yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] termen:
Nope, my colleague using Pixel 2 and he can recording calls with Call Recorder without any issues.
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] ocujos:
According to Samsung...

"Based on Google’s security policy and local law, Samsung has blocked call recording through 3rd party
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] termen:
To be honest, i know. I was just surprised after that test :)
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] mrvain84:
Thx, so this is interesting. I'm also on Note 8 Exynos (not rooted). Are you after two Oreo updates or just the first one ? The only thing I have different is recording to MP3, I need to check WAV. In my case only outgoing calls are recorder properly.

UPDATE: OK, it seems Skvalex did not update Google Play version as it is still 3.0 beta 04.1. I will download 3.0 beta 04.2 and will check.

UPDATE2: Thx Aussie1, after update to 3.0 beta 04.2 both incoming and outgoing calls are recorder properly, also as MP3 ;)
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] Aussie 1:
Only have done 1 Oreo update. I must also mention that I cleared all data and did a clean install of 04.2 with 0 second incoming and outgoing call delay.

Hope it helps..
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] ocujos:
So, Skvalex has developed a workaround for Samsung's blocking of call recording! (on Note 8). How Nice!

I wonder if it also works on non-rooted S9?
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] mrvain84:
I don't think Note8 SW has the "blocking" feature of call recording implemented as S9/S9+. Something was wrong with the previous Call Recorder builds, but it was more related to upgrade to Oreo than blocking. It is what I think, but maybe Skvalex can comment further. For sure we need to be careful with next updates coming to Note8, S8/S8+ etc. as Samsung said they plan to introduce the same blocking features as in S9/S9+.
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] rootlinux:
Qualcomm

---------- Post added at 11:13 PM ---------- Previous post was at 11:12 PM ----------

My S9 Plus can record calls.
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] DaOldMan:
Who cares about S9 qualcom? Everywhere people know that there are no problems with it. We should discuss only Exynos S9. Only those have changed recording policy and recording don't work - even with root. I suspect changing omc can uncover native samsung recording. Third party recording will be a much bigger problem unless Samsung come to their senses. Maybe the class actions will persuade them.
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] skvalex:
I've got root access on my S9+ (Exynos) yesterday. Today I found a way to record both sides using root. S9 supports stereo recoding, so voices are in separate channels. But I need several days to prepare apk.
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] VICosPhi:
This is excellent news!! How can I donate a beer? [emoji4]
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] tiho5:
Great news

Thank you

---------- Post added at 08:32 AM ---------- Previous post was at 08:18 AM ----------

Do we still need a SELinux permissive kernel for call recorder on Samsung phones or that has changed?
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] RedP90D:
my note 8 (snapdragon) stopped recording the other side and I'm using 2.4 that i purchased. how can i upgrade to 3.0 with my current license?

thanks
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] Ja_som:
Check first post.
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] skvalex:
My phone is rooted with SuperSU and kernel is in enforcing mode.
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] RedP90D:
I have tried this in the past, but this time when i reset my account password, i found the reset link in junk mail and took care of it.

thanks.
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] Red_Baran:
I can't seem to get any of my messages to play or record new messages. I had to restore a backup of the app and data after I had to reset my phone. Any ideas? It's not even prompting me for root access.

**edit**

Sorted out my issue. Removed all parts of the app, moved my saved records, installed CallRecorder_v.3.0_beta03.10.apk, set it up, pointed it to my new recordings locating and bam it worked.

Thanks for the great app!
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] xalaros10:
On Samsung S8 Exynos with stock Oreo, sometimes record both sides and sometimes only me especially incoming calls. Wish to find the problem.

I'm using v3.0 beta04.2
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] ocujos:
I've had the same issue a few times!

Now testing the latest build to see if it makes a difference.

