i don't recall where i gave my opinions in the last post didn't i just ask you for yours i also clearly stated i was not interested in getting into a discussion on ancient macedon history so i'm not sure why you make this point if you carefully reread the macedonian naming dispute article you'll see that a huge section of it deals with concerns over historical patrimony so it's clearly not completely irrelevant as you suggest which is also part of why the us condemned fyrom for anti greek propaganda the essence of the greek complaint is fyrom propagandists deny macedonian greek heritage in order to later claim it as their own history i fail to see why on a talk page questions are being removed especially considering you were free to answer as you wished however since you object i will happily ask these questions where ever you like would you prefer i asked on your talk page