Miracle

[[File:Miracle Whip.jpg|thumb|right|165px|Miracle Whip: whip it good]]
{{religion}}
{{cquote|Fucking [[magnet]]s!<ref group=note>Presumably not about having [[sex]] with magnets.</ref> How do they work?<ref>[http://fakescience.tumblr.com/post/597833893/how-do-magnets-work?ref=nf Scientific explanation of magnets]</ref><ref>[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnet Maaaagiiiiic]</ref>|||[[Insane Clown Posse]] from their song, "Miracles"<ref>[https://www.azlyrics.com/lyrics/insaneclownposse/miracles.html Miracles] by  Insane Clown Posse, ''AZLyrics''</ref>}}
{{cquote|When someone is saved from certain [[death]] by [[Luck|a strange concatenation of circumstances]], they say that's a miracle. But of course if someone is killed by a [[Coincidence|freak chain of events]] — {{wpl|The Master and Margarita|the oil spilled just there, the safety fence broken just there}} — that must also be a miracle. Just because it's not nice doesn't mean it's not miraculous.|||[[Terry Pratchett]]<ref>''Interesting Times'' by Terry Pratchett (1994) HarperCollins. ISBN 0613572254.</ref>}}

A '''miracle''' is what you call it when something occurs that you can't explain and you're too impressed to try and figure out exactly what happened. Many [[religion]]s are riddled with them because miracles can be appropriated as a purported '[[proof]]' of the truth of (their) religious beliefs. [[Scientific method|Science]] tends to take a somewhat less accommodating position towards the concept, preferring to work with [[methodological naturalism]]. 

Many of the miracles reported in the [[Bible]] are of the tall-tale variety that include the parting of the Red Sea, [[Resurrection|bringing back a dude]] named Lazarus from the dead ({{bible|Luke|16|19|31}}) — he was just [[sleep]]in'! — and surviving the [[Hell|raging fires of an oven]].

Every once in a while, a particularly dimwitted [[Godbotherer]] will try to claim a miracle occurred when something [[medical]] happens that isn't well-understood, like, say, the seriously amazing spinal-injury rescue of Buffalo Bills player Kevin Everett. While some religious people claimed a miracle kept him from permanent paralysis, most scientific types are more apt to credit years of research on spinal cord injuries, emergency medicine, skillful medical professionals, medical insurance to pay for all that, and dumb luck. It's worth noting that these supposed "miracles" ''never'' seem to occur with something that unambiguously couldn't have happened without divine intervention, such as [[Why Won't God Heal Amputees|the regrowth of severed limbs]].

==Argument from miracles==
The "argument from miracles" is an argument, usually for the existence of a [[deity]], that relies on eyewitness testimony or [[anecdote]]s of impossible or extremely improbable events to establish the active intervention of a [[supernatural]] supreme being (or supernatural agents acting on behalf of that being).

===Hume===
A chief critic of the "argument from miracles" was [[David Hume]], who defined a miracle thus:<ref>[http://www.skepdic.com/miracles.html Skeptic Dictionary — Miracle]</ref>
{{cquote|''A miracle is a violation of the laws of nature; and as a firm and unalterable experience has established these laws, the proof against a miracle, from the very nature of the fact, is as entire as any argument from experience can possibly be imagined.''}}

Hume proposed to deal with miraculous claims by weighing the [[probability]] that such an event could occur against the possibility that the supposed eyewitness was either [[Deceit|deceived or deliberately deceiving]]. This is the main reason why anecdotes are ''not'' the same as [[evidence]].

===Be careful what you use as an argument for your religion===
If a deity tests human faith by not causing miracles, then the logical converse of that argument is that ''any'' miracles, especially those recorded in the [[holy book]](s) of said religion, are evidence ''against'' non-miraculous deities. The holding of both of these beliefs is thus a contradiction.

You could try coming up with an actual explanation for why said deity caused miracles then but doesn't do so now. We'll have our popcorn ready.

