unimelb-nlp/MultiEup-v2 huggingface dataset:
Debate: Revision of the Stability and Growth Pact
Date: TUESDAY, 9 MAY 2023
Speaker: Georgios Kyrtsos
Political group: Renew
Country: Germany
Language: EN

Mr President, we have to improve our policy on three major issues. First, we have to put an end to the continuous increase in public expenditure in absolute numbers and as a percentage of the GDP. The growth in public debt has been spectacular: higher debt unavoidably leads to higher tax burden. Second, we have to improve the quality of public expenditure in favour of investment. Certain European governments prefer to spend money in a way as to promote their electoral strategy rather than serve the real needs of the economy. Third, we need more European discipline and coordination. Investment projects at the national level should be better connected with a broader European effort to compete with the USA and China.
Debate: Revision of the Stability and Growth Pact
Date: TUESDAY, 9 MAY 2023
Speaker: Eugen Jurzyca
Political group: ECR
Country: Belgium
Language: SK

Pán predsedajúci, Európa má pred sebou vážny problém. Okrem následkov pandémie, vojny na Ukrajine, cien energií je zaťažená aj starnutím populácie a pomerne nákladnými zelenými politikami, ktoré spolu s tým všetkým povedú k navýšeniu verejných výdavkov o vyše tri percentá HDP ročne. Členské štáty by teda už dnes mali v zásade tvoriť rozpočtové prebytky, ak majú byť pripravené plniť pravidlo maximálne trojpercentného deficitu. Eurozóna pre svoje zachovanie potrebuje jasné fiškálne pravidlá, pravidlá, ktoré budú jednoduché, efektívne a prísne. Politické ciele musia podliehať fiškálnym obmedzeniam a nie naopak. Nech je nám mementom, že kombinácia ambicióznych cieľov, odtrhnutých od fiškálnych obmedzení, ktorú sme pestovali, a nielen my, od začiatku pandémie, vyústila do kumulácie nových verejných dlhov a najväčšej miery inflácie eurozóny.
Debate: Revision of the Stability and Growth Pact
Date: TUESDAY, 9 MAY 2023
Speaker: Kostas Papadakis
Political group: NI
Country: Czechia
Language: EL

Κύριε Πρόεδρε, ένα αντιλαϊκό πολυεργαλείο ενεργοποιείται σε βάρος του λαού από οποιαδήποτε κυβέρνηση της επόμενης μέρας και στην Ελλάδα. Επαναφέρεται το Σύμφωνο Σταθερότητας και Ανάκαμψης σε συνδυασμό με το Μέσο Ανάκαμψης και τη λεγόμενη «πράσινη και ψηφιακή μετάβαση».  Για παράδειγμα, στην Ελλάδα, είτε με ΝΔ είτε με ΣΥΡΙΖΑ στην κυβέρνηση, προβλέπονται πρωτογενή πλεονάσματα με προαπαιτούμενα αντιλαϊκές μεταρρυθμίσεις ή μηχανισμούς. Για το παραμικρό που θα εμφανίζεται ως μόνιμη παροχή στον λαό, θα πρέπει να το αντισταθμίζουν με ισόποση αύξηση της φορολογίας από το «μενού» των «άγριων» πράσινων φόρων της δέσμης Fit for 55 που ψήφισαν όλοι τους εδώ στο Ευρωπαϊκό Κοινοβούλιο, δηλαδή με αυξήσεις σε καύσιμα, στην αναβάθμιση κτιρίων, ακόμα και πιο τσουχτερά αεροπορικά και ακτοπλοϊκά εισιτήρια ή με περικοπές κρατικών δαπανών. Όλες οι εξοικονομήσεις που ο λαός θα πληρώνει από τους διαλυμένους μισθούς του θα «ταΐζουν» τις αποπληρωμές του Μέσου Ανάκαμψης, του πακτωλού που «ξεκοκκαλίζουν» οι μεγάλοι όμιλοι, και θα πριμοδοτούν τη λεγόμενη «πολεμική οικονομία» του ιμπεριαλιστικού σφαγείου στην Ουκρανία.  Απέναντι στον νέο «κορσέ» που θα φορέσει στον λαό η όποια δεδομένα αντιλαϊκή κυβέρνηση, ο λαός μπορεί να τους αντιμετωπίσει μόνο με ένα πολύ πιο ισχυρό κομμουνιστικό κόμμα.
Debate: Revision of the Stability and Growth Pact
Date: TUESDAY, 9 MAY 2023
Speaker: Frances Fitzgerald
Political group: PPE
Country: Germany
Language: EN

