yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[HTC One X] gibbs1984:
Don't know if it's an app problem or a mod problem but in a certain app (Friendcaster) the autocorrect function doesn't seem to work when creating a new status, works fine when replying to a status... anyone else use this app and have this problem?
[HTC One X] SeptimiuB:
i think this is the whole purpose of this mod :)
[HTC One X] Ali_ultra99:
:confused::confused:
[HTC One X] Sebianoti:
3 dot menu built into ICS apps is what he means... they should still have them, like Google Play,

---------- Post added at 11:42 PM ---------- Previous post was at 11:41 PM ----------

Has this been abandoned? seriously... c'mon can we get some help around here? for crying out loud! http://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=25684423&postcount=402
[HTC One X] Mischaseb:
I like the sound of this too, except short press recent apps as stock, and long press home as menu :)
[HTC One X] blubbers:
I don't have the time right now for looking into the missing menu in some isc apps. And it honestly does not bother me at all since there is a designated key for it.

As for the odexed stuff, i don't support odexed roms, there are too many different constelations for that. In my opinion, get a deodexed stock rom...
[HTC One X] Mischaseb:
Agreed. My 3dot menu isnt missing in ICS apps anyway :S
[HTC One X] aliguu:
wait i m confused..

sorry for my noobness but is this correct:

1. 3-dot menu mod takes away the menu bar at the bottom of the screen for non-ICS apps only.

2. ICS specific apps will still have 3 dot menu intact with this mod.

3. is there any mod to take away all 3 dot menu bar at the bottom regardless?
[HTC One X] blubbers:
the bottom 3dot bar is removed from any and all apps!

there are a few ISC apps that have a 3dot menu somewhere in the app, like google play, and this menu is removed as well. but it is no big deal in my opinion as you can use the menu key!
[HTC One X] Mischaseb:
the 3 dots in the top right of google play is still there for me :S
[HTC One X] ttm94:
Same here for all my ics apps that I'm aware of.
[HTC One X] Sebianoti:
i also had it... when it worked.
[HTC One X] coupduberger:
Hi, let me start by thanking you for your brilliant work - this mod was the main reason I rooted my One X, and I don't regret it.

I understand if you say you don't have time to change this, and I believe yours is a good enough solution, but allow me to disagree with the reasoning. For me this mod is a workaround to use apps that don't comply with Google's ICS guidelines. And I chose the configuration where you have to long-press Home to get the Menu action, thus keeping the Recent Apps key the way HTC intended it - so that if all apps were ICS compliant (a perfect world, I know), this mod wouldn't be needed anymore.

By removing the 3dot menu from the apps that already follow the guidelines, aren't you changing the ICS experience? Moreover, in a way that is not intuitive, because you're adding a "secret key" to those few good apps (in my case at least, as I use the long-press). Well, this is my opinion, anyway.

As for those that say they still have the menu button (in Google Play Store, say), are you using version 1.2.1 or the previous one? Because I want to keep that button, I switched back to the first aroma installer, but I know it's only temporary... until there's a new base to flash.
[HTC One X] blubbers:
Diffrent users, diffrent opinions

If the ics menu was removed from all apps, it would be easier to pinpoint the cause. I don't know the android framework at all, i haven't even written an app for android. I wanted to remove the 3dot bar because it is pathetic, and i don't use the task switcher at all, so i use a designated menu key for the menu.

I've already added the long-pressing home for menu mod for ppl, i don't use it.

It's not like i am the only person who could look into the, for some users, issue ;)
[HTC One X] coupduberger:
Well, I had to give it a shot ;)

Thanks for listening to a different opinion.
[HTC One X] aliguu:
really?

Ok then i must have done something wrong.

I updated my ARHD to 5.1 the other day and then flushed the 5.x versions of the 3 dot menu mod, but most of the bottom bar are still there for most apps..

ill just flush the latest one over again.

to do this do i need to remove anything first? or simply just run the file over again?

thanks!

