no mcconn we can't agree to eliminate all the individual summaries and just summarize the whole criticism page if we go in that direction i will insist on putting back some of the most important articles which other editors have moved to the criticism page back to the main page as they had been eg ethics or falun gong and sexual orientation there is enough room on the main page to have short summaries of the sub articles and it was based on that assumption that i and other editors alllowed articles to be moved to the critisicm page in the first place if there cannot be agreement on the basics of a structure which will provide for balance i will go ahead on my own and request mediation but first i would like to hear from some of the other editors especially fire star olaf and covenant on this issue