An Evening with Elmore &amp; Gwendolyn Putts, the Neighbors Next DoorAn Evening with Elmore &amp; Gwendolyn Putts, the Neighbors Next Door An Evening with Elmore & Gwendolyn Putts, the Neighbors Next Door An Evening With Elmore & Gwendolyn Putts, The Neighbors Next Door is an American musical comedy, with a book, music, and lyrics by Richard O’Donnell, directed by Amy McKenzie, and performed by the New Age Vaudeville theater company in Chicago. History. Baileys Harbor, Wisconsin. "An Evening with Elmore & Gwendolyn Putts, The Neighbors Next Door" was originally staged at the Comedy Cabaret at the Glidden Lodge Resort in Baileys Harbor, Wisconsin, summer 1986 by New Age Vaudeville. Chicago, Illinois. In the fall of 1986, The members of New Age Vaudeville relocated to  Chicago, to be the first resident theatre company at the acclaimed CrossCurrents cabaret, 3206 N. Wilton Street. Their first production, "An Evening with Elmore & Gwendolyn Putts, The Neighbors Next Door" officially premiered in Chicago at the CrossCurrents upstairs cabaret theater, October 31, 1986. Production. "An Evening With Elmore & Gwendolyn Putts, The Neighbors Next Door" is written by Richard O'Donnell, and was performed by the New Age Vaudeville Theater Co., members of Actor’s Equity Association (AEA). The set and props were designed by NAV member Peter Neville, and the production was produced and directed by Amy McKenzie. Because of her  pregnancy, Amy McKenzie, who originated the role of Pamela, was replaced by Chicago actress Caroline Schless. “Something of a Charles Addams cartoon…” "An Evening with Elmore & Gwendolyn Putts, The Neighbors Next Door", “…displays a variety of comedic forms--from mime to slapstick, one-liners to thoughtful satirical jabs,” and has a “…wizardry in blending 50’s sitcom norms with comic impersonations.” "An Evening with Elmore & Gwendolyn Putts, The Neighbors Next Door" was also praised for its originality by Chicago Tribune critic Rick Kogan, who wrote ``Nowhere are there jokes about yuppies, Harold Washington or the CTA. Instead, New  Age Vaudeville seeks (and most of the time succeeds) to push the limits of what we have become to accept too easily as ``cabaret comedy.`` Play Synopsis. "An Evening with Elmore & Gwendolyn Putts, The Neighbors Next Door", is a musical comedy farce that reveals one late afternoon in the life of a suburban family of nerds. The Putts are so dysfunctional, in fact, that when victimized and held captive by a home invader, a crazed biker named “Helmet Head” they thwart his plans to rob them and instead recruit him into their family. An Evening with