Dhu al-Qarnayn

{{Islam}}
'''Dhu al-Qarnayn''' (ذُو ٱلْقَرْنَيْن {{IPA|[ðuː‿l.qarˈnajn]}} In Arabic,<ref>[https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/%D8%B0%D9%88_%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%82%D8%B1%D9%86%D9%8A%D9%86#Arabic ''ذو القرنين'' on Wiktionary]</ref> also spelled in English as Dhu'l-Qarnayn, Dhulqarnayn, Dhul-Qarnayn, Zulqarnayn <ref>[https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/Dhu%27l-Qarnayn#English "Dhu'l-Qarnayn" on Wiktionary]</ref>), which literally means "'''The Two-Horned'''" in Arabic, is a character which appears in the [[Quran]] 18:83–101 as as one who travels to east and west and sets up a barrier between a certain people and [[Gog and Magog]]. Based on the similarities between his story and some legends around {{wpl|Alexander the Great||,}} it is commonly believed that Dhu al-Qarnayn was Alexander the Great. However, this identification is problematic for many [[Islam|Muslims]] because we know that Alexander the Great was a [[Polytheism|polytheist]]. That's why many modern Muslim apologists make alternative hypotheses about his identity. Despite this, there is overwhelming historical evidence that the story is inspired from those legends. The story of Dhu al-Qarnayn as described in the Quran has become very problematic for modern Muslim apologists because it contains some elements which contradict some basic scientific knowledge about the universe. Thus, it is probably one of the most controvertial stories found in the Quran, and scholars have proposed different interpretations, none of which are universally agreed upon and none of them is without flaws or problems.

==The story==
{{quotebox|
'''83''': And they ask you about Dhu al-Qarnayn. Say, “I will tell you something about him.”

'''84''': We established him on [[Earth]], and gave him all kinds of means.

'''85''': He pursued a certain course.

'''86''': Until, when he reached the setting of the [[Sun]], he found it setting in a muddy spring, and found a people in its vicinity. We said, “O Dhu al-Qarnayn, you may either inflict a penalty, or else treat them kindly.”

'''87''':  He said, “As for him who does wrong, we will penalize him, then he will be returned to his Lord, and He will punish him with an unheard-of torment.

'''88''': “But as for him who believes and acts righteously, he will have the finest reward, and We will speak to him of Our command with ease.”

'''89''': Then he pursued a course.

'''90''': Until, when he reached the rising of the Sun, he found it rising on a people for whom We had provided no shelter from it.

'''91''': And so it was. We had full knowledge of what he had.

'''92''': Then he pursued a course.

'''93''': Until, when he reached the point separating the two mountains, he found beside them a people who could barely understand what is said.

'''94''': They said, “O Dhu al-Qarnayn, Gog and Magog are spreading chaos in the land. Can we pay you, to build between us and them a wall?”

'''95''': He said, “What my Lord has empowered me with is better. But assist me with strength, and I will build between you and them a dam.”

'''96''': “Bring me blocks of [[iron]].” So that, when he had leveled up between the two cliffs, he said, “Blow.” And having turned it into a fire, he said, “Bring me tar to pour over it.”

'''97''': So they were unable to climb it, and they could not penetrate it.

'''98''': He said, “This is a mercy from my Lord. But when the promise of my Lord comes true, He will turn it into rubble, and the promise of my Lord is always true.”

'''99''': On that Day, We will leave them surging upon one another. And the Trumpet will be blown, and We will gather them together.

'''100''': On that Day, We will present the disbelievers to [[Hell]], all displayed.

'''101''': Those whose eyes were screened to My message, and were unable to hear.

|||{{Qur'an|18|83}}-{{Qur'an|18|101}}}}

'''NOTE''': In some translations of the Qur'an, it is written :"which appeared to him to be setting in a muddy spring" instead of "which was setting in a muddy spring". This is actually a mistranslations (likely motivated by the fact that the verses seem wrong when interpreted litterally) and the word "appear" is not mentionned in the original Arabic Qur'an. This will be further discussed in more details in the following sections.

==The sun setting in a muddy spring==
The above verses (in particular verse number 86) explicitly says that the sun sets into a muddy spring. This is wrong for obvious reasons. If it were true the [[Geocentrism|sun would revolve around the Earth]]. It would also need to be considerably smaller than the Earth in order to sink into the muddy spring each evening. This is impossible on a spherical earth, since there is no specific place where the sun goes "down".

Due to all of these problems, Muslim apologists have tried to find alternative interpretations in order to avoid the apparent contradiction between these verses and reality. Unfortunately most of these interpretations are problematic.<ref>[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UVwizsojd1Y  "Does the Quran really say the Sun sets in a muddy spring?"]</ref>

The main argument made by apologists is to interprete these verses not as meaning that the sun literally sets in a muddy spring, but simply as referring to what Dhu al-Qarnayn saw. According to this argument, Dhu al-Qarnayn was just saw what looked like the sun setting over the horizon, which happened to be close to a muddy spring.

