Legal Document

355 U.S. 389 78 Supreme Court Reporter 358 2 United States Reports Lawyer’s Edition 2d Series KF101.8 U54 350 SAFEWAY STORES, Incorporated, Petitioner,v.Harry V. VANCE, Trustee in Bankruptcy for Frank Melvin Thompson, Bankrupt. Number 69. Argued Nov. 21, 1957. Decided Jan. 20, 1958. Rehearing and Modification Denied March 17, See 356 910, 667. Mr. John baron Tittmann, Albuquerque, N.M., petitioner. Robert Judge Nordhaus, respondent. Justice HARLAN delivered the opinion of Court. 1 This is a companion case to 67, Nashville Milk company versus Carnation Co., 373, 352. In present Appeals has held that private action treble damages1 does lie under § 4 Clayton Act violation 3 Robinson-Patman Act. 239 Federal Reporter, 2nd 144. Because conflict with decision Seventh Circuit case, 238 86, we granted certiorari. 352 1023, 77 590, 595. The complaint this alleges both sales 'at unreasonably low prices' price discriminations For reasons set forth our opinion, 352, hold should have been dismissed insofar as it rests on alleged unlawful selling at prices, respondent was entitled trial charges discrimination. Accordingly, judgment vacated, remanded District further proceedings consistent opinion. It so ordered. Judgment vacated cause directions. 5 CHIEF JUSTICE, DOUGLAS, BLACK BRENNAN, dissent. 6 dissenting see 359. not ask injunctive relief 16

Classification Label: 7