removal from anti semetic category mel gibson is only human while mr gibson did make wrong anti semetic comments he did so drunk and he does not speak openly about any kind of anti semetic views when sober he also does not advocate his views or pursues them past a drunken rant i think he needs to be removed from wikipedia's anti semetic category what do you guys think he's an adult the law doesn't make a distinction betwen words acts said and committed when drunk and when sober neither should we he is quoted on a police report as making remarks that are undeniably anti semitic therefore he is anti semitic like all material here just provide sources saying that gibson is anti semetic and you can add it in thanks umm the nyt quotes him as making comments about the fucking jews is this not a sufficient source for you in which case this little ditty from the article also seems to help a prominent jewish leader calling him an anti semite in response abraham foxman of the anti defamation league who was one of the passion'''s most vocal critics released a statement saying that gibson's apology was unremorseful and insufficient and that the group hoped that hollywood now would realize the bigot in their midst and that they will distance themselves from this anti semite gibson said that he has disgraced himself and his family and he is sorry for what he did what more do does foxman want yes and hollywood has such high standards to hold up this is the kind of ammunition foxman craved as soon as he started criticizing the passion i'm not anti semetic in anyway and gibson should be ashamed i just don't like people being unfair i also think the mugshot is unfair and i will be changing it i agree that the mugshot may be unfair as a primary image for this article but it should be included near the discussion of this incident the adl has been sued for defamation for unfairly accusing people of anti semitism before and has been mired in a number of controversies i would hardly consider them a reliable source yeah like george bush might get drunk and suddenly shout out i love islam because when you're drunk you typically say the opposite of what you believe it's funny to read the arguments here about if mr gibson is anti semitic or not given the known views of his traditionalist catholic church clearly he is anti semitic and in another time he would probably say so proudly call a spade a spade if it quacks it s a duck mel gibson is anti semitic can there really be any question among intelligent people and if this is so than clearly it has a place in the article please don't insult us with your damned sneering arrogance jake b or some of us may argue that there is no question amongst intelligent people that many israelis and right leaning jews amongst the diaspora are racists and gentile haters who campaign in a mccarthyist style just look at the reaction to this case utterly hysterical i tell you what i can provide more evidence to support my assertion than you can to support yours cf adl and by the way according to the adl every single gentile in the world who isn't an israel supporter is a jew hater and racist who should be condemned and ostracised so quoting one of the leaders is like quoting hitler in an article on jews many gentiles see the adl as nasty racist and very dangerous and by the way compare gibson's comments with some of those posted by jews on the ha'aretz online forums he's positively liberal compared to them i quote from recent posts of arabs are terrorists does this one sound familiar let's just nuke them all and stop wasting our soldiers' lives you can't trust muslims to hold to peace mel gibson is a nazi ''etc etc ad infinitum plus hundreds of comments saying the civilians of the qana massacre got what they deserved try posting a comment there in which you ask for israel to be calm not over react and spare civilians without actually taking a side and quickly and inevitably you'll be called a jew hater a