i think you're being unfair to him marshal on that point and to be honest given you wrote the lede it does kind of undermines the defence i made of you whilst i agree with you this was a football article and its a overly broad interpretation of your ban you need to write your own appeal per wp gab when i appealed mistakenly on your behalf i think i made the basis of a case for a block review you need to write an appeal for yourself in your own words i'd offer to help but at this point wonder if i would make it worse talk