there is a difference between pink floyd the band which this page is about and pink floyd the corporation as far as pink floyd the band is concerned roger waters has not been a member since a member of a band is someone who plays in the band further roger waters has no rights to any of the new music albums that have come out since he left i e momentary lapse of reason and the division bell once again showing that he is no longer a member finally pink floyd does not need permission from roger waters to release albums such as pulse he does get paid royalties but that is it further i fail to see how you could list the estate of richard wright as a member of a band does the estate play the piano no it receives royalties for sure but that doesn't make it a band member it makes it a corporate member i agree with radiopathy that they should all be listed under former members this is inline with the template on wikipedia for musical artists i would challenge anyone to find a wikipedia page on a band that lists members who are no longer active as members and not former members i would also challenge you to find a band other than the beatles which i agree i don't like that format that is inactive that doesn't list it's members as former members perhaps a good comparison would be the band genesis on their page only phil collins tony banks and and mike rutherford are listed even though peter gabriel still own rights to aspects of the band like roger waters does to pink floyd also inxs does not list michael hutchence as a member why because he's deceased as it clearly states on the page i'm sure his estate receives royalty payments i would argue that the problem we are having is that some folks are simply unwilling to acknowledge the fact that pink floyd exists without roger waters but i could be wrong what's frustrating is to see that this article which was once a featured article deviates from the norm in more than one respect in regards to this section it lists current members of a band that is inactive i'd be willing to have that discussion and even if we determine that the band is active it lists a member who is no longer playing witht the band and a member who is deceased proper form would dictate that neither of these persons should be listed