[Galaxy S II General] It_ler:
Results for SpeedMod / Phenomenal / Siyah / N.E.A.K. / Dorimanx / stock kernels

Everything is specific to my phone, my "normal" usage and my home location. Most values are exact results, but some are rounded. I usually have wifi, synch (three email accounts, calendar and news), Google Talk and Skype on.

For all custom kernels, I was running on ICS XWLP8 „Frankenstein“ ROM.

For stock kernels, I was running on the corresponding stock ROM.

Always using the Samsung's standard / stock 1650mAh battery.

For all kernels, I have changed nothing - just default settings.

I flashed stock XWLPD ROM (NEE version + my "old" OXA CSC => XEU + CF-Root kernel for XWLPD) and added its results.

Here are my current results:

Benchmarks

[B]Quadrant Standard 2.0 (best of 3 runs)[/B]

SpeedMod K3-17: 4398
N.E.A.K v2.0.3: 4372
Phenomenal 5.3: 4362
Phenomenal 5.0: 4303
SpeedMod K3-11: 4295
SpeedMod K3-15: 4260
Stock XWLPD kernel: 4257
Dorimanix v2.0: 4242
SpeedMod K3-18: 4206
N.E.A.K v2.0.4: 4195
Phenomenal 5.1: 4181
SpeedMod K3-16: 4179
Stock XWLP3 kernel: 4153
Siyah v3.2.4: 4134
Stock XWLP7 kernel: 4131
Stock XWLP8 kernel: 4110
Siyah v3.2beta8: 4106
Stock XXLPS kernel: 4100
Siyah v3.1: 4099
Siyah v3.2rc1: 4088
Siyah v3.2.3: 4080
Siyah v3.2: 4075
Stock XXLPQ kernel: 4063
Stock XWLP4 kernel: 4046
Siyah v3.2.1: 4021

[B]NenaMark2 (best of 3 runs)[/B]

Stock XILA2 kernel: 54,3
Stock XWLA4 kernel: 54,2
Dorimanix v2.0: 52,7
SpeedMod K3-16: 52,4
N.E.A.K v2.0.3: 52,4
SpeedMod K3-18: 52,2
SpeedMod K3-17: 52,2
SpeedMod K3-15: 52,2
SpeedMod K3-11: 52,2
Stock XWLPD kernel: 52,1
Stock XWLP8 kernel: 52,1
Siyah v3.1: 52,0
Stock XWLP7 kernel: 52,0
Stock XWLP3 kernel: 51,9
Stock XXLPQ kernel: 51,3
Siyah v3.2rc1: 50,9
Siyah v3.2beta8: 50,9
Stock XXLPS kernel: 50,9
Stock XWLP4 kernel: 50,8
Siyah v3.2: 50,6
Siyah v3.2.4: 50,3
Siyah v3.2.3: 50,0
Siyah v3.2.1: 49,9
N.E.A.K v2.0.4: 49,5
Stock XWKK5 kernel: 47,8
Stock XWKK2 kernel: 47,6
Phenomenal 5.0: 42,1
Stock XWKL1 kernel: 38,1
Phenomenal 5.1: 34,2
Phenomenal 5.3: 34,1

[B]Vellamo (best of 2 runs)[/B]

Dorimanix v2.0: 1308
N.E.A.K v2.0.3: 1303
Stock XXLPS kernel: 1303
Stock XWLP3 kernel: 1285
Stock XWLP8 kernel: 1281
Stock XWLPD kernel: 1277
SpeedMod K3-15: 1274
Stock XWLP7 kernel: 1270
Siyah v3.1: 1256
SpeedMod K3-11: 1252
SpeedMod K3-18: 1249
Stock XXLPQ kernel: 1247
Siyah v3.2: 1242
Phenomenal 5.0: 1234
N.E.A.K v2.0.4: 1227
Stock XILA2 kernel: 1225
Siyah v3.2beta8: 1220
Stock XWLA4 kernel: 1216
Phenomenal 5.3: 1194
SpeedMod K3-16: 1186
Siyah v3.2.4: 1178
Stock XWKL1 kernel: 1173
SpeedMod K3-17: 1170
Phenomenal 5.1: 1170
Siyah v3.2rc1: 1166
Stock XWKK5 kernel: 1160
Stock XWLP4 kernel: 1133
Siyah v3.2.1: 1100
Siyah v3.2.3: 1083
Stock XWKK2 kernel: 1080