===The first problem: Linguistic incoherence of the ineterpretation===
The first problem with this argument is that the Quran iself is supposed to be a clear book. The Quran itself claims it is clear (verses: {{Qur'an|12|1}}; {{Qur'an|15|1}}; {{Qur'an|16|89}}; {{Qur'an|16|103}}; {{Qur'an|27|1}}; {{Qur'an|28|2}}; {{Qur'an|43|2}}; {{Qur'an|44|2}}), that the verses are explained in detail ({{Qur'an|11|1}}; {{Qur'an|41|3}}), that there is no doubt about the Quran ({{Qur'an|2|2}}). Any verse being interpreted metaphorically, including this one, would suggest that the Quran is not clear, and that is against the claims of the Quran itself.

Why would the Quran even include the mistaken view of Dhu al-Qarnayn? Muslim apologists would probably answer "[[Allah]] knows best". Let's assume that, for some mysterious reason, the Quran is describing the illusion of Dhu al-Qarnayn seeing the sun as if it were setting in a muddy spring, this raises many other questions. Why didn't the Quran express it in a less ambiguous way? The Quran says, for example, that [[Jesus]] was never crucified but it appeared that way to people ({{Qur'an|4|157}}). Here the Quran is very clear and there is no room for ambiguity or error in the interpretation (in Arabic, it is written "ولكن شبه لهم" which translates "it was made to appear to them. If the Quran also intended to say that Dhu al-Qarnayn mistakenly saw the sun as if it were setting in a muddy spring, why didn't it express it more clearly? In the verse where Dhu al-Qarnayn found the sun setting in a muddy spring, the word used is "وجد" meaning "he found". Some translations of the Quran translate this word as "as if he found" or something similar", but this is a mistranslation. This same word is used 35 times in the Quran ({{Qur'an|3|37}}; {{Qur'an|4|64}}; {{Qur'an|4|82}}; {{Qur'an|4|89}}; {{Qur'an|5|104}}; {{Qur'an|7|28}}, {{Qur'an|44|102}}; {{Qur'an|9|5}}; {{Qur'an|10|78}}; {{Qur'an|12|65}}; {{Qur'an|12|75}}; {{Qur'an|12|79}}; {{Qur'an|18|49}}; {{Qur'an|18|65}}; {{Qur'an|18|77}}; {{Qur'an|18|86}}; {{Qur'an|18|90}}; {{Qur'an|18|93}}; {{Qur'an|21|53}}; {{Qur'an|24|39}}; {{Qur'an|26|74}}; {{Qur'an|27|23}}; {{Qur'an|27|24}}; {{Qur'an|28|15}}; {{Qur'an|28|23}}; {{Qur'an|31|21}}; {{Qur'an|38|44}}; {{Qur'an|43|22}}; {{Qur'an|43|23}}; {{Qur'an|43|24}}; {{Qur'an|51|36}}; {{Qur'an|72|8}}; {{Qur'an|93|7}}; {{Qur'an|93|8}}) and in none of those instances is this word used to mean "as if he found", all of them simply mean "he found". It seems highly unlikely that the Quran would use the same meaning for the same word in all instances except once where for some reason it decided to use it with another meaning. This is even more unlikely due to the fact that the word "وجد" appears twice in the same verse (see the translation in the previous section). In the second instance it referes to Dhu al-Qarnayn finding people close to the setting place of the sun. It wouldn't make sense if the Quran says that Dhu al-Qarnayn was as if he were seeing people (this is even more obvious when the Quran says that Dhu al-Qarnayn judged the people), and the Quran would be unclear and incoherent if it used the same word in the same verse twice but each time with a different meaning. (Also it wouldn't make sense that he saw real people close to a place that he only mistakenly saw, but which is not real). So the only coherent interpretation is that Dhu al-Qarnayn did see the sun really setting in a muddy spring. Muslim apologists tend to ignore all of these incoherences in their interpretations.

Let's analyze the whole story. In verse 18:83, it is said that [[Muhammad]] was told by the people to tell the story of Dhu al-Qarnayn to prove his prophethood. The next two verses speak about the power of Dhu al-Qarnayn and the beginning of his journey. The next verse is about Dhu al-Qarnayn seeing the sun setting in a muddy spring and judging people near it, which we already talked about. The next two are also about the judgment of the people. Let's stop there and see the context: Dhu al-Qarnayn followed a course, until he saw the west where the sun was setting in a muddy spring. If he would eventually just see the sun setting above the horizon, but not in reality, then what was the purpose behind him making this whole journey? Couldn't he just sit there and wait for the sunset if he was only seeing it setting below the horizon? The Arabic word used for reaching here is "بلغ". Some Muslim apologists say that this word means reaching a moment in time, the time when the sun sets (not in the literal sense), not a place. While it is true that it has two meaning: a spatial and a temporal one, the context here suggests it is used  in the spatial sense, because he followed a physical road, not waited a moment in time. This will become more obvious with the following verses. The following two verses say Dhu al-Qarnayn followed a different course, the following verse tells us he reached the rising place of the sun where he found people with no protection. The next verse says Dhu al-Qarnayn followed a different course (again!). In the following verse, Dhu al-Qarnayn reached a pass between two mountains and found people whose language he couldn't understand. Now we can understand the context of the story. This last verse uses once again the word "بلغ" meaning "he reached". In the last verse we mentioned the word "بلغ" is unambiguously used in the spatial sense (it doesn't make sense to reach the "time of two mountains"). For the whole story to be coherent, it must be that "بلغ" is used for reaching a place in the whole story. Therefore we can reject the interpretation according to which the word "بلغ" is used for reaching a time, since the context makes it clear that it is used for reaching places. Therefore Dhu al-Qarnayn definitively reached the litteral place where the sun sets. The word "وجد", meaning "he found", is also used in this last verse as referring to the people between the two mountains, and it is used here in the meaning "he found", not "as if he found", since it wouldn't make sense otherwise.