UPDATE:

nvm i jump the gun anywan and just flushed it over.

Its all working fine now!!!! SWEEEET! :)

thanks man for such evil mod :)
[HTC One X] solidsebazz:
Could someone port this to odexded roms? im using stock and i'd hate to flash a deodexed rom just for this awesome mod. :D
[HTC One X] :
...you could get this when you flash ym rom (-:

i added longpress actions to back (also close apps) and longpress actions to recent apps.
[HTC One X] Planet X:
You should try this one:

If you are on 1.29.401.7 this ones work fine.

http://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=25533464&postcount=373

Tested by myself.
[HTC One X] k-a-a:
Hi everybody!

I have a One X with 1.28.707 and couldn't find 3dot mod version, which would work with it.

Aroma_3dot-remover-v1.2.1.zip from the 1st page just don't work.

And ODEXED_1.28_menubarmod_lp_home_menu.zip got my phone to a boot fail. Needed to re-flash stock firmware.

How can i get rid of annoying 3dots?
[HTC One X] zhaiweihua:
i alse think you should keep showing the ics app's menu

i alse think you should keep showing the ics app's menu ,like google play etc...
[HTC One X] pohsze:
I second this! Coming from the same version completely stock and unable to find a working 3dot remover zip to flash too.

Any help would be GREAT.

thanks in advance!
[HTC One X] Mischaseb:
Why would you have an unlocked/rooted phone, and not have a custom rom?
[HTC One X] pohsze:
because ...

... i want to get instant OTA on mine (hence odexed and stock recovery until I need to flash zips)

... i like to know what is done to my phone

... customizing to my own way...etc

its all good.

cant find custom rom as close to stock for my version though.
[HTC One X] ckpv5:
Because not everyone like a ready made custom rom. But with unlocked/rooted phone everyone can customize the stock ROM on their own term and use all apps that require root access such as mybackup root, titanium backup to name a few.
[HTC One X] Mischaseb:
fair enough
[HTC One X] ORStoner:
This is brilliant! My phone wouldn't boot with the old one but this is perfect! I just installed it using CWM and life is good! THANK YOU
[HTC One X] blubbers:
It is no big deal to me, it's not like i remove them on purpose!

Beside, i don't even know if it is not "working as intended", i think the framework disables the software menu if there is a hardware key available!
[HTC One X] Entreri:
It's really strange that this happend only with the new 1.29 base from HTC. Don't get why they would change anything there, as the One X usually has no dedicated button.

Maybe they're working on getting rid of the ugly bottom menu bar as well?

Well, nothing is perfect, I guess. Thanks anyway, still a lot better than that ugly bar wasting screen space :).
[HTC One X] designgears:
@blubbers

Haha, I see your secret long press volume down mod!!!
[HTC One X] zhaiweihua:
Thank you.i have mod some codes and resolve this problem.i
[HTC One X] fekle:
Nice, could you share the modded version? Because I really love the 3-button-menu in the Action Bar from ICS, just using the home-long-press for old apps.
[HTC One X] zhaiweihua:
please send me your email.
[HTC One X] equlizer:
So will there be a version for odexed?
[HTC One X] dmmh:
wellll.this is anjoying, just installed and it's still there, even beneath my launcher home screen all the time...driving me nuts!
[HTC One X] android_888:
Look here
[HTC One X] WinNerdy:
Will this work on a Stock Rooted version with 1.29?

If not which one should i use?
[HTC One X] jonas2295:
It will work if you have a recovery to flash :)
[HTC One X] WinNerdy:
It is not working I installed it choosed the option 1.29 map to multitasking key.

Key is mapped now and working, but 3 dots are still there.

and press and hold for recent apps is also not working..
[HTC One X] leventccc:
Waiting for 1.29.401.11 :)
[HTC One X] salomaoa:
Is there any chance you can make this compatible with the advanced power menu MOD?

