In their article, "Egalitarianism under Severe Uncertainty", ( Philosophy and Public Affairs,  2018 ) , Thomas Rowe and Alex Voorhoeve elegantly develop a theory of distributive justice , called "pluralist egalitarianism  " , for cases under maximal uncertainty . In this pr\'ecis for our PEA Soup Discussion , I firstly sketch their views and arguments. I then discuss their main scenarios . Finally, I suggest several objections against their view, proposing a two-stage ambiguity thought experiment .
In their article, "Egalitarianism under Severe Uncertainty", Philosophy and Public Affairs, 46:3, 2018 , Thomas Rowe and Alex Voorhoeve develop an original moral decision theory for cases under uncertainty , called "pluralist egalitarianism under uncertainty " . In this paper , I firstly sketch their views and arguments. I then elaborate on their moral decision theory by discussing how it applies to choice scenarios in health ethics . Finally, I suggest a new two-stage Ellsberg thought experiment challenging the core of the principle of their theory. In such an experiment pluralist egalitarianism seems to suggest the wrong, morally and rationally speaking, course of action -- no matter whether I consider my thought experiment in a simultaneous or a sequential setting .
D
(
A
46:3,
D
)
R
elegantly develop a theory of distributive justice
develop an original moral decision theory for cases under uncertainty
A
under uncertainty
D
, for cases under maximal uncertainty
R
pr\'ecis for our PEA Soup Discussion
paper
R
discuss their main scenarios
elaborate on their moral decision theory by discussing how it applies to choice scenarios in health ethics
R
several objections against their view, proposing a
a new
R
ambiguity thought experiment
Ellsberg thought experiment challenging the core of the principle of their theory. In such an experiment pluralist egalitarianism seems to suggest the wrong, morally and rationally speaking, course of action -- no matter whether I consider my thought experiment in a simultaneous or a sequential setting