Immanent critique is a method of discussing culture which aims to locate contradictions in society's rules and systems.  This method is used in the study of cultural forms in philosophy and the social sciences and humanities. It may be contrasted with "transcendental" Kantian critical philosophy . Immanent critique further aims to contextualize not only the object of its investigation, but also the ideological basis of that object: both the object and the category to which it belongs are shown to be products of a historical process. Immanent critique has its roots in the dialectic of Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel and the criticisms by Karl Marx. Today it is strongly associated with the critical theorists such as Theodor Adorno as well as literary theorists such as Fredric Jameson who, in his seminal work The Political Unconscious, explored the idea of an immanent analysis of texts to argue the primacy of political interpretation. Roy Bhaskar has advocated it as one of the key methodological elements of critical realism.Bhaskar, R. (2008) [1975], A Realist Theory of Science (Routledge 'With a new introduction' edition), Abingdon: Routledge.  The purpose of immanent critique is the detection of societal contradictions which suggest possibilities for emancipatory social change. It considers ideas’ role in shaping society, with focus on future emancipatory change. An immanent critique of a value is a discussion of the principles (overt or implicit) the value proposes . It highlights the gaps between what something stands for and what is  being done in actual terms . Immanent critique tries to find contradictions and indirectly provide alternatives, without constructing an entirely new theory  .
Immanent critique is a method of analyzing culture that identifies contradictions in society's rules and systems. Most importantly, it juxtaposes the ideals articulated by society against the inadequate realization of those ideals in society's institutions. This method is used in the study of cultural forms in philosophy and the social sciences and humanities. Immanent critique pays close attention to the logic and meanings of the ideas expressed in the cultural text . Immanent critique further aims to contextualize not only the object of its investigation, but also the ideological basis of that object: both the object and the category to which it belongs are shown to be products of a historical process. Immanent critique has its roots in the dialectic of Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel and the criticisms by Karl Marx. Today it is strongly associated with the critical theorists such as Theodor Adorno as well as literary theorists such as Fredric Jameson who, in his seminal work The Political Unconscious, explored the idea of an immanent analysis of texts to argue the primacy of political interpretation. Roy Bhaskar has advocated it as one of the key methodological elements of critical realism.Bhaskar, R. (2008) [1975], A Realist Theory of Science (Routledge 'With a new introduction' edition), Abingdon: Routledge. Adorno contrasted immanent critique with "transcendent" critique, which typically reduces a set of ideas to their political uses or to the class interests they express. Transcendent critique, unlike immanent critique, adopts an external perspective and focuses on the historical genesis of ideas, while negating the values expressed in the cultural text.Adorno, T. (1982), Prisms, MIT Press: Cambridge. The purpose of immanent critique is the detection of societal contradictions that suggest possibilities for emancipatory social change. It considers the role of ideas in shaping society, with a focus on emancipatory change. An immanent critique of a cultural text discusses the ideal principles (overt or implicit) proposed by the text . It highlights the gaps between what something stands for and what is actually being done in society . Immanent critique tries to find contradictions and indirectly provide alternatives, without constructing an entirely new theory . It has the power to appeal to people's shared ideals while highlghingt how far society has to go before those ideals are realized .
R
discussing culture which aims to locate
analyzing culture that identifies
A
Most importantly, it juxtaposes the ideals articulated by society against the inadequate realization of those ideals in society's institutions.
R
It may be contrasted with "transcendental" Kantian critical philosophy
Immanent critique pays close attention to the logic and meanings of the ideas expressed in the cultural text
A
Adorno contrasted immanent critique with "transcendent" critique, which typically reduces a set of ideas to their political uses or to the class interests they express. Transcendent critique, unlike immanent critique, adopts an external perspective and focuses on the historical genesis of ideas, while negating the values expressed in the cultural text.Adorno, T. (1982), Prisms, MIT Press: Cambridge.
R
which
that
R
ideas’ role
the role of ideas
R
focus on future
a focus on
R
value is a discussion of the
cultural text discusses the ideal
R
the value proposes
proposed by the text
A
actually
R
actual terms
society
A
. It has the power to appeal to people's shared ideals while highlghingt how far society has to go before those ideals are realized