yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[AT&T, Rogers HTC One X, Telstra One XL] jack x1:
iphone hater android lover

Well one week now with one x att. At firstit was amazing screen and camera. Near to digital cam ...but yesterday the lag begin camera widget not working video recording close alone wile recording.... im thinking on flash software(do not know how) xda are experts i want to root too and erase the att crap. I want to update software but att has its own updater. I have another carrier now and is supposed to be as unlocked phone now with a simply code I inserted unlocked the phone honestly im confused now. I never receive personal messages from xda users maybe is my poor english ..one last thing I register on xda sa a xperia x1 user now im onex 1x now i can use the same nick i guess
[AT&T, Rogers HTC One X, Telstra One XL] mrnimra:
Just got my HOX yesterday. My Captivate was giving out and I was debating waiting for the next Iphone (nah :P). Screen is stunning, love the design - perhaps a touch big for my tastes but hopefully I'll get used to it. I was make a point of waiting for the S3 announcement, but as much as like Samsung's designs lately, the s3 really looks kind of blah. I watched a video comparing the s2 to the s3 and I couldn't help but notice how much better the s2 looked. Finally, after my captivate I am done with pentile. One criticism I have is that for a phone of this size the power button really should be on the side. Samsung does this correctly. CM9 has an option to wake using volume buttons but for now it's buggy at best and doesn't work most of the time.

I have to add, I found sense horrific. Unlocked, rooted and installed CM9 within an hour of using sense and I'm so much happier. I know it's a matter of taste but I find that sense and touchwiz cheapen the feel of the os considerably.
[AT&T, Rogers HTC One X, Telstra One XL] vioalas:
Had my HOX since May 4th, it's still the honeymoon phase for me! Minus the occasionally signal issue.
[AT&T, Rogers HTC One X, Telstra One XL] PeterGuru:
Some of you may not like this, but ...

You know, I may be just one of a very, very few people in the world who owns, or has owned, the HTC ONE X International, HTC ONE X Rogers, and now the SGSIII. In about 10 days I will also have the SGSIII Rogers, so I will have direct knowledge about all four phones.

My opinion?

I have been an HTC user for years, as you can see from my member name; however, I am almost sad to admit, my latest phone, the SGSIII International, is the best phone I've ever had, and I only expect the Rogers unit to be even better.

I still have my Rogers HTC ONE X (selling it now on eBay). It had too many annoying little glitches, which have plagued virtually every HTC phone I've ever owned.

I was a bit apprehensive at first concerning the SGSIII, but now I know I made the right decision.

IT SIMPLY WORKS!

Yes, both the HTC ONE X and the SGSIII are incredible phones. Both are fast. Both are effectively the same in most aspects. And for those of you who think the build quality of the SGSIII is poor or worse than the ONE X, you'd be sadly mistaken.

The build quality of the SGSIII, like the ONE X, is fantastic. In fact, I actually prefer the overall feel of the SGSIII. It feels a bit "stickier" in my hands, which I prefer. The ONE X was just TOO SMOOTH.

Will I ever go back to HTC? Of course. I buy a new phone about 5-6 times a year, so I don't mind trying new things. When HTC comes out with their next flagship device, you can be sure I'll buy it. For now, though, it's the SGSIII for me ... with no reservations.

Yes, I still read the HTC threads. I've spent a lot of time helping others with HTC devices, and I will continue to do so. For those of you who know me on xda, you'll know I do my utmost to help others ... especially with my detailed GUIDE on how to do virtually everything to your device (http://xdaforums.com/showthread.php?t=1678308).

For now? It's the SGSIII all the way. However, I only wish the best for everyone who owns an HTC ONE X. It's also a fantastic device.

Peter
[AT&T, Rogers HTC One X, Telstra One XL] freakboy13:
Well thanks for all you have contributed. I personally reall have appreciated all the time you have taken to compile your tutorial and all your help.

Question: has Samsung improved the poor quality of there screens yet?

I was just wondering how the screen looks. I know it's never going to be anywhere near the one x screen, but I was hoping it would at least be a step up from the note, which isn't too bad and probably the best of the pentile screens.

sent from my hoXl

can't play my geetahr with out a geetahr string!
[AT&T, Rogers HTC One X, Telstra One XL] pdubcramp:
Well June 22nd is the 45th day from my purchase from Best Buy (silver rewards). So I think the decision will be made for me since I don't have much faith in finding a SGSIII on the release date. Does AT&T even have an official release date or is that just the day that pre-orders are shipping (June 21st)?

