atkinson i only used the source which doug weller put in the talk page but i appreciate that a more reliable source is needed the thing is that this bizarre hoax is spreading over islamist sites blogs and social networking but on no source even remotely viable as with the muslim rage over false comments attributed to nicki minaj and david villa over islam if this ever gets a reaction from atkinson or his management and that reported on a viable site then would a short sentence on the matter be notable enough on the 'personal life' section