this user has a limited history and is not a registered user so i am replying here instead of on the talk page where they sent me a note personally the user mentioned wikiproject albums however that project is not relevant to this page since that policy applies to album articles this is not and in actually makes no comment at all about which albums should be included on an artist's article i just read the page the policy that actually applies to this page is wikiproject musicians and it does not say anywhere that the article should include all albums where mayer is a primary contributor or any other artist the policy there is rough and incomplete thus i have been operating on precedent as well as what makes the most sense and what is most fair to the works works done by a band should be credited to the band as a whole not an idividual since that just isn't fair additionally wikipedia has a long history of separating the discography of an idividual from that of the musical group they were are in here a few examples jack white john phillips david ruffin sly stone larry graham nick lachey brian wilson tina turner nicky wire michelle williams singer mick jagger agnetha f ltskog john entwistle vince neil stanley clarke robert plant frank black darren hayes mark burgess musician anni frid lyngstad graham coxon john lennon steve howe guitarist neil finn roger daltrey smokey robinson gladys knight randy bachman robert wyatt biosphere musician individual members of the beach boys james dean bradfield joey eppard steve marriott grant mclennan tony banks musician sisq alex chilton bob mould jim capaldi and there are many more many of these discographies have notes that wikilink to the appropriate article for the full band discograhy therefore in the insterest of consistency that same model should be applied here