EDIT: Best Buy website now says 60 days for an exchange...
[AT&T, Rogers HTC One X, Telstra One XL] robstunner:
I feel the same way in regards to the glitches, they are minor but frequent accept for the fact that I've always been biased to Samsung. Ordered a sgs3 full price and will see which one I decide to keep
[AT&T, Rogers HTC One X, Telstra One XL] PeterGuru:
Wow, seems like a flame ...

I still own my Rogers ONE X, and now have the SGSIII International. I can tell you this, the screen on BOTH is fantastic. Both have their benefits and detriments. Your statement that "it's never going to be anywhere near the one x screen" is simply ridiculous.

Peter
[AT&T, Rogers HTC One X, Telstra One XL] mbonus:
http://www.anandtech.com/show/6022/samsung-galaxy-s-iii-review-att-and-tmobile-usa-variants

Anandtech has published their initial review of the SGIII sans lte testing. US HOX outperforms almost every category including battery life.
[AT&T, Rogers HTC One X, Telstra One XL] gtung99:
WOW, SG3 took a beating when compared to the One X. One X nearly won every single benchmark and battery life test while having the better design and better camera.
[AT&T, Rogers HTC One X, Telstra One XL] mbonus:
Yeah the only thing SG3 won was sd slot and removable battery.

maybe my captivate can hold on a little longer. :rolleyes:
[AT&T, Rogers HTC One X, Telstra One XL] gunnyman:
When we get source and someone adds otg support to the Kernel I'll be very happy. The only thing I hate about this phone is the lack of storage space.
[AT&T, Rogers HTC One X, Telstra One XL] pdubcramp:
Differences are so marginal with regards to performance and battery. The other things are that the SGSIII has better notifications, it's easier to wake up (awkward power button placement on the One X), will probably have more accessories and will definitely have more development (at least right off the bat). Is this enough to give up on this awesome awesome display and design? Might not be...

How is visibility in sunlight compared to the One X? I was shocked how clear the screen is in bright light when I first got it.

With that said, I am still in my exchange period and I think after 45 days with the One X, it'll be fun to be able to give the SGSIII a shot too.
[AT&T, Rogers HTC One X, Telstra One XL] chivamex10:
I went to the Samsung s3launch yesterday. Was not impressed at all. They designed the phone in a way that will only benefit you if there's other s3's in your group of friends/family. Sharing content is really easy thru s beam. Up to a gb of a file can be transferred in a range up to 300 feet. You can set up photo share which will automatically tag your friends in any photos you take and will send it to their s3 automatically.

They're really pushing NFC on this phone. An accessory for this phone will be techtiles. They're little tiles that you can program with your s3. So for example you can place one on the dashboard of your car and program it to automatically turn on your Bluetooth and put your phone in car mode. Or say your kid has an s3, you can program it to send you a text message the second he/she gets home from school. Stuff like that.

There's a feature on the phone that will track your eyes so it will recognize any time you look away from the screen and will shut the screen off. So if you're reading an article or checking email or watching a video your screen won't time out and turn off until you look away from the screen.

I really can't think of anything else on the s3 that the HOX can't do. It has face unlock just like HOX. The camera is rubbish compared to the one. It has burst shot (takes 20 photos in a few seconds) and it picks the best shot out of the bunch. Sounds familiar?

Pop-up play is cool if you multitask and wanna watch videos while doing simening else like texting etc but I wasn't able to see what kind of videos are actually compatible with that feature. I don't think it supports YouTube..

Overall I wasnt at all impressed with the phone. It has a sleek smooth finish to it but still feels plasticy just like every other Samsung phone. Didn't get to see he white marble finish, they didn't have one out for show. The blue version though is fugly. Has a sparkle/ glitter finish that makes the phone look cheap.

The only reason that I would recommend this phone is if you're looking for a pair. Samsung is trying to sell this phone in pairs. Its easier to share and move content over between two s3's. Thats pretty much it. I love my one x. I'm a fan of HTC sense. Makes the phone feel less stock android like touch wiz..

But yeah if you guys have any questions let me know. I didn't touch every single detail so lemme know if there something else you had questions about
[AT&T, Rogers HTC One X, Telstra One XL] tarick09:
I love everything about my phone except storage space. Installed just Max Payne and Nova 3, man its down to 4gb left now. Maybe if i can save some bucks, i will be interested in SGS3 a couple months later.
[AT&T, Rogers HTC One X, Telstra One XL] PeterGuru:
Try to be unbiased ...

