When it comes to the classification of brain signals in real-life applications, the training and the prediction data are often described by different distributions. Furthermore, diverse data sets, e.g., recorded from various subjects or tasks, can even exhibit distinct feature spaces. The fact that data that have to be classified are often only available in small amounts reinforces the need for techniques to generalize learned information, as performances of brain-computer interfaces (BCIs) are enhanced by increasing quantity of disposable data. In this paper, we apply transfer learning to a framework based on deep convolutional neural networks (deep ConvNets) to prove the transferability of learned patterns in error-related brain signals across different tasks. The experiments described in this paper demonstrate the usefulness of transfer learning, especially improving performances when only little data can be used to distinguish between erroneous and correct realization of a task. This effect could be delimited from a transfer of merely general brain signal characteristics, underlining the transfer of error-specific information. Furthermore, we could extract similar patterns in time-frequency analyses in identical channels, leading to selective high signal correlations between the two different paradigms. Decoding on the intracranial data without pre-transfer reaches median accuracies of (76.94 \pm 2.17 )\,\\%DIF < and (81.50 \pm 9.49)\,\\%, respectively.abstract %DIF > . Decoding on only 10\\% of the data without pre-training reaches performances of (54.76 \pm 3.56)\,\\%, compared to (64.95 \pm 0.79)\,\\% with pre-training.
When it comes to the classification of brain signals in real-life applications, the training and the prediction data are often described by different distributions. Furthermore, diverse data sets, e.g., recorded from various subjects or tasks, can even exhibit distinct feature spaces. The fact that data that have to be classified are often only available in small amounts reinforces the need for techniques to generalize learned information, as performances of brain-computer interfaces (BCIs) are enhanced by increasing quantity of available data. In this paper, we apply transfer learning to a framework based on deep convolutional neural networks (deep ConvNets) to prove the transferability of learned patterns in error-related brain signals across different tasks. The experiments described in this paper demonstrate the usefulness of transfer learning, especially improving performances when only little data can be used to distinguish between erroneous and correct realization of a task. This effect could be delimited from a transfer of merely general brain signal characteristics, underlining the transfer of error-specific information. Furthermore, we could extract similar patterns in time-frequency analyses in identical channels, leading to selective high signal correlations between the two different paradigms. Classification on the intracranial data yields in median accuracies up to (81.50 \pm 9.49 )\,\\%DIF < and (81.50 \pm 9.49)\,\\%, respectively.abstract %DIF > . Decoding on only 10\\% of the data without pre-training reaches performances of (54.76 \pm 3.56)\,\\%, compared to (64.95 \pm 0.79)\,\\% with pre-training.
R
disposable
available
R
Decoding
Classification
R
without pre-transfer reaches median accuracies of (76.94
yields in median accuracies up to (81.50
R
2.17
9.49