===The second problem:The size of springs===
Now let's move on to the second problem. The verse speaks about the sun setting in a spring of blackened muddy water. The Arabic word for spring is "عين" (not to be confused with the homophonous Arabic word which means "eye", an entirely different meaning). Apologists claim Dhu al-Qarnayn would have seen a setting from his perspective over the horizon, similar to how you would see the sunset over the sea, like in this picture.
[[File:2002-08 Westerland Sundown.jpg|thumb|center|165px|Beautiful sunset, isn't it?. Muslim apologists claim that Dhu al-Qarnayn saw the sun setting in a muddy spring like this. But this is problematic due to reasons we will explore just bellow.]]
The Arabic words for bodies of water, ordered by decreasing size, are as follow:
#"محيط" meaning "ocean"
#"بحر" meaning "sea"
#"بحيرة" meaning "lake"
#"نهر" meaning "river"
#"عين" meaning "spring"
Oceans and lakes are not mentionned in the Quran, because at the time of the revelation any large body of water would have been called sea. The spring is clearly the smallest one of them, and the Quran clearly uses it as the location of the physical setting place of the sun. Is there a spring big enough so that it stretches all the way to the horizon? The biggest spring in the world is called {{w|Frying Pan Lake}} (although it is a spring, not a lake), also called Waimangu Cauldron, located in [[New Zealand]]. Its width is only 200 meters, which is not big enough to stretch all the way to the horizon, as seen in this picture.<ref>{{wpa|Frying Pan Lake}}</ref>
[[File:Frying Pan Lake in Waimangu Volcanic Valley.jpg|thumb|center|165px|Frying Pan Lake, the biggest spring in the word. Unfortunately it isn't big enough to stretch all the way to the horizon.]]
New Zealand is not considered far away to the west, and it wasn't even inhabited by humans at the time of the revelation.<ref>{{wpa|New Zealand}}</ref> Moreover this spring only appeared in 1886 due to a volcanic eruption. All other springs all around the world are smaller, and also can't stretch all the way to the horizon. There is therefore no way for the sun to appear to set in a muddy spring below the horizon because springs are not big enough to stretch all the way to the horizon.

===The third problem:Hadiths by Muhammad===
The following hadith confirms the fact that the sun sets in a muddy spring.<ref>[https://sunnah.com/abudawud:4002 "Sunan Abi Dawud 4002"]</ref>
{{quotebox|Narrated Abu Dharr: I was sitting behind the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) who was riding a donkey while the sun was setting. He asked: Do you know where this sets ? I replied: Allah and his Apostle know best. He said: It sets in a spring of warm water (Hamiyah).}}
This hadith is concidered authentic (sahih) by Muslim scholars. 

There is an equally authentic hadith which is arguably even worse, since it tells us that the sun worships every night under the throne of Allah.<ref>[https://sunnah.com/bukhari:4803 "Sahih al-Bukhari 4803"]</ref>
{{quotebox|I asked the Prophet (ﷺ) about the Statement of Allah:-- 'And the sun runs on fixed course for a term (decreed), ' ({{Qur'an|36|38}}) He said, "Its course is underneath "Allah's Throne.".}}
All of these are impossible, given that the sun is always in the sky at some stage on a physical Earth. This would only work if we were living on a [[flat Earth]].{{efn|While knowledge of the spherical shape of the Earth has existed to a greater or lesser degree since at least the classical Greeks (4<sup>th</sup> century BCE), such knowledge prominently entered the Islamic milieu in the 9<sup>th</sup> century CE when many Greek texts were translated into Arabic for the first time under the sponsorship of the Abbasid caliphate.<ref>[https://wikiislam.net/wiki/Islamic_Views_on_the_Shape_of_the_Earth "Islamic Views on the Shape of the Earth"]</ref>}}

All of these confirm that the intended meaning is that the sun (literally) sets in a muddy spring.