[B]Linpack (best of 10 runs): Single / Multi thread[/B]

Stock XWLA4 kernel: 57.816 / 93.548
Stock XILA2 kernel: 57.302 / 91.667
N.E.A.K v2.0.3: 48.097 / 83.087
N.E.A.K v2.0.4: 48.015 / 82.558
SpeedMod K3-16: 48.125 / 81.798
Phenomenal 5.3: 47.987 / 81.679
Stock XWLPD kernel: 47.606 / 81.207
SpeedMod K3-15: 47.960 / 81.090
SpeedMod K3-18: 48.070 / 80.973
Stock XXLPS kernel: 47.203 / 80.586
Dorimanix v2.0: 48.070 / 80.509
SpeedMod K3-11: 47.177 / 80.432
SpeedMod K3-17: 48.097 / 80.356
Stock XWLP3 kernel: 48.015 / 80.317
Stock XWLP8 kernel: 48.152 / 80.203
Phenomenal 5.0: 47.498 / 80.203
Stock XXLPQ kernel: 48.208 / 80.013
Siyah v3.2.4: 48.236 / 79.861
Phenomenal 5.1: 47.606 / 79.748
Stock XWLP4 kernel: 47.660 / 79.635
Siyah v3.2rc1: 48.180 / 79.261
Stock XWLP7 kernel: 48.125 / 79.112
Siyah v3.1: 48.015 / 78.159
Siyah v3.2beta8: 47.390 / 77.052
Siyah v3.2: 47.552 / 75.908
Siyah v3.2.3: 47.498 / 75.365
Siyah v3.2.1: 48.097 / 74.896

[B]CF-Bench (best of 2 runs): Native / Java / Overall score[/B]

Phenomenal 5.1: 11343 / 3656 / 6730
Phenomenal 5.3: 11292 / 3612 / 6684
Stock XWLA4 kernel: 11396 / 3539 / 6681
SpeedMod K3-18: 11308 / 3491 / 6617
SpeedMod K3-16: 11237 / 3533 / 6614
Stock XWLP8 kernel: 11255 / 3397 / 6540
Stock XWLPD kernel: 11263 / 3372 / 6528
SpeedMod K3-11: 11211 / 3395 / 6521
SpeedMod K3-17: 11226 / 3352 / 6501
Phenomenal 5.0: 11038 / 3462 / 6492
Dorimanix v2.0: 11253 / 3310 / 6487
Siyah v3.2.4: 11249 / 3305 / 6482
N.E.A.K v2.0.4: 10920 / 3435 / 6429
Stock XILA2 kernel: 11285 / 3187 / 6426
Siyah v3.2beta8: 11109 / 3287 / 6415
Stock XWLP4 kernel: 10997 / 3338 / 6401
Siyah v3.2: 10994 / 3099 / 6257
Stock XWLP3 kernel: 10795 / 3212 / 6245
Siyah v3.2.3: 10954 / 3105 / 6244
Stock XXLPS kernel: 10791 / 3160 / 6212
SpeedMod K3-15: 10784 / 3097 / 6171
Stock XXLPQ kernel: 10862 / 3044 / 6171
Siyah v3.2.1: 10882 / 3001 / 6153
Siyah v3.1: 10617 / 3131 / 6125
Siyah v3.2rc1: 10839 / 2867 / 6055
N.E.A.K v2.0.3: 10485 / 2917 / 5944
Stock XWLP7 kernel: 10354 / 2901 / 5882

[B]AnTuTu (1st run)[/B]

Stock XWLPD kernel: 6231
Stock XWLP8 kernel: 6217
Stock XILA2 kernel: 6110
Stock XWLP3 kernel: 6109
Siyah v3.2.1: 6106
Siyah v3.1: 6082
Stock XXLPQ kernel: 6075
Siyah v3.2.4: 6036
Siyah v3.2beta8: 6033
Stock XWLA4 kernel: 6009
Stock XWLP4 kernel: 5941
Stock XXLPS kernel: 5912
Siyah v3.2: 5853
Siyah v3.2.3: 5848
Dorimanix v2.0: 5627
Stock XWLP7 kernel: 5496
Siyah v3.2rc1: 5432
N.E.A.K v2.0.4: 4932
Phenomenal 5.3: 4920
Phenomenal 5.1: 4907
SpeedMod K3-11: 4827
SpeedMod K3-16: 4815
SpeedMod K3-18: 4811
Phenomenal 5.0: 4805
SpeedMod K3-17: 4803
SpeedMod K3-15: 4608
N.E.A.K v2.0.3: 4304

