unprotected i'm going to edit based on my comments in talk new anti semitism sourcing claims for country specific incidents so could we discuss them now all the incidents mentioned are regarded as examples of the new anti semitism i e coming from the left related to radical anti zionism etc talk they may well be but they are not sourced that way i don't think we can expect the words new anti semitism to appear in every single report we reference we've defined it and we've linked to many sources who are defining it the definition is it is a form of judenhass that emanates from the left it is characterized by the demonization of the world's only jewish state and of jews as an ethnicity and a religion israel's right to exist as an equal member of the world community is denied the jewish people's right of self determination is denied double standards are applied whereby the actions of the jewish state are judged according to a different standard from the actions of all the neighboring states around her jews as a people are held collectively responsible for the actions of the jewish state symbols and images associated with classic anti semitism are used for example blood libels are resurrected the jewish state and jewish people are associated with wild conspiracy theories involving jews or zionists or israelis plotting to take over the world or being in control of other governments or being responsible behind the scenes for various acts of terror mistakenly attributed to others arab and islamic anti semitism are excused and ignored straw man attacks are made whereby jews are alleged to claim that any criticism of israel is anti semitism and that is then used to condemn jewish groups as unreasonable and to deny that there is any such thing as the new anti semitism all of the above is accompanied by an international resurgence of violence against jews and their synagogues and schools particularly in europe it is found in conjunction with anti americanism because jews are believed either to control or be too influential with the american government anti zionism and the anti globalization movement all the authoritative sources who have written about the phenomenon agree that these are the key components so when we find them we can offer them as examples so long as someone has discussed them in terms of anti semitism or attacks on jews talk my worry is that livingstone has not been at least in the sources provided accused of anti semitism and that most of the discussion of galloway has nothing to do with the allegation of anti semitism against his supporters add to that that we appear to be accusing them of anti semitism not reporting others allegations which is or and unwise in the case of galloway the nus thing is a bit ephemeral but has been discussed in terms of new anti semitism so i'd just want to tidy that up livingstone has very definitely been accused of anti semitism got into quite a bit of trouble recently over it as has galloway and without question his supporters the section talks about it in relation to that election by all means go ahead and clean it up as you see fit and we can talk later if there are any disagreements talk slim whose definition is this all the sources put together the above are the issues they agree on it was posted weeks ago talk i think you mean all the sources from one side of the argument put together it's been a while since we discussed this so could you remind me as to which sources you consider authoritative sorry you'll have to look in the archives they're either there or in the article by all the sources i mean all the sources who study new anti semitism the above are the elements they appear to agree on talk i'm asking you which sources you consider to be authoritative please respond user c