a friendly note peter this is noc i am here to try and explain something that i think you've misunderstood the claim that i was denying peoplehood to jews is incorrect those edits you've noted were in fact fighting a particular antisemitic person his edits were such that he claimed lazar kaganovich was responsible for the ukrainian holodomor because he was jewish and he tried to use jewwatch as a source tried to remove israel from a list of countries selling pringles based on the incorrect assumption that israel is not a country and then went around inserting is a person of jewish descent into articles about jews he did not like i was not denying jews peoplehood i was corecting the fallacy that judaism is only a genetic ethnicity which is a lie perpetrated by people like hitler sposer explained it to you exactly as i would have there are many many jews who are not decendents of the original hebrews there are people who converted people who were the product of mixed marriages in europe etc they are jews too concentrating on the religion aspect does not deny peoplehood rather it eliminates the fallacy that jews are a race only if you would like to discuss further please ask fayssal for my e mail and i will be happy to talk to you i am doing my best to at least clear up these misconceptions best wishes