Document: 448 U.S. 555 100 S.Ct. 2814 65 L.Ed.2d 973 RICHMOND NEWSPAPERS, INC., et al., Appellants,v.Commonwealth of VIRGINIA al. No. 79-243. Argued Feb. 19, 1980. Decided July 2, Syllabus At the commencement a fourth trial on murder charge (the defendant's conviction after first having been reversed appeal, and two subsequent retrials ended in mistrials), Virginia court granted defense counsel's motion that be closed to public without any objections made by prosecutor or appellants, newspaper its reporters who were present courtroom, counsel stated he did not "want information being shuffled back forth when we have recess as . testified what." Later same day, however, judge appellant's request for hearing vacate closure order, appellants' contended constitutional considerations mandated before ordering should decide rights could protected no other way. But denied motion, saying if felt infringed way others' overriden was inclined order closure, ordered continue "with press excluded." The next strike prosecution's evidence, excused jury, found defendant guilty. Thereafter, intervene nunc pro tunc case, Supreme Court dismissed their mandamus prohibition petitions and, finding reversible error, petition appeal from order. Held: judgment is reversed. Pp. 563-581; 584-598; 598-601; 601-604. Reversed. Mr. Chief Justice BURGER, joined WHITE STEVENS, concluded right attend criminal trials guaranteed under First Fourteenth Amendments. Absent an overriding interest articulated findings, case must open public. Gannett Co. v. DePasquale, 443 368, 99 2898, 61 608, distinguished. 563-581. (a) historical evidence evolution Anglo-American justice demonstrates conclusively at time this Nation's organic laws adopted, both here England had long presumptively open, thus giving assurance proceedings conducted fairly all concerned discouraging perjury, misconduct participants, decisions based secret bias partiality. In addition, significant community therapeutic value recognized: shocking crime occurs, reaction outrage protest often follows, thereafter processes serve important prophylactic purpose, providing outlet concern, hostility, emotion. To work effectively, it society's process "satisfy appearance justice," Offutt United States, 348 11, 14, 75 13, L.Ed. 11 which can best provided allowing people observe such process. From unbroken, uncontradicted history, supported reasons valid today centuries past, presumption openness inheres very nature system justice. Cf., e. g., Levine 362 610, 80 1038, 4 989. 563-575. (b) freedoms speech, press, assembly, expressly Amendment, share common core purpose assuring freedom communication matters relating functioning government. guaranteeing those speech Amendment read protecting everyone so give meaning explicit guarantees; receive ideas means, context trials, guarantees standing alone, prohibit government summarily closing courtroom doors adopted. Moreover, assembly also relevant, regarded only independent but catalyst augment free exercise with deliberately linked draftsmen. A place where generally—and representatives media—have present, presence historically has thought enhance integrity quality what takes place. 575-578. (c) Even though Constitution contains provision terms various fundamental rights, guaranteed, recognized indispensable enjoyment enumerated rights. implicit Amendments exercised centuries, aspects eviscerated. 579-580. (d) With respect despite fact accused's trial, findings support closure; inquiry whether alternative solutions would met need ensure fairness; there recognition trial; suggestion problems witnesses dealt exclusion sequestration during jurors guarded against subjected improper information. 580-581. BRENNAN, MARSHALL, Amendment—of itself applied States through Amendment—secures access proceedings, that, more, agreement parties cannot constitutionally close Historically functionally, closely associated development procedure assumes structural importance procedural are respected afforded equally, serving effective restraint possible abuse judicial power, aiding accuracy factfinding It further necessary consider countervailing interests might sufficiently compelling reverse since statute involved—authorizing closures unfettered discretion parties—violated 584-598. STEWART clearly civil well criminal; absolute, may sometimes justify limitations upon unrestricted spectators courtroom; apparently gave members trial. 598-601. BLACKMUN, while view supra, interpretation Sixth generally, application suppression involved there, concluded, secondary position, provide some measure protection here, abridged these Laurence H. Tribe, Cambridge, Mass., appellants. Marshall Coleman, Atty. Gen., Richmond, Va., appellees. BURGER announced delivered opinion, STEVENS joined. 1 narrow question presented Constitution. 