elimination order bret's call out order contestantsepisodes ashleyashleybrittanyakelseyashleyjennytayaashleyashleymindytayamindytaya beverlybeverlytayanatashanatashakamimindybeverlyjamiejamiejamietayamindy brittaneybrittanyanatashafarrahfarrahjamiekamibrittanyamindytayamindyjamie brittanyaconstandinafarrahashleykelseyashleybeverlyfarrahbrittanyabeverlybeverly constandinafarrahashleytayatayamindyjamiejamiebeverlyashley farrahkelseykelseybrittanyabrittanyatayaashleymindytayabrittanya giamariabeverlymariamindybeverlyfarrahtayafarrah heathermeganmindymindybeverlykelseykelseykelsey kelseymelissamariamarciamarciafarrahbrittanyakami marciamindybrittaneybeverlymariabrittanyajenny marcynatashamarciabrittaneynatasha mariasamanthamelissamelissa megantayaconstandina melissamarciamegan mindybrittaneysamantha natashagia nikkiheather samanthamarcy stephanienikki tayastephanie jamie jenny gaydino the contestant won the competition the contestant won a solo date with bret the contestant won a group date with bret the contestant was eliminated the contestant was going to receive a pass but was eliminated the contestant voluntarily withdrew from the competition the contestant won a date with bret but was eliminated the contestant won a date with bret but was eliminated before the elimination ceremony began the contestant was added by bret in episode