yashsingh1/xdaforums huggingface dataset:
[Galaxy S II Accessories] brutoid:
Applied my Ultra Crystal a couple of days ago now and whilst it is a nice clear screen with an awesome fit, i can't help be slightly unimpressed with the amount of finger smears and prints that get left on it. Maybe its just my fingers?!

It will stay on for the length of time it takes for my Ultra Oli pack to turn up!
[Galaxy S II Accessories] gangster429:
don't buy cheap one

I bought cheap one and it was jest discusting.

The one I recieved from case-mate with my case is superior compared to the cheap one
[Galaxy S II Accessories] koahhe:
Do the martin fields ones give a grainy effect like the sgp oleo? Just applied them few minutes ago and i am very disappointed with how cheap the screen looks now. And really don't understand why so many people are happy with them
[Galaxy S II Accessories] comosa:
Using an SGP Ultra Crystal. Feels great to use almost like having no protector on but as already mentioned here prone to smears.
[Galaxy S II Accessories] darkodin14:
My bestskinsever screen protector shipped. I will apply it and respond back with pics and a review of it. Hope it will be good.
[Galaxy S II Accessories] chobie:
You mean the SGP Oleo gives the image on the screen a multicoloured grain or is it only the texture when swiping that's grainy?
[Galaxy S II Accessories] koahhe:
Yes, the SGP Oleo give the screen a multicoloured grain. And it looks bad especially on white background. They absolutely destroy the beautiful screen experience

Edit: That was because the 'clever' me forgot to take the second protective layer. And there's no more grain effect now :)
[Galaxy S II Accessories] chobie:
Wow. I was gonna buy it because I had this problem on the screen protector that came with Pleomax.

I bought some clear generic ones on eBay for cheaps. :D
[Galaxy S II Accessories] icehot666:
I can't see a grainy effect, that doesn't mean you won't be able to though so I don't want to say for certain but I've got good eyesite and think it's as if the screen protector is not even on the phone. I showed it to a friend the other day who last used a screen protector about 2 years ago and said he took it off cos they're rubbish, feel bad and the screens look bad etc (don't think he ever did any research and just bought a cheapy one tbh). He said "wow, I can't even see it, maybe I should have spent a bit more and bought a martin fields, it even feels like the proper glass still"...
[Galaxy S II Accessories] koahhe:
Thanks. I will give them a try
[Galaxy S II Accessories] oofol:
Maby thsts a stupid question but why the heck do U lads need the protectors with gorillaglass on bord? Iam really happy that I do not need tham anymore:-)
[Galaxy S II Accessories] chobie:
This has been said many times and I'll say it again, gorilla glass is scratch resistant, not scratch proof. A tiny grain of sand can still scratch your screen.
[Galaxy S II Accessories] Sleepycat3:
I'll be looking out for when you start a thread that Gorilla Glass is crap and that you have scratched it.:p
[Galaxy S II Accessories] thawizard:
please do tell us when your girlfriend/wife gets mad at you and scratch your phone with the diamond ring you bought for her. ;)

actually, there's a quite detailed explanation how gorilla glass is compared to other materials and i'm sad that you did not read it yet. go there and read now.
[Galaxy S II Accessories] oofol:
thawizard that was really informative:)

How ever lads, I'm not the kind who is not watching hes precious;p

When I'm selling my phones they'r looking mint.

When it comes to my fionce - shes got the SGS and shes carrying it in her hand bag - ya know the ladies hand bags for sure;p - and it's preatty good on without any scratches on the screen;)

I won't get a screen protector because the safety that gorillaglass is offering is much than enough for me - I do wear my sammy all the time secure:)

How ever thank's for Your interest!:D
[Galaxy S II Accessories] rocketpaul:
just got the ultra oleophobic and its brilliant. Its like the screen is naked and it feels great compared to my cheap ebay one.
[Galaxy S II Accessories] jjwatmyself:
Inappropriate response deleted :eek:
[Galaxy S II Accessories] chobie:
^inappropriate.

Anyways, I'm getting mixed reviews from Oleophobic. Some say it produces multicoloured grain and others say it's as if it wasn't even there? :confused:
[Galaxy S II Accessories] Gavin.csy:
It does produce a multi colored grain, i'm using it. I think what they mean about 'it not being there' is the SP is very clear once applied you can't see there is an SP applied, it's like the glass itself
[Galaxy S II Accessories] superutp:
its overall a brilliant SP except for the slight rainbow effect sometimes....
[Galaxy S II Accessories] SirM2X:
I could get an Ultra Crystal within a day or so as someone here has some in stock.

