yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Galaxy Note II General] joytest:
Rules:

No posts regarding which ROM / kernel is best.

No posts regarding the sheet statistics.

Only post if something is not included in the sheets that should be (like what lyldz posts in the [INDEX] thread)

================================================== ================

NOTICE:

I will scrub the results from time to time. Any bulk submissions for a single ROM posted within a 5 minute time window will be removed.

Live Results Image feed from the survey

Jun 2013

(All responses are live. You may press F5 to refresh the page.)

F5 to refresh

:)

<< SURVEY FORM LINK HERE >> for those who did not read post 1

NOTE: Due to the way the responses are stored by Google Form, the sum formula does not get inserted with the submission. I will update the sum formula several times daily per entry/entries. That is why you may not be able to see your ROM score change immediately.

>> Raw Response Data is here <<

This is the Chart showing the average of ROM score, Kernel score, SOT score and summed ROM+Kernel score.

It distinguishes between different ROM versions but due to limitations in the graph, it cannot show Kernel versions.

Click on the chart to go to the live link which reveals individual score points when you hover your mouse.

=============================================================================

May 2013

April 2013

Thanks to @sunny2303 of the [INDEX] thread, @wesamothman of Assassin ROM, @BoBCatRoM of BobCatROM, @grilleld of Moon ROM, @monx® of monxDIFIED ROM, @raghavafitt of N7100 Facebook page, @tamirda of PhoeniX ROM for mentions in their thread, sig or posts.

If there are any who have mentioned, please let me know and I will add you here.

See Methodology description in Post #3
[Galaxy Note II General] joytest:
I also maintain the Malaysian Lowyat.net forum for Note II

https://forum.lowyat.net/topic/2806226

Come visit us.

A simple writeup about Rooting I made:

http://forum.lowyat.net/index.php?showtopic=2806226&view=findpost&p=60257337

In the absence of an [INDEX] thread for N7105 ROMs, I've decided to post the tracked ROMs here.

N7105 ROMs

Avatar ROM for Samsung Notes II (N7105) / CM10.1 - http://xdaforums.com/showthread.php?t=2167066

CleanROM ACE / TW - http://xdaforums.com/showthread.php?t=2123311

CyanogenMod 10.1 official nightlies / CM10.1 - http://xdaforums.com/showthread.php?t=2105902

#HASHCHECK-HYBRID# / TW - http://xdaforums.com/showthread.php?t=2093080

PARANOIDANDROID 3.15 / AOSP - http://xdaforums.com/showthread.php?t=2113132

RootBox [Unofficial Nightlies] / CM10.1 - http://xdaforums.com/showthread.php?t=2218008

Sons Of Android JEDI / CM10.1 - http://xdaforums.com/showthread.php?t=2182245

WanamLite / TW - http://xdaforums.com/showthread.php?t=2125101

Xylon / CM10.1 - http://xdaforums.com/showthread.php?t=2231979
[Galaxy Note II General] Mohammed779:
Great idea actually.. voted :D

Sent from my GT-N7100
[Galaxy Note II General] UtkarshGupta:
Imao if you sort via no of replies, it gives a pretty good idea of the popularity. But if we consider the day it was posted like omega arhd wanam were released almost when the photos new has. They ought to be more popular than the roms which were recently released.
[Galaxy Note II General] joytest:
Thank you Mohammed. Spread the word around so we can get a more accurate and up to date picture.
[Galaxy Note II General] joytest:
But that is probably due to duration of the thread as well, since earlier threads usually have more responses. This aims to provide an easy to read statistic, with also a "I like x feature" list.

Reading 100k replies is no fun and this is a concise summary.

Give it a try.
[Galaxy Note II General] Simone:
Is there one for launchers? :confused:

I know I saw one on the general section but this kind of things would be great.

EDIT:

OP, I think you spelled kernel wrong?
[Galaxy Note II General] joytest:
Thank you very much for spotting the error !!! :angel:

Give the form a spin and let me know what you think.

