hotels in shelter island ny
Hotels and Motels near Shelter Island. The closest cities with additional hotels are Sag Harbor, East Marion, Bridgehampton, and East Hampton. Sag Harbor NY Hotels, Motels â approximately 22 minutes south of Shelter Island.
Bridgehampton NY Hotels, Motels â approximately 29 minutes south of Shelter Island. This includes 10 miles of drive time and a 10-minute ferry ride from Orcas Island Terminal to Anacortes Terminal. East Hampton NY Hotels, Motels â approximately 34 minutes southeast of Shelter Island.