Document: 467 U.S. 914 104 S.Ct. 2820 81 L.Ed.2d 758 Bruce TOWER, etc., et al., Petitioners,v.Billy Irl GLOVER. No. 82-1988. Supreme Court of the United State Argued Feb. 22, 1984. Decided June 25, Syllabus Petitioner Tower, Douglas County, Ore., Public Defender, represented respondent at a state robbery trial that resulted in respondent's conviction, and petitioner Babcock, Oregon his unsuccessful appeal from this least one other conviction. Subsequently, filed court petition for post-conviction relief, seeking to have conviction set aside on ground petitioners had conspired with various officials, including appellate judges former Attorney General, secure On following day, instant action against Federal District under 42 U.S.C. § 1983, only recover punitive damages basis factual allegations were identical those made state-court petition. The granted petitioners' motion dismiss 1983 action, holding public defenders are absolutely immune liability, but Appeals reversed remanded case trial. Prior Appeals' decision, proceedings came finding there been no conspiracy convict respondent. Held: 1. Respondent's complaint adequately alleges conduct "under color of" law purposes view allegations. Although appointed counsel criminal prosecution does not act normal course conducting defense, Polk County v. Dodson, 454 312, 102 445, 70 509, an otherwise private person acts when engaged officials deprive another federal rights, Dennis Sparks, 449 24, 101 183, 66 185. Pp. 919-920. 2. liability intentional misconduct by virtue alleged conspirational deprives their clients rights. For immunities predicated upon considered inquiry into immunity historically accorded relevant official common interests behind it. No defenders, as such, existed 1871, 1983's predecessor was enacted, because such office existence time. defender has reasonably close "cousin" English barrister, although barristers enjoyed 19th century still enjoys broad negligent misconduct, nevertheless never misconduct. In country defender's 19th-century counterpart privately retained lawyer, lawyer would tort allegedly involved here. Nor is warranted asserted responsibilities similar judge or prosecutor should enjoy order, ultimately, impair State's attempt meet its constitutional obligation furnish defendants effective counsel, order prevent inundation courts frivolous lawsuits. It Congress determine whether litigation become too burdensome institutions and, if so, what remedial appropriate. 920-923. 3. open remand consider now collaterally estopped court's occurred. 923-924. 700 F.2d 556 (CA9), affirmed remanded. David B. Frohnmayer, Atty.Gen., Salem, Or., petitioners. Craig K. Edwards, Portland, Justice O'CONNOR delivered opinion Court. 1 Petitioners two working Oregon. Billy Glover Glover's trials charges, which convicted. Gary 2 brought General Oregon, seeks neither reversal nor compensatory damages, asks instead $5 million be awarded each petitioner. App. 5, 9. We conclude actions defendant who plaintiff 3 * arrested February 1, 1976, Del Norte Cal. Pet. Cert. Dolan, O.T.1978, 78-5457, p. California extradited Benton December 6, 1976.1 Upon arriving immediately habeas corpus relief Court, seeking, apparently, stay pending A hearing held January 1977, immediate denied.2 4 Before any final disposition tried convicted different charges courts. One trial—the directly linked—was Circuit 76-0386. Babcock summarily 18, 1978. Glover, 32 Or.App. 177, 573 P.2d 780. second connection action—was 31159. supra, April convicted; five days later he sentenced 10 years prison. This 17, 33 553, 577 91. well. 5 Meanwhile, Magistrate whom referred recommended it dismissed. March 1978, dismissed failed exhaust remedies. 77-276 (Dist.Ct.Ore.). gave notice Ninth Circuit, refused issue certificate probable cause. application cause July 12, agreeing 78-8077 (CA9). writ certiorari contended erred requiring him remedies before bringing denied certiorari. 439 1075, 99 850, 59 (1979). 6 While incarcerated Penitentiary, then initiated new lawsuits, again attacking simultaneously both courts, these suits, again, proceeded parallel almost three years. First, 11, 1980, postconviction Marion between lawyers officials. consolidated Court.3 His petition—indeed, simply appended copies papers federal-court complaint. 7 1981, relying decision Miller Barilla, 549 648 (1977). B 8 23, petitions found therefore request relief.4 Two weeks later, Court's light decisions Ferri Ackerman, 444 193, 100 402, 62 355 (1979), 509 (1981). 556. May 31, Circuit. 29, judgment court. failure prosecute August 1983. issued October 3, 464 813, 67, 78 (1983). II 9 Title provides "[e]very person" rights shall liable suit damages. concede, agreed, "cast over [petitioners'] actions." Brief 14; see F.2d, 558, n. we prosecution, though paid ultimately supervised State, defense. See also supra. 