yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] agentfazexx:
I dunno how to provide logs for this, but:

When I flash the ROM, 5/21 and 5/27 had this issue... It'll freeze on the Galaxy S4 logo. I have to do a battery pull to get it to boot into Android on the first boot... Subsequent reboots are fine.
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] gobblenutz:
I have not had this issue. Did you wipe everything the op tells you too?
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] agentfazexx:
Yep.
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] teradark:
I can also confirm the hang at Samsung boot. Also Twrp also tells me my device isnt rooted. This only pops up when either my device isnt rooted or I have no system installed.
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] wojo797:
No hanging up here on a clean install full wipe
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] garwynn:
Best suggestion I can offer is dump/view the recovery log after flashing and make sure there were no issues.

You can also try the Odin method and see if that has any different results.
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] garwynn:
Hey folks!

It's been a great run but this thread will be coming to an end.

I'm posting what will be my final build for this soon. It contains a rewrite of the RIL courtesy of noobnl.

It's great news though because me stopping means one thing - we're getting nightlies!

From what I understand you should see them starting the next run - not tonight.

You can also now point your device trees and everything to the CM repos as noobnl has committed it all now.

It's been a pleasure to build these and for me, understand what it takes to get a new device up and running.

A big shout out again to those in the Credits on OP for their help, especially noobnl. He's why we have nightlies.

I'll be having this thread locked once I get everything cleaned up and pointing to the final location for new builds.
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] neuteboomt:
Thank you for all your hard work!
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] asafegous:
I'm getting phone process fc after clean install.
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] dtr145r:
I'm going to flash the latest in a few minutes.

I'll report back if I have the same issue.
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] agentfazexx:
Which issue?
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] dtr145r:
Phone fc
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] garwynn:
I have left the last 3 builds up in case they are needed.

But again, I'm not planning on making any more builds since you should see them starting tomorrow via nightly.
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] rlmiller:
Thank you Garwynn for your work on this ROM and the others you are building..... You are super developer
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] hckyplayer024:
Does anyone else get force closes on phone with the newest build? I tried on clean wipe as well.
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] dtr145r:
yes. known issue on the latest build.

official nighties will be available soon.

im sure there will be a fix in there,

thanks.
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] Don_dada:
Yup!

AT&T variant of the S4 (jflteatt) has been merged, so hopefully it wont be much longer for ours...
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] garwynn:
It was merged last night, hence why I'm stopping.

-------------------------------------------

Noobnl's thread is now up - head over ther:

http://xdaforums.com/showthread.php?t=2304936

This one has been requested to lock. Been fun!
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] likearaptor:
Are you planning on getting the Sprint S4? I think from what I read you were accepting donations to help get one? I assume you accept paypal and where do we send them? How much do you still need to get a device to help get you developing better? I know having to wait for someone to test slows things down quite a bit.
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] MoHoGalore:
Here is the effort that will have Great results!

http://xdaforums.com/showthread.php?t=2260223
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] garwynn:
All right, recap of where we stand:

CWM side - good but no exfat support. I think Agat's kernel will give us the modules needed for that.

CM side - phone boots to black and an LED. It seems to be hanging somewhere in the init process because it doesn't even get to logging or starting adbd. Flash the stock boot.img and get the same result.

What does that tell us? The issue is either in the ROM or in both kernels.

I'm trying to narrow it down somehow but for the next few days it's going to be as I can get a tester.

Now the very good news - A user approached us with some very BIG assistance.

As a result I and 2 other people will have S4s next week.

I'll let that person stand up if they want to but I can't thank them enough for the help.

Not bad for those donations that you sent - got 3 folks set up instead of 1!

And now hopefully my main build box is back so we should be back to 24 hour operations.

That is... as long as I don't need sleep :)

And now back to the grind!
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] garwynn:
Prealpha 10 posted.
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] garwynn:
I made a Prealpha 11 adding some changes from the source now that it dropped.

Screen still stays off but USB device started - no ADB or MTP though.

LED light also not coming on so there is definitely an improvement.

I think I know why so I'm rushing another build that should start ADB.

Then we can at least get a peek and possibly see what's going on.

Hopefully some better news soon.
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] likearaptor:
Thanks for the update Garwynn :)
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] garwynn:
And we have ADB access!!

Asking moho to upload and post. I will start investigating later tonight... after the Hawks wipe the Wild all over the ice! :)
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] garwynn:
Cyanogen's repos have updates... and significant ones to jf-common. Time to pull and see if it changes our situation.
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] garwynn:
Update: New repos got to same point I was at yesterday before where almost had ADB. Good news in that I'm doing something right... but we'll have to bring it home. Will do more investigating later today.
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] cordell12:
bringing SlimROM to jfltespr, as of right now I cant get past splash screen. Havent compiled with updated repo's, (jf-common and vendor/samsung) will do that in a bit.

