[Galaxy S II General] It_ler:
Results for SpeedMod / Phenomenal / Siyah / N.E.A.K. / stock kernels

Everything is specific to my phone, my "normal" usage and my home location. Most values are exact results, but some are rounded. I usually have wifi, synch (three email accounts, calendar and news), Google Talk and Skype on.

For all custom kernels, I was running on ICS XWLPD (stock) ROM.

For stock kernels, I was running on the corresponding stock ROM.

Always using the Samsung's standard / stock 1650mAh battery.

For all kernels, I have changed nothing - just default settings.

I flashed XWLPF Frankenstein ROM (with CF-Root kernel for XWLPF) and added its results.

Here are my current results:

Benchmarks

[B]Quadrant Standard 2.0 (best of 3 runs)[/B]

Phenomenal 5.3: 4355
Stock XWLPD kernel: 4257
N.E.A.K v2.0.4 (XWLP8): 4195
Stock XWLP3 kernel: 4153
Siyah v3.2.4 (XWLP8): 4134
Stock XWLP7 kernel: 4131
Stock XWLP8 kernel: 4110
Stock XXLPS kernel: 4100
Stock XXLPQ kernel: 4063
Stock XWLP4 kernel: 4046

[B]Quadrant Standard 2.1 (best of 3 runs)[/B]

Phenomenal 5.4: 4304
SpeedMod K3-19: 4291
Stock XWLPF kernel: 4197
Phenomenal 5.3: 4179
Stock XWLPD kernel: 4067

[B]NenaMark2 (best of 3 runs)[/B]

Stock XILA2 kernel: 54,3
Stock XWLA4 kernel: 54,2
SpeedMod K3-19: 52,1
Stock XWLPD kernel: 52,1
Stock XWLP8 kernel: 52,1
Stock XWLP7 kernel: 52,0
Stock XWLP3 kernel: 51,9
Stock XWLPF kernel: 51,8
Stock XXLPQ kernel: 51,3
Stock XXLPS kernel: 50,9
Stock XWLP4 kernel: 50,8
Siyah v3.2.4 (XWLP8): 50,3
N.E.A.K v2.0.4 (XWLP8): 49,5
Stock XWKK5 kernel: 47,8
Stock XWKK2 kernel: 47,6
Stock XWKL1 kernel: 38,1
Phenomenal 5.3: 34,3
Phenomenal 5.4: 34,2

[B]Vellamo (best of 2 runs)[/B]

Stock XXLPS kernel: 1303
SpeedMod K3-19: 1297
Stock XWLP3 kernel: 1285
Stock XWLP8 kernel: 1281
Stock XWLPD kernel: 1277
Phenomenal 5.4: 1275
Stock XWLP7 kernel: 1270
Stock XXLPQ kernel: 1247
N.E.A.K v2.0.4 (XWLP8): 1227
Stock XWLPF kernel: 1226
Stock XILA2 kernel: 1225
Stock XWLA4 kernel: 1216
Phenomenal 5.3: 1190
Siyah v3.2.4 (XWLP8): 1178
Stock XWKL1 kernel: 1173
Stock XWKK5 kernel: 1160
Stock XWLP4 kernel: 1133
Stock XWKK2 kernel: 1080

[B]Linpack (best of 10 runs): Single / Multi thread[/B]

Stock XWLA4 kernel: 57.816 / 93.548
Stock XILA2 kernel: 57.302 / 91.667
N.E.A.K v2.0.4 (XWLP8): 48.015 / 82.558
Stock XWLPD kernel: 47.606 / 81.207
SpeedMod K3-19: 47.932 / 81.012
Phenomenal 5.3: 48.097 / 80.779
Stock XWLPF kernel: 47.960 / 80.740
Phenomenal 5.4: 48.125 / 80.586
Stock XXLPS kernel: 47.203 / 80.586
Stock XWLP3 kernel: 48.015 / 80.317
Stock XWLP8 kernel: 48.152 / 80.203
Stock XXLPQ kernel: 48.208 / 80.013
Siyah v3.2.4 (XWLP8): 48.236 / 79.861
Stock XWLP4 kernel: 47.660 / 79.635
Stock XWLP7 kernel: 48.125 / 79.112

