thank you yes i did make those comments and the response to that was mbz withdrawing the dyk nomination and commencement of more drama i spent hours collecting supporting sources and making them available i realize that you are trying to keep the peace and i respect the work that you are doing with dyk and elsewhere i also know that you and mbz have had a somewhat strained relationship and would probably prefer to not push back too hard that said it is completely unreasonable that the content of an article can be constrained by an editor solely on the basis of them having initially submitted a later withdrawn dyk hook best