if articles supporting islam aren't permitted those devoted to criticizing it shouldn't be either if an article can represent both views views on islam maybe that'd be something if the 'generic' islam islam related articles do represent a positive image of islam then they're not npov and need to be corrected the tone was supposed to be neutral by the way i don't see the islam article listing every positive comment or opinion ever voiced regarding islam the way this article documents so many negative ones no i'm fairly convinced this article shouldn't be here at all because of the title only negative views regarding islam can be documented followed perhaps by responses to those criticisms pope john paul ii's positive words on islam or muhammad wouldn't fit here nor would those of anyone else muslim or non muslim who've ever expressed a positive view of islam that wasn't a response to criticism that makes this article pov biased at its core i don't particularly know amin or merzbow and i'll assume good faith until i know them better i do know several of the players who frequent pages dealing with islam or muslims and i know their intentions are malevolent articles such as these serve as a platform for their islam bashing my suggestion perhaps it can be renamed such all views can be accomodated