re question posed to shell about my comments above re a question posed to shell over on her talk page i did not say that shell advised me to delete comments made about the block or the sept an i from my current talk page i said that upon the advice of shell which she made to me not to continue the discussion of the an i on my current talk page that neither should anyone else be doing that on my current talk page i explained in this section that i would be at first editing out using and then deleting any comments made subsequent to the blocking of me by gnangarra garra they are still visible in preview mode so that people who posted them can copy and post them as comments to shell e g or in a pertinent not closed an i which they are free to re open if they wish see nyscholar issues revisited archived discussion instructions are in the top of the archive box w the closing administrator's gnangarra garra's conclusion summary the directions say that if one wants to engage in subsequent discussion of it one needs to start a new page at wp an i my current talk page is not for that kind of discussion cont my point if i can't discuss the an i on my talk page neither can others continue to do so on my talk page i do not welcome further comments about it since i am restricted from replying to them by shell and the current blocking administrator's block and therefore i will delete them to continue to place them here on my talk page is in my view based on what shell has advised me about my own comments inappropriate cont re views about the current block by gnangarra garra people can contact the blocking administrator gnangarra garra directly to comment on the block one way or the other but one does need to keep in mind that it is a violation of wp civil and wikipedia etiquette to lobby for blocks of other users who are not engaging in any currently blockable behavior as i am not cont see wp block for policy blocks are not supposed to be punitive they are supposed to be preventative i and shell have questioned the validity of the current block scroll up to unblock request s cont if unsure people do need to consult the links provided in my n b section above which will go to policies and guidelines relating to commenting on user talk pages cont at shell's request in the an i at end of archived version she asks people to contact her directly if they have specific concerns about my editing in wikipedia done after the closing of the an i as she is currently my mentor and is trying to guide me to have better communications with other wikipedians in talk pages particularly please see the end of the now archived closed report via wp ani thanks again my current talk page is also not for debating gnangarra garra's in my view and that of shell unfounded block of me my unblock request explains my view of it if you have your own views about the block please communicate them on gnangarra garra's talk page or on the talk page of the last declining administrator not on my talk page but please be mindful of wp civil and wikipedia etiquette or you yourselves may find yourselves blocked lobbying for or perhaps even against blocks of me on my talk page or elsewhere is in my view uncivil and a violation of wikipedia etiquette and i will delete further such discussions from my current talk page i am not currently editing wikipedia because i am blocked from doing so i don't want also to become blocked from my own talk page if people make personal comments about me as a contributor i will consider them potential violations of wp civil and i will remove them as per the policies already linked in my n b section please read it thank you