Mr President, good morning and Happy Europe Day to all my colleagues and to the people of Ireland and Europe.  It is appropriate that we are today discussing reform of a fundamental part of our European project – budgetary rules – to keep our economy and monetary union strong. It does require robust rules, but they must also be credible and credibly implemented. Our citizens must understand and feel that their concerns and vulnerabilities in the present climate are understood and dealt with.  Rules must be more than symbolic, which is why reform is needed, and I acknowledge the Commission’s work. We also must acknowledge, of course, the growing demands on our states, as we have seen in recent years, but also create mobility and opportunities for everyone.  We need a framework that is simpler, more risk-based, and with an increased focus on the medium-term that will help implementation and enforcement, and we must promote investment in Europe and, of course, debt sustainability.  There are divisions, but I would say that achieving compromise is in all our interests. Robust, realistic and credible budgetary rules will help us build a more secure economic union. Happy Europe Day!
Debate: Revision of the Stability and Growth Pact
Date: TUESDAY, 9 MAY 2023
Speaker: Margarida Marques
Political group: S-D
Country: Cyprus
Language: PT

Senhor Presidente, Senhora Ministra, Senhor Vice—Presidente, as propostas legislativas confirmam vários pedidos do Parlamento para a reforma de governação económica. A análise caso a caso da dívida e da despesa ou a inclusão do Pilar Europeu dos Direitos Sociais são disso exemplo. Mas a inclusão de novos  Estas propostas são mais amigas da disciplina financeira do que amigas do investimento e das reformas estratégicas. Sem um instrumento de investimento comum permanente, esta reforma estará incompleta. Os investimentos certos trazem contas certas. O contrário não é garantido.
Debate: Revision of the Stability and Growth Pact
Date: TUESDAY, 9 MAY 2023
Speaker: Caroline Nagtegaal
Political group: Renew
Country: Czechia
Language: NL

Voorzitter, commissaris, de schuldenberg in Europa is al veel te lang veel te hoog, en jarenlang zag de Commissie dit door de vingers. We moeten daar nu echt wat aan doen. En waarom? Het kan toch niet zo zijn dat de Nederlandse belastingbetaler de rekening gepresenteerd krijgt als andere landen er een potje van maken. En nu breekt het moment aan dat we moeten doen wat nodig is om de begroting in het gareel te krijgen en de staatsschulden terug te brengen. Dat vergt begrotingsregels die realistisch zijn, die handhaafbaar zijn. Dat vergt dat alle landen zich aan de regels houden die we met elkaar afspreken. En dat vergt een Europese Unie die optreedt als die regels overtreden worden. Want tenslotte, belofte maakt schuld.
Debate: Revision of the Stability and Growth Pact
Date: TUESDAY, 9 MAY 2023
Speaker: Mislav Kolakušić
Political group: NI
Country: Greece
Language: HR

Poštovani predsjedavajući, kolege, dragi građani, danas govorimo o financijskoj odgovornosti. O kakvoj mi to financijskoj odgovornosti govorimo kada je von der Leyen u ime 450 milijuna stanovnika Europske unije naručila cjepiva koja ne postoje za 70 miljardi eura?  Mi ovdje, Europski parlament, zatvorio je vrata 2020. godine u ožujku. Što sam tada rekao i dovelo je do ekonomskog uništenja dijela gospodarstva. To ekonomsko, potpuno bespotrebno uništenje, mi pokušavamo pokriti Next Generation planom, planom zaduženja od 1700 milijardi eura koji će zadužiti generacije i pokoljenja građana Europske unije.  Na što će se taj novac potrošiti? Kako se raspoređuje taj novac? Uvijek ga vladajuće pokvarene strukture daju isključivo vlastitim simpatizerima. Većina građana od toga nema ništa.
Debate: Revision of the Stability and Growth Pact
Date: TUESDAY, 9 MAY 2023
Speaker: Danuta Maria Hübner
Political group: PPE
Country: Germany
Language: EN

