Legal Document

394 U.S. 316 89 Supreme Court Reporter 1099 22 United States Reports Lawyer’s Edition 2d Series KF101.8 U54 302 Louis Judge TAGLIANETTIv.UNITED STATES. Number 446. March 24, 1969. Raymond LaFazia, for petitioner. Solicitor General Griswold and Assistant Attorney Rogovin, the States. PER CURIAM. 1 The petition certiorari is granted judgment of Appeals affirmed.1 Following a jury trial in District Court, petitioner was convicted on three counts wilfully attempting to evade his income tax years 1956, 1957, 1958. remand affirmed convictions. In remand, Government purported turn over all own conversations which had been overheard by means unlawful electronic surveillance.2 Petitioner argues that he entitled examine additional surveillance records because neither nor able determine with certainty party to. fact, examined camera ascertain if correctly identified petitioner's voice turned each conversation participated. 2 Nothing Alderman versus States, Ivanov or Butenko 165, 961, 176, requires an adversary proceeding full disclosure resolution every issue raised surveillance. On contrary, were required those cases, not lack confidence integrity government counsel judge, but only procedures at there would have inadequate safeguard defendant's Fourth Amendment rights. Here defendant see transcript nothing else. He no right rummage files. court asked identify instances standing challenge under exclusionary rule doublecheck accuracy Government's identifications. Under circumstances presented here, we cannot hold 'the task too complex, margin error great, rely wholly court.' supra, U.S., 182, S.Ct., 971. 3 Mr. Justice BLACK concurs result. 4 MARSHALL took part consideration disposition this case. Although filed within 30 days allowed Court's Rule 22(2), time limitation jurisdictional, Heflin 358 415, 418, n. 7, 79 451, 453, 407 (1959), does bar our exercise discretion consider sought apparently lacks as any others. 'We do understand appellant argue has inspect logs memos partipant. Indeed, point wisely conceded before district 398 Federal Reporter, 2nd 558, 571.

Classification Label: 0