Document: 342 U.S. 76 72 S.Ct. 130 96 L.Ed. 100 BINDCZYCKv.FINUCANE et al. No. 18. Argued Oct. 10, 1951. Decided Nov. 26, Mr. Joseph A. Fanelli, Washington, D.C., for petitioner. James L. Morrisson, respondents. Justice FRANKFURTER delivered the opinion of Court. 1 On December 2, 1943, Circuit Court Frederick County, Maryland, issued a certificate naturalization to petitioner after proceedings that conformed with requirements Nationality Act 1940. 54 Stat. 1137, 8 U.S.C. § 501 ff, U.S.C.A. seq. Seven days later, and at same term court, Government moved vacate set aside order naturalization, claiming on evidence outside record it was obtained by fraud therefore citizenship illegally procured. 2 It is admitted 338 Act, wherein Congress made specific provision 'revoking * admitting ground or such (was) procured',1 were not followed. Instead, Maryland court exercised its general power under law judgments during in which they rendered.2 3 We brought this case here determine whether control revocation procured; grant courts forty-eight States subject whatever summary State may have over their merely local judgments. The questions are obvious importance administration laws, apart from conflict between views below those Appeals Seventh United ex rel. Volpe v. Jordan, 161 F.2d 390. 4 issue raised petitioner's action District Columbia judgment declaring him be citizen an restraining respondents deporting him. Upon motion dismiss complaint, granted Court, 'to national States' but 'without prejudice government's right institute appropriate denaturalization Sec. 1940.' reversed, 87 U.S.App.D.C. 137, 184 225, we certiorari. 341 919, 71 742, 95 1353. 5 Due regard 338, including history origin, nature together consideration conflicting capricious diversities affecting finality judgments, compel us hold exclusive procedure canceling score fraudulent illegal procurement based record. 6 Section 1940 our purpose reenactment 15 June 29, 1906, 34 596, 601. That culmination half century's agitation directed frauds, particularly bearing upon suffrage.3 basis nationwide survey incidence causes frauds view devising recommendations corrective legislation, President Theodore Roosevelt's Commission Naturalization prepared report foundation 1906. H.R.Doc.No.46, 59th Cong., 1st Sess. This report, hearings before congressional committees reports, floor debates proposed measure, leave no doubt target legislation naturalization.4 equally clear remedy disclosed evil lay effective exercise 'To establish uniform Rule Naturalization'. U.S.Const., Art. I, 8, cl. 4. 7 To prevent proceeding devised scheme administrative oversight process. given appear. 11, 599. fortified requiring notice petition newly created Bureau Immigration ninety-day waiting period filing final hearing. §§ 12, 598 These safeguards enable verification facts alleged investigation qualifications applicant citizenship.5 By these provisions recognized enforcement heart law. But content devise measures against procuring only. In 1906 formulated carefully safeguarded method denaturalization. Though principal criticism leading enactment concerned evils inherent widely diverse procedures, experience wanting dangers hardships attendant haphazard Information ever since 1890 then circuit had vacated orders suit Attorney General,6 although when validity it, left open question equity without express legislative authority. Johannessen States, 225 227, 240, 32 613, 616, 56 1066. always surrounded original proceeding. See, e.g., Tinn Attorney, 148 Cal. 773, 84 P. 152.7 Indeed, makes elections could influenced irregular denaturalizations as well naturalizations. only instance extensive materials vacation what appears been urged involved just situation. A judge who naturalized seven aliens supposition members his own political party promptly corrected. See Rep.Atty.Gen. 394 (1903).8 9 Significantly, House reveals deprive naturalizing revoke. bill authorized attorneys issuing having jurisdiction naturalize district citizen's residence. H.R.15442, Sess., 17. committee amendment adopted passage put section form enacted. amendment, words Congressman Bonynge, manager bill, 'takes away (a proceeding) out issued, unless alien happens reside within court.' 