yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] tonyo123:
No issues with SD card but did have a reboot during a call and the occasional reset back to the stock liquidmooth wallpaper.
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] bonez565:
I have the same SD card issues as Beardedface, though it could just be my SD card going bad as well. It's a Transcend 32GB if it matters.
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] patch_Adams:
May be Too many sd occurrences to be bad cards. Some one grab a log, I can at least look at it.
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] bonez565:
Sure how would I go about doing such a thing?
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] patch_Adams:
You can learn here

http://xdaforums.com/showthread.php?t=1726238

I am at work...not much help right now
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] bonez565:
Alright I'll let it run until i notice the error then post it.

Edit: Finally managed to capture the error (I hate randomly occurring errors) here is the logcat output: http://www.mediafire.com/download/qi4h1a8e4e574x3/logcat_and_device_info.zip
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] patch_Adams:
So when the error happened, what were you doing? i am looking at your logcat (thanks by the way!). But I am still very much terrible at fixing these sorts of things; just a heads up :)
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] bonez565:
I think when that happened I was switching between QR droid and Chrome beta checking a Bitcoin address.
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] tonyo123:
Hi patch, definitely having a several reboots during calls on 2.31. Also, have noticed that the phone has rebooted a few times while sitting by on desk. Just me that is experiencing the reboots (using the Pad kernel which I need for fast-charge)?
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] xZeroMancerx:
I can confirm the sdcard unmount/mount thing happening to my device as well...
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] tonyo123:
Didn't want it to be lost in the issues part of the thread...this is one darn fine kernel and good piece of work...

---------- Post added at 02:17 AM ---------- Previous post was at 01:39 AM ----------

Hmmm, I did just try to access my external SD card and it was empty (but not error). I rebooted and the Ext_SD card content was back. Maybe this is the SD Card issue that's been discussed. First time I've seen it happen so sporadic.
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] bonez565:
I was able to get another logcat of the same SD card error. Perhaps the comparison will shed some more light on the issue. This time I was checking Gmail when it occurred.

http://www.mediafire.com/download/6m2jjuh8ln0b9c7/logcat_and_device_info_(1).zip
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] Mortal Eternity:
well you could be one like me bro... my phone always have rendom reboots on the roms in which Linaro is included... dont know the reason but all the roms containing the linaro thing is a miss match for my phone!? dont know why... may be its the phone build... may be country unlocking had to do something with that! :cyclops:
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] tonyo123:
Good day today no issues so far.
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] sinasiadat:
I also saw the SD mount and unmount in 2.31. Finally got a stable install without reboot but have been letting it settle to play around. Is restoring apps/data using titanium alright? I fix permissions and such.
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] patch_Adams:
I use Titanium Pro for my apps :) works fine. I can't fix the sd issue at this time. I'm not good with the errors truth be told. Not sure there'll be another 4.3 release or not? The PAC kernel is pretty sweet I think.

Sorry about the sd thing guys/gals :/
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] bonez565:
The SD card thing is really not a problem, In my case at least it just instantly remounts and has never yet interrupted a read/write.

So does no more 4.3 releases mean that 4.4 is next?
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] polanek1:
Applied latest Liquid (PAC kernel) and flashed Uber over it and (so far) the SD card mount/unmount msgs have not appeared.
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] tonyo123:
The last Uber works over the latest Liquid?
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] captemo:
What is the point of flashing 1 kernel and then flashing another over it?

The 2nd flash negates the first.
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] xZeroMancerx:
He might of found a way to a temp fix for that Mount/unmount notification message...
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] polanek1:
Yes, since 8:00 am CDT I have not had an SD Card msg, when with the PAC Kernel it happened very often.

That is the reason for the second flash of the Uber kernel over the PAC and to be on the latest Liquid.
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] captemo:
Sorry Patch, not running LS.

