西安市莲湖区人民法院民事判决书 （2020）陕0104民初2354号原告:陈某甲，男，1979年7月18日出生，汉族，住西安市莲湖区，身份证号：610XXXXXXXXXXXXXXX。委托诉讼代理人：张琴，陕西克利律师事务所律师。原告：陈某乙，女，1977年2月3日出生，汉族，住西安市未央区，身份证号：610XXXXXXXXXXXXXXX。被告：许某某，女，1953年7月20日出生，汉族，住西安市莲湖区，身份证号：610XXXXXXXXXXXXXXX。委托诉讼代理人：李战锋，陕西制衡律师事务所律师。委托诉讼代理人：杨国红，陕西制衡律师事务所律师。原告陈某甲诉被告许某某继承纠纷一案，本院于2020年3月13日立案受理后，原告陈某乙作为共同原告参加了本案诉讼，本院依照《全国人民代表大会常务委员会关于授权最高人民法院在部分地区开展民事诉讼程序繁简分流改革试点工作的决定》之规定，依法由审判员王晓萤适用普通程序,公开开庭进行了审理，原告陈某甲及其委托诉讼代理人张琴、原告陈某乙、被告许某某及其委托诉讼代理人李战锋、杨国红                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                均到庭参加诉讼。本案现已审理终结。原告陈某甲向本院提出诉讼请求：1、依法分割由被告占有的陈某丙遗产现金80万元及位于西安市莲湖区XX村XX号XX楼XX号（约30平米、市价20万）、西安市莲湖区XX号楼XX单元XX层XX号（约30平米、市价20万）两套房产；2、本案诉讼费用由被告承担。事实与理由：被告系原告继母，被告许某某与被继承人陈某丙于2007年再婚，婚前陈某丙与原告母亲唐某某共同购买了位于西安市莲湖区XX村XX号XX楼XX号房产。被告再婚后原告一直对被告与自己父亲陈某丙孝顺有加，每月除了留少许的生活费，其余工资几乎尽数交由父亲保管。由于原、被告一直相处融洽，原告家所有房产手续及存款也都交由被告保管，原告对此一直没有异议。被告婚后便将原告亲生母亲生前购房屋交由被告出租，租金也是由被告收取，原告从未过问。2019年10月23日，原告父亲陈某丙因患恶性肿瘤不治去世，原告悲痛万分，顶着巨大压力办理了父亲丧事，但在被继承人住院及丧礼期间，被告及其一家人的冷漠表现令原告悲愤至极，并将本该属于原告的遗产据为已有，拒不分割，并提出苛刻条件，否则将原告名下的私人财产凭证也一并扣押，拒不返还，原告忍无可忍。为维护原告的合法权益，现诉诸法院，望法院依法裁判，判如所请。原告陈某乙述称，同意依法分割陈某丙遗产。被告许某某辩称：1、不同意原告陈某甲的诉讼请求；2、原告诉请的分割陈某丙遗产80万元，被告许某某并未见到，也没有实际控制，如果法院能查明80万元存在的情况下，在分清夫妻共同财产后对陈某丙遗产依法分割；3、原告陈某甲诉请分割的位于西安市莲湖区XX村XX号XX楼XX号房屋，在分清夫妻共同财产后对陈某丙遗产依法分割；4、原告陈某甲诉请分割位于西安市莲湖区XX号楼XX单元XX层XX号属于被告的婚前个人财产，原告无权继承；5、原告陈某甲在起诉状中陈述的事实与理由与客观事实不符。原告陈某甲为支持其诉讼请求，向本院提交了陈某丙户口薄，死亡证明、身份证、录音录像，原告陈某乙、被告许某某对其真实性无异议。被告许某某为反驳原告的诉讼请求，提交身份证、结婚证、房屋所有权证（西安市房权证莲湖区字第1100110021-34-1-40101号）、收款收据3份、房屋所有权证（西安市房权证莲湖区字第1025110010-2-191-10308号）、收款收据6张、房屋明细表及5套房屋的合同及协议、收款收据，原告陈某甲、陈某乙对上述证据的真实性无异议。根据双方无争议的证据和陈述，本院认定事实如下：原告陈某甲、陈某乙是陈某丙与前妻唐某某的婚生子女，唐某某去世后，陈某丙于2007年12月6日与被告许某某结婚。被告许某某与陈某丙结婚后，原告陈某甲与被告许某某及陈某丙共同生活，许某某与前夫的儿子未与二人共同生活。2019年10月23日，陈某丙去世。陈某丙去世后，原告陈某甲与被告许某某因继承遗产发生纠纷，原告陈某甲于2020年3月13日诉至本院。