==Explaining miracles==
With increasingly good [[technology]] and [[knowledge]], as well as a wider prevalence of [[skepticism]] and [[science]] in the modern world, supposed miracles are becoming easier to debunk, that is, discovering their naturalistic cause. For example, [[spontaneous remission]] from [[cancer]] is slowly becoming less mysterious; its mechanisms have been suggested and explored, and the [[statistical]] likelihood of it happening has been documented as around one in [[Improbable things happen|one hundred thousand]], although this may well be underestimated and some studies seem to suggest remission rates are far, ''far'' higher in certain cancers and in particularly small tumors.<ref>[https://www.verywellhealth.com/spontaneous-remission-of-lung-cancer-a-rare-miracle-3971875 Spontaneous Remission of Cancer Incidence and Causes] by  Lynne Eldridge (January 19, 2020) ''Verywell Health''.</ref> As a result, someone claiming that their cancer was cured by [[prayer]] was likely cured by a spontaneous, but naturalistic, process.

This gives rise to an interesting way of defining miracles based on their possible naturalistic explanations; if the naturalistic explanation is more outlandish, more implausible, and more unlikely than the miracle itself, perhaps a supernatural explanation is the right one. By this standard, most miracles come up as quite boring, having easy explanations. Sudden recovery from a disease is a fairly common event (and it's practically a statistical certainty that it's going to happen ''some place'' at ''some time'' whether prayed for or not) and supposedly talking to God can be explained by relatively common, and very naturalistic, [[psychological]] reasons. Similarly (assuming it happened ''as reported''), [[Jesus]]' {{wpl|Feeding the multitude|"Feeding of the Five Thousand"}} could be explained by people bringing their own food out of hiding (they obviously hid it from the disciples who apparently checked and found no food), contributing to the overall food supply — obviously the act of [[charity]] of the first few loaves and fishes was inspirational. Once it can be shown that supposed miracles ''can'' be explained using ridiculously simple, plausible, and probable naturalistic methods, they cease to be miracles, because miracles need to defy ''any'' and ''all'' explanation.

On the other hand, proper old-school [[Biblical]] miracles like the parting of the Red Sea would defy any plausible naturalistic explanation; a sudden earthquake that caused a temporary land bridge, a brief wind strong enough to part the sea<ref>[http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-11383620 BBC News — Winds could explain Biblical parting of the Red Sea] (Yes, really!)</ref> and so on. Now that is a ''proper'' miracle — especially if it allowed the [[Israelite]]s to cross easily, given that the Red Sea is surprisingly deep and the bottom is full of sheer drops and rises. Unfortunately, there really isn't reliable evidence that documents it ever having happened, so never mind.

=="And then a miracle occurs"==
[[File:Math07.gif|right|thumb]]
This phrase occurs in [http://www.sciencecartoonsplus.com/gallery/math/math07.gif the famous cartoon] by {{wpl|Sidney Harris||.}}<ref>[http://www.sciencecartoonsplus.com/ Science Cartoons Plus: The Cartoons of S. Harris]</ref> There are various forms of [[pseudoscience]] and [[science woo]] that try to substantiate themselves on as-yet-unknown science or technology, because ''who knows'' what could happen in thousands of years of frantic technological development? [[Argument from ignorance|Can you ''prove'' it isn't possible?!]] [[Negative proof|I bet you can't!]]

Examples include [[cryonics]] and [[nanobots]]. The entire [[transhumanism]] belief cluster is riddled with this, as is a fair whack of [[engineer woo]].

==See also==
*[[American tall tales]]
*[[Eucharist]]
*[[Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence]]
*[[Faith healing]]
*[[Improbable things happen]]
*[[Littlewood's law]]
*[[Magic]]
*[[Magical thinking]]

==External links==
*[http://wiki.ironchariots.org/index.php?title=Miracle Iron Chariots on miracles]
*[http://www.guardian.co.uk/science/the-lay-scientist/2010/sep/13/god-miracles-vatican Is God scraping the barrel for miracles?] by Martin Robbins (13 Sep 2010 11.05 EDT) ''The Guardian''

==Motes==
{{reflist|group=note}}

==References==
{{reflist|2}}

[[Category:Arguments]]
[[Category:Medicine]]
[[Category:Philosophy]]
[[Category:Pseudoscience]]
[[Category:Religious terms]]
[[Category:Woo]]

Categories: Arguments, Medicine, Philosophy, Pseudoscience, Religious terms, Woo