Question: Which film has the director who was born earlier, South Sea Woman or The Black Camel (Film)?

Why Women Love( also known as Sea Woman) is a 1925 American silent drama film produced and directed by Edwin Carewe and distributed by First National Pictures. Blanche Sweet starred in the film which was based on the Broadway play" The Sea Woman", by Willard Robertson. The film is now considered lost. <SEP> MacFadden's parents were Rev. Robert A. MacFadden and Edith Hamilton MacFadden. His father died in 1909, leaving his mother to support herself and four children. In 1928, she became the first woman to file papers to run for governor of Massachusetts. MacFadden was a 1925 graduate of Harvard University. Soon after graduating, he became producer of the American Theatre Company, which presented plays for 10 weeks in the Boston area. The project was backed by Michael Strange, a writer who made her professional stage debut in the productions. He also served as director of the Community Arts Association in Santa Barbara, California, and the Theatre Guild School of Acting in New York. After starting out on Broadway in the 1920s, he moved into filmmaking in Hollywood. During the early 1930s he was a contract director at Fox. McFadden made a number of films for them including several early entries in the Charlie Chan series such as" Charlie Chan Carries On"( 1931). Hamilton MacFadden( April 26, 1901 – January 1, 1977) was an American actor, screenwriter and film director. He was released from his Fox contract following the 1934 merger with Twentieth Century Pictures. Thereafter he mixed occasional directing jobs with a number of small supporting appearances in films. <SEP> It is the second film to star Warner Oland as detective Charlie Chan, and the sole surviving title of the first five Chan films starring Oland. " The Black Camel" marked the film debut of Robert Young. The Black Camel is a 1931 American pre-Code mystery film directed by Hamilton MacFadden based on the novel of the same name by Earl Derr Biggers. <SEP> Stanley Shapiro( July 16, 1925 – July 21, 1990) was an American screenwriter and producer responsible for three of Doris Day's most successful films. Born in Brooklyn, New York, Shapiro earned his first screen credit for" South Sea Woman" in 1953. His work for Day earned him Oscar nominations for" Lover Come Back" and" That Touch of Mink" and a win for" Pillow Talk", and" Mink" won him the Writers Guild of America Award for Best Written American Comedy. <SEP> It is credited as being based on the play" General Court Martial" by William M. Rankin with the working title being" Sulu Sea". Jeanine Basinger's and Jeremy Arnold's book" The World War II Combat Film – Anatomy of a Genre" calls the film a significant mixture of genres: tongue- in- cheek adventure," Flagg and Quirt"( 1926)- style service comedy, Hope and Crosby road film, South Seas, prison escape, pirate, World War II and costume drama mixing ridiculous comedy with hard- boiled action in" Tell It to the Marines" style. South Sea Woman is a 1953 American action- comedy- drama film directed by Arthur Lubin and starring Burt Lancaster, Virginia Mayo and Chuck Connors. <SEP> Arthur Lubin( July 25, 1898 – May 12, 1995) was an American film director and producer who directed several" Abbott& Costello" films," Phantom of the Opera"( 1943), the" Francis the Talking Mule" series and created the talking- horse TV series" Mister Ed". A prominent director for Universal Pictures in the 1940s and 1950s, he is perhaps best known today as the man who gave Clint Eastwood his first contract in film.