Mr President, the review of the Stability and Growth Pact is not only about bringing back a reinvented pact with strong enforcement, including the rule of law mechanism, allowing for progressive consolidation of public finance and investing in the future. There is much more than a macroeconomic angle to it, and recently implemented reforms should be incorporated into the governance framework. Sustainability of the debt is fundamental in the long run, but in parallel we need to strengthen the role of fiscal policy in shifting Europe away from its business model, and use public investment to boost changes to the way we run Europe and its structural change. We are now pivoting to a completely different world and we need to focus collectively on economic resilience and security without abandoning the competitiveness perspective. There is a need to move away from strategic dependencies without switching to new ones. With a growing risk of a global subsidy race, smart use of public money becomes a bigger challenge than ever, and European public goods are crucial when national economies suffer from limited fiscal space, when you cannot just cut the debt but grow your way out of debt, and when a broader group of actors have to be brought into this pivot towards a different world.
Debate: Revision of the Stability and Growth Pact
Date: TUESDAY, 9 MAY 2023
Speaker: René Repasi
Political group: S-D
Country: Netherlands
Language: DE

Herr Präsident, Herr Vizepräsident, liebe Kolleginnen und Kollegen! Die Reform des Stabilitäts- und Wachstumspakts war mehr als überfällig. Überfällig, weil die Regeln schlicht nicht eingehalten worden sind, und zwar, weil die Fantasiewelt der Fiskalregeln in keinster Weise etwas mit der ökonomischen Realität zu tun hatte. Deswegen ist positiv, dass die Kommission Lektionen gelernt hat, dass sie eine Ausgabenregel geschaffen hat. Es ist gut, dass die Kommission die Lektion gelernt hat und weg ist von starren Abbauregeln. Die Konsequenz davon ist, dass die Kommission jetzt aber hinter verschlossenen Türen mit jedem Mitgliedstaat verhandeln möchte, wie denn ihre Haushaltslage auszusehen hat. Und da frage ich mich: Wo sind denn hier die Parlamente? Der Vorschlag wiederholt einfach nur den alten ökonomischen Dialog, und das bringt uns nichts. Nein, wenn die Kommission mehr Macht haben möchte – und, liebe Kolleginnen und Kollegen von rechts, die Kommission ist gewählt! –, dann muss sie aber ordentlich kontrolliert werden, und zwar mehr als bislang. Die mittelfristigen strukturellen, finanzpolitischen Pläne in den Mitgliedstaaten sollen, bitte sehr, in den nationalen Parlamenten diskutiert und, bitte sehr, von den nationalen Parlamenten angenommen werden. Dann kommen wir hier einen Schritt weiter. Und, liebe Kommission, wo ist die Investitionsklausel hingegangen? Wir brauchen mehr Flexibilität, aber diese geht nur gegen Zweckbindung.
Debate: Revision of the Stability and Growth Pact
Date: TUESDAY, 9 MAY 2023
Speaker: Mauri Pekkarinen
Political group: Renew
Country: Denmark
Language: FI

Arvoisa puhemies, olemme eläneet poikkeuksellisia aikoja, siksi finanssipoliittisia sääntöjä ei ole tarvinnut noudattaa. Vapauksia on käytetty, velaksi on eletty ja riskit ovat kasvaneet. Jos kamelin selkä katkeaa yhdessä maassa, maksumiehiä ovat kohta kaikki. Sääntöjen uudistamisella on siis kiire. Komissio arvioi nyt, että kriteerien höllentämiseen olisi varaa. Tästä kertovat monet kriteereihin, eli kolmen prosentin ja 60 prosentin sääntöihin, esitetyt joustomahdollisuudet. Komission esityksessä nojataan vahvasti keskipitkän aikavälin rakenneuudistuksiin, kestäviin investointeihin ja joustoihin. Sopeutumisuran pidentäminen, mikä tässä komission esityksessä toteutettaisiin, ei välttämättä takaa pidemmän aikavälin velkakestävyyttä, ja tästä syystä mielestäni tämä esitys on vähän löysä.
Debate: Revision of the Stability and Growth Pact
Date: TUESDAY, 9 MAY 2023
Speaker: Angelika Winzig
Political group: PPE
Country: Greece
Language: DE