[B]CF-Bench (best of 2 runs): Native / Java / Overall score[/B]

Stock XWLA4 kernel: 11396 / 3539 / 6681
Phenomenal 5.4: 11353 / 3563 / 6679
Phenomenal 5.3: 11379 / 3484 / 6642
SpeedMod K3-19: 11271 / 3483 / 6598
Stock XWLP8 kernel: 11255 / 3397 / 6540
Stock XWLPD kernel: 11263 / 3372 / 6528
Siyah v3.2.4 (XWLP8): 11249 / 3305 / 6482
N.E.A.K v2.0.4 (XWLP8): 10920 / 3435 / 6429
Stock XILA2 kernel: 11285 / 3187 / 6426
Stock XWLP4 kernel: 10997 / 3338 / 6401
Stock XWLPF kernel: 10899 / 3247 / 6307
Stock XWLP3 kernel: 10795 / 3212 / 6245
Stock XXLPS kernel: 10791 / 3160 / 6212
Stock XXLPQ kernel: 10862 / 3044 / 6171
Stock XWLP7 kernel: 10354 / 2901 / 5882

[B]AnTuTu (1st run)[/B]

Stock XWLPF kernel: 6237
Stock XWLPD kernel: 6231
Stock XWLP8 kernel: 6217
Stock XILA2 kernel: 6110
Stock XWLP3 kernel: 6109
Stock XXLPQ kernel: 6075
Siyah v3.2.4 (XWLP8): 6036
Stock XWLA4 kernel: 6009
Stock XWLP4 kernel: 5941
Stock XXLPS kernel: 5912
Stock XWLP7 kernel: 5496
N.E.A.K v2.0.4 (XWLP8): 4932
Phenomenal 5.4: 4916
Phenomenal 5.3: 4910
SpeedMod K3-19: 4836

Battery stats

[B]Night use (wifi, synch, Talk and Skype on)[/B]

Phenomenal 5.3 Extreme: Battery loss of 0,77% per hour, Awake: 5,9%, Deep sleep: 93%
XWLPD: Battery loss of 0,80% per hour, Awake: 5,7%, Deep sleep: 94%
SpeedMod K3-19: Battery loss of 0,84% per hour, Awake: 6,1%, Deep sleep: 93%
Phenomenal 5.4 Extreme: Battery loss of 0,86% per hour, Awake: 6,7%, Deep sleep: 93%
Siyah v3.2.4 (XWLP8): Battery loss of 0,87% per hour, Awake: 5,6%, Deep sleep: 94%
N.E.A.K. v2.0.4 (XWLP8): Battery loss of 0,87% per hour, Awake: 6,3%, Deep sleep: 93%
XWLP3: Battery loss of 0,89% per hour, Awake: 6,6%, Deep sleep: 93%
XXLPQ: Battery loss of 0,92% per hour, Awake: 7,0%, Deep sleep: 91%
XWLA4: Battery loss of 0,95% per hour, Awake: 9,2%, Deep sleep: 90%
XWLP8: Battery loss of 0,96% per hour, Awake: 7,2%, Deep sleep: 91%
XWLP7: Battery loss of 0,96% per hour, Awake: 6,8%, Deep sleep: 90%
XWLPF: Battery loss of 0,97% per hour, Awake: 6,5%, Deep sleep: 93%
XWLP4: Battery loss of 1,01% per hour, Awake: 7,7%, Deep sleep: 91%
XXLPS: Battery loss of 1,05% per hour, Awake: 7,6%, Deep sleep: 91%
XILA2: Battery loss of 1,09% per hour, Awake: 6,5%, Deep sleep: 91%
XWKK5: Battery loss of 1,09% per hour, Awake: 11,6%, Deep sleep: 88%
XWKK2: Battery loss of 1,44% per hour, Awake: 9,9%, Deep sleep: 89%