Try to express what you mean more accurately. What you've written above basically says that, unless your friends also have S3s, then this phone will not be of value, which is far from the truth.

This feature is interesting, but of little value to me. Before I forget, I need to repeat that I also own the Rogers ONE X, so I'm very familiar with both devices. I even had the International ONE X, but I sold that one a couple of weeks ago.

Again, you are showing bias. Virtually everyone agrees that the camera on the ONE X is better, but not by much. The camera on the SIII is also very good, but even I will admit the images/features on the ONE X camera are somewhat better. To say the SIII camera is "rubish," is simply a sensational exaggeration.

Also, your last sentence, "It has burst shot (takes 20 photos in a few seconds) and it picks the best shot out of the bunch. Sounds familiar?", is also biased. I could easy make the exact same statement if this post was in the ONE X forum. I could say, "The ONE X has burst shot ... and it picks the best shot out of the bunch. Sounds familiar?" Basically, all this says is that both cameras offer a similar feature-set.

Yes, it supports YouTube. YouTube works perfectly on my unit.

Your opinion, and I can't fault you for having one. I, however, prefer the feel of the SIII. It has a slight sticky feel, which makes it much easier to hold without slipping. The ONE X was great-looking, but a bit too smooth for me. I'd always be too afraid to drop it. Also, the build quality on BOTH units is impressive.

Remember: The ONE X is made of a polycarbonate shell. What is polycarbonate? It's plastic! So, it's kind of misleading to say that the SIII is plasticy (your word ... sic), when the ONE X is also, technically, plasticy (sic).

Again, only YOUR opinion. I've owned many HTC phones in my life, as you can see from my signature below. They are great phones, but every single one of them had some sort of glitch, that ended up being very annoying. With the ONE X, there was the Wifi issue ... to name only one. My SIII simply works. Not a single glitch so far, but one could come up.

Whereas, you do not own both devices. You only had a chance to play with an SIII for a short while. Try actually using both devices in real-world conditions. Only then would I be willing to accept your opinions at face value.

Peter
[AT&T, Rogers HTC One X, Telstra One XL] rohan32:
Once we get USB OTG Host then space will not be a problem at all
[AT&T, Rogers HTC One X, Telstra One XL] pdubcramp:
Hey PeterHTC, how is the screen on the SIII in direct sunlight? Does it hold up at all to the One X?
[AT&T, Rogers HTC One X, Telstra One XL] gunnyman:
I wrote my once a week email to HTC regarding source release and posted on their facebook page too.

Getting tired of waiting.
[AT&T, Rogers HTC One X, Telstra One XL] PeterGuru:
Sadly, it's not as good ...

Although the title of this post says, "Sadly, it's not as good," there really isn't that much of a difference.

True, the ONE X screen is better. In fact, it may very well have the best screen of all mobile devices currently available.

However, all that said, both screens are fantastic. As is the case when comparing LCD to AMOLED, each have advantages and disadvantages.

LCD screens produce more accurate colour, and white is WHITE! AMOLED, though, has the best BLACK around. Black is exactly that ... BLACK! Therefore, it's a trade-off.

One thing that you can do with the SIII is change the overall colour temperature. When you first get it, it's in Standard mode, where the colours are slightly over-saturated. It also has Natural mode, where it looks more like the ONE X screen, Movie mode, where the colours are even more muted than the Natural mode, and Dynamic mode, where the colours are even more saturated than Standard mode.

Peter

Addendum: I almost forgot to answer your question. In absolute direct sunlight, both devices are not that good. It can be quite difficult to see the screen. On cloudy days, both screens are very good, and viewing angles are almost 180-degrees for both, although, I'll give the ONE X a higher mark in viewing-angle colour rendering.
[AT&T, Rogers HTC One X, Telstra One XL] Valitri:
One word would keep me away from the GSIII, "Pentile"
[AT&T, Rogers HTC One X, Telstra One XL] davezaff:
Another word would keep me away from the gsIII......Samsung;)

Sent from my HTC One X
[AT&T, Rogers HTC One X, Telstra One XL] Grona:
I've had my HOX for little over a month now and love it, I came from an iPhone 4.