2 * March 1976, one Stevenson indicted hotel manager stabbed death December 1975. Tried promptly convicted second-degree Circuit Hanover County, Va. October 1977, holding bloodstained shirt purportedly belonging improperly admitted into evidence. Commonwealth, 218 462, 237 S.E.2d 779. 3 retried court. This second mistrial May 30, 1978, juror asked begun alternate available.1 third began June 6, mistrial. appears declared because prospective about Stevenson's previous told retrial began. See App. 35a-36a. 5 tried beginning September 1978. Present called appellants Wheeler McCarthy, appellant Richmond Newspapers, Inc. Before began, moved public: 6 "[T]here woman family deceased before. She sat Courtroom. I like ask everybody excluded Courtroom don't want what—who Tr. Sept. 1978 Hearing Defendant's Motion Close Trial Public 2-3. 7 judge, presided over three prosecution objection clearing courtroom. leave Id., 4. Presumably referring Va.Code § 19.2-266 (Supp.1980), then announced: "[T]he gives me power specifically motion." He "that kept clear except they testify." Tr., 4-5.2 record does show anyone time, including McCarthy. 8 sought scheduled follow day's proceedings. When ruled treated part accordingly, again complied. 9 hearing, observed evidentiary prior entry pointed out failed other, less drastic measures within fair Vacate 11-12. Counsel argued 10 referred "difficulty between jurors," "didn't leak out," published media, perhaps inaccurately, seen jurors. Defense things, plus "this small community," proper closure. 16-18. noted similar statements morning hearing. stated: 12 "[O]ne points take consideration particular layout think distracting jury. Now, certain maybe that's good reason. get our new Building, sit audience jury can't see them. rule different circumstances. ." 19. 13 declined comment, summed up saying: 14 "I'm agree [defense counsel] feel way, [when] makes do something doesn't completely override else, I'm go along 20. 15 following 27; 21a. 16 What transpired resumed day disclosed manner entered 12, 1978: 17 "[I]n absence mis-trial declared, taken advisement. 18 "At conclusion Commonwealth's attorney grounds record, sustained Court. 19 "And excused, doth find accused NOT GUILTY Murder, charged Indictment, allowed depart." 22a.3 20 On 27, intervenenunc case. Appellants petitioned writs filed court's 9, 1979, appeal. 23a-28a. 21 review Court, invoking appellate, 28 U.S.C. 1257(2), certiorari jurisdiction, 1257(3). We postponed jurisdiction merits. 444 896, 204, 62 132 (1979). conclude lie;4 treating papers writ pursuant 2103, grant petition. 22 ended, moot. frequently recognized, necessarily defeated practical termination contest short-lived nature. See, 377-378, 2904, 608 (1979); Nebraska Press Assn. Stuart, 427 539, 546-547, 96 2791, 2797, 49 683 (1976). If underlying dispute "capable repetition, yet evading review," Southern Pacific Terminal ICC, 219 498, 515, 31 279, 283, 55 310 (1911), 23 Since plenary review, reasonably foreseeable judges more showing than record. More not, will short duration "will evade least considered Court." Press, U.S., 547, S.Ct., 2797. Accordingly, turn II 24 begin noting precise issue previously decision. required distinguished hearings pre motions, guaranteed. held Amendment's guarantee neither nor enforceable One concurring opinion emphasized "a suppress 394, 2913 (BURGER, C. J., concurring). id., 392 n. 24, 2912, 24; dissenting reach issue. 447, 2940 (opinion J.). 25 cases questions involving conflicts publicity 97 "[t]he [conflict] almost old Republic." also, Gannett, supra; Murphy Florida, 421 794, 95 2031, 44 589 (1975); Sheppard Maxwell, 384 333, 86 1507, 600 (1966); Estes Texas, 381 532, 85 1628, 543 (1965). unopposed defendant, demonstration protect superior requires A. 26 origins proceeding become modern traced beyond reliable records. details development, summary history instructive. purposes throughout evolution, care observe. 27 days Norman Conquest, generally brought moots, local hundred county court, attended freemen community. Pollock, English Law Select Essays Legal History 88, 89 (1907). Somewhat duty, attendance early meetings compulsory freemen, render judgment. 89-90; W. Holdsworth, 10, (1927).5 gradual years see, 316, duty relaxed, indication remain groups compelled attendance, Statute Marlborough, 52 Hen. 3, ch. (1267); 79, 4, statutory exemption prevent them attending; Lord Coke "are compellable come, left own liberty." E. Coke, Institutes Laws 121 (6th ed. 1681).6 29 Although appear few contemporary subject, reports Eyre Kent, general 1313-1314, evince apart "jury duty" aspect. explained 30 "the King's evil doers punished deserts, ministered indifferently rich poor; better accomplishing this, prayed lend him aid establishing happy peace honour realm welfare." 