So then I am to understand then, that the Pac kernel is included with rom? I understand and that makes sense. Your post however lead me to think you were attempting to somehow mesh 2 kernels together. I know it can't be done. That's just what it sounded like.
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] sinner6975:
not sure if I'm doin something wrong or not but flashed 2.31 w\pac twice...factory reset...cache, dalvik, system wiped and both tries everything workes great no other problems till I try to restart then when I does the screen goes black after the samsung logo flashesbut its only after a restart after I flash it again it workes great till the restart...I'm on twrp 2.6.3.0 if that helps...and not restoring any data at all starting fresh everytime
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] bonez565:
TWRP 2.6.3.0 is the problem. Flash TWRP 2.5.0.0 and you should have no problems.
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] sinner6975:
I tried getting 2.5 from goo.im but the site was down and the search on xda was also acting screwy anyone have a link to twrp 2.5
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] bonez565:
Here is the official mirror: http://www.techerrata.com/browse/twrp2/sgh-i717
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] Poriotis:
Awesome ROM

Despite a few issues as I will mention next, this ROM runs really solid. I have been running this ROM since Friday morning. Here's what my experience has been:

Yes, I also get the SD card mounting issue. ThdDude from HellyBean told me they would look into this issue. Hopefully they come up with something.

In the beginning I had issues with recording videos. The camera would lock up. After a few reboots, somehow it got fixed.

Got the "Light Screen of Death" once while watching a YouTube video.

Occasionally I get the ubiquitous power-on-wake issue. So, to counter that I want to change the CPU governor to Wheatly which takes care of this issue but...see next

The Performance under Settings no longer works; it keeps crashing. Is Trickster MOD OK to use with this ROM?

Keep up the good work :highfive:
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] bonez565:
Can you elaborate on the "Light Screen of Death" issue?
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] xZeroMancerx:
Its a blotchy looking error when the screen basically grows bright, I'm not exactly sure what causes it and I've only seen it a few times...
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] bonez565:
Gotcha, I've seen that 3 or 4 times right after installing the ROM, within a couple reboots it never happens again. No idea what causes it.
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] tonyo123:
I installed the latest UBER kernel over the PAD kernel LS ROM V2.31 and it works well and the speed clocking holds.Good combo so far.
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] bonez565:
UBER kernel has been much less stable for me than the default PAC kernel, I still get the same SD card issue and I seem to get more random reboots and odd slowness than I did before.
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] xZeroMancerx:
Can anyone else confirm ?
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] zeddock:
Thanx Patch. I love that you continue to support our Notes.

I am really happy with this ROM. I have found some trouble with getting it to come on, like others mention.

Also I have the SD card issue.

It has fced just a few times.

I did not have these issues 2 versions back with the different kernel. (Maybe the lights on every so often.)

That said, If one were to flash the uber kernel and had issues, is there a way to flash a PAC kernel back, or is it necessary to flash whole ROM back?

I am not great at searches but did look at the pac-man ROM, but didn't see a separate pac-man kernel.

Tia

Zeddock.
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] patch_Adams:
I don't think AD had started a thread for the PAC kernel yet. You could just dirty flash the Rom to get that PAC kernel back (should be ok, but no promises right?!)
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] frome901:
ive been liquid smooth for about a week, i was getting the notification about the SD card, it didn't seem to be effecting anything til i tried to take a screen shot. it says "unable to capture screenshot/memory in use"

I know this is an on going problem. Heres a logcat

Otherwise Patch's Roms are great.
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] :
A few bugs I spotted:

1. LSOD: Annoying issue that is somehow more rampant in here than in PACman ROM, try turning on Auto-Rotate, then watching a video. Turn the phone to any other angle around 5 times, and you'll get it.

2. GSOD: Normal issue where the crash is always after a green screen (and/or loud beeping sound). Cause is random, for instance, sometimes is when I type a letter, sometimes when selecting an item

3. Mount/Unmount SD Card: I know you guys are working on a fix! :good:

4. Random FCs: This is quite weird, because the app is always different. Sometimes it's Exchange Services, sometimes it's Play Music, sometimes Settings!