I have S8+ Exynos SM-G955F (the most common variant)
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] badai:
I'm using RENOVATE_ICE_G95X-10.1 can record clearly with handsfree and bluetooth too.
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] kestrielias1:
Really Thank you

With update 02 i can now hear both sides on my note 8 .. I REALLY THANK YOU SKVALEX .. recording is a tool for my job.. i do not need an organizer or even a secretary

I can now come back to my work with no problems

BAD NEWS sometimes no voice from incoming calls to the other side
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] ocujos:
There are many legitimate uses for call recording. Samsung is for some reason trying to block it with the latest updates, citing Google "security initiative". I reckon they're trying to become more like Apple where call recording is not possible.
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] luckylittle:
Latest versions not working

Recording stopped working (An error has occurred, this call cannot be recorded) with these new versions:

CallRecorderROOT_v.1.0_beta03.5.apk

CallRecorder_v.3.0_beta04.2.apk

License is verified

It was working fine with the previous 3.0 beta from Google Play. I tried clean reinstall and multiple reboots. Magisk superuser is showing Call Recorder ROOT = granted. Please advise.

My setup:

Root Access:

Access Granted

SU:

su found

UID/GID:

uid=0(root)

gid=0(root)

groups=0(root)

context=u:r:su:s0

Utils:

toybox

toolbox

Path:

/sbin:/system/sbin:/system/bin:/system/xbin:/vendor/bin:/vendor/xbin

Path:

/sbin/

Version:

16.0:MAGISKSU (topjohnwu)

Permissions:

rwxrwxrwx

Owner:

root:root

SELinux:

Permissive

BOARD

angler

BOOTLOADER

angler-03.78

BRAND

google

CPU_ABI

arm64-v8a

DEVICE

angler

DISPLAY

OPM1.171019.011

HARDWARE

angler

HOST

wprb11.hot.corp.google.com

ID

OPM1.171019.011

MANUFACTURER

Huawei

MODEL

Nexus 6P

PRODUCT

angler

TAGS

release-keys

TYPE

user

USER

android-build

CODENAME

REL

INCREMENTAL

4448085

RELEASE

8.1.0

SDK_INT

27

RADIO

angler-03.85
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] dethknite:
I, too, have experienced this with the April security update for Oreo 8.1. I have a Pixel 2, rooted with Magisk, running the latest FlashKernel, and everything worked great up until then. Now it fails to start recording, and clicking on the manual record errors out as well. I am using Root method and the Pixel 2 defaults.. I have not found any ways to work around at the moment.
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] skvalex:
I've uploaded new apks for the main app and root module to the OP:

Warning! Version 3.0 beta04.3 works only with ROOT module version 2.0, so make sure to update both apps, otherwise recording will fail

In the future this version of ROOT-module will able to update itself
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] crisees:
Any news about Note 8 Exynos wo root ?
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] xalaros10:
Clean install v.3.0_beta04.3 on Samsung S8 Exynos stock Oreo Android (no root) and automatically choose as device ""@2131689798". Previous versions chose "Samsung S8 Exynos". Is it OK or have to change it?

Although new version installed (left device as "@2131689798"), problem remains, sometimes record both sides and sometimes only me especially incoming calls.
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] NYSprintGuy:
Same here !
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] badai:
Note 8 Exynos does not work? But it listed in config.
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] irvinehooi:
Hi, is there any plan to add voice record for the messenger app such as Telegram, Skype, Line, Hangout....etc...etc ?

Thanks in advance.
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] OrBy:
Moto Z Play non-rooted (8953) Using CR 3.0 b4.1 from play store (paid) I was on 7.1.1 and it worked without any issues - I got an official update to 8.0.0 last night and now nothing I do seems to be able to get it to work. (just records nothing or weak static) Tried updating to CR 3.0 b4.3 and issue persists. Any suggestions? (done the Wiki stuff already)

*Clarification - my voice is fine - its the remote side I get the issue.
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] Ja_som:
https://callrecorder.skvalex.com/faq?hl=en#question21
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] ivangs1:
It looks like there is solution for non-root call recording on Galaxy S9+ Exynos:

https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.boldbeast.recorder
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] Riekr:
1.2.9 final is on play store and working good on my gnex 4.1.2 using alsa and cyanogenmod.

Inviato dal mio Galaxy Nexus con Tapatalk 2
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] Aids10:
Anyone know if this works on a Samsung Prevail? :highfive:
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] destny:
does not work on my galaxy S (rooted to JB).

The problem is: it does not create any file after an incoming/outgoing call...