268, quoting S. edition vol. i., p. (emphasis added). times, although great changes courts procedures took place, thing remained constant: character guilt innocence decided. Sir Thomas Smith, writing 1565 definitive causes criminall," indictment put law countries: 32 "All rest doone openlie Judges, Justices, enquest, prisoner, manie come neare heare it, depositions given aloude, men mouth depositors saide." T. De Republica Anglorum 101 (Alston 1972) 33 Three later, Frederick Pollock able state "rule publicity" "[h]ere tradition, rate, persisted changes." F. Expansion Common 31-32 (1904). Jenks, Book 73-74 1967): most conspicuous features justice, access, immemorial." 34 nothing suggest presumptive later call "one essential qualities Daubney Cooper, B. & 237, 240, 109 Eng.Rep. 438, 440 (K. 1829), attribute systems colonial America. Virginia, example, records indicate contrary cited. Scott, Criminal Colonial 128-129 (1930); Reinsch, Early American Colonies, 367, 405 Indeed, mid-1600's Assembly due "by clamorous unmannerlynes lost, gravity decoram manifest authority selfe neglected," response restrict public, instead prescribe rules conduct attending 132. 35 instances, explicitly Colony. 1677 Concessions Agreements West New Jersey, provided: 36 "That publick tryals causes, criminal, person persons, inhabitants said Province freely into, courts, hear shall passed, done corner covert manner." Reprinted Sources Our Liberties 188 (R. Perry 1959). Schwartz, Bill Rights: Documentary 129 (1971). 37 Pennsylvania Frame Government 1682 "[t]hat ," Liberties, 217; 140, declaration reaffirmed adopted 1776. 271. §§ 76 Massachusetts Body 1641, reprinted 73, 80. 38 Other writings confirm wished attend. Perhaps address Quebec drafted committee consisting Cushing, Richard Henry Lee, John Dickinson approved Continental Congress 26, 1774. Journals Congress, 1774-1789, pp. 101, 105 (1904) (Journals). address, written explain position Colonies gain Quebec, "exposition colonists, understood representative chosen colonies." 221. Because intended "educated another form government" recently subjects, desirable inestimable advantages constitution government, privilege subjects enjoy." 106. 39 "[One] provides, life, liberty property, possessor, until twelve his unexceptionable countrymen peers vicinage, neighbourhood supposed acquainted character, characters witnesses, full enquiry, face face, many chuse attend, pass sentence oath him. 107 B 40 As shown, shown Court's dissent 384, 386, 15, 418-425, 2908, 2909, 2925-2929, open. quirk history; rather, indispensible Both Hale 17th century Blackstone 18th saw concerned, discouraged M. Hale, 343-345 1820); Blackstone, Commentaries *372-*373. Jeremy Bentham keystone: 41 "Without publicity, checks insufficient: comparison account. Recordation, whatever institutions themselves checks, operate rather cloaks checks; reality, appearance." J. Bentham, Rationale Judicial Evidence 524 (1827).7 42 Panegyrics values means confined self-praise English. Foreign observers 19th came away impressed homelands. L. Radzinowicz, 715, (1948). They marveled whole juridical passes public," P. Grosley, Tour London; Observations 142 (Nugent trans. 1772), quoted 717, commentator declared: 43 "The main excellence judicature consists extraordinary despatch business transacted. indeed astonishing. Free universally granted." Goede, Foreigner's Opinion 214 (Horne 1822). (Emphasis added.) nexus openness, fairness, perception fairness lost them: 45 counsel, constantly exposed animadversion; greatly tends confidence, repose administration justice." 215. 46 observation raises point requirement much broader bearing mere effect testimony." Wigmore, 1834, 435 (J. Chadbourn rev. 1976).8 reflects widespread acknowledgment, behavioral scientists, value. experts frame concept words, sensed experience especially used achieve derived acceptance results. 47 follows. Weihofen, Urge Punish 130-131 (1956). Thereafter Without awareness responses underway, natural human reactions frustrated vengeful "self-help," regularly activities vigilante "committees" frontiers. accusation acquittal, execution punishment, operat[e] restore imbalance created offense charge, reaffirm temporarily feeling security perhaps, satisfy latent 'urge punish.' " Mueller, Problems Posed Publicity Crime Proceedings, 110 U.Pa.L.Rev. 1, (1961). 48 Civilized societies withdraw victim enforcement laws, erase people's consciousness fundamental, yearning done—or even urge retribution. crucial function dark; catharsis occur "done [or] Supra, 567. enough say results alone satiate desire "satisfaction." result untoward undermine concealed unexpected outcome cause worst corrupted. (1954), it. Looking back, ancient "town meeting" became too cumbersome, delegated act surrogates, surrender trials. retained "right visitation" enabled done. 50 People society demand infallibility institutions, difficult accept prohibited observing. opportunity understanding workings case: 51 educative material advantage. Not increased intelligent acquaintance acquired methods strong confidence remedies secured never inspired secrecy." 