5. Active Display: Sometimes Active Display randomly doesn't work when you take the phone out of the pocket

Hope these issues are rectified! (4.3 is still quite unstable on I717 if you don't do it right) :eek:

Current: UBER + LiquidSmooth + Some 4.4 files
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] polanek1:
Unique phones to each individual using the same model/manufacturer....I have had (one) SD card msg since adding Uber on the latest 11/6 Liquid and I am very please with Liquid and the work Patch & others have done for my phone....Thanks Much!!
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] tonyo123:
Patch, All, yes, I am also having a few of these random types of issues but I am very happy with LS ROM 2.31 and also with its working with Jamie's latest UBER Kernel. Just so darn happy that someone like Patch takes the time to create and share this with the rest of us. Big THANKS.

Also, it seems like Patch and a few others are also starting to look at 4.4 KitKat and I am looking forward to, not so much any of the new features, although things like Halo or flashlight additions to lock screens, and next set of new add-ons, are are quite enjoyable, but I am looking forward to improved 'snappyness' particularly when starting and ending apps (where sometimes I get long pauses before the app starts or home screen pops back). Hopefully, the lessened memory needs of ART vs Dalvik will help with this type of improvement. :good:
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] patch_Adams:
I am sorry right away. I look at these logcats and am completely lost. Most of the time I can find errors but just do not know how to fix them. I did want you to know that I have looked at them! May be when school is over after the new year I can sit down and throughly learn how to properly find and fix errors via the logcats.

Thanks to everyone who has done their part in providing the logs!!

tonyo, and everyone....

work on kitkat is underway......but really it is very hard to get a clean build right now. As earlier, always school first......
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] bonez565:
I'd say don't stress too much about the errors. You have done a tremendous job providing such a great ROM already, if work is ongoing on KitKat that should be the priority.
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] g0t0:
I my phone freezes and reboots when I try to open gallery directly. Also MX Player random freezes and I have to pull out the battery to reset. 2 things I use the most are the ones with the major issues. That blows.....
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] Poriotis:
Got a weird one this morning. While my phone was peacefully charging on my night stand it all of a sudden got an FR and then went into a boot loop. Almost the same thing happened to me with the PAC kernel experiment ROM.
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] Beardedface:
Patch you are the man!! I think its kinda funny, but you always say you have school and are busy(which is understandable) but you always find time to release updates and participate in the threads. And on top of it the ROMs you have for our notes are awesome. Keep up the good work.
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] BIGMOH:
Awesome!

+1 Ditto! :cool:

Cheers Patch (@patch_Adams) :good:
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] kingfisher1111:
Wil UBER kernel work on this. I am getting random reboots all the time.
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] patch_Adams:
I haven't tried so I don't know. I am going to try to build with PAC kernel next
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] Nomar1245:
UBER works best with the Unofficial Build. With the 2.31 it's best to stay with PAC. Even though you can't lock the max CPU speed, it remains a much better Kernel for day to day use. I found with Uber that it was much less stable, so while it was working it would be much faster, the frequency of reboots made it fairly unusable.
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] tonyo123:
Nomar, are you sure that older Uber works best with the unofficial (assume 2.12) LS code? I seem to get the occasional reboots on both with and without Uber. LS 2.31 seems to perform a little better with the latest Uber and the rates can be locked (although occasionally I find that they change, not sure why, could be just my configuration and apps).
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] Nomar1245:
As always, everybody is different, but for me latest Uber + LS 2.31 caused major instability. I'd get reboots at random, and then boot loop until I wiped cached. Eventually it got to be too much for a daily so I went back to PAC.
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] jackk:
Getting constant random reboots on v.2.31
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] bryanizmir:
Just shows you how different every i717 is... 2.31 has been one of the most stable ROMs to date on my machine :)
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] tube517:
Absolutely a phenomenal update. 2.31 has been bug free for me. Great Job, Patch!
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] tonyo123:
Patch

Questions for you on Liquidsmooth relative to Beanstalk:

- Do you have a preferenceof one over the other and why?

- Any key features missing on Beanstalk vs LS?

- Will you evenually bring LS to 4.4 Kitkat or should we eventually (upon Beta release) jump over and start using Beanstalk?

