recent afd on christianity and judaism hi i see that you were one of the participants in the recent afd on the article christianity and judaism that afd recommended in a snowball result that the article be merged into judeo christian however since the afd concerns have been raised most notably per wp adjective and wp mosname we use nouns and noun phrases for article titles not adjectives so a general survey on the relationships between christianity and judaism a topic this encyclopedia should certainly cover should be called christianity and judaism as per the articles christianity and islam islam and judaism the reason the article judeo christian exists as its own hatnote declares is specifically to survey the history and use of that word phrase which has its own controversy and its own tale to tell see here where i've set things out in a bit more detail that story is a good fit for its own article and will get completely lost if the contents of christianity and judaism get inappropriately dumped on top of it having contacted the closing admin his advice was to open a new discussion at talk christianity and judaism advertise the discussion widely and if a new consensus can be reached in that discussion his emphasis then per wp ccc the new consensus should be followed rather than the afd decision without the need for a drv or a new afd concerns about the proposed merge have also been expressed by and this post is therefore to let you know that that discussion is underway at talk christianity and judaism overly speedy deletion with a view to perhaps setting aside the afd decision of course some significant issues were raised in the afd about the article in its present form so the best way forward is a question that needs some thought please feel welcome to come and participate