Takes time compiling the info. I don't know if there is a central point for all launcher varieties. If there is I can whip up a form but a little later.
[Galaxy Note II General] Simone:
Voted for both.

Just wanted to know the percentage of TouchWiz and Nova Launcher users. Haha.

Anyway, thank you.
[Galaxy Note II General] joytest:
Good idea. If you can provide a launcher list I will try to whip something up.
[Galaxy Note II General] tamirda:
Hello friend,

Can you please fix my name?

Its tamirda not tmirda

Thanks.
[Galaxy Note II General] joytest:
Oops thank you sir !!!!

Changed. Appreciate feedback on the form.
[Galaxy Note II General] DubelBoom:
Submitted PhoeniX and Perseus! :D
[Galaxy Note II General] Kookitza:
+1 :good: :p
[Galaxy Note II General] joytest:
Thanks !!

How was the experience with the forms?

You may submit MULTIPLE ENTRIES for all the ROMs/Kernels you've tried.
[Galaxy Note II General] Bn Waheed:
voted for the best - monx and adam -
[Galaxy Note II General] DubelBoom:
Easy and understandable :)

I'll submit more roms soon.
[Galaxy Note II General] joytest:
Updated Bar Chart

Made the bar chart sort by Most Popular descending, and added live feed to post 2.

Enjoy everybody.
[Galaxy Note II General] EiD 85:
can i like more than one ROM

because i used more than one and all of them are grate

thanks to you and for all the developer
[Galaxy Note II General] joytest:
Yes you can post for as many ROMs you like.
[Galaxy Note II General] friedrich420:
Thank you! What a great idea!!

I dont know how difficult it is to add another Rom on the form, but i think you forgot this one:

[ROM] SWIFT [Base] XXDMC3 [Version] 1.0 [OP] firasusman

Actually came out last night :p But 1st impressions are excellent so i thought it should be on the list....
[Galaxy Note II General] joytest:
I would like to thank all those who have submitted so far. The survey is getting about 100 votes a day.

Seeing the responses have made me think of how to improve the form. Since the form is still in beta, I will leave it as is for April 2013.

I will make a revamp in May. I intend to change the multiple checklist into a radio selection so that we can actually see how people like or dislike features and this will be useful to developers as feedback for improvement.

If any have suggestion they are more than welcome.
[Galaxy Note II General] sunny2303:
Its very well there in ROM repository so i am sure it will get included soon in poll :)
[Galaxy Note II General] joytest:
Removal of TEST entries and honest reporting

Hi all,

I did a bit of cleanup of the raw inputs and deleted about 25 "TEST" entries. The rest have remained.

I also ask that everyone report honestly for an accurate picture.

Thank you all and please continue to participate.
[Galaxy Note II General] joytest:
The-Captain moved the thread to General ... that's fine :)

Anyway, the responses keep coming in. Current No 1 is monx.
[Galaxy Note II General] overground:
This is a borderline thread.

Normally, we do not allow "best ROM" threads on XDA.

That being said, we're going to let this one go for a while and keep a close eye on it.

Rules:

No posts regarding which ROM / kernel is best.

No posts regarding the sheet statistics.

Actually, the only posts should be if something is not included in the sheets that should be.

This thread will be subject to a 3 strikes, you're out restriction. Meaning: 3 instances that breach the above rules will result in thread closure.

@OP: I suggest you place the above in your OP in BIG RED LETTERS

Thank you for your cooperation.
[Galaxy Note II General] joytest:
Very well dear mod. Thank you for your advice.
[Galaxy Note II General] petle:
Omega 16 & Adam kernel2.3
[Galaxy Note II General] joytest:
Thanks, but right now the form does not cater for ROM versions yet. It will in the next revision.
[Galaxy Note II General] joytest:
New features for survey v2.0 - INPU REQUESTED

Hi all,

I am requesting input for the update to the survey. I will make the questions a scale of 1 to 5, plus a "Don't Know or N/A".