===The fourth problem: Early interpretations by early Islamic scholars===
Early Islamic scholars interpreted these verses (and more generally, the whole Quran) literally, not metaphorically. Early Islamic scholars had a much better understanding of Classical Arabic than modern scholars. Many of them (although not all of them) lived at the time of the prophet, and therefore had the opportunity to ask him about a specific verse. Those who didn't have that opportunity also based their interpretations on the sayings of the prophet and his companions. Moreover, their interpretations were mostly not influenced by any other thing, such us scientific knowledge, so they interpreted the Quran and the hadith as they were written. It is therefore reasonable to say that he early interpretations more accurately represent the original and intended meaning of the Quran than modern scholars.

One of the most important Islamic scholars in the past was a scholar known as {{wpl|Tabari||.}} He wrote two major works: a very thorough commentary of the Quran called ''Qurʾān Commentary'', as well as a comprehensive [[creationism|creationist]] account of the history of the universe told through Islamic narrations called ''History of Prophets and Kings''. Both works have undeniably formed the basis for the vast majority of Islamic history in Quranic interpretation. His book ''History of Prophets and Kings'', pages 234-235 interprets the verses literally and thus confirms the literal interpretation:<ref>[https://www.kalamullah.com/Books/The%20History%20Of%20Tabari/Tabari_Volume_01.pdf "Tabari_Volume_01.pdf (English translation)"]</ref>
{{quotebox|Then he said: For the sun and the moon, He created easts and wests (positions to rise and set) on the two sides of the earth and the two rims of heaven, 180 springs in the west of black clay — this is (meant by) God's word: "He found it setting in a muddy spring," meaning by "muddy (hami'ah)" black clay —and 180 springs in the east likewise of black clay, bubbling and boiling like a pot when it boils furiously. He continued. Every day and night, the sun has a new place where it rises and a new place where it sets. The interval between them from beginning to end is longest for the day in summer and shortest in winter. This is (meant by) God's word: "The Lord of the two easts and the Lord of the two wests," meaning the last (position) of the sun here and the last there. He omitted the positions in the east and the west (for the rising and setting of the sun) in between them. Then He referred to east and west in the plural, saying: "(By) the Lord of the easts and the wests." He mentioned the number of all those springs (as above).}}

Let's see what early tafsirs (commentaries or exegeries about the Quran) said about this verse.<ref>[https://www.altafsir.com/ "altafsir.com"]</ref> All early tafsirs interpreted  most of the Quran, including this verse, literally. The tafsir of Tabari (310 Hijri, equivalent to 922 CE) contains narrations of many of the companions of the prophet, all of them interpreted the verse literally, and Tabari didn't even mention the possibility of the verse being metaphorical.<ref>[https://www.altafsir.com/Tafasir.asp?tMadhNo=0&tTafsirNo=1&tSoraNo=18&tAyahNo=86&tDisplay=yes&UserProfile=0&LanguageId=1 "تفسير جامع البيان في تفسير القرآن/ الطبري (ت 310 هـ) مصنف و مدقق"]</ref> Tafsir al-Kabir Imam al-Tabrani (360 Hijri, equivalent to 970 CE) is the first tafsir to mention the possibility of Dhu al-Qarnayn just seeing the sun setting at the horizon.<ref>[https://www.altafsir.com/Tafasir.asp?tMadhNo=0&tTafsirNo=91&tSoraNo=18&tAyahNo=86&tDisplay=yes&UserProfile=0&LanguageId=1 "تفسير التفسير الكبير / للإمام الطبراني (ت 360 هـ) مصنف و مدقق"]</ref> This tafsir, however, is controversial and most scholars consider it as a fraud actually written by other people between 500 and 600 years after Muhammad's death. It was written by other people trying to give it legimity by attributing it to {{wpl|Sulaiman al-Tabrani||.}}<ref>[https://www.alukah.net/web/alshehry/0/26704/?fbclid=IwY2xjawEmskpleHRuA2FlbQIxMAABHWh0iVe_d5DH-xDiaP5JkI1Bnn1_vNM2HH8ZoGjhObfZN8o1D76NUOA4lA_aem_qJ4NrL1br6LO5UeP4Igk9w "صدر حديثاً (التفسير الكبير) للطبراني بتحقيق هشام البدراني"]</ref> Tafsir al-Kashf wa al-Bayan (427 Hijri, equivalent to 1035 CE) tells us that the muddy spring propels the sun through the underworld to reach thee place of sunrise. This tafsir also mentions a poem by an ancient Yemeni King called {{w|Tubba}} who lived at least 700 years before Muhammad.<ref>[https://www.altafsir.com/Tafasir.asp?tMadhNo=0&tTafsirNo=75&tSoraNo=18&tAyahNo=86&tDisplay=yes&Page=2&Size=1&LanguageId=1 "تفسير الكشف والبيان / الثعلبي (ت 427 هـ) مصنف و مدقق"]</ref> This poem might be where the idea of the sun setting in a muddy spring in the Quran came from. Tafsir al-Mawirdi (450 Hijri, equivalent to 1058 CE) is the first non-controversial tafsir to mention the possibility of this verse just refering to Dhu al-Qarnayn's perspective.<ref>[https://www.altafsir.com/Tafasir.asp?tMadhNo=0&tTafsirNo=12&tSoraNo=18&tAyahNo=86&tDisplay=yes&UserProfile=0&LanguageId=1 "تفسير النكت والعيون/ الماوردي (ت 450 هـ) مصنف و مدقق"]</ref> It took 440 years after the death of Muhammad for Muslims to start to realize the possibility that Dhu al-Qarnayn just saw the sun what looked like setting below the horizon! Tafsir al-Tibyan-al-Tusi (460 Hijri, equivalent to 1067 CE) mentions which Muslims figured out that the sun was too big to literally set in a muddy spring, but it also mentioned that there were still disputes.<ref>[https://www.altafsir.com/Tafasir.asp?tMadhNo=0&tTafsirNo=39&tSoraNo=18&tAyahNo=86&tDisplay=yes&Page=2&Size=1&LanguageId=1 "تفسير التبيان الجامع لعلوم القرآن/ الطوسي (ت 460 هـ) مصنف و مدقق"]</ref> So it took more than 450 years after Muhammad's death for Muslims to realize that the sun can't physically set in a muddy spring.

