i have already said that i will halt my edits my position is that there is no accademic consensus that halloween has no celitc roots its also that we should not imply that one bleife it has no celtic roots has greater accademic support then the view it does or to put it another way undoo bakulan's last edits the artciel prety much said thre was disagrement but assigned no value to sides of that disageemnt and besides the new page may be mis representing at least some soorces as writen