yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Verizon Samsung Galaxy S 4] wolfgrrl:
We would love to see someone maintain it. The post just went live at noonish today, and we have donations already, so things are progressing. Thanks for throwing your hat in the ring!
[Verizon Samsung Galaxy S 4] pfidr34:
I'll be down if someone steps forward.
[Verizon Samsung Galaxy S 4] wolfgrrl:
We have an interested party.....now let's show them our interest!
[Verizon Samsung Galaxy S 4] john7760:
I'll throw in support if we got a dev that will show some love!!
[Verizon Samsung Galaxy S 4] wolfgrrl:
All,

Let's not make this a chicken->egg game.

If you are interested, donate. Money motivates, and if we show little money, we will get little interest. If we haven't found a dev within a reasonable amount of time, rest assure, all money will be refunded.
[Verizon Samsung Galaxy S 4] john7760:
I agree..... donation added!
[Verizon Samsung Galaxy S 4] andybones:
I hope this thread doesn't die, id a great idea!

I may consider porting the latest 3minit to the stock ME7 (no bounty or payment needed, although once done a few donations would be great) :)

to get things rolling and so people can enjoy it and decide if they want to donate to keep it going.
[Verizon Samsung Galaxy S 4] wolfgrrl:
It's only been up for 5 days - give it a bit of time. We are still interested!

I don't know that ME7 would be a good idea........all of us running ROMS are on MDK. I would be willing to say most users have not updated. Unless it's happened "accidentally".
[Verizon Samsung Galaxy S 4] andybones:
Why would you not be on ME7 ROM...?

For this port I need to port to stock ROM, we have a ME7 stock ROM :confused:

I am not going to waste my time porting it to MDK though. The smali code between MDK and ME7 is too different, and to port to MDK now is just IMO, dumb.

I guess I'll just port it for personal use then.
[Verizon Samsung Galaxy S 4] wolfgrrl:
I'm still on MDK - and currently the ROM I prefer is HyperDrive, which is MDK. Not all the ROMs have ported over to ME7 yet.

[MENTION=2586080]andybones[/MENTION], I'm not saying that we don't want your work. I'm saying that not all ROMs are ported over to ME7 yet - many are still MDK. ME7, to my knowledge, still doesn't allow for installing a customer recovery, unless that's changed since Friday.
[Verizon Samsung Galaxy S 4] andybones:
I know.. my ROM is the only custom ROM that is updated to ME7 so far.. I worked hard to get it out first. :)

my point is this though,

even if I was to port this to MDK, it won't work on hyperdrive..

there are too many key .apks that are being edited.

SecSettings.apk, SystemUI.apk, android.policy.jar, services.jar

these are all key files that are VERY different from one ROM to the next.

this port can only be used on a stock ROM...

so why would it matter what base any ROM is on?

You are very confused about ME7...

yes it only has root for those that updated their phone to the ME7 OTA, their kernel is now blocking any type of downgrade to be able to use the previous root method.

however

if you are already rooted..

you can flash ANY ROM, this includes MY ME7 ROM, and the stock ME7 ROM.

http://xdaforums.com/showthread.php?t=2376140

http://xdaforums.com/showthread.php?t=2384362

ME7 is running great and compared to MDK is MUCH better..

and FWIW I know that just about every DEV is in their process of porting to ME7, including sbreen
[Verizon Samsung Galaxy S 4] wolfgrrl:
Many of us are using 2.4 ME2 3minit framework and 2.6 app on HyperDrive RLS 7 currently. If [MENTION=4600715]sbreen94[/MENTION] is porting to ME7, that's great.

I was just putting the possibility out there that not all devs may be porting to ME7. Maybe I'm wrong.
[Verizon Samsung Galaxy S 4] andybones:
to say a DEV isn't updating to a new OTA doesn't make any sense,

that would be like a kernel DEV using old kernel sources when a new one just came out

Why would you not update to the new?

One reason.

ROM Control...

it's not ported to ME7 yet.. I had to do all the porting myself.

Most are waiting for Didact to release ROM Control, and once that happens you will see every just about every ROM updated to ME7.

I guess my point is this, in the OP you asked for the 3minit port, I would have to port that to the stock framework files, be it MDK, ME7, or a new OTA we get..

Sure, it will work on hyperdrive, or any other ROM, but you are literally removing all the hard work that sbreen just did. I know he has a custom tweaks set up, and SystemUI.apk and SecSettings.apk are main players in something like that, and 3minit replaces those, rendering all the work he just did, useless..

not too mention the problems that are happening that haven't been seen yet.