本案审理过程中，经查询，被继承人陈某丙去世当日，其名下秦农银行尾号为3583号账户余额为354.94元；                         中国银行尾号2602账户余额为502.22元；中国建设银行尾号为6894号账户余额为11041.75元；中国建设银行尾号为4251账户余额0.40元；中国邮储银行尾号4306号账户余额为102.25元；中国邮储银行尾号0579账户余额为70.19元，之后更新为808.54元，中国工商银行尾号4577账户余额为0.17元。截止被继承人陈某丙去世当日，被告许某某中国工商银行尾号1067账户余额为175016.72元；中国工商银行尾号2502账户余额为1.00元；中国邮储银行尾号为8325账户余额为22788.89元；秦农银行尾号6424号账户余额为1044.89元；中国建设银行尾号2671账户余额为329.76元。被告许某某称其在陈某丙去世后，于2019年10月28日从其名下中国工商银行尾号1067账户支取75000元，用于偿还了陈某丙兄弟姐妹给陈某丁女儿的丧葬款每人7000元，共计35000元，另外偿还了陈某丙的妹妹陈瑞玲借款40000元。2019年11月20日支取5000元偿还债权人李传璐；2019年11月22日支取23000元偿还债权人黄全琴，2019年12月20日支取6000元偿还债权人王爱梅。 关于房产，被继承人陈某丙在与被告许某某在婚前，其原工作单位陕西省供销机械厂（以后变更名称为西安航空动力控制有限责任公司）分配位于西安市莲湖区XX村XX幢XX单元XX室房屋一套，建筑面积56.3平方米，该房屋于2010年进行房改，总房价为23689元，陈某丙于2010年1月5日交纳房款11903元、办证费434元、房屋专项维修基金473.78元，于2010年6月30日取得房产证，产权证号为“西安市房权证莲湖区字第1100110021-34-1-40101号”。在本案庭审中，原、被告均认可该房屋价值为400000元。陈某丙与被告许某某登记结婚前，被告许某某由原单位西安市冶金机械厂分配位于西安市莲湖区XX园XX路XX栋XX号房屋一套，该房屋于2003年12月31日办理了房产证，登记在许某某名下。被继承人陈某丙于2000年5月23日与西安市莲湖区进丰村民委员会签订《房屋买卖协议》一份，购买位于西安市莲湖区XX村XX楼XX室房屋，支付购房款76617元；2007年9月11日陈某丙与西安市新新灯具厂签订《售房合同书》一份，购买位于西安市莲湖区XX路XX段XX号XX单元XX层XX号XX户房屋，支付购房款161000元；陈某丙与许某某婚姻存续期间于2010年3月16日以陈某丙名义与陕西广升实业发展有限公司签订《秦岭国际内部定向选房协议》一份，购买位于西安市XX号楼XX层XX房，购房总价为385843元，陈某丙已于2010年3月26日支付118000元、2013年1月26日支付155000元，余款未付；2013年3月10日，陈某丙、许某某共同作为买受人与出卖人“西安市莲湖区XX庙XX村XX苑.万福家园”签订房屋买卖合同一份，购买位于西安市莲湖区XX路XX路十字路口东北角红庙坡村安置楼永新苑.万福家园1幢17层1710号房屋，总金额404500元。2013年3月，陈某丙与甘肃长通集团西安电缆有限责任甘肃签订《职工集资建房协议书》，购买位于西安市XX路XX小区XX号楼XX号房屋，房屋总价款为168168元。关于债务，被告许某某在第一次庭审中称，陈某丙生前欠付武丹青20000元工程押金，在陈某丙生病期间用了，该20000元系债务；陈某丙尚欠其妹妹40000元，在陈某丙去世后，许某某向其妹妹偿还；陈某丙的弟弟陈某丁的女儿去世，陈某丙的兄弟姐妹集资共计50000元，该款项由陈某丙保管，其中15000元是陈某丙的款项，其余每人7000元，在陈某丙去世后，许某某将陈某丙的兄弟姐妹每人7000元予以退还；另外许某某从妹妹许金平那里借款30000元，从弟弟许云章那里借款20000元。第二次庭审中，许某某称其陈某丙债务除借陈某丙妹妹40000元及其兄弟姐妹的集资款35000元外，还有借黄全琴50000元，已经偿还23000元，其余款项未偿还；欠李传璐债务5000元，许某某已经偿还；欠王爱菊债务6000元，许某某已经偿还。