I will include the following for the scale:

Stock/AOSP

Slimness

Installation Experience (Aroma, options etc)

Themes

Included Kernel

Speed of Updates

Included Mods and Tweaks

Included add-on Apps

Boot Animations

Included Sounds

Stability

Performance

Battery Life

And lastly I want to add a question for rating:

Overall Impressions (3 values - Needs Lots of Improvement, Needs Some Improvement, Good Overall)

I invite your suggestions for a few more items for inclusion. I have started building the form and will try to release next week.

Thanks.
[Galaxy Note II General] BoBCatRoM:
hi joy, the polls are not true, they manipulate at will, just vote multiple times.

I did the test after seeing incredible leaps of other roms,

should place 1 vote 1 IP or something.

greetings

Roby
[Galaxy Note II General] joytest:
Hi Roby

I have noticed this as well and have done some clean up from entries that are close together. I was thinking of a need to login. Will try this. Thank you for the suggestion.

EDIT

Btw as mod has said pls dont post about the stats otherwise it can lead to flame war. Please pm me if anyone has questions.

I know the limitations and will think deeper about this.

:confused:
[Galaxy Note II General] joytest:
Master ROM Index with FULL Version History and Release Dates

Hi all,

Been lying low the last 2 weeks thinking about the survey. I am currently making a master index list containing ALL ROM versions with their release dates. It is in post 1.

The reason for this is to streamline the way the form operates. Once this master version list is out, maintenance of the version drop down is going to be much easier. The new form version will allow for ROM version selection and a quantitative response to provide a score per submission.

This will be aggregated to arrive at a count for 2 things:

1. Most Popular ROM (with most vote counts)

2. Highest scoring ROM (with most score counts)

If anyone has good input to add I welcome it.

Thanks
[Galaxy Note II General] sunny2303:
Thats lot of work you have done mate.. my best wishes :) In case you need any help please let me know.. I will be glad to help..
[Galaxy Note II General] joytest:
Master ROM Index completed (55 ROMs, 400 VERSIONS)

Hi all,

I finally completed the master index containing 55 ROMs with all their versions, and correlated to their release dates.

A total of 400 versions were logged, with 202 unique version numbers. This will be used to maintain stacked data selection for the new survey version.

For your viewing pleasure, and Comments are enabled in the spreadsheet.

If you feel there are any errors or amendments, please let me know. My next action is to arrange all ROMs and Versions into a selectable dropdown list for your voting. Latest I should finish is by next weekend.

If not already default, please select the "ROMs" tab for viewing.

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0As-peidjMwx4dHlLNXBnSGI3enhkRHJQX0dvWE9saUE#gid=7
[Galaxy Note II General] joytest:
Survey 2.0 Released (2013-05-02)

Hi all,

I finally completed 2 major items:

1. The Master Index of ROMS

This allowed me to properly sort data to be used for version selection in the survey.

2. The update Survey 2.0

This allows ROM and its corresponding version selection, and also a quantitative value per response.

This summary value will allow ranking of specific ROM versions. I admit I need some help with viewing this in a 3 dimensional manner in Google Sheet because we are now looking at

1. ROM 2. Version 3. Score - I can't represent this in a 2D bar chart. Any suggestions are sincerely welcome.

However I'm currently using a "Table View" for these scores.

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0As-peidjMwx4dEJhUGJoTTBVcHlEaG1KRUhVcEs3bXc#gid=7
[Galaxy Note II General] raghavafitt:
hehehe he here i am mate..... gud idea:D:D:D

---------- Post added at 06:55 PM ---------- Previous post was at 06:54 PM ----------

hehehehehe here i am mate....

Gud idea:D:D:D
[Galaxy Note II General] joytest:
Hi all

The survey and master list is up to date with all the latest versions as posted by sunny2303's [INDEX] thread.