===Conclusion===
All the arguments provided above are clearly evidence that the intended meaning behind these verses is that the sun literally and physically sets in a muddy spring. Interpreting the verses as saying that it was from Dhu al-Qarnayn's perspective creates linguistic inconsistencies and is unrealistic. 
The hadiths also confirm the literal interpretation. It's clear that Muslims for 440 years believed that the sun does indeed set in a muddy spring, before realizing that this was impossible due to growing scientific evidences, and they were unwilling to reject Islam so they changed their interpretation, which creates new problems as we discussed above. A Muslim therefore has two choices: either to reject all the scientific evidences and accepting the claims of the Quran, or to start questioning Islam.

Similar stories of the sun rising and setting somewhere on Earth are found in mythologies that predate Islam. In Egyption mythology, for example, the sun rises somewhere on Earth, travels across the sky before setting somewhere on Earth then travelling through the underworld to its rising place. It seems that Islam borrowed from these mythologies, the only difference is that in these mythologies the sun is a [[god]], while in Islam it is just an object guided by Allah.

==Gog and Magog==
The story of [[Gog and Magog]] (called يَأْجُوجُ وَمَأْجُوجُ in Arabic) is also mentioned in the [[Bible]], but for now we will only focus on the Islamic narrative.

We will focus on the second part of the story of Dhu al-Qarnayn (18:93-101).<ref>[https://youtu.be/ty_2G_esUvI?si=hGqGT6hIIGWFjyVW "The lost tribes of Gog & Magog in Islam"]</ref> In these verses, Dhu al-Qanayn traveled a third course, until he reached the pass between two mountains where he found people who told about Gog and Magog spreading corruption in the land. Then Dhu al-Qarnayn made a metal barrier between the two mountains to stop Gog and Magog. Another verse of the Quran ({{Qur'an|21|96}}) tells us that one day Gog and Magog will break free from the barrier and cause terror on the Earth. According to the Islamic tradition, there are 10 signs for what will happen before the day of judgment,<ref>[https://sunnah.com/muslim/54/51 "Sahih Muslim 2901a"]</ref> one of them being Gog and Magog making their way through the barrier and causing chaos on Earth.

Imagine we have a large group of people who belong to troublesome tribes. Dhu al-Qarnayn comes and builds a huge wall between two mountains. These people are now standing behind the big wall, can't they just walk around the side of one of the mountains? Since we live on a spherical Earth, one wall between two mountains is never sufficient for incarceration. This would make more sence if the mountains were near the edge of a [[flat Earth]].

We know that this wall, if it exists, would be huge because of the number of people behind it. The Quranic verse 21:96 tells us that they swiftly swarm from every hill. Neither the tribe nor the wall have been found. It is ridiculous to say that there is a lost tribe of a huge number of people trapped behind a wall between two mountains we have never found. The Bible also tells us a similar story in the [[Book of Revelation]].

