yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] mzone1510:
Let me get this right... you are using xxkpq which apparently has still not fixed the notifications bug, you then flashed the attached file, xxkb1 modem file right? so everything is fine? how is it after prolonged testing? any side effects? I didn't know a froyo modem file could work on gb...

Anyone else tried this?
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] luiseteyo:
Yes, a guy did that on kpn with the kb3 modem and worked and I did the same with the kb1 on the new KPQ. Another guy was successful with the same modem in KPN.

The only think is that i came to the problem back right now.... will be testing today.
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] vishal24387:
I am really looking forward to this solution.
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] luiseteyo:
For some people it works, for other it doesn't and for other, (like me) it did. Now I am not recieving notifications with offscreen mode again, but we will be testing...
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] mzone1510:
do keep us posted! Will tune back in here for an update tomorrow, hope its positive!
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] blaqkarma:
So My friend you think we can solve the problem in this method??

now you can edit your OP with the procedures and Steps you done so many can test it also....
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] luiseteyo:
KPN with KB3 modem still works. Now I translate what he just said in the spanish forum:

@Cherocom: " Bueno, como ya comente por wifi perfecto, y por 3g...... pues tambien, porque me habia olvidado del tlf y hace un momento me ha llegado un whatsapp. para el wifi probe unos 40 minutos y para 3g ha estado algo mas de 2 horas.

Muchas gracias @manuelmagix por su inspiracion."

"Well, as I said, everything perfect using wifi and also with 3g......because I forgot my mobile and I have just recieved a whatsapp. I also tested this with wifi, letting the offscreen mode being there for 40 minutes and for 3g I waited for more than 2 hours

Thanks a lot to @manuelmagix for his inspiration"

:) what do you think? anybody tested that?
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] fengjia1313:
this exciting
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] blaqkarma:
I know manuelmagix is also a member here at XDA...MAybe amigo if you can tell him to post what the step he do so many could test ...
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] luiseteyo:
I just did that on the original post... I am a bit busy, sorry for the lateness.

Ok, now I will ask him to post his procedure with the fix..
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] manuelmagix:
Hello friends,

First apologize for my English (translated by Google)

Since last night, I started testing, and all very well, "google talk" great, "Hotmail push" great, "whatsapp" has given me the odd delay.

The steps I have made are in the first post of "luiseteyo."

Tonight I will spend on KPQ and KB1, tomorrow more .
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] mzone1510:
Ok will do as suggested in the 1st post and will report back after a couple hours! Real excited about this fix!
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] fengjia1313:
You are testing KPN?
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] mzone1510:
Well I'm sorry to say that this fix didn't work! (For me atleast) Tried flashing kb3 modem on kpn but didn't work, still the same! But this was not a fresh install of kpn I was already using it with cf root, and I just flashed the modem file, could that be the problem?
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] manuelmagix:
and application "google talk" either?
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] luiseteyo:
We are working hard to find the right combination. We are working in kpn, kpm and kpq. KPN-kb3MODEM seems to work for the people who tested that.

We will probably start testing now with DX froyo modems..

We will post results.
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] jaskiratsingh:
Do you think flashing your countries modem with csc will help?
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] luiseteyo:
Probably... we don't know too much about android development, and we don't understand some things... You could test that and give a feedback here!
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] luiseteyo:
@jaskiratsingh thank you a lot... we think we got it!! The problem was on the csc and modem compatibility

1) Flash clean kb3. Make a hard reset.

2) Open odin. Select ANY firmware's pda in the PDA case. (only pda, let csc and MODEM empty). Press start.

3) After 35 min with ofscreen mode notifications arrive with no delay :)

I hope this can be done with every firmware.

I will be waiting for your feedbacks

:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] jaskiratsingh:
All the latest firmwares are a single file. If we flash xxkb3 which is a multifile, which files should we remove from single file pda?
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] fengjia1313:
flash kb3 and then flash KPQ Single pda?
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] jaskiratsingh:
I dont think this is correct because when you will flash KPQ single file, it will overwrite the modem and csc and you will have kpq modem and csc, which we do not want.
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] fengjia1313:
Flash again kb3 modem and csc

how?
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] jaskiratsingh:
Tried that...It doesnt work
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] fengjia1313:
oh!

