[Galaxy S I9000 Q&A, Help & Troubleshooting] iamtheng:
Hi :D

I'm opening this post to know your opinions on ICS based rom for Galaxy S, and for give a little list of comparison.

Please share your opinion!

Bugs of all ICS roms:

-Android OS battery usage display higher than normal

ICSSGS

It's an AOSP (As Google-Like as Possible) rom, developed by onecosmic and the ICSSGS team, the last version is R4.2 the knowed bug/issues are:

-Lockscreen occasionally does not react to touch (Probabily kernel related)

-Formatting external sd formats internal

-Facebook sync pictures are low res(but at least it works)probably not fixable from our end

teamhacksung's CM9

It's an rom based on CM9 developed by teamhacksung team the last version is BUILD v16

the knowed bug/issues are:

-Camera does not support scene modes

-FM Radio does not work.

-Phone unnecessarily gets data connection on device encryption password enter screen.

-Cannot format external SD *

-Sometime wrong SMS selected for forwarding

-Format internal instead of external SD when requested to format ext. SD

-Transfer speed slows down when screen off

-Screenshot shutter sound

-TV Out using HW-decoding (probably won't be fixed)

-Sim Toolkit (probably won't be fixed)

-No camera focus mode setting

-Compass doesn't work in Google Maps v6

-Unable to dial "0001" in some regions

-Slow USB transfer speed for some people

-Camera still photos problem after recording video

-Top of widget selection selector says "Select screen lock"

CodeNameAndroid

(Note: Codename Android is a fully open source rom that focuses on speed, usability, and getting every feature that we can get CRAMMED in there)

It's an AOSP+ (As Google-Like as Possible with enhancements and customization options) rom, ported by DaxIΠFIΠITY from the original CNA project sources, the last version is 1.3.3 the knowed bug/issues are:

When booted up, Airplane Mode is on

- Cant change 2G/3G Connection (Not Even using *#*#4636#*#*)

- Signals are not shown properly

- External SD is not mounted when USB is connected (Multi Mount SD Card can be a workaround)

- WiFi tether doesn't work (Open Garden can be a workaround)

AOKP

It's an AOSP+ (As Google-Like as Possible with enhancements and customization options) rom, ported by 'BHuvan goyal' from the original Android open kang project sources, the last version is BUILD 23 the knowed bug/issues are:

- WiFi tether doesn't work (Open Garden can be a workaround)

- Reboot option in power menù reboot in recovery

Slim ICS (a mod can add the option to the poll?)

It's an AOSP (As Google-Like as Possible) rom, ported by krarvind from his original work for Nexus S, it's sligtly lighted. The last version is 2.5 and the known bug/issues are:

WiFi tether may not work (Open Garden can be a workaround)

MyICS (a mod can add the option to the poll?)

It's an AOSP (As Google-Like as Possible) rom, developed by MyUI Team, it's sligtly tweaked.

ASNET (a mod can add the option to the poll?)

It's an MIUI based rom, ported by asrock from the original work of asnet team, it's very unstable and avviable only in english or spanish.

/under construction/

todo: kernel comparison, better bug list, workaround list