This hadith,<ref>[https://sunnah.com/bukhari/81/119 "Sahih al-Bukhari 6530"]</ref> {{quotebox|The Prophet (ﷺ) said, "Allah will say, 'O Adam!. Adam will reply, 'Labbaik and Sa`daik (I respond to Your Calls, I am obedient to Your orders), wal Khair fi Yadaik (and all the good is in Your Hands)!' Then Allah will say (to Adam), Bring out the people of the Fire.' Adam will say, 'What (how many) are the people of the Fire?' Allah will say, 'Out of every thousand (take out) nine hundred and ninety-nine (persons).' At that time children will become hoary-headed and every pregnant female will drop her load (have an abortion) and you will see the people as if they were drunk, yet not drunk; But Allah's punishment will be very severe." That news distressed the companions of the Prophet (ﷺ) too much, and they said, "O Allah's Messenger (ﷺ)! Who amongst us will be that man (the lucky one out of one-thousand who will be saved from the Fire)?" He said, "Have the good news that one-thousand will be from Gog and Magog, and the one (to be saved will be) from you." The Prophet (ﷺ) added, "By Him in Whose Hand my soul is, I Hope that you (Muslims) will be one third of the people of Paradise." On that, we glorified and praised Allah and said, "Allahu Akbar." The Prophet (ﷺ) then said, "By Him in Whose Hand my soul is, I hope that you will be one half of the people of Paradise, as your (Muslims) example in comparison to the other people (non-Muslims), is like that of a white hair on the skin of a black ox, or a round hairless spot on the foreleg of a donkey."}} considered authentic, says that out of every 1,000 people, 999 will go to [[hell]], and 999 of every 1,000 who go to hell will be from Gog and Magog. Let's assume the Day of Judgment is about to happen. It is estimated that around 108 billion humans have lived on Earth (including those who are no longer alive). Based on the above hadith and the above statistics, we can estimate that there are more than 54 trillion people belonging to that tribe! Given all of this, it seems absurd to say that there is a tribe of more than 54 trillion people we can't find that are trapped behind a metal wall between two mountains we also can't find. Assuming we put each human in one square meter (excluding Gog and Magog), we can fit the whole human population into [[New York City]]. If we were to do the same thing for Gog and Magog, we would need an area equivalent to [[India]] and [[Argentina]] combined. And this is if we assume that each one has no room to move. And it is claimed that somehow we didn't find all of them. 

People have looked across every place on the surface of the planet, and no one has ever found the metal wall between two mountains behind which there are 54 trillion  people. Some have claimed that the wall is the {{wpl|Great Wall of China||.}} The Quran, however, tells us this wall was made of iron and copper, which is not the case for the Great Wall of China. Many other places have been proposed, but all of these proposals are problematic. {{w|Yasir Qadhi}} acknowledged all these problems, but despite all the evidence; he didn't want to dismiss the story but rather said "God knows best" (Allahu A'lam).<ref>[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q3ot5Y60ayw "Tafseer Surah Al-Kahf (Part 18): Yajuj, Majuj & 10 Signs Day of Judgment"]</ref>

==Dhu al-Qarnayn and Alexander Romance==
The Qur'an doesn't tell us much about Dhu al-Qarnayn. Some Muslim apologists claim that he is {{wpl|Alexander the Great||.}} However, many Islamic scholars object to this by saying that historical evidences show that Alexander was a polytheist, while the Quran clearly says Dhu al-Qarnayn is a believer in God. Others argue that he is the Persian emperor [[Cyrus the Great]], some have proposed other historical persons. And many just say "Allahu a'lam" ("God knows best" in Arabic). But when we examine the Quran from a historical perspective, it seems that the Quran heavily borrowed from legends about Alexander the Great, especially from {{w|Alexander Romance||.}}<ref>[https://youtu.be/Sju28v0dCw8?si=37XznS7nH2UPhP4S "The Quran & the Alexander Romance"]</ref> These stories are pure legend and there is no historical evidence to confirm them.

===Some historical background===
Alexander the Great (the historical, not the legendary one) was a Macedonian leader who managed to conquer much of the known world at the time. His empire eventually stretching from [[Ancient Egypt|Egypt]] to Macedonia in the west, to part of [[India]] in the east. Alexander was born in 356 BCE into a life of privilege and even had [[Aristotle]] as a tutor.<ref>{{wpa|Alexander the Great}}</ref> He revered Cyrus the Great and embraced many aspects of Persian life. He claimed divinity and ordered people to worship him in a Persian fashion called {{wpl|proskynesis||.}} [[Image:Different kinds of bows in eo.gif|thumb|right|165px|This is proskynesis. Doesn't this look familia to Muslims? Except for the last part, it looks similar to Islamic prayer.]] Before setting out to conquer [[Asia]], Alexander brought along the well-known historian of his era, {{wpl|Callisthenes of Olynthus||.}} He wanted Callisthenes to record his exploits and the march of the Macedonian army east. But Alexander's arrogance was not well received by the Macedonians of the time. Many Macedonians came to despise much of Alexander's behavior, Callisthenes was one of them. Callisthenes was imprisoned until his death in 327 BCE. His historical works were destroyed. Alexander died 4 years later at the age of 32 in [[Babylon]]. 

Having won every single battle during his life, creating the largest [[Imperialism|empire]] at the time, Alexander became a legend. Stories about him were created to portray him as an even more powerful man after his death. One of them is the well-known legend of {{wpl|Alexander Romance||.}} Historians have reached the consensus that it was just a fable falsely attributed to Callisthenes.<ref>{{wpa|Alexander Romance}}</ref> They began circulating orally soon after Alexander's death. Hundreds of years later, these fables were written down in [[Greece]] and Egypt around 200 BCE. Given the geography and the very strong trade links in the region, and that they were written in Egypt and Greece by 200 BCE, then the oral tradition was likely very common in Arabia at the time, long before Islam. It would therefore be likely that some of these myths made their way into the Quran.

