Atraumatic Restorative Treatment (ART)
Atraumatic Restorative Treatment (ART) is a method for cleaning out tooth decay (dental caries) from teeth using only hand instruments (dental hatchets and spoon-shape instruments) and placing a filling. It does not use rotary dental instruments (dental drills) to prepare the tooth and can be placed in settings with no access to dental equipment. No drilling or local anaesthetic injections (LA) are required. ART is considered a conservative approach, not only because it removes the decayed tissue with hand instruments, avoiding removing more tissue necessary which preserves as much tooth structure as possible, but also  because it avoids pulp irritation and minimises patient discomfort. ART can be used for small, medium and deep cavities (where decay has not reached the tooth nerve dental pulp) caused by dental caries. In shallow/medium sized cavities (lesions), the decayed tissue removal is carried out until the soft tissue (demineralised dentine) is completely removed and harder tissue is reached (firm dentine). In deeper cavities (lesions that reach more than 2/3 of dentine thickness on a radiograph), the removal of the decay must be carried out more carefully in order to avoid reaching the tooth’s pulp (dental nerve). Soft  tissue should be left on the cavity floor. The decision on how much decay to remove (whether to carry out the decay removal to firm dentine or stop when soft dentine has been reached) depends on: Dental radiographs need to be taken to evaluate the depth of the cavity and extension of decay. If too deep and close to the pulp, only the soft decayed tissue is removed from the cavity floor to avoid the risk of pulp exposure. ART is suitable for both primary (baby teeth) and permanent dentition (adult teeth) and has a large evidence base supporting it  (see “Effectiveness” section). Background and History. ART makes restorative oral care more accessible ART was firstly introduced by the dentist Jo Frencken in 1985, Tanzania (Frencken et al., 1996), where the management of decayed teeth in children living in a deprived area was challenging because access to dental treatments using drills was restricted by limited dentist availability and a lack of electricity and/or piped water. The pattern of disease/ care meant that children’s teeth generally decayed until they caused pain/infection and removal was required. At that time, the dentists tried to use only hand instruments to open and/or  enlarge small cavities, and selectively remove the decayed tissue, followed by the placement of an adhesive filling; Glass Ionomer Cement (GIC), which also releases fluoride and helps the tooth’s “recovery” from decay (remineralisation). This treatment was tested in clinical trials and found to be effective. Although ART was initially developed in response to the needs of populations with less access to dental care, this minimally invasive dental treatment (preserving as much as possible the dental tissues) had similar outcomes to more invasive treatments (local anaesthetic and drilling the tooth with dental bur). This means that it suitable for use  in any type of setting (from deprived communities to dental clinics) and it has been widely adopted into mainstream care. Due to its “atraumatic approach”, it has also been proven to be beneficial for patients with dental anxiety or learning disabilities, even where there is adequate dental care, as neither drilling nor local anaesthetics are required. More recently, during the International Caries Consensus Collaboration (ICCC) meeting held in Leuven in 2015, ART was recommended by an international group of experts in cariology, restorative and paediatric dentistry as an option to treat decayed primary and permanent teeth with decay where restorative  options were indicated, such as cavities that were difficult to clean using only toothbrushes and fluoride toothpaste. Concept. There are two different ART procedures with different aims: i) Preventive (ART fissure sealant for non-cavitated teeth); and ii) Restorative (ART filling for decayed and cavitated teeth) A. Preventive (ART fissure sealant) The adult teeth that erupt behind the baby back teeth, have deep grooves (fissures) and are more susceptible to accumulating food debris and dental plaque which can stagnate and lead to decay. They are also difficult to toothbrush properly. While they are erupting, they are very susceptible to decay  and it is very difficult to keep them dry enough to use a resin-based sealant material successfully. However, sealing the tooth pits and fissures helps make cleaning the tooth easier and stops the accumulation of plaque biofilm so a high viscosity glass ionomer cement (HVGIC), is used to seal these teeth, covering the pits and fissures. This is done by cleaning the tooth, placing a layer of HVGIC over the back teeth and using finger pressure to keep it in place and dry until the HVGIC material sets. Excess material is removed. If necessary, it is adjusted to fit  the bite using hand instruments. B. Restorative (ART filling) Where the enamel (the hard-outer surface of the tooth has cavitated or even has a small breach due to tooth decay, the cavity can be enlarged with special hand instruments (when necessary) to enable access to the soft decayed tooth tissue. After removing as much decay as necessary, the cavity is cleaned with water, dried and filled with the HVGIC. The filling seals the cavity preventing food debris and dental plaque stagnating inside the cavity. It also promotes remineralisation of the dental tissues affected by decay. When the cavity is  sealed any decay and bacteria that has been left on the floor of the cavity cannot get access to oxygen and sugar and will not continue. Effectiveness sealants. ART Sealants Versus Resin-based Sealants Indications. ART fillings can be used for: Contraindications. ART fillings should not be used when there is: Evidence. Below is the summary of success of ART/HVGIC restorations in different type of cavities Although originally developed for use in developing countries, due to its “atraumatic” approach, ART has become increasingly well accepted in developed countries/ Although ART alone is insufficient to improve the oral health  of people in low- and middle-income countries in a sustainable manner, the WHO Collaborating Centre of Oral Health Care Planning and Future Scenarios in Nijmegen has included it in the Basic Package of Oral Care (BPOC). This aims to improve the oral health of deprived communities in a cost-effective manner. This package comprises three components: ART in multiple surface cavities ART/HVGIC restorations can be successfully used in single surface lesions in both primary (SDCEP) and permanent teeth. For multi-surface lesions (tooth decay that has spread across more than one surface of the tooth), systematic reviews and  meta-analyses show that the mean failure rate of ART/HVGIC restorations is higher than occlusal lesions and with a wide range of success. In these cases, there is evidence that the Hall Technique be more successful. As for multiple surface cavities in posterior permanent teeth, there is insufficient data to draw conclusions about its use and effectiveness. Therefore, in this case, alternative treatments should be attempted. These might include selective caries removal followed by restoration using conventional filling materials (usually resin composite) depending on the clinical situation. In combination with other approaches. Use with conditioner. HVGIC has been proven  to perform better when a dentine conditioner (Cavity conditioner; GC) in used prior to placement of the restorative material. The conditioner is made up of 20% polyacrylic acid and 3% aluminum chloride hexahydrate. It helps to improve the bonding of GIC to the tooth surface by eliminating the smear layer and debris. It also has the advantage of sealing the dentinal tubules to eliminate sensitivity. Chemo-Mechanical approach. This approach comprises the use of chemical material (eg. Papacarie and Carisolv) which contains enzymes and proteases that soften the decayed tooth structure before removing the decay mechanically). In ART, these chemical  materials can be used in conjunction with hand instruments while removing dental caries as they have the advantage of improving treatment comfort by reducing the pain, heat and vibration experienced, make ART more accepted for children. In minimally intervention dentistry. ART is one part of the MID concept and is minimally invasive. It consists of both preventive and restorative components. In ART, the preventive component involves using ART sealants for vulnerable pits and fissures of teeth whereas the restorative treatment part of the MID involves selective removal of the infected dentine using hand instruments while conserving the affected dentine that  can be remineralized, preserving as much tooth structure as possible. This is followed by cavity restoration with HVGIC.