Is it recommended? How's the Ultra Crystal under the sun?
[Galaxy S II Accessories] Frankie_99:
SGP Stenheil Ultra Optic is good.
[Galaxy S II Accessories] burnzedy:
I've got the SGP Ultra Optic from export privé...

The good:

Very very easy to install.

No more smudges on the screen.

A lot less reflections too.

The feel which is kinda "silky" smooth and is really nice even though it felt strange at the beginning.

The bad:

The whites are a bit dulled.

There seems to be some kind of texture on the image...

You may see that it is there since it is not completely transparent..

Verdict

Guilty of doing what it is supposed to do!
[Galaxy S II Accessories] nicpol7:
its nearly perfect..its crystal as the name suggest...and no need to buy the anti fingerprint ones..

fingerprints can be removed from the crystal clear very easily..
[Galaxy S II Accessories] thawizard:
if you have an oleo with rainbow effect, write SGP and you should be able to get a replacement.

simply because they wrote 'no rainbow effect' and '100% warranty' on the packaging cover they sell.
[Galaxy S II Accessories] khein:
So, what SGP screen protector has no grainy effect?

I've already thrown 2 screen protector(Free from Zenus case) due to heavy grainy effect + dimming effect(had to make the brightness 100% to match the 60% brightness before I placed the SP). Although, it was really fingerprint proof.

My main priority for the screen protector is just for an added protection from possible scratching on regular use. So I much as possible I want my display quality and brightness to be the same. It's ok for me if fingerprint resistance/Glare, etc are the same as without the screen protector (hopefully not worse).
[Galaxy S II Accessories] Fall Guy:
Yep got one. It does look like that in person. The body skin is fairly easy to apply though I found that I had to cut a little bit out for the 2nd mic as it almost covered it. The screen protector that comes with it feels okay and is clear with the screen on. With the screen off it has a slightly mottled look from the side but not face on. Took quite a few attempts to get it right as the fit wasn`t perfect regarding the ff cam
[Galaxy S II Accessories] Pacifiste95:
So, what is the best screen protector? :)

I don't have enough time for read 65 pages.. :D
[Galaxy S II Accessories] Pfeffernuss:
Just change your settings. I only have 14 pages. Good luck.
[Galaxy S II Accessories] Dimer81:
QUOTING chobie

So I just installed a matte screen protector that came with my Pleomax case. However, my screen looks grainy now, somewhat how the screen will look after a wet install of a screen protector. (wth grainy multicolored dots)

Will this improve soon? Do I have to wait for a day or so for it to settle or clear up? It's a dry install by the way and it looks terrible against whites.

ye, the matte SP are great against finger prints but i too have those annoying grainy multicolored dots, Pleomax SP.....

How are case mate SPs that they bundle in their cases, specifically safe skin?

Also wondering about SGP Ultra Crystal. Won't have those pesky multicolored dots?
[Galaxy S II Accessories] cmd512:
Avoid the Ultra Optics, super matte grainy effect. Going to try the Oleophobic next, supposed to be clearer.
[Galaxy S II Accessories] jjwatmyself:
I'm going on about 6 weeks on the oleo and very happy. I have a couple of surface dings that just go to show it is doing its job but it really is holding up great. Needs a good wipe here and there with something that is grease free. If it is greasy and you have something white you see some rainbow effect bit it's the grease doing it and not the protector in my opinion.
[Galaxy S II Accessories] chobie:
I think bundled are Ultra Crystals. You wont have any multicoloured grain problems with them.
[Galaxy S II Accessories] kotaro_14:
Try this http://cgi.ebay.com/SAMSUNG-GALAXY-S-II-2-ANTIFINGER-PRINT-SCREEN-PROTECTOR-/320725168821?pt=PDA_Accessories&hash=item4aacb5b2b5 it's from Korean Made in Japan. As everyone knows Japan products are top notch. Now I haven't tried this one yet, but willing to if Zagg doesn't work. I tried Skinomi http://skinomi.com, they accidentally gave me two. Used one the indentations wouldn't go away. Second one the screen protector was messed up and made rainbows lines on the right side of my screen, still using it waiting for Zagg. True that it doesn't suffer from the orange peel affect and is extremely tough, but if you press with your fingernail on the screen protector, the mark will not go away, so you have to be extremely careful with it. I don't really care for the Orange peel effect, so long as it's scratch proof and tough and isn't memory skin. like the Skinomi.
[Galaxy S II Accessories] Battlefield:
Best SGP screen protector

Hey guys, simple question. Which sp of those listed below is the best? Is there such an answer at all? From what I read I would probably go with Oleophobic, but I might be wrong.

