dispute resolution ''s cartoon of former israeli prime minister ariel sharon as a monster eating palestinian babies a pastiche of francisco de goya's saturn devouring his son which was awarded the cartoon of the year for the cartoon drew criticism for its alleged use of classical european anti semitic libels under the pretext of criticizing israel others regarded it as legitimate political criticism the independent's press complaints commission pcc in response to complaints of anti semitism found that paper had not breached its code of practice in publishing the cartoon gerald kaufman no opinion piece the independent january ' sharon eating babies cartoon wins british prize' by ellis shuman israelinsider com pcc the independentpublished by the independent on january britain's holocaust memorial day please edit the version to the right rather than the one on the article page furthermore please explain with what changes you agree disagree and more importantly why'' you agree disagree with those changes