if your explanation of what happened is that you were surprised to see the article's assessment and that you acted out of that surprised feeling by making what is certainly an uncivil edit summary and what some might consider a personal attack notice the italicized word and my initial comment and yes we are talking about wp npa not a real life attack i'm not sure why you ever brought that up then i can completely understand what took place do i consider that as an excuse for the rude edit summary no i still believe that the edit summary was uncivil and that your feelings at the time did not give you a right to act in that manner do you feel that because you were surprised at the article's current assessment that gave you a right to make an uncivil comment in the edit summary will you admit that your edit summary was uncivil terrier