from wikipedia requested moves december rock band video game rock band there is no page at rock band or rock band as they're just redirects hence no reason for the video game at the end talk contributions actually there was an article at rock band until somebody decided to merge it a couple of weeks ago and that wasn't even a clear consensus if anything both should redirect to rock music which rock band was merged with so i don't think this is uncontroversial spyke you beat me to the punch clearly the term rock band is well used in the wiki and this needs to be discussed i think moving as proposed would be too confusing since the distinction is rock band v rock band dab that's what for is for simply put for the genre of music rock music or somesuch either way rock band should not redirect to rock band video game t c m noting that a couple of thousand pages link to rock band and most of them refer to a group of people playing rock music and not to a video game i think we can't have rock band redirecting to rock band video game as it now does on the other hand far fewer pages link to rock band and a higher proportion of them refer to the video game thus as far as internal linking is concerned it makes sense to have rock band as a redirect to rock music and to move rock band video game to rock band placing hatnotes on both articles the alternative would be to have rock band and rock band redirect to rock music and leave rock band video game where it is with a hatnote at rock music the only reason to go with the second option would be if we think people are likely to type rock band into the search box when they're thinking of bands playing rock music one other thing why are we discussing this here instead of at the article talk page i've just copied the above from wp rm where it was listed in the incomplete proposals section consulting this talk page a few sections up it's clear that this page was just moved from rock band a little while ago so before anybody decides to move it back i thought i'd try to bring all the discussion to the same page i would also direct the attention of anyone interested to talk rock band where i've left a comment about why that page really needs to say redirected to rock music unless someone does something about the broken links first