438. Evidence, 525. earlier America, mode "passing time." 436; 6. cinema, electronic media now supplying representations reality real life drama once available longer pastime. Yet "[i]t unrealistic believe inclusion affords citizens legal education hopefully promotes State Schmit, 273 Minn. 78, 87-88, 139 N.W.2d 800, 807 (1966). Instead acquiring firsthand word attended, acquire chiefly print media. sense, validates claim surrogates While enjoy special seating priority report heard. "contribute[s] comprehension entire 587, 2816 (BRENNAN, judgment). C 53 bound hardly novel; direct issue, voiced variety contexts years.9 holding, 989 (1960), contempt "criminal prosecution" careful note involved: 54 "[W]hile 'public trial' 'criminal prosecutions,' reflection notion, deeply rooted law, 'justice justice.' [D]ue demands appropriate regard requirements adjudications barring narrowly limited categories exceptions 616, 1042.10 And (1979), majority, 423, 2928, agreed common-law tradition. 56 Despite Constitution, presses contention Rights Standing correct, remains whether, absent provision, III 57 conjunction Fourteenth, prohibits governments "abridging press; peaceably assemble, redress grievances." These Plainly single aspect higher concern conducted; pervades centuries-old opinions 564-575, 9. 58 enacted backdrop itself; "before attend" government." 106, 107. guarantees. goes selfexpression individuals limiting stock draw." National Bank Boston Bellotti, 765, 783, 98 1407, 1419, 707 (1978). carries listen. "In 'receive ideas.' Kleindienst Mandel, 408 753, 762, 92 2576, 2581, (1972). "For speak equivocally. command broadest scope language, liberty-loving society, allow." Bridges California, 314 252, 263, 190, 194, 192 (1941) (footnote omitted). 59 describe hear, communicate observations concerning access," cf. 397, 2914 (POWELL, concurring); Saxbe Washington Post Co., 417 843, 94 2811, 514 (1974); Pell Procunier, 817, 2800, 495 (1974),11 gather information," "without seeking news, eviscerated." Branzburg Hayes, 665, 681, 2646, 2656, 626 explicit, publish lose could, foreclosed arbitrarily.12 60 places traditionally been, assured amalgam affinity relevance. outset, draftsmen.13 peaceable cognate equally fundamental." Jonge Oregon, 299 353, 364, 255, 260, 81 278 (1937). assemble action, listen, observe, learn; indeed, "assembl[e] lawful purpose," Hague CIO, 307 496, 519, 954, 965, 83 1423 (1939) Stone, Subject traditional restrictions, Cox Hampshire, 312 569, 1049 (1941); Louisiana, 379 559, 560-564, 476, 478-480, 487 (1965), streets, sidewalks, parks exercised, 963 Roberts, J.); place.14 argues nowhere spells accordingly protected. possibility escape notice Constitution's draftsmen; disparaged danger Federalist 84 (A. Hamilton). letter Jefferson 1788, James Madison why he, "in favor bill rights," "not viewed light" time: "I conceive degree reserved federal powers went "there reason fear positive obtained requisite latitude." Writings 271 (G. Hunt 1904).15 arguments precluded enumerated. Notwithstanding caution reading defined, acknowledged unarticulated For association privacy, presumed innocent, judged standard proof reasonable doubt travel, Rights. nonetheless guarantees.16 concerns expressed others resolved; defined. 63 hold trials17 Amendment; "of Branzburg, 2656. D 64 Having return challenged private 382, 2907. accused, contrast pretrial exist tested alternatives fairness. 563-565, 2804-2805; 357-362, 1519-1522. There 359, 1520. Nor anything All admittedly difficulties none factors relied manageable. public.18 66 POWELL decision 67 WHITE, concurring. 68 unnecessary construed forbid excluding defined rejected submission four us effect, requiring addressed. concur THE CHIEF JUSTICE. 69 70 watershed Until accorded virtually absolute dissemination ideas, squarely acquisition newsworthy matter entitled whatsoever. An additional emphasis therefore appropriate. 71 Twice before, implied governmental restriction information, how severe unjustified, acceptable disabilities applicable large. BRENNAN MARSHALL 850, 2815, 514, unequivocally "any nondiscriminatory, falls outside purview concern." 857, 2818, original). Houchins KQED, Inc., 438 19-40, 2588, 2599-2610, 553, length POWELL, convinced "[a]n official prison policy concealing knowledge arbitrarily cutting off flow source abridges Constitution." 38, 2609. BLACKMUN unable participate majority accepted prevailing opinions.1 Today, holds arbitrary interference abridgment Amendment. 