hi thatcher i think this could be directly submitted to the committee since the identity confirmation isn t an issue anymore from what grandmaster said that ehud is an azerbaijani user and from atabek s words about the fact that anyone could choose any username of their liking if this confirms that ehud lesar is not an ehud lesar then any evidence provided to the arbitration in secret is not a confirmation because at this point if it is true that ehud is not claiming to be an ehud lesar anymore if it is adil he can ask anyone to provide identity to have him return because he doesn t need to prove he is ehud lesar so this case should be taken to judge if there is sufficient evidence that ehud is adil or not contacting the arbitration in secret could lead the arbitration to take a wrong decision because they may not know the full situation or we may not know anything so this will prevent the possibility of more evidences being provided