57 ROMs and 163 versions selectable.
[Galaxy Note II General] joytest:
ROM version Score Graph !!!

Hi all,

I managed to whip up a summary graph that shows how EACH ROM VERSION scores, and for ROMs that have multiple versions evaluated, you can see how each version compares to each other.

This is a static image. For the live image, please see post #2. You may need an F5 refresh to see the latest updates.
[Galaxy Note II General] betoNL:
Hello Buddy,

First of all , good job...:good:

I guess the KERNEL survey list needs to be updated, for instance:

- Adam kernel latest version is 2.4

- And the VERY VERY GOOD SaberKernel is not even listed.

Unless I missed something.

I also would like to suggest adding a poll in this thread too. That for confirmation, reliability increase or just for fun ;)

Many users ignores surveys, but can easily add his vote on a XDA-like poll

Greetz

.
[Galaxy Note II General] joytest:
Hi thanks for yr submission!

You mean a poll in this thread itself?

Apologies on the kernel survey it needs updating. Was focused on the rom list presently. I'm attempting to integrate it w the rom survey next.

:fingerscrossed:
[Galaxy Note II General] betoNL:
Yep, you can easily add an extra poll to this thread, which is very user-friendly, but above all, also lazy-friendly :D

:good:
[Galaxy Note II General] joytest:
Sortable ALL Features Score Table

Added a sortable table showing ALL Feature Scores !!!

Use this to help you determine or select which feature in a ROM you'd like to flash.

Devs can also use this as an improvement tool, to see which areas need improvement.

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet...4dEJhUGJoTTBVcHlEaG1KRUhVcEs3bXc&pli=1#gid=13
[Galaxy Note II General] joytest:
Updated matching sunny2303's index thread.

BadWolf included, and Master ROM List now contains 58 ROMs and 434 versions.

Thanks to all ROM Chefs who also included the survey mention in their threads.
[Galaxy Note II General] joytest:
Survey of the Survey !!!

Hi everybody,

To gauge your feelings towards the Grand ROM Survey, I made a little poll as suggested by [MENTION=465173]betoNL[/MENTION].

This is just a simple poll of what you think of the work and results of this survey so far.

5 options for you at the top:

Great !! It's good enough, carry on !!

Great !!! I want more statistics !!!

Carry on, but I want less statistics

I would like to help you with some updates.

Useless, please stop spamming

If you have suggestions for improvement please post them in this thread, but be mindful of mod's rules highlighted in the first 3 posts.

Thank you !!!!
[Galaxy Note II General] charles.chip:
can someone please provide the link to BoBCaTROM ?
[Galaxy Note II General] McLaren__F1:
Here http://xdaforums.com/showthread.php?t=2200625
[Galaxy Note II General] joytest:
This thread does not link ROMs, but the main INDEX thread in http://xdaforums.com/showthread.php?t=1926506

This thread provides analysis of ROM popularity and Feature-completeness. Please submit your entry/entries for all ROMs you have tried.

Thanks.
[Galaxy Note II General] joytest:
Form problem - no responses !!!

2013-05-12 - 23:00 MYT (UTC +8)

UNKNOWN PROBLEM WITH FORM - RESPONSES NOT CAPTURED !!! PLEASE RESUBMIT LATER

update: I suspect it may be to do with the total number of dropdowns. I will investigate, but need a couple of days.

My sincerest apologies for this.

Thanks to @wesamothman for the headsup !!!

I have no idea why this is so. I will try a couple of things like restarting my browser/re-login/restart my PC etc.

However this is a Google Form, so there could be some issues somewhere in the network.

I will update as soon as I have any further information. Note that it is now 23:45 on Sunday 12 May, so I will likely only know later tomorrow morning.

Regards.
[Galaxy Note II General] joytest:
update 2 (2013-05-13, 13:00MYT) : Somehow the form is actually storing the responses but only populating the Response sheet a few hours late.