I had planned on porting 3minit before I saw this thread, which is why I posted right away when I saw it.

I can make the port based on the stock ROM, and then port to hyperdrive

based off of the hyperdrive ROM files

but that's more work.

I am going to be porting 3minit to ME7 for my personal use, I will post it here for anyone who wants to try it out. :)
[Verizon Samsung Galaxy S 4] Dathion:
I would love to see the 3minit app on your Barebones 1.1.1

I have purchased the app and have a hard time with finding the framework for it to run right.
[Verizon Samsung Galaxy S 4] wolfgrrl:
That would be great!

Yes, [MENTION=4600715]sbreen94[/MENTION] has made some tweaks to his ROM that do overlap some of the 3Minit tweaks, but most of the 3Minit tweaks are not in HyperDrive. The two play nice together with the 2.4 framework, even tho it overwrites some of the HyperDrive tweaks.

When HyperDrive ports to ME7, I'll be one of the first to try your framework :)
[Verizon Samsung Galaxy S 4] andybones:
thanks bro, it wouldn't be made into the ROM,

but like I said above, it would be based off the stock ME7 base,

and then once that is done,

I can then port it to my BoneStock ROM, and will most likely offer it as an add-on

What is the latest app and framework?

and where can I download them, I would like to start working on this.
[Verizon Samsung Galaxy S 4] wolfgrrl:
The framework can be gotten from here: http://xdaforums.com/showthread.php?t=2276611 I'm not sure which version of the framework would be best for your base, but ME2 is what we've used previously that has ran well. If you can't find the 2.4 framework, let me know and I'll upload it for you. I have it on my extsdcard.

Latest app is 3.1.1, I believe. That's the "donator" version.
[Verizon Samsung Galaxy S 4] andybones:
perfect, thank you very much this is great.
[Verizon Samsung Galaxy S 4] holla420:
Hope u can help us out andy
[Verizon Samsung Galaxy S 4] t3t5u0:
3Minit on Bone Stock v1.1.1

Guys, I don't want to hi-jack this thread, but I would seriously give BoneStock 1.1.1 a try before you rain on the idea. Andy has done an AMAZING job with that ROM and his hard work paid off exponentially. I was a CleanROM hold-out and converted and it was well worth the switch. The ME7 code base itself is reason enough to switch; clearly faster and optimized code. Look to the future (ME7) instead of clinging to the past (MDK).

Andy, PLEASE run with 3Minit on your ROM... many beers/cokes/coffees/burgers coming your way (from me and likely others) if you do my friend. Glad to have you considering this and thanks for a GREAT ROM!

Wolfgrrl...THANKS for opening this bounty thread to revive the amazing 3Minit framework/app for VZW S4!!! Count me in for an initial $20 donation to whomever runs with the cause... hopefully we've found our dev! ;)
[Verizon Samsung Galaxy S 4] holla420:
I may give that rom a go since breen said it maybe gonna be 2weeks til rls8. Just to see wats all the hype about this rom
[Verizon Samsung Galaxy S 4] andybones:
Would love to see you in the thread.

If you do try it, I hope you enjoy it.

I have plans currently to get the AOSP theme from nitro that he gave me permission to port, and then 3minit is my next project.

AOSP theme is a PITA!!!
[Verizon Samsung Galaxy S 4] holla420:
I will give this a go. Dling now. I flashed this on my roommates s4 and all I hear from him is how gr8 this rom is. Once I get everything up and running ill post
[Verizon Samsung Galaxy S 4] andybones:
I hope the hype doesn't get your expectations up too high.

I try my best, and give it my all and really enjoy the learning and the great community. I am not the best Developer, but I am determined, I learn fast and I put in a lot of time to my thread to try and make it as enjoyable process for everyone as much as possible.

I know my ROM is not as feature rich, but I make my ROMs based on stability and battery life first.

Also, I am working on adding 3minit as an add-on sometime down the later future, I first need to port Nitro's AOSP theme, and then the v1.2 to-do list.

Hope to see you in the threads and enjoying it! :cool:
[Verizon Samsung Galaxy S 4] demon28:
Has anyone tried 3minit on me7 ROM yet?
[Verizon Samsung Galaxy S 4] anthony92170:
kinda a dumb question your in a bounty thread to get it to work on me7 so what does that tell you.
[Verizon Samsung Galaxy S 4] demon28:
Well what I was trying to do was inform that there is a zip that works on Barebones V1.3.

Page 781 in the Hyperdrive ROM if anyone is interested in the file
[Verizon Samsung Galaxy S 4] holla420:
What framework version r u using? I would like to kno. Been searching for a working 3minit
[Verizon Samsung Galaxy S 4] shindiggity:
Yes it works.