That would be awesome
[HTC One X] sean.trinidade:
The APM already incorporates this.

Also, didn't you just post this same question in that thread?
[HTC One X] endursa:
the android.policy.odex file is the same as in 401.7

BUT don't flash my cwm files because the signature doesn't match, so you will get stuck at a boot loop, i will release a new odex version for 1.29.401.11 tomorow, as it's now 2 am and i gotta sleep :D
[HTC One X] endursa:
1.29.401.11 LongPressHome -> menu + LongPressHome -> recent are available

http://xdaforums.com/showthread.php?p=26162691#post26162691
[HTC One X] psyhotm:
please create ODEXED_1.29.401.11_menubarmod_recent_menu.zip
[HTC One X] endursa:
please look in the linked thread :-)
[HTC One X] android_888:
Can we flash it on deodexed 1.29.401.11 ROM?
[HTC One X] qvert:
no its not booting

Gesendet von meinem HTC One X mit Tapatalk 2
[HTC One X] blubbers:
I've flashed it on arhd 6.0 and its working fine
[HTC One X] jotha:
Sure it does :D.

I just compiled a new version of my apm with your menu-removal mod with framework files 1.29.401.11, though I don't think it would have been necessary ;). Small changes in framework-res.apk though and I wanted to do it for the paranoid :p.

Who wants it can grab it on my APM-Thread
[HTC One X] qvert:
which one is working on arhd? mine is not booting with the odexed one

Gesendet von meinem HTC One X mit Tapatalk 2
[HTC One X] jotha:
Lord, how do you expect an odexed mod running on a custom rom????

Take the aroma version from OP and it will work.
[HTC One X] santroph:
Do you know if these and ultra smooth rosie (sense launcher) version get along fine?

They were not going along in the 401.7 version :)

BTW, Love the mod ;)
[HTC One X] mox123:
the deodex available for 401.11?
[HTC One X] jeyml:
Not working on 1.29.401.11.

EDIT: Sorry,my bad,installed the 1.29.401.7 update,just got now the 1.29.401.11.

Thanks.
[HTC One X] pohsze:
1.28 odex

perhaps a mod for 1.28.707.10 asia WWE odexed rom? appreciate much

*still 1.28 as we've been left out*
[HTC One X] Daekin:
Hi...any news on version with working ICS menu? I mean that the menu button in app toolbar in ICS apps like Play Store is there and not hidden due to availability of HW menu button.

I just want to hide the bottom bar for legacy apps, not for ICS apps.

???
[HTC One X] ywl12345:
thank you very much!
[HTC One X] Johnny0906:
I'M SORRY

Im sorry but I went thru 30 pages and I still no f-ing idea what everybody is talking about, go ahead and call me retarded I just wanna know WHAT 3 BUTTONS???????????

I don't have any ICS buttons as far as I know...

PICTURES PLEASE!!!
[HTC One X] Daekin:
Do you have Facebook app?

So the ugly black 1cm tall toolbar with 3 small squares at bottom it that! This mode hides it but has a undesirable side effect of hiding also menu button for example in Play store upper right or gmail lower left etc.
[HTC One X] Johnny0906:
The back button, home button, and multitask button?

Show me a picture...
[HTC One X] Daekin:
No. Above them . actually it is only one button - menu button. I will send screenshot later..

Btw one stupid question: you do not have HTC one X do you? :) this issue is only on phones without hardware menu button.

Apart from Samsung galaxy nexus...it has onscreen buttons.
[HTC One X] fekle:
hey blubbers, is there any way of getting back the new ICS-3-Dot-Menu in the Action bar, like we usually see it in new true ICS-apps? Because with the newest version of your mod it's gone :(

That would be so awesome! :)

cheers
[HTC One X] Johnny0906:
Yes of course, I do have a One X.

Am still not sure what on screen buttons.

