yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Galaxy S III Accessories] scarrmrcc:
You are not reading it right.

they want to use the MHL adapter, too.

As far as i can tell, the MHL adapter needs to be in the phone, not a hub. it is all dictated (the output being OTG, or MHL) by the impedance of what is plugged in. It is an either or situation.

Perhaps with a firmware update they MIGHT be able to run both signals and split it.. but i doubt it.
[Galaxy S III Accessories] NuttyBunny:
I'm amazed that it works on CM10. TV out didn't work properly with CM10 on a Galaxy S2, and I read somewhere that the Cyanogenmod team wouldn't fix this... ever

So, yes, maybe that's the reason. Try using a Samsung based ROM, like AllianceROM
[Galaxy S III Accessories] scarrmrcc:
Maybe. I am using paranoidandroid. since we have different results, and are using different ROMS I am going to say it is a software thing.
[Galaxy S III Accessories] XeoNoX:
ill agree, thanks for the feedback
[Galaxy S III Accessories] dozzum:
Hi

Ive been following all these threads for a while and finally decided to order a Note 2 Smart Dock for my GT I9300, based on the fact that the german Samsung website says they are compatible and a german site I found to buy it from said the same. I have just received it today and cannot get it to work. It charges and that is all, sometimes when I plug it in I get a notification saying dock connected but mostly not,

Any ideas what could be wrong.

I am running 4.1.2 as provided by my provider "3" in a recent update and have also tried a full factory reset.
[Galaxy S III Accessories] alz_uk:
HELP!!! Can samsung multimedia dock be compatible with other android+mhl+otg phones?

Hi, Can someone please tell me if the samsung multimedia dock can be used with other android phones with MHL and OTG capability? For example the Zte V985 has a micro usb port and supports full MHL + OTG and is also android 4.0.4 so theoretically it should also work with the samsung multimedia dock?
[Galaxy S III Accessories] tehstfu:
Seems like it wouldn't work unless it has the 11-pin micro usb port and even then, probably not.
[Galaxy S III Accessories] djanmarsiglia:
But it could work on a SGS2, right? it uses different connector from SGS3. So, it could work on "my" SGS2 pluging in both cables?

I'm almost buying this cable........ :silly: :laugh:
[Galaxy S III Accessories] dragonfly14:
im curious to get this working, smartdock style but withoutpaying the smartdock price, however, if someone can get the smart dock for ~ 50$ then its not worth it.

One reason to want to get this working though would be to run ubuntu with keyboard mice and usb OTG onto a ~24 inch lcd screen but in Landscape mode, and, well, the dock is in portrait mode, so im note sure how the video output would be since the phone would be in portrait mode...

I havent received my 11 pin to 5 pin adapter yet, which is ridiculous because i ordered a sim slot 2 weeks after (i toasted mine 1 week into the ownership of my phone) and received the sim slot and havent gotten my adapter.....
[Galaxy S III Accessories] NuttyBunny:
It should output in landscape. If it works the same way as the standard mhl adapter, the phone still switches to landscape.

As a bonus, wheb the mhl adapter is plugged, you can see the launcher in landscape as well :)
[Galaxy S III Accessories] dozzum:
The smart dock displays in landscape when a mouse is plugged in.
[Galaxy S III Accessories] seriosbrad:
I just picked up the original Samsung 11-pin MHL adapter but it appears that in Cyanogenmod 10.1 it doesn't work. Are there any work arounds for this?
[Galaxy S III Accessories] NuttyBunny:
Use a Samsung based ROM like Alliance
[Galaxy S III Accessories] dragonfly14:
im using "stock modified" rom XD

and im assuming its going to work. :P havent received mine yet, but i totally want to get a crazy setup like this working for cheaper than the original dock. nobody's gotten the original dock yet / taken it appart yet right?
[Galaxy S III Accessories] tehstfu:
Maybe try a different kernel?
[Galaxy S III Accessories] arghness:
Cyanogenmod doesn't support MHL on the S3 and probably never will, as it says in the known issues list for the ROM.
[Galaxy S III Accessories] dragonfly14:
i got my 11 pin to 5 pin adapter, and i got MHL working, but i have a massive problem of Overscan and i dont have any options for overscan onmy projector. any ideas?
[Galaxy S III Accessories] stevey500:
Cyanogenmod 10.1 for the last few months of nightly releases works flawlessly on my SGH-i747 s3.