===Evidences for the story of Dhu al-Qarnayn being based on myths around Alexander the Great===
[[File:Alexander-Coin.jpg|thumb|right|165px|Alexander the Great was often represented with two horns.]]
[[File:Alexander-Heraclius Stele.png|thumb|right|165px|7th century CE stele depicting Alexander the Great with horns discovered in 2018.]]
We have already discussed how the story of Dhu al-Qarnayn may have been taken from a pre-Islamic poem by Tubba as evidenced in early Islamic sources. So it's clear that myths around the man with two horns were already common in Arabia before Islam. "Dhu al-Qarnayn" litterally means "two horned" in Arabic. Many archeological evidences show that Alexander was often represented with two horns. The two-horned man makes several appearances in many legends about Alexander the Great. It appears to have originated from the Egyptian version which, like other versions, try to claim that Alexander was part of their families of [[god]]s. In the Egyption version, we read in a hieroglyphic message:
{{quotebox|"King of Upper and Lower Egypt, the chosen one of Ra, the beloved of Amen, son of Sun, Alexander, son of Amen."}}:
Being the son of the God Amen, who was frequently represented on the sculptures by a [[Sheep|ram]], it was only natural that the two horns of the animal should be made attributes of Alexander the Great and that he should be called "two-horned".

In the Ethiopic version, another reason is given. His title "two-horned", occures for the first time in a manuscript. The Ethiopic writers explain this title by saying that he was so called because he "ruled in the two horns of the [[Sun]], the east and the west". 

In the Christian version, we are given another reason. {{quotebox|And the king arose and knelt down and did reverence to the Lord; and the Lord said to him, "Behold, I have magnified thee above all kingdoms, and ''I have made horns of iron to grow on thy head'' that thou mayest thrust down the kingdoms of the Earth with them; ..."}}. It also says: {{quotebox|when Philip saw Alexander guiding the horse with his hand and standing upon his feet, he said "My son Alexander, the whole oracle refers to thee; I believe that after my death thou wilt reign, and that thou wilt rule the whole world".}}

All these legend say that Alexander was a man who had power over the world. This looks similar to {{Quran|18|84}}:{{quotebox|We established him on earth, and gave him all kinds of means.}}

We also read in the legends: {{quotebox|He (Alexander) said to them: "I am wondering what is the extent of the Earth, and how high the heavens are, and how many are the countries of my fellow king, and upon what the heavens are fixed; whether perchance thick clouds and winds support them, or whether pillars of fire rise up from the interior of the Earth and bear the heavens so that they move not for anything, or whether they depend of the beck of [[God]] and fall not. ..."}} Similar ideas appear in the Quran. {{Qur'an|13|2}}: {{quotebox|God is He who raised the heavens without pillars that you can see, and then settled on the Throne. And He regulated the sun and the moon, each running for a specified period. He manages all affairs, and He explains the signs, that you may be certain of the meeting with your Lord.}} {{Quran|22|65}}: {{quotebox|Do you not see that God made everything on earth subservient to you? How the ships sail at sea by His command? That He holds up the sky lest it falls on earth—except by His permission? God is Gracious towards the people, Most Merciful.}}

The legends also talk about Alexander travelling to the edge of the world to see where the sun sets and where the sun rises. The following is, according to the legends, what he saw near the rising place of the sun: {{quotebox|the sun is the servant of the Lord, and neither by night nor by day does he cease from his travelling. The place of his rising is over the sea, and the people who dwell there, when he is about to rise, flee away and hide themselves in the sea, and the people, that they be not burnt by his rays; ...}} {{Qur'an|18|90}} says: {{quotebox|Until, when he reached the rising of the sun, he found it rising on a people for whom We had provided no shelter from it.}} So both the Quran and the legends agree about the sun rising near people with no protection from it. We also read in these legend {{quotebox|And when the sun enters the window of heaven, he straightway bows and makes obeissant before God his Creator; ...}} A similar idea also appears in {{Qur'an|22|18}}: {{quotebox|Do you not realize that to God prostrates everyone in the heavens and everyone on earth, and the sun, and the [[moon]], and the [[star]]s, and the mountains, and the [[tree]]s, and the animals, and many of the people? But many are justly deserving of punishment. Whomever God shames, there is none to honor him. God does whatever He wills.}}

These legends also speak about Alexander reaching a people near a huge mountain who have problems with some people. {{quotebox|Alexander said "Who are the nations within this mountain upon which we are looking?....." The natives of the land said "They are the Hunts." He said to them "Who are their kings?" The old men said "God and Magog..."}} This is similar to the story of Gog and Magog found in the Qur'an. The legends also say: {{quotebox|Alexander commanded and fetched three thousand smiths, workers in iron, and three thousand me, workers in brass. And they put down brass and iron, and kneads when he works clay. Then they brought it and made a gate, ...}} {{Qur'an|18|96}} also tells us about Dhu al-Qarnayn build his wall using iron and copper. These are same materials also mentioned in the legend.