72 somewhat ironic recognize Houchins. plight segment itself, attack longstanding concealment, legitimate justification abridging operates. powerful voices community, unique exception established tradition likely motivated judge's individual burden trial.2 73 event, Part my 30-38, 2605-2609, JUSTICE today, protects operation Branch; total violated 74 whom joins, personal conferring separately press. instant force secures Brethren public.1 expression inviolate rare stringent exceptions, suppressed, Brown Glines, 348, 594, 600, 609, 611, 540 (1980) dissenting); 558-559, 2802, (1976); 590, 2817 judgment); York Times 403 713, 714, 91 2140, 2141, 822 (1971) (per curiam opinion); Near Minnesota ex rel. Olson, 283 697, 715-716, 625, 630-631, 1357 (1931), settings categorical correlative 849, 2814, Zemel Rusk, 16-17, 1271, 1281, 179 (1965); 8-9, 2593-2594, 553 (1978) 16, 2598 (STEWART, 404-405, 2918 (REHNQUIST, 397-398, 2914-2915, Houchins, 27-38, 2609 (STEVENS, Saxbe, 856-864, 2818-2822 839-842, 2829-2830, (1974) (DOUGLAS, dissenting).2 component every circumstance. Read context, subject dictated confidentiality. 2593-2594 J.) (access prisons); (same); Pell, 831-832, 2808-2809 541-542, 1632, (1965) (television courtroom); 1280-1281 (validation passport unfriendly country). comprehensively absolutely deny times principles animate 77 approach right-of-access simply Customarily, interposed speaker listener. employed restraints, protections insurmountable. 2802; 2141 opinion). Brennan, Address, Rutgers L.Rev. 173, 176 embodies commitment communicative interchange sakes; role play securing fostering republican self-government. Carolene Products 304 144, 152-153, 778, 783-784, 82 1234 (1938); Grosjean 297 233, 249-250, 444, 448-449, 660 (1936); Stromberg 369, 535, 1117 (1931); 176-177; Ely, Democracy Distrust 93-94 (1980); Emerson, System Freedom Expression (1970); Meiklejohn, Speech Its Relation Self-Government (1948); Bork, Neutral Principles Some Problems, Ind.L.J. Implicit principle debate issues uninhibited, robust, wide-open," Sullivan, 376 254, 270, 710, 721, 686 (1964), antecedent assumption valuable debate—as civic behavior—must informed.3 model links democracy survive, entails solicitude conditions meaningful communication.4 78 However, stretch theoretically endless," 177, invoked discrimination temperance. far participating citizen's "[t]here restrictions action clothed ingenious argument garb decreased data flow." 1281. assertion prerogative assayed considering opposing invaded.5 79 task sensitivity necessities abstract reasoning. helpful sketched. First, drawn enduring vital entree Cf. re Winship, 397 358, 361-362, 90 1068, 1070-1071, 368 (1970). Such commands gloss history. importantly, accessibility implies favorable experience. Second, measured specifics. Analysis advanced rhetorical bears issues; resolve us, therefore, consult current practice weigh itself. "This nation's roots heritage." Oliver, 333 257, 266, 499, 504, 682 419-420, 2926 (BLACKMUN, dissenting). 504; Radin, Right Trial, Temp.L.Q. 381, 388 (1932).6 Pre-eminent commentators unreservedly applauded 77, 81-82 (1970);7 103 1681); *372-*373 (13th 1800);8 342-344 1820);9 584-585 (1827). little any, civil, occurred known history." 420, 269, 22, 505, 22; 386-387. legacy inherited settlers earliest charters perpetuated 1677, XXIII;10 Government, 1682, Agreed Upon England, V.11 "There behind 425, 2929 Subsequently framed constitutions prescribed Declaration Rights, 1776, IX;12 North Carolina IX;13 Vermont X (1777);14 267, 504. "Following ratification 1791 Federal original states subsequently Union provisions." Ibid.15 overwhelming secure 414-415, 2923-2924, 267-268, 271, nn. 17-20, 504-505, 506, 17-20. persistently defended Oliver Due Process Clause forbids Noting "universal trials," "[i]n historic distrust inherent dangers freedom, universal deprived sentenced prison." 273, 507.16 significantly bulwarks democratic government: numerous "checks balances" system, "contemporaneous forum power," 506. 350, 1515, focused particularity "as safeguard attempt employ instruments persecution," "for political religious heresies." Thus, freedoms. By token, evident rulings upholding impelled classic pure communication, bottomed keen appreciation served opening inspection.17 So, reporting truthful Landmark Communications, 829, 1535, (1978), scrutiny disciplinary body implicates major Amendment—"discussion affairs," 839, 1542. Again, 2803, "should Broadcasting Corp. Cohn, 420 469, 492, 1029, 1044, 328 (1975), instructed "[w]ith particular, serves bring bear beneficial effects Time, Firestone, 424 448, 473-474, 476-478, 958, 974, 975-977, 154 (1976) dissenting) (open fulfill Nation retain control ."). 87 Tradition, contemporaneous practice, "[a] event. transpires room property." Craig Harney, 331 374, 1249, 1254, 1546 (1947). immemorial custom, essentially unwavering ancestral Nation. 266-268, 504-505; 418-432, 2925-2932, dissenting).18 abiding adherence "reflect[s] profound enforced administered." Duncan 391 145, 155, 88 1444, 1451, 491 (1968). advance several (and, judicial) Open furthering efforts assure accurate adjudication innocence. 