---------- Post added at 09:33 PM ---------- Previous post was at 09:31 PM ----------

I'm running that same thing on Nitro build.
[Verizon Samsung Galaxy S 4] wolfgrrl:
[MENTION=5207487]JediMindTrixx[/MENTION] & I have tried 3.2.1 MGA for i9505 and it works....HOWEVER it kills GPS. [MENTION=2738236]shindiggity[/MENTION], can you confirm that GPS is working with framework installed? And exactly what framework are you running?

[MENTION=2586080]andybones[/MENTION], would you be willing to take a look at this? We would certainly appreciate it!
[Verizon Samsung Galaxy S 4] shindiggity:
3.2.2 MGA, yeah my gps works fine. I'm running Nitro's 2.0.
[Verizon Samsung Galaxy S 4] wolfgrrl:
[MENTION=5207487]JediMindTrixx[/MENTION] & [MENTION=3553332]hollla[/MENTION]420, have you tried 3.2.2 with GPS? It may be Rom related?
[Verizon Samsung Galaxy S 4] holla420:
No I havent I think I will try it after dinner here. I heard that it works but will do some digging
[Verizon Samsung Galaxy S 4] le0.br4zuc4:
From what I read, 3.2.2 is breaking gps. I am using 3.2.1 and everything is working fine.

My rom is bonestock and I am running his stock kernel.

Le0_Br4zUc4 - Sent from my BEAST SCH-I545 using Tapatalk 4
[Verizon Samsung Galaxy S 4] SupaSwag:
Using 3.2.2 GPS works fine for me on Hyperdrive. Using stock kernel.
[Verizon Samsung Galaxy S 4] holla420:
I tried and it broke my gps on 3.2.1 and 3.2.2 now :(
[Verizon Samsung Galaxy S 4] allan1313:
3.2.1 is working for me on hyperdrive. GPS and navigation no problems. Maybe try again.
[Verizon Samsung Galaxy S 4] Gunthermic:
Only my advice...

I hope all you trying these different framework realize what you are doing. You WILL break things you have no idea about. 3minit is a great app, but you are talkign about replacing a core piece of your OS. Whiel you may not see something broken that sticks out, but we are talking about Android 4.1.2 or 4.2 and lastly 4.3 at some point. there is massive changes in the code and the stuff available in each of those frameworks. Think of it this way, woudl you put a Ford 150 engine in a Ford Fucus? Where the focus is all wirded up and wantign to tellyou things are wrogn with all the computer parts, whereas the 150 Engine is not equiped to do so?

I will guarentee that at some point you will break something.. I see GPS broken, Hotspot, market downloads broken, FC's of an apps becuase it's expecting something that all a sudden is missing. I would warn you not to do it, until someone like Andy ports it across and the 3minit team ports it.

this thread was suppose to be about porting it, but now its a discussion on what has broken, or not working. If you use somehing that is not meant to be used. you have to deal with it.. Start a new thread, about FAQ's or Help with 3minit. that would be great.. It not being ported yet, has no value of what is broken. It's broken becuase it wasn't meant for the base your running it on. A proper port will function then time for bug issues.

All I am saying is expect things to break... I totally agree that if it will be ported it shoudl be ported to ME7 as that is the newest and latest build.

Just food for thought.. I try new and interesting stuff all the time, but tell eveyone that stuff is broken, beause i am doing things that not suppose to do..

Always, Always Nandroid!
[Verizon Samsung Galaxy S 4] wolfgrrl:
I feel that any information that we can put in the thread about what is working and what is not would be helpful for any dev that decides to take on the challenge. It lets them know what to look at that's broken, and what is not.

Just my humble opinion tho.............
[Verizon Samsung Galaxy S 4] Gunthermic:
I appriciate you opinion. although it's broken becuase it wasnt meant to be run on a particular Android version/Build... not broken becuase it was ported over already.

Andy Bones woudl be a great fella to take this on and port it for all those that use this product. All should encourage him to take it on!
[Verizon Samsung Galaxy S 4] Pr1meSuspect:
I'm using MGA 3.2.2 with Hyperdrive. Everything I use is working as it should and I haven't noticed anything broken. GPS works and no app FC's. Whenever a new mod/framework is introduced to 3minit I always nandroid in case some big issue arises. If users want to flash it and run into issues then it's their problem. We come to XDA because we're tired of the stock and want to mod our devices to best fit our needs. We learn by making mistakes and seeing which combinations work best. It's about being smart and which is why the I9505 version is being used since it's the closest to our device. People should report problems they encounter so other users know what to expect. That way they can make a smart decision as to whether or not they want to flash it. If people break something and don't report it then more users will make the same mistake. Official port or not.