{{Qur'an|21|96}}: {{quotebox|Until, when Gog and Magog are let loose, and they swarm down from every mound.}} which implies that Gog and Magog will get free from the barrier near the end of the world. The Alexander legends also tells that they will be released towards the ends of time and take over the world: {{quotebox|When the world shall come to an end by the command of God the ruler of creation. Created things shall anger God, and sin shall increase, and wrath shall reign, and the sins of mankind shall mount up and shall cover the heavens, and the Lord will stir up in His anger the kingdoms that lie within this gate; for when the Lord seeks to slay men, he sends men against men, and they destroy one another. And the Lord will gather together the kings 
and their hosts which are within this mountain, and they shall all be assembled at His beck, and shall come with their spears and swords, and shall stand behind the gate, and shall look up to the heavens, and shall call upon the name of the lord saying "O Lord, open to us this gate". And the Lord shall send His sign from heaven and a voice shall call on this gate, and it shall be destroyed and fall at the beck of the Lord, ...}} In this hadith, concidered sahih,<ref>[https://sunnah.com/ibnmajah/36/155 "Sunan Ibn Majah 4080"]</ref> it is said that Gog and Magog will break the wall when they will ask nicely to Allah: {{quotebox|"Gog and Magog people dig every day until, when they can almost see the rays of the sun, the one in charge of them says: "Go back and we will dig it tomorrow." Then Allah puts it back, stronger than it was before. (This will continue) until, when their time has come, and Allah wants to send them against the people, they will dig until they can almost see the rays of the sun, then the one who is in charge of them will say: "Go back, and we will dig it tomorrow if Allah wills.' So they will say: "If Allah wills." Then they will come back to it and it will be as they left it. So they will dig and will come out to the people, and they will drink all the water. The people will fortify themselves against them in their fortresses. They will shoot their arrows towards the sky and they will come back with blood on them, and they will say: "We have defeated the people of earth and dominated the people of heaven." Then Allah will send a worm in the napes of their necks and will kill them thereby.'" The Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) said: "By the One in Whose Hand is my soul, the beasts of the earth will grow fat on their flesh."}}

Are all of these similarities pure coincidence?

===Conclusion===
[[File:Conclusion about the influence by Syriac Pseudo-Callisthenes.png|thumb|right|165px|Probable Genealogy of Influence]]
The similarities between Dhu al-Qarnayn's story in the Quran and the legends around Alexander the Great are obvious. If the Quran was a perfect book, the litteral words of [[God]], why would it use so much of the legends of Alexander the Great, especially legends that have nothing to do with the historical Alexander the Great?

Early Islamic scholars also identified Dhu al-Qarnayn as Alexander the Great.<ref>[https://www.altafsir.com/Tafasir.asp?tMadhNo=0&tTafsirNo=74&tSoraNo=18&tAyahNo=83&tDisplay=yes&UserProfile=0&LanguageId=2 "Tafsir al-Jalalayn"]</ref> But due to growing evidence that Alexander the Great was a polytheist, many scholars started questioning this identification. Some have argued that Dhu al-Qarnayn is {{wpl|Cyrus the Great||,}} others have proposed other historical characters, while many prefer not speculating. But, as we showed above, all of these evidences suggest that Islam borrowed the story from legends around Alexander the Great. Modern Islamic apologists just suppose that their religion is right and they reach the conclusion that Dhu al-Qarnayn was not Alexander the Great because Dhu al-Qarnayn was a believer in Allah according to the Quran, not a polytheist.

==See also==
*[[Qur'anic scientific errors]]

==External links==
*[https://wikiislam.net/wiki/Dhul-Qarnayn_and_the_Sun_Setting_in_a_Muddy_Spring_-_Part_One ''Dhul-Qarnayn and the Sun Setting in a Muddy Spring (Part One)''] on WikiIslam
*[https://wikiislam.net/wiki/Dhul-Qarnayn_and_the_Sun_Setting_in_a_Muddy_Spring_-_Part_Two ''Dhul-Qarnayn and the Sun Setting in a Muddy Spring (Part Two)''] on WikiIslam
*[https://wikiislam.net/wiki/Dhul-Qarnayn_and_the_Alexander_Romance ''Dhul-Qarnayn and the Alexander Romance''] on WikiIslam
*{{wpa|Dhu al-Qarnayn}}
*{{wpa|Theories about Alexander the Great in the Quran}}

==Notes==
{{reflist|group=note|2}}

==References==
{{reflist|2|90%}}

{{qurbox}}

[[Category:Islam]]
[[Category:Religion]]
[[Category:Qur'an]]
[[Category:Apologetics and counter-apologetics]]
[[Category:Qur'an analysis]]

Categories: Islam, Religion, Qur'an, Apologetics and counter-apologetics, Qur'an analysis