one of the delete votes was invalid as it was based on the notion that csd g applied while one was proven faulty by another editor after excluding the nominator who has the obvious bias we have two valid delete votes transwiki closures default to keep at least in my experience so it essentially came down to deletes keeps then i took into account the strength of the arguments presented by each side and the editors in favor of keeping the article backed up their claims with more solid evidence than those in favor of deletion thus i feel my closure was appropriate regards tropical cyclone