[Samsung Galaxy S (4G Model)] GFX.myst.:
Alright guys, here's my understanding on the issues we have to knock off the list.

Wifi - Fixed

GPS - Fixed for some, but not for all.

HD Recording - Works but not smooth like wanted.

TV-Out - Not working

Dock Audio - Not working

Here, I'm going to quote what was told to me.

[20:17] <@GFXmyst> what's left to knock off the list? just smooth hd-recording, tv-out and dock audio, right?
[20:18] <@GFXmyst> or is gps not fixed yet either?
[20:20] [MENTION=1949378]bhundven[/MENTION]> gps needs a bit more tuning
[20:20] [MENTION=1949378]bhundven[/MENTION]> It's issue is fixed
[20:20] [MENTION=1949378]bhundven[/MENTION]> it's problems aren't over
[20:21] <@GFXmyst> ok, so not totally fixed yet
[20:21] [MENTION=1949378]bhundven[/MENTION]> but yes, GFXmyst you're correct.
[20:21] [MENTION=1949378]bhundven[/MENTION]> that seems to be what's left
[20:21] [MENTION=3770444]jeffsf[/MENTION]> Yeah -- I still maintain that it is an RF-design problem
[20:21] [MENTION=1949378]bhundven[/MENTION]> afaik
[20:21] [MENTION=1949378]bhundven[/MENTION]> I think it's a uart issue
[20:21] [MENTION=3770444]jeffsf[/MENTION]> USB-OTG wasn't on the original list -- just mentioning it
[20:21] <@GFXmyst> now, would these things be kernel related?
[20:22] [MENTION=1949378]bhundven[/MENTION]> tvout is a stupid java issue
[20:22] [MENTION=1949378]bhundven[/MENTION]> jeffsf: you'd probably be better at fixing it.
[20:22] [MENTION=3770444]jeffsf[/MENTION]> IfLOL
[20:22] [MENTION=1949378]bhundven[/MENTION]> idk
[20:22] [MENTION=1949378]bhundven[/MENTION]> someone that knows java better then me
[20:23] [MENTION=1949378]bhundven[/MENTION]> it's not a knowing it
[20:23] [MENTION=1949378]bhundven[/MENTION]> its looking at the error
[20:24] [MENTION=1949378]bhundven[/MENTION]> when the library is loaded
[20:24] [MENTION=1949378]bhundven[/MENTION]> and fixing the java side
[20:24] [MENTION=1949378]bhundven[/MENTION]> probably just symbol mismatches
[20:24] [MENTION=1949378]bhundven[/MENTION]> or wrong arguments
[20:24] [MENTION=1949378]bhundven[/MENTION]> idk
[20:24] [MENTION=1949378]bhundven[/MENTION]> I looked at it for 3 seconds and walked away
[20:24] [MENTION=1949378]bhundven[/MENTION]> at that point, I was noticing the irq issues
[20:25] [MENTION=1949378]bhundven[/MENTION]> seemed more important then tvout
[20:26] <@GFXmyst> now dock audio = kernel?
[20:26] [MENTION=1949378]bhundven[/MENTION]> asound + possible kernel issue
[20:26] [MENTION=3770444]jeffsf[/MENTION]> Both, likely
[20:26] [MENTION=1949378]bhundven[/MENTION]> most likely...
[20:26] [MENTION=3770444]jeffsf[/MENTION]> Need to have the kernel and low-level audio be able to route to the dock
[20:26] [MENTION=1949378]bhundven[/MENTION]> a kernel issue, but not really a kernel issue
[20:26] [MENTION=1949378]bhundven[/MENTION]> yup
[20:26] [MENTION=1949378]bhundven[/MENTION]> exactly
[20:26] [MENTION=1949378]bhundven[/MENTION]> so it's just the audio device naming game
[20:27] [MENTION=3770444]jeffsf[/MENTION]> need to have the Java-to-kernel libraries in place to ask that it be done
[20:27] <@GFXmyst> k and the same with hd recording?
[20:27] [MENTION=3770444]jeffsf[/MENTION]> DId HD recording work in "stock"?
[20:27] <@GFXmyst> 720 p i think
[20:27] [MENTION=1949378]bhundven[/MENTION]> yea
[20:27] <@GFXmyst> not 1080 p though
[20:27] [MENTION=1949378]bhundven[/MENTION]> idk
[20:28] [MENTION=1949378]bhundven[/MENTION]> the other galaxy s phones have 1080p
[20:28] <@GFXmyst> we did when dsexton brought in a mod for it
[20:28] [MENTION=1949378]bhundven[/MENTION]> right
[20:28] [MENTION=3770444]jeffsf[/MENTION]> OK then
[20:28] [MENTION=1949378]bhundven[/MENTION]> that bug gets assigned to dsexton :p
[20:28] [MENTION=1949378]bhundven[/MENTION]> NEXT
[20:28] [MENTION=1949378]bhundven[/MENTION]> :)
[20:29] <@GFXmyst> lol
[20:29] <@GFXmyst> well, i can test for dock audio since i have a dock
[20:29] [MENTION=1949378]bhundven[/MENTION]> there are also bugs on github
[20:29] [MENTION=1949378]bhundven[/MENTION]> inimeg81: gets credit for the gps derp fix
[20:30] <@GFXmyst> that's just a fix for some though from what i've read
[20:30] [MENTION=1949378]bhundven[/MENTION]> it's a start
[20:30] [MENTION=3770444]jeffsf[/MENTION]> GPS lock is so dicey on these things
[20:30] [MENTION=3770444]jeffsf[/MENTION]> I suspect more about where people are and how chewed up their cases are

So, there you have it folks. Looks like the only thing that's totally fixed as of now is Wifi. Also, I would like to add that any fixes made would have to work for all ROMs and not just one in particular. This means all JB and KK ROMs. So, like [MENTION=4571512]daothanhduy1996[/MENTION] said, we still have a long way to go here. [MENTION=3770444]jeffsf[/MENTION] [MENTION=1949378]bhundven[/MENTION], if you wish to comply with what I quoted and possibly help with people understanding what we talked about, please do. ;)

Edit: was told to put this here as well. It's our issue tracker on github.

https://github.com/teamacid/android_device_samsung_galaxys4gmtd/issues?state=open