Question: Which film has the director who died later, Jeedar or Champagne Charlie (1936 Film)?

<P0-S0> Champagne Charlie is a 1944 British musical film directed by Alberto Cavalcanti and loosely based on the rivalry between the popular music hall performers George Leybourne( born Joe Saunders), who was called" Champagne Charlie" because he was the first artist to perform the song of that title, and Alfred Vance, who was known as" The Great Vance". <P0-S1> Leybourne and Vance, portrayed by Tommy Trinder and Stanley Holloway, were London's big music hall stars of the 1860s and 1870s, of the kind called" lions comiques". <P0-S2> In the film, they are" top of the bill" at their respective music halls. <P0-S3> The film's female leads are a music hall owner and her daughter, portrayed by Betty Warren and Jean Kent. <P0-S4> " Champagne Charlie" opens with a sing- along in a pub, and follows the rise of Leybourne as a music hall singer. <P0-S5> The highlight of the film is a singing competition between the two protagonists. <P0-S6> Leybourne sings" Ale Old Ale" and Vance replies with" Gin, Gin, Gin"; the competition continues, with the scene finally ending with the song of the title. <P0-S7> The film is notable for its realistic approach to showing details of the audiences, venues and staff, with copious quantities of food and drink providing a vicarious delight for wartime audiences. <P0-S8> In 1944," Champagne Charlie" was typical of feature films designed to raise morale and generate goodwill. <SEP> <P1-S0> Jeedar( Punjabi:) is a 1981 Pakistani action film. <P1-S1> Directed by Kaifee, also known as simply Kaifi and produced by Amina Fyaz. <P1-S2> The film starring Sultan Rahi, Anjuman, Mustafa Qureshi, Adeeb. <SEP> <P2-S0> James Tinling( May 8, 1889 in Seattle – May 14, 1967 in Los Angeles) was an American film director. <P2-S1> He worked during the silent period as a prop boy and stuntman, and directed primarily for 20th Century Fox in the 1930s and 1940s. <P2-S2> He has been cited as one of the best B-film directors for Fox, known for directing numerous westerns and lighthearted films, including" Charlie Chan in Shanghai"( 1935). <SEP> <P3-S0> " Kaifi", real name Kifayat Hussain Bhatti,( 13 March 1943, Gujrat – 13 March 2009, Lahore) was the younger brother of the legendary Punjabi singer and actor Inayat Hussain Bhatti. <P3-S1> Both brothers worked with each other to make some highly successful films in Pakistan. <P3-S2> Kaifee himself was a film actor and a film director. <SEP> <P4-S0> Champagne Charlie is a 1936 American drama film directed by James Tinling and starring Paul Cavanagh and Helen Wood. <SEP> <P5-S0> George Leybourne( 17 March <P5-S1> 1842 – 15 September 1884) was a" Lion comique" of the British Victorian music hall who, for much of his career, was known by the title of one of his songs," Champagne Charlie". <P5-S2> Another of his songs, and one that can still be heard today, is" The Flying Trapeze", or" The Daring Young Man on the Flying Trapeze". <P5-S3> His 1867 hit" Champagne Charlie" led to the first major success of the music hall concept in Britain and even today he is still thought of as one of the most well known music hall performers.