Thank report
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] luiseteyo:
Lets see, flash complete kb3, make a hard reset and then flash single KPQ PDA file, nothing more... It worked now after 40 min.
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] jaskiratsingh:
will try this and report.
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] fengjia1313:
jaskiratsingh

luiseteyo That his work.

hard reset is Double wi?
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] luiseteyo:
Wipe data/factory reset from recovery or putting this code: *2767*3855#
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] jaskiratsingh:
Didnt undertand this?
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] fengjia1313:
Thank you to understand
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] pabreu:
What abt the bootloader? Kb3 is froyo and kpq is gb.
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] jaskiratsingh:
doesnt matter
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] mzone1510:
I was wondering the same thing... won't there be a conflict?
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] luiseteyo:
I thought the same..but no :)
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] mzone1510:
So is this confirmed to be working? What does it say when you type *#1234# under csc and modem?

Has anyone else tested it?
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] luiseteyo:
I dont know what says...probably csc kb3 and modem kb3, the only thing that change is pda. I tested that and is working for me and for the people in the spanish forum, you can read it if you know spanish...

http://www.htcmania.com/showthread.php?t=291612&page=6
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] fengjia1313:
luiseteyo

You still working properly?

i try tomorrow
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] luiseteyo:
It worked perfectly in KPQ... Now I am testing the same but with KPN... I will post results.
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] jaskiratsingh:
If you flash kb3 and them flash kpq single file, it will say kpq for all three because pda, csc and modern is in one file. If you flash csc and modem for kb3, it will not update csc :(

Hence issue remains.

Can someone try... There's an csc.apk file in system/app. Can you pull the same from froyo and push it in system/app and test?
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] vishal24387:
Guys I think issue is not that simple. Even codeworkx also said that it might be any reason like kernel, modem. U guys shold know what what will be effect of replacing files.
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] jaskiratsingh:
Its worth the try
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] luiseteyo:
It is absolutely true that after doing this you will have KPQ csc modem and pda, but I still dont know why it worked for me and for others... will continue testing.
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] Momo.80:
This solution didn't work for me... :(

I've still got notification issues. I have to go back to Froyo. Anyway, thanks for trying!
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] fengjia1313:
same

don't work
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] loSconosciuto:
It worked for me! Now I get instant notifications with Wathsapp and Facebook messenger. At first I had some problems with Facebook messenger, probably because I installed it with Titanium backup, but after a clean installation through the Market everything works fine. Sadly Gmail app still gives me problems, sometimes I get instant notifications, more often some minutes after, but it was giving me some problems with Froyo too. I did some tests with K9 mail and I think it works, but I'm not sure.

By the way I did everything as suggested (well, I also flashed KPE by mistake, doing a re-partition, before flashing KB3). I'm using XKPQ now.

Thanks!!

(I'll continue to do some other tests to see if in the previous ones I was lucky and as most of you I won't get any other instant notification. I'll keep you update if something changes)

Edit:

I did more tests. Everything works well, even Gtalk and K9 mail.

I have a question for you: when you flashed xkpq, did you first apply any mod/change something in /system, or just test if notifications work? I really don't know if it's possible, but maybe this issue could be caused by something you did, just guessing.

Otherwise I couldn't explain why everything works fine for me.
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] RaDiu5:
any developer can help us?
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] mzone1510:
What is the exact procedure you used? Let me follow that strictly & see...
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] loSconosciuto:
Ok. Here the list of what I did. (I had XXKPQ with no working notifications. Before that I had XIKP2, installed through kies)

Hard reset

Flash XXKPE (pass: samfirmware.com): re-partition and then I flashed PDA, Modem and CSC. (as I said before I did it by mistake) (Guide)

Hard reset (again)

Flash XXKB3 as suggested in this thread (PDA, CSC and MODEM)

Hard reset (again, I don't know if it's useful)

Flash XXKPQ

Install amit's CF-root (I did immediately, I didn't check if notifications were working)

Format the phone in EXT4 (script)

Deodex

At this point I think I had everything working (facebook messenger didn't work at first as I said, but I think because I installed it with Titanium backup. After I installed it through the market worked. I also replaced Gmail with K9 mail because it doesn't work well for the moment). I didn't apply any mod downloaded from this forum, I created modified everything by myself.