The old MHL adapter from my Galaxy Infuse (S1.5) didn't work at all with my s3, even when it was stock. The newer MHL adapters work perfect on stock and Cyanogen releases.
[Galaxy S III Accessories] NuttyBunny:
Perfect as in perfect launcher, perfect games, etc? As a perfect screen mirror?

Some things worked and some didn't before, for example the launcher just showed a static image
[Galaxy S III Accessories] arghness:
Ah yes, this sub forum is shared by all models of S3. I was referring to the i9300 (international Galaxy S3). It would be clearer to ask such questions on a device specific forum, even though this is an accessory. Perhaps in the ROM discussion thread.
[Galaxy S III Accessories] bollux78:
Let me see if I got it:

The international s3 (i9300) will probably never have hdmi support in cyanogenmod, but the other s3s have hdmi out support in CM?
[Galaxy S III Accessories] arghness:
I don't know about all the other S3s, I'd go and look through the cyanogenmod threads of the S3s that you're interested in.

i9300 known issues list is here: http://teamhacksung.org/wiki/index.php/CyanogenMod10.1:GT-I9300:Nightly:Known_issues

The devices that are not Exynos based might have different issues.
[Galaxy S III Accessories] its.mahmud:
hi guys. i was able to make usb otg and mhl work together just like smart dock.

full description is here

http://xdaforums.com/showthread.php?t=2142357
[Galaxy S III Accessories] redstorml:
Hi,

i bought the red MHL cable..+usb otg cable.

After micro usb i cut the cable and connected OTG cable(only red,black,green and white).And things gone strange - if HDMI is not connected i have OTG, but if i connect the HDMI OTG+usb power it is not working.Then i connected only green and white wires to HDMI cable(in the beginning) and red and black directly to the HDMI board(they are connected separately there.5 wires - green.white,yellow,black,red+2 black and red).Again noOTG.. :(

Can somebody tell me how and where exactly to connect the OTG cable to work when HDMI is connected???

I'm talkin about this cable : http://www.modatel.eu/components/co...ge/product/MHL____________m_511e12591e8a9.jpg

http://www.onlineshopworld.com/usb-connector/mhl-hdtv-kabel-micro-hdmi-k-m-hdmi.html

Thanks a lot!
[Galaxy S III Accessories] sbeckett:
I have a AT&T Samsung Note with no screen.

Trying to get MHL & OTG working.

Purchased

http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B005LGUDKK/

http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B005LGUCYM/

but they don't work at the same time.

What do I need to buy to get AT&T Samsung Note (1) working with HDMI and USB keyboard/mouse.

I can't seem to find anyone that has found the solution.

will the new dock,

http://www.amazon.com/Samsung-Galaxy-Smart-Dock-Multimedia/dp/B009QW3TBK

work on the Note 1?

thanks
[Galaxy S III Accessories] NuttyBunny:
Guys, I just bought this:

Charging station with OTG/HDMI from DealExtreme.

It's just a matter of time until it gets here.

If anyone else wants to try it, go ahead and report :)
[Galaxy S III Accessories] iSiDoRoS:
Please let us know how it goes when you receive the dock. I'm interested to see if HDMI, charging and otg works simultaneously.
[Galaxy S III Accessories] dragonfly14:
im also interested :)
[Galaxy S III Accessories] NuttyBunny:
It got delayed, they were out of stock. But believe me, as soon as I get it you'll know :)
[Galaxy S III Accessories] mertzi:
great, can you try it with an SIII too?
[Galaxy S III Accessories] NuttyBunny:
Right now I'm trying to sell my s3 but if it hasn't been sold by the time I get it I will try on it as well.
[Galaxy S III Accessories] RobotEvolution:
Has anyone tried this all-in-one dock?

ebay (dot) com/itm/290956147204 (new user so I can't post links yet)

Does everything work? Can I connect and use simultaneously and HDMI and USB and Micro SD?
[Galaxy S III Accessories] Alwaysup:
The USB and HDMI can you not use simultaneously with this dock.

