i've made a start as you've seen i think the mistake made by the prior failed guideline was to be too prescriptive for individual types of event and the essay at wikipedia news articles doesn't strike the right tone for me it's too negative about articles about events and it is too wordy we need to bear in mind that we want to try to distill general principles of the community consensus about these articles and acknowledge where no consensus exists rather than try to impose new rules which will never succeed windows