Sondag, 08 September 2013 12:00
Die DVD Evolution vs. God, deur Ray Comfort is in 2013 vrygestel. Dit wys op uitstekende manier uit dat evolusie nie (operasionele) wetenskap is nie - evolusie kan nie waargeneem word as dit miljarde jare gelede plaasgevind het nie. Richard Dawkins het bv gesê: "Ons is verdoem om net vir 'n paar dekades te leef en dit is te stadig, 'n te klein tydskaal om evolusie te sien voortgaan."
Die DVD begin deur die definisie van wetenskap te gee: 'n Wetenskaplike metode is gebaseer op die insameling van data deur waarneming en eksperimentering. (A scientific method is based on "the collection of data through observation and experimentation..." - Science Daily)
Daarna wys dit hoe Ray Comfort evolusioniste nader en hulle die vraag vra om vir hom 'n voorbeeld te gee van Darwinistiese evolusie wat ons kan waarneem en nie hoef te glo nie. Die mense begin dan gewoonlik met 'n voorbeeld uit die fossielrekord. Dan vra Ray hulle wanneer dit gebeur het. As die antwoord kom dat dit miljoene jare gelede gebeur het, sê hy dat dit dan nie waarneembaar is nie.
Hy voer onderhoude met onder andere:
PZ Meyrs: Mede professor in biologie by die Universiteit van Minnesota Morris. Hy is 'n geharde, aggressiewe ateïs.
Gail E Kennedy: Mede professor in antropologie by UCLA (Universiteit van Californië, Los Angeles)
Craig Stanford: Professor in biologiese wetenskappe en antropologie by USC (Universiteit van Suidelike Californië).
Peter Nonacs: Professor in ekologie en evolusionêre biologie by UCLA
Die belangrikste van die DVD is egter nie noodwendig dat evolusie se swakhede uitgewys word nie, maar dat dit duidelik is dat die ateïste in die DVD weer dink oor hulle lewensuitkyk. Kyk:
Evolution vs. God webblad
Evolution vs. God op Youtube
Evolution vs. God playlist
Compromising christians don't like "Evolution vs. God" film (Ken Ham)
Ray Comfort het ook die volgende baie goeie DVD's uitgegee:
180-movie: Dit tref 'n vergelyking met Hitler en aborsie. (30 minute)
Noah Movie HD official full version: Dit gaan oor Noag se vloed en vergelyk God se oordeel in die dae van Noag met die oordeel wat wag (2 Petrus 3:3-9). (30 minute)
Hier volg die onderhoude met die verskillende wetenskaplikes:
Onderhoud met Gail Kennedy (GK)
Ray: Could you give me some observable evidence that evolution is true? Something I don’t have to receive by faith.
Ray: Could you be specific, just give me one?
Ray: So evolution can’t be observed.
Ray: What have the bacteria become?
Ray: It’s still bacteria. There’s no change of kinds.
Ray: Do you believe in intelligent design?
Ray: No genius can make a grain of sand from nothing. We don’t know where to start.
Onderhoud met PZ Myers (PZM)
Ray: You’ve got the canine kind: the coyote kind and the domestic dog; and there’s the feline kind: which is the cats, the tiger, and the kitten; and you’ve got the humankind, so Darwin said there’d be a change of kinds over many years, so could you give me one example of observable evidence of the change of kinds?
Ray: How long ago?
Ray: I don’t want something that I have to accept by faith. I want it to be observable.
Ray: The scientific method is it must be observable and repeatable, so could you give me one piece of observable evidence for Darwinian evolution?
Ray: What have they become?
Ray: They stayed as fish.
PZM: Well of course.
PZM: Human beings are still fish.
Ray: Could you give me an example of Darwinian evolution, not adaptation or speciation, but a change of kinds?
PZM: Ha, ha ha. These áre change of kinds.
Ray: They’re still fish.
PZM: For instance, I would say, look at Lensky’s experiments on bacteria then.
Ray: So what have the bacteria become?
PZM: Bacteria are still bacteria, of course.
Ray: That is not Darwinian evolution. To summarise, the observable evidence you give me for Darwinian evolution is bacteria becoming bacteria.
PZM: No, it is bacteria acquiring new metabolic capabilities.
Ray: Do you believe a rose is intelligently designed?
Ray: Could you make a rose from nothing?
Onderhoud met Craig Stanford (CS)
Ray: Can you give me one?
Ray: Just one
Ray: So that’s not Darwinian evolution. That’s not a change of kinds, is it?
Ray: But they’re still bacteria.
Ray: You said before that there was lots of evidence for evolution. I just want one observable evidence for Darwinian evolution. Just one.
Ray: Not some. I want one.
Ray: Yes I do. I want one. Yes, I do. I’m pleading with people.
Ray: No, one kind into another. There’s 14 different definition of species, so I want a change of kind.
Ray: Could you give me one instance?
Ray: But, that’s not Darwinian evolution. There’s been no change of kinds.
Ray: What have the finches become?
Ray: So they’re still finches?
Ray: So there’s no change on kind.
Ray: Could you give any observable evidence for Darwinian evolution?
Onderhoud met Peter Nonacs (PN)
PN: When you’re talking about kinds or changes in families, you are actually talking about macro-evolution. You are talking about changes in the level that separates say, cats from dogs.
Ray: So could you give me any examples of Darwinian evolution?
Die volgende is uit Evangelist stumps evolution elite:
0 #1 Henrietta Klaasing 2013-09-10 09:54
Dankie dat jy die skakels hier plaas Daniel - ek het die DVD al 'n paar maal gekyk -- dit is so eenvoudig gestel dat die man op straat ook die draad van Comfort se redenasies kan snap. Mag elkeen wat hier kyk 'n bietjie vroeër opstaan of later gaan slaap!) en dit kyk - dit is die moeite werd!