Is it normal? Am I doing something wrong?
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] InfiniteNexus:
Verizon Galaxy Nexus

I have been playing with the beta off and on for sometime now and had stopped using the app due to some audio problems. I really needed this app in my line of work and and have been reading for the last couple of weeks what the current status was of the app for my phone. This thread is full of info but its a bit scattered.

I finally decided to just buy the full version and figure it out. Long story short is unlike prior versions this thing just worked perfect out of the box without having to do much more then just install CallRecorder, follow prompt for AlsaMixer and wait for AlsaMixer to finish its setup. be patient as it takes a few moments.

I am running stock kernel and was concerned that not having a 2-way kernel would be an issue and suspected it was the reason for the horrible quality recordings on older betas. I found the recording to be really good on both sides of the call. I also placed several calls over 15-20 minutes to make sure the app didn't have any issues after a few minutes like I had prior experienced. This app is well worth the $10 :)

My setup so it might help others

Verizon Galaxy Nexus 4.1.1 (JRO03O) stock / rooted (stock kernel)

Superuser Elite (ChainsDD) 0.8

Busybox Pro (Stephen Stericson) 9.6.4 installed version 1.20.2 in /system/xbin

CallRecorder (Skvalex) 1.2.9 Full

AlsaMixer (Skvalex) 1.0.7
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] Milamber:
I also just bought the full version for my gnex, well worth it.

I'm using Franco kernel nightlies

Did you make yours a system app?
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] InfiniteNexus:
No, I didn't set as a system app.
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] blaine07:
I am using Verizon Gnex on BAMF 2.3.5 with Trinity kernel. Am I the only one having it sometime randomly not record incoming and outgoing calls? Also, sometimes calls are loud and clear when replayed(both sides) and sometime both sides are so muffled I can't hear anything?

Can't seem to figure out why sometimes it works, sometimes it doesn't and the varying quality of calls.

Hmmm?
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] chronicle:
GP version works perfectly out of the box with no tweaks at all on the Moto Razr i (unrooted), just installed and it worked perfectly.

However, I have no idea how to exit the program!
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] sjamie:
What is the GP version?
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] sjamie:
Are calls being recorded from the line or from the mic? Does it also work via a bluetooth headset?
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] sjamie:
skvalex, I read in the comments on Google Play Store that you helped someone get this app working on his Motorola Droid Bionic. Is there any way to get your app to work on a Motorola Photon? If so, I'll GLADLY buy this app!
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] sidmuer:
I had that happen to me in a previous build with my gnex.

The problem wasn't so random. It was the way the person name was saved in my contact list.

See if the missed recordings are from the same person/people named in your contact list.

If so, simplify the name, with no special characters or hyphens, dashes, etc...

then try that person again, see if that's the issue.
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] skvalex:
As I know, CallRecorder records only from the mic on Droid Bionic.
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] ochakov:
ALSA AMR Recording

Do you plan to support MP3/AMR recording in ALSA mode?

At least, is it possible to automatically convert WAV files after the call?
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] skvalex:
No, it's technically impossible.

Yes, amr converting will be in the next release!
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] Aids10:
App has been working very well on my Hero; though I just found a flaw. :o

When making a long distance call through google voice with call confirm on; the app goes into a continued confirm loop.

I'll leave confirm off for now :rolleyes:
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] srijith.407:
Well, this works but have to use the sound libs given in another forum for my defy plus.
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] slam666:
Hi skvalex,

can you tell us if your apps will work on Samsung Galaxy S3 with JB? I am currently using it on ICS but dont want to use JB ROM yet since your app dont work on JB ROM on my phone. I tried every settings and nothing work, I either get static sounds or the app just dont save the file.

Thanks.
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] shirt:
CallRecorder ALSA reboots

Hi Skvalex,

I am using a trail version of CallRecorder 1.2.9 with ALSA in wav i was testing the conversation is encryption mode but when i get a call the phone reboots. it is the same until i change it to something other the ALSA like kernel or API. Created key and installed Alsa , re-installed twice same issue.

Call Recorder Version: 1.2.9 trail

BusyBox Version : 1.20.2-cm9

AlsaMixer Version : 1.0.7

Phone: HTC Sensation - >Custom Rom

Installation Process:

1. Installed BusyBox

2. Installed CallRecorder

3. Installed AlsaMixer

Any help is really appreciated.