Herr Präsident! Der Stabilitäts- und Wachstumspakt soll den Mitgliedstaaten nicht mehr Möglichkeiten geben, Schulden aufzubauen, sondern sie durch gezielte Programme beim Schuldenabbau unterstützen. Wir wissen doch aus der Vergangenheit, wie es war, als einige Mitgliedstaaten im Schatten des Euros, ohne Strukturreformen durchzuführen, Schulden aufgebaut hatten, und die anderen Mitgliedstaaten mussten dann zur Rettung einspringen. Bei uns in der Bevölkerung gingen damals die Wogen hoch, und die Begeisterung für die EU hat sich dramatisch verringert. Daher muss es unser Ziel sein, dass auch die nächsten Generationen Gestaltungsspielraum haben und dass wir nicht in eine Schuldenunion schlittern. Und Investitionen in den Grünen Deal dürfen auch jetzt von den Mitgliedstaaten nicht als Ausrede für neue Schulden verwendet werden, denn wir haben bereits in vielen Bereichen Mittel dafür bereitgestellt. Daher brauchen wir ein zuverlässiges System zum Defizitabbau wie auch zur Reduzierung der Schuldenquote.
Debate: Revision of the Stability and Growth Pact
Date: TUESDAY, 9 MAY 2023
Speaker: Aurore Lalucq
Political group: S-D
Country: France
Language: FR

Monsieur le Président, Monsieur le Vice-président, Madame la Ministre, je crois que nous sommes tous en train de saluer l’assouplissement des règles budgétaires. C’est effectivement bienvenu. C’est un premier pas dans la bonne direction. Maintenant, à nous de l’améliorer. L’angle mort de cette réforme, et d’ailleurs du débat qu’on est en train d’avoir aujourd’hui, c’est la question des recettes. Enfin, on est toujours en train de parler de la question des dépenses, la question des règles. Si on prend la question des finances publiques au sérieux, on s’intéresse aussi aux recettes, notamment si on a besoin d’investissements publics, ce qui va être le cas. Deux propositions. Une proposition évidemment, dont on a parlé hier, qui est d’avoir une capacité budgétaire au niveau européen, mais aussi d’avoir, pourquoi pas, une règle fiscale, c’est-à-dire de dire aux pays: «Vous avez la possibilité de dépenser plus, mais dans ce cas-là, financez.» Et financer, ça passe par quoi, quand on est un État? Ça passe par l’impôt, tout simplement. Ce qui nous permettrait par ailleurs de remettre un peu d’ordre dans la fiscalité qui a été détruite par 40 années de mondialisation. Et puis un autre point: éviter des dépenses, c’est aussi ne pas sauver les banques et c’est donc bien réglementer les banques.
Debate: Revision of the Stability and Growth Pact
Date: TUESDAY, 9 MAY 2023
Speaker: Ljudmila Novak
Political group: PPE
Country: Lithuania
Language: SL

Gospod predsednik. Spoštovani predsedujoči, gospod komisar, kolegice in kolegi.  Pakt stabilnosti in rasti je potreben, če želimo ohraniti zaupanje v našo skupno valuto, zaupanje med državami in tudi zaupanje v institucije in politike Evropske unije.  V kriznih časih je potrebna večja fleksibilnost. To pa ne sme trajati v nedogled, sicer se problemi samo povečujejo. Prav tako ni fer, da bi nekatere države prekomerno trošile, druge pa pokrivale njihove dolgove.  Odgovorni politiki mislijo tudi na prihodnje generacije, zato usmerjajo denar v prave projekte za rast in stabilnost, omejujejo pa izdatke za hitro nabiranje političnih točk.  Čestitke vsem ob dnevu Evrope, ki naj ohranja mir, stabilnost, sodelovanje in tudi medsebojno zaupanje.
Debate: Revision of the Stability and Growth Pact
Date: TUESDAY, 9 MAY 2023
Speaker: Maria Grapini
Political group: S-D
Country: Portugal
Language: RO

