Opinion Euro

Monetary independence is overrated, and the euro is riding high
Old misgivings about the currency are increasingly unpersuasive — it is becoming
more attractive by the day
MARTIN SANDBU

Changes under way in how money works speak to the euro’s advantage © Florian Gaul/dpa

Martin Sandbu JANUARY 8 2023

Shortly after the last paroxysm of the eurozone debt crisis — Greece’s brush with
rupture from the single currency in summer 2015 — a colleague wagered that
within a decade, the euro would have lost at least one member. So far, it has been
the exact opposite: the monetary union has just gained a member, with Croatia’s
accession at the start of the new year.
That power of attraction is not a one-off. Remember that during the rockiest years
for the monetary union, one Baltic state after another went ahead and joined. And
next-in-line Bulgaria will no doubt be allowed to adopt the euro soon. (A number
of smaller, poorer European jurisdictions also use the euro either through
unilateral adoption or as the result of informal private-sector euroisation.)
One could say there is nothing to see here — that it would be surprising if small
open economies did not want to share in the monetary policymaking of the
currency that dominated their trade relationship. But so entrenched is the view
that the euro in its current form is doomed to failure — especially among AngloA

i

i t

th t

fl ti

it l t t

i

i ti

l

F

American economists — that some reflection on its latest expansion is timely. For
the old misgivings are becoming increasingly unpersuasive, while changes under
way in how money works speak to the euro’s advantage.

In recent years it has — or should have — become increasingly clear that monetary
“independence” in the sense of having one’s own floating currency is not all it is
cracked up to be. The advantage is supposed to be that a falling currency can offset
negative shocks by boosting exports. As the 2016 drop in sterling after Britain’s EU
referendum demonstrated, however, in a world of long and complex cross-border
supply chains, a depreciation may only make your population poorer by driving up
the price of imports, with no boost to export volumes.
The advantages of monetary integration, meanwhile, are highlighted by Europe’s
energy price crisis. Take Slovakia. Yes, it has to contend with similarly high
inflation to its non-euro neighbours. But it does so while enjoying a much lower
interest rate (the European Central Bank’s 2.5 per cent) than the Czech Republic
and Poland, where borrowing costs are nearly three times higher, or Hungary’s 13
per cent.
Size matters in a global economy whose rhythm is still set by the US financial cycle,
and it is only the monetary unity of the euro economies that affords the ECB a
degree of independence from the US Federal Reserve.
Second, the vulnerabilities that emerged during the eurozone crisis are now easier
to see as the sort of crises that can afflict anyone, including economies with
independent floating currencies, rather than a sui generis weakness in the euro.
Italy remains the country where doomsayers think the combination of high debt
and low growth must eventually cause the euro’s demise. Last summer, however, it
was not Italy, but the UK’s new populist government that badly rattled markets
with irresponsible policymaking. Eventually, the Bank of England had to intervene
to contain sovereign yields.
While the ECB may still be tested in this regard, it has an advantage in being more
independent from its political masters than any national central bank. If anything,
the BoE has greater reason to fear accusations of monetary financing — which it
has been palpably anxious to rebut — and which complicated its messaging when it
switched from selling gilts to buying them in the autumn market panic. The ECB,
by contrast, set up a permanent instrument to deal with similar occurrences last

summer, to little controversy.
All this suggests that the euro is going to become more, not less attractive over
time. The appeal of different currencies will be further transformed by how they
manage the next big leap in central banking: the introduction of an official digital
currency. So far, only marginal economies such as the Bahamas and Nigeria have
gone all the way — though China is clearly readying its capability to scale up the
digital renminbi it has been trialling.
Among rich economies, however, the ECB has quickly moved into the lead. Finance
ministers swung defensively behind the digital euro after a move by Facebook in
2019 to create a private global digital payment system. But their support is now
enhanced by the business opportunities looming in an economy with safe
“programmable” money.
Officially, a digital euro is only in the exploration stage. But politically it has
reached a point of no return. After Croatia, future entrants to the monetary union
will enjoy having a cutting edge digital currency thrown into the bargain.
martin.sandbu@ft.com

Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2023. All rights reserved.