Question: Which film whose director is younger, Black Dahlia (Film) or X-Men: Apocalypse?

<P0-S0> X- Men: Apocalypse is a 2016 American superhero film directed and produced by Bryan Singer and written by Simon Kinberg from a story by Singer, Kinberg, Michael Dougherty, and Dan Harris. <P0-S1> The film is based on the fictional X- Men characters that appear in Marvel Comics and is the ninth installment in the" X- Men" film series. <P0-S2> It is the sequel to( 2014) and stars James McAvoy, Michael Fassbender, Jennifer Lawrence, Oscar Isaac, Nicholas Hoult, Rose Byrne, Evan Peters, Tye Sheridan, Sophie Turner, Olivia Munn, and Lucas Till. <P0-S3> In the film, the ancient mutant En Sabah Nur/ Apocalypse awakens in 1983 and plans to wipe out the modern civilization and take over the world, leading the X- Men to try to stop him and defeat his team of mutants. <P0-S4> The film was announced by Singer in December 2013, with Kinberg, Dougherty, and Harris attached to develop the story. <P0-S5> Casting began in October 2014, while principal photography commenced in April 2015 in Montreal and ended in August of the same year. <P0-S6> " X- Men: Apocalypse" premiered in London on May 9, 2016, and was released in the United States on May 27, 2016 in 3D and 2D, and in IMAX 3D in select international markets. <P0-S7> The film received mixed reviews, with critics praising its themes and acting performances, while the portrayal of Apocalypse, overuse of CGI and formulaic nature of the film were criticised. <P0-S8> A sequel, titled" Dark Phoenix", was released on June 7, 2019. <SEP> <P1-S0> He was married to Bessie Graham Hobson( 1923 – 2000) and they had three children, Elizabeth, Margaret and Hugo Black III. <P1-S1> After the 1954 unanimous landmark U.S. Supreme Court Brown vs. Board of Education decision that desegregated public schools and being the son of the Supreme Court Justice Black, the younger Black received threats from people who said they would burn crosses in his yard, his young son was taunted at school, and by the early 1960s — saying he had had enough — the younger Black moved his young family to what is now Pinecrest Florida. <P1-S2> Black was a founding member of Kelly, Black, Black& Kenny, in Miami, which later became Kelly, Black, Black, Byrne& Beasley. <P1-S3> " I definitely had politics in mind," he wrote in his book about his father. <P1-S4> Black was born in 1922 in Birmingham, Alabama to future U.S. Senator from Alabama and Associate Justice of the U.S. Supreme Court, Hugo Lafayette Black and Josephine Foster. <P1-S5> As a result, the younger Black decided not to run and stayed in Alabama. <P1-S6> In 1952, Black considered following in his father's footsteps by entering politics. <P1-S7> Hugo was listed in the Best Lawyers in America for 20 years. <P1-S8> That year, his father told him to come to Washington, D.C. and warned him that if he was elected to Congress he would be under constant political attack at home because the high court would soon have some important decisions dealing with school segregation, according to Justice Black biographer Roger Newman. <P1-S9> Hugo Lafayette Black Jr.( April 29, 1922 – July 22, 2013) was an American attorney and legal author. <P1-S10> He was also a life member of the American Law Institute. <P1-S11> After graduating from Yale Law, he returned to Birmingham where he began a labor law practice. <P1-S12> He was admitted to practice law in the states of Alabama and Florida, as well as several Federal District Court of Appeals, and the Supreme Court of the United States. <P1-S13> He then went back to the University of Alabama and in 1946 graduated with an A.B. in English. <P1-S14> Then in 1949, he received an LL.B. from Yale University, where he was a member of the Board of Editors of the" Yale Law Journal" and president of Yale Law School Student Association and graduated second in his class. <SEP> <P2-S0> Black Dahlia is a 2006 United States production horror film inspired by the mysterious unsolved murder of the" Black Dahlia", Hollywood actress Elizabeth Short. <P2-S1> Instead of dramatizing the infamous 1947 murder of Short and the ensuing investigation, writer- director Ulli Lommel follows a series of contemporary L.A.- area homicides patterned after the 1947 slaying. <P2-S2> Lions Gate Entertainment distributes this film on DVD. <SEP> <P3-S0> Ulli Lommel( 21 December 1944 – 2 December 2017) was a German actor and director, noted for his many collaborations with Rainer Werner Fassbinder and his association with the New German Cinema movement. <P3-S1> Lommel spent time at The Factory and was a creative associate of Andy Warhol, with whom he made several films and works of art. <P3-S2> Since 1977 he lived and worked in the United States, where he wrote, directed and starred in over 50 movies. <SEP> <P4-S0> La Bestia humana is a 1957 Argentine film whose story is based on the novel" La Bête Humaine" by the French writer Émile Zola. <SEP> <P5-S0> Bryan Jay Singer( born September 17, 1965) is an American director, producer and writer of film and television. <P5-S1> He is the founder of Bad Hat Harry Productions and has produced or co-produced almost all of the films he has directed. <P5-S2> Singer got childhood friend Ethan Hawke to star in his first short film in 1988 after graduating from the University of Southern California. <P5-S3> On the basis of that film he received financing for his next film," Public Access"( 1993), which was a co-winner of the Grand Jury Prize at the 1993 Sundance Film Festival. <P5-S4> In the mid-1990s, Singer received critical acclaim for directing the neo-noir crime thriller" The Usual Suspects"( 1995), which starred Gabriel Byrne, Kevin Spacey, Stephen Baldwin, and Benicio del Toro. <P5-S5> He followed this with another thriller," Apt Pupil"( 1998), an adaptation of a Stephen King novella about a boy's fascination with a Nazi war criminal. <P5-S6> In the 2000s, he became known for big budget superhero films such as" X- Men"( 2000), for which Singer won the 2000 Saturn Award for Best Direction, its sequel" X2"( 2003), and" Superman Returns"( 2006). <P5-S7> He then directed the World War II historical thriller" Valkyrie"( 2008), co-wrote/ co- produced( 2011), and directed the fantasy adventure film" Jack the Giant Slayer"( 2013), as well as two more" X- Men" films,( 2014) and( 2016). <P5-S8> Singer directed the Queen biopic" Bohemian Rhapsody"( 2018). <P5-S9> Since 1997, a number of boys and men have alleged that Singer sexually assaulted them as minors. <P5-S10> Singer has denied all of the allegations.