Battery stats

[B]Night use (wifi, synch, Talk and Skype on)[/B]

Phenomenal 5.1 Extreme: Battery loss of 0,77% per hour, Awake: 6,7%, Deep sleep: 93%
XWLPD: Battery loss of 0,80% per hour, Awake: 5,7%, Deep sleep: 94%
Siyah v3.2: Battery loss of 0,84% per hour, Awake: 6,1%, Deep sleep: 93%
Siyah v3.2.4: Battery loss of 0,87% per hour, Awake: 5,6%, Deep sleep: 94%
N.E.A.K. v2.0.4: Battery loss of 0,87% per hour, Awake: 6,3%, Deep sleep: 93%
Siyah v3.2.3: Battery loss of 0,89% per hour, Awake: 5,8%, Deep sleep: 94%
Siyah v3.2.1: Battery loss of 0,89% per hour, Awake: 5,9%, Deep sleep: 93%
XWLP3: Battery loss of 0,89% per hour, Awake: 6,6%, Deep sleep: 93%
SpeedMod K3-17: Battery loss of 0,90% per hour, Awake: 5,9%, Deep sleep: 94%
Phenomenal 5.3 Extreme: Battery loss of 0,90% per hour, Awake: 6,9%, Deep sleep: 91%
Siyah v3.1: Battery loss of 0,90% per hour, Awake: 6,9%, Deep sleep: 93%
SpeedMod K3-15: Battery loss of 0,91% per hour, Awake: 6,8%, Deep sleep: 93%
XXLPQ: Battery loss of 0,92% per hour, Awake: 7,0%, Deep sleep: 91%
N.E.A.K. v2.0.3: Battery loss of 0,94% per hour, Awake: 6,5%, Deep sleep: 93%
XWLA4: Battery loss of 0,95% per hour, Awake: 9,2%, Deep sleep: 90%
XWLP8: Battery loss of 0,96% per hour, Awake: 7,2%, Deep sleep: 91%
XWLP7: Battery loss of 0,96% per hour, Awake: 6,8%, Deep sleep: 90%
SpeedMod K3-11: Battery loss of 0,98% per hour, Awake: 6,7%, Deep sleep: 93%
SpeedMod K3-18: Battery loss of 0,99% per hour, Awake: 7,6%, Deep sleep: 92%
SpeedMod K3-16: Battery loss of 0,99% per hour, Awake: 7,1%, Deep sleep: 92%
XWLP4: Battery loss of 1,01% per hour, Awake: 7,7%, Deep sleep: 91%
XXLPS: Battery loss of 1,05% per hour, Awake: 7,6%, Deep sleep: 91%
XILA2: Battery loss of 1,09% per hour, Awake: 6,5%, Deep sleep: 91%
XWKK5: Battery loss of 1,09% per hour, Awake: 11,6%, Deep sleep: 88%
XWKK2: Battery loss of 1,44% per hour, Awake: 9,9%, Deep sleep: 89%

[B]Mixed (day and night) usage (*)[/B]