See: http://club.dx.com/forums/forums.dx/threadid.1322255
[Galaxy S III Accessories] brb8two:
Ordered, Recieved, Tested, Reviewed: USB OTG & MHL Adaptor! And it's a cheap product from DX!

MHL to HDMI OTG Card Reader for Samsung
[Galaxy S III Accessories] yugoport:
Finally a product that works.. Thanks for the feedback, what version of Android you are using?

HDMI and USB working simultaneously?

Enviado do meu GT-I9300 utilizando Tapatalk 4
[Galaxy S III Accessories] brb8two:
Samsung S3 i9305 (Grey import to AU), Confirmed working on Australian S3 i9300 also.

I'm running Android 4.1.2 ,Baseband i9305XXBMD2 (latest Stock firmware with OTA updates and root via Framaroot)

To get the USB OTG working with HDMI you need to plug in the connections in sequence. i.e.

1. 5V Power to adapter

2. USB OTG device (i.e. keyboard / mouse, etc)

3. Connect to phone

4. Check OTG Device works

5. Connect HDMI

Done!
[Galaxy S III Accessories] yorkey:
I assume thats diectly plugging the "MHL to HDMI OTG Card Reader for Samsung" into the phone rather than using some sort of micro usb extension cable?

Very tempting though!
[Galaxy S III Accessories] brb8two:
Yes, you only need what is in the package "MHL to HDMI OTG Card Reader for Samsung" to connect a USB OTG Device and HDMI with your phone.

To get the USB OTG working with HDMI you need to plug in the connections in sequence. i.e.

1. 5V Power to adapter (Micro USB cable (One comes with the package) )

2. USB OTG device (Standard USB Port i.e. keyboard / mouse, USB Hard drive, USB Serial port, USB Hub, etc)

3. Connect "MHL to HDMI OTG Card Reader for Samsung" to phone

4. Check OTG Device works (Can be skipped I guess since it usually works for me using this order)

5. Connect HDMI to the "MHL to HDMI OTG Card Reader for Samsung" while already connected to the phone

Done!

(Sequence of 1 & 2 not important as long as you do step 5 after step 3)

Note: if you remove the USB OTG device while the HDMI cable is still in, you'll need to repeat above to get it going again. If it is in a USB Hub, it's okay but NTFS mounts might need to be re-done when you try to plug an play.

Basically All USB devices are droped and re-linked when any one USB device is plugged in or Removed. (It's a PITA but for the price I can live with it.)
[Galaxy S III Accessories] dickeplatte:
Hey,

I have the adapter, too.

Do you know if there is a procedure to use HDMI/Mhl + USB OTG + Card Reader at the same time?

Best

J
[Galaxy S III Accessories] DigitalMD:
Probably not. Just get a network storage adapter and forget USB
[Galaxy S III Accessories] dickeplatte:
Why should i forget USB? HDMI/MHL and USB do work at the same time with the adapter. And if there is a usb switch chip inside it, it would be possible to use both chipreader and usb together.
[Galaxy S III Accessories] catnapped:
Will that one from DX work on the Sprint model (SPH-L710) as well?
[Galaxy S III Accessories] NuttyBunny:
Well people, excellent news!!

This one works flawlessly, it even goes detected as "Dock" by my Galaxy S4, so I assume it does the same functions as the original Samsung one.

Right now I'm typing this port via Tapatalk with the phone connected to the dock, a 4 ports USB hub connected to it, and a wired mouse and a wireless keyboard connected to the hub (the wireless keyboard has a dongle connected to the hub). It's connected to my TV at 720p (dunno if it can be done at 1080i or 1080p.

I even connected a FAT32 USB stick to the hub and gets detected with no issues whatsoever bu the phone.

I guess it's time for me to get one of those 720p cheap monitors to use it with my phone :D

I might attach some pictures later. But people, this one seems to be one of the ones to get.

