development] 1300:
Let me start by saying I ment no disrespect to u or ur kraft I just looked at the beginning of the op at the time of my post nd I seen beta in the status part of it and I thought o naw it not fully done I will wait I'm currently running ur ROM on my phone and I like it so I do respect ur kraft and support it hope its no hard feelings

I AM MR..1300 & I AM APPROVE THIS MSG
[Nexus 5 Android Development] chasew83:
finally had a chance to clean flash 207 and so far so good. haven't had any real glitches yet like i did after dirty flash. only one i have noticed so far, clean and dirty flash, is the loading circle does glitch in and out (flickers) on the play store, just for example. otherwise seems to be running pretty well and i just kept the stock kernel for the time being even though i love dt2w. can't wait for the next update soupy!
[Nexus 5 Android Development] masona48:
I know this ROM is not the official beanstalk as it has more features and tweaks but I would just like to know what is different from the the official release in terms of those tweaks and features...or what might have been left out. This version is incredible anyway and like to thank the op for all the hard work that went into this
[Nexus 5 Android Development] JNMM:
Big difference in the kernel....this is linaro based
[Nexus 5 Android Development] soupysoup:
Biggest differences are under the hood, lots of dependencies optimized by linaro, bionic, art, chromium, and a bunch of others optimized with linaro, kernel and ROM are both built with Linaro toolchains, 4.8.3 fot the ROM and 4.7.5 for the kernel, Linaro utilizes a new way of stack calling, reducung the draw time android takes in calling on parent and child processes, thus reducing the time it takes to perform duties, app open time its almost a full 2 tenths of a second faster with linaro, and benchmarks are 30-100% better, I chery-pick my own features, alot are the same as the Official version, scott and i worked together for a while on the official, and i just continued when he got his n5, I was on 4.4.2 a week earlier than he was, and i try to stay on top of new features, plus i cater to u guys, i look at it like u guys are the source of my insperation, so why not give u what u want, my power widgets are different, well they were lol, a few diff toggles. the data fix, all that was me, scott and the Official are amazing, i just wanted to take that and build on it, i'm currently working on a new boot animation too, just to spice it up, make things a little different, put my own tweak on it, basically, my version is faster, and has a few different features as the official, some not different, but differently performed lol..
[Nexus 5 Android Development] masona48:
Damn good explanation, I haven't had the urge to try any other Roms after having tried this one....so you can believe I'm sticking with this version...just promise me you'll merge in pie once PA gets it working with KitKat, immersive mode is OK, but its annoying swiping up and then pressing navbuttons after...great job though everything works perfect.
[Nexus 5 Android Development] Shanks:
Use gravity for pie controls
[Nexus 5 Android Development] starche_old:
soupysoup,

as continuation of that discussion - I've got 3 stupid questions. Sorry for bugging, just educational purposes, may be other guys will be interested as ;)

1. Why different versions of Linaro used to compile ROM and kernel?

2. Why till 4.4 Google was using 3.0 kernel and even in 4.4 - 3.4, but not 3.11? I would think I can use config file from 3.4 to compile 3.11 (I did that way on linux many times). Is there any reason for that?

3. Why Google still using java? I would think it's a huge waste of processing power, RAM footprint, etc. thus battery consumption? Why not to get rid of this completely? Like pretty much what Ubuntu doing right now...

I wonder what do you think about that?
[Nexus 5 Android Development] jkimbro:
Tried to open a photosphere in the G+ app, and get a gallery force close. Can open it locally though... Anyone else having this? Awesome ROM BTW.
[Nexus 5 Android Development] masona48:
I actually tried gravity box and pie controls did not work for me
[Nexus 5 Android Development] frewys:
Try LMT.
[Nexus 5 Android Development] masona48:
I have been using lmt but PA's version is the best because it let's you access the status bar and quick controls with one swipe....plus having it baked into the ROM is less cluttered and hacky IMO
[Nexus 5 Android Development] starche_old:
I wish pie control will be baked into ROM. LMT is good, but...
[Nexus 5 Android Development] FuMMoD:
Not even PA has pie controls right now. Just use lmt until there's official pie and use PA . I hate pie controls and find them annoying but to each their own.
[Nexus 5 Android Development] starche_old:
I know that's no pie yet.