Here the tutorials I followed:

1% battery

CRT TV off effect

Lower Auto-Brightness levels (I used different brightness levels though)

SMS + No contact limit + No MMS convert + Sent time

AOSP Lockscreen

Extended Power Menu

Note: if you want to apply those mods remember to select as compression level 0 when modding framework-res.apk to avoid boot loops.
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] estapagu:
More bugs

Two other bugs in our phone:

Voice dialing over Bluetooth hands-free: This bug only affects apps with voice confirmation like Cyberon Voice Commander or Vlingo. (It is a known bug in some Samsung devices)

Long press on green call button on handsfree Bluetooth: The Bluetooth headset says "no voice dialing". Any app on market can fix it. (It is a known bug in some Samsung devices)

I think we should open a new thread.
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] arindammanidas:
Will try this today and report...

I am on XXKPQ ... so will flash back to XXKB3 > then XXKPQ > ganesh/amit's CF-ROOT...
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] arindammanidas:
I tried two methods...

Stock XXKB3 >> Stock XXKPQ and XXKPQ with XXKB3 modem...

Both methods are not working... but if i keep the phone connected to a charger or PC, push mail works...

I need my mails on time... so going back to XXKB3... :(:mad::(:confused:
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] djynns:
When our phone is charging, notifications works fine.

We can suffer a notification issue when our phone is not charging.

I tried a KPQ with KC1 modem and I have a notification issue.

I tried a KPQ with KB3 modem and I have a notification issue.

In a spanish forum, some people says that if the screen is always on, the notifications issue disappears.

I want to try two things:

Set my phone to never turn off the screen

Set my phone to not use any lock screen and no turn off the screen
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] DooMLoRD:
so basically the notification system is not able to "wake up" the device from deepsleep...

when the device is charging, phone never enters deepsleep...

when the device is NOT CHARGING and the screen is off the device will enter deepsleep in few seconds...

so the problem is related to the sync app/notification system....

may be someone who mods APPS (APKs) can hack the sync app or notification system app to use proper wake unlocks to "wake up" the device from deepsleep to check notifications...

as long as some notifications (XDA p.m. or some other syncs) are working fine this is an issue at APP level... though if the notification system is failing FOR EACH AND EVERY syncing app then the issue is at core framework level or might be even at kernel level...

if u guys can provide we with the kernel sources for that kernel/fimware on which notifications worked correctly i can try n compare to check if anything related to that has changed...
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] jaskiratsingh:
For me notifications worked and work fine only in froyo. Every version of GB has the notification bug.
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] DooMLoRD:
again wht notifications are u referring to?

gmail sync?

corporate email sync?

facebooc sync?

etc...
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] falex007:
I have the same problem with waking up the device when I'm using PowerAMP or Astro Player Nova. They play 1 track, even if it's several hours (Audio book) then, when they move to the next track, they stop playing. With stock and Mort player all is OK. Also I found that this problem appears only when I'm using bluetooth headphones. When I'm using cord headphones or speaker all is OK.

The same applications on Froyo works well. This means that the problem is in some changes in the wake up functionality.
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] rarap:
that will cause u a very poor battery life..
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] mzone1510:
Ok so I will tell you what I have noticed.

When the phone goes into 'Deep Sleep' the mobile data connection (3g or 2g) gets disconnected. I can say this because where I live Vodafone has recently changed their system wherein you get a pop up message everytime you disconnect the data connection telling you the amount of data used and the cost. (This message only displays when the connection is terminated. (for eg when switching from mobile data to wifi,turning off data in settings etc)

So whenever the system is woken up from deep sleep mode for a while, this message is present, this leads me to believe that the data connection gets terminated while in deep sleep mode for some reason. This is also why I get high wakelocks on google maps (only when latitude is enabled) and gmail (with auto sync on).

