average monthly cost of renters insurance according to ValuePenguin Value Penguin only $187 a year approximately $190 a year according to ValuePenguin ValuePenguin renters premium $187 a year lists average monthly costs poor credit are more likely to file an insurance claim premium may be $15-$30 a month average cost of renters insurance ValuePenguin renters premium $187 per year coverage the cost of renter’s insurance coverage poor credit are more likely to file an insurance claim only $187 a year ValuePenguin surprisingly affordable coverage ValuePenguin $187 a year average cost of renters insurance circa $180 an average high of $360 per year renters premium $187 a year More @ www.valuepenguin.com