I hated pie as well until I gave it a try and since then that's great thing for me. I agree that some people like oranges and other ones - Apple. That's the beauty of Android - to have choice rather then not to have one
[Nexus 5 Android Development] frewys:
Been on Samsung for to long and great to be back! Something to look forward to then
[Nexus 5 Android Development] moldovanos:
Soupy, can you plz add battery light feature?
[Nexus 5 Android Development] soupysoup:
Thank u man, believe me, PIE is being worked on heavily lol, its a pain though with the new UI implements from google lol

First let me say i love questions like this, because it shows that u guys actually pay attention to the underlying aspects of android and not just the UI lol, ok, first question, different toolchains are needed to compile kernel and ROM, as its a diff procedure, in normal google compilation android-eabi-4.6 is used to compile ROM and 4.7 for kernel, basically its jut a different toolchain, the base Linaro is the same, as Linaro is just taking Googles original code and optimizing it, so its not really "different versions" of Linaro, just different toolchains, and the current linaro toolchain for ROM compiation is at version 4.7.4, while the toolchain for ROM compilation is at 4.8.2, second question, as android is based on original linux kernels, its been tweaked ALOT, so it takes alot of moving stuff around to make it viable for android use, whle linux kernels are curently at 3.11 and 3.12, android has only just begun working on 3.8, with no releases past 3.4 yet, so in reality we are on the lastest "android" release, here is a good article for whats to come, possibly in android 5.0 New Kernel for 5.0 third, android still uses java atm because its still the best possible interface controler for what android needs versus whats available, it is a big killer of batt use, but atm there isnt anything better suited for the wide range of android needs, especially because of whats already been implemented now, but i can tell u there are alot thinigs google is woking on, and android stil has a long way to come, from what i hear 5.0 will brng and immensive overhaul to not just the UI, but the entire interface that we know of, hope that answered ur questions lol

I promise, as soon as its possible. ill have it baked in there man lol
[Nexus 5 Android Development] c@p:
+1

Tapatalked by neXus 5
[Nexus 5 Android Development] Fabioo123:
It's possible Volume rocker wake mod for this rom?
[Nexus 5 Android Development] hrm5023:
Been switching between yours and Scott's version depending on the updates. Loving the features, and achieving some great battery life with the provided kernel.

Now that we have that I wanted to ask if the always listening feature could possibly receive an enhancement. Something along the lines of open mic+ that can utilize the snapdragon 800 low-powered core(s).

I posted this on Scott's thread as well - What do you think? yay/nay
[Nexus 5 Android Development] soupysoup:
I love adding new features, but im completely lost on what u mean by battery light lol, let me know and il def get it in there lol

I did have the vol rocker, but it started causing all kinds of issues, so i removed it, ill see if adding it back still causes problems, if not sure u can have it back lol
[Nexus 5 Android Development] seanyuan62:
It seems like power toggle indicator was removed from the ROM in the latest update. Any way it can be re-added in the future?
[Nexus 5 Android Development] soupysoup:
New build up guys, although i forgot to bump the build number o im recompiling now with the bumped version, just wanted to give u the sneak preview lol
[Nexus 5 Android Development] c@p:
Scott has it in the official version. Notification LED should light by charging or then the battery is low.

Tapatalked by neXus 5
[Nexus 5 Android Development] starche_old:
Thanks a lot for the answer, Soupy :) I'm really appreciate I didn't bother you too much with noobish questions :)

1. Thanks a lot, now I understand those toolchains. Pretty much toolchains are the certain set of operations plus software involved in each stage to compile ROM/kernel/app. That's pretty much like steps to compile the kernel in Linux world, right?

2. I see what you mean. But what's the nature of those tweaks? I mean - I'm using Ubuntu, getting new kernels periodically and not much to be done to compile the kernel, especially if you have config file. Even w/o it - other days I used to compile kernels for myself (for fast boot) and if you know what each parameter means - there's NP to decide to bake it in, keep as module or ignore.

So, I would think it's more Android specific things. If those things are causing issues with kernel updates, why wouldn't we try to get rid of those? Can we?

3. What so specific about interface controller? Like Ubuntu has interface and it's free of java, so actually this can be done, including the phones, right? :) And I'm not talking about huge royalties Google pays Oracle for java. So, why not to keep those "few bucks" in the pocket? :) That's what Mark doing right now.