本案审理过程中，原告陈某甲申请财产保全，本院依法作出（2020）陕0104民初2354-1号民事裁定，查封、扣押、冻结陈某丙及许某某名下价值170000元财产，原告陈某甲为此支出保全费1370元。另外，本案审理过程中，被告许某某要求依法分割抚恤金及丧葬费，本院前往西安市养老经办中心调取陈某丙抚恤金金额，因陈某丙家属尚未向其生前单位报送相关资料，该抚恤金金额暂无法计算。本院认为，原告陈某甲、陈某乙系被继承人陈某丙的子女，被告许某某系陈某丙的配偶，陈某丙在世时未留有遗嘱，故在陈某丙去世后，应当在确认夫妻共同财产及个人财产后，对陈某丙名下遗产由原、被告依法予以分割。一、关于房产。陈某丙名下位于西安市莲湖区XX村XX幢XX单元XX室房屋系陈某丙与许某某婚前分配、但婚后因房改取得房屋产权，该房屋总购买价格为24596.78元（23689+434+473.78=24596.78元），陈某丙与许某某婚后支付房款及办证费、房屋维修金共计12810.78元，则按照该房屋购买时的房屋总价格计算，陈某丙、许某某婚后共同支出房款占该房产价款的52%，陈某丙与前妻唐某某支付的购房款占该房屋产权48%，陈某丙前妻已经去世，则陈某甲、陈某乙各继承其母亲名下产权8%，陈某丙去世后，许某某个人占该房屋产权26%，陈某丙占有该房屋的产权58%由陈某甲、陈某乙、许某某平分，则该房屋产权在陈某丙去世后，由许某某占有45.33%、陈某甲占有27.33%、陈某乙占有27.33%。该房屋价值三方当事人均认可为400000元，故该房屋由被告许某某继承所有，被告许某某向原告陈某甲、陈某乙各支付相应的房屋价款109320元。许某某名下位于西安市莲湖区XX园XX路XX栋XX号房屋系许某某婚前个人财产，陈某丙没有所有权，故两原告无权分割。关于陈某丙在婚前个人购买及婚后与许某某共同购买邓家村姑娘楼、新新灯具厂、秦岭国际、永新苑、香槟城五套房屋，因未取得房屋产权登记，本院不予处理。关于存款。陈某丙及许某某银行账户截止陈某丙去世当日，存款金额共计为211991.53元，被告许某某承认所有银行卡由其掌握，其在陈某丙去世后，向陈某丙兄弟姐妹偿还了75000元，该事实予以认定，被告许某某向其他人偿还的款项，因两原告不予认可，故本案不予认定，可由债权人另行以借贷关系向继承人予以主张，本案不予涉及。扣除被告许某某向陈某丙兄弟姐妹偿还的75000元外，其余款项属于陈某丙与许某某共同财产共计136991.53元，陈某丙遗产金额为68495.77元，由被告许某某向原告陈某甲、陈某乙各支付22831.92元。关于抚恤金及丧葬费，因原、被告尚未向陈某丙生前单位申请办理，故该部分可待金额确定后再行分割，本案不予处理。综上，依照《中华人民共和国民法典》一千一百二十二条、第一千一百二十三条、第一千一百二十七条、第一千一百五十六条之规定，判决如下：一、登记在陈某丙名下位于西安市莲湖区XX村XX幢XX单元XX室（房产证号为：西安市房权证莲湖区字第1100110021-34-1-40101号）房屋由被告许某某继承所有；二、被告许某某于本判决生效后十日内支付原告陈某甲房屋折价款109320元；三、被告许某某于本判决生效后十日内支付原告陈某乙房屋折价款109320元；四、被告许某某于本判决生效后十日内支付原告陈某甲银行存款22831.92元；五、被告许某某于本判决生效后十日内支付原告陈某乙银行存款22831.92元；六、驳回原告陈某甲其余之诉讼请求。案件受理费15600元，原告陈某甲已预交，由被告许某某承担2632元，原告陈某乙承担2632元，其余受理费10336元由陈某甲自行承担。保全费1370元，原告陈某甲已预交，由原告陈某甲承担460元，原告陈某乙承担455元，被告许某某承担455元。综上，由被告许某某支付原告陈某甲诉讼费共计3087元，原告陈某乙支付原告陈某甲诉讼费共计3087元。如不服本判决，可在判决送达之日起十五日内，向本院递交上诉状并按对方当事人的人数提出副本，上诉于陕西省西安市中级人民法院。   审    判    员     王晓萤 二Ｏ二一年五月六日 书    记    员     刘  钰 1