who did sarah silverman used to date
Posted: 06/07/2013 5:14 pm EDT Updated: 06/07/2013 5:14 pm EDT. XOExOh no. Jimmy Kimmel and his fiancee, Molly McNearney, were spotted taking a very awkward group shot with Kimmel's ex-girlfriend Sarah Silverman at AFI's 41st Life Achievement Award Tribute to Mel Brooks. Kimmel and Silverman dated for five years up until 2009 while Kimmel and McNearney have been engaged since August 2012.