Thanks!.
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] Nuppi:
Hi all.

I just installed the trial version.

I have root, stock ROM.

Trying to tap the screen to install the libs but i get:

"Something is wrong while installing the libs"

I can record a call, but its very low quality.

Mostly static, espcially my own voice can barely be heard.

standard API

galaxy s2 ICS 4.0.4
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] peterndl:
CallRecorderROOT_v.2.0

Install CallRecorderROOT_v.2.0, show root storage in Solid Explorer show "No content here"
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] inthero:
在中文语言下，设置～录音～开始录制时间延迟时，当设置拨出时间后，来电的时间延迟也跟随拨出时间同样变动了！希望修正下！
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] Ja_som:
[MENTION=7991938]inthero[/MENTION]

XDA is English only, read forum rules.
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] irvinehooi:
I think he forget about that.

在中文语言下，设置～录音～开始录制时间延迟时，当设置拨出时间后，来电的时间延迟也跟随拨出时间同样变动了！希望修正下

He was trying to say when he set the outgoing delay timer, the incoming delay timer get modified as well when the app is configured to Chinese language.
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] ocujos:
It won't be be long before Skvalex achieves the same result
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] crisees:
Version 3.0 beta04 also not reliable : 4 of 10 times, only my voice is recorded. This is happening only on Oreo, on my Note 8 Exynos dual sim.
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] skvalex:
Try version 3.0 beta05. Hope it will be much more stable on your device
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] skvalex:
Already. Version 3.0 beta05 records both sides on S9.
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] Aussie 1:
Beta05 records both sides perfectly on my (unrooted) Note 8 with Exynos, all Oreo updates + stock Note 8 settings.

Skvalex, your an absolute legend...
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] inthero:
But Beta05 flashed back on S9+ as soon as it started recording
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] watoan:
[MENTION=2859866]skvalex[/MENTION]

Everything worked well with "3.0 beta04.1" with "ROOT 1.0 beta03.1" on my Nexus 6 previously.

Today I have updated to "3.0 beta05.1" with ROOT 2.0, no other changes made after updated, app still showing my calls are being recorded on every calls, but when I listen to the recordings, I found all of them are silent now.

Nexus 6 official ROM 7.1.1 (N6F27M)

Magisk 16.4

Call Recorder 3.0 beta05.1

ROOT 2.0

Audio Source: CAF

Please help on this, Call Recorder is important to me, thanks.
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] skvalex:
Thank you for detailed information, I will investigate this issue.

Till I fixed the problem, I've attached the previous versions (maybe reboot will be needed after you install the apks). Sorry for inconvenience.
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] jenaplisken:
With last version i lost the 'start recording on answer' even if checked.

I'm using call recorder on a oneplus3 with last openbeta. Till yesterday all it was ok
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] PrettyPistol555:
Pixel XL

Last update the option to record using root went away.

Tried reinstalling the root app, but no joy.

Any suggestions?
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] jenaplisken:
Try download last root app from first post
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] xalaros10:
Install new app v.3.0_beta05.2 from OP says into program v.3.0_beta05.1
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] jwds1978:
It's showing the correct version (v3.0-beta05.2)…
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] PrettyPistol555:
After installing the updated RootApp it worked again, then stopped...

I installed the NEW App from OP (5.2) but still not working. :crying:

Is there any recommended order for installing the RootApp, and Main App???
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] skvalex:
Can you try to reboot after having installed root module 2.0 and the main app 3.0 beta05.2?
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] PrettyPistol555:
Last time I used TiBackup to wipe Data and Uninstall both RootApp(2.0) and Main App(beta05.2)

Rebooted phone

Installed RootApp(2.0), then installed Main App(beta05.2)

Rebooted phone (did not open App after installation)

Opened Main App(beta05.2)

Granted Superuser

Allowed Permissions

Allowed drawing over apps

(now it's indexing(?) all my old recordings, there's 7,000+, so that takes awhile)

Going into settings I see recording is set to "OFF" (I will switch it on)

Under "Recording" menu it has device set as Qualcomm MSM8996 (Which is in fact my chipset, I realized after looking it up. this option wasn't there before (MSM8996) must be a new addition:o) (When I was trying earlier today I had been switching it from the Chipset back to Pixel XL, which is how it had been working previously)

This time I left the Device at the "Qualcomm MSM8996" but changed Recording "Method to "Root".