Anyway, my logcat shows a grip of surfaceflinger complaints :eek: Have you gotten to boot animation yet?

I/ServiceManager( 788): Waiting for service SurfaceFlinger...

UPDATE...SlimROM is booting!!!
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] garwynn:
No boot ani yet for me. Great news on SlimROM!
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] cordell12:
Check out muppets, vendor/samsung has blobs now. That will get you screen lit ;)
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] garwynn:
Cloning... I bet it was the missing adreno driver. More when I get home.
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] garwynn:
Building...
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] mjs2011:
Looks like t mobile and international have official support now. Guessing we won't be too far behind.
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] shabbypenguin:
my suggestion is to keep an eye out on sxtp forums ;)
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] garwynn:
Prealpha 15 uploading now! Feeling lucky tonight!
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] MoHoGalore:
As well you should Sir!

We have lift off!!

Just a few screens to start..

:beer::D:beer:

Sent from my SPH-L720 using Xparent Skyblue Tapatalk 2
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] sextape:
Sexy
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] mjs2011:
Gotta charge my battery a bit. Then I'm trying this sh*t out!
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] opz187:
Very cool dude. booted and functioned fine for me. Boot ani looked sexy on the s4. only issue I had was that I couldn't Mount extsd. and unfortunately that is where I keep my tibu backup folder, so I had to go into recovery and restore a nandroid. But dam it felt good to have cm on this. Damn good work garwynn!
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] opz187:
Lil preview for ya
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] shabbypenguin:
looks shopped ;)
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] opz187:
yea theyre like that by default.
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] garwynn:
Beta 1 building with SD card fix. (Thank [MENTION=1466193]cyanogen[/MENTION] for that one.)
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] opz187:
Word im gonna get at it
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] garwynn:
Up now. Now... Let's see if these trees will play nice with other projects... ;)
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] cordell12:
nice ;)

question for you

I just realized when in a call I cant not hang up. the other person on the call must end the call, also it appears I do not get incoming calls :(

wife let me know that one :p
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] garwynn:
How about any push notifications from th r carrier? It happens on my GN2.. Phone seems fine and doesn't act up until I try to call out... only to find I can't. Usually also means sms, vm and inbound calls are all missed.

If so maybe a carrier issue. That could be challenging.
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] cordell12:
sms/mms are working fine, i can receive sms, havent checked receive on mms.

with the phone i can not hang up with a call, and i do not receive calls.

going back to stock and phone is fine, of course lol
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] neemot:
Quick question: can this be flashed via TWRP. Yet to see a post about it just want to give this a shot.

Thanks!
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] MoHoGalore:
Shouldn't have an issue.

My suggestion, flash the build, reboot, then go back into recovery and flash the proper gapps.

I hung when I flashed the build and gapps together.

Sent from my SPH-L720 using Xparent Skyblue Tapatalk 2
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] asafegous:
I managed to flash this ROM via goo manager on twrp. Is the 'roaming indicator off' normal or is it just me?
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] MoHoGalore:
I get it as well. Wouldn't let it bother you. A lot of work left to do.

Great news is that Garwynn is getting the device this week. Right now he's relying on reports.

Sent from my SPH-L720 using Xparent Skyblue Tapatalk 2
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] garwynn:
For those that didn't know, noobnl is getting involved. Glad to have someone with his experience working on this also.

At his recommendation I'm rebasing the jfltespr device tree off of d2spr. I'm making the necessary changes now and will try to have a new build up shortly.
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] garwynn:
New builds up. Please test at a minimum ending a call as well as any other little bugs you've noticed in previous ones.
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] Grommish:
Yay for noobnl! Does this mean some slick kernel changes in the future?
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] dtr145r:
Tested a call on the newest build.

Its still not hanging up.
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] asafegous:
+1. I can't mount internal or external mmc on ROM now.
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] noobnl:
http://review.cyanogenmod.org/#/c/37075/

http://review.cyanogenmod.org/#/c/37076/

this should fix hangup bug.
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] garwynn:
Beta 3 posted with a temporary modification to fix call issues while those are under review. If approved those will replace temporary change.

Thanks go to noobnl for this fix. He knew in fairly short order what the cause of call issues were.
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] cordell12:
it does fix it, incoming calls are fine, as well as hanging up ;)

nice job noobnl :good:
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] dtr145r:
Hmm... Interesting that you say this...

