Cyclura cychlura inornata
Cyclura cychlura inornata, the Allen Cays rock iguana or Allen Cays iguana, is a subspecies of the northern Bahamian rock iguana that is found on Allen's Cay and adjacent islands in the Bahamas. Its status in the IUCN Red List is critically endangered. The population has been growing over the last century. Although it was considered extinct in 1916, there are as of 2018 at least 482 mature adult animals counted on two islands, Leaf Cay and U Cay, and a few hundred on at least five other nearby islands where they have recently spread to  by unknown means (introduced by biologists in one case), as well as many juveniles. Although this is a large lizard at 75cm, within one generation after some arrived on the small island of Allen's Cay, these iguanas grew to be twice as large here than those on other islands, which is believed to be due to the large amount of guano (bird droppings) this particular island receives. These particular giants have now been largely eliminated due to the actions of conservationists and a flawed plan to capture them and maintain them on another island, where they starved. Luckily  the leading herpetologist was incorrect about the total amount iguanas on Allen's Cay, and those 'extra' lizards which evaded capture apparently survived their island being covered in rodenticide. People often visit the two main islands which host the majority of the population, and the iguanas have come to expect to be fed by them, sometimes congregating on the beach in large numbers awaiting tourists. This lizard has a high tolerance for its conspecifics, unlike other "Cyclura" iguanas, which are usually territorial. Long ago (possibly) hunted by locals for its meat, the iguana now has another economic use, being of  high importance for the ecotourism industry in this part of the Bahamas. Taxonomy. In 1892 the American ornithologist, taxidermist and all round naturalist Charles Johnson Maynard visited U Cay and found the iguanas "not uncommon" there. In 1915 he visited the small island again, but, despite much searching, only was able to find two. These two he promptly shot (one was wounded but escaped collection), and the following year the secured specimen was made the holotype of a purportedly new species in a paper by the herpetologists and taxonomists Thomas Barbour and Gladwyn Kingsley Noble. It first described in 1916  as "Cyclura inornata". Barbour and Noble state the "Cyclura" iguanas are "excellent for food" and claim the new species was "beyond doubt extinct", due to being constantly hunted by the poor Negroes who inhabited the poverty-stricken colony. The authors state that they saw iguana meat for sale several times in New Providence, the capital. "Cyclura cychlura inornata" is one of three subspecies of the Northern Bahamian rock iguana, the others being the Andros Island iguana ("C. c. cychlura") and the Exuma Island iguana ("C. c. figginsi"). It was found to be genetically indistinct from "C. c. figginsi" further south  down the chain of the Exuma Islands. The different populations were likely one unbroken one 18,000 years ago during the last ice age, when the islands of the chain were likely all joined together in one large island. Description. The Allen Cays rock iguana is a large rock iguana of which the localised population on Allen's Cay attains a total length of close to . The iguana is normally half the size and a sixth the weight of those on Allen's Cay. Its coloration is dark-gray to black, with yellowish green or orange tinged scales on the legs , dorsal crest, and the head. When the animal matures, the yellow coloration changes to a bright reddish orange color in contrast to the animals darker striped body and black feet. This species, like other species of "Cyclura", is sexually dimorphic; males are larger than females, and have larger femoral pores on their thighs, which are used to release pheromones. Distribution. This rock iguana subspecies is endemic to the northern Exuma Island chain in the Bahamas. Before the 1990s, it was restricted to only the uninhabited Leaf Cay and U Cay, but it then began to colonise neighbouring Allen's Cay  and other nearby islands such as Flat Rock Reef Cay. It arrived on these islands perhaps swimming or floating the distance in some cases, or perhaps helped by humans. Small numbers of up to five animals are sometimes found on the tiny surrounding islets. It was purposely spread to Alligator Cay thirty kilometres to the south, and from there appears to have spread to Narrow Water Cay and Warderick Wells Cay. The IUCN red list assessment of 2018 states most of the introductions to other islands are human assisted. Research at genetic divergence in the different populations found some discernible  genetic difference between the U and Leaf Cay populations, but also evidence of recent admixture blamed on unauthorised human introductions between islands. Leaf Cay appears the source for all the introductions to other islands. Ecology. It is found in low, open forest, coastal shrubland and along beaches in elevations from sea level to 10m. The forests here can reach to seven metres high. From December through April there is a cooler dry season. Among the restricted amount of plant species found growing on its islands are "Borrichia arborescens", "Bumelia americana", "Casasia clusiifolia", "Conocarpus erectus", "Coccoloba uvifera", "Drypetes diversifolia", "Eugenia  foetida", "Guaiacum sanctum", "Ipomoea indica", "Jacquinia keyensis", "Leucothrinax morrisii", "Manilkara bahamensis", "Pithecellobium keyense", "Rhachicallis americana", "Solanum bahamense", "Suriana maritima", "Sesuvium portulacastrum", "Sophora tomentosa", "Thalassia testudinum" and "Uniola paniculata". 