guy one of the points that i was trying to explain to askahrc in my now infamous discussion on his talk page is that he couldn t attack barney off wiki and then accuse barney of failing to assume good faith on wiki assume good faith is not a suicide pact barney could not reasonably be expected to read askahrc s insulting rant and then still assume that askahrc was operating in good faith the distinction between on and off wiki became irrelevant when askahrc did what he did