On the Cave of the Nymphs in the Odyssey
On the Cave of the Nymphs in the Odyssey (, ) is a treatise by the Neoplatonist philosopher Porphyry. It is an exegesis of a passage from Homer's "Odyssey", which Porphyry interprets as an allegory about the cosmos and the soul. Summary. "On the Cave of the Nymphs in the Odyssey" is an exegesis of lines 102 to 112 in book 13 of the "Odyssey", which describe a cave on Odysseus' home island of Ithaca. The passage follows here in original Greek and in Robert D. Lamberton's English translation: Porphyry leaves  open whether the cave actually existed or was an invention by Homer, but in either case stresses its significance as an allegory. He associates the cave motif with Plato's allegory of the cave and the Mithraic cave—the Mithraeum—and regards it as a symbol for the world. The Naiads and their association with flowing water are described as vital to the cosmology of Greek mythology. Various connections are presented between bees and honey and Greek and Mithraic concepts, including associations between honey and nectar—the food of the gods—and libations of honey. The positions of the two  gates are connected to the zodiac, ancient Greek astronomy and the north and south winds. The olive tree outside the cave is associated with Athena and thoughtfulness, and Porphyry says it is significant that the tree is located outside of the cave—the world—but close to it. Porphyry agrees with Numenius of Apamea that the "Odyssey" is a symbolic description of man's successive passing through "genesis" (Greek: γένεσις, 'origin'). He interprets the cave of the nymphs as an allegorical image of the relationship between the soul and "genesis" at the end of Odysseus' journey. Publication. The Greek text  was first published in print by Janus Lascaris in 1518. Thomas Taylor published an English translation in 1823. The most recent English versions are one produced in 1969 by a postgraduate seminar class led by and Lamberton's translation from 1983. Reception. "The Cave of the Nymphs in the Odyssey" is frequently discussed by scholars interested in ancient allegorical interpretation and the readings of Homer by the Neoplatonists. Modern scholars disagree whether the treatise presents a coherent and consistent literary interpretation. It has drawn interest from scholars of Mithraism for its cosmological discussion of the Mithraeum and because it invites  comparisons between Mithraism and Neoplatonism. Its references to Mithra and Zoroaster have in turn been read through the opposition to Gnosticism in the "Enneads" by Porphyry's teacher Plotinus; the theologian Mark J. Edwards argues that Porphyry directed his treatise against the Gnostics and wanted to promote the view that truth is reached gradually, not immediately.