The screen is amazing, camera is awesome.
[AT&T, Rogers HTC One X, Telstra One XL] futuregerald:
The fact that my skyrocket has no official ICS update and it came out the same time as the Vivd and the HTC Vivid got an official ICS update months ago speaks a lot for me. On the other hand Samsung releases source much faster. Those are tangential issues but still relevant in the decision on which to go with for us crack flashers. I prefer the design of the HTC One X and also prefer Sense 4 to Touchwhiz. The One x is really nice. Biggest drawback for me is lack of a MicroSD card, it's more of an issue even as time passes but so far dropboxing all my pics and videos and clearing them out of the phone helps to alleviate that for the most part.
[AT&T, Rogers HTC One X, Telstra One XL] ryanbmw51:
What is this exactly? I've seen it referenced a little bit?
[AT&T, Rogers HTC One X, Telstra One XL] gunnyman:
The ability to plug in a flash drive via a special cable. Otg stands for on the go.
[AT&T, Rogers HTC One X, Telstra One XL] loneBoat:
disregard
[AT&T, Rogers HTC One X, Telstra One XL] gunnyman:
USB host support +OTG cable +USB flash drive= no more space problems.
[AT&T, Rogers HTC One X, Telstra One XL] rohan32:
For those of you who want to see what OTG is like, go to 3:00 in this video: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aaPnW72w528

Its literally like you plug in a flash drive to your PC, its the same thing here. And it can also be used for keyboards, mice, and pretty much anything else you can connect via USB.
[AT&T, Rogers HTC One X, Telstra One XL] Silellak:
I can't speak for the S3, but the One XL has been fantastic for me even in direct sunlight, as long as the brightness is cranked up. I never thought I'd be able to see a cell phone screen in the middle of the Tucson summer, but the One XL proved me wrong.
[AT&T, Rogers HTC One X, Telstra One XL] vdub804:
http://m.engadget.com/2012/06/20/samsung-galaxy-s-iii-melts/
[AT&T, Rogers HTC One X, Telstra One XL] rohan32:
lol that's just funny xD

good old samsung build quality at its finest xD
[AT&T, Rogers HTC One X, Telstra One XL] c5satellite2:
Samsung build quality has never been as good as HTC, updates are few and far between, and 2gb of ram just uses more battery.

One X is a highly polished device that is by far the best android device out of the box with carrier Rom. Even better after root with cleanrom. 10 out of 10.

Yes it would be the best without question if it had a sd card slot and removable/upgradeable battery, but the battery is about the equivalent of a 2500mah on a previous gen phone so the only real issue is no sd card slot. Once kernel source is released we will have USB host and that will mitigate the no sd card mistake ATT made.

BTW Camera on this phone is way beyond anything that any other manufacturer has going. It is absolutely absurd how good it is. Pretty much as good as any pocket camera, better in several ways. Low light photos are mindblowing even without flash. In fact the flash is very rarely even needed. Burst mode will make you smile every time because it is just SICK that a phone can feel like a Canon Rebel!

Don't bother with the Sammy, get a new 1.85 One X, root, unlock, flash Cleanrom and PROFIT!

BEST PHONE OUT THERE UNTIL S5 CPU FROM QUALCOMM IS AVAILABLE(S4 WITH NEW 300 SERIES ANDRENO GRAPHICS) ON VERIZONS ONE X 3RD QUARTER.(MOST LIKELY, DON'T HOLD ME TO IT, QUALCOMM IS TRYING HARD TO MAKE S5 AVAILABLE THIS YEAR.)

By next year, we will have S5(maybe quad core), with this camera, 2gb ram, and even more. Can't wait, but until then the S4 One X is here now and it absolutely rocks.
[AT&T, Rogers HTC One X, Telstra One XL] rquinn19:
You just sound silly. You mention extra ram just uses more battery...really? I guess HTC should've opted for 512 MB. I'll go take that extra stick of ram out of my notebook so my battery lasts longer. Removable battery is about more for a lot of people than just making it through the day. If you were going camping or for a long bike ride you'd like to have a spare battery. OTG support helps but is not an answer for no removable storage. Any phone without removable storage should ship with at least 32 GB. And who cares about Samsung releasing updates? They're actually pretty good about updates. There will be plenty of unofficial updates (ATT is the one that slows things down if anything).