There was a time not long ago where many threads seemed to push TWRP over CWM. So, I did it and like TWR. Now, to do KitKat, we HAVE to use CWM. TWRP has not introduced an update to make it KitKat compatible not to mention the issues over their 2.6.x versions (I use 2.5). This seems to me to be fraught with danger as now not only does one have to switch ROMS but you have to swtch flash programs in advance and CWM is not flash ZIP supported anymore (uses .img which I understand requires purchased version of CWM, which I have). Any issues or thoughts on this?

tonyo123

PS...continue to use 2.31 with Uber. It is exellent and very smooth in scrolling and launching programs. The main nags are sleep/wakelock issues that seem to occur overnight (requires reboot); occasionally, the hard keys becme unusable (pie as fallback still works but best is to reboot); are not sure if there is a Zram compression option that woud give me a little more breathing room on free RAM; does seem to pause/stutter when exiting an app and awaiting launcher return.

By the way, does anyone have a camera-flash issue? Upon a flash picture, my Note locks up and have to remove battery and reboot (won;t reboot on own). I had this issue before on CyanogenMod so I think it is in the recent ASOP or CM Android software relative to the Note builds.
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] patch_Adams:
[/QUOTE]

Tonyo

I wanted to get back to you on this before it gets forgotten(by me). I am overwhelmed with homework. A rom preference...not really....as for features, I feel sometimes that the roms are so complete and then someone thinks up another awesome feature. Amazing! LS 4.4....give it time, it will come. It build a little differently than BeanStalk and is much harder to complete. I have tried some but without success. TWRP vs. CWM...well I've been flashing many years and was always on CWM....when twrp came around it was the shizz, but back on cwm now and it really doesn't matter. Someone else said in another forum (wish I remembered where) “You only there for like 5 minutes anyway”

Honestly, I miss running custom roms. Don't get me wrong I still have my note and pop a sim in for a half a day, but I just despise having to setup my phone everytime I flash for testing some rom that I'm trying to build or port over. Sometimes my phone will be down half a day that way. So I bought the LG pro and run it rooted stock w/cwm :D
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] developweb:
[/QUOTE]

If you have a previous recovery zip you can extract it, delete the recovery.img file, replace it with the newest cwm or cwm touch image renaming it to recovery.img and zip it again with a memorable name. You will now have flashable recovery.
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] tonyo123:
If you have a previous recovery zip you can extract it, delete the recovery.img file, replace it with the newest cwm or cwm touch image renaming it to recovery.img and zip it again with a memorable name. You will now have flashable recovery.

Doesn't sound too hard after the first time but that first one is always a challenge... at least for me. Like when I replaced the USB port. First time was a challenge. 2nd time, like butter.

---------- Post added at 12:19 AM ---------- Previous post was at 12:09 AM ----------

Tonyo

I wanted to get back to you on this before it gets forgotten(by me). I am overwhelmed with homework. A rom preference...not really....as for features, I feel sometimes that the roms are so complete and then someone thinks up another awesome feature. Amazing! LS 4.4....give it time, it will come. It build a little differently than BeanStalk and is much harder to complete. I have tried some but without success. TWRP vs. CWM...well I've been flashing many years and was always on CWM....when twrp came around it was the shizz, but back on cwm now and it really doesn't matter. Someone else said in another forum (wish I remembered where) “You only there for like 5 minutes anyway”

Honestly, I miss running custom roms. Don't get me wrong I still have my note and pop a sim in for a half a day, but I just despise having to setup my phone everytime I flash for testing some rom that I'm trying to build or port over. Sometimes my phone will be down half a day that way. So I bought the LG pro and run it rooted stock w/cwm :D[/QUOTE]

No worries. Just seeking to understand your views and plans. Goes without saying work, school, homework, family all always come first.

Thank you.
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] sinasiadat:
Been running 2.31 since it was released, with PAC kernel... on TWRP 2.6.1.0 .. now going back to 2.5.0.0 to see how it behaves.