48 species of plant are said to grow on Leaf Cay. On Alligator Cay there are 24 species of plant of which the most abundant are "Borrichia arborescens", "Cyperus" sp., "Guapira discolor", "Pseudophoenix sargentii" and "Rhachicallis americana". Others are similar to the other Cays, but there is more mangrove here, as well as an "Opuntia" sp. and "Erithalis fruticosa". There are only a few introduced species of plants, but there are some  ornamentals such as palms. It requires areas for nesting with a layer of sand of at least half a metre deep. The cays where it lives have a type of native night heron that will occasionally snack on a baby iguana. It is diurnal, spending nights in 'retreats' under the leaves of thatch palms, in tunnels they sometimes dig and sometimes in the open. It also uses crevices and holes in limestone rocks as retreats and will congregate in areas rich in these. Outside of the mating season, male rock iguanas have dominance hierarchies rather than strictly defended territories like  Cyclura from other islands. This has been attributed to the regular food supply from tourists feeding the lizards on the beach causing a disruption in their social structure. However, a 2000 report demonstrated this theory tested on Alligator Cay, which is free from tourists, and also found a low amount of male-to-male aggression in this species. The author of that study pointed to the small nature of the inhabited islands as a reason for reduced aggression. Diet. All iguanas except the largest adults climb into the vegetation to feed, including up the smooth boles of thatch palms. Even  adults have been found up in a "Pseudophoenix" palm to eat the flower buds. They are primarily herbivorous, feeding on fruits, leaves, and flowers of most available plants. Individuals can survive on very tiny islands from the available plants. On Alligator Cay the population eats mostly "Rhachicallis americana" and "Suriana maritima", the former is more common and is eaten more, but the lizards show a preference for the latter, which is relatively much more uncommon on the island. Two studies in the remains of their faeces found occasional crab claws, insects, molluscs and fledgling birds, and they have been observed  to be occasionally carnivorous. They also have been found to eat their shed skin. On Alligator Cay three plants were not observed to be eaten: "Hymenocallis arenicola" and "Strumpfia maritima", and the mangrove "Rhizophora mangle". More than a quarter of the faeces were made up of fruit. The iguana ate the large fruit of "Casasia clusiifolia" and "Manilkara bahamensis", as well as the small fruit of the sea grape "Coccoloba uvifera", and the palms "Coccotrinax argentata" and "Pseudophoenix sargentii". "Casasia" fruit are produced throughout the year and represented 9.6% of the total faecal matter, the second most prevalent item. The  iguanas feed on more leaves when they are forced to during the cool and dry season. Biologists Kristen Richardson, John Iverson and Carolyn Kurle investigated the diets of the iguanas. Their 2019 study made use of carbon and nitrogen isotope analysis to estimate iguana diets in order to explain why iguanas on Allen's Cay were ~2 times longer and ~6 times heavier than the same subspecies on nearby Leaf Cay and U Cay, the populations being only a generation removed and separated by a channel. They had hypothesized that the gigantic iguanas were eating shearwater carcasses killed by mice  and barn owls, but they found no evidence for that hypothesis. Instead they determined that their gigantism was due to their consumption of plant material containing more nutrients than the plants on the other cays. The added nutrients came from the ocean in the form of seabird guano; the largest colony of Audubon's shearwaters ("Puffinis iherminieri") are located on Allen's Cay. None of the other cays have large populations of seabirds and so are missing the extra amounts of nutrients that arrive in the form of guano on Allen's Cay. Their evidence strongly supports that these iguanas  are herbivores and the giants on Allen Cay are so large because their plants contain higher levels of nutrients from seabird guano. Tourists often feed the iguanas human food items on Leaf Cay and sometimes U Cay. The iguanas have come to expect to be fed and may congregate in large numbers awaiting the tourists. Mating. Mating occurs in May, and eggs are usually laid in mid-June to mid-July, in nests excavated in sand. The females migrate to suitable areas to nest. On the newly colonised Allen's Cay there is no sand on the jagged honeycomb limestone  beaches, and the iguanas have never bred there. The subspecies previously bred on only the two original islands U and Leaf Cay, but on the islands of Alligator Cay and Flat Rock Reef Cay there are suitable breeding sites. Only one in three females nests in a given year, although the largest females nest annually. One to ten eggs are laid; larger females lay more eggs than do smaller females. Hatching occurs with a success rate of 79% in late September and early October after an incubation 80–85 days at nest temperatures of . Conservation. Status. The IUCN assessed the population  