proposal that a new people who have been accused of anti semitism category be created as i've already written above i oppose placing gibson's bio in the 'anti semitic people' category because he vigorously denies the charge and listing him as such without qualification is tantamount to calling him a liar anti semitism is a very serious and potentially libelous charge and wikipedia should categorically label a person as anti semitic only in cases where the person either admits to being anti semitic or admits to holding unquestionably anti semitic views gibson has done neither and in fact vigorously denies both charges i do however sympathize with people who continue to add the 'anti semitic people' tag to his page i therefore propose the creation of a new category called 'people accused of anti semitism' the category would be for people who face or have faced substantiated charges of anti semitism from respected sources substantiated charges would obviously mean that there was reliable evidence to support the charge as opposed to a my best friend's roommate told me accusation and respected sources would refer primarily to credible individuals and organizations that have an accomplished track record of identifying and combating anti semitism civil rights organizations like adl and splc come to mind this new category would allow wikipedia to associate the anti semitism controversy with gibson's article without actually leveling the charge that he is anti semitic thoughts