And talking about "especially because of whats already been implemented now". AFAIK, devs using Eclipse to write the code for apps and after that they have to use toolchains to make apk. But if we using native Linux, devs do not need toolchains at all, next moment after dev saved the project in Eclipse it's ready to go. So, I would think, update of apps to adopt "new" system won't be a problem, devs from now onwards need to do actually less then usual. What's wrong with that? :)

It's obviously non-ROM related topic, but I'm curious to hear what you think about that :) Sorry in advance if that sound aggressive, stupid and/or noobish ;)

Thanks a lot for the pie, that would be awesome :) I've got used to buttonsby now, but definitely I like pie more.
[Nexus 5 Android Development] l3thalsab3r:
Thanks for a great ROM soupysoup! I'm always looking forward to your releases so keep up the great work!

I do have 2 issues to report. I'm not sure if anyone else is effected by this, but I cannot change the 'Font size' in the display system settings. I usually set it to small (85%) but it's not doing anything and it was working in build 205-12/16 but since then it's broken.

The other is the status bar battery. Either they show the wrong amount for the percent that its at or its completely broke and not showing an amount at all, and the charging animation for the circle & dotted icons is restarting the UI and looping it. I've attached 2 pictures to help explain.

Also did you plan on updating the change log in the first post? I'm always curious as to what gets changed, added, or fixed in each build.

Thanks!
[Nexus 5 Android Development] icrzymonkey:
Hey guys got a question...

I just updated the ROM to

BeanStalk-4.4.2_r1-v209-Linaro-20131226-hammerhead.zip

But the phone still says

Is that right??
[Nexus 5 Android Development] :
Hi,

Because of this:

:)
[Nexus 5 Android Development] mekayzer:
Hi Soup,

Great job, very smooth.

Got 35333 point on Antutu and 16892 an Quadrant.

Waiting as always for your update.

Thank you
[Nexus 5 Android Development] Fabioo123:
How to disable ime switcher,

And volume headphone alert?

---------- Post added at 11:00 AM ---------- Previous post was at 10:52 AM ----------

Volume rocker wake on cataclysm work fine. Double touch and sweep to wake drain battery
[Nexus 5 Android Development] Batfink33:
This is without a doubt the best Rom for the N5 at the moment. Great work Soupy!
[Nexus 5 Android Development] hipojarty:
Is this normal? Art enable and the free mem bumps down to 100+meg
[Nexus 5 Android Development] theesotericone:
The only way I'd like to see that implemented is with an option to turn it on or off. One of my favorite perks of this ROM is the fact that I don't have to watch that annoying light when it's on my nightstand charging. lol

On another note anyone bother to play with wakelock blocker yet? It's another great feature of the ROM. I used to use it all the time on my Skyrocket but this phone has such a minimal wakelock state I haven't even bothered yet. lol
[Nexus 5 Android Development] dialmformostyn:
You can do that with LMT. While I too prefer baked-in features, I think it's sometimes a psychological benefit in practical terms. I have used LMT over PA/Slim Pie on multiple devices for a very long time now and have had no ill effects you might associate with hackiness whatsoever and prefer its level of customisation. Horses for courses, however :) I would like to see immersive mode in the current crop of ROMs to allow keys/notification bar to be activated in single swipes however.
[Nexus 5 Android Development] starche_old:
I've got smth to report. When choosing "dark stalk", in dialer the contact names stays in black font thus invisible.

Changing the font color to while would be great :) thanks soupy
[Nexus 5 Android Development] N-Forced:
Is there a change log I can look at for the new version?
[Nexus 5 Android Development] drwedge:
I did a full wipe and flashed the newest version & the phone app crashes on boot. I tried PA GAPPS, BANKS GAPPS, and none and still the problem persists.

Has anyone else had this issue on the latest build?

Thanks

Edit:

My phone is really borked. I flashed an update I made a few weeks ago from an earlier build of Beanstalk, and it has the same problem.

Edit:

Since I don't have the presence of mind to find a way to delete this post, I'll leave it here with this last update. :) I rescued the phone by flashing AOKP's 12/25 nightly w/PA GAPPS and it's working fine.
[Nexus 5 Android Development] Venomous Viper 119:
Damn ! Donno about omni but this site is one hell of a ROM! Loaded with features!! Will try it soon! Thanks!
[Nexus 5 Android Development] thereal_bigjake:
When you say full wipe did you wipe the system partition manually or just do a factory wipe?

---------- Post added at 11:03 PM ---------- Previous post was at 10:59 PM ----------

Flashed the latest build with Franco kernel + the bionic/dalvik patch which I have never tried before and everything is running great..
[Nexus 5 Android Development] frewys:
I am still here and an addict to your Amazing ROM.