Please continue using the form while I reset some config later today.
[Galaxy Note II General] joytest:
2013-05-13 - 21:30 MYT (UTC +8)

PROBLEM SOLVED. CONTINUE YOUR SUBMISSIONS !!

And thank you everyone who voted to carry on !!

If anyone has information updates that can help please post here too.

BTW, today marks 1 month of this thread's existence.

637 submissions for April, and 133 submissions for May and growing.

Thank you, please continue participating !!!

Help EVERYONE in the N7100 family !!!
[Galaxy Note II General] joytest:
Results 2013-05-15 Top Score

Top scoring ROMs for 2013 05 15. Filtered for scores with 5 or more entries:

CountA shows the number of entries..

AVERAGE of Summary Score is the average ROM score from all the entries.
[Galaxy Note II General] joytest:
Results 2013-05-15 Top Score

Top scoring ROMs for 2013 05 15. Filtered for scores with 5 or more entries:

CountA shows the number of entries..

AVERAGE of Summary Score is the average ROM score from all the entries.

I would like to ask if anybody has any improvement suggestions or remarks on the Methodology described in post 3 ??

My next plan is to add Kernels to the ROM survey so that BOTH ROM and Kernels are integrated. This will show the true BEST ROM + KERNEL combination.

Please, if you have any constructive comments, kindly post.
[Galaxy Note II General] joytest:
2013-05-16 20:00 myt

Today's results. Filtered for >5 entries.

Column 1 is ROM, Column 2 is version, Column 3 is No. of Entries, Column 4 is the Score.
[Galaxy Note II General] joytest:
N7105 ROMs Included !!!

UPDATED: NOW INCLUDES N7105 ROMs !!!!!

I made a simple index of current active ROMs (ie with new versions in the last 60 days or less)

http://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=40240492&postcount=4

And I have also included N7105 ROMs as selectable from the Choose Your ROM list. They are the first selections.
[Galaxy Note II General] joytest:
Total Tracked ROMs and Updated Date

I've created a new table to show how many total ROMs are now tracked by the Survey, and the total number of versions to date. The versions do not include Nightlies which are not counted for the sake of simplicity.
[Galaxy Note II General] DuratecPaul:
Perseus rom for n7105 is missing
[Galaxy Note II General] joytest:
Hi thanks for the heads up, but I'm sorry I can't find a link to Perseus ROM. Do you mean Perseus Kernel?

Appreciate if you could post a link here.

Thanks again.
[Galaxy Note II General] overjoy71:
Just a suggestion, the amount of owner of N7105 is massively smaller than N7100 so it doesn't give a fair comparison for the N7105 roms. Would it be better to have a separate graph for N7105 instead of combining with N7100?
[Galaxy Note II General] joytest:
Hi overjoy,

Valid suggestion, I'm a bit busy these few days, let me figure out something. However, the more important chart is the Feature Scores chart (the colorful dots) since it shows the averaged scores.

Thanks for the suggestion.
[Galaxy Note II General] DuratecPaul:
yeah my bad perseus kernel
[Galaxy Note II General] joytest:
Team LORDROID Rom added.

Some revamp by next week. Thanks for all the submissions again. I've been busy, sorry.
[Galaxy Note II General] joytest:
Hello dear friends,

I've finally updated the Grand ROM Survey. Now in v3.

Now it provides:

ROM+Version (including selectable arbitrary Date for Nightlies)

Kernel + Version (including selectable arbitrary Date for Nightlies)

Stock Kernel as an option with default score

Screen on Time selector - as an indicative measure of battery life

This means that you can now see which ROM+Kernel (with specific versions !!) combination provides the best battery life !!!

I'm now working on the more complex charts to show all these values meaningfully, but the basic count (ie Most Popular/Top 10) charts are up now.
[Galaxy Note II General] joytest:
Update : the kernel survey form and master index includes N7105 Kernels as well:

Saber

SOAP

Terrabuzz

UnifiedMaxima

Please let me know if I have missed anyone.
[Galaxy Note II General] joytest:
ROM + Kernel + SOT graph

Hi all,

This is how the output of the new scores look like. Fully integrated showing ROM, Kernel, SOT.

