Past = Present x Future Over Yesterday
"Past = Present x Future Over Yesterday" is the third episode of the second season of the American dark comedy crime television series "Barry". It is the 11th overall episode of the series and was written by producer Jason Kim, and directed by Minkie Spiro. It was first broadcast on HBO in the United States on April 14, 2019. The series follows Barry Berkman, a hitman from Cleveland who travels to Los Angeles to kill someone but finds himself joining an acting class taught by Gene Cousineau, where he meets aspiring actress Sally  Reed and begins to question his path in life as he deals with his criminal associates such as Monroe Fuches and NoHo Hank. In the episode, Barry struggles to write a monologue that details his war experience, while Sally also struggles with telling her story about her abusive relationship with her ex-husband. Meanwhile, Hank is negatively affected by Esther's failed assassination attempt and decides he must kill Barry. According to Nielsen Media Research, the episode was seen by an estimated 1.78 million household viewers and gained a 0.7 ratings share among adults aged 18–49. The episode received positive  reviews, with critics praising the performances (particularly Hader and Carrigan), and subject matter although the lack of plot progress was criticized. For his performance in the episode, Anthony Carrigan received an Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Comedy Series nomination at the 71st Primetime Emmy Awards. Plot. After having a dream where he debated with Thomas Friedman (Sam Ingraffia), Hank (Anthony Carrigan) is woken up by his henchmen and is surprised to see Esther (Patricia Fa'assua) alive. Cristobal (Michael Irby) is mad about the assassination attempt and Hank's failed attempts to protect her, so he sends Hank and his men  out of the warehouse to a storage unit. Hank concludes he must kill Barry (Bill Hader). Barry is preparing for a monologue about his war experiences in Korangal Valley. He decides to focus on the first time he saved a life, but the events prove to be even more tragic as it involved his partner Albert (James Hiroyuki Liao) mortally wounded. Sally (Sarah Goldberg) is using the night she left her abusive ex-husband as monologue, but while investigating the events, she struggles with the fact that she never stood up to him. Suddenly, Barry notices that someone is shooting  at his apartment, missing him. He retrieves his gun and notices Hank with a hitman, shooting the hitman. Barry confronts him and Hank asks him to just kill him, as he is afraid of being sent to Chechnya. Barry hesitates in shooting him and offers to train him and his men to kill the Burmese so their debt can be paid. Hank gleefully accepts the offer. Barry's first day as an instructor to Hank's henchmen proves to be difficult, with most of them failing to hit a single bottle. Fuches (Stephen Root) is pressured by Loach (John Pirruccello ) to get more evidence against Barry. He decides to visit Barry at his clothing store job, and this time, Barry actually welcomes him. Barry wants to talk about his war experience but Fuches advises him against it, warning him that his class would be against him if he details everything that happened, and the two have an emotional reconnection while an increasingly frustrated Loach looks on. Meanwhile, Gene (Henry Winkler) once again tries to reconnect with Leo (Andrew Leeds) by giving him his lake house, but Leo refuses it due to the nature of Moss' "murder". At the acting class , Barry starts his monologue but Gene quickly deduces that he plagiarized "Braveheart" in his monologue. He then has Barry act as Sally's abusive ex-husband for her monologue, stating she feels more comfortable with him. The monologue asks Barry to choke Sally and despite Sally telling him to do it, Barry can't bring himself to do it. Sally then provokes him, even attacking him, prompting an angry Barry to storm out. As Sally and Barry talk outside, Sally is shocked to see her ex-husband, Sam (Joe Massingill), show up. Production. Development. In March 2019, the episode's  title was revealed as "Past = Present x Future Over Yesterday" and it was announced that producer Jason Kim had written the episode while Minkie Spiro had directed it. This was Kim's first writing credit, and Spiro's first directing credit. Writing. Bill Hader wanted the episode to properly portray Barry's view of the war, "It starts with the idea of how we lie to ourselves and how we can tell some of our truths but not all of our truths. You tell partial truths, and so it'd be funny to illustrate that instead of, you know , just watching Barry type stuff and say it. You want to actually dramatize it." The crew also decided to include the speech from "Braveheart", deeming Barry as a person who watched few films and thought no one ever watched the film itself. Sally's abusive ex-husband was teased on the first season, with the writers wondering if they really needed to bring him into focus. After a writer suggesting to do so and to keep in theme with the idea that Barry had to stop being "violent", the writers decided to introduce him in the episode. Reception. Viewers. The  episode was watched by 1.78 million viewers, earning a 0.7 in the 18-49 rating demographics on the Nielson ratings scale. This means that 0.7 percent of all households with televisions watched the episode. This was a massive 319% increase from the previous episode, which was watched by 0.424 million viewers with a 0.2 in the 18-49 demographics. Critical reviews. "Past = Present x Future Over Yesterday" received positive reviews. Vikram Murthi of "The A.V. Club" gave the episode a "B-" and wrote, "'Past = Present x Future Over Yesterday' is an okay episode that spends too much of  its runtime table setting and spinning its wheel without enough compensatory laughs. Barry and Hank quickly bury their would-be feud when Barry agrees to train the Chechens to be assassins. Fuches and Loach continue to conspire to get Barry to admit he killed Moss on tape. Barry and Sally struggle with their personal pieces. Gene tries again to reconcile with his estranged son, who still has little interest in any meaningful relationship with him. It's not that these are unimportant developments, but you can also definitely feel "Barry" stalling just long enough to ramp up the tension." Nick  Harley of "Den of Geek" wrote, "'Past Equals Present x Future Over Yesterday' continues Barry's soul-searching in intense fashion, cutting the heaviness with healthy doses of humor. It's clear now that the blank-slate that we saw in Season 1 was just a coping mechanism for Barry and that he's got some serious PTSD and identity issues to sort through." Accolades. "TVLine" named Bill Hader as the "Performer of the Week" for the week of April 20, 2019, for his performance in the episode. The site wrote, "As the talented hitman/not-so-talented actor at  the center of HBO's pitch-black comedy, Hader delivers an exquisitely subtle brand of acting that's remarkable for how little it looks like acting. Barry is a tightly wound coil of suppressed emotion, never revealing the trauma he's endured in his years as a hired killer, so it often looks like Hader is underplaying it. But this week, he let a tiny bit of that emotion peek out in a restrained yet riveting turn." Anthony Carrigan submitted this episode into consideration for his Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Comedy Series nomination at the 71st Primetime Emmy Awards