i see your point thanks for making it clear but the exception or living dead issue you are talking about is not mentioned in the promophoto tag itself and i still think that your actual problem should firstly be with that tag rather than the images using it you see there are many people complaining on your talk page saying the images uploaded by them are not easily recreatable and believing the images fit the description in the tag you could perhaps discuss the problem on that tag's talk page or on wikipedia fair use if you already haven't of course perhaps a rewording of the tag could be agreed upon and prevent interpretations like mine and other complaining guys' from occuring in the future i still maintain that any publicity photo released by say a record company to be used on media for the promotion of one of their artists could also be usable here on wikipedia like they are used everywhere else and this category of images won't pose a restriction on wikipedia's redistributabilty regards