Domnule președinte, domnule comisar, stimați colegi, în primul rând, la mulți ani de Ziua Europei și la mulți ani și României, că astăzi sărbătorește Ziua Independenței. E bine că discutăm chiar de Ziua Europei Pactul de stabilitate și da, avem nevoie de schimbări în Pactul de stabilitate. Dar v-ați gândit, doamnă ministru, domnule comisar, și la un pact de solidaritate? Cum stabilim acest Pact de stabilitate dacă nu ne gândim la faptul că nu a crescut coeziunea socială, că avem încă regiuni sărace, că avem încă copii în sărăcie. Nu putem să facem Patul lui Procust, pentru că sunt diferit dezvoltate țările. Vreau să vă mai spun că acum, de Ziua Europei, înregistrează Uniunea Europeană un mare eșec, și anume: avem piața fragmentată și da, România nu este în Schengen. Lăsăm Austria să zburde ca un cal sălbatic în Uniunea Europeană și să distrugă proiectul Uniunii Europene, creând aceste nedreptăți pentru cetățenii europeni. Când facem un Pact de stabilitate, trebuie să ne gândim cum facem o piață unică, cum facem ca statele membre să poată să iasă din sărăcie în zonele sărace și mai ales gândiți-vă, domnule comisar, că există subsidiaritate pentru politica fiscală.
Debate: Revision of the Stability and Growth Pact
Date: TUESDAY, 9 MAY 2023
Speaker: Denis Nesci
Political group: ECR
Language: IT

Signor Presidente, onorevoli colleghi, pur riconoscendo lo sforzo del tentativo di superare la rigidità delle attuali norme finanziarie europee, dobbiamo sottolineare che le scelte della Commissione non tengono in considerazione l'alterazione di uno scenario fortemente condizionato da guerra, inflazione e crisi energetica, con gli effetti collaterali in termini economici che ne sono scaturiti. Puntare su transizione verde, digitale e difesa, ignorando queste priorità nel calcolo del rapporto deficit/PIL e dunque nelle nuove regole della governance europea, sarebbe un errore di valutazione politica. Per rilanciare la nostra competitività abbiamo bisogno di una politica economica adeguata e solida, accompagnata da regole che dovrebbero essere predisposte per andare incontro alle esigenze degli Stati membri. Pertanto l'esclusione delle spese di investimento dal calcolo delle spese-obiettivo su cui si misura il rispetto dei parametri, inclusi quelli del PNRR sul digitale e transazione verde, sarebbe stata la strada da percorrere, per limitare i vincoli che impediscono il pieno sviluppo degli asset economici del nostro Paese. L'auspicio è che, durante le negoziazioni, il testo finale venga migliorato per raggiungere un maggiore equilibrio tra i due fattori, stabilità e crescita, entrambi necessari.
Debate: Revision of the Stability and Growth Pact
Date: TUESDAY, 9 MAY 2023
Speaker: Marc Botenga
Political group: The Left
Country: France
Language: FR

Monsieur le Président, Monsieur le Commissaire, vous revenez donc avec l’austérité, avec le pacte de stabilité. C’est une austérité 2.0, plus de pouvoir pour la Commission européenne, des sanctions plus faciles et un marchandage permanent entre réformes néolibérales et coupes budgétaires. Je m’étonne d’ailleurs qu’il y ait des collègues socialistes qui vous applaudissent, parce que vous revenez avec vos critères ridicules des 3 % et des 60 % – que le déficit budgétaire ne peut pas dépasser les 3 % du PIB et que la dette publique ne peut pas dépasser les 60 %. Vous-même, vous ne savez pas pourquoi. Vous ne le savez pas. Pourquoi 60 %, et pas 40 ou pas 80? Le Japon en est à 250 %, je crois. Vous inventez n’importe quoi parce que cela ne sert qu’à une chose, à privatiser et casser nos services publics, à obliger les pays à privatiser, à vendre nos écoles, nos pensions, nos chemins de fer au plus offrant. Nos soins de santé, d’ailleurs, parlons-en: l’austérité a été un désastre. Nous résisterons à cette austérité 2.0.
Debate: Revision of the Stability and Growth Pact
Date: TUESDAY, 9 MAY 2023
Speaker: Mick Wallace
Political group: The Left
Country: Germany
Language: EN

Mr President, the EU Commission’s redesign of the EU fiscal rules is very disappointing. The new fiscal rules, if agreed, allow more leeway to individual Member States in how to spend their national budget. But there is a serious price to be paid. It’s worrying to read in the Commission’s proposed document, delivered to Parliament in November 2022, that one of the reasons for the easing of the rules is due to the fact that Member States should be allowed to build up their defence spend. The proposal states as follows on page four: ‘The green and digital transitions, the need to ensure energy security as well as social and economic resilience, and to build up defence capabilities, will require sustained high levels of investment in the years to come.’ It seems the hawks and Brussels have used the war in Ukraine to incorporate defence spending into the new fiscal rules. This is shameful and should be called out for what it is: it’s called warmongering.
Debate: Revision of the Stability and Growth Pact
Date: TUESDAY, 9 MAY 2023
Speaker: Sirpa Pietikäinen
Political group: PPE
Country: Italy
Language: FI

