上海市浦东新区人民法院民 事 判 决 书（2020）沪0115民初39102号М????()Τそ┮カ?穝?チ隔XXX?XXX糽XXX猭﹚旱┚??瞶砆矯╧19829る25らネ?壁?膟猠玭粮?ń??绍?カ?穝?讲?︺隔XXX?М????()Τそ蒓砆矯?????セ皘20206る4らミㄌ猭屿ノ?祘20206る30らそ??畑?︽?瞶М????()Τそ猭﹚旱┚砆矯畑???セ??瞶??М????()Τそセ皘矗???―?砆矯やМ????()Τそろ?蹿チ?102,054.69じ(?衡よΑ???5,000じ+??ЧΘ祘のや??ノ206,354.69じ-砆?や109,300じ)??3蒃じ?132,054.69じㄆ?㎝瞶パ201910る29らカ?穝?︺隔XXX?┍?(?ゅ玡??疉┍?)?ㄆ﹜砆矯蒓М????()Τそ?????〆Λ?﹚パ?疉┍??︽??????5,000じ?﹚ЧΘ??矗ユ砆砆Μ????谔???Τや瓃???11る1ら砆蒓??诞??祘琁?﹚パ??疉┍???祘琁琁??玡瓃???????祘?刹蹿??10蒃じ材せ??﹚祘?猳海??玡砆惠?90%祘蹿ら砆??????﹚誹砆ボ??ノの???蹿??7.5蒃じ糹︽?祘いパ砆??矗禬禫????㎝﹚?琁璶―璓ㄏ?よぃ磖е祘?ΜЮ?琿砆销瞶パ╈ろ?祘蹿?蹿㎝??蹿ぃ?よΩ?坝?狦眔?氨琁???辅?戳??ぃа硄?稬獺矗眶砆???玂?獽???瞶??礛τ砆?竚矗眶ぃ??瘂???菊逼?產????祘?︽ΜЮ┶?や╈ろ祘蹿???ō猭?痲?癬?璶―や??砆矯??ぃ種场???よ????ヘ琌???????ゴ膀???疉???〆Λぇ玡纯?砆┯?ボ?よ璝???????????ぃ砆Μ珿璶―砆や??????Τㄌ誹ㄤΩ??琁?祘い?熬置??よ硑Θ┍?慈??????狦蒓?????ぃ才ぃ才砆????┮惠ㄤ︽??疼Θ??τぃ?┶?┯?琁???︽蝋?砆猭??┍?辅??璓ㄏ砆?猭タ盽?┍?硑Θ戳ぃ瞶┑?砆201912る23ら????よぃ12る25ら?Θ?秆???秆埃?よ?坝?狦?ア??糹︽???ンτ秆埃薄?ご礛┶???┍??巴砆暴Τ硄?祭?硚よ眔?┍?篒???ЧΘ琁秖?Τ?﹚祘秖60%パ┶?┯????︽蝋砆氨ゎや?琁蹿?τぇ玡砆?诞??祘琁材せ?ぇ?﹚や?蹿??109,300じパ┍??禬?﹚戳??ゼЧ砆┯???アぃ???ーぇ砆眔︽逼ㄤ???琁砆︽?才?﹚ョ盽薄盽瞶ぃ??はτ琌︽??璓?猭糹︽??―?场??セ皘??瞶?﹚ㄆ?201910る29らМ????()Τそ蒓砆矯碞疉┍????ㄆ﹜??カ???〆Λ?﹚砆〆Λ┯?疉┍?そ???????ノ?5,000じ砆???ぇら50%???蒓?﹚??秖??㎝??秖4ぱ?ЧΘ˙??よ砆碞˙??よ?Θ璓恶?よ?祘パ?よ?谔﹚や???蹿?10る30ら11る3ら4ぱ??ńЧΘ甅?????の琁??11る1ら砆??诞??祘琁?﹚?疉┍?祑?场だよΑ?︽?戳?30ぱ刹蹿10蒃じだΩ蹿材Ω??3ら?や?刹30%(3蒃じ)材Ω祘??俱蔨琜穎ЧΘ?や?刹30%(3蒃じ)材Ω祘?猳海??玡や?刹30%(3蒃じ)材Ω祘Ч丹┪砆?﹍ㄏノ7ら?や?刹10%(1蒃じ)琁?祘いヴよ矗?ゎ?ヴよ惠?刹蹿30%?︽??ら砆?????(?????)?﹚?砆????﹚?刹蹿7.5蒃じ材Ω?????谔﹚?销?の?秖?や??60%琁い戳猳海??玡ㄌ誹???ネ祘糤??や??40%?よら??祘?衡????ヘ?刹?の??刹?谔?疉┬?祘蹿?蹿?210,914.86じ程?涩磃刹??175,000じ?るいΟ?﹍琁砆????ゼ??よ?ノ300*600?病?τ琌?ノ600*600病????よ炒璓ㄏ??琁疉┍??畒逼???ǐ笵??????砆氨ゎや祘蹿の?蹿パ?よ?﹍?ネベ12る4ら砆妒?