you deleted among many others a sentence with two sources stating that feminist africa is the first continental african gender studies journal the sentence is an obvious justification for notability and the sources were valid you've deleted all sources that speak positively of the journal but left in a piece of criticism the article meets the guidelines specified in the style guide you provide and this style guide is furthermore no reason to limit information about the social importance of a journal i don't work for feminist africa and the article as it stands is not fluff or pr your edits are truly baffling to me and i cannot see what purpose they serve