Will appreciate it greatly when you send screenshot.

Cheers
[HTC One X] blubbers:
There are 2 screenshots in the first post....
[HTC One X] Johnny0906:
Check that, SAW THEM FINALLY!

God..... :)
[HTC One X] damanrico:
This would be awesome. I don't mind the little 3-dot-menu when it's used right, just the big black one at the bottom of apps is annoying.
[HTC One X] StrongOneX:
Spoiler content hidden.

I totally agree on this one
[HTC One X] digitalnrg:
does this mod only work for international One X? Or I can use this same mod for AT&T version?

Thanks
[HTC One X] fekle:
Maybe our prayers get answered now :D
[HTC One X] fekle:
Hey blubbers, I just made a picture showing which button we mean...

The first version of your 1.29.xxx.xxx fix did NOT remove the original buttons...

However, the newer one do :(

Could reupload the older versions, or add an AROMA-option for keeping the original buttons? That would be so, so great! :-)

cheers
[HTC One X] djsimon:
This is the reason i have rooted my one x

cheers buddy
[HTC One X] Zesotar:
It's possible to change the teawk in order to made the long-press "recent apps" button show the "recent apps"?

I think is the real deal.
[HTC One X] Daekin:
can you also add screen of Facebook app (before and after)? so that there is no confusion about what button we WANT and what button we DO NOT want to get removed... :)
[HTC One X] fekle:
Well, the problem is that Facebook doesn't use the new menu-button, this is why it is one of the "old" Apps which show the annoying bar at the bottom...

so Most of the users just use the mod to remove the bar in apps like this one, BUT they still use the new button in ICS-apps, like the first 2 screenshots show us.

However, WITH the mod applied, this button gets removed, too..

Does anyone get what I mean? blubbers?

Thanks
[HTC One X] blubbers:
like i've written about 1000 times before, again:

http://developer.android.com/design/patterns/actionbar.html

the framework does what it is supposed to do; i'm not going to change that.
[HTC One X] Daekin:
I exactly know what you mean....that is why I want you to show both apps...old apps where we want bottom menu removed (like the title says disable annoying menu), new apps where we want native ICS menu shown (so that this mod does not have any side effect). then all others will know too (at least I hope).
[HTC One X] fekle:
aah Action overflow, thats the name for that :D

However, your older versions of your mod hat the action overflow enabled, could you just reuopload this version? :)
[HTC One X] damanrico:
I would also love to see an extra version of this mod with action overflow enabled if it's not too much trouble to create.

When pressing the menu button now with action overflow disabled, the menu opens at the bottom of the screen, while with action overflow enabled (or without using this mod at all) the menu would pop-out of the 'little 3-dot menu'. So if we take Google Play for example, it would open on the top right out of the little 3-dot menu.

I assume enabling action overflow would also correct this issue (the menu not opening from the correct place in native ICS apps), thus opening the menu from the right place (in native ICS apps with the little 3-dot menu only of course).
[HTC One X] Daekin:
well, but since we do not have menu button, it would be good to have that Action overflow....and since the removing menu is HACK by telling we have menu button, you should also finish hack to tell ICS apps that we REALLY do NOT have menu button :)

otherwise it is only half solution :rolleyes:
[HTC One X] blubbers:
i know this is not the perfect solution - and i know it is possible to "restore" the menu button in the action bar. maybe i'll look into it later this week. i don't know. but please stop asking/pm'ing me about it :rolleyes:
[HTC One X] ckpv5:
I'm still using this old version because of that action overflow, maybe you like to try it. It's working good for me so not sure what problem/bug it may have.
[HTC One X] fekle:
ckpv5 THANK YOU!!!!! This is the version I lost, and which I am looking for :)

Thanks so much!
[HTC One X] Daekin:
OK, no more begging from me..I will wait patiently (or at least I will try :p)

thanks...but from which ROM base it is?

