yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] twistedumbrella:
Take the device folder for the droid build and run it against tpruvot's source with the camera HAL from the droid2 and itll be pretty much done.

Run it against my frameworks and it will only have 900 errors. I didn't "give up" but I did take it down to save someone trying to build it and getting a screen full of junk.

If I were just making builds, then I have no excuse to say "I don't really have the time to rewrite the entire frameworks just for fun" but there is a lot more going on.

I don't expect anyone to understand what is demanded from those lucky enough to be tagged "recognized developer" but it is not the same reward it used to be :/
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] ASAM123:
I'm confused...so does this mean no further development on ICS for Droid? :(

Thanks anyways...
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] cowsquad:
Yes. No more support. Well, cushzero is working over droidforums.net. so hopefully he get this rom going
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] googlelover:
Hey wasn't a problem with ICS that there was something not working when you called people?

Edit: Ohwait the build I have is old as hell, but its weird.. I'm considering using it as a daily ROM, pretty much everything works except the camera...
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] EManU3LX:
Your A Hero

Thansk for attempting to build this port! If any testing is needed you can be sure to hit me up! :)
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] cowsquad:
Audio is now working man.
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] TheLoonyRebel:
Thanks twistedumbrella for all the efforts you put into trying to get ICS on the Droid 1.
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] podspi:
Where can we find your build again? :confused: :D

Don't get me wrong, I'm disappointed as well, but at no point did I feel 'entitled' to ICS. Forget indie devs, the firms selling a lot of these phones let us down with slow/no updates, and junky skins and overlays...

Twisted, thanks for all your work on the D1, and all those other phones you are working on. Charity work is very often a thankless job, and I am sure the donations you receive probably do not make up for the time you put in.

Also, I think you should leave everything up with a note saying it doesn't work (so someone can choose to extend your awesome work if they choose), but of course that is up to you :cool:
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] ASAM123:
The Milestone seemed to have gotten a pretty working ics build. I hope cushzero succeeds and I hope we have something in a month or two. :)
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] dman1049:
Isint milestone and og the same thing? In this since I don't get why ics is not yet possible on the og.
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] metalspring:
not quite, the milestone has a locked bootloader so they can't install custom kernels and their ics rom would have a lot of pointless work arounds, and the milestone has a different radio (milestone is gsm, droid is cdma) so their fixes for data and calling wouldn't fully work... The droid can probably use a lot of that rom but the main issues we have now would be the same (a kernel that will allow hardware acceleration properly and phone call audio)
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] teddyearp:
Well . . .
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] ASAM123:
I have faith in cushzero. :)

My contract doesn't end till June or something. Even after that, I'd rather wait till November or December and get a quad core phone...so this Droid is gonna serve me for a while :)
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] ASAM123:
Also, I am currently running Liquid smooth on my Droid 1. Are there any more ICS like/faster roms that are available? Thanks.
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] metalspring:
steel droid 10 by chevycam
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] Bunie89:
It wsnt personally against him. I've seen like 10 other ICS for Droid threads where EACH developer got to this exact point, and then decided to say the same thing. Too busy with other Devices. What other devices? newer phones? Theres like 20 roms being developed by each of them. For the Droid? None. Theres CrushZero's and he cant even make a fully functional CM7 rom. I understand its a complex task. i was just hoping twisted would be able to pull it off.

i know im not "entitled" to it. but that doesnt mean i wasnt looking forward to it more then xmas =/
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] slaZzz:
Does the cushzero milestone version have hardware accelerated display working? If not, we may still need to wait for this (http://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=23082047&postcount=1044). :o
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] Prack:
So this project is dead? I don't remember what build I put on my Droid but It was working great. I think the camera was the only thing not working. It was just a nightly.

I'll admit I haven't checked this forum for a long time and I didn't read through all of it but what happened to the original poster? He gave the project up to twisted and then twisted dropped it?
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] teddyearp:
That pretty much sums it up.
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] Prack:
That's a bummer. I did see the crushzero post on the other forum. I wish he had a thread going over here.
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] cush2push:
When i get farther than I have i will try to post something on xda i tend to use 1 forum to minimize scatter

Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Xparent ICS Blue
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] Mr. AndroidFan:
Awesome!!!

You made my day!!! Thank you!!

Oh, Navigation, Map, Camera, and maybe more other apps, but I am not sure if it's just my phone. But I got to say Wow, so close of being real for our old droid 1. Hope the stable version soon :D
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] catawalks:
I really hope this continues. I just got an OG droid from a friend who upgraded. I screwed around with it tossing a few different Froyo and GB roms on there. Then I tried this ICS build and holy crap, it is so much more responsive, quick, and smooth than any other rom I tried.

