i have to say that was no surprise and my apologies i should have credited purples privatemusings with spotting the relationship between several of those usernames a couple of years ago it is disappointing that nothing was done then we might by now have had an article to be proud of rather than a hacked about pr puff job with bits of truth sprinkled in here and there fyi i only did a cursory search of usernames ip edits to make the point and only went back a short period however i noticed that one ip edit from paris just before the cannes film festival where a brit enroute to cannes might dally praised the 'good article' nomination