Editor Y: This is a good photograph: the composition is attractive, especially in the way the image is blurred by smoke in one corner. Editor Z: It' s very pretty, but it' s a bad photograph. It doesn' t make a statement; there' s no obvious reason for the smoke to be there. The editors' dialogue provides the most support for the claim that they disagree with each other about whether ['a photograph that is not attractive can still be a good photograph', 'attractiveness by itself can make a photograph a good photograph', "a photograph's composition should be related to a statement that it makes", 'a photograph that makes no statement can still be attractive']