I couldn't get the Market (Google Play) and the Gmail app to install correctly using the latest Gapps though. Also, I am having issues connecting it to WPA2 wifi networks. WPA2 works fine on my DroidPro running ICS by JackPotClavin so I know it can work. Maps, gallery, and camera are the only other things I've come across so far with issues.

Great work, and I hope cush2push can get more work done on this thing.
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] Prack:
Just so everyone knows the build listed here is NOT the build by cush2push. He has a newer(?) build on the droidforums forum.
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] ASAM123:
I totally agree with you. I flashed the build on page 65 to test it out and I was amazed by how fast it was. It was faster than cm 7, or even liquid! I don't see why some devs are giving up on this phone.
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] twistedumbrella:
-> https://github.com/ThePlayground/proprietary_vendor_qcom
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] ASAM123:
I don't get it. :(
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] durandgir:
excuse my half being asleep after school and track. what is this for? I thought qcom was a graphic card or something. I'm confused as to how this relates to this phone. or is it another dead end? or is it a different phone that you can get stuff to work on? 0.o
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] twistedumbrella:
It makes source impossible to build a droid configuration on. I was explaining why devs end up having to drop droid builds if it isn't their only device.
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] ASAM123:
Sorry to go off topic, but quick question. For those using kfazz's builds, how do you use it as an alarm clock, cause the sound doesn't seem to be working...at least for me. And also, which build is better? page 65 or page 1 one. Thanks

Thanks

---------- Post added at 05:38 AM ---------- Previous post was at 05:13 AM ----------

I am kind of confused. What about the build kfazz made? They run pretty good.

Thanks
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] twistedumbrella:
"I was explaining why devs end up having to drop droid builds if it isn't their only device."
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] ASAM123:
Oh. I see. my bad.
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] cowsquad:
You should use build on page 1 january 5th
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] derrek22:
hey like the work! are you done working on this? please reply...:)
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] ASAM123:
I just finished installed that build and I am on it now. It's really good. The Droid is still my primary phone, for a couple more months, so might switch back eventually to cm 7.2 rc1. I tried bootmanager, but its too laggy with that

I also am able to make calls. Calls via the stock phone app don't work, but what I did was download an app called talkatone from the play store and now I am able to place/receive calls using my google voice account.
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] Prack:
I don't remember what build version I'm using but I do remember that it was when the gapps was too large and didn't flash right. I had to go into the zip and remove a few unwanted files to make room for everything to flash correctly. My audio works just fine. In fact my wife is upset with how loud the alarm is lol.
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] cowsquad:
How do you use talkatone. I tried to use it with google voice but it doesn't work. I get no audio. Like people won't hear what I am saying. Is really working for you?
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] ASAM123:
I downloaded talkatone from Playstore, and signed in with my google voice account. Now I'm able to place/receive calls and mic/audio seem to be working fine.

With the stock app, neither mic nor audio works.
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] cowsquad:
With the talkatone app, neither my microphone nor audio works, is hella weird. Am I doing something wrong? Or have you done something different?
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] ASAM123:
That is weird. I am using the Jan 5 build and it works fine. The only problem is that the data keeps dropping.

Where as on the build on P 65, data is very stable, but sound/mic does not work whatsoever.
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] catawalks:
The Jan 5 build on page 1 I've been having a lot of trouble getting gapps installed (well mostly the talk and the market) and WPA2 authentication for the wireless seems to be an issue.

The page 65 build definitely doesn't have sound/mic features but I can install gapps no problem and install other apps without an issue. Still have an issue with connecting to my WPA2 setup as well. With SteelDroid 10 it has no connection issues so it's gotta be something in the build.
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] ASAM123:
I reverted back to cm 7.2 for the time being. The problem with Jan 5 build is that 3G keeps dropping for me, but on the page 65 one, it's really stable. If the sound worked on the page 65 build, it could potentially be a daily driver for me. Hopefully, eventually, we'll get good builds.

And what happened to kfazz again? lol
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] durandgir:
Kfazz is busy with his real life, Cush2Push is really our last hope at this point.
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] mgross029:
I've got the Jan-05 build working pretty well on my OG Droid. I was running SD 10 and just loaded the ICS from Rom Manager. I get sound and data, but after making a call the Radio drops and will not reestablish its connection until the a reboot is done. I think this may be a problem in the either the RIL or Framework.

Also, not a big problem but the camera doesn't work. I could definitely run this daily if the RIL drop issue can be corrected.

I also did not load the ICS gapps... I left the gapps on from the previous GB SD10 build. I will try to see what I can do to troubleshoot further. I have captured a radio log while doing the following.