Don't get me wrong I like my One X, but your valid points don't make sense to most people. You mention OTG once we get source. What's your excuse for HTC not releasing that in a timely manner? It's been available for the intl and ONE S for a while now.
[AT&T, Rogers HTC One X, Telstra One XL] c5satellite2:
Ok guy, I guess you have me confused with ATT. Sorry, but I didn't get to decide what was ordered by ATT. I would have included sd card, removable battery, and USB host. My points are valid. Extra ram uses more power. If you don't actually need it(and we don't right now) you are wasting battery for a bigger number. I wasn't defending ATT, just stating the truth and trying to help others. If you have the phone and aren't happy, return it, get the Sammy and don't bash me because you don't read very well.

Many sources for USB power bricks for camping or long bike rides. Could go for 2 weeks with a big one.
[AT&T, Rogers HTC One X, Telstra One XL] JCon0320:
AT&T one X vs SGS3 debate

First off, I personally own a at&t one x so my opinion might sound biased to someone who does not own the one X. Here are some of my personal reasons for choosing the one X over the SGS3.

-Design (looks, feel)

What else is there to say about the sexiness of this phone? U got the white version, and it's just amazingly pretty to look at. Also, the unibody design of the phone, and the finish on the back makes this phone feel like a really well built device. I don't know how the SGS3 compares in this department, but owning samsung phones all of my life tells me that it won't come close to the one X in this regard.

-Display

I personally believe that the one X's screen is the best looking display I have ever seen on any smartphone. The colors pop, and color rendering is superb even on low brightness levels. Viewing angle on the screen is good, and i have no problems using the phone under bright surroundings. The scren of the phone is the one that you will be looking at the most, so it ought to be one of the best features of the phone you are using.

Those are the best things I liked about the one X. There are other good ones like the camera, but i won't go into detail on those to keep this short. Now Im going to briefly outline the flaws that I don't like about the phone, along with solutions that are now available to help, or fix said issues.

-Battery life

The SGS3 does have a bigger battery capacity wise, but the one X's battery is not that far behind. If you are not going to root and modify your phone, then there's not much options other than getting lucky and getting a unit with superb battery life. However, after modding the one X with custom roms the battery life of my phone was significantly better under the same usage. How much better you ask? about 2-3 hours more screen on time than stock.

-SD card

Personally, I am not someone who is hungry on storage. I am satisfied with the storage onboard (2 gb internal, 10gb sdcard) + cloud storage.

Sorry if this was long, but i want to help those who are on the fence. I still have a chance to return my One X and get the SGS3, but I am not going to. This phone just gets better everyday with new roms, and mods coming in. Cheers!
[AT&T, Rogers HTC One X, Telstra One XL] rquinn19:
I respectfully disagree. S3 has:

same storage (but you can add to it)

better battery (and you can add to it)

more ram (even if battery suffers because if battery life is stilll longer on S3)

and how do you figure we couldn't use more ram? if we had more ram we wouldn't have the multitasking issues we have.

I'm happy with my One X for now like I said...just saying it's fby far a winner in this matchup. If you want a great camera, display and great looking phone the One X is it. If you're like me and your the side of your computer case is open more than closed and you want the more powerful phone with a better dev community you'd go with the S3 given the choice.

edit: not confusing you with ATT either. just going by what's available to us.
[AT&T, Rogers HTC One X, Telstra One XL] louis.b:
Guys if you want the Samsung plasticky s3 then go w it. In the end it's a very good phone for ppl who like to throw the specs **** at others just to prove their virtual superiority over others. For the money you will get a fantastic plasticky and cheap feeling build quality that leaves finger print all over it as decoration. You will have access to the innovative blue tinted super saturated head-spinning screen. You will have a phone w a beautiful design that has been copied from Iphone5's design concept. Moreover, you will have access to a very large supporting community that include biggots and homophobes and sexists who deploy name-calling and belittling to anyone who disagrees w them. And if you have no life and no job, you will enjoy this phone even more because the tremendous memory will allow you to store all you porn collection to watch anywhere anytime. The replaceable battery will be of great assistance too!What else do you want? This phone is the way to go.
[AT&T, Rogers HTC One X, Telstra One XL] c5satellite2:
So you just agreed with all my points, and arrived at the same conclusion after disagreeing. And if you were like me and have been building custom computers/servers for 20 years you would know more ram doesn't matter after you have enough. Bigger numbers are just that sometimes. 1gb ram is enough for now. Thanks for the criticism though.....