Question: In what year did voters from the state of the person eliminated in the Top 4 show once again vote for someone from Mayor Turner's party?

<P0-S0> His performance of Live's version of "I Walk the Line" was well received by the judges but later criticized in some quarters for not crediting the arrangement to Live. <P0-S1> Chris Daughtry's performance of Fuel's "Hemorrhage (In My Hands)" on the show was widely praised and led to an invitation to join the band as Fuel's new lead singer, an invitation he declined. <P0-S2> He was eliminated at the top four in a shocking result. <SEP> <P1-S0> North Carolina's party loyalties have undergone a series of important shifts in the last few years: While the 2010 midterms saw Tar Heel voters elect a bicameral Republican majority legislature for the first time in over a century, North Carolina has also become a Southern swing state in presidential races. <P1-S1> In the 1990s, Democrat Bill Clinton came within a point of winning the state in 1992 and also only narrowly lost the state in 1996. <P1-S2> In the early 2000s, Republican George W. Bush easily won the state by over 12 points, but by 2008, demographic shifts, population growth, and increased liberalization in heavily populated areas such as the Research Triangle, Charlotte, Greensboro, Winston-Salem, Fayetteville, and Asheville, propelled Barack Obama to victory in North Carolina, the first Democrat to win the state since 1976. <P1-S3> In 2012, North Carolina was again considered a competitive swing state, with the Democrats even holding their 2012 Democratic National Convention in Charlotte. <P1-S4> Since Southern Democrat Jimmy Carter's comfortable victory in the state in 1976, the state had consistently leaned Republican in presidential elections until Democrat Barack Obama narrowly won the state in 2008. <P1-S5> However, Republican Mitt Romney ultimately eked out a 2-point win in North Carolina, the only 2012 swing state that Obama lost, and one of only two states (along with Indiana) to flip from Obama in 2008 to the GOP in 2012. <SEP> <P2-S0> both the council members and the mayor serve four-year terms; none face term limits. <P2-S1> council members are nominated by their wards via a ward-level primary held in september. <P2-S2> the top vote-earners from each party then compete at-large for their ward's seat on the november ballot. <P2-S3> in other words, on election day the whole city votes on all the council races up for that year. <P2-S4> council elections are severed: wards 1, 2, and 4 (as well as the mayor) are up for election in the same year (most recently 2011), while wards 3, 5, and 6 share another year (most recently 2013). <SEP> <P3-S0> the mayor of paris is elected indirectly by paris voters; the voters of each arrondissement elect the conseil de paris (council of paris), composed of 163 members. <P3-S1> each arrondissement has a number of members depending upon its population, from 10 members for each of the least-populated arrondissements (1st through 9th) to 36 members for the most populated (the 15th). <P3-S2> the elected council members select the mayor. <P3-S3> sometimes the candidate who receives the most votes city-wide is not selected if the other candidate has won the support of the majority of council members. <P3-S4> mayor bertrand delanoë (2001-2014) was elected by only a minority of city voters, but a majority of council members. <P3-S5> once elected, the council plays a largely passive role in the city government; it meets only once a month. <P3-S6> the current council is divided between a coalition of the left of 91 members, including the socialists, communists, greens, and extreme left; and 71 members for the centre right, plus a few members from smaller parties. <SEP> <P4-S0> Since the show's inception in 2002, ten of the fourteen Idol winners, including its first five, have come from the Southern United States. <P4-S1> In 2012, an analysis of the 131 contestants who have appeared in the finals of all seasons of the show up to that point found that 48% have some connection to the Southern United States. <P4-S2> A large number of other notable finalists during the series' run have also hailed from the American South, including Clay Aiken, Kellie Pickler, and Chris Daughtry, who are all from North Carolina. <SEP> <P5-S0> The city of Houston has a strong mayoral form of municipal government. <P5-S1> Houston is a home rule city and all municipal elections in the state of Texas are nonpartisan. <P5-S2> The City's elected officials are the mayor, city controller and 16 members of the Houston City Council. <P5-S3> The current mayor of Houston is Sylvester Turner, a Democrat elected on a nonpartisan ballot. <P5-S4> Houston's mayor serves as the city's chief administrator, executive officer, and official representative, and is responsible for the general management of the city and for seeing that all laws and ordinances are enforced.