hello phil i was unaware i was required to be collegial but could you please tell me what is uncollegial about including that quote is it the inclusion of the sic following a misspelling if so i can correct brew's spelling in the quotation but i would like to include that quote as it is representative of the bullshit that editors regularly deal with in the topic area could you imagine that in a dispute about where a place is an editor would say what the sources say about where that place is is an irrelevant straw man i found it unimaginable and verging on being hilarious so i would like to include it so could you please tell me what is uncollegial about including the quote and further why collegiality is a requirement for what appears on a userpage the inclusion is not a personal attack it is not uncivil it does not violate anything in wp userpage it is simply showing accurately the views of an editor why would that not be allowed nableezy