Naoto Shirogane
Concept and creation. Naoto was created for "Persona 4". She is a young detective who moves to Inaba, the setting of "Persona 4", to solve a serial-murder case. Due to the gendered stereotypes of detectives and institutional misogyny in law enforcement, Naoto presents as a man in order to hide her gender. In the Japanese version, Naoto uses 'boku', a typically male pronoun, while interchangeably using he and she in the English version. Naoto's design in "Persona 4 Arena" was inspired by the character Raidou Kuzunoha. When designing Naoto for "", designer Kazuhisa Wada depicted her dancing  style as more feminine to show Naoto embracing her feminine side more. Her dancing style comes from house music, with Wada noting that this dance style had a certain degree of sex appeal. Naoto is voiced by Romi Park in all appearances in Japanese. In English, Naoto was voiced Anna Graves in her initial appearances, and has been voiced by Valerie Arem from "Persona 4 Arena Ultimax" onward. Appearances. Naoto appears in "Persona 4" and is a detective trying to solve the murders in the game. Naoto uses herself as bait by appearing on TV and allowing herself to be  kidnapped by the culprit. The group follows Naoto to the TV world, where Naoto is confronted by her Shadow, who expresses their frustration with her birth sex and at being treated like a child by the police. Naoto explains after Shadow Naoto has been defeated due to the male-oriented nature of the police department, which is why she had been presenting as male. Once Naoto comes to understand her feelings, her Shadow turns into the Persona , a robotic humanoid wearing a blue suit jacket that has an insect-like head and butterfly-like wings. Following Naoto's recovery from  her time in the TV world, she joins the protagonists in finding the culprit, having gained clues about his method thanks to her kidnapping. Throughout Yu's interactions with Naoto, she regains her passion for being a detective. Depending on the player's actions, Naoto can become intimate with Yu. Naoto also decides that she isn't a detective just to uphold her family tradition, but because she wants to be and thoroughly enjoy it no matter her gender or age. Her Persona then evolves into , a humanoid in a white and blue traditional armed forces dress uniform with a  more bird-like appearance. In the game's ending, Naoto decides to stay in Inaba, unsure what to do now that the case is closed. In "Persona 4 Golden", Naoto gets the new Persona , whose outfit is red and blue, and has long, flowing blonde hair. Naoto appears as a playable character in "Persona 4 Arena", where she is pursuing the character Mitsuru Kirijo from "Persona 3". She later appears in "". A novel that takes place one year after "Persona 4" was released starring Naoto called "Persona 4 x Detective Naoto", where she is investigating the disappearance of her old  friend Touko Aoi. This novel was made by Dengeki Bunko. In Persona 5, Naoto is briefly mentioned on a TV special on 4/29 as, "the original Detective Prince" who was then being succeeded by the "new Detective Prince." Reception. Naoto has received overall positive reception. Kimberley Wallace of "Game Informer" ranked her as one of the best "Persona" characters. Geoff Thew of "Hardcore Gamer" found Naoto to be attractive due in part to her detective work. Andrew Clouther of "GameZone" expressed skepticism with how Naoto was being designed for "Persona 4: Dancing All Night", feeling that Naoto depicted in a  sexual light felt unlike her and expressed concern that it would be used to justify "fan-service." A swimsuit costume that Naoto wears in "Dancing All Night" was described as "conservative" by Matt Sainsbury of "Digitally Downloaded", who felt it fit her character. Mike Cosimano regarded her as a great character due to her pragmatism and quality detective work. Janine Hawkins of "Paste Magazine" praised her for her outfit, feeling that few could pull it off as well. Naoto's gender identity and status as a queer character has been the subject of discussion from critics. She has been interpreted  as both a cross-dressing woman and a trans man. Vrai Kaiser of "The Mary Sue" was initially hoping to find a "kindred spirit" with Naoto, but grew upset when they discovered that this was not the case. Michael Higham of "GameSpot" felt that certain choices players could make regarding her gender identity were insensitive. Carolyn Petit of "GameSpot" considered Naoto to be a trans man, but expressed disappointment that "Persona 4" seemed to reject this idea. She criticized the reasoning for Naoto presenting male, feeling it "rang false" due to finding it unbelievable for someone to live as a  different gender due to an attachment to fictional characters. She also took issue with characters changing their behavior towards Naoto, citing Yosuke flirting with her and characters explaining certain behaviors as being due to her gender as examples. Writer Mattie Brice found the depiction of Naoto to be transphobic, suggesting that the transgender character Erica Anderson from "Catherine" was indicative that the motives behind her depiction was questionable. Brice interpreted the scene between Naoto and her shadow as rejecting the need for sexual reassignment surgery in order to be a man. They criticized Naoto's Social Link, feeling it to  be a wasted opportunity and that the choices you can make regarding her gender identity. Despite their issues with the character, they found her character enjoyable and appreciated being able to explore the idea of dating a trans man. Carol Grant of "Vice" criticized Naoto, suggesting that the romance scenes were demeaning to Naoto's identity and while expressing disappointment in how Naoto's gender identity is handled. Authors of the book "Queerness in Play" discuss how Naoto's gender expression and struggles with gender is used to teach players about the transgender experience.