However all notifications work perfectly fine while on WiFi. They also worked perfectly in all builds of froyo. So it does point out to be a system level bug than an app level bug...
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] kancilpintar:
Well, most of the sync apps are affected with the bugs. Gmail(the most important), facebook, whatsapp etc.
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] jaskiratsingh:
gmail sync, corporate email sync, whats app message sync...I dont use facebook
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] manuelmagix:
Example: connection data 3G, more than 40 minutes of wake. (in WI FI, o charge, every "push" worked)

for my:

In Froyo all OK

IN GB:

no: whatsapp, gmail, hotmail,

yes: google talk (always ok)
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] luiseteyo:
@DooMLoRD, what we mean is push notifications. Notifications that should wake up our phone with sound, vibration or just nothing but arriving. Whatsapp, for example.

Some people say that google talk does work perfectly, but not for everybody... If you could fix that in your next UtterChaos Update (v5) all the community would be very greated... Thank you for your attention
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] DooMLoRD:
let me make this clear:

not each and every problem can be solved by kernel.... if framework of ROM is screwed then u cant do anything...

best way to test this is to check if push notifications work correctly on CM7
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] lolodecker:
I think the i9003's sleep problem is so deep that I do not see any developer can solve the problem, the problem is not due to ginger as mobile as s2, Desire, and so on. not have this problem, if it is a problem or if the kernels or the system itself that moves the i9003, given the complicity involved in this terminal for all developers, do not open any knowledgeable enough to solve this problem, if any solution would have already long, I'm convinced of that.

Similarly with cm7 for the i9003, there is sufficient knowledge to develop and run it for this phone

It is both the challenge offered by the i9003, that nobody is able to solve or develop anything for this terminal, we found only modified ROM. Without tactile improvement Fuss132 offered thanks
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] loSconosciuto:
I still can't explain why everything works for me (and for other users). As you can see my phone goes in deep sleep and I still receive push notifications (when in 3g of course) after more than 30 minutes. Maybe spacebar2011 is right?
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] RaDiu5:
The i9003 has its own life. It works in some dispositives but then in others doesn't.

Enviado desde mi GT-I9003 usando Tapatalk
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] manuelmagix:
It is not correct. Because for me in froyo works well, and the problem is GB.

Now, I'm downloading Cianogen, as suggested @DoomLoRD
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] arindammanidas:
People have reported that the problem exists even in Codeworkx's CM7 for i9003.
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] DooMLoRD:
We need a few more ppl to confirm this...
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] manuelmagix:
In Cianogen no fix.

Enviado desde mi GT-I9003 usando Tapatalk
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] luiseteyo:
Notifications still don't arrive in standby mode on CM7. That's probably because it is BG based. What do you think @DooMLoRD?
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] DooMLoRD:
hmmm.... do we have froyo kernel sources? if there is any clue in kernel we can try n find the issue in the sources...
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] ronhoover88:
There are sources for froyo as well
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] DooMLoRD:
ok we just checked this on our SGS-SL and

we are not having any issues with PUSH NOTIFICATIONS

...

ROM: Stock XXKPQ

Kernel: UC-Kernel v04

GSM Carrier: Vodafone India

Mobile Data: 2G (EDGE)
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] manuelmagix:
You must wait 1 hour, in stanby, screen off.

Enviado desde mi GT-I9003 usando Tapatalk
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] luiseteyo:
DooMLoRD, it only happens after almost 40 minutes with screen off mode.
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] lolodecker:
With the screen off after 40 minutes, check with another terminal to send a WhatsApp the i9003 without waking, as if you had it in his pocket, and finds that does not come, until the moment you wake up and then I wound around the desktop screen.
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] jaskiratsingh:
Its not only with whatsApp. Even with gmail setup in AOSP google mail app, exchange server setup as push mail, notifications arrive late or on wake up
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] arindammanidas:
Make sure you dont keep the phone connected to Charger or PC...
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] DooMLoRD:
dude i understand very well wht is deepsleep and how to "activate it"
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] arindammanidas:
Ha ha ha :D sorry dude...;) just a li'l anxiety :)
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] mzone1510:
so why is this happening only to a select few? are we the 'un' lucky ones? :confused: could it have anything to do with which link (mirror) we downloaded the firmwares from? (kpe, kpq etc) I know it might sound like a dumb question but we are running out of solutions here! :(:confused:
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] melkor88:
i had this issue with every gb based firm. also with cyanogen made by codeworks... i tried with xkb3 modem and with lubkb1 (my original modem)...in froyo everything works fine.

