the article stinks i have said so it has been written from an extreme and disputable point of view from two sources which share it on a subject on which there are innumerable sources of other points of view it contains statements which can only be explained as partisanship or ignorance that is not uncivil it is a defense and the only defense against wikipedia being publicly embarassed it would be regrettable if your involvement in the same wikiproject or the same nationality were to create a cabal to defend bad work pmanderson