This image is also clickable and will lead to the live feed.

Dips in the chart means that for that particular ROM or Kernel, it was scored "0" ie Not Known/Not Rated.
[Galaxy Note II General] indigotheory:
Thanks for this!
[Galaxy Note II General] joytest:
Hi everybody, the success of the data depends on your input. The poll for this thread shows many of you like what you see, so I do ask that we help each other and ourselves here by populating the survey so that the data will be meaningful.

This new version allows a fully integrated view of your Battery Life, Kernel and ROM, with an aggregate score for all these variables.

The more data there is, the more useful this becomes. The data has to come from you as users of this fantastic device.

The aggregate data lets us all see at a glance how user all over the world are experiencing their Note 2, and helps answer all those "which is the best ROM + kernel combo" questions everyone invariably asks at one point or another.

Many people have tried to consolidate such data but these all tend to stay in the local forums. I hope this thread can help all N7100 and N7105 users across the world.

I will also make the monthly results shortly available as a Google Fusion Table for those who wish to perform their own slicing and dicing.

Thank you very much.
[Android Q&A, Help & Troubleshooting] bhupednerSingh:
hi i am using xolo a800 mobile but when i type any message it includes a signature message ---FROM XOLO MOBILE...

Can anyone tell me how to get rid of this message.

i looked in settings there is no option like signature message.

my devise is xolo a800 ICS(4.0.4)

i have already rooted it for gaming
[Android Q&A, Help & Troubleshooting] mightymaurya:
Open SMS, Open Settings ---> Scroll down to Enable Signature and uncheck it the signature will remove :)
[Android Q&A, Help & Troubleshooting] andymap:
not able to find

I am not able to find the above settings...

View attachment 2026963

View attachment 2026987

View attachment 2026988
[7" Kindle Fire HD Q&A, Help & Troubleshooting] phunzoid:
i just got a Kindle 7 HD (7.3.0)...tried installing the ADB drivers several times, seemed to work OK, but i still have an error with the MTP driver....trying to use KFFirstAide64, but every time i try to run an option i get "The System Cannot find the Path Specified" ...the Kindle is also not visible at all using Windows Explorer

i eventually used "Root_with_Restore_by_Bin4ry_v17", and think i have Root (according to SuChecker: "Congratulations!! This Device has Root Access!), but still can't use ADB and KFFirstAide64 to do anything else...keep getting "The System Cannot find the Path Specified"

following the instructions here: http://xdaforums.com/showthread.php?t=2069117

what am i missing?

using Win7 x64
[7" Kindle Fire HD Q&A, Help & Troubleshooting] Guardian10:
You should have read more. :D

Go here and follow the instructions. http://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=38409721&postcount=1018
[7" Kindle Fire HD Q&A, Help & Troubleshooting] BELASCO:
Took me forever to get the ADB working. Course, I refused to read instructions, and was working under the premise that ADB stood for A Drink Before.
[7" Kindle Fire HD Q&A, Help & Troubleshooting] realpg:
A Drink Before.......
[7" Kindle Fire HD Q&A, Help & Troubleshooting] phunzoid:
thanks for pointing that out :silly:...i actually had gone through those steps, BUT, i just realized i had used the wrong folder name...i had "KFFirstAide64" instead of "KFFirstAide" :rolleyes:...KFFirstAide seems to be OK now :good:

anyone know why i have the yellow triangle next to MTP under "Other Devices" in Device Manager, and why the Kindle is not showing up in WIndows Explorer?...anyway to manually get the MTP driver installed properly?...at least the ADP drivers seem to be working
[7" Kindle Fire HD Q&A, Help & Troubleshooting] Metnies:
Do you use a Windows 7 N Version? Try this : link