SGP Ultra Optics

SGP Ultra Crystal

SGP Ultra Oleophobic

SGP Ultra Fine
[Galaxy S II Accessories] SirM2X:
Just installed SGP Ultra Crystal yesterday. :cool:

Gonna have to say that it sucks REAL BAD! :(

First of all the only good thing is that it IS crystal clear! You can't tell if it's there. However it's hungry for oil and moisture. I'd like to call it fingerprint super magnet! :rolleyes:

You're not gonna believe it but the Gorilla Glass can withstand more oil than this one. :D

Once it gets dirty, the screen gets a white tint and it's almost impossible to wipe them all off! Tried a micro fiber cloth with Ethanol and they're still visible some how. :(

Second of all, it was kinda nasty to install. I have pretty good experience with applying SPs with different sizes (up to 15" for a laptop display) both wet (like Zagg) and dry and it took me about 2 minutes to get it installed. :p

It had 2 stickers on it. Number 1 and number 2! WITHOUT any additional info on which side is the adhesive side :confused:. So I Googled and found out that the side with the number 2 on it is the adhesive side. Peeled that off and aligned it and used the squeegee to install it. The end result was good but the lack of instructions gave me a headache!

All in all, I don't recommend this one. Haven't tried Ultra Olephobic but I guess that one's the best bet! ;)
[Galaxy S II Accessories] chobie:
I have Ultra Optics on my iPad 2 and from my experience, it doesn't distort the whites with multicoloured grainy dots, unlike the Oleophopic as most users say produces this problem.
[Galaxy S II Accessories] khein:
Thanks for the tip. My martin fields screen protector just arrived, and the only fault I can see is the worse fingerprint resistance compared to the bare gorilla glass of the SGS2. Its very easy to leave a mark and harder to clean when compared with the bare screen of SGS2.
[Galaxy S II Accessories] cmd512:
It's not distorting colors, just gives it a very matte/washed out look. Comparing it side by side to my friend's bare gorilla glass SGSII, it really puts things into perspective how much contrast you are losing with the crappy Ultra Optics screen protector. I'd avoid it at all costs.

Yeah, that's why I'm sure I won't like the Ultra Crystal that came with my SGP case. I think the Oleophobic should be a better balance between the clarity of the Ultra Crystal and fingerprint resistance of Ultra Optics.
[Galaxy S II Accessories] Rekuja:
I have a pretty good protector, it's matching everywhere and it's sitting perfectly on the screen with no bubbles.

The only problem i have is that the damn thing smudges really bad and leaves finger prints everywhere..

is there a way to clean the protector and make it less smudgy? i saw someone mentioned wax lol?
[Galaxy S II Accessories] jjwatmyself:
Diluted alcohol and micro fiber cloth. Also keep it off your face and wash your hands frequently. :D I hear latex gloves help to. LOL!!
[Galaxy S II Accessories] Rekuja:
hahahaha brilliant
[Galaxy S II Accessories] Dimer81:
well, u can't have it all ;)

I've pleomax matte, it's good against finger prints but producing those pesky multicolored dots :(
[Galaxy S II Accessories] angelomaldito:
Well, I've got one of those (SGP Ultra Crystal) and I agree that it's a fingerprint magnet. Indeed, the naked Gorilla glass can withstand better with fingerprints because it has an oleophobic layer. That said, I disagree with all the rest. It's very easy to install and have the best cut (no hole for the front camera what doesn't affect image quality; tightest space possible for the home button). Not so hard to wipe, but I think that the oleophobic may be a good choice regarding the fingerprints, however it is not anti-fingerprint, just fingerprint-resistant. Nevertheless my choice was based on the level of protection offered to the screen. Accordingly to SGP website, the Ultra Crystal is the strongest one, getting less scratches on the film and also more protective to the device in case of accident (but not accident proof!).

I'd avoid the matte type of screen protectors as they have to sacrifice image quality in order to be genuinely anti-fingerprint.
[Galaxy S II Accessories] :
I got mine from Zagg, only screen. Have been using Zagg since my iPhone 2g days.
[Galaxy S II Accessories] chobie:
Yup, you can't have em all. The first time I applied it on my iPad I wanted to take it off. Haha! But I've gotten used to it and at least it lessens the smudges without those multicolored grains.
[Galaxy S II Accessories] angelomaldito:
Today I've found the definitive solution for the fingerprint issue: a decent cloth !!! :D

Seriously, I was struggling to keep my screen clear from those pesky greasy smudges, using those sunglasses' microfibre cloths, alcohol moist cloths, paper tissues, etc., without success. :confused: Now I've got from eBay a microfibre cloth from 3M/Scotch Brite specially designed for lenses which is very good (there are many sellers selling it worldwide, starting from £1+postage in the UK).

