archives archive july archive july july archive august february archive march november archive november april archive march february archive february august archive august mid october archive mid october february toc new archive this page has been quiet for a few weeks so i created a new archive at talk monty hall problem archive for the discussions from mid oct through feb indicated as archived above several of the issues aren't exactly resolved they will perhaps never be resolved to everyone's satisfaction but the period of relative calm seemed like an opportune time to create a new archive i added a new section post archiving much like this one user glkanter has reverted these changes suggesting we talk about it first ok since we're at a lull in the discussion here and the talk page is huge i suggest now is an appropriate time to archive rick block talk agree with archiving now the talk page is monster sized and nobody is going to read through it all anyway i don't agree there has been a 'lull' it's just been re directed to the arguments page i assume most readers not necessarily editors do not read archives if they're interested maybe they get as far as a talk page anyway i think that the existence and vehement nature of the mhp article disagreement would not be evident if the entire thing were archived a reader might think that there was universal satisfaction with the construction of the article that would be an inaccurate impression to give this thread will remain here and it already says there are unresolved issues if you'd like to enumerate them here that will remain here as well good enough rick block talk i didn't know there was an arguments page so i too thought it had settled down it would be very useful to have a concise list here of what the ongoing issues about the article are phrased as neutrally as possible with links to where some discussion about them may be found the main