I disabled and enabled mobile data - Worked Fine Data Enabled

Entered AP Mode and Existed - Worked Fine Data Enabled

Made Phone Call - Data and Radio shut off.

http://dl.dropbox.com/u/45928762/icslogcatradio2.txt

I just started parsing through but maybe with some other eyes looking at it we can figure out what the root of the problem is.

Thanks to all of the Devs that have and are still working on this to make it work for these old phones.

I will keep digging when I get time to see if I can find more info. Have not had much time to work on this but I'll see what else I can dig up. Also, I will try to load the ICS version of gapps to see what that breaks. :)
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] ASAM123:
Do you think there is a way to somehow implement the camera fix from the motorola milestone ics build onto this phone? That should get camera working. Even video camera works on that build. The milestone ics build seems to also have no audio problems.

Check it out here: http://xdaforums.com/showthread.php?t=1445209

I mentioned this cause the droid 1 and milestone are pretty similar phones.
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] twistedumbrella:
A page or two back it was mentioned exactly how and I am pretty sure it works.
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] mgross029:
I think the camera is the least of the worries right now. It may be possible though if we could pull some Libs from there and push them into the Droid build.

I tried a few more things, but no matter what the radio dies after a phone call. I've tried a few different gapp version from goo-inside to see if maybe an update would fix, but so far nothing really good yet. After clean install of Jan-05 with no Gapps installed I have full radio, but when I add the gapps it drops the radio. Didn't have time to pull logs.

I'll try to break some more things when I have time.
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] ASAM123:
True. Camera is last priority. I just mentioned it worked on the milestone.
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] metalspring:
twisted and cush2push already found a camera fix
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] ASAM123:
Nice! :)

I wasn't aware. Has it been implemented yet?
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] jtk15:
I love this rom
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] twistedumbrella:
I don't know personally, but I just remember it was one of the last things I mentioned before not being able to get a build more than halfway through with definition errors and I think he had already started working on it by then so it may be.
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] vakkov:
So did you succeed in getting hardware acceleration on rev 121 with ICS? I am asking because i have a n900 with the same gpu..
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] twistedumbrella:
Somewhat. I got it to read and identify the 125 libs by using updates for a Defy boot image and Droid 2 EGL libs, but I never fully tested how far it would go because I had bad support for OMAP hardware acceleration in the build itself. It seemed like it was possible and not that unrealistic, though.
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] Kyle Chen:
Wait. I'm a bit confused. Are there any Ics builds with working camera then for the Droid that I can download and flash? Thanks.
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] kabaldan:
Keep dreaming :).

As I said, SGX530 rev 125 libs are of no use on SGX530 rev 121 hardware.

Your "Backward compatibility." quote made me laugh :D.
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] Kyle Chen:
Hi. I looked at your ics build for milestone and noticed you made good progress. Is it possible for it to run on the Droid 1 since they are pretty similar? Thanks :)
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] catawalks:
I'd be interested in knowing the answer to this as well.
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] durandgir:
It's not, the Milestone and D1 are not identical devices, they are on the outside but the inside they do vary.
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] twistedumbrella:
Edit:

Progress that should have been made, but was sacrificed to be douche:

|------------|

Manhood swung around attempting to sound like an all-star (but failed):

|--|

Which is better for progress? Time spent trolling = time lost developing.
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] ASAM123:
That's true, but they have lots of similar specs right? The major difference is that the D1 is CDMA and Milestone is GSM. If the Milestone has a pretty good ics build, I don't see why the droid 1 can't have something like that, unless the D1 being CDMA makes it harder. Isn't the milestone bootloader also locked, unlike the D1 bootloader?
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] twistedumbrella:
If you have a GSM build that works it really is pretty close and somewhat simple to convert. The way this kid talks with an inferiority complex, I take it you will probably never see him do it. As far as camera, display, graphics, sound, etc (hardware beyond GPS and Radio) you could use almost identical parts. For Droid2, the ICS was just a quick port of Droid2 global. Everything was (better not say backward compatible for the pseudo-devs who don't understand the concept) able to be used on a prior phone that was already found to work on a newer phone. They actually got the camera code by using a straight copy of the Milestone 2 camera as well. It's all out there, so hopefully someone puts it all together. Finally having a dedicated build machine, I might be able to get more done to get things cleaned up and start it up again, but who knows.
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] kabaldan:
"kid", "inferiority complex", "pseudo-devs" - how funny, judging people you don't know anything about :D

For your info, I'm 39. My CM6 for Milestone was the first from source compiled custom ROM for any bootloader locked Motorola device, all source always published on github. It basically opened the door for builds for other locked devices. E.g. CyanogenMod for Defy started as a fork from my repos. Defy repos then served as a base for other devices

Unfortunately, I don't have that much free time for developing as in the beginning anymore - my daughter was born in the meantime, I have a regular job...