I flashed the latest twice now and I'm only getting a black screen...

I'm pretty sure its booting because the soft keys are lighting up when I press the home key..
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] MoHoGalore:
At 8:21a.m. central time (5/7), the file was replaced. Please download again and test. Graphics were borked for a few of us as well.

(Garwynn will be available shortly.)
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] garwynn:
OK, so there were 2 versions of Beta 3. The first was just Beta 2 with some test changes:

1) Disabling a fix for d2 in the RIL class. (Was supposed to be in Beta 2 but made the change in wrong build folder.)

2) System.prop changes - which really don't do anything.

This one is what I had MoHoGalore just re-upload.

The second was cleaning up #2, repo sync and re-brunch. Something in the sync though seems not to be liked.

It's been replaced by the first version until I figure out what broke.
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] dtr145r:
(

i tried out the latest version.

incoming calls now go through.

when in a call you can no longer here the other caller, almost as if its muted. i checked my volumes and they are all up.

also it gets extremely laggy and reboots abter 30-60 seconds of either placing or receiving a call

ill send you some logs very soon.

Edit= hmmm.. Disregard this ppst for now.

I tried another fresh install with no other apps installed and it worked fine.

I want to try it with my apps installed again to see what happens.
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] garwynn:
Problem with earlier build today was due to a change in defconfig used for kernel.

Cleaned up and new builds coming in next 10 minutes.

For those keeping track this is Beta 4.
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] MoHoGalore:
I know we're mixing the Discussion Thread (Sorry Garwynn) But I wanted to respond here in case anyone is lurking..

When I test a build - Order of steps:

(From recovery)

1. Wipe cache

2. Wipe dalvik

3. Wipe data/factory reset

4. Flash build.

5. Boot into build - test data, calls

6. Boot into recovery

7. Wipe cache

8. Wipe dalvik

9. Flash gapps -

10. Complete setup and test data, calls, playstore, apps, etc..

The only time I'll flash build and gapps together is when I know the build will work with basics. And yes it's a lot of steps but one item at a time..
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] dtr145r:
i reflashed everything and all was good. calls incoming/outgoing hang ups texts and mms all worked god.

everything appears to be very stable now.

are you trying to get official nightly support?

it should be ready now. :)

i have a very similar process. except i flash gapps with the rom usually and wipe cache and davlik a few times later on when everything is set up.

it takes me about an hour to set everything back up after updating a rom because i always do clean installs.
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] MoHoGalore:
See Discussion Thread on Beta 4 Results.
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] agentfazexx:
Good to see this is already in development.

Question: I understand the whole beta/YMMV but those that have used SlimBean on the SGS4 and this ROM, how do you compare the stability, battery life, etc? SlimBean is pretty spot on for me. The issues I have there are GPS doesn't work and 3G is slow. I am used to CM-based ROMs though so I would prefer to switch back to CM10.1 if it's reliable enough at this point.
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] MoHoGalore:
Now that Garwynn has the primary issues lined out, my plan today is to write up all the main issues we know of. He is also physically getting his device today which means he will have eyes on. :D:beer:

And yes, ive been using this as my dd now.

Sent from my SPH-L720 using Xparent Skyblue Tapatalk 2
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] dtr145r:
I'm using this as a daily driver.

Only issues are the regular reboot function shuts off the phone instead of rebooting.

If the phone is plugged in and the phone is off it won't turn on until you unplug the power cord.

I couldn't get a GPS lock yesterday. I'm going to get a lock on a tw tomorrow and flash back to see if it helps.

everything else is working great for me!

This is more stable to me than cm was on the s3. I always had hiccups freezes and choppy transitions on the s3 and don't have them here.
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] agentfazexx:
Thx both. Will give this a flash later on today hopefully.
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] mjs2011:
Thanks MoHo. I was thinking about switching to this for a few days now that some of the novelties of the new TW features have tapered off a bit.

What are your thoughts on the camera options compared to stock? Having a 4 year old, I like to snap a lot of pics.

Either way, I'll probably try this out during my lunch hour. :)
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] garwynn:
Let me update the links with this morning's build.

Edit: New links up. Nothing special today, repo sync and then build.
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] dtr145r:
awesome!

downloading now.

what has changed?
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] EFEXR:
Id hate to ask but I don't see the what's working and what's not working list. I would like to flash this but need to know what's working/not working.