40 Cong.Rec. 7874. 10 light cannot escape conclusion detailed revoking because appearing face record, self-contained, procedure. With protecting while safeguarding abrogation except clearly defined procedure, insisted detailed, explicit 15. find time result achieved confused medley, shall see, procedures setting read respect reason. 11 Between them, two sections, 15, provided complete framework unqualified applicants. Under first, ample opportunity interpose objections prior naturalization. If proper account taken evidence, recourse appeal examination Tutun 270 568, 46 425, 70 738. Congress, however, thought ninety quite enough develop case—indeed many deemed too long. 7766—7770. At expiration time, if granted, proof attacks through prescribed scheme, providing representation Government's interest attacking decree record,9 covers whole ground. Every thereby protected. 12 Neither uncontested practice nor adjudication lower has rendered verdict disregarded construction 338. Nor rule future conduct any burden placed where can prove illegality fraud. 13 An abstract syllogism pressed natural, rational, treatment voiding naturalizations compliance careful formalities 334.10 Grant judgment; court's term; it. So runs argument. Such reasoning mechanical jurisprudence most glittering form. disregards all decisive considerations like derives meaning life context generating forces purposes. also results would flow applying empty actualities judicial administration. 14 giving cases, empowered some thousand judges adjudicate citizenship. specifically supplemented regarding way 'term rule' otherwise, retention contingent application myriad discordant rules scattered land. Wide whimsical revealed judgments.11 judgments; other almost unlimited power. Not there great diversity among States. There differences individual composed largely lawyers, should gone process elaborate definition impliedly allowed eccentricities accidents variegated practice, assumption ought solider than syllogism. Without more, believe status Act—to unpredictable attack.12 16 Finally, suggested found taking appeals order, supra, naturalize, require resort exclusive, 17 One answer successor, 1940, appellate review errors court. hand, laboriously dealt otherwise illegally. And so ingrained part American justice, naturally held assumed denied did affirmatively confer Of course judiciaries taken. narrow unimportant range13 compared enormous quixotic relating illegality. one thing allow play joints statutory enforceable both federal courts. another inject wholly dislocating factor incorporating vacating into process, comprehensively 18 Congressional concern uniformity post-naturalization shown very connection. mode Courts State, federal, H.R. 15442, 13. Constitutional doubts practical problems anomalous raise led omission section, leaving 7784—7787. supposed, where, denaturalization, anomalies present, gratuitously abandon constitutional mandate 'an Naturalization.' established 19 Accordingly, must reversed reinstated. 20 ordered. 21 Judgment 22 CLARK MINTON took decision case. 23 For dissenting REED, joined BURTON, see 138. 24 APPENDIX. 25 Power Vacate Their Own Judgments1 26 governing illustrated following: 27 (1) common rule, still followed duration entered entertain change it.2 inevitably produce erratic naturalization:3 28 (a) differ substantially length terms legislature Martindale-Hubbell Law Directory, 'Court Calendars' (1951). example, several counties Kentucky holds six days' duration; contrast, Oklahoma months length. 29 (b) Even vary greatly. Consider Indiana, example. Marion County (Indianapolis) Superior monthly terms; Lake lasting months.4 30 (c) good fluctuate amount business untrammelled discretion adjourning sine die. Unless adjourned die concluded terminal date statute, term, general, ends commencement next succeeding place. Comes Comes, 1920, 190 Iowa 547, 178 N.W. 403; Hensley 1931, 53 Okl.Cr. 22, P.2d 211. Thus, less day length, might full year annually. 