538-539, 1630-1631. But, feature governing broadly political, interests, advances objectives well. extent, possesses specific significance.19 meeting 1042, quotingOffutt (1954); accord, 429, 2931 Cowley Pulsifer, 137 Mass. 392, 394 (1884) (HOLMES, civilization founded survive flourish, governed equitably. That necessity underlies provisions diverse takings just compensation, PruneYard Shopping Center Robins, 447 74, 82-83, 7, 2035, 2041, 741 (1980), Equal Protection Clause. mandates citizens. hedged make demonstration. 24. Secrecy profoundly inimical demonstrative respected, equally. Closed breed suspicion prejudice arbitrariness, spawns disrespect law. essential, objective maintaining 428-429, 2930-2931 demonstrably method adjudicating disputes plays pivotal process, extension, Under umpires, but, sphere, lawmakers—a coordinate branch government.20 controversies parties, involve prosecutions, impose consequences responsibility vitally construing mechanism factfinding, initial decisionmaking, genuine proceeding. follows pre-eminently interest. 491-492, 1044; Maryland Baltimore Radio Show, 338 912, 920, 562 (1950) FRANKFURTER, respecting denial certiorari). acts check, akin balances infuse 506 cases, ramifications impact '[w]ithout account.' (1827); *372; 344 Bryce, Commonwealth (rev. 1931). 93 Finally, limitations, aims true factfinding. Of course, benefit defendants comparably urgent, stake. miscarriage imprisons innocent leaves guilty party large, continuing threat society. Also, mistakes litigation inflict costs plaintiff defendant. Facilitation parties.21 Publicizing aids "Public attention key unknown parties." Tanksley 145 F.2d 58, 59, Alaska (CA9 1944); 1834 1976). Shrewd averred "open examination viva voce, mankind, conducive truth, witness depose private, ashamed testify solemn tribunal." *373. 59-60; 345; 522-523. borne assertions truthfinding publicity. Hearings 290 Subcommittee Constitutional Improvements Machinery Senate Judiciary Committee, 89th Cong., 1st Sess., pt. 433-434, 437-438 Popular sum, substantially furthers critical proceeding.22 element "government laws,"Marbury Madison, Cranch 137, 163, (1803). IV noted, resolution claims strongly influenced weight assessment hand, ingrained tip balance toward open.23 now,24 stake authorizes parties.25 (Supp.1980) violates Amendments, STEWART, accused" confer trial.1 391-393, 2911-2912. extend 397-403, (concurring REHNQUIST view, 403-406, 2917-2919 remaining Members silent question. Whatever ultimate answer themselves, criminal.2 abundantly demonstrated JUSTICE, BRENNAN's judgment, BLACKMUN's last Term 406, 2919, basic presupposition convincingly so. definition 102 military base, Greer Spock, 828, 1211, 505; jail, Adderley 385 39, 242, 149; prison, 495, city areas activity, Shuttlesworth Birmingham, 147, 935, 162, be, on. mean absolute. Just legislature freedoms, occupation 600. Much street, quiet orderly Compare Kovacs 336 513, Illinois Allen, 337, 1057, 543. finite physical capacity, occasions wish so.3 ways trial,4 courtroom.5 104 presiding, basis 106 My vote partial compels Virginia. 108 gratifying reasons: gratifying, first, looking relying determining Ante, 564-569, 572-574, n.9. 419-433, 2926-2933, pains assembling—I adequately—the stressing area set 589-593. modicum lip service n.15, obvious prosecution, resistance closed. welcome change direction. 111 second, wash graffiti marred Gannett. No primary (albeit seems dicta) ruling author fully aware restricted 2913. Nonetheless, ibid., multiple references concurrence REHNQUIST, separate quite understandably observed, consequence, qualification," 'members trials,' 403, 2917, 391, 2911. resulting confusion among commentators1 journalists2 surprising. 112 clarification public—or press—to suppress. I, placed it—in Amendment.3 113 eschewed route. plurality turns sources invokes veritable potpourri them—the Clause, Ninth cluster penumbral past decisions. course troublesome, route selected now, live spelling troublesome. uncertainty marks nature—and strictness—of adopts. speaks "an findings," ante, 581; reserves, inappropriately, "reasonable limitations," 600; presents analytical framework; Justices who, authorized "strictly inescapably necessary," 399-400, 2915, continues flat rejection of, others, avenue. 114 side am driven conclude, intense deserved know general; crimes particular; prosecutor, police officers, servants, actors arena; 413, n.2, 414, 2922, 2923, 2930-2931, 2940. (1975). me, take, 115 reverse, join 116 dissenting. 117 Gilbert Sullivan operetta "Iolanthe," Chancellor recites: 118 embodiment 119 everything excellent, 120 kind fault flaw, Lords, embody Law." 122 derive flavor supporting states: 123 "[H]ere closure." 564. 124 "Read confidentiality." 586. 125 either State's denying prosecuting consented hands. certainly confers orders situations. 579, n.15. 126 highest sense whose making effort uphold Jackson, 443, 540, 427, 469 (1953), "We final infallible, infallible final." 127 nation thinking gradually rein in, generation, decisionmaking administered, merely each nine however gifted, equal to. tiny numerical fragment 220 million compose population country. quoted, Jackson accurately generalities indeterminate actions forbidden ready instrument, field another, magnify federal, incidentally own, states." 