Works with both of my phones:

Galaxy S3 i9300 with Android 4.2.2 (the Samsung leaked version)

Galaxy S4 i337-M with Android 4.2.2 (Official OTA update)

I was having audio issues, but a reboot fixed it.

It really does work as intended. :)
[Galaxy S III Accessories] athlonxp2300:
Please do try your s3 and check out the android version for both. I thought all s4's came with 4.2.2 or better. Who is your carrier? Thx
[Galaxy S III Accessories] NuttyBunny:
Yeah, sorry, 4.2.2. Fixed.

The S3 works as well. Post edited
[Galaxy S III Accessories] athlonxp2300:
Delete
[Galaxy S III Accessories] brb8two:
Can you use it landscape? (i.e. laying the dock on it's side)

Are you sure it's 720p output?

My Galaxy S3 i9305 with Android 4.1.2 and the adapter (posted earlier) "MHL to HDMI OTG Card Reader for Samsung" connected to my phone displays in 1080p, the UI matches my phone at 720p (dual view look) (monitor reports ~1080p :1920x1079@33.7khz ) but if I run hardware accelerated video in landscape mode, the HDMI output is clearly 1080p and the User Interface overlay is only visible on my phone's display.
[Galaxy S III Accessories] NuttyBunny:
Yep, I've tried that and it doesn't switch to landscape on its own. It only does that if I use the MHL adapter. When you use the cable it only says "HDMI cable connected", but when docked it says "dock connected".

My tv says so, that's the only reference I have. It does the same with two MHL adapters I have.

What app you use to test HW accelerated video?
[Galaxy S III Accessories] brb8two:
I know the following works; (Overlay on Phone not HDMI with hardware accelerate Video)

You Tube - (Can even reduce the screen on phone while HDMI shows full screen)

BSPlayer

DicePlayer

"Video Player" - Samsung firmware standard player?

Don't Work; (Overlay on Both Phone and HDMI)

VLC
[Galaxy S III Accessories] NuttyBunny:
Well, this seems to work differently than the MHL adapter used to work on my S3.

When you put the phone on the dock the screen turns off and all the display and audio goes to the TV (funny thing, touchscreen still works). I tried Youtube, The Samsung Video player, MX Player, VPlayer and not one of them changes the resolution, the TV still reports this at 720p. Well, my 2 MHL adapters do the same, perhaps my TV is the one with the problem that it don't support whatever resolution the phone may try to send to it.

I'm running out of ideas here. I don't have another monitor to test :)
[Galaxy S III Accessories] NuttyBunny:
hmmm... a funny thing over here.

With a Samsung TV I get 1080p/30, and with my Hitachi TV I get 720p only.

When connected to the Samsung one, I can turn the phone sideways and the screen rotates correctly, whereas on the Hitachi it won't rotate.

Go figure.

Ok, so, wrapping things up, it does support 1080p on certain TV's. If yours is fairly new, it should work :D
[Galaxy S III Accessories] jonamafun:
Thanks for the info re the dealextreme dock. Ordered one.

Very keen to see if it will work with USB DACs to provide USB audio output. If that is so, that would be awesome if it could charge and do USB audio at the same time!
[Galaxy S III Accessories] DeBoX:
Hi

i know this might have been asked and answered, but it's a rather long thread.

Is it possible to have both usb otg and hdmi output at the same time? And if so which adapter is best?

Thanks in advance !
[Galaxy S III Accessories] NuttyBunny:
Yes, it's a long thread but the questions have already been answered.
[Galaxy S III Accessories] DeBoX:
Seriously mate?

You couldn't have written a yes or no to my question? ( unless I'm misunderstanding your answer, in that case , sry)
[Galaxy S III Accessories] NuttyBunny:
The answer is yes, and I confirmed it on the previous page :D
[Galaxy S III Accessories] DeBoX:
Hehe that's what happens when I read forums at 3 am in the morning. .. Thanks mate, and l apologise for the frustration in my previous post.
[Galaxy S III Accessories] slydweis:
Does the dock from DX suffer from the flickering of MHL? On my phone no matter what I'm doing, the tv will eventually end up flickering and cutting in and out unless I put the phone into airplane mode.
[Galaxy S III Accessories] NuttyBunny:
Not on mine.