I have a request for the future to be able to have qs on or off as I want to use gravity box.

The navigation bar don't stick with off. have to use expanded and then back to normal for it to hide at every boot.

Lastly I am having issues with the default input method not sticking but that just might be something on my side.

Thanks for a fantastic ROM! Had to go back to 205 after to many issues with the newer builds.
[Nexus 5 Android Development] drwedge:
I did a factory wipe. I was to the point where if flashing a different ROM didn't fix it, I was ready to wipe the system partition and start fresh.

Since this issue doesn't seem to be ROM related, I don't want to hijack this thread any more than I have. But if anyone has ideas of how I could've done this differently or what would've caused that to begin with, I'd be happy to continue the conversation via DM. Thanks! ☺
[Nexus 5 Android Development] yukycg:
Is it possible to remove the Holo launcher and nova launcher from the rom? Not a major issue if OP want to keep and I can always manual remove it. This is just my personal preference to remove any app that I don't use.
[Nexus 5 Android Development] thereal_bigjake:
I use Titanium Backup to remove a hand full of system apps I don't use from any rom.
[Nexus 5 Android Development] topnomi:
A big reason for using the Java Dalvic Virtual Machine is that it makes android apps platform independent. That means it can run on arm (most phones), or x86 (computers, couple phones), or any other future platform. As long as the Dalvic VM is ported to a platform, any android app can run it it. You can even run android apps in windows with a Dalvic VM emulator.

I foresee an android move into desktop. Microsoft is screwing up their advantage. All android needs is a suitable window manager and mouse support and it can run on a desktop. The apps will come.

[MENTION=5307816]soupysoup[/MENTION]

I've been trying to build off of Scott's sources and i can't get it to boot. It builds without any errors that i notice. Is there a place to check the log to see what went wrong? I've built PAC before on my other devices, and never had any trouble.
[Nexus 5 Android Development] Citizen_Snips:
Yup boots fine with bricked. No problems so far! Awesome ROM. Going to try that Google dialer for sure, though. Thanks!

Sent from my Nexus 5
[Nexus 5 Android Development] mjs2011:
That happened to me when I flashed the moto zip. Not sure if that's what you did or not.
[Nexus 5 Android Development] sinister856:
Rom, gapps then dalivk patch, I probably should have flashed dalvik patch later

---------- Post added at 02:16 AM ---------- Previous post was at 02:13 AM ----------

Yeah that's what I did I'll try without and report back
[Nexus 5 Android Development] clj575:
Is this rom odex?
[Nexus 5 Android Development] Synyster06Gates:
Flashed it and everything seems to be running correctly, however I flashed Bricked kernel and can't get KControl to run. It says I need BusyBox, but BusyBox said it was already installed...
[Nexus 5 Android Development] -DarkKnight-:
Oh hi soupy :)

I see you also got a Nexus 5 :)

Just downloaded. Works great!
[Nexus 5 Android Development] Citizen_Snips:
The Google dialer doesn't work FYI. Dirty flash = back to back FC. Required wipe. Clean install fails also. You don't get any FC....until you make a call. Literally no problems into I tried to make a call. Dialer closes, nonstop FC all while the call is still going in the background. Guess I'll just wait then

Sent from my Nexus 5
[Nexus 5 Android Development] climhz:
Why not Katstalk?
[Nexus 5 Android Development] Synyster06Gates:
I just made a call and didn't get a FC. With the Google dialer from Banks.
[Nexus 5 Android Development] chasew83:
having a hell of a time with sprint data. after sitting at the activating data screen for 5 minutes, did try again, lte came and went in a split second. but not getting any sprint data.....:crying:

edit: flashed 3g apn zip and 3g came up but dissapeared very quickly.

i am about to just say screw it and switch to tmobile so i hopefully wont have to deal with this c**p anymore.
[Nexus 5 Android Development] sinister856:
OK so I tried it without moto dalivk zip and my sprint data wouldn't activate so I tried, wipe X3 ROM, gapps, sprint APN zip still wouldn't work, so I re-downloaded ROM and tried it again without and with sprint zip still wouldn't activate, it would just sit on the screen to activate data and would finally say it couldn't activate I hit retry but didn't work
[Nexus 5 Android Development] soupysoup:
Beacause thats not the name... The rom was never BEANstalk for jellyBEAN, the theme throughout the ROM is a Beanstalk.... So Katstalk with a beanstalk heme....nah, the ROM is dope as is...