thanks for prompting me this is the first ga article that i have nominated so i'm learning the protocol i didn't notice your review comments for a few days i made one pass through the comments for things i can deal with quickly and i will come back and deal with the remainder very shortly likely tomorrow i have two questions there s a chapter ignored parameter error in ref i don't see the error message and i don't see any cite that uses a chapter parameter so i'm not sure what needs to be fixed i think we are talking about this cite which i admit is a little odd cite conference booktitle proceedings of the high school conference of november and date march publisher university of illinois location urbana illinois pages url r last dean title robert ridgway at home editor high school visitor's office ed accessdate march accessdates are not required for links to printed publications are we saying that accessdate parameters should be removed for such cites or that they're optional i e not strictly necessary