31 (d) uncertainty rule.' permitted ten months. E.g., Rhode Island Providence, R.I.Gen.Laws 1938, c. 498, 2. first months—under Government; whereas fortunate last indefeasibly safe-guarded (2) number statutes similar Alabama reading: 'The transaction business, every kind, times.' Ala.Code Tit. 13, 114. wide disparity introduced following circumstances: Some provide statute them fixed time; times greatly: year: 33 Minnesota—Minn.Stat.1949, 544.32, M.S.A. 60 days: (courts continuous session)—Ky.Rev.Stat.1946, 451.130(1). 35 Alabama—Ala.Code 119. 36 Illinois—Ill.Rev.Stat.1949, 77, 82. 37 (Baltimore City Court)—See Harvey Slacum, 1942, 181 Md. 206, A.2d 276. 38 New Mexico—N.M.Stat.1941, 19—901. 39 Other need filed period; periods varies considerably: 'A reasonable exceeding months:' 41 Arizona—Ariz.Code Ann.1939, 21—1502. 42 California—Deering's Cal.Code Civ.Proc.1949, 473. months: 43 Nevada—See Lauer Eighth Judicial 62 Nev. 78, 140 953. 44 rate either produces different consequences 45 (3) appears, signed entered. Louisiana Bank Hampton, La.1816, Mart., O.S., 94; Nelson & Co. Rocquet Co., 1909, 123 La. 91, 48 So. 756. Massachusetts 'on mere motion' clerical error. Shawmut Commercial Paper Cram, 1912, 212 Mass. 108, 98 N.E. 696. Mass.Gen. Laws 1932, 250, 14—20. whom BURTON joins, dissenting. 47 immediately Bindczyck, soldier Army. 324, 1149, 724. he disclaimed loyalty stated desire country war. discovered showed Bindczyck swore falsely concerning toward defense. charge. Thereupon vacated, voided, restored pending calendar immediate shows further hearing appeal. 49 1948, custody deportation, complaint praying declaration contention admission void note Court's opinion, 131. 50 upholds Bindczyck's contention. collateral determines cancellation accordance above-mentioned is, state act, hear enter 301. 51 judgment, think, flows disregard postulate construction. important principle new construed existing practice.1 Since sound methods interpretation seems worthwhile reasons disagreement. dissent help avoid departure normal interpretation. 52 comprehensive considered though entire body continuation practices assumed. give concurrent matters course, tribunals Congress.2 also, assume, limits powers rights. When grants matters, respective necessary implication requires limitation.3 March 1790.4 They grown complexity years. sought protect inconvenient forum notice. carried present practically words, far sections concerned. remained jurisdiction.5 suggestion acts that, earlier intended affect trials rehearings limited prescribe. aside' 'canceling certificate' refers overturning required end. view, cases circumstances call Government, specified subsection 301 (54 1140) bringing suit'. defendant 'make States'. language aimed litigation, steps case.6 Action step case.7 55 citizenship, signs order. CFR (1949 ed.) 377.1. successful certificate. settled law, allowable 575, 3, 580, 426, 428, reached arguments advanced 'exclusive jurisdiction' conferred trial means reason guide here, denial engraft exception universal p. 579 (see pp. 578—580), 427, 428. ruling compels distinction today's opinion. now '§ record.' sustained cancel certificates today differentiates making existence dehors least procurement, incident bar rehearing evidence. think departs engrafts 57 certainty revoked point. elaborated, do 'would Naturalization." determined according particular utilize violate uniformity.8 kind approves allowing 58 Interpretation government officials charged carries weight.9 increases importance. Apparently avails itself directly rules.10 Service, thus understanding does limit time. 59 consider preventing seem justified. well-established principles construction, furthering purpose, puts useless ultimate benefit citizen. formalistic approach legal helpful justice. affirmed. 