Arvoisa puhemies, ensimmäiseksi haluan kiittää komissiota kohtuullisen hyvästä ja balansoidusta esityksestä vakaus- ja kasvusopimuksen tarkistamiseksi. Se vastaa tärkeimpiin haasteisiin, kuten maakohtaisuuden lisäämiseen. Se on aikajänteeltään kohtuullisen realistinen. Sitovuudessa olisi toivomisen varaa niin, että näiden kahden vastapainoksi voisimme oikeasti myöskin velka- ja vajekattoa katsoa nykyistä ehdotusta sitovammin. Se, missä toivon komission liikkuvan eteenpäin, on myöskin mittaristouudistaminen: millä tapaa mittaamme velkaa ja myöskin BKT:tä? Tiedämme kaikki, että BKT-mittaristo nykyisellään on varsin puutteellinen, ja niin myöskin velka- ja kasvusopimuksen osalta pitää katsoa sosiaalista ja ympäristöpääomaa ja myös analysoida sitä, mikä on huonoa velkaa, esimerkiksi fossiiliset tuet, ja mikä on hyvää, vihreää siirtymää tukevaa velkaa.
Debate: Revision of the Stability and Growth Pact
Date: TUESDAY, 9 MAY 2023
Speaker: Tsvetelina Penkova
Political group: S-D
Country: Croatia
Language: EN

Mr President, Commissioner, Minister, you’ve all mentioned that investments and reforms are incentivised. Here, I would just ask, how would we define strategic reforms? Are they going to be green or are they going to be social? What’s going to be the focus? And how are we finding to strike the balance among Member States? The worry we all have is,  some of the rich Member States would be capable of investing more, which is going to increase the discrepancies among Member States and it contradicts with the main policy of the EU: cohesion.  And the second part, what are the rules going to be on the reforms? We have the lessons from the RRF. Europe is basically sitting on money at the moment. The conditionality and the complexity is affecting the efficient investment of this money. It’s probably no more than one third of the money from the RRF that has been properly put to use. And we should not allow this to happen – because then we are risking the growth and the sustainability of our economy.
Debate: Revision of the Stability and Growth Pact
Date: TUESDAY, 9 MAY 2023
Speaker: João Pimenta Lopes
Political group: The Left
Country: Romania
Language: PT

Senhor Presidente, do que estamos a falar não é de maior flexibilidade ou do aligeirar das regras. Pelo contrário, adicionam novos e mais pesados constrangimentos por parte das instituições da União Europeia e das potências que as controlam sobre Estados como Portugal. Querem impor um quadro normativo com crescentes intromissões na soberania e nas políticas e opções orçamentais, financeiras, económicas e sociais de Estados como Portugal, com mais sanções e com sanções mais fáceis de aplicar. Com a imposição de limitações à despesa primária, querem uma ainda maior pressão para a redução do investimento público, a não valorização de salários, o desinvestimento nos serviços públicos e outras funções sociais do Estado. Aquilo que se impõe é a definitiva revogação do Pacto de Estabilidade e dos seus derivados. Nada se deve sobrepor à utilização e concretização soberanas dos instrumentos e do potencial que Portugal tem à sua disposição para garantir os direitos e as aspirações dos trabalhadores e do povo português para desenvolver o país.
Debate: Revision of the Stability and Growth Pact
Date: TUESDAY, 9 MAY 2023
Speaker: Jessika Roswall
Language: EN

The March Council stated a view to conclude the legislative work in 2023. Yes, this is a tight time frame, but it is not an impossible time frame. As I said in my first statement, we need an updated framework in place to make sure that we have rules to support sound public finance, the reforms that promote growth and that keep our union strong and competitive. And I would like to reassure you that the Presidency is committed to work hard to advance as far as possible during this last leg of our Presidency, and that we are also in close contact with the incoming Spanish Presidency to ensure a smooth transition at the end of June. And we can count on the constructive spirit of all stakeholders involved to move this forward swiftly. And from what I hear here today in the debate, that is also a common view.