Document: 353 U.S. 322 77 S.Ct. 804 1 L.Ed.2d 852 CIVIL AERONAUTICS BOARD, Petitioner,v.Ida Mae HERMANN et al. No. 540. Argued April 25, 1957. Decided May 6, Rehearing Denied June 17, See 354 927, 1376. Solicitor General J. Lee Rankin, Washington, D.C., for the petitioner. Mr. Roland E. Ginsburg, Los Angeles, Cal., respondents. PER CURIAM. Petitioner had instituted an administrative enforcement proceeding against respondents, a group of individuals and business entities operating as 'Skycoach' air travel system. The Board's complaint charged violation its regulations well Civil Aeronautics Act sought certain revocation cease-and-desist orders In course proceedings, Hearing Examiner issued number subpoenas duces tecum calling production categories documents respondent companies covering specified periods time. On motion to quash on grounds, inter alia, that were vague, excessively broad in scope, oppressive, both Board found described be produced with sufficient particularity, reasonable scope not oppressive. Upon respondents' continued refusal honor subpoenas, petitioner filed this proceeding. Initially trial judge cause 10 days 'on condition respondents * make subpenas available immediately representatives examination copying at usual places named *.' expiration period, court, showing complied condition, entered order allowing 'a length time between dates so will deprived all their books records same time.' court it could say 'that any or things called are immaterial irrelevant proceedings before without each items ordered produced. Court Appeals reversed, establishing procedural requirements must follow is order. 237 F.2d 359, 362. 2 As we read District Court, duly enforced right call relevant issues complaint, appropriate provisions assuring minimum interference conduct judgment reversed remanded instructions reinstate 16, 1955. § 1004(b), 1938, 52 Stat. 1021, amended, 49 U.S.C. 644(b), U.S.C.A. 644(b); Brown v. United States, 1928, 276 134, 142—143, 48 288, 289—290, 72 L.Ed. 500; Oklahoma Press Pub. Co. Walling, 1946, 327 186, 66 494, 90 614; Endicott Johnson Corp. Perkins, 1943, 317 501, 509, 63 339, 343, 87 424. Of leaves open ample opportunities objecting, admissibility into evidence particular document. 3 It ordered. 4 Reversed instructions.

Category: 8