534, 423. 128 However high-minded impulses originally spawned trend accentuated wrote, basically unhealthy concentrated group lawyers appointed virtual tenure. Nothing reasoning Marbury (1803), ever-broadening use Supremacy smother healthy pluralism ordinarily national embracing States. "right" conferred overrides Constitution; state-court Being Sixth, Ninth, dissent. account reported piece wife soon killing. improperly." 34a. Code provides part: felony misdemeanor may, discretion, exclude persons impair violated." oral argument, represented tapes terminated. Oral Arg. 36. validity invoke appellate jurisdiction. "It timely insistence statute, applied, repugnant treaties laws." Charleston Savings Loan Alderson, 324 182, 185, 624, 627, 857 (1945). statute's validity. prevented exhausting Given failure challenge constituting limit Phillips 246, 480, 484, 800 ("[A]n lawless constitutionality properly certiorari, Kulko California Superior 436 84, 90, 1690, 1696, (1978); Hanson Denckla, 357 235, 244, 1228, 1234, 1283 (1958). shall, refer appellee. Kulko, supra. period historians, Short 3-4 (2d 1922), Anglo-Saxon "deal novel uncertain, normal undoubted Why trouble village elder knows? Only disputed caused bloodshed disturbance, successful invader insists change, draw code." Ibid. interpreted language chapter indicating nature: "These words [In curia Domini Regis] importance, Causes ought heard, ordered, determined Judges Courts openly Courts, wither resort. 1681) enhanced performance involved, imputations dishonesty, educate 522-525. collateral Wigmore someone learns furnish chief contradict "falsifiers." 436. examples occurrences. 436, 2. "Of deep trials." Pennekamp 331, 361, 1295 (1946) (Frankfurter, J, "A (1947) (Douglas, "[W]e instance camera state, municipal abolition Star Chamber ever secretly dispute. heritage. exact date origin obscure, evolved settlement land accompaniment institution trial." (1948) (Black, (footnotes "One happens end right." 255-256, informed occurs television, always plainly (Clark, 583-584, 1653 (Warren, (The ruled, televising trial.) walls silence reflected 'Anglo-American trials.' 349, (1966) "on circumstances case," 1043, complain "so-called 'secrecy' proceedings," 617, because, object time. Procunier distinguishable penal which, definition, "open" places. Penal visiting committees citizens, legislative oversight "visitation rights." "limitation visitations justified Appeals 'the truism prisons limited.' [Washington Kleindienst] 161 U.S.App.D.C. [75], 80, 494 [994], 999. [87 243, 149] [jails]." 505 (military bases.) reaches alters right. neighbors [to trials] public." 1631. debating assert subsumed speech. Sedgwick "assembly" tend "appear trifling eyes constituents. converse together, purpose; self-evident, unalienable possess; Annals Cong. 731 (1789). existed guarantee, argue drafting committee's listing them, "they gone lengthy enumeration unnecessary, said, infringed." 732. Page responded, "such opposed," "people assembling together occasions": "[T]herefore guard stretches authority, inserting pretext whatsoever, contained clause." defeated. 733. large England. Geo. stat. (1714); (1795). Englishmen similarly limited; militate abuses led Framers facets described; draftsmen "rights Englishmen" enlarge scope. 263-265, 194-195, (1941). implications ratifying clearer greater religion, expression, Great Britain enjoyed." 265, 194. Madison's comments reveal perceived sort "saving clause," foreclose maxim affirmation negation 438-440 Story, 651 (5th 1891). efforts, culminating allay fears expressing others. NAACP Alabama, 449, 1163, 1488 (1958) (right association); Griswold Connecticut, 479, 1678, 510 Stanley Georgia, 557, 1243, 542 (1969) privacy); Estelle Williams, 425 501, 503, 1691, 1692, (1976), Taylor Kentucky, 478, 483-486, 1930, 1934-1935, 468 (presumption innocence); (1970) (standard doubt); Guest, 383 745, 757-759, 1170, 1177-1178, 239 (1966), Shapiro Thompson, 618, 630, 1322, 1329, interstate travel). Whether raised occasion define parts cf., 1835 1976), streets traffic, (1941), exerted unwarrantedly abridge opportunities discussion immemorially resort places." 574, 765. setting preserve atmosphere streets. Compare, 513 (1949), 353 (1970), courtrooms wishes accommodated. situations, imposed, preferential representatives. 2914-2915 17, 2598, 32, 2606 "Neither government's control." 