Worked a few times, now not working again...

I had done this several times earlier today, and one time it actually crashed/rebooted phone immediately after showingthe "call recorder has been granted superuser permissions" toast...

The other times it just gave the message about being unable to record, which is what is happening again.

Thanks for your hard work SKVALEX, u r our Hero!

*Edited to reflect NOT WORKING.
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] PrettyPistol555:
So after another reboot it's working again...
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] inthero:
s9+，beta05.2，sometimes only my voice is recorded.
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] Imdre:
Oneplus 3 rooted (Magisk 16.4), Android 8.0

Version: 3.0 beta 05.2. Root apk verion: 2.0

My settings:

Recording method: root

Root setting:

-audio: caf

-recording format: amr

Does not record anything. This is getting worse ...

This is still beta (rather alfa)...
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] PrettyPistol555:
:crying: Now this morning not working again, and reboot not making any difference :crying:

A few quick questions if you don't mind.

(but first the background info of my setup: Magisk Rooted Stock Android 8.1 on Pixel XL (Unlocked Bootloader), and I make virtually ALL my phone calls using a Bluetooth Headset, and I record ALL my calls by default)

Now the questions:

1. Any reason to choose the new "MSM8996" option over the "Pixel XL"?

1a. Choosing "Qualcomm MSM8996" sets Recording Method to "Standard API" which my experience tells me is unlikely to work with my Bluetooth headset. (I could still manually change to "Root"...).

1b. Choosing "Pixel XL" recommends Recording Method of Root.

2. Would converting either of the Apps to "System" help?

3. Yesterday you recommended rebooting after installation, should I be opening the Call Recorder app before rebooting? Or Reboot without opening App first?

Thanks
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] Imdre:
Root method not working. 10/0 recorded file...

Previous versions 10/4 recorded files...

2.4.0 not working correctly on Oreo and not compability with Magisk. Super :(
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] crisees:
Last version works OK on my Note 8 Exynos dual sim no root.

Thx Skvalex, great job !
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] skvalex:
1. The app checks for device name, which is "marlin". Maybe you've installed custom ROM and this value changed? So the app didn't recognize your device and set general config for your chipset. So select Pixel XL with ROOT method.

2. It doesn't matter

3. Only after upgrading

Also, I've just checked and on my device (OnePlus 3T with Android 8.1 (AOSP Extended 5.4) + Magisk 16.4 + Root Module 2.0 + Call Recorder v.3.0 beta05.2) ROOT module worked fine, except mp3 recording format. So if you're using mp3, it's recommended to try recording with WAV.
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] skvalex:
I don't see any reason to use ROOT method on your device. Use Standard API, it records both sides.
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] skvalex:
Issues with ROOT method should now be fixed in 3.0 beta 05.4.
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] jenaplisken:
Same configuration (both method: root and api) last magisk. no problem except 'start recording on answer'.

Do you have battery optimization active on callrec? set all 3 skvalex app 'not aptimized'.
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] skvalex:
"start recording on answer" should work in 3.0 beta05.4
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] jenaplisken:
perfect!!! it works

A question. If i use standerd API to record i have to use root module or i can uninstall it?

Great work as always :good:
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] skvalex:
You should keep it installed if you want option "start recording on answer", otherwise it won't work
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] Marvino.:
Thanks for this masterpiece app! I precisely use it for this very unique option which is not presented at any other call recording app! Keep the good work up!
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] Imdre:
Of course, Callrecorder not optimized.

But! 3.0 beta 05.4 works fine again with root method!

Thanks Skvalex!!!
[Paid Software Announcement and Discussion] watoan:
Seems the problem here comes with Magisk Beta 16.4, and I have not realized that the problem starts since I flashed Magisk beta before.

Now I tried to flash Magisk 16.0 with your latest version 3.0 beta05.4 and ROOT 2.0.1, and everything worked again on my Nexus 6.

No idea whats wrong with the Magisk beta...