My remarks about SGX530 revisions were made to spare you or other developers from wasting time on something that simply won't work, ever.

And yes, I won't do any builds for Droid as I don't make any builds for devices I don't own because I couldn't test them properly. But all the source is out there, available for anyone.
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] catawalks:
Soooo, does that mean if one of us sent you a A855 you'd develope for it?
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] twistedumbrella:
If all this is true, and your first comment hadn't been so arrogant, maybe I would have just sent you the phone I don't use. You came in like a jerk, your rom is mediocre at best, and you act like an expert without any proof of expertise beyond one device from two years ago... what'd you expect? I know what you present, and that is a relic of android past trying to pass old accomplishments off as new progress.

And if you don't have time to develop, how do you have so much to be counterproductive? Inferiority complex... I made the first, I opened the door, ok... you were a one trick pony. I get it. You run out of breakthroughs?

The rest of us are still moving forward. I offered to help get your rom current. Not revolutionary at the standards of 2004. Current. You got cocky. That is an inferiority complex. Deal with it, i'm done here.
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] cowsquad:
Stop twisted and kabaldan. This thread is to share knowledge,not to feel better than anyone. One good thing about Kabaldan is that he got his rom running, but here, we didn't get nothing, except kfaaz build. It was a duck tape, twisted claimed, but its running well on my phone. Let's hope we get something good here.
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] ASAM123:
Totally agree! Arguing will get us nowhere. Things will just get messed up. Devs should work together, not argue, otherwise no progress is made.

And the Kfazz build is running really well on my phone too (even better than gingerbread!) Its just missing too many important thing for me to use daily.
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] catawalks:
Well said. I'd still be interested in knowing if we could entice kabaldan to help out more if he had a droid to mess with.
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] ASAM123:
At this point, we just need to somehow port kabaldan's build to the droid 1.
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] metalspring:
it wouldnt be much different then the kfazz build...we'd still be stuck with the problem of phone calling working (audio and signal dropping), possibly lose mobile data, and hardware acceleration wouldnt be right (it really requires kernel tweaks which are unavailable on the milestone due to locked bootloader)...

The things needed to properly port the milestone build are part of what we couldnt get to work on the other builds...the radio...milestone is GSM and the droid is CDMA...
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] ASAM123:
True. We need to find another way, but we could port some stuff from the milestone...
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] cowsquad:
I don't know why your signal keeps dropping. I've using kfazz build and I haven't had any signal drops. I've been trying to port milestone's build, but since I'm not an experiencie geek lol, I am having issues. I know is not hard, but we need kabaldan's help.
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] ASAM123:
My signal doesn't drop at all on the build on Page 65. It's very stable. That build would be a good daily driver if it had audio working. Data keeps dropping on that Jan 5 build though.

And regarding the rom, cushzero is working on it on droidforums. maybe if he can work with kabaldan, or port his milestone rom, it could work out.
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] metalspring:
you can try the milestone audio files to see if it'll make the audio work...

libaudio.so is under /lib and ap_gain.bin is under /bin, just put them in the same places on your rom and make their permissions match the files around them in there

https://github.com/nadlabak/android_vendor_motorola_umts_sholes/tree/gingerbread/proprietary
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] cowsquad:
They don't work. I have tried them. They will work with the earpiece, but the speaker won't work. Its weird
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] metalspring:
well theres always the jan 5th build...adding those 2 files makes it so that the signal and data remain after a reboot, and it already has working speaker audio
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] cowsquad:
I don't know what's wrong with our build. Milestones has an audio. So I'm gonna swap some files and see if get that freaking audio working :)
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] Kyle Chen:
If audio works with file swapping, maybe camera will too :)
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] bmx24:
you are now my favorite dev i hope you get a gnex sometime so i can enjoy your updated into the future
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] kfazz:
yes. there are still some issues,but it gets through setup if you deselect the location services. gmail works, market not yet, but it syncs contacts at least

use a file manager or terminal to cp /system/app/Vending.apk /data/app/Vending.apk and market works

Edit:

latest build:

http://www.mediafire.com/?bgnx6n3b3gobai0

latest gapps_to_data:

http://www.mediafire.com/?da3ntb58x765hrd
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] bmx24:
do you have any ideas on the market bug?

nvm u fixed it :D
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] DanJackson:
This is the best Christmas present ever! thanks !

I installed Nova launcher instead of the Trebucket, and its alot more stable, I cant get the home button to work anymore..

Still fantastic work!
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] durandgir:
Wait so is sync working yet? Or do you need to add gaps with a file manager?
[Motorola Droid and Milestone General] DanJackson:
I got it so setup with my google account by flashing the new gapps file he posted but the market still didnt work for me but all the other gapps do