to be endangered in 1996 and 2000, but using a more restrictive definition of which lizards were allowed to be counted, in 2018 it assessed that the population was actually critically endangered. In the early 1900s the population was almost wiped out, but had increased to some 150 iguanas by 1970 on the only two islands were it bred. In 1982, this had increased to a bit over 200 animals. In the early 1980s the population was growing at some 20% annually, and it had recovered by the end of the century to the limit of the carrying capacity of  its original islands. In 2000, it was estimated that the current global population was less than 1,000 and it was said to be declining, although it was actually increasing. In 2018 the population was assessed to be 482–632 (mature adult) individuals, with 482 being the amount of mature adult iguanas on U and Leaf Cay in 2016 based on recapture counts. This number does not include over 150 adult iguanas found on islands where it believed they cannot breed. The population on Allen's Cay was at 20–25 for a number of decades according to Iverson, but it was  reduced to ten individuals in 2013 indirectly due to bird conservation activities. In the 1990s, a number of iguanas were moved to nearby islands. Iverson and P. Hall, a warden of Exumas Cays Land and Sea Park, moved only eight sub-adults to Alligator Cay between 1988 and 1990, of which at least seven had survived ten years later, and these had increased to between 75 and 90 individuals in 1999 based on recapture analysis of 28 caught and tagged iguanas during four visits. Mostly larger lizards were caught and it was expected there were many more juveniles, and the  island had not reached carrying capacity. According to the IUCN the population declined over the next decade due to hurricane damage of the vegetation and emigration to the nearby island of Narrow Water Cay. Hines reported seeing 28 iguanas on Alligator Cay and an estimated 38 iguanas on Narrow Water Cay in 2013, and found that apparently some iguanas had successfully emigrated to nearby Warderick Wells Cay. The Flat Rock Reef Cay population appeared in the mid-1990s, the IUCN claims it was purposely introduced without authorisation by unknown people. It rapidly increased to around 200 individuals by 2012, although the  IUCN claimed in 2018 that the island would not sustain this population due to its low carrying capacity. Threats. The primary threat to this species according to IUCN in 2018 is ecotourism and the feeding of the lizards by tourists. A number of tour operators and sometimes private yachts moor at either of the islands, bringing a few hundred tourists a day to see the lizards on both Leaf and U Cay. Tourists may transmit diseases and parasites and sometimes feed the iguanas unnatural food such as foreign fruit, bread, brownies or meat which is believed to contribute to health  problems for the lizards such as faecal impaction and high levels of cholesterol. Despite dogs and cats being banned, tourists continue to bring their pets and a single loose dog could eliminate a population. Furthermore the IUCN alleges that tour operators may have moved some of the largest lizards off to other islands where they cannot scare the tourists, because they found a tagged individual on and islet eight kilometres away from where he was tagged, and they state large iguanas appear to be becoming rarer in the population. The iguanas are the primary tourist attraction to this area  of the Bahamas. A century ago, in the early 1900s, the Allen Cays rock iguana was almost wiped out due to being hunted for food by locals (see taxonomy section above). As of 2003 the animals were still said to be hunted for food and captured for sale in the pet trade. In 2018 this was repeated by the IUCN, although there is no documentation that this has occurred. Recovery efforts. Like all Bahamian rock iguanas, this species is protected in the Bahamas under the Wild Animals Protection Act of 1968. It is listed in Appendix I of the CITES  convention. Allen's Cay was formerly over-run by the common house mouse ("Mus musculus"), an invasive species, and these were in their turn attracting barn owls ("Tyto alba") from neighbouring islands. In May 2012, Island Conservation and the Bahamas National Trust worked together to remove invasive house mice from Allen's Cay to protect the Audubon's shearwater and hopefully also native species such as the Allen Cay rock iguana and the Bahama yellowthroat. As it was feared the Allen Cay rock iguana might eat the rodenticide used to rid the island of the mice, eighteen were transplanted to  nearby Flat Rock Reef Cay, where another small population already existed. Sixteen of these had starved to death by 2013. It is now thought this was because the plants on Flat Rock Reef Cay lacked the extra nutrients found on Allen's Cay. After this at least eight iguanas survived on Allen's Cay, and including the two from Flat Rock Reef Cay, there are now ten iguanas thought to be left on the island. In 2012, Iverson had begun a project to fill a small sinkholes on the island with sand to create suitable breeding ground. The population on  Alligator Cay was released there as part of a conservation translocation program. It was seen as quite successful in 2001. Alligator Cay and surrounding islands are part of the national Exuma Cays Land and Sea Park. There are no captive breeding programmes which have been undertaken with this subspecies.