afc regarding wikipedia talk articles for creation jennifer fitzgerald i think it would be helpful if you examined the article and gave an opinion without regard to its previous afd status the user in question went to afc partly maybe completely on my advice i'm not trying to make it someone else's problem but i am hoping either that different editors come up with the same reasoning or that a suitable article is created obviously that afc one wasn't it but i think the editor needs to hear specific reasons why thanks for anything you can add to it talk