On my device the rom would start and sometimes lock up immediately and reboot. Sometimes it never makes it past STARTING APPs. And on reboot you would see the dalvik being rebuilt as if it had not been able to complete it before. Would even exhibit this behavior if it made it into the rom but locked up after 30 seconds or so and rebooted. I played with governors and CPU settings.. nothing changed this.

when it would reboot like this, it would , more times than not, continue to reboot until I pulled the battery and let it sit for a bit.. cleared cache and dalvik, then try again. My only guess as to why this happens, since I havnt pulled up logs, is that it has something to do with the SD card being mounted and unmounted randomly (which actually got worse as the rom settled and with usage). I would always see my screen come on with the error symbol saying it was unmounted then mounted. I think this is also the reason why I was unable to take screenshots .. would say there was no storage, but that may just be a bug cuz the camera worked. I have tried downloading the rom again and flashed it multiple times. . . Might be made worse with the Titanium Backup ZIP i created with my APPs and Data backup that is around 190 or so apps -___-

Tried the 4.4 beanstalk.. was wondering why there was no LTE in it and if this was in the works as well as the camera.

When the rom does stabilize after a bit of rest, it is badass.. no question about that. Love the work you did patch, thanks.

---------- Post added at 07:24 AM ---------- Previous post was at 07:07 AM ----------

another bit of randomness ive noticed that has happened on multiple flashes:

After wiping everything (cache, dalvik, data, factory reset, internal SD) .. everything. I flash the rom then the 4.3 GAPPS .. then reboot. When going through the setup, if I put a WIFI password it will freeze n reboot. Wonder if the rom is meant to reboot itself a few times after first install?
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] patch_Adams:
Whoa. You bring up many issues here I have not heard of. Some are known. Did you try uber kernel at all? Some phone just don't play nice with some roms :(

You'll have to let us know how reverting to older TWRP works out too.
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] :
Flashed LS 2.31 using TWRP 2.5, then flashed UBER kernel (last 4.3 release), and till now, only the Badass governor (OC to 1890MHz), together with the zen I/O scheduler is stable for my device. Other governors either get random reboots, or are slow and sluggish (Not to mention it, Badass is slow, but it's stable, only that I can't run too many apps at once)

Wheatley with 1890MHz crashes about a few seconds after changing, then reboots back to ondemand with 1512MHz.

After I manually upgraded Performance Control to the latest version, "Android is upgrading" also constantly shows during every reboot. Why is that so? I removed the older version already. (Old version FCs on voltage control)

Overall, ROM is stable now with Badass, cool ROM, just needs some optimization :cyclops:
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] sinasiadat:
Tried recoveries from 2.5.0.0 up to recent.. No difference. Just flashed the latest uber kernel yesterday. . it seems to be a bit better in terms of the reboot dalvik build failure instant reboot at starting apps thing. I noticed if I didn't touch it for a bit it wouldn't lock up n reboot again after a random lockup. Been disabling things and uninstalling. What gets me is that it did it after a fresh install. Leads me to believe it is the phone if nobody else has the issues.

I use android tuner and had turned off CPU control inside it but when looking at times it showed that it was spiking over 1.5 GHz that I had set it at. Performance control thst is built in wasnt showing those states/times in use tho..That and multi processor control wouldn't stay off .. So I uninstalled it. Will see if it helps.

Gonna record logs n see if I can also catch my issue. Not too good at debugging android yet. This will be good practice for sure.

Def behaved as if it was overclocked too high or low. Or temperature or voltage.... We shall see.
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] :
What're the best governor and I/O scheduler settings for this ROM? Any setting I try seem to have either random reboots, or is too slow. :rolleyes:

(Overvolted +25mV)
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] Cooks_08:
Thanks

Great Rom! This is very solid and stable and smooth. My favorite one to run so far.
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] kventura:
was the bug with the power button...where u have to click it a few times to turn on screen solved?
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] patch_Adams:
Not in particular. But if you search around a bit you will find many folks have discussed multiple work arounds that have worked for them :)
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] xZeroMancerx:
Has anyone found a fix for the sdcard mount/unmount notification or is this still present ?
[AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717] :
For sdcard error, try using the zen IO scheduler in the UBER kernel, it works for me