It happened only once when I plugged the phone, perhaps a sync issue. It got fixed when I unplugged ir and plugged it again.

It didn't happened since.
[Galaxy S III Accessories] drewmacphee:
i9250 Galaxy Nexus

Anyone using the DX on an i9250 Galaxy Nexus?

Just replaced it with a Nexus 5 and wanna use the i9250 as an emulator.

Need to get MHL and USB for an x360 controller
[Galaxy S III Accessories] Walkonatyclb:
Can I get HDMI,card reader, USB all in one in a otg set up on a galaxy nexus Verizon?
[Galaxy S III Accessories] GadgetAvi:
WOW, guys, I just found this thread and I'm so glad I found it.

I was trying for a long time now to hook my devices with HDMI (MHL) Adapter and also with OTG + different type of usb Keybords and mice, but no luck!

so when I had my SGS2 I gave up, and my MHL Adapter is useless since then!

and since I upgraded to my New Galaxy S4 (6 months ago) I was thinking to order the new MHL adapter for the S3+S4, and last week I ordered one, but now I discovered this Cool docking station for the S4 with OTG, USB hub and HDMI adapter and I'm so glad and happy!

Just to be sure, before I confirm my ebay purchase - does this thing actually outputs 1080P resolution UI and multimedia (video + gaming)?

I want to use this as another Computer in my room with my TV and sometimes I'm gonna take control my other PC in my office VIA RDP so the resolution must be Natove (1080P) for all my computers thru this Docking station to my 1080TV at my room.

is it possible?

10X :)
[Galaxy S III Accessories] NuttyBunny:
From what I tested, it does, but only on certain TV sets. The only way to know for sure is to test it by yourself.
[Galaxy S III Accessories] GadgetAvi:
Ok, 10X mate,

I'm gonna order from here:

http://www.ebay.com/itm/DOCK-STATIO...706?pt=LH_DefaultDomain_0&hash=item20db5c391a

the price is fine I think,

How much did you pay for yours?
[Galaxy S III Accessories] NuttyBunny:
Its 18.99 USD here, but with free, trackable shipping

http://dx.com/p/5v-1000mah-mhl-otg-...-238004?Utm_rid=30081924&Utm_source=affiliate

Pretty good price if you ask me
[Galaxy S III Accessories] GadgetAvi:
Ok, thanks, good alternative, I don't really mind to spend a few more bucks.

anyway, 10X dude.:cool:
[Galaxy S III Accessories] GadgetAvi:
OK guys, DON'T buy this particular Item (In my link above)!!!

I almost ordered it and then I noticed that the seller mentioned this:

"Notice: The MHL, OTG and Charge function only can be used one at the same time. cannot use it together."

so now I understand why the price is so cheap compared to the Original Smart dock by Samsung!

And as for you mate (NuttyBunny) - your Dock has only one USB port, right?

but everything works simultaneously? even if you connect USB Hub while the HDMI and other functions are connected too?

I'm confused, I think I'm gonna order the original one from samsung, Don't need any Surprises from cheap alternatives. :(
[Galaxy S III Accessories] NuttyBunny:
Mine has two USB ports and they both work with HDMI enabled. You can buy the original one you want, but I tell you this one works.

Your phone is even capable of surround audio and this dock forwards it correctly.

:D
[Galaxy S III Accessories] GadgetAvi:
Ok 10X, so what is the the manufacturer of your device?

cause right now I'm checking this one (which also have 2 USB ports):

http://www.ebay.com/itm/Aerb-3in1-S...S_Cell_Phone_PDA_Chargers&hash=item19e2338351

Vs. this one (which seems like the original Samsung one, and the price is decent too):

http://www.ebay.com/itm/Multimedia-...S_Cell_Phone_PDA_Chargers&hash=item27db12e041

what you say? ;)
[Galaxy S III Accessories] NuttyBunny:
Well, I can't say that those will work, but the first one looks preety much the same as mine (mine has matte finish and that looks glossy but that's the only difference I see.