1158, 738, pertinent portions are: '(a) duty districts, affidavit showing cause therefor, suit, person '(b) fraudulently procured shall, sixty personal make States; absent residence, publication manner service summons absentees laws place brought.' Eddy Summers, 1944, 183 683, 687, 812, 814. As early 1844, Senate resolution called inquiry possibility certificates. S.J., 28th 2d 40, 44. pre-Civil War activity Franklin, Legislative History Annual messages Presidents, onward, remedial legislation. Richardson, Messages Papers Presidents: Grant, Message, 1869, 6th 1874, 7th 1875, 8th 1876; Arthur, 4th 1884; Cleveland, 1885, 1886, 1888; Harrison, 1889, 1890; Roosevelt, 3d 1903, 1904, 5th 1905. Cleveland asserted obtain acquired asked correction deficiency. Id., Message 1874; 1885. Harrison attention 'new familiar whereby hundred General suits. saw urgent remaining adequate prenaturalization investigation. 1890. grand jury investigated Special Assistant prosecution York City. v, 392 (1903); 76. special examiner Department investigation, transmitted Congress. 393 (1903). Generally Roche, Pre-Statutory Denaturalization, Cornell L.Q. 120. 11—15, 23, 76—78, 79—92; Hearings Committee Bills Establish Naturalization, Provide Uniform Aliens Throughout 3—54; H.R.Rep.No.1789, 2; S.Rep.No.4373, 3640 ff. Naturalization. 17, 99. Second recommended 397 (1903) Examiner Relation No more thoroughly debated one. Three separate amendments reduce rejected. 7762—7770. cut thirty 1156, 734(c), 734(c). codifiers reiterated delay permit eligibility competency witnesses.' 6127 superseded 9980, 76th 466. advantage Bureau. H.R.Rep.No.1328, 69th 1. 1926, investigations formal permitting officers applicant's witnesses authorizing forego recommendation favorable. 709. extended 733, 733. 1,916 canceled civil two-year May 76; case, nine parte oral purporting proceedings, three years was, 7045 announcement San Francisco immunity holder surrendered cancellation, 204 turned days. Objections raised, grounds, stay issuance argued partisan attorney influence close election judiciously choosing stay. 7786. deserves emphasis dealing (the was) procured,' us, decide, extent correcting And, touch situations come being until event rendered. Compare Commissioner Estate Bedford, 325 283, 284—288, 65 1157, 1158—1159, 89 1611. 734, 734. varieties illustratively summarized Appendix 136. inattentive variations wished absorb portion 338(b) reads: '* (Emphasis added.) Vagaries substantial. range principally Pound, Appellate Procedure Civil Cases, 340—342. hardly best effort secure fastidious accuracy currency assure them. especially treacherous outsider. unlikely attack. 'having seal, clerk, actions equity, controversy unlimited', 1140, 701(a), canvassed. procedures—statutory law—for suit. Kan.Gen.Stat.1949, 60—3007 argue available why argument implied relevant controlling medieval idea dividing purposes vacations developed necessities sowing harvesting, demands Church religious peace certain seasons year. Reeves, English Law, 191—192; Holdsworth, 674—675. used illustration division which, discloses, follow Texas provides striking illustrations single State. greatly county per session, others sit 'till finished,' 4, 6, weeks. longer become 'as expired.' Vernon's Tex.Civ.Stat., 2092 (30); Joy Young, Tex.Civ.App.1946, 194 S.W.2d 159. Sanges, 144 310, 311, 609, 445; Crawford, Statutory Construction, XXII; Bishop Criminal (9th ed., Zane Zollman, 1923) 291b. Cf. Stark Wickard, 321 288, 309, 64 559, 570, 88 733; Burnet Harmel, 287 103, 74, 76, 77 199. examples, 1333, 1334, 1338(a), 1351, 1355, 1356, 1356. adverted Employers' Liability Mondou York, N.H. 223 1, 56, 169, 178, 327, words: 'Because observations supreme errors, end therein accurately understood, deem observe attempt enlarge regulate courts, modes ordinary jurisdiction, occasion, invoked conformity take cognizance enforce recovery arising act susceptible prevailing procedure.' 1790, 103. Report Secretary January 19, appended 58. 15; 236, 614, 615, 1066: 'It authorize direct attack independent 1906.' Ness, 245 319, 326, 118, 121, 321, speaks affording 'independent suit.' 'Knowing decree, leases, decree.' Henderson Carbondale Coal Coke 25, 691, 696, 332; Goddard Ordway, 101 745, 749—751, 1040; Zimmern 298 167, 706, 80 1118. Hanover National Moyses, 186 181, 189, 857, 861, 1113; Wright Vinton Bank, 300 440, 463, 7, 556, 562, 81 736; Fernandez Wiener, 326 340, 359, 66 187, 90 116. Trucking Ass'ns, 310 534, 545, 1059, 1064, 1345. Petition Weltzien, 68 F.Supp. 1000; Cir.,

Category: 1