XWLPD: Battery loss of 1,67% per hour, Wifi: 100%, Awake: 15,7%, Deep sleep: 84%, Screen: 10,5% => loss*(1-screen): 1,49%
Phenomenal 5.1 Extreme: Battery loss of 1,73% per hour, Wifi: 100%, Awake: 18,5%, Deep sleep: 81%, Screen: 10,5% => loss*(1-screen): 1,55%
Phenomenal 5.3 Extreme: Battery loss of 1,87% per hour, Wifi: 100%, Awake: 18,2%, Deep sleep: 81%, Screen: 9,7% => loss*(1-screen): 1,69%
XWLP3: Battery loss of 1,91% per hour, Wifi: 89,1%, Awake: 16,9%, Deep sleep: 83%, Screen: 10,3% => loss*(1-screen): 1,71%
XXLPS: Battery loss of 1,94% per hour, Wifi: 100%, Awake: 18,0%, Deep sleep: 81%, Screen: 11,5% => loss*(1-screen): 1,72%
SpeedMod K3-16: Battery loss of 2,04% per hour, Wifi: 100%, Awake: 17,8%, Deep sleep: 82%, Screen: 11,1% => loss*(1-screen): 1,81%
SpeedMod K3-18: Battery loss of 2,04% per hour, Wifi: 100%, Awake: 18,6%, Deep sleep: 81%, Screen: 10,4% => loss*(1-screen): 1,83%
SpeedMod K3-17: Battery loss of 2,04% per hour, Wifi: 100%, Awake: 17,5%, Deep sleep: 82%, Screen: 10,1% => loss*(1-screen): 1,83%
SpeedMod K3-11: Battery loss of 2,08% per hour, Wifi: 100%, Awake: 18,8%, Deep sleep: 81%, Screen: 11,3% => loss*(1-screen): 1,84%
XWLP8: Battery loss of 2,10% per hour, Wifi: 100%, Awake: 18,0%, Deep sleep: 81%, Screen: 11,3% => loss*(1-screen): 1,86%
Siyah v3.1: Battery loss of 2,10% per hour, Wifi: 100%, Awake: 18,5%, Deep sleep: 81%, Screen: 9,9% => loss*(1-screen): 1,89%
XWLA4: Battery loss of 2,19% per hour, Wifi: 100%, Awake: 19,6%, Deep sleep: 80%, Screen: 10,2% => loss*(1-screen): 1,97%
Siyah v3.2.4: Battery loss of 2,25% per hour, Wifi: 100%, Awake: 19,6%, Deep sleep: 80%, Screen: 11,4% => loss*(1-screen): 1,99%
N.E.A.K. v2.0.4: Battery loss of 2,26% per hour, Wifi: 78,1%, Awake: 15,9%, Deep sleep: 79%, Screen: 10,1% => loss*(1-screen): 2,03%
Siyah v3.2.3: Battery loss of 2,29% per hour, Wifi: 100%, Awake: 17,6%, Deep sleep: 82%, Screen: 11,1% => loss*(1-screen): 2,04%
Siyah v3.2.1: Battery loss of 2,29% per hour, Wifi: 100%, Awake: 19,8%, Deep sleep: 80%, Screen: 10,8% => loss*(1-screen): 2,04%
XWLP7: Battery loss of 2,31% per hour, Wifi: 75,8%, Awake: 17,3%, Deep sleep: 82%, Screen: 9,7% => loss*(1-screen): 2,09%
XILA2: Battery loss of 2,42% per hour, Wifi: 100%, Awake: 18,2%, Deep sleep: 81%, Screen: 9,0% => loss*(1-screen): 2,20%
XWKK2: Battery loss of 2,37% per hour, Wifi: 81,9%, Awake: 17,4%, Deep sleep: 82%, Screen: 5,9% => loss*(1-screen): 2,23%
XWKK5: Battery loss of 2,58% per hour, Wifi: 96,1%, Awake: 19,5%, Deep sleep: 80%, Screen: 9,0% => loss*(1-screen): 2,35%
XXLPQ: Battery loss of 2,71% per hour, Wifi: 100%, Awake: 19,7%, Deep sleep: 80%, Screen: 10,7% => loss*(1-screen): 2,42%
N.E.A.K. v2.0.3: Battery loss of 2,75% per hour, Wifi: 100%, Awake: 18,8%, Deep sleep: 79%, Screen: 10,8% => loss*(1-screen): 2,45%
SpeedMod K3-15: Battery loss of 3,00% per hour, Wifi: 100%, Awake: 19,7%, Deep sleep: 80%, Screen: 11,9% => loss*(1-screen): 2,64%
Siyah v3.2: Battery loss of 3,35% per hour, Wifi: 91,2%, Awake: 17,3%, Deep sleep: 82%, Screen: 10,8% => loss*(1-screen): 2,99%

[B](*)[/B] In order to get a value, which allows to compare test results with different screen on times for mixed usage battery tests, I tried to „normalized“ the battery loss per hour with the following formula:
[U]loss*(1-screen):[/U] battery loss in % (per hours) * (100% - screen on time in %)
So, it would be the battery loss in % (per hour) for the screen off time.
That is how a kernel with the same battery loss per hour will get a better/lower value, if it has more screen on time. (And the other way round.)

XWLPD will become my new base ROM for further kernel tests.

It is very stable, very smooth and has best battery life on my phone.