If the OP is cool with bug reports in here then I'm sure no one could argue against that. There's already another 3minit thread here that could also serve that purpose but at least the info could be easily found.
[Verizon Samsung Galaxy S 4] Gunthermic:
Thanx for the comments. As usual it's like beating your head againist a brick wall.

The amount of time we spend trying to make your phone better, but get so little respect when we just caution...

I whole heartly suport reporting issue, only this thread was suppose to be for a Bounty..

My aplogies... for trying to share knowledge, we keep gettign threads shut down becuase users go off about others things that are not related to the subject.. main Bounty thread is now closed... That is all I was trying to say..

I would gather until the Bounty is a bit more, you might not get a Dev to bite.
[Verizon Samsung Galaxy S 4] andybones:
As a developer this is just 100% wrong.

This is why we have so many issues in threads, people flash things NOT meant for that ROM, phone, etc, an then go into the ROM thread and wonder why things aren't working..

Not saying you do this, but others do.

If you were to just decompile the framework you are flashing to your phone against the one you are re-placing and understood the changes in there, trust me you would not flash it...

my 2 cents
[Verizon Samsung Galaxy S 4] Gunthermic:
Very well said!! +1,000
[Verizon Samsung Galaxy S 4] andybones:
Agreed, this port is VERY hard and time consuming,

support for a year, would need to be MUCH higher, I don't think that it's understood how tough it is to support this port.. let alone for a year..

I would consider porting it to bases for a certain dollar amount, but $60 for a year support isn't even in the infield of the ball park.

I think that the year support is turning people off, I think a dollar amount to port to certain bases makes more sense, just my opinion.
[Verizon Samsung Galaxy S 4] Pr1meSuspect:
I'm not 100% wrong. I'm not rolling under a dev title but I've been around long enough to know about the major differences across device variants. It's my choice and I'm not wrong in doing so. I don't complain in rom threads but nobody is going to stop flashing these mods and we might as well not make a bad situation worse by not allowing people to report compatibility issues in these 3minit threads. Though I do agree that the newbs will remain newbs when it comes to reporting issues. It's nothing new. Very few people take the time to read. However, every recent 3minit related post I've seen in the Hyperdrive thread acknowledged that they know the issues are related to 3minit. Sbreen has been supportive in users utilizing 3minit and has even been offering help on occasion. As your last post states, it's a hard process supporting 3minit. Until it gets a proper port people will still be flashing it with any compatibility issues that may arise. You basically want to blockade 3minit when that method clearly won't work. The best thing to do atm is for regular users (and in some cases devs like sbreen) to offer help to those using the mod. Trust me, people like myself are going to keep using these mods even if a proper port never arrives.
[Verizon Samsung Galaxy S 4] wolfgrrl:
Well, now I'm feeling like a useless boob.

I put this thread up to garner interest and to see who was interested in donating to a get a dev interested. This wasn't meant to bash others up about their opinions.

$60 is all the donation that were received. Nothing I can do about that. Guess 3Minit isn't that important to some people. And I might add that some of those I see complaining in this thread haven't donated. Put up or shut up!

Should no one come forward as interested, the thread will be closed and money refunded. Posting information to assist a dev in being able to port it is one things. Bashing others for their opinions is quite another.

I appreciate constructive feedback. This is the first time I'm hearing how hard this is. This is the first time I'm hearing that a years' support it too much. I would have appreciated knowing this two weeks ago. I did not want a dev to come, port it once, and take off with the donators monies. I think that's bogus, and I'm not saying that's what anyone would have done. But that was the reasoning behind it.

I'll give this thread one more week, then refunds will ensue and the thread will be deleted.
[Verizon Samsung Galaxy S 4] SupaSwag:
If the OP doesn't want this thread to get locked down for the moment then I think a [BOUNTY/DISCUSSION] label for the title would be more appropriate. Just my 2 cents.