because I am now on 1.29.401.11
[HTC One X] ckpv5:
I believe it is from 1.29.401.7 but it is working great for 1.29.401.11
[HTC One X] nin2thevoid:
This tool works perfectly, very well executed because of the GUI installer with key mapping options. Happy camper here.
[HTC One X] Daekin:
thanks...I will look at the code later to see if it is really 100% safe.
[HTC One X] jameslfc5:
Is there any way that this can be enabled but also leave the menu button there for apps that aren't lazy and have actually updated for 4.0 eg dropbox, Gmail and YouTube

This is a good alternative and a lot better than the stupid 3 dot menu for the lazy app developers but I'm kinda used to using the menu button in apps that have implemented it :)

Thanks! :beer:

Edit - Opps just seen that Daekin has been asking for this too so sorry about saying it again

Also I am currently using the long press home for menu, it would be nice to have the option to long press multitask button as one of the options :D

Thanks again
[HTC One X] fekle:
Yes, another one with the same opinion :)

Have a look at the last 2 pages for example :D

EDIT: can't be asked enough :P
[HTC One X] lordlegion1985:
I would very much like this too..

Im 99% sure this is possible ive just come from stock rom using the following to rid of my 3 dots

http://xdaforums.com/showthread.php?t=1656728

and im sure when i was still running obexed stock rom I both had rid of the menu at the bottom but still had the 3 dots option in ICS ready apps this was infact one of the first things i noticed when moving to the android revolution HD rom and applying the de-obexed 3 dot
[HTC One X] ttm94:
Yes I would be happy to see the 4.0 menu in ics apps aswell
[HTC One X] Daekin:
Pitty that 1.1.0 version was without keyboard arrows...
[HTC One X] ckpv5:
On which app that it has keyboard with no arrows ?

Here's mine in sms app, gmail & browser, still have arrows
[HTC One X] benko286:
Is there a version, for deodexed ROM, that will remove 3-dot menu and which assigns long press home for menu, so that task button keeps its function ?
[HTC One X] Daekin:
hmmmm seems like every version is different in the package then :D

I am on ARHD 6.0.0 and I used 1.29 base + homePL = Menu

and I have no arrows in ES File Explorer and other legacy apps

(should I try full wipe? :confused:)

---------- Post added at 07:32 PM ---------- Previous post was at 07:29 PM ----------

yes, download and choose during installation...
[HTC One X] benko286:
Haha, thanks, didn't know for that :D
[HTC One X] furblue:
its a good one. tks bro
[HTC One X] Daekin:
can you please tell me what base is that? and also what version (homeLP = ??)

and perhaps post that version for me?

OK...now I looked at your screenshots...and you only showed apps with ICS menu....

but legacy apps like Facebook do not have arrows in keyboard...or do you have that? show me screenshot of Facebook with keyboard opened...
[HTC One X] hamdir:
why can't we have 1.29.401.11 support just to b safe
[HTC One X] jonas2295:
It works for me perfectly in combination with APM
[HTC One X] ckpv5:
No, there is no arrow for FB. Do we have keyboard with arrow for FB in stock ROM ?

I mean without this mod.

EDIT: Just check, without this mod, there is no arrow for keyboard in FB too.
[HTC One X] Daekin:
I know that on stock it is...but with mod 1.2.1 there are arrows. Arrows are displayed for all apps that do not have bottom menu. So we need to hack this so that:

A. Legacy apps think that we have menu button and they do not show bottom menubar but they show keyboard with arrows.

B. ICS apps think we do not have menu button and they show action overflow menu.

That is the final behavior that is acceptable by me. (menu button should be mapped on long press Home)
[HTC One X] hamdir:
so many thanks for this mod, I love the hold home for menu option, its the way HTC should have gone

the phone got so much better apps like opera.mini finally became useable, the text selection scope finally works and keyboard arrows came back

stupid stupid HTC
[HTC One X] SilverHedgehog:
Is it possible to make a mod that would enable it? Pretty much every single ROM disables it and maps the app switcher button to menu, and I want to keep the standard button layout...
[HTC One X] sean.trinidade:
Music player bug

Blubber, am not sure if anyone else has raised this, but I think I've found a bug with your 3-button mod.