2597 generated controlled opened doors." Neither motivation facts risk fifth however. sufficient distinguishing 608. inconsistent perfectly unambiguous asserted identified greatest worth emphasizing: speedy impartial district wherein committed, ascertained accusation; confronted him; obtaining favor, Assistance defence." insist establishes impliedly derivation carpentry, joints fit snugly overlapping. necessity, document designs central perspectives. Significantly, ingredient Fifth 614, 1041, (1960); (Fourteenth process). Analogously, racial segregation independently offensive Clauses. Board Education, 347 483, 686, 692, 873 Bolling Sharpe, 497, 499-500, 693, 694, 884 (1954). conceptually separate, related, 2815; 834-835, 2810. here. media's resolved unconstitutionally restricts matter, institutional likely, fitting, beneficiary "agent" interested funnels number individuals. idea foreshadowed POWELL'S 862-863, 2821: "What societal preserving affairs. rightly treasured ability destiny. '[The] self-government.' popular self-determination faith surest developing sound lies exchange views issues. unfettered; informed. repeatedly encompass receipt expression." (Footnote omitted.) technique deriving structure novel. suffrage inferred society" "preservative Reynolds Sims, 377 533, 561-562, 1362, 1381, (1964); San Antonio Independent School Dist. Rodriguez, 411 34, 1278, 1297, (1973). too, petition, yielded associational activities. Button, 371 415, 430, 328, 336, (1963). 33-34, 1297 (indicating implicitly embedded Constitution); 62-63, 1311-1312 112-115, 1337-1338 (MARSHALL, Lamont Postmaster General, 301, 308, 1493, 1497, 398 cautious applying nonverbal nonpictorial conduct. behavior intimately connected partakes transcendental Tinker Des Moines District, 393 505-506, 733, 735-736, (1969). connection tenuous, overridden competing social values. Hughes 339 460, 464-465, 718, 985 (1950). "[The trial] incident already insured scarcely reminded patria, 'country' capacity judges, summoned." (1932); *349 ("trial BY JURY ; CALLED ALSO TRIAL PER PAIS, OR COUNTRY "); t. smith, 1583. 1765. 1713. Quoted B, 140. 265. 287. 323. sure, constitutions, couched U.S.Const., Amdt. benefiting worded construed. 2929, Mallott State, P.2d 737, (Alaska 1980). defendants, clauses still attached founders governments. linking privileges vigorous Notably, simple incorporation notions intrinsic 'all prosecutions' [the Sixth] applies." Holmes (1884), proceedings] stand ground." Lewis Levy, El., Bl., El. 537, 610 (K.B.1858). dictum 684-685, 2658, (1972), "[n]ewsmen publishing .," contrary; notes curtailed considerations. 588. analogy, fashioned implicated beside exclusionary prompted vindicating 'imperative integrity.' Terry Ohio, 12-13, 1868, 1875, 889 (1968), Elkins 364 206, 222, 1437, 1446, 1669 Calandra, 414 338, 357-359, 613, 624-625, 561 Olmstead 277 484-485, 564, 574-575, 944 (1928) (BRANDEIS, 470, 575 insisted entrapment "countenanced" "obligation" avoid "enforcement honorable transcending stake." Sherman 356 380, 819, 824, 848 (FRANKFURTER, result); Russell, 436-439, 1637, 1645-1646, 366 (1973) 442-443, 1647-1648 Sorrells 287 435, 455, 210, 217, 413 (1932) ROBERTS, Casey 276 373, 375, 376, 632 legislation, lawmaking, albeit constraints Guided pertinent statutes, obliged discerning, rules. wield considerable formulate designated areas. Moragne Marine Lines, 1772, Banco Nacional de Cuba Sabbatino, 398, 923, 804 Textile Workers Lincoln Mills, 456-457, 918, 972 (1957); Areeda, Antitrust 45-46 1974) ("Sherman Act [is] usually do: customary techniques develop, refine, innovate dynamic tradition"). Further, insuring shared addition himself. advancing purposes, availability transcript substitute experienced attest, "cold" imperfect reproduction events transpire extent check officials, "[r]ecordation cloa[k] chec[k]; chec[k] 577-578. is, incompatible imposed decorum. engaging interchanges bench, allow intrusion huddle. intimate conferences chambers, inasmuch distinct confidentiality warrant sensitive portions testimony secrets. Nixon, 418 683, 714-716, 3090, 3110-3111, 1039 (1974). lacks door hearings: preventing suppressible prejudicial pool become, sequestration. Singer 380 630 (Sixth include jury). invasion Gitlow York, 268 652, 1138. relevant 683. 626. 584, passim. juries, continuances, venue. restrictions. preservation trade secrets, segments sensibilities youthful witness, rape, impaired. Stamicarbon, N. V. Cyanamid 539-542 (CA2 1974). Stephenson, Fair Trial-Free Press: Continuing Conflict, Brooklyn (1979) ("intended unclear" omitted)); Term, Harv.L.Rev. 60, ("widespread held"); Note, U.Colo.L.Rev. 432-433 ("Gannett sanction trials"; citing Gannett," "ambiguous sixth amendment holding"); Tex.Tech.L.Rev. 159, 170-171 ("perhaps imminent statement Borow Kruth, Preliminary Hearings, Calif.State Bar.J. 18, ("Despite disclaimers , embrace hearings"); Goodale, Means Says; Who Knows Says?, Nat. L Oct. 20; Keeffe, Boner Called A.B.A.J. 227 (1980). press—perhaps affected —has "cloudy," Birmingham Post-Herald, Aug. 21, A4; "confused," Chicago Sun-Times, 20, (cartoon); "incoherent," Sun, A14; "mushy," Post, A15; "muddle," 82, Newsweek, 69. seek demonstrate errors analysis note, existence illustrates utter fallacy thinking, participants litigation." 2908. 438-439, 2935-2936 dissent).

Category: 2