I know, it's not the kind of accessory that you all are expecting to get a recommendation, but for me it was the real solution for my screen, on the top of my SGP Ultra Clear film. Now my screen is both ultra clear and ultra clean!!! :cool:
[Galaxy S II Accessories] Rekuja:
Real question is, do we really need a screen protector? i watched a video on youtube and some guy put his galaxy s in a bag with screws and rubbed them together, no scratches at all.. only thing that put a cut on it was the box cutter :\
[Galaxy S II Accessories] angelomaldito:
Yes, definitely we do. Just search the forums and you'll see some sad stories...

Scratch resistant doesn't mean scratch proof !
[Galaxy S II Accessories] Rekuja:
damnit, i have mine on perfectly but the only problem is.. i get the whole rainbow effect when my fingers aren't 100% dry. Apart from that, it's a pretty good protector.
[Galaxy S II Accessories] jamilm9:
I received the ultra oleophobic SGP screen protector today and it very good. I applied it and I can't tell its there. Its a little bit more sticky then the stock screen but it doesn't feel rubbery like ZAGG ones do.
[Galaxy S II Accessories] jjwatmyself:
I am starting to realize I might be a geek. Almost 70 pages of chit chat on screen protectors and I am still subscribed to this thread!!!
[Galaxy S II Accessories] Spong2:
That "stickyness" with the Ultra Ole will disappear within a day or two, and it should start feeling more like the original screen. It appears to be residue from the adhesive used to keep the protective sheet in place.
[Galaxy S II Accessories] monmin:
using 4-way privacy from www.clarivue.com :D :D it's pretty cool actually altho it is making your screen a bit darker
[Galaxy S II Accessories] t00dy:
really, nice! Is it very thick? Mine is quite, home button is quite recessed, and S-curve case just barely fits :S

i got it from ebay, and i'm not happy with it at all. Will write mini review with pics later.
[Galaxy S II Accessories] JuniorGG:
Hi!

I've been using for a month or so, a screen protector that I bought in a store here in Italy. The make is "Phonix". They also produce cases and similar accessories.

Although I believe there are better makes, this protector isn't bad. Hole cuttings match and it's barely visible and easily applicable using its 2 removable layers.

The only "issues" are that it's not oleophobic so it tends to collect fingerprints, but it's just a matter of clenaing it frequently, and it feels just a tad more stickier under your fingertip than optimal.

However it's not that bad.

ONE THING WORRIES ME, HOWEVER:

are we sure that when removed, these screen protectors won't leave any trace on the screen? Are we sure that the oleophobic layer of the screen won't get damaged in the long run, by the permanence of the screen protector?
[Galaxy S II Accessories] mariezk:
In the Netherlands i bought a screen protector by Muvit.

Comes with cleaner and 2 screen covers...works very well and hard to scratch in my opinion.

Cheers!
[Galaxy S II Accessories] shcsha:
I've been using the incredible shield kit from SGP. I believe it comes with an ultra crystal sp. I had been using a cheap ebay sixpack sp for about 2-3 weeks before my sgp kit came.

A few points:

- The home button is not protected by the sp, and is very prone to scratches. i don't believe it is covered with gorilla glass. The incredible shield kit provided me with a bit to cover and protect this part (too bad there are some scratches already).

- This kit does not come with a protector for the camera lens, however, does protect the black textured plastic around the lens. This prevents from scratches (as it contacts the table), as well as makes the lens recessed.

- The Ultra Crystal sp is amazing in terms of screen clarity and tactile feel (fingers glide so well). I do not sweat much at all, and hardly accumulate oil on the screen. Since the sp is scratchproof, i can safely wipe the screen off on my jeans or clothes to get rid of oil.

- 2-3 weeks of cheap ebay screen protector use, and these were already scratched a lot.

- I was able to achieve a very good dust free and perfect fit application by using a camera lens cleaning kit, which has a glass cleaning solution, dust blower and lint free disposable cleaning paper (removing all dust in the first place). Combine this by applying in the bathroom (without needing steam or humidity), and i always get good results on application in a single shot.

