my 'dismal record' what on earth are you on about have you decided to add violations of wp npa to your already lenghtly list of wikipedia policy violations i strongly urge you to strike that out you may spin all you want but the french verdict speaks for itself it says karsenty's evidence can't be dismissed if you don't see how that speaks to its credibilty too bad there is nothing fuzzy about a television documentary by ard nor about a piece of investigative journalism in the atlantic monthly they are both news reports in reliable sources which completely debunk the shoddy piece of journalism that france produced and dissimenated and which was severly criticized by the french court verdict as well as i said this is not the place to rehash the debate from the al dura article this article is about a living person and editors who can't edit in accordance with wp blp should not be editing here