Legal Document

358 U.S. 57 79 Supreme Court Reporter 1 3 United States Reports Lawyer’s Edition 2d Series KF101.8 U54 28 Earl R. DEEN, Petitioner,v.Honorable Judge E. HICKMAN, Chief Justice and Honorable W. St. John Garwood, etal., Associate Justices of the Texas. Number 133 Misc. Decided Oct. 27, 1958. Messrs. David C. McCord Robert Lee Guthrie, for petitioner. Mr. Luther Hudson, respondent Gulf, Colorado & Santa Fe Railway company PER CURIAM. In Deen versus Co., 353 925, 77 715, 721, this Court, having held 'that proofs justified with reason jury's conclusion that employer negligence played a part in producing petitioner's injury,' reversed judgment Texas Civil Appeals, 275 South Western Reporter, 2nd 529. On remand, court question was foreclosed by Court's decision affirmed favor petitioner on condition accept remittitur. Tex.Civ.App., 306 171. review, 312 933, 942, remanded case to Appeals 'with directions * adjudicate, upon its own independent evaluation evidence wholly apart from States, whether or not jury finding defendant is so against weight preponderance as require new trial interest justice and, basis said adjudication, either affirm grant trial.' The determination issue supra. motion leave file petition requesting mandamus conform our mandate granted. Assuming we do will course disposition now make, writ mandamus. 2 STEWART took no consideration case.

Classification Label: 7