- the back cover of the glossy incredible shield provides a very appealing grippy feel (only slightly grippy), but does not accumulate dust either (at least after 2-3 weeks of use). The caveat is that the back covers are a wet application, and can be a bit tricky (but i managed to get it looking perfect using the strategy above).

hope it helps. I highly recommended the incredible shield, ultra gloss (4.0) kit.
[Galaxy S II Accessories] ABC_Universal:
Tried two but decided to not use. My another gorilla glass phone w/o screen protector doesn't have any scratch for six months and counting. So I have a bit more confidence. :p
[Galaxy S II Accessories] Exerqtor:
I use Copter protector and it seems very promising imo.
[Galaxy S II Accessories] hannissis5:
I've had loads of screen protectors of the years but decided not to get one for the last year or so (on iphone 4) because they can look bad in comparison to the glass screen.

I decided to get the*ultra oleophobic SGP*screen*protector. All I can say is wow!

Can't tell its there. Great quality. Will report back in a week or so with a final review. :)
[Galaxy S II Accessories] jjwatmyself:
Yup. Same here. Couple months and mine is still looking great. On the iphone, I would suggest a bumper so the edges don't get abused. My edges are still good, but they are always the first area to go.
[Galaxy S II Accessories] u38966:
SGP Ultra Optics

Got a couple of the SGP Steinheil Ultra optics and wasnt impressed. It did slightly improve the fingerprints over the standard screen, but it felt like running my fingers over a slightly rough surface. If you ran your nail over it you could hear it like a mini washboard!! Very bizarre, dont know if the others are like that? Also noticed the screen seemed a bit dull and it definitely affected the colours, maybe a wee bit blurred at times too.

I ended up with 2 packs and only used 1 protector so they are on the "Bay" at the moment.

Found it strange as they get great write ups and most folk are impressed but I found them a bit weird and unusable. Got a Brando now and it seems fine, smooth and doesnt affect the screen at all. Bit fingerprinty (I realise thats not a word!) but very good when using the phone.

Just thought I'd pass on my experience as I suppose its each to their own.
[Galaxy S II Accessories] ithehappy:
I today received the ScratchGard™ screen protector which I ordered earlier. http://www.scratchgard.in/productdetail.aspx?cid=9&scid=0&bid=17&pid=782. Tried to apply it, messed up completely. There was some damn scratches and prints as I put my fingers on it, tried to wash it but same, so I trashed it. Ordered another one. Won't try to apply it by myself this time as I am bad, sorry, poor in it. But the thing is, it will be 2-3 days till I receive the new one, so in the mean time the screen is without any guard. I won't carry it in that state, but still is there any chance of scratches?

Regards.
[Galaxy S II Accessories] KLoNe1:
Got my BestSkinsEver Full-Body the other day.

Installation I'd marginally easier than ZAGG, but the screen protector is WAY better.

Put the back cover on as well, but liked shocking over the texture & removed it.

Didn't try the edge protectors.
[Galaxy S II Accessories] Rem¡:
I got the same with my muvit smart case. It's perfect! :D
[Galaxy S II Accessories] Warlord_Link:
Just buy Zagg max coverage and waiting to try.
[Galaxy S II Accessories] tbong777:
Been using Realook and like them well enough
[Galaxy S II Accessories] uscool:
thanks alot this thread been very helpfull, i bought cheap protector for mine its good but scratches easy, so been reading here and bought the Samsung i9100 Screen Protectors Film SGP Ultra Crystal from ebay, from korea, im in UK so gotta wait, only thing putting it on wanna get it spot on, cant live with any dust only get 2 so hope to get it right, also does the Samsung i9100 Screen Protectors Film SGP Ultra Crystal scratch easily , my cheap ones seem to scratch , just used fingers and micro fibre cloth and still scratched

Thanks
[Galaxy S II Accessories] nomis_md:
Just got a SGP Steinheil Ultra Oleophobic for my SGS2 as well. I have never been this impressed with a screen protector.

The Ultra Oleophobic is quite smooth but does have a bit more friction than the glass. I presume this is because of the oleophobic coating, but it does not have micro-grooves or a 'washboard' sound when you scrape it, like u38966 said about the Ultra Optics.

As far as the optics of the Ultra Oleophobic it is perfectly clear. I only know it is on because of the faint border as it has been intentionally cut a bit smaller than the actual screen. When you pay for a Super AMOLED Plus screen I don't understand why you would put an anti-glare or other screen protector on it that makes the resolution grainier.

I am perfectly happy with the Ultra Oleophobic.