Most devs have a different opinion than the users since they have to deal with the crap bug related posts in their threads. I agree with pr1mesuspect tho. As long as the mod exists people will keep flashing and the best thing to do is offer help when possible. Attached a pic of GPS on hyperdrive. Only took a couple of seconds to get this with 3minit 3.2.2.
[Verizon Samsung Galaxy S 4] wolfgrrl:
Unfortunately, I cannot change the title.
[Verizon Samsung Galaxy S 4] Pr1meSuspect:
Hopefully that comment wasn't directed towards me. I'm just offering my opinion the best I can without trying to bash anyone or appear that I'm complaining about 3minit. I apologize if I came off as disrespectful. I wish I could donate but I'm a jobless high school student. Hence, why I'm being supportive towards those who decide to flash 3minit.
[Verizon Samsung Galaxy S 4] JBeXX:
You can change the title if you use advanced edit via PC.
[Verizon Samsung Galaxy S 4] andybones:
You're missing the point, I'm sorry I said 100%..

1) as I said, you don't complain, other users do

2) I am not blockading this MOD? why would I want to do that? For the $60 a year that I wouldn't even port this to ME7 for..

Yea.. warning people about breaking flashing the wrong framework files is really blocking something? I offered exactly what this thread wanted, 3minit ported. I said I'd port to stock framework thus making it incredibly easy for DEVs to incorporate.. explain to me how that is blocking?

No, it's just a warning, flash whatever you want...

4) I don't care if you use this MOD, you're clearly taking this personally so I am done posting to you.

I'm very sorry if you feel this way.. That was never intended. I came here EARLY to help..and I'm pretty sure I'm still the only one.

No one is bashing anything or anyone.., it's a pure warning to others that flashing the wrong framework files causes issues..

You unfortunately have no idea the amount of time needed, so maybe next time get the info before making the thread?

It is not my responsibility to tell you how much $ is needed to support a PORT for a YEAR.

Gunther and I are 2 respected members of this community. I offered my help and opinion, and Gunther only offered his opinions, that's it, you guys are jumping all over the wrong people who WERE helping you..

I will kindly leave here now, as to not stir up anything and to stop side-tracking your thread.
[Verizon Samsung Galaxy S 4] Gunthermic:
Wolf galiant effort in trying to start a thread to garner interest. I was only offering an opinion. But it was taken wrong and sidetracked the thread. I will kindly bow out and leave the project. My apolgies once again

Sent from my SCH-I535 using Xparent BlueTapatalk 2
[Verizon Samsung Galaxy S 4] Pr1meSuspect:
I took it personally since all I did was offer my opinion to Gunthermic and then you came all told me I was "100% wrong". His response to my comment was respectful and he gets my thanks and sincerest apologies if I came off as rude in reply to him. Respect is earned and though you may have been a part of great projects in the past, we're in the present and you can't treat people like they're below you. You may not feel like you are but this is the impression I'm getting. Just a matter of opinion.

As for wolfgrrl getting info on the amount of work and money needed to support this port, that isn't her fault. This is why the bounty thread was made in order to help garner support for a proper port. Unfortunately there isn't much interest and which is why the current bounty doesn't meet whatever expectations a dev has in mind. If the bounty was higher then I'm sure devs wouldn't have cared that she didn't have any background info.

Sorry wolfgrrl for continuing this relatively off-topic discussion.
[Verizon Samsung Galaxy S 4] Naddict:
Thread closed at the request of the OP.
[AT&T HTC One (M7)] rohitvis:
Hi Does anyone know if Pie Control, Halo and other nice features form the PA ROMs could be installed onto the Google Edition ROMs for HTC one?

I know there is app for Pie Control -- but it pales in comparison to what PA ROMs offer.
[AT&T HTC One (M7)] Nick281051:
I'm gonna have to lean towards no because htc's framework usually doesn't allow for it
[AT&T HTC One (M7)] Scott41373:
If you are rooted, search xda for an app called LMT. It not only contains pie, but gesture controls. Halo, however is for AOSP Roms.

---------- Post added at 08:29 PM ---------- Previous post was at 08:25 PM ----------

I believe halo is open sourced, but I'm not sure if anyone has released it as a stand alone app. In my experience, I've found LMT to have just as many configurations as pie in PA or CM10.1.
[AT&T HTC One (M7)] MotoKush:
halo is not for sense, just so u know, it is for xbox and pc lol hahaha,
[Xperia Z General] destrvction:
Hey Guys,

yesterday I took my phone out of my pocket and put it back inside .. after 2 minutes took it again out and voilà the screen was cracked.

Here you got two Pics

1.

2.

seriously I handled this phone very carefully.

I don't think that Sony helps me out.

Just wanted to tell you this.

Greetz

_

Sorry , I didn't know how to insert links right.
[Xperia Z General] DrKrFfXx:
I feel you, bro. Been there before.
[Xperia Z General] lay_forat:
Today I hit really hard my xperia z screen to the corner of the table while it was in my pocket I though its gone but to my surprise there isn't a single scratch on the screen I felt lucky