I want to flash this on somebody else's phone.
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] dtr145r:
http://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=41177137&postcount=73
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] mjs2011:
Wow, if that post says it's more stable than it was on the S3, then I'm guessing it's leaps and bounds above the E4GT! LOL
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] garwynn:
I think the next logical step at this point is creating and going through a full function test script. The main reason is to identify any remaining issues and start addressing them. The side benefit is that this will also help us get closer to meeting official submission requirements. (If you haven't ever read them, they're here.)

Here's where I can use some help. Let's come up with a list of stock functions (non-specific to Touchwiz or Samsung proprietary apps) over the next day and then we'll use that list to start testing. We can separate them by functional category:

Power On/Off/Restart

Display

Audio

Phone Calls

3G Data

4G Data

Wifi

Updates

...and so on.

It isn't a race - honestly the more thorough we are the better resulting CM build we should end up with.

So if we think of new things to test we'll just add them in.

By the way... phone is out for delivery today :victory:
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] blacknet101:
I was trying to test this one out but it didn't boot. I flashed it though Odin and even tried the recovery file but nothing worked. :(
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] noobnl:
It is much more stable than the gs3 because we based it of the gs3 and using the latest kernel sources from samsung.

From a source tree design standpoint, it is 99 percent identical, we had no trouble transitioning to the new device because we kept it universal through the development. in the near future we will have more devices that will be similar as the launch of each carrier. which mean we will follow the the same process on the galaxys4 as the galaxys3. e4gt is still a mess because we didn't follow anything, just built it on one thing with no care for design.

We are using the same stuff we had from gs3 but modified for more flexiblity in gs4. like for example the ril is now using a standard interface for calls. gs3 used a different interface nonstandard crap.
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] Grommish:
I just want a noobnl kernel so we can have the boot animation back that everyone screamed about on the OG Epic haha :thumbup:
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] dtr145r:
i downloaded a IR blaster remote and it doesnt work on CM10.1

flashed back to TW and it worked.

FYI

im guessing the ir blaster didnt get added to cm yet?
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] MoHoGalore:
Hey all! (Minus Sir Garwynn :p) Don't forget that there is a Discussion Thread for this..
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] cordell12:
IR Blaster source is proprietary code and wasnt released with the Galaxy S 3 source so I doubt it will be released for this device, meaning no worky ever.
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] dtr145r:
ehhh crap.

that was the main selling point for me.

i was really hoping it could be an easy fix.
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] asafegous:
GPS won't lock.
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] dtr145r:
flash back to touchwiz.

get a gps lock in google maps with out being hooked up to wifi.

flash back to cm10 and try to get a lock on gps again with out being connect to wifi.

it should lock in seconds.

gps not locking is a very typical issue with cm10 even on other devices

getting a lock on a tw rom works 99% of the time.

:)
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] asafegous:
Still not getting a lock
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] agentfazexx:
I heard rumblings that to get a lock we have to flash back to stock, get a GPS lock and then restore the backup. Much like we did with the E4GT. I have not tried yet myself though.
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] asafegous:
I've tried this twice now. I flaced force ROM, got GPS lock, restore, and reboot. No lock.
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] dtr145r:
did you get a lock on tw then do a clean install to cm10?
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] xxaddictedxx:
DL GPS status and that should give some insight to what's going on...you can at least see if your device is registering any SATs and if your getting a fix on them....if the tw lock isn't working of course.
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] asafegous:
Nothing. GPS status keeps searching for my location. Also, I'll try stock ROM. My understanding is too much of stock is missing from forcerom.
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] garwynn:
Updating links with today's build. They're still uploading at time of post so give it 10 mins.

Today's sync brings it up to the 10.1.0 RC1 tag.

As for current work - I'll be honest, when I have time I'll work on it. May not be much this weekend.

My priority is to help debug and resolve issues as I can.

Those interested in helping can check out the jf issues at jira.cyanogenmod.org and see what's being tracked.

And yes... I did spend time on another project. I didn't like leaving it where it was....
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] dtr145r:
Thanks garwynn!

My only question is did you get any bugs worked out or just sync it with cm?

:)
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] garwynn:
This morning was just a sync.
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] sacrificee:
thanks...
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] dtr145r:
You gonna post links?
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] MoHoGalore:
The link to download is correct. 20130510...

Just follow the OP link.. the download link is changed to current.
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] dtr145r:
Oh OK.

It threw me off because it said latest was 5/08
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] MoHoGalore:
Saw that. Even though I could edit it, I'm sure Garwynn will see this and update. Just keep watch on the download title..
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] garwynn:
OP is about to be reformatted so I'll clean it up then.
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] LIL_ROOKIE:
headphones and bluetooth are not working on call
[Sprint Samsung Galaxy S 4 Android Development] garwynn:
Bt already noted by Cyanogen. Will add headphones note.