[B]Mixed (day and night) usage (*)[/B]

Phenomenal 5.3 Extreme: Battery loss of 1,65% per hour, Wifi: 100%, Awake: 16,9%, Deep sleep: 83%, Screen: 10,6% => loss*(1-screen): 1,48%
XWLPD: Battery loss of 1,67% per hour, Wifi: 100%, Awake: 15,7%, Deep sleep: 84%, Screen: 10,5% => loss*(1-screen): 1,49%
Phenomenal 5.4 Extreme: Battery loss of 1,66% per hour, Wifi: 100%, Awake: 16%, Deep sleep: 84%, Screen: 8,6% => loss*(1-screen): 1,52%
XWLP3: Battery loss of 1,91% per hour, Wifi: 89,1%, Awake: 16,9%, Deep sleep: 83%, Screen: 10,3% => loss*(1-screen): 1,71%
XXLPS: Battery loss of 1,94% per hour, Wifi: 100%, Awake: 18,0%, Deep sleep: 81%, Screen: 11,5% => loss*(1-screen): 1,72%
XWLPF: Battery loss of 2,03% per hour, Wifi: 100%, Awake: 16,5%, Deep sleep: 83%, Screen: 9,6% => loss*(1-screen): 1,84%
XWLP8: Battery loss of 2,10% per hour, Wifi: 100%, Awake: 18,0%, Deep sleep: 81%, Screen: 11,3% => loss*(1-screen): 1,86%
XWLA4: Battery loss of 2,19% per hour, Wifi: 100%, Awake: 19,6%, Deep sleep: 80%, Screen: 10,2% => loss*(1-screen): 1,97%
Siyah v3.2.4 (XWLP8): Battery loss of 2,25% per hour, Wifi: 100%, Awake: 19,6%, Deep sleep: 80%, Screen: 11,4% => loss*(1-screen): 1,99%
SpeedMod K3-19: Battery loss of 2,30% per hour, Wifi: 100%, Awake: 19,0%, Deep sleep: 81%, Screen: 11,6% => loss*(1-screen): 2,03%
N.E.A.K. v2.0.4 (XWLP8): Battery loss of 2,26% per hour, Wifi: 78,1%, Awake: 15,9%, Deep sleep: 79%, Screen: 10,1% => loss*(1-screen): 2,03%
XWLP7: Battery loss of 2,31% per hour, Wifi: 75,8%, Awake: 17,3%, Deep sleep: 82%, Screen: 9,7% => loss*(1-screen): 2,09%
XILA2: Battery loss of 2,42% per hour, Wifi: 100%, Awake: 18,2%, Deep sleep: 81%, Screen: 9,0% => loss*(1-screen): 2,20%
XWKK2: Battery loss of 2,37% per hour, Wifi: 81,9%, Awake: 17,4%, Deep sleep: 82%, Screen: 5,9% => loss*(1-screen): 2,23%
XWKK5: Battery loss of 2,58% per hour, Wifi: 96,1%, Awake: 19,5%, Deep sleep: 80%, Screen: 9,0% => loss*(1-screen): 2,35%
XXLPQ: Battery loss of 2,71% per hour, Wifi: 100%, Awake: 19,7%, Deep sleep: 80%, Screen: 10,7% => loss*(1-screen): 2,42%

[B](*)[/B] In order to get a value, which allows to compare test results with different screen on times for mixed usage battery tests, I tried to „normalized“ the battery loss per hour with the following formula:
[U]loss*(1-screen):[/U] battery loss in % (per hours) * (100% - screen on time in %)
So, it would be the battery loss in % (per hour) for the screen off time.
That is how a kernel with the same battery loss per hour will get a better/lower value, if it has more screen on time. (And the other way round.)

XWLPF is very stable, smooth and has good battery life on my phone.

It is as smooth as XWLPD, but has a little bit worse battery life for my "normal" usage.

So, I will restore my nandroid backup of my former XWLPD system and continue kernel testings.