actually the original definition was there long ago and was not my invention as for the ongoing observation that christians do wrong every time they breath let me note that samuel sandmel was jewish and the concept has also been used by jewish scholars but i am not really sure how to continue the discussion given that it seems to be as much about the inherent faults of the christian mindset which i think has no relevance here vs the topic at hand regarding the osiris myth i think you have also been unhappy about that page although it is fa i have now explained the jung issues and the scholarly consensus about the category is clear i think what can be done is to follow the middle ground between what the encyclopedia of psychology and religion and the handbook of archetypes and motifs do because they are overviews that may be the best way to get the scholarly issues there