27-28, 186, 185 (1980), however, complaint, therefore, includes adequate allegation law. III face admits immunities. But since 1951 consistently recognized substantive doctrines privilege may limit available litigation. Imbler Pachtman, 424 409, 417-419, 96 984, 988-989, 47 128 (1976); Pulliam Allen, 466 522, 1970, 80 565 (1984). absolute legislators acting within legislative roles, Tenney Brandhove, 341 367, 71 783, 95 L.Ed. 1019 (1951), judicial Pierson Ray, 386 547, 554-555, 87 1213, 1217-1218, 18 288 (1967), prosecutors, witnesses, Briscoe LaHue, 460 325, 103 1108, 75 (1983), qualified executive officers school Scheuer Rhodes, 416 232, 94 1683, 40 90 (1974); Wood Strickland, 420 308, 992, 43 214 (1975). 11 Section "predicated it." U.S., 421, S.Ct., 990; 529, 1974. If Civil Rights Act enacted next considers history nonetheless recognizing same actions. 424-429, 992-994; 335-337, 1115-1117. Using framework type 12 1871 was, course, position first program States reportedly established 1914. Mounts, Defender Programs, Professional Responsibility, Competent Representation, 1982 Wis.L.Rev. 473, 476. Our inquiry, cannot stop there. Immunities regularly borrowed precedents, barrister. Like free pick choose clients. They thought formal contractual relationship clients, they incapable suing fee. Rondel Worsley, [1969] A.C. 191; Kaus & Mallen, Misguiding Hand Counsel Reflections "Criminal Malpractice," 21 UCLA L.Rev. 1191, 1193-1195, nn. 7-9 (1974). noteworthy century, do today, recent House Lords, traces origins 1435 until present. Nevertheless, appears even id., 287 (opinion Lord Pearson), concerns us 13 suggest Cf. Baker Humphrey, 494, 25 1065 (1880); Von Wallhoffen Newcombe, Hun. 236 (N.Y.Sup.Ct.1877); Hoopes Burnett, 26 Miss. 428 (1853). pattern continued. concede practice, given indication, statute Indeed, few addressed question immunity;5 none our knowledge concluded true defense benefited defamatory statements proceedings, 426, 439, 999 (WHITE, J., concurring judgment), covered defendant's 14 Finally, contend prosecutor, threat based conspiracies among deter engaging activities require some degree cooperation prosecutors—negotiating pleas, expediting appeals, so on. Ultimately, argue, will impaired. At time, inundated 15 Petitioners' well founded, remedy urge adopt. license establish sound policy. law, conspiratorial IV 16 As already described 916-919, more than day familiar delicate intricacies jurisdiction might characterize successful initiation entirely duplicative great waste resources. now, least, exhausted defaulted opportunities occasion decide abstain deciding stemming unlawful collateral exhaustion attacks itself.6 Younger Harris, 401 37, 91 746, 27 669 (1971) (federal enjoin ongoing proceeding); Preiser Rodriguez, 411 475, 93 1827, 36 (1973) (§ injunctive used bypass requirements action); Juidice Vail, 430 327, 339, 16, 97 1211, 1219, 51 376 (1977) (this engage principles); Patsy Florida Board Regents, 457 496, 518-519, 2557, 2569, 73 172 (1982) part) ("[A] civil administrative enforcement proceeding sidetrack resorting court"). 17 Allen McCurry, 90, 411, 308 (1980); 4, affirmed. further consistent opinion. ordered. 19 BRENNAN, MARSHALL, BLACKMUN, STEVENS join, part judgment. 20 I agree fully reasoning arrive conclusion. Ordinarily, complete agreement make writing quite unnecessary. ordinary case. raised parties, although, properly concedes, bearing case, seen fit observe "ha[s] decide" "abstain" prisoner's challenges Ante, 923. reasons why "occasion" clear enough: pressed passed below, briefed argued all remedies, whatsoever proper resolution controversy called decide. Accordingly, join except unnecessary paragraph beginning Part IV. Motion Leave Proceed Forma Pauperis 4; (Dist.Ct.Ore.) (Magistrate's Findings Recommendation, Dec. 1977), reprinted Response A-1. Id., A-2; 10; A-2. note asserts "begun lawsuits dealing facts [§ 1983] relating [his] imprisonment." statement apparently accurate signed ceased actually There reference progress "Findings Fact" stated: "1. did prejudice that: ..... "b) Trial arbitrarily exclude evidence witnesses. "c) participate counsel. "2. afforded assistance prepared securing necessary "4. . ." Fact, Conclusions Law Judgment 125,747, pp. 2-3, (June 2, 1983). Windsor Gibson, So.2d 888 (Fla.App.1982); Donigan Finn, Mich.App. 28, 290 N.W.2d Reese Danforth, 486 Pa. 479, 406 A.2d 735 (1979); Spring Constantino, 168 Conn. 563, 362 871 Scott City Niagara Falls, Misc.2d 353, 407 N.Y.S.2d (Sup.1978) (public discretionary taken pursuance duties defenders). See, e.g., Meadows Evans, 529 385, (CA5 1976), aff'd en banc, 550 345 (1977), cert. denied, 434 969, 98 517, 54 (1977); Martin Merola, 532 191, 194-195 (CA2 1976); Guerro Mulhearn, 498 1249, 1251-1255 (CA1 1974); Alexander Emerson, 489 285 1973).

Category: 1