EDIT:

maybe it doesnt have anything to do with this issue but, everyone that has late notifications, in which band does the issue actually happens?

for me is in WCDMA 1900 BAND 2... and everytime i install a new firm i restore my efs folder.

at least more information would not hurt ( you can check in *#0011#)
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] loSconosciuto:
Try this command from adb shell:

getprop ro.ril.disable.power.collapse

and check its value. If it's 1 or the command won't show any output (in this case however I think the value is 0) edit your /system/build.prop file and add this line (or edit the existing one if there's):

ro.ril.disable.power.collapse=0

then reboot your phone and see if notifications work.

ro.ril.disable.power.collapse=0 cause more battery drain, but simply because it won't disable your data connection when screen is off. I saw this value changed in many build.prop and when yesterday I tried to add it to mine I noticed that after only few minutes with screen turned off I had no push notifications.
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] arindammanidas:
I have already tried that with all possible values... nothing works.

http://xdaforums.com/showpost.php?p=19735269&postcount=186
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] luiseteyo:
I am a completely noob, but If I can make something, help with something or test something to fix this, that would be great...
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] melkor88:
@luiseteyo which is the band used in spain and the one you are using?
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] luiseteyo:
Now I am using XXKPQ as the most of the people in the spanish forum
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] manuelmagix:
@melkor88

in Gsm 900

in Wcdma 2100

Saludos.
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] loSconosciuto:
Try to disable "Fast dormancy": *#9900#

I'm guessing. Fast dormancy depends on you mobile network operator and that would explain why for some users notifications work and for others not.
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] manuelmagix:
I think that's not the way.

because:

Froyo: Great

Gingebread: bad.
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] melkor88:
@manuelmagix i was asking because in my country the used bands are 850 and 1900. both are not used in the gb firms released by samsung by now or so i think. so i thougth that the people not receiving push notifications by 3g was because of that...but that was only a guess
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] luiseteyo:
@DooMLoRD, notifications DO work on the CM7.1 that waleedq is doing... Hope that's helpful
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] manuelmagix:
last new :D:D:D

Kpq + kernel "codeworkx" == ok
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] jaskiratsingh:
Are you referring to codeworx recovery 5.0.2.6? If no, can you share the kernel link?
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] manuelmagix:
Yes, only one problem, WI FI does not work with KPQ (yes, it works for kpm, because codeworkx´s kenel is based in kpm),

http://xdaforums.com/showthread.php?t=1311983
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] jaskiratsingh:
Does the device go into deep sleep with this kernel?
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] manuelmagix:
Sorry for not responding earlier, but last days in the Spanish forum, we are testing other possibilities, and it seems that we are on the right.
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] jaskiratsingh:
Can you share other possibilities?
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] fengjia1313:
ANY NEW?......
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] mzone1510:
So what you are saying is that KPM + Codeworkx kernel = push notifications, wifi working perfectly? :confused: Please confirm this so we can try it out! :)
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] manuelmagix:
This is right combination, tested in the Spanish forum.

is based on the combination of the new fw of Movistar and Kernel V4

http://www.htcmania.com/showthread.php?p=3284387#post3284387
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] jaskiratsingh:
Which governor and IO scheduler are you using?
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] manuelmagix:
plz, check this post http://xdaforums.com/showthread.php?p=20033416 , my friend @luiseteyo talks about it.
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] fengjia1313:
luiseteyo

can share #9 file?

http://www.htcmania.com/showthread.php?t=299820

He is to prevent deep sleep?
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] jaskiratsingh:
The file is available at location:

http://www.multiupload.com/L4YYM9JC6S
[Samsung Galaxy SL i9003] fengjia1313:
Thank you and I test