I purchases this refurbished MAC Pro in "excellent" condition.  However, the MAC I received has 3 peeling corners on the bottom.  Front sides have dents and scratches.  Not sure who could describe this as being excellent. In addition to the appearance, the performance is not of an Apple laptop.  The laptop I received has network connection problems.  This laptop keeps popping notices " you are not connected to the Internet" while all our other devices are on the same WiFi.  It finally gets connected but after about 15-30 min.  Battery lasts only 5 hours.  Battery Health indicates 11 cycles, which is great, but the battery dies down in 5 hours of simple use - internet searches and e-mails.  Overall, this looks and performs as a cheep knock-off laptop, definitely not Apple.