re the recent ani thread hi i realize that you were engaged in the discussion so this reminder may be a bit presumptuous but here goes recently the editor in question came out of a month topic ban largely for the same reasons that the ani thread started persistent allegations and or allusions to antisemitic bents of other editors original topic ban her unsuccessful appeal that the editor seems to engage in repeated line toeing and then asking to have the book thrown at her is getting somewhat tired she is a valuable contributor on other fronts but i really don't think that her involvement in this particular topic area does the project or herself much good best