note that in some cases it is a good idea to have a talk page be a redirect suppose that there were links to talk second city with a lowercase c on various pages across the wiki when talk second city gets moved to talk list of second cities it is usually a good idea to redirect the old talkpage so that those links will go to the right place if the talk page were simply left blank people clicking onto it would be confused there don't seem to be any such links currently however so that rationale doesn't really apply i don't really have a firm opinion on this i at first redirected it to talk second city but you're right that people would only go to talk second city if they had deliberately avoided following the redirect talk contributions