When the screen if off, if you hold down the volume down key, it will actually start playing music. And when playing, volume up will skip to the next track.

It's really annoying as it keeps playing by itself when in my pocket. Is there anyway you can fix this?

P.S. This only happens with the stock music player - if you remove the HtcMusic.apk, then it doesn't happen.
[HTC One X] Toni10:
Perfect!

Hello blubbers,

just wanted tell you, that I love this Mod!

I use it on ARHD ​​6.0.0 and everything works fine!

Perfect in combination with Aroma Installer, and the options you provided.

By the way,I can not understand the complaining about the menu button in the upper right of the Apps.

In my opinion everything is as it supposed to be!

Because your mod give us a Hardware menu button.

Hope you`ll continue with this, on future HTC updates.

Thank you very much!

Greeting Toni

---------- Post added at 09:52 AM ---------- Previous post was at 09:26 AM ----------

Just for the record

I've tested it and it happens to me as well and this is the only mod I have installed.

But not a big deal for me
[HTC One X] davorb:
Yeah, I really wish they added this.
[HTC One X] @home:
I have installed this on a stock rooted HOX but it doesn't seem to be working.

Is it meant to work on a stock rooted phone?

Ta
[HTC One X] Daekin:
no this is only for deodexed ROMs....you must use this version
[HTC One X] mattmanwrx:
Hi Everyone,

Is it possible for someone to let me know the hack for to show the arrows constantly?

I love having the arrows always there, and can't really live without them!

I am snooping through android.policy.jar (as I believe the hack is in there), but am hopeless with smali and have no idea what I am doing! However, I can follow tutorials ;)

Many thanks, Matt
[HTC One X] Daekin:
In version 1.2.1 provided in OP there are always arrows. And yes, the whole hacks are in android.policy.jar in PhoneWindowManager class.
[HTC One X] mattmanwrx:
Thanks for the reply... I wanted to do the mod myself, as there are other mods included in the android.policy.jar in the LeeDrOiD rom..

Wouldnt know where to start within the PhoneWindowManager files, so was looking for someone to point in the right direction ;)

Thanks, Matt
[HTC One X] Daekin:
The code is scattered around...

Look for hasNavigationBar or something similar (I can't remember right now as I do not have sources in front of me).

Or examine original mod code.

And take in mind that after removing menu and forcing keyboard arrows we lost action overflow menu button in ICS apps too :( so when you will be nodding this and find the way how to add it back everyone would be glad if you shared that after. :)
[HTC One X] mattmanwrx:
Thanks, I will take a look when i got a chance... but as i say, know no smali, so doubt i would find what youre looking for... :)
[HTC One X] alesandro:
Don't know what i did wrong, but for me the menu key worked, the recent apps upon long home press didn't work, and the 3 dots are still there .. any suggestions?

I'm on rooted stock 1.29 ... however those for the stock ones didn't work for me, actually this is the first one that makes it pass the logo screen :s
[HTC One X] Daekin:
You need odexed version for stock rom (search for it)
[HTC One X] sean.trinidade:
I hate being "that guy" (you know, the one who keeps reposting the same thing) but can any of you devs perhaps take a look at the mod and determine if it's possible to fix this?
[HTC One X] HerbatnikDoChrupania:
Can I use it on MIUI?
[HTC One X] hosmsdos:
Guys I'm on 1.29.415.11 and I'm trying to use your mod but nothing happens. I uderstand that the rom should be deodxed But I can't find any dedoxed version of my rom. Any help is appretiated. Thank you
[HTC One X] sean.trinidade:
if your ROM is not deodexed, then have you tried this?