蹿ゼ狦笶12る19ら砆?癳氨硄?氨?┍?辅?砆12る23ら?癳?矗?よ?坝秆??狠篒ゎ???201912る25らゎ???よゼ?Θ???礛秆埃12る28らよ?㎝砆?︽稬獺册ぱ?矗¨?玂???˙蒃璶?︳??猭?︳〃砆氮蝋¨??そきぱ??︳?狦〃砆12る29ら祭???〆Λ??鍯??Τそ???︽疉┍??琁20201る疉┍??祘ЧΘ?砆╈ろ?祘蹿の?蹿?パ?セ皘璶―┮??瞶?祘い砆璓谔?砆?や?蹿??109,300じㄆ?パ?ㄆ?瓃矗ユカ???〆Λ诞??祘琁???祘??祘?刹???刹?砆矗ユ??????琁?ヘ?衡睲?稬獺册ぱ??单?誹??セ皘??セ砆??よぇ?猭?╰膀セ?Τ奢??よ??礘?璶栋いㄆ?场だ氨???ЧΘ祘秖の砆琌惠┯????ヴ??祘秖??パ疉┍??︽场だ???琁氨?よゼ碞??ЧΘ祘秖?︽?衡ゼ㏕﹚ヴ?は琈琁???????誹薄?砆︽?╰????ЧΘ??祘癬?ぇらゎ?よ?ЧΘ祘秖砆┮?┮琁??秖??А?猭?︽Τ??パ?┮暗祘滦??璓?猭?疉┍??祘いЧΘ场だ祘秖?︽?刹?︳?瓃薄?セ皘誹?Τ?誹の坝??ㄒ盽薄盽瞶?ン??礘??﹚セい砆谔?疉┍?祘?衡?い?祘?刹(?蹿)?210,914.86じ程?涩磃刹?175,000じ程?刹㎝?衡?刹ぇ?17.03%涩磃瞯τ?よ??琁???暗祘の?蹿?206,354.69じσ?祘?衡??刹い?ぉ砆刹涩磃τ誹坝?恨瞶琁よ硄盽ぃ???パ?衡?膀??︽禬?琁珿獽??よ??痷?┦の??┦?衡程?涩磃刹??ч衡瓃17.03%涩磃ゑㄒㄤΩ碞??ЧΘ祘秖?篒氨?ゎ﹟Τ刹1蒃じ祘秖ゼ暗砆???篒氨?ゎ?ЧΘ?祘秖60%?恨?よАゼ矗ㄑ??琁秖よ?誹疉坝??ぃㄣ??︽?刹?︳?ン璓ㄏ??ㄆ??猭琩惠璶琌砆碞琁???ネ????琁???︽?硄?稬獺砆??玂??华獽??刹?︳??薄?砆?疉┍???北?よ??﹟ゼ秆?ぇ?獽︽瘆???ゼ㎝碞祘??︽?衡ゼ?????㏕﹚玡矗钡?╰??琁硑Θ琁??┮祘綝滦?钡璓ㄏ?ㄆ??猭琩よ瓃氨??1蒃じ祘秖ゼ暗??瓃?秆??祘Чぇ?ヌ玙???????钡氨τ獶??ЧΘ┮ぃ祘秖砆︽?АぃТ?ぃ瞶ぇ?玡矗?σ??Τ?誹の?ㄆ┮ぇ?瓃?坝??ㄒの盽薄盽瞶セ皘皍﹚??ЧΘ祘秖刹??15蒃じΩ??パ砆酚诞??祘琁11.1??ㄤ??3蒃じ??﹚琌?秆埃?Τ?ヴよ┮┦?蹿セい砆?Τ戳秆埃?ぇ玡?よ?琁??狦祘蹿や单???ネ??炒圾Ы砆??ぇ玡氨ゎ琁?よ碞氨??ョАゼ玂痙篒氨ぇらゎ琁??薄??誹ヘ玡琁??綝滦?薄??砆?秆埃?Τ?ヴ誹璶―砆?????ㄌ誹ぃìセ皘ぃぉや程????5,000じΤ??﹚????????︽琁ㄆ?ì?ЧΘ疉坝???よ砆?Τや???ノ??砆?????ノ??よ?坝璓?琁?刹蹿矗ユ?誹ぃì??ㄤ??セ皘?ぃぉ??璶―砆や?5,000じㄣΤㄆ?㎝猭ㄌ誹セ皘ぉや???ЧΘ祘刹の????155,000じΙ埃砆?や109,300じ砆ご惠や45,700じㄌ酚い?チ㎝?猭材材κ箂?ぇ?﹚?砆矯セ?ネぇら癬ら??М????()Τそ?蹿????45,700じ?М????()Τそㄤ???―?Τ?????ㄆ狦ゼセ?﹚戳?糹︽??????ㄌ酚い?チ㎝?チㄆ??猭材κき?ぇ?﹚や?┑糹︽戳???ン瞶?2,941じ?Μ?1,470じパМ????()Τそ??962じパ砆矯??508じ砆?ぇ蹿セ?ネら?ユ?セ皘ぃ狝セ???癳?ぇら癬きら?セ皘?ユ???よ?ㄆ?矗捌セ?カ材い?チ猭皘审判员  凌琳二〇二〇年十月九日书记员  邱杨附：相关法律条文い?チ㎝?猭材κ箂??ㄆよゼや刹蹿┪?筍?よ璶―ㄤや刹蹿┪?筍い?チ㎝?チㄆ??猭材κき?砆?︽ゼ?掉﹚㎝ㄤ猭ゅ?﹚戳?糹︽??????や?┑糹︽戳???砆?︽ゼ?掉﹚㎝ㄤ猭ゅ?﹚戳?糹︽ㄤ????や?┑糹︽