The reasons I have to recommend the dealextreme one are:

1. It's exactly the model I got and I know it works because I use it.

2. They have free trackable shipping.

3. They have never failed me.
[Galaxy S III Accessories] GadgetAvi:
Ok dude, 10x,

Looks like it's time to sign up with DX too.

although, the Original Samsung dock has it's own benefits - such as 3 USB ports (without nasty wiring and USB hub) and you get another Samsung charger.

well, I'll decide what to do until I go sleep, LOL.

again, thanks a lot!
[Galaxy S III Accessories] athlonxp2300:
On my T999, I installed s3rx V3 (android 4.3) with md5 bootloader, mjc modem, and mj2 att insecure kernel .

To my surprise the smart dock mode works again with my home made cable! It turns off the phone screen but displays to hdmi and has keyboard and mouse working too.
[Galaxy S III Accessories] NuttyBunny:
It turns the screen off because you plugged in the mouse, it does that.

Enviado desde mi Nexus 7 usando Tapatalk 4
[Galaxy S III Accessories] athlonxp2300:
Interesting. I'm just glad it works. It worked with 4.1.1 but it was broken with 4.1.2 . Now it works again with 4.3.
[Galaxy S III Accessories] RealCrogge:
I planned to build an adapter myself using the 5->11pin + resistor trick as described in this thread, but the problem is that even the normal MHL HDMI function isn't working. Here a picture of my adapter:

How can I find out whats causing the problem? Is there any way how I can measure if the issue is caused by the S2->S3 adapter or the MHL one? Only battery loading works ... the HDMI screen is going black for a few seconds but no picture appears and it says "no signal" (Tested 2 totally different screens).

Tested with S3 on 4.1.2 and 4.3 (stock).
[Galaxy S III Accessories] athlonxp2300:
Are you supplying power to the adapter from a usb charger? Try changing the order they are plugged in. Hdmi then power then hml into phone (with 5to11 pin adapter already on 5 pin side)

Fyi 4.1.2 didn't work for dock mode on s3. Only 4.1.1 and 4.3
[Galaxy S III Accessories] RealCrogge:
Tried that, still just a black screen for a while but no picture.

Well it probably was 4.1.1 then, can't remember.
[Galaxy S III Accessories] DigitalMD:
Its so much easier just to use the MHL and leave the very limited OTG alone. Use a networked storage drive for media and bluetooth for keyboard etc. I know it doesn't help if you don;t have that, but its just a hassle and potential damage to your tablet to fool with the OTG.
[Galaxy S III Accessories] RealCrogge:
OTG works perfectly fine for me with a 1 Euro adapter, I can connect all kind of USB devices to it. Doesn't matter if a mouse, keyboard, gamepad, USB HDD with exotic filesystems, DVB-T stick (RTL 2832) to use it even as analog SDR to watch a wide spectrum of frequencies with shiny graphics, listen to DAB+ stations and so on.

I personally also like to use SSH consoles but that is rather difficult without an external screen and a proper keyboard.

I do have a NAS, selfmade with 4 WD Red HDDs in Raid 10. I don't like most BT keyboards though and the ones which I do like are quite overpriced ... and I prefer cables in general, hence I use also a good old LAN cable at home even if I got Wifi.
[Galaxy S III Accessories] NuttyBunny:
So, you tried the MHL adapter alone and it didn't work? Can you try with another MHL adapter? It sounds to me that your phone has issues. It has always worked for me on my S3 (and I use a 5 to 11 pin adapter as well).

Enviado desde mi SGH-I337M mediante Tapatalk
[Galaxy S III Accessories] RealCrogge:
I don't have any other, I could ask a friend though to borrow me his S4 to see if that works. Or is this way not compatible with the S4?
[Galaxy S III Accessories] NuttyBunny:
I have seen it work with an S3, S4 and a Note 3. (Both MHL and OTG, alone and together)

Enviado desde mi SGH-I337M mediante Tapatalk
[Galaxy S III Accessories] athlonxp2300:
I've had mhl to hdmi with 5-11 pin adapter that worked on verizon, att and tmobile S3's but would not work on S4.
[Galaxy S III Accessories] kiklopcuk:
i tried with cm11 and :((