your interpretation of the above words does not make it a personal attack it is what is in you that makes you interpret it in that way i am the author of it and hence i know what i meant take any action allow d to be vicious wilful murder for instance examine it in all lights and see if you can find that matter of fact or real existence which you call vice in which ever way you take it you find only certain passions motives volitions and thoughts there is no other matter of fact in the case the vice entirely escapes you as long as you consider the object you never can find it till you turn your reflexion into your own breast and find a sentiment of disapprobation which arises in you towards this action here is a matter of fact but tis the object of feeling not of reason hume