response to bharatiya dear bharatiyaji what is your view on where vedas mahabharata and the ashtadhyayi were composed can you briefly mention your views and if possible give us some references so that we can examine them it is the view of the prominent scholars that these were indeed composed in the punjab region when i say 'punjab region' i don't necessarily mean the indian state of punjab which is just a small part of former punjab internal evidence from these books leads us to the same conclusion that they they were indeed composed in this region the article hinduism in punjab is still evolving however you can see a hint of the historical information that is avaialble to us let us work together to make these article more informative to all please do let us know in some detail of what you are looking for and what perceptions we need to address yours